Administration Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Live capture
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Administration Committee Actual start House of Commons
Follow its sittingsEleanor Elizabeth Chowns
We ourselves as a group benefited very much from inheriting a few members of staff who had previously worked with Caroline Lucas, so there was a huge amount of institutional memory for our group and support. So they were our main source of support in, you know, hitting the ground, but the practicalities of setting up offices, getting casework, MP working, etc, etc, were things where I think there are things that could be improved in terms of the support.
Ann Celia Davies
And I would totally agree with that. You know, the buddy system for me worked well for that first week. But I would say as well with regards to the induction that I would really have appreciated revisiting this in three months' time. And I know with the general election was in an awkward time really in that it was at the beginning of July. We were off for summer recess.
We were back for three weeks. We were off then for conference recess. But I think revisiting as somebody who had no knowledge of how legislation, for example, was presented to Parliament and how the system of going through the legislation, I would have really appreciated revisiting that say in October or November to gain an understanding because when you land here, the practical issues are what you focus on.
The information or the knowledge that you need to be an effective MP sort of beds in a little bit later really after you've sorted out, as you were saying, your office, your staff, and all the practical issues. And the fact that, you know, it was in October really after the conference recess when we were allocated offices. So up to that time, we were working, I was working in the library in Portcullis House downstairs there. So it's practical issues that would have been fantastic if we could have sorted offices out a little bit sooner rather than actually working in Portcullis House.
Lovely as it is, but it's not the best place to have some peace and quiet and some thinking time.
Nick Smith
So all of us elected to this place remember the shock of being elected and coming here. Where did you turn to for advice as a candidate and what would it have been helpful to know about parliamentary life before your election do you think?
Ann Celia Davies
Well, I'm going to be perfectly honest with you. I didn't think any further than election day. And I don't know if everybody else was in the same situation, but that was mine. I wanted to get to election day and then, you know, the realization, oh, actually, I've been elected. I've won this election.
And then you start thinking, oh, right, okay, here we go then. So for me, I didn't think about the after. It was just, you know, it felt right to stand and it was the right thing to do. And it was just the practical issues then that came afterwards.
So with regards to once you landed here, I would say that I was very, very fortunate in that one of Ben Lake's ex-staff who was who wasn't working for Ben at that time really helped me enormously. He was based in Carmarthenshire, he was an he was a Plaid activist, but he he really helped me enormously.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
It was different for us. We had four target candidates as Greens and we had monthly meetings with the person who was Caroline's chief of staff and is now our chief of staff for at least a year prior to the general election where we went through a, you know, informal but fairly structured programme of understanding more about how Parliament works, talking about practicalities around things like security, setting up an office, the fact that we would have a tsunami of emails on the very first morning and we would need staff working with us at least on a temporary basis until we were able to permanently recruit people and so forth. So in that sense there was some preparation.
So in that sense there was some preparation, there was lots of preparation done, but still, you know, the realities of just the, I mean, as Ann says, it was an unusual time because we had recess shortly after we were elected.
Thank goodness we did. You know, I spent that entire summer basically trying to set up systems, finding an office, etc., etc. If we'd been also trying to function four days a week in Westminster, you know, scrutinizing legislation, etc., etc., it would have been even more difficult. So, I think that for me, it's not that we needed more information after we were elected or more training sessions. It's actually we need more practical support on the part of IPSA in particular, for example, offices that are just the constituency office and pass seamlessly from one MP to the next at handover, staff that are there and know parliamentary systems and are able to respond to constituents.
Because if you're elected in a place where, I mean, probably in most places, there's huge pent-up demand. And so you have a huge number of people saying, please raise this issue with the minister, please do this, that, and the other.
And as a new MP, you are not yet familiar with all of the mechanisms that MPs have to deal with things. And so I think every single MP pretty much ends up with a backlog from that early period, which means you're not starting off on the foot that you want to start off on. And that could be addressed with the practicalities of support being in place, I think.
Nick Smith
Yeah, we'll come on to some of those issues shortly in questions from colleagues.
One more question. Would you say what was the critical information that you needed to know in the first weekend, the first week, and the first month?
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
First weekend, what would happen in the first week. And we did get that. I mean, literally the morning, you know, you get your results, you get given a folder and it says be in this place at this time, as I recall.
The first week, yeah, you do need a laptop. That was really good. Got a laptop, got an email address, etc., etc. You need to know things. I did write a few notes on this.
I think in the first week, I've written getting staff and systems to help with the initial huge wave of constituent emails. You know, we were wrestling, I was wrestling with kind of homegrown Excel spreadsheets for the first couple of months until I'd got Caseworker set up. That took about a month. You know, all of these sorts of things. And then actually our chief of staff ended up doing huge amounts of admin in the first few months because you have to get all of your, even if you've got temporary staff already who've said that they will help you in the initial weeks, you have to get all of them through security vetting, get them passes, get them set up on the system.
There's so many sort of admin-y things that take up a lot of time.
So you're not actually, you've not got a whole lot of head space for working out, right, doing my maiden speech or whatever. I mean, many of us did do our speeches and got, you know, threw ourselves in at the deep end right at the start. But it's understandable that some MPs don't because you're completely struggling just with getting set up as a functional representative. Yeah.
Anything to add on that?
Ann Celia Davies
Yeah, the only thing I would add to that is accommodation. As somebody that lives four and a half hours away from London on the train, I found it very difficult that this place only sorted out our accommodation for two weeks. After that, we were on our own. And you know, most of you know, we run a farm at home, we run a children's nursery at home, I do other work, you know, within my community as well as being an MP.
And my head space was half past ten on a Sunday night to find accommodation for that following week because I simply didn't have time to do that until I was getting ready to come back up. So I really think that on a practical issue, I really think this place needs to sort out accommodation for about three months for people who live or who are eligible to have accommodation in London simply because of where we live.
And you know, we need to represent our people effectively. Having finding accommodation which is three quarters of an hour out of here or more because of the time, you know, because of the time that I was looking for accommodation on a Sunday night. And I fully appreciate that that's my fault. Fully appreciate that. I should have done it sooner or should have done a block booking.
But your life at home, you know, when you're beginning to juggle your life at home and your life as a public servant, as a full-time public servant, then practical issues such as accommodation is the last thing that you think about before coming up.
Speaker 8
Okay, thank you. So this question's sort of for you two, really. I'm sorry. Did you want to say something?
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Just on accommodation. Yes, this is clearly felt by some people in our group very, very strongly. We just feel that, you know, Parliament should have flats. Not, it's not even about the first three months. Parliament should just have the leases on the flats and or, you know, have like in France, I think they've got a block of bedsits that MPs can have.
That's I would love that. Because I stayed in three different places, cousins, friends, for the first seven months and then recognized I couldn't sustain it. I did need to get a flat in London. And then you have two weeks where you're basically just house hunting in among everything else. It's such a waste of an MP's time.
