Highways (Financing) Bill
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Highways (Financing) Bill House of Commons
Follow its sittingsGreg Gregory Smith
So, I put it to the minister, let's let's let's let's accept this amendment. Let's get an act on the statute book that can move forward at pace, that favourite political phrase at the moment, with the Lower Thames Crossing, to get it built. It's what it's what we want.
Alison Louise Griffiths
Will my honourable friend give way on that point? He makes such an important point. And I know during the evidence sessions that the minister was categoric that his intention was not for any other road to be covered by this.
So, I join my honourable friend in asking the minister why he wouldn't agree to this amendment, since he's so adamant that there's no other need for this clause.
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to my honourable friend for reasserting the argument that I'm making. And I hope the minister can answer that question. There has been some speculation, Mr Dowd, that the government has wanted to avoid a hybrid bill around the Lower Thames Crossing. And, believe you me, I see the pitfalls, from my own constituency, of hybrid bills when it comes to 35 km of a certain railway being built through the middle of it. But I don't see a real argument why it would have to be a hybrid bill,
why we can't explicitly talk about the Lower Thames Crossing in this piece of legislation that we're considering in committee today before us. So, I gently ask the minister, who I know to be a reasonable man, for whom on this particular point of the Lower Thames Crossing we can share agreement and a determination to get on with it, why we can't have this piece of legislation around that, which all parties can get behind?
And then we can have the debate on the other matters that will take more time, get rightful parliamentary scrutiny, and we can move forwards.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Mr Dowd. It's a pleasure to see you in the chair this morning. And can I thank all members of the committee for attending? And I hope we will all learn a little as we go along. And can I start with recognising the shadow minister's desire to try and reach consensus wherever possible?
I'm sure as the committee goes on he will find that he's in agreement with me 90% of the time, and if not the committee will make sure that we are in agreement with the government's position. But he makes a he makes a lucid argument, Mr Dowd, which obviously I'm here to address. So, I think the amendment obviously is very clear in terms of its intention. It is to restrict this bill to the Lower Thames Crossing, and I understand that there is a desire from the shadow minister to seek some clarity about what other projects might be used for this legislation.
It is the case that this is very much made with a one, a single project in mind: the Lower Thames Crossing, but I think that naming it in the bill would actually undermine the attempt that we are trying to make here to actually set a framework for potential future use. So, it's clear that under the intended operating model, ownership and operations of the Dartford Crossing would transfer to the new regulated private sector entity, which would be responsible for operating and maintaining both the Dartford Crossing and the new Lower Thames Crossing, which would ensure a consistent and reliable service. And it's important to have both crossings covered, because that will ensure that the crossings are operating in an integrated way. And I think the amendment actually only spoke specifically about the Lower Thames Crossing,
so that would be something that would undermine the intention of the government. Restricting the bill so the legislation can only be used for the Lower Thames Crossing would undermine the purpose, which is to build a framework for major road infrastructure. We should not unnecessarily constrain future governments where this financing approach may be appropriate. I think the honourable member is tempting me to come up with a shopping list of potential projects, but the truth of the matter is that at the moment the Lower Thames Crossing is the project that is suitable.
It's probably worth flagging up that the Street Works Act of 1991, under his party's watch, created a power to create tolled roads.
I think there's only ever been one project built under that. That's not to say that's what will happen here, but I think the importance of getting the Lower Thames Crossing right will give us confidence moving forward if a suitable project does arise in the future, and we don't want to constrain future governments in terms of this. I think it's also worth bearing in mind what the shadow Minister said about the potential procedural consequences of this. You mentioned the potential risk of hybridisation and, of course, that's a matter for the House, but actually this amendment would actually risk hybridising the Bill. It would, of course, as the honourable member has referred to, bring additional parliamentary stages and, of course, considerable delay to the delivery of the Lower Thames Crossing.
Hybrid Bills are often actually used for projects which do not have planning consent and which need planning consent by Parliament, and that is not the case for the Lower Thames Crossing. It has, of course, as we know, finally got planning consent and, as we all know, the Lower Thames Crossing has had already a very long history, something that we discussed at second reading. We know that the original work to address the capacity issues around the Thames goes back as far as 2009, but risking hybridisation of this framework Bill will put the timetable for the legislation, therefore the financing and ultimately the delivery of the new crossing, at risk. The 2025 autumn budget confirmed the importance of harnessing private investment to build the Lower Thames Crossing, unlocking the next stage of delivery for one of the UK's most important infrastructure projects. This amendment would, I'm afraid, actually risk the opposite happening and, of course, the honourable member's party's reasoned amendment at second reading recognised the urgency of this particular project, and therefore, I would gently suggest that actually if we accepted this amendment, the progress that has been made will be put at risk of further delay, and I invite him to withdraw it.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Mr Dowd. I do hear and understand the points that the Minister has made, but the key word he used in his response to this amendment was risk. And whilst I accept that risk can exist, what I can't accept and don't accept is that risk cannot be mitigated away, that risk cannot be worked through. The most powerful question all of us have to ask, particularly when honourable and right honourable members find themselves in a ministerial position wanting to make progress on manifesto commitments, on other things that the country needs and that the Government perceives the country needs, isn't to ask the question around the procedure, but to ask the question how do we make this happen without a hybrid process, how do we make this happen in the fastest possible way. And from the research I have done, whilst that risk exists that some may be able to argue that a hybrid process would be the only way forward, I can see that there are pathways to ensure that it could be done as more straightforward legislation as with a usual second reading, Bill Committee, Report, third reading before we get to the other place.
Therefore, I we are going to push this one to a vote, because we do want to show our commitment to the Lower Thames Crossing being built, but not writing a blank cheque for other schemes that - Will the honourable member give way? No, in one second. I certainly will. I'm always very happy to give way and to have a discussion on these matters.
That's fundamentally what we are here to do in the line-by-line scrutiny of this bill. But to get us to a place where we can just move forward around one project and not a blank check. And on that, I will happily give way to the honorable gentleman.
Jim Dickson
Can I thank the honorable member for giving way? And it's a pleasure to serve under your chairship Mr. Dowd. The minister has made very clear that it is incredibly important that the mechanism we're setting up today not only works to get the Lower Thames Crossing constructed, but also integrates the work at the Dartford Crossing so that tolling is equalized, so that traffic is hopefully distributed properly across both crossings in order to do what the Lower Thames Crossing is there to do, which is to take the pressure off the Dartford Crossing, a single point of failure which not only costs the economy, but costs my residents in terms of delays, air quality and all sorts of adverse life consequences. Does he not understand that if we do limit the bill entirely to the Lower Thames Crossing, there is a possibility that we can't undertake that integration between the two entities, and therefore the point of what we're moving today and in this bill committee is lost?
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman. I do hear the point that he makes, and actually it's in exchanges like this that, in theory, we the we can, the four of us from His Majesty's loyal opposition and the crowds from the government side, as is our current parliament, can work to improve the bill if there is that willingness. I do understand the point he makes, and I would be very open to something that did connect that limited the scope to the Lower Thames Crossing and existing crossing points, the Dartford Crossing, that affects his constituents so considerably, we've heard from the honorable gentleman in other debates on that point. But the wider point still stands that what this bill is doing at the moment is writing an open-ended, unpredictable future under this model beyond those projects that I think all of us can get behind, can support, that our constituents will understand no matter where in the country, many of us that wish to get down to, particularly Kent, perhaps down to Dover to get on a ferry to go to France, will find themselves behind their wheel or worse still, the kids in the back screaming because of the delays getting to the Dartford crossing. And therefore everyone can get behind the need to get this particular project done, but let's restrict it to this project, albeit with, and I stay for the record very clearly, with that integration, with the in the existing infrastructure for the existing Dartford Crossing, because the very worst thing we could create with any new project, Lower Thames Crossing being a good example, is for there to be a an unintended consequence, an unintended impact on existing road networks, existing crossings, existing tunnels, etc.
That integration does have to be there and I fully accept the honorable gentleman's point on that. But on the core principle of this amendment, which will be no surprise, we fully expect to lose given the current parliamentary maths, we do want to put that marker down to show our support for the Lower Thames Crossing, but our skepticism on the way this model could be applied to other unnamed schemes in the future.
Peter Dowd
Thank you.
Amendment paper, the question is that the amendment be made. As many as of that opinion say aye.
Aye.
To the contrary, no.
Peter Dowd
I think the ayes have it. The, noes have it. The noes have, just keeping you on your toes. The noes have it. The noes have it.
Do you want a division?
Peter Dowd
You will go for a division? Okay, we will go for a division in that case. That's fine in that case. It's a division. Lock the doors, everybody's in.
Jacob Collier?
Jim Dickson?
Zoe Franklin?
Olly Glover?
Alison Griffiths?
Aye.
Sarah Hall?
Douglas Lumsden?
Aye.
Justin Madders?
Amanda Martin?
Tristan Osborne?
Dr. Peter Prinsley?
Richard Quigley?
Shivani Raja?
Aye.
Mike Reader?
Greg Smith?
Aye.
Michael Wheeler?
Peter Dowd
Thank you. The ayes were 4, the noes were 13. Excuse me, I'll get this right. So, the noes have it. The noes have it.
