Fifth Delegated Legislation Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Live capture
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Fifth Delegated Legislation Committee Actual start House of Commons
Follow its sittingsMatthew Pennycook
I can come to address that more fully in my closing remarks, but we do expect the fees to be ring-fenced. And he may recall we took powers in the Planning and Infrastructure Act to ensure that is the case, but I'll come on to say that in a bit more detail in my closing remarks. They will establish that baseline, Sir John, by providing for a national default fee that will continue to apply unless a local planning authority chooses to set a different fee to reflect its costs. Earlier this year, we carried out a consultation on fees for planning applications, seeking views on a proposed national default fee schedule, including the appropriate level of fees, whether structural changes should be made to specific fee categories, and the wider framework for local fee setting. The feedback received indicated broad support across the sector for increasing fees, provided that the additional income is reinvested in planning application services and results in improved performance.
The Government is clear that additional funding should support measurable improvements in performance.
We expect authorities to use this additional income to strengthen their planning application services, reduce delays and provide a better service for applicants, and we will of course continue to monitor performance through planning statistics and the existing planning performance regime. In general terms, Sir John, planning application fees typically account for less than 1% of overall development costs, while delays and uncertainty in the planning process can impose far greater costs on development and investment. Ensuring that planning authorities are properly resourced is therefore in the interests of applicants, communities and the wider economy. However, it is of course important any changes to planning fees strike the right balance, ensuring authorities can recover their costs while remaining proportionate for applicants and supporting continued investment and development. Having considered the consultation responses carefully, we think the revised schedule does just that.
Let me just briefly set out the main changes made by these regulations.
First, the regulations introduce a revised set of national fees, which we refer to as a national fees schedule. Fees will increase by varying amounts across existing application categories, with the aim of recovering approximately 90% of the estimated processing cost for each application type. These increases are informed by benchmarking work undertaken by the Local Government Association and Planning Advisory Service, which showed that every application category currently operates below cost recovery. Increasing all fees to approximately 90% of estimated costs will provide a significant and immediate increase in funding for planning application services. We are not, Sir John, moving to full cost recovery through a nationally set fee schedule because the cost of processing applications varies significantly between authorities.
A uniform national fee set at 100% of estimated average costs could therefore lead to over-recovery in some areas.
Second, the regulations simplify and restructure selected fee categories. This includes aligning the household fee thresholds with the medium-sized development category introduced through the NPPF and simplifying the fee bands applying to certain agricultural, minerals, waste and other operational development. These changes will make the national fee schedule clearer and easier for applicants and local planning authorities to operate. Third, the regulations introduce a standard fee of £310 for prior approval applications that currently attract no fee. Prior approval applications require local planning authorities to devote time and resources to their assessment, so it's right that applicants contribute towards those costs.
As part of that third change, the regulations also enable the £310 fee to apply where prior approval is required for larger electricity substations. The separate statutory instrument introducing that prior approval requirement was laid before Parliament on the 30th of September and comes into force on the 21st of October.
Finally, the regulations correct omissions in the existing indexation provisions. This ensures that mixed-use outline application fees and the new standard prior approval fee are subject to annual inflationary increases in the same way as other planning application fees. Subject to parliamentary approval, Sir John, they will come into force on the 8th of December 2026. To conclude, these regulations will provide an immediate increase in funding for local planning authorities, support the government's wider program of planning reform, and establish a stronger baseline for the future operation of local fee-setting powers. In return, applicants should expect improved performance, more timely decisions, and greater certainty across the planning system.
A better-resourced planning system that is better able to deliver homes, infrastructure, and growth that this country needs, and I commend the regulations to the committee.
Thank you.
John Hayes
The question is that the committee has considered the draft Town and Country Planning (Fees for Applications, Deemed Applications, Requests and Site Visits) (England) (Amendment and Transitional Provision) Regulations 2026. I call Shadow Minister Gareth Bacon.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you, Sir John. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship as always, and I welcome the opportunity to sit opposite the Minister again, and I appreciate the remarks he's already made in this debate. I also welcome the opportunity on behalf of His Majesty's Opposition to address these regulations. British housebuilding is being buried, Sir John, under cumbersome and expensive regulations. Layers of protocol, regulation, and fiscal burdens are stifling housebuilding and inhibiting economic growth.
The industry needs relief, not red tape.
