Domestic Abuse Act 2021 Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Domestic Abuse Act 2021 Committee House of Lords
Follow its sittingsJess Jessica Rose Phillips
And I would spend quite a lot of time annoyed that, for example, all of the victim services in our country are funded almost exclusively, apart from the Part 4 of the Domestic Abuse Act allocation of funding for refuge accommodation, the vast majority of victim support in the community funding comes from the Ministry of Justice. And I just found it to be a complete and utter misnomer that why on earth, when my local Rape Crisis, the greatest number of referrals come from GPs, health professionals, it's over, I think it was over 60%, and I asked various different Rape Crises around the country to get me their local data, why is it that if a GP refers to a Rape Crisis center in our country because the person in front of them is suffering from mental ill health because of the trauma, or physical ill health in fact, because of the trauma they've suffered, they don't think they have to pay for it? They wouldn't send them for an MRI scan and go, oh, the NHS has no responsibility to pay for this scan. And that to me is a deeply, I could come up with a million examples of other government departments that do the same. Why is the Ministry of Justice not paying only for things that achieve better justice outcomes?
The Independent Sexual Violence and Independent Domestic Violence Advisors funding and ring-fenced by the Ministry of Justice is absolutely right, but that was in the days when those roles were invented, and there are some other people in the room who were there in there when that happened, and they were invented to help people go through the criminal justice system. That is not what they are now. Why are hospital Idvas, or, you know, we just like get any name and put it in front of the word Idva, any word, why are they being funded by the Ministry of Justice? It is, it sort of became a sort of obsession of mine that government departments did not take their responsibility. All of the work that was going on in education or amongst children and young people, which is not very much...
Funded by MOJ? That was actually coming from the Home Office, not the Department for Education. Like, it is, that is unacceptable to me, and that is, that is, it basically comes from a tradition of people relying on the free labor of women. So brilliant women set up these organizations in localities and run them on a shoestring, totally undervalued, and our state exploits that. The idea that you, you know, the, act more like Big Pharma is what I'd think, because like you wouldn't send somebody who came into you because they had diabetes or even severe mental health problems, you don't think you can have the medicine for free, but you do think you can have the cure for free provided by a load of underpaid women.
Helena Kennedy
And would you say that in fact that that although this seems to be simply about money, it's actually also about culture? It's absolutely about, if you want to change culture, you have to feed this into all the different ministries.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
It absolutely has to be about changing culture and that was initially about changing culture just even within the number of ministers and civil servants who were leading on it, many of them weren't leading on it at all, making some people in departments take accountability for, and just to pick on health who actually have come on the biggest and best journey if I were to be giving them praise. The idea, for example, the NHS England did fund SARC's, sexual assault referral centres around the country, they are the responsible authority, but it became as soon as it wasn't forensic and it was about health, they were commissioned for forensics. And so if I say, okay, well yesterday, for example, I was with the Institute for on strangulation and a similar model where it would be better if we had better clinical evidence in trials on cases of strangulation, for example, and most of that evidence is clinical, is medical clinical about having brain scans, about the effect of oxygen. I'm not a doctor, I realise there's one in the room, I don't want to, I don't want to pretend that I am. But when I, when speaking to them, they say, oh, you know, that actually unless they are commissioned to do the forensic work and knowing that it will definitely go to trial, less concern about whether like they won't do that if the person seems okay.
And that, so it's those sorts of things are happening all over the system and trying to, over many years I've tried to make different parts of the system responsible for it. When I was on Birmingham City Council, for example, I made it so that there was routine inquiry in housing around domestic and sexual abuse and I will never forget sitting in a housing office in Northfield in Birmingham and the person, slight screen between me, the person I was supporting and the person next to me and the person going, have you been a victim of domestic abuse? And the woman went, yes. So, have you been a victim of sexual violence? The woman said yes and she said, have you got any pets?
Like, you know, like routine inquiry won't do it. System change won't do it. You have to make the culture, you have to make people feel responsible for it and like they will get in trouble or they will get praise for doing a good job if they take it on. And at the moment that, well, no, actually, we are in a better place than where we were when we came to government, but still a long way to go and some good and bad players across the board, I'd say.
Helena Kennedy
Well, that was a very interesting, very interesting assessment of what you think the problems are. Now, our doctor is in sunny climes, but she wants to ask a question. Claire.
Claire
Yes, thank you so much for all the work you've done. I just want to say that, are you describing the complexity of not having joint commissioning because I'm old enough now to know that the only way we tackled unwanted teenage pregnancies was to bring the various departments together under a sort of joint commissioning framework?
Is that what you're describing, that it's so disparate that actually, and we've heard a lot of evidence of some people that have managed to navigate their way through the commissioning process, but do you have, is that your dream?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
There are brilliant, there are brilliant examples. Devon and Cornwall, for example, the ICB commissioning there is a really, really good example of really good localized joint commissioning being done incredibly well, and in fact the sort of model that went into the violence against women and girls strategy was, you know, pretty much based on the model that we had seen in Devon and Cornwall. However, and also, you know, it's not in the Domestic Abuse Act, but I can't even remember which bill it is, but we now have the duty to collaborate piece of legislation that was championed by the Domestic Abuse Commissioner. How that is playing out in joint commissioning in the field, I went to the West Midlands duty to collaborate meeting recently and I would say early days would be my best review I could give of that. I wasn't well liked by anyone in the room when I left, I don't think.
But a joint commissioning, look, I think personally that when the CSR was done, there should have been a big joint violence against women and girls nationally commissioned, basically the violence against women and girls strategy should have come alongside it with a big pot. Whereas actually what happened was that each government department had to beg and borrow from within itself. We all put in CSR bids, don't get me wrong, we all put in bids and some were successful, some weren't. And there was a sense that we were doing it in a collective in some ways, but none of the collective bids were granted. So actually, yeah, I think that you make a good point.
