Justice Committee

20 October 2026

Justice Committee House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:07 - 00:27
Speaker 2
Order, order.  Welcome to this session of the Justice Committee.  We'll be taking evidence from Charlie Taylor, the Chief Inspector of Prisons.  But before we begin questioning, we'll ask members of the committee to briefly make their declarations of interest.  So can I start with Warinder? 
00:27 - 00:48
Speaker 11
Good afternoon, Mr. Taylor.  I'm Warinder Juss, Member of Parliament for Wolverhampton West.  I'm a solicitor, a member of the GMB trade union executive council, member of various APPGs, as well as being an officer and, relevant to today's meeting, I'm also the chair of the APPG on legal and constitutional affairs. 
00:48 - 00:56
Speaker 4
Good afternoon, Mr. Taylor.  I'm Janet Daby, Member of Parliament for Lewisham East, and I just refer you to my declarations of interest. 
00:56 - 01:13
Speaker 6
Good afternoon, Sarah Russell, Member of Parliament for Congleton.  I'm a solicitor with a current practicing certificate.  I am a member of the Community and Usdaw trade unions and chair of various relevant APPGs, all of it's in my declaration.  Thank you. 
01:13 - 01:27
Speaker 7
I'm Catherine Atkinson, I'm chair of the Justice Committee.  My interests are as declared on the register, of particular relevance is that I'm a non-practicing barrister and patron of a rehabilitation charity. 
01:27 - 01:46
Speaker 13
Hello, I'm Tessa Munt, Member of Parliament for Wells and Mendip Hills in Somerset.  Everything's on the register, but I will just point out I am a director and vice-chair of Whistleblowers UK and I'm also the chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Penal Affairs. 
01:46 - 01:53
Speaker 1
Hi, I'm Vicky Slade, Member of Parliament for Mid Dorset and North Poole.  I refer you to my register of interest, but there is nothing on there relevant to this committee. 
01:53 - 02:03
Speaker 8
Neil Shastri-Hurst, Member of Parliament for Solihull West and Shirley.  I'd refer to my register of interests, but of relevance, I'm a member of the Bar of England and Wales. 
02:03 - 02:11
Speaker 3
Good afternoon, I'm Ashley Fox, the member for Bridgwater.  I'm a former solicitor and my interests are on the register. 
02:11 - 02:29
Speaker 2
Thank you.  Mr. Taylor, you are approaching the end of your tenure, but started back in 2020.  I wanted to ask whether you think the prison service is better or worse than when you began. 

02:29 - 06:12

Charlie Taylor

Well, thank you very much first of all, Chair, for inviting me and many congratulations on your elevation. And I obviously won't be around in the future, but I think the engagement between my organisation and this committee has been enormously important. So I just thank you for your continuing work. You've started off with an incredibly difficult question. I have to say, in my darkest, and remember we're going back when I took over was during COVID.

So things were just so radically different. Prisons were massively locked down. The inspection team went in, I think we were back in prisons by April that year. So we went in very quickly. The prison service were fantastic, very cooperative, because they were keen that we should be shining light into such enclosed places in such a difficult time.

So there was that issue, which dominated the first probably 18 months to two years of my tenure.

After that, the issue that's then dominated has been the has been the challenge of population pressures and a prison system that was in danger of falling over because there were just too many people coming in and not enough spaces available. In terms of the state of things, I think there are some areas that have got worse and I think there are some areas that have got better. So I think the areas that have got worse, I think particularly has been the ingress of drugs through drones and I'm sure that's something you might want to talk about later on. But I think that poses a a serious risk to the stability of of some individual prisons and is enormously disruptive. I also think it affects the ability of prisons to actually fulfill their, if you like, three responsibilities: punishment, rehabilitation, and public protection, because the way in which some of the organized crime gangs are currently operating in prison, it means actually that none of those three functions are genuinely able to be fulfilled.

Also depressingly, I think the purposeful activity results continue to be an area of huge concern. There are too many prisoners locked in their cells for far too long with with not enough to do during the day. And and that's enormously depressing. I think in other ways there have been some some excellent developments. I think the prison service is focusing in on on leadership and we'll see how their new Enable program works out over time.

But but that is timely because prison governors, people who work in prisons, get remarkably little training. So so that has been very encouraging. Despite the fact that when there is an escape from prison, that that causes a huge amount of public noise and anxiety, actually in my tenure of six years as as Chief Inspector, there have only been two escapes from prison. And if you went back 20 years or so, that is absolutely transformed. So there are aspects of security that certainly have got a lot better.

And I think just the overall professionalism and skill of governors is something that's developed, not always because of the prison service, sometimes in spite of the system in which they work. But I think out there now we have some of the some of the best leaders of any public sector that I've come across, of any public sector service that I've come across in my career. So I think there's lots to be concerned about in the future, but I think we also have some some opportunities for the prison service to take things on further in the future.

06:12 - 07:01

Speaker 2

As you anticipated, I think two of the areas that we will be starting with are the most challenging in relation to purposeful activity and drugs and violence. I wanted to note last year you gave evidence to this committee twice and part of your remarks included that you felt that time spent productively is good not just for mental health, but also for protecting the public because people that got out were much more likely to get a job. But you also said that purposeful activity is one in which is one of the healthy prison assessments that consistently scored the lowest and had been consistently scoring the lowest since the inspectorate began in 1982. Since you last gave evidence, has that got better?

07:01 - 08:10

Charlie Taylor

Well, sadly, there have actually overall, even though there have been some improvements in some jails and that's encouraging, we are really worried about the the future here when it comes to purposeful activity. Recently, there were big cuts to provision within prisons from last October.

And that means in some jails lots and lots of teaching staff have had to be made redundant. And governors have had to try and find a way to consolidate the limited services that they've got in order just to get some prisoners the most basic skills. So what that's meant in reality is there aren't enough English and maths places for prisoners, many of whom are desperately in need of remedial basic reading, basic arithmetic, basic writing skills in order that they'll be able to be successful when they come back into the community. But also some enrichment activities also have been cut within the last year as well. So I would say depressingly overall I think this is more fragile than it would have been last time I was in front of this committee.

08:10 - 08:14

Speaker 9

Going to hand over to Brenda, I know who has a number of questions on this point.

08:14 - 08:33

Warinder Juss

Yes, thank you Mr. Taylor. You've mentioned COVID and you've mentioned that prisoners are spending far too much time in cells and there are statistics, 34% of men and 50% of women are spending more than 22 hours locked up. What impact does that have on prisoners?

08:33 - 11:00

Charlie Taylor

It is really astonishing when you come across prisoners in these circumstances. Some appear to cope actually remarkably well. They get their heads down, they do their time. They're used to sharing a cell in often very squalid and inhumane conditions with another prisoner, an unscreened or barely screened toilet in the corner of the cell, incredibly cramped without enough furniture. Some appear to be able to survive reasonably well there.

But what worries me I think most is the long-term corrosive effect on people's health there. We know that there's a group of prisoners with really seriously poor mental health, diagnosable mental health conditions. But on top of that there are a lot of prisoners who just have fragile mental health. They're mentally and they're being kept in an environment that is incredibly mentally unhealthy. And whilst we comment often quite positively on the support for people in prison who are getting more acute, with more acute need, apart from those who need to transfer for hospital where there's a huge problem, but for those with acute need in prison often the treatment is reasonably good.

But for the vast swathe of prisoners who are just mentally unhealthy, I think being locked in your cell for long periods of time is unhealthy. But on top of that, it feeds boredom. So prisoners have got little to do apart from lie on their bed, watching daytime television, and in many cases take drugs in order to pass the time. And tragically I think the way in which they're spending their prison sentence is probably not that dissimilar from how they spend much of their time at home, lying on their bed, watching daytime TV and taking drugs. So I think there is a corrosive long-term effect on prisoners' mental health.

But I also think the fact that those prisoners are not being given the support they need in order to be able to get work successfully when they come out and to function successfully within society. You know, the difference between locked up for 22 hours a day in Pentonville versus walking out on the street is so enormous that many prisoners just can't make that transfer and they're back again within days. So it's a huge concern and it worries me enormously that actually time out of cell has reduced since the pandemic. It hasn't got back even to the very poor levels that it was before that time.

11:00 - 11:20

Warinder Juss

So when this committee prepared its report about ending the cycle of reoffending and on rehabilitation as well, the report concluded that purposeful activity is being deprioritised by the HMPPS and that prisons do not have support for rehabilitation.

11:20 - 11:21

Do you agree with that?

11:21 - 11:35

Charlie Taylor

Yeah. Absolutely. I thought the report was really important and the timing was excellent. And it highlighted some very concerning issues that we continue to flag and our colleagues at Ofsted continue to flag on inspection.

11:35 - 11:39

Speaker 5

And what do you think needs to change then?

11:39 - 13:05

Charlie Taylor

I think there needs to be a reorientation of prisons towards being places of purpose. And I know that's a difficult task. But as an inspectorate, we score prisons at one to four, so one is poor, four is good. If we give a prison a one for safety, people in the prison service really are taken aback by that and they take it really seriously. But I get the impression if we give another one, another poor for purposeful activity, I think there's just a sort of collective shrug.

You know, that's the inspectorate, that's Ofsted, we'll never get this stuff sorted. So the focus, understandably to some extent, is on safety and security. But actually, prisons have another job, which is protecting the public. And they're not going to protect the public, they can protect the public when people are locked up, but they also have a responsibility to protect the public when people come out. And if people leave prison having just been locked in their cells for hours a day, if they're not involved in the kind of purposeful activity which is going to help them to get work when they come out, then I worry that prisons aren't fulfilling that particular function.

And bear in mind it's costing the public fifty-seven, fifty-seven odd thousand pounds a year to keep someone locked up and there has to be a question for the public about whether they're getting value for money.

13:05 - 13:36

Warinder Juss

So the government has said that we should be recording the amount of time prisoners spend in purposeful activity and they hope to achieve that by 2027-28. But at the same time, you also mentioned that there has been a national reduction in core education across prisons. So I mean, how important do you think the government's proposal is and what do you think the impact of that reduction is going to be on what the government is trying to achieve?

13:36 - 13:52

Charlie Taylor

It sounds to me, or it feels to me like they're pulling in two different directions at the same time. So on the one hand, you have an aspiration in order to improve the standards in purposeful activity, at the same time you're cutting provision. That just feels counterproductive to me.

13:52 - 14:14

Warinder Juss

Okay, thank you. Your report did actually identify some encouraging signs of progress and you said that some prisons do have a strong rehabilitative focus and they are supporting prisoners to overcome addiction and are providing incentives for good behaviour. Are you able to give us examples of best practice?

14:14 - 18:08

Charlie Taylor

Yeah, I mean, it is a great privilege of this job that I do get to see, even in prisons that are often struggling in difficult circumstances, actually we see prisons helping to transform the lives of individual prisoners. I mean, I'll just give one example, or a couple of examples if I may. We recently inspected HMP Colchester, which is a really hard to run, very busy local prison in Essex. Lots of organised crime gang members within the jail and a difficult and complicated environment. We inspected that jail in 2022 and we gave urgent notification because we were so worried about what was going on in that place.

We then went back a couple of years later and things had begun to improve. We were there last year and the place is really transformed. And this is in spite of the very high profile release in error that had taken place at that prison earlier on this year. So under a really strong leader, Mark Howard, the prison has made really amazing progress. And particularly what was impressive there was despite the fact they've got a very big perimeter, the fact despite the fact that it's quite a risky site, they've actually managed to bear down on the amount of drugs that are coming into the jail by just getting lots and lots of different things right.

