morning II - Competitiveness Council
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Live capture
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Council of the European Union
Follow its sittingsTeresa Ribera Rodriguez
Healthy competition is still a key element to allow the right players to grow, invest and succeed. A merger may also allow a small innovative company to scale up more quickly and bring its innovation to the market. This is something that we want to promote. When a small company is not bought by a dominant player, it could benefit from what we are calling an innovation shield, a commitment that I introduced during the last time we met.
But when innovation is at risk, as in killer acquisitions, we will not shy away from intervention. So on one side, we want to protect these innovative companies counting on a shield, and at the very same time, we think that it is important to prevent acquisitions that may kill innovation. The third element that is being reflected in the current draft guidelines is sustainability. Many industries are investing in decarbonization and green solutions, shifting market dynamics. Merger control can contribute to a more sustainable Europe.
The draft guidelines therefore explain how we will consider sustainability as a parameter of competition. This includes support measures that allow firms to develop novel green technologies and opposing those that reduce the choice of green products. Lastly, we comment on resilience. In times of geopolitical uncertainty, as the president has underscored, EU business depends on an internal market that is robust enough to absorb shocks. Mergers can have positive or negative effects on resilience, and both must be looked at during our merger assessment.
For example, a merger can create a single point of failure or eliminate a supplier of key inputs to European customers. But a merger can also secure access to inputs, for example through vertical integration.
The draft guidelines provide guidance on how the Commission assesses both positive and negative resilience effects. This is a very relevant element in today's global political environment and something that has been demanded by business, but also by governments. What we will not change is the core mission of merger control: ensuring effective competition in Europe for the benefit of our business and citizens.
Many Europeans are concerned about the rising cost of living. Merger control is an important tool to help keep prices in check. And we are therefore also sharpening our focus on affordability, including new ways to identify harm to competition on labor markets. In terms of process, we have conducted an extensive and open consultation over the past year, listening to hundreds of stakeholders: European industrials, SMEs, startups, non-European players, civil society groups, and experts from many disciplines, including leading competition lawyers, Nobel laureate economists, and academics.
This open consultation process is currently ongoing on the draft test that we have published. It is an inclusive approach that will help us to adopt a new framework that is predictable, impartial, and transparent. I thank you very much for your attention, and I take this opportunity also to share my gratitude towards your national competition authorities that have been deeply engaged in the work up to now.
Speaker 1
Thank you very much for this presentation. Before giving the floor to delegations, please let me remind you that AOB items are for information purposes only. I will give the floor now to delegations, we have Finland.
Speaker 3
Yeah, thanks Chair, Commissioner, and dear colleagues. The common non-paper presented by Czech Republic, Estonia, Finland, Ireland, Latvia, Romania, and Slovenia at the Competitiveness Council in February highlights our views on effective competition policy and merger control.
In the Commission's draft merger guidelines, we we notice that the proposal introduces a number of new elements to the analytical framework. It is important that such amendments safeguard the fundamental purpose of merger control, which is to ensure that mergers do not cause significant impediments to effective competition. We welcome that this draft revision does not seem to undermine this purpose. So thank you.
Sébastien Martin
Merci Monsieur le Président, Madame la Commissaire. Vraiment je salue le projet de lignes directrices sur les concentrations révisées qui présente des avancées très positives vers une meilleure prise en compte des enjeux et des évolutions économiques depuis maintenant plus de 20 ans. Enfin nous allons favoriser la croissance des entreprises et leur envergure internationale plutôt que la fragmentation au bénéfice court terme d'un consommateur ensuite soumis à des multinationales étrangères ultra-compétitives et je crois que ça a été le fil rouge de nos débats tout au long de cette matinée.
La France appelle donc de ses vœux à suivre l'exemple de la création d'Airbus plutôt que l'interdiction à une époque de la concentration Alstom-Siemens, notamment dans le cas de l'examen en cours de la concentration dans le domaine des satellites qui là aussi est un domaine stratégique sur lequel nous devons compter des acteurs importants.
Speaker 8
Gracias, intervendré en español. Gracias a la vicepresidenta ejecutiva por la presentación. España valora muy positivamente el esfuerzo que la Comisión está haciendo con el amplio y transparente proceso de consultas y debate que está teniendo tanto con los Estados miembros como con las empresas para adaptar estas directrices.
Nuestra valoración de las líneas generales presentadas por la vicepresidenta ejecutiva sobre innovación, escala, sostenibilidad y resiliencia no puede ser más que positiva. Esta modificación ha sido largamente esperada y ha sido solicitada por empresas y Estados miembros, incluido España, y es coherente con los informes de Draghi y Letta. Como se indica en el non-paper español presentado por el presidente del Gobierno en marzo sobre competitividad, la política de competencia debe adaptarse de manera pragmática, permitiendo que las empresas líderes europeas alcancen la escala necesaria para competir a nivel mundial e invertir en innovación sin comprometer la competencia efectiva ni el bienestar de los consumidores.
