Welsh Affairs Committee

21 October 2026

Welsh Affairs Committee Actual start House of Commons

Follow its sittings
19:46 - 21:35
Speaker 1
Welcome to this oral evidence session of the Welsh Affairs Select Committee.  My name's Ruth Jones and I'm the chair of the committee.  And before we begin this afternoon, I do want to draw attention to the remarks made by the Prime Minister this afternoon in Prime Minister's Questions. 

Today we mark the 60 years since the disaster that happened in Aberfan.  So we want to send our thoughts to the families and communities who continue to be impacted by these tragic events.  So it's good to commemorate that and obviously apologies from Geraint Davies who can't be here today because he's at home in the constituency with the King and Queen.  So there we are.  But moving on, we are today talking about child poverty in Wales in our first evidence session of our inquiry into working towards ending child poverty in Wales. 

And as part of our work, we will be looking at the key drivers of child poverty in Wales and how the UK and Welsh governments work together towards ending child poverty in Wales.  So I'd like to welcome our witnesses today.  We have Mabli Jones, Head of Policy at Bevan Foundation, who is on screen virtually.  We have Laurie Ryall, National Director for Wales at Action for Children.  We have Tom Wernham, Senior Research Economist at the Institute for Fiscal Studies. 

And Sarah Crawley, Director of Children's Services for Cymru and UK Programmes at Barnardo's.  So welcome to you all.  I will just start by asking could any members declare any interest they may have before we start the session?  No, that's fine.  Okay, thank you very much. 

Let me start by asking Mabli Jones first, maybe.  Could you briefly outline the story of child poverty in Wales over the past 25 years?  You know, we're looking at say where we were at the millennium, the beginning of the turn of the century, and where we are now in terms of the trends and things like that.  If you could just very briefly outline that, please. 
21:35 - 21:39
Speaker 2
Yes, of course.  And thanks for inviting us today. 
21:40 - 22:41
Speaker 3
So I'd say the general picture is probably one that people are familiar with, that we know that one in three children in Wales live in poverty.  And that's a figure that hasn't really changed over the last two decades.  It's basically hovered around that one in three level.  However, despite the fact that that headline income poverty rate hasn't changed, what's been happening under the surface is that poverty has got deeper, particularly over recent years.  So we know now that almost half, so 47% of people in Wales who live in poverty live in what's classed as very deep poverty. 

So that's an income that is at or below 40% of the median.  And we know that, you know, families who are experiencing that kind of poverty are likely to be going without many of the basics.  So that, those are sort of the headlines at the moment. 

And there's a lot more obviously to discuss in how some of the characteristics of child poverty have changed too. 
22:41 - 22:46
Speaker 1
Yeah, thank you for outlining that so clearly.  I'm going to move on to David Chadwick, please. 

22:46 - 23:13

David Chadwick

Thank you, Chair. And this is a question for, for Tom. I'm sure everybody in this room is well aware that we've suffered job losses, lack of investment in Wales for decades now. How does that economic weakness, those economic failures, contribute to the very high levels of child poverty that have been mentioned already?

23:14 - 24:31

Tom Wernham

Yeah, and it's definitely a sort of a key part of the underlying context. Obviously, the labor market and earnings are key drivers of household incomes. And I think what stands out when looking at Wales and comparing it to the rest of the UK is that a gap seems to have opened up between Wales and the rest of the UK in terms of employment rates, particularly since 2019. And though the data's got very uncertain since then, so it's really hard to be sure of exact magnitudes, it does look like, you know, though Wales had been catching up with the rest of the UK in terms of employment rates up until then, the gap has widened again. So that just makes the job a bit harder in terms of bringing poverty rates down.

It also makes it more expensive to bring poverty rates down because you've got to either pay more in benefits to those families who are getting less money from work, or you've got to, you know, take real efforts to restore that level. And then we also see lower earnings amongst those who are in work in Wales. And that's got, you know, quite a few contributors.

There are fewer sort of very high productivity industries in terms of financial sector and tech sector, but there also seems to be lower productivity when comparing industries like-for-like with the rest of the UK. So yeah, there's a few different challenges there.

24:31 - 24:48

David Chadwick

And would you agree that developing, growing the private sector in Wales is the best long-term tactic to solving child poverty? And do you see any policies either from the Welsh or the UK government that give you particular hope at the moment that this will be closed?

24:48 - 25:41

Tom Wernham

Yeah, it's a good question. I think, you know, Wales also stands out, part of the story of the lower earnings is that there's a bigger gap between private and public sectors in Wales than other regions in the UK.

So if the government, the UK or the Welsh government wants to boost incomes, then boosting private sector earnings needs to be a part of that. That said, you know, if you want to achieve quick reductions in child poverty, really it's the benefit system that provides the levers to do that quickly and to deliver change now. But it's also the costlier option. Clearly, you know, if you can boost household incomes by achieving increases in employment or earnings, that saves money for the exchequer and boosts families' incomes, but it's a much harder job to do. And it's going to depend on policies both at the UK and the Welsh level.

25:41 - 25:43

Speaker 6

So it's a bit of a trade-off there.

25:43 - 26:22

Sarah Crawley

Would you mind me just coming in on that one? And I think it's really important because we have to have good work, don't we, or have well-paid work and work that's accessible and able to get to.

And I just wanted to share that 74% of children living in relative income poverty in Wales live in a household where at least one adult is in work. So it's not a silver bullet to transforming people's lives. And it's also difficult to get to work, have good work, and to be able to have access to childcare and the right level of childcare to be able to do the hours that you would need not to then impact on your income and then your benefits.

26:22 - 26:28

Ruth Jones

I'm sure we'll cover in depth as we go through, but yes, your points are well made. Thank you, Sarah. Let me move on to Andrew Ranger.

26:28 - 26:48

Andrew Steven Ranger

Thank you very much and good afternoon all. This is a question for the three of you in the room, if I may. So all of your organisations operate across the UK, but are there any trends or issues that impact Wales in particular compared to the other UK nations? So if I start with Laurie, please.

26:48 - 27:06

Laurie Ryall

Yeah, I think that's a really good question. Thank you for having me here today. I think what we do see in Wales is that we have one of the highest levels of personal independence payments, for example. So we see a real difference in terms of the level of need and therefore the level of support or the type of support there is required to support people to get out of poverty.

27:07 - 28:30

Sarah Crawley

Yeah, we're seeing it deepening very, very quickly. We've got families that are in deep levels of poverty now, so they're unable to afford essential goods. So that's things like hygiene products. So we're seeing hygiene poverty. So they can't afford shampoo.

They can't afford washing for their clothes. We're seeing children without beds and so bed poverty.

We're seeing children sharing beds. We're seeing children in families which are in one room, and that's particularly prevalent when we've got no recourse to public funds families. So we are seeing greater levels of poverty and families really, really struggling to make ends meet. And I'm very concerned, Barnardo's are very concerned about the rising cost of living. We've seen cost of living go up in excess of 30% in the last five years.

And families' incomes haven't gone up by 30%. Their income in terms of employment haven't gone up by 30%, so they're really, really struggling in deep poverty. And it is affecting children's health. It's affecting their life chances. It's affecting their mental health.

It's affecting their education.

And we have to address this now because otherwise we will have whole generations of children who are not getting the life chances and opportunities they should have within Wales.

28:30 - 29:06

Laurie Ryall

And I think it's just worth mentioning on that point that there is a difference as well between those who experience poverty in rural areas. And I say rural Wales, but I also mean places like the valleys or coastal areas of Wales where access and transportation is even more difficult. So it's harder for them to access support. And actually poverty can be a little bit more hidden because we're not seeing the home conditions they're going back to. We're not seeing what these families are experiencing.

And there's a lot of even shame sometimes to be able to come forward and say, actually, I don't have a bed to sleep in. I don't have a warm home. I don't have food on the table. So that's a real issue we also need to consider.

29:06 - 29:20

Andrew Steven Ranger

Just briefly before I come to you, Tom, on the points you raised there, were they specific to Wales? Because obviously cost of living is across UK, across Europe, across the, you know.