You could say the same about knife crime. The trouble is is everybody wants their thing in government to have that. Everybody wants a ring fence for their thing. Everybody wants, so I can see the Treasury's concern, but it's also if you don't ask for enough, it never crosses the proper desks in the Treasury would be my, anything less than a billion and they don't care sort of thing. So don't worry, I asked for more than that all the time.
I once in a letter wrote that said you can give me this free thing or you can give me three billion pounds, you choose. But that was not done and that is what I would suggest going forward in the next CSR if we're truly going to try and do it jointly. But that doesn't make commissioning happen jointly on the ground, so you need both. You do need joint commissioning on the ground and the violence against women and girls strategy does commit to doing a proper centralized guide, and I don't like the word guide, I want it to be, I want it to be completely and utterly mandatory for commissioning.
Helena Kennedy
Now, you said there should have been a nationally commissioned and you didn't finish the sentence.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
There should be, there should have been a joint bid across government for a pot of money that was, and I asked, this was not asked for, it was asked for repeatedly, to do the violence against women and girls strategy, yeah. Because it covers every government department. It's very hard when you go to Secretaries of State who've got a prison crisis or immigration, everybody's got an iceberg, SEND, whatever it is, pick your poison, every government department has got an iceberg in it. And so then you are asking, it felt a lot of the time while I was, we were getting to the end of writing the strategy, that Wes Streeting said to me that it felt like I was holding him upside down and shaking out his pockets. He said it in a charming way, but that was what it, that is essentially what it was.
Speaker 4
We need somebody who's going to turn people upside down and shake their pockets.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
It was trying to...
More than happy to do it, but that became like my job to do that. The Prime Minister, to be fair to him, he would regularly convene meetings of the cabinet, but there was never like, you know, never anyone saying, well, you've got to give a certain percentage of your budget or whatever. And everybody would come for that treatment if I got it. So it was a lot of shaking people down, some with success, some with not with success. But I have to say, the Department for Health admittedly get a better settlement than anyone else, apart from the Ministry of Defence who also put their hands in their pockets.
The Department for Health, what is written into the strategy is the thing I am proudest of actually, because it shows a forward-looking complete cultural change. So it became all the children's sexual abuse services, including the bit that is courts and police going into these multi-agency centers, is being, the bill is being footed by the Department for Health for the first time. And they are paying money into the Ministry of Justice victims' pot because I managed to win the argument that they should pay for what they use. And also they are, the ICBs will all be given money to do specific domestic abuse and to fund domestic abuse specialist community-based services. So they were the ones who took the mantle the greatest and they came on the farthest journey actually.
But it is, I mean, so much of that I have to say the credit needs to go to good leadership from Wes in putting Jess Asato, another woman who's not afraid to hang people upside down and has a huge amount of knowledge, it's like a characteristic of being called Jess in this building, in DA to really, really do a sort of task and finish piece of work. And that is what every government department needs, they need a Jess, whether me or her.
Polly Neate
Yeah, so we're going to narrow down a bit with this question. So one of the things that we've heard consistently from witnesses is that the police are still treating domestic abuse as incident-based and not focusing on the pattern of behavior that is coercive control and actually all domestic abuse. So I just wondered, what do you think needs to be done to change this? And will the formation of a national police force be an opportunity or not? And then I've got a third little thing.
So we heard yesterday from survivors and they, it was a small group, so they all agreed that probably they felt the DA Matters training is out of date now. So what, bearing those three things in mind, national police force, the DA training, DA Matters, what do you think needs to be done to get that focus on the pattern?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
The, I mean look, there is a real opportunity with police reform, and I say this tentatively not knowing whether that will go ahead or not. We're all in a sort of weird limbo.
But there is a real opportunity to take a blank piece of paper and start again with regards to and actually my experience of working with chief constables across the country is that they want to do that. There is no shortage actually I'd say at grassroots policing and at the very top of policing in a desire to improve the police response. I think there is a sort of there is definitely a problem with promotion and middle management is where I perceive most of the issues and who is held accountable within police forces for failures. And we're not talking about trouble is when you start to talk about police failure you get into like people being kicked out and suspended because they're sex pests or like they do terrible things and domestic homicide reviews. I am talking much much much more pedestrian just not the not doing a good enough job really.
Now I have to say I feel for police forces across the country in the manner in which there is a number of things that you could do that around promotion around training and I'm absolutely here to hear the DA matters training is potentially I mean if you just include the online space which most police officers if they sat in front of you now would say that the digital element of violence against women and girls is their biggest problem in the workplace at the moment and they don't really have the tools and resources. Lots of them are working on various different technologies to try and overcome that. But all of this there is there needs to be a better accountability about just good service I'd say with regard and that can be done by what the Home Office monitors. And there is always a balance when you want to collect data you want to monitor performance of not making a too burdensome system for a copper on a call out because I want them to actually act like a copper with curiosity and spend time with the woman. So like you have to try and find a fine balance in that.
Police if the police were sitting here what they would say to you is that the reason that they don't like you know like getting a coercive and controlling charge over the line would be much much harder looking at patterns of abuse is not actually how the court system works not certainly not with speed. So the vast majority of people actually have become much police forces have become in a good way much more focused on safeguarding the victim so get them an order get the person in front of a court tomorrow like you know it's become much more safeguard the situation than it has about following the lines of inquiry about the perpetrator. Now Operation Soteria has done some of the work in looking at that in rape and looking much more at following lines of inquiry in rape but we need essentially a similar Operation Soteria for DA and the National Center and I have discussed this so we the the government funds a new national policing center for VAWG. And we have had this discussion even about like what the risk assessments that they use let alone the training what are they fit for purpose to both you want to keep doing the safeguarding but also follow the lines of inquiry. And I think that lots of us around this table have campaigned so much for like let this get this woman quick and safe like I take some I take some of the blame for actually that it has moved away from lines of inquiry into pattern and onto immediate rescue.
So I think that that we need to look at what risk assessment that work is undergo is being under is being done at the moment by the National Center about training about about risk assessments and secondary risk assessments as well in in other sort of crime types beyond the DASH or the DARA risk assessment which is the names of the risk assessments that that most agencies in the field use.