So so that's an example of a really busy reception prison which is able to succeed despite some of the many challenges. I think probably in my time as Chief Inspector, the best closed prison has been HMP Oakwood, which is just north of your patch in Wolverhampton. There are 2,000 prisoners there, it's the biggest, currently the biggest jail in the country. And normally when you walk round a prison, prisoners come and accost us and they want to tell us all the things that are going wrong. What's amazing at Oakwood is you walk round the jail and prisoners do come and accost you, but they come and tell you all the things that are going well at that jail.

So there is a willingness at that prison to pass responsibility down onto individual prisoners, provided they earn it and provided they behave well. And the rules are strictly enforced within Oakwood, but there are great opportunities for them to be able to take on other activities, to be able to work with other prisoners, to be able to support other prisoners and to be able to make a real difference. And then if I may just flag two open prisons which again I think are outstanding. The first is Haverigg in Cumbria, which is a sex offender prison which has a risky population. And it's very close to a local community and a village out there.

They've worked enormously hard to build an understanding and a rapport with local villagers who understandably are very nervous about that population being locally. They've also worked very hard to develop the sorts of relationships with employers that mean that when people leave the jail, they're able to actually get proper work on release, because obviously by the nature of their offending, people are often very reluctant to employ former sex offenders. So a really impressive, a really impressive jail. And then finally HMP Hatfield just outside Doncaster, run by a terrific governor called Mick Mills. Again, that prison is all about work.

And what he says very interestingly is, I'm not interested in you walking round my prison and seeing lots of hanging baskets and lots of beautifully manicured lawns, because what I want with my prison is I want them out in the community actually working. So they get a very high proportion of their prisoners out of the gate every day, going off to work, doing the kind of jobs that they will be able to continue very often in post even when they leave the prison, and building up a sense of continuity and a really rehabilitative ethos that can actually transform the lives of some of those men.

18:08 - 18:38

Speaker 2

Could I also ask a follow-up question and I'll hand straight back to you, Verinder. I think when I visited HMP Ranby, I saw some good examples of work which cut the cost of the prison estate, so kind of laundry, building furniture, but I also saw some good examples of work in prisons for the private sector which in some cases was leading on to work after release. Do you think that we've got the balance right in the types of work that is being conducted in prisons?

18:38 - 20:35

Charlie Taylor

No, not always. I mean, I think there are two things you're trying to do here. I think the first thing is you're trying to just get people into the habit of work. And that means getting up in the morning, ideally spending the whole day at work. And Ranby is actually one of the pilot prisons where the prison service is trying to do a proper working day for groups of prisoners.

So they get up in the morning, they go off to work, they have their lunch together and then they go back to work in the afternoon. They don't get banged up during the day. So what they're doing is living a much more, much more realistic working day. That's really excellent. Sometimes we get to places where prisoners are involved in very mundane activity which doesn't really get them anywhere.

Now that's fine if it's a starting point for them developing skills that will actually help them to get employed when they come out.

But at times we see people just stuck in some very basic workshops, stripping out old CDs, ripping up pieces of cloth. But if there is no progression from that, then it feels like it's probably not getting them very far. But prisons like Ranby, prisons like Hatfield, prisons like Haverigg, who are able to link up with employers on the outside to find suitable types of work for prisoners, is enormously important. And what was interesting is despite the sort of travails of the economy at the moment, when I talked to a group of open prison governors recently and I said, "Are you able to get employment opportunities for your prisoners?" What they say is employers are biting our hand off because they know that these are workers who will turn up every day, they'll be reliable, they obviously have a lot to lose, so they become particularly good, capable, reliable employees.

So, yes, there are some real positives here, but I think sometimes if the work doesn't develop at the right pace, then it feels like prisoners just get ground down by it and then attendance falls away and progress gets lost.

20:35 - 20:44

Catherine Helen Atkinson

So if employers are biting the hands off, what are the obstacles in actually enabling that work to take place?

20:44 - 22:25

Charlie Taylor

Well, I think when it comes to open prisons, I think they're doing a really good job, by and large. I think they're doing really well with linking up with local employers. Of course, one of the difficulties is if you're in an open prison and you're working out in an office or a factory or whatever it might be nearby, but actually your home is a long way away, then the challenge is to connect you with an organisation closer to home. Now, in some cases with much bigger national businesses, they're able to do that. So you can work for company X over here and then you can move elsewhere.

But that certainly can be a challenge with finding an employee in people's local area who's prepared to take them on. But employers like the ones who have the courage to do it, and obviously there is a leap of faith to some extent here, those employers do like having prisoners coming to work for them because they are reliable, they are hard-working. The other thing is that release on temporary license, which used to happen from category C prisons, so you would be, if you were a well-behaved prisoner, you were able to get out and go and work in the community. That almost never happens, partly because the rules have been tightened so much on it and governors are much more constrained about who they can let out. But also within category C prisons, what you see is often a very, very fast population churn, so people are only in the prison for a matter of weeks and obviously wouldn't be able to risk-assess whether someone was capable of being released on temporary license in those circumstances.

So there are some headwinds which mitigate against being able to get prisoners into work.

22:25 - 22:32

Warinder Juss

At the beginning of your answer, Mr. Taylor, you mentioned that HMP Colchester have been able to reduce drugs.

22:32 - 22:39

Charlie Taylor

Chelmsford, sorry, did I say Colchester? I may have said Chelmsford, sorry, yeah, I may have said, sorry, apologies.

22:39 - 22:51

Warinder Juss

So what have they done differently to reduce the use of drugs in their prison that other prisons fail to do?

22:51 - 24:28

Charlie Taylor

Well, it's interesting, what they've done is just get the basics right, really. So, and there are a number of things. The first is about assertively managing prisoners who come in, who they know are at risk of being able to move drugs around. So that's making sure that those prisoners are moving cells regularly if they're beginning to build up connections on a particular wing, putting them into wings where they can be more closely supervised or in cells where it's much more difficult to get deliveries from drones. So it's about keeping track of individual prisoners.

But it's also about making sure some of the basic officer craft is done well. So searching the grounds really well. Making sure that cell searches take place. Making sure that prisoners are properly body scanned when they come into the jail. Making sure that visitors get searched.

Following up on any concerns over staff corruption. So there isn't a kind of magic bullet here. And it still doesn't fundamentally solve the problem of drones which continues to dog prisons. But actually what it does show, I think, when we inspected Chelmsford, the mandatory testing rate for drugs, I think about 15% of prisoners were testing positive for drugs. Now that's not great by any standards.

But when you compare it with other prisons, I was in a jail, Forest Bank, last week where their rate of testing is over 30% of prisoners testing positive. So there is something about what Chelmsford's done, just getting the basics right, that has helped to bear down on that overall number. But 15% is still too high.

24:28 - 24:33

Speaker 18

As we've moved on to drugs and violence, I'm going to bring Tessa in.

24:33 - 25:10

Tessa Munt

Thank you. So the committee did our tackling drugs crisis in prisons report last October and said that without urgent reform addressing the underlying crisis of demand for drugs, the prison estate remains unstable, it's unsafe, and it's incapable of delivering any of its rehabilitation objectives. I just wondered how effective, I think I know the answer to this, but I'm just going to ask you, what, how effective are the current measures at tackling drugs in prisons? And what would you like to see the government do on this?

25:10 - 27:34

Charlie Taylor

So I think there are two things here. One is about supply and one is about demand. And I think both are big and complicated issues. I think the first thing when it comes to reducing supply is about the prison service working with other organisations. And I think we've been very slow in our response to the threat of drones here.

I don't think there's been proper collaboration between the Home Office, the Ministry of Justice, the prison service, the police, the National Crime Agency, security services, the Ministry of Defence in order to really think about this. And the criminals have been winning the race, not least because they don't have to go through government procurement exercises in order to get more kit, which is obviously to their advantage. But they have been winning the race and I think the response has been too slow, too piecemeal. There are partly technological solutions that will help with this, particularly for example about bearing down on the number of mobile phones that find their way into prisons. However, if you get into a technological arms race with organised crime, there's quite a big chance you might end up spending a lot of money and actually losing.

So it's partly that. It's partly about target hardening. So it's making sure that windows are secure, making sure that netting is in place in yards. It's about making sure that CCTV works around prison in order that you can keep an eye on what's going on. Some prisons have got ANPR, automatic number plate recognition systems, that are connected with local police services, which also make a very big difference.

And then it's also in my response to Mr. Juss, which is about getting the basics right when it comes to jail craft and doing that. You combine all those things together and then on top of that, I think thinking about the really big players in prison, people who come into prison, their feet barely touch the ground, they're already running a big organised crime operation within the jail, and thinking about actually how you manage those people in order that they can't just carry on with impunity running not only a new market within a prison, but also continuing to run their drugs operation on the outside as well. And sadly that's all too common. So, sorry, you were going to...

27:34 - 27:48

Tessa Munt

No, I was just going to say, I think we had a discussion, maybe not with you, but certainly with others about the business of segregating those who are serious organised crime organisers, bosses, whatever, and putting them into separate wings or whatever.

27:48 - 27:51

Speaker 19

Can I just ask you to give your views on that?

27:51 - 30:53

Charlie Taylor

I think there's a strong case for trying something here, because I think there are some very big players who've got the means and the wherewithal to be able to move big amounts of product around the place, big amounts of cash around the place, that they understand the way in which these complicated systems operate. And actually being able to really make life more difficult for them while they're in prison, I think will make a big difference, because at the moment prison is not a particular deterrent for them, they're able to carry on running a successful business. I was also just going to briefly mention reductions in supply. So I think, again referring back to Mr. Justice's questions, reducing supply by having prisoners doing something that feels productive, that feels like they're making progress. But I think also having really proper drug treatment in place within prisons.

And again, that feels like it's something that is not always a huge priority. Now again, there are some brilliant examples. I was in HMP Bristol a couple of weeks ago, really hard to run prison with all kinds of challenges there, which again we gave an urgent notification to I think three years ago because we were so worried about the place. Under a fantastic leader, Amanda Corrigan, that prison has been transformed and it's now going in the right direction. But what they have in that jail is an incentivized substance-free living wing in which addicted prisoners are selected to come onto it and they have a really strong recovery offer for those men, which is really making a difference.

And I talked to a number of prisoners on that wing who said, "This has A, saved my life, but it's also going to transform my life as well." So there are examples of these IFSLs, incentivized substance-free living wings, that are really good. Sadly we go to other prisons where they're a really good place to buy drugs. Sometimes they are full of organized crime gang members who have got themselves onto this wing in order to stay away from the chaos that they created elsewhere in the jail. And sometimes they're just full of normal, reasonably well-behaved prisoners, but they're not actually involved in any sort of drug recovery program.

But it is interesting in all the talk about population and population pressures recently, that there hasn't been much discussion about how do we actually bear down on the people who keep coming back to prison. And one of the biggest groups of prisoners who just go through that revolving door are these prisoners with addiction, either to drugs or to alcohol. And until we're able to deal with that problem, until prisons are really able to take that seriously, as we've seen at HMP Bristol, at HMP The Mount, at HMP Cardiff, at HMP Aylesbury, some really good work going on, until we're able to really take on that drug addiction, then the danger is that prisons just become a respite from life out on the streets for some of these people.