Thank you. Unlock. We now come to group 2, which is led by amendment 37 to clause 1, with which it will be convenient to debate amendment 47, clause 1 stand part, amendment 48, clause 2 stand part, and amendment 68. I call Olly Glover to move amendment 37.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Thank you, Mr Dowd. I'm going to defer to my honourable friend on this one.
Speaker 22
Thank you, Mr Dowd. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. Clause 1 currently obliges the Office of Rail and Road to regard only to avoiding adverse impacts on the strategic road network, creating severe, statuesque asymmetry that leaves potentially council-maintained local roads completely unprotected. And this amendment corrects that omission by elevating local road protection onto an equal statutory footing, regarding, requiring the regulator to actively evaluate and mitigate traffic displacement, road surface wear, and congestion on local surrounding roads which is caused by potential toll avoidance. Surrounding A and B roads managed by local highways authorities face accelerated asphalt degradation when heavy commuter and freight traffic diverts from tolled highways, creating potentially massive, uncompensated repair backlogs for local council taxpayers.
We all know the challenges our local roads face under our local highways authorities. As Steve Gooding, director of the RAC Foundation, cautioned the Public Bill Committee, drivers faced with a toll will naturally choose local free alternatives, creating negative traffic impacts across adjacent networks, and this must be taken into account. And as Ralph Smyth from the Transport Action Network highlighted in evidence, creating private toll infrastructure without a statutory duty to protect adjacent road networks breaks integrated transport planning and leaves local highways authorities without recourse. Why does clause 1(3)(b) explicitly protect National Highways strategic networks from adverse impacts while leaving out local council roads to absorb the traffic gridlock and financial fallout of toll evasion and avoidance? So, I ask, will the Minister accept amendment 37 to ensure the regulator has an explicit statutory duty to protect local communities and local highways authorities from toll diversion impacts?
Speaker 14
And I'd like to indicate, Mr Dowd, that we would wish to move this to a division on this amendment.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Mr. Dowd. Within this grouping, I particularly wish to speak to amendments 47, 48 and 68 tabled in mine and my honourable friend's name, but also speak to the Amendment 37 tabled in the name of the honourable gentleman the Liberal Democrat spokesman. So, if we cover that one first, the His Majesty's official opposition does have considerable sympathy with Amendment 37. The unintended consequences that we sometimes see from infrastructure projects must not be brushed to one side. They must be taken seriously.
Because I was in a small hamlet in my own constituency at the weekend where the unintended consequence of something as simple as a road diversion in, I have to say it, as the Liberal Democrat spokesman is an Oxfordshire MP, in Oxfordshire has forced a considerable volume of traffic through a very small hamlet, causing considerable distress, very narrow rural lanes. And the same could happen from any major infrastructure scheme. We've heard in the oral evidence sessions and we've heard in the second reading debate of the concerns immediately surrounding the Lower Thames Crossing, that traffic displacement can be a very serious problem for communities, for people trying to get their kids to school, trying to get to work, trying to just go about their daily lives. And it is those local roads that are the very veins that flow the traffic to these newer infrastructure projects as they are built. They are the roads off which people predominantly live.
Nobody lives on a motorway or on a bridge or in a tunnel. And therefore without the due regard for how you get vehicle movements through those roads, from people's houses, businesses, schools, hospitals, doctors' surgeries to those new major infrastructure projects, like the Lower Thames Crossing, nothing is going to work. It is almost the very definition of needing joined-up government, joined-up planning, joined-up approaches to anything at all that we build in this country, including those things, the Lower Thames Crossing and other potential future unnamed projects that this bill would allow for. So, the official opposition does have considerable sympathy with Amendment 37 and if the Liberal Democrats push this to a division, Conservatives will vote for that amendment. Moving to the other amendments in group 2, Mr. Dowd, 47 would remove the ORR's duty to have regard to contributing to sustainable development when carrying out its duties under this Act.
That is not an attack on the environment or anything like that, but it is about getting the balance right between getting infrastructure built and doing it at the lowest possible cost.
And we saw in the oral evidence sessions, I've certainly seen in my own research, that one of the things wrapped up in sustainability in this is the, through separate order, but, fundamentally coming back to the wording in this clause, the banning of the use of diesel plant in construction. Now, with white diesel running at between 20 and 25p a liter cheaper than HVO, hydrotreated vegetable oil, which is the primary, current alternative that can be used in diesel plants, although it has to be said it's not a drop-in fuel, it does require mechanical changes to fuel filters and other parts of the vehicle to be operational, that is just going to drive up the cost, which will ultimately born be born by payers of tolls. In 1 second, I'll finish my point. The honorable gentleman knows I will always give way where I can. That is going to be born by the ultimate toll payers of the Lower Thames Crossing and any other scheme that could be built under this.
And that is a position that I don't think any of us really want to see. We know from other debates that there seems to be either an unwillingness or an inability to name what the toll is going to cost on the Lower Thames Crossing, but what we can be sure of is that clauses around this sustainable development point that we find in clause 1 of this bill and the duty specifically that the opposition is seeking to remove for sustainable development can only possibly drive the cost up. I will give way to the honorable gentleman.
Jim Dickson
Well, I thank the honorable member very much for giving way. I hear what he's saying. It is in absolutely in the interest of my constituents to see tolls as low as possible and, therefore, costs controlled through the project. Is the honorable gentleman mindful of the evidence given by the executive director for the project from National Highways, Mr. Palmer, when we spoke to him on Thursday, that the cost of HVO and electric plant, when taken together, was pretty much comparable with continuing with diesel, and that, in any event, that element of cost to the project was extremely marginal to the overall cost of delivering the Lower Thames Crossing, and, therefore, to try to prevent these measures to make it a sustainable project and make it, quote, unquote, the greenest road ever built, and that's something my constituents care about, the attempt to do that is really pretty futile in terms of the overall size of the project?
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman, but he may not be surprised to hear that's not a point that we're going to find consensus on. I accept that Mr. Palmer did give us his view of the world, that it wasn't a differential in price, but any simple look at market prices of the differential between white diesel and HVO shows that differential very much is there. That differential exists. It's not even a point of debate. It is just the market price of these two different projects at the moment.
I will give way in one 1 second. And secondly, we equally heard evidence later on that the building of the road pales into slight insignificance compared to everything that will then use the road. And the number of vehicles that will still be operational, powered by either petroleum or diesel, will still be the vast majority of vehicles using the Lower Thames Crossing, which clearly hasn't been taken into account by that. Now I will give way to my honorable friend.
Alison Louise Griffiths
I thank my honorable friend for giving way, and I just wanted to refer back to the evidence session again where we heard that from Mr. Palmer himself that, actually, he hadn't taken different quotes from other organizations looking at the differential costs between HVO and white diesel. It, all of the quotations had been based upon HVO alone, and so his assertion that it was comparable in price was based on his view and his view alone.
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to my honorable friend for that. It did strike me, she is absolutely right, that the answer the witness gave in that particular instance wasn't necessarily to say that there is no differential in cost, but that he was under a duty to get to simply get a quote for HVO, therefore he wasn't going to take a quotes on any other fuel source, which, you know, goes contrary to certainly my view of the world and belief that we would all be better served as members of this place and politicians at large if we didn't just accept what we were told, but we properly challenged and looked at the consequences of absolutely, in one second, absolutely everything we look at. The failure to challenge there and say hang on, isn't white diesel 20, 25p a liter cheaper was actually something that I would certainly want, were I to be in the minister's place, to be pushing back on National Highways over and ensuring that value for ultimate, for toll payers of the future in this instance was indeed being met, and I will give way to the honorable gentleman.
Mike Reader.
Michael Reader
Thank you, Mr. Dowd. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I was asking the honorable member if he understands how construction procurement works. National Highways wouldn't have specified a specific fuel type, but would specify an outcome, and the contractors appointed would choose how they'd meet that outcome, the outcome set out in the DCO signed under his government. So, is he suggesting that the government should be interfering in the activities of those contractors working on Lower Thames? And given that fuel cost is less than 1% of the build cost, does he think actually this is an issue that really we should be focusing on?
Greg Gregory Smith
Well, I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman. I know he has a background in this field, and I respect his point of view on this. I accept that it is a small part of the build cost, but small parts, unchallenged and just allowed to persist and carry on unchallenged, eventually become very large costs to the ultimate toll payers. Now, to the point he makes about the DCO, and I put my hands up in the oral evidence sessions to it, there were things that the previous government got wrong. We paid a heavy price for that in July 2024, just as his party has paid price for getting things wrong in government in previous general elections.
Under our new leadership, we are putting our hands up to some of those mistakes and challenging some of those parts of the past that we think should be put right. And the DCO that he refers to, yes, was signed under the last Conservative government, but I would put it to any incoming government, the government that he serves as a backbencher on in particular, not just to accept that and say to the contractors, "Just follow everything that went before. Don't question it. Don't look at it again, but perhaps ask those questions and say, "Is this going to deliver ultimate value for the future toll payers on the Lower Thames Crossing?"
