Public Accounts Commission

20 October 2026

Public Accounts Commission Actual start House of Commons

18:11 - 18:27
Speaker 5
Order, order, welcome to today's meeting of the Public Accounts Commission on the National Audit Office's report and accounts for 2025-26.  And can I just ask the witnesses to introduce yourselves for the record. 
18:27 - 18:32
Speaker 4
Thanks, I'm Fiona Reynolds and I'm chair of the board of the National Audit Office. 
18:32 - 18:36
Speaker 1
I'm Gareth Davies, I'm the Comptroller and Auditor General. 
18:36 - 18:39
Speaker 3
Rebecca Sheeran, I'm the Chief Operating Officer. 
18:39 - 18:44
Speaker 2
You're all very, very, very welcome.  We're informal here, so we'll be using first names, is that okay? 
18:45 - 19:01
Speaker 5
So, first question's from me.  You came in under budget by around two million, split evenly between spending less than forecast and receiving more income than forecast.  What were the main drivers of each? 
19:01 - 20:32
Speaker 6
Well, it's worth taking expenditure and income separately.  So, we were slightly under on expenditure.  It wasn't staff costs, actually, staff costs came in just slightly over budget, but very close to budget.  Where we were under was our cash costs, particularly the spending on the firms for specialist audit advice.  And this mainly relates to the train operating companies, which as you remember was our big new chunk of audit work in the year. 

We'd estimated a fairly prudent amount for specialist advice on these audits.  It was the first year we'd undertaken them.  We weren't quite sure what it would take but we could see there were areas that required specialist advice like the leasing of rolling stock, allocation of fare revenue and so on.  As it turned out, we needed less of that advice in practice than we had expected.  And that's the bulk of that difference. 

There were other smaller underspends but that's the most significant one.  On income, we underestimated the income at the year end for three main reasons for that. 

Firstly, an audit that we had expected to be funded out of the grant that you award the NAO, the parliamentary funding, was actually funded from a fee.  That was the Infected Blood Compensation Authority.  So that came in as income we hadn't budgeted for.  Then we did slightly better than expected on renting out our spare space in our building, about 0.2 million.  And the rest was the timing of audit work at the year end. 

20:32 - 20:56

Speaker 6

As our accounting policy is that we recognize income for fee-paying audits according to the amount of the audit that's complete at the year end, and slightly more of that was completed than expected, partly led to the achievement of our target on signing off opinions before the summer recess, which I'll come onto later. But so those are the main reasons for the variances against budget.

20:56 - 21:08

Clive Efford

So you received the supplementary estimate of 1.2 million last year, but you've come in under budget by 2 million. So in hindsight, why didn't you manage the extra cost within your existing budget?

21:08 - 22:10

Speaker 6

It's really the same explanation because at the time we asked for the supplementary, that's when we were taking on those new train operating company audits, if you remember, which hadn't been in our original budget. And we needed we needed the expenditure. If we hadn't asked for the supplementary, we would have been well over on our expenditure budget. As you say, as it turns out, the income overshoot would have covered that. But we couldn't have ex- well, we didn't expect that at the time we asked for the money, and it would have been pretty reckless to assume that would happen.

As you know, the one thing the NAO can't do is overspend in a way that triggers an excess vote, particularly given that we have a role in policing that system across the rest of government. It would not be good for our credibility to be the one on the list with an excess vote. So we have to be prudent in estimating the cost of the audit work. And so it was the right thing to do at the time.

As you say, as it turned out, the income actually covered the additional expenditure that we needed.

22:10 - 22:33

Clive Efford

So you mentioned the renationalisation of Avanti. What impact has that had on your audit resources? And has it given you an insight into what you can expect with other additional burdens that are going to be placed on the National Audit Office as we go forwards?

22:33 - 23:48

Speaker 6

Well, we've certainly learned a lot from the first year of auditing the train operating companies, the first wave that came into public ownership. So we audited seven of them in the year we're talking about, in 25-26. The teams did a great job of preparing for that.

We treated this as a major additional chunk of work in a new sector. We spent a lot of time talking to the previous auditors, making sure we understood what we were inheriting, and then getting to know the businesses in the way you have to in your planning the audit work. All of that planning paid off because it meant that we weren't surprised by any of the audit issues that came up in that first year of auditing the train operating companies. All seven were signed off before the planned date, before the summer recess. So a great achievement from the team involved in that.

And it means we've got three more, as you mentioned, Avanti is one of those coming in. We've also got Chiltern and Great Western coming in for this year. So we're going to build on that experience. We're not expecting major differences, although you never assume anything as an auditor. But what we were kind of pleasantly surprised by the consistency of the accounting treatment and the issues across all the train operating companies.

They weren't as different as we'd been expecting.

So all of that means we've been able to build that into our into our budget for the current year.

23:48 - 24:03

Clive Efford

And going forwards, do you feel confident then, having had a good run at all of this, that you have the resources to deal with the additional pressures without having to seek a supplementary estimate this year?

24:03 - 24:22

Speaker 6

For this year, we are pretty confident about that. Rebecca might be able to kind of give an update on the figures, but all of our projections say that it's quite tight this year, actually. We're certainly not going to have plenty of room, but it's within the bounds that we should be able to manage both on income and expenditure for the rest of the year. I don't know if you want to add to that, Rebecca.

24:22 - 24:52

Rebecca Sheeran

Yes, just to say at this point we're essentially at the midpoint in the year and have just conducted, um, a detailed mid-year review, and our forecast is that we will be, um, in line with our budget this year. I should say the contrast with last year when we, uh, sought the supplementary estimate was because partway through the year, uh, there was a change in the number of those train operating companies that we were expected to audit within that year. We're not in that position this year. We've got that kind of clarity about, about the new work, so at this time we would not be expecting a supplementary estimate.

24:52 - 25:31

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Okay. Good afternoon, team. Um, can I start with one issue that's probably, uh, I think, um, of all the important issues the PAC has to deal with and the NAO has to deal with, and that is devolution in local government.

