Westminster Hall

3 November 2026

Westminster Hall Actual start House of Commons

Follow its sittings
15:28 - 15:33
Speaker 1
Order.  Andrew Ranger to move the motion. 
15:33 - 15:49
Speaker 2
Thank you, Ms. McVey.  And it is a pleasure to serve under your chairship.  And I'd also like to thank the Backbench Committee for allowing me to bring this debate forward.  Each generation is judged by one question.  Will we leave the next one better off? 
15:49 - 17:27
Speaker 3
Will they have the greater opportunity, more security and the same hope that we had?  Around one million young people across the UK are NEETs. 

That's one in eight.  Of those, six in 10 have never had a job.  And without action, the interim Milburn review warns that it'll be one in six within five years.  If we do not act with the magnitude, imagination and substance that this moment demands, we risk failing in that generational question.  How did we get here? 

Or better phrased, how do we allow our young people to end up in this position?  The systems set up in the shadow of the Second World War to support and enable a good life for everyone in this country, regardless of post code or wealth, are at the very core of meeting this challenge.  But we must also ask if they are working in the way they should.  Why does our welfare system spend £25 on benefits for young people for every £1 it spends helping them into work?  Why are young people who could work with the right support being signed off and left there with no route back? 

Why do 67% of NEET young people tell us the curriculum did not prepare them for work or life?  The stark reality is that the institutional infrastructure that accompanies this system has been hollowed out, without anything to take its place.  The youth clubs and community spaces, where young people learn to work together, build relationships and find their place in the world,  the Saturday job, where they develop those vital soft skills, learn the value of responsibility and discover what it means to be part of a team.  Too often, politics often runs on short term decisions, 
17:27 - 17:33
Speaker 4
whatever the party, whatever the colour of the Government.  I will. 
17:33 - 18:08
Speaker 5
I'm very grateful to him for giving way and thank him very much for securing this important debate.  Supported internships are an incredibly useful way of supporting young people who've had an EHC plan along the pathway to work. 

They cost more.  They require significant investment.  But they are very cheap in comparison to seeing that young person living a life on benefit.  Does he agree with me that we should be doing all we can to support more supported internships, because that investment will make a long-term difference to getting people off of unemployment and into work? 
18:08 - 18:31
Speaker 3
I thank the honourable member for his intervention, and yes, I do totally agree, and I will come onto that a bit later in my speech.  As I was saying, politics too often runs on short-term decisions, regardless of party or government.  And on this issue short-termism will not do.  The young people affected will not accept it, and nor should we.  Picture a young person in my constituency of Wrexham. 

18:31 - 19:26

Andrew Steven Ranger

Let's call them James.

Talented, but school never worked for them. Moves on to further education, that is the wrong fit, that does not work out, and before long they are signed off and written off. And what does this all come back to? It comes back to a moral mission that touches every post code. It cannot be left to the state alone to solve this.

It needs businesses, third-sector organisations, community groups, every one of us. It takes a village to raise a child, and on this, it's going to take a nation. 6 years ago, we asked young people to carry an extraordinary burden to protect older and vulnerable people from a pandemic. They did it without question. They sacrificed the experiences, the milestones, the opportunities the rest of us took for granted.

And this sacrifice is not without its aftershocks, many of which we are seeing come to prominence in the last few years, particularly around health and educational outcomes.

Yes, I will.

19:26 - 20:01

Speaker 6

Thank you. I thank the honorable member for giving way and indeed for all the work he's doing in this area. I visited my local employability service work in Denbighshire last week, and they run an amazing program called Barod, which means ready in Welsh. And they do the pre-employability work, if you like. They work on confidence, social and communication skills, and the things that really start young people on that pathway.

Does the honorable member agree with me that it's this sort of service we should be providing to all of our young people across the UK?

20:01 - 21:07

Andrew Steven Ranger

I thank my honorable friend for that intervention. And yes, I totally agree. Another thing I will come onto a bit later in my speech, thank you. And it's now our turn to repay that debt that we owe them.

There are many players that are going to help us solve this crisis and one of them is are our businesses, local and national. And to those businesses, I want to recognise those who are already meeting the challenge. Examples from my own constituency include Moneypenny, for example. And on a national level, the likes of Sainsbury's and Greene King among others are giving 100,000 much needed opportunities to young people. These are vitally important.

