Work and Pensions Committee

28 October 2026

Work and Pensions Committee House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:03 - 00:48
Speaker 2
And a very warm welcome to this third of our sessions, three sessions for, third and final session for the Child Maintenance Service inquiry.  And we're delighted to welcome Paula Sussex, who is the Public Services Ombudsman this morning.  Paula, I'm going to start with questions if I may.  I just wanted to reflect on your, the complaints that you deal with in relation to the Child Maintenance Service and to try and understand the patterns that you've observed and also why they seem to differ in volume in particular to what the DWP is experiencing in reporting. 
00:48 - 02:47
Speaker 4
Thank you, and thank you Chair, thank you Committee.  So, I think it's perhaps helpful to say right at the start that the Ombudsman comes right at the end of the process.  So by definition, a parent who is complaining will have been through two stages of complaint process and the good work that our colleagues at ICE do before they come to us.  But nonetheless, as you say Chair, it is remarkable that although we observe that DWP says that CMS complaints have declined, that ours have over four years doubled.  Now, we are still, I'm afraid I have no firm evidence as to what might be driving that, but we do think that there's some element of complaints not being handled effectively by definition. 

And there's that compound of if you've been through two stages and then you go to ICE, the Independent Complaint Examiner, and then you come, you're still not satisfied, you come to us.  I should set it in the context of, however, we are doing some wider research on the general increase in complaints across all public services.  We ourselves are seeing something like a 20-25% increase in complaints coming to us.  And our analysis is starting to show that there is generally, if I can describe it as greater persistence, greater distress, which is causing complainants to persist for longer.  And then I would say probably the third possible reason, which is of course another global reason, is of course the pressure of the cost of living on a lot of parents and families. 
02:47 - 02:57
Speaker 2
And you say that the Child Maintenance Service is one of the services that you have most complaints about? 
02:57 - 03:28
Speaker 4
No, we, as the Committee I'm sure knows, we have a health and a government jurisdiction.  Health is 80% of our work, government only 20%.  And in terms of the government work, last year we received only 500 complaints, and that will be against a considerably larger number for the whole of our government work. 

It is, however, CMS is about a third of the complaints that we receive about all DWP services. 
03:28 - 03:36
Speaker 6
A third.  Okay, that's, that's very interesting.  I'm going to hand over to Peter Bedford now, if I may. 
03:36 - 03:46
Speaker 3
Thank you, Chair.  Just touching on that, those statistics, what are the themes that are coming out in terms of the complaints regarding the CMS? 
03:46 - 05:20
Speaker 5
So, we have recently written to the department about a systemic investigation that I'll come to in a minute.  But I would say that, just by way of overarching comments, as the committee will know very well, CMS manages an unenviable combination of high volume and highly complex processes.  And so I think it is fair to say that they are doing some very good work in the simple cases.  But in terms of the themes that we see, we are, there are a raft of issues about, I would say, better customer service.  And something that we observe in other areas of DWP is a process that is designed and run around the customer rather than the policy or the regulations. 

And at the root of it, standing in your customer's shoes, which is difficult to do if you're operating something which, as I know from my own operational experience as an accounting officer, but nonetheless, when you know that your customer base is having an extraordinarily tough time, is in, you know, not, not the best of, you know, best of states, you have to be really rigorous about how you communicate with your customers, how you keep them up to speed, how they are understanding the rules and regulations. 

05:20 - 05:46

Peter Bedford

And just building on what you've just said about the kind of customer experience, so why do you think there's been a fall in the number of complaints directly to the department, but there's been a significant rise that you've received? I, I would, I would surmise that could be because there's a lack of confidence in the process within the department to handle those, those complaints effectively. What's your view of why that could be the case?

05:46 - 06:47

Paula Sussex

Well, I will of course encourage you to ask the department why theirs is falling. I can't perhaps speculate on, on their behalf. But we do, and I will turn to it at some point in this hearing, we do believe that there is work to be done on their complaints handling. So how they actually manage their complaints, manage and resolve their complaints. But as to the disparity between us, I should also say that ICE is also showing an increase.

So we and ICE are showing an increase, broadly increasing trend, whereas CMS is showing a decreasing trend. It's not, it's not what we see across our health and our government jurisdiction. So generally, when I, as I was yesterday, out with a mental and community trust, they too are seeing, you know, 20, 30 percent increase in complaints. So I, I would speculate there is something about the ease with which customers can complain.

06:47 - 06:56

Speaker 8

And what difference would removing the MP filter in cases involving the CMS, what, what impact would that have?

06:56 - 07:39

Paula Sussex

Generally, we are supportive, as the committee knows, of the MP filter being removed in our government jurisdiction, although we always welcome the opportunity for complainants to work with their MPs. In this particular service, we see a higher than number of complaints which have an MP actively engaged and involved, which we welcome. And my team sitting behind me work quite closely also with caseworkers, I'm sure, of a number of your constituencies as we work together. So in this particular service, it might not have a huge impact. Generally, we would welcome it.

07:39 - 07:49

Peter Bedford

Just finally, you mentioned, so was it, I think you said a third of your caseload was from the CMS, or the, a third of the 20 percent that you deal with, is that right?

07:49 - 07:56

Paula Sussex

A third of the DWP of the 20 percent. And DWP is about probably 20 percent of government complaints.

07:57 - 08:05

Peter Bedford

So you obviously see a lot of different organisations. Which of those could the CMS learn from in terms of their own processes?

08:05 - 09:38

Paula Sussex

So the first thing I would say is although CMS and the department have not brought this to us we have identified in our caseworker to caseworker interactions that the service modernisation programme and I'm sure the committee is aware of what it intends to cover. I think it is a multi-year programme and having got an outline of that and again if I go back through my own operational experience if the department executes on that well if it is a funded programme and executes to the outcomes that we've been indicated that it will achieve they will be in a better place. But in terms of learning from other organisations we do see some organisations that manage communications of complex financial affairs and these are complex lives are complex regulations are complex sometimes unnecessarily so and we do see other organisations which can handle communicating that complexity better. You know we would probably point to we certainly see that HMRC and student loans which I should confess I ran for some years manages to reflect not flawlessly but will give a repaying individual a better breakdown of where they are in their process in their account.

09:38 - 10:13

Brian Patrick Hurley

And on the complexity issue you said in your evidence that the CMS performs less effectively perhaps than other organisations in complex cases. Is this do you think inherent to the work the CMS does that sometimes there are just issues relating to families that cause that complexity or do you think perhaps this is an issue around competence or a training need for DWP itself? Could you just speak to that?

10:13 - 11:46

Paula Sussex

So I mean first I think we said in the evidence we have identified that simple cases are dealt with well but complex cases so perhaps more in the absolute. Again if you go back to the perfect storm of a high volume I think CMS has about 800,000 I'm going to say customers over presumably an 18 or 19 year time period and highly complex rules and regs which change that is a very difficult state of affairs. Where other organisations have taken different operational decisions for example having a specialist or complex caseworking team that sometimes works we see that in HMCTS probate. But I think the key thing is how you communicate with the customer as you are going through a complex set of circumstances. And if I can turn to I suppose how does it feel we the ombudsman work from the complainant evidence in the first instance so we are in the privileged position of standing initially in their shoes.

We hold neither for the complainant or the organisation as you know because we're impartial but a very sort of typical expression of sometimes how it feels is confusing protracted and without support and that's particularly in the complex cases.

11:46 - 11:53

Brian Patrick Hurley

Do you think that would be addressed by a complex case unit being brought in?

11:53 - 12:27

Paula Sussex

It could be. In terms of operational flow and backlog, there are arguments for and against that and I'm sure the CMS team have looked at that. I think I would probably go more to the service modernisation programme where which we very much welcome stronger engagement to understand that that reading between the lines getting that in is are the sorts of things that we have identified in our cases that would help.

12:27 - 12:31

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you very much. John Milne.

12:31 - 12:59

John Milne

Thank you Chair. Good morning. Yeah, I want to talk about how how the CMS communicates with parents and that's sort of in two in two ways. One is just your basic admin, do they answer the phone, do they reply to an email, so basic admin level. But then more deeper than that, are their are their communications letters etc. comprehensible?

Do they get the information across? What's your feeling on that?

12:59 - 15:20

Paula Sussex

I'll go to the second one first if I may. So again we find with DWP in different areas in pensions as well and this is well on public record that the communications some if you look hard at the DWP service charter you will sometimes look at the communications and say this isn't measuring up well. So in terms of how clear but also that checking of how well it is understood. And I think I took the opportunity to look at their 26 customer experience survey and you can probably see that echoed in the feedback on that. So we sometimes find that the communications are too boilerplate, too macro.

We certainly find that the the regular updates to the customer of what what is happening with my case, why is this the case. So you know giving it a very grand word also procedural justice, why have you made this calculation this way, what caused you to do this. So there's there's certainly work to be done there and again if I go back to the programme they reflect on that and say you know we will get better at that. In the first one, keeping customers up to date up to speed, that too and we are also not blameless in that respect and we're working hard on it. None of us do well enough.

Both they and we are creating an online account which does help a bit because you have a a dedicated space where you can you'll get more of an update of how your case is progressing and why. So there is certainly more work to be done there. And there is just there's just one thing which I think we've picked up anecdotally and that is some of the communications assume that a paying parent intends to be delinquent from from the off and that they are sometimes rather harsh from the start. They assume whereas and I'm sure the department knows this, you know many paying parents actually want to be doing the right thing by their children.

15:20 - 15:36

John Milne

Yes, I've heard exactly that from some of the cases in my own constituency as I'm sure everyone else has has too.

So you've you've done a lot of work with the the WASPI women issue, which was very much about a failure a failure to communicate. Any any lessons from there to be applied, do you think?