And just talk about the establishment of the local audit office and their role in all of that. Will it free up your resources as they take over more of that work?

25:31 - 28:53

Speaker 6

Well, I mean, obviously I strongly welcome the creation of the local audit office. It's been an unacceptably poor situation in local government audit, as the committee knows. And so it remains urgent that that's tackled so that local taxpayers have properly audited council accounts. It's just a basic requirement. And that's before we talk about devolution.

So, but with devolution on top of that, there's a really significant issue now about credible audit arrangements to allow proper scrutiny of local spending.

If significant amounts of what's currently central spending are going to be devolved, which they are, then the system of accountability needs to be able to deal with that. And so, the chair of the new body, the Local Audit Office, has been appointed, Bill Butler. He and I have met several times. He's been a guest at our board meeting. And we've had really constructive discussions about how do we advise government, who'll be policy-making on this issue, to make sure there's a joined-up audit framework that delivers the accountability that Parliament expects, but respects local decision-making and local accountability too.

And that's I think has to be quite different from anything we've had before given the scale of devolution that the government is contemplating, that we need something more robust than existed even when the Audit Commission existed. Because I think Parliament needs to be confident that the framework for devolution is clear, responsibilities are clear, you haven't got people pointing at each other when something goes wrong, and the importance of local accountability is properly respected. So I think that means quite a big role for the local audit office, not just auditing councils but also the accounts of the mayoral strategic authorities. It means a significant role for the NAO, I think, in helping the Public Accounts Committee understand how well the devolution framework is delivering value for money for taxpayers. And that doesn't mean second-guessing local decisions, but it does mean being able to understand how the money's being spent and what difference that's making to value for money.

Crucially, it means understanding the different approaches that have been taken to the same issue around the country. That's the whole point of devolution is you're expecting more innovation, you're expecting better targeted solutions because of knowledge of local circumstances.

Is that how this is playing out? Is the evidence demonstrating that local decision-making means better value for money? And I think that's a question that Parliament has a legitimate interest in. And I think our work will shift in those areas being devolved, which of course isn't everything that government spends, but it's significant amounts. In those areas, I think our work shifts from central government audit to how is the devolution framework delivering.

And I think that means working closely with the local audit office to understand what their audits are showing and to give PAC national reports that allow you then to understand how well the framework is developing. So overall, I don't think that needs a kind of shift of resources from us to the local audit office.

I think it means us doing a different program of work in the future. And as you know, our VFM work is very selective and will remain so even even with devolution.

28:53 - 29:16

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

I think the critical question in all of that is shifting this devolution from central government to local government means that there will be a shift in auditing from you to local government auditors. Will, given the past history of local government audit, do you think there will be sufficient capacity to be able to do all of that work?

29:16 - 30:45

Speaker 6

It will take time for that capacity to build.

I'm very confident that by the earlier appointment of Bill Butler, for example, somebody who knows the local audit very well, that you've got people with a good understanding making the decisions about that future regime. But realistically, it's going to take years to develop the kind of capacity that we're talking about because it isn't just about making sure council audits are more timely and more robust. It means an audit regime around the mayoral strategic authorities. And as we know, there've been cases where there've been questions about individual mayoral spending decisions without really a satisfactory local answer about how they're being held to account. And that really does need solving.

So it's going to take time for that local capability to be built. I think there's a clear plan to do that, but it's years. And so I think there's two points there for Parliament. What's the end state that we're aiming at? And that's where the early discussions that we're having and we're trying to have with officials are proving helpful, I think.

But then, what about the interim between now and three years' time, say, which is probably as early as you could expect mature arrangements to be in place? We might need some transitional work, perhaps more work from the NAO in the meantime. And because I don't think we can wait for that gap to be filled for three years or more. I think we're going to need something in the interim.

30:45 - 31:13

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

And the bigger the authority, the bigger the mayoral combined authority, the potentially bigger problem when something goes wrong. Look at Birmingham, for example. I believe you have powers to start to be able to carry out an investigation when something goes wrong with one of these authorities. Would you like to sort of let us know how you intend to use that power and in what circumstance?

31:13 - 33:06

Speaker 6

Well actually, I mean Birmingham's a council of course, rather than a strategic authority. We don't have any powers to audit councils. And that's my point about the robustness of the local audit regime absolutely needs to be able to tackle the issues that a council like Birmingham has been facing for a long time and to be honest give a more satisfactory answer to local taxpayers than we've had so far. The West Midlands, which is the mayoral strategic authority, I mean the NAO was given powers when the Audit Commission was abolished but only as a way of looking at thematic areas of expenditure across the system, not to scrutinize individual authorities.

That's specifically excluded, which is why the NAO couldn't go into Tees Valley when there was a big clamor for that, if you remember, a few years ago. We had, we couldn't do that under our existing powers. It would have to be a special measure to make that possible. So, we've listed what we think the powers will need to be for the NAO as well as the LAO to put in place that effective joined-up framework of audit that I was describing earlier on. And as part of that is us having clearer access powers to individual strategic authorities.

I don't think it needs to be for councils specifically because I think the LAO must be the body to do that. But if we're going to do the kind of comparative analysis I was describing for PAC on how well a transport service is being delivered with through devolved systems, what's the value for money evidence there? We need clear access powers to be able to produce a report like that that we don't, they're not clear enough at the moment. And we've suggested that to the team in MHCLG that's looking at the requirements of the devolution framework.

33:06 - 33:09

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

There's a lot we could discuss on that, but it's a very big subject.

33:09 - 33:12

Speaker 9

Yes, of course. It's complementary of yours, of your prerogative.

33:12 - 33:28

Clive Efford

Just on accountability, you're accountable to Parliament through us for the role that you play. But where would the LAO fit in? Where will be the democratic oversight of the LAO? Do you have an understanding of that?

33:28 - 33:45

Speaker 6

Yes, constitutionally it's an arms-length body of MHCLG. So it's a ministerial body in that sense, so accountable to the Secretary of State for that department who appoints the board, agrees the budget and so on.

33:45 - 33:51

Speaker 11

Will there be a mechanism of public accountability like we have here?

