First Delegated Legislation Committee

19 October 2026

First Delegated Legislation Committee Actual start House of Commons

Follow its sittings
15:23 - 15:25
Speaker 1
Order. 
15:25 - 15:32
Speaker 2
The draft Electrical Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector and Social Rented Sector (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026. 
15:32 - 15:52
Speaker 4
Is it the wish of the Committee that the instruments be debated together?  I will now call the Minister to move the first motion and to speak to both instruments.  At the end of the debate, I will put the question on the first motion and then ask the Minister to move the second motion formally.  I call the Minister to move the motion. 
15:52 - 19:24
Speaker 3
Thank you, Sir Desmond. 

It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair.  I beg to move that the Committee has considered the draft Hazards in Social Housing (Prescribed Requirements) (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026, commonly referred to as phase two of Awaab's Law.  And as you've just noted, we're also considering the draft Electrical Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector and Social Rented Sector (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026.  Sir Desmond, alongside our commitment to delivering the biggest increase in social and affordable housebuilding in a generation, this government is driving a lasting change in the safety and quality of social housing.  The regulations before us are integral to that effort, and once brought into force will play an important role in keeping social tenants safe by ensuring social landlords are clear as to their responsibilities and respond to complaints in a timely manner. 

I'll take each of the regulations in turn, starting with the second phase of Awaab's Law.  As honourable members will know, Awaab's Law is named in memory of Awaab Ishak.  Awaab was just two years old when he died in December 2020 as a result of a severe respiratory condition caused by prolonged exposure to mould in the social home that his family rented from Rochdale Boroughwide Housing. 

His parents repeatedly raised concerns about the conditions that the family were living in, but their landlord failed to act.  Confronted with the grief of a loss so overwhelming, Awaab's parents determined that they would secure justice not only for their son, but for all renters.  And we remain deeply grateful to them for the dignity and tenacity they've shown in fighting for change and bringing us to this point.  Sir Desmond, Awaab's Law is vital legislation that empowers social tenants to hold their social landlords to account using the full force of the law if they fail to investigate and fix hazards in their homes within set timeframes.  When it comes to those hazards, I want to be clear that social landlords had legal obligations to keep homes fit for human habitation, free from HHSRS category 1 hazards, and to remedy disrepair before the first phase of Awaab's Law commenced in October last year. 

Awaab's Law does not introduce new obligations in respect of new hazards. 

It is designed to compel and expedite the meeting of existing obligations by introducing clear time-bound requirements and a robust route to enforcement.  Phase 1 of Awaab's Law, covering significant damp and mould hazards and emergency hazards, came into force in October last year, as I've mentioned, and it is helping to drive up standards in the social housing sector.  The draft regulations before us extend the requirements of Awaab's Law to the following significant hazards: excess cold and excess heat, falls, structural collapse and falling elements, fire and explosion, electrical safety, and hygiene.  In addition to expanding the range of hazards that are within scope of Awaab's Law, we're also drawing on feedback and lessons learned from the rollout of phase 1 to make two groups of changes with a view to ensuring that policy works as effectively as possible. 

First, we've clarified thresholds for the types of hazards covered by Awaab's Law and updated the definitions of emergency and significant in respect of the hazards that fall within the scope of it.  This will help landlords to make more effective assessments, will provide tenants with greater clarity as to when landlords must act, and will support a more consistent application of the requirements across the sector.  Second, we've made changes to avoid duplication with existing fire safety rules.  Where fire risks relate to parts of buildings that are already covered by existing fire safety legislation, such as communal areas, we've clarified that these are to be managed under those rules rather than also being subject to the requirements of Awaab's Law.  These changes are reflected in updated guidance that we've published covering all phase one and two hazards with a view to helping tenants and landlords determine precisely what is and what isn't within scope of the requirements. 

19:24 - 22:19

Matthew Pennycook

Sir Desmond, once the regulations before us are in force, Awaab's Law will operate as follows. Potential significant hazards must be investigated within ten working days.