30:53 - 31:17

Tessa Munt

So we definitely had evidence from various individuals who sort of said, "Oh well, can't do it under current legislation, moving those people who are the problem cause into separate wings or separate prisons." I don't know which is the answer perhaps, but do you sense there's a problem with legislation, the current legislation?

31:17 - 32:05

Charlie Taylor

Well, we currently have a separation regime for the most risky prisoners who committed murders in prison, so they live in what are called close supervision centers.

We also have a provision in place for prisoners who are radicalizers on the wing, prisoners who who may not do anything physically risky themselves but are dangerous radicalizers on the wing. Those are separation centers. So if we're able to to run those types of of deep custody, and there are risks of course with holding people in in those sorts of conditions. If we're able to do it in those circumstances, I'm not entirely sure why it wouldn't be possible to think about that with with people who are enormously disruptive within prisons but in a different way.

32:05 - 32:14

Tessa Munt

Thank you. So, um, I just if I can just move on to the next questions are really about violence.

32:14 - 32:37

Speaker 2

Before you do, Tessa, could I ask one more question about drugs if that's all right? Um, you were talking about some really positive examples of where drug treatment has been effective in prisons. Do you feel that when they are then released, there is ongoing adequate support to maintain that recovery and avert them coming straight back through that revolving door?

32:37 - 33:47

Charlie Taylor

I think there I think there's a real challenge there. And I think some places do it better than others. Often it's the third sector organization who's out there who will pick people up as they come out of the gate. Because if you think for many prisoners, if if you've served a sentence, you walk out of the gate, you have 80 quid discharge grant in your in your pocket. And you and and there may be dealers waiting outside the jail sadly for for for prisoners because they know they'll have some money and they they know that they want to take drugs.

So helping people in that critical bit when they come through the gate is really is is really important. I think the other feeder of risk here is also homelessness as well. So I think when people go out street homeless from prisons as, you know, up to 20, 25% do in in some cases. I think Wormwood Scrubs it was around that number. We were in Forest Bank last week again it was around that number up in Manchester.

So if people are going out street homeless, then it's very hard just to be able to for them to be able to do the stuff they need to do in order to be able to stay away from drugs. And of course they are then a target for for drug dealers themselves.

33:47 - 34:02

Speaker 2

It feels like a lot of the levers that need to be pulled to maintain staying on the straight and narrow are levers that are not necessarily focused in justice. They are housing, they are health, they um which makes that a difficult.

34:02 - 35:21

Charlie Taylor

Absolutely true. If if I may, Chair, I'd just to give one more example. Um, there's a a drug called Buvidal, which is a um it it's like a for opiate addicts. And it's a monthly injection. So rather than needing to take methadone every day, and methadone has a psychoactive effect, so in effect it makes you high, whilst Buvidal doesn't.

Um, so so Buvidal is a really good drug for long-term opium addicts who have struggled to get off the drug. Unfortunately, what we find is that some prisons are unable for whatever reason to be able to prescribe it, but also when prisoners go back out into the local community, some local authority areas don't provide Buvidal for for patients in that area. So despite the fact that, you know, this is an enormous money saver because the amount of social cost of having a drug addict stealing, you know, up to I was talking to a guy the other day who said he was spending 500 quid a day on drugs. Well, that's an awful lot of crime that guy's committing. If he was on Buvidal, that that that would be three and a half thousand quid a week um that wasn't being stolen from from somewhere or someone.

So just that kind of lack of connectedness is is a big source of frustration for us.

35:21 - 35:56

Warinder Juss

Yeah, um, I would have thought that we need particular prison spaces to deal with drug treatment and rehabilitation and purposeful activities. So the government has announced that in order to create more prison spaces, they want to convert certain parts of prison spaces like laundry rooms into cells. Do you think that there is a danger in doing that in reducing, because will that have an effect in reducing the spaces that we need for rehabilitation? And do you think that that's a measure that is necessary to create more prison spaces?

35:56 - 36:38

Charlie Taylor

I think, I'm not sure it's the magic bullet which is going to solve our population crisis is by squeezing out a few more cells on wings out of laundries and things like that. And of course there's an opportunity cost because if prisoners can't wash their clothes, then that is also a source of disgruntledness as well. So, you know, here and there there are bits of the estate out of which they may be able to squeeze more spaces, but I think overall that won't solve the fundamental prison population crisis which will probably blow up again I would have thought sometime next year at some level and then will become much more serious in 2028 under current projections.

36:38 - 37:15

Tessa Munt

Okay, thank you. So yes, moving to violence and safety of prisoners. So your inspectorate's annual report found that I think it was violence had increased in two thirds of the men's prisons that you inspected last year. And serious assaults had risen in 40% of the prisons you inspected. Um, so what, I think you've touched on it already, but the measures that you feel would be most critical in reducing the level of violence and improving the level of safety in prisons?

37:15 - 38:50

Charlie Taylor

I mean I think drugs critically because drugs equal debt and debts get paid by violence in effect. And the debt either gets paid by the prisoner themselves or very often it gets paid by their family out in the community. And we have no idea of the scale of that problem, but it's pretty terrifying. So drugs is a critical part of that. It's also about having properly recruited and trained staff who are, who have got tuned in radars, who understand what a risky situation begins to look like or feel like, who are able to work with individual prisoners in order to make sure that they're looked after, that their risk is being reduced.

And it's also I think about having specialist units in place for some of the riskier prisoners. And that doesn't always have to be particularly sophisticated. If you go to somewhere like Pentonville, there is a wing for neurodiverse prisoners, particularly some of those on the autistic spectrum who really struggle with life in prison. They bounce in and out of the segregation unit. Their behavior can be enormously challenging for other prisoners, but also for staff as well.

And by training some staff, by creating a discrete unit, actually you talk to men there who said I would have been causing trouble all the time and actually I'm settled here and I'm able to get on with my time and be able to be successful. So where staff are well trained, where you keep and bear down on the level of drugs, where prisoners are involved in purposeful activity and where you're specializing with some of the riskier prisoners, I think there is the possibility of progress and the good prisons are able to do that.

38:50 - 39:20

Tessa Munt

You've referred, I accept that those who are on the autistic spectrum, those who have ADHD and there are various other conditions. But you said your prisoner survey where you've got 25% of the overall respondents said they felt unsafe, but it was up to 75% when you went to Swaleside and to Wakefield. What's going on in those two particular prisons that make them stand out or leap 50%? I mean that's just...

39:20 - 41:19

Charlie Taylor

I think Swaleside, I mean they were risky places but for different reasons. Swaleside was a prison that was in real crisis when we inspected it. We gave it our lowest scores, four in all four of the healthy prison assessments: safety, respect, purposeful activity, and preparation for release. So what we had is staff who are backing off prisoners because of the level of anxiety that they felt. There was a palpable tension walking around the jail.

The hairs on the back of your neck were going up as you walked around. You were always checking that you were kind of near a wall. So it was producing a kind of visceral reaction. And that was just an inspection team who were there for a week. So for staff who are living in there, you can imagine the corrosive effect of being in an environment that was so frightening.

We saw really astonishingly high levels of violence in that place. People walking onto the wing and being stabbed within seconds of arriving on the wing because the prison wasn't able to filter out prisoners from different gangs who were then meeting each other very quickly. So almost everything that could go wrong in a prison was going wrong at Swaleside. At Wakefield things were slightly different. It's an unusual prison in that it has a mixed population of, it's a category A prison, so very serious offenders, and it has a mixed population of some serious sex or serious offences committed against children and other prisoners.

And there'd also obviously been a high-profile murder and then a second very high-profile murder at that prison. And therefore prisoners who were in that category who'd committed offences against children were very nervous about the environment they were finding themselves in. Actually when we went back to do a review of progress at Wakefield, they'd really thought hard about how they manage their population and they'd put the most vulnerable prisoners, those who were at most at risk, they had them on a separate unit and certainly things felt calmer and there was a greater level of confidence there than we had been in the past. We haven't been back to Swaleside so we'll wait and see how things are progressing there.

41:19 - 42:17

Vikki Slade

Okay fine, thank you. I've got a couple of very brief questions on this and then I've got some other questions. First of all, people with mental illness. So I have a couple of constituents who have ended up in prison where their families are saying prison is absolutely inappropriate and that their needs need to be met in a hospital. How confident are you that our prisons have the ability to manage not mental health issues but mental illness?

People who are, you know, schizophrenic, they've got serious mental illnesses and yet they are being managed alongside people who are allegedly mentally well. What's your confidence level on that and what needs to change to make that a safe situation?

42:17 - 44:55

Charlie Taylor

Confidence level at the inspectorate is low on that. We put out a report about 18 months ago looking at mental health transfers, so transfers from prison into hospital. So people who palpably could not be in prison because of course prisons can't treat people under the Mental Health Act. So you can't force people, in a prison you cannot force someone to take medication. So if you've got a schizophrenic prisoner who is a huge risk to themselves, a huge risk to the staff around them, apart from locking them in the segregation unit there's very little that those prisons are able to do for those men.

So they make a referral through mental health processes. Partly there's a shortage of beds but partly we described in our report a labyrinthine game of sort of snakes and ladders where you apply for a particular provision, you get knocked back and you have to start from scratch again and then try and find somewhere for that prisoner to be placed. And you know these are difficult prisoners to place because they're challenged. But I think one of the worst we came across was at Swaleside where there were more than 700 days. It's supposed to be 28 days is the standard that's set for a transfer from prison to hospital when it comes to mental health problems, severe mental health problems.

And we came across a case that had been in Swaleside for over 700 days waiting for that transfer. And I think the average, if I can remember rightly, I think the average on that report was about 80 days that it was taking to get people transferred. Now we were in Bristol two weeks ago and actually it was a pretty seamless process for whatever reason. It seemed to be working reasonably well there, probably because of the amount of beds and the way the prison was working with the local authority. But any sense that prison is a good place to be putting mentally ill people, any sense that you're actually protecting the public in the longer term by sticking really unwell people in prison is really simply fanciful.

And it puts staff in an enormously difficult position because they're not mental health practitioners. They shouldn't be mental health practitioners. And if prisoners won't engage with their treatment, then there's really nothing that they can do. And we come across them, I was in Forest Bank in Manchester last week, some incredibly unwell men living in the segregation unit in totally inappropriate conditions. You know, this is normally where you put the bad guys, but there was nowhere else they could reasonably keep these people.

But it simply wasn't an appropriate place to keep someone who was in a complete mental health, not even crisis, complete mental health meltdown.

44:55 - 45:31

Vikki Slade

So I mean, one of my two constituents actually died in prison a couple of months ago where their family was adamant this young woman should have been in a hospital and the prison was saying, no, no, no, we can manage, we can manage, we can manage. What do you do when you have these mental illnesses that then become very serious cases of self-harm or suicide? How does the inspectorate use those lessons and are they consistent in making change of how people with mental illness are managed?

45:31 - 47:03

Charlie Taylor

So this is something that we often flag in our reports, that in a high proportion of our reports we flag the amount of time that it's taking for mental health transfers to happen within the jail. So that if you're a prisoner and you're on a treatment program and you're taking your medication and you're engaging, then you can be cared for within the jail. But if you're not, that's a big concern. Now what we've seen recently, particularly in the West Midlands, has been under a new scheme called the Red Route run by West Midlands Police. They were failing to triage properly prisoners leaving within the police station as to whether they should be assessed as needing to go to hospital rather than needing to go to prison.