But it yeah, look, but I also think that that and an accountability framework that is of that you have opportunities to create. Also, you shouldn't ever be able to get promoted on that basis.
Helena Kennedy
I agree. I have to tell you, I I did a thing on banking once, and it was middle management that was a problem about not promoting women to higher levels in banking. And I said, all you have to do is you introduce into middle management that one of the things that will determine what bonus they get is what they've done to promote women.
Helena Kennedy
And you so you create the the carrots and the sticks around that kind of thing, and they could do that in the police as well.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Don't have any any I don't know why it wouldn't be possible if you were running like a unit in Birmingham of the the public protection unit, you were working on child abuse and DA, and you had nationally a much worse no further action rate, or you you know, like or even, I don't know, ask the people you're serving how it was for them. You know, crazy idea. Like, I don't know why that shouldn't mark against you for promotion. I also don't think you should ever be able to become a chief constable unless you've worked in public protection. I don't think that you and actually the pathways of promotion within policing are far greater if you hold a gun than if you hold a baby in your arms and rescue it.
That's not acceptable. You shouldn't ever be able to be a chief constable if you have not done a good, reliable, a good job in public protection.
Suggs
Thank you. I wanted to ask you about tech and online, and obviously you talked about that in your introduction and also shared some of your frustration on that in your resignation letter. And we've heard lots of evidence about the growth of it all. You talked a bit about, you know, the police talking about not being able to address that, but what are your thoughts on where we need to go forward from here?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
I think that that there is needs to be a whole scale rethinking about, you know, I'm quite old school, I was trained 20 years ago, 25 years ago now in the field when this was completely and utterly not part of the issue. And I would say that across the board of all agencies is that so I met with all of the clinical leads for the SARCs around the country, for example, whilst I was a minister, and I said to them, so how much how many referrals are you getting for online child sexual abuse? So all of the children's SARCs around the country. And they were like, none. So like our system is not technically it's not like, you know, and if you were to if a kid is has images shared around the school of her and she goes to a teacher and talks to them about that at the moment, there is not proper the guidance is currently being updated because myself and Josh had started to work on it, Josh the minister for children, Josh MacAlister, should give everybody their full names.
But the like there is no way that people react the same way to online abuse as a harm to a person in the way that they would if they said my uncle raped me last night. Actually as well, you have an age problem in that as well because we don't react in the same way if a young person says a young person has raped them or a young person has abused them. There is that that falls into it because they're much more likely to be as a part of their abuse be as their digital natives to be there is a cultural problem with not recognizing online harm as actual harm.
Now as a person who has suffered huge amounts of online harm, I of course don't think that the kind of harms that I have suffered should ever in any strategy trump the idea of like, you know, like a domestic abuse refuge. Of course I don't think that. However, we we I think that that attitude that even of people like me has missed a moment in time where online harm became really, really bad and really, really dangerous. So the there is a need for a sort of culture shift amongst all agencies dealing with this. The police, I would say, are crying out for it.
I like I cannot sit in front of, you know, whether it is the local sergeant in my local force right up to, you know, the head of the Met without them just being like, oh my god, like so many of the cases that are coming into us are online harm, are are child abuse online, are they are like desperate. Look, there are technological solutions that can be done in this space, but I do think that like there needs to be a much more fundamental regulation of the online space as well that I mean, look, the Online Safety Act, I think, doesn't say women in it anywhere. So.
Helena Kennedy
One of the things that certainly in the House of Lords that we've we've heard evidence about in the course of recent legislation going through was about grooming of children being done by bots online. And and the and the challenges that presents to a a legal system that's not been put in prepared for that. And so, I mean, those those challenges are really significant. Is there a sense that in government of of how how that should be?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Yeah, like so it's well, look, there there is both. So any policy around the online space sits, I'm going to be completely honest with you, quite uncomfortably between the Home Office and DSIT. You uh I'll I'll speak I'll speak really, really frankly now. There is a there is I've rarely I wouldn't say this about the ministers, uh or certainly the Secretary of State. I never found particularly that I always found we were me and Liz Kendall were always on the exact same page.
That when the machine starts to look at it, the priorities that sit within DSIT, the Department for Science and Technology, you can't want growth from online, right, and also be responsible for policing it. It it is it is completely and utterly at loggerheads with each other. And so the relationship between the Home Office and that department in trying to progress anything, which, you know, as Lords around the room, you know, may remember some of the disastrous issues around pornography and terrible outcomes, I have to say, that were stupid, are is is because there is this there is a there is a problem. And so it's whether the government departments that lead on growth in in that sector. I mean, I would argue, of course, that like, you know, we could have loads of growth in our country if we went back to slavery.
Yeah. You shouldn't any growth that is made on the backs of child abuse is not something that I think that should ever be particularly welcomed. Yes. So, yes, there is a there is a fundamental problem. So some of the solutions sit in regulation that sits in the OSA that sits with DSIT.
And then the Home Office will stream in, quite rightly, when they're not happy with that and start making lots of criminal law.
And then you go to the point that you're saying is, who's responsible if it's a bot? How do you follow the money if it were... It's really about following the money. It is about how do you follow the money, how do you find out the platforms? And then the Home Office gets all like, well, we'll put these people in prison.
And then you get once again into this argument where they're like, oh, they'll defund everything in the UK. Anyway, like, that's just a snapshot of the insanity of some of the meetings I've had to live through and my frustration with them. But there is a need for considerably stronger regulation, I would say. And I think that it starts to get into a massive mess. Of course, the actual perpetrators of it.
So in the thing that I resigned over, like, the platforms, regulating the platforms will make 91% of that abuse stop. Now, of the 9% that is done by adults to children, that is the responsibility of the Home Office. That is the responsibility of law enforcement to just focus on that part of it. And you need the regulation to do the other side.