But I ask all businesses to give young people opportunities. They may not necessarily have on their CV the skills on paper, but they are undoubtedly talented and will repay that chance you give them. Spend that extra time doing an in-person interview with an applicant who will gain much more than they would have talking to an AI chatbot. Look past the gaps in the CV and see the potential behind it. That-

Of course, I will.

21:07 - 21:40

Anna Dixon

I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way and for securing this debate. I'm sure he'll be aware that in the Milburn's interim review, it found that 23% of young carers are not in employment, education or training and 40% of those are over 18 months out of employment, education and training, and yet they have amazing resilience and experience to bring to a job. So, does he agree with me that in the review's final report we must outline a package of support for young carers and encourage businesses to take a chance on those young carers and give them an opportunity?

21:40 - 21:41

Andrew Ranger.

21:41 - 26:29

Andrew Steven Ranger

I thank my honourable friend for that intervention. She makes an excellent point, and I think that's a really good ask at the final review. So, yeah, we must look past the gaps in those CVs, see the potential behind it.

That faith will be repaid many times over. Turning to the education sector, Milburn reported two in three NEETs say the curriculum did not prepare them for work. Careers education often arrives too late, at a time when decisions about the future are already being made. Research by Education and Employers show children's ideas about what they can achieve are being formed by the age of seven and these are already being narrowed by gender, background and who they see around them. So careers education must start earlier.

By seven every child should be meeting people from the world of work and seeing where their learning could take them, not to choose a career at that stage, but to open those doors before they are closed. In the Netherlands fewer than one in 20 young people are NEET. Work-based learning is built into vocational education and employers and colleges plan placements together through a national body that brings them to the same table.

Work experience is not an add-on, it is part of the course. And to the third sector organisations who are doing remarkable work across the country, some of whom join us in the gallery today, I say thank you for all the work you're doing, keep going and be loud about it. You are our partners in this mission, and we have a great deal to learn from what you are achieving. In Wrexham, We Mind The Gap's six-month programme is doing exactly that: getting you- young people back into work. As my honourable friend from Clwyd North said, also helping them build those sc- soft skills, that confidence, that resilience.

And to Government, we must share the risk with employers. Support must not stop the day a young person starts work, because a job landed is not a job done.

The mentoring and coaching that got them through the door must carry on through those first months when too many placements fall apart. You know, let's work with those third-sector organizations to help support them, too, to deliver this. Strip away the paperwork. Too many employers who want to help are put off before they even begin. Every form that stands between a willing business and a young person is an opportunity lost.

Also, we need to open up the data. Information exists, but it is not joined up, and no one is accountable for the whole of it. This is resulting in a hidden cohort of around 314,000 young people who are NEET, claiming no benefits and are invisible to the very systems meant to help them. If we cannot see them, we cannot help them.

But the answer cannot be designed entirely in Whitehall. Every place knows its own picture best, you know, which employers are hiring, which schools are struggling, which young people have dropped off the radar and why.

In my own constituency and many others, it's going to be the local authorities, the schools, the further education providers, the employers, and the organizations like We Mind The Gap, who know the young people behind the numbers. We need a whole society approach to tackling this crisis. It takes more than all the individual elements acting alone.

It requires families, communities, businesses, educators and public services working together, united by a shared responsibility to give every young person the opportunity to thrive. A system to mind the gaps. If we achieve the above, back in Wrexham, James is getting the support he deserves,

on a work placement with a local business, backed by a mentor and a coach every step of the way, and slowly but surely getting back on his feet. The question I will finish with and ask colleagues in this chamber today

The question I will finish with and ask colleagues in this chamber today is where we want this generation to be in the next ten to 20 years' time. Do we want NEET rates to still be growing because the big decisions, some not easy, were pushed down the track and never delivered? Or do we want the phrase NEET to be a historic term, something that was, not something that is? Alan Milburn's final report will be the moment of truth, not just for us here, but for businesses, those third-sector organisations, the schools and colleges. It will ask whether we are willing to be partners in the great challenge of our time: one national moral mission, one team.

Again, I would like to thank all the wonderful organisations and individuals who have contributed to making today's debate possible, and for everything that you are doing to support young people across the country. I also want to thank Alan Milburn and his team, including Peter Hyman and Shoeb Gamote, for their visit to Wrexham to meet our incredible young people as part of the wider work on this report.

They've had a massive impact already, and the impact on our future of our country's going to be substantial. And as I finish, as I must in Wrexham, 10 years from now, where is James? He's in secure long-term work,

happy, and has built a life that he is proud of and fulfilled with, which is all we should want for every young person. Thank you.

