Women and Equalities Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Live capture
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Women and Equalities Committee Actual start House of Commons
Follow its sittingsMargaret Rachel Taylor
And do you think it's also true in some of those technical roles, you know, those people who are there operating the cameras or the producers?
Natalie Pirks
So I'm obviously a lot older than Flo. So my experience sort of lasts two decades working in sports broadcasting. And when I started, I was very much one of one, maybe one of two in a press box and a press room. So you learn to, you have to be a certain type of woman to then rub along with this very male press pack. I think now there's a landscape in certainly in print and print journalism where they're losing headcount rather than adding people.
So it becomes a lot harder to break into those traditional legacy media roles. But there is, there are a lot more women now in press boxes. You know, I will go into a press box or go into a press conference and there'll be maybe five, six women.
We all know each other of course we all talk. But um that feels more positive. And when you go to events there are a lot more of us and that does feel like a step forward. But equally when it comes to what type of women are now getting those roles and what type of women are coming in that does feel like a bit of a step back um because journalism itself isn't quite what it was. And so if you're coming through a degree for example and you're a woman that's taking a journalism degree and you want to work in sport what the the advice I would give now to women is very different to the advice I would give women a decade ago on getting your getting your journalism degree and you know working really hard and going into a print room and doing your work experience.
Speaker 8
It's just not the same way in anymore. So it's become better and harder at the same time.
Margaret Rachel Taylor
Do you think there's been a change with the rise in viewing for women's sport? Do you think that's changed the routes in for people?
Speaker 9
I don't work exclusively in women's sport. You two sort of work a bit more in that world. What do you think?
Fiona Tomas
I think to a certain extent, yes, there has been a small uptick in the number of women-specific roles when it comes to, you know, digital and print.
But I would argue that everyone talks about this broadcast boom, and I think there's been a print lag when it comes to the coverage of women's sport and how much coverage it gets these days. I mean, you pick up any newspaper out on the shelves today, flick through the back pages, and I will guarantee that there are a couple, if that, of female bylines. And that's been the same for quite a while now.
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
I would just to jump in, I would say yes, I mean, in the last sort of four years, you've seen a huge shift in that. Probably before the Women's Euros in 2022, we weren't at a stage where there was a national correspondent for women's football at every single newspaper. Now we've got to that stage, some newspapers even have two, so that is huge progress. But that doesn't necessarily filter out across the board.
And as Fiona's mentioned, you know, like men's Premier League football still dictates a vast majority of coverage. And, you know, I know the Women's Sport Trust, I think last week, just released their most recent visibility report, so they're constantly crunching the numbers on how much coverage women's sport is actually getting around, whether that's newspaper or viewing figures. But I think so much of that also relies on kind of how the market's looking. And obviously for a lot of legacy media, they're having to shift their focus to a more kind of digital element. And therefore, sometimes women's sport or more women getting into those roles might suffer.
But I think it's also there's I think there's sometimes a like unfortunate assumption that women's sport and women working within women's sport and media roles are the same. And I think like I wouldn't speak for the others on the panel but sometimes you feel like you're necessarily, you know, fighting that assumption that they often do go hand in hand but they're also separate in that there are lots of women who just work predominantly in the men's game. And that was the case for me probably up until the Women's Euros where it just shifted because there was more media spend going towards women's football. But up until then, you know, pretty much all my work was in the men's game.
Margaret Rachel Taylor
And and how important are mentors and networks within the industry for young women who are aspiring sports journalists to to navigate through their careers? And do you think there are enough of them? I mean, come to you first on that, Natalie.
Natalie Pirks
I think they're hugely important. I belong to WiF, Women in Football, probably do as well, and that is an invaluable network of women that started out as a few women who were just fed up in a pub and had a conversation, and it's now grown to thousands of people that work in sport, women that work in sport. And also, I think we have to talk about the importance of male allies as well, because sometimes it can come across as, you know, perhaps that men are difficult or men are the barriers. And actually, yes, I've obviously experienced that in my 25 years, but I've also experienced brilliant male allies, men that absolutely want to make a difference. They know they need, there is a need to employ more women and bring more women through.
So I think, you know, we have to acknowledge that as well.
Going back to what you were saying, you know, there's a saying in news that if it bleeds, it leads. And when it comes to sport, it's... it's Premier League football. And so it often leaves very little space for anything else. And women's sport certainly does get a bit of a raw deal when it comes to coverage. Unless they're winning or doing something exceptional, it's probably not going to get on.
And that is the reality. And when it comes to this digital space that we're now living in, if people aren't clicking on it, then it's perceived as people aren't interested in it, so it gets pushed down the agenda.
Fiona Tomas
Yeah, just on that point, I think women's sport is now at the phase stage where it tends to coverage tends to spike around major events, such as, I mean, that's very true for football, rugby, cricket. And yeah, I mean, it's not too dissimilar from Olympic coverage, really. It's it's very hard, I think, to sustain a kind of consistent cut-through during regular seasons because I guess leagues like the Premier League are still so so dominant. You know, football is king, it always will be. But I know certainly from a domestic perspective, you know, at the Telegraph, we do cover women's sport on a weekly basis from, you know, the run-of-the-mill season.
But it is very difficult to to cut through, you know, during during the regular months when there isn't a sort of a World Cup or a Euros happening.
Speaker 1
And just before I come to Nadia, Flo, I was really interested in your point there that you made that you have to fight against this assumption that just because there's more interest in women's sport that it's going to mean there are more women in sports roles. So I just wanted to invite the panel to sort of say anything further about that and why you think that might be and, you know, why you wouldn't see an increase in the number of women working in sport if there has also been that expansion of interest in women's sport.
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
Yeah, I think a lot of it comes down to the realities of the economies of the media landscape. Obviously we're at present witnessing, you know, huge cost-cutting at the BBC and changes that are being made in relation to that. And I think women's sport and minority sports in general actually often bear the brunt of that.
And I think that's the unfortunate reality of the ecosystem. And even the BBC itself, its coverage around the WSL, for example, short window of pre-match, short window of post-match, it's not necessarily always guaranteed to be on linear, BBC One or BBC Two. And that over time takes its toll around the number of eyeballs that are going to see that. Obviously, you know, things around number of contracts that can be awarded to pundits to be on that coverage, etc. So I think all of that is operating within the challenges of the wider media landscape that we're seeing.
And actually, the reality is very few major sports in this country apart from the Premier League have the opportunity to actually be as kind of aggressive in the media market.
Everyone else is actually fighting for eyeballs, whether that's men's cricket, men's rugby, against that beast. So I think there's not always a run-off, and I think that kind of wider digital view on things means people are trying to, in a way, it's been, it's democratized it because you can jump in and you can tell those stories, but it's probably removed the kind of allowance of the legacy media to do that.
Speaker 12
Really interesting. I don't know if Fiona or Natalie, did you want to add anything on that?
Natalie Pirks
The only thing I would add is that sort of from my perspective as a broadcaster, I don't think you have to be a woman to cover women's sport. It would often be, and this is industry-wide, I'm not speaking as just a former BBC person, but industry-wide, there's a, you know, you put your woman on it.
And it's lovely to be able to go and cover women's sport and I've done it my whole career and it's brilliant. But I don't think, you know, you're maybe slightly doing it a disservice if you don't put your sports editor on a woman's story if it's big enough. Why aren't you putting a man on it as well? It doesn't have to just be the woman you've got in that day. So and I have seen that happen across the industry.
So I would say that there's that element to it as well, as much as we want women to be covering these stories, it doesn't just have to be.
Fiona Tomas
I mean, I joined the Telegraph seven years ago and it was a newly created role called women's sports reporter and I was one of two. We still have two at the paper, but over time I have kind of generally just morphed into, you know, all sport.
And while it was sort of my big break per se, because I came from local news, at the time it felt really novel. And I think having been in writing for a national for seven years now, I do think there is this sort of strongly held belief that women can only cover women's sport. They have their expertise questioned more when they are sent out to men's sport. And obviously there are exceptions. I mean, like Natalie touched on earlier, there's probably a handful of women who are regularly covering the Premier League football from a print perspective anyway.
It's different for digital and broadcast. And that all has a knock-on effect further up the food chain.
There are less women in editor roles and less women commissioners on sports desks. And that ultimately means that historically there are less, I would argue, female issues that are covered by the mainstream media. And I'm very fortunate enough to have been mentored by some brilliant women in sports journalism, such as Anna Kessel, who's always pushing the sort of the female, the sports science take, like how is athletic performance impacted by those who take the contraceptive pill or when a woman's on their period.
And just going, going back to the kind of male allyship angle that Natalie touched on, I, you know, I've been fortunate enough to have some kind of quite eye-opening, brilliant conversations with male colleagues who, who want to know more about how these sort of female-specific issues are relevant to sport. Just because, you know, whether they come to you for advice because they're not, they're a bit under-confident on how to approach these subjects, you know, that's totally fine by me. It's not to say they can't, but I do think there has been historically a sort of kind of belief, yeah, that, that women can only cover women's sport and it's, and it's just not true.
Nadia Whittome
Thank you, Chair.
The Committee's heard previously, and also from the three of you today, about how women in sports media roles are still facing gender bias, whether it's having their expertise and their credibility questioned and undermined. We've heard previously from academics at Nottingham Trent University that men are often seen as an automatic authority on sports and on sports journalism, whereas women are having to kind of prove themselves in order just to get a seat at the table. How far in in your experience, if I can start with you, Flo, does gender bias shape women's careers in sports media roles?