33:51 - 34:27

Speaker 6

I mean, clearly the Public Accounts Committee will be able to take evidence from the senior people at the Local Audit Office. In fact, I think you have a session on whole of government accounts in December where the plan is for Bill Butler to be a witness at that session. So there's that route into parliamentary accountability. But it kind of illustrates the point that it's a government body, not independent of government in the way the NAO is. And that's why Parliament is going to have to be satisfied that the whole system provides adequate assurance from central decision to local implementation.

34:27 - 34:29

Speaker 10

Did you wish me to go on?

34:29 - 34:52

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Yeah, I do. Question four. Financial impact. And I'm not fussed whether you, C and AG, answer it, or Rebecca, or even Fiona.

I'm just not fussed. But I'll ask the question, you decide who's going to answer. Your financial impact has fallen from fifty-three pounds per pound spent to twenty-four pounds per pound spent. What caused the lower result this year?

34:52 - 36:52

Speaker 6

Fair question. They are the two highest figures in the NAO's history, just to put it in context. So had they been the other way around, of course, that would have been an easier story to tell. But it kind of makes a point, though, that these are lumpy, almost by design.

The way that this works is where we've got evidence that our work has either accelerated a decision or actually created the drive for a new approach that's saved money, then we measure from the first year that that takes effect. So this is quite a lagging indicator because we need to actually see that happening before we put it in this list of impacts. And so in the first year, maybe there are two years to catch up on from the beginning of that impact, and so there'd be quite a lumpy impact in the first year. And then in some cases, there's an annual run-on until that finishes. Sometimes these are genuine one-offs and they just feature in one year.

So that gives you a lumpy profile is my point. And you wouldn't expect this to be a smooth measure every year. We increased our target from ten to one to fifteen to one because our new strategy is predicated on making a bigger impact. So we thought that was putting our money where our mouth was. And that's it's also been helpful in concentrating the minds of our teams doing the planning of the work.

So it's not the only factor when we plan our work. Clearly PAC's interest is a huge factor. The other reasons why we might want to give wide coverage to government spending. But really important that where our work has genuinely, together with PAC's impact obviously, has genuinely created pressure for improvement, that we do try and measure the scale of that. So the Parliament's got an accurate picture of what difference is all this making.

Because the NAO costs taxpayers, so it's right that they have a measure of the difference that it makes.

36:52 - 37:04

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

You anticipated my next question, which was this increase from 10 to 15 pounds. So the follow-on question from that is, is 15 pounds still adequate or could you be increasing that?

37:04 - 38:03

Speaker 6

Yeah, we do, we ask ourselves this frequently, and the board challenges us on the same question. What I suppose the care we're taking here is that, first of all, that's quite a substantial increase in, in the target, and we wanted to give that a bit of time to see what difference it made. I don't want to make, I don't want to get into the territory of perverse incentives here too, because obviously great to do work that saves taxpayers money, but Parliament needs assurance on lots of other things as well, sometimes systemic areas of improvement like digital transformation, the kind of issues that PAC was discussing yesterday on digital ID. These are, these are the kind of levers that are going to change value for money on a huge scale across every department, and it can be harder to pin down individual savings when we're doing that thematic work.

So I don't want to drive out that work because people are chasing a cash figure with every study. So it's getting the balance right, I think, is, and obviously PAC's view on that is very influential as well.

38:03 - 38:45

Fiona Reynolds

Yeah, I'd just add that the board did think about this very carefully because it is important for us to be able to show improved financial impacts, but we are also just as keen, as you know, to show impacts on other areas of public policy to deliver value for money. And so creating a mixed portfolio where we can track impact across different kinds of outcomes is really important to us. So I'm sure the board in future will keep as close an eye on it as we've been doing. In fact, we do have a member of the board sit on a panel which once a year looks at the whole value for money in terms of financial impact achievement. So we're staying close to it, but it's not the only thing we're trying to do.

38:45 - 39:09

Speaker 15

Thank you very much, Chair. All I was going to suggest is, as a former maths teacher, have you considered doing it with moving average? Because you'd avoid the peaks and the troughs. Because I take what you said, I'm looking at the graph there. Yeah, if you say you've gone from 53 to 24, it doesn't look very good, but you're right in saying that before that it was 17.

So actually, across the five-year, six-year period we're looking at, overall, a moving average would give you that, which would probably be a bit more reasonable.

39:09 - 39:14

Speaker 13

We have discussed doing exactly that, actually, so I think we should take that away. Yeah.

39:14 - 39:15

Okay, Josh.

39:15 - 39:55

John Glen

Yes, can we turn now to staff numbers? You've got 73 more members of staff in this year.

And if we look back over the last five years, you go from 882 to 1,101, which is a fraction under 25% increase. Now, obviously, your body of work that you have to evaluate has increased, I imagine you'd say that. But also there are new trends in terms of tools, AI and so on. Could you explain that figure and explain when we might see it level off or potentially be reduced?

39:55 - 41:55

Speaker 6

Yeah, sure. I mean, I'll start and Rebecca will come in. I think, as you say, quite a few things going on over that longer period. Increase in the number of audits and the increase in the complexity of those audits as well. The balance sheets of government departments are significantly more complex, particularly post-pandemic, but also lots of other financial instruments have been creeping into government over that time.

Auditing standards have been driven up across the profession for the big firms and for us, and we're subject to the same inspection regime, as you know, as the big four. And we've worked really hard to ensure that our quality is at least on a par with theirs. So all of that has required that kind of investment in audit resource. On the question of what's the direction for that, the Commission approved our estimate for the current financial year back in April this year. And those of you who were there for that will remember that our bid for the current year was essentially flat, in small real terms reduction actually.

So that's had an impact.

So the recent growth that you've pointed to has leveled off already in this current year. We're forecasting a similar picture for next year, partly because we're now generating some of the investment we need through productivity improvements driven by the investments in our audit technology that you mentioned. So we're in the kind of foothills of applying AI tools in our financial audit work and our value for money work. We're already seeing some productivity benefit from that, but you'll remember when we discussed the estimate we've got a three-year program for delivering more through there. And so that means I think we've as I say we've already leveled off for that reason.