But what specific, are they all specific to Wales, what you just described?

29:20 - 29:36

Sarah Crawley

Those cases I was talking about, absolutely, they all are. And they are occurring across the UK, but we're seeing higher levels within our family support services, I would say, within Wales. Particularly around the Merthyr areas, Rhondda Cynon Taf, those, those valleys communities.

29:36 - 29:49

Andrew Steven Ranger

And you mentioned recourse to public funds as one issue, but am I right in taking it that from the answers to the previous question, that those elements in Wales that are around lower incomes and all that kind of, that's the driving force behind those differences?

29:49 - 29:51

Speaker 11

Yeah. Yeah.

29:51 - 29:54

Speaker 13

Great, thank you. And Tom, please.

29:54 - 31:14

Tom Wernham

Yeah, so, yeah, as partly the stuff I've already mentioned and just the background weaker employment and earnings situation is, is something that makes Wales stand out.

And yeah, I agree the rising sort of cases of ill health is, is a key driver of that. Wales doesn't seem to have higher unemployment per se, but fewer people in, in the labour market at all. On sort of, yeah, looking at sort of how the nature of poverty differs. I mean, from my perspective, which is looking at the survey data rather than thinking about, you know, the experience of, you know, services for these families, it's actually really difficult to draw rigorous conclusions because there isn't a huge amount of data from Wales. I mean, the main surveys do cover Wales, but the sample sizes are really small, so all the measures are really noisy year to year.

There are a few measures such as material deprivation and deep material poverty, which do try and get at, you know, are families able to afford essentials? I think actually on those measures, Wales stands out less than the rest of, than on the income measures of poverty. But yeah, you can't really draw firm conclusions from that because these measures haven't been around for very long and the survey measures are so noisy. So yeah, I don't necessarily want to contradict anything that's just been said there because there's a huge amount of uncertainty in all of the data.

31:14 - 31:16

Speaker 15

Thank you very much. Thank you, Chair.

31:16 - 31:18

Speaker 14

Anna McMorrin, please.

31:18 - 33:27

Simon Hoare

Thank you, Chair. There would be a dwindling percentage, almost to the point of invisibility, of society who will say, because they remembered or they heard from an older generation, if people really want to experience poverty, go back to the sort of, you know, the 1930s is always drawn up as the sort of decade where it was most amplified.

So I just wanted to ask this question. We are living in an age where the welfare state and its principal purpose, the safety net below which nobody can fall, is probably at its most complex, but also most comprehensive. We have an incredibly advanced, free-at-the-point-of-use, comprehensive National Health Service and a range of interventions in school to support kids from lower-income or no-income families.

Concomitant to that, we have a rise in the fast-moving consumable goods on our high streets, be that vape shops, be that nail bars, be that mobile phones, be that large televisions, etc, etc, and so on. And a lot of people will sit back and say, not in a cruel way, not in a nasty way, how how how do we join up those pieces of a jigsaw that create the picture that you have set out hitherto for the committee, which almost is counter-intuitive in how it manifests itself against the backdrop of the level of state support and supports which are available at no higher time, they've never been greater in volume at any time in our history. I don't know who wants to pick up that monumentally challenging doctoral thesis type question.

Maybe Ms Jones would have a stab at it.

33:27 - 34:31

Mabli Jones

Yeah, I think in terms of what's happened in recent years, we know that those benefits are not haven't really been able to give people the safety net that they perhaps should be expected to. We know for instance that the two-child limit on the child element of Universal Credit was a big driver of child poverty and there's been a clear link in recent years between families with three or more children making up a huge amount of the children who are living in poverty.

So I think there's that, there's other sort of policies that have been brought in over recent years such as the overall benefit cap, the bedroom tax, things like that which have meant that those benefits haven't kept pace with people's living costs, particularly then given the huge increases in the cost of living that we've seen in recent years which I think have been together, taken together, those have been the drivers of that deepening of poverty that we've seen.

34:31 - 35:52

Tom Wernham

I think so. And yeah, I mean, there's people mean different partly people mean different things when you talk about poverty. We have sort of a relative sense of poverty and an absolute sense of poverty.

And, you know, if you certainly if you construct, you know, a fixed poverty line and look back decades and decades, I think, you know, for almost all groups, poverty, you know, will have will have fallen on that measure. Sometimes, you know, people think relative poverty, you know, particularly over time, you know, is something you need to be concerned about because you're concerned about inequality and you're concerned about, you know, the poorest families falling behind the standards sort of set by society at large. And that's what relative poverty statistics are getting at, the poverty line grows as median income grows, and that's a sort of a real sort of distributional concern. As for whether, you know, in absolute maybe there are people falling through through the gaps of the of the safety net, and if you think about cases like no recourse to public funds and that sort of things, actually sort of making those comparisons over the time though is is probably just too difficult because of the low sample size and we don't have comparable data over time.

So actually trying to sort of quantify whether there is in an absolute sense, you know, a certain group for whom poverty is persisting and the scale of that over time is a bit difficult to do just from the data.

35:52 - 36:41

Laurie Ryall

And and I suppose from my perspective, I just want to I appreciate that people might look back at poverty and how things have changed. But from what we're seeing, poverty is very real for the children and families that we're working with. We are talking about families who cannot put food on the table, whose children are coming to school, and I accept they might have free school meals and we know that that has been a benefit, that has supported families. But when they're coming to school in the first instance and they haven't had breakfast, they haven't had a good meal the night before, they don't have a good bed to sleep in or even bedding, then they are in real poverty. And I think yes, there are a number of of measures that are in place to support families and there are a number that are really beneficial.

But we also know access to some of those benefits is a challenge. And I know the UK and Welsh government are keen to look at increasing the uptake of some of those benefits, but there are still issues that we need to look at.

36:41 - 37:58

Sarah Crawley

I was going to say, I think we should also ask ourselves the question, why does Wales have a higher than average percentage of households receiving benefits? And is that related to a lack of opportunities for employment? Is it related to other factors to do with health? And so if we're comparing that across the UK, if more of them are on benefits, there's a greater negative impact, isn't there, over time? And we also have to take things like housing into account.

I mean, private rented housing is extremely expensive, and access to social housing is extremely difficult, particularly larger properties across Wales. So if you're looking at local housing allowances rates, they don't actually reflect the real cost of rent, do they?

So having to make up that shortfall, so that means it's nearly impossible for people relying on housing benefit to actually be able to afford private rented accommodation. And it's the situation particularly difficult in Wales where we have fewer than 1% of homes listed for private rent in Wales which are actually affordable for people on housing benefit. So I think that's a substantial change, isn't it, over the last even over the last two or three years with mortgage rates and private rented access, but that's probably been one of the starkest changes over the last five to 10 years, I would say in Wales.

37:58 - 38:59

Simon Hoare

I mean, that segues well to I suppose the my next question, which is the responsiveness to data from policymakers and and lawmakers.

So we have effectively a mixed mosaic of Westminster, the Senedd, and local government, all striving in the same broad direction. I wondered if you might have a word or two on the um how they join up in order to maximize the bang for the buck, if you don't mind my using that phrase. And are they sufficiently fleet of foot in order to meet the specific and bespoke problems as they arise in Wales? We could do that in reverse order if you wish, just to mix it up, so we might start with Ms. Crawley.

38:59 - 39:42

Sarah Crawley

Yeah, it's a very large question again. Um, I think I think it's having access to good data, and that data is held within different places.

So it's held within the local authority, or it's held within the Senedd. So actually all seeing that data and all analyzing it for a specific purpose is quite tricky to do so. We did work alongside the Bevan Foundation to look at nought to four-year-olds impacted by poverty and we used it there, and we collectively did that. So that was an effective use of data. But what we're not able to do is necessarily leverage that data as a voluntary or third sector or charitable organization.

39:43 - 39:46

Simon Hoare

And is that just due to our old friend GDPR?