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
Yeah, I think we've already spoken about some of that, especially around expertise and certainly around like pigeonholing you based on your gender. But I think for me personally, a huge angle is around social media safety.
And I think that's something that's very much gender specific in sport and especially football, but also I think probably is something that impacts a lot of minorities, whether that's people who are, you know, from different races or ethnicities, different religions, sexualities, and you know, anyone trans working in football especially. So I think that's something I've experienced massively when you have a more public facing role within journalism. And it's obviously not something that's exclusive to sport or football either, but it's something that I've experienced. And I think you can see that that, you know, how you are treated on social media is a huge barrier to wanting to work in sport, wanting to work in media because it's certainly something that given my experiences I'm not sure I would say to the next generation, or I do say to them now, look, you know, you need to go in eyes wide open about the realities of existing on X or Instagram or TikTok in this, you know, society that we live in and how people are going to view your opinions on football or your analysis or anything really because that is one of the things you'll face.
Nadia Whittome
I'm very sorry that you've had those experiences. I just want to express my solidarity to you. It's absolutely disgraceful. Natalie is there anything that you wanted to add in that vein?
Natalie Pirks
I'm very fortunate. I've never had anything like that.
I guess because I've worked in news for the majority of my career, which meant I wasn't giving my opinion. I have now got a podcast where I do give my opinion and boy, do people like to tell me I'm wrong. Even if I've expressed an opinion that's exactly the same as my male co-star, I will be told that I'm the one in the wrong. Especially, we did an episode on women's football. Well, that was enlightening.
But it's not something I've experienced badly. I've had all the usual misogyny, but never anything like that. Thank you.
Nadia Whittome
I bet you're told you're wrong by men who never watch the women's game, don't like the women's game.
Natalie Pirks
Yeah.
Often, you know, I'd sometimes get if I'd done a live broadcast about something, someone saying, you know, it wasn't good or whatever. And I think it must be what it's like to be a, you know, a footballer when someone who's never played the game is telling them they're very bad at their job. It's like, I'm sorry, until you do live broadcasting to millions of people in a stadium where you can't hear yourself think, you know, until you've done that, come back to me.
Speaker 15
But until then, it's very "I would've got that penalty" kind of energy, isn't it?
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
And I think it's probably, you know, the fact that Natalie's saying the usual misogyny as well is that we normalize it so much because we feel, we see it as part of the job. And I'm sure there's lots of young people who are so now exposed to some of the darker sides of social media that they too may see it as part of the reality of existing on the internet, whatever field you're in.
And it's a challenge that doesn't necessarily have an answer, whether that's, you know, the work that Women in Football have tried to do or online safety bill and things like that, but it's almost kind of we've normalized it so much now as part of our jobs.
Nadia Whittome
Thank you. Fiona, you've already spoken about this quite a bit, but is there anything that you wanted to add?
Yeah.
Fiona Tomas
I think the reality is you need a thick skin to work in this industry, to not be affected by these sorts of issues that we've just talked about. I'm quite fortunate, like Natalie, not to have experienced, you know, the scale of the abuse that Flo just referred to. But unfortunately, it's symptomatic of the world we unfortunately live in. And, you know, in terms of young people trying to break into this industry, like we've already touched on, it is unfortunately shrinking, like jobs are being cut left, right, and center.
And that makes, it puts the pressure on, I guess, to push your own brand, I suppose, as a journalist. You know, the role of a traditional print journalist has had to change so much to adapt to the boom in social. I mean, an uptick from a women's sport coverage perspective, I suppose, to counter all this kind of negative chat, is the fact that we are seeing a lot more kind of athlete-led storytelling, which has been, you know, crucial to the rise in women's sport coverage. But yeah, the bottom line is you do need a thick skin.
Nadia Whittome
Thank you. Just one final question. In your experience, are there differences between the culture in sports journalism and other areas of journalism?
Fiona Tomas
I've only ever worked in sports, but we know that women are terribly underrepresented across the journalism sector as a whole. And I think the latest figure is something like women accounted for 10% of all sport print journalists in the most recent research, which, you know, is still really woeful. I think with regards to things like workplace culture, I've been in media suites where, and I'm sure you guys have as well, where you are the only woman.
And it happened to me earlier this year where I walked in and there was a hospitality angel there working at this particular stadium and she had locked the ladies' toilet because she said that I've locked it for you because the men use it. And I think as a young journalist when it, when I, when she first came up to me, she still works at this same ground and I sort of didn't question it at the time because I was young, you know, you're eager, you're starting out, you want to make an impression and not cause a fuss. But, you know, the fact that that sort of thing is still happening, it's like, well, I am starting to question it because I'm older, I'm more experienced and it's like I wouldn't expect to walk into the Telegraph and for the men to be using the women's toilets, for example. So why should it happen, you know, in other areas of work such as media suites and things like that? That's probably like a really tip of the iceberg example.
I'm sure there, you know, if you spoke to many women across the industry, especially those who cover solely very male-dominated sports such as F1 or the Premier League, they'd have much worse stories to tell than that.
But that's just an example of how woefully women are underrepresented in sports print journalism.
Speaker 17
Thank you. Do either you, Natalie, or you, Flo, have anything to add to that?
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
I think we touched on it earlier, but when thinking about this sort of like gender diversity of sports press rooms themselves, I think we've got to a positive place, but we need to make sure we don't risk sort of othering women's sport and women that work in sport in that we've created a platform for a lot more women to work in the industry by crafting more roles for women's sport coverage. So, for example, if I go to a women's game, the vast majority in the press box will be women.
It'll be a very white press box and that's a huge challenge for the media industry moving forward, but it's very probably 60-40 women I'd say, maybe even more, which is great. But I think there is a risk of continuing to sort of other that. So more women get pushed into that, more women go into those opportunities and that only makes the men's side of sport even more male-heavy. So I think that would be one to to consider around that, you know, making sure there's not a lack of opportunity for women because they're just continued to be pushed elsewhere.
Christine Jardine
Thanks very much.
I used to be a journalist and as part of my career I did sport at a time when there were almost no women and there was no coverage of women's sports full stop other than golf and curling. But I wonder just from what you're saying about women being pushed into covering women's sport, there was at the time when women started to break through, there was a kind of, oh well we've got to do this attitude in broadcasting. Is, does that still persist? Is there still a kind of resistance to the sort of developments that we want to see with women having access to all areas in their careers and being able to progress? Is there still a kind of underlying almost resentment sometimes, do you find?
Natalie Pirks
I certainly think I've seen examples across the industry, broadcast industry, of almost, "Well, we've got one, we don't need any more." You know, because we've ticked that box. I do genuinely feel, particularly in newsrooms that I've worked in, there is a real desire to bring more women through and to give them opportunities. But again, I do hear still too often of the WhatsApp groups that the men are in, or the golf days that they'll take to go and have the conversations that women are just naturally excluded from. The decisions that are being made by very senior men that affect women's careers.
I also think, you know, as a slightly older broadcaster now, you could probably, we could all probably sit here and name the women that are prominent in broadcast, sports broadcast, that are 50 or over. And we could do it on one hand. And I do feel that that is a problem because whilst the pathways need to be good, there needs to be a world where you don't reach 45 and feel that your career is over. I don't think that's got much better. And I think in the digital world that we're now living in and that push for new talent coming through, it's almost like one in, one out.
We probably do need to be much better as an industry at looking after women that reach a certain age and want to stay. A lot of friends that I have and we talk about this a lot are going freelance or becoming self-employed like I've just recently done because they want a better work-life balance, because they want to be with their children, for example, but they also feel their career has reached a natural stop and they can't really see what that next bit is. So we're not particularly good as an industry at doing that either.
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
And just to follow up what Natalie said there, when I started my media business two years ago, that was very much at the forefront of that is, you know, a lot of it was about creating, I wanted to create more coverage opportunities for women's football, but I also realized as a woman working in broadcast, you age out very quickly.
There's always a younger, fresher, more interesting person behind you. It's the same for much of the media industry, TV, film. That's kind of the way of the visual landscape. So I was very conscious of how do I pivot ahead of time, because I think the reality is that very few people in broadcasting are going to be working even in mid-forties. And that's a pretty scary reality when most of us are going to be having to work till our seventies.
So I think that's the kind of challenge for that more public-facing broadcast side for sure.
Natalie Pirks
Also, as an industry, if we've worked really, really hard to bring these women through and train them and get them to a point where they're actually very good at their job, and then you watch them walk out the door, what was that for?
What was or or all those years for if if we're letting women walk away?
Fiona Tomas
I was just going to say that I mean Natalie will be able to speak on this point more, but I've certainly witnessed from from, you know, older colleagues within the industry, you know, once you have kids as a woman and of how hard is it to actually, you know, get back into the game as such. Because I've seen I've seen, you know, women editors having to rush out of news conferences because they've got to do the school run and feeling really guilty about it. And as a young woman looking up to these women, it kind of makes you think well, you know, what is that going to look like for me in five or 10 years' time?