And then you're sorting out all of the, you know, signing up for electricity contracts and things like this. If the House administration can do this for us and then just say, look, here's your flat, stay there for three months or six months or a year, then you can sort out your own thing after that if you want. But just to take all of that admin burden off of people would be really helpful.
Nick Smith
So being elected as an MP for a smaller party presents its own challenges during the immediate post-election period for sure. Can you tell us about your experience and what the House could do to improve the support offered to MPs of smaller parties or none?
Ann Celia Davies
Well, I'll start then. And for me, IPSA, the buddy system was great. IPSA, I had a dedicated person, Gina, but I would have loved to have spent a day or an afternoon with her face-to-face going through things like being an employer. Now, as luck would have it, I've employed people before, so I had an understanding of that, but not everybody would have that.
And coming from a smaller party, you don't have the resources that perhaps you have within within the Labour Party or or within the Conservatives or even within the Lib Dems where you have a really big whips office that can help you with this. We don't have that. And therefore I think having that dedicated person was great, but having a face-to-face meeting rather than constant Zoom meetings would have been very beneficial for me in understanding and not just understanding but again practical issues of where to find because you know, if you haven't been on that IPSA website before, it is not the most user-friendly, I'm going to be perfectly frank with you. It really isn't. And finding your job descriptions, finding all the other, you know, the wage bands and and all the other bits that you need in order to start advertising your jobs would, you know, having that sit-down three hours or whatever it would have taken to go through all of that would have been far more beneficial for me, speaking personally, than having a Zoom meeting.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Yeah. I mean, I wrote down, we need extra support with ready-to-go staff to get offices set up and IPSA setting up offices and accommodation, including searching for flats and doing all of the admin. And another member of my group said, has said, provide interim staff support for new MPs, particularly for admin, urgent casework, understanding parliamentary process and supporting setup. The light-touch briefing sessions don't scratch the surface when there are no basics in place.
This will make the first few months more bearable and reduce the backlog that the permanent staff face when they start. And this other member of my group also asked to have a bank of London flats and a constituency office in each constituency rented by IPSA on an ongoing basis to avoid lots of time searching and doing the time-consuming setup and admin. Honestly, that isn't about being a small group.
I mean, it's harder in a small group, but I think they're principles that probably apply to pretty much everyone.
Marie Rimmer
Yeah, thank you. So in the focus groups that were conducted not so long ago, some members expressed a frustration at the volume of emails, and you've touched on it already, about the volume of emails that came in without any staff to respond to it, and said it might be helpful for those emails not actually to be switched on until a bit later on. What do you think about that? And while you're thinking about that, also, can you explain what else you used your laptop for in those early days?
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Okay.
I really disagree with the proposal that our emails shouldn't be switched on. I think voters should be able to reach their new MP immediately. It's really good that they were able to reach us. However, I do think we should have a one, two, three month moratorium on all of the lobbyists contacting us because one of the things, you know, you might get 300 emails in a day and 100 of them might be from people saying please come to my drop-in. And it's hard at the start when you're still kind of finding your way.
So constituents, yes, absolutely should be able to contact their MP straight away. And the thing that we need to support us to respond to that is the, you know, the experienced staff support really to help with that. The using the laptop, I mean, you know, like Ann said, you know, working in the library over at Derby Gate or whatever, you know, we were, yeah, we were working mobile right from the start. So it was useful to have the laptop and the iPad to be able to work on the train etc right from the beginning.
One member of my group has also asked that all MPs be issued with a work phone immediately, just right at the start as standard. Probably a sensible idea. I just have one phone, but many people like to be able to switch off from work very occasionally. Um, I think the point that Ann made about it actually being really quite difficult when you're trying to deal, for example, with no office.
Like I remember desperately trying to find a place to have a private phone conversation. There is nowhere. You can't do it in the Derby Gate library. It's got a mezzanine and all sorts of things. There was nowhere to have a private conversation or even to do, you know, a media interview down the line, a radio interview.
I remember sitting in the ladies' room doing a radio interview and desperately hoping that nobody was going to, was nobody, not the ladies' toilet, I'll specify, the lady members' room.
So just having some small meeting, if we can't have our offices from the start, then at least there should be many more small meeting rooms or small workrooms where you can go and work in privacy on your laptop to get stuff done. One thing that was really brilliant was that, you know, the member support room in PCH. You can just drop in there still now anytime, somebody will help you with your IT or your IPSA or whatever. That's been fantastic.
Ann Celia Davies
But IPSA are only there on a Wednesday. And I have to tell you, I was a weekly visitor to that desk every Wednesday for a long time until you've found your feet, really. Somebody said to me, and I can't remember whether this is true or not, that the MP account had an out of office, but your private account, you know, you have two email accounts, that the private account didn't. Now I can't remember whether that's right or not.
I well, I can't remember. So just check that if that should be on both of them. And like Ellie said, I've no problem with constituents at all getting in touch straight away, but the lobbies, I think, you know, we could have a three-month moratorium on that. You know, but as it happened then, if it was three months, it would have been back in October, in which case we were all back and had found our feet and at least seen an office, if not yet moved in.
The time, I have to say as well, it took me to sort the office lease out, I thought was absolutely ridiculous. You know, we found an office, it then had to go to a solicitor in Carmarthen to check it and then come back. And you know, that whole process took about three months. And I don't understand why. I understand everything has to be right, but surely there must be in-house solicitors that can check a lease without us having to wait for a private solicitor within Carmarthen and the time that that took, I felt was a waste of time.
Marie Rimmer
And just if I may just follow up on that, Chair. So, I mean, I take your point about constituents needing to be able to contact you and I totally take your point about lobbyists ideally not being able to contact you in that time because I remember having to play whack-a-mole with my own inbox and it was impossible without staff. But you do need your laptop for other things as well. You know, laptops are not just about emails, they're also about websites and other things you need to sign up for like CaseworkerMP, for example. Writing a maiden speech or sort of finding accommodation, searching for that as well.
There's so many things you need to do with your laptops, so I can understand why it's helpful and also being able to connect to the parliamentary networks more easily as well, which is secure. So I think that's really important. But I wonder what you think about the idea of potentially harnessing the power of AI in the future to help sort out those inboxes.
You know, I think it's fairly obvious some of the things that were coming in from constituents that were just saying congratulations. I think if they could be perhaps put into a folder for review that AI might suggest that that would be a folder. Not that you have to rely on it, you know, just so that it can be helpfully categorized. It may not get it right 100% of the time, but it might just be helpful. I wonder what you think about that.
I see Ellie looking slightly skeptical, but I wonder what you think.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
No, so I, I, I joined in with the parliamentary AI pilot, the co-pilot pilot about a year ago because I am skeptical about AI but wanted to, you know, wanted to understand and explore it.