39:46 - 40:43

Sarah Crawley

We only have the... yeah, we only have the data that we hold on our service users or that we work with partner organisations to calculate or to utilise for policy or practice direction. So I think it's... I think what we're seeing is we're able to then raise the voices, the stories, the experiences of those children and young people to go alongside the data that we do have. And so it's the quantitative and the qualitative experiences. And I think that's probably more our area of bringing change, we would hope, and focus and rigour, I suppose, to actually addressing the issues of child poverty. But what we're not seeing is an alignment of data and information between, say, the Welsh Government's developing tackling child poverty strategy and the Westminster and UK Government's tackling child poverty strategy.

40:43 - 40:54

Simon Hoare

Is there an anxiety that we as a committee should be aware of, of effectively benign turf warfare getting in the way of maximising meaningful solutions?

40:54 - 41:11

Sarah Crawley

I don't think I'd call it turf warfare. I think Welsh people and Welsh Government are trying to, is trying to do the best for children and young people in Wales and is trying to tackle child poverty.

41:11 - 41:13

Speaker 20

And I'm not for a moment suggesting that they are not.

41:13 - 41:14

But what they need to do...

41:14 - 42:11

Simon Hoare

But sometimes there can be a tendency of effectively being very, very precious about remit. Oh no, that's Westminster. Oh no, that's devolved. Oh no, that's local government, etc. And that matters not a jot or tittle to people who are looking for services and support.

They don't really care where it comes from as long as they get it and it's meaningful in delivering change. So I suppose the question I'm asking directly, and would in all honesty appreciate a sort of, you know, black or white answer, is: should we be concerned of sort of territorial protections getting in the way of maximizing solutions?

And I think... I can see Laurie is absolutely itching, itching, she's barely restraining herself there. And then we'll come to Mabli afterwards.

42:11 - 43:17

Laurie Ryall

Sorry, Mabli. No, I think you have identified a really key issue.

And whilst the UK government and Welsh government are aligned in some aspects of this strategy, as I think I mentioned earlier, we've seen instances where the universal basic income pilot, for example, is, you know, that was rolled out and it had unintended consequences because there wasn't a join-up between the Welsh government and UK government. And we're now looking at the canal payment, for example, in Wales and looking at how we can work together. And that really needs to happen quickly to make sure that that doesn't have unintended consequences. So I think there are areas where there needs to be better alignment. We need to, we need to stop the kind of, oh, this is your area, that's your area, because different levels of government are working on different things and they're working in silos.

And that creates real difficulty. And going back to kind of accessing benefits, again, that's a real challenge because there's some benefits at Welsh government level, or it might be through the UK government, DWP, and there's different access routes to all of that, which is overwhelming for families. So they can't always, they don't always know what they're entitled to or where to go. It's confusing. It's a minefield.

And there's no single point of access. So I think there is work that we, that we need to do in that space.

43:17 - 43:25

Simon Hoare

Thank you. That's, that's enormously helpful.

Ms. Jones, a word or two on that, and then and then other Ms. Jones, I then really will shut up.

43:25 - 44:48

Mabli Jones

And yeah, just yeah, reiterating a lot of what Laurie's said there actually around how some of that joined-up working isn't happening. So we know that not all local authorities in Wales have data-sharing agreements with DWP, for example, which if that was done more effectively, we know people would be accessing more of the support they're entitled to. But yeah, I think the Cennad pilot is going to be a key test of that sort of attitude that you're referring to, because we commissioned expert legal advice earlier this year which showed that Welsh Government does have the power under devolved powers to introduce a child payment for Wales.

But the risk is that DWP and HMRC treat the Cannah payment as income and then families actually lose out some of that money that should be coming to them. And I think it's a good example of something where if UK Government were able to facilitate that pilot happening, we can then, you know, there's a lot of learning that can come from these schemes about what works to tackle child poverty. And, you know, we've seen in Scotland with the introduction of the Scottish child payment that that's had a real impact on driving down rates of child poverty there, so there's a lot we can learn from that.

44:48 - 44:51

Speaker 23

Thank you, I'm very grateful. Thank you, Chair.

44:51 - 44:53

Speaker 22

Yeah, go on, Tom.

44:53 - 45:45

Tom Wernham

If it, I'll be very quick. No, no, no, forgive me. I'm sorry, sorry. No worries.

I was just going to add my voice to some of this. One interesting thing I found, you know, when I've just spoken to various civil servants in the Welsh Government in in recent months, they often had a different view on precisely what the powers were in terms of, yeah, Wales's power to do things like the council and and that kind of thing. And that doesn't seem like a very healthy setup for effective policymaking if the policymakers don't know what the powers are. So in that one sense in which there really should be coordination. And just to add my voice that, you know, there should be more effective data sharing between governments and even within governments as well.

You know, often UK Government departments don't share data with each other in the most timely manner and they'll say they have good reasons for that. But, yeah, and I don't want to make an overall judgment, but that's definitely a pattern that we see all the time. So, yeah.

45:45 - 45:46

Thank you, Chair.

45:46 - 45:54

Ruth Jones

Thank you. And the lack of data or the lack of coherent and joined-up data is something I think we will be returning to. Thank you for highlighting. Andrew Ranger, please.

45:54 - 46:14

Andrew Steven Ranger

So, having just, I think we've agreed that we all need to work better together, I just want to focus on the UK government's strategy separately. So I think starting with Mabli Jones, I would just be really interested to hear what you think the key barriers are that may prevent Wales from achieving the ambitions of the UK government's child poverty strategy.

46:14 - 47:58

Mabli Jones

Yeah, I suppose it depends what you define as the ambitions in that strategy. I think our opinion of that strategy is that it isn't sufficiently ambitious given all the levers that are at the disposal of the UK government.

While we did welcome the decision as part of that strategy to lift the two-child benefit cap, we know that that on its own isn't likely to be sufficient to tackle child poverty and that forecasts by Joseph Rowntree Foundation show that over the coming years that child poverty rates are likely to creep back up without further action. So I think that's important to note. It's probably also important to note that Welsh government obviously has its own child poverty strategy and it has a legal duty since the 2010 Children and Families Measure to have a strategy to eradicate child poverty. So there are going to be different priorities. And we know that the new Welsh government is committed to developing a new Welsh child poverty strategy and has particular policies in this area.

It's one of its priorities in government, which, yeah, I suppose does take us back to that question of how well these sort of different strategies work together.

And I suppose there's also a point about often UK Government policies undermining efforts in Wales to tackle child poverty. Like we heard the example earlier about, despite housing being a devolved area, you know, local housing allowance isn't, and that's a huge driver of poverty for families in the private rented sector.

47:58 - 48:25

Andrew Steven Ranger

Right, thank you. Yeah, it probably might be fairer of me just to outline what the child poverty UK Government strategy was around the themes, just so we're all talking about things. That was a bit unfair of me not to do that. But, you know, the main three themes they were looking at was boosting family incomes, driving down the cost of essentials, and strengthening local support, such as the Pride in Place programme and things like that. So that's sort of the strategy themes there.

48:25 - 48:29

Speaker 24

But if I can come with the same main question to Laurie, please.

48:29 - 49:15

Laurie Ryall

Yeah, I think in terms of realizing the ambitions, I think we've talked about some of the things already. We mentioned there is a focus within that around getting people back into work, but actually for a lot of families living in Wales, they're unable to work, whether because they've got caring responsibilities or health or disability needs, so they can't get into work. So we can't just focus on work being a route out of poverty because that isn't going to work for a number of our families. Working in silos, as we may have already mentioned, is another barrier, and that's something that we really need to overcome. And there is a kind of lack of indicators and milestones, I think, set out within that.

And I know for the Welsh government, they are now currently looking at what those measures and targets could be within the Welsh strategy, but it's unclear what they are within the UK strategy at the minute.

49:16 - 50:52

Sarah Crawley

Very, very similar points, to be honest. The depth of poverty that we're seeing and experiencing, I think is... trying to lift 32% of children out of relative poverty and deep poverty is a big target. So we would welcome some aligned measures between both strategies. Also, social security system, which we've already talked about, it's just not sufficient at the moment to be able to afford those families what they need to not be in relative poverty. And I've mentioned it earlier, we have a lack of data and information about families, particularly with no recourse to public funds.