26:29 - 27:03

Esther McVey

I remind Members that they should bob if they wish to be called in today's debate, and because of the number of people who've indicated their wish to speak, there will be a strict time, deadline, two minutes for speeches in order that we can get through everybody.

The question is that this House has considered the findings of the Milburn review into young people and work: interim report, published on the 28th of May 2026. Ann Davies.

27:03 - 29:10

Ann Celia Davies

and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. Let me start by saying that I don't like the phrase NEET. I much prefer LEET because most young people are looking for employment and education and training. And it just the NEET phrase makes people feel as if they're not trying hard enough, and that's could that couldn't be further from the truth. I know young people are hardworking and passionate, and they want to contribute to their skills to the workforce.

But the system we have doesn't give doesn't set them up for this success, and many have not yet found the opportunities or the pathways that allows them the space to figure out and to find their niche.

I know that everyone is good at something, but too many young people are not being afforded the opportunity to figure out what that may be. The most recent data shows that 14.6% of young people aged 16 to 24 in Wales are not in education, employment, training to the year ending June 26, and that's an unacceptable figure. Nearly one-sixth of our talented young people in Wales have not been given the opportunity to thrive and to find their place.

And one thing that stood out for me in the Milburn's interim report was the impact on place on levels of young people not in education, employment or training. And in rural Wales, the access to, barrier to not having a driving licence or none access to a car makes this a very visible problem.

And we also know that young people are facing financial constraints are more likely to struggle from these barriers. And if we're serious about widening opportunity, tackling child poverty must be a priority. And with that in mind, can the minister confirm whether the Welsh canal payment will be disregarded for benefit purposes? Since becoming a Member of Caerfyrddin, I've met so many fabulous young people and I'm really proud to be their MP. So, today, I'm asking the minister what steps the Government is taking to ensure that every young person, no matter what their postcode or financial background, has the same chance to succeed.

29:10 - 31:12

Alexander Forbes McIntyre

It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I thank my honorable friend for securing this important debate. Alan Milburn's interim report is stark. Nearly 1 million young people aged 16 to 24 are not in employment, education, or training and, in Gloucester, around 2,500 young people are in that position.

And when I speak with them, I hear the same thing time and again. They've worked hard, but the opportunities that were meant to be there for them have turned out to be closed doors. They are not lazy. 84% of young people who are out of work or training say they want a job or to be in education. The interim report is clear that this needs a whole of society effort, and I welcome the Prime Minister's leadership on this, but it must be matched by local leadership across the country.

That is why I have made it my mission to ensure that no young person in Gloucester is left behind. At the end of this month, I'm hosting the Gloucestershire's Future Summit at Kingsholm Stadium with Gloucestershire County Council, bringing schools and colleges, employers, health services, local government, and the voluntary sector into one room.

Gloucester's young people have talent in abundance, supported by fantastic schools, local colleges and training providers. What they need are open doors and clear pathways. And I'm hopeful that our upcoming summit will help build the consensus needed to deliver them. I'm delighted that the skills minister will join us for the summit. Now, one of the big things that I hear from young people is how demoralising it is to apply for hundreds of jobs only to be ghosted and not receive a reply from employers.

Small businesses in Gloucester tell me they receive hundreds of applications for a single role. They want to do their bit. They want to give feedback and support young people, but they need help to do it. And I'm pleased this Government is acting. The £3,000 job youth jobs grant supports any employer that takes on a young person that has been out of work for six months.

And the new partnership with hospitality businesses aims to create 100,000 jobs for young people. But what more can the Government do to help smaller businesses with practical pro- recruitment support as well as grants to play their part in tackling this crisis? Gloucester's young people have talent in abundance.

I believe it is our moral mission in Gloucestershire to support them. What they need are open doors, and I look forward to Alan Milburn's final report helping us to open them. Thank you.

31:12 - 31:14

Esther McVey

Adam Dance.

31:14 - 33:22

Adam Dance

Thank you, Madam Chair. When the government commissioned a review, people often just roll their eyes, because we all know there is no better way to kick an issue down the road than an independent review. And there are few issues that have been as kicked down the road as much as this, doing something about 1 in 8 young people not in employment, education, and training. But from what has been published so far and the conversations I've had, I'm genuinely hopeful that the Milburn Review will give us a real shot at change. Now, I could talk all day about this, but given the time, I obviously can't.

But there are two special areas of the report I'd like to focus on: rurality and SEND.

