First Delegated Legislation Committee

2 November 2026

First Delegated Legislation Committee Actual start House of Commons

Follow its sittings
15:26 - 15:30
Speaker 2
The draft Housing Tenancy Deposit Schemes Order 2026. 
15:30 - 15:32
Speaker 1
The Minister to move the motion. 
15:32 - 18:40
Speaker 3
Thank you, Sir Desmond.  It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair.  I beg to move that the Committee has considered the draft Housing Tenancy Deposit Schemes Order, which was laid before the House on the 8th of September 2026.  Sir Desmond, this Government promised in its manifesto to transform the experience of private renting.  In addition to the greater security, rights, and protections we've given private tenants through our transformative Renters' Rights Act, improving how tenancy deposit schemes work is a way that we can further deliver on this promise. 

As things stand, when tenants provide a deposit as a security for any breach of tenancy terms, the landlord is required to protect this through a Government-approved tenancy deposit scheme. 

This means renters can feel confident that their deposit is safe and secure, and at the end of the tenancy, is returned to the tenant and or landlord in accordance with the appropriate outcome under the scheme.  When tenants and landlords disagree over the amount due to each party, the schemes also offer free and independent dispute resolution.  Custodial tenancy deposit schemes are delivered via concessionary contracts, whereby administrators fund the service from interest earned on deposits, rather than receiving payment from government.  Custodial schemes currently hold over 2 and 1/2 billion pounds worth of tenants' money on which they accrue interest.  The interest is retained by the scheme administrators as revenue, unless arrangements are in place for part of it to be paid to the tenant. 

As part of improving the tenancy deposit system, this Government wants to unlock the value generated by the schemes and expand the ways in which it can benefit tenants in the private rented sector. 

Ultimately, this will mean better value for both tenants and the taxpayer.  The order before us, Sir Desmond, enables the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government to receive part of the interest accrued on tenancy deposits protected under a custodial tenancy deposit scheme.  Currently, the legislation allows interest to be retained by the scheme administrator, subject to scheme arrangements providing for part of it to be paid to tenants and/or landlords.  The order, I want to be really clear about this, does not remove these options.  It adds flexibility by introducing a new power that may be used in combination with one or both of the existing options, for example where higher interest rates mean that the interest generated by the scheme as a whole considerably exceeds the costs of running the scheme, after allowing reasonable returns to scheme administrators. 

The order does not itself require any payment to be made to the Secretary of State, nor does it prescribe how such amounts must be determined. 

Those matters will be determined through future scheme arrangements established via procurement and contractual processes.  What the regulations do, Sir Desmond, is allow the Secretary of State to take account of market conditions, scheme performance, operating costs, value for money and the need to maintain an effective free service for tenants and landlords while avoiding disproportionately high profits being made by scheme administrators.  The instrument is intended to provide flexibility for future arrangements with administrators of custodial schemes.  The Secretary of State's intention is if the new power is exercised, the Secretary of State would use any funds received towards programs or activities that benefit tenants in the private rented sector.  The Secretary of State would be transparent in publishing the amount received from the scheme, the program or programs funded, and any metrics demonstrating the value delivered. 

Any arrangement for interest to be paid directly to the Secretary of State will be subject to agreement from His Majesty's Treasury. 

18:40 - 19:22

Matthew Pennycook

Future arrangements will continue to allow scheme administrators to keep part of the accrued interest to cover the cost of the free service they provide to tenants and landlords. This amount should be sufficient to enable the scheme to provide a safe and effective service that safeguards tenants' deposits, to meet its key performance indicators, and to make a reasonable profit if it is a private sector entity. Future arrangements, Sir Desmond, may also provide for part of the accrued interest to be paid directly to tenants where it is decided that this is appropriate. To conclude, this order will give the Government additional flexibility to determine how the interest accrued by custodial tenancy deposit schemes is distributed, so as to ensure a fit for purpose scheme that will ultimately benefit tenants in the private rented sector and the taxpayer. I beg to move.

19:22 - 19:30

Desmond Swayne

The question is that the Committee has considered the draft Housing (Tenancy Deposit Schemes) Order 2026. Gareth Bacon.

