Public Accounts Committee

2 November 2026

Public Accounts Committee Actual start House of Commons

Follow its sittings
20:18 - 22:07
Speaker 1
Order.  Welcome to the Public Accounts Committee on Monday the 2nd of November 2026. 

Since 2014, A&E departments at the national level have failed to meet their constitutional target of 95% of patients should be discharged, transferred, or admitted within 4 hours of arriving at A&E.  In addition to this, proportion of patients waiting in A&E for over 12 hours or more has tripled from around 3% before COVID-19 to around 10% last year, 25-6.  And in May 26 of this year, during any 24-hour period, almost 3,000 people were waiting on corridors.  Not only have wait times, but also costs are rising, too.  The cost per patient in A&E has increased by a third, from £211 in 2018-19 to £280 in 24-5. 

Overall spending in A&E is also increased from 4.3 billion in 18-19 to 6.6 in 24-5. 

This represents a wholly unacceptable level of care with the increase in long waits and rise of corridor care significantly impacting safety, patient safety.  Analysis by the Offices of National Statistic estimates that patients waiting in A&E for 12 or more hours are twice as likely to die as patients waiting for two hours.  So today, we will therefore be challenging NHS England and the department DHSC on A&E waiting times, patient experience in hospital, as well as rising cost costs and flow within hospitals.  So we have a very senior team here with us today.  Would each of you like to please introduce yourself starting with you, Permanent Secretary? 
22:07 - 22:12
Speaker 3
Thank you.  Good afternoon.  I'm Samantha Jones, Permanent Secretary at the Department of Health and Social Care. 
22:13 - 22:16
Speaker 2
Hi, Jim Mackey, Chief Exec NHS England. 
22:16 - 22:22
Speaker 4
Thank you.  Hi, Dr Emma Rowland, I'm an A&E consultant, and I'm the NHSE Exec for Performance and Delivery. 
22:22 - 22:30
Speaker 6
Tim Briggs, clinician surgeon, National Director of Clinical Improvement, Elective and Elective Recovery and Chair of the GIRFT programme. 
22:30 - 23:02
Speaker 1
Thank you all very much.  I think, Dr Emma and Professor Tim, this is your first time at the committee.  You are very welcome and, I'm I hope at least the committee, even if you don't enjoy it will enlighten things for you and us.  So, I'm going to start.  I think hopefully you've been warned by about Anna's top of the session question? 

Maybe not.  Anyway, so, Anna will and you'll have to do your best to answer us, please.  So, Anna. 

23:02 - 23:52

Anna Dixon

Thank you, Chair. And before I go in, I guess I should just declare potential conflict of interest having worked myself at the Department of Health previously.

So, we had you in previously at the time that the reorganisation of the NHS England was announced. Obviously, the health bill is currently passing through to give the sort of legislative abolition of NHS England. As it was debated in the House of Lords, there was quite considerable discussion about the transition plan and the costs of transition. And I just wondered if you had any update for us here at the Public Accounts Committee as to your current estimates of the cost of the reorganisation associated with the abolition of NHS England.

23:52 - 24:13

Samantha Jones

So, I will come back to the committee and confirm the latest, if that's okay, Anna.

And I don't want to give you something on the hoof. What I can confirm is that, as the Secretary of State said at the dispatch box, remain totally committed to the abolition of NHS England and the creation of the new department, and further information will be coming in due course.

24:13 - 24:49

Anna Dixon

Okay, would be grateful. I think you're back with us for another one on ICB reorganisation, so it may be if you can make sure that we've received any information ahead of that hearing, we could include a further question. And can you just clarify, and this may be for you, Sir Jim, I think this has been reported in the news about the possibility of needing to create a separate arm's-length body because it's not possible to absorb all staff, particularly those on senior salaries, into the Department of Health and put them on civil service pay grades. Could you just provide clarity on that?

24:49 - 25:14

Jim Mackey

Yeah, so Sam said, we will be making, or Secretary of State will be making some more announcements on this in the very near future. It's still being subject to debate very recently. And one of the key points is not just on the terms and conditions things, it's about alignment with the devo principle and philosophy. So, it's not fixed yet. It'll be communicated very soon.

25:14 - 25:30

Samantha Jones

And if I may, just to build on that from Jim, obviously, it's hugely important, and we've discussed it before, that we discuss anything around with our staff, and that's our commitment to do so, to make sure that we get communicate appropriately as much as we can. But, yeah, it's just

25:30 - 25:36

Anna Dixon

So, for now, they're unconfirmed reports the in the media, they're not come directly from you. Okay.

25:36 - 26:42

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

That's very helpful.

I think just for the record, my clerk did say that you had been warned of that question, I think. Thank you anyway for those answers and we look forward to hearing more of that on Anna's inquiries. Just before I bring Rupert in, I'd like to raise an important issue that was raised both in the NAO report and by the Royal College of Accident and Emergency. I think that's what they call themselves, Royal College of Emergency Medicine. They say, and I think you this evidence you've had sight of this evidence, because it was published a week or so ago, paragraph one, there were around 16,000 excess deaths in England associated with long waits in emergency departments.

And the NAO in paragraph 1.9 on page 19 delves down into this a little further. They say, "Twelve-hour waits are associated with higher mortality."

This is clearly a very difficult situation and a sad situation. What do you intend to do to try and reduce that?

26:42 - 26:44

Speaker 10

If you're comfortable, Chair, I'll ask Emma.

26:44 - 26:45

Of course, yes. Yes.

26:45 - 26:47

Speaker 9

Thank you.

26:47 - 27:51

Emma Rowland

Thank you, Chair. So, just to acknowledge initially, so behind every one of those numbers is obviously a patient and a family, and I think we are all in complete agreement that's completely unacceptable and that's not what we want to see or what we want to deliver. So, our focus is absolutely on eliminating and abolishing all those long waits. It's a complex system,

and the predominant causation of patients residing in corridors or any other treatment escalation space as they're called, so places that are not suitable for clinical care, are essentially flow, problems with flow. All of those patients that are currently in a corridor should be in a hospital bed.

That's the bottom line. So the question is, why can't they get to those hospital beds and in a timely and safe fashion? And the cause for that is that delay all the way through the system, particularly at what we call the back door, so the back of the hospital. So it's that flow through the hospital system and encouraging a timely discharge, timely hospital processes, and timely exit from A&E, and then also timely system processes around the hospital to support that.

27:51 - 28:03

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

You do accept causation that long waits do lead to these excessive deaths? And therefore that's why, one of the main reasons why, we need to do something about those long waits.

28:03 - 28:17

Emma Rowland

I think there's absolutely no doubt that long waits, particularly in A&E, cause harm. We're in agreement with that. Likewise, long waits also increase patients' length of stay, and likewise, long and inappropriate stays in hospital also cause harm.

28:18 - 28:19

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Thank you, that's a very clear answer.

28:19 - 29:21

Jim Mackey

Can I just add to that as well? So, first of all, we are all in agreement this is a good report, it's a very good, balanced view, it emphasizes we've got to look at the whole system rather than parts of the system. Hopefully this afternoon it will explain what we're doing about all of that and we've had some really useful challenge from new ministerial team, especially on discharge and the impact of discharge and rebalancing the plan.

But probably what we'll try to mainly convey it's very this is all very complicated, and especially in the context of all the things we've had to do in the last year around financial turn around and improvement in various settings, etc. And this year, the main thing that set us off course has been quite a strange increase in demand from the early part of the year, which we're still struggling with. But at no point will we be disagreeing with the content or the balance or the tone of the report. I think it's a very good report, very helpful for the service.

29:21 - 29:34

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Well we agree it is a very helpful report and we will be delving into some of the specific issues that you've been talking about there during the course of this hearing. So to start us off with that, please could we turn to Rupert Lowe?

29:34 - 30:34

Rupert Lowe

Thank you, Chairman. And I echo your the NAO's great report as usual has helped to understand this better. I do come across this quite a lot in my constituency in Great Yarmouth with the James Paget Hospital where we do have issues with A&E. So I'm quite aware that it is a it's a major problem across the country. I guess I mean my first question really is given that in your constitution, in the NHS constitution you actually promise 95% within 4 hours in terms of A&E, type 1 A&E,

you last met that target in 2013-14. And it appears you now have an interim target which is 85% but not until '28, '29. So I guess the question I've got for you is, in which year will you meet the 95% that is in your constitution?

30:34 - 31:36

Jim Mackey

Want me to take that?

So, you've rightly pointed out, it's a long time since the NHS has delivered this standard. So, the way my memory looks at this is, in the run-in to Covid, we'd had a long period of steady decline, then we had the Covid event, and we've struggled since then to get back to normal levels. The report acknowledges some progress since then. But as I described at the beginning, given all of the other competing challenges, the overall resource position, etc., we've tried throughout to set stretching targets and objectives for the service, but not so stretching they were beyond reach and therefore everybody gave up. When the last plan was published, we didn't, because there was an uncertain medium-term financial position, we didn't commit to a time at that point to delivering the standard overall.

We absolutely, that's what we're aiming for every day, but from where we are now, it's not going to be in the next couple of years. It's going to be a longer timeframe than that.

31:36 - 31:38

Speaker 13

Have you got a date, Jim?

31:38 - 31:56

Jim Mackey

No, we haven't. We're just about to go into further discussions about planning and stuff for next year, and objectives for next year. So, we haven't set a date for complete delivery of that overall standard. And, as I say, part of that is about the demand growth we've had this year, that's knocked us off course a little bit.

31:56 - 32:06

Rupert Lowe

So, should it be in your constitution? I mean, is it just words in the constitution, or is there, because if you can't give us a date, you can't really be taken seriously, can you, for delivery?

32:06 - 32:18

Jim Mackey

They're in the constitutional standards and I would like the NHS, every organisation, to be delivering the standard every day.

It's just, realistically, not something we can plot a path to from where we are now.

32:18 - 32:47

Rupert Lowe

I mean it did concern me, Jim, again, when I read, you know, your own analysis, basically it's saying, the NAO says we need 115 to 120,000 beds, and you've got around 103,000, I think. Is that right? And it And the NAO report says you haven't actually costed the gap. So, if you costed the gap, you really can't be that serious about delivering on that 95% target, can you?

32:47 - 34:00

Jim Mackey

Well, we know what the cost of a ward is and the cost of those beds are. What we've not What we haven't got is a realistic prospect of being able to secure that overall level of resource, and we're all trying very hard to shift patterns of care, so people who are currently being treated in beds aren't treated in beds, they're treated nearer the home and through SDECs and UTCs and in neighbourhoods, etc.

So all of those things are currently being considered again. But if we said that the only plan was to open 15,000 extra beds we couldn't afford it and we couldn't staff it. So we do there's an imperative as to how quickly we can change the pattern of care. One thing that doesn't come across through strongly in the report is the implementation of same-day emergency care across the service which has materially reduced our reliance on beds in the last few years. So when you're right in that if you look at where we are now doing as performing as we are now and with clinical systems that we've got now, we need a lot more beds.

What we're trying very hard is to find alternatives to that through shifting the model of care.

34:01 - 34:25

Rupert Lowe

I mean, again, as the Chairman says, it's pretty shocking that statistic about people being twice as likely to die if they're waiting for 12 hours rather than for 2 hours. So, it does strike me it's quite important to try and meet that target. And then with regard to corridor care, which is a major problem still, are you now collecting data each month on how many people are actually in corridors waiting to be treated?

34:25 - 34:32

Jim Mackey

We are and we have been since the spring. And Tim, I asked Tim last year to get in involved in this. So, Tim, do you want to do you want to pick

34:32 - 37:43

Tim Briggs

Yeah. So, I was asked to get involved in trying to resolve this issue of corridor care September of last year, bringing the GIRFT methodology and the clinical leads to bear to try and make a big difference.

We've gone live now with a new definition of 45 minutes in a undesignated space, and that is being measured. There is some discrepancy between what we say is corridor care and RCEM, and we think that the answer is somewhere in the middle, I think we probably are reporting it at the moment. The critical thing for me is it's the risk of these patients that they have in the corridor. And the corridor care piece, where people are in the corridor, could occur at any part along the pathway. You don't have to be admitted to end up in the corridor.

And what's really important as we tackle this is to tackle the areas where there is the greatest risk. And if you look at the patients in the corridor, 60% are over the age of 65 and that is the real risk to us that these patients frail, multiple comorbidities and they're the ones that we've really got to we've got to really try and manage first. We've got to get out of the corridor as quickly as we can. Now in the last year we've worked very hard with 45 trusts. 21 is what we call a further faster cohort.

They were just about managing and then we worked with 24 tier one trusts who were not managing at all. And what we did, we brought our clinical leads, we got the data and went in to help, because when you look at corridor care, the issue is the whole pathway. And often when we went to these trusts, they were silo working. Everybody's going to work doing trying to work really hard, do a good day's work, but what we found was it was silo working and what we needed was everybody to own the problem, both all the clinicians and also the management teams.