So I'm concerned to come here today to find the government proposing to increase planning fees and add yet another straw to the camel's already broken back. I've reminded multiple ministers of the excessive costs and regulations that developers already find themselves saddled with, and I will keep on doing this for as long as the government fails to relieve the industry. According to the Home Builders Federation, at present, housebuilders are already facing more than £7,000 in taxes and levies, including £2,000 in landfill tax, £2,320 from the forthcoming building safety levy, £2,055 in other taxes, and £985 from inflationary increases on existing charges such as Section 106 agreements.
Moreover, developers face over £23,000 per property in regulatory costs, including £7,770 for building regulations, £5,700 for biodiversity net gain and £10,200 in costs linked to the future homes standard, and that is not the end. Indeed, under this government's watch, house builders will have seen material and labour costs reach heights of £37,000 per property, alongside costs of up to £7,000 in additional potential site-specific elements like nutrient mitigation requirements. Taken together, the cumulative impact of the policy, taxation and regulatory pressures on home building means that it is so costly to build that for many companies it no longer makes economic sense to do so. This has been evidenced recently by Taylor Wimpey's decision to stop building new homes in London.
Their chief executive, Jennie Daly, attributed this decision to the fact in London, and I quote, "baseline viability is fundamentally broken, with reward for developments having just evaporated in some cases." Sir John, it is clear that the greatest barrier to unleashing a new wave of house building in England is viability, and it is even clearer that the biggest damage to viability comes from state regulation and taxes. Therefore, an effort to increase additional upfront costs for developers is an effort the opposition will oppose, and we will seek to divide on that point. However, it's not just the opposition that recognizes the disproportionate impact that this policy has on developers, because the government's own impact assessment estimates increased fee revenue of 143 to 190 million pounds a year if fees are increased to 90% cost recovery as is proposed by these regulations, with average undiscounted impact amounting to costs of 141 million pounds to businesses every year.
But it isn't businesses alone, with another 3 million pounds of additional costs for householders as a result of the fee increases. If housebuilding is already so expensive, it rather begs the question: why are the government doing this? What defense can the minister possibly present? Well, in both the explanatory notes and in the other place, the government have claimed that increasing fees will strengthen capacity and capability across the planning services for a more efficient and speedier system, and the minister did so in his speech today. Why?
Local authorities all over the country are increasingly hard-pressed financially, not least those who have been the victims of the government's malicious so-called fair funding review. It would be no surprise to find this extra money funneled elsewhere as they try to keep up with funding cuts, increased taxation, and social care costs. After all, the money this policy would raise is not ring-fenced.
In answer to my honorable friend, the minister said that the government expects, I quote, expects that this money will be ring-fenced and spent on planning. Well, over the years, Sir John, those of us who have been in this place for a little while know that that is classic government speak. It is not the same as requiring local authorities to do what the minister wants them to do. Therefore, we cannot guarantee with any certainty that this would benefit the planning system, nor that the money raised would even go towards planning applications at all. And a system that is not working does not need more barriers, such as hiked up costs, but streamlining and simplifying.
It needs fixing, not taxing. The opposition would welcome a simplified system, clearer fee categories, improved planning system performance and speedier decisions. But we believe this policy does not deliver on any of these targets.
This is because greater cost to developers means further weakened viability. Before we seek to divide, I hope the minister will take the necessary time to address these concerns and answer a few of the questions they generate. Most importantly, will the minister commit to a full review of building regulations to identify the most burdensome costs and red tape to cut before bringing in force any additional layers of expense? We on this side would be more than happy to help. After all, as my honorable friend the member for Weald of Kent announced in Birmingham a couple of weeks ago, we have a plan that all in all will cut the cost of delivering and therefore buying a new home by up to fifty thousand pounds.
Secondly, will the minister commit to a planning system that supports the market rather than restrains it by exploring how we can avoid even more red tape in the future and end the culture of regulatory layering that currently pervades Whitehall?
I look forward to the Minister's answers to these questions and I would encourage all members present to vote against this cost to business and householders and back British housebuilding instead.
Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Sir John. Can I thank the Shadow Minister for his response and the questions he's put to me. Before I address each of them in turn, I just want to reinforce a general point I made, Sir John, concerning the rationale for these regulations. As it stands, based on the most recent local government spending data for 2024-25, councils are facing an estimated funding shortfall of £330 million per year as a result of the gap between the fees that they are able to charge and the cost of processing and determining planning applications.