19:30 - 23:00

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Thank you, Sir Desmond. It's always a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I welcome the opportunity to sit opposite the minister again, who I've seen more often in the last few days than my own wife. I appreciate the remarks he's already made in this debate. And I welcome the opportunity on behalf of His Majesty's opposition to address this set of regulations. I must be frank, Sir Desmond, we don't like this very much because this order appears to be little more than an act of state-sponsored thievery.

In this Halloween season, Sir Desmond, lurking in the shadows is not a vampire or a monster, but the larcenous light fingers of Marsham Street. This order seeks to give the Secretary of State the power to hive off a portion of the interest accrued on someone else's money and then pocket it on behalf of the Government. As a Conservative, as a believer in private property, I'm astounded to find the Government pushing through yet another stealth tax just days after the budget. I know I shouldn't be. After all, it's not the first and I doubt it will be the last stealth tax we see in this Parliament.

But the brazen lack of respect for other people's money beggars belief. That is why the Opposition will seek to divide and will vote against this order today. As the deposit protection service have stated, at present, interest goes towards the effective running of the scheme back to tenants or landlords, or in some cases, to charity. In siphoning off funds to pay for MHCLG's litany of costly policies, the Government's action raises a number of questions. For example, and I think actually, to be fair, the Minister may have just answered some of this, will this leave the deposit protection schemes financially exposed?

What assessment has been made of the funding needed to keep these schemes running so that tenants and landlords are protected with certainty along with the jobs that these companies provide? This instrument has no clear purpose, outlines no formula and sets no clear cap.

We're being asked to approve a power without knowing how much money the government are seeking to take, nor what limit the Secretary of State will impose on herself in a scheme that lets the government profit from other people's money. I also want to raise concerns about the relationship between this policy and the planned abolition of insured tenancy deposit schemes. Taken together, hiving off the interest on deposits for the government's benefit and moving all deposits into the custodial schemes will create a perverse incentive. If the government takes income from the same custodial deposits that they are forcing the whole market towards, how can the government demonstrate that profiting from interest on other people's money has played no part in their decision-making process? This is a very serious concern and deserves far greater parliamentary scrutiny that honorable members have been afforded today.

Indeed, we believe that there is a convincing argument that these changes should be made not through a statutory instrument, but through primary legislation. Here today, we can make no amendments. We have little time to probe the details, and we're being asked to provide a new sorry, to approve a new tax outside the place best suited constitutionally to scrutinize financial legislation. This order lets the Secretary of State, on behalf of the Government, take a share of the interest earned on tenants' deposits. It does not say how much.

It does not say what the money is for. It sets no cap and no formula. The Government are asking this House for a blank check to draw down on other people's money. That money does not belong to the Government. A week after a tax hike on landlords, by changing this system, the Government are creating another stealth tax.

This comes on top of a new database fee, a rewritten tenancy system and a sector in which landlords are already considering the viability of their portfolios. Every cost, Sir Desmond, eventually lands on renters in the end. The opposition's tests are simple. Is this a stealth tax? Well, yes, it is.

Is it the Government's money? No, it's not. Does it deliver for renters? Clearly not.

It is for all of these reasons that we will divide the House and we will vote against this instrument.

23:00 - 23:02

Speaker 6

Sarah Edwards.

23:02 - 25:53

Sarah Edwards

Thank you, and it's an honor to serve under your chairship, Sir Desmond. This, Chair, is one of those occasions where a rather niche piece of legislation comes forward, but actually seems completely obvious once you examine its purpose. The private rental sector has been broken for decades and in Tamworth and around the whole country, we've seen skyrocketing rents for poor quality and substandard housing.

Tenants have been living in houses or flats that feel neglected by their landlords in areas that often may say they also felt neglected by Westminster. Now community spaces have vanished and have been left neglected. And where people cannot own their own home, some areas are left without strong advocacy for change. And this Government's Renters' Rights Act has overhauled the entire sector, restoring fairness between tenants and landlords by giving over 5,000 tenants in Tamworth alone greater security, rights, and protections with the same rights to over 11 million renters across the country. The new rules mean that renters no longer have to fear last-minute no-fault evictions.

Future rules brought forward by the act mean that rented homes will have to meet higher standards, especially when it comes to tackling damp and mould in rented properties. Renters have certainty that they can stay in their homes for longer in safe, good-quality homes, and they are no longer locked into contracts, unable to move for years. Now people with greater housing security can be further empowered to start building lives in the communities that they live in.