Following the conclusion of an investigation, landlords must send written summaries to tenants within three working days, and they must take action within five working days. Potential emergency hazards must be investigated and made safe within 24 hours. If the landlord cannot make the home in question safe within the relevant timescales, they're required to secure suitable alternative accommodation. Additional works to prevent the hazard from recurring must begin as quickly as possible, but no later than 12 weeks from the time of the investigation, and they must be completed within a reasonable time period. Once these regulations are in force, all social landlords will have to comply with the requirements of Awaab's Law in respect of the wider range of hazards covered.

If they do not, tenants can take legal action through the courts for a breach of contract or seek redress through the Housing Ombudsman.

I should point out that Awaab's Law provides for a statutory defence in instances where a landlord can prove that they have used all reasonable endeavours to comply with the requirements but have been unable to do so. In other words, if failure is due to circumstances completely beyond the control of a landlord, they will not be liable for a breach of the regulations. As per the commitments we've made, we will next year expand the requirements of Awaab's Law to apply to the remaining hazards as defined by the HHSRS, excluding overcrowding. In doing so, we will continue with the test and learn approach we took to phase one so that any beneficial lessons arising from the implementation of phase two can be addressed. To return to a point I made earlier, Sir Desmond, the phased approach we are taking does not mean that social landlords have leeway when it comes to meeting their existing duties to provide safe and decent homes for their tenants.

It's also important that tenants are aware of the protections they are entitled to and landlords are clear on their responsibilities. The Make Things Right social housing information campaign will launch in January to raise awareness of the new protections among social housing tenants and residents ahead of the regulations coming into force in November. I will write to all social landlords in England setting out clearly what the regulations require and the standards they must meet. I now turn to the Electrical Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector and Social Rented Sector (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026. As honourable members may recall, last year we brought social housing into the scope of the electrical safety requirements that private landlords have had to meet since 2020.

As a result, all landlords must now check the electrical installations in their properties at least every five years. The regulations before us are required to ensure that those existing requirements align with the latest version of the relevant British standard, namely BS 7671. As a result of the changes required, the existing references to further investigative work are no longer relevant and have been removed.

We're also, Sir Desmond, clarifying that a pre-tenancy inspection and test is not required if the previous inspection and test took place within the last five years and the report is still current. These changes will make sure there is clarity and consistency on the standards that are expected of landlords in both rented sectors. And with that, Sir Desmond, I commend both sets of draft regulations to the committee.

22:19 - 22:33

Desmond Swayne

The question is that the committee has considered the draft Electrical Safety Standards in Private Rented Sector and Social Rented Sector (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026. Gareth Bacon.

22:33 - 26:09

Andrew Gareth Bacon

Sorry, Sir Desmond, you caught me on the hop there. Thank you, Sir Desmond, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I welcome the opportunity to set opposite the minister again and I appreciate the remarks he's already made in this debate. I also welcome the opportunity on behalf of His Majesty's opposition to address this set of regulations and I'm going to address my remarks in the reverse order to those made by the minister.

So the first set of regulations regarding electrical safety, these are broadly technical in their concern. They're uncontentious really in terms of legislative change. And it's vital that all homes meet the necessary electrical safety requirements that tenants, landlords, registered providers, and others rightly expect. I would, however, like to raise one question about these regulations. As my noble friend highlighted in the other place, the legislation requires that such standards be monitored by local authorities.

Now, with all the uncertainty surrounding local government at the moment and the lack of action taken by the government to allay such concerns, on whom will the monitoring responsibilities fall during the transitional periods? And what impact will local government reorganization have on this and the innumerable other small-scale but vital responsibilities?

Secondly, in the other place, both the opposition and the Liberal Democrats raised the important point that extra responsibilities for landlords do not always match up with expected compliance of tenants. What plans does the Minister have not just to enforce responsibilities and compliance on the landlord's side, but also on a tenant's? Turning to the other set of regulations regarding hazards in social housing, I want to start by acknowledging the critical importance of ensuring that every tenant has a safe, hygienic, and sturdy home to live in. It was this very concern that led the previous Conservative government to introduce the original Awaab's Law. Awaab Ishak, as the Minister has said, his sad and untimely death in 2020 was a shock to all of us in this place and up and down the country, and showed that there clearly was and still is more to be done to ensure safety for all residents in social housing.