So what was happening, and we found this in HMP Birmingham, where prisoners who were extremely unwell were arriving in the jail and there wasn't even room for them in the segregation unit. So you had a guy who was walking around the wing naked. You had other guys who were smearing all over the walls of their cells and the prison really struggling to cope. We've written publicly to a number of ministers from Health, from the Home Office and also to the Chief Constable and to the Police and Crime Commissioner there to flag this issue in Birmingham and in the West Midlands. And sadly it's likely that may have led to a death in HMP Foston Hall as well, though we don't yet know the details of that particular case.

So if that became more generalized police practice, then we would have an even bigger problem on our hands.

47:03 - 47:06

Speaker 21

Sarah would like to come in on...

47:06 - 47:39

Sarah Russell

Yeah, in terms of mental health in the women's estate, I've just been hearing prevention of future death reports about Styal Prison, which is not a million miles away from me. The prevention of future death report said that half of all the deaths in the women's estate are occurring in Styal. Do you have a view on whether the problems are the same in the women's estate as the men's estate? What's gone wrong at Styal specifically? I can see there was a report here at the end of 2024 for an unannounced inspection.

Have the service been back since, when would they be due to?

47:39 - 48:58

Charlie Taylor

We haven't been back since. It will, we will, you know, Styal is a risky prison.

It's holding some very challenging women and therefore it's always one of those prisons that we will be back to at some stage. Obviously it would be an unannounced inspection so we will turn up when we turn up. But certainly prisons like Styal, prisons like Bronzefield, prisons like Eastwood Park, which are taking women off the streets, Foston Hall, those are incredibly risky. What we find I suppose the difference is from men's to women's prisons is really just the level of need is different. And the level of vulnerability of women is often extreme.

So incredibly unwell women who are often living homeless with all the vulnerabilities that that will bring in, often being exploited by men, often with serious mental health problems or personality disorders who are really struggling, often with addiction issues as well. So in some cases it's almost a more extreme version of what we see in male prisons. And of course the risk to those women is even higher out in the community than we would find for men.

48:58 - 49:36

Vikki Slade

Thank you. That brings me beautifully on to women in prison. And some of us earlier this year actually went to visit. It was Eastwood Park that we visited, wasn't it? Is that the one?

We went to visit a women's prison. And one of the things I recall from that visit was the comment that 90% of the women who were there were victims of crime that then led them to being perpetrators. So what lessons have you learned about when custody is most or least appropriate and how can those lessons inform the move to have fewer women in prison?

49:36 - 52:01

Charlie Taylor

Yeah. I mean I think one has to be a bit careful here because I think a huge amount of men who end up in prison are also victims of crime too. And I think one sort of has to caution a little bit against the idea that all the women who end up in prison could probably be somewhere else. And actually when you look at the offences they've committed you think, yeah, you're probably in the right place. And even if they haven't been convicted of a violent crime, I'm not sure the public would tolerate people who've been involved in the importation of very large quantities of category A drugs or defrauding old ladies of their life savings necessarily needing to be avoiding prison.

But nevertheless what you do see in women's prisons is women getting shorter custodial, so a greater proportion serving shorter custodial sentences. And there's a real question about what good the prison is actually doing for those women. Now the work that Edwina Grosvenor has done with the centre for women down in Sussex, it's the kind of thing that you think could be replicated in order to keep women out of prisons and to help them to rebuild their lives without going through the trauma and the challenges of being locked up with a group of people some of whom are very risky and potentially violent. So women's prisons are different and the women who end up in prison are different. There's a different population in there.

And I'm in no doubt that some of those could be better managed in the community. But it's very often that group and we talk about it with men as well of these drug addicted, mentally ill, living homeless, revolving door of criminality and coming in and out of prison. But part of the big challenge and it was one of the most eye-opening things that's happened to me as Chief Inspector was when I was at HMP Styal and I was in the property room where people collect their property before they go out.

And there was a woman there and and and the officer said, "Do you want your stuff?" And she said, "No, just leave it, I'll be back soon." And actually for lots of these women, they the the prison was the most stable thing in their life. And actually going back into Styal or back into Eastwood Park or Bronzefield was actually an area of stability that that that they just didn't have anywhere else. Well, that's a pretty depressing um place to find your stability, quite honestly.

52:01 - 52:44

Vikki Slade

So I'm really interested because the government's got an aim to reduce the women's population by 400. Um, it's interesting what you were talking about, you're right, I mean there's people in there that you wouldn't want on the streets. And and what we witnessed was these very short sentences. So um do you think that it's right to be looking at reducing that population or do you think that's the wrong focus? And is there a sort of counter-intuitiveness of saying, well actually is a longer sentence something that we should be aiming for with the purpose of rehabilitation and public protection as opposed to the punishment side?

52:44 - 52:48

Speaker 22

Because if they're coming back anyway, I mean if you put the two together and you reduce the population...

52:48 - 53:32

Charlie Taylor

No, no, I mean I think it's, you know, it's a really interesting question. I mean I think as Chief Inspector of Prisons I have to be cautious about kind of comment, you know, going into areas outside my remit like sentencing. And ultimately that's a decision for the courts and it's a decision for ministers, uh you know, to work with judges in order to set the sentencing framework. Um but but uh if if it's possible that that uh you could manage someone's risk in the community and that the public can be reassured that someone's risk is being managed in the community and they can be getting the treatment they need in order to to not commit further offences, to not make people's life a misery out in the community, then then certainly wherever possible, um you know, it's something that we would encourage. But I I have to be careful not to go beyond my remit.

53:32 - 53:35

Speaker 23

No, that's completely fair. I think Tessa wanted to come in.

53:35 - 53:41

Tessa Munt

Can I just come in very quickly? Do you have a view on community payback schemes? Do you not have...

53:41 - 53:42

I I um...

53:42 - 53:43

You don't have to have a view.

53:43 - 54:05

Charlie Taylor

No, I mean it's not something that we at the inspect... I mean I've seen some brilliant stuff. When I was at Youth Justice Board I saw some fantastic stuff going on and I can't remember the name of the organisation that was doing brilliant work with with with guys who were coming out from prison or who were who were on probation. Um but as Chief Inspector I think it's probably just beyond our beyond our remit.

54:05 - 54:45

Vikki Slade

I tried. So that moves me on to children in custody. You said at the beginning of your presentation that there's been a struggle to get people teaching English and maths. I presumably that was in the adult prisons. Uh we know that children in prison have got a statutory right to a minimum of 15 hours a week.

According to the report, your report 25-26, 16% said they weren't participating in any education, work or offending. We saw that again when we when we visited a young offenders institution. Um what are the reasons behind that and how do you think they could be addressed?

54:45 - 54:50

Charlie Taylor

I we um and bear in mind it used to be 27 hours a week that they were supposed to get.

54:50 - 54:53

Speaker 24

15 hours is outrageous when they've got nothing else to do, right?

54:53 - 58:08

Charlie Taylor

Yeah, exactly. So it was reduced from 27. I mean what we find in I mean there's an outlier here which is HMP Parc, which is a which is a small YOI inside a big prison in South Wales, which is a real outlier and I'll come on to that. But in the three public sector run young offender institutions, whether it be Werrington and Feltham, um one of the biggest problems is the amount of time people are just stuck behind their door. So these are energetic young men by and large um who are locked behind their door for 19 hours 19 18 19 hours a day.

They're lucky if they get out for more than six hours a day in many cases. And some are locked up for long periods of time. They also have these incredibly complicated keep-apart lists, so A can't be with B, who can't be with C, who can't be with D. And look, there are some circumstances when that makes sense. If someone's committed a serious offence against, you know, a relative of someone else in the jail or something, it makes sense to keep them apart, and they're probably not going to be able to resolve their difficulties.

But lots of cases we find it's because they've had a row in the van on the way in or something like that, or they fell out with each other somewhere in the jail. Now, there has actually been a reduction in some of these keep-apart lists, which is good, because it means if you've got three boys who can't mix on a wing, that means you can only unlock each boy for a relatively short period of time per day. So the first thing is about bearing down on the amount of keep-apart lists. The second thing is about having proper behaviour management in place. So what are the incentives for the people who behave well in this establishment?

And when we inspected Feltham in 2023, they were doing this stuff really well. So there were real incentives for behaving, and also what are the consequences if you misbehave? And again, what we find is that with some prison officers, we just see boys in places like Feltham just really pushing the boundaries and being able to get away with stuff. And of course, if there's that sense that actually the rules don't really apply, then of course people are just going to break them. So it's about having incentives for people to do the right thing, but also following up where people do the wrong thing and making sure there are consequences for that as well.

It's about having really decent education provision, really strong first-class teaching. And also sadly what we see in so many of the places that we inspect, that children are allocated to classes not because they have the same interests and the same abilities as their peers, they're put into classrooms just because they're not going to hit the people in there because they have a reasonably good relationship with them. You know, that's no way to be running things. So the outlier is HMP Parc, where the boys are out for around 10 to 11 hours a day. They all attend education, it's really excellent.

The standards of teaching are far better, our colleagues at Estyn gave them a very high rating when we go and visit that jail. There's a very capable staff team within there who really understand the boys in their care, but also set very clear boundaries for them. And there are opportunities for boys to be able to do activities that will help to enrich them, rugby inevitably, other sorts of sports as well. So overall that makes it into a far more capable and competently run establishment.

58:08 - 58:17

Vikki Slade

So what, why? Why are they doing it well, and why is that not reflecting on the three others?

58:17 - 59:28

Charlie Taylor

It's a question that we ask a lot. I mean, they have certain inherited, I mean, it's a pretty grim unit, I have to say. So it's not like it's some brand new wonderful, it was an old segregation or high security unit that was converted into a YOI. They've made the best of what they've got, but you know, it isn't about the environment particularly. What it is, it's about having a really clear ethos, really clear rules, great incentives if you do the right thing, and clear consequences if you do the wrong thing.

It's about having a highly capable staff team and a very strong leadership team who drive forward improvement. And it's about the momentum that they're able to get. So you walk into that prison, and instead of walking into chaos and anxiety and fear, what you walk into is somewhere where you think you might be able to cope. And I think it's worth saying about Parc, it used to be a South Wales jail for South Wales people. Actually it is now a national resource, so people are coming from all over the country.

And often we see people who have really struggled in Feltham or Werrington or Wetherby go to Parc and actually be far more successful to get their head down and be able to get on with their sentence in there. So it's a really excellent establishment, and I think at our last inspection we gave it four fours across the board, which is unusual.

59:28 - 59:34

Vikki Slade

Is there any evidence that reoffending is lower following spending time in Parc?

59:34 - 01:00:17

Charlie Taylor

I wouldn't know what the, it's, I mean, the problem with reoffending, there's a couple of problems with reoffending rates. The first thing is that you're only measuring those who get caught. So people who come out and don't get caught obviously don't feature in the reoffending rate, so it's hard to measure.

But also, if people have completed their sentence, you have no way of being able to keep tabs on them. So if they come out and they're on, if they come out and they're on license, then obviously probation services will be keeping tabs on them. But, but it, when I started this job, I thought it should have been much easier to be able to track reoffending rates. But actually, with individual people, it's not always that, it's not always easy as I hoped it was going to be.

01:00:17 - 01:00:21

Vikki Slade

There's not a single record that follows somebody through their life.

01:00:21 - 01:00:52

Charlie Taylor

You, you can, you can pick up the reoffending rate of some individuals, but it, it doesn't always tell you overall what, it doesn't give you an overall picture of the effectiveness necessarily of the rehabilitation. So there is to some extent a leap of faith here, that, that we say, if you put someone in a safe and decent environment, you give them a decent education, you have staff who look after them and care for them, and they're not being involved in violence, one has to assume that when they go out, the options are probably going to be better for them.