Helena Kennedy
Is the regulatory framework at the moment... I mean, Ofcom, we've had discussions in this room about problems about accepting the powers that they have and whether they're good enough. What's your view on that?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Look, I think it's still all so a bit too early to say, isn't it? Like, I was with somebody from a child abuse online charity yesterday and I just put the simple question, do you think that... Because we're arguing for similar things for women as exist for children and terrorism within Ofcom. That's like, you know, what people who want to see this improved have been arguing for 10 years in the build-up at... The trouble is is I'm not sure it's made child abuse online better.
So the simple question I asked was, do you think that the safeguards within the Online Safety Act have made child abuse online better? And the answer is no, not really. It has made some places safer. But, and I think it, you know, I think that the big mainstream platforms act much quicker on child abuse on their sites than they ever would before and that they have put in safeguards to try to stop them. However, I don't think that the regulatory framework as it is currently works at the moment, no.
And I think that that's lots of the work that went into the violence against women and girls strategy was trying to look at different ways that we can regulate to prevent rather than detect.
Helena Kennedy
Now, we're specifically looking... I personally would say that you can't disentangle these things because the overlap, the violence against women and girls policies and efforts to deal with that seep into the whole business of domestic abuse and violence. And so we, you know, but we are dealing with the Domestic Abuse Act. But it's the extent to which new technology is, if you like, an enabler and in fact an expander of abuse because we've had the evidence in relation to, you know, sexual violence against partners using drugs to make people comatose so that you can have the kind of sex that a woman might perhaps not agree to. You also have the whole business of people being able to be followed and pursued in ways and for basically knowing what women are doing because of access to their phones and to their technology.
Um, I mean, do you see that as being one of the, one of the areas that we've got to get the Science and Technology Committee to, to engage with?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Yeah, I mean, absolutely, like, and what the strategy commits to in that is that DSIT wrote into it. I don't want to, like, make out like they didn't want to do anything. They, they absolutely did. Is the idea of safety by design, and that it has to be designed into the system. Like, you know, like, if you go to America, you see those enormous, stupid, massive cars that are Tesla, that just, you won't see them in Europe because the regulation wouldn't allow for this weird box to drive, that looks like a fridge, to drive around.
Like, it's that. Like, actually, I don't think that glasses that can record you, I mean, you might as well just call them pervy glasses. Like, what, I mean, I, I can't imagine what the use for a pair of glasses to record you could be for other than harassment of one form or another. Like, you know, like, I'm sure, you know, Meta have a completely different view, but, like, anyone, if they had had any woman in the meeting about that, you would have said, hang on a minute, that's a bit pervy. So, of course, there is, that we need to make sure that the things that go to market.
And, unfortunately, the greatest lie that was ever told by tech companies, and I could absolutely, I wish I could go back in time, is that our phones, our Ring doorbells, they made you safer. They absolutely didn't. They didn't solve any crime. They didn't, they didn't make your neighborhood any safer. People walking dogs makes your neighborhood safer.
Um, but what they have been used to do is surveil everybody and make everybody feel frightened. And I, I think that the latter is an important point as well because you cannot domestically abuse somebody unless they feel frightened of their environment. And so much has been done with technology to advance the causes of stalking. I say, I won't ask you for a raise of hands. I don't do this and I'm the only one of my friends who doesn't do this.
I don't survey my children. I don't know where they are. I don't watch them on a map. But every single one of my friends does that. Every single one.
And every parent thinks that when they gave their kid a phone, it made them safer. And what it did was opened a room to a load of pedophiles. You basically said, oh, there's a scout group down there that's run by pedophiles, why don't you go and join it? Like, that, like, absolutely, we have to, like, face down the fact that, that we can't put that genie back in the bottle, but we should massively regulate what is the, if it can be used to domestically abuse, and like, there has to be at least, it shouldn't be allowed, or there has to be specific safeguards put in place.
Meral Ece
Thank you. Thank you very much. Um, so I'm going to take you back. You mentioned this already as a growing problem at the beginning in your introduction. So my question really is about the statutory definition requires that both the perpetrator and the victim have to be over 16, and we know now, in order for domestic abuse to apply, but we've known, we've heard lots of evidence now and we know far more now that this, this fails to capture domestic abuse in teenage relationships, which is a huge, huge issue for those who are under 16.
Do you think there's anything more that, well, if anything the government would like to do or should do to address this?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Yeah, I mean, obviously the, the answer is just to take the age limit out of law. The, seemingly that is the answer, except that the definition of domestic abuse is that for 16 and 17-year-olds, and none of the data suggests that when we, and as the person who moved the amendment, I think I moved most of the amendments of the Domestic Abuse Bill, but, um, we haven't seen a massive increase in services for 16 and 17-year-olds.
We haven't seen a massive increase in the charging in that. I don't think that police forces have been particularly trained in how to deal with cases where it's a 16 and 17-year-old, or even just let's go 16 to 25 even. 16 to 25 where you're not living in the house with the person, like a different sort of relationship, obviously not my age of child bride. But the, yeah, like just changing the law, and I would take that age out of it, I'm absolutely fine with that. I don't think that that will just work on its own.
There is a far bigger piece of cultural work, and actually, I think that before we do that, we should try and focus on why we've not improved anything for 16 and 17-year-olds who are included in the definition. I don't, like there has been no particular, there's no, like where I live, there isn't suddenly lots of teenage relationship abuse services, or like, you know, strategies for the police. There isn't a team of police officers or people in the CPS specifically looking to become specialists in teenage abuse. So we have to be really, really careful in this building of thinking that our job is done when we change a law. Because so actually, like I don't, I don't recognize the age, and actually the vast majority, the only thing it stops you from doing, there are some things where changing it would make it better.
One is domestic homicide review. So you would get a domestic homicide review if, so Holly Newton is the case that of course most people will know, and I've met Holly Newton's mom many times, she's an absolutely brilliant woman. Because children's safeguarding starts to do the review. It's not that you don't get a review, it's that children's safeguarding, and I have to say, having spoken to Holly, to Holly Newton's mom about this, like she didn't feel that that was involving her and her family in the same way a domestic homicide review has absolutely built into it. So yeah, getting rid of the age would improve the domestic homicide review system, no doubt about it, in that area.