Of course the big firms are investing billions in AI.

41:55 - 41:57

Speaker 16

You're probably not able to.

41:57 - 42:26

Speaker 6

We will never be able to do that.

But the investment we've made so far won't cut it on their own, I suppose that's the point. So we are, whilst we're seeing some early benefits from the investments we've made, there's much more to come on modernizing our audit in line with practice in the rest of the private sector. So this is an ongoing issue and we're going to come back with our estimates in the early part of 2027 to explain how we're taking that forward as well.

42:26 - 42:53

John Glen

Do you think, just if I could just pursue that a little bit further, if you were in an optimal situation where you could bring forward investment into year one and two more, do you think you would do that to secure better outcomes further down the period? I mean, is the sort of accounting profile you have to work with inhibiting optimal investment?

42:52 - 43:58

Speaker 6

To some extent, but only to some extent, because money is only one of the capacities that we're dealing with here. There's the change capacity of the organisation itself. I mean, I'd just pay credit to our staff. I mean, across the board, they've absorbed methodology change, technology change, real performance improvement pressure, quality improvements, and they've done a great job in responding to that. And it's involved working differently for all of us, right right through the organisation.

That's a great question.

AI means there's more of that to come. We've just rolled out Copilot to the entire organisation. Everyone's been trained. We're now implementing that. We've got more specific audit tools coming through.

So I think we're trying to judge how quickly the organisation can absorb that change and produce high-quality work in the meantime. So I think to some extent is the answer, but I wouldn't like to kind of try and spend a very large amount of money in one year and be able to demonstrate value for money as a result. But Rebecca, you might want to add.

43:58 - 44:34

Rebecca Sheeran

I think perhaps just to reinforce that point, actually some of that head count growth that you cited in the last year, a small amount of that actually was to build up some of our digital capability to deliver our digital strategy and to also ensure that we were investing proportionately in cyber security, information security, something the committee has asked us about in the past. And we have earlier this month had our first Chief Digital and Information Officer join us to help augment those skills so that we can pursue the opportunities that as Gareth says are increasingly available to us.

44:34 - 44:55

John Glen

And this year you've had 19 members of staff leave, an average exit package of 57,000. Previous year it was eight on an average 30,000. Now that might just be more senior people letting go. Is that what's happened and I mean do you consider that sort of how do you look at it from a value for money point of view?

44:55 - 45:26

Rebecca Sheeran

So this year for the first time in a number of years we actually ran a voluntary exit scheme where there were 17 exit packages agreed. This was very much as we were coming to the end of our first year of delivery of our new strategy to make sure that we've got the skills mix that we need to deliver that strategy and also to help us manage our overall cost base. We hadn't run a scheme of that nature for some time so the numbers in previous years were more sort of ad hoc agreements relating to unique circumstances.

45:26 - 45:28

Speaker 17

The payback on that is less than a year.

45:28 - 45:30

Speaker 18

Yes.

45:30 - 45:54

John Glen

And then on the staff turnover, you were below target this year as you were last year. Would you like to explain to us what's going on there? I think you told us last year that too low staff turnover could create budgetary pressures and blockages preventing promotion opportunities obviously. Please address that.

45:54 - 46:23

Speaker 6

Yeah, that's a continuing situation actually. So it's a better problem to have than the opposite.

You know, and that within a few years ago, we did have the opposite as the private sector was gearing up coming out of the pandemic. But it is a problem though for us that if turnover is too far below our assumptions, exactly the reasons you say, that opportunities come up too slowly and that just creates kind of a build-up of frustration.

46:23 - 46:42

John Glen

Also could, Gareth, excuse me, paint a picture of an organisation where people are settled in a role, they're going through the motions, but they're not being challenged, but they don't aspire to the same sort of up-and-out culture elsewhere. And therefore, how do you sort of ensure that doesn't happen and you maintain high performance levels?

46:42 - 47:03

Speaker 6

Well, partly through the scheme that Rebecca described, partly through performance management. So we have a big focus on high-quality performance management. And so, I mean, obviously a voluntary exit scheme is one thing, day-to-day good management of performance to make sure that we're getting what we need out of all of our colleagues is another. Learning and development is the third leg.

47:03 - 47:06

John Glen

Would you evidence that to us about that being effective?

47:06 - 48:12

Speaker 6

Well, because we have a case load of active performance management cases at any one time. And it's not appropriate in this setting, but if you're interested in more detail, we can provide that out of the public. But we take that really seriously. We have changed our performance management arrangements so that we've got clearer allocation of management responsibility and that's coming through this year. And a lot of training for people to make sure they're good at handling difficult cases.

And our HR team has done a great job in modernising our processes around that and making sure that we're not in the position you described. You know, I think the the results of our work shows that we're not a coasting organisation. We're improving in all of our core areas and I think we're making a really big impact and that's that's down to the performance of all of the individuals in the organisation. So the evidence suggests we're making a good job of that, but but you're right, it's it's more difficult where we don't have healthy levels of natural turnover and we're we're always looking at how we manage that.

48:12 - 49:02

Fiona Reynolds

I'd just like to add the impact of the strategy around impact has also been huge in terms of a culture change in the organisation because every single member of staff is now really aware that their job is not just to produce a piece of work or to complete an audit or to do a value for money study or play a part in a study, but actually to themselves promote a more impactful outcomes.

And I've seen in the last two or three years a huge amount of energy unleashed internally with staff feeling incredibly motivated by this much stronger focus on impact, which plays into the HR processes and performance management and all the rest of it. But it is a sense of people working really hard and in a really focused way to deliver impacts and outcomes that are more stretching, actually, than simply doing a job.

49:02 - 49:05

Speaker 19

Thank you very much, John.

49:05 - 49:35

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Yes, thank you. Can I just follow up John's questions? AI efficiency can sometimes be a euphemism for shedding staff, particularly at the lower levels. But on the other hand, you might need less staff at the lower levels, planning the audit or whatever it happens to be, but you're going to need at least as many and possibly more at the higher levels. Is that actually what's happening in your organisation?