And so they're not even experiencing that safety net. They're unable to access Universal Credit, Child Tax Credits, etc.

So we've got a very hidden group of children who are in those families experiencing poverty, and they're more likely to experience deep poverty and they're more likely to experience homelessness. So I don't think we can see child poverty strategies as homogeneous. I think we have to see them as layered. And we've done examples earlier, didn't we, Mabli, where we mentioned the Bevan and Barnardo's report, and that looked at nought to four-year-olds, and the sort of likelihood of nought to four-year-olds to be in poverty within families is far higher than other age groups. So we need to have a nuanced and addressed and targeted poverty strategies that are actually aligned with clear measures around those groups and around those targeted indicators and drivers for change that we really need to see.

50:52 - 53:18

Tom Wernham

I suppose in some sense the challenge is the same in Wales and the rest of the UK. It's just a question of, you know, what happens to incomes in general and the fact that the really fast ways to achieve reductions in poverty through the benefit systems are also the most costly. Earnings and employment of course has to be taken seriously as a lever, but I agree there are these challenges. And to add an example, there's been policies in the past where, you know, through the benefit system with tightened conditionality, the UK government has tried to get more parents into work, but they've got into low-earning jobs, part-time jobs that don't really help for long-term career progression. So, you know, that's not going to provide a huge amount of help for families in terms of long-term getting them out of poverty.

Thinking about, yeah, the sort of wider ambitions, I mean, clearly, you know, there's some areas where the Welsh government just has more responsibility for, you know, local services or education and health than the UK government, so it's just going to be a question of whether the policy priorities are aligned and, you know, whether they're talking to each other, making sure policies don't undermine each other. On the indicators point, I think the UK government does have quite a good range of indicators broadly in terms of it's not just looking at incomes, it's looking at spending on core essentials, that kind of thing, but it's not disaggregated, you know, very much, it's not zooming in on Wales and it can't because the survey data you need for that is just not large enough in Wales. So, yeah, more evidence to be able to answer these quick questions of, you know, which particular groups in Wales and in the rest of the UK are struggling would be valuable.

And yeah, just this joined-up working thing again, I think is important. Another sort of example I recall from the English case was when the removal of the two-child limit was announced. That was announced quite late and so local councils in England were not able to adjust their own support schemes to sort of take account for that. And some families will have seen lower council tax support because of a UK government increasing their benefits, which probably wasn't anyone's intention, but it's just a matter of policy announcements happening in a timely manner and the data being shared in a timely manner. And that kind of thing could easily happen between the UK government and the Welsh government as well, just if policy intentions aren't communicated well and if the data isn't shared so that these policies can be designed in tandem.

53:18 - 53:20

Speaker 26

Thank you all. Thank you, Chair.

53:20 - 53:23

Ruth Jones

We're going to move on to the rural issues of Wales now, and I'm going to move on to Ben Lake, please.

53:23 - 53:42

Ben Morgan Lake

Thank you chair and thank you all for appearing before us this afternoon. Can I turn to Ms Jones first and following on from the UK government strategy ask whether you think there are any particular challenges for rural Wales in particular from benefiting from the UK government strategy?

53:42 - 55:19

Mabli Jones

Yes definitely. And I mean one I think you know has been alluded to already but I think for us as well it's not just about the communities that we consider purely rural. We've been doing a lot of work this year with communities in Caerphilly borough and many of those communities are sort of as cut off from services as as more sort of traditionally considered rural areas.

So I think, you know, some of the issues that come up when we talk to families all over the country in those rural, post-industrial, coastal areas are transport. That's a consistent theme. And, you know, we know that access, public transport provision has fallen in terms of, you know, reliable, accessible bus routes and bus services being a really key one. And, you know, the impact that has on people's ability then to access employment opportunities, training opportunities, just getting back and forth to services or childcare settings. That all sort of increases a family's likelihood of living in poverty.

And we know that a third of low-income households in Wales don't have access to a car. So particularly if you are living in a rural area, you know, that makes life much harder and it makes your ability to access support or increase your income or manage costs is a lot harder.

55:19 - 55:50

Ben Morgan Lake

Diolch yn fawr iawn i chi i gyd am hynny. Ms Crawley, do you have anything to add in terms of the challenges that more rural areas, whether, and I think it's important perhaps we need to be clear about as to what we mean by rural areas now, and perhaps I might suggest, you know, access and transport or the lack of public transport might be a helpful definition in that regard. But other specific issues that you have identified for rural areas benefiting from the UK government's strategy?

55:50 - 57:14

Sarah Crawley

I think Barnardo's in Wales, we're actually predominantly a sort of town and city-based charity working with families. But when we have worked in rural areas, we've often seen those areas quite cut off. For example, some of the Merthyr Valleys communities, as you say, if only a third of people haven't got access to a car, you're relying on bus routes. Also access to schools as well and access to education. If you live more than three miles away from a school, then you can potentially get access to home-to-school transport.

But if you live less than three miles, then you don't have that funding support. So you could be walking your child to school or ensuring your child gets to school sort of five miles a day. And so that's putting a strain on time and ability to work, access to transport, access to education.

So we've also got the oil issue, haven't you as well? In terms of rurality has often oil containers for heating. It's much more expensive, it's more difficult, much more costly to fill up. So we've got certain communities living with that issue as well and no great solution to that at all. So that's what we've seen generally, but yeah, most of it's towns, city communities that we're working with.

57:14 - 57:26

Ben Morgan Lake

Oh, thank you. And as an MP representing an area with 73% of households off-grid, I very much hear your concern about the heating oil situation. And Ms. Ryall, do you have anything you'd like to add?

57:26 - 58:12

Laurie Ryall

Yes, thank you. Well, within Action for Children Wales, we do support a number of families who live in rural communities, both in North and South and West Wales.

And actually, last year, Action for Children took part in the Welsh Government lived experience exercise to try and get the voices of children and young people. And some of the themes that came from that in terms of for those families who are living in rural communities were raising exactly the things we've been talking about today: the challenges with transport, accessibility of services, the lack of opportunities for children and young people within those rural areas, meaning actually those young people are much more isolated. It affects their emotional wellbeing. They don't have the experience of even leaving their community area. And that unfortunately sometimes can build this generational sense of, well, there's nothing out there for me, we'll just stay where we are, unfortunately.

58:12 - 58:18

Speaker 29

So there are lots of issues I think with the rural areas that we need to consider.

58:18 - 58:21

Speaker 28

Thank you very much.

And finally, Mr. Wernham.

58:21 - 59:13

Tom Wernham

Yeah, I think, you know, from my perspective, one important thing to consider is that, you know, the broad income poverty statistics do not take account of lots of the differences in costs between rural and urban areas. And also, you know, the benefit system doesn't take account of all of these differences in costs either. So those main levers and some of these main indicators aren't going to shed light on all of these issues. Now, it seems, you know, we're all still aware of them because we are talking about them and that's good. But I think it's important to just, you know, bear in mind that there aren't loads of sort of indicators that's going to help us very easily track progress in this over time, which is a bit of a shame.

So I think there should be a focus on, you know, trying to make sure there is the survey data there to try and actually, you know, measure the prevalence of these difficulties and test if policies going forward are helpful at addressing them.

59:13 - 59:28

Ruth Jones

Thank you very much.

Yes, I'm conscious of time and we have a lot more questions to get through. So your answers are really comprehensive, but if a point's already been made, you're more than welcome to reference I've made that point, whatever. So that would be really helpful. But let me move on to David Chadwick, please.

59:28 - 01:00:13

David Chadwick

So on that note, I definitely want to emphasize the importance of transport, please. I mean, Brecon, for example, used to have a direct service to Cardiff, which obviously meant, you know, it was easier for local residents to be connected with employment opportunities all the way to Cardiff. But then going the other way, it made it easier for tourists to get to Brecon, and clearly tourism is one of our major industries. So that's had a disastrous knock-on impact. But my question is for Tom.

What are the distinct economic challenges in rural Wales that we should consider when talking about child poverty? And I fully agreed with Sarah when she mentioned the importance of heating oil and LPG, because those prices are going through the roof at the moment.