And the one thing that I wanted it to be able to do was in my hundreds of emails a day in the inbox, identify emails that were identical apart from the name of the person, the constituent sending them. You know when you get 50 emails that are all the same in a single day? I just wanted AI to pick them out, send them all to Caseworker so that I could deal with them later through my Caseworker system. I, like, I asked the people who were presenting this pilot scheme to me, this is the thing I need it to do, it's simple. But instead they kind of showed me how AI could do me a presentation on how it would relieve me of admin jobs and leave me time to do the creative things.
It, I mean, it was utterly extraordinary because it wouldn't do the admin stuff and instead it wanted to do the writing PowerPoints.
Just ridiculous. So yes, ideally AI, I think, could be really helpful in doing that, indeed within Caseworker, in logging the cases. But of course you need humans to check that there aren't any mistakes. So it's not a silver bullet, but yes, that could be very helpful.
Nick Smith
Thanks, Marie. Colleagues, we are on question five. We've got ten questions for the first panel and then we've got another panel. So I'm sorry, we're going to have to nudge you to turn it up. Thank you, Bambos.
Charalambos Charalambous
You've both touched on the buddy system that you found very useful when you became MPs. But we've had feedback from people saying that they would find the value of a buddy who was a returned MP. And we're just wondering what the best ways to support you for things like the ad hoc questions you might have during the induction period.
Ann Celia Davies
I didn't use my, I think looking back, I didn't use my buddy to the extent that I could have done. And that's simply because of lack of experience. And really, you know, he was great on the first day. And then I didn't touch base until a week after really, when he took me around again after I'd been exploring a bit more on my own and then he took me around again. I think mine was a staff member from the House and he was great, you know.
But I think having lived experience from the other side as well, or an ex-MP, I think would have enhanced that experience.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
I don't think for any of us there's a particular need for that. I mean, we had access to an ex-MP if we've got any questions anyway. The buddy was useful for walking us around in the first day and saying which room was where. But actually, it's a different sort of buddying we need after. It's somebody who absolutely knows their way around security vetting, getting staff set up on the system, running casework.
You know, all of these sorts of things. So it's an IPSA account manager who handholds you for months that is actually what you need, not a, from my perspective, not an ex-member or a buddy as per the first day.
Speaker 21
Thank you, Chair, and good morning both. You've touched on it a tiny bit, I think, in some of the excellent responses that you've given. But IPSA and some MPs have suggested a temporary pool of staff that could help new members before they recruit their own staff. Would either of you have used this?
Ann Celia Davies
Yes. Yeah, I think I would have done. Yeah, I think I would have done here. Although we have, we have a small pool of staff here with Plaid. We have six members of staff now, and they were fabulous, in fairness.
But it's constituency work, it's casework that just didn't get done to be honest for the first two or three months really. You tried, you know, tried very hard to get on top of it, but you physically couldn't do it on your own. So yes, I think we're done.
Speaker 21
And if there was this pool of staff, would the members have to be from the same political party as you? Or would you be perhaps happy to share a member of staff in that situation, temporary staff, or would you want a dedicated member of staff? How would that have worked?
Ann Celia Davies
I would have preferred a dedicated member of staff. I think they have to be of the same political leaning as you because your views and you've been elected with a political view in mind by your constituents. So they have to be of the same, you know, center-left. It would have to be a person that thinks in the same way as I do really, to be honest. What I would have wanted help with is casework and employment, you know, finding staff and that admin work really that took time to do.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
My feeling is slightly different. So yes, absolutely for a bank of staff, you know, people who are already on the system and can literally start helping you to answer those emails from the very first day would be really, really useful. In terms of political leaning, I think if somebody's kind of working in more of a parliamentary assistant sort of way, then yeah, they do need to at least have understanding and sympathy for your political perspective. But if somebody's doing casework for you, in my view, it's actually much more important to have experience of how to help people with housing queries or council issues or to understand the locality. And so I could absolutely see a situation in which even if in a particular locality, even if the MP's party changed, the people who were doing the casework, which is just about public service for individuals.
You know, my staff aren't members of the Green Party. In fact, I've no idea if any of them, well maybe one of them is, you know, out of many. People often, staffers often aren't members of a party. They often do work for different parties over time because so much of the skill is about public service to the constituents and helping them navigate through systems that have failed them in one form or or another. So I think it's that, it's that experience and understanding that means that if somebody writes in, you know, literally I had a constituent write in very quickly, say, you know, terminal illness, had updated the DWP, their benefits had been stopped completely and they needed just somebody to help them connect with the DWP.
That's not a political issue at all. So, yeah, I think a bank of staff would be really, really useful.
Speaker 21
Okay.
And practically, would you be happy for them to be working remotely or in a shared office space with you and perhaps other members? Is that very important?
Ann Celia Davies
The only thing I'd like to add, because my constituency has a high level of Welsh-speaking, first-language Welsh speakers, it's been really important for me within my permanent staff to have a Welsh-speaking team, because emails come in in both languages, and therefore having an understanding and a written and vocal competency within the Welsh language is really important. So, you know, apart from the political leanings, but having a Welsh-speaking team has been really important.
Speaker 23
Miles away. Um, listening to what you're saying. Um, I wondered about, to talk about your experience of setting up the constituency office and you've explained some of the difficulties. Um, would it have been helpful if you'd rented your predecessor's office?
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
My predecessor had his office in a building owned by the Conservative Party, so, which I don't think should be allowed to happen, so, so no, that wasn't an option. But, you know, if heaven forfend I am ever no longer the MP for North Herefordshire, then I think it would make sense for constituents for the office to remain the same and, you know, to have that continuity and for the MP to be able to inherit it, at least in the beginning as already set up.
It took us five months to get a landline phone number. Five months. And that was my constituency office manager, who was in place and, you know, for three months of that was tearing herself her hair out, and the person before that was trying. It was just ridiculous. Now, I know that Hannah's office has not had the same trouble getting a phone line.
Perhaps it's partly a rural-urban thing, but, you know, we're in a town of 12,000 people. We could not get a phone line installed.
Ann Celia Davies
And mine, mine was in Ammanford.
There's a Senedd office in Ammanford as well, so I just wanted to make sure that we had a visibility and that we were spread all over the constituency. So my office is now in Carmarthen, the Senedd member is in Ammanford. So we're spreading ourselves around the constituency, which makes it easier really for, for, for people to, to visit and come into a surgery wherever is suitable for them.
Alex Burghart
Thanks, Chair. Thank you. We know that other parliaments will involve their families, partners in the sort of induction process, maybe social gatherings and otherwise. So is that something you think would have been helpful? Maybe you'd like to see that or some sort of variation on that in respect of, you know, the induction in particular of new MPs?
Ann Celia Davies
I've shared Gareth's experience with you, my husband. He came up with me on the first day and we had a lovely gathering outside Victoria Gardens with the four of us. And then we came into Parliament, met up with my buddy. Gareth was put in a room, which I think is room M in Portcullis House. And he stayed there for three hours on his own without any food or drink, without nothing.
He was in that room. He didn't know where I was.