And that isn't interfi- in a second, and that isn't interfering, that isn't interfering with contractors, it's actually setting contractors free to be able to come to market without the restrictions that clause 1 of this bill places upon them in this instance, and the DCO in other instances, and be able to offer a better value to the future toll payers, and, in other schemes, the taxpayers of this country.
And if he wishes to come back again, I will happily give way.
Michael Reader
Mike Reader. Thank you, Mr Dowd. I'm trying to understand, is the hon. Member suggesting that we should go back and change the DCO to remove these climate targets? I decided, after the evidence session, to go and speak to some planning lawyers who told me that would add at least five years to the delivery of this program. So, is he advocating for stalling the Lower Thames for another five years?
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful, Mr Dowd. No, I don't think we should stall this project. I was very clear in my comments in group one that the Conservatives want to see the Lower Thames Crossing built. We want to see it as a major road-building priority for this country, and therefore, no, anything that adds delay is something that we do have to think very seriously about. However, I do not believe it is beyond the wit of any of us to find a way to lower costs within the scope of that without having to relitigate and to re-legislate on absolutely everything, but to apply a bit of common sense, which is precisely what amendments 47 and 48, by removing that duty from both National Highways and the Secretary of State sorry, the ORR and the Secretary of State would do in this instance.
And I very much hope the Committee will consider those in the spirit with which they are intended, of delivering value and speed on this project. Indeed, when it comes to that point I made about HVO, it is, whilst it is in fairly plentiful supply in this country, even with the global challenges we face at the moment, it is not in as plentiful supply as white diesel is. The other amendment in this grouping, Mr Dowd, is amendment 68, in my name and my hon. Friends'. And this amendment prevents the Act from coming into force until the Secretary of State has published the guidance to the ORR on how and that is the critical word in there, Mr Dowd, how it must undertake its regulatory functions under this Act. I remember, in future, in past bills that I've debated in Committee during this Parliament, there does seem to be a bit of a theme of kicking many features of intended legislation, the Employment Rights Bill as was, into the long grass for future publication.
And I don't think it's something, and Governments from time immemorial have done this, and so it's not particularly a point I make just to the current Government. It's one that I invite the Committee to reflect on more widely, where our constituents send us here to do things in the best interests of them, of our country. And yet, too often, including within this bill we debate this morning, we're in a place where we're straightforwardly saying we're going to pass a law, but too much of it has to come later; too much of the regulation that will actually shape the legislation will come far down the road, that we cannot be confident, as Members of this place, whether we sit on the Opposition Benches or the Government Benches, precisely what this is going to look like. So I ask the Minister to give examples of how duties will be applied and whether they could take they could actually form an override to the main task of delivering and regulating roads built under this scheme, including the Lower Thames Crossing.
So, Mr. Dowd, I confirm that we will be supporting amendments 37, as well as hoping the Committee can back 47, 48, and 68 as part of this briefing.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Well, thank you, Mr. Dowd. Can I first of all thank honorable members for their contributions and welcome the honorable member for Guildford to the Bill Committee and for putting forward her amendment. It's clear that the concerns that she's raised in the amendment are about the impact of licensed roads on the surrounding network and that they should be properly considered. But that does not mean we need to actually extend the Office of Rail and Roads general duties in Clause 1, nor does it mean that the license holder will be free to simply disregard the impact of its activities on surrounding local roads. And the reason for that is that Clause 1 reflects the scope of the licensing regime, which concerns trunk roads.
The bill deals with the impact on local roads in other more appropriate ways elsewhere in the bill. For example, under Clause 4, before a license can be granted, the licensing authority must consult appropriate persons exercising functions in relation to highways. That enables local highway authorities to feed in their views where roads may be affected. And it's true to say, Mr. Dowd, that the relationship does not end once the license is granted. Clause 8 also allows the ORR to require the license holder to cooperate with other highways authorities as part of the license.
So, the framework under this bill provides a route for local road impacts to be addressed without extending the ORR's overarching duties beyond the roads that it is actually regulating. So, it is the case that local roads are considered as part of the bill. The bill provides appropriate ways for their interests to be considered without extending the ORR's overarching statutory duties beyond the scope of the licensing regime. The existing provision provides the appropriate balance between ensuring the wider impacts are considered and giving the ORR clear and workable statutory duty. And I think just in terms of the specifics of the Lower Thames Crossing, it's difficult to see what this other local road crossing the Thames would actually be that would be affected, which of course one of the reasons why the honorable member for Dartford has explained so clearly this project is crucial.
So, I would ask that the honorable member withdraw her amendments. I then turn to the amendment 47 from the Shadow Minister. It's in effect, removing the ORR's duty to have regard to contribute to sustainable development when carrying out its duties under the Act. We have deliberately designed these duties as a balanced package. The ORR's principal focus remains the interests of road users alongside the efficient and economic delivery of highways and the ability of license holders to finance their activities.
And sustainable development is one of the wider considerations that the ORR must have regard to when carrying out these functions. It does not override those principal considerations. I think it's also important to say that this is not, in fact, a novel duty. It is an approach consistent with established economic regulatory regimes in the energy and water sectors, where sustainable development forms part of the wider statutory framework within which independent regulators operate. Projects brought forward under this legislation will involve significant infrastructure works, including the construction and improvement of roads.
This can have significant environmental and wider impacts, and therefore it is right that sustainable development, including consideration of environmental impacts, is expressed in the duties on the face of this bill.
I will give way.
Speaker 28
Douglas Lumsden. Thank you, Mr Dowd, it's a pleasure to serve under your stewardship. Can the minister give us any idea of how much these sustainable measures are actually costing onto the project?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
I'm not I've not got any specific details and I will write to him, but I think it's probably worth saying that the requirements on sustainable development are actually originating from the Environment Act 2021, which of course I know he wasn't here at this at that time, but that was a piece of legislation brought in under the opposition. And under Section 19 of that Act, ministers are already required to have due regard to the government's Environmental Principles Policy Statement when making policy. These principles ensure environmental considerations are built into policymaking from the outset as we are doing here. So, we're not actually breaking any ground or doing anything different to what has come before in respect of sustainable development. They are real considerations in delivering major infrastructure.
I believe it is right that we consider those as part of the Bill. I'm sure my honorable friend, who whose constituents are affected by this Bill, would want the local environment to be considered. Turning to Amendment 48 now, Mr Dowd, again, I think the general thrust of the arguments will be the same, because it is the case that this is a consistent approach with established economic regulatory precedents as seen in the energy and water sectors. The Secretary of State's primary focus remains the interest of users of trunk roads in England, particularly regard to the efficient and economic delivery of highways and the ability of the license holder to finance its activities. And as I've already stated, sustainable development does not override those considerations.
Decisions under this framework should take into account the wider public interest factors set out in the clause and not focus on any single consideration in isolation. In terms of the honorable member's questions about these, well as we've heard, the evidence is good that this is at best a marginal issue in terms of costs. It is something, I think, the honorable member for Northampton South suggested if we were to reopen, that would possibly lead to significant delay on the project, and of course the DCO has been settled for a considerable period of time. It has actually bought significant benefits already, particularly in terms of large landscape-scale environmental hands- enhancements of semi-natural habitats, woodlands, species-rich grasslands, open mosaic habitats and wetlands. This will support a greater and more diverse range of wildlife than areas such as agricultural land or amenity grasslands.
And by making it LTC a tunnel and extending, the project actually avoids protected wetlands on the banks of the River Thames, helping to reduce impacts on environmentally sensitive habitats such as the marshes special protection area and Ramsar site. So it is, I think, something that we would say is of benefit to the wider community. And I would consider that the suggestion that we withdraw that element of the Bill to be something that would be regrettable. In terms of amendment 68, this was in the groupings, Mr Dowd, but I don't think the shadow minister spoke to it, so I'll just seek your advice as to whether we are dealing with that now. Did you?
Okay.
I must have missed that. Well, this This would in effect force the Secretary of State to publish guidance for the ORR under clause 1.5 before the Act came into force, and would simultaneously also remove the government's ability to make regulations ahead of particular clauses coming into force. The amendment would mean that the vast majority of the Act can't come into force until the guidance under section 1.5 is published, but there would be nothing meaningful to issue guidance about until the Act is in force because the bidding will not have happened for the opportunity, and we do not know who the investor might be, and therefore we do not know what the ORR would have to provide guidance on. So, the Secretary of State in those circumstances could not meaningfully provide guidance.
And Mr Dowd, I want to move on to clause 1 stand part now as well. Do it with those, yes, okay. So, I will turn to clause 1 stand part now. I think this is, something we have probably covered in some detail already. This is in relation to the overall duty that will guide the Office of Rail and Road, which I will, for ease of reference, now refer to as the ORR in future when carrying, this will relate to their duties when carrying out their functions under the Bill.
ORR must act in a way it considers best supports the interests of users who use highways covered or potentially covered by the licensing regime. This also includes future users. This is important because the ORR may make decisions about a road before construction or improvement works has been completed. When carrying out this duty, the ORR must consider the efficient and economical construction, improvement, operation and maintenance of those highways. ORR must also consider the need for licence holders to be able to finance their activities required under the licence.