And with that comes the need for serious investment in their local areas. Now, this delegated legislative committee piece of legislation means that the interest already accruing on an estimated 5.5 billion pounds that's already in the tenancy deposit schemes will not go to the pockets just of those administering that scheme that's meant to be nonprofit, but instead, it could under this legislation be invested into local projects that align with what renters want to see in their area. And after all, that interest is generated from the tenants' own money, and it's only right that the renters and their communities could see the benefit.

We can estimate that the interest earned on a pot would be around 550 million pounds.

Now, that's a lot of money that could help restore libraries, reopen community centres, improve local facilities, and create places where people want to live, not have to live. Renters deserve more than just a secure roof over their heads, and they deserve thriving communities, decent local facilities and a stake in the place that they call home. We can already see the trajectory that the government is plotting with its renters' rights legislation, and we already see the difference it's making to communities like Glascote Heath and Stonydelph, one moment please, through its £20 million Pride in Place programme.

And this opportunity to boost funds that communities can spend is one I urge the minister to consider.

I will give way.

25:53 - 26:18

Andrew Snowden

Andy Snowden.

I thank the honourable member for giving away. The honourable member just highlighted a stat around 500 million potentially raised in interest. How much does she think would be appropriate of that interest to go into the investments that she's outlined, given that we don't have in front of us the kind of numbers of what we're supposed to be approving? As the shadow minister said, it is in fact a blank check.

26:18 - 26:19

Sarah Edwards.

26:19 - 27:23

Sarah Edwards

I thank the member for his comments. I think that the purpose of this is to actually outline that there's a possibility for its use, and it doesn't negate the fact that tenants can also still claim against the scheme if they need to. But what it does say is that there's money here that currently isn't doing anything for our communities. So I think that what we need to look at is what already needs to be used for administering the scheme, and then what else there needs to be to support, you know, the ebb and flow of currently what it does.

but the rest of it, I think and hopefully, and this is what I'm asking the Minister to do, is to define how it is that we can look more creatively with that money. Now, I would like the Minister to be creative with it, and I urge and encourage problem-solving by those who live in the communities and have bold ideas, because it's quite a lot of money, and whilst it may be undefined, it's been under-utilized to date,

and I think that it offers a lot for communities. And so, I support this legislation, and I hope that it will be reinvested into communities' big ideas, and boost hope, play, knowledge, safety and joy.

27:23 - 27:24

Gideon Amos.

27:24 - 28:44

Gideon Amos

Uh thank you, Sir Desmond. It's a pleasure to serve the committee with you in the chair and to continue the almost daily tradition of meeting with the Minister and the Shadow Minister in these rooms. The Liberal Democrats support this principle of directing interest payments towards tenants themselves, and the schemes that they need they want to see for their communities.

The 9,000 tenants, private tenants in Taunton and Wellington, would very much like to see the proceeds of these profits being directed in their direction. But we don't see anywhere in the regulations any guarantee that the funds will be ring-fenced for the use of private tenants. 5.6 in the explanatory notes says it's an expectation, and I quote, that the money would, that the Secretary of State would use funds received towards programs of activities that benefit tenants in the private sector. And 5.8 says, as an example, the Secretary of State could require funds to be used to fund a program supporting vulnerable tenants. We would like to see this, these funds ring-fenced so they are used for benefit of tenants and don't disappear into some Treasury coffer.

And at this stage, without that guarantee, we have difficulty supporting it, Sir Desmond. Thank you.

28:44 - 28:46

Speaker 10

Minister.

28:46 - 30:34

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Sir Desmond. Could I thank the shadow minister, the Liberal Democrat spokesman, and my honorable friend for those contributions? If I could clear up a few misconceptions on a couple of points, and then I'll respond to the other distinct points that have been put to me. Firstly, Sir Desmond, I think it is worth pointing out the government has already improved the value that tenancy deposit schemes deliver for tenants and landlords. The current administrators of custodial schemes are already expected to pay part of the interest accrued, in addition to the original value of the deposits, to tenants.

The allocation mechanism is different for each of the three current schemes, but requiring administrators to pay interest to tenants and landlords will continue to be an option for future arrangements.

