House of Commons

How to watch the Highways (Financing) Bill

Every sitting is free to watch on Polyfact, live and on replay, no account needed.

Latest updates

Latest update 4 days ago

What is said in the sittings, update by update, the latest first. Each update opens the video at the second it was said.

  1. GMT

    Committee closure and Bill reported to House

    Members exchange closing thanks to Chairs, staff and officials, note that no Opposition or third-party amendments have been accepted while reaffirming support for the Bill’s principle, and formally agree that the Bill, as amended, be reported to the House, thereby concluding the Committee’s proceedings.

    Watch the moment

  2. GMT

    Clauses 98–104: interpretation, extent and final amendments

    The Committee turns to the closing clauses on interpretation, regulation-making powers, Crown application, territorial extent, commencement and short title, handling a series of opposition amendments to clause 100 and clause 103, several of which are withdrawn while others are put to divisions and defeated, before agreeing that clauses 100–104 stand part of the Bill.

    In this chapter

    1. Clauses 98–104: interpretation, regulations and extentPeter Wishart
    2. Further clause 100 amendments and clause 102 agreed
    3. Final amendments to clause 103 and agreement of clauses 103–104

    Watch the moment

  3. GMT

    New clause 6: compensation for works disruption

    New clause 6 is introduced to earmark toll revenues for compensating SMEs and charities affected by prolonged licensed roadworks, with wider calls to cover additional categories such as public services and larger businesses; the Minister raises definitional, legal and practical objections and points to existing planning and commercial incentives before the proposer presses the clause to a vote, where it is defeated in division.

    In this chapter

    1. New clause 6: compensation for businesses and charities
    2. Greg Smith: broader compensation beyond SMEs and charitiesGreg Gregory Smith
    3. Minister Madders: objections to drafting of new clause 6Justin Piers Richard Madders
    4. New clause 6: proposer’s reply and divisionPeter Wishart

    Watch the moment

  4. GMT

    New clause 5: ORR roads and rail remit

    Members propose New clause 5 seeking a report on the Office of Rail and Road’s differing roles in road and rail, questioning regulatory consistency between private toll roads and the rail sector, while the Minister cites an existing independent review and argues that structural differences between road and rail justify distinct regimes, leading to withdrawal of the clause.

    In this chapter

    1. New clause 5: ORR roads vs rail powersGreg Gregory Smith
    2. Minister: ORR independent review and differing regimesJustin Piers Richard Madders
    3. New clause 5 on ORR withdrawnGreg Gregory Smith

    Watch the moment

  5. GMT

    Minister’s SAR clarifications; New clause 4 fuels

    The Minister corrects the record on clauses 72 and 85 regarding special administration and financial assistance, before the Committee moves to New clause 4 on construction fuel costs, examining whether licence holders may restrict diesel or require alternative fuels and debating impacts on contractors, toll levels and decarbonisation policy, concluding with a division that defeats the proposal.

    In this chapter

    1. Minister: clarifications on clauses 72 and 85Justin Piers Richard Madders
    2. New clause 4: Greg Smith: cost of construction fuelsGreg Gregory Smith
    3. New clause 4: scope extended to maintenance vehiclesGreg Gregory Smith

    Watch the moment

  6. GMT

    New clauses 1 and 3: additional penalty charges and airport access tolls; adjournment

    Members add new clause 1 on other penalty charges without division, then debate new clause 3 to restrict airport access road tolls being used as de facto drop‑off charges or behavioural tools, which the Minister argues is already controlled by existing safeguards before the Committee votes it down and agrees to adjourn further consideration of the Bill.

    In this chapter

    1. New clause 1 on other penalty charges addedPeter Dowd
    2. New clause 3: airport access roads and drop‑off tollsGreg Gregory Smith
    3. Minister’s response on New Clause 3: tolling vs road user chargingJustin Piers Richard Madders
    4. Division on New Clause 3 and adjournment of further consideration

    Watch the moment

  7. GMT

    Clauses 89–97: toll offences, enforcement technology and adjudication regime

    The Committee reviews offences and enforcement powers for toll evasion in clauses 89–94, including vehicle immobilisation and disposal and cost‑recovery from operators, then examines minimum equipment standards and the independent adjudication framework, with concerns over technology failures and a proposed amendment to require rather than permit Lord Chancellor regulations, which the Minister rejects before clauses 95–97 are agreed.