So, we did a lot of work with the 21 trusts, and we improved four hours, we improved ambulance handovers, and we reduced the 12-hour wait and therefore corridor care. And on the Tier 1, which was the issue where it's the really the back end that was really the problem, we reduced the 12-hour breaches by almost 12%. So, we knew that our methodology would work, and what we then did, we worked with nine providers and six trusts to focus on corridor care, and we were able to reduce that by 50 to 60%. So, we know the methodology we've got is right, and we are absolutely being working with 40 trusts this year. We've just agreed with Emma and the regional COOs on the 40 trusts we're going to use all our efforts on this winter, and I hope that we can make a significant impact, but it's hard yards.

it's going to be at trust level, working with the trusts, changing cultures, behaviors, getting the whole team to work as one right from the front door right through to discharge. But we're on our way, and I think we're seeing change in behaviors that I think is going to make a difference. There is stats about this as well,

37:43 - 37:47

Speaker 14

Do you know how many were treated in corridors in September for instance?

37:47 - 37:51

Tim Briggs

It's 3,300 a day, about 99,000 a month.

37:51 - 37:55

Rupert Lowe

And that's not a winter month. So, sorry? And that's not a winter month is it, Sir? That's,

37:56 - 38:16

Rupert Lowe

Okay. So, I mean, are you going to publish a plan on how you're going to deal with it? Cuz I always think when I'm running something a plan written down with a, an actual sort of structured approach to it is better than just words around a committee.

So, are you going to have a plan published? Because I really do think this is quite serious.

38:16 - 38:48

Jim Mackey

Yeah, so we've used in the last year, and some of it's referenced in the report, the model ED, model discharge. So, when we've got a bit more reliable data over a longer period of time, I'd expect Tim and colleagues to produce some model approach to eliminating corridor care. I'll just The point I was going to make as well, so there's absolutely a harm issue, but we shouldn't lose sight of the dignity issue as well. So a patient could wait a long time and not suffer harm, but still have a horrible loss of dignity. So, I just want we should acknowledge that's the thing that we're all very focused on and colleagues are very focused on.

38:48 - 38:54

Speaker 15

Somebody who is who's over 65, it worries me slightly that I might find myself in a corridor one day.

38:54 - 39:16

Samantha Jones

And if I may, just also just to confirm, I mean, the Secretary of State and the ministerial team has been very clear there is no tolerance at all for corridor care. And the challenge from the ministerial team and certainly the Secretary of State is for a plan to come back in terms of eradicating it, over what time period, by when and who's doing what. So, in terms of the answer to your question, they're very clear.

39:16 - 39:47

Rupert Lowe

Okay. Now, I've just got two other quick questions. So one thing that also concerned me was it doesn't appear there's a correlation between how much money you spend and how successful you are. It seems you've hurled a lot of money at this issue and it hasn't got better. So, you've mentioned some things that you're intending to do.

I mean, is there a is there an actual better approach than just hurling money at it that you're aware of now? I mean, you've had a chance to look at it. I mean, how are you going to solve it?

39:47 - 41:03

Jim Mackey

I think the answer as the report is looking at the whole of the system. It is right, factually correct that post-COVID there were two or three years of significant investment in the workforce in this area, but generally across the NHS. That's partly what we've been dealing with in the last year, trying to you know just trying to address that. Last year was the first year in 12 years we haven't had a workforce rule, first year in 11 years we haven't had to make it call on the treasury reserve. So, there's a correction going on there.

And I mean clinical colleagues should speak up, I don't think the answer is more money into ED. You know, we've definitely got discharge problems, we've definitely got social care investment problems, and we want to do more in neighbourhoods.

So it's more about how we address the whole thing. I think again what this report proves and our performance data proves is all of these things are connected. And if we squeeze one part of the balloon without changing other parts of the thing it's just going to pop out somewhere else. And I think you can see that day-to-day and especially in some of the places that Tim and Emma work with regularly where part of the system is being fixed, but not the whole of the system. And that's really what we've got to try and do in this next couple of years.

41:03 - 41:19

Tim Briggs

So, can I add to that? So, from the clinical perspective, last week I was visiting 22 PCNs across five regions. And this was a part of a program we've been doing now for two years. And what the PCNs had done it was

41:19 - 41:20

Primary care network.

41:20 - 43:33

Tim Briggs

Primary care network, sorry about that. And so, we met all the GPs and what we found is that since we given the head space to look at their population, if you like, and using neighbourhood and community services, what they've been able to do is look at the most vulnerable people.

So, they've looked at the people with multiple comorbidities, frailty, mental health issues and those patients, so if I may say, were frequent attenders either at in the ED or in the GP surgery. And universally, across the 22 PCNs in the five regions, there was a 20% to 30% drop in ED referrals as a consequence of that. You've then add to that the care homes. There are care homes that have frequent referrals to ED, when others don't.

And again, working with GPs and providers, they're now aware that of the top three care homes that have the highest number of referrals, so we can work with those in a clinical way to make sure the patients are managed in the right place and get the right care they need and using the community services.

Secondly, with the ambulances, we're working with all the 11 ambulance trusts. I've included Wales in that because on the west part of England with Countess of Chester and hospitals like that, there's a lot of patients coming from Powys into England from there. And again, we've asked them to do five things this year to standardize, which they're working very hard to do, around call before convey, hear and treat, make sure that we stream patients, and we're going to have the maximum hand over time of 45 minutes, but we want it less than that, and also how we manage patients that don't need to come to the ED that evening but can come tomorrow, and how we keep them safe in the community.

All that feeds into the front end of the pathway, because as I said, if we're going to get this right, it's the whole pathway that we have to resolve and the so I think we are making progress there, and, as Emma says, we're working at the back end of the whole pathway within the acute trust to try and make sure that we can have a we have a better winter in terms of flow.

43:33 - 43:41

Rupert Lowe

And that's exemplified, isn't it, by this £2 billion in less than a year as a result of people being in hospital for longer than they need to be?

43:42 - 45:01

Rupert Lowe

So, my last question really, on performance and this timing, involves senior executives and their pay, and I came across the TaxPayers' Alliance rich list for the NHS for '26. I have to say, Jim, you came out pretty high up. Looks like you were making out like Dick Turpin at the Newcastle NHS.

But I looked up the best and worst-performing trusts by A&E waiting times. Hum Teaching came out top; East Cheshire came out bottom. Now, for me, as a businessman, the key here is it doesn't appear that there's any correlation between the pay and rations of the people who do very well and the pay and rations of people who do very badly. Indeed, the person in East Cheshire, in a year the pay went from 172,000 to 377.5 thousand, even though they remained as the worst-performing trust for A&E waiting times for the second consecutive year. So, is there now a correlation? You do mention in the report that there's an intention to link performance to pay, which must be one of the things you probably need to do to get this problem sorted out.

So has that happened number one? And number two, how many people have underperformed and therefore been penalized since you introduced that rule?

45:01 - 45:45

Jim Mackey

So there's a link to the oversight framework, and in certain segments So this is our way of looking in the round at organizations and segmenting them, high performer right through to the lowest performer. And in the lowest categories of performance, other than where there's a need to change a team and encourage people to come in to run the organization—some of the organizations you've mentioned have had lots of turnover over the years—it would generally be the case that if you're in those lower categories, you couldn't receive a pay rise. That was the intention.

It is, as I say, complicated if you've had a lot of churn and then you've got to pay the market rates to encourage a chief executive and an executive team to join an organisation in trouble.

45:45 - 45:49

Rupert Lowe

So, has anyone been penalised yet for lack of performance?

45:49 - 46:00

Jim Mackey

There has been no pay award paid generally this year, has there, for anybody? So, that's still being That's everybody. What about the underperformers? It will be it is the intention that for the lower segments their pay awards will be withheld.

46:00 - 46:07

Rupert Lowe

Wasn't there a plan to penalise them and actually reduce their salaries? I thought I read that in the report.

46:07 - 46:39

Jim Mackey

The action has always been that there was a policy agreed last year that if you're in the lower segments, you wouldn't earn the pay rise, the annual pay rise. You couldn't just automatically reduce anybody's salary, but you would withhold pay awards until performance was in an acceptable level.

That was That has been applied. It is being applied. As I say, with the exception of if you've got an organization where a team, a board is changed and you need to encourage people to come in, you've got to pay appropriate market rates for them to go into that organization.

46:39 - 46:40

So, from the Committee's point of view, that is helpful.

46:40 - 46:54

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Mr. We must move on, I think, because other members have got a lot they want to ask. I'm going to bring in my I'm going to bring you in a second, Matt, but I think my deputy had a point on GPs, your point, Professor Briggs.

46:54 - 47:46

Clive Betts

Yes, Professor Briggs. I spoke on Friday, fortuitously, to a GP in my constituency, Tom Holdsworth, who's chair of the Townships PCN, which one of the national pilots about frailty and what could be done to improve it. I understand and I understand you've been to see the project, so they referred that to me that there's been a net saving of about £600,000 per annum as a result of the work done to improve frailty amongst patients.

That's net. The cost is something initially 350 saving is nearly a million. I understand now the ICB say they can't find the money to continue the project next year. Come on, what's going on? We've got a project that actually deliver savings, but the initial funding to deliver those savings is now beyond the ICB at local level.

47:46 - 49:11

Tim Briggs

So I was there on Friday, and the all the PCNs in Sheffield and Rotherham had done extremely well in terms of what we're talking about and these patients with complex needs reducing the referrals. And in addition to that, two of the two of the trusts, Barnsley and Rotherham are really good in terms of very low numbers of 12 hours in corridor care, they are doing extremely well. To be fair, we had a very good discussion about their impact that they've all done.

And when you bring all the 22 PCNs together and look at the data is very powerful about how we're going to solve this problem. And so there was a discussion with the ICBs, and I have to say the ICBs were very open and very fair about taking this way, looking at the evidence and then deciding on whether they're going to continue it. And the message I got from the ICB in Sheffield was that they were going to do all they could to make sure it continued. And we highlighted the fact that the clinical staff gone from being where they were just about managing to now could see real light at the end of the tunnel, were really keen that this continued.

And so, we've asked them, they've been given money to show the evidence of what they've done. We're going to produce the evidence across the 22 PCNs, and I think the evidence there is very powerful for it to continue.

49:11 - 49:20

Clive Betts

It is very powerful, but the ICB's reply apparently has been they can probably find the money for three months and then the project comes to an end. I mean,

49:20 - 49:27

Jim Mackey

If you could if you could encourage the person who told you that to get in touch with me and provide the information, I'll take it up with the ICB.

49:28 - 49:43

Clive Betts

Dr Holdsworth, who chairs the PCN.

They've been told that NHS England isn't happy and have told the ICB to try and find money for six months, but, yeah, this is an example of the bureaucracy of the NHS being detached from the clinical experience the GPs have got, I'm sorry.

49:43 - 50:01

Jim Mackey

Yeah. So I generally, on a weekly basis, I get two or three of these.

Often, there's a there's something behind it about the ICB once a bit longer on the data to be able to prove its case. Occasionally, there's a complete misunderstanding of how the financial flows work, but if I can get the facts, I'll pick it up with the ICB.

50:01 - 50:06

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

You've got an open invitation there, Clive, to email Sir Jim with full details.

50:06 - 50:11

Speaker 20

Okay. And Professor Briggs, no doubt you'll continue your interest in this as well.

50:11 - 50:14

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Matt, you've been very patient. Sorry to keep you waiting.

50:14 - 50:52

Matt Matthew Robert Turmaine

No, it's quite all right. I'd like to go back to corridor care, if I may, for a moment. West Herts Teaching Hospitals Trust in my patch, which runs Watford General, a hospital in desperate need of rebuilding as part of the NHP, and I'm sure you know that. Nevertheless, the team on the ground at that hospital is fantastic, and they have eradicated corridor care in that particular setting. So, I know a couple of Secretaries of State have been to see them and talk about it.

I just wanted to know if you could tell us a little bit about when you have that best practice, what are you doing to share that across the system? Thank you.

50:52 - 53:08

Emma Rowland

Do you want to start and then we'll pass around, so thank you, and several of us have also been to visit West Herts and they are a fantastic team, I would second that, and I actually took my team from Homerton as well, who and we are a high performing trust, but to go and learn for exactly that reason. And I know since then they've actually done several visits. So, I think there are lots of good ingredients there, and I think we absolutely have to learn and the question is then is what do we share and how do we share it across the patch from a delivery perspective? There are a couple of things I think to me, it's number one, it's exec engagement, and it's very clear certainly from their chief nurse how engaged she is, and I'm sure many of us have met her, and she's fantastic.

And the fact that she got down and spent time in A&E, understanding what the challenges to the barriers are, and then made a commitment at exec level that it was going to be no more, that it was a red line for them. And then the questions were, once you've done that, how do you unpick that? And there's lots and lots, as I say, that they have done there. They've focused, exactly as my colleagues have said, from both the front door all the way to the back door. So, some of the front door good examples that they've done is call before convey, what's called call before convey.