The review has already highlighted what is obvious to everyone from South Somerset. Transport is a huge barrier to work, or future education. Nothing else for the young people or the system does matter. The review highlights that journeys on buses in rural England have declined sharply. We have seen this with the number 11 and the 54 bus routes in Yeovil.

Even if there is a bus, some young people still face three-to-four-hours delays. So, what we urgently need is action on improving rural transport networks, and access to affordable driving lessons and tests. The £2 bus fare cap is a good start, but we need to get a new bus fleet in Somerset, and we need to start looking at more innovative ideas, like smarter booking for our most isolated communities. Equally, the Milburn report paints a clear picture of the challenges faced by young people with SEND. We are 8% 80% more likely to be a NEET.

And as I have been saying for ages, it's the lack of early intervention that is largely the driver of this. The report backs that has highlighted that children who fall behind are at five years old are on average still behind at 16. I was incredibly happy to hear from the that the Universal Classroom got more government funding we have been calling for to develop free profile building screener for key learning strengths and weaknesses. Madam Chair, I understand that in the final recommendations, Alan Milburn will look to present solutions radical enough to address the scales of crisis. I can only hope that government does something about this.

Thank you.

33:22 - 33:23

Jack Abbott.

33:23 - 35:33

Jack Abbott

Thank you very much, Mrs. Cummins. It's a pleasure to serve under you today, and I thank my honorable friend for bringing this important debate forward.

And it's clear we face an urgent national crisis and one with devastating consequences, and this is a challenge facing every part of our country. I'm pleased to say that NEETs in the East of England has fallen since 2024 from 14.2% to 11.7%. However, that is still much too a higher figure. And behind that figure, our young people unable to move forward into the next stage of their lives. People who should be building skills, gaining confidence and learning how to stand on their two feet, but instead they're struggling to take those important first steps into adult life.

And Alan Milburn is right to warn against the emergence of a lost generation. This is more about youth unemployment though, as well as being disconnected from the education system, the labor market, but the opportunity, confidence, and independence that good work can provide. And so, there is a cost here, a cost of their confidence, their health, and their future earnings, too.

And obviously, the moral crisis is all too clear. We are at a risk abandoning a generation of talented, ambitious people to worklessness, poor health, and poverty, too. I just want to highlight a few things that we are doing in Ipswich and Suffolk to change, to turn the tide here. Whether that's the new Youth Hub funded by the government in Ipswich, bringing together employers, training providers, careers advice, mental health support, and housing support under one roof, that is incredibly welcome. Of course, Sizewell C, a project that is transformation for our energy security, but also what it represents to our young people.

And I was delighted as an MP to secure 500 jobs from them and as a guarantee for Ipswich as well. And also, Seetec, who deliver employability support. And I will just ask the ministers that we make sure, as a government, we make they we ensure that there's no gap in support between the Restart Scheme, which has been incredibly successful, and the future employment support program, as well.

So when there's apprenticeship to apply for, skills training to access, and a career's build ambition has somewhere to go. But what they do need is the ambition and the potential to meet opportunity all at the same time. So behind every headline figure is a young person who wants to contribute, but our responsibility is to make sure that chance is there.

35:33 - 35:35

Esther McVey

Hannah Spencer.

35:35 - 37:36

Hannah Kathrine Spencer

Thank you, Madam Chair. Last week, I went back to HideOut, a youth club in Gorton that opens its doors to hundreds of young people every week. And I asked some of the kids I met about their future hopes and dreams, and they all scrambled to tell me about who they thought they could be, and you could genuinely feel the hope in the air. But if you ask anyone slightly older, a teenager or a young adult, and you'll hear a clear, bleak understanding of the ways that the world is already letting them down. Their hope has faded away.

Almost a million young people are growing up finding themselves not in education, employment or training. And every week I meet young people across the constituency who want to work hard and build a good life for themselves, but find the system is stopping them. I've heard from a 25-year-old care leaver with no family, no network and no safety net, who told me that he tries so hard every day to stop himself becoming homeless, and who despite being a university graduate, cannot find secure, well-paid work. And this is not equal. The risk of being not in education, employment or training doubles if someone comes from a disadvantaged background and has lower qualification levels.