    In this chapter

    1. Minister: offences, enforcement powers and regulatory costs for toll evasionJustin Piers Richard Madders
    2. Opposition: technology failure risks in toll enforcementGreg Gregory Smith
    3. Technology failures in tolling: operator discretion and appealsJustin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

  8. GMT

    Part 7 introduction and clauses 87–88: free‑flow tolling and keeper liability

    The Minister introduces Part 7 on updating historic tolling legislation for free‑flow systems and explains clauses 87–88 and related government amendments, while opposition Members support modernisation but press amendment 83 to shift liability from registered keepers to hirers/lessees; the Minister defends long‑standing keeper‑liability and the Committee rejects the amendment before moving on.

    In this chapter

    1. Minister: Part 7 introduction and free-flow tolling powersJustin Piers Richard Madders
    2. Opposition: support for free-flow tolls and problem of keeper liabilityGreg Gregory Smith
    3. Opposition and backbencher: consistency with parking fines and leasing concernsShivani Raja

    Watch the moment

  9. GMT

    Clauses 85–86: financial assistance powers, ORR levy and funding model

    Debate on clauses 85 and 86 centres on the breadth of the Secretary of State’s power to provide financial support, the ORR levy, and amendment 73 demanding publication of the financial model and limits on taxpayer exposure, with Members warning about demand risk, cost overruns and moral hazard and the Minister framing clause 85 as an in‑extremis safeguard within a regulated asset base approach.

    In this chapter

    1. Clauses 85–86: government power to assist and ORR levyJustin Piers Richard Madders
    2. Amendment 73: demand for financial model and taxpayer exposure limitsGreg Gregory Smith
    3. Support for amendment 73: demand risk and construction overrunsShivani Raja

    Watch the moment

  10. GMT

    Clauses 83–84: ORR stakeholder group composition, powers and independence

    The Committee debates clauses 83 and 84 establishing an ORR stakeholder group, probing who must be represented, how influential its advice will be, safeguards for its independence, and remuneration arrangements, with a proposed amendment to secure statutory local authority representation before ministers defend leaving appointments to ORR discretion and the clauses are agreed.

    In this chapter

    1. Clauses 83–84: ORR stakeholder group for road usersPeter Dowd
    2. Clause 83: Scope and membership of stakeholder groupGreg Gregory Smith
    3. Q: Alison Griffiths: ORR only ‘considering’ viewsAlison Louise Griffiths

    Watch the moment

  11. GMT

    Clauses 81–82: trunk road status and CAT appeals

    Members consider clause 81 on allowing licensed highways to be designated as trunk roads and then clause 82, which establishes appeals to the Competition Appeal Tribunal for key regulatory decisions, with questions focused on potential delays and continuity of project delivery before both clauses are approved.

    In this chapter

    1. Clause 81: licensing regime and trunk road statusPeter Dowd
    2. Clause 82: appeals to the Competition Appeal Tribunal and concerns on delayPeter Dowd

    Watch the moment

  12. GMT

    Clauses 71–80: special administration and information powers

    The Committee opens this sitting and examines clauses 71–77 on safeguarding the special administration regime and constraining insolvency routes, followed by clause‑by‑clause scrutiny of information‑sharing and information‑gathering powers in clauses 78–80, including probing on proportionality and commercial confidentiality before the clauses are agreed.

    In this chapter

    1. Committee opening and move to clauses 71–77Peter Dowd
    2. Minister: special administration and insolvency safeguards (clauses 71–77)Justin Piers Richard Madders
    3. Q: Greg Smith: voluntary winding‑up; Minister’s reply (clause 72)Greg Gregory Smith
    4. Information sharing and powers (clauses 78–80) and probing amendments 75–77Justin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

  13. GMT

    Clauses 67–70 and schedules 2–3: Detailed SAR procedures, transfer schemes and closure of sitting

    The Committee finalises the highways special administration regime by defining the status and duties of the special administrator, importing and adapting Insolvency Act procedures, creating court‑approved transfer schemes for licences, assets and liabilities (with amendments to prevent transfer of criminal liability and refine who can enforce schemes), and empowering highways administration rules, while a Shadow Minister challenges the original criminal-liability drafting before all remaining provisions are agreed and the sitting is adjourned.