Of course these are not the only considerations, the ORR must also have regard to safety, as I've said, sustainable development, competition, and the effects of its decisions on the wider strategic road network. This clause also reflects the principles of good regulation. ORR's regulatory activities should be transparent, accountable, proportionate and consistent, and should be targeted only when action is needed. ORR must also have regard to guidance issued by the Secretary of State. Clause 1, therefore, places road users at the heart of the ORR's role while ensuring it takes account of safety, efficient delivery, financial viability and wider public interest.
I believe that is an important framework to set forward, and I commend that clause to the committee. I'll turn now Mr Dowd
Would my honourable friend give way?
Oh, okay.
Jim Dickson
Can I thank my honourable friend for giving way? Just briefly, it's clearly incredibly important to all users of this future infrastructure and the present Dartford Crossing that the ORR is as capable and fully equipped as it can be to carry out these duties. Up to now, the ORR is more equipped on the rail side than the road side, albeit obviously has considerable responsibilities for roads at the moment. A recent report by BEIS indicated that it needed to increase its skills and capacity level in order to be able to do this work. Can the Minister reassure my constituents and all other future users of the infrastructure that the ORR will be fully equipped, have full capability and be able to discharge its duties under the Bill?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
I thank my honourable friend for his intervention. I can give him that assurance. It is vitally important that those duties set out in clause 1 are capable of being delivered to the best of the ORR's ability. That is the whole purpose of the RAB model, that we do have a functioning and effective regulator, so resourcing it is vitally important.
On that point?
Yeah.
Greg Smith.
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to the minister for that point. And the point he's making is actually an eminently sensible one around the ORR's ability. But can I ask him, given the government, the Department for Transport indeed, within the Railways Bill is playing down the ability and role of the ORR, give can he give the Committee an assurance that the framework being set out here is deliverable by the ORR, and that they are a capable organisation to take on this important work in the way that the other arm of the DFT is suggesting they're not for the railways?
Hear.
Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
I'm grateful to the shadow minister for his question. Of course, the purpose of the bill is to give the OR the powers and ultimately the responsibility to regulate this model. It will be able to levy the licence holder to finance that particular work. There is already a great deal of preparatory work going on to make sure that the OR is capable of delivering the important functions set out under the bill.
Will the minister give way?
Yes, yeah.
Gill Edwards.
Alison Louise Griffiths
I thank the minister for giving way. He made the point in his own sentence just now that the OR is not yet capable of delivering this. So, what is the plan from the Secretary of State and the minister to actually deliver an OR ORR which has the capability to do this? And we also heard in evidence last week that they don't believe that they're ready for it either.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Well, I'm grateful for the honourable lady's question. There is a plan in place. And of course, it would be a little bit ridiculous for us to have everyone ready now when the legislation has not been passed. But I can assure her that already a number of considerations are taking place about having the right skills. I think the evidence we heard last week was that there is confidence that the right skill sets and the right people will be in place to provide the important functions that the ORR will have to deliver under this legislation.
I'll turn now to clause two stand part, if I may, Mr Dowd. This sets out the overarching duty that will guide the Secretary of State when exercising functions under the bill. It mirrors the duty placed on the OR in clause one and ensures that both key decision-makers operate within a consistent statutory framework. As the bill gives important functions to both the Secretary of State and the OR, it is therefore important that decisions made by each are guided by the same overarching objectives and principles. The clause further requires the Secretary of State, like the OR, to act in a way that furthers the interests of road users.
In doing so, the Secretary of State must balance a range of important considerations, including efficiency, safety, sustainability, and the impact of decisions on the wide wider strategic road network. Those duties are underpinned by established principles of good regulation, helping to ensure that these decisions are transparent, accountable, proportionate, and targeted only when action is needed. Therefore, I commend the clause to the Committee.
Speaker 38
Thank you, Mr Dowd. And I thank the minister for his comments. However, I remain unconvinced in relation to the core bodies not having that special duty, and we, therefore, wish to press the vote.
Peter Dowd
Thank you. In that case, amendment 37 proposed to clause one, as on the amendment paper, the question is that the amendment be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Of the contrary, no.
Aye.
Are we okay to push on?
Jacob Collier.
Zoe Franklin.
Aye.
Olly Glover.
Aye.
Alison Griffiths.
Sarah Hall.
Douglas Lumsden.
Aye.
Justin Madders.
Amanda Martin.
Tristan Osborne.
Dr Peter Prinsley.
Richard Quigley.
Shivani Raja.
Aye.
Mike Reader.
Greg Smith.
Aye.
Michael Wheeler.
Thank you.
Peter Dowd
The Ayes were 6, the Noes were 11, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock. Amendment 47 to clause 1 was debated in group two with amendment 37 to clause 1. Does the wishes to indicate?
Peter Dowd
Okay. Is that agreed, that it's withdrawn? Agreed, thank you. We now come to clause 1 stand part. The question is that clause 1 stand part of the bill.
As many of that opinion say aye.
Contrary no? I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to amendment 48 to clause 2, which was debated in group two with amendment 37 to clause 1. Do you wish to
Aye.
Peter Dowd
Thank you. Is it agreed with the committee that be withdrawn? Thank you, withdrawn. Clause 2 stand part, which was debated with amendment 37 in group two, the question is that clause 2 stand part of the bill. As many of that opinion say aye.
Aye.
Peter Dowd
Contrary no? I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Excuse me. We now come to group three, which is led by amendment 82 to clause 3, with which it will be convenient to debate amendment 44, amendment 81, and clause 3 stand part. I call Greg Smith to move amendment 82.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Mr Dowd. I wish to propose amendment 82, an amendment that would ensure that licences could only, and the key word in that is only, be granted for the construction of new roads. I would be grateful if the minister, when he responds to this amendment, could explain in detail why the government thinks a licence should extend beyond simply the construction of a new road and how the bill prevents modest works being used to justify a toll-backed licence. I think this really does go to the crux of what we are debating today, what we are being asked to consent to on behalf of all of our constituents who are motorists and who use the strategic road network, and who will, I am sure, enjoy the new Lower Thames Crossing once it is constructed, but that are concerned that some of the drafting of this bill does open a back door, does open a pathway to enable things that most people, via any lens of common sense, would consider to be minor, to enable increases in tolls in the future or indeed new tolls in the future. I don't think anyone that backs the Lower Thames Crossing would necessarily be willing to back something that isn't supporting something as significant as a major new piece of road infrastructure, be that the Lower Thames Crossing or anywhere else in the country.
And that is a point that we explored a lot in the oral evidence sessions last week and in the second reading debate. Now, the Minister has been very clear, and I commend him for the clarity that he has given at the dispatch box in second reading and in his own evidence that he gave in the Boothroyd Room last Thursday, that the Government has, that favoured political phrase, no intention of delivering new tolls for other projects, for things perhaps as simple as new cameras or perhaps some line painting that makes the road a bit clearer, or smart motorway provisions- not that I believe there's anything smart about smart motorways, but- using any of those mechanisms to introduce new tolls. But the question that we, therefore, have to ask ourselves, and which is why the opposition have tabled amendment 82, is what if that is a clear signal, if there genuinely is absolutely no intention, and for the record, I believe the Minister, then let's put it on the face of the bill. Let's say clearly and unequivocally this is only, repeat only, about the construction of new roads in the United Kingdom.
Scotland, I'm sorry to say to my honorable friend, not included in the scope of this bill, always. Therefore, can the Minister rise to the challenge? Can he put the legislative commitment where his words have been at the dispatch box and in the evidence sessions of this Bill Committee, and accept amendment 82? Because I fear, Mr. Dowd, that if the Government is reluctant, or straightforwardly doesn't want to accept amendment 82, those questions are forever going to persist in the minds of British motorists, in the minds of all road users, be they driving the car themselves or reliant on the passenger seat of a car to be taken to wherever it is they want to go. I think that is an important point of principle on which the Minister surely must accept the view out there in the country, accept the view of His Majesty's loyal opposition, and put this on the face of the bill.
Speaker 47
I thank my honorable friend for taking an intervention. What I'm struggling to understand from this bill is that let's say there's a road. Let's say it's 100 miles long. Now, if there is an improvement made on just a small section of that road, is it clear whether then there could be tools introduced for the whole road or whether it would just be for the section that was improved?
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to my honorable friend for that question. It's really a question for the Minister, but he highlights one of those key points that the public out there, all of our constituents, will be asking about what this really means, and the scope within the way the bill is currently drafted at best allows for a bit of a lawyer's paradise to argue over it for many years and decades to come, and at worst, straightforwardly allows precisely the fear that my honorable friend has outlined to the committee this morning.
So, let's just have clarity on this, Mr Dowd. It's a simple amendment. We're not asking for the world in this. We are saying we're broadly with the Government on introducing this model for the Lower Thames Crossing, but it has to have that legislative certainty to it that does not allow for mission creep from where the current Minister sees the world under this legislation compared to where any future Government might wish to try and take it. The Opposition does not believe that toll should apply beyond the construction of wholly new roads.