Because, you know, doing this job, there's a lot of travel involved. You're required to cover events sometimes many miles away from home and have extended periods away from home. And we know as a society most of the caregiving roles still fall on women's shoulders. And it just isn't the same for men who become fathers in the industry, take their paternity leave, and then they just sort of kind of waltz back in. I'm not saying it's not challenging for them, but I just don't think it's the same as women.
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
And I think there's also an assumption for many people. And I had a friend who recently went up for a role and there was an assumption because she was a parent that she therefore wouldn't be up for the role because of the travel. So even then there's an assumption about your limitations before you even get started.
Speaker 1
Thank you. Brilliant. Thank you. Thank you very much. And Richard, I'm going to hand over to you now.
You've got questions on a similar theme.
Richard Quigley
Yeah, thank you. I think something struck me that you said there, Natalie, was the usual misogyny. And that sort of bit of a chill through. I mean, as politicians, we get lots of abuse, but I know Natalie will get more abuse because she's a woman.
And that's just not acceptable anywhere, really, is it, in society, to be able to say the usual misogyny? But something that you did say, which my wife and children will be cheering at at home, is men are difficult and get in the way. So I can only agree with that, and they'll be really glad you pointed that out. On employment conditions, and to Natalie first, things like job security, flexibility, maternity pay, all the things, you know, you expect in all jobs. Do you think that the provision or lack of in your industry is preventing women entering it?
Natalie Pirks
I was hugely fortunate in that when I had my two daughters, I was working in ITV, ITN and at the BBC, both of whom looked after me very well, both of whom gave me the exact maternity leave I wanted and supported me and I went straight back into my role and I had no issues. If I were about to embark on my journey as a mother now, I don't know in this industry, and again not about those individual newsrooms, but just industry-wide, that I would feel as comfortable or as confident. And if I were freelance, I would be incredibly worried. Because Fiona's incredibly, you know, you're absolutely spot on in that you're coming back after, with my, I actually planned both my pregnancies around the Olympics. That's how ridiculous my life was.
Natalie Pirks
I know, right? I got told that it was really bad timing by someone and I actually said it's a feat of human engineering actually.
Natalie Pirks
It was a man, yeah, funnily enough. But I think with my first, I only took six months because I needed to be back for London and, you know, you can't miss the London Olympics.
And it was not enough, and it broke my heart. So then the second time, I took nine and a half months. And the first thing I did was fly to Rio and present the one o'clock news for 15 minutes with no autocue, no monitor, throwing around... And I was so scared. And someone remarked to me afterwards, "You should probably just smile more."
Natalie Pirks
They're a dear friend of mine, but yes, again, it was a man. And it was just a bit of a different time.
But my point was going to be, when you sort of talk about usual misogyny, it is so much water off a duck's back now that it is something we just deal with. I did a story about sexism in sport where this very prominent woman in her sport was being chanted at regularly. Every time she went to a football match, she was getting awful sexist abuse. And when I had this conversation internally, a woman said to me, "Well, I go to football every week and you just hear that all the time, like, what's the issue?" We have become a little bit, it's just, we're so used to it that it's just become a bit normalized.
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
And there's a certain resilience as well that you build up. And so you probably are desensitized to certain things as well, to that, you know, normalizing the misogyny and what you experience because it becomes so regular and so common. I think as a freelancer and being self-employed, you don't have any of that security.
I think as a freelancer and being self-employed, you don't have any of that security and that's something that, you know, I think about a lot in terms of if I were to experience long-term sickness, I have no security, no maternity leave. So if I don't work, I don't make any money. And that's, you know, for the vast majority who work in the sports media industry, they are freelancers.
Richard Quigley
And I think for the concern around that is some of the work I'm doing on the creative industries, you find what is happening is people entering the creative industry are the ones whose parents can pay for them to do it. And there's a danger that you're not getting rewarded for your specialism and ability to be a journalist, you're getting rewarded because your parents can afford to pay, not you guys, but you, and it's a bit of a concern that an industry is disappearing that way.
But keeping on self-employment and freelance, is it even harder for women than it would be for your male counterparts? And you'll know the answer to that, I'm not trying to lead the question, but in what ways is it harder if you're freelance and self-employed to stay in the industry?
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
I think it's harder certainly when it comes to the case of maternity, because you have to decide to make those decisions and I've heard very similar stories to Natalie's in terms of people who rush back to get to work because they're worried if they don't turn up someone else is going to take their place. And you know, it's probably very similar to how a player feels when they get injured, is if they don't come back they're not going to get back in the squad or they're not going to get their place on the pitch.
And I think that's the reality of certainly being self-employed and being, and it's very different if you were a father or a mother, I think, because it's that physical impact that you have as, you know, as a parent. And like Fiona said is that, you know, more often than not the main caregiver in the family. So I think that that is a big element of it. And some places are really supportive and others aren't. And I think there's such a, because there are so few jobs now, it increases that competition and it increases that uncertainty and that insecurity about your place.
And I think social media's added to that too because I think as someone who is freelance, that comparison culture is always there because you're saying, "Oh, that person's doing that, that person's doing this, I need to make sure I say yes to this because otherwise I won't get this." So that is kind of a constant cycle of things playing on your mind.
Richard Quigley
And on that point, as the move towards digital media and the way we all consume news in whatever form, has that widened or narrowed the opportunity for women in sports journalism?
Fiona Tomas
I think it's, I think it's widened opportunities for fans and those who consume women's sport because we know that I think the fandom in women's sport is very different to fandom in men's sport. So a prime example being it's, it's very niche and you don't read a lot about it in newspapers because male, predominantly male desks won't commission it. Netball, because the men haven't ever played it, it's very unlikely they've ever been to a netball match or know much about the sport itself.
I know for a fact that Sky have broadcast netball for the past two decades and they've blown up their YouTube channel, which is entirely, I think it's the largest female audience across all of their sports that they show. And they've noticed that women won't necessarily watch the sporting event live, but they'll come back to it because they've got other commitments, whether that's putting the kids to bed or whatever it might be. So I think the boom in social and digital has definitely led to an uptick in the cut-through when it comes to women's sports, reaching more people, people engaging with it more. But yeah, I guess the counter-side to that is that they're scrutinized more, they receive more abuse, more pile-ons, those sorts of things. But yeah.
Speaker 1
Thank you, Chair. Thank you. I'm going to hand over to Kim. Before I do, let me just say we've got about, I'm going to try and finish this session in about 15 minutes, so if Kim and Rose, between you, you could try and keep your sections within that, that would be great.
Kim Leadbeater
Lovely, thank you, Chair. Um, there's a nice segue from Richard's questions actually there, and and I just think it's really fascinating, thank you for giving such honest and open evidence to us. We could be having probably pretty much the same conversation about women in politics and women in sport and women in broadcasting, so you've got three areas there where I think we've probably got a lot of shared experiences, shall we say. So, just diving into that a little bit further, how significant a factor would you say online abuse is in shaping women's experience of your profession at the moment? Natalie, I'll go with you first of all.
Natalie Pirks
Well, I think if I was starting out and I was seeing the level of abuse that that future me would would get, it wouldn't it wouldn't make me want to do that as a job.
I can't say I want my children to become camera-facing journalists, if I'm honest, because it's not particularly nice. So, yeah, I think when I started out, my role models were women like Claire Balding and Gabby Logan and latterly, obviously, brilliant Kelly Cates, and all still brilliant at their jobs today. But we didn't have social media then, so I couldn't see what anyone thought of Claire two minutes after she came off her Wimbledon broadcast because it didn't exist. So people coming into this industry now are living in a very different landscape to the one I came into.
And I came into one without too many women, but brilliant role models in them and very much being on my own in press boxes and sort of taking a, having to learn to rub along with men and get their help. And you know, I'm forever grateful to the men in those press boxes that really helped me in my early career. But now, if I could go back and see the abuse that women do get now, it would, I feel it would be a barrier. I'm not sure I'd want to do it as much as I did when I started out. But you guys?
Fiona Tomas
I would probably say I encounter it less than the two women either side of me, and that's purely because I work in print journalism. That said, it is so energy-sapping to scroll in the comment section, which I've, you know, I've now stopped doing it because of the amount of misogyny that is like a cesspit of misogyny most times.
And we were all actually, me and Flo were saying before we came into the room that, you know, in this day and age, journalists have no choice but to push themselves on social media to, you know, foster their brand. But we wouldn't necessarily have it if we weren't doing this job because of, you know, all the stuff that you have to put up with in this day and age. So, yeah, it's just modern-day world, isn't it?
Flo.
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
Yeah, I would echo what Fiona and Natalie have said and said if I was having a conversation with a young person, I would probably have to be quite frank and say consider what you might be experiencing if you put yourself into a public-facing role and maybe, you know, doing something where you blend more into the background and you don't have to put yourself in such an exposing position, that might be the way to go.
Because I think you have to be willing to kind of take so much and it does take its toll.
Kim Leadbeater
It's so depressing, isn't it? I mean, and that is, I mean, and we have the same in our jobs. I mean, I've just shown a bunch of school children around Parliament and you want to say to those young girls and women, get involved, we need good women in public life. And actually, it is a hard sell. It's challenging.
And do you think for people who are currently working in the industry, there is an element of self-censorship, that you don't say things that you might want to say because you worry that there might be consequences? Because we've had evidence for the committee that that can be the case. Any experiences of that you personally or maybe other people have talked about?