But everywhere else it would just, we would just end up, I'm sure you are likely to come onto this later, to the exact same place where we wrote into the law that children were victims of domestic abuse in their own right. Which is just nice words, isn't it?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Yeah, I mean arguably, arguably it is captured by that, and in lots of cases you could argue for a domestic homicide review in a case of a relationship of somebody under the age of 16. You could probably argue as the person who sat over and said yea or nay to various different domestic homicide reviews, I was quite lax. I'd let most of them through. I was like, yeah, that seems like one we should do it. So it's, but it's how it interacts with children's services.
That's the thing when the Domestic Abuse Bill was going through as well, that was the argument that always constantly came back, to much chagrin on my part because I thought, oh my gosh, I'm talking to a minister who's clearly never made a children's safeguarding referral. Because if you try and make one on the basis of domestic abuse, unless somebody has got a machete to your kid's neck at that exact moment, there's no way you're going to meet the threshold. So how it interacts with the children's safeguarding system and the review systems that go on in that, it's that is the fundamental problem in that space, I think, where we end up with both being unsatisfactory actually. And actually, if only we could all say we could all work together, that would be better, but you know.
Helena Kennedy
And because we've got, you know, limitations on time, I'm going to pause this, but that was a very interesting answer there about children's safeguarding and the interaction with this Domestic Abuse Act and how that could be much more effectively used. So I'm holding on to that thought and we may come back to you about ideas around that, but I'm anxious that we let everyone have their opportunity to ask you specific questions. Baroness Porter.
Lord Porter
Thank you. We've heard lots of evidence from people about the Domestic Abuse Protection Order pilots. Could you say a little bit about your views on the upcoming rollout, what you think will work, won't work? We've heard specific concerns around things like enforcement, the extent to which there's, even within the pilots, there's adequate resourcing for the positive requirement provision services.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Yeah, so all of those, I imagine it was Nicole who spoke to you, obviously she and I talk about it quite a lot. So look, the first thing I'd say is positive is that the difference I have seen the Domestic Abuse Protection Orders playing, and it again goes back to my obsession with culture, is one that I feel very, very positively about. So in the first initial stages of the rollout in Greater Manchester, parts of Greater Manchester and boroughs in London, there were two things that I saw happening in that pilot that gave me real hope for the future. The first one was a case in the Metropolitan Police where they had turned up to, I think it was like a drink driving thing, he'd crashed his car, they turned up and the son, it was an adult son, had said something like, "Oh well, he was always like this, and you know, when he's not drinking he's beating up my mom," and had made a passing comment to the police officer who on that day, it was when the DAPOs started, had then sat down with the woman and said, "Would you like a Domestic Abuse Protection Order?" And it was done on the basis of coercive and controlling behavior, not on violence, which is obviously a good thing and a culture change.
And so there is this idea of like inquiry because they had a tool they were interested in and wanted to try and use. And that woman never, like just in that case and another case where it was in Greater Manchester where a man had breached his order, so they gave him a Domestic Abuse Protection Order and he then breached that order, not by going back to her, but like not being at the right address when they were doing the offender management, and went to prison for eight months for breaching the order. And in both of those cases, when I say that what culture matters, the woman never left her house. We didn't rely on the free labor of women. The woman never left her house, never went into a courtroom, a man ended up in prison, and a woman never had to step foot in a courtroom.
And that to me, that like the police taking the responsibility to keep people safe and actually doing that without the woman ever having to do a moment's piece of admin is like, that is manna from heaven to me, that you could within a week of you getting an order have somebody in prison and you've not set foot inside a courtroom is like, I can't let go of how much hope that gives me, that it isn't the responsibility of that woman to take, it is the responsibility of the police to take that.
That said, in the rollout, it was very clearly found that the stuff around positive requirements that is part of the legislation was not working because it wasn't mandatory. It is now. We have made it mandatory in the legislation. It was very strong feedback, I have to say, from Greater Manchester, where all our overlords come from now, so I'll say nice things about them. They were really, really, really keen, keenly feeding back to us that basically without it being mandatory and being able to be enforced by a judge, it didn't work.
So we have changed the legislation. The rollout has been different. It is almost all police at the moment. It is almost all police. Hardly any is being done in the family justice, and that is because it doesn't cover children.
And so Alex Davies-Jones and I, one of our last acts was that we have drafted up the legislation to make it include the protection of children so that it can be used in the family court. And we were seeking to get it into the sentencing bill, not sentencing, what's the one that's going through at the moment, the piece of law about juries and everyone's having a row? That's the one, the courts bill. We were seeking to get that legislative change into that piece of legislation. And that came from meetings with the judiciary, who really, really specifically just the family court bench were basically like, no one's going to use it in family court unless that is in there.
So that legislation, when I left it, that legislation was due and frankly, I don't need to be a government minister to amend legislation.
Helena Kennedy
But it is interesting because you're talking about making things mandatory, because the Domestic Abuse Commissioner told us that the courts can now make it mandatory, but she wants to see that becoming a positive requirement.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Yeah, yeah, yeah. So I think that now that it is mandatory, the positive requirements are mandatory, we will see a greater uptake. The other problem that you raise is that there isn't, where I live, there isn't perpetrator program schemes that, well, certainly not ones that I would trust. So that is a problem. So the Home Office, at the same time as this is all happening, the Home Office is commissioning the Drive program across the entire country.
That is only for high harm. So in some of these cases, we're going to get into a mess.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Well, arguably, well exactly, arguably, I mean, the Drive program works basically on a MARAC protocol, Multi-Agency Risk Assessment Conference protocol, or child in need, child protection.
Helena Kennedy
I'll take us over to Lord Polak because I know he wants to get in on his question.
