House of Lords
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
House of Lords
Follow its sittingsDianne Hayter
It requires openness about normal legal behaviour undertaken by in-house executives. At present, our UK register lists just under 300 entries. Scotland by contrast has one and a half thousand and Canada has 8,000 because both cover in-house lobbyists as do most other countries' registers. So let's do it now. Let's not wait for a scandal.
Simply any organisation which lobbies should register. It's not difficult. It's the right thing to do. I beg to move.
The Baroness Finn
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness Lady Hayter of Kentish Town on her success in the private members' bill ballot. And while the official opposition cannot support the bill in its current form, it is a very interesting bill which seeks to address one of the most important issues in any free democratic society, namely transparency. And in the interests of transparency, eyebrows were raised when peers received an email from Inflect Partners, a strategic communication and public affairs consultancy. The email said, "I am writing on behalf of the Chartered Institute of Public Relations, CIPR, to share a short briefing and ask whether you would consider speaking in support of Baroness Hayter's Lobbying Transparency (In-house Lobbyists) Bill at the second reading debate on Friday the 3rd of July." My Lords, there is some irony in a lobbying email being issued to support a bill on lobbying.
So does the Chartered Institute of Public Relations stand to gain from this bill? Perhaps the noble Baroness Lady Hayter can illuminate us. My Lords, while this bill is very short, its effect is very broad. The noble Baroness Lady Hayter is correct that the current registration rules under the 2014 Act cover just a small number of the activities that could be termed lobbying. There are just 240 registered consultant lobbyists in the country and the office of the registrar employs just three staff members in addition to the registrar.
The 2014 Act was never meant to be comprehensive. The bill before us, my Lords, though it may be tightly drafted, is not targeted. It expands the registration rules to encompass a whole range of communications. If this bill becomes law, almost all persons communicating with ministers or permanent secretaries on behalf of their employer, engager or principal, or with the intent of furthering the interests of their employer, engager or principal, will have to register. Yes, many would like to see greater transparency of engagements between stakeholders and ministers, but that broad and well-intentioned principle would represent a huge administrative burden on business.
We are concerned that such a burden would disincentivise businesses, charities and other stakeholders from engaging freely with ministers.
My Lords, I hope we can have a constructive debate today and at committee and report stages. The principle of transparency is not contested, and it is essential ministers and departments are transparent in their own contact with lobbyists. The previous government committed to develop a single database to collate and publish departments' transparency returns. This appears to have been scrapped, so I would ask the noble Baroness the minister to say why this might be the case. Our foremost concern is to avoid unintended and unexpected negative consequences for small businesses, charities, and stakeholders.
We are also interested in the risks to well-intentioned individuals who are simply unaware of the new broader rules, the capacity for the Office of the Registrar to handle the rise in registrations, and finally the issue of the annual registration fee. On burdens, the broader application of the lobbying register rules will see many more people subject to the burden of registering with the Office of the Registrar. In some ways, this is not a cumbersome step; the register is now well-established, and it should not be difficult for individuals to use the service. But no matter how easy it is to register, this is a new administrative burden. Furthermore, we must not forget that those registered with the UK Office for the Registrar of Consultant Lobbyists pay annual fees of one thousand pounds.
Nothing in the noble Baroness Lady Hayter's bill amends section twenty-two of the 2014 Act. That means the one thousand pound annual fee will apply to in-house lobbyists just as it applies to consultant lobbyists. Contrast that with the fact that the average UK small business has a profit margin of seventy thousand pounds, and we see that two members of staff having to register at a total cost of two thousand pounds is not an insignificant burden for smaller organizations. As we proceed to committee and report stages, we will seek to establish protections for small and medium businesses and other smaller stakeholders. My Lords, we want businesses, especially small ones, and other stakeholders to have open channels of regular communication with ministers.
So can the noble Baroness say whether she has reflected on the interaction between the one thousand pound per annum registration fees and the proposed wider rules on stakeholders' willingness to make representations to government? And further to that, I'd be grateful if the noble Baroness could confirm one point. So, for example, should a minister meet a pub landlord on a visit, and that landlord goes on to tell him or her that the government must cut alcohol duty, reform business rates, or abandon Ed Miliband's obsessive net zero policy, would the landlord have to register and pay his one thousand pound fee? And if yes, does she accept that landlords will feel disinclined to give the minister a piece of their mind? Is that not an obstruction to good government?
I accept, my Lords, that this is an unlikely hypothetical scenario, since the Prime Minister and Chancellor, along with many ministers and government MPs, are banned from their local pubs in protest at the government's appalling anti-business policies, but it does illustrate the point. On unintended harms to individuals, I would like to consider another example. Under this bill, an in-house lobbyist who fails to register within the three-month registration period, whether that be a mistake or not, faces a civil penalty of up to seven thousand five hundred pounds or an unlimited fine on conviction.
Is it reasonable and proportionate for a small business owner who may be unaware of these rules to face that? So what thought has the noble Baroness given to protections for well-intentioned, well-intentioned upstanding people who fall foul of the rules through ignorance, as they will if we broaden the scope of the law in this way? And on the possible backlogs in registration, what assessment has the noble Baroness made of the capacity of the four people currently in the office of the registrar to cope with a large increase in registrations? As she pointed out, there are just 240 people currently on the register. The EU has over 17,500 organizations on their register and the Scottish Parliament 1,642.
And finally, can the noble Baroness tell the House what her view is on the 1,000 pound annual registration, on the 1,000 pound annual registration fees? Does she feel that this is reasonable for a small business or charity simply for allowing the Prime Minister or any other minister to visit and discuss business? My Lords, I hope we can all have a constructive debate on the principles underpinning this bill, but there are a number of unanswered questions to consider. And I look forward to the response of the noble Baroness Lady Hayter of Kentish Town and to our further debates at later stages.
Stephen Benn
My Lords, I'm very pleased to contribute to today's debate and it's a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness. Like many members, I occasionally show visitors round the House, including Americans. I take them to Central Lobby and I say, here it is, it is a place, it is a noun. And I say, of course, it is also a verb. It is the place where people come to meet their members of Parliament, as they have every right to do.
And the problem, of course, is when, well, there's nothing wrong with lobbying. It's an integral part of our system of Parliament and government, and indeed all members of Parliament themselves, including humble backbenchers on the government side in this House, are lobbying and lobbyists. The dangers only begin to emerge when financial benefit arises and when money is involved. I want to concentrate on the benefits of lobbying for influence, which goes on all the time. Now, this is a bill about transparency and accountability, and I'd like to think that they're two principles that commend themselves to all sides of this House.
And as I've mentioned Americans, tomorrow is, of course, the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence and the foundation of the United States. And if I may, I'd like to quote one of the most famous justices of the American Supreme Court, Mr. Justice Brandeis. Sunlight, he said, is the best disinfectant. And I think that this phrase remains very relevant to discussing the subject of this bill. Now, my noble friend has argued that the rules as they currently are under the 2014 Act leave a large loophole and that this bill provides the remedy, though it does involve some considerable administrative consequences.
Now, previous governments have argued, perhaps my noble friend the Minister will argue the same case today, that there is already a regime in place whereby government ministers and permanent secretaries of government departments voluntarily disclose information about who they meet on a quarterly basis. But is this enough, my Lords? I do not think so. The Committee on Standards in Public Life produced a report in 2021, not long after I myself arrived here, which specifically argued for the Cabinet Office to collate all departmental transparency information and publish it in an accessible and, above all, searchable database. They also advocated an expansion of the register to include contact between lobbying companies and SpAds and senior director-level civil servants.
Now, perhaps my noble friend the Minister could have something to say on this point. But that committee stopped short of calling for the register to be expanded to include in-house lobbyists. Now, as the House knows, the post-legislative scrutiny of the Act by the PACAC committee in another place also stopped short of recommending the extension to cover in-house lobbyists. However, it did refer to loopholes which should be closed, and the March 2026 Rycroft review specifically drew attention to the current VAT exemption under the 2014 Act, which in effect now allows foreign lobbying firms or foreign-based subsidiaries of UK lobbying companies not to register.
This is an error, and I hope my noble friend the Minister can address this. Now, and as has been mentioned already in this debate, our outgoing Prime Minister commissioned the new Ethics and Integrity Commission in March to review, among other things, "the current arrangements for transparency around lobbying and whether they are sufficient." And if the report is being published next week, then we look forward to what the answer will be, and maybe the Minister can also say something about that. And as for the Chartered Institute of Public Relations already referred to, their survey found that two-thirds wanted the lobbying register to include both consultants and in-house lobbyists. Now, if the House wants to know why I take an interest in this private member's bill, it is this: it is my own experience.
Before I was elected to serve in this House, I worked in the science community on behalf and for the science community. As I knew a little bit about how Parliament worked, indeed in the family in which I grew up, it was impossible not to know a little, I was called upon to help represent the science community to both Parliament and Government. And I did so in various ways, such as organizing events and arranging meetings. And I suppose you could say I did this work in-house. I organized on behalf of the science community year after year, indeed decade after decade, the biggest science events ever held in the House.
I hope the House will not mind if I give a couple of examples. Parliamentary Links Day brought together the whole scientific community on a single day each summer, comprised a huge standing-room-only meeting in the House of Commons and another major event here in this House. And you only had to look at the invitation card to see what I mean. All the major science sectoral societies were represented: biology, maths, physics, chemistry, engineering, as well as many of our national academies such as the Royal Society. But the event was all about educating members on science and technology issues and making the case for science and technology and the resources needed to fund them.
We got speakers year after year from the Cabinet: the Foreign Secretary, the Environment Secretary, the Health Secretary, the International Development Secretary, the Science Minister, not always in the Cabinet but crucial, as well as the Chancellor of the Exchequer. Indeed, 21 years ago this year, the then Prime Minister himself addressed Parliamentary Links Day, and I can well remember the frisson in the room and people astonished to find a Prime Minister walking in to address them. In 2001, I brought together the wide range of scientific organizations to produce the first-ever Charter for Science and Engineering, which the then Chancellor subsequently responded to point by point when launching the 10-year investment strategy for science. Voice of the Future is another event which is still going, and it brings young scientists and engineers to Parliament to question the Minister, the Shadow Minister, the Chief Scientific Adviser, members of both Houses' Select Committee on Science and Technology. They sat at the witness table and the young scientists and engineers sat round the horseshoe questioning them.
And it used to be launched by the Speaker himself. I also organized parliamentary receptions, not just the Christmas reception at which we gave awards for outstanding contribution to the cause of science. We had others, indeed my noble friend Lord Anderson over there will remember himself the reception we organized to welcome back Helen Sharman, the first British person in space. And that was quite a long time ago.
About 10 years ago, I arranged for Tim Peake, a name you may also remember, to give the first ever evidence to a select committee from space. That was took place in the Boothroyd Room, and I can tell you that I remember meeting the parliamentary engineers who worked in the basement of Millbank, and they were thrilled when the first signals came through from NASA conveying Tim Peake. And the noble baroness, Baroness Blackwood, not sadly in her place at the moment, was the chair of the committee at the time, and if you don't believe me, you can ask her all about it because it was really quite an event. Now, and all in parallel with all of this is the work done by the Parliamentary and Scientific Committee, of which as it happens I am now president, but we organize the annual STEM for Britain event, which takes place in another place, which brings early career scientists and engineers to meet their own local members of Parliament and exhibit their work, and it's highly competitive. Now, my purpose in giving these examples is to illustrate that lobbying activity goes of this kind goes on all the time, and it is about seeking influence.
Now, my lords, I've run out of time. Parliament is not a museum. It is a workshop, and this type of activity is to be encouraged, and expanding the 2014 Act register will do no harm and may well increase the sunlight we can shine on the whole area of lobbying. So when it comes to this bill, I, my lords, will be voting for sunlight.
Andrew Lansley
My lords, great pleasure to follow the noble Viscount Stansgate. I was much entertained by that and thought he along with the proposer of the bill, in the way in which she introduced the bill, I thought quite rightly said this is not about trying to restrict lobbying activity, it's about trying to introduce transparency in relation to lobbying activity. We want to see lobbying take place. I'm reminded in relation to the to the Declaration of Independence, American Revolutionary War, Benjamin Franklin, of course, his major contribution was as a lobbyist in London and in Paris. So lobbying can play its essential part in creating democracy as well as in sustaining.
I should declare an interest. I am director of a company that is on the register of consultant lobbyists, principally and I think for recent in recent times only because they act as a secretariat to development forums and contact planning and housing ministers in that context. But I am also an advisor to a company in Brussels that is on the transparency register of the European Union. And I will come back to the comparison between those two registers. I should also declare an interest in that I was the minister responsible for the 2014 legislation under the coalition government and with the benefit in the other place of being supported in that task by the deputy leader of the house, Tom Brake, who is now the distinguished director of Unlock Democracy and is, I suspect, a supporter of this bill.
So it will it may surprise the the proposer of the bill that in in principle I support what she is attempting to do. I am going to, I'm afraid, irritate her by saying while I agree in principle, I I disagree in almost every practicality of how she's doing it. The and the reason is because I come back to this comparison between the Westminster register and the Brussels, the EU register transparency register. It is virtually impossible in Westminster register to reconcile the quarterly information reports that ministers make about their meetings with the consultant lobbyists who are on the register to try to see how do they directly relate to one another in terms of meetings and especially in terms of content. There is nothing about the content.
Speaker 8
I should remind the House that in 2013-14 when the bill was going through, the reason, and it's not reflected accurately in the library briefing unusually, the reason why it was not extended to companies that were not consultant lobbyists is because we had in 2010 in the coalition government introduced that ministerial reporting requirement. As far as we were concerned at the time, the ministerial return would make it perfectly transparent if any company on its own behalf met a minister because that would appear in the quarterly return from ministers. The point was a meeting by a public affairs or consultant firm with a minister might appear in the minister's return but you didn't know on whose behalf they were speaking. That was why the register of consultant lobbying was established and why it had the parameters that it did. It was not an intention to restrict transparency, it was an intention to add a transparent register where the quarterly information return would not provide the information.
So why do I think we need to go further? Well, there is a capacity within the bill to go further which administrations since 2014 have not used. And those are twofold. One was mentioned previously, to add special advisers to the ministers and permanent secretaries because actually consultant lobbyists know perfectly well that special advisers are an extremely effective way of avoiding the transparency that the register is meant to provide. That is available under the by secondary legislation under I think it's in section 2 of the act.
The other is section 23 gives ministers the regulatory power to change what information is required to be provided to the register. And there is a very big difference, I won't bore the House by enumerating the differences between the Westminster register return and the EU register, but the EU register is far more substantial in terms of what you know about an organisation that is seeking to influence the policy of the European Union. You know on whose behalf it's working, what clients, what funding it receives, in what band of financial activity is it devoted to this task and so on and so on and so on. Why do I think actually the EU register now is a better way of doing things? Because actually you can reconcile the content of lobbying with the organisation that is doing it and who they're doing it on behalf of and what resources they are devoting to it.
And I think if we're going to be transparent we might as well go to the EU register. But it is substantively different from the one we have in the 2014 act. The 2014 act is constructed around regulating the person who lobbies, whereas the EU register is about regulating the nature of the activity itself. And it is possible to move the 2014 act in that direction and I suggest we should. But this bill does not sufficiently do that.
I'll give you just one example. In schedule 1, paragraph 1, subparagraph 1, an exclusion exemption from the requirement to register is if the person conducting the communication with ministers or permanent secretaries does so in a manner that is in an organisation in a business for which lobbying is not their main activity. Most organisations will say we're covered by the exemption, lobbying is incidental to what we do. And so most organisations will say we don't need to register.
And when they do register, they'll get very confused about who they register. Should it be the chief executive, should it be everybody? Well the EU doesn't have that, the EU register does not have that problem. Everybody, the organisation is registered, not the individuals within it. So I do suggest at this stage, given it's second reading, we say yes to the principle of trying to do something about this, but we may have to come back in committee at looking at how we do it in some detail.
Because I think it is not simply putting in-house lobbyist alongside consultant lobbyist, it's about shifting from consultant lobbying and in-house lobbying to creating a register which is about organisations who are seeking to influence the legislation and policy of the government and they should be on the register in the same way as is true in the Brussels register.
Speaker 9
My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend Baroness Hayter in bringing forward this bill, and I agree with every single word she put forward in her introduction. Going back to first principles, I agree that lobbying is a useful part of democracy and like many members of this House, I have done my fair share, possibly more than my fair share of lobbying, meeting ministers over many decades to talk about issues that concerned organisations that I represented. And this is a type of democratic participation that is legitimate. And it's a good thing because decision making benefits when decision makers hear from a very wide range of voices. But lobbying is widely regarded as a bit dodgy, a bit grubby and a bit suspicious.
And in many cases, people who hold those views are right, as some of the well-publicised scandals we have seen will testify. And we all meet people in our daily lives who suspect that a privileged few are getting an unfair chance to shape government decisions behind closed doors. So at the basis of this bill is the contention that too much is left hidden from view. And I don't think that it's too lofty to say that this bill can help build more public confidence in our democratic institutions because it introduces more transparency over who is trying to influence ministers and senior decision makers and on whose behalf. Greater openness would strengthen confidence in government and our current system just isn't rational.
As things stand now, two lobbyists could walk tomorrow into the same ministerial meeting and talk about the same issues, and one might have to register because they're an external consultant acting for a client. The other might represent a major corporation employing its own in-house public affairs team and they'd avoid the statutory register altogether. Try explaining that distinction to the average concerned member of the public. It makes little sense. The political influence on policy doesn't depend on whether the lobbyist receives a consultancy fee or a salary from the organisation they represent.
So we've got a system now that reflects organisational structure rather than the reality of influence. And I had an example recently from a senior partner in a consultancy who set out why the current system needs to change. Not long ago, one of their clients, a prominent financial institution, was sending experienced in-house government relations specialists into the Treasury to have material conversations about banking regulations.
Those meetings didn't have to be registered. But when a young employee of the consultancy wrote to a minister simply requesting a meeting, that fell under the definition of direct lobbying under the Act and needed to be registered. And I think that that is more than a harmless anomaly because it contributes to public mistrust in government decision-making. So it is about time we had the straightforward change that this bill would bring about, simply extending transparency to in-house lobbying. And I do hope that the government will give it consideration.
As the noble Lord Lansley mentioned, it's relevant in this discussion to talk about the government's own transparency releases. And as my noble friend Lord Stangate said, as it stands, these releases are hard to find and they're hard to search. They're published in different places, in different formats, with different names. They could be published on a single accessible searchable format, and I hope the government will give that consideration. And I'd also invite the government to consider the remit of the Office of the Registrar of Consultant Lobbyists while we're at it.