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
100% for me, I would say 100%. So in the early days of Twitter, I would be far more likely to share my opinion on things.
And after what I experienced over a number of years, I completely changed my the way that I use any social media. I restricted and altered my privacy settings entirely. I reveal hardly anything of my opinion, myself on there. And it's purely kind of self-promotion in a very basic way. And that's the only reason to be on there.
And if I didn't need to be on there pushing articles and trying to grow a business, I would absolutely not be on there. But unfortunately in my line of work, I kind of have to be on there. But I wouldn't be if I didn't have to be for my work.
Fiona Tomas
Yeah, to a... I can totally relate to what Flo's saying in the sense that the longer I've been in this industry, the more about, you know, your personal life you don't want to put on social media because you're purely on it for professional purposes. I mean, I think that's increasingly common to be fair across the industry, because, you know, your profile is everywhere these days. People can just look you up, you know where you live, and as a woman it can be quite scary if you kind of reveal too much about yourself. But yeah, I'm fortunate in that I've not had anything as drastic as Flo.
Kim Leadbeater
Natalie, for you, have you sort of said, "I better not say that, I better not give my opinion on that"?
Natalie Pirks
Oh, 100%. I mean, anyone that knows me knows I'm quite opinionated on lots of things, but there's just no point. What's the point? Because once you put it out there, it's out there, and then you're just going to get... it's just not worth it. And then it just consumes you, and then, you know, you're knee-deep in the comments section or something, and it's just not good for your mental health.
So I really—I did reach my 40s and just go, "I'm not doing this anymore."
Kim Leadbeater
Yeah. And just following on again from what Richard was asking, so given that that is the landscape that you're all working in, what more can employers do to try and support you and help with that? And Flo, as a freelancer, you know, you don't have that support that you would hopefully get from an employer, so what does that look like? So first of all, what do you think employers could do to sort of address those issues a bit more? Natalie, I'll go that way round.
Natalie Pirks
I don't know, because I am freelance now, but I was protected to a degree. There was nothing that ever happened to me that was ever anything that required the BBC or ITV to ever have to jump in and protect me in that way. So it's a little—I can't really speak to it as much.
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
I would say be mindful of when working with anything that's going out publicly, being in conversation with who you're working with about what the clips are you are posting. So for example, there was one particular broadcaster I used to work with and I just had to say please don't tag me in anything because if you tag me in something, these are the consequences. So making sure you work alongside someone so that you can protect them as well. Or if you know you're looking at a segment and you think oh this 20 seconds is going to go so well, we should pump that out, is being mindful of the person, of what that clip out of context and the impact of that and not just because you think it's going to be great engagement for the website or the broadcaster or whoever it may be.
So I think keeping the person front of mind rather than the engagement and the reach of said clip, I think is really important. But I've had lots of support from people I've worked with and people in the game, you know, managers that I know who've been really supportive of when I've experienced things, which is great. And I think, you know, because those, they go through it as well, because social media is, that's the reality of social media now. So I think it's just making sure that, yeah, you support people to protect them from certain things, for sure.
Rosie Duffield
Thanks, Chair. Um, again, everything you've said in that answer, I think, you know, totally resonates with all of us as politicians. Fiona, we've been told that women's sport currently occupies less than 10% of annual TV and print sports coverage. That's quite a shock, actually, isn't it, 10%?
What is your view of that percentage relative to the demand? Because, you know, we know about those figures in netball and just women's World Cup and all of that, and it doesn't seem to tally with how much coverage it gets.
Fiona Tomas
Yeah, it's woefully low when you hear it out loud, isn't it? And, you know, that's the highest it's ever been. Like, you know, 10, 15 years ago, it would have been as low as 2%, I would argue. And I think we've already touched on it before. It hasn't necessarily kind of tallied with a rise in the number of sports writing roles for women.
They've very much stayed the same, if not, you know, we're talking really women's football specialists who, like we have one, I know the Mail have one, the Guardian have two.
Women's football is probably leading the way on those kind of specific, on that sort of front. But yeah, it's, I think in print it's difficult. I think during major events when interest levels will spike, that's when you'll tend to see women's, female athletes on the front pages, actually being the front page news. And, you know, during the regular season, it's very hard to come by unless there's, you know, a massive story that broke, or you're fortunate enough as a print journalist to land a big exclusive which is sort of agenda-setting, etc. I think it goes back to the reality that a lot of the people on sports desks are male.
You know, there aren't a lot of women in editorial roles. There aren't a lot of women who are, you know, at the decision table per se. And although it has got better, I think I think the quality of women's sport coverage has grown significantly over the past five to to eight years. We're seeing lots of, you know, long-read interviews. We're seeing a lot more analysis, which, you know, 10, 15 years ago, it would be very, very sketchy, you know, very few and far between.
And and I think that's the ongoing challenge. You know, women's sport wants to be female athletes want to be taken seriously. Like, it's their profession. They they want to be critiqued. They want to be, you know, they want to be critiqued from a a performance perspective.
And there has been a big push on that front, but I think there's still a lot of work to be done. You know, it goes without saying that the column inches are very firmly rooted in men's sport.
Rosie Duffield
Thank you. I want to move on to Flo because Fiona just touched on analysis. And that's the other thing, isn't it? It's not just coverage, it's kind of let's discuss this and get really down into it. And Flo, you've previously commented on the lack of quality in-depth analysis and the coverage of that.
What do you think are the challenges that still remain? You mentioned the economic landscape and that women's sport is still seen as a minority interest, which seems crazy because we're the majority of the population. Do you think that plays a huge part?
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
Yeah, I think the opportunity is with digital media. That's something that I'm really focused on and I think with, you know, we spoke about content creators and how they're coming into the landscape, but I do think the digital approach from legacy media or digital approach of new media in general can put a spotlight on women's sport. And that's really important because I think some of the traditional media are going to constantly keep going through the same motions and going through the same cycles. And they will still focus on the top six teams of the Premier League and not necessarily even EFL, for example. So I think we're going to go through those same patterns and that rarely changes.
But I do think the rise of digital new media allows people to create that for themselves.
Certainly something I'm trying to do, which is, you know, a frustration having worked in many sports environments where you were just telling the same story about the same England player or the lack of Women's FA Cup prize money, which is an important story to be told, but you can't be saying the same thing every season. So I think the good thing is is there are people like myself and others who are trying to challenge that or trying to say, look, can we actually write about what's happening on the pitch for once? And I think that will continue to happen, you know, within traditional media landscapes too, because people are fighting for that. But there is more of a kind of a new media and digital media push I think to make that happen.
Rosie Duffield
Thank you. Natalie, would you think that you're able to go more into that area now that you're freelance?
Does it free you up to kind of concentrate on that analysis if that's what you'd like to do?
Natalie Pirks
I think it probably frees me up to have an opinion because I haven't been able to have that my whole career and I can now, whether I want to because of all the things we've already said. You know, that that's the big question, I guess. I suppose it goes back a bit to what I was saying earlier, if it bleeds it leads in news in in the digital world, if you're if you're getting clicks and they will push it higher. So if they can see that people are reading it, they'll push it higher. But Premier League football and, you know, if England are playing men's football, it will just dominate.
And so women's sport just gets pushed down and it becomes what's the story. You know, if the Lionesses are winning, if they go and, you know, win and they're now in the playoff final, that's a story.
But it will get jumped by what Lisandro Martinez said last night, because that's men's football. So it's almost like a hierarchy thing. And I'm just not sure unless you're in the middle of a World Cup for the women or the Euros for the women and they happen to do quite well. You know, I've been in situations where I've covered women's finals and it's been dropped from the broadcast because they lost. So that was only a decade ago.
We're not talking about 50 years. So, you know, I think we're much better, but they still women still need to seem to do to do something exceptional. They have to be winning and there has to be a story and there has to be something for journalists to get stuck into. It can't just be they've done this thing. You know, it has to be exceptional.
Speaker 1
Thank you. Thank you, Rosie. You've all given extremely powerful and helpful evidence this afternoon. Thank you very much for for doing it. And although it is it is very depressing, it's a consistent theme from this inquiry, this sense that women in sport have to be kind of exceptional.
And it's come across again today that you need a thick skin to sort of succeed. And it's really tough to hear this. So I'm just going to ask in the last one minute a hard question. What's the one thing now that you think would be most helpful to a young woman starting out trying to have a career in sports journalism? What's the one thing that would be most useful that you would like to see that young woman have to have a good career in sports journalism?
Told you it was a hard question. Who wants to start?
Flo Lloyd-Hughes
I've got one if you need more time. I think recognition.
I mean, it's something we talk about a lot in our industry because so rarely are women recognized for their achievements in industry awards or elsewhere and beyond. So I think a way that recognizes women to keep them coming back, because that's the kind of stuff that keeps, if you feel like you're respected by your peers, you're doing good work, you feel like you're doing impactful work, it's making a difference, your audience appreciates it, that stuff I think keeps you going. And I think this industry probably really does grind people out because they rarely see that recognition.
Fiona Tomas
It's a good one, because we can all relate to the number of women who were shortlisted for journalism, sports journalism awards.
I would say don't let your gender hold you back. I know it's easier said than done, but if you want to paint your nails pink and walk into a room full of men and ask the questions that truly matter, which can be hard, especially when they're relevant to female athletes, don't shy away from doing that because you know, I think when you ask those sorts of questions, people, you automatically kind of pull the wool up from someone's eyes, often male eyes, and you open the door to a completely different avenue that they might have not explored or thought of. Yeah, just be you and although it's tough, kind of just, yeah, tough it out.