So, what they're trying to do if patients particularly are frail, there is a combination of the ambulance team and the hospital team coming together to say, is there an alternative in their patch that they that could be offered to? And certainly, we're learning across how do we lift and shift some of that. Secondly, in the A&E itself, how do you take, as I say, the model ED that we've done? So, we've learned from them. They have been round the table for several of our models, particularly Model ED and Model Discharge.

So, how do we take that good practice of seeing that front door, the streaming, the assessment and the flow through A&E itself? Thirdly, that hospital part, so particularly around that discharge, again, they have come together with their providers and particularly for their frail, most vulnerable population, how do you ensure a timely discharge? And they have really focused again there. And again, what we've done is we have part of the frailty, what we're also trying to do is take three examples, of which West Herts is one,

and we have put people together with other good providers and say, "How do we replicate this?" So, we're taking very specific providers with providers to provide that peer support at a local level. And then, probably more to Professor Briggs, how do we take it as a an overarching? How do we take it as a Getting It Right First Time, which is exactly what GIRFT is designed to do?

53:08 - 54:39

Tim Briggs

Yeah. So, what we've tried to do is we know now what works. And for me, the West Herts thing is all about leadership.

And it's the CEO, CMO, Chief Medical Officer, and the Chief Nursing Officer. Those three have driven that trust into the place it is today. And so, if they can do it, we can do it everywhere. What we've tried to do is try to set standards with what we call the GIRFT clinical operational standards, setting the time when patients come in, when they're seen, and then flow through the hospital. We've produced documents about reducing length of stay, because we now know how to do that, about how we can discharge improve discharge, how we can use the discharge lounge more appropriately so you get 10 in there 10 patients there before 10.

And then we've got a UEC improvement guide building on, such as West Herts and others, that are doing things really well. Now we've got those, we've got the teams to go out there with these trusts we're helping, and what we want them to do is adopt and embed all these processes.

So, I think that's what's going to be different this winter. This is what we want them to do. We don't really want it to be optional because we don't want to lose the learning of places like West Herts and others, Maidstone, Tunbridge Wells, other Northumbria, Newcastle, where Jim is and what have you. There's some really good work out there.

We just need to scale that up and then help, and that's what we try and do, is help the trusts, clinicians and operational teams, then embed it that and that's how we're going to improve the flow of patients.

54:39 - 55:27

Jim Mackey

And just to add to that, with the help of the Corridor Care Coalition, we've had a couple of events. West Herts give a very powerful presentation, a nursing colleague I think at the first event, and because of their physical constraints, what we found is what's most helpful is people go and see them, because it's, I mean it is the sort of place where you see if they've solved it must be soluble everywhere because they've got really terrible physical constraints that they're working with. And it is an absolute leadership commitment throughout the organisation. I think what struck me in the event was just the the the the the power of the nursing voice on standards and compassion and doing the right thing for patients etc. Some took that away and it's helped their journey.

Others are still really struggling with it and haven't quite got off the ground yet.

55:27 - 55:49

Samantha Jones

And just the other bit to add, I know the trust very well from a very long time ago. The other bit that the leadership have done is work very well with the local system and local partners. So, they are a very good example of a very practical neighbourhood health and care in practice, which they've been doing alongside the internal flow and leadership elements.

55:49 - 55:59

Matt Matthew Robert Turmaine

That's great. Thank you very much for that. And Tim, you were saying that this winter you're looking to scale it up and roll it out or not across everywhere in that time frame, but?

55:59 - 56:22

Tim Briggs

Yeah, so we're going to work with 40 trusts this winter that we've agreed with the regional coos and also with Emma of deploying the team with these documents what have you, plus the knowledge and the challenge, but the support to enable that whole pathway along with what we are doing with the ambulances and primary care really.

56:22 - 56:24

Speaker 22

Right, thank you very much.

56:24 - 56:42

Samantha Jones

And may I just also add, Secretary of State recently announced the investment in urgent treatment centers and the capital with a further 25 new or expanded urgent care sites to be opening before winter. So, it doesn't It's not necessarily about the model of care, but it is around supporting in terms of capacity constraints as well.

56:42 - 56:43

Thanks very much indeed. Thank you.

56:43 - 56:52

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Thank you very much, Matt, for drawing our attention to a very What sounds like a very successful operation there in Harrogate. Sarah Green, please.

56:52 - 57:05

Sarah Green

Thank you, Chair. I'd like to ask Sir Jim why so many people are still waiting 24 hours or more for care, when NHS England's own guidelines state it's a red line for safety.

57:05 - 57:44

Jim Mackey

It's mainly because the because of that complexity, the system, and lots of things needing to be fixed at this at the same or similar times. The more The organisations with the most stubborn problems generally have more of a discharge problem and a bed capacity problem, which is a really stubborn thing. It's a It's a complicated thing to unblock.

It involves partners. It's very expensive, you know, etc. So, that would be, if we could solve it tomorrow overnight, we would solve it tomorrow overnight. But we have to do it at a pace that we can afford with partners, making sure every part of the system works together.

57:44 - 57:50

Speaker 25

Your own documents referred to it to needing a zero tolerance towards it. What does that look like in practice?

57:50 - 58:34

Jim Mackey

Yeah, so it's a it's a of it's a version of what we saw in West Herts, a leadership commitment to basically saying, we're just going to do absolutely everything we can within our power to eradicate this.

In places where it has been possible, probably where there's been much less of a discharge problem or a social care interface problem, it has been more down to the leadership effort, and everybody pulling together, clinical, operational, administrative, everybody just pulling together to eradicate it. I think what were I think what Tim's describing is a process whereby it doesn't work unless there's a leadership commitment that is that focused and that driven to try and eradicate it.

58:34 - 58:38

Speaker 26

Does that come back to your point earlier about culture?

58:38 - 59:21

Tim Briggs

Yeah, so let me give you two examples where we've gone to help a trust that had a real problem.

BHUT which is in going east out of London, they we were asked to go to there because they had 55 patients in the corridor and were struggling to move those patients. So, we got a commitment from the leadership, from the medical director, the chief nurse, and the CEO that we were going to have this say that this is just not acceptable, we're going to do something very different, and over 3 months we were able to clear the corridor. Now, there's been a little bit of slippage back since that time, but on the whole they are doing very much better. So, it just shows I think what can be achieved. And the other example I'd give you is

59:21 - 59:24

Speaker 27

May I interrupt you, sorry, what changed specifically?

59:24 - 01:00:40

Tim Briggs

So, it was the agreement by all that this was unacceptable, that we had to do something really different, because when you went to the corridor, again, patients over 65 in unacceptable places, and everybody agreed this was no longer acceptable. So, the triumvirate, the chief executive, the chief medical officer, and the chief nurse said, "Right, we're going to do this differently."

And we were able to support them with the implementing the clinical operational standards, how we're going to get discharges out, what we're going to do at the front door, and we were able to make a really big difference. What was amazing was the morale in the hospital improved so much afterwards and they could now see that there was a way out of this. I was just going to give you one other example, which is in East Kent, William Harvey. Again, they had patients, it made I think it was made the news, they had patients in the Costa Coffee corridor, which was just totally They realized that. So, they asked us to go and help that.

And again, with exactly the same scenario, this is unacceptable, the triumvirate leadership, giving them the tools and also support from my team to help them they cleared the corridor. So, again, just shows how working together and this work we're doing in NHSE can make a big difference.

01:00:40 - 01:00:46

Sarah Green

Can I just ask, were you invited in by the teams, or were you sent to intervene?

01:00:46 - 01:01:07

Tim Briggs

It's it was a it's a mixture, I have to say. In the early days, I think we were asked to go in, but now we are welcomed with open arms. And, in fact, I think we've got too many people asking for our help than we've got capacity for at the moment, but we're hoping just to reorganize the teams. But no, we've never been refused when we've offered help. Everybody's said yes, please.

01:01:07 - 01:01:28

Sarah Green

Thank you for that. Can I turn to the patient experience and ask the permanent secretary, if I may, how you are using or what plans the department has to capture and utilize the patient feedback, the patient experience, in order to help improve the situation in A&E?

01:01:28 - 01:01:30

Speaker 29

If I may, do you want to start on the immediate, and then I'll pick up?

01:01:30 - 01:01:47

Jim Mackey

So, we've just appointed a new patient experience director, Jacob Lant, whose job is to bring a new approach to all of this. So, we've got to get, in my view, he'll have a view when he's when he's started, he starts very soon, this week or next week, to give us a

01:01:47 - 01:01:48

Already appointed?

01:01:49 - 01:01:49

Already in post, I think you were

01:01:49 - 01:02:15

Jim Mackey

He's just started this week or next week, he was appointed a few months ago. And his job is to try and shift us away from annual surveys into a world where we're much more actively measuring experience in a real real-time way. Some organisations do this around the NHS, but try and do it systematically across the whole of the service.

So, that'll, he'll have a plan within a few months as to how we're going to go about that.

01:02:15 - 01:03:12

Samantha Jones

And just to build on that for the creation of the new department as part of the transformation, we have a very clear challenge set by the Secretary of State to ensure that how Jacob puts things together, he has the patient voice right at the heart of it. You know you'll've seen, obviously, the decision around the move not the move of Healthwatch the abolition of Healthwatch to make sure that we truly are taking the patient voice. So the stuff that's being done not stuff the information has been taken locally to make a difference. We have obviously patient complaints that come through, reviewing those from a departmental perspective, but the Secretary of State has charged us very clearly with giving Jacob, obviously, more than a day to start how do we best ensure that we have the patient voice at the centre, the citizen voice and family voice at the centre of the stuff that the department does on a daily basis? So, I suggest if, well, we can come back with further details on that when he's being post for longer than a day.

01:03:12 - 01:03:13

I think the committee will welcome that.

01:03:13 - 01:03:38

Jim Mackey

Yeah, and there's, there was an example started in Northumbria but continued after I left, that tried to connect patient and staff experience with length of wait, as well, so I'll share that with you after this if you wanted to see it, and it's that kind of approach we'd like to try and bring to this setting. What that work found was that patients were often more tolerant than you'd expect them to be, as long as they were communicated with and could understand what was going on.

01:03:38 - 01:03:43

Speaker 31

Not just citizens, as long as they know where they are, they know what's happening, Yeah. they know if they're if their expectations are being managed,

01:03:43 - 01:03:50

Jim Mackey

Yeah, but the impact on staff was higher than you would expect it to be, as well, where they were feeling the burden of letting the patients down, so.

01:03:51 - 01:03:53

Sarah Green

I can see you're nodding away, did you want to add something?

01:03:53 - 01:04:22

Emma Rowland

Just to add from a sort of a day-to-day A&E perspective, we know and we can see, hands down, that if you communicate and you're clear with the patients, they can see what's going on, so they understand the situation around them. As long as they know what's happening and they can see what's happening to them, they're actually relatively comfortable and assured. It's when they can't see, they can't understand what's going on or they wait for extended periods of times with no information and that void, that's where we see most of our complaints. I've answered many complaints in my time and that is a hands-down standard thing.

01:04:22 - 01:04:23

Really helpful, thank you very much.

01:04:23 - 01:05:00

Samantha Jones

I was just going to I was just going to add that none of us are complacent at all about the impact on individuals as Jim said, both from a dignity perspective and a harm perspective. So I wouldn't want any member of the committee to feel that we are either complacent or not focused on it in terms of the things that need to be done. I think their particular learning is making sure, as Jim said, around the whole system approach. I'm sure we'll come on to social care a bit later.

But I just want to finish, there's no complacency at all from any of us around the impact on individuals and families.

01:05:00 - 01:05:06

Sarah Green

I'm sure my colleagues will be keen to hear the detail once your colleague is established in role. Thank you. Thank you, Chair.

01:05:06 - 01:05:57

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Can I ask you, the president of the Royal College of Emergency Medicine, who I'm sure you know well, Dr. Higginson did an interview for LBC, which was headed A&E facing perfect storm ahead of winter, as leading medics warn only 3% prepared for severe pressures.

And indeed, he says that the number of people admitted to A&E was 44,000 in or nearly 45,000 in August, but in September, it was 50,500. So what preparations are you making for a, you know, particularly if we get a severe outbreak of something like influenza to be able to cope with that on top of this quite distinct increase in summer demands?

01:05:57 - 01:09:22

Emma Rowland

Thank you, so I'll start if I may, Chair. So I, as you rightly say, I know Dr. Higgy very well and he's right to say that we've had a really difficult summer. I think that's the first thing to say. So certainly from an attendance perspective in A&E, it has been higher than anticipated and is maintained and even in September now it continues, so that we know demand at that front door is a problem. The good news, where I would suggest that some of the investment that we've made and a lot of the work we've made at the front door is working for things like our same day emergency care and our urgent treatment centres, that increase in attendance is not translating to increase in admissions in hospital.