It has admirably performed the role Parliament assigned to it, but I think it's reasonable now to ask whether its scope is still relevant after more than a decade after the original legislation. Because since then, the practice of lobbying has evolved. More large organizations now have invested in sophisticated in-house government relation teams, and there's more digital campaigning. And the boundary between public affairs, strategic communication, and direct government engagement has become less distinct. So I think it's therefore legitimate to ask whether the regulator's remit should evolve as well.
And in that context, ministers might also look at the experience elsewhere. The Scottish system, for example, operates under a broader framework. It focuses on recording lobbying activity itself, rather than relying so heavily on distinctions between different categories of lobbyists. And the noble Lord Lord Lansley has given another example of the EU register. And I'm not suggesting simply copying another model, but maybe there will be there could be lessons worth learning about proportionality, about coverage, and about public accessibility.
A review of the registrar's remit could consider questions such as whether the current definitions are still fit for purpose, whether the public can easily understand who needs to register and who doesn't, and whether reporting requirements are proportional. The system we should be aiming for needs to be comprehensive enough to command public confidence and proportionate enough not to discourage legitimate engagement. And recognizing the points that the noble lady Baroness Finn made about businesses, proportionate enough not to place disproportionate burdens on business.
And the system also should be straightforward enough for both organizations and the public to understand. And I think that this the bill makes important contributions towards that goal. It recognizes that transparency should focus on influence, not merely organizational form. It begins to correct anomalies that have become increasingly difficult to justify. And it offers an opportunity to modernize a framework that has not kept pace with changes in the lobbying profession.
Natalie Bennett
My Lords, I congratulate the noble lady Baroness Hayter on this excellent bill and enabling us to have a really crucial discussion about transparency. We have a huge problem with public trust in government. Just 27% of the population trust the national government. There's very good evidence to say that transparency is one of the key drivers of trust. And others have already referred to the Transparency International research showing that current lobbying register covers at most 4% of those engaged in lobbying activity.
I don't think necessarily if you went out on the street and surveyed 100 people, many people would know that figure. But there is a very strong and rightful sense that a lot of murky things happen here in Westminster and that does damage trust. However, as the noble lady Baroness Hayter said introducing the bill, a lot of lobbying is positive and we do need to keep that sense when it is lobbying in the public interest. NGOs and campaign groups, patients and consumer groups, communities affected by proposed developments. But most lobbying is not in the public interest, but for private interests.
Big oil and gas, big tobacco. And boy did we see some shameless examples of big tobacco lobbying in the recent Tobacco and Vapes Bill. Big supermarket, big developer, big finance, including of course the City of London Corporation, whose special access I'm addressing in other other areas. And it is worth saying, however, that it is up to the government to decide who to meet, who to hear and who to listen. And successive governments have very much balanced access in favor of these big interests, not in favor of those lobbying for public interests.
But and also as the noble lady Baroness Hayter said, the current way the the register is arranged actually means a lack of transparency for the big lobbying and creates extra work and barriers for those lobbying in the public interest. It might seem to be a deliberate weakness in the law and I commend the noble lady for seeking to fill it. It's worth noting that we rely very heavily on journalists to dig and burrow to find out links. They make a very expensive investment in finding out what is going on from companies that are trying to get windfall profits whilst the public good is ignored. And it's worth noting that as a number of other noble lords have said, that we effectively are relying on stronger laws in other jurisdictions.
And of course we have to note Scotland's much stronger law and the EU to occasionally draw back the veil. And I note a publication this week on the Substack Democracy for Sale, an article by Adam Bychawski and Peter Geoghegan, which is a really interesting case study of that. I don't know that this particular bill would solve this problem, but it is a concerning problem. They report that Andy Burnham's incoming chief of staff, who until very recently was the chief executive of Flint Global, this is James Purnell. Now Flint has said that its British client list is confidential and has declared just two clients in the UK in five years.
But on the EU lobbying register, it emerges that Flint works for Uber, Amazon and Diageo.
You might say that's big interests very clearly. But I wonder, I think just that's one interesting case study, but we've had some horrific case studies and there's already been some reference made to these. We've got to think of Greensill, of Westferry and the COVID-19 VIP lane. And I declare in the interests of transparency that the rest of what I'm going to say has been informed by lobbying from Spotlight on Corruption, Unlock Democracy and Transparency International UK. And they stress those examples that of the transparency gap we have now that this bill could partially fill.
But I understand the noble lady kept this bill narrow and focused. In my next bill coming up, I've gone very much in the other direction of having a very broad private member's bill. But I think it is important to raise some of the issues, some of the gaps that the government I hope will say it intends to act on some of the other things this bill doesn't cover that we do need to see action on. The VAT registration requirements represent a problematic loophole. And other similar registers of consultant lobbyists do not present these exemptions.
There's a real problem with timeliness. It hasn't got better, but knowing what's happened before a government make a decision is really important and too often we only find out months and months after the fact. And that's something the government itself should be promising, I hope, to solve. And I think a number of noble lords have already referred to this, noble lord Lord Lansley in particular. We get descriptions of meetings from governments that don't really tell us anything meaningful about what was being discussed, what the subject of the meeting was.
We have registrations of lobbyists saying they're working for a particular company, but how do all these pieces match up? And that is something that's got to be solved so that the public can see who indeed have ministers' ears. There's also got to be out of those meetings, what was the actual purpose of this meeting? Meeting to discuss trade issues. What does that mean precisely?
Are you meeting to discuss Australian beef imports or meeting to discuss sanitary and phytosanitary standards? Knowing those details is absolutely crucial to really understand what's going on. So I finish by again commending the noble lady. I think this is a really interesting, important discussion and I hope the government, whatever the government means, is listening.
Speaker 11
My lords, I start also by congratulating Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town on bringing forward this bill and I understand why she has done so. But I want to make a more general point about what I think what effect the bill might have. One of the big problems we've had over many years has been the growing gap between government and business. And we need to make sure that there's a great understanding of people who are making economic decisions in government about what the business community needs in order to advance the economy and achieve what governments talk about all the time, which is economic growth. And I'm therefore asking myself how would this bill work in practice and what effect it might have on the relationships between government and business.
So I have in mind a a very pro-business, very proactive government that wants to break down the barriers between business and government, wants ministers to be out there understanding what motivates businesses, what they what they need to be able to get on with their job of growing businesses, creating jobs and so on. So I imagine a Chancellor of the Exchequer or a business minister at a conference and he or she is working the room and talking to different business leaders and there's a chief executive of a a house building company who explains that he's sitting on various pockets of land and would like to develop them but the planning regulations, the tax system and so on and so forth need to be changed. Does that person become an in-house consultant when he has that conversation with the minister? Imagine the chief executive of a international bank is worried about what the the government might be doing in terms of banking regulations or other aspects of banking and he or she, the chief executive of the of the bank speaks to the Chancellor of the Exchequer and wants to make it clear that if these changes in banking rules, regulations or or tax go on, the bank may have to consider relisting somewhere else. At that point is the chief executive of the bank an in-house consultant?
And then I look at the bill before us today and I see in I think it's clause one, subclause eight, sub-subclause four, which talks about regulations which would require the in-house consultant or or regulations to be disclosed about the topics of discussion. So would this have an inhibiting effect on the communication between business leaders and government? What I don't think the the baroness would want to see is that the bill would have that sort of inhibiting effect on relations. It would be very helpful both in her wind-up and perhaps no doubt when we come to the details of the bill at committee stage for the noble baroness to explain how we can avoid what I think are, if we're not careful, unintended consequences.
Philip Norton
My Lords, I agree with a great deal of what's been said by a number of speakers, which also has the advantage that I'll be able to shorten my contribution to today's debate. My Lords, this is a modest bill which seeks to improve an act that is not up to the task of enhancing the transparency of lobbying. The 2014 act was fundamentally flawed. Its name bore no relation to the contents. I moved an amendment to change the long title, replacing transparency of lobbying with registration of lobbyists.
The measure did not enhance transparency of the substance of lobbying.
Speaker 13
It required the registration of lobbyists, or rather, as we've heard, certain lobbyists. It was notable as much for who was not required to register as for who was. If we're going to stick with the 2014 Act, then it makes sense to extend the scope so that the register lives up to its name. Baroness Hayter moved an amendment then to include in-house lobbyists, and was supported by many other noble Lords. For her, it's unfinished business.
I would urge the Minister to go further. The 2014 Act was a missed opportunity. There was no statutory code of conduct, no stipulation of the principles that should govern that conduct. We could have put ourselves on a par with other nations in embracing best practice, ensuring that representations made to government, to ministers, to civil servants, to advisers, were put in the public domain. I moved an amendment when the bill was being considered in 2013 to provide for that, stipulating that representations made to government should be published when a policy was announced.
So it goes way beyond, goes, extends what my noble friend Lord Lansley was referring to in terms of the quarterly return. It would be far more targeted to the actual policy that was being announced. Now, such a reform, my Lords, is essential to tackle declining trust in politics. Again, this has already been referred to. The 2014 Act was, as I argued, an output of the "something must be done" mentality.
Scandals surrounding lobbying are nothing new. They undermine, as we've heard, public trust. Simply requiring lobbyists, or rather some lobbyists, to be on a register has not really tackled the problem. As we've heard, the objection to extending the register to cover in-house lobbyists is one of cost. Yet what we have is a limited register that requires a bureaucracy, not a large one as we've heard, but a bureaucracy that puts a burden on the public purse.
And as it stands, I'm not sure it justifies the expense. We expend the money for no clear benefit in terms of public trust. My Lords, we need a radical reset if we are to ensure that lobbying operates in a fully transparent manner. The problem is not so much one of resources, but of political will. The answer is to ensure that there is transparency at the point that a policy is announced.
If the representations that are made are revealed, then one has openness. That produces discipline, ministers knowing that what's been put to them is known. That should help bolster support for their policies if they can show the persuasive arguments that have been placed before them. The focus shifts from the status of those lobbying to the content of the lobbying. In essence, it removes the need for a register.
As I said in 2013, any representations made to anyone in the department should be shown. It would not matter who the lobbyists were: full-time independent lobbyists, in-house lobbyists, part-time lobbyists, or individuals making representations on that particular issue. All would be caught. We would thus have true, comprehensive transparency. That is the key point, and it's important that we establish that principle.
The Minister responding to the debate was Lord Wallace of Saltaire, and he said of my amendment, I took him down as saying that the government believe in transparency, but not too far. I would say that the government believe in transparency, but want to be proportionate in our approach. That was an interesting concept. Perhaps the Minister can tell us the threshold for determining disproportionate transparency.
Speaker 17
My Lords, the public money used to maintain the register could be deployed instead to facilitate the release of representations made to government. Such transparency was achievable when we debated the bill back in 2013, given the strides made in technology since then, this can now be achieved far more efficiently than was the case then. My Lords, this is to take us beyond the content of the bill before us, but it helps make the case for the bill. The argument that I've deployed emphasizes that what is before us is a modest but necessary measure to address a deficiency in the 2014 Act. I hope the minister will give it a fair wind, even better of course if the noble lady announces that the government are prepared to go further and ensure that we do have full transparency.
Let us pass this bill and then get on and be a leader internationally in ensuring the transparency of lobbying.
Speaker 14
I congratulate my noble friend Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town on her success in the private members' ballot. I've asked her to advise me on my future selection of lottery numbers and on her compelling introduction to this important and overdue bill. Like my noble friend and other speakers, I believe that lobbying is an essential and potentially productive component in the communication between government and business, consumer groups and other constituencies. Government should not determine policy or propose legislation in a vacuum, but rather do so as far as possible after considered and thoughtful interaction with all interested parties. The quality of that interaction is directly related to the transparency of the conversations that government has, to enable everyone from legislators to the public to form a view as to how the balance has been struck between the arguments and interests of different parties.
The Transparency of Lobbying, Non-party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Act 2014, amidst its many other more overtly partisan measures, attempted to increase the transparency with which lobbying was conducted. But this start was fundamentally flawed, with the statutory register set up, as we have heard, only in respect of external consultants and not in-house lobbyists. Without disrespect to the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, this was demonstrably a wrong call by the then coalition government, even though arguments were made at the time that other initiatives were supposedly in train and made it inappropriate to cast the net wider to include in-house lobbying. The past 12 years have laid bare the failure of those other initiatives and processes which were meant to create the level playing field and the necessary level of transparency for all lobbying. That is why I welcome and support this bill so strongly and wish to see it in the statute book, or in the light of the Prime Minister's commissioning in March of this year of the Ethics and Integrity Commission to review the issue of lobbying disclosure and access to government, possibly instead its measures incorporated into wider government legislation.
Andrew Lansley
My support for the bill is informed by two past roles I've held and by one current one, which I will formally declare as an interest. Some time ago, I was the chair of a public relations and public affairs consultancy, albeit as a corporate suit rather than as a lobbying practitioner. And more recently, until last February, I was chair of a trade association. In both cases, one already required to register and one which would be required to register under the terms of this bill. I believe these organizations would see this as desirable and positive change.
My current role, as included in my entry on the register, is a director of Digbeth Loc Studios Limited, a company now operating the first phase of a film and television studio in Digbeth, Birmingham, and planning further phases as part of the overall regeneration of Digbeth. One of my co-directors is the distinguished screenwriter Steven Knight, who has been the driving force for over 10 years to rectify the historical underrepresentation of the West Midlands in film and television production and hence employment in the skilled sectors needed for that activity. Steven Knight is a passionate and not surprisingly articulate advocate for his vision with ministers, regional and local government leaders. Indeed, if he grows tired of screenwriting, he would be an outstanding professional lobbyist, however much that would disappoint the fans of Peaky Blinders and James Bond, whose next film he is writing. For many years, he operated essentially on a solo basis.
Even now, with a very small corporate infrastructure in place, there is not a public affairs department of the sort that large companies and organizations will have. The noble Baroness Lady Finn has flagged her concern for the implications of the bill on small businesses and organizations, and I offer Digbeth Loc Studios as a vivid case of what may not represent a large proportion of lobbying activity but can be vitally important for innovation and social and economic change. I do not believe that there should be any exemption for small companies and organizations. The ludicrousness of the VAT threshold exemption for consultancies should be a warning against that. I do not believe either that the registration fee is a meaningful issue.
Even small companies have to incur similar or greater costs in the ordinary course of their business. What I think is crucial, though, is ensuring that the registration process, both initial and continuing, is as streamlined as possible for organizations that do not have the established public affairs department of, say, a big pharma or energy company. That said, I strongly support my noble friend's bill and look forward to the later stages when we can address the details and issues which I and other noble lords have raised.
Speaker 18
I warmly welcome the bill introduced by the noble Baroness Lady Hayter, and I congratulate her on bringing this important measure before the House and on seeking to bring the United Kingdom more closely into line with jurisdictions including Scotland, Canada, and others, all of which have adopted broader approaches to lobbying transparency.
Helene Hayman
I also welcome the words of the noble lord Lord Lansley and I support his proposals. The principle behind this bill is straightforward. If consultant lobbyists are required to disclose their activities, there is no convincing reason why larger organizations with substantial in-house lobbying operations should not be subject to comparable transparency requirement. Greater transparency strengthens public confidence, improves accountability and increasingly serves our national security interest. I therefore strongly support both the purpose and the direction of this bill.
However, registration is only the beginning. Transparency has real value only if the information disclosed is examined, understood and where appropriate acted upon. A register should not simply be a repository of information, it should be a tool that enables government and parliament to identify patterns of influence, assess potential risks and ensure that lobbying is conducted openly and responsibly. The foreign influence registration scheme provides a useful illustration. Although it serves a different purpose from the lobbying regime before us today, it demonstrates that disclosure alone cannot answer the more difficult policy questions.
Political influence activity may lawfully and currently there is at least one example be registered under FIRS on behalf of overseas public authorities or bodies connected with individuals or entities that are under United Kingdom sanctions on based on the fact that they influence and engages UK defense and security policy. Registration provides transparency but it does not resolve the question of whether such activity is compatible with the public interest or whether it warrants closer scrutiny. Disclosure is therefore the beginning of effective oversight, not its conclusion. The same principle applies to this bill. Extending the register of consultant lobbyists to encompass significant in-house lobbying operators will undoubtedly improve transparency.
Yet the success of the measure will depend not simply upon the volume of information that we have collected but upon whether that information is systematically analyzed, whether emerging risks are identified and whether appropriate action follows. Otherwise we risk creating appearance of accountability without fully achieving it. Other jurisdictions have recognized this. Germany's lobbying register requires lobbyists to identify the legislation and policy proposal they seek to influence while the United States Foreign Agents Registration Act requires considerably more detailed reporting of clients, activities and expenditure. These approaches demonstrate that transparency is most effective when it generates information that enables meaningful scrutiny rather than merely satisfying reporting requirement.
This is particularly relevant at a time when democratic institutions face increased sophisticated attempts to shape public policy or political debate by external factors. Most lobbying is entirely legitimate and makes a valuable contribution to better policy making. But the challenge the government is is to distinguish legitimate engagement from activity that may undermine the public interest or present wider risks. That requires not only transparency but effective analysis, proportionate oversight and informed judgment.
Against this background, I have three questions for the noble lady the minister. First, how will the government ensure that the additional information generated by this bill is systematically analyzed so that it strengthens accountability and informs policy making rather than simply increase compliance requirements? Secondly, where lobbying activity raises concerns related to foreign policy, national security, or other significant public interest, what mechanisms exist to ensure that transparency is accompanied by appropriate risk assessment and, where necessary, proportionate action? Thirdly, as the government reviews the operation of both the foreign influence registration scheme and the register of consultant lobbyists, will it consider whether lessons from each regime can be used to inform the future development of the other so that the United Kingdom has a coherent and effective framework for transparency in political influence? My lords, I welcome this bill because it addresses an important gap in the current framework.
It represents a significant step towards greater openness and accountability. But transparency, as I have already said, should be regarded as the beginning of effective oversight, not its end. Unless the information disclosed is systematically analyzed or used to inform government's decision making, we risk creating appearance of accountability without fully delivering it. And this bill provides an opportunity not only to expand transparency, but to ensure that transparency serves its proper purpose in strengthening confidence in our democratic institutions.
Thomas Tom McNally
I'm pleased to add my support to my friend the noble baroness Hayter of Kentish Town. We need to get more lobbying transparency in the Lords. My lords, we've been here before. The noble baroness and myself, she encouraged me back in 2016 to move a private members' bill on this topic. And we managed, I remind Lord Lansley, we managed to get it through.