Natalie Pirks
I would just say it's not an industry for the meek, but it has got better. I know we've just spent maybe the last hour saying that it hasn't, but it has. I have had entire away ends chant sexual obscenities at me live on air. That doesn't happen now. It is much better.
There are more of us. We all know each other.
We all talk. We all have each other's backs. It is getting much better. But don't come in expecting it to be easy.
Speaker 34
Thank you very much. Thank you all three of you for, for coming this afternoon and for your fantastic evidence. Thank you.
Speaker 1
Hello and welcome to our second panel this afternoon and thank you so much all three of you for joining us. And I hope you've enjoyed listening to the first panel. I thought it was really interesting and it's given you a good flavor of the kinds of topics that we want to discuss with you this afternoon. For our second panel today, we're really pleased to be able to hear from Ashley Broadley, who's the chair of the Sports Journalists' Association. Thank you for coming.
Leon Mann, founder of the Black Collective of Media in Sports, and Barbara Slater, former director at BBC Sport. A really fantastic panel. Really looking forward to hearing from all of you and thank you for giving up your time.
Richard Quigley
Thank you, Chair, and to Ashley, first, welcome all of you. In terms of your assessment of accessibility to sports media for young women looking to get into the profession, how would you measure it? How would you say successful or otherwise it is?
Ashley Broadley
Well, at the SJA, I've also got a second hat. I'm also head of sport at the Press Association, the national news agency, so I've got, I'm looking at it from two different places. But from an SJA point of view, we measure it, we look at it through our shortlists, our people who apply for the awards, because we want to celebrate journalism through the SJA awards. That's our main, our flagship awards ceremony. So we look at how many young people are entering, we look at how many women are entering, and it's something we've looked at closely over the last few years.
It was mentioned just previously now about that and how important recognition is. So that's how we, that's the sort of some of the data that we have around it.
Richard Quigley
And would you say, you know, is it harder for young women to break into the industry? Are the measures saying otherwise? You know, are we all wasting our time here? What does it look like?
Ashley Broadley
Well, interestingly, we've got a job going at the moment that's just being advertised at PA, which is for a Premier League football reporter in London, which sounds really exciting and it will be. And also will be covering a bit of England cricket at Lord's and the Oval, etc. And I've just got some information this morning. We had 170 applicants as of this morning, and 19 were women.
So from a starting point of where you begin, that's, you know, what is it, just less than 10%. 10% is a percentage figure that we keep hearing, 10, 12%, it seems to be that sort of figure. We've got to look at why those people aren't applying for those jobs. Why aren't women applying for the sports journalist roles? I did some work a few years ago where we spoke to our recruitment department and we made the language on an advert specific.
I got people in women in football to retweet the job advert, and then we got the same, 200 applicants, 20 from women. So there's something fundamentally wrong there and why women aren't feeling as though they're comfortable applying for those roles. And I don't know the answer to that. Barbara, Leon, please feel free to add anything to what Ashley said.
Barbara Slater
I mean, I would echo what you've said and I think the issue is almost where are you recruiting from? Because I think that recruiting pool is almost a sort of a kind of filter that is making it more difficult for women. So if you are looking to appoint a journalist, actually more often than not you are looking for people with experience. So, you know, where are you going to look for people with experience? Well, it might be a local newspaper, it might be print media, it might be etc.
Speaker 39
And I think so it's almost systematic right the way through the system. And therefore it makes the more, if you like, the high-profile roles, that is in a way a consequence of what's happening, if you like, lower down.
Leon Mann
Yeah, I think it's an interesting question and one that as an industry we should be able to answer fairly easily.
I think um anecdotally we can say speaking and looking around our industry there's an underrepresentation of women. But I'm incredibly disappointed that we don't have any data points to look at. So even the three of us we can refer to different data points but it's not actually an industry-wide kind of picture. So how do you go about trying to solve a problem without understanding where it is? As BCOMS, um we're the Black Collective of Media in Sport, we are um a group of black men that started and then my wife told me off and pointed out that it was black men and actually black people are women as well.
So we quickly made a change in terms of um making sure we were relevant and actually kind of effective for our um for our industry. But we we we're a black-led group, um but we have done um a series of conferences that we call the D Word.
In fact, last week at the Premier League's headquarters, we held our sixth D-word. We hold them every two years. And we do it like a bit of a head count, essentially, as diversity that we can see, which is very dangerous because, of course, we're only able to kind of that person, they're mixed heritage. If you look at one of my daughters, maybe she wouldn't count as someone's looking in terms of she's got blonde hair and blue eyes. My other daughter would count, for example.
They both should be as part of a head count of women of color within, you know, a data point. But the fact that we don't know, we don't have data, is a real kind of problem. At every single D-word conference that we've held, we have asked the industry, please come together as leaders and put some research together.
Because what we're talking about here is just what we can see. So we can see reporters, we can see, you know, we can look at a byline in a newspaper and understand, we can look at who's on social media, but actually the majority of our industry you can't see. So if I was to walk through a production management side of broadcast, it would be majority women. So that's an interesting kind of dynamic. Why is it that women are arranging and doing the operational structural things?
If you were to walk through the kind of editorial side, if you like, the filmmakers, then it's mainly men. That was my experience of different places. Mainly men, I'd say. And Barbara, I'd love you to challenge me because I'd want us to have the data to be able to kind of back it up. But in terms of what I experienced being on the shop floor, I saw an underrepresentation of women in particular areas and an underrepresentation of men in other areas.
But we don't have any data.
So this is all finger in the air stuff. And that's not how you solve a serious problem. We need to come together as an industry, put a little bit of money, dare I say, aside, maybe get some support from government to say this is something that we need to look at. Maybe work with universities in terms of who's coming out there. That's not the only pathway, but that's a significant one.
We know there's lots of research from universities that shows people are coming out waving their kind of qualification in the air and then they haven't got the networks or the soft skills necessarily to get into the industry. So there's loads of things, loads of opportunities that we have. But to answer your question, yes, it is much harder for women, I would say.
Barbara Slater
I mean, I think there is a degree of tracking of that in the legacy media. But I think what we are seeing is such fundamental shifts in this industry.
I mean, they are huge. And actually, it's very difficult once you're looking at the social media and the digital world actually to make those assessments because so much of it, it isn't just about pure journalism skills. It's about, and we've heard it mentioned before, about the content creation and influencers. And if you like, I would almost describe them as subject matter experts. And that might be an athlete that now creates their own channel or network.
So we're seeing on the one hand, I think, a shrinking of opportunities, particularly in those traditional media. But you're seeing a literal explosion of opportunities elsewhere. And I think if one wants to address some of the issues, I think it's really important that we're looking at where the future opportunities are coming from.
You know, and I'm possibly slightly more broadcast rather than journalism. And you know, I think some of the progress we've seen with women has been based on their success as athletes. So we're sort of seeing, if you like, new roles being created for people that have got the credibility in the eyes of the audience, and the audience want to engage with them and they want to follow what they've got to say. You know, you just look at the explosion in podcasts. Who is succeeding in the podcast world?
Who isn't succeeding in the podcast world? More often than not, it's people with a reputation, a credibility and an expertise. So how do we make sure that our women are having those opportunities?
And I would say, actually, the investment that's been made on the field of play has been really, really important and actually allowing women to be credible in sport. And I don't think it was that long ago where they were not. And you look at 2012 and the extraordinary success. You look at our women footballers, our women rugby players, women cricketers. I mean they are, they're, they're if you like in the first battalion to really win over a mindset change about the value of women's sport, its importance, the enjoyment a fan can get from it.
And I think what we've got to hope is that over time those role models, and they might be on the field of play, but that will translate to an industry that is more welcoming to women and accepts women.
Because the truth is, I'm sure, well actually I've got two men, so I can't say you've probably experienced it. But, you know, the, you know, I've been in a room when I was a sort of junior and I just was a non-person. Why would anybody care about my opinion, you know, I was just a woman, you know? And, and that is fundamentally changing.
Richard Quigley
No, that's a really good point. And I think so, two-part question then: what can, what more can government do to encourage more women into the non-playing sports roles? And then, connected but will sound unconnected, apprenticeships: are they accessible and are they a good thing in your industry? Leon, first.
Leon Mann
Well, I, I just wanted to address the tracking point, Barbara, just very briefly, because Sky aren't talking to TNT, TNT aren't talking to BBC. There is no kind of overall industry tracking. Individually they may be, but... I'm sure BBC will know exactly what their stats are.
They're not being shared with us as BCOMS, but we're not asking directly, maybe we should. But we would love to know what it looks like behind the scenes at Sky Sports. You know, we would love to know what it looks like behind the scenes across the print media, because our stats are showing it doesn't look great. So let's find out what the picture is. We know it's not good.
It's not going to be a good news story. It's fine, let's just crack on with what we're actually going to do and have a plan from there. In terms of some of the things that BCOMS have done, so in recognizing that pathways into the industry are incredibly hard. So people are just putting in applications, sorry, unsuccessful. What I've discovered through my career is actually this is a contacts business.
This is about who you know. This is about them understanding who you are, this is about understanding where the opportunities are. So we put together what we've called our BCOMS Academy.