So, that is a good thing to take out of some of the work that's been done. That aside, it does, because of the flow and the challenges we've already alluded to at the back door, mean we have what's called less operational headroom going into winter, which is what he's rightly flagging, because the capacity in the hospital, and the occupancy of the hospital at the moment is very high and higher than we'd like it to be going into winter. From winter itself, we have done a lot of preparations. We've prepared earlier than the usual. There's a There's a lot gone on.

We've gone out for, bringing up some of the previous points on culture, we've gone for board assurance statements about how is the how are the trust and the ICBs, the integrated care boards, and the regions all assured by their plans. And what does that include? For example, how do we look after our frailest population during winter?

How do we ensure primary care is there to meet people's needs? How do we ensure people are vaccinated, particularly from the children's perspective and also from our staff perspective? So all the way through, how do we prevent the things we can prevent, particularly for things like influenza? Then we come into, perhaps, preparing the hospitals is another way of looking at it. So how do we're focusing heavily now on discharge, and we have done since the beginning of September, so that we can clear out as safely as possible some of our hospitals to recreate some of that headroom.

So over December, we've created some new data, looking at data and discharge delays so we can understand the challenges of what's going on, get some of those foundations right.

We've published, as it's said in the report, not only the model ED, the acute care pathway, but also the model discharge. So how do we ensure patients flow safely entirely through our hospitals? And we're working incredibly tightly with social care particularly about how we can enable that process at the end of hospitals and social care to work closely together to ensure that we can improve that discharge process at the end there. So, we're trying to create some of that additional head room. Then the third perhaps I'd bring the committee's attention to is what I call the process, particularly from an NHS England perspective.

So, we have started that and we've started that formally this week. So and that's a couple of folds. That is we do every Monday a weekly clinical brief and that is sharing to the clinicians such as ourselves and the operational teams out in the hospital what is going on, because we assume that information is out there, but often it's not. So, even this morning we've shared what is flu doing, what is COVID doing, what is the occupancy doing so that people are sighted on what's likely to come and particularly over the next couple of weeks, so you can be prepared.

Secondly, then we've got a coordination cell, so we've got what's called a winter cell where we're coordinating everything so that we can aim that we only add value. And thirdly, then, how we escalate people in trouble and add support, but also de-escalate so that we're not there to create noise. So there's a huge amount of planning, testing, and real rigor already gone into this base.

01:09:22 - 01:09:34

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Very brief follow-up there. I suggest that you concentrate on your comms really well so that the general population can be reassured that you are making those preparations.

01:09:34 - 01:09:47

Samantha Jones

Absolutely, Chair. I would also just take the opportunity, therefore, to encourage everybody to have their vaccinations, if they haven't done already, families and particularly those vulnerable individuals and also children. It's really important.

01:09:47 - 01:09:49

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Clive Betts, please.

01:09:49 - 01:09:52

Clive Betts

Declare my interest there. I have my vaccinations, so.

01:09:53 - 01:09:56

Speaker 35

Right. Two questions.

01:09:56 - 01:10:03

Clive Betts

First of all, why is there an increase in people coming to A&E? Do you actually know?

01:10:03 - 01:11:11

Jim Mackey

Not really. No, we've had we've actually had a quite a significant growth in demand in urgent care, so roughly 6% this September compared to last September, which is pretty significant when you're on fine margins. But we've also had a significant growth in elective demand this year, as well, which we're struggling with, not quite as high, but similarly a problem for us. Our main We've looked at everything to just try and work out whether there's a geographical issue, a kind of disease pattern issue, it's fairly uniform, fairly consistent around the country.

And we think it's related to better access to primary care. So, patients being able now, more able to see a GP, reporting better experience and seeing a GP, and as a result, more patients flowing on into hospital care. Well, we can't say for definite what it is. We started the year thinking we had a bit of a spike, sometimes you have spikes and then they settle down. It's pretty consistent and I think we should assume it's here for the

Any surveying of patients into A&E and asking them how they got there, why they got there?

01:11:11 - 01:11:38

Emma Rowland

I can certainly say from a local level, we absolutely have done. Sometimes though, it's about ensuring some of the accuracy of that.

So yes, people have a right to walk into A&E, and people might have tried other routes and we know, but that the referral rates from each of those are fairly standard. The majority of patients self-present to A&E, and most of them rightly believe that they need support and help.

01:11:38 - 01:11:46

Clive Betts

Some of my GPs have told me they think 111 is part of the cause, because people go there, and the default is always go to A&E.

01:11:46 - 01:12:10

Emma Rowland

So that, certainly I can come back on some of that. So, looking at the increase in demand, there hasn't, there's been a significant spike over summer in the use of 111 in the region of approximately 11%. However, that has not translated to an increase in 111s going over to A&E, and that has stayed about the same, which is about 6%. Overall, everything has increased slightly.

01:12:10 - 01:12:25

Jim Mackey

And for 111 and primary care, we've looked hard at whether there's a change in thresholds, so whether there's a disproportionate growth on hospital care relative to the volume growth in primary care in 111, we're not seeing any evidence of that.

01:12:25 - 01:12:48

Clive Betts

One thing that has grown is the number of staff working in A&E, more than 20% for all the categories, whether it's nurses, doctors, senior doctors working in A&E. So, more than 20% growth, yet, that's higher than the number of people coming increase in people going through the door. Why is performance not improving?

01:12:48 - 01:13:43

Emma Rowland

Do you want to start? So, I think it's absolutely fair to say there's been a significant increase in resource into the UEC, so the urgent emergency care sphere, and I think this does demonstrate that over the last couple of years there has been significant improvement in performance as the report rightly pulls out. However, that has plateaued.

So I think it rightly demonstrates that an investment is required, but is not the only answer. The some of the some of the how it has captured, for example, in A&E, these staff might also be covering other areas, such as same day emergency care, so in order to increase those alternatives. Certainly as an A&E consultant, we cover both areas. So some of those are the other additional options. Some of it also relates to the fact that with corridor care, that is not good value care for patients or for staff or for resource either.

01:13:43 - 01:14:03

Jim Mackey

So I would add to, I think same day emergency care is a big factor in this, but also in the analysis we've had a very big shift away from agency and bank usage, which we've been trying to drive down.

Some of that has involved substantive recruitment, so permanent recruitment to avoid expensive use of agency, and it's part of that equation.

01:14:03 - 01:14:26

Clive Betts

That may be a saving then, less use of agency, but actually the cost per patient has gone up significantly. I think 2018 for six years onwards, the cost rose by £69 per patient, allowing for inflation. So, lots more money going in and not better service at the end. Not right, is it?

01:14:27 - 01:15:39

Emma Rowland

So, if I may, coming on to the cost per patient, absolutely, we acknowledge the cost per patient has gone up and then has started to plateau again over the last couple of years. That doesn't surprise me, if I'm honest, being there in an A&E, and I'm sure it won't surprise Tim either.

The, it is evidenced and also evidenced in the report, the patients coming through to A&E now are much more complex, and that's estimated to be about 2% to 3% increase in complexity per year. And the reason that's happening is the lower complex patients we are managing to see in alternative environments, either the same day emergency care, as I said, in urgent treatment centres, by primary care, et cetera. So, you are you result in that more complex patients coming through to the A&E. The evidence, I think, in the report was welcomed with that. If you saw the increase in diagnostics, particularly on CTs and MRIs, they're quite expensive investigations, and they're investigations that take a significant period of time to deliver, and their use has really increased.

So, in the region, on average, about 50% for both of those increased over the last couple of years. So, the amount of diagnostics, the amount of time and the complexity of each patient now coming through to the emergency department has increased.

01:15:39 - 01:15:48

Clive Betts

Why are people who want those complex procedures, why are they getting to the point of A&E?

Why is the system not picking them up a long time before?

01:15:48 - 01:16:45

Emma Rowland

So, I think it depends a little bit on where they are. Part, absolutely, and that is exactly our intention, particularly about frailty. Can we manage people in a different way, and that's what neighborhood health is here to deliver. Some of it is changing how we've worked in emergency medicine over the last couple of years. Perhaps an example, if I may.

So, a particular change that's happened is what's called silver trauma. So, trauma in the elderly population. Previously, if you'd come in having had a fall from standing and you were, for example, 80 years or plus, you probably would have got some X-rays. You would have had a review and some X-rays.

Now we know that was insufficient, and guidelines have suggested we treat people very differently. So now, in what's called silver trauma, you get a CT scan, which is nearly all of the body, and we've picked up several injuries in that way. So, we are we're investigating people in a much more thorough manner and picking up occult injuries that previously would not have noticed.

01:16:45 - 01:16:50

Speaker 36

Is there a tendency to overinvestigate in some cases?

01:16:50 - 01:17:44

Emma Rowland

I think there is no doubt I think the evidence is there that we will increase investigations when, for example, there is a highlight. A previous example I've got is there is a campaign, I don't know if anybody's seen it, called "Think Aorta". When it is publicised, there is no doubt that comes to the forefront of your mind and therefore you are more likely to do an investigation. Another example is particularly on cauda equina.

So, we know from when the HSIB set out their investigation, I think it was on in 2002, the number of MRIs following that publication increased. Some of that is absolutely right, because that report was flagging that we were not picking up as many cases as we could. However, the incident has not increased. So, there is definitely now a degree of more investigation in order to catch a small population of patients.

01:17:44 - 01:17:56

Clive Betts

So, if you're going to the Chancellor and saying, "Chancellor, we need more money again for the NHS," how do you convince him that more money's going to deliver better results?

01:17:56 - 01:18:41

Samantha Jones

I think the important bit that the NHS England team are focusing on is the things that will make an impact for the individuals using urgent and emergency care services. So in terms of avoiding admissions, how people are actually treated in the department, what happens when a decision to admit is made, how we actually support with partners through primary care and social care. So the important bit is for us, as DHSC, to ensure, collectively with NHS England, of course, is to make sure that people are doing the things that actually really do make a difference, hence all the model documents that have been described in the way. So actually doing the things that make an impact.

01:18:41 - 01:18:54

Clive Betts

Is there a tendency, as before, to overdiagnose, overtreat, try and put everything together to make sure that there's no risk at all attached that the doctor can be blamed for if things go wrong?

01:18:54 - 01:19:00

Samantha Jones

I think I'll allow the doctors to answer that question, otherwise happy to have a go, but

01:19:00 - 01:19:57

Emma Rowland

I think I so, as I say, there is no doubt when a report which suggests further investigation is required or further imaging is required, that it becomes at the forefront of your mind. So, there is no doubt, as I say, when things like the HSIB report which flagged medico-legal concerns, that then becomes at the forefront of your mind. However, as a medic, it is absolutely paramount that we deliver the right patients with the right investigations at the right time, and we also balance that if you do incorrect or too many investigations, that potentially can cause harm.

So, it's up to the individuals. We however are and do support the guidelines which surround us, and some of those guidelines have changed. So, for example, I'll bring it back to, that silver trauma is a guideline. Our NICE guidelines have changed, so the expectation is that we do follow some of those.

So we follow the guidelines in which we work.

01:19:57 - 01:20:31

Jim Mackey

And this is challenged all the time as well nationally and locally in the operational environment. It's really important to keep the challenge, but keep the balance right. And as clinicians, especially younger clinicians coming through, when they've decided to not investigate and something goes wrong, it's pretty impactful on them as well. So that this just behaviour. So it's not to say that this growth in diagnostics has gone without any scrutiny or any oversight at all.

It is being challenged, it's just very hard to get the balance right.

01:20:31 - 01:20:54

Clive Betts

I understand during the junior doctors' dispute, when they weren't around in A&E and the consultants stepped in, there were fewer referrals from A&E upwards.

More decisions were taken at A&E. Is that a that's a reflection of perhaps that, again, junior doctors without so much experience tend to pass things up and into the system, a more experienced doctor probably won't?

01:20:54 - 01:21:49

Emma Rowland

So I'll answer that for mayor. I was working during the IA, so I can certainly comment. There are probably a couple of different layers. There definitely, as consultants, we are more experienced and therefore are likely to make different decisions to our junior colleagues, absolutely. So in some respects we are likely and will refer less and are likely to take more risk based on our experience. The second thing, though, that I'd bring to the committee's attention during IA is how people worked was also quite different.

So, for example, the process in most A&Es, if I see a patient in A&E, I would then call one of my colleagues, such as medical colleagues, and the patient is referred through the system. A lot of people staff particularly collated within ED. So, it's actually several other consultants there, so you could easily have a conversation with a colleague that I wouldn't need to refer, because the colleague was here because they were potentially relieved of other duties during that day.

01:21:49 - 01:26:48

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Okay. We're quite behind time, but I'm going to take a very short break today, if we could be back here fairly promptly at 10:00 at 16:40. So, that's just 4 minutes time, just at least we could have a leg stretch and whatever else you want to do in 4 minutes. We've got a lot to cover and we will start with Anna Dick-

We're now resuming our hearing on emergency care, and first to start with questioning is Anna Dixon, please.