01:00:52 - 01:01:11

Vikki Slade

My final question is, the committee's been undertaking an inquiry on children and young adults in the secure estate. Ahead of the government's youth custody transformation plan in the coming months, where would you suggest the committee focuses its attention before we finish that work?

01:01:11 - 01:01:31

Charlie Taylor

I think looking at why, I think looking at why Park is successful, and what it is that Park are able to do. Because, you know, if all the provision was as good as Park, then, then we wouldn't be having this conversation. We'd be congratulating ourselves on, on the fact that we have a youth justice system to be proud of when it comes to custody.

01:01:31 - 01:01:36

Vikki Slade

Do you have, and this is my last one, do you have a view on the secure children's homes versus the secure...?

01:01:36 - 01:02:07

Charlie Taylor

It's not, I mean, obviously I have a view because it was originally my idea in the first place, from my 2015 review of the youth justice system. I would like there to be more of them, so that they would be able, and that was the original plan, was there were going to be more of them in order that they would be able, and this is personal, I'm not speaking as Chief Inspector now, because then they would have been able to learn from each other and grow as a kind of type of institution. But we don't inspect Oasis Restore, so I wouldn't have a view on, on their current state of play. It's our colleagues at Ofsted who do that.

01:02:08 - 01:02:34

Janet Jessica Daby

Yes, yes, well, yes, it's sort of maybe been covered a bit more really. I just wanted to get a view on Oasis Restore actually. And I don't know how much you can say on that, because obviously you said it's Ofsted. But, you know, I'm hearing that it's not meeting its expectations. And I just wanted to get a sense of how well it is or isn't doing, in terms of what it was first set up to do.

01:02:34 - 01:03:03

Charlie Taylor

I think from, I think it's very difficult to say from our point of view. I, you know, the credibility, my credibility, the credibility of my organisation comes from what we say when we're on inspection, what we, what we see when we're rigorously digging under the skin of an institution. And I think we don't inspect Oasis, that's Ofsted's responsibility. And therefore, I, I think it would be unfair of me to, to express a view on that. And I haven't been to the place for, I have visited, but I haven't been there for, for since it's reopened, whenever it was, eight months ago.

01:03:03 - 01:03:16

Janet Jessica Daby

I hear you very clearly. But if I could just press you, obviously in terms of young people being referred from the YOIs or being transferred to Oasis Restore, are you seeing much of that happening or taking place?

01:03:16 - 01:03:23

Charlie Taylor

I think currently the numbers in Oasis Restore are fairly low. But I, I don't know how, I don't know how high they are at the moment, I couldn't say.

01:03:23 - 01:03:42

Janet Jessica Daby

Okay. And if I could just ask you, it's, it's about PAVA spray really being used in YOIs, but it's obviously also being used in adult prisons as well.

And I just want to ask you, what do you feel prisons need to do in order not to rely on the use of PAVA spray? What needs to happen in the prison?

01:03:42 - 01:05:28

Charlie Taylor

So it's a really, it's a really good question and I think it's really important particularly in the context of the youth estate because to some extent, you know, I wouldn't have started here because I think if our youth estate had clear boundaries, very well-trained staff, a vision for how they can operate, as we see in HMP Parc where they, I don't know if they even have PAVA and if they have, I'm sure they haven't deployed it there. So it shows that actually these children are not sort of beyond the scope of being able to be managed in a sort of traditional, almost more of a school-like way. And when you watch the footage of PAVA being used and you see the situations that develop and the use of PAVA, from a pragmatic point of view, it's hard not to think that that could have saved someone from serious injury. But what I would like to see is prisons not in the state in which they were even having to be relying on PAVA in order to solve problems in the first place. I think elsewhere within the adult estate, it does tend to be in the young adult part of the adult estate where use of PAVA is very high.

And again, you look at CCTV footage or camera footage, body camera footage, and sometimes you think actually that officer has probably saved a whole lot of serious harm to people by intervening. But we come across other uses where we're really worried about the way in which it gets used. And there is disproportionality here. We do know that it gets used more on particularly young black men than on other groups. And again, that's something that the prison service needs to look at and really understand why that's happening.

01:05:28 - 01:05:52

Janet Jessica Daby

And thank you for that. And I just want to press you on Parc and in terms of obviously it's functioning from what I'm understanding what you're saying, it's functioning very well. But in terms of the learning of how well Parc has functioned, why has not that not been transferred on to Feltham or in your view or to Werrington?

01:05:52 - 01:07:02

Charlie Taylor

I think it's, I think it's difficult because I think there's a stability about the staffing at Parc and about the leadership at Parc that really helps. And I think we've seen more turnover of leadership in other establishments. They're also bigger and I think that poses a challenge, though I think there are around 35 to 40 boys currently at Parc and I think there are only 70 or 80 at Feltham at the moment. So it's not, you know, it's not hugely bigger. It's not like the days when there were more than 200 boys in individual establishments.

But there is something about the culture, the ethos, the high-quality behavior management, the skills of staff in there that makes a big difference and the genuinely purposeful activity that makes kids think it's really worth turning up because they're learning something that's going to make a difference to them. To the credit of the prison service, they have seconded a brilliant prison officer from HMP Parc to help them to do some of the enrichment activity in order to help to engage boys elsewhere in the estate. And I haven't spoken to him for a bit, but he was doing outstanding work when he was at Parc.

01:07:02 - 01:07:25

Speaker 2

Okay. Before we move on from children and young people, there was huge public concern in response to the Fordingbridge rape case. And I wanted to ask you whether you feel that there are effective interventions available in custody or in the community to address that kind of sexual offending by children.

01:07:26 - 01:08:03

Charlie Taylor

I think when we when we inspect with children often locked up for very long periods of time, often fearful of of the offense being known by their peers, we don't always see or we rarely see any effective treatment or support for for children convicted of sexual of serious sexual offenses. When it comes to that individual case, you know, obviously there were huge concerns raised publicly there, but in terms of the inspectorate, we again that would be beyond the scope of our remit.

01:08:03 - 01:08:14

Speaker 2

The question was more widely as to whether or not you are aware of there being effective interventions, because I think that there is real concern about what what availability there there is to do.

01:08:14 - 01:08:50

Charlie Taylor

Yeah, and I think I mean it's it's difficult because treatment programs for sex offenders anyway, the efficacy of them, you know, has been challenged over the years. So there are various programs that the prison service does and that and the efficacy and whether they actually make a difference has been challenged. I would say one thing, which is that is actually the reoffending rate for sex offenders tends to be much lower, notwithstanding there are some serious and dangerous and persistent criminals in this area, but overall the reoffending rate for sex offenders tends to be lower than it does for other sorts of offenses.

01:08:50 - 01:09:00

Sarah Russell

Thank you. Do we have do you know if we have any reliable statistics on whether or not that's the case for very young child sexual offenders?

01:09:00 - 01:09:27

Charlie Taylor

I don't think we've I mean I we can we can certainly check, but I don't think we have anything probably that is I mean the trouble is they're so they're so rare and so few that it's probably hard to get any kind of concrete meaningful data on those cases, but just because understanding what works for for a handful of individuals probably doesn't give you an overview of what the right thing to do is when the next one comes in.

01:09:27 - 01:09:58

Tessa Munt

Can I just check something? You were talking about sexual offending reoffending. Can I check whether somebody has cross-checked that data for those who do not reoffend and whether there is a relationship, not the right word, between those who do not offend again and those who might have it might have been family offenses, incest or a close family member with whom the for which they've been caught? Do we have an idea of?

01:09:58 - 01:10:11

Charlie Taylor

I to be honest, I don't know. It's something we can certainly pick up and and look into.

Thank you. Could you write to the chair about that?

We may I mean if if we can find the data, we'll we'll share the source with you, but I don't know if that data's available, sorry.

01:10:11 - 01:10:14

Speaker 28

I think we'll move on. Sir Ashley.

01:10:14 - 01:10:42

Ashley Peter Fox

Thank you. Mr. Taylor, I'd like to talk to you about the early release of prisoners. You've stated that even after the early release of prisoners on the first and the 13th of October, the prison population will remain extremely high and the ongoing problems of overcrowding will remain. What is your assessment of the effectiveness of the government's early release scheme on easing pressure on prison capacity?

01:10:42 - 01:12:03

Charlie Taylor

So I think there's a there's a number of things here. I think the first thing is they had to do something. I think with with the number of prisoners coming in and the number of places available, the bath was going to overflow and they either had to turn the taps off, which was not going to be possible, i.e. to stop sending people to custody who'd been sentenced by the court, or they were going to have to find a way to let people out early. Otherwise, prisons were just going to become overcrowded to the extent that we were going to see a a real risk to stability inside. The inspectorate during my tenure has for many years focused on prisons' failure to do proper rehabilitative work that's going to make people less likely to reoffend when they come out.

So I've talked about purposeful activity, I've talked about drugs, but also just the management of cases leaving custody and the way in which the the handover takes place between the prison offender manager, the person who's managing their case within prison, and the community offender manager, probation services out in the community.

And in our reports over the years, we've frequently commented on how that doesn't work. Now, of course, if you're as well as the normal thousand prisoners a week, I think it is, who come out of prison, if you're adding a large number to that at the same time, of course it's going to stretch both prison services, but also services out in the community, and therefore that adds to the risk to the public.

01:12:03 - 01:12:17

Ashley Peter Fox

So if it wasn't working very well before the early release of prisoners, it's reasonable to assume that it's working even less well if they're having to cope with even more prisoners in a sort of a flood.

01:12:17 - 01:13:05

Charlie Taylor

Certainly my colleague Martin James at the Inspectorate of Probation has throughout the last couple of months has been flagging up his concerns about how these prisoners will be cared for in the community, making sure that if they're due to be tagged, they get tagged in a timely fashion, that they are being genuinely monitored when they're out in the community, and that where appropriate they're pulled back into custody. So inevitably an area that's been a big concern for us then has an increase in the amount of prisoners going through gives us a worry. But also I think there's an opportunity cost for prisons as well, because if prison staff are focusing in on just doing releases, there's other stuff within the jail that they're not able to do with their time.

01:13:05 - 01:13:19

Ashley Peter Fox

And presumably those prisoners that are released early without any sort of care as to how they are released into the community, presumably the result is more reoffending and them being recalled back to prison. So actually nothing has been achieved in their cases.

01:13:19 - 01:14:17

Charlie Taylor

Yes, certainly. We've been doing a thematic report with our colleagues in probation where we've been looking at drug treatment within prison and then what happens to people when they come back out into the community. And depressingly, part of the process of this thematic report will be talking to people who have come back into custody very quickly. And what we often find is we'll talk to prisoners on inspection, so the team will talk to someone on the Monday who says I'm getting out today, but don't worry, you'll see me again by the end of the week, because I'm going out homeless, I won't make my appointments for probation, and I'll get picked up by the police and thrown back into custody. And of course, Adrian Usher, the former police officer, the Prisons and Probation Ombudsman, told me that their estimate was that it takes probably two days of police time to recall someone to custody.

So it isn't just about the strain that's put on probation services and the prison service, it's also on other local services in the community.

01:14:17 - 01:14:22

Speaker 29

And this is entirely counterproductive, releasing people like that early.