It's 25 young people in the north, 25 young people in the south. And across the year, they will go into different places like the BBC, like ITV, like TNT, Sky, News UK, etc, etc. And they will do masterclasses, so they'll understand the environment, but also allow the industry to see these young people. And as a result of the masterclasses we've been doing, we're really, really proud. Our masterclasses in the south have a 100% success rate of all 25 young people going into paid work.
We're really, really proud of that. In the north, it's 70%. So again, it goes to show when you're really intentional and you have a plan and you give people an opportunity, this is about opportunity.
There is talent there, but when talent doesn't have opportunity, you know, again it just drifts away and then people work in different areas of the industry. So I can only really talk to the work that I've been involved in helping to deliver and there are people that work for BCOMS that deliver this and are specialists in working with younger people. They are not journalists, they're working with organizing young people to get them into places. The industry has been incredibly positive and engaged with this. In the north it's the BBC in specifically who support that.
In the south we've got some commercial funding from Nike to be able to kind of do things.
We want to scale up this work. Journalists aren't necessarily good at getting funding, so it's not our skill set. But there are things that can potentially be done if there's a unified approach to these problems. And I'd say on these masterclasses, anticipating this question, the ambition is always to have a 50-50 in terms of gender split on that. I would say we are close to that, but we haven't quite achieved it just yet.
Probably around 40% we're probably tracking at at the moment, which is not good enough. If we're going to hold people to account, we have to hold ourselves to account as part of that.
Richard Quigley
That's interesting that you say that, you know, it's tracking at 40%, which is great, you know, it's four times the average you'd hear in the industry. But what is, you know, what is stopping that other 10%? There's obviously something fundamental out there that's stopping it happening. So just in terms of the apprenticeship point and access one way or another, is you saying targeted, focused, supported, you're in?
Leon Mann
I think quite simply it's a plan. If we sat here to make more money, we would all have a plan, right? We would have things that we measure. We would have things that we do. People would be accountable.
If someone didn't do their job properly, they might get sacked.
With this, it's just chip shop. It's just rely on an individual who might give a monkeys and put all the all the pressure and kind of pat them on the back etc. and then see where it ends up. There is no industry approach here.
Richard Quigley
Fair enough. Barbara or or Ashley in terms of anything government could do to encourage more women into the non-playing...
Barbara Slater
Into non-playing roles? Sorry, I'll go first. Um, again I would say the importance of role models. I think it's worth mentioning, and I've obviously left the BBC so I'm not speaking on behalf of the BBC, but I should say that when I was there we we did reach a 40% in our department, which actually I think was because there was a plan, but I do I totally agree with you, there was not a plan across the industry. And I think that that's very different.
And actually, it can be very powerful when you work together. And I remember conversations we had with Channel 4 when they were doing the Paralympics because obviously they'd brought a lot of disability athletes into their team, and we didn't want them to just disappear. So I think we tried to find ways of actually where there are opportunities. So I do think cross-collaboration. But I do think the legacy media are shrinking.
And I think that actually they could do a lot more. But in the end, I think there is a bit of a free-for-all going on over here. And I think it's how we can support people more within that because that's probably where the opportunities are for the future and that's where we will achieve maybe long-term greater equality. And I remember, I think it was your comment, you said, "Is this something we have to do?"
I I I would personally very much dispute that. I think it was seen as incredibly important in terms of having that relationship with your with your audience with your audience. So I I'm not trying to get the legacy media off the hook by any means. It's not perfect, far from it. But I I worry more around where the future opportunities are coming from and in many ways a broader a broader mindset.
Ashley Broadley
Just very briefly going back to the stats again, I suppose SJA's in a unique position in that we've got a wide range of membership. So our we've got close to a thousand members and around 12% of those are women. So again, that 12%, 10%, 12% figure's there coming in again.
Interestingly we've also got an SJA Academy which has around 500 members. These are young people trying to get into the industry who we help and support. And that percentage of women is about 25% to 30%. So there's something happening there between people who are wanting to get into the industry and being interested and then eventually getting into the industry. So that's just going back to some stats.
Barbara Slater
But I think that's where role models are really important. And when we've got fantastic role models, and Natalie mentioned it didn't she, in Clare Balding and Gabby Logan and Kelly Cates, I think it gives to young women this is an industry that actually can welcome me.
And so I do think that there's a big time lag, but I think it's absolutely crucial that we celebrate some fantastic women broadcasters who have, you know, overcome, I'm sure, huge challenges in getting to their position. But I think that does open the door and allows people to sort of, if you like, see themselves and therefore feel this is something that I can do.
Ashley Broadley
And I think that's where the SJA has a role to play because we recognize the incredible work that journalists do, but it's the shortlists don't reflect that because there's not women on there. We had a review of this in 2023, which we commissioned internally, which I'm happy to share with you, and came up with some recommendations about how we can improve the shortlists because it's important that those role models exist. A lot of women were telling us, you know, it's a model for excellence, having an SJA award can be career-changing.
You see journalists being interviewed on television and they've always got their SJA trophy in the background, which is nice. So we commissioned this review, we found a few things, we've implemented a few of the recommendations, such as trying to get as much as possible on the panels 50/50 gender split. We also did a number of other things, like looking for workshops and mentoring, that was something that really came out of it. What happened though, we lost our major funding partner, we're going to go back to money now. We lost our major sponsor and then for 18 months after that, we were spending our time just trying to get this awards ceremony to happen.
And we're all volunteers on the SJA committee and this was just like, that was our priority, otherwise it wouldn't have happened. So now, since April when we had our awards, we have improved the number of women on the shortlist, that has increased. But it's still not where it should be. But we've also implemented a new structure on the committee where I've asked for subcommittee groups, one in particular looking at inclusion and diversity so they can concentrate on that. Because what we found is we were all concentrating on trying to get the awards ceremony off the ground and we weren't looking at the other aspects that we should have done.
So yeah, that's that. And the mentorship is something key to that, something very key to that, something we're hoping to improve in the next year or so.
Kim Leadbeater
Thank you, Chair, and thank you all for coming. Ashley, it's always good to hear a good strong Yorkshire accent in Parliament, and as in true Yorkshire style, it does always come back to money, you're quite right. Barbara, I'm going to start with you if I can, and I'll just disclose that I had the pleasure of coming to see you at BBC Sport, I think it's about four years ago, and had a fantastic visit, so thank you very much for that. I hope you're enjoying the freedom of being able to speak a bit more freely maybe now than you could. But you've touched on this in terms of role models, both in terms of presenters you've particularly talked about, but in terms of having women in senior decision-making roles when it comes to recruitment and progression of women in sports media, how important do you think that is?
Barbara Slater
It's absolutely crucial, and in many ways, I think that there's, some still applies, you know, you need to see women in those senior roles to allow, I think, people to kind of, you know, aspire. You know, there's a long way to go. It felt very lonely at times, I'm afraid.
I wish it didn't. But I think there's sort of lots of complicated reasons for that. Often, you've got a very, very talented woman and, you know, for personal reasons, they decide other things are more important. A work-life balance, I think, is incredibly relevant here because it is a very competitive industry. And Natalie spoke very well on that.
And there is a pressure, and that doesn't necessarily always work with family life. And I think that should be somehow recognized and built in. I think it is better, significantly better.
And I hope that over the next X years, we'll see far more women coming through. And interestingly, I mean, look, when I joined, it was many, many years ago. If you'd said to me there would ever have been a head of department that was a woman, I would have laughed at you. And I've said, that is simply not possible. I would now say that if you have got the absolute steel and determination and the talent, that you can aspire to all sorts of roles.
You know, we have a woman chair of the FA. If I look at across UK Sport, what an amazing track record of really impressive senior women. You know, Liz Nicholl comes to mind, Sally Munday. You know, women who are absolutely shaping British sport at that level.
So I think massive progress is made, but whoa, it's not there yet.
Kim Leadbeater
Just on that point, going back to Richard's question about apprenticeships, we were fortunate enough to be able to go to Sky Sports this morning and we met some absolutely outstanding young female apprentices on their scheme. And that was a scheme I didn't know about, which was extremely impressive. And you could tell that those four young women had got huge futures ahead of them. But in terms of the barriers that they may face, what do you think the biggest barriers are that might stop them from progressing?
Barbara Slater
I suppose it is some of the attitudes that they will encounter. Because sadly there are quite a few dinosaurs still out there. And I thought it was very interesting, somebody talked about allyship. And allyship is really, really, really important.
And seeking those out and rewarding those that demonstrate that allyship, I think is incredibly important. I think the environment in the workplace is much better, but I don't think it's necessarily there yet. I mean, I just hope they're all very tough. Can I just say I'm so pleased social media, sorry.
Speaker 1
Should we, should we break? We are going to need to, I'm afraid, suspend just because we've got to go and vote briefly, unless there's anybody here who, no, I suppose we'll lose quorum anyway. So we're going to have to go and vote. I'm so sorry. We'll return as soon as we can.
We'll just suspend the session.
Democracy in action.
I will have to go at some point.
Kim Leadbeater
Lovely, thank you, and thank you for that, Barbara.
Leon, just coming on to you, you've, in the nicest possible way, seemed to have been doing this for quite a while. How have you seen diversity within the sports media sector change over time?