15:36 - 16:32

Paula Sussex

Yes, I would probably go back to standing in the shoes of your customer. How does this individual how does this in how could this individual receive this communication? Is it coming through the right channel at the right time? Is it being delivered empathetically? I note that they are investing in trauma-informed, so will they be able to receive it?

How do we know they have received it? What can we expect? What's a reasonable expectation of that communication? It's it's the very definition that, you know, we're not talking we're talking about a receiver of communication, a customer who is at a heightened state of they're not at their best, shall we say. And so the effort to communicate really, really well and check that it has been understood needs to be more than your average day-to-day communications.

16:32 - 16:51

John Milne

Yeah. And you've previously told us about a case where a parent was sent a letter threatening legal action, but it was based on incorrect information. So how how can what checks and balances can we put into the system that the CMS doesn't leap to this draconian or tough tough demand?

16:51 - 17:57

Paula Sussex

We we realistically on that sort of volume of service and complexity and inevitably the IT was not designed for the complexity I suspect successive years of policy regs have have put in. Sometimes that is unavoidable. The really important thing is that that all organisations respond really quickly with an apology and what are we going to do to fix it. So yes, there are various checks and balances that you can put in, but we accept that of course mistakes are going to be made. It is how you respond and how you show contrition and also, and I may come later on to the complaints handling, go to the impact on the customer, not on the how you what went wrong in the process.

Where you can redress, can you redress? What was the impact of this? And we don't see enough focus on the complainant in that in the complaint process.

17:57 - 18:19

John Milne

I have a constituent who went through a two-year process with mandatory review of his case. He wasn't told at the start the tribunal had no power to change the way the calculation was done anyway. So he two years, you know, for absolutely nothing, but he wasn't told that at the start. It's bad enough that the system is like that, but not being told in the first place is is even worse.

18:19 - 18:21

Speaker 12

Yeah.

18:21 - 18:23

Speaker 9

Yeah. Thank you.

18:23 - 18:26

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you so much. Damian Egan.

18:26 - 19:02

Damien James Egan

Thank you, Chair. I'm going to ask a bit more about the service modernisation programme because there has been criticism and comments about the limited functionality of it, issues about uploading documents. And certainly that's the feedback I've had from constituents that have come to my to my surgeries and have been very distressed about it. How is the service modernisation programme progressing? How confident are you that we can get to a service that truly matches the expectations people have?

And I guess more critically, what what do you need to get there?

19:02 - 20:40

Paula Sussex

So if I can go to that last question first, we'd welcome the Committee's support in encouraging CMS. It's not that they've said no, they're not going to share the service modernisation programme, but we would find it helpful if we could get closer to the programme, its aims, to be able to follow through on its delivery.

We we have heard anecdotally that the the portal is not working perfectly, which I think is what you are referring to. And you know, that's not infrequently the case. You know, this is government IT. It's not going to be flawless, shall we say, as I'm sure the committee has heard before. But we would happily come back or or submit something to the committee once we've got a better understanding of what is the program, what's the process, how can you keep us up to speed with how it's going and how it's addressing things.

Committee will be aware that we're working much more closely with pensions side of the department on the action plan. I'm not suggesting nor do we have the resource that we work as we are working closely with them on the action plan, but I think something in between so we can see what they are trying to do, which will help give an assessment of, you know, also on our individual redress, but also how we can support the committee for you to oversee the success of their service. And this is particularly key if the move to collect and pay kicks in at some point, because that's going to be a major program for them, a major disruption.

20:40 - 20:44

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you. Very useful. Steve Darling.

20:44 - 21:17

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you. And thank you for coming along and giving evidence. I see from your previous employment that you've been a merchant for change and transformation, and a big part of that of taking people on the journey is is trust and ensuring that they continue to trust in the system. How do you see your role now of ensuring that the there is a greater development of trust? Do you being able to pull from stuff in your previous life, or equally are you able to look at how other large organizations have developed trust with users?

21:17 - 22:43

Paula Sussex

An enormously good question and one that does exercise me quite considerably. The the backdrop to this societally, as I'm sure you and the committee are very well aware, is that trust in government, trust in national public services has decreased worryingly over the last few years. In fact, we surveyed it, we haven't yet published this analysis in August, and 51% said over recent years their trust in national government services had declined. So that is a fairly serious backdrop to be operating in. The the trust more immediately, I mean, we see no evidence that endemically customers don't trust CMS.

They don't trust it for its competence when things are going wrong and things aren't being explained, and then they lose confidence and therefore you can say lose trust. But nonetheless, closer engagement, and it would be interesting to hear from the department how they do this with their users in the way that they are working to modernize the service is the first thing that I would do in terms of building more trust in the overall organization.

22:43 - 22:45

Speaker 15

Thank you.

22:45 - 23:56

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Well, we've we've come to the end of our formal questions, but I just wondered in in terms of if there is anything that you would like to add to the evidence that you've provided to the committee, specifically on on the CMS services. This we were very concerned in terms of the level of complaints, and particularly given as you rightly said that this follows on from ICE involvement, National Audit Office was similarly very scathing in in terms of of this. And is as you rightly said, it's a very emotional time for families, and I I really do reflect on what you're saying about treating people as you are living in their shoes. I think all too often that that doesn't happen.

I think all of us as public servants need to, I'm sure we all do with our constituents. But what is there anything specifically that you would like to add to what you to recommendations that you have made to from complaints or or whatever?

23:56 - 25:38

Paula Sussex

Yes, I mean I think Chair just building on that point of, I mean we too, it is it is a considerable increase in complaints. And we don't we can't see a key driver, but we do see a lot of people coming to us in heightened distress, challenging, etc, etc. So we have opened a systemic investigation which is about the collection of arrears, but that's not it's not a dominant theme. I think the key thing that I haven't really shared with the committee is that probably it lies in their complaints handling. So they have a two-stage process which is not uncommon, but it only works well if the first stage is about review and exchange and informal, but a productive and effective stage.

If that's not the case, we have seen evidence that the word dissatisfaction is used, which I'm sure from your constituents some of them think that means a complaint has been registered and then it hasn't and you bounce around the system. We think that if I can say really leaning into that complaints process and really working and investing in it to resolve your caseworkers, we know, will say we don't get consistent communication or timelines from the complaints function. I am sorry that we don't have a clearer answer of what is driving that increase, except one would say have a look at the complaints function, how they are handling it. That's the only thing that I can logically point point to.

25:38 - 26:42

John Milne

Thanks Chair. The there are problems with with all kinds of departments and DWP in general. But I think anecdotally we most people most MPs would agree that this we get more issues with this department than any any other. So whether whether that's a fair representation or not, it's some of the most distressing cases. And I think they're particularly distressing because in many cases it can result in a parent being separated from a child for a very long time whilst some appalling bureaucratic process is going on.

And a year separated from a child is is an infinity. It's so damaging. That time cannot be made up. We we did feel last time we met with the CMS that we that we didn't they didn't really fully appreciate the scale of the scale of the challenge. Do you think that they do because they they absolutely need to up their game because the human consequences are particularly egregious.

26:42 - 28:28

Paula Sussex

I mean it's difficult. We in with this particular part of DWP we, you know, we work at the operational level and it's always important to say that there are a lot of great frontline workers in both of our jurisdictions working hard. So we don't in this area we don't engage with any senior levels. So it's difficult for me to say whether institutionally they grasp this and they're putting the resource into it. I would go back to what I say which is a focus on the life of your complainant.

Anecdotally and not somebody from the department said about 15 years ago when they were designing the IT they thought that the max number of change of circumstances that anybody would have would be four.

Now, that's probably not borne out in practice. So if systems and regulations are designed around a set of lives that don't exist, it makes it extremely hard. The only thing that we have seen in our health jurisdiction happening is where your IT or the regulations means it's very complex and you can't really speed it up is this concept of waiting well, which where in health they have backlogs in ADHD assessments. The waiting well is they ensure that they have a way of making contact with parents or patients, but also helping them cope as they go through and possibly through some of their trauma-informed work, that waiting well concept. Some of this can't be avoided.

Some of this can't be avoided, but you can certainly make it a better experience in that year that you say, which is very painful and very painful probably for both parents.

28:28 - 28:55

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you. Thinking about complaints handling then, Paula, would you be able to say, or would you be able to weight what you're saying about the administrative issues, consistency, record keeping, compared to what you're saying about the cultural issues within the service? Would you be able to weight those relatively?

28:55 - 29:22

Paula Sussex

Yeah, I mean, that's tricky, but I would probably lean towards the complaints handling and also make the offer to CMS to put, we have been running some training across DWP, but if CMS would find it helpful to lean in more to the work that they're doing on their complaints handling function.

29:22 - 29:54

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

We were very surprised in relation to some earlier questions around safeguarding across the service that there wasn't automatically flagged where there might be issues around domestic abuse, which certainly have come up with our roundtables with parents. Is this something that you are highlighting with the complaints that have been brought to you?

29:54 - 30:45

Paula Sussex

We have not seen that specifically as a clear theme, but if you in the committee have seen that, it is probably consistent with the way in which they risk assess their cases and that as the cases come through, the ability to see where there is compound complications and a case, if you don't pull it out of what's sometimes known as the inappropriately in this circumstance, the happy path, which is a straightforward processing path. And we certainly, you know, we can see elements of that. So therefore, if it's not being risk assessed against risk of harm, other safeguarding issues, then that is something that we would recommend that CMS does, but I don't know that is the case or not.

30:45 - 30:53

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

I think we've probably concluded our questions for today. Paula, thank you so much for joining us, very, very grateful.

30:53 - 30:53

Thank you.