01:00:13 - 01:00:56

Tom Wernham

Yeah, I don't have a huge amount of detail to say on this point. You know, once just looking at the sort of broad patterns in labour market, it seems like, you know, rural pay versus urban pay is a significant factor here. Sort of rural employment rates aren't, you know, the difference doesn't seem to be too great with urban areas, but the jobs are lower paid. And that interacts with transport in that there's sort of less opportunity for people to sort of migrate within Wales to those higher paid opportunities. And then, yeah, beyond that, it's just thinking really carefully about what are the extra costs faced in rural areas that might be missed by the system as it is, and what are the optimal policy levers to really target those.

01:00:56 - 01:00:59

Speaker 30

But yeah, I don't have a huge amount to add beyond that.

01:00:59 - 01:01:01

Speaker 31

Let's move back to Ben Lake.

01:01:01 - 01:01:37

Ben Morgan Lake

Thank you and and forgive me, Mr. Wernham, I'm coming back to you. Something you mentioned in in answer to my question there about the statistics and and that they don't always perhaps, and please tell me if I'm misquoting you, but you know, reflect the differences between the challenges that an urban household may have and and a rural one. Would it be correct therefore to conclude that the the way that we currently measure poverty and the statistics we currently use fail to truly appreciate and give us a proper idea of, you know, rural poverty, however we might wish to define rural?

01:01:37 - 01:03:04

Tom Wernham

Essentially, I mean, so the really headline income poverty statistics, they only take account for costs in so far as you've got families of different size and differences in housing costs. They don't take account of any of these other different costs at all, so you know, they're going to be very much blind to that. And indeed, you know, maybe one area has higher housing costs than another, but because they've got better public services so people, you know, want to live there, so it can sometimes get, you know, I think in general the after housing cost measures of poverty are better at predicting deprivation. You need to be a bit careful when comparing between areas, sometimes, you know, there can be other things going on like that example.

And then beyond that, you know, we've got our material deprivation indicators and those sorts of things which should, you know, indirectly take account of these different costs in that, you know, even if they're not explicitly asking about the transport available and the types of heating available, you know, if these things are eating up the budgets of families, then that might make them more likely to, you know, be unable to afford essentials. So we do have the statistics there that should be getting at these things. Whether they are, you know, really optimally getting some of these specific rural factors, maybe not, but you know, I'm not actually an expert in what those specific factors are, so I can't be definitive on that. But then just the point I've made several times now of we've got just really small sample sizes. So even with the best measures in the world, we're asking so few people in Wales and in urban Wales and rural Wales that the measures bounce about year to year.

01:03:04 - 01:03:07

Speaker 32

It's really hard to rigorously keep track.

01:03:07 - 01:03:38

Ben Morgan Lake

And on that specific point there, we received some evidence last week as a committee that touched on the survey data or the inadequacy of the survey data from Wales just because of the small sample. And I'm just wondering how useful would it be if, for example, a government body of some sort, I won't name which, might decide, right, let's get a better baseline understanding here and actually invest in more extensive survey data. How helpful would that be?

01:03:38 - 01:04:48

Tom Wernham

I think, you know, more data is always going to be helpful as long as it's, you know, designed in a sensible way. So, you know, if your goal is to just sort of boost the sample size for income measures or deprivation measures, you would want to make sure you're asking the same questions so you can sort of combine those measures together. By all means ask additional questions as well to find out, you know, Wales-specific information. But you don't want to end up with a different survey that's asking questions in a different way so you can't pull it together. So that's important.

The other point is that with surveys in general we've seen big drops in response rates in recent years.

So it's not just about the numbers of people you survey, but are they representative of the population? And, you know, we've got reasons to think that's got worse even at a UK level. I haven't studied specifically what the situation is in Wales, but, you know, I wouldn't be surprised if, you know, we've also got concerns about representativeness there. And partly you can get around that by reweighting the data, which we do, but that's not going to solve all of this problem, especially when you've got really low proportions of people actually answering the survey. So thinking about how you make sure you reach everybody with a survey, how you incentivize people to answer and to give accurate answers is also important.

01:04:48 - 01:04:51

Speaker 33

Thank you very much. Llinos Medi, please.

01:04:51 - 01:05:31

Llinos Medi

Diolch. Diolch.

And this is about intergovernmental working, and you have touched on this, so if you've already answered that, obviously don't repeat. But the importance of that cooperation between the UK government, Welsh government, and also local government in ending that child poverty. And do you think that both those three layers are committed to work in partnership? And you have already touched on it with the Connell payment, and do you think the Connell payment might be the first test in that intergovernmental working as well? So maybe, Ms. Crawley, you started on this, so can I start with yourself because you touched a bit on this?

01:05:31 - 01:06:52

Sarah Crawley

Yeah, I would say the Connell payment is definitely the testbed for us. If we can get DWP and Welsh government and others working together, then we can get that devolution and that devolved powers, then that would be fantastic. But it's only ten pounds that they're suggesting. I mean, it's quite small, but it will support many, many families.

But it's probably not enough. We've already talked about the benefit system, social security system being part of the big driver for getting families out of poverty. So I think it's a good start, but it needs to go much, much further in terms of that. My thing would be around local authorities understanding their own data. So understanding the poverty levels of single parent households or understanding the poverty levels of larger families and actually looking at services that can be targeted towards those communities.

We do have certain programs, Flying Start, Families First, Communities First, which we've had for quite a long time. But they're supporting families in these issues and with these issues, but they're not putting money in their pockets.

They're not putting the direct money in their pockets that's what they need. So I would be advocating for a better and greater understanding at a local level and powers and changes at a devolved and Westminster level.

01:06:52 - 01:06:57

Speaker 35

Can I ask Mabli Jones as well about that?

01:06:57 - 01:08:17

Mabli Jones

Um, yeah, definitely. And, you know, the Welsh Government does have the power to to introduce that payment. Um, what it doesn't have is the power to to legislate to give it a um longer-term basis um as Scotland did because they obviously had deep further devolution of um powers over social security.

But what is needed from DWP and HMRC in the short term just with that pilot is to agree not to treat that ten pounds a week as additional income for those families to make sure that that pilot's able to operate effectively and that we can see, you know, what difference it might make. And, you know, as Sarah said, it is only a ten pound a week pilot, whereas the full child payment in Scotland is just over twenty-eight pounds a week, which, you know, per child can obviously make a big difference in terms of families' experiences. But yeah, we'd definitely longer term want to see that sort of full program and roll out. But we do, we do think that that we would want to see further devolution of powers over social security to give that a legislative long-term basis and, you know, potentially the additional funding that comes with that devolution as well.

01:08:17 - 01:08:19

Speaker 36

Anybody else want to add?

01:08:19 - 01:08:53

Laurie Ryall

Can I just add one quick thing just to build on what Mabli just said in terms of that longer-term support, that that is really key.

I think a number of the the measures that are in place at the moment provide crisis support. And actually what we need to be looking at is how can we support families in a much longer-term approach rather than at the point when they're in crisis and then we're providing crisis grants or discretionary assistance funds. Within Action for Children, we've we continue to provide crisis grants for families even though they do already have access to the discretionary assistance fund, for example. So it's that longer-term need that's key.

01:08:53 - 01:08:55

Speaker 37

Yeah. Andrew, please.

01:08:55 - 01:09:28

Andrew Steven Ranger

Thank you. So returning to this point about cooperation between governments. So I know we've touched on quite a lot of this already, but if there's any points just to add. So two elements to this question.

You know, so how does having two child poverty strategies, Wales and the UK level, influence the degree of cooperation and coordination between the two governments? And in future, how could it strengthen it, or shouldn't it? You know, so if I go to Laurie Ryall first on that.

01:09:28 - 01:09:58

Laurie Ryall

Yeah, absolutely. I think having two separate strategies across UK government and Welsh government isn't a bad thing on its own, but actually there's a lot more join-up that is needed. We see that there is some crossover across the two areas, but actually how is the Welsh government strategy influencing the UK government strategy and what are the consistent measures around that? I don't know whether Mabli might have a better answer than me for that one.