Leon Mann
Yeah, we had this question at our conference two weeks ago, a D-Work conference, and there were varied answers from those in the room. So I have my perspective and I'll probably start with that in terms of saying things have absolutely changed. We're seeing Jeanette Kwakye, for example, who is on our BCOMS board, she's emerged from being a former athlete into now being a major part of the BBC's talent team. Reshmin Chowdhury is an Asian woman who's come through from Real Madrid TV to being on TNT as a lead presenter for them. There are examples that things have got better, but not enough.
So many of the people at the conference would shout me down for saying this here. And so it's important to share that perspective as well, because for them, they said things haven't changed at all, which for me, I don't think that's the case. But they feel, in terms of their industry, they're feeling that things haven't changed at all, which is an interesting feeling. In terms of the stats, it would be great to like show what has changed so people can, you know, have a look at what's changed. But how they're feeling, they're feeling that things haven't changed.
And I think sometimes when we talk about role models and change, it's kind of like, who are we talking about? You know, are we talking about women of color? Are we talking about women who wear hijab? Are we talking about, you know, the wide spectrum of what it means to be a woman or to be diverse?
Because often, you know, and Barbara, this is not a slight on what you're saying at all, because those are very good examples. But those are all white women. Many of them have incredible support networks to help them achieve. And that's not saying that it would have been easier for them at all, because if your dad is a famous footballer, you will have other challenges in the workplace because people assume you're being given things. So it's a complex conversation.
It's not kind of a straight line thing. And again, many people at that conference would shout me down for even sharing that perspective here because they don't feel that's the case. They feel people get favors because of who their family members are, etc. But I believe it's much more complex than that, and that's what I would want to represent here. But things are getting better, but they're not getting better for everybody.
A lot of the young black and Asian women who are coming into the industry are seeing the Jeanettes, the Reshmins, the Alex Scotts etc on screen and going I want to be like them. But the pathway is incredibly tricky. And many of them haven't won gold medals in Olympics or been in Olympics. Many of them haven't played 400 times for their country or won major medals in football in this country or been athletes at all. So they begin to question things.
And I guess that's where a Reshmin Chowdhury becomes more of an achievable role model because she's sat presenting the Champions League on TNT as somebody who hasn't kicked a ball. Sorry Reshmin if you're watching and you have, but as far as I know she's a good friend of mine, she hasn't played professionally.
She's worked through those professional layers. So we need to consider all of those things when we're talking about who the role models are and who gets opportunities and chances because I have a major problem going into a school in Tottenham, in Brixton, wherever there is very diverse communities if you like, and saying you're not going to be something, you're better off becoming a professional footballer or athlete before you get a chance to be a presenter. That we can't, that can't be the case.
Kim Leadbeater
We talked about that a bit this morning as well in terms of school careers education, that most schools don't even talk about those jobs. So most kids don't even know those jobs exist. So I think there's maybe a piece of work to be done there.
In terms of, and we talked a lot about race, we've talked a lot about gender, and I guess with lots of other issues, there will be an intersection with disability and LGBT communities as well. So what do you think the most important intervention is to improve diversity within sports media? And do we need different interventions for different groups?
Leon Mann
Yeah, I mean, you know, that intersectionality, those protected characteristics, and I've talked in the past about it feels like there's a bit of a hierarchy in terms of protected characteristics, of which disability would sit at the very bottom. If you're black and disabled, like good luck to you, because, you know, we've got Ade Adepitan, who's a good example of someone who's amazing, who's made his way through, again, former athlete in terms of his pathway into the, the presentacy. But I think we, we don't have enough information and knowledge around those experiences. We don't have enough data to refer back into. So I can give you a view, but it's very, very much based on my experience of the world as a straight man of mixed heritage from North London.
And that might be of value, but it's kind of again, it's not anchored in all the things that if you were trying to change any industry, it would be around data. It would be around serious knowledge. It would be about bringing serious expertise. It would be about a pathway plan. It would be about what we're saying to our universities, what we're saying to our media schools.
They're calling me going, we're not getting enough diverse people from the colleges. I'm going, right, okay, that's another problem to add to the list to solve. If we're all really joined up about this, we can do some amazing things. I'm really positive about it because the change that we've had, in my view, has come down to individuals who care and have done things and have made decisions as individuals. But that's what it is.
It's like there's a woman at the BBC, formerly of the BBC, Shelley Alexander. She said, Leon, I reckon you could do something at the BBC one day. And I was an anti-racism campaigner and I was like, oh, what, really? You think I could?
"Because I've always wanted to do that, but never saw anyone who looked like me who was doing it." "What about Garth Crooks?" I said, "Well, he played 400 games for Tottenham Hotspur in the top league, so I'm alright at football, but I'm not that good." So, like, what is the plan? What what are the conversations?
And I must say, I've been really, really encouraged by the individual conversations I've had from very senior leaders right at the top of Sky, TNT, the newspapers, Press Association, BBC obviously, ITV. But what's what's missing is coordination. And do we do that as a just just for 15 years, we're a charity just like six months now, hardly got any funding, we're I'm self-funding part of this.
Like are we are we going to solve this problem or is this going to be something that's seriously joined up with a proper plan?
Speaker 1
Brilliant, thank you very much. Conscious of time, so we're going to have to move on now to Rachel, but we are going to have to whiz through them, I think both questions and answers would be great.
Margaret Rachel Taylor
I mean, it's interesting you're talking about the the pathways for for people who have been fairly famous athletes or sportspeople, and that's kind of where our inquiry first started about participation in sport more broadly from from the playing. But moving on from that, Ashley, I'll come to you first, in your experience, how supportive is the sports media sector of employees with family or caring responsibilities?
Ashley Broadley
Yeah, I mean, I can only look at it through what I oversee at PA. You know, I came from a news background. So when I was at PA in the news desk and then moved to the sports desk and I saw that there was far less women and it was something that, you know, was quite stark. I put in place some initiatives that have had some success. We for the Paris Olympics, for example, we sent eight reporters and I insisted on it being 50-50 gender split.
We've improved our maternity leave. We've got a woman CEO and a woman chief people officer right at the top of the business, which is really encouraging and great role models. And slowly, and to Leon's point, it's been a slow process though. So now we've got a deputy sports editor who's a woman. But that has taken some years because people remain in the positions a long time and the industry is shrinking.
So put those two things together and you've got blockages.
You've got blockers there. And that is something that has to be overcome somehow. And very quickly on to Leon's point about collaboration, that is something that came out in our report about the awards in that we've got all these amazing groups, Women in Football, BCOMS, the SJA. We do talk, but we're not talking well enough together. And I think if we can, with the support of government, then I think it could be a much more powerful organisation that can get sports editors, decision makers round a table and we can be a much more forceful organisation.
Margaret Rachel Taylor
Barbara, do you think sport has a particular sort of workplace culture as distinct from journalism more generally?
Margaret Rachel Taylor
A distinct between sports journalism and journalism more generally. Do you think there's a different sort of culture in the workplace?
Barbara Slater
I would say there's maybe a bit of a legacy issue there that I think over time will be overcome. I believe it will. So there's probably a starting point that in a way going back to sort of expertise, well you know do women have the expertise? I mean hopefully that's just something, a myth that's just, we can get rid of, of course. But I just think there's a bit of a time lag.
So I think it is tougher in sports journalism. Yes, I do think it is. And there's probably still a reluctance to maybe have women talking about men's sport. That isn't sufficiently in place.
And I also think one of the, the big challenges around what you was just saying is it is increasingly a freelance world. And, and I do think that you should not lose sight of the fact that I think that does disadvantage women because there isn't the, there, and there is not the workplace protections for a very, very freelance-driven culture. And, and I, and I would say that that's, and as, as legacy shrinks, um, I, I think that's probably only going to get worse.
Margaret Rachel Taylor
You've taken me onto my next question very helpfully.
Leon, do you think that freelance culture has an impact on other groups as well as women?
Leon Mann
Yeah, I mean, interestingly, looking at having more freelancers, I thought there'd be an opportunity there to diversify your workforce. Because for years we were told, well, actually there's no jobs here, so there's very little movement. And to address the question beforehand about sport versus the wider media, it kind of feels like lots of people don't leave sport because everyone's hanging on for the next Olympics, the next World Cup. It's a great way of working in the sports media, it really is. And a lot of people do hang around for those big moments.
So that would be an interesting thing to look at again. I haven't seen any data points to be able to refer to.
Leon Mann
No. But really I would flip this on its head and say, okay, we've got more freelance opportunities, so you have more opportunities to choose who you have coming in. You're not wedded to the person who won't move from their contract because they're waiting for the Olympics in LA. So you can have more freedom of movement in terms of who you choose to employ. Employ more women, more freelancers.
I think there's maybe an opportunity there. But and that would actually, I think, suit the kind of trends I'm seeing with many of the young people who don't actually want a full-time job necessarily at the BBC because they can do their content creation and then they can do their kind of production work and they can live between those two worlds and have a more interesting, maybe, career as opposed to being on one path. I think it would be interesting to do a session like this with young people to get their perspective as well.
Rosie Duffield
Thank you, Chair. Barbara first, what's your assessment of how effectively broadcasters approach the safeguarding of their staff, particularly those in the public eye?
And I'm really mindful of the fact that actually this is all to do with the fact that we're essentially in a Wild West situation because legacy media just isn't employing anyone.