32:02 - 32:40

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Order and welcome to the second panel of this third and final evidence session for the Child Maintenance Service. And it's a pleasure to be joined by the DWP Minister Maeve Sherlock, Baroness Sherlock. Thank you very much for joining us. And you've brought your team as well. Simon Hunter, Director of the CMS.

Duncan Gilchrist, Deputy Director responsible for policy. And then Lucy Appleton, who's Deputy Director responsible for enforcement. Have I got that right?

Is there anything opening remarks you'd like to make?

32:40 - 32:44

Speaker 20

No, Chair. I think we're just with you, we'll be happy to answer any questions you have for us.

32:44 - 32:56

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you, that's very kind of you. I don't know if you managed to catch any of the evidence that the PHSO was able to provide to us specifically around complaints.

32:56 - 33:04

Maeve Sherlock

We got the heads up that there was evidence about complaints, but we were outside reading our papers nervously and encouraging each other, so I'm afraid we didn't get to hear.

33:04 - 34:19

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

All right. I mean, I'll just quickly put this in before I ask my substantive question. But it was, there was concerns that contrary to DWP data, the PHSO complaints are increasing and have I think doubled over the last five years. And there was concerns that this was contrary to as I say to DWP data that it was actually reducing. And the comments were in relation to both administrative issues around complaints handling, particularly around complex cases.

But also in terms of cultural issues. Assumptions were made about paying parents, for example. And the phrase that sticks in my mind because I think it's a really, really good one is about service users being treated with respect and trying to for the complaints handler to live in those people's shoes to understand where they're coming from in their dealing with them. I don't know if you want to reflect briefly on that before we go into questions.

34:19 - 35:36

Maeve Sherlock

I'm very happy to do that, and I might ask Simon to say a word about, I think if two sets of officials disagree on stats, I think I may let them fight it out if you don't mind. But I think there's a couple of things it's worth saying about complaints. The volume of the CMS caseload has risen really quite significantly. So since 2019-20, the number of cases has gone up by about 64%. So while the number of complaints is going up, relative to the caseload that isn't the case, the complaints that we see overall.

And so having said that, I'm not being complacent about that, and we take all complaints very seriously and CMS does regard complaints as a source of intelligence and feedback to make sure we can learn about what happens and how we can make things better. But I think just two things are worth noting. Complaints about the CMS, of course, the CMS unlike most government services has two customers. And so even if one customer is very satisfied as a result of an action by CMS, it's entirely possible that that will leave the other customer unhappy with what's there.

And I'm grateful to you for putting it in that context. Simon, without delay, could you just give two minutes on what, how you take that seriously and what you do to make sure that our caseworkers listen to customers, understand their context and their lives and respond appropriately?

35:36 - 36:27

Simon Hunter

Yeah, thanks. May I do that, if that's alright? Sorry. Yeah, absolutely. So we, we kicked off a, a big piece of work in December of last year, which was looking at quality as a whole.

And certainly some of the feedback that you've given us there around, you know, treating the, the case with respect, understanding the, the scenario, all of that information, as the Minister said, is rich information to us. So we, we're doing a, a substantial piece of work around that, and that also helps us in the telephony work that we do as well. So it is a body of work that will take time to embed in. The feedback's really, really important to us. I think, again, what's really important to stress here is we do have very good relationships with ICE and the PHSO.

So that feedback that we get in, we use that feedback to see how we can improve, you know, what we're doing generally. So, again, as, as the Minister said, the feedback's really, really important to us. We take that incredibly seriously and we work with that to see where we can be better.

36:27 - 36:50

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Okay, thanks very much. So, um, I, I just wondered, thinking about the perceptions of fairness, and we touched on those just, just now, what, what work you'd like to highlight in terms of how you are increasing confidence, so it's not just perceptions of fairness, but actual fairness that, that customers will experience?

36:50 - 40:47

Maeve Sherlock

Oh, thank you, Chair, and an excellent place to start. I, I think the first thing I would say is customers' perception of, of fairness and, and trust in the CMS is going to be driven by their experience of using it. So the job of the organisation is to make sure that the, the experience is one which can inspire a sense of confidence, of fairness, um, and, and of understanding and responsiveness, so it's not just an administrative service. Now, it is a challenging environment, as you know only too well. Um, inevitably, by the time often trust has broken down between the two parents before they ever get to use the CMS.

So, so it's important the CMS does follow the rules consistently, because the two customers will have different expectations and, and different desires from the process. But also to do it in a way which feels appropriate and responsive. So one of the things that we've been setting out to do is to look at how do you make it really clear what's going on at every stage. So how do we make, be clear as to, so when, if you come to the service, if you're a paying parent, how do you know that all the information you've given us has been taken into account? How can you see clearly on your customer account or when the caseworker talks to you why you owe what you owe, where it came from and what you need to do as a result?

If you're a receiving parent and you're expecting money, when should you expect it? What do you do if it doesn't turn up? Who do you tell, how do we do that? And so a lot of work has gone into communication, into both the content and the repre-, the expression, the, the formatting of information for customers, but also trying to drive some reform about, um, making sure that we do get better. I mean, performance in terms of compliance, which I'm sure we'll come onto, is better than it ever has been in a difficult environment.

But the, but the most important thing is it's not just about that. Our job is to get money to children. In the end, the CMS is about making sure children get the maintenance they're entitled to. So our job is to get money to children and, but to need to do it in a way that both parents understand and feel heard and seen in that process while applying the law consistently. And that's what we're setting out to do and that's been the purpose of the reforms.

Thinking about fairness and, and the trust that builds or it doesn't, um, I mean, do, do you think that there is an acceptable level of trust of customers of the service?

I, I think it's going to always be challenging for the, partly the reason I said there are two customers. And so it's quite possible, I've seen cases where the CMS did all the right things. I've listened to calls, I mean, so I do listen into them and not as many as Simon, who can tell you Simon listens to a vast number of calls. So I, and I've come to the conclusion that our job is to try to make the system as fair as it can be while recognising this is a zero, child maintenance is a zero-sum game. If one parent pays more, the other one is getting more, if the one parent wants more, the other one is having to, um, is getting less.

But the key to this is to try to make sure our caseworkers are trained to understand the context in which parents are working. And a lot of work has gone into that. A lot of work's gone into the quality, to assurance, to customer service, to consistent training, to having a program where the managers listen over and over again to calls, where team leaders work with customers to make sure that not only are they doing the right thing, which is, which should be taken without expectation, but also that parents can understand that and that they can be appropriately sympathetic or empathetic to the circumstances while not trying to say to, because you can't tell both parents they're right if they want different things. The final bit, I think the real source of trust is CMS gets things wrong. And when I've seen cases where it gets things wrong, of 820,000 cases a year, it's going to get things wrong.

And so that, there's no way we can, we have to apply the law fairly.

The most important thing is that when it does that, it puts its hands up, it says it's got it wrong, it works out why it's gone it wrong, it puts it right, and then it works out how it's going to make sure the system's improved for next time. And one of the things I have been really impressed is it is a learning organization. I mean, I knew some of this world from the outside. It's only when you become a minister that you get to be a bit closer up and to peer into the, into the darker corners. And they are a very learning organization.

I find that they do, they will absolutely say we messed this up, this is what we've learned from it, this is how the procedures are going on. And we've been working very hard together in continuous improvement to try to get constantly better, because I think that's the way to improve trust from customers.

40:47 - 41:14

Liz Twist

Thanks very much. So there's major changes coming up, as I understand it. And, and what I'd like to ask is how the department will make sure that when cases currently on the direct pay service move over to the single tier system based on collect and pay, it's done safely, for example, without escalating the conflict between parents.

41:14 - 43:01

Maeve Sherlock

Thank you, that is a great question. We have come to the conclusion that this is absolutely the right thing to do. At the moment with direct pay, one of the, many of the challenges we see, and some of the complaints that you as MPs will see, are that in direct pay, CMS simply works out, gets the information, works out what has to happen and parent one pays parent two. The problem is if they don't pay, and we found out from research quite how often they don't pay either what they should or on time, we don't know unless one or other parent tells us. So it can go quite some time before they come into the, to the, to the direct, to the collect and pay service, by which time arrears have built up, things have gone badly wrong.

So in the transition, what we're going to do is that firstly we will make sure that customers get plenty of notice. The applicant, the person who applied to the CMS, will be the one we'll go to first. They will get given three months' notice. We'll give really clear communications. We'll help them to work out what do they want to do.

Are the circumstances between their parents such that they could actually make an arrangement on their own, what we call a family-based arrangement? Because direct pay will have lots of parents who actually can get on perfectly well and do it. So we could help them work out what's to be paid, give them support in making that decision, in making that arrangement, and then go off and do it. If that isn't going to work, then they need to come into the service. And so we're looking now really carefully at how do we transition them.

We're working through different ways of doing that. I mean, about what, you know, how do we move cases over together, do we consider pathfinders? We're working through all of that. But the key to this is going to be advanced communication, supporting parents who want to consider a family-based arrangement, safeguards for vulnerable customers, making sure the system is ready, not rushing into it till we know the system works, and then monitoring the effects on compliance, the effects on customers, and the effects particularly on any vulnerable parents. So we are really taking that very seriously.

43:01 - 43:09

Liz Twist

Okay, so two things come out of that. One is the communication, which we've talked about in more general terms, and you're looking at that carefully is what you're saying.

43:09 - 43:11

Speaker 24

Very carefully, very carefully.

43:11 - 44:06

Maeve Sherlock

And, and the second thing is then, are there pilots going on to see how this might work, or detailed plans of implementation?

We're working through whether we might do pathfinders about the process. Pilots are always quite complicated, I mean, in CMS because of the way the statutory service works. However, we are looking at whether or not a pathfinder is the best way to do it.