01:14:22 - 01:14:46

Charlie Taylor

Well, the risk is that if you just have that revolving door and you're not able to do the stuff in order to make people less likely to reoffend, then that risk is simply increased. And it's an area we've commented on throughout my tenure as Chief Inspector, and the more people that are going out, the more strain there is on local services, the more risky it becomes.

01:14:46 - 01:15:11

Ashley Peter Fox

Can I move on to the tagging of prisoners? There's now a presumption to tag offenders on release, and the government has been piloting a scheme to tag prisoners before they leave prison. But we've heard that there are some issues on some parts of the prison estate, and that contractors have been preventing offenders from being tagged at source. What are these barriers to tagging prisoners on release, and how can they be mitigated?

01:15:11 - 01:15:22

Charlie Taylor

We haven't yet inspected a jail which has got this going on, so I wouldn't be able to comment on what the challenges are at this stage.

01:15:22 - 01:15:36

Ashley Peter Fox

Do you think it's feasible to tag prisoners either as they leave prison or outside the prison immediately outside, but by prison staff, perhaps in some sort of departure lounge or some sort of arrangement?

01:15:36 - 01:15:53

Charlie Taylor

I mean, you have a captive audience. One would think that this might be possible to do.

And I don't know, having not seen this in action and not seen the pilots, I'm not sure what the what the barriers to being able to do that successfully might be.

01:15:53 - 01:16:12

Ashley Peter Fox

We've got the Met Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley saying that there have been over 100 tag breaches a day since this scheme started. Is tagging realistically a suitable alternative to custody if it is being so haphazardly applied and ignored even when it is in place?

01:16:12 - 01:17:12

Charlie Taylor

Well, I think, I mean, one of the things is if prisoners go out homeless, they're not being tagged. So that's a category of prisoner who won't be supervised in that way. I think when you talk to prisoners, and again, this is to some extent anecdotal because it's too early to say what the outcome will be and to some extent it's outside my remit. When you talk to prisoners, some prisoners actually quite like having a tag because it gives them something they can point to when their colleagues try and, when on the outside their associates try and pull them into getting into nefarious type activity. But there are also some prisoners who are so chaotic, or some ex-prisoners who are so chaotic, that you can't help thinking that they may struggle in order to cope with the strictures of being able to wear a tag and the discipline that it embraces.

But I think we need to wait and see when the data is in about about how effective this as a policy change has been.

01:17:12 - 01:17:18

Ashley Peter Fox

So do you think it's feasible for the government to roll out this scheme to the whole estate from January as planned?

01:17:18 - 01:17:30

Charlie Taylor

Well, we'll wait and see. Again, that's an area for for our colleagues in the Inspectorate of Probation rather than for us at the Inspectorate of Prisons. In effect, our remit ends at the prison gate.

01:17:30 - 01:17:32

Speaker 30

Thank you, Chair.

01:17:33 - 01:17:49

Sarah Russell

Not entirely dissimilarly to tagging, the government has talked about removing foreign national offenders directly from prisons and has powers now to do that at any point within a sentence. Do you know if that's actually happening effectively?

01:17:49 - 01:19:06

Charlie Taylor

Well, it's certainly the the work between the Home Office and between particularly the the three foreign national prisons, so Maidstone and Huntercombe and Moorland, certainly that has got better. So the process is now more streamlined than it used to be. What we used to find is loads of prisoners in jails like Wandsworth sitting around on what was called an IS91, so they were past their release date and they were they were in effect in Home Office detention whilst being retained in prison, which was which was not ideal at all. Actually, partly because of the prison population crisis, expediency has meant they've had to speed up that process. So it is more streamlined than it used to be.

But nevertheless, we still see difficulties with deportation when we inspect immigration removal centres and of prisoners of, sorry, of detainees who end up in immigration removal centres, only around 50% actually end up getting deported in the end. So so most are released ultimately back into the community again.

01:19:06 - 01:19:12

Speaker 31

We'll move on to the 10-year prison capacity strategy, which is back with you, Sarah.

01:19:12 - 01:19:32

Sarah Russell

Thank you very much for that. So the government is aiming to deliver 14,000 new prison places by 2031. How confident are you that they will achieve that aim? Yeah, that's to start with.

01:19:32 - 01:21:08

Charlie Taylor

I think, I think there's one thing building the places and having the cells and the and the prisons and the extra cell blocks available, it's another thing actually making sure they're staffed properly.

So we were just looking at the plans earlier, one of them is for a prison to be built in Buckinghamshire. There are three prisons in... I think there's four prisons in Buckinghamshire, HMP Bullingdon, Grendon, Underwood, Wormwood Scrubs and... sorry, not Wormwood Scrubs, Bullingdon, Grendon, anyway, Springhill and Aylesbury, sorry. All of those prisons struggle to recruit enough staff. Bullingdon is... has for many years been a black site for recruitment, so they've had to try all kinds of ways of having enough staff in there, not helped by the difficulties with vetting, but that's another issue at the moment. So those prisons have all really struggled to recruit enough staff.

Now next door to HMP Grendon, they're due to open a 1400-place prison. I just don't see how they're going to be able to staff it. I cannot see how they'll staff it, particularly as just up the road in Kidlington there is an immigration removal centre, Campsfield, which has also just opened, where staff starting salary will probably be higher than it would be within prisons as well. So you can build the prisons, but you've actually got to have the staff to be able to work in there. And if you haven't got good, decent, capable staff, then you can have beautiful buildings but they'll remain empty.

01:21:08 - 01:21:25

Sarah Russell

And 14,000 is quite a lot of places, because you've obviously... you've talked about staffing them, but actually where... how does it look like it's going in terms of producing them?

01:21:25 - 01:22:29

Charlie Taylor

I mean, it's hard to say overall. We've seen some new bits of prisons come back on stream, so Norwich was going through a very long-term refurbishment and they're beginning to fill up those cells there that they've finished. Other places are completely stuck, Birmingham's been stuck for years with two huge wings that have been closed because of various contractual issues, similarly HMP Liverpool. So you've got prisons who are needing to be refurbished. You've also got new house blocks being built, so there are two huge house blocks being built, or due to open, at Highpoint in Suffolk.

There's also one, a big one opening at Elmley on the Isle of Sheppey. But again, Highpoint is a prison that traditionally has struggled to be able to recruit enough staff, Elmley on the Isle of Sheppey is another jail that's struggled to recruit enough staff. So building the places is only part of solving the problem. It's also about... and you know, there are contractual delays with some of this stuff, but you know, the bigger problem is having enough good, capable, competent staff to be able to really run the place well and safely.

01:22:29 - 01:23:05

Vikki Slade

Thank you. Can I come in on that? Is that alright, Sarah, or while you've... this is a bit more of a sort of radical point, in that if 80% of the people in prison are reoffending, or are there because they've reoffended, if prison's doing its job properly, why do we need 14,000 new places, or significantly more if you look at some political perspectives? Why are we... surely the answer is what we build needs to be better, not more of it. Is it the right thing to be building more prison spaces?

01:23:05 - 01:24:11

Charlie Taylor

Well, I'm really glad you asked that question because there's been this great big debate that's been going on for the last couple of years or so about prison population and the huge pressures on the prison population estate, but nowhere within this conversation has actually been about, you know, could we do rehabilitation a little bit better? And I think the reoffending rate for... the proven reoffending rate for prisoners is about 27%, much higher for children, but around sort of 27 to 30%.

If you could bear down on that by one or two percent only, you know, if there were proper drug treatment, if prisoners were involved in purposeful activity, they got a job when they came out, actually that would make a significant dent in the overall prison population because these are people who are taking up a lot of space, even though they're coming in and out, they're coming back in 56 days, out again another 56 days. So, yes, I couldn't agree more. I think if we were thinking more about rehabilitation and just seeing this as a population management issue, I think then we'd be able to bear down on the prison population in different ways.

01:24:11 - 01:24:33

Speaker 2

Thank you. I'm going to bring in Janet, but can I just ask, you said earlier that it was more difficult than you had hoped to be able to gather and retain the data in terms of what people move on to do. Do you think that more effort is needed to collect and retain data so that you can measure what actually works?

01:24:33 - 01:25:59

Charlie Taylor

Yeah, I mean, I'll give you a couple of examples if I may, Chair. We know that in somewhere like Wormwood Scrubs around 20% of, and in other jails as well, around 20, 25% of prisoners leave homeless, but those are the only prisoners for whom we have data. So they're the only prisoners who are being released on license. If you're being released direct from court, so you go to court, you get sentenced to time served and you're sent out of the court, we have no idea what happens to those. Also, we have no idea what happens to people who have completed their license period because again, they're free, there's no one keeping tabs on them and therefore they're just out in the community as well.

So even the data that we have is a bit weak there. Similarly, the data on employment on release, we're pretty skeptical about the strength of that data because it often in a prison of a thousand prisoners, it's only measuring a very small proportion of prisoners who are coming out because again, we just don't have that data. Now, it is hard to track someone who has been released from prison, they've discharged their offense, they're no longer on license anymore, it is hard to keep tabs on what those people get up to. But of course, if they do reoffend, then you can have a sense of that. But I think the data on release is definitely not great and I think the numbers can hide the scale of the problem.

01:25:59 - 01:26:03

Speaker 33

You said it's hard, but do you think it's useful to actually try?

01:26:03 - 01:26:23

Charlie Taylor

I think it's definitely useful to be able to try. I think the more we can get good quality data on what happens to people when they come out from prison, the better it will be. And I think there are some areas where we certainly think the data is not telling the whole story.

01:26:23 - 01:26:25

Speaker 32

Which areas?

01:26:26 - 01:26:29

Sarah Russell

You said there are some areas where you think the data is not telling the whole story, I wonder...

01:26:29 - 01:27:37

Charlie Taylor

I think homelessness is the one that worries me most. So out of prisoners that get released on license from Wormwood Scrubs or Forest Bank or, you know, we're seeing about 20, 25% of prisoners going out homeless. But there will also be prisoners who are being released direct from court and many of them will also be street homeless as well. Or they will have a very precarious situation, so they'll be sofa surfing, that counts technically as not being homeless, but they may well be homeless very quickly. Or you've got people going into AP, so they're going into supervised housing for a bit, but then they get removed after I think it's 12 weeks generally, 8 to 12 weeks after that, and then again, some of those are going out homeless and we don't always know where they're getting to.

So I suspect the data that you get on homelessness is actually nothing like as serious as the problem of prisoners going out homeless.

And I think the link between homelessness and reoffending is just so strong.

01:27:37 - 01:27:41

Speaker 2

Okay. I know that Varinder also had a...

01:27:41 - 01:29:03

Warinder Juss

Yes, Mr. Taylor, can I ask you a question about HMP Wandsworth and procurement? So back in May 2024, you put that prison into special measures because of the physical state of the prison, but also endemic drug usage, high levels of self-harm and deaths. The response to what you did was the MOJ putting 100 million pounds for improvements, but there seems to be lack of awareness, lack of knowledge as to how that money has been spent and where it's been spent. I understand that the Justice and Home Affairs Committee of the House of Lords, which is their equivalent of the Select Committee, are looking into this. So my question is, are you satisfied that in response to you putting that prison into special measures, the appropriate steps have been taken?

And can you say more about how that money has been spent? The reason I ask that question is because we've had allegations like a quarter of a million pounds being spent on the installation of one new shower and 35,000 pounds being spent to replace a shower head. It may be that you need to write to the chair afterwards.