And I think it is entirely reasonable on the principle of the matter that we seek to close that gap so that local authorities are able to deliver a timely service. The shadow minister spoke at some length about viability pressures and the role that regulations have played in those viability pressures. I'd gently say to him that lots of the regulations that we are either bringing into force or that were in force were introduced by his government. Second staircases is a good example. We recognize that developers must meet a range of costs when bringing forward development.
We are acutely aware that viability pressures remain very pressing in many parts of the country. London is a very good example, and that they have become in many cases more acute over recent months as a result of the conflict in the Middle East. He will know the statistics when it comes to an increase in, for example, building materials costs that all developers are facing.
But I come back to the point I made in my opening remarks, Sir John: planning application fees are typically a very small proportion of overall development costs. The purpose of these regulations is to ensure that planning application services are properly resourced so that they can process applications efficiently, because there is a cost to delays in planning applications to services that are not efficient. And so I would argue that ensuring that local planning authorities can make those high-quality and timely decisions can support viability and investment just as much as keeping application fees proportionate.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Thank you very much, Sir John. I don't doubt the Minister's sincerity on that point at all, but taking back to what I said in my remarks, the Government expecting something to happen is not the same as the Government requiring it to happen.
So in the event that that doesn't happen, what steps will the government take to make sure that it does?
Matthew Pennycook
And I will come to that and I'll specifically answer the point on ring-fencing as well because I think the Minister slightly misrepresented, Shadow Minister, sorry, slightly misrepresented my response to the honorable gentleman. On a related point in terms of viability and it sort of tempts me to stray way beyond the regulations that are in front of us. But it is important to say that we obviously consulted on the fee schedule that we're discussing. We received 173 responses to that consultation. Overall 59% of respondents supported the proposed national fee schedule.
Support included 68% of local planning authorities and 52% of developer respondents.
There is support for the fee increases out there, provided as I said that those fee increases result in an improved service. Specifically in terms of ring-fencing, the government is clear that planning fee income should be invested in planning application services. The Planning Infrastructure Act, and this is where I sort of slightly take issue with the shadow minister saying that we're just relying on, you know, the pressure and moral suasion to ensure that planning departments do that. The Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025 introduces a statutory ring-fencing requirement to ensure that fee income is retained and applied to the delivery of the planning function once commenced. The ring-fencing measures will come into force through separate regulations at the same time as the local fee setting measures that I've mentioned earlier are introduced.
And the ring-fencing duty will apply regardless of whether fees have been set nationally or locally. So he can be assured in due course as soon as we've commenced those regulations that that ring-fencing will apply.
But while those provisions are not in force, the government expectation remains that planning fee income should be reinvested into planning application services. But once we have commenced those regulations, it will not be an option for those authorities. In terms of general planning performance, he will know that we monitor through planning statistics and our planning performance regime, which is in place. Many of his colleagues have squirmed at their own local authorities being put onto that performance regime for not making timely decisions, not having the performance required. We'll continue to monitor where we need to intervene using the powers available for us in individual local authorities.
But to conclude, Sir John, these regulations are a key step towards improving local planning authority resourcing, enabling faster decision-making, higher service standards, and stronger overall performance across the planning system. They will facilitate, as I've said, an immediate funding uplift for all local planning authorities, and by providing for a new national fee schedule, will provide a more robust baseline for the operation of future local fee-setting arrangements, which we'll come to debate on a future statutory instrument. A fast, effective, and reliable planning service is essential to support housing delivery, economic growth, and the provision of infrastructure. These regulations will ensure that local planning authorities are sufficiently resourced to determine applications in a timely and high-quality manner, and I commend them to the committee.
John Hayes
Very good. So the question is that the committee has considered the draft Town and Country Planning (Fees for Applications, Deemed Applications, Requests and Site Visits) (England) (Amendment and Transitional Provision) Regulations 2026. As many of that opinion say 'aye'.
Aye.
Very good.
Gareth Bacon?
Julia Buckley?
Aye.
Mr Luke Charters?
Aye.
Lewis Cocking?
Tracy Gilbert?
Sarah Hall?
Aye.
Sajjan Joseph?
Kevin McKenna?
Aye.
Alan Mak?
Margaret Mullane?
Samantha Niblett?
Aye.
Matthew Pennycook?
Aye.
Peter Prinsley?
Aye.
Lawrence Turner?
John Hayes
The Ayes were 11, the Noes were 4, so the Ayes have it. The Ayes have it. Order, order.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.