Speaker 9
Thank you very much chair. We welcome the revision of the merger guidelines. The Commission is accommodating the needs of companies in challenging political circumstances while also protecting competition, supporting sustainability and incorporating existing case law and practice. And this effective competition increases competitiveness and spurs innovation. While we should be mindful of and find solutions to increased and maybe also sometimes unfair competition from outside Europe, this cannot unconditionally justify decrease of competitions between undertakings within Europe because that would actually only make us weaker in the longer term.
So, we urge the Commission to keep the varying interests at the center of merger control, ensuring a balanced future-proof framework that strengthens our single market and also makes sure that it doesn't force our SMEs, for example, to accept higher prices or lower quality for input in their products. Thank you very much.
Speaker 10
Grazie Presidente. L'Italia condivide l'iniziativa della Commissione che va nella giusta direzione. Se il mondo cambia devono adeguarsi anche le regole, tra cui quelle sulle fusioni.
Abbiamo già avuto modo di in più occasioni di segnalare la strategicità della revisione delle linee guida anche nei rapporti bilaterali con altri Stati membri. L'Europa e il suo tessuto industriale non possono competere con altre aree del mondo se non si dotano di imprese di taglia idonea a tener testa alla competizione globale. Ciò vale in particolare nei settori più strategici, quali l'industria della difesa, lo spazio, le tecnologie di frontiera. È parimenti essenziale costruire intorno ad esse filiere di forniture e catene di valore sicure ed europee a fine di de-risking, il cui il capofiliera traina l'ecosistema.
Ne abbiamo validi esempi in Italia e in Europa ed è la strada che dobbiamo perseguire. Grazie.
Teresa Ribera Rodriguez
Just two words to express my gratitude for the comments and we'll try to do our best to reflect in the final version the comments being expressed by the ministers and also to reflect the comments that we will be assessing in the coming weeks being provided by the different stakeholders during the public consultation terms. Thanks a lot.
Speaker 1
Thank you very much.
So we take note of the information provided during this discussion. The colleagues will now continue with our next AOB point. The Netherlands, Czech Republic, Germany, Latvia, Luxembourg, Poland, Slovakia and Spain have shared with us a paper on the topic of undertakings in difficulty and how they must be addressed under the General Block Exemption Regulation. I will now immediately give the floor to the Netherlands.
Speaker 9
Thank you very much, Chair. The Netherlands urges the Commission to revise the definition of undertakings in difficulty. And we've sent a joint statement and I want to thank the colleagues for the collaboration in sending this paper to the Commission.
The core actually is that the first draft of the revised GBER does not really reflect the financing and growth realities of what we all want: startups, scale-ups, innovative SMEs. Right, this will not solve their problems. On the other hand, we do recognize that a clear demarcation is needed. And so we call upon the Commission, basically as a proposal of a solution, two things. First, to broaden the scope of what we would consider own funds by adding quasi-equity instruments that are economically equivalent actually to equity but just take a slightly different form, but in the end in principle they actually are equivalent to own funds and should be calculated as such in the context of the definition of these undertakings.
And additionally, we propose introducing some broader exemptions to the UID definition, for example, an exemption for aid for environmental protection in section six of the GBER. I think this also very much connects to the previous discussion we had and the previous discussions we had today about combining competitiveness, resilience, and sustainability as they are also aligned. And for this, these SMEs, startups, and scale-ups are absolutely vital. The challenge is urgent with EU competitiveness under pressure in a hardening geopolitical environment, so we really have to take action to tackle this barrier that limits the growth potential of what we really need, these most innovative companies.
Teresa Ribera Rodriguez
Thank you, thank you so much to you all and the presidency, but in particular to the member states that have submitted this comprehensive and constructive comments note in the context of the revision of the General Block Exemption Regulation and the revision of the rescue and restructuring guidelines, including the joint letter from you on how to best define the undertakings in difficulty. You know that in this process, being open for public consultation, we have got more than 600 comments, responses that we are assessing, analyzing.
The proposal formulated in the letter is part of our intention to find the way to reflect it adequately in the final version. We hear your views and suggestions and are now looking into options to cater for your concerns. What we intend to do, we will clarify further, both in the rescue and restructuring guidelines and in the GBER, the concept of equity.
This is one of the key elements in determining whether an undertaking is considered to be in difficulty and one of the points of concern that you have raised. We intend to provide a more detailed and broader up-to-date definition of equity, including financial instruments such as convertible bonds that are comparable to equity in nature. You also comment on another relevant aspect that we plan to reflect somehow, a general exemption for innovative startups from the definition of an undertaking in difficulty during the first five years following their registration. What we try to ensure is that innovative startups can benefit from all types of aid available under the GBER during this important early growth phase, including environmental aid and aid with social objectives.
Some member states have asked to extend the current SME carve-out from three years to seven years so that SMEs considered to be in difficulty could continue to receive aid under the GBER for a longer period. Our preliminary position is that the framework already contains significant flexibility for young and innovative companies. We are assessing your request, but just as a short reminder, risk finance aid can already be granted for up to 10 years after registration or seven years after the company's first commercial sale. In addition, innovative startups can receive startup aid up to 10 years. So we need to assess and to look into the comments that you sent to us.