49:35 - 50:15

Speaker 6

Very slight impact on our entry-level recruitment, but not significant. And we're in conversation with the big firms, obviously in the same sort of business as we are, and it's very interesting to hear their reflections on the same question. What they're saying is we're actually not backing away from graduate recruitment and school-leaver recruitment. We think those people will be doing different things in the future, and we are emphasising digital skills from the outset, not just accountancy training. And so it's changing the way in which people are trained and their early career experience will be different.

50:16 - 50:58

Speaker 6

You know, in my day, I remember standing by the photocopier thinking, "Why did I do all that studying at university to stand by the photocopier?" That kind of work is now disappearing from audits, and so junior staff are getting earlier engagement with some of the more judgmental bits of the work. Because one of the big questions all professions, I think, are grappling with: how do we make sure people get first-hand experience of the nuts and bolts of this job so that they can make good judgments when they become managers? And that just means a different way of training them and giving them early work experience. But in numbers terms, actually, we're continuing with 55 graduate recruits this year, similar to last year.

50:58 - 51:01

Speaker 20

It's not, it's not affected that number yet.

51:01 - 51:12

Speaker 15

Thank you, Chair. Thank you. Despite significant investment in technology and obviously, as we've said, higher staff numbers, you've again failed to hit your target of certifying 70% of audits before the summer recess.

Do you want to comment on why?

51:12 - 53:14

Speaker 6

In summer 25 we did, which is the period covered by this report.

Right.

And that was a step up from the previous year, but we hit some barriers in that summer to hit the target. We redoubled our efforts, and of course since we published this annual report and accounts, we've had the summer recess for 26. And so pleased to say that we actually did achieve 70% this year. So this long haul back to a timely set of accounts from the disruption caused by the pandemic, we're getting close to where we want to be now. And not just 70% by this summer, we're also expecting to have more than 90% finished by the end of this month.

Big step forward from previous years.

Our target for next year will be 70% by the summer and 100% by the end of October. And to me, that's got the accountability framework for accounts into the right position for central government. And you know, I'll be very pleased if we're in that position this time next year. So again, I just wanted to pay tribute to the staff who delivered that. That's a lot of really complex work all by the summer recess, less than four months after the year-end that these accounts relate to.

That's a real achievement. And there were departments that were pre-recess for the first time in several years: DEFRA, DESNZ, and MOD recovered from the severe problems it had the previous year linked to the Afghan resettlement scheme and missing provisions and so on. And MOD was on time and unqualified this year, which was a significant achievement for that department. So some really, you know, this really matters.

We're talking about a lot of public money being properly accounted for on time. Apart from everything else, it frees up the finance teams in those organizations to do what they should be doing, which is adding value to the financial planning of that department, not still completing the accounts months and months after the year end. So all ways round, that's real progress, I think.

53:14 - 53:22

Speaker 15

Thank you. So you said you're your target for 90% at the end of October, so not complete. When are you hoping to be having all those 2025-26 audits complete?

53:22 - 54:06

Speaker 6

Well, soon after the end of October, but the the purpose of setting this kind of firm deadline of the end of October for everything, which will be next year's target, that that's a deliberate message to the small number that have drifted on towards the end of the calendar year, because often in most in some cases they've got used to a particular rhythm and in a small organization that takes some resource to shift.

So we're working with them now to say, okay, well, this is now the expectation. Treasury's taking the same line as well. And what does that mean for every organisation moving its audit committee dates, releasing some resource to get this thing done in a more timely way? So, yeah, I'll be very pleased if we hit those deadlines for next summer.

54:06 - 54:33

Speaker 15

Great, thank you. So, positive is 83% of your value for money reports met internal standards, which is significantly higher than obviously that 70% target and higher than corresponding scores for financial audits as we've sort of discussed.

So why do you think it is then, and it says on my sheet MPs and senior officials, not necessarily this MP by the way, routinely scores your quality of value for money work in general lower than financial audits?

54:33 - 55:44

Speaker 6

Yeah, obviously we're asking those questions, we're asking MPs as a whole, not just the ones who engage with our work directly through PAC and other committees. The actually the numbers aren't bad, you know, it's not as if they're poor. They're of course what they what they mean by quality is very different to the technical assessments of quality that we're measuring through the rest of our processes. So these are different angles on the quality question, all of them valid of course, and that's why we have them all in here as performance indicators. So we want to drive that up for MPs as a whole.

We're trying to increase awareness of our work. We have a fortnightly newsletter to MPs which is increasingly well used actually, and... but we're also targeting researchers and MPs' offices because we know, we know how busy MPs are, how difficult it is to get through the inbox of a typical MP inbox. And so we're working hard with the staff side as well to make sure that they pick things out and say, "Well, actually, this one is worth highlighting through the rest of the spam that they're otherwise engaging with." So, it's a... it's a constant challenge. You know, we use this to challenge ourselves and say, "How can we drive these numbers up and get better results?"

55:44 - 56:07

Speaker 15

Yeah, no, thank you. So you don't feel, as suggested, that value-for-money quality standards are lower compared to financial audit, it's just the perception? Yeah, that's fine. My last question then: the proportion of your expenditure on financial audits has increased compared to last year, meaning proportionally less is now spent on value-for-money work.

Is there a risk of financial audit work becoming too much of a focus?

56:07 - 57:04

Rebecca Sheeran

I think it's important to bear in mind there some of the things that Gareth was speaking about earlier about the way in which our financial audit portfolio as a whole has grown over a number of years. And that is really the driver of the increase in the headcount and the increase in the expenditure there. To put some numbers around that, back in 2017-2018, we certified 370 accounts. In the year that we're looking at now, that's 413. We see within that there's quite a variation, some of those are quite significant endeavors.

So it's not that the expenditure on value for money has gone down, it's that it's the proportions. But we are really keen to make sure that we're continue to invest in our value for money work. And in the current year that we're in, we've particularly put some resources aside to modernize our reporting and how it looks on our website, for example, as an example of that continued investment.