And we clearly we will not be moving all customers over on the same day because that just isn't how the system works. So we are looking at what's the best way to to test and learn the best way to work that out. We're also engaging with stakeholders from across the spectrum so that we can understand going into this what are the kinds of issues that parents are concerned about both receiving parents and paying parents. So we we are engaging with stakeholders. They've come to us wanting assurances which is exactly the right thing to do and very helpful.

So we we do engage with them parents from across the piece and listen to what they have to say. So so both of those things. Communication's something CMS is working on very hard. I mean going over and over all of even just its regular letters reviewing every single letter looking both the tone as well as the content making sure it's understood testing how things go down and a lot more work will go on in that.

44:06 - 44:36

Simon Hunter

Can I just add to that if if I may just in terms of what the minister was saying there in terms of written communication and we're just about to conclude in January of next year a complete rewrite of all CMS letters so that's started with over 500 letters and that'll be done in January so again as minister said that was looking at the pitch the tone the content and making them a lot more user friendly so that it was you know a lot more user friendly so we've done that big piece of work there so again that's another part of the communications that we've been bolstered.

44:36 - 45:01

Liz Twist

Thank you. And then moving on to enforcement what progress has the department made on exploring initiatives to speed up and use enforcement powers more effectively as it talked about in its written evidence to the committee and are there particular improvements in processes that you want to see happen?

45:01 - 45:53

Maeve Sherlock

Yes and I'll actually I'll bring Lucy in in a moment who is our enforcement person who can talk through that a bit more what we're doing in that area. But there's already been a number of steps that we that we things we've made better. We've made change the processes to make it quicker for us to for example if somebody is not paying on direct pay we'll make it much quicker to be able to transfer that in collect and pay get there quicker. The key to the key to the ideal with enforcement is you never want to get there. So really what you want is early visibility when a payment's not there jumping quickly getting it back on track before it ever escalates and gets to a and gets to the stage where you have to engage with enforcement.

But if that and then if someone doesn't pay we we can move in quickly and for example if necessary take the money out of somebody's wages um or or look at other ways to get it from them. Only if that fails do you then have to move into the kind of escalated enforcement enforcement sessions. And Lucy's been working very closely about what are the all the ways if that Lucy do you want to explain what you're doing because Lucy's background is very strong in this area and she's she's our if you want to give them a give them a two minute version of what you're doing to make this better faster and better.

45:53 - 48:01

Lucy Appleton

Yeah of course yeah of course. So our our approach to enforcement is a is a escalated approach. In the vast majority of cases we generally don't need to use our enforcement powers in order to be able to um for paying parents to make their payments. However there are some instances when we do have to deploy them. We have powers as the minister referred to there to be able to deduct from earnings etc and also to be able to take money directly out of bank accounts.

And then we move into our more legal our legal power route by issuing a liability order which obviously we need to go to the courts for. Now that's one place where we are really making improvements in improving the time that it takes to get there and then hopefully be able to prompt more voluntary compliance. We have we we are planning to complete our legislation for admin liability orders for example in March and April of next year and then we'll be able to sort of really get them out as part of the process over the summer. So we do have plans in place to do that but in the meantime I've only recently joined CMS and of course this is one of the first things I asked is you know how how can we really improve this process to get there quicker. We have negotiated with HMCTS additional court slots and we are already starting to see the real benefit from that in actually being able to speed up the process of getting those liability orders into court.

So that's one of the initial things that that that we have done already and hopefully our customers will will start to see the benefits of that. There are other things that we are doing around the use of predictive analytics, for example. Our early enforcement team our early intervention team was launched last year in 2025 and we use predictive analytics there to look for patterns in customers' behaviors that imply that somebody might be about to go non-compliant. And then our that team then can reach out to those customers and say, what can we do to help you? So far proven really quite successful.

48:01 - 49:37

Maeve Sherlock

Well, that's really helpful. I mean, we we work on the assumption that most most parents want to do the right thing by their kids. And so our job is to make it as easy as possible to do the right thing. And then if but if they really for the small minority that really don't want to, then then of course the CMS's job is to step in and say, I'm sorry, however difficult things are, you do have to pay for your children. But most most paying parents want to do that.

And the predictive analytics is a good example. Sometimes it's something changing in someone's life that can disrupt the payment. You know, they maybe you change jobs, you know, something happens in your and that can disrupt it. And if you can step in at the before things go wrong, it then it's much easier to stop it going down going going down. But the final bit just to so I would want you to know and and Mr. West, that the CMS in the year to June 2026, the CMS collected 235 million pounds via enforcement.

So it's not that it's not working. I mean, 1.7 billion overall in the year. But just by enforcement, that bit did collect 275 million 235 million via enforcement in that year. So there's an awful lot of money is being collected. So it's about we're looking at ratcheting up improvements each stage by stage.

And I've come to the view that there are some big things we have to change, like collect and pay, because there's only so far we'll ever be able to go if we can't see as in direct pay, you can't see what's going on, which means it all goes badly wrong before you can pick it up. But after that, it's my view it's a little bit like British cycling. You know, there isn't you don't just need a better bike. You need an accretion of small gains. You know, you need to make all the things better.

You need to make the operations better, the communications better, the casework better. You need you make it easy all the stages. And that in the end is what will transform the experience of customers and money getting to kids.

49:37 - 49:39

Speaker 28

Thank you. And JK.

49:39 - 49:53

Brian Patrick Hurley

You mentioned communication, trying to get communication better. Maybe could you just talk me through how you're trying to improve communication specifically with parents? And then I'll come on, I've got a supplementary once you've spoken to that.

49:53 - 52:35

Maeve Sherlock

Yeah, no, it's really I think the the big one has been Simon's team going through all of the letters. I mean, I know it sounds I mean, why would you need 500 letters? But it's just because there are so many different within those 820,000 customers and cases and twice as many customers almost, there's lots of different circumstances. So going through all of those letters, making sure that that where you retire them where you don't need them and then the other rest of them are clear is key. But for me, the probably the single biggest change is going to be about communicating the things that matter most to the customer.

And what they most want to know is how much do I owe, how much am I owed, why, where did it come from, and how do I pay it. And so a lot of work has gone into, I touched on this earlier, to developing a system within so, for example, we now have My Child Maintenance Case. I mean, a lot of parents now use CMS mostly online. 80% of customers only use the CMS online. About another 14% do online and phone and 6% just do phone.

Now, it's in some ways I'm not surprised because for DWP, this demographic skews young because they've got kids. I mean, you know, so they're probably more used to using online things than other parts of their lives. So a lot of their a lot of people will only be communicating with CMS via the online service. So what's really important is when you log on to My Child Maintenance Case, you need to see what's there and find out, okay, what's happened. Now, one sometimes in the really complicated cases that you will see in casework, one of the reasons it's complicated, these cases could go back 15 years.

Each time one of those things happens, then the whole assessment has to be redone, if it's relevant. Both parents written out to, the amount of money changes and you start again. If there are arrears, that builds up. So what we need is that parents when they log on can see really clearly, okay, this is how much I owe, it's because of that's because of shared care, that's because of my job. Okay, it changed, okay, that's because this happened at that point and that happened.

And during that 15 years, they may have somebody may have changed jobs repeatedly, children may new children may have been born, parents may have separated, they may have re-partnered with somebody else.

And so if we can make it clearer for them, then I think that will help the perceptions of fairness and their understanding of the system. And also it'll equally make it easier for our caseworkers, because they too, if someone phones up, you know, you have to go all the way back through. If they can see really clearly, they can explain it to customers on the phone. So that's one of the key ones. But the other bit is about is about the thing that the chair touched on, which was about making sure our caseworkers, all of our staff are engaging with respect, understanding with customers.

Because it isn't just in the end a sum, these are your kids, it's your life, you know, the point at which you come to us, the whole thing's just fallen apart, you know, and this is this is terrible. And so we need to have empathy and understanding for that. And I talk to loads of CMS staff and they are really good people, they really get this. So our job is to support them and make sure it's consistent and they can explain things well, but with appropriate levels of empathy and then support customers. Sorry, I could go on, let me stop, stop me.

52:35 - 53:17

Brian Patrick Hurley

Yeah, I think, you know, as we all know, it's a difficult time of life for a lot of the people that you're interacting with, and that emotionally intelligent approach is key. I think even though maybe the demographic might be used to dealing with online dashboards and that way of interacting with the state, when people are going through difficult periods of their life, they might value phone support or they might value face-to-face interaction. So what provision is there for, you know, even though people might ordinarily want to interact online, around the edges and on the margins might people might need a bit more focused and dedicated support?

53:17 - 53:53

Maeve Sherlock

I'll ask Simon to answer that in a moment, but just for my end, firstly, you're absolutely right. One of the reasons that we've been putting so much work into making sure that the online system works well is that there are lots of things that customers want to do which are relatively straightforward. You want to report a change of circumstance, you know, something's happened, you know, you've had a change of income, you've had a change in your family, and things that are relatively straightforward. And those are much quicker to do online, they'll get actioned much quicker, it's much more straightforward. The other great advantage is it frees up our staff to talk to the customers who either can't or won't use digital, or who exactly want to have a conversation with a real human being who will understand their circumstances.

53:53 - 54:02

Speaker 30

So what we are trying to do is to drive as much as so the to digital where it's appropriate, but phone is always there. Simon, do you want to pick up?

54:02 - 55:08

Simon Hunter

Yeah, I think what the minister said there is absolutely right. I think the digital channels, we need to have them at a standard which, you know, delivers to what people want, but we've never ever changed our emphasis in terms of being a multi-channel organisation. And so, you know, for those customers want to ring us, then, you know, we we take quite a a lot of pride and satisfaction in having a telephony service that's always improving. I alluded to it before in terms of the the quality assurance framework. So again, we've introduced a new quality assurance framework from December of last year, which is making sure that customers who do contact us via that telephony channel, the delivery they're getting a service to a standard that we expect.