01:09:58 - 01:11:07

Mabli Jones

I don't know if it's a better answer, but yeah, I think you'd naturally expect to have two different strategies because the governments have different responsibilities and powers over different areas. And you know, likewise, some local authorities as well will have their own anti-poverty strategies for areas that they're responsible for. I'd say, you know, in general, our sense is that some of the weaknesses to those child poverty strategies at both the UK and Welsh government level in the past have been very similar in terms of, you know, both current strategies from both governments do, they lack clear milestones and targets, which is something that we would want to see.

And yeah, going back to Laurie's point actually about often the programs or policies that are put in place are more about dealing with the, mitigating the impacts of poverty rather than really tackling those root causes. So that's something that we would like to see a lot more of from both governments.

01:11:07 - 01:12:12

Andrew Steven Ranger

It's interesting that you say that because, you know, we said right at the start that actually child poverty's remained pretty constant for the last 20 years or so in Wales. And I think that there's similar figures from across the UK. So, you know, ultimately, are we ever going to solve this by the types of systems we've got now, or do we actually need to, while helping people in need at the current time is obviously clearly important, obviously, are we always going to rely on redistributive policies, or do we actually, as you just mentioned, need to actually get to these root causes?

So some of them have been mentioned: it's transport, it's infrastructure, we've talked about jobs and economy and those services. So, because it feels sometimes that sometimes we entrench it rather than actually providing services and support to people to actually get them out of it. And I'm probably being quite simplistic there, but it just feels like we're never going to solve this because there's so much great work being done, but as we said, it's not changed in 20-odd years. I don't know if Mabli wanted to come back on that.

01:12:12 - 01:13:42

Mabli Jones

Yeah, and no, it's a good question. And I suppose when we're talking about what drives poverty, it's the dual issue of people's incomes not being sufficient to meet their costs.

And, you know, that is ultimately what's behind the fact that those child poverty levels haven't shifted because people's incomes, whether that's from work or the social security system, haven't really kept pace with how much costs have gone up. So I think, yeah, if we want to tackle the root causes of poverty, that's where work needs to focus. So, you know, that can be things that are in the UK government's hands, like the social security system, sort of overall powers of the labour market and the economy. But there's a lot that Welsh government can do as well. You know, housing costs are obviously a huge driver of poverty, and, you know, Welsh government does have a lot of powers over housing.

It has, you know, powers over things like childcare, which is why we've advocated for, you know, more funded childcare hours on a universal basis to enable more parents to take up work or to take up more hours of work because there's a very clear link between the number of parents in a household and the amount of hours they work and that children in the household's likelihood of living in poverty. So it needs to happen at different levels. But, yeah, it definitely always needs to, from our perspective, always needs to keep those sort of core drivers in mind.

01:13:42 - 01:13:47

Speaker 38

Yeah, thank you. Did anyone from the panel want to add anything to that that's not been said? No?

01:13:47 - 01:13:48

Not compulsory, no.

01:13:48 - 01:13:52

Ruth Jones

That's great, yeah. No, thank you very much. Okay, Henry Tufnell, please.

01:13:52 - 01:14:24

Henry Tufnell

Thank you, Chair. Can I just ask, the honourable member for North Dorset talked about turf warfare. So I was wondering whether we could talk a little bit more about that, about whether, you know, we've got agencies, UK Government agencies like the Jobcentres, then we've got Welsh Government agencies, local authority action.

Can we have some real-world examples where these agencies are helping or hindering, you know, the addressing, trying to bring down child poverty across the country?

01:14:24 - 01:14:26

Speaker 40

Who would like to start?

01:14:26 - 01:15:17

Laurie Ryall

Yeah. I suppose from our experience, there are some good examples of where local authorities are providing a single point of access, for example, for our families. And that single point of access will link into a range of support systems to be able to bring families to one point of contact to say, this is all the support you're entitled to, this is where you can get it from, and we can help you with that. And that is where it is working really well. For other families, it is a bit of a postcode lottery because local authorities don't always do that consistently.

So then families don't know where they can access support, how they can access it, who they need to speak to, and it becomes a complicated system of application forms, criteria that they don't really understand.

So I think something that's working well is when local authorities have a single point of access that links into all those different factors, all those different areas across governments and is able to give that information to families.

01:15:17 - 01:15:39

Henry Tufnell

Because you have skills advisors in England, that's sort of done by Careers Wales in, but I don't know how as another example of whether agencies are helping or hindering their meeting their objectives as a sort of concrete example. I don't know whether that's helpful to focus in on more specifics, but appreciate your point there about local authorities and a single point of access.

01:15:39 - 01:15:57

Sarah Crawley

We in Wales as a charity don't support parents directly to get into employment, training or skills, so we do leave it to existing organisations and parties.

That doesn't mean we don't direct them to them and signpost them to them, but we wouldn't directly do that as a charity.

01:15:57 - 01:16:29

Henry Tufnell

Okay. Does anyone else have anything to add? Do you mind if I slightly change the topic slightly, a little bit? Just because I don't think we've talked about education. So I was wondering about the impact of education.

We've seen the shocking results that have come out of Wales in respect to the PISA scores, so in terms of Welsh children being behind England even two years on science and consistently performing worse. Can you comment on whether you think that's had an impact on a higher child rate, higher child poverty rate in Wales as opposed to other parts of the UK?

01:16:29 - 01:17:03

Laurie Ryall

Can I reverse the question?

Because I think for me, the impact of child poverty is affecting the educational attainment rates for children across Wales, rather than it being the other way around. So as I mentioned right at the beginning of the committee, children who are living in poor home conditions with families who can't afford to put food on the table or heat their home or have bedding or a bed to sleep in at night, that is going to impact not only their emotional well-being, but their ability to engage well with education, to be able to achieve what they actually potentially could achieve had they had all that support in place and had they had a reasonable standard of living. So for me, it's about poverty impacting education.

01:17:03 - 01:17:26

Henry Tufnell

But if you look at London, right, in terms of after housing costs, the percentage of children in relatively low income, 23, 22, 23 to 24, 25, London has 38% after housing costs. Obviously, quality of education in London has gone up. So how, in terms of reconciling those figures, how would you view those?

01:17:26 - 01:17:39

Laurie Ryall

It's difficult to compare London to Wales for a start.

I think they're very different geographic areas, and there's lots of things, you know, without me understanding that data set completely, I don't know if I can answer that, but whether Tom, you've got anything to add?

01:17:39 - 01:19:31

Tom Wernham

Yeah, I've, I mean, we've done some sort of research in this area which is, you know, relevant to this question. I think, you know, we can think of, you know, a potential causal direction in both ways. I think, you know, poor education today might lead to lower earnings in the future, lower, you know, poverty rates going forward when they grow up. In terms of the other way round, you know, we've got very, you know, broadly speaking, stark correlations with poorer children doing worse educationally than, than richer children. It's not clear, you know, the best way to actually close that gap, whether, so one example we've looked at is the two-child limit, where we were actually able to evaluate the effect on early educational attainment of the two-child limit.

The way the policy was designed meant you could get quite a convincing, you know, group who were affected and group who weren't, who were otherwise very similar. And even though that two-child limit really drastically reduced children's family incomes, it didn't seem to move the dial in terms of their early educational test scores at all. That doesn't rule out effects down the line. But that's one point, you know, that doesn't mean that there isn't interactions between poverty and educational attainment, but it might be a question of improving access to services and things rather than just giving, you know, cash income in terms of closing that gap.

Whereas, you know, where we've looked at Sure Start centres in England, they were shown to have quite strong effects on educational outcomes by comparison. So, you know, to some extent, if that finding is sort of borne out as we look at other outcomes, it does make the job a little bit harder of do you want to really support living standards now, or do you want to sort of close some of those longer-term inequalities with, you know, more targeted measures through services and so on. But yeah, it's a question where there's sort of ongoing research to do in terms of what's the causal connection between income and these wider outcomes.

01:19:31 - 01:19:33

Speaker 41

Let me bring in Simon Hoare.