The new GBER will apply retroactively. This is already included in the draft GBER that was published for public consultation, so the Commission's approach is already clear on this point. And I think that it is good that we take this opportunity to remind ourselves on this point. The current GBER continues to apply until the new version officially enters into force, but as I said, this is already covered.
Final comment, taking advantage of this AOB point, we envisage to adopt the new GBER as well as the new version of the rescue and restructuring guidelines by the end of this year. We will have public consultations and dedicated meetings with Member States in the context of the revision of the two instruments and will be happy to continue to work together in those set up, working, learning and improving together this setting.
Speaker 1
Thank you. I will now give the floor to delegations. We'll start with France, followed by Portugal and then Belgium.
Sébastien Martin
Merci Monsieur le Président. La France soutient les Pays-Bas dans leur souhait de venir clarifier la définition de certains concepts importants dans la réglementation des aides d'État et de pouvoir soutenir les startups innovantes plus longtemps. Avec une douzaine d'États membres, nous travaillons par ailleurs à éviter une procédure de notification longue pour les entreprises et chronophage pour la Commission européenne pour les projets partenaires de d'important d'intérêt européen commun, les PIEC.
Cette exemption permettra d'accélérer fortement les soutiens de PME dans le cadre des PIEC. J'espère que je pourrai compter sur votre soutien pour simplifier la vie de toutes les entreprises associées aux PIEC et éviter l'engorgement des services de la Commission alors que neuf PIEC sont en cours de conception.
Speaker 18
Thank you, Chair. Portugal supports the joint paper on undertaking in difficulty, but we take this opportunity to put forward just two complementary suggestions. The first one is to suggest that the definition of UID should additionally incorporate differentiated assessment criteria that will take into account business plans, technological maturity and sectoral dynamics. The second one aims to highlight the need to clarify which concrete definition of innovative enterprise applies for UID purposes, and we consider that the appropriate reference is the definition set out in the recent Commission recommendation from 18 March 2026 on the definition of innovative enterprises, innovative startups and innovative scale-ups.
Speaker 22
Thank you. I would like to express Belgium's support to the non-paper presented by Netherlands. Thank you.
Speaker 21
Ja, herzlichen Dank. Deutschland gehört auch mit zu den Unterzeichnern des Papiers, weil wir das für sehr wichtig halten und wir begrüßen die laufende Novellierung der allgemeinen Gruppenfreistellungsverordnung und der Rettungs- und Umstrukturierungsbeihilfen. Ich möchte hier an diesem Punkt noch mal klarstellen, um Start-ups, Scale-ups und KMU effektiv zu fördern und damit die Wettbewerbsfähigkeit Europas zu stärken, ist insbesondere eine Überarbeitung der Definition gemäß der gemeinsamen Erklärung erforderlich.
Insbesondere bedarf es der Anerkennung von beteiligungsähnlichen Mitteln, die bei wirtschaftlicher Betrachtungsweise eigenkapitalähnlich sind, als Eigenmittel im Sinne der Definition für Unternehmen in Schwierigkeiten. Und wir brauchen eine Verlängerung der Zeitspanne, innerhalb derer KMU, die in Schwierigkeiten sind, Fördermittel erhalten können, von drei auf sieben Jahre. Herzlichen Dank.
Speaker 10
Grazie Presidente. L'Italia, pur non essendo tra i firmatari del non-paper, esprime una posizione sostanzialmente in linea con il documento. Riteniamo opportuno procedere a una revisione della nozione di impresa in difficoltà basata su criteri oggettivi, chiari e facilmente verificabili, evitando effetti distorsivi derivanti da valutazioni estese al gruppo societario, anche focalizzate sull'impresa beneficiaria.
In tale contesto l'Italia considera altresì opportuno valorizzare il ruolo del mercato e degli investitori privati, le cui decisioni costituiscono spesso un indicatore attendibile della sostenibilità economica delle iniziative imprenditoriali, in linea con quanto evidenziato nel primo punto del non-paper promosso dai Paesi Bassi. Grazie.
Speaker 24
Yeah, so first of all, thank you for your initiative. And Lithuania would like to express the support.
While we support the amendments proposed in this informal document, we recommend adding an exception from undertaking in difficulty assessment to risk finance investments. Market-based assessment already ensures that financing is provided only to viable companies, so an additional requirement to conduct undertaking in difficulty test becomes unnecessary and creates an administrative burden. But thank you very much.
Teresa Ribera Rodriguez
Sorry, I thought that there was still someone asking for the floor. No, thanks, thanks a lot. I I take note of the very broad support of the initiative being presented by several member states, being expressed by other member states that not were not part of the original list of signatories. I think that it is a very good initiative and I appreciate the the share of of your views.
I think that the intention is to do our best according to the spirit of what you are stressing and of course, as I was commenting in the previous AOB point, it's a final formal but important comment within the limits of the current regulation. So I think that this is not a change in the law and we are doing our best to provide the right answers to the concerns being expressed, but that's the context where we work.
Speaker 1
Thank you. So the Council has taken note of the information provided by delegations and the Commission. We now continue with an AOB point on state aid which will be taken in non-public session. I would therefore ask the technicians to cut the live stream.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.