Lord Lansley contributed significantly, moved many amendments, and I look forward again to seeing him moving amendments, but I look forward to him again giving support to try to get this onto the statute book. We had the second reading on the 9th of September 2016, and it endeavored to build on the 2014 Transparency of Lobbying, Non-party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Act of 2014, which had its deficiencies. I think it's very important indeed that in the light of what happened with COVID, that we're back on this topic. And I'm not going to speak at great length. If anybody wants any great justification from me for supporting this, I suggest they look at the Hansard for 2016, which I've recently just got out and refreshed myself on and read many of the speeches again.
But the case is compelling, and as the debate has proceeded today, I believe we've heard a general movement towards support for this, even though Baroness Finn, I thought, was rather more strident than perhaps her counterpart was back in 2016 with her opposition. I hope that she's going to be prepared to move her ground a little bit, because change is needed. Transparency is needed. We need to build that trust. And the House of Lords is certainly out of step with the Commons, out of step with Scotland, out of step with Europe, and certainly well out of step, as has just been demonstrated by the previous speaker, with what happens in the States.
So I hope that we can see a coming together and that this time round it will be different because, and I conclude on this, we have a different government in power. So I have a question to my colleague, I hope my front bench colleague, I hope she's going to indicate that this government is going to give support to this particular private member's bill, the modest change which it is seeking. But at a minimum, if she cannot say that she's going to embrace it totally, I hope she will be prepared to give an indication of the way in which we can take the substance and principles of this change and add it to other legislation that may be in prospect to ensure that we're going to have greater transparency and accountability in the Lords than we have at the moment.
Reg Empey
My Lords, it's a pleasure to be in the chamber this morning discussing a piece of legislation on a Friday morning. It's a bit of a change from the atmosphere of the Coliseum that we're used to having here on a Friday mornings this year, but nevertheless, I think the noble Baroness Hayter has struck a chord. There's clearly a broad consensus. I think the previous speaker perhaps was perhaps a little harsh on the opposition, and I think the principle I think is accepted as opposed to the minutiae. And of course we all look forward to getting to the stage of committee when we can actually get down to the details.
But I think the big thing that has happened in the last 12 years since the current arrangements were introduced, not only has technology changed, but the whole structure of government and access to government has changed. We've had an exponential growth in SpAds, and of course these are people now who are the recipient of a lot of lobbying. And of course the government itself, as we all have done in bringing forward legislation, actively seek consultation as part of our process. I think Lord Scriven and others have pointed to some of the anomalies and they may be not included in the current legislation, but the VAT is one thing, it doesn't make sense. We do not wish of course to get into a hugely bureaucratic process, but what is perfectly obvious is what we have today isn't doing it.
We need look no further than this house itself, where unfortunately some members have found themselves coming afoul of our own procedures, and there is a skepticism out in the general public as to whether or not things are open and clear. Now, Baroness Sherbourne of Didsbury did make a very valid point. We all lobby ministers, we do so perhaps during a vote, we do this sort of thing happens every day, it's part of the process. But it is a question of getting a balance, and I think the fact of the matter is the balance is wrong at the moment. And we have an opportunity here, and I have to say to the minister, I suspect that her response will be, well next week we're expecting the reply, it's on page two of her briefing no doubt, that we have the EIS reporting next week and we'll wait and see what that says.
And I understand that, and that's fine. But I do think that because there is a broad feeling around the chamber that we need to do something, it would be good if the minister could either guarantee that the government will provide more time for this bill or, better still, that it will adopt the principles and actually bring forward its own proposals. And I think that that would be broadly welcomed around the chamber.
So for all those reasons, the other anomaly is of course the limit to the minister and the perm sec. My experience is the permanent secretary doesn't by and large get involved on the day-to-day things, it goes much further down, whether it's directors, whether it's people of that calibre. So I think we all know what needs to be done, the bill's on the table, let's do it. I hope the minister will be able to send us away rejoicing here at the end of this debate that she has going to adopt this and is going to be its champion as we move forward to the next stage.
Robert Hayward
I welcome the opportunity to be able to speak in the gap. I didn't put my name in to speak because I was at a Madonna concert last night and I wasn't absolutely certain that I would be available to speak. But it's relevant in that I was actually a guest of a major company, that company was Grinder, and therefore the question in terms of lobbying is relevant in terms of the actions of major companies. I noticed a number of noble lords' response to my presence at the gig last night, it looked like jealousy. The important thing about lobbying and Baroness Hayter's welcome bill is that it raises questions in terms of how people now lobby in terms of this period, and we've actually heard a lot of contributions making suggestions as to how circumstances have changed.
Particularly those people who are paid but do not at the moment have to declare the fact that they are actually lobbying. And one of the groups that comes to my mind is in fact lawyers. Lawyers will say that they actually, it's client confidentiality or it's a peripheral interest. But if they're paid to represent a particular view, to advise in relation to a particular issue, I do think it would be appropriate that major law firms should actually, or small law firms for that matter, should actually be obliged to disclose what they are doing in a way that others who will be affected by Baroness Hayter's bill should also be required to disclose their actions. Can I just say in conclusion, I agree with Baroness Finn's questions that she raised about the implications of some of the bills, because it's easy to pass a piece of legislation and think, oh, it doesn't affect small businesses, and there's been reference to small businesses.
Every bit of regulation that impacts on a small business adds to cost, and therefore I do think that one of the ways of looking at or exempting certain circumstances or certain occasions which have been cited about private conversations and the like is either the question of whether they are paid to do so and the other aspect is some form of de minimis turnover that might actually apply in relation to small businesses, because it's just too easy to say, oh well, it's just a little sum of money. Lots of little sums of money can send a lot of small businesses under, and we certainly wouldn't want that to happen. But in broad principle, I welcome the objective of the bill because it brings up to date where we are in terms of lobbying in 2026.
Speaker 21
My Lords, Lord Shinkwin is hoping to take part remotely but he has been having audio problems. I hope that they've been fixed. I invite Lord Shinkwin to speak. It appears that the problems have not been resolved, therefore Lord Pock.
Lord Pock
Thank you, my Lords, and congratulations to Baroness Hayter for winning the legislative lottery. I too am envious of your luck and thank her as well for choosing this important, focused but important topic. I used to work for a consultancy firm and some of that work involved lobbying, so I have a personal experience of being subject to the regulatory regime that we were talking about today. Of course, it's perhaps no surprise to therefore add that I also share the views that others have expressed of the benefits that good, reputable lobbying can bring in terms of a useful dialogue and a useful exchange of information and expertise that can inform and therefore improve decision making. But as Viscount Stansgate mentioned earlier, sunlight is the best disinfectant.
There absolutely are aspects of lobbying to be concerned about, to be nervous about, but the best way of protecting the good side and the genuinely beneficial side of lobbying is a strong dose of sunlight to distinguish that from other activities and behavior. I'll talk a little bit more about I think the light touch nature of the current setup in a moment as that has obviously come up a little bit in some of the speeches this morning. But first, I think it's worth highlighting just how back to front the situation is that we've ended up in. And we've had a little bit of the history lesson as to how we've ended up where we are. But it is a very odd back to front situation because normally when we talk about regulation, we do it on the basis that the larger, the more powerful, the richer you are, the more important it is to be regulated.
But instead, we've ended up with a situation that is the opposite. The small outfit that cannot afford an in-house lobbying operation employs consultant lobbyists and therefore is regulated. The large, rich, more powerful organization that can afford an in-house team therefore escapes regulation. It is the exact opposite of what we have repeatedly legislated for in all sorts of other areas. It's also a back to front situation in that normally when we are discussing regulation in one form or another, one of the elements of the debate is hearing the people who will be most directly affected by the regulation saying, please don't go too far, what about, you know, we don't want too many burdens placed upon us.
And we obviously have to judge that against wider interests. But in this case, it is again back to front. As we have heard, you know, through the CIPR and other industry bodies, the view of the lobbying industry overall, collectively, very much is that they wish the regulation to change. It feels a little Alice in Wonderland where we are doing the exact opposite, have been doing the exact opposite of what we usually do in other areas. But as there have been some references to the potential administrative burden of extending the current regime, I think it is worth highlighting a couple of points.
One is it is a pretty light touch regime. I certainly didn't feel that I was being unduly burdened. There was certainly a little bit of nervousness, I would say, when each time I would sort of collate the list of things that we needed to make sure that we were declaring, because, you know, that's a list you really don't want to leave something out from by mistake. But it is a fundamentally a light touch, low cost regime. And Baroness Finn earlier said that in some ways this is not a cumbersome step.
Well, I would only disagree slightly. I would say in every way it is not a cumbersome step.
But also, I would say that if you compare the administrative and financial burdens, small though they are, that this bill would extend to some other firms, and if you compare that to the burdens that, for example, any of those firms who export goods or services to the European Union now face following Brexit, this is extremely small compared to those additional burdens that some in this house at least have enthusiastically argued are being a reasonable and acceptable step to take. There's also been some reference to the government's transparency data and to what extent does that, you know, provide an appropriate form of regulation of lobbying and does that, do we therefore really need to extend the current regime? Well, I think there are a couple of points worth reflecting on. One is, really since that government transparency data was first introduced, there has been continuing queries, comments, sometimes complaints about the quality and timeliness and format of that data. And I think there's a point at which it's reasonable to say that problem has been going on for so long that simply hoping that that problem in itself will be fixed and everything will therefore be resolved is maybe not the right step to take.
But also more fundamentally, I think there are some occasions where double transparency, double regulation if one wishes to call it, is the right thing to do. It is actually beneficial to not only have the government transparency data, hopefully in an improved, enhanced form, and also a requirement on lobbyists. That double procedure acts as a double protection. And indeed, we are quite used to the idea of doing something twice in order to be absolutely sure that we've got it right, with, for example, double-entry bookkeeping. Nobody who does double-entry bookkeeping thinks, this is an awful administrative burden, what a waste having to do everything twice.
No, you absolutely, double-entry bookkeeping has become so widespread because the very act of doing things twice is a cross-check to make sure you are getting it right. And in this case, that sunlight is so important that having transparency requirements on both ends of the process is not a duplication or unnecessary, it's an essential part of having a robust system that we can trust in. Now, I suspect the noble lady the minister will shortly be telling us about how the Ethics and Integrity Commission report on lobbying is shortly coming and how, of course, in many ways it makes sense to roll this issue into a wider government response to that. And there are certainly other important issues, aspects to this topic that need addressing, as Viscount Stansgate, Lord Lansley, Lord Norton, Baroness Hayter, Lord McNally and others have raised in this debate. But whatever route we choose to take, whether it is through this immediate bill in front of us now or a wider government response in due course, or perhaps even through both routes, it is important that there is change, because it is about enhancing and protecting our democracy and also, frankly, our own reputations.
The more controversy, the more doubt, the more conspiracy theories, the more scandals there are around lobbying, the more that damages all of us in this house and in politics in general. And that is an important act of self-interest, one might think, but also an important act of public good to improve and enhance our systems. So yes, we should do more than what this bill offers, but that isn't a reason not to do the bit that this bill in front of us does give us the opportunity to do. So often we hear action is promised when legislative time allows. Well, we have some legislative time, we have a piece of legislation in front of us, so I hope the government and this house will in due course support this bill.
Speaker 21
My Lords, the audio problems have now been fixed, and I therefore invite Lord Shipley to speak now.
Kevin Shinkwin
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to be able to speak in support of Baroness Hayter twice in the same week. I do so today because I start from the premise that transparency is inherently a good thing. Transparency in lobbying is not only a good thing, it is crucial because transparency engenders and underpins trust in individuals, the decision-making system and the policy influencing process informing it. The noble Baroness's bill makes sense because transparency makes sense. The fact that this modest bill addresses an omission from the Transparency of Lobbying, Non-Party Campaigning and Trade Union Administration Act 2014 makes the measures within it both logical and necessary.
Necessary because, as we've already heard, while consultant lobbyists comprise around 20% of those who lobby, they are currently the only group the register covers. In other words, the vast majority aren't on the register. They need to be. My Lords, I speak as someone who was privileged to spend 95% of his career before I came to the House as an in-house lobbyist for some of the UK's best household names in the charity sector. In fact, it was through working for charities like RNID, Macmillan Cancer Relief as it then was, Cancer Research UK and the Royal British Legion that I really came to appreciate the value of your Lordships' House.
On Monday next week, the latest Armed Forces Bill, which this time focuses on the Armed Forces Covenant, will receive its second reading. But that's only happening because the principles of the Armed Forces Covenant were enshrined in law for the first time in the Armed Forces Bill 2011, when I led the public affairs team at the Royal British Legion. That in turn only came about because Philip Hollobone, formerly of the other place and then your Lordships' House, took it to the wire and backed the Legion's campaign on the Armed Forces Covenant right through to ping-pong, if my memory serves me correctly. At no point in that campaign did I or any of my team act without transparency. Indeed, the Prime Minister at the time, now Lord Cameron of Chipping Norton, might have wished that we had, at least in the directness of our campaigning.
We didn't pull our punches and he was very gracious in the way he conceded the need for the covenant principles of no disadvantage due to service and special treatment where injury was sustained on service to be enshrined in law and in no less recommending me for a peerage a few years later. I thank him on both counts.
I would never have had a problem with being required to sign a register of in-house lobbyists and of lobbyists overall. And I can't imagine why anyone who has nothing to hide would either. My Lords, I close by returning to the point about importance of trust. It is the glue that binds people and politicians together. Earlier this week, the House recognized the urgency of getting the National Security State Threats Bill onto the statute book as soon as possible.
It did so because democracy is under attack by both hostile state and non-state actors as never before. This bill is the other side of the same coin because it recognizes that enhancing faith in our democratic parliamentary system is crucial to taking the fight to those who would seek to undermine our democratic principles. Now is the time to enhance trust through transparency. This bill does that and I welcome it.
The Baroness Finn
My Lords, this has been a thought-provoking debate with excellent contributions from all sides of the House. Private members' bills are so often a good way to start a debate on a topic that otherwise would not be discussed in so much detail. And I think the noble Baroness, the Lady Hayter of Kentish Town, has certainly achieved that with this bill. This bill has particularly provoked a particularly interesting debate on the important balance between transparency, which we all we strongly support like other noble Lords across the chamber today, but a the balance between that and the administrative burdens on particularly small businesses. Ministers rely on open and frank conversations with stakeholders, whether they be businesses or charities.
The noble Baroness Lady Hayter has been very clear that she is not opposed to that. Our concern is that this bill, by placing an administrative and financial burden, as my noble friend Lord Hayward also highlighted, on organizations that engage with ministers, could disincentivize those open and frank channels of discussions that ministers rely on. Furthermore, my Lords, we are concerned about the unintended consequences. My noble friend Lady Finn gave the example of a pub landlord who might have to register following a conversation with a visiting minister. My noble friend Lord Sherbourne spoke eloquently about the impact of the bill on the relationship between government and the business community and gave a number of examples where there right there could rightly be some confusion.
And I'd like to give two further scenarios for the noble Baroness Lady Hayter to consider as she prepares to take her her bill forward to committee stage.
Baroness Carbury
Firstly, her bill made me think of the much loved British cabbie. All of us, my Lords, will have got into a taxi and immediately found ourselves in conversation with the taxi driver on the issues of the day. Cabbies talk to their customers about their day, about their work, about the businesses they run and the challenges that they are facing in those businesses. If a cab driver were to say to a customer who happened to be a minister that the government ought to change policy to make it more make it easier for him to do business, would he have to register as an in-house lobbyist? It is these brush-by conversations and social interactions that risk confusion, registration and attendant costs.
My Lords, the second scenario I would like to put to the noble Baroness Lady Hater is that of the minister meeting a local business at a constituency surgery. Where a local businessman, employee or charity goes to a constituency surgery with their local member of parliament to inform them of a particular challenge they have are facing, um, is this not deemed to be lobbying? It is merely, and I quote now from Edmund Burke, an MP doing their duty to be in the closest, and I quote, the closest correspondence and the most unreserved communication with his constituents. But under this bill, if the local member of parliament is a minister, it seems the local business could be deemed to be an in-house lobbyist. Can the noble Baroness Lady Hater comment on that discrepancy?
My Lords, it is clear from these examples that the definition of an in-house lobbyist in this bill is far too broad. Where is the line, my Lords? We would be happy, though, to work with the noble Baroness Lady Hater to seek to improve on this, both as we go into committee stage and then into report stages, my Lord.
Lady Anderson
My Lords, firstly I'd like to thank my noble friend Baroness Hater for bringing forward this bill and facilitating such a thought-provoking debate on such an important topic. I find myself in the very unusual position of a Lords minister of actually speaking from the dispatch box on a policy area I am in theory responsible for, so we'll see how well this goes. My noble friend has campaigned with admirable vigour on this issue over many years. Indeed, many of the issues raised across your Lordships' House today were highlighted with foresight by my noble friend in opposition during the passage of the Lobbying Act twelve years ago, along with the active campaigning of the noble Lord Lord Norton of Louth and my noble friend Lord Brooke. I think it's fair to say that there is definitely considered to be unfinished business in this area.
As we have heard, this bill would transform the register of consultant lobbyists into a broader register of all lobbyists, including in-house lobbyists working on behalf of their employer, engager or principal. In doing so, it significantly expands the 2014 bill's prohibition on consultant lobbying unless registered and the associated civil and criminal penalties scheme. When considering the question of transparency around lobbying, we should note that it is the government's own publication of minister and senior officials' meetings that has carried the weight of our transparency obligations on lobbying over many years.
have received sufficiently serious consideration by government that the issue has warranted a meeting with the relevant minister or official. The 2014 Act was designed to complement this dataset, as the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, rightly highlighted. Where a minister or senior official is meeting with a consultant lobbying company and making a declaration as such, it would not be immediately clear whose interests were being advocated for. The 2014 Act was designed to remedy that flaw, requiring all consultant lobbyists to publish a list of their clients. However, the government recognizes the view of a number of members of your Lordships' House and across the wider public relations sector that this system of transparency around lobbying does not have widespread support and is widely viewed as insufficient.
I repeat, my Lords, it is unfinished business. The Prime Minister recognized that there is more to be done on transparency around lobbying to further strengthen standards in public life. High standards of integrity in public life create stability and certainty. In turn, this builds trust in the consistency of public authorities and the conduct of their officials. Trust creates confidence, particularly for members of the public and businesses who want to make decisions that are positive for economic growth in the knowledge that they may face less risk.
There are also, as the noble Baroness, Lady Hayman, highlighted, national security considerations. Transparency can help protect us from the efforts of bad faith actors too. In the current climate, it is a very important element of this discussion. That is why we commissioned the Ethics and Integrity Commission to look into this matter. Just, I have to say, my Lords, that that was point 12, not point 2, for the purposes of Lord Empey.