57:04 - 57:26

Sarah Olney

Thank you, Chair, and apologies for my late arrival.

So, risk reporting. You've changed the number of principal risks that you report against this year, previously 24, now 9. And obviously this is to align with the strategy. But does that mean that there's a lower level of detail in your risk management processes?

57:26 - 58:16

Rebecca Sheeran

It certainly doesn't mean that there's a lower level of of detail in our overall risk management processes. What it does mean is the way in which we're looking at risk is a bit more focused at the executive team and at the board level.

So as well as making sure that our risk framework aligned with our strategy, we also did a refresh of our framework to make sure we were in line with best practice and adopted a framework whereby we categorize the principal risks, those that we think have the greatest impact on our strategic performance, our reputation, for example. And underneath that there are a series of component risks, broadly the same number that we had before, that feed into that. And that's supported by a kind of rigorous bottom-up risk assessment process with business owners throughout the business so that we are looking at a comprehensive picture at the executive team.

58:16 - 58:32

Sarah Olney

Thank you. And this year you've rated the risks of poor service delivery and of a failure to deliver impact as areas of concern above the target level in your risk rating. Why is that?

58:32 - 59:38

Rebecca Sheeran

So I think in terms of impact, this was partly a response to the strategy and the fact that we've upped our ambition in terms of the impact that we're looking to achieve and specifically the ambitions that we have set to positively influence productivity, resilience and financial management in government. And we don't want to be complacent. So we have been using that to challenge ourselves and the board have very much been challenging: are we doing as much as that strategy indicates that we should be doing there? And in response to that, we have a new parliamentary engagement plan, we've refreshed our communications roadmap, but we also think very deeply, as Gareth said earlier, about the impact that we are looking to achieve at the point at which we're commissioning our VFM programs of work, for example.

In terms of service delivery, this connects back principally to making sure that we are achieving those ambitions that Gareth has already spoken about in terms of improving the timeliness of, in particular, our financial audit work to make sure, as we have done this year, we've met the 70% pre-recess, but continued focus in coming years.

59:38 - 59:53

Sarah Olney

So you're expecting to see the your your risk analysis of your failure to deliver impact, you're expecting to see that improve as your new kind of approach to engaging MPs getting to our inboxes.

59:53 - 01:00:01

Rebecca Sheeran

Indeed, and the poor service delivery one has already improved, actually, and we should be reporting an improved position in next year's annual report and accounts.

01:00:01 - 01:00:19

Sarah Olney

Fantastic. And in last year's report, you were highlighting sickness absence, mental health, and well-being as being principal risks to the National Audit Office, but it's not featuring this year, or they're not featuring this year as principal risks of concern. What's changed?

01:00:19 - 01:00:55

Rebecca Sheeran

Partly they are risks that would now sit as component risks that would feed into PR2, failure to maintain an open, inclusive culture that supports engaged, motivated, and high-performing staff. But we have, I mean, it's all of the things that Gareth has spoken about in terms of focus on performance management, our well-being strategy. Our sickness absence has continued to fall almost month on month. We're now down at, I think it's about 5.2 days per FTE, which is a very strong position and again, an indication of an organization that is thriving rather than one that is perhaps stagnant.

01:00:55 - 01:00:58

Speaker 22

Thank you. Thank you, Chair.

01:00:58 - 01:01:53

Clive Efford

Before we finish, Gareth, a number of people have approached me about the future accountability of governments for inquiries and the recommendations of those inquiries. I know you may have had a number of conversations with people.

I'll declare my interest that I'm the chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group on haemophilia and infected blood. And so duty of candour and the accountability for for Sir Brian Langstaff's report is is dear to my heart. So, um, the suggestion has been that the National Audit Office is the is the place where this should sit and that that that should hold the ring on holding the government to account for how it responds to inquiry recommendations. Do you have any advice or a view on on that debate?

01:01:53 - 01:04:31

Speaker 6

As you say, we've been approached by government on exactly that point. You know, the kind of strong level of dissatisfaction in Parliament, I think, about the rigor with which public inquiry recommendations are followed up and whether they've been implemented in the way that was intended from when the recommendations were made. Too many inquiries, and the most recent one is the Thirlwall Inquiry into the Lucy Letby case from that appalling set of circumstances up in Cheshire. And the judge in that case made a specific recommendation that the NAO should be following up NHS-related inquiries because they were so concerned that previous recommendations hadn't been implemented at that trust in question and could have helped prevent the terrible events there.

So I completely understand the seriousness of the issue and the kind of public interest in improving the position. The point I've made to government is that it needs to be really carefully thought through here because the NAO cannot become part of government's own system for managing these risks. We can stand outside that system and audit it as we do with other areas of public expenditure. And so getting the design of this right is absolutely crucial that at the moment I don't think government has a reliable system for monitoring the implementation of public inquiry recommendations. And that is the problem that needs to be fixed first.

Then a question about can the NAO provide assurance to Parliament on whether that system is working effectively is a legitimate question and you know obviously prepared to engage on that.

We have a really strong sense that we mustn't allow our mission to creep. And we must absolutely hold on to our mission to support Parliament in scrutinising public expenditure. That's what the NAO is for. You can make a case that this is a legitimate extension of that, but it needs to be really carefully grounded in that governance structure that I've mentioned so that we're not being drawn into something we should be independent of. And of course you can be so pure that you're ineffective, so I'm aware of that risk as well.

But these are the issues that we've suggested that we work through with government before they're taken any further.

Clearly Parliament's view on this, because being clear where the parliamentary audience for that question, I think that's crucial, because otherwise we can't deliver our mission in supporting Parliament and helping make government more accountable.

01:04:31 - 01:04:48

Clive Efford

Yeah, it strikes me that if you look at the recommendations of these inquiries, they're not just about the financial trail or value for money. They're things that go beyond that, which is not the responsibility of the National Audit Office.

