Highways (Financing) Bill

3 November 2026

Highways (Financing) Bill House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:02 - 01:14
Speaker 1
Good morning everybody.  Would everyone make sure that all electronic devices are turned off or switched to silent mode?  Of course we now begin line-by-line consideration of the bill.  The selection for today's sitting is available in the room at the bottom there and on the parliamentary website.  This shows how the clauses, schedules and selected amendments have been grouped together for debate. 

A reminder for that the member who has put their name to the amendment in the group is called first.  Other members are then free to indicate they wish to speak in the current debate by bobbing.  Please bob on each occasion which you wish to speak during proceedings.  The end of the debate on a group of amendments and new clauses, I'll then call the member who moved the lead amendment or new clause again.  Before they sit down, they will need to indicate if they wish to withdraw the amendment or the new clause or to seek a decision. 

If any member wishes to press any other amendment and this includes grouped new clauses and schedules in a group to a vote, they need to let me know.  The order of decisions follows the order in which the amendments appear on the order paper.  Alison Griffiths. 
01:14 - 01:27
Speaker 2
Chair, I do apologise, I'm really struggling to hear you and I'm partially deaf, so I'm I just wanted to ask everyone speak as clearly as possible.  Thank you so much. 
01:27 - 01:45
Speaker 1
Thank you.  Noted.  Thank you.  We start with group one, which is on the amendment, which is amendment 46 to clause one.  I call Greg Smith to move amendment 46. 
01:45 - 02:14
Speaker 4
Thank you, Mr Dowd.  Pleasure to serve with you in the chair this morning on this important bill, on its first day in bill committee.  It seems that whenever I do a bill committee, I'm opposite the honorable gentleman.  We spent many happy weeks on the Employment Rights Bill together earlier in this Parliament and I look forward to the next few weeks.  But I rise to speak and to propose amendment 46. 
02:14 - 06:48
Speaker 3
There is a lot in this bill where I genuinely believe there actually is cross-party consensus, certainly between the government and His Majesty's Loyal Opposition.  However, as we explored in some of the evidence sessions the other day, as we explored in the second reading debate, there are some question marks over many aspects of this bill, no doubt that we will explore in future groupings during committee and later in the passage of this bill in our house and the other place.  However, it is my proposition through this particular amendment 46 that we should seize on that which there is agreement in order to get progress on a project that I think all sides of the house wish to see built, namely the Lower Thames Crossing, which is why amendment 46 seeks to restrict this bill to just the Lower Thames Crossing.  There are other parts where I think there is a genuine consensus, such as the provisions for barrier-free tolling on roads, such as the M6 and the Mersey Tunnel.  And I think that could be very easily brought forward in separate legislation. 

But the real purpose for Amendment 46 is so that the Government can get on with the Lower Thames Crossing, something that I know particularly Members in the direct locality of the crossing very much want to see happen from the Government party, as well as a number of conservative Members from Kent and Essex.  And if we can do that, then I think there can be a speed that we don't often see in infrastructure projects in the United Kingdom.  I think when we had that evidence last week around the differentials between ourselves in the United Kingdom and our nearest neighbors in France on the differential in the way that they get stuff built faster and cheaper.  And so, why don't we grasp the nettle for once in this Parliament, take that which we do agree on and move forward with it, and then have the debate on those other aspects further down the line?  And one of the arguments I really make about that is that something I have seen throughout my political career, both in this place, in local government, and just as an activist, is the importance to trialling new models to prove that it works. 

This is innovation around the Lower Thames Crossing, so let's test it, try it, work out the gremlins before the Government, whoever that might be at that point, comes forward with other projects that could be financed and secured through the RAB model and the innovations of this bill.  So, if I can ask the minister a few questions to that point.  Given so much of the media narrative and the debate narrative has been around the Lower Thames Crossing, what other projects do the Government think might come forward or could be financed through the model proposed in this bill, other than the Lower Thames Crossing?  Because if there is literally nothing on the table, why are we legislating?  Why are we legislating in this place for something that nobody has the first clue what it might be for? 

We can all gather around the point on the Lower Thames Crossing.  There may well be divergence on other projects, particularly if no one can name a single one of them.  The framework that this bill brings forward really is an open-ended one, and I think the public we serve in all of our respective constituencies would expect us to have far greater clarity in any law that we pass in this place around what precisely it is for.  I think my constituents and those in every other honourable and right honourable Member's constituency can understand and get behind the Lower Thames Crossing.  It is far more difficult to get behind an abstract, to get behind something that they cannot see, touch, breathe, smell, etc.