Sir Desmond, as I tried to make clear in moving the regulations, the order is not intended to enable Government to profit from tenants' deposits. It enables future scheme arrangements to provide for part of the interest accrued on protected deposits to be paid to the Secretary of State. This additional flexibility, as I've said, would be particularly relevant where high interest rates mean that scheme returns on the deposits held considerably exceed administrators' costs of providing the scheme and wider ancillary services. Now, the Shadow Minister is perfectly at liberty to take issue with the principle of that, to take the view that administrators should benefit from the entirety of the interest accrued on the deposits. We take a different view.

We think we should have the flexibility to provide for other uses.

The Secretary of State's intention is that the funds received, and I hope I can provide the Liberal Democrat spokesperson with some assurances on this point, our intention is that the funds received would be used towards programs or activities that benefit tenants in the private rented sector. It wouldn't be, as he asserted, be siphoned off into some Treasury fund that doesn't deliver on that purpose.

30:34 - 30:35

I will give way.

30:34 - 30:34

Will the minister give way?

30:35 - 31:13

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Gideon Amos. I thank the minister, and I'm listening carefully to his response. If that is so, then why not simply put it into the SI? I share the suspicion, and the honourable gentleman and I seem to be agreeing a lot these days, and I'm sure that makes both of us feel uncomfortable. But this we the minister's used this phrase again, and the government expects, and we've heard this so many times over the years.

An expectation is not the same thing as something actually happening. For something to actually happen, you need to put it into the law. So, why don't you simply put it into the SI?

31:13 - 31:14

Minister.

31:14 - 31:46

Matthew Pennycook

Simply because, and I was going to come on to make this point, this order is enabling in nature. It doesn't require any payment to be made to the Secretary of State or prescribe how any payment amounts would be determined. Those matters will be determined through future scheme arrangements established via procurement and contractual processes and, I've said it before, I'll say it again for reassurance, the Department will publish any information about any amounts received, the programs funded and any metrics demonstrating the value delivered so there will be full transparency on the use of funds. I will give way.

31:46 - 32:03

Lewis Cocking

I thank the Minister for giving way, and he's always very generous with his time.

Could he just then provide us with some examples of what MHCLG could use this money for to support renters because he hasn't listed any yet, and obviously there's none stated in the SI, and I'm a bit concerned about where this money is going to be used?

32:03 - 32:37

Matthew Pennycook

Minister. Forgive me, I think I did give an example in my opening remarks, but I don't want to stand here and speculate on the precise programs that might be funded through those interest payments if we make a decision to take a portion of them in future. But being very clear about, they would be directed to support private rented sector tenants. They couldn't be, to the point, be siphoned off for other government activities. But again, any payments made to CLG would be subject to future agreement via contractual and procurement processes.

My honourable friend may want to intervene.

32:37 - 33:07

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you. I thank the minister for giving way and for his explanation.

I do wonder, though, whether he's able, at this stage, to give an indication of what sort of thresholds there might be within the department, at which point this manoeuvre, this mechanism would kick in, to allow them to make those directions. I think it's perfectly right and correct that if there is a windfall and interest that can be put to good public use, but I'm interested where the department currently considers the threshold for that windfall to start, so we know when these schemes might subsequently start making a contribution.

33:07 - 35:04

Matthew Pennycook

Minister. He helpfully brings me on to the two further points that I wanted to respond to. And I think the Shadow Minister probed at both of these rightfully so, essentially, how will the amounts due to the Secretary of State be determined, specifically, what do we intend to spend them on. I can't confirm to my honourable friend today what the amounts due to the Secretary of State will be.

As I said, the order allows for the distribution mechanism to vary, taking into account market conditions such as interest rates. Specific arrangements, as I've said, will depend on commercial negotiations with prospective scheme administrators. I can commit that first and foremost, the distribution mechanism will prioritise ensuring the deposit protection and dispute resolution services offered to tenants and landlords continue to be free and effective, and we'd all agree, I assume, that is particularly important. My department, again as I've said, will set key performance indicators and cost efficiency metrics to monitor the scheme administrators' delivery. If the interest accrued exceeds the minimum cost of meeting the key performance indicators, the additional amount of interest will be distributed between the administrator of the scheme, tenants and/or landlords, and the Secretary of State.