And it is far worse in Greater Manchester and the north than in London and the south-east. Opportunity should not be a postcode lottery where it's those who need a hand most who are being left behind. Left behind by the government's sustained real-terms funding cuts for schools and colleges, despite ever-increasing demand.

left behind because small and medium-sized businesses are unfairly being asked to train up the next generation of workers without the money and support needed to make this a success. Young people don't need cuts to Universal Credit health, which will just harm those who can't work; cutting cash benefits does nothing to improve employment outcomes. What they need is an approach from this government which acknowledges that investment now will save money in the long run. What they need is change to the very structure of our economy and education system,

more flexible and inclusive post-16 pathways, and putting green skills at the forefront.

The Milburn review is clear that urgent action is needed. The question is not whether young people in Gorton and Denton and across the country have ambition, but whether this government is willing to match it.

37:36 - 37:39

Esther McVey

Peter Swallow.

37:39 - 39:41

Peter Swallow

Madam Chair, the Milburn review interim report was clear that in order to be fit to provide the support young people need to enter the workplace today, we need to fundamentally rewire not just the welfare system, but our health system and our education system, too. Education has a critical role to play in preparing young people for the workforce and for life. What we hear again and again from employers is that young people, even in entry-level roles, have not been able to develop the skills that are essential in any workplace, and indeed, for life skills like communication, problem solving, and critical thinking. This is not just about the NEET crisis we are facing today, painful though it is already for so many. It's not also about just bringing down the welfare bill, although that is vital, too.

It's about taking the opportunity now to grasp the even greater NEET crisis that may be coming down the track as we face the reality of an economy being fundamentally reshaped by AI. It's clear that AI is the defining technology of our time. In just a few years, we've seen it power breakthroughs in fields as wide ranging and important as medical diagnostics and research, agriculture and mathematics. And that's why it's so fundamental that young people develop not only the skills they need to use AI critically and thoughtfully, but also to exist in a world where things we have always relied on humans for are increasingly being automated. I've long argued that an education system rich in the humanities must be at the heart of preparing young people for the age of AI.

This is not just because the content you learn, but because of the skills the humanities encourage you to develop.

As part of their research into the future of the labour market, the National Foundation for Educational Research found that it was skills such as collaboration, communication, problem solving and information literacy which will be most needed by employers in 2035. And that's why it is so important that we develop an education system that provides young people with just these skills.

39:41 - 39:43

Esther McVey

Jim Shannon.

39:43 - 40:49

Jim Shannon

A real pleasure to serve under your chair ship, a big thank you to the honourable gentleman for setting the scene. In Rob in Alan Milburn's report, he helped up a mirror to a stark and uncomfortable reality in the United Kingdom. 1 million young people aged 16 to 24 currently classified as not in education. The it also reveals a staggering 84% of these young people actively want to work, learn or train, and the work ethic is very clearly there.

They referred to a system failure across health, education, and welfare. A 70, a devastating 70% increase in the number of young people struggling with work-limited health and mental health conditions. And as regards disability, it's raised from 21% to 44%. So my question to the Minister, what's been done specifically to help those with mental health issues and depression? The failure costs our economy a massive 125 billion annually.

In Northern Ireland, we're seeing the exact same structural failure, we've cut funding to local youth work, and training programs to strip away the last line of defence for vulnerable young people, especially care leavers and those from rural communities.

I'm very happy to give way.

40:49 - 40:59

Gregory Campbell

I thank the honourable member for giving way. Would you agree with me that many of the young people don't want to go into formalized education and we really need to reach out into those communities to try and assist them and deal with this problem once and for all?

40:59 - 42:12

Jim Shannon

Yeah, well we certainly do and I thank the honourable friend for that. It's important that this is not specific to the UK mainland, it affects us back home in Northern Ireland to a degree as well. Instead, we need a complete shift from a pass passive welfare state to an active working state. We need to see powers and funding handed down to local authorities and devolved executives who actually understand the job markets in their areas. We have to bring about seeing the mental health system work hand in hand with employment hubs so that getting better and getting into work are part of the same journey.

It's so important that we marry those two together. And perhaps more importantly, we need to see delivery of the promise of the Youth Guarantee by providing clear pathways into work, education, or apprenticeships alongside a massive expansion of meaningful work experience placements. It's so important. I recognize the government and the Labour government has a plan for young people and to do that. I conclude with this, Madam Chair.

we if we continue to allow a million young lives to remain on hold, we are writing off the future of our workforce and fracturing the social fabric of our communities. It is time to treat youth detachment as a national emergency that it is, break down the silos between our departments, and give the next generation the genuine opportunities they deserve. Thank you very much.

42:12 - 42:14

Esther McVey

Amanda Hack.