Stuart Polak
I'm intrigued, this whole conversation is, you know, there's no point us legislators putting down or enacting laws that are then just not going to be followed through. Now, you talked about the amendments you put down. Well, Lord Russell and I put a load of amendments down too and we succeeded in getting children on the face of the bill. But I just ask you, I mean, A, was it worth it, and B, what else does the government need to be done to protect children?
Helena Kennedy
Yeah, I mean, I do, I mean, I was going to bring in Baroness Barron, because generally this was considered to be, and there was some sense of celebration to have produced such an effective piece of law. And while law doesn't always deliver everything, it is an important thing. You do need law. It is a glue that kind of, and if you're talking about culture, it has a role to play in the creation of culture shifts within society. So it's vitally important that it's not continuing to do the old tropes about, you know, women bring these things on their own heads, etc., all of that stuff.
But I just wondered if, I'll take Lord Polak first, but I'm just giving you a little warning, it would be quite useful to talk about the things that you feel were real gains and that shouldn't be forgotten in the discussions about all of this. Lord Polak, would you like to ask about children first?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
So yeah, I mean, look, was it worth doing? Yes. Because it eventually will change the culture, just doesn't do it very fast. Coercive and controlling behavior when the Domestic Abuse Bill was going through had been on the statute books for I think at that point six years, and in that year, in fact, and in some of the years after, 56 people went to prison for more than 12 months. So, you know, like it take, now there's a better story to tell, it does take time.
I have to say, and look, I was certainly, you know, part in the Commons of making sure that that got into the legislation as well, so I feel very, very keenly that it was the right thing to do and that it will change culture. I just don't think that people have a very, in the field, or so what we haven't seen, for example, is children being able to take cases against their fathers, for example. We haven't seen a case where a mother won't do it, but a child who has lived in that, and arguably, if the child is a victim of domestic abuse or a certain sort of crime, then they should be able to do that. We have not seen any of that, and there hasn't been any sort of case law, there hasn't been any, that hasn't shifted. And that was the real worry, I have to say, of the civil servants at the time.
They were like that, oh my god, what happens if this happens? And I was like, yeah, that's not going to happen, but okay. But so, but we also we haven't seen a large uptick in the commissioning of domestic abuse services for children, which actually I think if those two things had happened together and the provision, the reason why, not always perfect, the brilliant thing about the bill, which is part four of the Domestic Abuse Act, which makes a statutory duty to fund refuge accommodation, like that has had a cultural change in every local authority. That's like there were some that had none. Like it's not perfect, loads of work needs to be done on how you make those standards right and good, but it did do that.
And it did that because it was given a back amount of money from government to do it. There should have been the same thing around the children that could have then, at the same time as the law changing, started a sort of whether it's pilots on what would work or cultural like stuff doing in local authorities saying that, you know, it's not okay really that every children's services in the country doesn't have like a referral pathway for children's counseling in cases of domestic abuse. Like that seems like that's a thing that should exist. Doesn't exist anywhere, and 80% of children who are victims of domestic abuse or sexual violence get turned away from CAMHS for being too complex. So it like, you know, like those things should have happened at the same time and they didn't, and that I think has been a failing, but it was definitely worth putting in there because we can do it now.
And then we can get some like snazzy kid to take a like legal case when it's not done properly. That's what we need is more kids who like judicial reviews. Oh, now that the word's gone out, I'm sure they're going to do it against the bill.
Stuart Polak
No, no, no, I'm happy. All I was just going to say before is you talked about the refuges and so on, but just a tiny percentage of people who suffer domestic abuse, or children or adults, get to a refuge.
Speaker 30
Oh yeah, I think it's 40%. Many more are picked up in the community, but that didn't get... I made the amendments to the bill to make community services a statutory duty, but yeah. Polly, you had a follow-up, if you could take it quickly.
Polly Neate
Yeah, very quickly. So, I mean, there are programs, as you know as well as I do, for children and for children and non-abusing parents together that could quite easily be commissioned and rolled out, but we've heard evidence that they're among the most vulnerable parts of community-based domestic abuse services, and I just wondered what you thought about that. And I also have a question about one of the things we've heard, we really heard it yesterday from the survivors, is that women are being held responsible for protecting their child in a domestic abuse situation. And I just wanted you to talk about that a bit, and in relation to the child being a victim in their own right and the potential kind of danger in that space.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Yeah, I think there was tension, because we do repeatedly, and we heard it yesterday with survivors, of the fear of getting embroiled with social services because they fear that their children will be taken away from them. Of course, and they're not wrong. It's not an irrational fear, it's a completely regular fear that will be played out. So yeah, so there is a number of things that... There was quite a lot of concern at the time that making children direct victims, that the failure to protect them would be used on a legal basis against those women.
I have to say, I'm not sure that the family court and the manner in which it treats victims of domestic abuse could need any extra tools for how to quite so badly fail, in my view. And actually, one of the failings of the Domestic Abuse Act was the failure to get any real advancement in the change in family courts, which has been put subsequently into other bills, and I'd say quite a lot more attention on it now. However, you're absolutely right, there is a fundamental problem, and I think that the new way that the government, the Department for Education, is looking to do the sort of families first and sort of like rebranding of the children's centers is... There is a real opportunity to try and shift the ideal, and it is a fundamental ideal that is taught to social workers, and I've trained them myself, I've trained many, many social workers in my time on the front line, because you know, they all come and do their periods of practice with you when they're being trained, is the quite rightly, after a number of, whether it's Victoria Climbié or Child P or whatever it is, is this idea of the sort of focus on the child. There is a fundamental failure of children's social care and therefore the agencies that sit around it to recognize that happy mothers make happy children, and that the protection of the woman in this circumstance is as important.
And there is... myself, I was in... when I was a minister, we were on a roundtable about a serious case review of a baby, in fact the sort of famous case of the aristocratic woman who's gone on the run. And the baby's death in that case, the real need for interventions, early interventions that are supportive of mom, not punitive towards her.