I knew where he was. The Plaid office thought he was with me, but he was in that room. And I thought that was, looking back, you know, that should have been dealt with a lot better than it was. You know, he's a grown man, he was fine. But, but you know, if you had young children and they had been put there, I sincerely hope they wouldn't have been put in there on their own, really.
And perhaps people thought other people would be there, but there was nobody there. He was there. So I, I think that really needs to be looked at, that if your partner or your children come with you, that they are, that they're looked after a bit better than, than he was. Yeah. So I missed that.
Alex Burghart
And do you think there's, sorry.
And do you think there should be an ongoing kind of element to that? And I don't mean locking them up in Room M every like Christmas time, but in terms of some other form of kind of interaction because of the kind of balance, the adjustment for our work-life balance, especially if it's a very different work style to what you've done before. It has its, you know, takes its toll on family, private life, and it's just is there some way to ameliorate that with, you know, the way Parliament kind of interact allows members and their families or, you know, immediate close ones to interact with this strange and wonderful place?
Ann Celia Davies
For us it wouldn't work because we have a farm, you know, we have cattle to milk. So, you know, that's that it wouldn't work for us. But I think for the vast majority of people having an invite at the end of each term, say at Christmas time or Easter or at the end of summer, where where partners can come for a gathering on the terrace or if there's something on in in Westminster Abbey that we can bring our partners with us to that would be lovely. Yeah.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Thank you, Ashleigh. My view's quite different. For me it's very low down on the list of priorities of things that that need improving. Um, yeah.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
No, no, it's just, you know, there are so many things about supporting us to better serve our constituents that for me are more of a priority than involving my family here. Yeah. Thank you. Thanks. Thanks, Alex.
Tessa.
Speaker 23
Okay, so we've just been talking, touched on children, and I was just going to ask what you feel the, those members who do have children, um, what the House might do immediately after the election and, and during one's time as an MP, and what information on childcare provision in Westminster would be helpful for, it says here candidates, I think probably for MPs, but yes.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
Um, so my children are now in their twenties, so it's not an issue, um, but I do have a colleague with younger children, primary-aged children, um, who says that childcare in Westminster is not relevant to them.
What is important to them is a timetable that enables them to spend as much time as possible in the constituency with their family. And so practical suggestions include no sitting Fridays, build private members' bills days into the normal Monday to Thursday parliamentary week, move sitting times on Wednesdays a couple of hours earlier so it's more practical for MPs to get home that evening if they don't have to be in Parliament on the Thursday if there are no votes or debates they're doing. And potentially consider moving the last two sitting hours on a Monday onto a Tuesday, starting Tuesdays two hours earlier, so the London-based MPs can get home with some evening left to spend with their children and all MPs and House staff don't start the week really tired.
Ann Celia Davies
Thank you.
I think that's excellent actually. The you know there is a crèche here which which I'm sure helps people with very young children but then trying to balance school life with here is very difficult. And on the other side as well you know being you you might be a carer for your elderly parents and having that balance needs needs to be addressed as well so it's not just about children but it's about the caring responsibilities of elderly parents and family members in general and partners.
Absolutely. So I would agree, I think those suggestions are brilliant. We have a system within the Plaid where, you know, some of us come in on Monday, some of us go back on Wednesday night, some of us then stay on Thursday. So we have a rota system which works well for us. So Llinos, for example, with two children, will leave on a Wednesday night.
So she's home Thursday and Friday. So that, but that's our, that's the way we've done it, you know, to try and accommodate.
Charalambos Charalambous
Yeah, what was your experience of the induction with IPSA and how easy was it to follow IPSA's processes and were there any areas that were unclear or could be improved?
Ann Celia Davies
Well, I've said my views. I think we need a one-to-one round table with your dedicated IPSA person rather than Zoom meetings would have been far more beneficial for me. The drop-ins on Wednesdays are great, but they can be there on Monday, Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursdays if they want, you know, especially at the beginning. And I was very lucky with Arlet. I think without him, I felt, I think I would have drowned really.
He was such an asset to me, such a help in having experience of working with Ben and knowing the system and such a huge support.
Eleanor Elizabeth Chowns
For me, I still find, so I'm now, my constituency office manager does a lot of the interaction with IPSA on my behalf now. Our chief of staff did a lot of that early on. I couldn't tell you who my IPSA account manager is, I'm afraid, which is a bad on me, but it kind of goes to show that there isn't a close, like a close link there. I still find these days, even though I'm quite organized with kind of bookmarking all of the useful places on the various parliamentary websites I need for security and IT and all the rest of it.
Actually, the thing that works is IT, because you ring them up and you say you've got an issue and they sort it for you immediately. With everything else, it feels like there's still a lot of navigating around to be done, and a lot of things that I keep having to try to remind myself about doing. The induction sessions with IPSA, I remember attending them because I had to, so it was a kind of tick-box thing, and I was paying attention, but I don't think I could recall anything specifically that I was told at that point. I'm not quite sure what the solution to it is, but it feels like the ongoing permanent relationship with somebody who hand-holds for you and who basically does a lot of stuff for you would be really good.
Nick Smith
Listen, that was a quick canter around the course and really grateful, Ellie and Ann, for your evidence. It was really worthwhile and it'll be included in our wider report. So thank you for your time this morning.
My pleasure.
Nick Smith
No problem. Okay, so while the shuffle's occurring, I can see our next panel members, John and Sarah, are good to go. Do you want to change the nameplates?
Speaker 35
Thanks both. I'm really grateful for your time. I'm going to have to ask you to canter through this section because the last one did go on longer than we'd planned, but I know that you both sat in diligently hearing what colleagues had to say, so I think that'll help us all now. Can you please introduce yourselves?
Madeleine Sarah Smith
Yeah, I'm Sarah Smith, I'm the Labour MP elected in 2024 in Hyndburn in East Lancashire.
John Slinger
And I'm John Slinger, the Labour MP for Rugby, and I was elected in July 2024 as well.
Nick Smith
Welcome both. Tell us about your experiences of the induction process, including the new members' reception area, the chamber briefings, and the other induction sessions in the committee rooms, please.
John Slinger
Well, as colleagues in the first session mentioned, I want to start by saying thank you, a huge thank you to the staff of the House. And they clearly had put a lot of thought into what they provided and it was very helpful. But I would say that there was information overload and there was a default of having clearly thought about the kind of information we would need, but assuming that by providing maybe a brochure or a quick briefing meeting or a hyperlink, more often than not a hyperlink. You know, the information is there, it's on this hyperlink.
And you click on the hyperlink and there's, you know, 40 pages of detailed advice. And so it was completely overwhelming. And I think as colleagues have already said, you're doing a new role that you'd given some thought to, but no one can prepare you for it. You're trying to deal with how to operate as an MP here. You're thinking already about employing staff.
You're trying to work out accommodation for yourself, looking for an office, dealing with the register of members' interests and on and on, security, and it goes on and on.