42:14 - 44:11

Amanda Hack

Thank you very much. Pleasure to serve under your leadership. I thank the honourable Member for Wrexham for bringing forward this incredibly important debate. Unsurprisingly, in his interim report, Alan Milburn laid out the current system as failing a generation. I had the opportunity to host a meeting with Alan and the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions to launch Opening Shift, alongside the British Retail Consortium, who've worked with the DWP and retailers to offer more than 11,000 work placements for young people, with a view to get to 100,000 jobs by the end of the Parliament,

opening up that very first rung of the ladder. In 2012, the coalition government scrapped compulsory work experience, despite major rejections from employers, where the 2015 poll by British Chamber of Commerce found that 82% of bosses said pupils under 16 should be offered work placements. I also believe that in order for employers to feel confident and take a risk in employing anybody, let alone a young person with limited experience, they also need to have the experience to see young people grow and develop in the workplace.

The role of work placements should never have been downplayed, and critically it's a first step into the world of work. In my earlier career, I was lucky enough to work alongside the Leicestershire Education Business Company, an independent local charity set up to support employers, and it was inspirational. They still organise and support young people and employers with work experience locally today. Data from other comparable countries state that when more 14 to 16-year-olds have had employment experience,

employment experience, less young people are NEET. The review sets out on almost every conversation with young people and NEET, they found an interest, a passion, a talent, despite all the barriers holding them back. It was the same experience on the Work and Pensions Select Committee. Young people are inspired to work. We just need to give them that inspiration.

44:11 - 44:13

Esther McVey

John Milne.

44:13 - 46:20

John Milne

Thank you, Madam Chairman.

The first installment of the Milburn Review has been well received on all sides, and as a member of the Work and Pensions Committee, we had the chance to ask him about it a few months ago. One of the things he said, which got a lot of press, but which has been misunderstood, it's his observation that we spend £25 on benefits for every pound we spend on helping a young person into work. Contrary to what some on the right have assumed, this emphatically does not mean that slashing benefits is actually the way to cure youth unemployment. For years, under the Conservatives, we operated Jobcentres under a sanctions-based culture. It failed.

Job hunting is a difficult challenge, totally demoralizing people by distrusting their every move is not the way to coach them through their first interviews. In evidence to the committee, young people describe being made to feel like a leech. How does that help anyone? The demand for people to demonstrate large number of job applications, like notches on a belt, has been completely destructive.

Local employers have disengaged in my constituency of Horsham because they've been spammed with poorly targeted applications. We shouldn't be so hasty to write off the current generation as a bunch of snowflakes. We rather we should remember that the cur- current level of nearly 1 million NEETs is actually less than the peak back in 2011, when we had 1.25 million. The remarkable fact is that 44% of NEETs aren't claiming any kind of benefit at all. Surely even the most zealous right-winger can see this challenges the cliché of an out-of-control benefits culture.

Success stems from intervention at an early age. When kids stop attending school, that's a powerful indicator of their likelihood to become NEETs later. In that context, the Government's youth guarantee scheme won't do the trick.

It only kicks in after 18 months at unemployment when the damage is done and it's not available to kids on benefits. This Madam Chair, will not be a quick fix, but actions today will bring huge long-term rewards for the people who matter most: our children.

46:20 - 46:21

Brian Leishman.

46:21 - 48:23

Brian William Leishman

Good morning, Ms McVey. It's a pleasure having you chair, and I thank my honorable friend from Wrexham for introducing this debate. Now, the Milburn Review gets a lot right. It's right to say that the NEET rate is so high because of decades of structural dysfunction in education, health, welfare, and employment support.

It's right when it states that poverty shapes early childhood and is a contributing factor to how children grow up. It's also right in saying that care experienced young people are particularly at risk of disengagement. And clearly a reason for this is because of support and stability falls away when they are most needed. And 84% of the surveyed NEET young people want to find a job, education, or training. That shows that young people do have a desire for work, contrary to the stereotyping that we see from some politicians and some in the media.

And crucially, the report highlights that there are fewer entry level roles and apprenticeships available, down over 40% in the last decade. Now, the Government must take an early interventionist approach, and provide intensive employment support, and work with organizations, bodies, and charities that have comprehensive experience in this area. However, the Milburn report is weak on the role of incentives in the social security system.

It suggests the system's design encourages young people to claim and remain on health-related benefits rather than participate in work and training. But that narrow framing is wrong, and does not take into account individuals with complex needs having to negotiate a difficult system. Claiming the UC health element of Pip is no easy process. The government must end the degrading manner of this system, and correct the often regular result of people being wrongly denied support. For so many, the act of claiming is an undignified and demeaning endurance test.

