Lords Grand Committee

16 September 2026

Lords Grand Committee House of Lords

Follow its sittings
00:36 - 08:27
Speaker 1
I gave me yesterday, um, um, in which we discussed the question of the general functions of Great British Railways, a subject that came up in on the first day in committee when the noble lord offered that meeting, which as I say took place yesterday.  I discovered in that meeting the question of GBR's functions is a great deal more complicated in the noble lord's mind even than we discovered when we debated it here.  And that there are functions of GBR which are not functions, and that there are activities of GBR which are subject to the Secretary of State's direction, and other activities that are not subject to the Secretary of State's direction.  And I wondered, I can't force the noble lord, I wouldn't want to, but I wondered if the noble lord we should take at some point, not necessarily today, at some point we should take an opportunity to find a way of introducing into our debates in committee a sort of a reprise to some extent of what was debated rather messily on the first day, so that we have his whole view of the question set to music so that we can all understand it.  I just leave that as a thought for the noble lord to take up if he wishes. 

My lord, I'm going to start in as far as the group is concerned with amendments 63A, 91A and 116A.  And all of these are related to the question of innovation.  It was only a few years ago that people were debated, people in the industry were debating what it meant to talk what it would look like to have a digital railway, what did that expression mean?  Everything was very forward-looking.  And I look in this bill, which is about the future of the railways, and I find nothing at all about innovation. 

I find no obligations on the part of Great British Railways to innovate.  I find no policies directed towards innovation, no mandate on the Secretary of State to include innovation in the long-term rail strategy and so forth.  And I think that's missing.  In fact, I think, not to be too difficult about this, but I think it's part of a general pattern of this bill, which is very back to the 1970s.  The theme of this government, of course, under Mr. Burnham, is back to the 1970s. 

He's made that very clear.  And we could go back to the 1970s technologically as well, but I don't think that's the government's intention, but there's no intention here to make any progress either.  So these amendments are tabled, I won't go into them in detail, but they're tabled with a view to encouraging the noble lord to make a statement as to what the government's intentions are and how they might be reflected in the bill in any changes he might bring forward later in committee or on report. 

If I turn to amendments 330D and 330E, both of these have been put forward by Tech UK.  They're very anxious about the information, the data which is gathered and generated by Great British Railways and they want to ensure that that data is in the public domain and is transparent.  Now I'd hope the noble lord would have no difficulty in accepting that as a principle, completely free and open access, because that is after all the policy he introduced in relation to TFL data when he was commissioner, and it led of course to an explosion in apps in the private sector, which, some of which turned out to be very useful to members of the public, some of which fell by the wayside, that's the way of technological development, helping people find their buses, connect their trains to the buses, finding which door would be the most intelligent door to get on on the tube in order to make a quick exit at the next station you're changing at and so forth.  Now all of these things are done in the private sector, they're only possible if the data is provided.  So that commitment to open, completely open data and its inclusion in the bill would be extremely helpful. 

And 330E also suggests that as I say by Tech UK is about smart data schemes in which rail planning and integrated ticketing are identified as candidate use cases and the rail data marketplace itself falls within scope of that work.  This amendment is intended to ensure that the relationship between the two is resolved and reported and commits the government only to considering its own policy.  So I would hope again that it would be easy for the government to accept it.  And I turn then I think finally to amendment 89A.  89A is on a slightly distant subject, but that's the way our groupings very often work, and it's to do with steel. 

It is of course the case that the government has shot British industry in the foot by imposing steel tariffs on imported steel.  That's the policy they've gone for, it's very reminiscent of the 1970s I might say, wouldn't have been possible naturally if we'd stayed in the European Union, so at least it's a Brexit bonus as far as the government is concerned.  This amendment responds to the government's new steel trade measures which came into force on the 1st of July this year.  Those measures reduced the overall tariff-free steel import quota by 51% compared with the previous safeguard regime and imposed a 50% tariff by value once the relevant quota is exhausted.  So in other words there's much less tariff-free steel available to British industry and the tariff on that which comes in is higher than it was before. 

All very bad news.  One of the government's central arguments for the creation of Great British Railways has always been that bringing the railway together will reduce costs.  Now the government says its reforms on the railway will secure more than a million pounds, a billion I beg your pardon pounds in savings and efficiencies by the end of the decade for the railway.  The government's own document UK Steel's Trade Measure from 1st July 2026 specifically identifies product category 19 as railway material.  That's significant because Network Rail has already contracted for almost 450,000 tonnes, that's European tonnes of rail over the five years to 2000, including at least 78,000 tonnes from Germany, 8,500 tonnes from Austria. 

Network Rail itself has said that these European suppliers are important for specialist products and security of supply. 

Of course they are.  The issue here is where GBR needs imported railway steel to maintain, renew or improve the network.  Should the taxpayer bear an additional 15% cost simply because the relevant quota has been exhausted?  The amendment would exempt steel imported specifically for GBR railway infrastructure from that additional tariff.  It should therefore, and I imagine will be, welcome to the noble lord the minister and to everyone in the railway, in the railways.