Noble Lords will be aware that the EIC is indeed due to report very shortly, and we are grateful for the work that they have completed at significant pace. While we await the EIC's recommendation, I hope noble Lords will accept that the government must express its reservations about progressing this bill today. On receipt of the EIC's recommendations, we will consider the case for legislative reform very carefully. And while the views of noble Lords expressed in this debate will undoubtedly form an important part of that consideration, we now need to take some time to consider these issues in the round. And undoubtedly, the next Prime Minister will also have strong views with regards to strengthening trust in public life.
So when the government does consider the question of reforming the 2014 Lobbying Act on receipt of the EIC report, we want to look at all aspects of the lobbying scheme: privileged access to decision-makers, transparency arrangements, and business appointment rules, as well as the recommendations of the Rycroft review, rather than solely the question of whether or not to bring in-house lobbyists into scope. But that does not mean I am not sympathetic to many of the points raised in this debate. With that being said, may I now turn to some of the specific points raised in the debate on the 2014 Act. I believe this debate raises three questions for the government to consider when it receives the Ethics and Integrity Commission's report. The first question at the heart of the debate on transparency around lobbying is this: should it be government who carries the transparency obligation or the lobbyist?
Our current system places that obligation almost entirely on government, with the register of consultant lobbyists only providing transparency on a very small element of the lobbying conducted. I've heard the arguments from across your Lordships' House and from important stakeholders in the public relations sector who feel that we have got that balance wrong. I recognize there is a desire from the public relations sector for the lobbyist to carry more of the transparency obligation and for all lobbyists, rather than just consultant lobbyists, to declare their lobbying activity. This is, of course, the purpose of my noble friend's bill, but it does have the opportunity also to establish a kitemark in lobbying, making it clear both for ministers and others who is acceptable to engage with. Which brings me to the next point.
At the heart of this bill is the question: who is a lobbyist, as touched on by the noble Lord, Lord Hayward?
The bill as drafted amends the 2014 Lobbying Act to include the term "in-house lobbyist" throughout, covering those working on behalf of their employer, engager, or principal. We should be clear that when we think of an in-house lobbyist, we are not just thinking of public affairs managers at large corporations or other private sector bodies. In-house lobbyists may include a wide range of organisations making representations to government, including charities, campaign groups, think tanks, and others. We should not fall into the trap of thinking that transparency around lobbying is only required for those advocating on behalf of private or corporate interests. I want to assure your Lordships' House that as we consider reforms to the lobbying transparency scheme, that we will use a definition of lobbyist that is fair and proportionate across different sectors and types of organisation.
We must also, however, ensure that we do not create unnecessary or disproportionate bureaucratic obstacles to individual citizens' routine engagement with government. As many members of your Lordships' House have stated, and I agree, I do not believe that lobbying is a bad word. Engagement with ministers is a core British right and value. Listening to our fellow citizens is also a sensible approach for any government which is seeking to make its legislation work. In terms of making our legislation work, good definitions are key.
The 2014 Lobbying Act defines lobbying as oral or written communications made personally to a minister of the Crown or permanent secretary relating to any potential government legislation, policy, or functions. Such a definition is broad in scope. I recognise my noble friend's view that the definition is sufficient in capturing the range of government engagements that might commonly be seen as lobbying. And while this may be the case when the definition is solely applied to public relations professionals, be that in-house or consultants, we'd want to think carefully about how such a definition may work if applied to a much wider range of organisations and engagements. Ministers will have all manner of engagements and conversations in the course of their work on matters of government business.
Not all of these, however, could reasonably be said to constitute lobbying, and fewer still of these engagements might be said to constitute lobbying formally enough or taken seriously enough to warrant publication on an external transparency register. A change in approach to the scope of declaration requirements, such as applying the 2014 Act's definition to a far wider range of lobbyists, would require careful consideration to ensure the right balance is struck between informing the public about meaningful lobbying engagements and not putting too much irrelevant or trivial information into a transparency scheme which means it is of limited value. Turning to some of the specific questions I have been asked, not least by the noble Baroness Lady Finn and by my noble friend Baroness Carbury about the single transparency register. I want to reassure your Lordships' House that this was not scrapped by this government. It was not funded by the last government.
They announced it without any budget associated to it and therefore has not been progressed. However, this is a matter which the PAC is considering and that we will reflect on after the publication of their report. With regard to another point raised by the noble Baroness Lady Finn, the flat fee scheme, we are aware of concerns raised about the disproportionate impact of the flat fee scheme on smaller businesses, and any decision on funding will depend on the scope and range of a revised register if changes were to be made. The noble Lord Lord Lansley touched upon declaring the subject matter of lobbying approaches on the register. I recognise concerns that information published on the register does not always enable the public to understand the subject matter of the lobbying approach.
Requiring consultant lobbyists to publish the subject matter of their lobbying could be one way to approach the issue and we will consider this carefully. Ministers and senior officials already publish the subject matter of their meetings, which does go some way to putting this information in the public domain, although I do appreciate there may be further recommendations from the EIC in this space and we will reflect on them. Several members of your Lordship's House also touched on the issue of the VAT exemption, not least Viscount Stansgate, my noble friend Viscount Stansgate, noble Lord Lord Empey and Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle. The government recognizes that the current VAT exemption has had the unintended consequence of exempting foreign-based lobbying from the ORCL transparency scheme. We're grateful to Philip Rycroft for his review and we'll consider this change carefully.
This change would require primary legislation and we will consider all recommendations for legislative change together. Noble Baroness Lady Haylick also asked me to consider three points on the strengthening accountability and how we analyze data, transparency and risk assessment, and FIRS versus ORCL. I think that as we're awaiting such a substantial report in this area of recommendations, I will ensure that those issues are included in the round when we're debating what next steps in terms of the EIC's report. Noble Lord Lord Hayward also rightly focused on lawyers, but there are other organizations which also campaign in this space or lobby directly in this space under the incidental purpose exemption. We are aware of the concerns that a significant amount of lobbying can and does fall under the incidental purpose exemption.
We will want to consider carefully any possible amendments to this exemption, which will be affected by the scope and range of any revisions to the register. But I think issues possible as I have said, calling yourself a think tank, calling it a lawyer, or there are other ways that you can get round the current process, which is why as my noble friend Baroness Hayter highlighted, it's less than 5% of people are currently touched by the regime. In conclusion, I'd like to thank my noble friend Baroness Hayter for raising this important issue and provoking a discussion on reform to the 2014 Lobbying Act. I applaud her consistent campaigning, or should I say lobbying, on this issue and her commitment to improving the transparency and integrity of our democracy, an aspiration I genuinely do share. We know there is more that can be done on transparency around lobbying and that is exactly why the Prime Minister has commissioned the Ethics and Integrity Commission to report on this matter and I look forward to their report.
However, until we have their report, the government is not in a position to make any policy commitments on reform and therefore I cannot support the bill. However, I'm sure all noble Lords will look forward to seeing the conclusions of the EIC review and the government will give that report the full and fair consideration it deserves in a timely manner. On a final point, I hope that my response genuinely doesn't disappoint the noble Lord Lord Empey, I would hate to do that, and that he and many members of your Lordship's House have a little hope about our direction of travel.
Dianne Hayter
My Lords, I don't know what flatters me most. I think it's noble Lord Lord Hayward moving from Madonna to myself. I think that's the biggest vote of confidence I've ever had from anyone. But I am delighted by the people coming today. I don't know whether I'd call the noble Lord Lord Lansley one of the guilty men from having put through a bill that I think we now agree was perhaps a little too modest.
In fact, even this bill today is being called too modest. I think Lord Norton, my noble friend Lord Brooke and the noble Lord Lord Pack all called it modest. And I think that is a good start for where we go. I really would like to thank my noble friend the Minister Lady Anderson. She said it's unfinished business.
I'm going to take that as a very positive state, which she's promising that the government will do a little more.
Because I think that what we all know is that it is time for change. I'm not going to try and answer all the points that she has so nicely dealt with, but I do think it is important to note the breadth of support we've had. Baroness Hayman also pointed not just to transparency, but for the responsibility of lobbying that it should be in the public interest. And the noble lord Lord Sharkey also expressed how transparency itself can enhance trust, which I think my noble friend Baroness Carberry also said. I think also we all agree that lobbying was good, and we didn't want in any way it to be sort of diminished by this.
However, the issue of sunlight, I think, which I mentioned, but also my noble friend Viscount Stansgate did remind us it was Mr. Brandeis, I think, who first used that phrase. What's important is that, and I think it was the noble lord Lord Empey said, that this is, it is timely, but I think he also said we know what needs to be done. And I think my plea to the minister is not to delay. My noble friend Lord Brooke mentioned the COVID inquiry. Lady Bennett, I think, mentioned Greensill.
We cannot wait for another scandal. Let's get this right and let's do it quickly. There are issues raised about cost. I think I have to say that is a bit of a red herring. I mean, I'm very sympathetic having run very small charities, but if actually you go to a consultant lobbyist, it costs you much more than a thousand pounds to get their advice.
And if you happen to be based in Manchester, don't know why I mentioned Manchester, and you bring three of your people down to meet a minister, that's going to cost you more than a thousand pounds. So, you know, let's not use this as an excuse for not bringing a bit more sunlight into this. There are then some other issues about administration and what is a private conversation. I have to say I think the cabbie was a bit OTT. But what is a private conversation?
Is it, you know, meeting at a meeting in a constituency? But that's all in the case of the act now, because if a consultant lobbyist has a brush-by or meets at, happens to meet at a school or in a pub or anywhere, you know, anywhere else, that issue of what counts as a minister is there in the current law. So maybe Lord Lansley ought to be saying what exactly did he mean by a meeting, because that's the current law. All we're saying is that an informal conversation with a minister is as relevant whether it's a consultant lobbying having that or the chair of a PLC. And I think what's really important is, yes to the Lord Sherbourne, we don't want this to be chilling, but we do need to know who's talking to ministers about what.
And the problem we've got at the moment is the ministerial declarations are nothing near detailed enough. So they may meet a publican, but they don't know whether that is about the alcohol pricing or about the general age at which you can drink, or indeed about whether pubs should stay open until five o'clock in the morning for a football match that's taking place. Those are general policy issues. But if it's from a publican saying, I need something for my particular pub or brewery, ministers need to know whether that is something on which they are being lobbied, in which case they should have a civil servant there and they know what they should do.
So let's not pretend this is a new issue. We... there is a difference between general discussion and the Public Bill Office when they helped me with the writing of this, talked me through this. A headmaster, they... or headteacher, meets a minister, talks about general education. Is that an issue? No.
They talk about, you know, how they're finding young people today. Is that an issue? No. If they ask for planning permission so they can extend their particular playground somewhere else, that's lobbying. Ministers know it and actually lobbyists know it.
I've left till last the noble lady, Lady Finn. I have to say I was very disappointed. I was disappointed yesterday when we had a general discussion about political funding of political parties, that it all seemed to be, "Oh, don't interfere with the size of donations given to political parties." This does not seem to me a very good approach to these issues. And I think the idea that... that one of her big things was, "Well, is a thousand pounds too much for an organisation?"
The Baroness Finn
I thank the noble baroness for giving way. I... I find it rather disappointing to be conflating a debate we had yesterday on political party funding where I raised some serious concerns about the asymmetry of the... the government's approach, and I didn't necessarily want to go any further on the size of... size or otherwise of donations, but... but I don't think it's relevant for the conversation today and why that was a disappointment.
Dianne Hayter
The issue is whether we are wanting greater trust in democracy, because that's what part... this bill is about today. And the... the idea that we start putting technical difficulties, administrative difficulties...
The Baroness Finn
Noble baroness again. If we're talking about trust in democracy, the point I was making yesterday was that if the government of the day inflicts substantial damage on opposition parties in political party funding, then... then that is actually... that is questioning trust in democracy.
Dianne Hayter
I disagree with what you were saying yesterday. We don't need to go in that... in the detail of that. The point I'm trying to make is that if we want to enhance trust in democracy, if all the time the issues are how we're getting there, or the cost of it, or the administration, instead of the absolute core issue, which is what this bill is about... it may be too modest a bill, it may be not the right bill, but actually we're talking about enhancing democracy and trust in democracy, then I think it is a shame if the... the... you know, the official opposition, which is what the noble lady, Baroness Finn, is speaking on behalf of, that the attitude is all about the problems and not about the great steps forward that we could make. I think most people who spoke today were in favour of the... the direction of travel of this bill, which is that we don't just regulate or register the five percent of lobbying that takes place at the moment, but we move towards the ninety-five percent of lobbying that takes place.
I think that's what we all want to achieve. I hope my noble friend the minister is going to move more speedily perhaps than sometimes happens within government for understandable reasons and we will soon move forward on this. In the moment I beg to move.
Speaker 29
The question is that this bill be now read a second time. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.
Dianne Hayter
My lords I beg to move that this bill is committed to a committee of the whole house.
Speaker 29
The question is that this bill is committed to the committee of the whole house. As many as are of that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. I'll just give a minute for people to change over before we start the next business.
Yes. Second reading of the Nature's Rights Bill. Baroness Bennett of Manor Hill.
Natalie Bennett
My lords I beg to move that the Nature's Rights Bill now be read a second time. I begin by quoting to the house the government's own words from a biodiversity strategy published jointly with the devolved governments in February 2025. Biodiversity is key to all the processes that support life on earth. We rely on it for our essential needs like food, shelter, energy and medicine as well as for the ecosystem services it provides such as climate regulation, flood management, water purification, disease and pest control and pollination. Additionally more than half of the world's gross domestic product is highly or moderately dependent on nature.
End quote. You'd think then that it and governments around the world would be would have established legal systems and forms that would effectively protect and enhance nature. But that is not what is happening. Particularly in the UK, one of the most nature depleted countries on earth as the State of Nature Report of 2023 concluded. That report was arguably still only very soon after the 2021 Environment Act which set the very modest target of halting the decline in species abundance by 2030.
But half a decade after the act there's still scant signs of progress. For evidence I go to a peer reviewed study by the UK Centre for Ecology and Hydrology out this year which found little sign to the end of the spiralling decline with its lead author pointing to the grave risk of loss of the merlin, the mountain ringlet, the large heath butterflies and plants such as burnt orchid, grass of parnassus and alpine gentian and many other species. The lead author said this will negatively affect local habitats and a range of ecological functions from soil health and nutrient cycling to pollination and food production with knock on effects for wildlife and people. That reflects what is happening around the world. The UN Environment Programme in 2019 found that 150 countries have enshrined environmental protection or the right to a healthy environment in their constitutions.
176 countries have environmental framework laws and 164 countries have created cabinet level bodies for environmental protection. But the laws for environmental protection have not worked. And that's not surprising for as Mari Margil from the US Center for Democratic and Environmental Rights explains environmental laws are put in place to determine how much we can harm or exploit nature.
Environmental laws and regulations have not fundamentally changed the rate of environmental destruction, despite 60 years or more of awareness of environmental issues and half a century of environmental law. Short-term economic interests, particularly of powerful companies, now with the resources and power rivaling those of all but the largest states, nations' determination to exploit and extract from states unable or unwilling to resist them through mining, through logging, through polluting, have overwhelmed what are essentially ineffective legal provisions. That has potentially existential consequences for humans, for our nation, for as the long-delayed and still not fully released Joint Intelligence Chief report that finally emerged in January identified six ecosystem regions that it called critical for UK security that were on a reasonable worst-case scenario on the pathway to collapse. So the search has begun for an alternative approach to secure the future of our biospheres and all of our futures. And the approach that many have settled on, the approach that this bill brings in, is that of rights to nature.
Now, I thank the Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology in setting out a clear briefing about the ethical framework of rights to nature. It notes there are competing views on this, and I expect we will hear some of those today, but I think it's worth going through the origins and the advance of this issue. The origin of this alternative approach is often traced back to Christopher Stone's Should Trees Have Standing?, published in 1972. He noted that for many centuries, women and slaves were not fully recognized as legal subjects, and he saw how there had been a progressive widening of the law's circle of concern. Stone proposed that we give legal rights to forests, oceans, rivers, and other so-called natural objects in the environment, indeed to the natural environment as a whole, and that's what this bill does.
The rights to nature approach offers a reset in our relationship, an ending of the disastrous 17th-century paradigm, a mechanistic worldview that falsely separates people, nature, and the economy as though they can operate independently. Global application of that paradigm has led, as the Stockholm Resilience Centre charts, literally in the case of one diagram that shows the current state of human impacts on nine planetary boundaries, seven of them have not just been exceeded, but smashed. As the European Economic and Social Committee spokesman said, it is irrational to have societal systems that undermine nature. As one of the many who've mustered on Instagram to support this bill very beautifully put it, we need a green Magna Carta. And that is what the bill I present before you today is.
The bill was written by lawyer Mumta Ito of the Nature's Rights charity, drawing on experience working with the UN Harmony with Nature program, and for more of its foundations, you can go to a study conducted for the European Economic and Social Committee towards an EU fundamental charter for the rights of nature. What I present here today is a new legal framework that recognizes nature's rights as the foundation of human rights, social, and economic activity.
It aligns law with modern scientific understanding. Now it is a long bill for a particularly for a private members bill, 57 pages, and it doesn't only set down a major change in legal principle. It also establishes a legal duty of care for public bodies, businesses and individuals, establishes an integrated rights framework, introduces mechanisms for dispute resolution and legal enforcement, establishes a Nature Guardianship Council, bioregional councils and a Nature's Rights Tribunal, and creates a government structure for implementation and integration. As usual, our excellent library briefing sets out the impact of the bill clause by clause, and the bill itself is written in clear and accessible language, with a particular focus on ensuring democracy and local democratic voices are at the heart of decision making across its proposals. If we are going to change everything, and yes, I do have a book out with that title, we have to set out a plan as well as the paradigm shift.
But in this introductory speech, I'm going to concentrate chiefly on the major change in legal principle and approach, nature's rights, because making the case is the first step to delivering it. I will focus on making the case for rights of nature as the foundation of a healthy society, a foundation for all of our futures, to genuinely at scale not just protect the fragments of poisoned, degraded, limited nature that we have left, but to regenerate. To do that, I'm going to briefly outline the international picture, for while this bill is, I believe, the most comprehensive to be considered by any global legislature, the concept of rights of nature and its application has been spreading like a rich and diverse mycorrhizal fungal network, nourishing a flourishing tree of legal change. To quote the Oxford Handbook of Comparative Environmental Politics published in 2021, rights of nature has gone from being a radical idea espoused only by a handful of marginalized actors to a legal strategy seriously considered in a wide variety of domestic and international policy areas. Its authors count 185 legal provisions recognizing rights of nature in 17 countries across five continents, and 50 more pending in 2021 across a dozen other countries.