01:26:48 - 01:27:06

Anna Dixon

Thank you very much, Chair. I'd like to come back to the issues of hospital flow, in particular, the related issues of bed occupancy and delayed discharge. So, firstly on bed occupancy, the NAO report notes the increase from 87% to 92%.

01:27:07 - 01:27:12

Speaker 38

What do you think, Professor Briggs, is a safe occupancy level?

01:27:12 - 01:28:33

Tim Briggs

RCEM say about 85%, I think that's very reasonable. But if you look at the data what it also shows is that about 14.7% of all the bed-days that we have are taken up by patients who are ready to go home, and if you're in hospital for a long time, again there's risk of harm, deconditioning, loss of mobility etc. And so, what we've got to do is to make sure that we use every bed available for the right patient. So, for me, the part of this whole issues about getting this flow right is making sure we've got adult discharges,

and one of things that we've been trying to do as part of the whole program of the bringing the right standards is having the ward round starting on time, having board rounds in the afternoon, identifying the patients that are likely to go home tomorrow morning,

That's another really big issue. And making sure the discharge lounge, which is available now in many hospitals, has the appropriate number of patients in at the right time. Because if the more patients you can get there and through by midday, then the better flow you can have and bringing patients through from other parts. So that's one of the things that we are doing and driving to try and make sure we're using our beds efficiently, effectively.

01:28:33 - 01:28:52

Anna Dixon

So effectively, you're agreeing with the RCEM that 85% is really the ideal occupancy. Obviously, we're a long way from it. And yes, it seems there are two solutions: either more beds, which was the direction that my colleague was going in earlier, or eliminate the 4.7 million lost bed days, which is the number that I have here.

01:28:52 - 01:28:56

Speaker 39

Yes.

01:28:56 - 01:29:09

Anna Dixon

Which of those two, well, I mean, obviously, it's both/and, but how much do you think you can eliminate through eliminating 4.7 million to get down to 85%? And how much do you think we are short of capacity?

01:29:09 - 01:30:18

Tim Briggs

The second part of the question I don't know, but one of the things we're doing at the moment is we're working, it's called the RIO, which is working in the Midlands, which is working across six trusts in the Midlands, and what we're aiming to do is eliminate the P0, i.e., patients go home, or P1, so they need a bit of support, the hospital-related delays, and really trying to remove those barriers to discharge, because those are absolutely crucial,

and what we want to try and do is by doing that, achieve 80% 80% occupancy by Christmas Day and then sustain that in the first week of January.

So, I think it's both parts. I think one of the things we've got to make sure is every bed is used for the right reason, and that's why we're working with this group, which if it works well, and we're already, for instance, seeing the percentage of beds occupied by long-stay patients is reducing in relation to all other trusts in the Midlands region, which is, and they're improving at a greater rate. So, we're making progress there. But no, I understand that we've got a certain bed base, we've got a increasing demand, and there is a, there is a need probably for more beds as well.

01:30:18 - 01:30:55

Anna Dixon

It sounds like quite a lot of that focusing on sort of what's within the control of the hospital to accelerate delayed discharge.

What, I mean, I think Permanent Secretary, you sort of preempted, how much of this is down to the lack of social care? How much is down to the lack of other intermediate or step-down care? And what plans are you putting in place to ensure that there is more seamless join up at that back door with community health services, social care and other provision?

01:30:55 - 01:32:32

Samantha Jones

If you're okay, I'm going to ask Emma to describe how we are we have joined up in terms of planning and execution from a, particularly with our with social care colleagues, from the department perspective. I'll just if I just start out to say it's about a third of delay people waiting for discharge is around social care for social care reasons.

As you will note that some of that classification is a little bit more difficult to drill into, but we do have a focus in terms of the intersection which Emma will talk about. In addition, as you will obviously be aware, we also have capacity information for social care from a local perspective, both from a regional perspective in terms of both home care and also care home itself. So, matching capacity and demand at ICB level as well, to although I wouldn't say that the data is perfect, that would be not the right thing to say.

So, there is final bit I'd add and then I'll just hand over to Emma, is that from a department perspective with the Secretary of State, a clear focus on a very on a regular basis, weekly if not more often, in terms of what are the reasons for the delay, what is happening from a discharge perspective, and we go through on a weekly basis, both in terms of attendances, what's happening from a flu, from a weather perspective, what's happening within the hospital from a plan perspective, and also a very clear challenge from our ministers around working with local government and local authorities on what more can be done on that particular

01:32:32 - 01:32:43

Anna Dixon

Can I just check that third you talked about, does it also include hospice and end-of-life services? Is that in the same third as social care or is that in community health services?

01:32:43 - 01:32:48

Speaker 41

I don't know actually. I will confirm. I'd also be interested what the other two thirds are made up of.

01:32:49 - 01:33:06

Samantha Jones

Just on end-of-life care and hospice, again, as both as part of this, but also of course as part of our work around social care reform and the National Care Service looking particularly at end of life and what does that mean in practice for people at end of life. Emma, do you want to talk about our processes?

01:33:07 - 01:33:54

Emma Rowland

Thank you, perm sec. No, thank you. So, as the perm sec says, the Secretary of State has brought us all together. So, we're all very much around the table, and we're using winter as that leverage to bring that and make that start. So, it's very clear that the planning in the winter is across the system, and is expected to bring all partners together, and likewise, so from the top all the way down to the bottom, if you like, the expectation is collaborative working.

We know when people collaboratively work, we get much better outcomes. So, those board assurance statements that I mentioned earlier, the expectation is that local authority, etcetera, are around that table. There's also some very specific examples, perhaps going from national level, so we have declared a focus on discharge, because we know that's what's going to get us through this winter, and we've done it together. So, it's us standing side by side. Secondly, coming down to that next level

01:33:54 - 01:33:56

Speaker 42

You're standing side by side with LGA?

01:33:56 - 01:34:42

Emma Rowland

With social care, with social care. And then coming down to that level, from a regional perspective, what we are doing is hosting regional, we're hosting weekly regional calls, where we look at two acute and one community provider. And again, that is us coming together to say, what are your blockers, and how can we, if everybody's around the table, how can we cut through some of those barriers and deliver? And then, as Tim then alludes to, there's much more local level. Some of it, the RIO in the Midlands, but also we've got what's called DAG, which is the Discharge and Admissions Group, which is a combination, again, of social care colleagues, local authority and NHS England coming together to say, how can we help you as a system unblock some of your barriers, and what are those barriers?

So we are we have taken a much more collaborative approach at looking across the park.

01:34:42 - 01:35:18

Anna Dixon

That sounds positive in terms of working together, but the incentives aren't there, are they, to actually collaborate? So, Age UK was suggesting in their briefing on corridor care that part of the deterioration in from March 2022 was that special arrangements for funding social care and discharge that were there in the pandemic came to an end. Do you think that does play a part, and are the arguments to, you know, change the incentives, whether using Better Care Fund, to be able to get people out quicker?

01:35:18 - 01:36:06

Samantha Jones

I was just about to talk about the Better Care Fund for precisely that reason. So, the incentives may be different from a local government perspective and a health perspective, but there is the pooled budget in terms of the Better Care Fund. And from a both at a national and a local perspective, there is a very clear expectation about what the Better Care Fund is to be used for and how that actually works through in practice. As clearly as part of our work to look at how we can better support social care in terms of social care reform, we're looking at what else do we need to do to make sure we've got the right levers from a national perspective and a local perspective to support if it's over and above the Better Care Fund. And how do we actually make the Better Care Fund have teeth locally so that all partners are playing in as part of it?

01:36:06 - 01:36:09

Speaker 46

And could you just remind me how much is going in this year into the Better Care Fund?

01:36:09 - 01:36:11

Speaker 45

Over nine billion.

01:36:11 - 01:36:41

Anna Dixon

Nine billion, okay.

Because obviously at the moment we're spending money on failure, aren't we, 2.7 billion estimated costs of delayed discharge. So I've heard a few of the steps that are being taken to try and reduce that spend and that cost of failure around the third that may be connected to the social care. But can you just say if there's any other big blocks in the other two-thirds and how you might be addressing those?

01:36:41 - 01:37:29

Emma Rowland

I think there one of the important ones is probably hospital discharge, so there's different ways that you can cut up some of this data. And I think one of the simplest things that we sort of said, there's at least 22% to 23% is within the capability of the hospital, what's called Pathway 0. So, no immediate changes to care, but just pure process. And that for us is a massive focus. So, there are a large amount of patients that go through there, their delays are relatively low, but at a cumulative level then that starts to add up, so it's about 9,000 patients with a three-day delay on average.

So the question is, how do we reduce that? And that comes back to what Professor Briggs has said, which is about making sure the board rounds, making the decision, making sure the paperwork is done on time, making sure those logistics are all done, the transports ready and booked. That's what we need to get a grip of from a hospital perspective, certainly.

01:37:29 - 01:38:11

Anna Dixon

And maybe coming back to you then, Professor Briggs, I mean work on flow isn't new. I was reminding myself about the Health Foundation's work, I think, on flow in 2013. And, you know, discharge planning starting on admission, you know, there's been innovative models and conflict of interest around HelpForce, but the use of volunteers to try and speed up discharge, whether that's, you know, running around to the pharmacy, making sure everything's in place. You know, there's lots of good practice examples.

Why are we having to, like, do this all over again and come up with a special programme?

Do leaders in the NHS just forget like what works?

01:38:11 - 01:38:59

Tim Briggs

Well I think that I think Covid had a has had a big effect on the health service without a shadow of a doubt. And I think some of the learning has been lost both the operational side and also clinically. And so I think the great thing we have with the GIRFT programme is people respect it. Got the right clinical leaders so we can go back out there now and redo that and relearn it. The key will be to embed it.

And this is what myself and Emma are really trying to do to make sure that it sticks and we actually get that flow right and those discharges. I think we now have a programme and working together that we can make this work this time, and I think it's really important it does.

So, that's where we are, and I think as we go forward in winter with the 40 providers we're going to be trust we're going to be working with, we hope that we'll see significant progress.

01:38:59 - 01:39:17

Samantha Jones

If I may, can so just to add and Jim's talked about this before at the committee about around the muscle memory and setting the expectations, and hold and NHS England holding every single leader within the NHS to account for what is you know this is the national standard, this is what needs to be required, this is a national standard, this is what needs to be required.

01:39:17 - 01:39:20

Speaker 49

I mean you must have déjà vu like me, Sir Jim.

01:39:20 - 01:40:44

Jim Mackey

Absolutely. I was going to say there's not many of us in the room probably remember the 2013 Health Foundation thing. We're putting a lot of emphasis into trying to rebuild both capability and the curiosity in the board, and the hunger to try and find a place that's done it better, improve in something, where the evidence is, either here or abroad.

Emma and I had an interaction over the weekend on email as well about whether we like it or not, a large part of our workforce has only worked in this kind of context. They haven't worked in a four-hour world necessarily. They haven't worked in a world where it's been anything other than a slog to try and find beds for patients. I can remember what it was like and I remember you know how lovely hospitals were when they were free-flowing and EDs were empty, but that's not the experience that a lot of our staff have ever had. And the other bit, just as a check on the problem with macro stats versus local stats.

We often default to the discharge thing being a social care problem.

That was never really my experience as a hospital leader. Our council partners were brilliant in the north-east generally and, whereas in other parts of the NHS social care is a really big part of the, part of the problem. So, we have to have a nuance between our overall national approach, but then reflect the local differences and variation as well, otherwise we'll solve, we'll solve the wrong problem.

01:40:44 - 01:41:19

Anna Dixon

And one final question from me, Sir Geoffrey, and I'll start with you, Sir Jim, but please feel free if there's anybody else wants to come in. And really is about data and technology. So, I went to visit the Bradford Royal Infirmary to their amazing, I guess it's a bit like air traffic control, with a, basically, data screens showing who was coming into A&E, all the flow through the hospital and who was being discharged. And so they could anticipate, as demand was coming into A&E, they could be sending people to say, right, these are ready to discharge, can we accelerate them going out?

01:41:19 - 01:41:22

Speaker 50

So, they were able to in one place, it was very calm in there, actually.

01:41:22 - 01:41:58

Anna Dixon

I've never like Gone were the days of screaming down the phone, "Have we got a bed? Have we got a bed?" from somebody. It was all very calm and wonderful. So, it was like I mean, the results are not too bad, they've got 83% A&E performance, it's 4-hour performance, it's not the worst. But how much does a model like that in terms of, you know, being able to have real-time data, a control centre effectively for the hospital?

I have no idea how widespread it was. It looked really to be brilliant. So, how much can is that sort of tech and data something that also can help get down these delayed discharges?

01:41:58 - 01:42:20

Jim Mackey

So, it's not it's not the only thing. So, again, in my Northumbria experience, at that time, the trust was quite poorly developed from a technology point of view, although did have bed management technology which is hugely valuable.