There should not be the mission creep that is currently allowed, which is why Amendment 82 has been tabled in my name and that of my honourable friend. Also within this grouping is Opposition Amendment 81, and that is an amendment that would require consultation with relevant local and mayoral authorities before granting a licence for a road that is to become a trunk road. I think there is considerable concern in the country, particularly with councils, particularly with a number of mayors. Certainly, arguably, the best mayor in the country at the moment, the mayor for Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, a very old and dear friend of mine, if I need to declare an interest on that. Currently, whenever I phone him up, frustrated as I try and do the journey from Buckinghamshire the journey from Buckinghamshire to Suffolk where my in-laws are, and the minute you hit Cambridgeshire everything stops and everything seems completely dug up.
And so, I immediately phoned him to have a go, and he will continually push back and say that the Government hasn't given him any highways powers or authorities, whereas we know other mayoralties in the country do. So, I think it is very important for this amendment to be looked through that lens of the importance of ensuring that when new projects are to be stood up, starting with the Lower Thames Crossing, but any other projects that may occur anywhere else in the country in England under the terms of this bill, that local authorities and those areas that have mayors are properly consulted on them, because local authorities and mayors are engaged in their own infrastructure projects. They are engaged in those things where they are trying to do their best of whatever political persuasion to improve the lot of the residents of their areas. And to fail to adequately, and I use the word consult relatively lightly, to fail to adequately engage and discuss and be joined up with those local authorities and mayoral areas that are affected, I think is a pathway to failure, a pathway to end up making mistakes, a pathway to expensive retrofitting of projects, where if only that engagement had taken place at the very beginning may well have been avoided. So, on those two amendments, Mr Dowd, I look forward to the Minister's response.
They are not made with any intention of trying to undermine the bill, but to concretely improve the bill, to ensure that voices are heard that can make sure it works as it is intended to work, as opposed to so many of those instances in infrastructure projects in the past of going off course.
We also have in this grouping, Mr Dowd, the amendment 44 in the name of the honourable gentleman, the Liberal Democrat spokesman around, and I won't steal his thunder, but setting that strict physical threshold for what legally constitutes increasing capacity. Again, the official opposition does have sympathy with this amendment. We are we always come from the standpoint that clarity is better than leaving something completely vague. And anything that seeks to pin down precisely what the government means by that actually does work pretty well hand-in-hand with amendment 82 in my own name to be really clear about what it is that we are trying to do. And if the Liberal Democrats do wish to push their amendment to the vote on that, His Majesty's loyal opposition will give their support to it.
So, when the minister responds, can he please be as clear as he possibly can be about the full intent of this bill, and whether he will, particularly around amendment 82, put the legislative commitment where words have currently been?
Peter Dowd
Thank you. Amendment 82 to clause 3 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. Olly Glover.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Thank you, Mr Dowd. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairship, and I hope you're not too distraught by not having been in the chair for some of the other very exciting Transport Bill Committees we've had this year. In terms of this Bill Committee, I just want to start by addressing amendment 82 tabled by the shadow minister. We understand where he's coming from this, because we did hear evidence from Steve Gooding of the RAC Foundation in the Public Bill Committee about the dangers that clause 3 could be used as a Trojan horse for widespread road pricing, something that the minister has given his assurances that it won't be done. We perhaps Our amendment 44 is a different approach to the problem from excluding non-new roads altogether from this.
And as I said at second reading, we feel that the idea of tolls and fees is a reasonable one in principle and is used quite widely in Europe, but of course safeguards for that must be very clear. And that's why our amendment 44 would require a fresh a strict threshold for applying role tolls to existing roads, which would which we are defining as a continuous extra lane to show that is genuinely an improvement in capacity for the road and to justify any introduction. In terms of clause 3, I think I mean, I'd agree with the shadow minister insofar as he was saying that so much of this bill relies on us to take on trust that the government will do the right thing with the very extensive powers that it brings. I mean, The Economist wrote a good article a few years ago about the problem with the good chaps theory of government that has been a historic feature of the British so-called constitution. But I think the problem with that is it is difficult to just take things on trust and to rely on the current generation to do the right thing and interpret a bill as it's intended.
Because, of course, a bill can't force the hand of a future government, but those future governments do need to work to the legislation that has been passed. So, we have some concerns about that, and it'd be interesting to hear the minister's comments. On clause 81, it tabled by the shadow minister, we support this amendment. We think it is sensible to require consultation with the relevant local and mayoral authorities because it's so important that they're involved in major changes to their area, and major changes that would potentially increase local traffic flow and the burden on the local community. So, we would support that if we're to move to a division.
But subject to what the minister says, at this point, we would be keen, with your permission, Mr Dowd, to move amendment 44 to a division.
Sorry, Greg Smith.
Alison Louise Griffiths
Thank you, Mr Dowd, and I'd like to speak to amendment 82 in the shadow minister's name and in my own name. And it's on the face of it obviously looks quite straightforward that this licence would be granted for works involving, not delivering, notice, just involving the construction of a highway specified in the licence, but the consequences of this particular clause, the granting of this licence for the lines that are involved in our amendment 82 mean that the ORR is responsible for determining what is fair and transparent in terms of a toll which could be charged in the future for these works. And again, sorry, for these lines. And again, just being very clear, it's not talking about delivery, it's just talking about involvement, total lack of clarity there. And the ORR is going to rely on a code which has not yet been written, will not come before this House and for which we will have no say in what it looks like.
As far as I am aware, there will be no constraints on cost-effectiveness for the licensee, so the toll could be considerable, and the toll doesn't need to end at the point where the costs have been recovered. So, these lines in clause b and c of the granting of the licence create the prospects of a never-ending toll upon our constituents for of pretty unspecific piece of work. And so, I just go back to the points already made by the shadow minister that this granting of a licence should only be for the construction of new roads, and if we want to look at future roads, then it the code should be subject to a parliamentary vote at a later stage. And if we refer to the discussion we've already had this morning, we should be looking at, obviously we've voted against this now, but we would prefer that we were looking at the very specific two roads: the Lower Thames Crossing and potentially the associated Dartford and other Thames crossings, but without those constraints, this is a very problematic piece of legislation and I support this amendment.
Speaker 47
Thank you, Mr Chairman. We heard last week that this bill was potentially a Trojan horse, and we could have narrowed it down earlier by amendment 46. We could have said it was just for the Lower Thames Crossing, but that was ruled out. But we also have issues around what constitutes actually an improvement that would increase the capacity. You know, we've heard it's not necessarily a new road, it might not even be a new lane built along the whole length of the highway.
It could just be a smart gantries, it could be other little improvements that increase the capacity slightly. Now, we've had some assurance from the minister that this won't be a Trojan horse bill, that it would only be used for the Lower Thames Crossing. But as we know, ministers change, government changes and we're just meant to put this all down to trust.
So, I think what we have in Amendment 82 really makes it quite clear that it has to be a new road and it would only be able to be used on that new road, because the way it stands just now, I think we're leaving too much down to interpretation, leaving too much faith in governments that may come, may go. And I think it's I think this is probably the most important amendment that we're going to be looking at today. So, I think it's vital that this is included within the bill to make it as really as clear as possible that it is just for new roads, and it even should be just for the Lower Thames Crossing. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Oh, thank you, Mr. Dowd. So, I'd like to thank honourable members for their contributions in this particular group. And there's no doubt this is a this is an important subject about the scope of the licensing regime, including which road schemes can be brought in, and, of course, as the other amendment referred to, how local authorities should be consulted. So, turning to Amendment 82, I thank the shadow minister for raising the issue of the circumstances in which a licence can be granted for improvements in existing highways. This he asked why the licence would extend beyond the construction period.
The simple answer to that is that it's a model deliberately designed around the whole life cycle of a major infrastructure, not simply at the point at which it is built. That is why the bill provides not only for construction, but for qualifying capacity-enhancing improvements and the subsequent operation and maintenance of the infrastructure within the regime, because, of course, particularly with things such as the Lower Thames Crossing, a very expensive project, that will need consistent and persistent maintenance and repair. This matters because one of the benefits we are seeking from this model is strong long-term management of the assets. The regulatory framework provides ongoing oversight with incentives to manage operating costs and maintenance investment efficiently over the life of the infrastructure. Removing capacity-enhancing improvements would unnecessarily restrict the framework.
It would mean it could not be used for major upgrades to existing road infrastructure simply because the project involves improving an existing road rather than constructing an entirely new one. For example, a significant reconstruction of an existing bridge to add capacity, or a new tunnel that increases the capacity of an existing highway, could be excluded from the regime.
Will the minister take an intervention?
I will.
Speaker 47
I thank the minister for giving way. I had asked that question of my colleague, and I'll ask the minister the same question. If there was an improvement made on one small section of a road, could a with this coming into play, could a toll be introduced for the whole length of that highway, or would it only be able to be introduced for the small section where the improvements were made?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Well, it would actually be where clauses 1 and 2 come in, which I think would should give the honourable member sufficient reassurance. I think it's important to say, and I'll use the Scouse terminology if you don't mind, Mr. Dowd, that I think the arguments coming forward are a bit jarg. I don't know if that's a phrase you're familiar with, Mr. Dowd, but it is a bit of a scaring the horses moment. It is a bit of a ride on the ghost train. It is, unfortunately, what we've come to expect from the opposition.