Rights of nature are now also recognized in many international policy documents. Two exemplars are found in New Zealand, centered on the Whanganui River, a very famous example, and Ecuador. In both cases inspired, as the whole nature's rights movement is, by indigenous thinking, the foundations of cultures that have existed for many thousands and in some cases tens of thousands of years that allowed human societies to live and flourish without trashing their local environments or the planet. Perhaps the most globally comprehensive is Article 71 of the Ecuadorian Constitution written in 2008. Nature, or Pacha Mama, where life is reproduced and occurs, has the right to integral respect for its existence and for the maintenance and regeneration of its life cycles, structure, functions and evolutionary processes.
Now it's important to say that this bill does not represent an alternative to the very strong local action, such as by the Friends of the Thames and the West Sussex Rivers Trust working on rights to river and declarations of the rights to rivers, on which the House of Commons library recently wrote an excellent report, but rather is this bill is complementary to those efforts.
Defending the rights of one river can only have limited impacts on the microplastic and nanoplastic pollution that now covers the planet, the explosion of novel entity pollution that has far exceeded the planet's limits, and of course the climate emergency, with every ton of carbon dioxide emitted having global impacts, and every ton prevented from being emitted being a global positive. All of that demands far broader action than just a focus on one river, as important as that is. It is also complementary with the campaign, of which I declare I'm a member, to create an international offense of ecocide, and also with calls, on which I'm also working, to strengthen the rights of Antarctica to continue to exist as a healthy part of the cryosphere. And it fits very well with the one health approach that acknowledges that human, animal, and environmental health are all interdependent. I very much look forward to our debate today, and I thank the wide range of peers who've signed up to participate, and particularly I look forward to the noble lady the minister's response, for the world is watching, I can say from the social media interest that this debate has already generated.
The current UK government has no stance on the rights of nature on the formal record that the House of Lords library could find. Two years ago at the United Nations, the former Tory government caused international upset by vehemently opposing a motion from Bolivia on living well in balance and harmony with mother nature and mother earth with centric actions. This included a passage on the rights to nature. But we now have a Labour government, and I hope, I trust, that we will hear for the first time whether it has moved on from that disastrous anthropocentric perspective of 2024. Labour's 2024 manifesto acknowledged that we are in a nature emergency and said that it would tackle the unforgivable pollution of our rivers and seas, promote biodiversity, and protect our landscapes and wildlife.
In the nature's rights debate, it has a chance to acknowledge that demands acknowledging a place for nature not as a source of extraction, but a place for the human and the more than human to flourish. To conclude, any noble lord participating today might like to check out Instagram to see a positive use of social media offering broad support for this bill from around the UK and beyond. And I'm going to finish with one the words from one of those posts from 12-year-old artist and naturalist Benjamin Fellow, who made a video supporting this bill. Benjamin said, listen to the children, we need nature and wildlife to survive. I beg to move.
Anne Thérèse Coffey
My lords, I congratulate the noble baroness lady Bennett on introducing this bill. I think it's certainly been a comprehensive bill given the number of clauses that is there. And I do completely understand the sentiment in which she wants to bring this forward. She's right to point out that the Environment Act was actually very important piece of legislation, still only a certain element along the way of aspects being commenced and the like. But I do also understand her huge concern, recognizing that this government is actually rowing back on a lot of the measures that were put in that bill deliberately to try and improve the standing of nature.
Now, the Natural History Museum's index is that the UK stands as 189th out of 240 countries when it comes to considering the completeness of its original nature, with the UK only having 53%. And that is what gives the phrase that often comes out is that the UK's one of the most nature-depleted places in the world.
But of course that doesn't recognize the amount of change that's happened, the growth in population, industrialization and the like. But what I think is fair to say is that it was recognized that we needed to get nature back into balance, which is what brought about the Environment Act. And indeed through the Environmental Performance Index run by Yale and Columbia Universities, the UK in 2024 was actually the fifth best in the world at trying to improve the environment. The countries, the only countries ahead of it were Estonia, Luxembourg, Germany and Finland. And in particular, I know that the noble baroness will be interested in ecosystem vitality, and on that the UK was 11th best in the world.
And that's because there has been a real focus on trying to restore habitats. And it's why I'm worried about other aspects of consultations already underway, changes that have happened in the Planning Infrastructure Bill that seems to put habitat aside if actually a building can be placed there instead. I'm conscious that there has to be an ongoing balance between nature and the development of humanity and the development of housing, but I am, understand her sentiments on why that, she thinks this bill may be necessary. But what I do want to try and get a sense of, because I feel that the existing legislation we have today already has a lot of what she wants, and that some of the extra points may well be superfluous. It's also a very ambitious bill, it's UK-wide with only a duty to consult the devolved administrations.
The government already has statutory advisors. It has Natural England as its principal statutory advisor on nature, but also the OEP in terms of aspects of legislation. But also in the bill, nature itself isn't defined. Will it cover all flora and fauna? But is it about landscapes?
Is it about ecosystems? Is it about cryosystems? That isn't defined in this bill. If it is to include fauna, will that exclude the kept and farmed animals away from this definition? Is it supposed to be what is in a natural environment?
So that is something that I think at committee stage we need to probe further. In terms of trust, I agree with, as I've already started to set out, that I agree somewhat with the noble baroness on her concerns about this. And this is why I will continue to press on other aspects of legislation already coming through, but just to encourage the Defra family to think a bit more carefully about that development of trust. It's when people have seen it elsewhere in climate, when people just think the world's going to end tomorrow, why are we going to be the ones to save it? Those sorts of things start to, people start to become rather skeptical when they hear about the actions they're undertaking and then in other parts of the world nothing is happening.
It then becomes very difficult. A recent example, for example, there in March there was huge publicity about the coastal path being fully open around the country. Actually, as the parliamentary answer given by the minister showed, that was not the case. And it's this sort of deception being done in this sense of publicity is not helpful. Now, I don't know the 2024 motion to which the noble baroness referred, I wasn't in office then, but I was proud to be leading the delegation to the Convention on Biodiversity held in Montreal, the second meeting, where frankly we listened to the EU's concerns about our ambitions, but we put them aside and reopened negotiations and made it completely comprehensive.
Of course, we need to keep going to try and make sure that's a reality. But that's, I think that does reflect actually the ambition of the Conservative government, and indeed my noble friend Lord Gove was the leading force in driving the Environment Act. I want to turn a little bit more to, um, particularly the scrutiny of, um, the legislation. And, um, one of the things in clause 45, it largely sets out these to be negative resolutions, which surprised me, um, in the operation of this, apart from the establishing of the bodies in, um, sections 15, 17, and 28. In terms of criminal offences, I think that makes sense, but I am nervous about the huge Henry VIII powers set out in section 46 and also section 45F.
Um, I will also gently say, um, in clause, uh, section 45(3) is one of the few places where affirmative resolutions are referred to, but it does refer to section 43(6), which is not actually in the bill. So it may be something got, um, deleted by accident. So it would be interesting to hear what further, um, parts of the bill that, um, was intended to apply to. Now, one of the things that I will consider bringing forward as, um, amendments will be about how is this going to... oh, sorry, my other question was how both the noble baroness and the minister might think this is going to work with the EU reset. I think that's going to be an important part of this, um, recognizing that if we're in a EU reset, very soon this Parliament will have no say.
They'll have no vote on any regulation that will then be applied in this country when it comes to a lot of the factors affecting this, um, particular area to which the noble baroness is rightly concerned. Um, so I'd... when I'd also be interested to see what the new Prime Minister will have to say on some of the powers already put in place, which are depleting nature, um, some of those starting today, uh, and... or started yesterday, sorry, and we'll see if we have a Manchester reset, uh, on that particular aspect. Um, there's also an amendment that I am minded to table, and it does relate to the Environment Act and its section 23. And this is about when a minister makes a declaration at second reading only in each, um, house. And I did ask the Procedures and Privileges Committee how this could... the accuracy of those comments could be challenged.
And the answer was you just ask a parliamentary question or ask the minister, and the minister, um, kindly said that, um, the votes... ministers were bound by the ministerial code. However, due to an action, a legal action undertaken by Wild Justice, um, it was determined that actually these are parliamentary proceedings. This has got nothing to do with the ministerial code or any other aspect of law. Um, but so far the... the government would not release the legal opinion, uh, presented by First Treasury Counsel, or indeed Parliament would not release Speaker's Counsel's, um, provisions. So it may be that I table some amendments at that point.
But with that, while I wish generally the baroness well, I'm afraid I won't be supporting her bill through its full passage.
Yevgeny Lebedev
My Lords, this bill addresses one of the greatest crises of our times: the ravaging of nature, the destruction of the environment of which we depend and of which we're an inseparable part. I congratulate the noble lady Baroness Bennett on her good fortune in coming second in the private members' ballot and using this opportunity to bring forward this bill. I would like to lend my voice of support to her.
The noble lady has made the case for the bill with admirable clarity and passion. She is absolutely right to remind us in this house of the scale and speed with which the natural world is being destroyed. Deforestation, loss of habitats, the hunting of endangered species for gain, unsustainable farming practices, the ruthless race for rare earths, the rapacious approach so many nations take to mineral extraction, the accumulation of plastics and other waste in our rivers and seas, mankind in so many ways is laying waste to the planet which is our only home and demonstrating a reckless disregard for the creation of which we are not only one part. And this global phenomenon is sadly all too apparent in our own poor stewardship, our own disdainful lack of care for nature in these islands. The UK is one of the most depleted nations in the world.
Valuable habitats have been lost to unsustainable development, our rivers continue to be polluted by poorly regulated water companies and inadequately supported farmers. The sanctity, the preservation of nature, is a deeply personal cause for me. My grandfather, Professor Vladimir Sokolov, was a pioneering zoologist and ecologist and a member of the Brundtland Commission, which helped to define our modern understanding of sustainable development. As a boy I travelled with him to Africa and across the old Soviet Union, inspired by his tireless work to protect nature. I have tried in my own small way to carry on that work, campaigning against illegal wildlife trade, supporting indigenous communities to protect their way of life and precious environments they and the species they live alongside depend on.
I am particularly moved by the efforts I have been proud to support to safeguard African elephants and other megafauna. But as Baroness Bennett reminds us all, nature demands our care and requires our protection. I know that some aspects of the bill and the expansive nature of legal and regulatory protection it envisages will not be to the taste of many of your lordships. But no one has been clearer about their wish that this bill be improved through debate and dialogue than Baroness Bennett herself. Working with civil society, she has made clear we need broader conversation about precisely the measures we need to implement to recognise the interdependence between our species' fate and others.
We cannot be in doubt though, what cannot be in doubt though is the need for greater urgency and action. The government and its predecessor has taken some important steps, moving away from the wasteful system of subsidy we had in the Common Agricultural Policy to providing public money for public goods such as carbon sinks and enhanced habitats. The 25-year environment plan with its targets for habitat reclamation, the creation of marine protected areas and the establishment of office for environmental protections are all welcome moves forward. But the public expect us to go further. I'm sure your lordships are familiar with the work of the gifted nature writer Robert Macfarlane.
His latest book, Is a River Alive?, is a runaway Sunday Times bestseller. Its popularity speaking to the new clamour for us to all recognise what we owe nature. We need to recast the language of rights and duties to arrest and transcend the destruction of the natural world. This bill helps us to do just that and I am pleased to be able to support it in its second reading.
David Frost
My Lords, I thank the noble lady Baroness Bennett for bringing forward this bill. It's an extremely interesting bill, well worthy of debate. And indeed, it's good to have a bill that raises properly philosophical issues. Apart from the recent Assisted Dying Bill, we don't often get them. Now, the question of what nature is has, of course, preoccupied philosophers and theologians since the ancient Greeks.
And they ask, is the natural order itself divine, merely God's handiwork, something in between, or more recently, of course, neither or none of those things? And in examining this question, one issue very relevant to this bill recurs, which is whether, and if so why, it is reasonable to personalize the concept of nature for theological, philosophical, or indeed political purposes. And this bill seems to do just that. And one is led to speculate, indeed, whether we're seeing not just the embodiment of the modern Gaia concept, but also a return to the Lady Nature of the early medieval Chartres school of Bernard Silvestris and Alan de Lille. Now, these are not, I think, irrelevant or purely intellectual questions.
The bill asks us to believe that nature exists as a specific, recognizable, even self-evident concept, and builds an entire political structure around that. Yet intellectual history tells us things are a bit more complicated than that. Get the concept wrong, and the politics and the legislation will be wrong too, and I fear that's what's happening. Now, despite what I've just said, I actually have more sympathy with the bill's proponent, with the noble lady Baroness Bennett, in this area than she might perhaps imagine, even if she doesn't necessarily agree with the route by which I get there. The bill itself, of course, is very problematical, of course, but we will come on to that.
But I do think it's trying to recognize something important with which I actually sympathize. I'm personally, I'm rather with Thomas Aquinas in thinking that nature is something distinct from the divine creator, but also some way special. The natural world is not God, but nor is it just sort of stuff. It is special and should be treated accordingly. It bears witness to God in a sacramental way.
We shouldn't be casual, therefore, we shouldn't be casually mistreating of our natural environment. Now, it's one thing to say that, and another to turn it into meaningful and practical legislation. And in fact, I worry, I think it isn't actually possible to do this in a secular democracy. And the reason I've begun with this theological excursus is precisely because I think the bill is trying to bring in a kind of confessionalism by the back door. If we were to take it seriously, it would require every one of us and every organization to pay obeisance to nature and its rights as if it were some kind of goddess, someone or something with super-personal rights, with superior status, reducing us as humans to beings subordinate to her.
And indeed, that's exactly what we find in clause 4.2, in which humans and human rights are explicitly made secondary to the rights of nature with a capital N. I contend that this is a sort of religious approach, but not, of course, a Christian one. It's more a pagan vision, and one which I would say is fundamentally anti-human and antithetical to human flourishing and should therefore be resisted. My Lords, the bill raises not just such philosophical issues, but also practical and important public policy issues.
one of them is the way that this approach treats nature with a capital N again as a single unified rights-bearing subject. but nature is not a single it. indeed clause 42 of the bill itself defines nature at some length as I quote the interconnected community of living organisms ecosystems habitats species landscapes etc etc collapsing an almost limitless heterogeneity of entities into one legal person in what I would contend is a rather meaningless fashion. indeed the bill's proponent has summarized this I think by saying that nature is everything there is and the economy is a complete subset of that. well I would agree on that but that's precisely the problem.
how can nature be a rights-bearing entity as clause 2 describes it if it's everything there is? how are we supposed to address all the trade-offs and conflicts that arise within that? the only way of doing it is to do what we already do to establish various rights human corporate property whatever and adjudicate between them on the basis of agreed criteria. you can't adjudicate between those rights and the whole system. they're on different levels they're different kinds of things.
it simply doesn't make sense to try and do it and in that sense I think the whole bill just is not workable. but let's suppose we tried it anyway. the problem then is that nature is full of competing interests predator versus prey native versus colonizing species one bioregion's water needs versus another you could go on endlessly. so any coherent rights of nature framework means you need some sort of metric to compare harms and benefits across radically different kinds of entities. now the bill's own definition of concepts like ecological integrity safe limits planetary boundaries as set out in clause 42 all gesture at scientific provision but actually they just relabel these same incommensurable variables as things that purport to be legally operative thresholds.
actually they're just bringing scientific contestability directly into the binding law. and in these circumstances I contend that the judges the tribunals or the members of the sinister-sounding nature guardianship council will simply be making their own value judgments dressed up as adjudication and that risk becoming arbitrary government in the purest form. my lords conclude there are many other problems with the bill and I'll just mention a few. clause 33 creates a sweeping new criminal offense incredibly with up to 20 years imprisonment as the maximum sentence for quote recklessly causing serious harm to nature entirely disproportionate. clause 30 allows proceedings to be brought in the name of nature I quote by charities community bodies public interest organizations long long list combined with a state-funded environmental justice fund.
all this is yet further subsidy to campaign groups to litigate against infrastructure housing farming real activity in the real world as if that wasn't problematic enough already. we're seeing the enshrining of the precautionary principle in a very broad form in clause 34. clauses 10 11 direct the entire financial and banking sector to reorient lending investment and pension decisions around ecological criteria. we're seeing the creation of huge regulation-making powers for secretaries of state with very few limitations and of course the creation of a vast additional bureaucracy to support this new activity. my lords conclude I think in short and I say it with a degree of sadness for the reasons I set out at the start I'm afraid the bill is not just philosophically incoherent but probably unworkable.
In saying all this, I'm doing the bill the courtesy of taking it seriously, and I wonder whether one really should, given that it involves a complete upending of our economic, environmental, and legal systems, and it's difficult to imagine it could really make progress given that. But I do think, to conclude, it's worth identifying and dismantling these ideas now, while they're marginal and merely crankish, rather than risking them acquiring momentum and becoming actively dangerous. We've had enough bad ideas in politics in the last few years, let's not import another one in this bill now.
Carmen Smith
My Lords, I begin by thanking the noble Baroness Lady Bennett for bringing forward this bill and for her long-standing commitment to environmental protection and climate justice. Firstly, I draw the House's attention to an early day motion tabled in the other place this May, entitled National Emergency, sponsored by members from the Labour Party, the Liberal Democrats, the Green Party, and my own party, Plaid Cymru. It highlighted the escalating risks posed by climate change and nature loss. It noted that one in four properties could be at risk of flooding by 2050, that heatwaves and wildfires are becoming more frequent and severe, and that the UK ranks among the lowest globally for biodiversity. It further recognized that food security, public health, and national security are increasingly threatened by climate-related impacts.
The motion called for emergency legislation to address the scale and urgency of these challenges. That is why I believe this bill comes before us at a particularly important time, and we must consider it seriously. We often speak of a climate emergency and a nature emergency, yet emergencies require more than declarations. They demand that we seriously consider new approaches and, where necessary, new legal frameworks. Time is not on our side.
The systems upon which our society depends are undergoing pressure, and the consequences of inaction are becoming increasingly clear. The central principle of this bill is both simple and profound: should nature itself be recognized in law as a subject possessing rights, rather than being regarded as property or a resource to be managed? In considering that question, we must be honest about the scale of the crisis the bill seeks to address and ask ourselves whether the status quo is delivering the protection that nature and indeed future generations require. The noble Baroness Lady Bennett had already referred to examples internationally, including in Ecuador, where recognition of the rights of nature has provided a new legal mechanism for environmental protection, including the successful defense of the Los Cedros forest against mining activity. Whether or not we conclude that that model is directly transferable to these islands, it demonstrates that alternative approaches are possible and worthy of serious consideration.