These regulations go further, as the Minister has said, than the original Awaab's Law by extending the same principles to cover other hazards, such as excessive heat or cold, hygiene hazards, structural hazards and more. These are very real and pressing concerns for some tenants, but these regulations are not a perfect response to the issue in hand. It's important that the valid concerns of industry groups are also noted in this debate, because they highlight how, when considering any new regulatory requirements, we must remember the added financial cost and extra time that must accompany their enforcement. For example, the National Housing Federation has raised concerns about the substantial additional costs to housing associations. We know and hear, both in our constituencies up and down the nation, that many housing associations are already stretched, with some struggling to cover their costs already.

New requirements can take away money earmarked for other repairs and maintenance, forcing unwelcome choices for housing associations.

Homeless Link has also warned that at present no government funding exists to help providers finding themselves on the brink, operating on very tight margins. As the hazards for consideration expand in scope, so too do the pressures on cost and time. The government's own impact assessment shows this, with an estimated increase in cost of 213.6 million pounds. Importantly, this covers only the administrative costs, Sir Desmond, so the true figure is likely to be considerably greater. So it is important that the government engages closely and meaningfully with the sector as these regulations come into force.

I call on the minister to commit to this when he sums up, both to ease the concerns and understand the true nature of the costs not included in the impact assessment. I hope the minister will make that promise in this debate and support tenants, landlords, housing associations and registered providers alike.

26:09 - 26:10

Sam Carling.

26:10 - 28:50

Samuel Carling

Thank you very much, Sir Desmond, and it's a pleasure to have you in the chair for the second one of my meetings today. I just wanted to very briefly put on record my strong support for what the Government is doing here in relation to the extension of Awaab's Law, both in the social sector and the private sector. As an example of the importance of it, I recently had a mother in my constituency get in touch worried about her son who is asthmatic, and in their property, which is managed by a social housing association, significant damp and black mould on the windows and walls was aggravating his condition. And Awaab's Law, which places a legal duty on social landlords to address damp and mould hazards that present a significant risk of harm within fixed timeframes, was a really useful foundation for me to stand on when contacting the council on her behalf.

And extending those principles to the private sector will do so much for another one of my constituents, who recently had his bed condemned by his letting agency for being infested with black mould, with the root cause again being the state of the housing, which resulted in his case in a chest infection and a hospital visit, and he has had to pay for a new bed himself at significant expense, and one caused, as I say, by that problem with his private rented house. So I'm confident the changes the government is making will give private tenants far more strength and backing to assert that mouldy conditions are a clear emergency health hazard, and rectified within a strict timeframe. I also wanted to touch very briefly on a briefing that came through from Shelter earlier today, and I appreciate that as this has only come through today, the Minister may not have a response to it right now, but I wonder if he would commit to writing to Shelter in response to their concerns.

In short, Shelter are arguing that in the amended regulations today, that the significant risk of harm means a risk of harm to the occupier's health or safety that a reasonable lessor with the relevant knowledge would make safe within 15 working days, but not within 24 hours. And Shelter are saying they're concerned that the 15-day definition could put tenants at risk in cases where there are no quick fixes to make a home safe from a hazard ahead of further works, meaning it could fall outside the regulations. And they give an example that a reasonable landlord might not be able to make a significant structural collapse hazard safe within 15 working days if no temporary fixes were available. They're arguing that the amended definition could potentially, I'm sure not in an intended way, undermine Awaab's Law because if the landlord were to argue the hazard was out of scope, tenants would lose their right to be offered suitable alternative accommodation until the hazard could be made safe. And then they close by just saying that if Awaab's family had of course been offered suitable alternative accommodation while the damp and mould was made safe, he may still be alive today.

So I just wanted to bring that to the Minister's attention so that he can respond when possible. Thank you.

28:50 - 28:51

Gideon Amos.

28:51 - 31:01

Gideon Amos

Thank you, Sir Desmond. It's a pleasure to serve the committee with you in the chair and once again I draw the House's attention to my registered interests as a social landlord. From the Liberal Democrats, we support and recognise the work that's been done on Awaab's Law and the passing of it in the Renters' Rights Act, which we supported as a major step forward.