And so again, that communication channel that you mentioned before is really important. And just another addition to add to that as well is, you know, what customers and colleagues alike told us was they liked the idea of being able to message us. So we introduced some technology which is called Customer Connect. So those customers that are using our digital channel could also do two-way messaging with us. So again, that's been something which customers asked us for and colleagues asked us for and we've brought that in.

So again, the challenge around communication is important, but I think we're doing a huge amount in this space to improve the communication as best as we possibly can.

55:08 - 55:12

Speaker 29

How about face-to-face interaction, is there a facility there?

55:12 - 56:14

Maeve Sherlock

No, there isn't. I mean, it is a it's a real challenge, partly the scale of CMS. If you've got 820,000 cases and almost twice as many customers across Great Britain, then to be able to offer a consistent and efficient service across the entire country on that scale is is something that that in the end we've decided the combination of digital and phone is important. However, one of the things we do work with with our colleagues in CMS is to make sure that if parents sometimes when they're having a conversation, I mean, you know, I mean, you said I listen to calls, you know, obviously some of what is there is not CMS business, but it's still nonetheless really important to that parent, because life is complex and you don't separate out the bit that's to do with your maintenance.

So our caseworkers have a clear toolkit where they can refer people to local support or they can signpost them to local support rather than refer. If there's things that they need, if they have particular issues, then we're very happy to do that. We're also looking at how we might be able, for example, to use things like family hubs or other local services so that CMS information and support can be directed through those, even if we can't see them face-to-face.

56:14 - 56:22

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Can I just follow up, first of all, in terms of the customer connect, is that a person or is it a bot or?

56:22 - 56:23

No, it's a real person.

56:23 - 56:25

Speaker 32

It's a real person who's responding to that, okay.

56:25 - 56:26

It's a real person, yeah.

56:26 - 56:58

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

How does the system in terms of communicating, how is it able to respond to the complexities that we've heard? I understand the point that the minister's making about most of the cases fairly straightforward can be dealt with online and so on, but how do the different elements that you have now, including the one that you've just mentioned, how do they cope with the complexities of people's lives?

56:58 - 58:22

Simon Hunter

Yeah, so the objective in terms of the digital, as the minister says, is to be able to deal with that easier stuff, but obviously there is stuff kind of that comes out of the back of that which is the more complex stuff which the system can't do or isn't automated. So in terms of the approach that we take internally, you know, we do outbound calls to customers, so we might receive a piece of work which is received through the online portal, but there actually needs to be a follow-up conversation from a caseworker. In some cases, the technology that I mentioned before, the customer connect, there is that interaction between the customer and ourselves via that two-way messaging. But in some cases, because of the complex nature of a particular case or because of something that we need to address, we will just make an outbound call and speak to the customer in person. So again, I think it's that differential's really important.

We do, we are finding now the volume that we're getting in terms of telephony volume, it is the more complex stuff that you can't necessarily do online. And again, we have a very proactive approach from our caseworkers where if we need to contact the customer to get more information or understand more to help us resolve the problems on the case, then we'll do that. So we communicate with the customer to try and get the information or have that conversation where we can.

58:22 - 58:24

Andrew Elliot Pakes

Thanks very much. Can I ask a quick follow-up?

58:24 - 58:25

Of course, Andy.

58:25 - 59:06

Andrew Elliot Pakes

So just a quick follow-up just about how you're going to be measuring the success of this in future. So all of us as MPs will deal with cases at the edges of process late in the day. In places like mine, lots of that will be where we have people where English is not their first language, so that mix between digital reading and phone is difficult. I deal with a lot, both constituency-wise and because of my hearing, a lot of work with the deaf community where the phone may not be the right way. So what impact assessment or what learning are you going to do about the different communities and parents you're dealing with to ensure that the accessibility is equal across different types of needs that people have?

59:06 - 59:55

Maeve Sherlock

I'll ask Simon to explain the support we can give in, for example, in translation services, but in fact just yesterday I was listening to some CMS calls and one came from, I won't be too specific, but from a customer who had a visual impairment.

In whatever way they do it, we'll ask them, do you have any particular needs, do you have any disabilities, any communication needs, anything particular we need to know about your circumstances, and they can then tailor it. And in this case, the caseworker was really careful, talked through quite specifically, what can and can't you do, what's useful, what is helpful, and then looked at what's the best way. Do you normally, does someone normally work with you on your case, in which case do you want to use, can we support you to use the online, do you want to do it on the phone, this is how you do it, what kind of format can we give you documentation in, and went through that. And that is part of the training for caseworkers to understand that customers will come with a range of needs. But Simon, do you want to?

59:55 - 01:00:16

Simon Hunter

Yeah, I think you've encompassed it to be fair and obviously being part of the wider DWP, you know, we lean into the wider DWP in terms of just generally how we, you know, handle the different customer characteristics and make sure the support is there for the people who need us and how we need to tailor that to the individual cases. So I think in that regard, you know, we are pretty strong and we provide the support that's necessary.

01:00:16 - 01:00:37

Maeve Sherlock

But I would ask if you find we're not doing that or there's something which isn't, please let me know. I mean, it's really helpful because we like to think we've got it all set up, but there may just be something that we're, if it gets through and like any case, if we get it wrong, I want to know about it. So if you find cases, it's particularly helpful if you have a really diverse constituency and there are things coming through, I'd be really grateful to know.

01:00:37 - 01:00:58

Andrew Elliot Pakes

That's very reassuring, so we're getting it right by design, because it's been an uneven patchwork. And I know the department's put some investment into deafblind interpreters to help that particular user group, which is important in a constituency like mine. But making sure, reassuring us that different user groups and different representative groups are involved in the design phase rather than mopping up if those things are missed.

01:00:58 - 01:01:01

Speaker 33

No, that's really helpful, I will make sure we do do that.

01:01:01 - 01:01:29

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

In fact, I mean, given that we're currently going through a co-design, co-production approach in the Timms review, it'd be very interesting to see how you, in terms of the customer's journey and how we improve that, that you are thinking about accessible needs and thinking about the point that Andrew's just made in terms of deaf people. Obviously telephony isn't the best approach there. So what else you do provide, that would be very, that'd be very useful if you could write to us on that point.

01:01:29 - 01:01:57

Maeve Sherlock

Very happy to write to you on that point. And just to try, just one final, we do work with quite a range of stakeholders. And so when we're defining our, so for example, we've been refreshing repeatedly our training on dealing with customers who've experienced domestic abuse. And have had some really, a really helpful workshops with a range of organisations. And no matter how much you think you've thought of everything, you know, there's always, there's always other things to think about and other ways to improve it.

So but we're very happy to write to you on this specific point.

01:01:57 - 01:02:01

Speaker 35

We'll come back to that one, but I'm going to hand over to Liz Twist now.

01:02:01 - 01:02:41

Liz Twist

Thank you, Chair. So my question is about the relationship between Child Maintenance Service and the family courts, because we've heard evidence that a lot of families may have conflicting experiences and conflicting responsibilities of the two courts. So we just wondered what scope you see for DWP to undertake work with the Ministry of Justice to understand the common issues that arise for parents interacting with the CMS and the family court on maintenance and what used to be called contact orders.

01:02:41 - 01:04:34

Maeve Sherlock

Indeed. Again, a really great question. One of the things we spend quite a bit of time doing is I spend quite a bit of time doing is having to explain, not to you, but to other audiences, the distinct roles of the CMS and the family courts. They do have quite distinct roles and operate, as you know, under quite distinct legislative frameworks. And so where CMS on the one hand is a rules-based statutory service designed to calculate across a large caseload, whereas the family courts inevitably are more focused on individual cases and that.

What however we do, so it's not that the two have no connection at all. And we are working quite closely with the Ministry of Justice. So for example, the MOJ is developing some digital tools for supporting parents in kind of post-separation conflict.

And we're really engaging with them looking at how the work we do in supporting parents to make arrangements can dovetail with them and can align well. So I've met with them, I've met with my counterpart in MOJ, I'm meeting again shortly, my counterpart minister in MOJ shortly on the family justice side to discuss how we can make sure what we do doesn't fight and aligns well while recognizing that they have distinct roles. And the CMS of course, it's not that there's no connection. So if people go to the family courts and they come for example with a court order, then CMS can and does take account of court orders or other official documents in the range of evidence in making a decision, for example around shared care. But in the end it will have to make it along the way Parliament has prescribed it.

It will have to make it along the lines of the law around child maintenance. But we are, it's just to reassure you that we do talk to MOJ and we do recognize that we overlap to some degree in the same space. But it's really important that we make clear we're doing different things. So for example on contact, it is not the job of CMS to say, and clearly that's contact must be about the best interests of the child. It's not for the CMS to decide that.

It is for the CMS in law to recognize where does the child spend their time and how should that impact the amount of maintenance that's paid.

01:04:34 - 01:04:51

Liz Twist

Do you think there's more work that could be done at local level? You're having the discussions nationally. How is that going to filter down because clearly the child arrangements orders will impact as you said on the child maintenance side. Do you think there's more work could be done on that?

01:04:51 - 01:06:09

Maeve Sherlock

Well I think it has, I mean in a sense we're tiptoeing a line because obviously the courts make their own, the independence of the courts is something which they value and which we respect fully. What we are, we've heard, I mean I certainly heard indeed from evidence to yourselves the suggestion that there isn't enough understanding in some parts of the judicial system about the way that CMS works. Now so I'm going to reflect on that and see what more could we do to make sure that there's a full understanding about the distinct roles of these two public services. So I think that's probably the most useful one. I think the other place, there are places where they meet in practice.