01:29:03 - 01:31:01

Charlie Taylor

Yeah. I mean, we, I mean, don't get me started on procurement of repairs and work in prisons because talking to governors, it is an enormous source of frustration. I remember inspecting Lincoln Prison a few years ago. They'd been relying on temporary boilers at enormous cost for seven years. They had a new boiler house, but they had no new boilers.

So this stuff just happens all the time where being able to procure and get stuff done is just not effective. I'll just give you one example if I may, which a governor told me. They wanted to get some repairs done to some windows in the jail. These were not security windows, so they could just be, you know, a standard glazier could fit them. They got a quote from a local firm for 14,000 quid.

They were told they couldn't spend that money. They had to go through a procurement exercise. They went through a procurement exercise. They found a provider who was going to do it for 47,000 quid. The provider subcontracted it.

Guess who they subcontracted it to? That kind of stuff happens all the time. So the cost of getting stuff done is unbelievably slow. It's a huge source of frustration for governors. It's unbelievably slow and it's also unbelievably expensive as well.

So there's a huge challenge there. When it comes to Wandsworth specifically, we did that really awful inspection of Wandsworth. We went back for a review of progress and actually under the governorship of an excellent and very strong governor, Andy Davey, things have got better there. But he's now due to leave and therefore it's a jail that we'll continue to keep a close eye on. But in terms of the individual, anecdotally we hear this stuff a lot from governors, but in terms of the individual cost of things like shower heads, I don't know the details of that, but it doesn't sound beyond the realms of possibility given what governors have said to me certainly.

01:31:01 - 01:31:14

Ashley Peter Fox

Can I just come in there? Because what you've described, Mr. Taylor, is a scandalous waste of public money. So what is the justification from the Ministry of Justice to that procurement exercise that you've just described?

01:31:14 - 01:33:25

Charlie Taylor

It's because this is, I mean, this is the line. This is public money and therefore we need to follow correct procurement processes. And you know, I do understand that.

However, the constraints put on individual governors' ability to be able to spend money is really astonishing. So, a classic case is washing machines, and I may have mentioned this before in front of this committee, but you cannot spend more than 500 quid on an individual item without getting permission from people right up the food chain from you as a prison governor. So if your washing machine breaks down on the wing and you'll get very disgruntled prisoners very quickly if they can't do washing. So either you go through a long-term procurement exercise and get a decent industrial washing machine that will last years, or you go out and spend less than 500 quid on a domestic appliance, which will break pretty quickly, but at least you'll have something in place there. That sort of thing happens a lot.

Now I talked to a headteacher friend the other day because I hadn't been a head for years and I wanted to know how things had changed. And I said, "How much are you able to spend in your school before you need to get permission from your governing body?" And they're able to spend 5,000 quid before they need to check in with their governors. So in other words, the headteacher of a small primary school can spend 10 times more than a prison governor can in being able to spend money without having to go through a procurement process. Partly this is because prisons are civil servants, so prison governors are civil servants, so they're more tied into some of those processes.

But it's just a huge drag on governors' ability to be able to get things done. And bear in mind, you know, these are governors with a thousand prisoners, with 300, 400 staff members, who have budgets of 25 million quid, whose phone rings on a Sunday morning to say someone's killed themselves in the jail or that there's been some terrible incident. We put enormous responsibility their way, and we don't trust them to spend more than 500 quid. I think it's absurd.

01:33:25 - 01:33:47

Warinder Juss

Just very quickly, Mr. Taylor, I've had personal experience of this because I've gone into a prison and I've had a governor say to me a light switch needed to be replaced. Because they had to go through the procurement exercise, first of all, it delayed the replacement of the light switch, they couldn't go to the local shop and get another switch, and it also cost multiple times more.

01:33:47 - 01:34:34

Charlie Taylor

Yeah, and I think more experienced governors will sort of push things as far as they're able to do. But if you're a new governor coming into a prison, you know, the rules are there, you've got to follow the rules, you don't want to fall foul of these arrangements. But it appears to be so risk-averse that we're actually putting these amazing professionals who do an unbelievable job in incredibly difficult circumstances and we're not trusting them to be able to do some really basic stuff within their jail. We're not talking about great big security arrangements and building new walls and that kind of thing. We're talking about some really basic maintenance issues that they struggle to get done because they have to go through so many hoops in order to make it happen.

01:34:34 - 01:34:50

Speaker 2

I think it's been a really valuable to explore and shine a light on. I'm conscious of the time and we have got a number of issues, not least of which IPP, which I know a number of members want to ask about. So can we move on to question 14, James?

01:34:50 - 01:35:04

Janet Jessica Daby

Yes. I just want to take you back to recruitment and retention of prison staff and just get a sense of how you would describe the morale of prison staff at present and has anything changed during your time as Chief Inspector?

01:35:04 - 01:36:03

Charlie Taylor

I think morale of prison staff varies and it really varies about, to some extent it varies on how well the establishment is functioning. So when you go to a prison that feels safe, that's well-run, that's well-organized, where prisoners feel cared for, where staff are motivated, where sickness levels are low, where people are able to enjoy their job, where they're well enough staffed in order to be able to really do the things about the job that they really enjoy, then what you find is morale is pretty good there.

And we do a survey of prison staff when we do every inspection. But on the other hand, prisons can also get into a vicious cycle where sickness levels go up, staff are frightened, they're not enjoying their work, they're backing off prisoners, the level of risk is really high, and of course there you get very high levels of staff turnover as well. So it really varies between different establishments. When it's good, it's great, when it's bad, it's really bad.

01:36:03 - 01:36:13

Janet Jessica Daby

And would you say in terms of remoteness of areas having an effect on recruitment of staff, or are there certain factors you think that are affecting the whole recruitment cycle?

01:36:13 - 01:37:33

Charlie Taylor

Yes, so what you find is certain bits of the country, often bits near the sea because they can only in effect recruit in one direction, so Isle of Sheppey things can be difficult, Isle of Portland things can be difficult. But also in what tend to be some wealthier bits of the country, so the South East. London things aren't always as bad because younger people often want to live in London. But within the South East there are some real challenges. East of England is really, really difficult to recruit as well.

As you go further north, things tend to get a little bit better. But I think my other frustration in this area is how little control prison governors have over who ends up working in their jail. So the recruitment is done, all the recruitment is done centrally by a central team. And of course they are about filling the pipeline, they're not necessarily about being accountable for the quality of the people who come through the pipeline. And when you talk to directors of private sector prisons, they are recruiting their own staff, recruiting them locally as opposed to people who are just pulled in through the pipeline of the system and may or may not be any use.

And governors will often say to me, within seconds we could tell that this person wasn't going to make it.

01:37:33 - 01:37:37

Speaker 35

Are you picking up that governors would like to be part of that recruitment process then?

01:37:37 - 01:39:06

Charlie Taylor

I think they would. I think, you know, they have a lot of work, they're very busy. But I think it's, you know, I used to be a head teacher. The idea that I would employ staff in my school without having met them, without having interviewed them, without having seen the whites of their eyes and understood what their values are, the idea that I would do that in my school is just not in a thousand years would I do that. So and I suspect governors would feel the same about that.

Things are often, I mean I'll just give you another anecdote, things are often so bad that, for example, governors are responsible for recruiting the very lowest grade, which is the operational support grade. These are the most junior uniformed staff who are not in contact with prisoners but will do things like operate the gate, those sorts of things. What they've told me, and more than once, is they have people who have applied for a job as an operational support grade, the governor has said this person is palpably not capable of doing this job, hey presto, six months later that person ends up in their prison as a fully qualified prison officer. We've even had a case where a prison officer was sacked by a governor, I'm not sure how this worked out, but anyway that prison officer then just walked through the gate some months later having been re-recruited back into the service. So you can imagine the frustration of governors in order to be able to deal with those sort of situations.

01:39:06 - 01:39:08

Speaker 36

And my final question, the prison...

01:39:08 - 01:39:45

Sarah Russell

Could I just on this point, if I could interrupt, Chair, and then we'll come back to you Janet. I'm with you Mr Taylor. I don't employ an admin assistant in my team without them being interviewed by me personally. I don't have my office manager do it, I do it. But nonetheless, because you have raised this before and I agree with you, it seems absolutely preposterous and I don't understand how you can create a successful culture in a prison if you do not recruit for people with the same values as what you're trying to project.

So what is the impediment to public sector prisons being allowed to do this themselves?

Is there any statutory reason why they can't?

01:39:45 - 01:40:36

Charlie Taylor

No. It... I mean, it will cost more to individual prisons and they'll have to set up... You will be told about a pilot at HMP Berwyn, which is up in North Wales, where they were encouraged to be able to do their own recruitment locally. A report was produced which said this didn't go at all well and it, you know... I'm pretty skeptical about all of that.

I think this is an area where governors would be able to do it well. I mean, they could get together in groups of prisons. They could do it in clusters. But I just think having an interface, you know, a direct face-to-face in... because of course prison officers don't get face-to-face interviews either. But having a direct face-to-face interview with someone and really understanding what they're about and what their values are and what they can bring to your prison, I think is just absolutely critical here.

01:40:36 - 01:40:38

Speaker 38

They're doing it face-to-face interviews.

01:40:38 - 01:40:42

Charlie Taylor

Doing face... I think face-to-face as well is critical too.

01:40:42 - 01:40:44

Speaker 39

Yes, exactly. Neil and then Janet.

01:40:44 - 01:41:06

Neil Shastri-Hurst

Mr. Taylor, the examples you have described are frankly ludicrous, aren't they? Is there no mechanism where a governor has said, "I think this person is palpably unsuitable for the role," for those individuals to be tagged in the system so when they reapply at a different part of it, it triggers an alert opposed to them being able to effectively get in by the back door?

01:41:06 - 01:41:34

Charlie Taylor

Yeah, and that's what this particular governor who told me this story, he was told he should have done something, but the thing he was told he should have done actually didn't make a huge amount of sense to me. So I don't think those flags are... I don't think it's working in the way that it ought to be working and I don't think governors are aware of it. You would like to think that if you'd fired someone for being no good, that they wouldn't be coming back into your jail. So something's going badly wrong.

01:41:34 - 01:41:41

Neil Shastri-Hurst

Is that a failure of the MOJ of not disseminating that information so governors are aware of the levers that are available to them?

01:41:41 - 01:41:47

Charlie Taylor

Yeah, yeah, and but I'm not entirely sure that the lever that is available is actually the right way of applying a lever anyway.

01:41:48 - 01:41:53

Janet Jessica Daby

Mr. Taylor, I understand the prison officer apprenticeship has stopped. Do you have a view on that?

01:41:53 - 01:41:54

The Unlocked graduate scheme?

01:41:54 - 01:41:55

Yeah, that's right.

01:41:55 - 01:42:39

Charlie Taylor

Yeah, I mean, I'm really... I'm very disappointed about that. You got some absolutely amazing people who would never have come into prisons. You know, like Teach First, you got amazing people, really bright, really able, really interested in the role who were coming in. Some of them have gone on to be outstanding leaders. I think the scheme was outstanding and I'm really sorry that it doesn't exist anymore.

And what governors said to me is it wasn't just about the people who were coming in. They were actually pulling other people in their wake. So people who may have joined the service, they weren't really sure whether they wanted to do it or not, but they'd joined and they were then being enthused by these Unlocked graduates who were kind of showing them the possibilities of the job and they were able to grow as well as the graduates themselves. So, um, I'm really sorry it's gone.

01:42:39 - 01:42:44

Speaker 40

Do you know why it's gone or any view on that? It went back in in April 2024.