So while it was very helpful and thoughtfully put together, I still felt that it could have been improved, perhaps by, in my view, providing not just the buddy, although mine was excellent, but someone who could carry out, I would say, PA or secretarial support from the get-go, really, so that there was someone there to help you with all of this, because you're, as I said, you're doing multiple things simultaneously every hour of the day for the first month at least, and you really do feel completely alone. And I think just providing a range of information in written, in paper or online form really doesn't help the individual who is going through the process.
Madeleine Sarah Smith
And for myself, navigating that holding a four-month-old baby brought a whole range of other challenges that I believe will come to a little bit further within some of the things that you're keen to learn from this session. But when I reflect on what I can remember of those first two weeks, and frankly I was also barely sleeping, so forgive me that I may have forgotten more details than some other colleagues.
The, you know, we've all got different learning styles, unfortunately, that's the truth. And so there's not quite a perfect answer in this, and I recognize the huge efforts that are done by the House staff and I'm sure previous committees, etc., to put together what we did have when we came in in July 2024. I think there's an opportunity to simplify what we needed in that first week or two and challenge the prioritization, work with the whips to ensure that completing some of the lesser priority in week one or two still gets done, because I absolutely acknowledge that then you get pulled into the machine of government, of Parliament, and it can be then hard to prioritize going back to sort of complete some of the foundations that you need.
But I think if you worked with the whips in making those mandatory and having the whips, you know, ensure that their members do do satisfy those criteria, you could, you could extend that program not just within the first two weeks, but perhaps over that first month or six. I also found some of the specific challenges. So that, for example, we were such a big intake, sometimes it would take two committee rooms to get us all in and then the tech wouldn't work.
So if you came into the second room, you know, you found you couldn't access the session, or it took 20 minutes to fix that, and so you'd miss half of it. So just kind of like making sure that if we have another big intake, some of that's been worked through and the tech support's available to fix what should be quite basic issues. And I absolutely, by the way, would underline that even though it was the hardest couple of weeks of my life, I don't deny that it's a positive wherever possible for people to be physically present for those couple of weeks, because it is so instructive in establishing yourself, and it's about as much about relationship building as it is about information loading.
However, having virtual hybrid options whilst still making it, you know, pretty encouraged that you are here most of the time, at least would give those of us who had the challenges and it wouldn't have just been me of sitting physically in that room still able to access the information because that was that was not possible. You basically still had to be in the room to receive the information.
I remember one of the sessions that was probably the most impactful, and that was the one they did around the code of conduct. That was a fabulous session, and I thought really well delivered. I remember still to this day, I'm not sure that every MP from every party attended it sadly, but I do think there's learning from that particular session and how it was delivered. Could there be a bit more variation in some of the other sessions as well? You know, again around sort of like how we remember things is partly about how it's delivered to us, and maybe we can challenge how some of the delivery was done to help it embed in people's minds a little bit more.
I think some of the essentials in the early weeks, I realize I think in your consultations some questions were asked about when you access your laptop for example and your emails.
I do think that okay it's overwhelming but you have to be able to be plugged into that because the first thing is people want to be able to invite you or add things to your calendar or whatever it is and fundamentally that is the best way to do that. I think understanding the estate and being able to get around it is one of the key skills you need to learn. That didn't happen for me because I couldn't meet the buddy on the day I was supposed to and frankly I don't think I only ever met my buddy once. It didn't work for me that particular issue. But I think understanding the estate, having a space to be able to base yourself and get some work done, knowing what support's available to you, understanding the IPSA offer, finances, HR is important in that first week and the chamber etiquette session was really, really good and really, really important.
Then I think some of the stuff around your pensions, the legislative process, how you hire and how you set up your office. Hiring and setting up an office is the first question people are asking, so I think you have to start talking about that in week one. But the legislative process, pensions and some of the other things I think could easily be pushed back further.
John Slinger
Yes, to add that an analogy that I would use is imagine being appointed as a head teacher having never been a teacher before. It's a slight exaggeration, but and then being told that you have no secretary or PA, you have no immediate staff, you have no physical office apart from maybe a desk in a busy hot room somewhere. And here is a load of brochures telling you about how to be a head teacher, all your legal responsibilities, all your duties. Now you, while also teaching lessons or managing the new team that you've never met before, have to learn and do all of these things simultaneously.
So that's the analogy. So I wonder whether there is something around professionalizing the training that we receive. And while I completely accept Sarah's point about being here physically is wonderful, it's exciting, it's important, and it almost has to be an information overload because people are coming at this with different levels of experience of this place and of politics. But could we not, could the House authorities not think about something like an Institute for Government training outside of this place? You know, maybe two or three days away, away from the sheer chaos of what has to be chaos, organized chaos, brilliantly organized.
Is that something we could consider? But I think it almost goes a little bit above all of our pay grades because it's a role without a job description, perhaps save one page on the website. And given there's no job description, it's quite hard to know how to train you to do it. But I think we all know collectively that there are things that we would have benefited from knowing and to have been able to absorb them in a more rational and professional way would have been good.
Marie Rimmer
Yeah, we talked, we've already heard quite a bit about email accounts and laptops and computer usage, and Sarah, you've already touched on it a little bit as well. You heard the previous session. Do you want to add anything in about the deluge of emails that you've received and the importance of having a laptop early or not, as the case may be?
Madeleine Sarah Smith
I think having the laptop is, is needed. And if you took it away from people, you can just imagine the next session you'd hear would be everybody saying, "I can't believe you wouldn't let us into our emails for four days," or whatever you decide the cutoff is. I think there's some expectation management for people as they come in, saying you are, and we did get it a little bit, I think, you know, you're going to get hundreds of emails, you don't have to answer them all.
But I think this more importantly is the question of how we could better provide earlier staff support for the new intake. And I know it's been talked about quite a lot around that sort of creating a pool of available and experienced staff that could be, you know, a temporary hire for the new intake of MPs. And then you can immediately have somebody who can at least start to organize your inbox. So that then when you get your staff in place, the staff can start to start from, you know, hit the ground running. And within that, the expertise of that person next to you, they can start to say to you, these are the three you actually do need to think about this week.
Because any effective MP office, you know, the MP is dealing with a directly with a chosen number of the whole intake of emails. And getting the MP working in that way early is a better way to tackle the problem of that overwhelm.
John Slinger
Yeah, well I agree with all of that.
I do think that the key thing would be to help us prioritize the inbox. I don't think you can, much as I would have liked there to have been a delay of a few days, I think from a democratic representation perspective, your new constituents, you are their MP, they just voted for you, you have to have it switched on.
But it's about the support that you receive. And you know, we had zero support, if I'm honest, absolutely zero. And at that point, day one, you have no training. If someone emails you about some terrible situation that they or their children or whoever are suffering, you can only try and deal with it in the best way you can amid all the other things you're doing. So I would say merely having a PA or a secretary, or maybe even a former member or a former researcher.