I mentioned family hubs earlier on where for example we, although CMS clearly has to be quite careful about its boundaries, it's not a relationship support service. But we have for example done some work around reducing parental conflict where we worked again with services working inside family hubs and we're looking at that. So if there are things that we can do to try to make sure we both, we and MOJ share the objective of trying to make that post-separation process as good for the children as it can be. I mean in the end this is about the kids. It's about parental conflict impacts on children and anything any of us can do to try to make that better in our own lanes while making sure we're aligned is better.

But no, I've heard that, I picked that up from the evidence to you and that was and I'm very happy for us to look into what more we could do to make sure there's an understanding across the piece.

01:06:09 - 01:08:23

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you. And I think it's a really good point. When we had our second evidence session this was highlighted. I think it's not just between the stakeholders but also the understanding of service users, of customers really. And it might be you might want to look at if somebody's going to courts that they understand about CMS's role and vice versa because sometimes they go down the path from the evidence we've received and weren't aware of how they impacted on each other.

Moving on to me. So I'm going to ask some questions or a question specifically on safeguarding. You'll be aware that the committee has done a huge amount of work around safeguarding within DWP as a whole. And we were quite surprised talking in other spheres of DWP in terms of the lack of awareness there was about domestic abuse and how that affects customers, service users. And you've obviously mentioned that you've just had some workshop to try and understand around that.

And we really wanted to make sure and be reassured that this is being considered. You'll be aware that the department now reports on an annual basis the deaths of claimants. And we know that the reported number is just a tip of the iceberg figure. But it has also included service users of the CMS service in recent years. And we must be mindful of that and how we can do whatever we can do to safeguard paying parents and receiving parents at the same time.

So on that level, would you like to explain what you're doing particularly around service users who may be having been abused and more generally as well, if you could?

01:08:23 - 01:09:35

Maeve Sherlock

Of course, I will, Chair. And I'm very much aware of the work of your own interest in this and the work you've done with the department and that the committee has done over some time in exploring this. Firstly, just to I want to re-absolutely reassure the committee that the Child Maintenance Service takes the issue of safeguarding in general and domestic abuse in particular extremely seriously. Absolutely safeguarding is embedded at the heart of CMS's processes. And because as I've explained, because of the nature that a family breakup is emotionally fraught and because almost by definition, always a significant number of customers at the point at which they come to use the CMS are going to be their circumstances will be very challenging.

And so it's incredibly important to CMS to make sure that everything about the systems is appropriate and that our colleagues who are talking, engaging with customers understand that. I'll ask Simon to explain more specifically what he's doing. But we make sure that all of our colleagues are trained in domestic abuse. They understand that. They have all been trained.

They all receive training. And every two years and in the intervening year, they get a refresher to make sure that they're still across this. So it's really important that we help them to understand that. We also make sure...

01:09:35 - 01:09:36

Is that all staff, Minister?

01:09:36 - 01:11:07

Maeve Sherlock

It is. It is, yes. All CMS staff. It is. In fact, I think you guys have done it as well, haven't you?

It's not just frontline customers. Yep. No, I've even looked at the training myself. I'm not going to say I sat down and did the whole thing because that isn't my day job, but even I've looked at it. So it absolutely is taken extremely seriously.

So when I say we're working at the moment, we are refreshing the training. It's not that we're creating new training. This is an organisation that believes in continuous improvements. We want to keep getting it better. And also the truth is understanding of different aspects of abuse evolve over time.

We know from engaging with stakeholders that of course there are either different forms of abuse or just different ways of understanding how it can happen in practice. And so that's I mean so that's I really want to reassure you on that count. But the workshop we held recently was 17 stakeholder organisations. They again they still came up with with ways in which we could as we each time we adapt, we find ways of making it better. So that is something we're really committed to.

On the wider question on safeguarding, I mean it's we recognise that because some of the customers coming to us have extremely difficult personal circumstances and some may be experiencing emotional distress. Now so our again the training of colleagues is is really clear to help we train them in the same way we train them to look out for the signs of domestic abuse because not all customers will want to disclose it to us and that's absolutely their right. We also train them to look out for the signs that a customer may be in distress or particularly if there's any risk that we may think that they may harm themselves in some way. And they have a clear protocol. They're supported.

01:11:07 - 01:13:09

Simon Hunter

Simon can talk you through it, but they're trained in what to do in those circumstances and to look carefully and to get the help. Simon, do you want to explain how how we embed safeguarding in that way?

Yeah, and and again I think in terms of giving you the confidence and the reassurance that you need, we undertook a domestic abuse discovery piece of work and that basically ran from May to September.

The idea from the 17 specialist organisations was to help us redesign the training that we do for our colleagues. And so we got some really rich feedback from them sessions and essentially we've just relaunched that training. So that training, for example, incorporates trauma-informed training. So again, the information we got from them stakeholders was really, really key. So we launched that training that goes live as of this month.

And what we want to do there in terms of making sure everyone in the organisation gets captured with the new training is they will get put through an enhanced module specific to that so that there's not that gap. The other thing that's just kind of recent thing that's been launched is we have a safeguarding gateway. So that was launched just on Monday of this week. And again, it's something that I've been on myself. So it's a really easy resource.

So if you're a colleague, it basically gives you a kind of what do you need to do in certain circumstances. So again, you know, the resources that we give to colleagues is really important. So the training we give to colleagues is key. And as the Minister said, domestic abuse training happens every two years with a refresher in the intervening years. So that's really, really important, including a knowledge checker.

We've now got this enhanced training which is as a consequence of the feedback we had from the 17 specialist organisations. The other thing which I think's really important here as well, Chair, is that I mentioned before about the quality assurance framework. So the quality assurance framework, the standards are embedded in there in terms of what we look out for in relation to, you know, what we needed to do around safeguarding and domestic abuse. So if you think we're, you know, we've year to date listened to over 60,000 calls. That's a lot of information in there where it means we can make sure that our colleagues are doing what we need them to do.

01:13:09 - 01:13:14

Speaker 37

So lots of really good stuff in this space that I think we're doing to kind of, you know, really make a difference.

01:13:14 - 01:13:49

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you, Chair. I just want to go on a slight tangent in light of some of the comments that have been made by the Minister. Thank you for you and your team coming along today. It was repeatedly there's been talk of the direct payment system and things going wrong with the direct payment system and collect and pay being a system that where payees and the organisation know where you are a lot more. Gingerbread are really keen to see the shifting of all cases to collect and pay and the ending of direct payment.

What are your thoughts around that, Minister?

01:13:49 - 01:14:58

Maeve Sherlock

Well, as a government, we consulted on this, as indeed the previous government consulted and I extended the consultation when I became the Minister. And having reflected on the responses and all the evidence, I've concluded that the right thing to do is to remove direct pay and to move all cases over to collect and pay, or to make collect and pay the only service that the CMS offers for the reasons I touched on earlier. I won't rehearse them again, but yes. However, I do, it's not, customers have to have a choice. And direct pay will consist of a mix.

There'll be customers for whom it works perfectly well and a family-based arrangement arranged between the two parents with the right support may be absolutely the right thing. But if that isn't something that works, or if they simply want a service where they have more confidence that it's going to be handled without them having to engage with each other for all kinds of reasons, which may be safety, but they may just be preference, then if they're going to come into the system, we want them to come into collect and pay where we, it's really visible. So if a payment is not made, we can see straight away it's not made and intervene in the ways that Lucy was describing earlier on so we can get things back on track as fast as possible. So I'm committed, so yes, sorry, I'm clearly not answering your question. Try me again, sorry.

01:14:58 - 01:15:09

Matthew Stephen Darling

But are you going to close down direct payment completely because I know that's what Gingerbread would like and just have collect and pay because you know exactly where you are?

01:15:09 - 01:15:13

Speaker 38

Yes, yes, just be clear, yes we are. That was what was proposed by the previous government and by us.

01:15:13 - 01:15:31

Matthew Stephen Darling

What time scales? Because the worrying thing is, whilst there's the aspiration, is there going to be, particularly if there was a general election in December, but you know, what time scale do you have programmed in for starting the process of making that quite significant change?

01:15:31 - 01:16:34

Maeve Sherlock

Just to be clear for the record, I have no belief there'll be a general election in December. I just want to make that clear. I didn't say that. Government wasn't... so definitely. Just to be... and I think to be clear, what the process I've described is actually a major change.

And as I say, it's one that was committed to by the previous government and by this government. But it will need primary legislation and it will need a massive overhaul of CMS's processes, communications, the entire system will be changing. So the first step is we have to get primary legislation. So we need a primary legislation vehicle. So when parliamentary time can be found, and obviously we are waiting to find out what will happen in the next parliamentary session, then when we get parliamentary time, we'll be taking legislation forward.

And so that's all I can say. I mean, I think colleagues here all know how the system works, that everybody wants legislation and we all want it tomorrow and we all get it when we get it. But we are... the government has made clear its commitment to doing this. As I said, the previous government committed. I certainly couldn't comment on a subsequent parliament, although I have my own preferences of what it might look like.

But obviously I couldn't commit that to anything. But I can simply say that this government and the last one did say yes.

01:16:34 - 01:17:24

Matthew Stephen Darling

Right. So my real question now. Internal process reviews have actually highlighted where people were in payment and they were talking about doing harm to themselves. And yet we heard really a really good messaging from yourselves around safeguarding training and it's all... but those internal process reviews are turning up where that isn't actually happening. So what is going wrong then and how are you ensuring that that learning happens?

It goes back to once upon a time I visited my local DWP office and they said, "Oh yes, no, I know all about trauma-informed," one of the coaching members of staff said, "I know who to refer them to," and you think, that's probably not the level that we want you at. So, you know, what lessons are we learning from those reviews?