01:19:33 - 01:20:46

Simon Hoare

Thank you. Can I just follow up on Henry's question really with Ms Ryall, because I'm, forgive me, I'm a little bit confused. Maybe you can help me.

Mr. Tuffnell asked you a question, you said no, you've reversed the question, that poverty is feeding into lower educational attainment. And the poverty figures show, as Mr. Tuffnell's pointed out, that London is higher up in terms of the poverty figures when housing costs are taken into account than Wales is. And yet London's educational attainment, notwithstanding that data, is markedly higher than Wales. So either Mr. Tuffnell was asking the question in the right order, or your contention is rather, it's not passing my sort of logic test.

01:20:46 - 01:21:01

Ruth Jones

But I think the witnesses have already answered the question in the way they wanted to present the evidence that they gave.

So I think that's, you know, if they wanted to reverse the question and then say that you can't compare, you know, London and Wales, then I think we accept that's their evidence.

01:21:01 - 01:21:01

But if, it will manifest itself with some nuance, but if poverty is poverty is poverty, if the lack of, the impact of a lack of a bed, a lack of bedding, a lack of a hot meal in the evening, etc., is going to have a broadly similar impact on an individual irrespective of where they are living, there must be some correlation surely as Mr Tuffnell appeared to be driving us towards, which is you get into this sort of spiral that lower educational attainment feeds into less opportunity for well-paid economic activity and it also reduces the attractiveness of entrepreneurs, of investors, of jobs.

01:21:53 - 01:22:03

Simon Hoare

So the two are inextricably linked, are they not, irrespective of which end of the telescope you might be looking?

01:22:03 - 01:22:13

Laurie Ryall

Yes, I think that's a fair point, but I still stand by my original point that actually the impact of poverty does affect children in terms of their educational attainment.

01:22:13 - 01:22:31

Sarah Crawley

And I would say you're not taking into account some other dynamic factors of rurality, lack of access to services in general, lack of access to educational materials, lack of access to opportunities that they might have in London, lack of access to the school that they might have.

01:22:32 - 01:22:36

Speaker 42

So there are other dynamic factors that are at play, I would say, within that position.

01:22:36 - 01:22:46

Speaker 44

Okay, but let's just... Yeah, okay, that's a fair comment. So if... Tom also wants to come in too.

01:22:46 - 01:23:25

Tom Wernham

Yeah, I would just say, look, you can't just compare London and Wales and say, you know, one's got higher poverty but also higher education. There are lots of other factors at play in terms of your access to services, in terms of quality of the schools and those sorts of things. I think, you know, where we have been able to do this research on the two-child limit, that's sort of isolating the effect of income but holding everything else constant. And that tells us that, okay, maybe if you just, you know, give poorer families more money and do nothing else, that won't necessarily move the dial on these gaps, but it doesn't mean that you shouldn't target resources at poorer families in other ways to try and close these.

01:23:25 - 01:23:29

Speaker 43

Absolutely.

But let's just tease out...

01:23:29 - 01:23:31

Speaker 45

Well, I'm conscious of time, Simon, and we do need to move on.

01:23:31 - 01:24:28

Simon Hoare

Yeah, but but can we because I I just think you're asking us to accept on the face of it what you believe to be true without necessarily having it fully interrogated. So let's so let's move away from London and look at the North West figures, again after housing, 32% identical to Wales. Um, the part of the country that I'm lucky enough to represent, the South West of England in Dorset, 21%, a differential clearly between that and and Wales.

You go to the North East where there will be very similar demographics and geographies and access points and everything else, similar to Wales, sitting at 30%, much closer to the Welsh figure of 32. And yet educational attainment is better in England than it is in Wales. So there must be something else that's playing into that.

01:24:28 - 01:24:31

Ruth Jones

Okay, that's a major point, Simon. Thank you very much.

01:24:31 - 01:24:33

Speaker 46

Well, if it's more a question than a point.

01:24:33 - 01:24:43

Ruth Jones

I know, but I'm conscious that education is not an issue that we're covering today. We're looking at child poverty. I accept the links with education. I'm going to bring in Selaine Saxby at that point.

01:24:43 - 01:25:28

Llinos Medi

Yeah, and I think I'm going to ask the question, the data being used here is after housing costs, and you did mention it at the beginning. So can you please explain the housing cost and the pressures on Welsh families due to rurality, due to deprivation, deindustrialization for decades and so on, that this alone for falling housing costs isn't a true reflection of the challenges faced our facing our children and young people, and then how they can then succeed educationally in those communities as well? And maybe you can evidence that if you can, if you have any of that as well. I mean, maybe do you want me to turn to Mabli first?

01:25:28 - 01:27:01

Mabli Jones

Um, yeah, I think it's important to note that there is a belief that the lower child poverty rates in Scotland and Northern Ireland are in part due to lower housing costs in those in those parts of the UK, whereas in England and Wales, we do have in general higher housing costs, and there's a very clear link there with that as a driver of poverty.

And members will know that those high housing costs apply across the country and there are pressures around the supply of social housing, affordable housing, the private rented sector that apply all over the country and there's a really clear link there with families' experiences. And then on the point about the different measures of poverty, I think it is an important one.

There's no single measure of poverty that is perfect and that will be able to give you a complete picture of children and families' experiences on their own. So I think what we would recommend, particularly as the Welsh Government develops its new child poverty strategy, is to look at including measures and targets across a range of different measures of poverty, because sort of taken together they can provide a more complete picture of, you know, incomes, costs, material deprivation, depth of poverty, and that's needed to sort of give a more complete picture.

01:27:01 - 01:27:03

Speaker 47

Let me bring in David Chadwick.

01:27:03 - 01:27:10

David Chadwick

This is a very quick question. Laurie, you mentioned that there's one local authority where they have a single point of access. Which local authority was that?

01:27:11 - 01:27:13

Speaker 48

Thanks.

01:27:13 - 01:27:18

Speaker 49

I like that. That's marvelous. Let's move on to Llinos Medi, please.

01:27:18 - 01:27:53

Llinos Medi

Diolch.

Yeah, we were fortunate over the summer that we were able to have an in this inquiry, we sat down with the young farmers members so that we were able to speak to teenagers and young people and the impact of rural poverty and so on. But obviously, the voice of young people, children and young people is extremely important. And have you any good examples where young children and young people have been able to influence and share their experience and then see a policy change following their intervention? So I'll start with Laurie.

01:27:53 - 01:29:22

Laurie Ryall

Well, across Action for Children, we actually have young ambassadors who support us. And they're from across Wales, but also from across the UK. So we have young ambassadors from every nation who are able to share their experiences with us and share the experiences of other young people. And that influences policy change within Action for Children.

But we also give them the space to be able to speak to councillors, MPs, MSs where possible so that they can directly influence decision-making as well. We also have a young person within our Headlands School who attends the Welsh Youth Parliament, so they're able to influence from that perspective, which is a really good opportunity for them and they feel really valued and heard within that, which is really, really helpful. I think what we we have also seen, unfortunately, is that young people are often engaged in consultations and they share their experiences. And I think it's important to note that when children do share their experiences, they can often feel quite vulnerable in that, even if it's just writing that down, because for them they can be embarrassed, as I mentioned earlier, or it just brings up feelings of trauma that they're having to relive. And they don't always hear back from those consultations about, okay, what's actually happened following on from this?

What has my voice led to? What change has it led to? What's the impact it's had?

So we talk about kind of consultation fatigue as well, which is which is a real thing. And I think we mentioned earlier the lack of uptake in surveys and I suppose we don't want to risk doing the same thing to our children and families and then them not willing to engage so that we can't hear what their voices are saying.

01:29:22 - 01:32:08

Sarah Crawley

I'll give you a really quick example of where we've really raised children and young people's voices. Young carers in Newport. So we run a Newport young carers service. Education maintenance allowance was doubled with their voices going directly to the Senedd to say we need more money to be able to access our education, to travel to school, to get the books we need and the resources we need. So that is a direct young people saying what they need, how they need access to it and what would make a big difference and change.