I believe our legal frameworks must continue to evolve if they are to respond effectively to ecological decline. As legislators, we have a responsibility to engage constructively with ideas that seek to protect the natural world, which we all depend on, and which future generations have every right to inherit in a healthy condition.
For me, this bill poses a fundamental question: if the well-being of future generations depends upon clean water, healthy soils, thriving biodiversity, resilient ecosystems, pollinators and a stable climate, should the law continue to treat nature principally as a possession and a resource, or should it begin to recognize nature as the living foundation upon which long-term societal resilience ultimately rests? From a Welsh perspective, this question is particularly relevant. Wales has already sought to place future generations at the heart of public policy through the Well-being of Future Generations (Wales) Act 2015. The legislation was pioneering in requiring public bodies to consider the long-term consequences of their decisions and the world they leave behind for those who come after us. It reflects a growing recognition that prosperity, well-being and environmental stewardship cannot be separated from one another.
And in many respects, this bill can be seen as part of the broader evolution in governance. The Future Generations Act asks us to think about the well-being of future generations. This bill invites us to consider more explicitly the ecological foundations upon which that well-being depends. As this legislation progresses, there will undoubtedly be important questions about how such an approach would interact with existing Welsh legislation and devolved responsibilities. But I don't think that should be considered a blocker.
Those are precisely the kinds of issues that can and should be explored in committee. Ultimately, the key question at second reading is not whether every clause is perfect, rather is whether the principle underpinning the bill is worthy of further examination. And in my view, the rights of nature are not in competition with human rights or economic prosperity, rather nature is the foundation upon which they depend. A degraded natural world cannot support flourishing communities or resilient economies. And there is work still to do and legitimate questions remain.
Those questions should not prevent us from examining this bill further, they should encourage us to do so. Supporting its passage today will be a sign of the recognition that the challenges of climate change and biodiversity loss require us to examine new ideas with an open mind and where necessary improve them through the scrutiny of committee. And this is what the public are asking for, and many young people. For that reason, I believe this bill merits further consideration by this House and I'm pleased to support its progression today.
Helene Hayman
My Lords, may I begin by thanking the noble Baroness Lady Bennett for bringing forward this bill. And it's a pleasure to follow noble lady's speech today, I agree with much of what she has said. As someone who has recently retabled my own private member's bill to introduce a closed season for hares in England and Wales, I appreciate how much determination and luck it requires to bring issues such as these before Parliament. I welcome the spirit of this bill. It invites us to consider our relationship with the natural world and to reflect whether our laws adequately recognize our responsibilities towards the species, habitats and ecosystems upon which we all depend.
In particular, I welcome its emphasis on the duties of public bodies, businesses and individuals to act as responsible stewards of nature. The noble Baroness is right to argue that there remains gap in our legal framework.
Too often nature is viewed primarily as something from which we derive benefit, rather than something for which we owe a duty of care. The result is that species and habitats that are widely admired and often deeply valued, nevertheless remain inadequately protected. The case of the wild hares illustrates this point particularly well. At present hares are the only game species in England and Wales without a statutory close season. They may be shot throughout the year, including during the breeding months between February and September.
Other game species, whether deer, pheasants or partridges, receive seasonal protection during these sensitive periods. Hares alone remain exempt. The consequences are significant. Pregnant hares and nursing mothers may legally be killed, leaving dependent leverets orphaned. A 2017 peer-reviewed study published by the UK Health Security Agency found between February and August that majority of female hares are either pregnant, suckling young or both, and that if a nursing female is killed, her leverets are unlikely to survive.
This creates both an animal welfare problem and conservation challenge, and is inconsistent with Natural England's own guidance that control of species during peak breeding season should be avoided. There is also a broader ecological concern. Evidence suggests that large organized hare shoots can remove substantial proportion of local populations, while the peak period for shooting coincides with the start of breeding season. This undermines population recovery and increases the risk of localized decline. The wider picture is equally concerning.
In 1880, there were an estimated 4 million brown hares in England and Wales. Today there are fewer than 600,000 remaining. Agricultural change has undoubtedly been the principal driver of this decline, but unsustainable exploitation through shooting, poaching and coursing has also played a part. My Lords, the United Kingdom has often been a leader in advancing animal welfare standards. Yet in this instance, we have fallen behind.
Scotland introduced a statutory close season more than a decade ago, and a comparable protection already exists across much of Europe. England and Wales remain an exception. For many years campaigners have sought to address this anomaly, however they have failed. I therefore welcome the government's animal welfare strategy published last December, which committed to introducing a close season between the 1st February and the 30th of September. I was also grateful to hear the minister reaffirm her commitment to animal welfare reform when we discussed this issue in the House last week.
I have no doubt about either her personal commitment or her determination to secure legislative time. It was therefore deeply disappointing that despite reports earlier this year suggesting that a close season would be included in His Majesty's gracious speech, the proposal did not ultimately appear. That experience reflects one of the central themes of this bill. Responsibilities towards nature cannot always be postponed until a more convenient political moment. If we recognize that we have duties towards the natural world, then even relatively modest reforms should not repeatedly fall victim to competing legislative priorities.
A close season for hares is one of such reforms. It is modest in legislative terms, but significant in its practical effect. It would prevent the unnecessary killing of pregnant and nursing hares, reduce the number of orphaned leverets, bring England and Wales into line with protections already established elsewhere, and contribute to the government's wider commitment under the Environment Act 2021 to halt species decline by 2030.
It would also command considerable public support. Polling by More in Common found that 66% of the public support a close season, only 6% opposing. Whether or not noble lords agree with every mechanism proposed in this bill, it raises an important question. Are we content with a legal framework that too often recognizes the value of nature only after damage has occurred, or should our laws better reflect our responsibility to prevent that damage in the first place? The story of the brown hare demonstrates how easily necessary and widely supported protections can be delayed.
I hope this bill will encourage us to translate our responsibilities into practical action, not only for hares, but for the wider natural environment upon which future generations will depend.
Robert Winston
I'm grateful for the ability to speak very briefly in the gap. I wish to congratulate the noble lady on her introducing this interesting debate, this, this, and I hope it goes to the committee stages where I think I'm going to have some very serious objections to it, but we'll come to that in due course. I think we have to accept that nature, if it has rights, it's very difficult to see how they can be enforced. And secondly, if nature has rights, how do those rights become protected? And if in fact there is a conflict, who resolves that, that conflict?
Is it merely lawyers, because of course there will be different issues. And one of the questions I think really is that we have to understand in this bill, the definition of nature and the definition of those rights is extremely difficult, and I think that would need a great deal of tangling out to do if we do do that. And when I think about, for example, even in medicine, we go, the noble Lord Frost, I kept on thinking of him as Lord Tree, but of course Lord Tree, who is another natural thing, is also not protected in this, in this debate. But I agree completely with what Lord Tree, Lord Frost says, which of course actually one of the issues is that these things are so difficult really to disentangle and are very, very difficult to define. So if we come to Aquinas, for example, in the history of the embryo, even he had difficulty, and he had to define the notion of life, whether in fact the embryo was alive, and he decided it might be once it had an anima, but not while it still just merely had flesh.
That was one of the issues of Carra. So I would argue really that ultimately, if we really looked at this, we have to recognize that even the conflicts in medicine are massive. The biggest single cause of death in humans worldwide is due to bacteria. How would, how, at what stage do we deal with this, and how can we possibly do it in terms of natural justice?
Kathryn Parminter
My lords, I'm very grateful to the noble Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle for bringing forward this very timely opportunity to examine this concept. And as we've heard today, it does involve practicality and philosophy. As she rightly said, nature is critical, and we're on the brink of a mass extinction. I should declare an interest as my daughter-in-law works as a scientist for Friends of the Dart, which I will mention later. Now, I've been thinking particularly about these issues around rights of nature after the conference I went to recently that was organized by the Real Farming Conference and the New York University School of Law's More Than Human, that's MOTH, Life Program.
That conference was really exciting because we heard from agroecological farmers, citizen activists, scientists, and local authorities who were all taking very effective action and learning from each other how to put nature's well-being at the heart of their work.
And actually that's what this bill is about too. It's about a new way of thinking and working. As other noble Lords have mentioned, it's about economy and society working in harmony with nature. Now several noble Lords have mentioned Ecuador and I will spend a little time here because I think there are lessons to be learned. In 2008 Ecuador introduced the rights of nature into its constitution.
And of course it has the Galapagos Islands, Amazon rainforests, volcanic landscapes, cloud forest and high elevation moorlands. In short, it's a diversity to protect that's internationally recognized as extraordinarily special. Now obviously it's a very different country from the UK with very different strengths and very different problems. But I think there are some lessons that we can learn from Ecuador. First, scientific evidence.
The fact that evidence is crucial to argue the case for an ecosystem, there needs to be a sound scientific basis. Rights of nature work in Los Cedros, which is quoted by Robert Macfarlane in his book Is a River Alive?, referred to by the noble Lord Lord Levedev, has shown how inadequate the typical environmental impact assessment is for industrial projects. In Los Cedros, scientists and local farmers have found many more endangered species than the environmental impact assessments had reported. Secondly, nature's rights need to go hand in hand with human rights. There was a journalist who was investigating a lot of these issues in Ecuador and she, Katie Surma, wrote in Inside Climate News an interesting analysis that actually has global application.
She said, and I quote, "Ecuador's emblematic of a global trend that governments and corporations increasingly rely on criminal charges, retaliatory lawsuits and other forms of legal harassment to stifle opposition." Having rights of nature in their constitution hasn't been a silver bullet. And it's not that the government has always been on board. Currently multiple heads and board members of the Amazon Sacred Headwaters Alliance that protects 35 million hectares of the Amazon rainforest are on the prosecutor's list and face all sorts of things like frozen bank accounts. Now before noble Lords think, well that wouldn't happen here, just remember the recent direction from judge to jury to disregard motives for protest.
That was about climate change. And the arrests of those holding placards reminding juries of their rights. That was shocking abuse of a fundamental right. So I think human rights and nature's rights are absolutely intertwined. Another lesson from Ecuador is about press freedom.
Reporters Without Borders documented four cases of death threats just this year between January and February on journalists in Ecuador reporting on environmental issues and they also face increasing restrictions imposed on the press by the state.
Again, noble Lords shouldn't think that here in the UK press freedoms are a given. They're compromised at the moment by the SLAPP, the strategic lawsuits against public participation, and there are plenty of examples of public interest activism that's quelled by a SLAPP on, for example, pollution, environmental reporting, and corporate accountability. And I hope all noble Lords will be supporting Baroness Stowell's forthcoming very important bill on SLAPPs. So I think local activism is incredibly important. And perhaps the one thing that we might thank noble Lord Lord Frost for in encouraging Brexit is that actually it really made people realize the value of their local rivers and what was happening to them once the water framework that had protected the rivers all the time we were a member of the European Union, once that disappeared, because it took rivers to a different place of being used basically as drains by the water companies.
The rights of rivers charters and declarations have grown as a movement incredibly quickly in these last few years. And around my hometown, there's Friends of the Dart that I mentioned, it's a community interest company based in Totnes that works to protect and restore the River Dart through scientific monitoring, advocacy, and community action. And it really brings people together to recognize that river. And then of course the more famous example is the River Wye that had such issues with agricultural pollution, and the Hereford County Council and Powys County Council came together to make sure that from source to sea that river is properly protected. And that movement is really at an early stage, but it's growing exponentially.
And then of course we've also got local nature recovery strategies which local authorities are putting into effect in, again, my home county of Devon. I can see there will be immense effects, beneficial effects as those strategies are beginning to bed down and work. And I've a whole list of county and district councils who are doing all sorts of work, and I won't weary the House with them, I'm sure they're aware of them. But my concern is that this bill, which I support wholeheartedly, the rights of nature principle, I can see that it is stronger to build it from local actions that are already happening and are effective, and that will give it much stronger foundations. My concern about this bill at the moment is that it's very top-down and very prescriptive and doesn't consider how the current law will mesh with what's in the bill, nor does it address the failure of enforcement and regulation.
Current laws for protecting nature are ignored. Just take the fly-tipping in Hoad's Wood, for example, sewage dumping in rivers, but the awareness of this and the anger people feel has really begun to cut through, and local community action, citizen scientists are actually all nature's guardians now.
I worry the approach in this bill would mean tying up resources in lengthy legal battles. So on these benches, we're very grateful to Baroness Bennett for introducing her bill. And I do look forward to the committee stage where we can discuss some of these issues in greater detail. But in the meantime, I think that really the difference between us is that the Lib Dem approach is one of practical action and localism. And that whilst we may legislate to have rights of nature in principle, action on the ground, fast action, rests at a local level.
Edward Mowbray Nicholas Howard
My Lords, please let me thank all noble Lords who have contributed to this debate, and the noble Baroness Lady Bennett of Manor Castle for bringing this bill before your Lordships' House. My Lords, this bill is clearly driven by good intentions, but it does propose a number of radical shifts, which the noble Lord Lord Frost references problematic on several different levels, and which the noble Lord Lord Winston suggested he had very serious objections to. And His Majesty's loyal opposition also has significant concerns about the bill's practicalities and the implications for individuals, businesses, and policymaking. Our concerns center around two main points. Primarily, we do not believe in creating all-powerful governance structures which potentially override democratic decision-making, nor do we believe in imposing new requirements for nature which override existing legitimate considerations and interests.
I should clarify, His Majesty's loyal opposition stands tall on our principles when it comes to nature, and this is not a recent commitment. The noble Baroness Lady Thatcher was crystal clear when she advised that no generation has a freehold on this earth. All we have is a life tenancy with a full repairing lease. We passed the Wildlife and Countryside Act in 1981, and we established the modern framework for sites of special scientific interest and species protection. The noble Baroness Lady Coffey highlighted the Environment Act 2021, and it was my noble friend Lord Goldsmith of Richmond Park who supported the passage of the Environment Act through your Lordships' House.
And we championed the Blue Belt program. Indeed, in recent months, noble Lords on our benches have consistently advocated for a brownfield-first approach to development to protect our land. We have advocated for reforms of arms-length bodies such as Natural England and to better enable private investment in nature restoration. However, I am afraid to say we are now seeing the consequences of a flawed approach to the environment on both our industry and our own cost of living.
Instead of drilling our own oil and gas in the North Sea, we are importing it from Norway. Instead of growing more of our own food, we are covering productive farmland with solar panels, an estimated 68% of which come from China. We are weakening our own energy security and increasing our reliance on imports. The Aberdeen South by-election was a referendum on homegrown oil and gas, and the result was overwhelming. The country wants a common sense approach.
And our major concern is that this bill risks pitching economic growth against nature and giving the rights of nature, as currently drafted, precedence in all instances. But as I flagged earlier, we do not fault the intentions behind the bill, but we do have serious questions as to how it will play out in practice. Nature will inevitably be impacted, perhaps on a site allocated for development, but where biodiversity net gain requirements will compensate for this impact elsewhere. Yet if our interpretation of clause 3 is correct, the bill gives nature the right to restoration and regeneration where the impact has occurred, potentially hindering development in that very location. We have to ask ourselves, do we want to risk slowing or even blocking housing needs, which are significant?
Do we want to risk hampering infrastructure or energy investment at a time when delivery is absolutely critical for the country? Please let me now turn to the new governance structures proposed in the bill, which will be tasked with implementing, monitoring, and enforcing the bill's provisions. The membership, appointment, governance, procedure, and accountability of both the proposed Nature Guardianship Council and Bioregional Councils are left to the Secretary of State to determine via regulations. The appointment, qualifications, and independence of members of a new Nature's Rights Tribunal are again left to the Secretary of State to decide. Yet these would be immensely powerful bodies.
The Nature Guardianship Council would be tasked with interpreting the integrated rights framework, a framework which would apply to all ministerial decisions, whether they are legislative, policy, fiscal, planning, procurement, or investment. The council would issue guidance on new rights impact assessments, which public authorities and UK entities would be required to carry out when any decision, policy, plan, program, project, activity, financial decision, or regulatory measure may, I quote, materially affect nature. Furthermore, the bill is explicit that there are no exemptions for any entity, even on the grounds of national security, which we would suggest is the first duty of any government. Much will depend on what is interpreted as lawful, what constitutes a significant effect on nature, and how risk or harm is measured.
Nor are the bill's rights and duties applicable just to national and local government. It would establish a legal duty of care towards nature on all individuals, private businesses, and public bodies. Trade, supply chains, and overseas activities would have to comply with the bill's provisions. My Lords, this is a huge, radical, and all-encompassing change. And His Majesty's loyal opposition believes we should never, on any account, risk sidelining the everyday economic realities for UK citizens or indeed our national security.
A cross-departmental approach to nature, which is driven by both evidence and data, with advice from experts in their respective fields, is the way forward. And there are undoubtedly significant improvements to be made to the existing status quo, but in our opinion, this bill is not the way to do it.
Sue Hayman
My Lords, I'm very grateful to all noble Lords who've contributed to today's debate. We've heard pretty strong strength of feelings here, and I think that reflects a deep and widely shared concern for the state of our natural world. And it also reflects the seriousness with which this House approaches questions of environmental protection, governance, and accountability. So I'd like to pay tribute to the noble Baroness Lady Bennett of Manor Castle for bringing forward this bill and for her long-standing commitment to the protection and the restoration of nature. Whatever our differences on the legislative route, there is absolutely no doubt about the sincerity and the intellectual rigor and energy that she and those supporting the drafting of the bill have brought to this issue and to these proposals.
As the noble Lord Lord Frost mentioned, we have heard some very thoughtful contributions on the philosophical and ethical foundations of recognizing nature's intrinsic worth. And we've heard reflections on international examples, on local initiatives, and on the growing public desire for stronger action to protect the environment. These are of course really important perspectives, and the government recognizes the legitimacy of the concerns that underpin them. And I think the noble Lady Baroness Bennett recognized the government's commitment to this when she referenced our manifesto regarding our environmental commitment specifically. But as many noble Lords have also made clear, the question before us is not whether we value nature or whether we need to act urgently to protect it and to restore it.
The question is whether the mechanism that is proposed in this bill, recognizing nature as a legal subject with enforceable rights, is the correct approach within the UK's constitutional and legal framework. My Lords, the government's position is that it is not. We already have in place a comprehensive, outcomes-focused, and legally binding framework for environmental protection through the Environment Act of 2021 and the Environmental Improvement Plan of 2023. And I'd like to assure the noble Lady Baroness Coffee that this government is not rowing back on any of its commitments. And these provide long-term statutory targets.