01:17:24 - 01:19:12

Maeve Sherlock

I mean, I think obviously the internal process reviews obviously are place that whenever we become aware of the death of a customer and obviously then there'll be an independent review and they'll look at all the evidence. And in DWP they would mostly not be about child maintenance. They would... I mean, there aren't that many of them, but they would not normally have come through child maintenance. However, CMS is never complacent about this. I think one of the things Simon could touch on earlier is that we have a six-point plan for colleagues.

It's not just about referral. Simon, do you want to just read out the... I can never learn the six points, I can always forget one of them. Do you want to tell her what the six points are? But essentially so that colleagues are trained absolutely as to what do you do is you have to listen out for the information, identify it, get support, report it, escalate it, you know, go through the stages. Now, just to be clear, I mean, you know, sometimes the stage at which people engage with the Child Maintenance Service, they may be in significant distress.

And there's only... you know, there is only so much that a government service can do to identify that or to react. However, what we want to try to do is anything that was within our gift, we want to make sure our processes are as sensitive to that as they can be. Now, where with CMS, things do go wrong. I mean, I see complaints and things go wrong. And the one thing I do want to assure you is that if we see things go wrong in any part of the service, the key is to make sure we learn from that and get it better.

We can't make... we can't stop all problems, we can't make everything better. But we can look at our own responsibilities and where we think, for example, our services are hard to use or we want to make sure someone can get through to a human being, we will do that. We're now at a stage if somebody wants to phone us up, the average wait time is 11 minutes. You know, so I mean, that's really improved a lot. You know, I mean, I used to get letters complaining of very long wait times.

01:19:12 - 01:20:14

Simon Hunter

I don't get those very much anymore. So the key I think for us is to look at our process and trauma-informed training, I mean, I was talking to the colleague who leads on this recently in the department and it's as much about design. So it's thinking about things at the design stage, being aware of the impact. But in the end, CMS does have to make... to do tough things. And it just has to do them as safely as it can.

Simon, what are the six points?

Yeah, I mean, I'll come on the six points, but just a quick point I want to make as well is when we've done the safeguarding training, that's DWP-led safeguarding training, we've actually put all of our leaders through that training first. And the vast majority of our leaders have been through that and actually some of the IPR information we've used to inform that training to help them in terms of how we coach our colleagues.

But yeah, the six-point plan is one to six, it's one, take the statement seriously. Number two, summon a colleague to act as support. Number three, gather information to gauge the level of risk. Number four is to provide a referral, provide referral advice. Number five, summon emergency help.

And number six is to review the incident. So the colleagues have a very, very clear six-point plan. And when I mentioned before the safeguarding framework, them resources are within that, so it's in a very, very easy place to find. So yeah, the six-point plan is something that we brief out comprehensively.

01:20:14 - 01:20:16

Speaker 39

Really helpful. Thank you. Thank you, Chair.

01:20:16 - 01:20:22

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you so much. John Mill. It's Peter, isn't it? Oh, it is, you're absolutely right. Peter, thank you so much, John.

01:20:22 - 01:20:57

Peter Bedford

Thank you, Chair. Turning to affordability, in previous sessions obviously we've heard from the department that say the child maintenance calculation is designed to be affordable for paying parents. But given the history of that calculation in terms of the 1998 thresholds, using gross income, arguably it hits those on low earnings disproportionately and it makes it often unaffordable for them to pay. Could you give me your thoughts on that and why the department's sticking by its position on this?

01:20:57 - 01:23:11

Maeve Sherlock

Yes, of course. Let me pick up, there's a couple of things embedded in that. Firstly, let me deal with the gross income point because this comes up quite often. There are two ways to do this, you can assess on gross income or you can assess on net income. And you simply would set the rates to take account of that.

I think that's often not understood. I mean, a previous system had used net income and then you'd set the rates to take account of the fact that obviously it's net income. The big problem I think if you go for net income is what the previous administrations found, that it just caused lots of instability and uncertainty and movement around rates, whereas gross taxable income is a really clear and unambiguous basis on which to make a judgment. On affordability, one of the benefits of the system is that the key, the biggest driver for most paying parents is simply you pay a percentage of your income. And so obviously if your income goes down, so too does the percentage.

And if your income goes up, so too does the percentage. And the reason behind that is that the whole point of CMS, CMS is there to get money to kids, or crucially it's there to make sure that the children continue to benefit from the income of both parents even if the parents have chosen to live apart. And so obviously if you were still both living with your child and your income went up, the child would benefit from the income of both parents. Or again, if you were living together and the income went down, the child would have to bear the consequences of that payments going down as their household income going down. So broadly speaking, it does track that.

Where I think it has been, what happens, you make an assessment once a year and then it's reviewed after a year. And in that year, the assessment will only change if the paying parent's income has moved up or down by more than 25%. Now I felt when we reviewed the calculation that that was too much, that your income could fall by 24% and your child maintenance would not change at all until your next annual review. So I've decided I'm going to reduce that to 15% because that feels, you're trying to find a sweet spot. If it's too low, then even small changes in income mean that the person who's having to, the receiving parent who's having to receive the money could find their payments moving around too quickly.

But if it's too big, it's too tough on the paying parent if the income drops down. I think 15% is a good sweet spot. So actually I've made a decision to do that. I think that will help with affordability in those cases where people's income fall. So does that help?

01:23:11 - 01:23:38

Peter Bedford

Yeah, I mean you mentioned that obviously the child should benefit from the income of both parents, but that's something that's not been incorporated into the affordability calculation. I think previously the Work and Pensions Committee before my time on it recommended that the calculation took into account the income of both parents in deciding on that. And I think back in, was it June earlier this year, this was raised again at committee and I think the department basically said that it wasn't looking at doing so because it would be overly administratively burdensome to do so.

01:23:38 - 01:23:39

What's your thoughts on that?

01:23:39 - 01:24:12

Maeve Sherlock

I might I might ask Duncan just to Duncan's done a lot of thinking about this when we were doing the cat reviewing the calculation we did look at this. But just briefly, just to be clear, I did I didn't talk about affordability for both parents. I talked about the child benefiting from the income of both parents. By definition, the child with whom the parent is is primarily living, of course is benefiting from all that parent's income. I mean or or lack of.

I mean because they're because they're living in that household, assuming as most parents are they're living primarily with one parent. So it's a it's really about trying to find to make an appropriate balance that they benefit from from the incomes of both parents. Duncan, do you want to just say a word about how we reflected on this?

01:24:12 - 01:25:02

Speaker 42

Yes. So effectively, when you're you know that the the fundamental point of the CMS, the reason we brought it in in place of the courts, was because if you're going to handle a very big caseload, then you need to smooth out some of the differences. So you need to pick and choose the kinds of changes that you're going to action. So you're always making a balance in the regulatory framework around it of trying to get the right changes that will make the most difference to most people, while not doing so many changes that it will mean that the cases then become aged and you fall into the trap that the CSA did when it was first launched, which is you can't keep up with the workload and you end up in a situation where lots of people get no maintenance because you're not able to work the cases properly.

01:25:02 - 01:25:08

Peter Bedford

So so that that sounds like more of a department problem in that in that you're looking at what your capacity is rather than what the problem is.

01:25:08 - 01:26:12

Speaker 42

But I think it's a societal problem. I mean, there is no society which operates a complete that that I'm aware of, that operates a complete court-based system which looks at every case where they are getting particularly good results. The Irish in 2022 just did a study of their system, which is the court-based system that we had prior to bringing in the CSA first, and the majority report that came out of that review was that in order to increase the number of people getting maintenance, they needed to move to a more agency-based approach. So it's it's not a I mean, you could, yes, pour as many people as you wanted to into the CSA and they could deal with, you know, whatever sorts of changes you wanted. But in a real world where we have the, you know, government having to make sensible prioritisation decisions, you can't have a system that is as sensitive as the courts are to every single change.

01:26:12 - 01:27:36

Maeve Sherlock

Can I just clarify two two I think there are two questions here, which is is the principle of how it's structured and and the operation the operation of it. Now, on the principle, as what I was trying to explain, probably obviously probably not very well, is that the CSA was set up on on to do one job. And that job is to make sure the child benefits from the incomes of both parents. Now, by definition, the the parent with whom the child is living, the child's already benefiting from that parent's income. The parent is is feeding, housing, clothing the child, providing for the child.

The point of the child maintenance service, it's not primarily there to level things between the parents. Its job it was given is to make sure the child benefits from both parents based on an assumption that both parents continue to maintain responsibility for the children even if they've separated and their relationship's come to the end. So the job of the CMS is specifically to add in to that to that household an appropriate amount of money from the parent who is not the primary care of the child in order that the child benefits from from both parents' income. And I in my experience from dealing a lot of families, even if and it would be unusual, even if unusually you had an extremely wealthy receiving parent, um, and sometimes a much less wealthy paying parent, I've talked to plenty of people who would say, I want to contribute to my child. It's not just about does the household need it.

01:27:30 - 01:28:21

Peter Bedford

Pages and pages of them. I'm not going to read them all out now today, but there are a lot. And you know, the example you gave about, you know, a high earner, you know, so a man earns less than the ex-wife, who the ex-wife has several properties, and the child, the teenage child stays with him two nights a week. He's paying his ex-wife 700 pounds a month, which is a significant part of his earnings. He's a very low income person.

I want to contribute to my child. I think that's appropriate.

Yeah, so on that, so before this evidence session, I said to my team, can you produce me a list of all the CMS cases you've got we've got problems with?