    In this chapter

    1. Minister: clause 67: status and duties of special administratorJustin Piers Richard Madders
    2. Minister: clause 68 and schedule 2: applying Insolvency Act proceduresJustin Piers Richard Madders
    3. Minister: clause 69: overview of highways administration transfer schemesJustin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

  14. GMT

    Clauses 60–66: ORR reporting and creation of highways special administration regime

    Following agreement on ORR reporting, information-sharing and interpretation provisions for Part 4, the Minister introduces Part 5’s highways special administration regime covering triggers for administration orders, the special administrator’s objectives and court tests, while Opposition and Liberal Democrats unsuccessfully seek to extend administration triggers to persistent service-standard failures, which the Minister argues should be handled under Part 4 enforcement powers.

    In this chapter

    1. Minister: ORR reporting, disclosure and definitions (clauses 60–62)Justin Piers Richard Madders
    2. Chair: clauses 60–62 agreed and introduction of special administration regimePeter Dowd
    3. Minister: clauses 63–65: highways SAR frameworkJustin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

  15. GMT

    Clauses 50–59: Financial penalties, appeals and use of fine revenues

    The Committee considers clauses 50–59 establishing ORR financial penalties for licence breaches and non-compliance with enforcement orders, detailed procedures and caps for calculating fixed and daily penalties, appeal rights to the Competition Appeal Tribunal, and publication of a penalties policy, alongside amendments on non‑company licensees and a contested proposal (Amendment 86) to ring‑fence penalty income for road maintenance which is rejected after division.

    In this chapter

    1. Clauses 50–52: Financial penalties for licence breachesJustin Piers Richard Madders
    2. Committee approval of clauses 50–52 and move to group 23Peter Dowd
    3. Clauses 53–55 and Govt amends 18–19: Penalty calculation and turnover capsJustin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

  16. GMT

    Clauses 37–49: ORR information powers and staged enforcement orders

    The Minister outlines new ORR monitoring and information-gathering powers, civil penalties and procedural safeguards for false or incomplete information, then explains a graduated enforcement-order regime (standard and urgent) for licence breaches with transparency, representation periods and limits on repeated action, while Opposition questions on the necessity of clause 42 are answered as clarifications of process rather than new powers before clauses 37–49 are approved and the Committee moves to penalties.

    In this chapter

    1. Clauses 37–39: ORR information powers and sanctionsJustin Piers Richard Madders
    2. Clauses 40–41: Procedure for ORR information penaltiesJustin Piers Richard Madders
    3. Committee approval of clauses 37–41 and move to group 21Peter Dowd

    Watch the moment

  17. GMT

    Clauses 31–36: ORR tolling oversight and mandatory appeals framework

    Debate moves to clauses 31–36 on delegation of tolling functions, expanded enforcement powers for the Office of Rail and Road, continuity of tolling where licences change, and the design of a statutory disputes and appeals system, with Opposition amendments seeking to make appeals regulations mandatory, court‑avoiding, and subject to the affirmative procedure before ultimately being withdrawn as the Minister relies on standard drafting and negative procedure precedents.

    In this chapter

    1. Clauses 31–34 and gov amendments 14–17: ORR enforcement and tolling continuityPeter Dowd
    2. Enforcement transition and penalty notices: Opposition query and procedural decisionsGreg Gregory Smith
    3. Group 19: Opposition demands mandatory appeals scheme for tollsGreg Gregory Smith

    Watch the moment

  18. GMT

    Clause 30: Private toll enforcement and outcome

    Committee examines Opposition and Liberal Democrat amendments on clause 30, focusing on whether vehicle immobilisation and destruction powers should rest with private toll operators or the police, the level of parliamentary scrutiny of related regulations, and safeguards such as prior notice to motorists, before all amendments are withdrawn and clause 30 is agreed without division.

    In this chapter

    1. Clause 30: Opposition amendments on vehicle immobilisationPeter Dowd
    2. Amendment 43: Lib Dem safeguards and Minister’s defence of delegated powersGuy Nicholas Oliver Glover
    3. Outcome on clause 30: Opposition withdraws amendmentsGreg Gregory Smith

    Watch the moment

  19. GMT

    Clause 29: private enforcement powers, safeguards and adjournment

    Debate turns to clause 29 on examination and search powers for toll enforcement, with opposition and third‑party amendments seeking to restrict powers to police or require warrants, the Minister defending the regulatory model and safeguards, and recorded divisions defeating key amendments before clause 29 is agreed and the committee adjourns further consideration of the Bill.