Bradford are generally one of the top ten performers in the weekly ED stats, so they're actually doing pretty well overall in performance.

01:42:20 - 01:42:22

Speaker 51

You should come and visit if you haven't recently, it's great.

01:42:22 - 01:43:09

Jim Mackey

Yeah, absolutely. And their command centre is really impressive when you see it. Lots of people are trying to either replicate that, so if they've got an EPR instance that's similar to them, they can replicate a lot of it, and then others are using adapted approaches. But if you haven't got live data on your bed occupancy and who's ready to go, and all those things, you know, you're going to really struggle. So it absolutely has to be has to be part of the plan.

But that technology without the leadership will, without the clinical and operational alignment, without the whole system being in sync with each other isn't going to get you there, either. I've seen a bit of that at times where people have put the technology in and think that would solve it. If you have If you haven't got a good relationship with social care, or primary care is out of balance, you're still going to suffer.

01:43:09 - 01:43:16

Anna Dixon

I mean, they also have a brilliant ED model with the local hospice called React, which is why I was asking about hospice, because they turned people around at ED who don't need to be there.

01:43:16 - 01:43:24

Jim Mackey

Doing very well, aren't they? Historically, they haven't in ED, you know, at different times, they have had challenges, so the team have done a fantastic job there.

01:43:24 - 01:43:25

Thank you, Chair.

01:43:25 - 01:43:26

Thank you, Anna. Tris.

01:43:26 - 01:44:18

John Tristan Osborne

Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Many of my questions have already been answered, but I'm going to focus on a couple of areas. So, I represent Medway and Kent. Obviously, the Kent and Medway ICB has challenges and Medway Maritime as well. So, my question is just around the aging The over 65 population in my area has grown by 25% in 10 years.

We know that those people are much more likely to go into hospitals.

The bed population has not grown in a similar guise. Similar, the care home capacity in the local community hasn't either, so the hospital struggles. Can I ask, if you I know you mentioned and alluded to this question, have we modeled which parts of the country have some of these process problems, and which potentially is in the northeast, and how many are related to specific care problems in those localities? Do we have you modeled where what are the main challenges in each part of the country?

01:44:18 - 01:45:14

Jim Mackey

We haven't modeled everywhere, but when there's a cause for concern, Emma will come in on this, we have an approach called tiering, where we'll look at an organization and a system, and then the first step is a diagnostic. So what's going on here? Where do we think this system is out of balance?

Can we bring data in insight and then connect to somewhere else in the country that has a similar problem and has been able to solve it? So, it's not a one-size-fits-all thing at all. It has to be quite tailored. The system you've described has historical, long, complex challenges that are really multi-factorial so it is one of our handful of most worrying places in terms of all the problems they've got to solve. But I can assure you it is very tailored.

There's a lot of data and analysis goes in initially to just try and work out exactly what's going on and then try to help with targeted support and intervention. Anything you want to add, Emma?

01:45:14 - 01:45:46

Emma Rowland

No, probably not. Maybe a little, sorry, having said that. So, there's a degree of absolutely we look at very specifics because everybody is not the same. Everybody's population is not the same. Everybody's need's not the same.

Everybody's A&E is different. So, the question is we try and do two things: one from a model what can we take that does what can we do once, but what actually needs completely nuanced and we try and balance exactly that. And certainly, when it comes to specific support, it very much depends on population needs, primary care, community care around it, social care, the whole package, absolutely.

01:45:46 - 01:47:00

John Tristan Osborne

Thank you very much. And can I just say we have a new CEO for Kent and Medway ICB, who's outstanding, and there's a clear plan going forward, which I'm really impressed with. So, there is change coming, and I think there's confidence in that ecosystem about that. Just want to put that on the record.

My second question is just around the fact that, you're right, in parts of the country the care system, which represents a third of the discharges, is extremely expensive and has also seen a reduction in the number of beds. Is there any nuance around perhaps supporting some ICBs around expanding some of that community capacity, because we have a ostensibly a privatised care model in our area. It's extremely expensive for the council. Councils are struggling financially. Is there dialogue with MHCLG and others just around how do we build that capacity?

And my second part of that question is just around, there is a proposal by the NHS to move more into neighborhood at the moment. Obviously a lot of people entering primary and hospitals are secondary care. There is a concern that as you take money out of hospitals and move it into neighborhoods, that they won't they won't have the capacity to deal with these challenges. And has that been fully gone through?

01:47:00 - 01:48:37

Jim Mackey

I'll take the second one if that's all right, and then I'll dodge the social care, MHCLG one for Sam. The neighborhoods thing is a is one of our core priorities.

And it's we absolutely need to be shifting people who are in hospital and care for them more locally wherever possible. That's what the whole philosophy is about, but also in a value for money way. There's a huge tension every day about do we just take a lot of money out of the hospital sector and invest in that, and then hope that it stems the flow. We've done that before over my career, and it hasn't worked, and we've ended up with double running. Or can we stimulate things with financial mechanisms?

Hopefully in the next couple of weeks we'll meet a group of GPs who want to take more risk in outpatients for example, where they think they can shift out the outpatient model, that would then free up resource to allow them to start investing in other things.

but importantly, it reduces the burden of work in the hospital sector. I've just left a discussion earlier on about this actually and I get played back to me a lot about so what do we do with the stranded costs and in the hospital sector when people have lost income because they've lost work, and I honestly think that's a that would be a lovely problem to have because every hospital in the country is just absolutely full at the gunnels. So, I'd like us to take a bit of risk on shifting patterns, try and get the financial incentives right to incentivise and encourage mainly primary care, but other partners, to do that,

and then get ready and agile to deal with the fixed costs. I think realistically that's a few years down the path.

01:48:37 - 01:49:31

Samantha Jones

And then in your first, question, answer to your first question, yes, as a summary. So obviously linked through to the Casey Commission and what does kind of the future around the National Care Service look like in practice, obviously not waiting for that although that has been brought forward.

Definitely, as part of our winter planning, we work very closely with the other government department, in fact they're part of the winter team. And in terms of what can we what do we do locally in terms of understanding capacity locally, there is a piece of work that we're just looking at the moment, which is obviously around with ministers, around social care reform for workforce, what does that actually look like from a capacity perspective, what does that look like in terms of supporting our workforce, our social care workforce? And as well as that, around the future of how the funding around the care home sector.

01:49:31 - 01:50:23

John Tristan Osborne

Okay. And just my last questions, because I'm cautious of time. So, are you make are there any data gaps here? So is there anywhere where we need to be much more cognisant of data, where we have data weaknesses?

I think some of your answers have alluded to the fact you might need to improve some of the data collection or the data collection needs to be standardized better. For instance, you mentioned about bed How do we define bed blocking, for instance? Is there a national definition around that every hospital is working to? Because if there isn't, then how do we know that the data is really salient? And just lastly, on this seven-day service, obviously, that could be How do we get hospitals into a seven-day service sort of process?

Because obviously, they have the staffing and they have the capacity potentially in terms of the building, but how do we get the operational elements to get to that point so that we can have more efficiency with the structures that we have already? So, there's two questions there, actually.

01:50:23 - 01:51:25

Jim Mackey

I'll start, if it's all right, and then you can correct me when I get too far in. In my opinion, on discharge delays, there is there's a bit of subjectivity and blurriness at times, like it would be really nice to be really definitive, and some of that's our data, but sometimes it's just complicated patients, where it's hard to tell, is this a social care problem or a health problem? People need something, and we need to get better at tightening that data up. I would also love a scenario, I think this is referenced in the report, where at every stage of the pathway, we're clear how long every stage should take, and whether we're actually complying with it. We're nowhere near being able to do that, and not even not just setting the standards, but having the technology that could work in that kind of real time.

There's no one in the world able to do it yet.

Well that within, you know, the next few years, I would have thought that would be possible and within reach. So, we're working with the data we've got, we're trying to refine it as much as we can. Well, there's always going to be a bit of you know, a bit of blurriness in it.

01:51:25 - 01:52:10

Samantha Jones

I think, I mean to go back to the question that was earlier asked about patient experience, from a patient or family perspective, they'd just expect us to know from across health and social care and within the hospital what's actually going what's actually going on. So, it's not a very good answer for any of us to say to any member of the family, "Well, actually it's because of this." So, there's always a need to make sure that we've got the most joined-up data possible, and that everybody agrees on the data. So, you got past the argument to, well, actually, it's not a social care delay, it's this delay.

We do have data on those patients with no criteria to reside, which is a terrible expression, but which is kind of breaks down where the delays are in practice, but that can always be refined.

01:52:10 - 01:52:26

John Tristan Osborne

Just the last thing just on the bed blocking sorry on the delay bed blocking definition and the corridor care definitions, are they standardized across all hospitals? Are they interpreted exactly the same way from one trust to another?

01:52:26 - 01:53:23

Emma Rowland

So, there's two in there. So, with regards to the corridor care definition, there is a clear definition that is available for all. There is naturally some local interpretation on that, and we know that is happening, and certainly that is a conversation that goes on particularly amongst clinical and operational bodies. From a what you define as a bed blocking, there is no definition there as such, but what the team have explained what we've got recently is a new acute discharge sitrep, is what it's called, which defines what the patient requires. So, from the point of view you are ready for discharge, what do you now need?

And it's what's called pathway based so it's needs-based. It's not perfect, but it does give us an idea how many patients might not have any needs to go, no care needs, additional needs to go home, so on Pathway 0, all the way to the opposite end of Pathway 3 where you might need a care home, because it gives an idea about where we would be best to focus looking at those delays and the bed potentially that is lost during that time. Okay.

01:53:23 - 01:54:01

Jim Mackey

Can I just Sorry, just slide as well. So, I think on this discharge thing, I can't overemphasise the need for all partners to work together. There's nothing worse than if you're a family member on the end of it and it sounds like health and social care are arguing about whose problem it is.

We're just That needs to be as joined up as it can be and the best places really deal with that properly. I think I would also, going back to the crowding points earlier on, I would love to have us have a crowding metric and we'll talk to RCEM about that to see if we can construct something together. I think would be really useful for us in trying to make the improvements in this area as well.

01:54:01 - 01:54:02

Thank you very much.

01:54:02 - 01:54:30

Samantha Jones

And just the other point I was just going to make was it's pathway-based. We don't use the expression "bed blockers", which I know No, I know, absolutely no, because you were saying it yourself, because it's an individual within that bed and it's and making somebody feel as if they're in the wrong place is That was the definition previously. But as Emma said, it's understanding the pathway delays for the reason, because as Jim said right at the beginning, the dignity of the individuals involved as well.

01:54:30 - 01:55:08

Jim Mackey

And the corridor care metric was started from scratch with the coalition as well.

So, Tim, Emma and I have all been to this hospital which I'll not name, but we was an outlier, had terrible visible patients on corridors. When I went to see them, there were no patients on corridors, but the data still looked bad because the definition had started capturing things elsewhere in the hospital that people were less focused on. So, I'm sure over time we'll refine the measurement and then we'll get more consistency. But what we just needed to make a start, and try and take a stand, and start shining light on it.

01:55:08 - 01:55:46

Tim Briggs

Can I just also say about the seven-day hospital? One of the conversations we're having is because discharges fall off at the weekend, and what's going to be absolutely critical this winter is we maintain that on a Saturday and Sunday, because what happens otherwise, trusts then are blocked up by the Monday, don't free up until the Tuesday, Wednesday, and we've got to change that.

So, conversations ongoing about making sure the discharge lounge is open at the weekend, making sure we get the ward rounds done at weekends, again the board rounds so we make sure it becomes a seven-day hospital and we absolutely maintain our discharges during the weekend that which means on a Monday, you start fresh and you can really start to really get the flow right.

01:55:46 - 01:55:50

Speaker 53

Look forward to seeing those results. Yeah. Thank you, Sir.

01:55:50 - 01:56:04

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

On that point, Professor Tim, anything I've ever had to do with hospitals they've always made a special effort to get people out before Christmas. Why are they not doing the same thing to get people out on a Friday before the weekend?

01:56:04 - 01:56:43

Tim Briggs

So, that's part of the conversations that Emma and I are having with individual trusts, systems and what have you. Again, I think it's part of the re-learning and I think what we are going to do is make it become business as usual which it hasn't been.

And so, but I think people are now beginning to understand the need for this. Discharge lounges at weekends being open is going to be critical, and what they mustn't do is get bedded by patients that come in the night before. But if we can get that right, and then they get the clinicians and the teams coming in to do the ward rounds, and also discharging by nurse-led discharge, criteria-led discharge can make a big difference.

01:56:43 - 01:56:45

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Thank you. And Matt Turmaine, please.

01:56:45 - 01:57:28

Matt Matthew Robert Turmaine

Thank you, Chair. I'd like to talk about the delivery plans and Sir Jim, if I could direct my question at you, that would be great. The NAO report says that the main objective of the two-year 2023 plan was to deal with reduced patient flow through hospitals resulting from increased bed occupancy rates, which NHSE saw as the key driver of falling A&E performance.