Perhaps there are people who've been MPs here who want to help newly elected MPs, and their experience and just going through an inbox, categorizing things, would be invaluable and would have taken away a huge amount of stress.
And I'm pretty certain I'm not alone in that stress being quite overwhelming, because colleagues who are more experienced would say things to you like, oh, you know, I wouldn't necessarily feel you have to go through your dot MP email account. But when you're a newly elected MP, immediately and every day, because, you know, you really want to get to a situation where the important things are coming to you on a daily basis. Well, you cannot do that when you've just been elected and you're seeing all these emails coming in.
You have to respond and without that secretarial support it is, it actually I found it impossible. I would dedicate an hour or two a day to it and it was totally impossible to get through the emails because there were so many of them.
Marie Rimmer
And as a very quick follow-up to that then, do you think that there's a danger that by not providing the support that has been asked for in this way in those early days that some constituents might be put actually at risk because of the things they might be contacting you about but actually might get buried in the inbox because you're not getting the support that you need to go through them?
John Slinger
Yeah, I think that touches on another above our pay grades point which is the point around the extent to which MPs have any legal responsibility.
For example, if someone's coming to you with a matter of, you know, legal jeopardy or child protection issues and so on, you don't have any legal, as I understand it, responsibility, but you have a duty, I think, a moral duty to try and help them. So absolutely there is a risk that that could be lost.
And I was very conscious of as I was going through the emails, trying to pick out the ones where this was someone essentially crying for help or making an appeal for help in extreme circumstances. But yeah, there is that, there absolutely is that risk, for sure.
Charalambos Charalambous
You've both mentioned the buddying system that was set up when you became MPs. We've had feedback from MPs that they've said they would welcome the chance to have a buddy who was a returned MP. Do you think that would be helpful and do you have any thoughts about how best to deal with ad hoc questions that you may have had when you got elected?
Madeleine Sarah Smith
Yeah, so I think on the buddying opportunity, as I say, for me, the way it was set up with staff didn't work on this occasion. It was theoretically for one day. That just, I wasn't able to attend, I wasn't there on time that day because I was breastfeeding or something. And I really think that we need both somebody from the, from the House side that is more freed up to do a little bit more with us over that first few weeks. And the reality was for my buddy, they were excellent, but they had another job and this was obviously like a bit of a tag-on that they thought would take a couple of hours and it couldn't really quite flex to when I was available and things like that.
But I think even more helpfully, to speak to former members about buddying seems the most obvious opportunity. These people are probably often really keen to give back if they, if they were asked, if they wanted to.
And I think within buddying with existing members, actually it's a really probably a good opportunity potentially to do that cross-party. And you know, those early days, because I think when you come in, you're obviously, you're often kind of consumed by your party. And certainly when there were so many of us in our intake, it was that much energy trying to get to know our own lot. You don't, you miss potentially that opportunity to start build relationships on the other side of the house, which we know is so essential to how we operate as a, as a parliament. So I would certainly, you know, I'd think consider, you know, there's, there's sort of three groups where there could be some buddying.
And maybe, you know, there's a choice for new members about which of those they want to work with.
I'm not saying everybody wants all three, but it would be good to have that option.
John Slinger
Yeah, I agree with that and I do think actually to your point, Bambos, that former MPs helping newly elected MPs would be useful because I think they have learned as, as our chair has said, he's still learning 16 years in.
So that shows you how difficult it can be if you're 16 days in. So absolutely. But I'd just if I may chair just add that I think constituents absolutely have a right to a professional service from day one. So really the system ought to help us provide them with that professional service. And just as we are in the process when we're newly elected of learning what our responsibilities are and how to make it work.
The other thing I just want to flag is that no one although there is a disclaimer on the email as I recall that says this is a newly elected MP they are very busy, you know, etc. Without wanting to sound too defensive, that was great. But really no one is properly educating the public and I'm not blaming them for this but they don't know how the system works.
They don't know, for example, that you don't have an office in your constituency. They assume, the number of people who asked me, "Oh, you'll be just taking over the former Conservative member's office?" No, I won't be. I don't have an office yet. So there is a role, I think, for all of us and the system to educate the public to help them understand how they can get the best out of a system as it adapts to a huge intake of new members.
Speaker 21
Thank you, Chair. You touched on a little bit about the pool of temporary staff for new members. First of all, would you have used it? And how would you have wanted somebody dedicated to you, someone you could share? What kind of things would you have wanted that person to be able to help you with?
And would you want them to be, could you work with them remotely or need to be with them in the one-to-one situation?
Madeleine Sarah Smith
Yes, so I was in exceptionally kind of fortunate and not everyone had this that I was able to find some staff back in the constituency quite quickly because of a situation on my neighboring seat where the Labour MP lost their seat and so there was some well-qualified staff, you know, looking looking for the job. But down here I had nothing and to have that pool staff available that I could have on day one hired for two months, you know, who I knew had some skill sets in organizing my inbox, supporting me a little bit with my comms, helping me get my office set up here and advising back in the constituency, particularly if you had new staff coming in up in the constituency and to do a bit of diary management. And just to help you have those things, you know, in motion who could then also say to you, if you can't get to this induction session, I'll go and make sure we get the notes and bring them back to you or this is where else you'll be able to find that information and I'll make sure you get it.
Yes.
And if you need to get to committee room 3A, this is where it is. You know, that I would have, I wouldn't have minded which party they'd worked for previously or really anything else. I just would want somebody that I could trust to crack on, give me some good advice on those basic tasks, and it would have made a world of difference.
John Slinger
Yeah, I agree, absolutely, Mary.
The only thing I'd also add is that the pressure to respond to the very legitimate pressure that you feel from your constituents and other organisations, but most importantly constituents, means that you're, all of us were under immense pressure to hire. And hiring under pressure is the absolute worst possible kind of hiring, isn't it? I've been very fortunate with the people that I hired. I went through a proper process which took time, but I'm very conscious of how some colleagues made fairly quick hires to deal with the deluge, and it didn't necessarily work out.
Speaker 47
So that's in no one's interests, not ours and more importantly not our constituents'.
Bob Blackman
A couple of quick questions. I sorry, I don't know your backgrounds, but I just wonder if you've got a background in any form of government before, local government, because one of the issues is obviously if you don't have any background at all, coming into this place is a real, oh God. I just wonder what preparation did you make when you were selected as a candidate to consider what you'd need to do if you were elected?
Madeleine Sarah Smith
So I had briefly been a, so I'd done a little bit of local government, I'd been a councillor for a quite short period of time.
I was a sort of appointed, I became the candidate a month before the general election and at that point my baby was three months old. So some of the kind of what preparation was I able to do as a candidate was very, very little in that, in that final period. Obviously I'd thought previously about what the reality of being a Member of Parliament would entail, but I had come into politics on purpose not seeking to work here before I was elected because I wanted to bring a different type of experience from my experience in the charity sector working in and at the frontline with communities on how we bring about change. And so that meant I fundamentally, no, I didn't realize and understand the sitting hours and how they worked and fully, you know, understand what all of those demands were going to look like.