I mean, the ex-wife clearly has a lot of capital, a lot of income elsewhere. He's now basically pushed on the verge of suicide because of the financial pressures that's putting on him. So I guess the point I'm making is the fact it doesn't take into account the income of both sides or both parties. Typically it's the man's the paying parent. Therefore, it's pushing a lot of people into distress and you know, particularly mental health issues as well.

And my inbox is full of cases like this.

01:28:21 - 01:29:41

Maeve Sherlock

And obviously, I read the complaints that come in from MPs. I mean, but I just wanted to say two quick things at first. One is that the cases that you see are the most complex, the most difficult. I mean, you know this from elsewhere in your postbags. The overwhelming majority of cases work straightforwardly.

Secondly, obviously I can't comment on this case, but I'm very sorry to hear that somebody feels that they're at risk of suicide and obviously you will have your own ways of dealing with that, but we would never want to see that. But just to come back to that example, the affordability of the question of what that paying parent will pay is based on his income, not anything to do with her income. It's based on his income. So in a sense, it wouldn't matter, the impact on his finances would not be affected by whether or not the other parent had plenty of money or not enough money. Can I just finish the point?

The point, the system is set, Parliament set the system up, I mean back in 2012, on the assumption that both parents retain responsibility for supporting the child. And therefore, that's all the system is set up to do. However, for example, if there's shared care, then the system takes account of that. So if the child stays with him for some certain nights a week, then he pays less because it's recognized that he's bearing some of the costs of that child. So this is about them contributing to the cost of the child.

It's not about their respective financial circumstances.

01:29:41 - 01:30:02

Peter Bedford

Yes, I don't think it's disputed that both parents should be contributing. But I think it's the way the system you described is the system that we have, that there was due to be a consultation, I think, following the previous iteration of this committee, which was then cancelled on this. I'm not clear as to why that was cancelled in terms of the evidence that the department used to cancel that consultation.

01:30:03 - 01:30:04

Yeah, please do, Simon.

01:30:04 - 01:31:28

Speaker 42

So the reason it was cancelled, I mean, there are a number of reasons, but if we look at low income paying parents in particular, we asked low income paying parents and receiving parents on relatively low incomes how they would feel about a change that broadly speaking brought the calculation up to date. So in other words, pushed up the threshold for the flat rate and therefore the other thresholds, which would then reduce the amount that those on paying parents on low incomes would pay and reduce the amount that receiving parents on low incomes would receive. And the feedback we got was from paying parents, a large number didn't think that that research has been published, so if the committee wants to go over it, then I won't give you the figures now, but they are there. The paying parents felt that this reduction wouldn't really make much difference to them. A number of paying parents were concerned about the impact this would have on their children and receiving parents felt that this would be quite damaging for them.

So in other words we've got essentially a big no from the parents who would be affected by this in the research.

01:31:28 - 01:31:37

Peter Bedford

So that was research prior to the consultation. So that was almost like a pre-consultation consultation based on some research.

01:31:37 - 01:33:44

Maeve Sherlock

The decision was a ministerial decision so let me take responsibility for that. We deliberately set out to do evidence because we wanted to understand the impact on both paying parents and receiving parents of any changes to the system. Because as I said before because it's a zero sum game every single change we make will affect right across the piece. So if one paying parent pays less out there somewhere is a receiving parent who is getting less money in to pay for the child. Conversely if a receiving parent wants more maintenance which they generally do that means out there is a paying parent who will have to pay more.

So we looked across the piece at the impact of that. We also looked at the way the system works at the moment. We looked at administrative evidence. We did evidence reviews. We talked to stakeholders.

And then in the round we made a decision. Is this the moment in which we're going to have wholesale change of the system in the middle of a cost of living pressure time? And we didn't feel the evidence was. Our driver was will this improve compliance improve fairness and get in more money to children? And that were the criteria by which I judged it.

Would they do those things? And the evidence did not suggest that wholesale change to the actual calculation would do those things. Where the evidence was clear we followed it. Which is why as I said we've I've decided to reduce the income threshold from 25% down to 15% which is something we've often been asked for. I've also been often asked why if somebody has income which is not wages can you not take account of that?

So I've also made a decision that other forms of unearned income will be incorporated in the calculation again so that the aim of the two of those things together is they will more the calculation will more accurately reflect the genuine income which is being assessed both its current level and its combination of sources. So that's what we set out to do. We went where the evidence led. That's why the evidence led and that's why I made the decision.

01:33:44 - 01:33:59

John Milne

Move on now Peter if that's okay.

Just I don't think this issue's going away and I think it will continue to be in the political agenda and I think that I would implore the department to re-look at this again. Okay thank you.

Thank you Peter. John Milne.

01:33:59 - 01:34:20

Maeve Sherlock

Thank you. And just before I get to my main question just following on from Peter there's as repeatedly during these this inquiry we've had a terrific discrepancy from what we hear from CMS to what what our lived experience is from our constituency casework.

I've got a whole spreadsheet of everything that's ever been raised with me by an MP.

01:34:20 - 01:34:21

So if I may write to you afterwards with some because I think the detail is a very good test of the theory.

01:34:21 - 01:34:27

Maeve Sherlock

I go off and interrogate I find out what's happening and and so I'm really really up for hearing this.

01:34:27 - 01:34:27

You know you've got a great theory and then you see what's happening on the ground and it appears to contradict some of these things but we haven't got time for it now.

01:34:27 - 01:35:21

Speaker 46

The one that I would say is you see you see and the vast majority of complaints about CMS now come through MPs so it's not that you're seeing a tip of an iceberg and everything else is also terrible. Two very quick things. One is please do but also in case you haven't heard I do regular CMS surgeries for MPs where I invite it's obviously not for me to interfere in individual cases but I actually what I do is invite you to come in tell me what you're seeing look at any patterns or thresholds and I go off and look into all of those. Actually mostly it works really well. You see really hard cases.

Sometimes we get it wrong and we need to get better at doing that. I'm committed to doing that but I wouldn't want you to go away thinking it's all terrible because it honestly genuinely isn't. Now the question sorry.

Thank you very much yes. So DWP said in its gave us in its written evidence that the child maintenance calculation is represents the amount of money and I quote that a paying parent would spend on the child if they were still living with them. Now that assumption the workings I believe date from the 90s. Do you think that do you think it needs updating? Do you think it's still appropriate?

01:35:21 - 01:35:59

Maeve Sherlock

I mean the system is based on it was originally Duncan can explain the background to this. It was based on the cost of raising a child. But of course the way it cashes out in practice is overwhelmingly it's related to a percentage of income. And so and because the percentages are still there obviously even though people's as I said even though people's incomes have gone up and down in fact the amounts of money changing hands have carried on going with that original calculation. So although it hasn't changed the system in practice the amounts of money changing hands through maintenance of course as a percentage have carried on broadly being the same proportion of somebody's income that was there.

And it's based on the assumption that when you're living with a child, of course, if your household income is smaller, less money will get spent on the child. If your household income is larger, more money will get spent on the child. So it's not just about what's the bare minimum a child needs to have to not be going barefoot. It is about what's an appropriate amount for both parents to pay to make sure the child carries on benefiting from both parents' income. Duncan, do you want to add...?

01:35:59 - 01:36:27

Speaker 42

Just to say that we absolutely looked at that in the research. And you're right, there are obviously, you know, it's 25 years, there are some changes. They're not enormous. But broadly speaking, the main difference, I think, is we believe that the costs of two and three children have probably increased compared to one child in the period since the last lot of research was done.

01:36:27 - 01:36:35

John Milne

So is it your view then that that was a reasonable or effective assessment or basis?

01:36:35 - 01:36:37

Speaker 43

Absolutely.

01:36:37 - 01:37:18

John Milne

Okay. And are you concerned about the interaction between some of your calculations and demands on behavior? So, for example, you talked about number of nights a week a child stays with a parent. Now, and that does interact with behaviors and can be weaponized because there's a financial incentive to have more nights with you as opposed to your estranged partner. So are you concerned about that, that the calculation is actually leading to, or can be weaponized?

01:37:18 - 01:38:59

Maeve Sherlock

I think the aim, the element of the shared care part of the calculation is that we need to find some way, some reasonably consistent way of reflecting the fact, the circumstances when care is shared. Now, it's not the majority, I think about a quarter of our parents using the service do have shared care. But in those cases, we need to find some way of reflecting on it. Now, in the end, the CMS can't make a judgment based on the motivations of parents. It can't look into people's souls.

It simply has to apply the law as Parliament set it out. And Parliament set it out in that way. And I think we have to trust that the majority of parents want the best for their children. And so the system couldn't not take account of that because that would be unfair, because it would then leave parents who were, say, taking the child for two or three nights a week having to bear some of the costs and yet still also having to pay the other parent to do it. And so the system, it's not, it feels like of all the ways of doing... we looked at different countries around the world and we didn't think any system had found the perfect way to do this.

And so in as much as one has to find a proxy for shared care, this feels like the nearest proxy that we've found, and so that's why we're applying it. But we are applying it sensitively. But the bigger question about whether or not... I mean, it's up to the courts, as I was discussing earlier with Liz, to decide what care should, how contact should be arranged or how care should be distributed. All CMS is, the way Parliament set CMS up, it gave it the job of reflecting what was actually done, not what should happen. And it has to stay in its lane in that.

It couldn't ask our staff to be making the judgment of Solomon as to where a child should be. All it can do is ask both parents for evidence, look at a full range of evidence, and if it comes to the conclusion that both overnight and day-to-day care are completely equal, then nobody pays anybody anything.

01:38:59 - 01:39:01

Speaker 44

Thank you very much.

01:39:01 - 01:39:12

Angela Deborah Elspeth Marie Abrahams

Thank you. And that concludes our evidence session this morning. Can I thank Baroness Sherlock for coming to see us today with her officials. Order, order.