01:42:44 - 01:42:59

Charlie Taylor

It did. It went... it went very quickly. I think there are conflicting stories about it, but I just think when you have something great in a service that really struggles to get brilliant people, you know, don't let it go.

01:42:59 - 01:43:01

Speaker 37

Thank you.

01:43:01 - 01:43:05

Speaker 2

Can we hand over to you, Neil, to start talking about the imprisonment for public protection?

01:43:05 - 01:43:43

Neil Shastri-Hurst

Thanks very much, Chair. So in August of this year, the Prime Minister announced that as part of the government's plans to ease prison capacity issues, he was going to ask the Lord Chancellor, Justice Secretary, to bring the injustice of IPP sentences to an end during the course of this Parliament. We've not had any real detail of how that is going to work. No. You have broadly welcomed the principle behind it, but you've cautioned that a careful approach needs to be taken for public safety reasons.

If you were to be advising government, what are the key features you would be looking at in those plans?

01:43:43 - 01:45:15

Charlie Taylor

Well, I think the first thing to say is it's enormously welcome that this has happened. I think the idea that you sentence someone for a crime they might or might not commit in the future, I think is a great injustice. And I think David Blunkett, under whom the offense was originally designated, has said exactly that as well and regrets it enormously. So I think it is a good and positive move. However, these are prisoners who may have committed further offenses while they're in custody.

They may continue to pose a risk to the public. So I think the scheme needs to be done in a thoughtful and measured way, which combines an ending of this injustice to those individuals, but also making sure that the public have some assurance that they are going to be protected when people come out. But often we see that these are very troubled men who are so caught in the system, who have struggled so hard for many years because of the uncertainty that surrounds them and their sentence, that life's very difficult. There is a real exciting innovation going on at HMP Aylesbury, where the Phoenix wing has recently been set up for this particularly troubled group of prisoners. And I think it's that sort of support that will help to unpick those who are able to go on and go out and be successful, and those who are going to need more support in order that they'll be able to do it.

01:45:15 - 01:45:38

Neil Shastri-Hurst

You've quite properly highlighted that these are high-risk individuals in a number of cases, and therefore this plan as a result of that is high risk. How do you think the government should be mitigating that? You've touched on HMP Aylesbury, there may be other examples that would help us understand how they're going to mitigate what is a significant public safety risk.

01:45:38 - 01:46:35

Charlie Taylor

Yeah, I mean, I saw there was another very good program, I was at HMP Featherstone just outside Wolverhampton recently and again, just in the summer, and again, they were thinking really closely about how they offer support for these particular men. So I think it is about making sure that services are coalescing around them so that they are getting support both while they're in prison in order to reduce their level of risk. Because some of them have been locked up for long periods of time and actually their risk has certainly been reduced, but making sure that you can establish the risk has been reduced. But also making sure that out in the community, there is some decent coalescence around them in order to support them back into the community. But overall, this is an initiative that we really welcome.

We've written two extremely critical reports about the treatment of these prisoners over the course of the inspectorate has done over many years. So it's not going to be easy, but I think it's a welcome innovation. I think the government are doing the right thing.

01:46:35 - 01:46:55

Neil Shastri-Hurst

At its maximum, this Parliament's got just under three years to run. Do you think it is realistic that within that time period, there will be the sufficient measures taken whilst these prisoners are still in custody to ensure that they can be safe for release and then transition into society?

01:46:55 - 01:48:36

Charlie Taylor

I think it's very hard for me to be able to say because this is really on a case-by-case basis about individual levels of risk. But I think the principle is now established that this is a sentence that has now ended and now should end the Kafkaesque nightmare that these prisoners are caught in. And often you can see them coming a long way away in prisons, they are trapped and haunted by their experience of just felt that whatever they do, they're unable to get out. So the principles are right, but I think the devil will be in the detail and we'll wait and see what the policy is like and what the outcomes are for these prisoners over the course of time.

And do you have any views on the specific support or additional support that would be required for these prisoners upon release, not just before?

I think again it depends on individuals. I mean, prisons are releasing risky people all the time. You know, every week a thousand prisoners leave jail and a number of those are very risky. And therefore they'll be, for example, subject to various levels of MAPPA, Multi-Agency Public Protection support, that they will get different levels of intervention from probation services. In more extreme cases they'll get very specialized support and very close monitoring from the police as well as probation services.

So I think it's about assessing the level of risk for these men as they come out and making sure that the package that is set up around them is suitable to be able to support them back into the community, but also to protect the public.

01:48:36 - 01:48:58

Neil Shastri-Hurst

And there's one thing for a government to sort of set an objective or an aspiration, there's a very different thing to deliver it and to deliver it on time. If the government fails to deliver on this aim by the end of this parliament, do you envisage any detrimental consequences that arise out of that?

01:48:58 - 01:49:22

Charlie Taylor

Well, I think you end up just leaving these prisoners dangling. You know, dangling for a crime that they committed a long time ago, but ultimately the sentence was for a crime they might yet commit in the future. And you can't have a justice system that really operates in that way. That isn't justice in my opinion.

01:49:22 - 01:49:25

Speaker 41

I think Vicky wanted to come in and then Janet.

01:49:25 - 01:50:19

Vikki Slade

Yeah, so thank you. Very briefly on the IPPs. We know that of those still in prison about 800, 850 have never been released, but 1400 are there because they've been recalled, sometimes not for something related to a crime. But many of those people who have been recalled can't go back through the system of release again until they can access the courses which have often got waiting lists of a year or more, or are in the different part of the country or, you know, it's not physically possible to get them in. What suggestions would you make in your role about how that process can be made better because if people have been recalled and there's a need for them to do a course, presumably that course still needs to be done?

01:50:19 - 01:51:11

Charlie Taylor

Yeah, I mean this is a huge frustration, not only for IPP prisoners but also for other prisoners as well, whereby on their sentence plan they have a course that they have to complete. They know that when they go in front of the parole board if they haven't completed that course, the parole board are likely to knock them back. But they're nevertheless locked up in a jail where that course isn't available or where the waiting list is so long that they're not going to be able to do it in a realistic amount of time. And it isn't just about them getting released, it's also about them getting an opportunity to spend time in open prisons. And I think referring back to Dr. Shastry's point about the things that need to take place, actually getting IPP prisoners into open prisons again is a really good way of gradually integrating people who are massively institutionalized back into the community.

01:51:11 - 01:51:14

Speaker 42

That's really helpful, thanks. Janet.

01:51:14 - 01:52:07

Charlie Taylor

Yeah, I was just going to say this is a big area for the government and it's an issue that's been going on for some time. Is there something, is there anything else that you think would be helpful for the committee to know as this unravels or becomes clearer in terms of how the government is thinking about doing it?

I think what would be really interesting would be to look at how things pan out. I mean, it's early days at this Phoenix unit at HMP Aylesbury, but I think it will be really interesting to see how this pans out over time and the extent to which they are able to take on the challenges of some men who are, in some cases, very troubled, very caught within the system, who have had lots of difficulties while they've been in prison. And to see the extent to which the work in HMP Aylesbury and the brilliant governor Kevin Marshall-Clark will be able to support those prisoners to go out successfully. So, but, you know, I'm optimistic that this is a jail that's operating well and I think they'll do a good job of it, but let's wait and see.

01:52:07 - 01:52:26

Tessa Munt

Thank you. I've just got four very quick questions to ask you about the Rudd review. And I recognize that her aims are wider than your inspectorate's stuff, but I just wondered, firstly, has she contacted you? She has, I hope.

01:52:26 - 01:52:39

Charlie Taylor

No, certainly, and we were delighted to host her on inspection at HMP Bristol a couple of weeks ago. And I've also been involved, had a meeting with her, a couple of meetings with her and had some roundtables looking at security and looking at staffing.

01:52:39 - 01:52:56

Tessa Munt

I just wondered what chances she might have and whether, because there are quite a lot of reports on all the things that might not be as right as they might be, and what chances she has of actually achieving her objectives of sort of tackling crime and making prisons safer and delivering those reforms. I wonder how you feel about that.

01:52:56 - 01:53:41

Charlie Taylor

I mean, ultimately, you know, ultimately this is a political matter, ultimately. So I'm in no doubt that the recommendations that Amber Rudd makes will be very strong, will offer some really tangible solutions to some of these problems. But ultimately, these are going to be political decisions which will need to be made, also within a system that sometimes struggles to move at pace and to be innovative as we've discussed earlier as well. So, but it's a challenge, but I think I'm sure the proposals will be excellent and will be full of loads of good ideas, but ultimately it's for ministers to take that on.

01:53:41 - 01:54:01

Speaker 2

Thank you. In a few months, you will be handing over to your successor after more than six years. What issues would you advise your successor to prioritize and what advice would you give to them so that they will be successful in the role?

01:54:01 - 01:55:31

Charlie Taylor

I think some of the issues are going to remain the same. I think the issue of drugs and drones, I think will continue to be an issue. I think the recruitment and retention of staff, I think is critical. And I think the role of the governor, the more I do this job, the longer I've gone on in this job, the more I just think that the role of the governor is so critical here. These, I think, are the most dedicated, the most impressive public servants that I've come across in a long career.

They work unbelievably hard in often unimaginably difficult circumstances and they do amazing things. But I think there's a system that doesn't always help them to be the best that they can and I think it's a big source of frustration. So I think really thinking about, you know, what is it we want governors to be doing, spending their time? Do we want them to be sitting tapping away at a computer screen, plodding through another HR issue or a government procurement exercise, or do we want them to be out there leading their prison, setting an example, driving forward improvement? And I think at the moment we have a system that is constraining some outstanding professionals from being able to do their job.

And I think to focus on that and to really think about leadership in prisons, I think is critical.

01:55:31 - 01:55:37

Speaker 2

So if you could resolve just one issue facing our prisons, what would it be?

01:55:37 - 01:55:39

Speaker 43

Would it be that?

01:55:39 - 01:56:02

Charlie Taylor

I mean, the temptation is to say no drugs, and I think that would make a huge difference. But I would also say, I would also say leadership. I would say about giving governors the accountability and responsibility and putting them in the same place around the governor. So if you allow me a real fantasy, it's drugs, but if it's something more prosaic, it's about leadership.

01:56:02 - 01:56:13

Speaker 2

Can I finally ask where this committee can add the greatest value in scrutinising the government's work on prisons?

01:56:13 - 01:57:40

Charlie Taylor

I think recruitment is really critical about who's coming in, how good they are, how well they've been trained, how capable they are, excuse me, and how long they stick around for when they are trained, so what happens to them. I think that pathway is really critical, particularly as if we're going to, excuse me, open 14,000 new places by the end of the decade, there's going to have to be a lot of thinking done around that area. I think it's less exciting, but I actually think this issue over procurement and being able to just get stuff done, I think it's a great source of frustration. And you know, it's not like governors, directors in the private sector are better, they're not better, there's some great people in both types of prisons. But if you talk about people who are refugees into the private sector from public sector prisons, what they will say is I just am able to get stuff done in a way that when I was a governor in the public sector I wasn't.

And to think about what are the constraints that stop people from being able to do that, to what extent are we gold-plating processes in order to make sure that no one ever breaks a rule in any way, constraining people so much that at least they don't do anything wrong, but they're not able to flourish either.

01:57:40 - 01:57:59

Speaker 2

Well, that brings us to the end of our questioning. I'd really like to thank you for your time and for your answers and to wish you luck in the future when you've handed on the baton to the next Chief Inspector of Prisons. Order, order.