Now, no doubt if I'd been selected earlier as the candidate, the party probably would have taken me on that journey. In my particular circumstance, I wasn't able to access that, and I'm sure some individuals might come in without having accessed that information as well. So I do think in that first, even that first weekend, getting a bit of a sense of that as early as possible so that you can talk that through in a bit more detail with your partners, etc., is quite important.
Bob Blackman
So in terms of, for example, acquiring a constituency office, what was your experience in achieving that?
Madeleine Sarah Smith
So, yeah, so that I was fortunate to work with, um, as I say, have somebody quite experienced come into my constituency team, but it was a massive fight for them, even though they had that experience of doing it before. We had to move office, uh, from the previous, just due to location, a few other things. The biggest challenge we faced was around create, uh, finding an accessible office, um, because that was important to me, obviously, and just in many towns and high streets, you know, like mine, that's very rarely available. So, um, we ended up obviously using some of the budget to be able to create and put in a ramp and do all the sorts of things to the office. Um, that's not something really I realize you guys can fix, but, uh, I think potentially the idea of moving to the, to a model where, you know, you're not, each MP isn't getting, needing to get a new office would be a positive one.
The limitation my office have found with working with IPSA to transfer over the pilot to transfer our lease into IPSA's hands is that we can't under those terms do a sublet with our with anybody. And it's quite normal that MPs do work in some way with their local parties in that sort of arrangement. So we were looking to explore that pilot and we've actually decided not on that basis.
John.
John Slinger
Yeah, thanks Bob. I have a private sector consulting background for the previous 17 or so years, but I was a councillor for two years prior to being selected as the Labour candidate for Rugby and 20 years ago I'd worked here for Labour MPs.
So I felt that I had a better than average understanding of how this place worked. And I think I did have a better than average understanding, but I think I probably speak for other colleagues in saying that there is nothing like actually being elected to focus the mind and there is nothing like actually being here to realise just how enormous the role is and multifaceted the role is.
So I did have some, but it wasn't enough. And then I think what your question is getting at is the preparation that we can all do psychologically and practically probably in the if you think you have a chance of being elected. I think the problem with that is that the certainly in a seat like mine, which was a marginal seat, the amount of effort that you all we all put in is so enormous and completely overwhelming. And it has to be because that's the nature of, you know, the political competition. And that's that's okay.
Bob Blackman
But that does mean that you really do not have much chance to sit and contemplate what you would do. And finally from me, what experience did you have of people coming to you who maybe had gone to your predecessors and perhaps, shall we say, not got a very satisfactory response, and suddenly there's a new MP, I'll try them, see if they can actually do something for me?
Madeleine Sarah Smith
We had some of that, and so I arranged with my predecessor, as I know we were recommended to do this, we arranged to sit down and do a, she got approval to transfer some cases over to us, and we did go through that process. But there were other cases that came to us that had had some previous experience that maybe they hadn't seen the email to confirm the handover or whatever, and they were making some issue with that.
The, yeah, you know, I think that's the opportunity of a new MP and the new team is to take on some of that challenge and, you know, that is, that is how sort of change, the changeover can happen.
Bob Blackman
Particularly true in terms of dealing with the local authorities. Because unless you've got those arrangements set up quickly, you're going to get overloaded with stuff which probably, arguably, is not an MP's job, but...
Bob Blackman
We could get into a whole other discussion, I think, on that. No, no, but the reason why I asked that question is obviously we're looking at preparations for the future and guidance that can be given to both candidates and also preparations for the House when people are elected.
John Slinger
Yeah, that would be... sorry. No, no, you go. So that would be very helpful in the future. For example, knowing what the previous MP's process was, for example, with flagging issues regarding your local council that constituents feel haven't been dealt with properly.
So in my case, I have a particular route in which works, but that did take a good month to get to. I do wonder whether it's been touched on before, but I'll mention it again. Having in the constituency a permanent, almost a civil servant per constituency whose role is, I just flag this as a suggestion, there are pros and cons, but who would be in potentially also a permanent office that transfers between MPs because so many people just assume that the state essentially is what we're talking about here provides for this service that they, the public, understandably expect. And there isn't one. There is not an office.
The moment you're elected, there is no physical office. It doesn't exist. There is no staff. There are no staff. It is just you.
And I think that might be worth thinking about, someone who can provide some continuity, who knows exactly how the systems work, knows how to get things like phones put in properly and, you know, can call upon the right kind of support because it does feel that it does really feel as the newly elected member that it is on your shoulders. All of that stuff right down, as colleagues were saying earlier, right down to phoning the phone company or, you know, that kind of thing.
You do end up doing it's from the sublime to the ridiculous, from the exciting to the utterly mundane. And it's stuff that frankly, it's not about being grand and high and mighty, it's stuff that takes you away from the job. Takes you away from that inbox with people who potentially are in peril or worried about things. You shouldn't be doing it.
Nick Smith
Oh, this we all remember the difficulty of in our first few days having to do some sort of social services emergency and not being able and having the tools available to demonstrate to action. Gosh, Alex.
Alex Burghart
Thanks, Chair. So we know other parliaments will run induction programs or have social gatherings for members' families, immediate close ones, and so just wondered what respectively you thought about both the kind of induction process because of the kind of tumult this new way of working introduces to one's personal life, and then what kind of on a kind of ongoing basis, if if anything, you think that parliament could do better in respect of trying to bring in members' kind of close family, immediate close family, to sort of share what is the kind of weird and wonderful way that this place works. Thank you both.
Madeleine Sarah Smith
Yeah, absolutely.
And look, I think, you know, if we're going to have the most diverse and representative Parliament, we've got to continue to make the case for families, for people from all walks of life as to how being in this place can work for them. And frankly, you know, we know the statistics around the impact this place has on people's mental health, on their families, on divorce rates, on addiction levels, is truly hor- you know, is truly horrifying.
And particularly as well when you add the increased level of attack that particular groups of MPs come under on social media and in mainstream media, it's becoming a harder and harder job I think for parties across the spectrum to persuade candidates to stand. And I think that this is part of tackling that problem. I would think it would be a great idea to invite other halves into this place, whether it's once a year or a couple of times in that first year.
So Speaker, for example, does put on some children's parties at Christmas and at a couple of times in the year, which is lovely and an opportunity that the plus-ones can also come to those. But that excludes those that don't have children. And why can't we have something that might just be for the adults, for example, as well? Because how often do MPs and their other halves get to have a date night and things like that? We know it's pretty rare.
And so, you know, like let's encourage and support families on this to be a really, really good example, as we want employers across the country to be.
And I do think whether it's with Speaker or other parts of the House that that could be offered and very much in the kind of cross-party spirit.