    In this chapter

    1. Opposition (Greg Smith): limit intrusive powers and require police or warrantPeter Wishart
    2. Third party (Olly Glover): case for amendment 88 and scrutiny balance
    3. Minister (Justin Madders): defence of clause 29 and regulatory safeguards

    Watch the moment

  20. GMT

    Clauses 27–28: penalty regime, caps and regulatory scrutiny

    The committee considers the enforcement framework for unpaid tolls under clauses 27 and 28 and new clause 1, including Minister‑led technical amendments, opposition proposals for a £100 penalty cap, affirmative procedures and commencement conditions, and detailed discussion of ANPR, postal delays and regulator oversight, before agreeing the government amendments and allowing clauses 27 and 28 to stand part.

    In this chapter

    1. Minister: Enforcement regime for unpaid tolls (clauses 27–28, new clause 1)Justin Piers Richard Madders
    2. Greg Smith MP: Practical concerns on physical notices and postal delaysGreg Gregory Smith
    3. Greg Smith MP: Opposition amendments on caps, scrutiny and commencementGreg Gregory Smith

    Watch the moment

  21. GMT

    Clause 26: ORR tolling code and commencement conditions

    Members scrutinise clause 26 establishing the ORR tolling code, debate amendment 69 to require publication of the code before commencement, and test the government on the planned content, consultation, and guiding principles of the code before agreeing that clause 26 stand part and moving on to the next group of amendments.

    In this chapter

    1. Minister: introduction to clause 26 and ORR tolling codeJustin Piers Richard Madders
    2. Conservative (Opposition): amendment 69 on publishing the ORR tolling codeGreg Gregory Smith
    3. Minister and backbencher: government rejection of amendment 69 and demand for principlesJustin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

  22. GMT

    Clause 25: toll discounts and adoption

    The committee examines clause 25 of the Highways (Financing) Bill, focusing on mandatory toll discounts for disabled users and local residents, hears stakeholder‑based arguments from opposition and third‑party members, receives ministerial assurances and reasons for rejecting the amendments, agrees Government amendment 5, and then votes on amendments 41 and 42 before adopting clause 25 as amended.

    In this chapter

    1. Chair: opening and agenda for clause 25Peter Wishart
    2. Liberal Democrat: amendment 41 on blue badge toll discounts
    3. Liberal Democrat: amendment 42 on local resident discounts

    Watch the moment

  23. GMT

    Operational responsibilities, asset transfers and toll payment regime (Clauses 22–24)

    Debate turns to litter and complaint responsibilities on licensed roads under Clause 22, followed by Clause 23 and Schedule 1 on statutory transfer schemes, compensation and tax flexibility for assets and liabilities, before Clause 24 is contested over toll payer liability, in‑vehicle equipment, consultation requirements and parliamentary approval for schemes, with government amendments and positions prevailing before adjournment.

    In this chapter

    1. Clause 22: litter responsibilities on licensed highwaysGreg Gregory Smith
    2. Clause 23 & Schedule 1: transfer schemes, compensation and tax flexibilityJustin Piers Richard Madders
    3. Clause 24: toll payment, in‑vehicle equipment, consultation and parliamentary approvalGreg Gregory Smith

    Watch the moment

  24. GMT

    Licence modification, revocation and allocation of highway powers (Clauses 11–21)

    The Minister explains post‑grant licence modification, revocation (including on national security grounds), and transfer mechanisms with National Highways as operator of last resort under Clauses 11–15, then details how Clauses 16–21 allocate highway and traffic authority powers, allow delegation and emergency intervention, and ensure responsibilities revert to National Highways when a licence ends.

    In this chapter

    1. Clauses 11–15: modifying, revoking and transferring licences; operator of last resortJustin Piers Richard Madders
    2. Clauses 16–21: allocation of highway powers, delegation and ‘emergency’ interventionJustin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

  25. GMT

    Toll impacts, local mitigation and standard licence conditions (Clauses 7–10)

    Members examine toll impacts on local roads and users through Amendments 39, 40 and 72, with the Minister defending ORR‑controlled toll‑setting and rejecting mandatory compensation and automatic toll refunds before Clause 7 is agreed, then move to Clauses 8–10 on detailed and standard licence conditions, consultation requirements and competitive safeguards prior to adoption.

    In this chapter

    1. Amendments 39 & 40: local road compensation and ‘delay repay’ for tollsGuy Nicholas Oliver Glover
    2. Minister on toll impacts, local roads and toll‑setting transparency (Clause 7, Amendment 72)Alison Louise Griffiths
    3. Clauses 8–10: licence conditions, standardisation and competitive safeguardsJustin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

  26. GMT

    Opening and core licensing framework (Clauses 4–6)

    The Committee resumes with a procedural vote on Clause 4, then the Minister outlines the new licensing regime under Clauses 5–6 and members debate Amendment 49 on introducing a mandatory five‑year ORR review cycle for licences, which the Minister rejects in favour of continuous oversight powers and related publication duties.