They provide strengthened duties on public authorities and independent oversight through the Office for Environmental Protection. And importantly, they require government to act, to report, and to be held to account. Taken together, these measures will help us to restore nature, improve environmental quality, create a circular economy, protect environmental security, and improve people's access to nature. The environmental improvement plan ensures that nature's recovery is a key priority, fundamental to the government's approach to economic growth. And this government is committed to delivering for nature, taking action to meet our Environment Act targets, to restore and to protect our natural world.
And this is not a system that lacks ambition or enforceability. It is one of the most robust environmental governance frameworks in the world and sets out our goals and targets, how we will achieve them, and who is responsible for delivery. And it is designed to integrate environmental considerations right across government, through regulators, and through the local authorities. But achieving our environmental ambitions requires collective action from individuals, communities, and organisations across all sectors. And this was particularly referenced to by the noble lady Baroness Hayman.
So we have sought views and advice from civil society, business, landowners and managers, and local government in developing the environmental improvement plan, and we will work in partnership to achieve its goals and targets. And we are also already strengthening nature recovery across government land by publishing a first-of-its-kind government estate nature plan. And that improves coordination, evidence, and delivery within our existing legal framework. This demonstrates that we can work together to accelerate nature recovery without creating new legal rights or legal personality for nature. Introducing a parallel and overlapping rights-based system as the bill proposes would create significant risks.
It could duplicate or conflict with existing statutory duties. It could generate uncertainty for regulators, land managers, businesses, and communities. And it could divert resources away from delivery and into litigation, into procedural complexity and institutional restructuring. The noble lady Baroness Smith particularly talked about this impact on Wales and the challenges facing Wales. And I just thought that it was important to stress to noble lords that the bill has UK-wide ambition, but it still preserves the devolved competence which enables devolved governments to make decisions around implementation.
We've also heard today about the serious legal and constitutional implications of recognising nature as a legal entity. Such a step, through the bill's proposed integrated rights framework, would require a fundamental reworking of long-established principles of administrative, property, and planning law. It would introduce new enforcement bodies, including a Nature Guardianship Council and Nature Rights Tribunal, without clarity on how these would interact with existing regulators and courts. And it could lead to a proliferation of claims brought on behalf of ecosystems or species. It is important to consider the whole system in the round, as demonstrated through our recently published land use framework, including considering wider democratically determined priorities such as housing, infrastructure, and economic development, and to utilise existing tools to access their impacts on nature.
International examples of nature being recognised as a legal subject were cited in her introduction by the noble lady Baroness Bennett, and they are important to consider. As the noble lady Baroness Smith said, we do need to be aware of alternative approaches.
However, evidence and outcomes are mixed, and the interaction with relevant domestic legal systems and frameworks is complex. And whilst I acknowledge that rights of nature is a concept that is legally recognized in some countries, the UK's consistent position in international negotiations alongside many other countries has been to focus on environmental outcomes, such as halting biodiversity loss, restoring ecosystems and reducing pollution, rather than debating legal constructs whose practical implications remain uncertain. The noble lady Baroness Miller spent some time talking about this and about the fact there's been a marked rise in international and domestic litigation drawing on existing human rights, such as the right to life, a right to private and family life, and linking these to adverse environmental conditions. The Council of Europe of course has been particularly active on the issue in recent years and has been scoping a possible new instrument on this right, which could create a new right to clean, healthy and sustainable environment alongside other human rights protected under the European Convention on Human Rights. So I'd just like to clarify that the UK is open in principle to exploring a new instrument to enshrine the right.
However, there is not yet consensus among member states on the type of instrument, should it be binding for example or non-binding, or the content, the nature and scope of the right. But none of what we've just discussed diminishes the urgency of the challenge. The government is clear-eyed about the pressures on nature. It underpins our security, our prosperity, our resilience, and understanding the threats we face from biodiversity loss is crucial to meeting them head on. So we are acting through the environmental improvement plan to restore habitats, improve water and air quality, strengthen resilience and invest significantly in nature recovery.
This is a statutory, science-based and accountable framework. And it is the right one for our legal system. Before closing, I would just like to pay tribute to Baroness Hellich for her energy and her determination on the need to bring in a closed season for brown hares, and I'm sure we will hear from her again on this issue. But can I finally just thank the noble Baroness Lady Bennett for bringing this bill forward and for stimulating what has been an important and thoughtful debate. But as the noble Lord Lord Frost said, legislation must be workable, coherent and compatible with the UK's legal framework.
And for these reasons, while we share the ambition that motivates the bill, the government cannot support it. We will continue to focus on delivering the environmental improvement plan. We do want to meet our legally binding targets so that we can ensure that nature in this country is protected, restored and valued for generations to come. My Lords, I commend the house for the quality of today's debate.
Natalie Bennett
My Lords, in rising to follow the noble lady the minister, I wish to echo that.
I think all noble Lords who've participated in this today, it has been a very fine debate and I thank very much everyone who's contributed. Picking up the noble lady the Minister's comments to start with. I'm taking encouragement from a part near the end where the noble lady said the government may be open in principle to considering the rights of nature in an international context. I will have to read the fine detail of her study, her comments, but I'm taking that as a positive step forward. I'm also acknowledging that the noble lady recognizes the legitimacy of concerns about the state of nature, which are very widespread.
Picking up both what the noble lady and the noble Lord Lord Frost said about this being a transformative, even revolutionary bill, step forward rights of nature, I agree. But I think the noble lady talked about changing the UK's constitutional and legal framework. Well, of course that's a broader question. We very much have before us today, we are going to have to see major changes to those to create a modern functional democratic constitution, and of course the rights of nature could very much be part of that transformation. I think the noble lady also talked about a fundamental reworking of principles.
Well, as some of the early proponents of rights to nature said, that's also what happened when we created rights for enslaved people and rights for women. We have seen significant changes in the past. But I want to begin by thanking particularly the noble lady Baroness Smith for her strongest support for the bill. And I think the noble lady summed up in one sentence why we need this bill, or one question. Is the status quo delivering for the protection of nature and the rights of future generations?
No, the current framework is not. And the noble lady also said that the rights of nature are not in competition with human rights or economic prosperity, and explained as the noble lady the Minister I think did, how this very much fits within the rights of future generations act in Wales. And as the noble lady the Minister acknowledged, this does acknowledge the competencies of the devolved administrations. That's very much been carefully written into the bill. I will also very much thank the noble lady Baroness Helich, who said how we have looked at how we derive benefit from nature rather than seeing us owing a duty of care.
And I wish her bill, her bill, all fair winds behind it, and thank her for starting my morning as we had a pre-debate discussion with a lovely picture of a leveret, which really cheered up my morning. I can recommend that any morning you need to be cheered up. I thank the noble Lord Lord Debvedev very much for stressing the need for urgency and action. I'm going to look up the work of his grandfather. I'd be very interested to find out about that.
And also for the focus on the need to support indigenous communities. I've recently come back from the high north, and indigenous communities in the high north, indigenous communities within Europe, have a lot to teach us but are also under very significant threat and need that protection. And also, as did the noble lady beside me, highlighting the work of Robert Macfarlane, Is a River Alive? These are, that's a great book and anyone who hasn't read it should read that book. I engage now with the noble Lord Lord Frost and indeed the noble lady Baroness Coffee, and I very sincerely say to both of them my thanks for seriously engaging with this debate and this bill, and I appreciate that.
I am a little surprised that the noble Lord Frost regarded as an argument against it that it would be a complete upending of our current arrangements. Coming from one of the chief proponents of Brexit, that seems a little curious that that would be an argument against the bill, but I'll park that there. Although I will also note that the noble Lord said we should have more philosophical debates in our chamber, and I very much agree with that. We have philosophies that have led us to a very bad place in the world at this moment.
Debating the philosophies, thinking about the foundations of our thought is something we need to do a great deal more of. One of the points the noble Lord Lord Frost said, that there's a problem of how do you balance various types of nature, various organisms, various ecosystems. A number of others also said this. The noble Lord described it as an incommensurable variable. Well, we have had about four billion years of life on this planet.
It has always been a balance. It has always been very often cooperation between organisms, cooperation between species working together and working it out. And that's what we would have to continue with as part of that nature. Now, the noble lady Baroness Coffi asked about the definition of nature, and I will point the noble lady to clause 42, page 37, which actually sets out the definition under the basis of this bill. And I really appreciate again the careful engagement and some of the questions about the negative and affirmative procedures, and I will very much look at those going forward.
And the noble lady asked how this might work with the EU reset. Well, I will point out of course that there is a parallel effort happening within the EU at this moment. The rights for nature empowerment of citizens to represent and protect ecosystems has been accepted under the European Citizens' Initiative Regulation and is being taken forward within Europe. And of course, should we in the future return to being part of Europe, then it wouldn't be a problem anymore at all. The noble Earl of Effingham, I'm just going to pick up a couple of points, I'm aware of time, but said national security is the first duty of any government.
Well, I would of course point to the Joint Intelligence Chiefs' report highlighting how biodiversity is essential to our security and how food security is a pressing problem because of those risks. So these are not two things to be set against each other. Now, the noble Lord seemed to find problems with a legal duty of care for companies and organisations with regard to overseas activities. Well, again, I would cross-reference the JIC report. Those overseas activities are not far away things with no impact on us.
They very much have close impacts on our, as the noble Lord said, everyday economic realities. Now, the noble Lord Lord Winston said this might be giving too much power to lawyers. Well, a great deal noble Lords will read and why there's so much detail in the bill is there's a stress on democracy, particularly local democracy, picking up the points of the noble lady Baroness Miller. There's a stress throughout the bill on local democracy and that being where the power lies rather than with the lawyers. And the noble Lord raised perhaps a fairly obvious point about bacteria.
Well, of course, that's where we have to acknowledge that we are holobionts. We consist of some 50,000 species. We tend to think of bacteria as being that thing out there we want to kill. But protecting the bacteria, our own microbiome, is an absolutely crucial step to protecting our own health. And finally, I'm just going to pick up the points from the noble lady Baroness Miller and wish the Friends of the Dart absolutely all the best and all of the other similar groups around these islands.
The noble lady said we need to address the failure of enforcement and regulation. Yes, we do, but we've been trying to do that for decades and failing under our current model.
It's a model that's not working. And the noble lady pointed to the way in which there are limitations in how rights of nature has been working for Ecuador. I'm not going to claim any single bill, any single action is a silver bullet to fix all of our problems. Anyone who tells you that, I would immediately tell you to disregard. I've got this one thing that's going to fix everything.
This is an essential foundation for our future. It doesn't solve all of our problems or deliver everything we need. It's a foundation to build on, a foundation that acknowledges our life is dependent on all other life. And the noble lady mentioned agroecological farming and a new way of thinking and working. And that is what we actually need is a new way of thinking and working.
So I beg to move.
Speaker 38
Question is that this bill be now read a second time. As many of that opinion shall say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.
Natalie Bennett
I beg to move that this bill is committed to a committee of the whole house.
Speaker 21
Question is that this bill be committed to a committee of the whole house. As many of that opinion shall say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. Perhaps this might be a moment at which the noble lords might wish to leave the chamber.
Second reading of the Local Plans Burial Space Bill, Lord Mohammed of Burnley.
Magid Magid
My lords, I beg to move that this bill is now read a second time. Death is one of few certainties in life, we often hear. Yet the question of where people may be laid to rest has too often been treated as an afterthought in our planning system. This bill, my lords, seeks to address that omission through a simple but important principle: that every community should plan responsibly for the burial needs of its population. At present, my lords, the local authorities have powers to provide cemeteries, but they are under no statutory duty to ensure that sufficient burial space exists.
In many areas, burial provision depends upon a patchwork of local authority cemeteries, faith organisations, and private providers, with no strategic assessment of long-term demand. The result is that in some parts of England, burial capacity is becoming increasingly constrained, placing pressure on bereaved families and on the communities they serve. This bill does not seek to dictate where burial grounds should be located, nor does it impose unrealistic obligations on local authorities. Instead, it asks local planning authorities to do what they already do for housing, schools, transport, green infrastructure: to assess future need, incorporate that assessment into their local plans, and publish a long-term strategy for meeting any shortfall in burial capacity. Planning is about looking ahead, my lords.
We routinely plan decades into the future for homes, employment, land, and public services. It seems only right that we should also plan for the final resting places that communities will inevitably require. My lords, the urgency of this has also been recognised independently by the Law Commission in its comprehensive review of burial and cremation law.
The Commission concluded that England and Wales faces growing pressures on burial capacity, particularly in the urban areas, and described the existing legal framework as fragmented and outdated. It observed that many burial authorities are approaching capacity and that outside of London, councils generally have no powers to reuse old graves as a means of managing demand. We can already see the consequences. Councils including Birmingham, Leicester, Slough, Luton, several London boroughs have all warned of diminishing burial capacity. I first-hand saw the situation in Birmingham and in Dewsbury in Kirklees, as well as in my home city of Sheffield.
While national surveys have found that around one in four local authorities had 10 years or less of burial space remaining, around one in six had less than five years. The issue has been particularly significant for many faith communities. And for Muslims and Jews, my Lords, for example, burial is a religious obligation and cremation is not an acceptable alternative. Many Christian denominations also continue to place great importance upon burial. While this bill has obvious benefits for those faith communities, it is not a sectarian measure.
It's about ensuring that every family, whatever their belief or tradition, have access to a dignified burial within a reasonable distance of their community. Without forward planning, families may increasingly find themselves having to arrange burial many miles from where their loved ones lived, worked, and worshipped. That creates unnecessary emotional distress at a time when people are already coping with bereavement. This bill also supports better land use planning. By requiring burial needs to be considered as part of a local planning process, it enables authorities to identify suitable land well in advance rather than responding to shortages through emergency or piecemeal decisions.
Early planning allows burial provisions to be balanced alongside competing demands for housing, environmental protection, and other essential infrastructure. Some some may question whether these plans place an additional burden upon local authorities, and I recognize those concerns. However, the duties proposed are proportionate and aligned with existing planning processes. The bill does not require every authority to provide a cemetery itself; rather, it requires authorities to understand local need, assess existing capacity, and explain how any future demand will be met. Those are reasonable expectations for any effective planning system.
Others may argue that changing burial practices or increased cremation rates will reduce demand. While those trends are relevant, they are far from universal. Significant sections of our population continue to require burial, and demographic growth in many areas means demand is likely to continue for decades. Ignoring the issue today simply passes a greater problem to future generations. My Lords, this is a modest bill, but it addresses a genuine gap in our planning framework.
It promotes foresight rather than crisis management, supports local decision-making rather than centralized prescription, and helps ensure that communities can continue to meet one of humanity's oldest and most fundamental needs with dignity and respect.
I hope, whatever our views on planning policies more broadly, noble Lords will agree that preparing responsibly for the future is one of the core purposes of local government. This bill helps ensure that burial provision is no longer overlooked in that process. I therefore commend the bill to the House. My Lords, I beg to move.
Stephen Benn
My Lords, tomorrow we're celebrating or commemorating 250 years since the Declaration of Independence, which established the United States, still as far as I'm aware supposed to be a republic. And I mention it because one of its founding fathers, and the noble Lord has alluded to this, Benjamin Franklin, was famous for having said there are only two things in life that are certain: death and taxes. Well, this is a bill about death, or more particularly about where our dead bodies are put to rest. And throughout human history, the way we deal with our dead and dead bodies has a great deal to say about our humanity. I read recently that there's now archaeological evidence that Neanderthals had burial practices.
And of course we know a great deal about civilizations like the Egyptians and the Chinese, and even, if I may say so, more recently HS2 unearthed a great deal of knowledge about the way in which people were buried in the 17th century when building the line through central London. Now, so I want to say straight away that this is a bill that the House should very much take seriously, even if it is not everybody's cup of tea. Now, I commend the noble Lord, Lord Ahmed of Wimbledon, for sponsoring this bill. He was kind enough to draw it to my attention, for which I thank him, and who has adroitly made his case for the bill today. I also congratulate him on having been successful in the lottery of a private member's bill, and as someone who's piloted a private member's bill myself through onto the statute books, I wish him every success.
If you read the bill carefully, you will find several references to, and I quote, "the cultural effects of communities", and I want to return to this aspect of the issue later because the bill tackles issues that are of growing concern to people of all communities. And reference has been made already to the recent Law Commission report of March this year on burial and cremation, which concluded not only that the last serious survey of burial space is already 20 years old and out of date, but also that the burial space in Church of England and local authority burial grounds might run out within the coming decades. I rather regret the fact that the bishops' bench is not contributing to today's debate. And it may be a short debate, and I'm sure we'll hear some very interesting speeches, but before I turn or say a bit more about the bill itself, I hope the House will allow me to make a few general comments because I think this bill is best approached with some understanding of the recent history of approaches to burial in this country. Supposing we were holding this debate 200 years ago today, what would it be about?
Well, you would find a situation where there was widespread concern about body snatching. It was 200 years since the great private cemeteries of London were being planned: Kensal Green, Nunhead, West Norwood, Highgate, and so on. And they were built by joint stock companies, and their whole design was about security. No coincidence that they were built with high walls and imposing gates because the whole point of them was to provide the emerging middle classes with a safe and secure burial environment. Planned in the 1820s, literally 200 years ago now, and built in the 1830s, they were known as the Magnificent Seven.
And incidentally, they no longer felt obliged to bury in the Christian east-west orientation, sunrise to sunset, but they could be planned according to a more elaborate layout, and hence you see these beautiful cemeteries that we have today. And on the whole, of course, the aristocracy had provision for their own burials in their own vaults and lands. But the poorest in society, by contrast, were most vulnerable to body snatching. And it was a very successful business, which fulfilled a need for medical colleges as well as providing a lucrative living for the body snatchers.
Now people were murdered for body snatching and their bodies were sold to the anatomy schools and the infamous case of Burke and Hare in Edinburgh, they murdered 16 people in the 1820s and it provided the impetus for Parliament to pass the Anatomy Act of 1832 because the murders raised public awareness of the need for bodies for medical research and contributed to the passing of the act. And intervening in this way Parliament sought to deal with the body snatching problem. Incidentally the bill made its way through this Parliament at the same time as the Great Reform Bill of 1832 only it was passed, it was known as the midnight bill because it passed late at night when people were not as interested and the main business of Parliament was carried on during the day which was the Great Reform Act which most of us learn about when we learn about history in school. Now at all events the Anatomy Act did provide sufficient bodies for medical schools and the pauper institutions at that time were used as a means of furnishing the dead bodies required for them. Basically if you were qualified for a pauper funeral you certainly qualified for dissection.