01:04:48 - 01:05:44

Speaker 6

Particularly if they're issues of clinical practice, for example, which are more a specialist inspectorate than it is the NAO. But it kind of makes the point that if the question is, can the government department responsible evidence that these recommendations have been satisfactorily implemented, then the evidence base for that would be the reports of inspectorates to say, yes, we're satisfied that clinical practice has changed in the way intended, here's the evidence.

That's why, but we can, we will be reporting one layer up from that, which is, does government have the evidence to show that these recommendations have been satisfactorily implemented? And that's at the moment I haven't seen that that framework is in place to deliver that evidence base. Because you can see in that case, then that would be something the NAO could, could add value to. But what we can't do is go in and sub, and give a properly informed judgment on whether clinical practice has changed in every NHS trust in the country.

01:05:44 - 01:05:45

John, you want to come in?

01:05:45 - 01:06:49

John Glen

Yes, I mean, just on the Infected Blood Compensation Authority, I declare an interest because I was the minister responsible for passing the legislation for it being set up.

Indeed, it was set up remote from any department of government at the insistence and request of many of the victims. However, the point that the Chair makes is a reasonable one, in that if you've legislated with the expectation of certain outcomes, and then because it's so independent of the Department of Health or the Cabinet Office or whatever, we are then two years later in a situation where as parliamentarians we can't apparently achieve any accountability. And I think what you're saying is that it's quite delicate and difficult for you to insert yourself into that audit process if they are an entity that is sort of remote from one department and just dependent on legislation. Is that correct?

01:06:49 - 01:08:04

Speaker 6

Not quite, because first of all we are the auditor of the Infected Blood Compensation Authority, and we qualified their accounts in the first year because the estimate of the liability was patchy. That's improved significantly for this summer, and so they're in a much better position this summer.

So financial audit is clear. Actually we did report on their performance in implementing their responsibilities for paying compensation as part of the report that the Public Accounts Committee took as a basis for two separate evidence sessions earlier this year, really successful week I think for the Public Accounts Committee. And that session had witnesses from the IBCA itself, from the Post Office, and from the military veterans scheme and the Windrush scheme. So we had four schemes accountable to Parliament for their performance in paying compensation. And that session was informed by a session with representatives of the victims in each case beforehand as well.

So the existing framework can cope with holding public bodies to account, including independent public bodies of that kind. This question is more the technical question of the public inquiry that gave rise to that, have its recommendations all been satisfactorily met?

01:08:04 - 01:08:27

John Glen

Isn't that a matter for the government of the day to respond to the report and discern what they think is the appropriate response to an inquiry? So how could you possibly be holding to account, because in a sense the government's judgment, you might dispute it, whichever the government is, but you're there to audit what they've said they will do with the report.

01:08:27 - 01:08:42

Speaker 6

Well, I think that's the proposal would be that we wouldn't get involved in how the government should respond to an inquiry. It would be to take the agreed action plan once government had responded and say, has government done what it said it would do?

01:08:42 - 01:09:12

Fiona Reynolds

Yes, exactly.

We are going to be discussing this later this year, so actually this is a really helpful input. But we're talking as much as anything, I think, about a sort of third line of defense, so that we're not actually involved in the mechanics of the rights and wrongs of particular recommendations, but the fact as to whether those recommendations have been implemented. So if we were to consider this the right thing to do, I think we'd be extremely careful about the terms and the conditions, as it were, of any engagement. But we do think it's something important for us to consider.

01:09:12 - 01:09:38

John Glen

In something like that, there was an iterative process through statutory instruments after conversations with the victims over changing the parameters of the scheme to reflect different needs of different cohorts of victims.

So to have a coherent single point of reference to audit would be quite challenging until the scheme is fully embedded, which has only happened relatively recently, I think.

01:09:38 - 01:09:56

Speaker 6

It is. And I mean, I do understand the impetus behind this, which is it's very frustrating to see public inquiry recommendations that could have headed off subsequent problems and weren't implemented. I can understand the frustration. But as this discussion has illustrated the complexity of it.

01:09:56 - 01:10:52

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

The C and AG was kind enough to mention the PAC inquiry into this matter. I think that from all of the four groups we actually had in front of us and a lot of the other witnesses, the feeling was very much that the government department that had caused the injury in the first place should not be setting up a scheme to compensate the victims.

And therefore, without, I mean, just from the hearing, we haven't issued or we haven't had a response from the government yet, was that there should be some form of independent standing body there so that when the next scandal comes along, and you've mentioned one that has come along, H&G, it's there to draw on all the experience of the previous schemes that went wrong and try and produce some common standards across new schemes, you know, trying to resolve the thing as quickly and as litigious-free as possible so that victims can get their compensation quickly and fairly.

01:10:52 - 01:11:53

Clive Efford

Yeah, it's just not, it's not just about compensation, it is about justice, which encompasses a whole wider range of things as well, but compensation is at the heart of it.

And that's absolutely right, that's my understanding of where we need to get to, because what happens is that the government accepts recommendations of inquiries, but no one holds them to account as to whether they do anything about that, and on how they're followed through and how they're implemented. And there is, there needs to be an independent body that sort of stands equivalent to a body like the NAO, that has that responsibility and can hold government to account. So they literally pick up responsibility for the inquiries' recommendations being taken forwards independent of government, is where I think we need to go. I know others disagree and think that that should be the select committees. I'm not convinced that they have that sort of, that they have the resources to be able to do that.

01:11:53 - 01:11:55

Speaker 23

But anyhow, thank you.

01:11:55 - 01:12:22

Geoffrey Robert Clifton-Brown

Sir Chair, I mean, it would be quite possible once the standing committee had established the terms of an inquiry and the government had accepted those terms, because government's always got to accept it because they're going to have to pay in the end. That I mean, I don't want to put work in your way, Gareth, but you could, I mean, these are only going to be fairly large matters because a small matter the government will deal with in another way. You could then become the auditor of that particular scheme.

01:12:22 - 01:13:05

Speaker 6

Which we have. So all the compensation schemes do get audited by us. So that that's definitely covered. It's more the it's more the situation of and I think I think this discussion shows this is a question for government really. How does government demonstrate that it has a grip on the public inquiry recommendations that it has agreed to implement?