The 2023 plan was to increase capacity in A&E, as well as expanding care people can access without going to hospital, such as community care. What changes have you made under the 2025 newer plan in response to those slightly limited improvements that were made in the 23 one?

01:57:28 - 01:58:43

Jim Mackey

Well, as we've described earlier on, especially with a new ministerial team, there's been much more focus on improvements in the round, rather than trying to over focus on one specific element, so specially on the social care element, interface with neighborhoods and primary care.

And we're hoping in the next couple of weeks to publish a new urgent and elective care strategy that will set out a bit of a path as also for the next few years in terms of strategic direction. I think the way So, this the '23 plan was before my time in this role, but from memory, the team were very focused on long ambulance waits as well. And actually, to be fair, made a pretty significant improvement in category two performance, which sustained that through last winter also. So, it was as stated in the plan, but then after the plan was published, there's a really big focus on category two performance and handover delays, which did improve fairly dramatically. What we're now doing is try just trying to take a more rounded approach and a more tailored approach, as we discussed there before as well, and make sure that in particular organizations and systems we're focused on what the issue is, rather than a kind of standard approach that works everywhere.

01:58:43 - 01:58:56

Matt Matthew Robert Turmaine

My understanding is that the 2025 plan is for a similar time period, so do you think that this one's going to be more effective? I mean, absolutely acknowledging that the 2023 plan did deliver a lot of what was supposed to do.

01:58:57 - 01:59:54

Jim Mackey

I would hope so. As I've described before the, we're trying to deal with an awful lot, you know, and I think when you look back and you sit back from all of this, what local leaders are trying to deal with is I think often understated, the level of complexity, the financial turnaround they're trying to pull off, the delivery of or improvement of standards across elective, urgent care, the big shifts, you know, et cetera.

There's an awful lot that we're trying to do at the same time. Compared to other times in NHS history, we're try we're trying to improve at a rate that's much quicker than ever before. We're in a much tighter fiscal context. The economy is much tighter than it was in the last time we made big improvements, you know. So, we're all cognizant of that, and just trying to, you know, keep the right pace, keep things as stretching as we can, but also not so that it feels unreasonable and therefore unachievable.

01:59:54 - 02:00:09

Matt Matthew Robert Turmaine

Okay, thank you. The 25 Plan has got more focus on I quote, operational improvements in A&E. So Emma, I don't know if you had anything that you wanted to say on that as well, which is your area, I think, isn't it?

02:00:09 - 02:01:08

Emma Rowland

Thank you. Yes, absolutely. And also to declare I used to be the Chief Operating Officer at Homerton, so probably crosses both. So, that probably stems all the way down really from again, that grip and control, which I think we've hopefully alluded to. So, yes, it's about resource.

Yes, it's about mapping out that pathway. But it's also about getting hold of your data. It's about understanding what your flow and your patterns look like, and what that means.

And that's all the way down from executive and from board to the down to the individuals on the ground. And some of that hopefully comes by the models that we've alluded to, so again the expectation is comply or achieve by other means. So, for example, model ED, it is there, it has just come from the learning, so how are you implementing it if you are not achieving? And likewise, again through that grip and control that we've alluded to, across the next 72 hours, so what's the board round look like, the expectation for you to discharge the patients, etc.? And then, how we finish off towards the end with that collaborative working across the patch.

02:01:08 - 02:01:22

Matt Matthew Robert Turmaine

And so, as a result of that, you probably don't envisage us being here in a couple of years time talking about the same issue because of that different approach or is there a risk that might be the case?

02:01:22 - 02:01:27

Speaker 56

Emma is still young enough to be here, so shed be heard.

02:01:27 - 02:01:31

Speaker 57

Time moves slower than we think sometimes, doesn't it, but

02:01:31 - 02:01:44

Samantha Jones

I think we are working on the basis that this plan will work. There is always a risk with any plan of course, but I think total focus on delivering this plan and the areas that have been set out.

02:01:45 - 02:02:01

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Thank you. Before I bring Anna in, something that was not covered at all in the NAO report, but it occurred to me when I was reading it, how far has industrial action by the junior doctors affected the performance of these two plans?

02:02:01 - 02:03:30

Jim Mackey

So, we have a really good point and we're potentially going into another industrial action soon with consultants, which is terribly difficult to manage as everybody will be aware.

When you look back at last year, it is easy to forget that we had a lot of rounds of industrial action with resident doctors. Now, we saw, in the event, as colleagues have pointed out, performance improved short-term, but then over the longer period, you pay the price, you know, that you get deteriorated performance afterwards as things start to settle down and you everyone starts to, you know, get back into balance, etc. So, it's hugely disruptive from a performance point of view, no question about that. I think the biggest issue, though, is it squeezes headroom, leadership headroom, clinical headroom for innovation. All of the things that we've that are highlighted and we've talked about today, absolutely everybody you meet will want to do them.

You know, you very rarely meet anybody who is arguing about whether patients could be in a different setting, or whether we could improve discharge, or we could be more seven days.

It's just really hard to do when every few weeks, you've got to strike. So there's the headroom impact, you know, have people got the time and the head space to do it, there's the financial impact, and then there's the actual performance impact of a short-term game for longer term deterioration over time. You weigh all those things up, and it is very hard to improve when you've got industrial action.

02:03:30 - 02:03:35

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Thank you for that candid answer. Anna, on mental health, please.

02:03:35 - 02:04:05

Anna Dixon

Yeah, thank you, I just want to come back to the issue of mental health.

So, I think the data suggests that about 3% of ED attendances are mental health related, and yet they're twice as likely as other patients to remain in the department for more than 12 hours. What action are you taking to address long waits for patients who are in mental health crisis, and ensure that they're getting the right care in the right place?

02:04:05 - 02:04:33

Jim Mackey

Yeah, I'll bring Emma in a second, but you're right, Anna. And especially when you look at very long waits, there's a very big proportion of those patients are mental health patients, and you know, it's the wrong place for them, it's not the right environment for them, hugely disruptive also for other patients and staff. So, it is part of the part of our approach. There will be a new mental health strategy published as well at some point, but Emma, do you want to pick this up?

02:04:33 - 02:05:52

Emma Rowland

Certainly.

So mental health patients are obviously very vulnerable and particularly as you rightly pointed out having extended long stay in A&E and I suspect there's a significant proportion of patients in those 24 hours are probably mental health patients. It's all the way through the pathway really, so again, we've invested, how can we how can we prevent those patients escalating into this need so that they don't require an A&E because ultimately A&E is the last place anybody should end up. So, what does that look like? For example then things like crisis cafes and community healthcare in primary care so how do we make sure people are as well as possible all the way through. Certainly then when people are either heading towards A&E, how do we ensure we've got the collaborative pathways right? So, for example, mental health in A&E, we've also got mental health lines on 111 and also links with the 999 so how do we make sure that individual goes to the right and the safest place that they can do?

Once in A&E, care and safety is obviously paramount.

So, how do we look after that individual and how do we also make sure that they get the needs they want? Most A&Es now have a what's called psychiatric liaison service, so a direct 24/7, seven days a week service that they can lean into mental health, so individuals get prompt reviews, and the expectation is that is a synchronous review, so you don't wait for one person followed by the other person.

02:05:52 - 02:05:59

Speaker 59

Are these usually people employed by the mental health trust to work Are they usually people who are employed by the mental health trust co-located in the ED?

02:05:59 - 02:06:09

Anna Dixon

And does it actually count as a place of safety?

I mean I is it set up to meet standards to allow people to be effectively safely detained?

02:06:09 - 02:06:54

Emma Rowland

There are variations in standards. So, A&E by definition, in most A&Es, is de- declared as a place of safety, not necessarily the same thing as saying have we got a safe environment for an individual. So, I would certainly say from a noisy A&E, that is far from ideal from a poor patient that is acutely disturbed during that time.

So, what we're trying to do very much is say, what does a mental health A&E and what does other things look like that we could get those individuals to the right place. A lot of the delays that go on for these individuals are because of the complexity of their need, plus also the men- the mental health beds that's required and some of the process required, particularly for a section 2.

02:06:54 - 02:07:09

Anna Dixon

Okay, so it's so is it, sorry, is it the a difficulty in accessing a mental health inpatient bed, or is it the time it takes to assess and potentially detain?

02:07:09 - 02:07:17

Emma Rowland

The in my personal opinion, the significant delay is usually around a bed, but there are also delays around the process for those individuals as well.

02:07:17 - 02:07:54

Anna Dixon

It would be good to actually get the data on that if it's possible. I respect your personal opinion, obviously, Emma, but it would be good to get that. And then, sorry, on a different topic, in the evidence we received, we heard and I think you talked about some of these other units. You've used some acronyms in, and they seem to be widely used, but I don't actually know what this stands for, some SSTUCs, or something, which are sometimes called "off-the-clock" units. How much are they really the best place for people and how much are they being used to game the system and effectively get people out of A&E?

02:07:54 - 02:09:30

Emma Rowland

I'll try and split all the different acronyms because it sounds like they've all got merged into one. So, there are what's very specific units, for example, urgent treatment centres, which is an "on the clock" area, which is where you might see more minor illnesses, minor injuries, and it is part of what we call the left-shift from A&E. So, how do you take some of the lower acuity patients out of A&E to reduce crowding? Very much on the area "on the clock", apologies, and performance rate is high; at least 96% of people are seen within the four hours. There is then what's called same day emergency care.

So, that is almost the other end, if you like. So, in A&E, if I was thinking of admitting a patient, I might see if they could instead be seen in the same day emergency care, where their care might be coordinated in a much faster fashion, both from a consultant level, so they get the consultants' review, they get the diagnostics, but try and save a bed day if the individual is capable of doing so in an ambulatory fashion.

And that's been quite a change over the last couple of years. So, for example, we one example might be a kidney infection where previously you might have come into hospital for three or four days for IV antibiotics, you now might get that if you can walk and go home safely through a same-day emergency care system. There's then a new area in model ED, which what's called EMAC as well, which is extended emergency medicine, which is specifically to remain under A&E.

So, that might be if I had seen a patient, and I wanted an additional blood test that I think again that they could go home with, that they might remain in me under that time. So, they'd remain in the footprint of the emergency care. So, they're sort of three different types of settings.

02:09:30 - 02:09:36

Anna Dixon

And that third one is on the clock, sits still a type of emergency medicine, but they have not been formally admitted?

02:09:36 - 02:09:50

Emma Rowland

It's not a formal admission. It comes off the clock with regards to after 4 hours. However, you remain on the clock with the expectation that you will be seen and treated with a total time of 12 hours,

And that was intentionally the reason, so that it shouldn't be gamed.

02:09:50 - 02:10:15

Jim Mackey

And we're just about to refresh some guidance for the service to make sure everybody's counting in the appropriate way because of all these extra services that have been developed over recent years. There is a bit of confusion, and I've seen both ways. I've seen places that have patients off the clock when maybe should be, on the clock and vice versa. So, Emma's team are working on something that will get out in the next couple of weeks to just say, can everyone just comply with these standards, now.

02:10:15 - 02:10:42

Anna Dixon

I mean, innovation great, as long as it's for the right reasons, getting people safe care in the right place.

And whether it's on the clock or off the clock, I mean in a way the main thing is that people are doing the right thing and not being driven by the target, and they're driven by safety and quality. So, can you give assurance that this proliferation of different models and different units isn't is still achieving that goal of safe, timely care for patients?

02:10:42 - 02:10:49

Emma Rowland

That is absolutely our intention, and certainly, my first-hand knowledge, and I'm sure of Tim's, too, that is exactly the intention of the clinicians and what is being driven.

02:10:49 - 02:10:51

Speaker 61

And that's a guidance that you are issuing in terms of best practice?

02:10:52 - 02:10:54

Speaker 60

Yes. Thank you. Okay.

02:10:54 - 02:10:58

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Well done, Anna, good line of questioning. Clive, please.

02:10:58 - 02:11:33

Clive Betts

Yes, just to follow up, we've talked quite a bit about the need to have a whole system, end-to-end approach in hospitals to the challenge of A&E, amongst other things.

To refer back to my colleague Anna Dixon's comments about the system in Bradford, where there is, you know, sort of a control position where the management of the hospital can see where everyone is, what the delays are, what the obstacles are, and look at every patient. Many trusts don't have that. Why?

02:11:33 - 02:12:24

Jim Mackey

Because they don't have the technology infrastructure. We're going through a process of everybody installing an EPR, which is one of the core, electronic patient record, one of the core fundamentals that allows this to start being built out. The system in Bradford, as I understand it, did involve quite a significant investment, so not ever not everywhere can afford to do that, and we can't afford to do it at all nationally, everywhere. And also, in an ideal world, you wouldn't just have the hospital data and all of that, you'd have what's going on in primary care, what's going on in the social care system as well.