So we're trying to do that all the time. What I would say is that we are speaking about policy changes and and practice changes as well. And also directly influencing organisations like ourselves. How do we direct our services?

How do we direct our resources? What do we choose to do that could make a bigger difference? And we're always listening to children and young people to try and do that. We're also working with local authorities and commissioners to say, where's the feedback that we're getting? What could we do differently with this service?

How could we make it more accessible to children and young people? So we're always working within that sort of environment, a more dynamic environment of feedback. We also deliver the child poverty fund through Barnardo's as well. And whether we want to see that data or not, what it is telling us, absolutely telling us, is the levels of poverty and deprivation they're experiencing. And one of the things was a lack of opportunities that people, children and young people experience when they're living in relative poverty and deep poverty.

And I just want to give you a quick example. We've supported 1,450 children and young people in Wales in the last year with a spend of over £126,000 to, and it is that sticking plaster, it is that, do they need utilities payments, do they need clothing, suitable clothing, winter coats? But the one thing I wanted to focus on was 30% of that spend was actually for what we called the Winter Wonder offer. And that was children and young people saying, "I'd like a present, I'd like this this year." And that could be a toy, it could be an experience.

But actually, they weren't going to have access to that otherwise.

So we've been able to give those children and young people some treat over the festive period. And we've done the same over the summer period as well, because their friends might be getting access to days out and trips out and things that you would hope all children and young people would want to experience. They're not having access to that. So it's been charities like Barnardo's that have stepped in and really given those opportunities. So that's where we hear it most and directly from individuals: "What do you need? What would you like? And what could you have?" And we can support that.

01:32:08 - 01:32:11

Speaker 51

Yeah. Have you anything to add?

01:32:14 - 01:32:27

Llinos Medi

No. And can I just come back? You mentioned that model and you did one example of the impact on government decision. Are there any other decisions that you can say that have happened from our young people?

01:32:27 - 01:33:58

Sarah Crawley

Yeah, definitely baby bundles. So although it is postcode related in terms of deprivation and it's through the Flying Start program, on average a parents bringing their baby home from hospital, it's about five hundred pounds plus just to bring your baby home, just to have the items that you need to ensure that baby's safe, well and supported. And so we've influenced that through work with families, through work with Bevan Foundation that I referenced previously, and we now have baby bundles being implemented within Wales, which is fantastic. But it is again, it's a start for families bringing their children home. And you've got particular cases where we have parents who are incredibly anxious about bringing their child home.

Baby bundles.

We've had children through our Parent Factor program where we've assisted them with parenting skills, and we've got the Baby and Me service where we support families to try and stay together through changes in their parenting ability. And so that's actually preventing children from being removed, it's preventing children from going into care and actually costing an awful lot more money and having poorer life chances. So what we're always trying to do is ensure that we can maximize those opportunities for families to stay safely together. Baby Bundles is just one small part of that, but it's also reducing and removing that stress and anxiety at a very, very difficult time, stressful time for families. So...

01:33:58 - 01:34:41

Laurie Ryall

Sorry, I just, I'm mindful of time. Just to give one example, I think something that we have done within Action for Children again for our young carers in North Wales actually is we've developed a young carers sort of ID card and app.

And that came from young people telling us it's really, really difficult when they're having a difficult morning with caring responsibilities, they don't always want to tell people what's happened. So we've developed an app which links directly into the school so they can contact the school and say we're having a bad morning. And that change has made a real difference to the lives of young carers and that communication. We've also worked with young people around our J-review, which is around the child, the criminal exploitation of children. And young people's voices were instrumental in that whole inquiry.

And obviously there has been some changes as a result of the Crime and Policing Bill as well.

01:34:41 - 01:34:44

Speaker 52

Thank you, Sian-Nia. Ben Lake, please.

01:34:44 - 01:35:27

Ben Morgan Lake

Thank you, Chair.

I think we've discussed quite a bit about the inadequacies of the current data that is available to us. And so, I suppose the final question I would have is just that, do you believe that from the evidence and the data that we currently have, do we have a reliable and effective picture of the situation facing people in poverty in Wales at all? Whether that is, you know, is it the case that we have a firmer grasp of the levels of poverty in rural areas versus urban areas, or are there deficiencies just across the board? Mindful of time, so I don't know if Mabli I could come to you.

01:35:27 - 01:36:40

Mabli Jones

Yeah, and I don't want to repeat the points that have been made about the quality of some of that data and how it's actually reduced over time. I would say that it would be good to improve that data.

It would definitely be good to improve some of the sample sizes in Wales, particularly to allow us to go a bit more in depth around different groups and who's more likely to experience poverty, what that looks like for them. But I would say in general, that shouldn't be seen as a barrier to putting policies in place now because we do know enough in terms of which, you know, some of the larger groups that are most likely to be impacted by child poverty. So, you know, that's going back to those larger families, those with three or more children, and particularly households with a child under five in the household. There's a very, very clear link with the likelihood of the children in that household living in poverty and current policies aren't designed to support families with younger children. So there's a clear gap there where the data is showing something, but the policies aren't responding to it.

01:36:41 - 01:36:44

Speaker 53

Thank you very much.

David Chadwick, please.

01:36:44 - 01:36:54

David Chadwick

Are there any specific gaps that you would recommend are addressed as a priority, and Mabli, starting with you again?

01:36:54 - 01:37:25

Mabli Jones

Yeah, I suppose families subject to no recourse to public funds are an obvious one that have been referenced already. We also don't tend to be able to do demographic breakdowns in terms of ethnicity in Wales due to the sample sizes that we have. But, you know, there is the evidence that there is there shows that there is like a higher risk for those households from ethnic minorities to be living in poverty. So there are definitely gaps there that could be addressed.

01:37:25 - 01:37:27

Speaker 54

Laurie?

01:37:27 - 01:37:47

Laurie Ryall

I think one of the things I would say is we need to better understand the impact of some of the measures that are already in place.

So for example, we've got healthy start vouchers and we know that there's a good take-up of those and they are having an impact, but what does that mean longer term? What is the impact they're having? Does that affect longer term the benefit, does it improve the lives of families on a longer term basis?

01:37:47 - 01:37:49

Speaker 55

Nothing additional to add.

01:37:49 - 01:38:24

Tom Wernham

I'd just say, you know, very big picture, you can, we can get big picture ideas of which groups are struggling by, you know, looking over a long time period, combining data and also thinking about, you know, commonalities with the rest of the UK. Really the gap is that because we've got small sample sizes, actually trying to measure, you know, how is Wales diverging and how is that being affected by policies, that starts to become a bit of a hopeless task. So even though, yeah, we've got some big picture facts we're confident of, trying to actually precisely measure how things are changing in Wales for different groups, that just becomes really difficult with the data landscape as it is at the moment.

01:38:24 - 01:38:54

Ruth Jones

Thank you, David. And suppose just to finish, I just wonder, we've talked a lot about data today and a lot of our inquiries seem to find that data is poor across the board. But I'm just wondering if we could end on a positive note. I wonder if there's anything in terms of the data that's out there at the moment which has enabled within your organisations or within your knowledge to to make sure there's a more effective policy design or delivery? If there's anything you can think of.

Oh, Mabli's nodding her head. Let's go to Mabli first.

01:38:54 - 01:39:23

Mabli Jones

Yes, I suppose following on from my previous point about the link between having a child under five in the household and the risk of child poverty, and you know, the work we did with Barnardo's on that, I think that has helped us then advocate for new policies around increasing access to funded childcare, a child payment for the youngest children, and sort of more support targeted at those families. So I think, yeah, that would be an example from us.

01:39:23 - 01:39:48

Ruth Jones

Thank you Mabli, that's helpful. Laurie, did you have anything? No, okay. Sarah, no? Tom?

Okay, thank you so much. I'm going to bring this session to a close. Thank you very much for your time this afternoon. You've given us some really in-depth answers and I'm sure we will be using those answers to build on as we go forward in our inquiry into child poverty in Wales and how we can mitigate against it. But I want to say thank you very much to all of you and I'll now bring the session to a close.

Order, order.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.