They are trying to create a scare story where none exists. I'm going to be clear, I've been clear at second reading, I've been clear at the evidence sessions, and I'll be clear again now. Improving an existing Well, can I just finish this? Improving an existing road does not mean that the road will automatically be brought into the regime or be subject to tolls. Establishing and structuring a RAB arrangement comes with significant costs, so for small-scale improvements, such as the setting up of a speed camera, it's just not going to be financially viable for anyone to consider that.
It just simply would not be justified or work in any way.
In practice, and I think we're clear from the evidence we've heard last week actually, the model will only make sense for projects of sufficient scale, where the benefits of bringing in long-term private investment justify these costs. And I think members should be clear that I know that what I say on the record here is actually relevant to the intention of the bill, and that will be something that any future court will take into account. I'll give way to the honourable lady now.
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to the minister for giving way. I understand the arguments he's putting forward, and I reiterate that I believe his intent, but we're not being asked to put his intent on the statute book, we're being asked to put the words that are printed
as part of this bill onto the statute book. Therefore, to my honourable friend's question, is it conceivable
that a road licensed, new road licensed under this bill, that would carry a toll, that at some point down the path, into the future,
then has another enhancement built into it under a new license, such as a bridge, a crossing, whatever it might be, as part of that road, is it possible, as this bill is currently written,
for that new bridge, that new crossing, whatever it might be, to carry a new and separate toll, just for that small section, compared to the entire length of the original road?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
I'm grateful to the honourable member for his questions. I think we're very clear that this is about the specified highways, about the trunk road, it is about the protections in clauses 1 and 2, and I'd just I'd just simply push back that if there was some secret plan to expand road tolls, there's already legislation in place that would allows to do it. It was the New Roads and Street Works Act of 1991, which, of course, was passed by his government, and that created the powers to introduce road tolling.
So, if there was a secret plan to do this, we wouldn't need to bring forward legislation. This is about setting up a new regulatory model to bring in investment for particular projects. So, I don't know if the honourable lady wants to intervene?
Alison Louise Griffiths
I'm grateful to the minister for giving way, and I wanted to just refer back actually to the intervention I was going to make earlier, which was about clarity, and the minister said several times that he was being very clear, but I would
gently suggest that the legislation is not very clear, and that is the point that several of us are making, that we are in danger of passing legislation which may not deliver what is perhaps intended by the minister at this stage and at a point where a future government,
perhaps not as benign as others, may may abuse the wording of this legislation.
So, we are really just looking to ask the minister to be clear in the bill, not just in his words.
Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
I'm grateful for the honourable lady's question, and the description of benign, which I will frame and put on my wall at home. I think, you know, I think the bill is clear. There are reasons why you have to look at the existing network, particularly when you look at consider what's happened with the Lower Thames Crossing, but the
simple economics of this are not going to be attractive to investors if we were going to broadly open up road charging across the country. As I say, there is already legislation that would enable us to do that. Now this is about setting up a specific financial model which will have strong regulation, which will enable capacity-enhancing improvements to be made to the road network. And as I say, I think it's very clear that there are sufficient protections already within the legislation to avoid the situation that opposition members are concerned about. I'll now turn to amendment 44, Mr. Dowd, and thank the honorable member for Didcot and Wantage for raising this question of capacity-enhancing improvements.
We'd be clear this framework is not intended for this framework is intended for major road infrastructure, not minor changes to the road network. There are practical constraints on the use of this model, as again as I've referred to. Clauses 1 and 2 require the ORR to act in the interests of users of the highways specified in licenses or proposed to be specified, and clause 2 requires the Secretary of State to act in the interest of users of trunk roads in England. Both have regard to the principles that regulatory action should be proportionate and targeted only where it is needed.
Also, I'm not entirely sure that the amendment would deliver the changes that he proposes. I'm concerned that whilst he's talking about an extra lane, he's not actually put any de minimis length on that. And I think that actually might give a future non-benign government encouragement to take that further than certainly is our intention. We've got to be clear, Mr. Dowd, that establishing and structuring a RAB arrangement carries substantial costs. And it is something that has got to be sufficiently large and economically viable for this financing approach to make sense.
We heard evidence last week that actually our geography in this country is such that simply adding lanes on here and there is not really a viable option. And I'd therefore suggest that the honorable member withdraw his amendment. I'll now turn to amendment 81, which the Shadow Minister has raised. I hope I never have a call from him when he's feeling frustrated. I'm not sure how that would go for either of us.
But he's made an important point about ensuring local and mayoral authorities are notified where there may be a proposed scheme. But of course, it's the case that the bill already ensures that relevant authorities are consulted. As set out in clause 4, before any license can be granted, the licensing authority must publish the proposal and share it with the relevant bodies expressly including the strategic highways company and any other appropriate bodies exercising highways functions. At least 28 days must be allowed for representations from these bodies. Different projects will affect different places and of course, there will be different authorities.
Therefore, the right consultees will depend on the project. And we should remember that of course, as we've seen in recent times, the structure of local government can change. So, it would not make sense at this stage to hardwire into legislation that particular types of authority should be consulted, because that, of course, could become out of date dated. So, the bill, therefore, takes the correct approach by All right. Greg Smith.
Greg Gregory Smith
Is the minister seriously suggesting that we might move on from a model that is either local authority or mayor, because those seem to be the two that we've got at the moment? No one is suggesting anything else, and it's hard to see how it could possibly be the case that we'll be moving on from an environment that we're trying to lock into the bill with this amendment of local authorities and/or mayors. Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Well of course the answer to that, Mr. Dowd, is that we can't predict the future. Certainly in 2010, the idea of a mayoral combined authority was you know, nothing more than a glint in George Osborne's eye. But this is something that is about future-proofing the legislation.
It doesn't make sense for us to come back at a later stage to add in extra consultees because actually the Bill already has the correct powers in it to ensure that the licensing authority has to consult appropriate bodies. This makes the framework flexible enough to respond both to the circumstances of individual projects, but also to recognize that there may be changes to local government structures over the lifetime of the legislation, which of course, as we know, will be significant because of the LTC project. I'll turn briefly now to clause 3 stand part, as obviously that has gone to the heart of a lot of the debate today. This does establish what a license is, what it can authorise and the circumstances in which one can be granted. The purpose of the licensing regime is to provide the framework through which private investment can support the delivery of strategic road infrastructure.
In simple terms, clause 3 allows the licensing authority to grant a person a license giving them the right to charge tolls on a highway specified in the license, but that right is not free-standing, it is granted in return for the licence holder securing specified works to the highway. The work falls into three main categories: a license may support the construction of a highway, it may support the improvement of an existing highway where the purpose is to increase its capacity and where a highway has already been constructed or improved under this licensing regime it may provide for its maintenance, operation or further improvement. Even if a highway is specified in the license, the licence may also authorise the licence holder to charge tolls in respect of this highway. This is an important point about the structure of the regime. Clause 3 is not simply a general power to allow private companies to charge motorists; the authority to charge tolls is tied directly to the license holder securing the highways work specified in the license, nor does clause allow the model to be applied indiscriminately across the road network.
Obviously, we have heard the concern about this being a change to existing roads. A small improvement to an existing road, such as smart motorway camera, does not automatically mean a road will be brought into the regime or become subject to tolls. A highway can be included in the licence only if, or it is to be, a trunk road in England or part of one. The licensing regime created by this part is therefore deliberately confined to that network. Clause 3 also sets out who may grant the licenses.
When the regime first begins, both the Secretary of State and the ORR will be licensing authorities. This is known as the initial period, put simply it is the period for dealing with the first license under this Bill. Once that first license has been issued, the initial period will end and the ORR will become the licensing authority. The end of the initial period will be specified by the Secretary of State in regulations. There is also, I think it's important to say, an additional safeguard during that initial period: the ORR cannot itself grant a license without the Secretary of State's consent.
Where the Secretary of State gives that consent, the decision must be published in a way that the Secretary of State considers appropriate to bring it to the attention of people likely to be affected. Where the Secretary of State grants the license directly, a copy must be provided to the ORR as soon as is reasonably practicable. Clause 3 should also be read alongside the safeguards in the rest of the licensing framework. In particular, clause 4 requires consultation before a licence can be granted. The proposals must identify both the works to be secured and the highway on which tolls would be authorised, and there must be at least 28 days for representations.
A license cannot be granted unless that consultation requirement has been met. This is an important safeguard because it is bringing a road into this regime, of course, as we know, is a significant decision, so before a licence is granted, those likely to be affected must have an opportunity to understand what is proposed and make representations. The licensing authority must go through that process before deciding whether that license should be granted. It is also important to be clear that whether we are talking about a new road or capacity-enhancing improvement, the regime is confined to the trunk road network. A highway can only be included in a licence if it is or is to become a trunk road in England.
We will come later to clause 8, you will be pleased to hear, which makes the necessary changes to the existing trunking provisions in section 10 of the Highways Act 1980 so that a new highway built under this licensing regime can become a trunk road.
It does not create a blanket power to designate any road as a trunk road, rather, enables the existing process to work for the new type of highway, and I'll give way.