That is a stain on the state. Reform of the system is needed, but it must be achieved with care, compassion and investment.

48:23 - 48:24

Darren Paffey.

48:24 - 50:33

Darren James Paffey

Thank you, Madam Chair. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairship, and I congratulate my honourable friend for securing this very popular and important debate.

The Milburn Report shows that we have to change how we talk about young people out of work and out of education. As has just been cited, 84% of those we call NEETs do not want to be out of work. They don't lack potential or desire. What they lack is opportunity. So that's the problem this has to fix.

The report also shows that disconnection begins long before 16, in school, and I see that sadly in Southampton, where persistent absence has been creeping up year on year. So I very much welcome the curriculum and assessment review's push to make school more engaging, to broaden the curriculum so that there are more hooks, including, as my honourable friend has said, in the humanities.

If we allow children to switch off before 18 or around 14, they are far more likely to be out of education and training at 18. Southampton has also shown some great opportunities that work. Safe New Futures is a local charity that works with long-term unemployed young people, combining mental health support and group CBT with job-ready skills and vocational training. When I visited, one of the young people told me that after an incredibly difficult period, this course had given them the confidence to actually enter the world of work and pursue their career. Half of the NEET participants in that scheme go on to find work.

Half.

Saints Works is run by the Saints Foundation, the charitable wing of our excellent football club, and they combine skills growth and mentoring, and then in-work follow-up support once they've got into jobs. And we've got a young adult employment hub that brings the council, the job centre, work coaches, and youth workers under one roof. None of these are national schemes; they're all local partnerships that know their young people by name, and that's the lesson I hope the final report draws. So, my question to the minister is, when we respond to the final report, will there be sustained funding for local programs like this that are getting the work done?

50:33 - 50:35

Esther McVey

Rachael Maskell.

50:35 - 52:37

Rachael Maskell

Thank you, Ms McVey, it's a pleasure to serve you in the chair today, and I thank the honourable member for Wrexham for securing today's debate. We understand the long-term sustained challenges as a result of young people and work, evidence-based and astute in its diagnosis.

We know that the challenges that young people face today have been sustained as well through generations and this is the generation, of course, who had Sure Start stripped away, youth services removed and of course have been in that straitjacket of the education system, not to mention COVID. So, the challenges are high in a society where young people are facing multiple challenges today. But we've got a great opportunity before us to change the system. And I've met young people who have been on a programme in York, called the Spear programme, getting 78% of young people into work from long-term unemployment because it doesn't penalise, it encourages young people, giving them confidence, aptitude to engage in work, the skills that are needed in order to get work, but also working with employers in the city too.

And that's a really important piece, because employers themselves need to be equally engaged as partners on the programme. And I do think that Alan Milburn, in his diagnosis in chapter seven of his report, when he's saying, we don't just need programmes, we need a system change and one focused on outcomes. Well, the one point that I really want to draw out to the minister today: it starts too late. These programmes kicking in from people being 16 means young people are already on that pathway. If we can introduce these programmes into school, not only with the careers support and putting in the those work placement opportunities, but ensuring there are programmes around employability.

This scheme with Spear is a four-week programme, two half days a week and then a one session, one-to-one, where young people get those skills, are driven forward, but also a year of support into work. They're the kind of programmes we need.

52:37 - 52:39

Esther McVey

Joe Morris.

52:39 - 54:53

Joseph Ronald Morris

Thank you, Mr Paisley. It's an absolute pleasure to serve under your chair ship. Can I just quickly draw attention to my register of interests?

I'd like to start out with the fact that in the North East, almost one in five young people are not in education, employment or in training. To put another way, it's estimated to be over 53,000. Every week across my constituency, whether I'm in Haltwhistle, Haydon Bridge, Allendale, Bellingham, Prudhoe, Hexham itself, or Throckley, or any of the other 200 communities that make up my constituency, I do meet young people who are being failed in different ways by a system that has for a long time failed to perform for them. For a long time, constituencies like mine simply haven't been part of the national conversation on this at all. Rural youth unemployment has been off the political agenda for quite some time.