Barbara Slater
I mean, I'm so pleased that the abuse in social media has come up several times actually in the discussion because I just think this is a massive issue. And there is only so much an employer can do. And by the way, I think there is a real appetite to offer support and help in these circumstances. But it's incredibly difficult. And I suppose, and I know I'm reaching way beyond the powers probably of this group, but I suppose I just don't understand how it's possible for people to be so abusive without them being identified and called to account.
You know, if a newspaper published an article that, you know, defames somebody or what have you, I mean, there would be consequences. Yet it seems to me entirely possible that you can say what you like, however derogatory, and you know, and nothing is done. And I know, and I'm sure other organisations are the same, you know, there is a moderation of the comments. So there are people who are acting as a filter, so if there are comments, but that's that is controlled within only that organisation, not an individual's site. And I just don't think enough is is is done, frankly.
Rosie Duffield
Absolutely. Leon, I'm guessing, I mean, you've got organisations like Kick It Out that you've been really involved with and Show Racism the Red Card, but in terms of that Wild West, do you feel a bit lost as well? How do you control that?
Leon Mann
Yeah, I know Kick It Out have done a lot of work in this space, particularly around the protection of many of the footballers, and Sanjay Bhandari as chair's done loads and loads in this space. What we're seeing and hearing from our journalists is very, very similar to what Flo was sharing earlier. You share an opinion on something, there's a big pile-on. I've noticed what feels like a real coordinated response to some of the things that I might say on social media, where I almost feel like what I've said is just put in a WhatsApp group of the far right or forums on the far right, because there's so much engagement on that particular post and there's not on other bits. So it's something that we need to be aware of.
We know all the challenges that there are with freedom of speech, etc., etc., and the dynamic that exists. But it will absolutely put off young women from becoming journalists.
It'll put off people of colour. It'll put off it's going to put off so so many people. At the London Olympics in 2012, when it wasn't what how it was now, I saw household names jump off social media because they just couldn't deal with the abuse and do their job in the best possible way. I was I was shocked, but that was the reality that they faced. They could not do their job to the best of their ability with that in their ear.
Rosie Duffield
Well, thank you. Um, if the panel could recommend one practical intervention to reduce the abuse and harassment aimed at women, people of colour working in sports media, what would have the greatest effect? I'll start with Ashley.
Put you on the spot, sorry.
Ashley Broadley
Doesn't it sit with the social media companies' responsibility? I guess so, yeah. And it should be them who we are telling whether there's legislation that can be done around it or... but surely that is... like Barbara said, if we publish something that defames someone, you know, we would be held to account for that through IPSO or through the courts. But, you know, it's just... it is the Wild West as you say, so it's got to be... the buck stops with the social media companies.
Barbara Slater
It's the anonymity. Yeah. But surely if you, you know... I mean, people can create multiple accounts etc. etc., but ultimately surely they can be traced back to individuals.
Leon Mann
It would be interesting to see what the interventions around porn have been in terms of registering your passport or whatever I've read in the news and the impact that that has had positively in that space. That would be interesting to kind of review that because I do believe there needs to be some regulation here clearly. And if that involves you using a particular platform in this country, you have to share your, your details. I understand in other parts of the country, other parts in the world, sorry, so I've heard the argument for if you're in the Middle East, actually sharing your details was one example that I'd heard could be kind of dangerous for you using that platform. I understand that.
Do we have a different situation here in the UK that actually means we should be asking people to kind of register their passport, their details? I don't think we've had that conversation loudly enough, in my opinion, because something needs to change.
This is significant way beyond sports media.
Christine Jardine
Thank you very much. Just, I was remarking when you were all out, this is quite odd for me because I worked for both the Press Association and the BBC in my career, so déjà vu. But Barbara, I wonder if I could ask you, what factors do you think are influencing the prominence given to and the volume of women's sports broadcasting now?
Barbara Slater
Oh gosh, that's quite a big question. I mean, firstly, I think that huge progress has been made. And I think we have major events which have actually, I think, really ignited interest in women's sport, and I think they've provided a great platform.
I think it is a struggle though. And I think the truth is that the economic climate we're in, cutbacks to something like, you know, your public service broadcasters, definitely a massive challenge. And I think there are massive opportunities in the digital space. Um, an example of Netball, but the challenge there is getting the eyeballs to that content. So there is now, compared with even relatively recently, unprecedented choice.
Governing bodies are individually able to cover their events. And they might not have a traditional media partner, but there is YouTube and other opportunities and there's broadcasting in the digital space. The problem is how do you let an audience know it's happening?
And so what you, on the one hand, you've got massive opportunity, and on the other, you've got the diff- the challenge of audience ever finding that content. But I don't think we should lose sight of the importance of those pinnacle moments. Because that, that, I think the success across a number of events, including our women's football, women's rugby, etc., and our, and our athletes across Olympic sports, have fundamentally shifted an attitude and a mindset to women's sport. And I think we should not lose sight of it. I think the big challenge is how to keep that momentum going and how to build from it.
Because those pinnacle moments, I mean, you know, the women's football was one of the most watched television programs of the year. I mean, of anything, of dramas, of comedies, of etc. Um, that was extraordinary. You think about that a few years ago, people would have said that's, that's impossible. But it's not yet translating down.
And so broadcasters are going to look at audience numbers.
They are, because it's your job, isn't it, to, to make sure that what you're, you're broadcasting, you know, appeals to as broad a section of the, of the population as you can, accepting that in a public service space, you can take risks. You can take more risks than you can if you're a, a predominantly commercially driven model. And, and I would say we've, we've seen that, the evidence of that. So, so it's, it's a, it's a moment of, of concern. But, but I don't think we should lose sight of progress made.
And I think one of the challenges, how do you let people know there is actually a, a really huge volume of coverage of women's sport, but it goes under the radar?
Christine Jardine
Sky have called for a, um, targeted tax relief for live broadcast of women's sports.
What are your thoughts on that and do you think that could help drive that?
Barbara Slater
Well, I would say interventions, the listed event legislation, we've actually had women's events listed now. Those protections and those interventions, I think if they are proportionate, should absolutely take place. This is, women's sport is a great space of opportunity. And it's worth really getting behind it and supporting it because imagine if we had greater equality, how the value of that more broadly to, you know, you look at men's sport and the money and everything that's generated there. I mean, if you could start to see women's sport viewed in the same way, this is a massive opportunity.
So, proportionate and sensible intervention, absolutely.
Leon Mann
No, apart from Alexis Ohanian speaks incredibly well on this as a business person focused on making money. If we look at things like that, things change pretty quickly. When people want to make money, they make big decisions and they do big things.
Ashley Broadley
Just on the amount of content of women's sport, it has increased. I mean, we've seen a lot of newspapers put some in. Premier League still rules, as was said at the early panel. We've introduced at the SJA a women's football journalist award to recognise how much reporting goes into that now.
And then with my PA hat on, we ripped up our spec some five, six years ago and now do comprehensive coverage of WSL, Lionesses, women's cricket, women's rugby, the Hundred cricket women's, and we've dropped off some other sports because of that. But, you know, I'm keen on that we have that content out there for customers to use if they so wish. And also internally, it shows that we are supporting women's sport as part of our organization.
Speaker 1
Thank you. Thank you. You've all given brilliant evidence this afternoon. Thank you. I just have one final question just to ask Barbara before we close.
And I think the general theme of everything we've heard this afternoon is that you've said things probably are getting better. But we started off at the beginning with not enough applications that are coming in for the jobs, even now. And we've also talked about the challenge of there's athletes being translated across because they kind of come with the currency of having that prominence. So yes, things are getting better and that's good to hear.
But from your rich experience, where are the biggest remaining challenges? For what is it, what is the reason that there are not more women in that application pile?
Barbara Slater
Well, I think it's where you're recruiting from. So I think you've got to track it right back down to the universities. And I certainly remember we, we, we, when I was in post, we did work with universities. And we were always incredibly taken by universities for which equality was, was, was important. And it was interesting, for some universities, it just wasn't an issue that they were even considering.
So, you know, I've gone and, and, and lectured and spoken and, and, and you look across a room of people and, oh yes, there's a woman at the back. And it literally is like that. So, so I think it is, this isn't, this isn't just a top-end issue.
It it's got to go right the way down. And almost to the playground where, you know, if you're in a playground, the chances are the girls are standing around the outside and the boys are playing football. And and it's it's that rooted in in and and so that so I don't think we're going to see big changes until there is more societal change, which in a way is why I think if you go to the top end, it's where you want attitudes and mindsets to change towards women's sport. That it's seen to be it's got credibility, it's got kudos, it's I want to be that champion footballer, I want to win that medal at the games. And okay, a lot of people won't be able to do that, but I still think it opens doors to a role in the industry.
And we shouldn't just look at journalism, if this is a whole broadcasting, there's a mass of technical roles there, which again is a massive space of opportunity. And again, we sit very male-dominated, we don't see women. And if you probably go to the technical colleges, I haven't been, I don't know, I have to admit, but I suspect you're going to see a similar balance. So your nursery slopes, if you like, your training grounds are still very, very male-dominated.
Speaker 1
Brilliant. We'll call it to a close there. Thank you. Thank you so much to all three of you, really fantastic evidence this afternoon. Thank you for giving us your time.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.