Other developments in the 19th century included the creation of Brookwood Cemetery, some members may know it, it was designed to deal with the rapidly expanding population of London and a special train service was set up going from Waterloo Necropolis station which transported the bodies down I think it's near Dorking and indeed it was only bombing in the Second World War that blew up the station otherwise you'd be able to see it today. Now cremation as a means of dealing with death only really started to appear in the 1890s and began to take off after the Great War, perhaps, it's only a guess, because of the colossal death toll of that war and a natural fear of decomposition changed people's perceptions in the Christian community about burial. But the fact is the growing trend towards cremation in the Christian community did not erode the pressures on burial space. Over the decades churches and local authorities have had to make increasing provision for burial space and by the way there's quite a market in burial spaces. One colleague in this house told me a couple of days ago that the going price for a space in his particular hoped for cemetery was 24,000 pounds.
This is not inconsiderable. Now perhaps it would be a good moment to declare that a few years ago I was a member of an opposed private bill. There are not many of these, it's something of a specialism. I'm not sure if many members here have ever had experience of one but I'm glad to say we've got some clerks in this house who are great specialists and I sat on this bill. It was a bill promoted by Bishop's Stortford Council, known I am sure to my noble friend the minister, which was seeking permission to reuse burial space in its cemetery because space was running out.
Now these proposals can arouse great emotion and depth of feeling. The proceedings were quasi-judicial and eventually the house did grant permission for the proposal to proceed and I believe it was the first such bill to succeed outside London. But the point I'm making is this, the pressure for increased burial space is growing and the issues that we're discussing today whether or not this particular bill succeeds will not be going away so we might as well tackle the underlying issues head on. I mean if I may say so no London borough could have possibly afford to burial space in their within their boundaries at the moment. Now it may be that my noble friend the minister will agree that there is a real issue here and will tell the house that it must be addressed but perhaps this bill is not the right way or vehicle to do it.
But the bill does seek to meet those needs in the context of local authority planning and I think we should debate closely what effects this may have up and down the country when we reach committee stage. But before we reach the minister's speech let me return to the phrase all faith and cultural communities that appears on the face of the bill. My lords different communities have different burial traditions. For example as has been mentioned Jewish and Muslim communities have strong preference for burial as soon as possible, hardly surprising as the religions originated in the Middle East where a quick burial was a health necessity. And I think it's fair to observe that both communities still broadly prefer burial to cremation, this is a generalization.
But some communities also prefer an individual grave and dislike multiple graves and people are entitled to have their own views. But I think the effect of changing times and our many and varied communities is producing a more explicitly demand for more burial space. Now my Lords, I've run out of time. Now I need hardly add that I'm very much looking forward to hearing what my noble friend the Minister has to say and whatever approach the government take to this bill to taking part in further proceedings on it.
Thomas Tom McNally
My Lords, I too congratulate Lord Mohammed of Tinsley on coming so high in the ballot and I hope that his luck continues in his dealing with the government on the bill because I'm one of those who was in support of his efforts. I would have too would have welcomed the presence of some bishops today given the nature of the subject and that the Church of England has probably got the majority of the acreage of burial grounds around the country. My interest comes really from the fact that I'm in my eighties and in a sense I'm in the waiting room. I've long expressed a desire to be buried in the churchyard of St Paul's Church in Alverthorpe in Yorkshire, the parish of my birth and my family roots. But space is limited there.
But with the help of a friend, my friend Philip Collins, who's used genealogy, used WikiTree, used AI, we've managed to trace a whole range of my forebears there. And we think that some of those graves in which they're buried are not full. So there is an opportunity, a green opportunity I would say, for me possibly to be buried in one of those graves. And Lord Mohammed's suggestion I would like to add to it that we should have an extra section on the end about the full utilization of existing cemeteries around the country. And there are acres and acres of them.
And I think given that now we have AI and we've got other methods of genealogy, we can make a connection between the graves and between the ancestors. And the likelihood is given that what the noble Lord just mentioned about somebody being willing to pay twenty-four thousand pounds to find a burial ground, this is an amazing opportunity certainly for the Church of England, maybe for the Roman Catholic Church and for other faiths if they explore this to make a connection with individuals who would wish to be buried if there is an opportunity to link with their forebears. And they would probably be willing to pay for it. So where have we got to? I wrote to the Bishop of Leeds and he's given some assistance to me.
I asked him to raise it with the Church of England. I think it may have been buried somewhere. So I raise it myself with Marsha de Cordova who is my MP in Wandsworth but she's also one of the Church Commissioners and she had an open meeting for the Church of England for anyone to raise questions. I raised it there and there seemed to be little disposition to give support.
One response was, this is all about money. Well, of course, the Church of England is badly in need of money for the upkeep of their churches, as are Roman Catholic churches. So I really think I've stumbled on a business opportunity for the churches of all faiths, that we should be exploring the link between technology, between the new way of exploring the way into our genealogy and to link up with people who may have an interest in finding a burial spot, given that there's such pressure on finding appropriate places. And in addition, we will need new space, and I support Lord Mohamed all the way with that. So I'm wondering if my noble friend the Minister, who's at the end of a tiring week and doesn't want too much trouble from me, whether she would be willing to explore.
I'm not sure how we take this further forward. I've spoken to the Public Bill Office and they said, well, after you've had the debate and see where the Minister responds, how she responds, we will then look to see whether we can table additional amendments, maybe a new section, which would be about utilization of existing burial grounds to the maximum extent. Whether in fact there is an opportunity there, I would say as a green policy, to open it up, but more particularly for those who own the churchyards actually to raise additional money for the upkeep of their churches or for the benefits of their communities, their local communities. So it's, I'm not causing trouble. It's an interesting area that I don't think has been explored previously.
There are great opportunities. There are acres and acres of burial grounds around the country that is of valuable land. It is not being fully utilized and we should really, before we start worrying, we need to extend, yes, but we can probably minimize the encroachment of other land into other land if we utilize what we already have. So I hope the Minister will be, give me a pointer on the direction I should go and I will then talk to the Public Bill Office and come back with some appropriate amendments, which I hope she might find acceptable.
Gerard James Jamieson
My Lords, I am also very grateful to Lord Mohamed of Tinsley for bringing forward this bill and with the clarity of its purpose that he has spoken about. This is a thoughtful and timely proposal for addressing an issue which other noble Lords have raised that is clearly important. And I declare my interest as a councillor in Central Bedfordshire and not unsurprisingly, space in cemeteries is a key issue. In one of my villages, Westoning, there are six spaces left in a village of around 2,000 souls. And the noble Lord Brook of Alverthorpe said he is in the waiting room.
Well, we're all in the waiting room. Some of us just wish to wait a little bit longer than maybe he does. But, but that point is very much prescient amongst some of my residents who are very conscious and they want to be buried in their local village. And actually I've been helping them for the 17 years I've been there to try and find a site and it's not necessarily easy. You would have thought in a village in the middle of the green belt there would be space.
But when you take account of land ownership and in particular in my area, the risk of flooding because you obviously have to have a water table well below the depth at which you bury people. So it, it's not simple and it is very important, so I do recognize that. Now, responsibility for burial provision rests primarily with local authorities, not quite sure of the case in London, but much of the rural area, the actual delivery of it is parish councils and religious bodies and churches.
Now, with the pressures on land use, demographic change, different faith and cultural communities, I mean the current framework frankly is increasingly stretched. The Law Commission's ongoing review of the death management system has highlighted the complexity of existing arrangements and the need for a more coherent and long-term view. I'd also like to highlight what the noble Lord Viscount Stansgate raised, which is if you go back as he said into the 17th and 18th century, this was a commercial opportunity and he mentioned the seven major cemeteries in London, one of which is Highgate Cemetery, which I had the pleasure of visiting about a year ago. Well, that was set up as a private enterprise and made a lot of money until it went bust. And running cemeteries is a long-term business, it is costly to set up and there are ongoing costs for a long period of time.
Now the noble Lord Brooke of Alverthorpe mentioned the price of 24,000 pound. Well, for many people that is way out of reach and I wouldn't like to go back to the 17th century provision of where the nobility can bury themselves nicely and the paupers can't. So it's very important that I think we look at this in the round and I take his suggestion that maybe we should look at extending this bill to look at how we can have reuse of existing facilities, bearing in mind that would also raise the whole issue of ownership of those facilities. So we recognize the challenges, we recognize the sensitivities, but ensuring that all communities have access to dignified, appropriate burial space is a basic matter of respect. And the bill's emphasis on consultation with faith groups, burial authorities and neighboring councils is very welcome.
We also note the context of the Law Commission's work on grave reuse, and while the government have yet to publish their full response, the Commission's proposal strengthening safeguards and extending powers beyond London and protecting war graves demonstrate the scale of reform that may be required in the years ahead. Now the bill does not preempt that work, but does provide practical interim framework for local planning. Now there are clearly going to be questions at the committee stage, and one of the ones that I'd like to focus on is the resource implications. As I mentioned, it's not just the cost of setting up a cemetery, but looking after it not for five or 10 or 20 years, but potentially over a hundred years. That cumulative cost is significant.
Now given that many local authorities are severely stretched, and I appreciate the noble Lord Tinsley implied that it was not going to necessarily be a burden on local councils, but as I understand the way that the bill is written, ultimately they're the backstop. And I think if you're the backstop for anything, then you need to make sure that you can afford that backstop. So I'd be very interested to hear from the minister, given the stretched finances of local government, particularly after some recent cuts for some councils, what is the government's positions on new burdens, because this will be a new burden for local councils. In addition, we need to look at the interaction between existing planning duties, the balance between local discretion and national prescription, and the responsibilities for existing sites and how they are managed. But the principle that burial space should be planned for transparently, consistently and with due regard to community need is one that we support.
I look forward to hearing contributions from across the house as we move forward on this bill, and for our part, the opposition will not oppose the bill and we welcome the opportunity to scrutinize it further.
Jane Sharon Taylor
My Lords, I will resist the temptation to talk about last thing on a Friday being the graveyard slot, I'm not going to do that obviously.
It's a serious, a very serious topic, and I would like to thank the Lord Mohammed for bringing forward this private member's bill and for giving me the opportunity to meet with him yesterday to talk through what he wanted to do in terms of the principles around the bill. And can I thank Viscount Stansgate and Lord Brooke for speaking to me in advance, in advance of the bill coming before the House. I wanted to really start where, with the phrase that Lord Mohammed used, that every family should have access to a dignified burial close to their community. I think that was a very important phrase and certainly as someone who's been involved with local government for as many years as I have, and I know he has too, I think it's very important that we keep our focus on that. I absolutely recognize the importance of the provision of burial space.
I have some reservations around the necessity for the bill, and I'll come to those in a moment. The bill as proposed, of course, would require local planning authorities to include suitable provision for burial space in their local plans and put that on the statute book as a separate issue to other issues that come forward for planning. The National Planning Policy Framework sets out the policy expectations for what should be considered in the development of the plan, including local plans and in decision making. And the framework for what should be considered is set through policy and not statute in order to offer the necessary flexibility to local planning authorities across the country to consider their local area and the specific needs of the local population. It's a matter for local authorities to allocate local resources in line with their priorities, and this includes burial provision.
In areas where this is an issue, such as London or Cambridge, many local authorities already include specific policies on burial grounds in their local plans. And we want to ensure that local planning authorities can do this where there is a concern, but are not required to allocate where there is not an issue in their local area. Now, the current NPPF includes policies to ensure there is provision for community facilities and public service infrastructure in local areas. And whilst the current version of the NPPF does not directly reference burial spaces, it sets out that strategic policies should set out an overall strategy for the pattern, scale, and design quality of places that make sufficient provision for community facilities such as health, education, and cultural infrastructure, as well as allowing for the provision of burial space in green belt land. And I think that might respond to one of the Noble Lord Jameson's points about treating that, that kind of development differently.
We consulted, as Noble Lords will be aware, we consulted on an updated National Planning Policy Framework between September 2025 and March 2026. And the draft NPPF is clear that development plans should promote the creation of healthier and inclusive places and the provision, retention, and enhancement of appropriate community facilities and public service infrastructure. So it's up to a local authority to determine the local need for those facilities, which could include burial grounds as many local authorities have already done. The proposed NPPF also offers protections for existing burial grounds through setting out that the presumption in favor of sustainable development is unlikely to apply in situations which would involve the whole or partial loss of undeveloped land which is used for a cemetery or burial ground. Furthermore, the NPPF sets out that burial grounds are a form of development where there are benefits for approval outside of settlements and that are not inappropriate in the green belt.
So we, we received over 20,000 responses to the consultation, including a small number on this specific issue. And we're currently analyzing all of those responses, and we intend to publish our response with the new NPPF in the summer.
In relation to the Law Commission report, which has been mentioned by a number of noble lords, we're acutely aware of concerns around burial space, which have been considered in the context of the Law Commission's recent report. And while this report didn't call for statutory burial provision as the Noble Lord Mohammed's bill does, this report did address a number of issues such as burial ground management and records, which my colleagues in the Ministry of Justice are leading on. We will publish a government response to the Law Commission report in due course, and I look forward to working with MOJ colleagues and local government as we take these important issues forward. Turning to some of the specific points raised by noble lords, I thank my noble friend Viscount Stansgate for taking us through a kind of history of burial and how it works. And I would say to him that I found the HS2 excavations and some of the information they've thrown up really fascinating.
We've had our own example of that in Stevenage where Roman remains have been found when we've been excavating sites. It's fascinating, that. Both him and the Noble Lord Brooke mentioned the fact that the bishops' bench aren't present today, and I'm sure they will have their own views and I'm sure they'll get involved in the bill at a later stage. When the noble viscount referred to the midnight bill and the Anatomy Act of 1832, it did put me in mind of a much more up-to-date version of that, which was the Planning and Infrastructure Bill, which we were here at 4:00 in the morning. So that wasn't limited to the 19th century, that practice.
And of course, I'm very aware of the issues around Bishop's Stortford and the bill that came through this house on that. My noble friend Lord Brooke spoke about being in the waiting room. Well, I hope he has as long a wait in that waiting room as we'd all want him to have. We want to see him here long into the future. Both him and my noble friend Viscount Stansgate mentioned the Church of England, and of course burial on land consecrated by the Church of England is governed by the faculty jurisdiction and is a matter for the church.
And I'm sure my noble friend Lord Brooke will continue his dialogue with the Church of England on that. And just on the point that the Noble Lord Brooke made about green policy, I just wanted to highlight the very good practice we're seeing in some areas of providing for green burial grounds, which I think is very creditable. And I pay tribute to my colleagues in local government for their action in this respect. I think that's been a really great development in recent times. The Noble Lord Mohammed raised the question of what the government is currently doing on the provision of burial space.
We are aware of increasing localized pressure on burial spaces in some parts of the country. He will know that we don't have day-to-day operational responsibility for burial grounds, which are managed locally, and there's no statutory duty on local authorities to make that provision. It is a matter for each local authority to allocate local resources. But the Law Commission's recent report means we are very keen to engage with stakeholders, including local authority representatives, to understand how, in the context of responding to the commission's recommendations, we can best facilitate the local provision and management of burial capacity going forward. And certainly it will be my intention to do that.
I think I've already spoken about the Law Commission recommendations. There is, of course, a very close connection between the workstreams that the Law Commission has underway on this, and we will consider the most practical approach to publishing our response, including timing. The noble Lord Mohammed mentioned the issues around specific requirements for different communities in terms of burial practices, as did my noble friend Viscount Stansgate. Measures have been taken in recent years to update crematoria, particularly so they better reflect and understand the needs of different cultures and faiths. It's for local authorities to deal with this because they can decide what their priorities were depending on the groups that they represent locally.
And we're very keen to engage closely with representatives from faith communities on all issues in relation to death management, particularly when we work on that response to the Law Commission report. The noble Lord Mohammed and the noble Lord Jamieson referred to the issue around funding for this. And it is, as I think was mentioned, it's a very long forward commitment. I think the noble Lord Jamieson was talking about Highgate Cemetery. Of course, these are long-term commitments that have to be made by local authorities.
So if the government were to support this bill, we would consider relevant impacts such as those set out in the new burdens doctrine. So I hope that responds to those questions. Of course, it's appropriate for these matters to be addressed in local plans rather than legislation, so that local planning authorities retain the flexibility to respond to the particular circumstances of their areas and the needs, which may of course include specific needs of their diverse communities of their local population. It's a very timely intervention because of the progress of the National Planning Policy Framework. So I'm incredibly grateful to the noble Lord Mohammed for prompting me as we go through the stages of publishing the next version of the policy framework to look in particular at this issue.
We will respond to the recent consultation in due course, and of course we keep the matter under review in the light of all the consultation responses we've had and of contributions in the House today. I'm most grateful to the noble Lord.
Magid Magid
My Lords, can I thank everyone for their very constructive comments? And actually, during the debate, my phone's been quite busy, and particularly the question of the attendance or not of the Lords Spiritual. And actually, I've had a message from them, which I would like to share with your Lordships' House, which is: "We apologize for this, but because it's ordination season and the majority of Lords Spiritual are in the diocese ordaining new clergy, however, this does not reflect their lack of interest in this, and actually they are very supportive of the bill itself and welcome an opportunity to discuss taking it forward." Similarly, my colleagues at the South Yorkshire Muslim Burial Trust are also watching, and so many others, because clearly this issue, as we've heard, is across communities, across faiths. And as we heard, this bill is serious.
And you know, we talked about, you know, being all in the waiting room. And you know, I think the fact is that we hope that many of us are still there to make sure that we do see the change that this bill requires. Now, clearly there may be a disagreement between us in terms of how we get to the destination, but it's very clear from the debate, from whether it's from the comments from Viscount Stansgate or Lord Brooke himself, or actually Lord Jamieson and actually the noble Baroness the Minister, in sense of we have all acknowledged there is an issue, there is a problem.
How do we deal with it? I've, like he said, luck of the draw, I put my faith into that lottery and my name came out with this bill. I know other noble Lords in the past, particularly Lord Sandhurst, has talked about this issue in the past. And it's something that I look forward to getting into further debate at the committee stage. And clearly the fact that during the debate we heard that, you know, £24,000 for a burial plot is, my Lords, it is a huge issue that's way beyond most average residents.
And we've got to look at the supply side. And clearly there are opportunities here to be able to, like I said in my speech, that if we're planning for homes, businesses, schools, etc., then there has to be thought given to how we deal with burial. Now, it's better if we do it by long-term planning rather than knee-jerk reactions in terms of trying to find space. And clearly this challenge is, you know, in London there's clearly land issues here. That's why I said it's not every local authority has to have its own provisions.
It's about saying how do we deal with the need that is there, like we heard from one of our contributors that, you know, death and taxes are given in life. And I really welcome the opportunity to present this bill to your Lordships' House. Thank you.
Speaker 52
The question is this bill be committed to the committee of the whole House. As many of that opinion say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it.
We just did that.
That the House do now adjourn.