And we therefore welcome the regulations today on extending the hazards in the definition. I think in response to the honourable gentleman opposite who just spoke, who made a very good speech on the efficacy of Awaab's Law, I agree entirely. And indeed, my constituents in Taunton and Wellington have also found it useful already in terms of securing action for matters such as damp and mould and so forth. In regard to the electrical regulations, to us they appear to be a tidying-up exercise. I don't have any further comment, and we're happy to support them.

In regard to the social housing prescribed requirements amendment regulations, the question we'd like to ask the Minister is whether consideration is being given to extending the hazards to encompass overcrowding.

I was pleased to campaign over a number of years in different roles to restore minimum space standards in housing, which when I trained as an architect many decades ago was a requirement until the Thatcher government swept them away, and we ended up with some of the smallest homes in Europe. But there's not much point, and I was delighted that the across parties also campaigned for that. I was delighted that the Liberal Democrat Minister Don Foster brought in nationally described space standards. But there's not much point in having space standards if the homes themselves are completely overcrowded. So we'd be interested in asking the Minister whether there's been consideration given to encompassing overcrowding in amongst the hazards in these regulations or in future regulations.

31:01 - 31:07

Speaker 10

Other than that, Sir Desmond, we stand to support these regulations. Thank you.

31:07 - 31:08

Speaker 9

Minister.

31:08 - 38:11

Matthew Pennycook

Thank you, Sir Desmond. Can I thank honourable members for those contributions? I'm pleased, Sir Desmond, that there is general support for both sets of draft regulations and their intentions in respect of improving the safety and quality of social housing. A series of questions have been put to me, I'll endeavour to respond to each in turn. The Shadow Minister put to me two questions, essentially on who enforces the electrical safety requirements, what are the implications of that enforcement duty in respect of local government reorganization.

Local councils enforce the regulations, as he's made clear. If a local council has reasonable grounds to believe that a landlord is in breach of one or more of the duties in the regulations, they must serve a remedial notice on the landlord requiring remedial action. Should a landlord not comply with the notice or urgent remedial action be required, the local council may arrange for remedial action to be taken themselves. I note the point he makes about the burden that places on them.

I say to him, I don't immediately make the link between local government reorganization generally and that point. He's more than welcome to write to me with further details, or if he has evidence of particular local authorities that say in respect of these quite simple and straightforward regulations that they think that they will have problems enforcing them, I'd be interested to know about that. He then asked a question about what if, I took his meaning to be, what if the hazards in question are being caused by the tenant, what if they are the tenant's fault? Firstly, it's important to say, Sir Desmond, the government's completely clear that it's unacceptable for social landlords to assume that a hazard, such as damp and mould or pests, is based on a tenant's lifestyle. In fact, our family had that allegation put to them.

The Housing Ombudsman has been incredibly clear on that point. It's rightly the responsibility of landlords to identify and address underlying causes where they exist, such as structural issues, repairs, or inadequate ventilation. And the same goes for other hazards, such as pests. But landlords should, of course, continue working with tenants to make small, reasonable adjustments to their behaviour if that is required and appropriate to reduce those risks. The Shadow Minister then put to me a series of points about the cost to the sector.

I'd say to him a couple of things in response. We have taken as an approach to regulation generally, ensuring that it is proportionate and that timescales, in particular, are sufficient for social landlords to be able to enact those regulations in a proportionate way.

We've done that with minimum energy efficiency standards. We've done that with the modernized decent home standard. We are doing it with Awaab's Law by rolling out the requirements in phases, give landlords time to adjust to embed the necessary processes they need to have in place and so we can learn, as I referenced in my opening remarks, test and learn through that approach what works, what needs clarifying. In terms of the cost specifically, we've published a final stage impact assessment for phase one of Awaab's Law. We've previously published a final stage impact assessment for phase one, as I said, having updated the policy in light of consultation feedback from both the sector and tenants.