And how is it accountable to Parliament for doing that?

And so, we could help with the debate because we've got some practical experience. But in the end, this is a matter for Parliament and government, I think, to... As to come to a view on how do we make sure that we have better accountability than we currently do for acting on these recommendations.

01:13:05 - 01:13:17

John Glen

The issue in this particular one is how do you be accountable for delivery of something that you were asked to hand off to an independent entity?

01:13:17 - 01:14:12

Clive Efford

Well, as chair of the APPG, I might question just how independent IPCA is, but given some of the things that are in the path of, you know, dealing with some of the claims that are currently waiting to be finalized. So, that rabbit hole we won't go down right now. But anyhow, thank you for your answers on that.

I think this is going to be a debate that's going to be very important going forward. So I appreciate you giving your time to answer those questions for us at the end of this meeting. But before we do conclude, Dame Fiona, this is your last annual report and accounts session with the Commission as Chair of the NAO Board. Looking back on your six years as Chair, how do you think the relationship between the NAO and Parliament has evolved?

01:14:12 - 01:20:39

Fiona Reynolds

Thank you for the opportunity to speak briefly.

Well, it has been six fascinating and indeed quite tumultuous years because I came in when COVID was in full spate. We've seen the Brexit settlements since then. We've seen actually a huge churn in both Prime Ministers and in Permanent Secretaries with whom we deal regularly and indeed, you know, global uncertainties which really affect how people feel about public expenditure. But I believe through that period we've built an ever stronger, ever more purposeful and ever more effective NAO. And I'm really proud of that.

And perhaps I'm particularly proud of our strategy. When I came in it was very clear that the role of Chair here is unusual, is very strategic in focus, but fortunately I love strategy, so that suited me very well. But actually the strategy which we are discussing the first year of here today is very different. It's, we call it Trust, Value, Impact.

And it is about using every ounce of our energy not only to audit and to do series of studies on government expenditure, but actually to help the government do a better job. And I think we've demonstrated in many ways how that has both liberated the organization's potential, but actually has also beginning to lead, and we are being deliberately modest about what we've done so far in setting ambitious objectives, but to our two strategic outcomes of greater productivity and resilience in public services and improved financial management in government, both of which I think are absolutely critical to our role. So just briefly on on audit, I think we've seen real improvements in quality, which you have each year challenged and tested us on through wise investment in both people and technology and and in culture change.

We're never going to be complacent about audit quality, but we are increasingly confident that we can hold to that level of sustained quality. There's been for me a really interesting creative shift between audit as a compliance tool, where you simply have to do it, to using audit as a way of improving insight and analysis of where the money goes in order to do a better job. And I think that's a really interesting development, and there's more to go. And actually, the bringing in the TOCs, the train operating companies, is a really good example of that. We're not just auditing them, we are drawing insights and learning across different companies in order to demonstrate how they could collectively be more effective and do a better job.

And of course, we've talked today about the local audit office and improving audit at the local level, which has been an absolutely shaming gap in recent years. And now, at last, it will take time, but we can see real improvements.

On value for money, we have had similar really heart-searching discussions about making best use of our capabilities in those areas. I think there's been an ever more strategic approach to the value for money studies we do. We're obviously very keen to ensure that the Public Accounts Committee has the reports that it needs and values from us. But I think what's been exciting is to see the development of more cross-government studies and whole-system approaches.

I was particularly taken by the asylum report, which I think is a model for future systems that cross departmental boundaries and are quite difficult for government to track, but we can really be helpful in that respect. And our new studies, which we're just beginning to do, of particular initiatives of government departments, for example, the one on Ministry of Justice use of AI to ensure that the records that need to be produced in court are both present and correct, is a wonderfully example of a very helpful tool, which I think will really benefit departments. So I think in all of those areas, we've made real progress. And of course, there's now this new approach to the scrutiny of sensitive defense expenditure, which I think is a major step forward. So you asked me to speak about challenges for the future, and since we've already discussed them today, I can be very brief on those.

One is clearly AI, where we are both determined, both internally and in our audit of government departments and value-for-money studies, to watch both the potential of AI but also the need for clear guardrails. I'm not saying anything original or new there, but it's both a vital tool, one that is completely with us and impossible to ignore, but also has to be carefully managed and carefully observed. Second, devolution, and we did speak at some length about this this afternoon, is huge potentially. And I think we can play a very helpful role both in terms of the devolution framework, but also our work with the local audit office. Devolution won't work unless we can assess whether it is working.

There will be huge questions about postcode lotteries and different outcomes in different parts of the country, but actually, I think we are well placed to support the local audit office as well as doing our own work to ensure that the parliamentary accountability is clear and well judged. And finally, I suppose a personal plea from me is that I hope we are entering a slightly more stable period, simply because some of the issues that we know are really important, long-term issues, have been squeezed out by short-term crises. And so the opportunity, I think, to use our expertise and our very good and strong strategy to move forward on important issues, whether it's climate change, food security, public health, there are so many areas, but taking a longer-term view, social care is another, I think is going to be really important. So that's my tuppence worth as I approach the end of a job that I've really enjoyed.

I'm hugely grateful both to my board, but to Gareth and the executive team, and in fact to all the staff at the NAO. They're an amazing bunch of very committed, very bright, very dedicated people, and I think we're extremely lucky to have them working so hard to ensure that Parliament has the assurances that it needs. Thank you.

01:20:39 - 01:20:57

Clive Efford

Thank you. I think you're with us on one more occasion where we'll say a fond farewell and thank you for everything you've done. But certainly, as you've just set out, the NAO has moved forwards considerably under your chairpersonship.

01:20:57 - 01:21:00

Fiona Reynolds

It's a collective, it's been a collective progress, but thank you.

01:21:00 - 01:21:12

Clive Efford

I'm sure it is, yeah, but thank you for what you've done and it's been a pleasure to have worked with you. So that concludes today's evidence session. So thank you all very much for coming along this afternoon. Order, order.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.