Speaker 53
I thank the minister for giving way. This will be the easiest intervention. I only wish to ask him to speak more slowly so that I can understand what he is saying. Grateful to him. Thank you.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
With apologies to the honourable member. Taken together, these provisions mean the bill can support both new strategic roads and significant and capacity-enhancing improvements, while remaining firmly focused on the trunk road network. The licensing authorities will also exercise their functions within the overarching statutory duties we have just debated. Those duties put the interests of road users at the centre of decision making, while requiring consideration of matters including efficiency and economy, safety, the wider strategic road network, sustainable development and competition. Therefore, I commend this clause to the Committee.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Mr. Dowd. I'm grateful to the minister's response, particularly to amendment 82, but I feel, as the debate has moved on, we're actually no further forward in the clarity that we are seeking as the official opposition to this bill. And whilst the minister likes to paint a picture of some sort of looking for a scare story or something that will be more befitting of trick-or-treating last Saturday night, that is not, that is not what the opposition are seeking to do. We are seeking clarity. We are seeking, through the usual procedures of this House, to check that the bill in front of us does what it says it's going to do, without having an unintended negative consequence.
And I fear that, in the answers the minister has given to this point about whether we should or should not restrict this to the construction of a new road in its entirety, we still don't know, we still don't know the actual answer as to whether it is feasible, to the point my honourable friend for Aberdeen South made, on whether a licence could be granted for a subsection of a road that already has a master licence for the entirety of its run. The minister made reference in his response to the installation of smart motorway cameras. Well, I accept the point on simply a deck of cameras, if we could have a deck of cameras, a set of cameras. But what is still unclear in that is whether a motorway, part of the strategic road network, that is not currently designated as a smart motorway, the M40, for example, that runs in part through my own constituency, if that were to be permanently changed to an all-lane running motorway, bringing what we currently know as the hard shoulder into a permanent running lane, whether that could suddenly find itself with a licence and therefore a toll. I don't want that scenario.
I categorically do not want that scenario. But as this bill is currently drafted, it is unclear at best as to whether that would, in fact, be permitted.
Therefore, I come back, without repeating them, to that core argument that to make this bill work as I think the minister intends it to work, it should, as amendment 82 makes clear, restrict operation of a new license to the construction of new, repeat, new roads.
Peter Dowd
Thank you. Right. Amendment 82 proposes clause 3, as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many as of that opinion say aye.
The contrary, no.
Division.
Lorraine Beavers.
Jacob Collier.
Jim Dickson.
Olly Glover.
Alison Griffiths.
Sarah Hall.
Douglas Lumsden.
Justin Madders.
Amanda Martin.
Tristan Osborne.
Dr Peter Prinsley.
Richard Quigley.
Shivani Raja.
Mike Reader.
Greg Smith.
Michael Wheeler.
Peter Dowd
Thank you. The ayes were 4, the noes were 12, so the noes have it. The noes have it. Unlock. Amendment 44 to clause 3 was debated in group 3 with amendment 82 to clause 3.
Do you wish to press the amendment?
Peter Dowd
Okay. Excuse me. Amendment 44 proposed to clause 3, as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many of that opinion say aye.
The contrary, no.
Peter Dowd
If you could indicate if you wanted a division, that's the right approach should be keep it simple if you if in that regard. So, amendment 81 to clause 3 was debated in group 3 with amendment 82 to clause 3. Amendment 81 proposed clause 3, as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made, as many of that opinion- Happy to withdraw.
Peter Dowd
Is it agreed by the committee that the amendment be withdrawn? Agreed, withdrawn. We now come to clause 3 stand part. We now come to question that clause 3 stand part, which was debated with amendment 82 in group 3. The question is that clause 3 stand part of the bill.
As many as of that opinion say aye.
Peter Dowd
On the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. We now come to group 4, which is led by amendment 45 to clause 4 with which it would be convenient to debate amendment 78, amendment 87, and clause 4 stand part. I call Olly Glover to move amendment 45.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Thank you, Mr Chairman. Just to indicate very clearly at the beginning, on amendment 87 we will be keen to move this to a division. Turning to amendment 45 first of all, this amendment mandates an independent modal shift and alternative transport assessment before any new highway tolling licence can be granted. It would prevent multibillion-pound road schemes from proceeding in isolation without evaluating whether rail passenger, rail freight, or bus upgrades could deliver better value and lower carbon emissions.
There is a clear need to reduce pressure on the Dartford Crossing and improve connectivity in the South East of England via the Lower Thames Crossing, but so far the Labour Government appears to only be looking at road-based means to do so. Now, I grew up in Staines, which is near very close to junction 13 of the M25, of which road lovers will know is the busiest set- segment of motorway in Europe. When I was growing up and the M4 M25 was new, it had three lanes. It then got increased to four lanes, and then, eventually, five lanes. It was sort of the an accompaniment to my youth and adolescence seeing the M25 permanently under upgrade.
And guess what? Do people who use the M25 now find it a and that section of the M25 find it a joyous driving experience, one entirely bereft of stress and complaint? Or do they still consider what Chris Rea once called a road to hell? They still consider it a road to hell because whilst, of course, the M25 is a useful asset, one of the challenges of increased road investment is that, very often, that capacity gets absorbed and doesn't address some of the wider transport challenges. Now, there is a clear need to improve rail con- connectivity in the region alongside the Lower Thames Crossing project.
There is currently no Kent-to-Essex rail connection, and very limited provision for channel port freight to move by rail, only road. There are developed proposals on the table to upgrade the Kent rail network and the Barking freight terminal via High Speed 1 as part of a plan to significantly increase rail freight through the Channel Tunnel. Now, as Ralph Smyth from the Transport Action Network argued in front of this Public Bill Committee last week, granting certainty to a major private road scheme can make it significantly harder for regional mayors or local authorities to promote sustainable alternatives like rail, tram, or bus upgrades. Ben Garrett of Logistics UK noted that whilst road capacity is needed at Dartford, rail freight connectivity to ports plays a vital role in national supply chain resilience, and must be integrated into transport planning. So, we ask, why should ministers grant a potentially centrally century-long highway licence without first publishing an independent eval- independent evaluation of whether rail or public transport investment could solve the bottleneck?
If we are to move toward achieving our environmental goals, and, indeed, providing good transport for those who either cannot, will not, or can't afford to drive, serious investment in other infrastructure, public transport, is needed alongside improving the road network. Now turning to our amendment 87, this would make it mandatory to publish a local road impact and mitigation report. Toll-avoiding traffic that diverts into surrounding residential streets and local A-roads could cause severe congestion, noise, air pollution, and safety hazards for nearby communities. So, this amendment would force the licensing authority to assess the exact financial cost of extraordinary road wear imposed on adjacent local highway authorities, such as Kent, Essex, or Surrey, or whatever they're called now as part of local government reorganisation. As Declan Pang, who's the director of policy at the Road Haulage Association, warned us last week, traffic displacement and unmitigated local congestion can drive significant indirect costs across local economies and businesses.
Now, turning brief- saying something briefly about the opposition amendment 87, we support this amendment, which would require licensing authorities to send a copy of the notice to mayoral combined authorities, combined county authorities, or local highway authorities. And this would go some way to address some of the deficiencies of clause 4, which basically leave it quite open as to what are the organisations that need to be consulted. Primary text of clause 4 does not explicitly list local highway authorities, local planning authorities, or emergency services as mandatory statutory consultee- consultees, amongst others.
So, one thing I hope the minister will address in his comments is why is clause 4 so open and why are local highway authorities and emergency services not explicitly named as mandatory statutory consultees on the face of clause 4?
Peter Dowd
Amendment 45, to clause 4 is on the amendment paper, the question is that the amendment be made, Greg Smith.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Mr. Dowd. If I can start with amendment 78 in this grouping in my name and that of my honourable friend. The Liberal Democrat spokesman has hit the nail on the head in his remarks around why we have tabled this amendment. We've come back to what I fear will be a familiar theme as we go through the various clauses of this bill in committee: the openness, at times fuzziness, of the drafting that leaves too much open to the imagination, ill-defined legislation that then gets caught up in the courts forever, with lawyers arguing over what was really meant forever, does none of us, certainly none of our constituents, or indeed our local authorities, or those areas of the country, I do not, that have mayors the clarity that they need and want from this bill. So, amendment 78 really is a very clear, straightforward amendment that is not made with any intent to undermine the bill, or derail the bill, or try and push it off course, but to give an opportunity to the government to lock in something that gives clarity to those important institutions that are out there, that we all as individuals, and all of our constituents, rely on to deliver local services.
Those local authorities, councils, in my case Buckinghamshire Council, which is also the highways authority covering my constituency, and in other parts of the country, where we are right now, with the Mayor of London, or indeed going back to my earlier reference, Cambridgeshire and Peterborough, wherever they have mayors, to be absolutely locked in to the process. I cannot see a single argument why the government wouldn't want that clarity on the face of the bill. And if they do have an in-principle opposition to that, I think there needs to be a very clear and compelling reason why not to simply include the status quo of local authorities, mayors, mayoral combined authorities, the emergency services, as the honourable gentleman said, into the bill. And if any future government, and I can't see us moving away from a local authority and mayoral model, but if any future government, that we cannot predict, changes that, I'm sure it will not be difficult to update the legislation to bring those authorities, those institutions into effect. I'll happily give way to my honourable friend.