    In this chapter

    1. Procedural opening, vote on Amendment 87 and Clause 4Emma Lewell
    2. Minister: licensing regime: applications and duration (Clauses 5–6)Justin Piers Richard Madders
    3. Amendment 49: ORR five‑year licence reviewsGreg Gregory Smith
    4. Minister rejects fixed review cycle; relies on ongoing ORR oversightJustin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

  27. GMT

    Modal alternatives, local impacts, consultees and adjournment

    Amendments propose mandatory assessments of rail and other modal alternatives, publication of local road impact and mitigation reports, and explicit listing of mayoral and local highway authorities as statutory consultees, but the Minister argues these issues belong in scheme appraisal and existing DCO processes, defends a flexible consultee duty under Clause 4, and moves stand part before the committee adjourns until the afternoon.

    In this chapter

    1. Group 4: Amendments 45, 78, 87: modal shift and statutory consulteesGuy Nicholas Oliver Glover
    2. Minister: reject new assessments and fixed consultee list; adjournmentJustin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

  28. GMT

    Licence scope, tolling existing roads and Clause 3

    Backbench and opposition members seek to confine licences to wholly new roads, hard‑wire local and mayoral consultation, and tightly define capacity increases that could justify tolls, whereas the Minister maintains that licences must cover major capacity enhancements, operation and maintenance under Clause 3, rejects fears of generalised road pricing, and sees off Amendments 82, 44 and 81 before Clause 3 is agreed.

    In this chapter

    1. Group 3: Amendment 82: licences only for new roads; consultation dutyGreg Gregory Smith
    2. Minister: scope of licences, capacity improvements and Clause 3 frameworkJustin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

  29. GMT

    ORR duties, local-road impacts and sustainability obligations

    Opposition and backbench amendments attempt to extend ORR duties to local roads, strip out or condition sustainable development duties, and require pre‑commencement guidance, while the Minister defends the existing framework, climate alignment and ORR capacity before Amendment 37 is defeated and Clauses 1 and 2 are agreed.

    In this chapter

    1. Group 2: Amendment 37 and Opposition amendments on ORR dutiesGreg Gregory Smith
    2. Minister: local-road safeguards, sustainability duties and ORR capacityJustin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

  30. GMT

    Lower Thames Crossing: scope of bill and first division

    Members seek to confine the bill to the Lower Thames Crossing while the Minister insists on a general framework covering future schemes, debating integration with Dartford, hybrid bill risks, and concerns over a ‘blank cheque’ before the committee rejects Amendment 46 in the first division.

    In this chapter

    1. Group 1: Amendment 46: limit bill to Lower Thames CrossingGreg Gregory Smith
    2. Minister: oppose limitation to LTC and first divisionJustin Piers Richard Madders

    Watch the moment

Schedule

  1. Replay

    Part 1Part 2

  2. Replay

    Part 1Part 2

  3. Replay

    Part 1Part 2

  4. Replay

    Part 1Part 2

Where these transcripts come from

House of Commons broadcasts the sittings of the Highways (Financing) Bill. Polyfact shows each one live, keeps it as a replay with its transcript and links its key moments to the second they were said.

8 sittings on Polyfact since 29 October 2026

Polyfact records and transcribes the sittings and committee hearings of United Kingdom's parliaments. A speaker is named only once their identity is confirmed, by the official record or by a person; automatic guesses are left out.

Every committee

Questions

How can I watch the Highways (Financing) Bill live?

On Polyfact, free and without an account: a sitting on air is marked live in the schedule above, and each sitting stays available as a replay.

Is it free?

Yes. Watching the sittings on Polyfact is free and needs no account. A Polyfact subscription, which you can try for free, adds the full transcripts as soon as they are ready, search across every sitting and alerts on your topics.

Where is the transcript of the Highways (Financing) Bill?

On each sitting's page on Polyfact, speaker by speaker, with its key moments one click from the second they were said. The search on this page covers the sittings held more than two weeks ago.

Follow every committee without searching

With a Polyfact plan you read every sitting as soon as it is transcribed, ask questions to the video assistant and get an alert as soon as your topics come up.

14-day free trial. A card is required, nothing is charged for 14 days, and you can cancel anytime.

Updated