And also for those systems, we can't do it until we've built it. So we're trying to build it. We're trying to build a perpetrator system across the country because where I live, if you're a victim of domestic abuse, you get sent on a course. Now, I'm not saying anything against the Freedom Programme in Birmingham, which is brilliant and run by some of the most amazing women and it gives succour to those women and I would personally just attend because it's good fun and it's a lifeline for those women. However, the perpetrators aren't sent on courses.
There's no system in the country that says, actually, you're the one doing the problem, you're the person making the errors, you're going to lose your children. And I tell you what, you're going to lose them and we're going to do everything we possibly can to support your missus to find a nice house and she will be away from you. We don't do that. They don't even attend the conferences. Dads are missing from the conversation always.
And like where I live, fair enough, they don't have a thing to refer them to, whereas they do have the Freedom Programme because they rely on the free labour of women to provide the services. So they just refer them to that and then don't pay for it. So we end up where I started.
Helena Kennedy
It was interesting that yesterday the survivors said that their experiences of the family courts were worse than the criminal courts.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Oh, a million times worse. Women are treated like pariahs. There is also a growing issue, I would say, of women being criminalised for being victims of domestic abuse. I would say I am just on an anecdotal basis as a person who holds a caseload always of around a hundred cases at any one time, I am seeing again and again, just in my own constituency, the amount of women being charged with harassment and the criminal justice system being used against them as a tool of control. So it's what has happened in the family justice system for decades is creeping into the criminal justice system.
Helena Kennedy
Very interesting. Now, I wanted to bring in Shaistha if you would come in.
Shaista Gohir
Yes, hello. My question is on migrant victims of domestic abuse. So we've heard that their situation is made worse when they've got indefinite, when they don't have indefinite leave to remain, they can't access funding, they can't access accommodation, and then with the lack of firewall between the police and enforcement agencies, and now we're hearing that they will be asked for permission to let enforcement agencies know. Now, I'm not sure how free and informed that consent is going to be. So I'd like to know what you think, how that issue can be addressed.
But I'm going to add something else on as well. I feel that when it comes to minority ethnic women, that they can tend to be put into a bucket of, you know, migrant women who have an insecure immigration status or minority ethnic women who experience honour-based abuse. I've written many letters to you about this, so declare my interest there. Forced marriage, honour-based abuse. A large number of minority ethnic women will not fit into those categories.
British-born, speak English, not experiencing honour-based abuse, forced marriage, are experiencing intimate partner abuse, and they tend to get ignored. So how are we going to address domestic abuse for those women? Is that a cultural shift that needs to happen?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Yeah, I mean, look, there needs to be far greater by-and-for services. I mean, actually, if we were talking about minority ethnic women that are less served in like with specialist services in domestic abuse, actually black women, for example, don't, you know, there will be all sorts of reasons why they would need a specialist approach and that is nothing to do with migrants, that is absolutely nothing to do with forced marriage, that is nothing to do with like, but that they absolutely might need like real specialist from people within their own community.
And look, I, you know, we live in the same place so I don't need to, we literally live very close to each other. So like I don't need to tell you but that the, the, the there is a far, far greater representation where we live of South Asian women's services. And that, that, and then there is for black women or other Polish women, newly settled women from Romania, which have a really, really, really key issue around exploitation. And there aren't those specialist services that exist in the same way. And that is almost certainly led by commissioning that is done on the basis of this many percentage because obviously where we live there's a very high percentage of South Asian people so those, those services in a very brutal way of commissioning goes, okay, 28% will go to South Asian women's services.
So we do really, really need to look at then where there are gaps in local commissioning, how do the national, how does nationally does that get commissioned with whether it's helplines and advocacy because like we don't have a lot of military people where we live. In Portsmouth, you absolutely need a Rural New Dawn, the organisation that focus on, on that, whereas like there might be somebody there where I live but they can't get to Portsmouth. So you do need to then look at how nationally you offer at least a base level support service to everybody in those sort of minoritised and specialist groups that is run by those, those people and those organisations while making sure that commissioning is done better on the ground. With regard to migrants, obviously the firewall is under development with the sector at the moment about how it will look. I saw many wild iterations of what it could look like that went through various different people but it essentially it will, there will be a firewall between that.
We're quite late in the day in solving a problem that doesn't exist quite as much as it did. The fear exists though, the fear exists within the community. So and one of my case, one of my constituents was part of the, that's why I'm looking for kids to do a judicial review, was part of the super complaint and the judicial review because she was sent to Yarl's Wood detention centre when she rang up because her husband had threatened to kill her. And so but we haven't seen that those sorts of cases are not happening anymore. There has been a shift in, in that.
So we see that much less now. However, the fear that it did exist exists and that's a problem as well. So the firewall hopefully that will be created will create that. Now as somebody who has handled thousands of these cases, as have you, the issue of the consent that you talk about is important to get people's consent is that the vast majority of women who I have dealt with in that circumstance are interacting with immigration services. They just, they already are because they're part of trying to get visas and like it would so when, when in my head what that consent means is have you got an open immigration case and would you like me to help getting in touch with them to say that you're in trouble.
That is what that means to me, which I do all the time. I seek that consent from victims, migrant victims that I work with all the time. So that, that is how I perceive that idea of consent. But the vast majority will already be in the immigration system somewhere anyway as you know, like I do a million immigration cases a week. So that's how I perceive that being rolled out.
Sarah
Yes, so apologies, we're going to go back to the family courts again just briefly. But say, yeah, I think we can all agree from a variety of evidence that we've heard about the significant issues there. More positively, we have heard some good things about the Pathfinder courts, to be renamed Child Focused Courts when they're rolled out nationally. So what do we do to ensure the positives from those pilots are retained and developed in that rollout?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Absolutely, we have a Pathfinder court in Birmingham. And as I'm sure she wouldn't mind me saying, there is, you know, I can be quite a cynic, but the woman who runs Birmingham and Solihull Women's Aid, Maureen Connally, is the greatest cynic on earth and about, you know, whether new things will work, and she absolutely loved the Pathfinder court. So I feel like if it had her sign of approval, we're okay. Look, we absolutely, it just needs to be available everywhere, and we have to make sure that whatever pressure can be put on the Ministry of Justice to make sure that the Pathfinder system is available everywhere. I would also say, similarly, what we also have in Birmingham, which is, we have the drug and alcohol courts, and we have the women's specialist courts as well.