We've assessed that costs have been kept to a reasonable level while delivering necessary impact for tenants. Social landlords that will incur the greatest costs are those not currently meeting their obligations regarding hazards and decency. I come back to the point I made in my opening remarks: these are existing obligations that we are trying to ensure are better enforced. Alongside laying phase two regulations, we're publishing an impact assessment. Our estimate is that the total cost to the sector of the proposals will be 146.3 million over the 10-year appraisal period for phase one and 190.2 million over a 10-year appraisal period for phase two.

But as I said, the duty to make repairs to reported hazards is not a new burden on landlords, and the costs associated with the investigation and repair timescales are likely to be the result of additional staffing, familiarisation costs, and the preparation and postage of written summaries. To my honourable friend's points, I have got Shelter's letter here.

I wasn't going to detain the committee with responding to the two main points they have made, but he's challenged me to do so, and I think it's important to just put them on the record. We heard in respect of the definition of significant hazard, we heard very clearly from both tenants and landlords in our phase one test and learn that it was difficult to distinguish between an emergency and a significant hazard. We've therefore changed the definition for both emergency and significant hazard to remove the ambiguity around the previous language, which asked landlords to assess if they would take steps to address the hazard as a matter of urgency. We've instead made it clear that landlords must make an assessment of whether a reasonable landlord would make the hazard safe within 24 hours for an emergency hazard, or within 15 working days for a significant hazard, to determine whether the hazard falls within the scope of Awaab's Law. For a significant hazard, the 15-day working period has been used to align with the existing timescale of 10 working days to investigate and then five working days to make safe upon the conclusion of the investigation.

There is an objective test of what a notional reasonable landlord would do, and landlords should not factor in their own considerations, such as budget or staff availability. To determine what a reasonable landlord would do, we would expect landlords to take into account the risk to the tenant, information about their health circumstances, as well as how feasibly the works can be made safe within three weeks. And landlords should also consider where a reasonable landlord would use temporary measures to make hazards safe where that is necessary as a first step. They've also raised concerns about fire hazards in communal areas not being covered. I can see the committee urging me to bring my remarks to a conclusion.

My honourable friend can be assured we will respond to Shelter in full on both points. I'm more than happy to share that response with colleagues if they're interested. And lastly, just on the Liberal Democrat spokesman's point about why we've excluded overcrowding.

Awaab's Law, Sir Desmond, is intended to address hazards that result from defects, disrepair, or a lack of maintenance for which landlords are responsible. And we came to the conclusion that overcrowding is a complex issue that's not usually a result of disrepair or something that can be fixed by repairs or maintenance. We therefore took the decision to remove overcrowding from the scope of Awaab's Law to ensure that these regulations are focused on repairs issues. Social landlords obviously will still be expected to take overcrowding issues seriously, and the sector must continue to address these through their transfer and allocations policies. Tenants concerned about overcrowding will be able to seek redress through the Housing Ombudsman Service, and tenants in housing association properties can obviously report overcrowding issues to their local council.

And beyond that, as he knows, and I know he shares my ambition in this area, we need to boost the supply of new social and affordable homes to ensure that more families who are overcrowded and severely overcrowded can be moved into appropriate accommodation. Sir Desmond, to conclude, it's imperative that we continue to work to improve the safety and quality of social housing.

These regulations will enable us to do so. They will play a vital role in making sure social landlords are clear as to their responsibilities and respond to complaints in a timely manner. I commend these draft regulations to the Committee.

38:11 - 38:25

Desmond Swayne

The question is that the Committee has considered the draft Electrical Safety Standards in the Private Rented Sector and Social Rented Sector (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye".

38:26 - 38:32

Speaker 13

Of the contrary, "No". I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it.

38:32 - 38:37

Speaker 12

The draft Hazards in Social Housing (Prescribed Requirements) (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026.

38:37 - 38:39

Speaker 11

Minister to move formally.

38:39 - 38:40

Move formally.

38:40 - 38:48

Desmond Swayne

The question is that the Committee has considered the draft Hazards in Social Housing (Prescribed Requirements) (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2026.

38:48 - 38:50

Speaker 14

As many as are of that opinion say aye.

38:51 - 38:54

Speaker 15

Of the contrary no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Order.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.