When setting the distribution mechanism, the Secretary of State intends to allow the scheme administrator to keep a reasonable amount of profit as reward for the service delivered.

It is not the Secretary of State's intention to exploit the tenancy deposit system and agree to arrangements that leave tenants and landlords worse off. Specifically in terms of how the, I'll just make this point, then I'll happily give way, in terms of what we intend to spend any money received on, again, the Government has demonstrated its commitment to improve condition for tenants in the private rented sector, while a specific program or programs can't be confirmed at this stage. It is our intention to use any receipts to fund Government programs to benefit tenants in the sector. It will take time, I think this is important to say, Sir Desmond, it will take time for interest to accumulate and be paid to the Secretary of State under future arrangements if we decide to make use of the power. But those arrangements, as I've said, will depend on market conditions and priorities for the private rented sector and will be subject to agreement from the Treasury.

I happily

35:04 - 35:32

Andrew Snowden

I thank the minister for giving way. In the department's calculations and crafting of this statutory instrument, would the minister give any indication of what level interest rates would be at to trigger this, going back to the threshold point?

If it's a windfall from high interest rates generating additional revenue, what general ballpark does the minister think interest rates would have to be at to trigger this?

35:32 - 35:33

Minister.

35:33 - 36:37

Matthew Pennycook

I commend him for the attempt, but I'm not going to stand here and give him a general ballpark estimate of what the interest rates might be. As I've said, any payments to MC MHCLG will be subject to a future agreement via contractual and procurement processes. I did just want to clear up one specific point that the shadow minister made in terms of insured schemes. No final decision has been made in that regard. The department is assessing the benefits and risks of both insured and custodial models.

Sir Desmond, to conclude, this government continues to deliver improvements for tenants in the private rented sector.

This order will provide additional flexibility in how interest accrued on deposits held under custodial tenancy deposit schemes may be distributed, to use excess returns that may be generated by the scheme effectively. And the order will enable my department to deliver an improved tenancy deposit scheme, which is fit for purpose and which will, as I've said, deliver better value for money for both tenants in the private rented sector and the general taxpayer. And notwithstanding the Shadow Minister's very clear intention to divide, I hope the rest of the Committee will welcome this amendment to the Housing Act 2004. And I beg to move.

36:37 - 36:46

Desmond Swayne

The question is that the Committee has considered the draft Housing Tenancy Deposit Schemes Order 2026. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye".

36:47 - 36:48

Of the contrary, "No".

36:49 - 36:52

Desmond Swayne

Division.

36:52 - 37:03

Speaker 13

Division is nine.

37:03 - 37:11

Speaker 28

Lock the doors.

37:11 - 37:12

Gideon Amos.

37:12 - 37:16

Speaker 23

Abstain.

37:16 - 37:17

Gareth Bacon.

37:18 - 37:19

Lee Barron.

37:19 - 37:21

Speaker 24

Aye.

37:21 - 37:23

Speaker 26

Lewis Cocking.

37:23 - 37:25

Lewis Cocking

No.

37:25 - 37:26

Sarah Edwards.

37:27 - 37:29

Speaker 18

Mary Kelly Foy.

37:30 - 37:32

Speaker 16

Douglas Lumsden.

37:33 - 37:34

Kerry McCarthy.

37:34 - 37:36

Speaker 20

Aye.

37:36 - 37:37

Andy MacNae.

37:37 - 37:39

Speaker 15

Aye.

37:39 - 37:40

Matthew Pennycook.

37:40 - 37:42

Speaker 27

Aye.

37:42 - 37:43

Mike Reader.

37:44 - 37:46

Speaker 17

Michelle Scrogham.

37:47 - 37:48

Gareth Snell.

37:48 - 37:50

Speaker 22

Aye.

37:50 - 37:52

Speaker 25

Mr Andrew Snowden.

37:52 - 37:54

Speaker 21

No.

Kenneth Stevenson.

37:54 - 37:56

Speaker 29

Aye.

37:56 - 37:57

Laurence Turner.

37:57 - 38:06

Speaker 30

Aye.

38:06 - 38:16

Desmond Swayne

The Ayes were 11 and the Noes were four, so the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Unlock. Order. Order.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.