I honestly think, Clive, over the next sort of 5 years, definitely 10 years, this will be built out, it'll be everywhere, it'll just happen organically. We can't, we haven't got the resource and the technology fundamentals in every place to be able to do exactly what's described in Bradford.

02:12:24 - 02:12:33

Clive Betts

It just seems to me as such an obvious that if you're going to control patient flow flows through a hospital, you have to know where the patients are.

02:12:33 - 02:12:44

Jim Mackey

Yeah, so everybody will do it, but they'll have they'll have different degrees of technology. What Anna's described is a very polished, it's been there 5 or 6 years, I think, now, as well, from memory.

02:12:44 - 02:12:45

Track every bed, every patient.

02:12:45 - 02:13:12

Jim Mackey

Yeah, it's a well it's a well-established, way ahead of nearly everybody else in the NHS, because they made some early moves when they put an EPR in.

They had some, again from memory, some technology investment from the technology companies to try and prove the case. But that's not the case everywhere. And you've heard before, you know, trying to get everybody up to a basic level of technology capability, which is going to take time.

02:13:12 - 02:13:14

Speaker 63

Is there a central drive to do that?

02:13:14 - 02:13:39

Jim Mackey

There is, but it's if every hospital I mean, I think, again, I'd be guessing, it's maybe four or five million quid to do that in a normal hospital. We couldn't do we couldn't do that everywhere. But also, even if we had the money, we have to bear in mind what everybody else is trying to cope with, all of the things that people are trying to deliver at the same time. There's a there's a limit to what people can actually absorb.

02:13:39 - 02:13:42

Speaker 64

Without it, bringing about some of the improvements.

02:13:44 - 02:14:06

Jim Mackey

It's harder, but there are simple bed management systems around that are really effective and people are using them really effectively to manage flow with good performance. So, it's not It's ideal, and it definitely would enhance your ability, especially if we could do it across the whole system, but we're not completely reliant upon it.

02:14:06 - 02:14:10

Speaker 65

Have all hospitals got a manage bed management system in place then?

02:14:10 - 02:14:49

Jim Mackey

Everywhere has a version of and it could be Yeah. Well, it means different things to different people. I've lived in a in an environment in Northumbria that had a had As I've said before, didn't have a big, mainstream EPR, had a brilliant bed management system. I went to Newcastle Hospitals, that had a well very well-known EPR, but didn't have a digital bed management system. It was very much old-school in the way that was developed.

And couldn't the EPR couldn't cope with a bed management system being attached to it.

So, because of our infrastructure being built over time and everybody's got a different inheritance, it's very complicated.

02:14:49 - 02:14:51

Speaker 66

It's a big problem. Needs addressing.

02:14:51 - 02:14:53

Speaker 67

Yeah.

02:14:53 - 02:15:30

Clive Betts

Can I ask you just about the join up then across the piece? Perhaps Permanent Secretary or yourself Sir Jim would answer. And that's about trying to get local leaders generally together to address the issues, clearly the interface between the Health Service, social care, public health right across. I think you know my comments in the past about the ICBs withdrawing from this process, and the importance of actually having named officials in the NHS who can link with their named counterparts in Social Services and Public Health. It's worked really well in Sheffield in the past. It's been pulled apart now.

02:15:30 - 02:15:32

Speaker 68

Can it get addressed properly across the piece?

02:15:32 - 02:16:24

Jim Mackey

Absolutely, and as Emma's described, all of our local winter planning processes should be whole-system. So, we obviously start in the NHS, but locally, you'd expect all partners to be working together. Everything we're talking about with regard to neighbourhoods, for example, and our work on frailty, etc., we're really clear no single organisation can deal with that by themselves. We've discussed before when your ICB changes happened, you there was a your view, strong view, was there was a loss of focus in place.

Absolutely.

Secretary of State last week in a conversation about our operating model's been very clear with us that arrangements at place, however they are developed and delivered, partners working together, mainly health and social care working together with other partners, has to be a core priority, and we are carrying that forward in the in and what we're doing.

02:16:24 - 02:16:35

Clive Betts

It's all right you having a core priority or the permanent secretary, but when ICBs don't have any regard to it and pull all their staff into the bureaucratic centre.

02:16:35 - 02:16:55

Jim Mackey

So, as we've discussed before, not everywhere has done what your experience has been in with your ICB. Others will speak strongly about the place-based working and the partnership working, et cetera, Clive. And we'll have a separate conversation again about your specific ICB.

02:16:55 - 02:17:01

Clive Betts

Well, hopefully, that soon that this could happen. Because in the meantime things are deteriorating, and I don't want my experiences

02:17:01 - 02:17:15

Jim Mackey

I, so I checked a couple of weeks ago, and I was assured that things, and colleagues locally, had seen improvements in these things in your neck of the woods.

So, let's talk about it offline and I'll get back involved in that.

02:17:15 - 02:17:24

Clive Betts

And, Professor Briggs, what's happening across the country in this regard? You, obviously, go around and look at, you know, from a more detached perspective, certainly, about how things are working.

02:17:24 - 02:17:44

Tim Briggs

Yeah, I think that the some, given the areas that I've been to, I think the response from many of the ICBs was very positive. Clearly, they've got to look at the evidence and what have you, but what we want is the local evidence and then the national evidence, which I think will tell a very compelling story.

02:17:44 - 02:17:52

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Thank you very much, Clive. Now, the clock is moving pretty late, but I've got three or four quick-fire questions, and I really mean quick-fire questions, please.

02:17:52 - 02:17:53

I want to, if I can.

02:17:53 - 02:17:55

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Will you start, but very quickly?

02:17:55 - 02:18:30

Rupert Lowe

Well, just listening to debate, I've got a question. The NAO found that NHS England has no means to enforce recommendations on the various NHS trusts, which I think is one of the points they made. And listening to this very useful debate today, my question for you is: so when an NHS trust doesn't follow your recommendations and it basically falls short with regard to the amount of hours, say 24 hours people have to wait and it falls outside your guidelines, I mean what do you actually do?

02:17:55 - 02:17:55

Speaker 72

Right, very quickly.

02:18:30 - 02:18:33

Rupert Lowe

What's the censure on that trust and their leadership?

02:18:33 - 02:19:47

Jim Mackey

So, we do have the powers of enforcement and intervention in extremis.

From a regulatory perspective, that has to be a proportionate act, and it has to be There has to be a series of actions that a reasonable organisation would carry out if able. So, generally, that would mean in this context a lot of the things we've been talking about are changes to clinical systems, operational systems that if a regulatory body intervenes with indirect, there is There's a very significant chance you create more risk than you resolve. So, we have to exercise those powers very carefully. Have you ever used them? We're in the process of using it somewhere now in England on another matter.

So, these things do happen. Generally, our intervention will involve removal of key individuals, removal of a board, implanting a turnaround director, et cetera. But these powers are used, there's a process to go through, you have to have the legal instruments in place.

But as I say, as of today, a set of actions were initiated last week to enforce some clinical change where we didn't have confidence that the local leadership are doing that of their own volition.

02:19:47 - 02:19:55

Rupert Lowe

It just struck me it's difficult for you guys to sort it out if you haven't actually got the power of censure over those people who are failing to deliver. But

02:19:55 - 02:20:43

Jim Mackey

Careful about how It can't be the first tool you get out the box. And it's all In this area, everything we do is about managing risk. Everything that local leaders do is about managing risk. There's a real chance we increase risk by not knowing the local nuances in operational and clinical systems well enough. And I think also there's a point here about, our whole model only works if boards do their job.

And we need to really build board capability and capacity over time, because in all of these things, there's a natural inclination obviously from our point of view that we have to solve every problem nationally.

It's not, can't work like that. Everything has to be solved locally, with a few things resolved nationally, and us creating the frameworks and rules and mechanisms to support that.

02:20:43 - 02:21:19

Tim Briggs

Sir, can I just add from the clinical viewpoint, on the local aspect, this is where the chief medical officers are really important. And since we started this whole programme, what we've seen now is trust build a dashboard where they can monitor real-time whether patients are being seen at the right time, and find out the reasons why that doesn't happen. And then there's the conversation with the chief medical officer about why it's happened and how we prevent it happening again. And I think that will be quite effective, something that was missing before, but I think now it's going to make, I hope, quite a difference.

02:21:19 - 02:21:53

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Rupert, thank you for asking that question.

I don't want to get anybody into trouble, but that was exactly the same question I was going to ask about my own trust. I visited one of my local hospitals, I'm not going to name it, in the early summer and they did have some capacity admittedly, but they had a delayed discharge payment patient who'd been in that hospital for 120 days. 120 days, and I checked it. I didn't believe I'd heard correctly. Now, I see my trust is at the lower end of the four- four-hour target at 63%.

It does seem to me that somebody needs to pay some attention somewhere.

02:21:53 - 02:21:54

Yeah, we'll do.

02:21:54 - 02:22:25

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Thank you.

Could I, just while you're sort of on your feet metaphorically, Jim, we, you will recall in our earlier hearing on hospital building programmes, had some discussion about the number of beds. Given the evidence we've got in this report from the NAO that another 9 to 14,000 beds would make a huge difference to this whole matter, have you altered or are you do you have a different policy on new hospitals and the number of beds that new hospitals are going to provide?

02:22:25 - 02:23:29

Jim Mackey

We haven't got a new policy on it, but we in various board sessions over summer, especially relating to the new urgent and elective care strategy, there's been a really big focus on that strategy and the impact it has and then the read across into the hospital estate and what that might mean in terms of capital investment, and also similarly in our work on neighbourhoods to make sure the modelling and assumptions in all of that are consistent. So, across the board, we've got a score set of assumptions that all that's held by Paul Deighton, our strategy director, to make sure all of these things are in sync. We're not saying this is going to shrink over there, but it's actually going to grow over there.

There's quite a lot of realignment to do in all of that. And then the main thing I worry about that is we get too carried away about how much change we can pull off and then start making heroic assumptions that turn out not to be possible, because we've done that a lot over the last 20 or 30 years. So being again, as stretching as possible, but realistic and reasonable.

02:23:29 - 02:23:34

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Is that policy aligned with areas which have got large growths in population?

02:23:34 - 02:23:47

Jim Mackey

Yeah, right, it will be. But again, all would expect locally those plans to be sensitized. So, we'll publish a strategy nationally. Those things really need to be very sensitive to local demographics, etc.

02:23:47 - 02:24:07

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Thank you very much for that answer. Professor Tim, last question to you. You were, or are, I think, still leading the Getting It Right First Time program.

Can you say what effect that's having? Is it having a beneficial effect, and perhaps combine that answer with how effective virtual wards are in solving this problem?

02:24:07 - 02:24:09

Speaker 73

And he wants a quick answer, Tim, as well.

02:24:09 - 02:24:50

Tim Briggs

So, I'd say, yes, as I think the Getting It Right First Time is respected by clinicians, operational teams, respected by all regions, and the advice that we give, people listen, and the great thing about is we look at the data, and then we offer support and help. As regards virtual wards, I think they also have a role in helping us with discharge, either step up or step down from primary care, or indeed, from secondary care.

Again, this is where technologies come in. I think technologies for remote monitoring can make a big difference, but I think it has to be all things together like virtual wards, hot clinics, discharge planning. All of those together mean that we'll get our flow right and we'll have, hopefully, a better winter.

02:24:50 - 02:25:10

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Final question, again with all my experiences with hospitals, a problem in delayed discharges relates to relatives being able to take their relatives out of hospital on time. What are you doing to address that? Can you give them more notice, for example, when their relative is likely to be discharged?

02:25:10 - 02:25:12

Speaker 74

Can I hand over to Emma on that?

02:25:12 - 02:25:41

Emma Rowland

Thank you. Yeah.

I don't know a specific answer on that, but I think the expectation is that good communication throughout is obviously absolutely paramount, and we'd say not only with relatives and patients, knowing what's going on, but also our partners, for example, in social care. So, to come back to the original point, I think we need to start planning discharge, including those conversations with patients, relatives, partners, right at the beginning of their journey, and then, actually, completely involved as they go through, so that it's a joint decision-making.

02:25:41 - 02:25:44

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Thank you very much. Permanent Secretary, of course.

02:25:44 - 02:26:13

Samantha Jones

I just wanted to, this pains me, but the reason that GIRFT works so well is evidenced by today's clinically led. So, if you take what Emma and Tim do, it's clinically led with data and is kind of relentless focus on the clinical leadership and the data associated with it. And the Secretary of State is very clear with us around the importance of clinical leadership, it doesn't even need to be said, but the importance of clinical leadership leading the change that you see set out today as examples.

02:26:13 - 02:26:39

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Thank you for that clarification. This is a huge subject which I have no doubt we will want to return to. Lots to be done.

We will take very carefully your evidence and have a look at it to produce a report with recommendations, which I hope you will seriously consider. An uncorrected version of the transcript will be available then in the coming days. You are all very busy people. We do appreciate your appearance here this afternoon and the evidence you have given us, which has been very interesting, indeed. Thank you.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.