And you know, like, I have seen a lot of things in my life, but the brilliance of the women's intensive and the drug and alcohol court that exists in Birmingham, and you're talking 80% of it is DA. I mean, like, so much of it is in both the drug and alcohol court and in both of those institutions. And this is a proper, like, wrap-around, the amount of people who work, the, and it's all done, frankly, on a wing and a prayer of a bit of commissioning from good police and crime commissioners, a little bit of money from the Ministry of Justice, like, but the benefit I have seen to women and children in the community of those three courts existing in Birmingham should not be underestimated. And frankly, actually, the drug and alcohol courts and the women's courts, you're talking like five million quid from like each government department that is involved in it. It's peanuts, seriously, and it would make such a massive difference.
Helena Kennedy
So I mean, we went to see the court there the other day, and what's clearly vital for it is that you have this real integration of organisations and women usually, as you say, who've got real experience in the field and a really good programme coordinator to pull it all together and to work with the prosecution people, to work with the probation service, to be working with the court administration, the whole thing. And it was, it was really great to see the clerks as well. Somebody said to me, the clerk is the most important person in like how this whole thing works because we have amazing administration of the court. Apparently, there's a real issue on recruitment of clerks to the magistrates' court. If anyone's listening, go and be a clerk.
Speaker 33
Thanks, Jess, for brilliant insights and sharing your expertise so generously with us. Now, I'm just speaking as a kind of ingénue in court systems, I've got a nursing background. So I'm just struggling to understand why the family courts seem to fail in these instances. You know, courts seem to have different distinctive cultures and MOs, modus operandi. What is at fault with the family courts?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Two things. The first one is patriarchy. I mean, like, that's the reality of the situation.
These are patriarchal institutions built on the basis of the idea of the supremacy of man in a family. Like, you know, like that, that, like, I'm sure that none of the judges, none of the clerks, none of the people at Bull Street in Birmingham think that. They think that, yet their entire institution is built on that basis. And it is... It is also about the fact that there is an unwillingness to break the link of a parent with a child.
Yes. And so that is the informing, informing... From here as well. So this building similarly is very, very anxious about that. Like the idea, you'd be surprised about how sort of Christian and traditional family values go through absolutely every part of public policy.
And, you know, you have to untangle some of those. And I don't say Christian in any derogatory sense. I don't think you would find it was that different in most of the other main religions. Yeah. No, no, no.
I don't... but I mean we have like a sort of patriarchal Christian because this building, we're a state... we have a state church. The idea of traditional family values, of course, is so fundamental to our lawmaking that it's that has a... the other thing is secrecy. So other courts are much more... are much more... yeah, you can, you know, like judges say some things I don't agree with and it gets written in a newspaper and but like, you know, and they get pilloried or whatever. I don't like any of that particularly, but there is an element that the lack of scrutiny over the family court just means it's sort of going on just in total secret. So and look, I want to pay absolute tribute to the past two heads of the family court division who definitely recognize that this is a problem.
Like there's absolutely... they are not showing me any patriarchal... they are absolutely like it's too secret. Sir Mumby absolutely tried to get rid of the secrecy in the family court, no two ways. Sir Mumby was a remarkable... Absolutely. And as he came to his... what I always like is when anyone is coming to their end of their tenure, a bit like the Prime Minister.
Get a lot of stuff done at the end of your tenure, don't you? There's often a swan song and there was a whole lot done at the end of Mumby's. We were like, rush in, let's get him to do all this stuff. He... but he was... but, but, you know, also there is definitely an appetite for improving the family court amongst... like, but we have to change the law in this country. So at the moment the law is the presumption of contact and the bond between a parent and a child.
And the idea, the very fundamental idea that a child seeing having two parents is the very best thing for it. Like these are... when I say it's patriarchal, you're raised to think that. You're born, it's in the very... it's in your bones that you used to think that. But where I worked, the absolute opposite was true. So it was definitely better just to have the one parent.
So that's the fundamental... but we are seeking the... the bill that's passing through will change the presumption of contact and hopefully that will do some of the work. But also the... we need to really, really regulate the kind of people who can call themselves an expert in the family court. Lord Russell, you had your hand up. We can't hear you. All the way from Liverpool.
I mean, it sounds as though you're in a... in a fish tank. Yeah, take your things out. Wi-Fi. Yeah, that's good. Try... try just the old-fashioned...
Can you hear me?
Is that better?
Simon Russell
Great, so Jess, you keep on talking about amazing women and the patriarchy. And when you're looking at culture change, it does occur to me that getting men to accept that we are predominantly the problem and that we have to take responsibility for it is a fundamental part of the culture change. Would you agree?
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Yes, I would absolutely agree. And for too long, I think feminists like me like small-hoarded the gold. I don't actually think that we've sort of hoarded it, but I do think that there has been quite a lot of gatekeeping that has not meant that men felt like they could talk about it. And that was actually really dangerous post the MeToo movement, I think, because we didn't talk to boys about what that meant. And I watched my own teenagers overreact, if I want of a better word, and for nobody to, like, you know, like any sort of slight infraction by any boy in their class, they'd be like, "Oh, you're a wrong'un."
So yeah, and I don't think anyone spoke to boys, and that was a real failure.
Helena Kennedy
Well, we can count on Lord Russell and Lord Pollak as being champions on this issue, challenging the patriarchy. Now, I think we've covered the terrain, and it really has been wonderful having you come, and the whole wealth of your experience has been great to hear. And so thank you. And if you could, you know, I've got to end this session, and let me just say that this has been an invaluable piece of time. So I thank you for coming, Jess Phillips.
Thank you very much indeed. So thank you, and the public session is now concluded.