Speaker 68
I thank my honourable friend for giving way. And does he agree with me that if a proposed highway scheme touches an area or impacts local traffic nearby, the local authorities covering that ground need to be kept in the loop and this amendment simply ensures that local highway authorities, combined authorities, mayoral authorities get a copy of the notice right at the start? It ensures the local councils responsible for the surrounding roads aren't left out of the loop so that they can plan for traffic and protect local roads for the local people.
Greg Gregory Smith
Absolutely. I am very grateful to my honourable friend for that intervention. It goes to the heart of what we're talking about here that projects, not on the strategic road network, but that are important to local people, roads, or indeed other forms of transport, as the Liberal Democrat spokesman has spoken of, will be integral to getting traffic flows and to getting people onto the new schemes that this bill would enable.
by shutting out, by turning backs on those other authorities that are part of the all-important jigsaw puzzle of our road network in its entirety that feeds into and feeds off of the Lower Thames Crossing, or other schemes that this bill would enable, surely has to be all-important.
Would my honourable friend give way?
Give way to my friend.
Alison Louise Griffiths
I thank my honourable friend for giving way. And I was reflecting on listening to the Secretary of State for MHCLG in the chamber yesterday when she was espousing the future of her devolution programme, which of course encompasses many strategic authorities and regional mayors, and is absolutely at the heart of the programme of this government. And so it seems inconceivable that this bill excludes them specifically from this. And I would just simply urge the minister to come together in a spirit of cohesion and future clarity.
And let's show our constituents what we can do when we work together. We can improve legislation. And the minister would be working absolutely hand in glove with the Secretary of State in order to deliver that. So I encourage him to support us.
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to my honourable friend. She adds to the argument behind amendment 78. I just for the sake of the record, say that those local authorities, mayoral combined authorities aren't excluded, they are just not implicitly included and named within the bill as important stakeholders within the road system that we've got, that are so important to ensuring that any new scheme functions properly, functions well, doesn't lead to those unintended consequences I've spoken of earlier. And I look forward to the minister's reply. Turning briefly, Mr Dowd, to the two amendments the Liberal Democrats have tabled, 45 and 87.
I understand the point the Lib Dem spokesman makes about modal shift, looking at bus networks, rail networks, particularly the point he makes about the integration between the strategic road network and rail freight, because, of course, there is a reality that rail freight can only get so far. And there is always going to have to be at one end or the other, a road solution, save that in very few cases, a road solution to get that freight off rail and to its ultimate, final destination. Therefore, that integration is important. But the official opposition does take issue with trying to prioritize modal shift over improving, in this instance, the Lower Thames Crossing, solving the problems we've heard argued very eloquently by the honourable gentleman for Dartford about the challenges experienced with the current arrangements, because there is a reality. And maybe some members don't like this, but there is a reality that the vast majority of people in this country choose the private motor vehicle as their primary way of getting around.
And I don't think it should be for any of us in this House to tell people how they should or should not get about, but to ensure that the In one second. To ensure that the road network is sufficient, where it clearly isn't right now, when it comes to the existing arrangements at the Dartford Crossing, that it is there for road users, private cars, haulage sector alike, to be able to get about freely. And I will give way.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
I thank the shadow minister to give way. I was not seeking to say that we shouldn't have more cars or we shouldn't support private road users, merely that the reason why a lot of people choose to drive is because that has been the relentless direction of policy going back decades. The rail network has significantly contracted and a lot of investment has gone into motorways. Would he accept that the statistics very clear: younger, far fewer young people are learning to drive at a young age than they were, and they also do need alternatives, and we can't just rely on continuing to promote the private motor car over everything else?
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm not sure the private motor car has been promoted over everything else, but I accept the challenge he lays down about issues young people have learning to, or so not necessarily learning to drive, but securing a driving test in a timely manner. But the statistics out there absolutely show that the majority of miles traveled, be it commuting to work, or traveling for leisure or holiday, or getting to school, or whatever it might be, across the totality of the country are by private car. And that's why bills like this that seek to ensure that, on the face of it, the Lower Thames Crossing is built, potentially future capacity increases elsewhere, are there for the vast majority of our constituents, certainly outside of the major cities of the country like London that have tube networks and much more frequent bus services, are able to use their cars. So we do take issue with amendment 45, and I will reflect over our lunch break whether to report to my honourable friend for Spelthorne that the Liberal Democrats have defined the junction to Staines on the M25 as the road to hell. Now, amendment 87 I think has more to be said for it around that comprehensive assessment of the impact on local roads.
I won't repeat the arguments I made earlier about the importance of the local road network supporting any new infrastructure. There is some there is some merit in the honourable gentleman's amendment 87. I think that is something that we should all reflect on and not try and look at the road network as if it can be compartmentalized into strategic road network and local roads, but see the two as absolutely part of one ecosystem that cannot be separated.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Mr Dowd. I'll turn first to amendment 45. I thank the honourable member for Didcot and Wantage for raising the issue of whether alternative transport investments should be considered before a license is granted. I'd say I've not ever been entirely clear if the Liberal Democrats support the Lower Thames Crossing. I think his comments were pushing more into the no territory on that, but we'll no doubt see as the bill progresses whether they do indeed think Lower Thames Crossing is something that they can support.
Will the minister give way?
Olly Glover.
Yeah.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Well, thank you. I thank the minister for giving way, given he was putting words in my mouth, let me clarify: we do support the need for a Lower Thames Crossing because the Dartford Crossing is very much under pressure and there is no resilience when it closes, but that doesn't mean that we only support the Lower Thames Crossing, and that is the problem with policy for successive decades, I would disagree with the shadow minister on this, it's been roads, motorways, and we need not either/or, but both.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Mr Dowd, I appreciate the honorable member's clarity, and actually, I understand the argument he's making. But I think he's probably sort of a bit too late to deal with this now, because actually the assessment on alternative transport options belongs in the scheme appraisal and business case process, not under this bill, which is about whether to grant a license in the first place. As the Association for Consultancy and Engineering was clear in its written evidence, schemes need to be sufficiently development developed before we take them to procurement and financing decisions. And for the Lower Thames Crossing, as the honorable member will know, the development consent order has already been issued, where all the relevant issues that he has talked about were considered. It's approved, and construction is underway.
The bill does not decide it's not about which road should be built; it is about creating an additional financing and regulatory framework that can be used where there is a need for a road scheme. It's not about putting roads ahead of rail, bus, or transport. This will already be considered through the earlier business case process. Requiring that to be assessed again when a license is already granted would duplicate the work; it would also, of course, add delay. And as we've heard from honorable members, there is an urgent need for this scheme to proceed.
So I would ask him to withdraw the amendment. I'll turn to the opposition amendment 78. We have, of course, already debated a very similar point in relation to amendment 81, which I know the shadow minister didn't push to a vote, but I think with the gusto he advanced his argument today, he may put this forward. But I'm not going to repeat the points that they made. But it is very clear, if one reads the bill itself under clause 4(1)(4), that there is a requirement on consultation to such other persons, including persons exercising functions in relation to highways, as the licensing authority considers appropriate.
So it's there in black and white, Mr Dowd, as to the assurances I think that the opposition members are seeking. And it's right to say that, of course, if we are too prescriptive, we may not cover every type of authority, because I know that we are in a period where we know exactly what the local authority structures are, but as we've seen in recent years, that can change. So it would not be prudent to hardwire that into primary legislation. So the bill rightfully allows the licensing authority to identify and consult the appropriate bodies exercising functions for the particular scheme. This makes the framework flexible enough to respond to circumstances of individual projects and changes to local government structures over the lifetime of the legislation.
I turn briefly to amendment 87. I understand the Liberal Democrat spokesperson's concerns. We absolutely recognize that major road schemes can have impacts on surrounding local roads, and those impacts need to be properly considered, and indeed, of course, the reason why the Lower Thames Crossing is proceeding is because we want to improve the conditions on the local roads. But I don't believe this amendment actually puts the consideration in the right place. As I said previously, the license granted under this bill, it's about bringing a qualifying trunk road project within the new within the new financing and regulatory framework.
It is not the process through which underlying impacts of a road scheme are first identified and addressed. Those impacts, including changes to traffic and congestion, should be considered through the development and planning of the road scheme itself. And as he will know, in the context of the Lower Thames Crossing, traffic forecasts were assessed and considered as part of the development consent order, which is the appropriate stage for such considerations. Carrying out that work again, as I said previously, would delay the project and would actually duplicate work that has already been completed. And I'll speak briefly now, Mr Dowd, about clause 4 stand part.
This sets out the requirements that must be met for consultation before a license can be granted under the bill. It ensures that the grant of a license is subject to a clear, transparent, and accessible consultation process, giving those likely to be affected a proper opportunity to make representations before a license is granted. I therefore commend that clause to the committee.
Peter Dowd
Thank you. Order. It being 11:25, the committee is now adjourned until 2:00 p.m. or