John Slinger
Absolutely. As ever, I agree with Sarah in the things that she's said. And I would add that your family, especially your spouse and to some extent your children, but definitely your spouse, they're making enormous sacrifices which is hard to comprehend before you get elected. It's hard for you to comprehend, it's hard for them to comprehend and predict. So that's another thing that really ought to be flagged more to candidates.
But they are, they suffer quite a few indignities as a result of you having made this decision. And you are serving your constituents and ultimately your country and you've chosen to do it, but they didn't choose it. And they are also by extension serving.
So I think they need to feel part of the team. And so bringing them into that team. And I do feel that this place, one of the greatest things about it is when we're out of the argy-bargy pantomime stuff in the chamber, actually we are colleagues and often friends across party. And the House staff are wonderful, from the doorkeepers to the officers of committees like this.
And we do feel a bit like a family. But it's ironic that your own family doesn't feel part of that. And it's a shame because as I said they are sacrificing a lot and sometimes suffering and they would benefit from being brought into the fold. It would help a huge amount.
Marie Rimmer
Thank you. Very quickly move on to childcare. How do you think the House should support members who have young children both immediately after the election and during their time as an MP? And what if any information on childcare provision in Westminster would be helpful for candidates?
Madeleine Sarah Smith
Yes. So I'm going to indulge slightly and just explaining what that first couple of weeks was really like for me.
So I was elected on the Thursday, and then we had to work out by the Monday both like where we were going to stay. And there are some specific allowances that need to be considered for anybody that might come in in future in my position. And I think that's with a baby particularly under six months, but I think arguably even under a year. Because if you're still on maternity and you're working with a and you're you know, your baby is up several times a night. We had to yeah, so we had to work out where we were going to stay.
We had to obviously put everything into the car. There was no way the train was realistic. For us, it's kind of like a five it's a five-hour drive if we don't have to stop, but with a baby you have to stop. So realistically it was an eight or nine-hour drive for me each way in that first couple of weeks.
Fortunately my husband's job gave him the flexibility to come down with me. We had to work out everything that we needed, pack it in the car, um, you know, spend that whole of the Sunday getting here, um, set everything up in an Airbnb which fortunately like we were able to find and source, um, and then and then turn up here with a very unclear sense of like what the week was actually going to look like, what I had to be in, what I actually had to be in. Like none of that was, I couldn't, I couldn't discern or understand as a newbie. And then at times in that first week I left my baby screaming with one of my friends who was kind enough to come and sit in one of the rooms that was made available for us, um, which is pretty heartbreaking because apparently I had to be in whatever session.
I remember like when I had to even the swearing in, like literally kind of because he needed to feed at that moment and I but I had to be in that queue at that moment, like leaving him in the family room with somebody else and like dashing in to do that moment. It was all quite traumatic in a way. And there are ways that it could have been made easier. I think I think for the situation that may occur again, for there to be have been some consideration of some local accommodation that would meet a family's needs.
So we needed a living area, right? Like, it wasn't realistic that we could just be in a hotel room. So we'd sorted our own B&B. But fundamentally, you can either find that in a hotel and it costs a bit more, but I think that should be covered, or you could find a local Airbnb and say to a person in that situation, "Here's one that we've identified and it meets the budget criteria." The other specific thing was that the budget obviously only covered me down here for the nights that I was needed to be here, as I understood it.
So that meant we had to pack everything up, do the drive back, and do it back into another place for the second week. I think that was entirely unnecessary, and it should have been outlined to me that in my situation, a reasonable adjustment was that this was your location for the two weeks.
Choose whether you want to do the dash up and down or just stay down for that first couple of weeks to do this process and save yourself that pain and that whatever. I think you could have recommended like a nanny agency. They exist. It took me some time to find them down here because I in the end depended after the first week it was so awful. My mum very kindly brought herself down here and she also stayed with us.
And she, you know, supported me through that second week. Not everybody's mum can do that. So there could have been, I think, different options. I was then told I didn't have a nursery space. So I had to intervene.
The Leader of the House had to intervene to make sure I secured that a few months later when my baby was six, seven months old. And I think everyone in that situation, there should be a sort of reasonable adjustment conversation when they first announce, you know, in that first phone call with the House about having a small baby. A conversation about what the reasonable adjustment is for accommodation, support in terms of like how they could access some immediate childcare. And then I think they should have the right to meet with the Leader of the House, because it was the Leader of the House that then was able to fix the things I faced into.
And and I think and I think that that was a chance. I knew Lucy, um, you know, and so I immediately reached out to her. But another newbie might not have known that that was the route to getting the kind of intervention support that you needed. I think also that within the kind of conversation around induction, again, I think the leader and a whip and a senior whip within your party as well, I think should have that meeting and then give you real advice as to like, okay, if you really have to narrow down what you have to attend, here are the things to do your best to get to. The other thing that never happened, and I realize it was because of the like legal framework, but no one ever discussed with me like an option of kind of maternity leave.
Now, I realize that was because I was coming into the job when my bit, you know, all of those, we've changed it all now a little bit on that, but it was never actually mentioned to me, for example, that I would get my proxy vote.
Now it, it wasn't a big deal because of the timings, came in in July, did the first two weeks, it was then pretty much straight into conference recess and I actually started in the October. But if that election had been called in January, would I have had the conversation to say you can get the two months of proxy, how, I don't know if that would have kicked off that conversation, but it should be expected that if you're coming in in that first six months you can have the conversation about your proxy and make sure that you're not feeling like you should be here when you don't have to be.
And then as well I think in that as I say slightly exceptional circumstance on that return to work the House should offer a bit of a sort of refresh and induction and support in those first few weeks. I was just back in it like full on settling into the nursery and trying to catch up and it could have been a bit more supportive.
John Slinger
Well my children are significantly older than Sarah's so I don't really have anything to add to what Sarah said. I'm just sorry that she had to go through that and other colleagues. And we really do need people like Sarah in this place and we need new mums to feel that they can become MPs and so it's incumbent upon the system to make sure that that support is provided. It's as simple as that otherwise we will not have new mums wanting to go through all of this and that would be bad for democracy.
Speaker 52
Colleagues, I want to end today by thanking you for talking to us and answering our questions.
John Slinger
Can I just, sorry, if you're wrapping up, can I make one point, if that's okay, Chair, very quickly? I do think that parents of teenage children perhaps could benefit from, in a subtle way, for them to be brought into the fold somewhat. Because I think teenage years can be challenging.
And while I know that thought has been given to this by the authorities, more perhaps could have been proactively offered. Maybe it was, but in the deluge of information I and others may have missed it. But I do think they could do with particularly around social media and just how to manage this very bizarre thing that's happened where their mom or their dad becomes this person with a very bizarre new role. That's the only thing I would add. Sorry to interrupt.
Speaker 52
Yeah, no, bizarre captures it beautifully. So thank you for talking to us and answering our questions. You've given us a lot to think about as we set the scene for this inquiry and plan for further sessions, so we're very grateful. We will now conclude this session. Thank you.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.