I think it was in 2012 when the Commission for Rural Communities warned that rural NEET numbers were rising fast, and no one in government was taking overall responsibility for it. This is a crisis that has been rooted in my communities in decades of complacency and a failure to take on the underlying factors. It is hard enough to find a job for young people at the moment without having to worry about a bus that may never arrive, a train connection that won't be on time, a bus disruption that doesn't take place. I do want to touch very briefly in the short time I have to mean I would like to go into my slightly longer speech if I had the full time for it, but on the requirement for post-16 travel support, and to make sure that any holistic system that comes forward works for the entirety of the communities it serves.

So in Northumberland for example, the post-16 support that does exist is largely targeted at that central Alnwick to Morpeth corridor in Northumberland, rather than being targeted at West Northumberland,

And the Morpeth Conservatives who run the county council are largely occupied with making sure the system works for that corridor, rather than being a holistic solution for the entire county. That's not something that happens by accident, that is the ongoing neglect of the west of the county by the county council. So, I'll ask the minister three further things. Will the system be rural proofed from the start? Can the government look further at councils to bolster that post-16 travel duty?

And can it back vocational and SEND provision closer to where those young people live, even in those real communities where the head count is naturally smaller?

54:53 - 54:55

Esther McVey

Paul Davies.

54:55 - 56:53

Paul Davies

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I would like to acknowledge the important role of the Milburn review and its interim report within the broader context of welfare reform. Social security is important in achieving social justice, but it's also a key part of a thriving and resilient economy, providing the necessary safeguards to help people in times of need and provide the route back to work for those that can. Currently, the Department for Work and Pensions spends £25 roughly on benefits for every £1 spent on employment support. In practice, this means that only around one in five NEETs receive meaningful employment support. This is simply not sustainable.

Thus, I welcome the emphasis on Milburn's interim report on strengthening employment support for these young people. And expect the final recommendations of the review to build on this with a clear national strategy. And such a national strategy is crucial, but also what we do locally is equally as important.

Hence, the importance of partnering with local providers and career services on this issue. And in my own constituency, I've been leading the Aspire project, in which I'm working with Kirklees College, C&K Careers, and local businesses to identify young people who are NEETs, pair them with mentors who can offer guidance, support, and work experience. The aim is to help them gain confidence in themselves, provide pragmatic advice when it comes to accessing educational and employment opportunities. Now this is the first step, but it's a big step for many of these young people in engaging with colleges and employers. And in my view, local and national need to be in lockstep when it comes to the issue of NEETs.

So, please would the minister comment on how the government can help achieve this?

56:53 - 56:54

Patrick Hurley.

56:54 - 59:01

Brian Patrick Hurley

Thank you, Ms McVey, it's a pleasure to serve.

The number of young people not in education, employment or training is one of the biggest challenges facing the country. Contrary to stereotype, though, in my experience, most young people desperately want the opportunities that previous generations took for granted. The problem is that those opportunities simply aren't there for too many of them. And that's partly because we've spent so long over the past few years talking about the cost of welfare, but nowhere near enough time talking about the cost of failing to invest in our young people. So, I'm pleased that the Milburn report is reportedly calling for much more investment,

because we can't seriously expect to tackle this problem on the cheap.

And also, it's not just about how much we spend, it's about how we spend it. Earlier this year, I led a debate in this chamber on place-based employment support and I made an argument then that I wish to repeat today. The barriers facing a young person in my Southport constituency aren't necessarily the same as those facing someone in London or Manchester. So localism matters. We need to give local areas the freedom and resources they need to bring together colleges, employers, job centres, health services and community organisations and actually design support around the people who need it.

We need a system that aligns training and education with the type of jobs that might be on offer in the local area. There's no point training young people up for jobs that don't exist locally now, never mind in ten or 15 years' time. So what we're debating today has to be part of a wider economic strategy, one that creates decent jobs in our towns and communities, not just in our big cities.

So, my request of the Minister is a simple one. Let's invest properly. Let's trust local communities to deliver. And let's judge success not just by how much we cut the benefits bill, but also by how many young people we help build decent, fulfilling working lives because ultimately, making the country a better place for the next generation should be what we're here in this place to do. Thank you, Madam Chair.

59:01 - 59:03

Esther McVey

John Whitby.

59:03 - 01:01:28

John Whitby

Thank you, Madam Chair. Every young person deserves the opportunity to fulfill their potential. Where someone grows up, the circumstances into which they were born or the financial position of their family should never determine the opportunities available to them. We have 1 million NEETs, but we should be clear that this is not simply a question of young people needing to try harder.

It's about whether we, as a society, are providing the right opportunities, support, and pathways into employment. Particularly, I want to highlight the challenges facing young people in Derbyshire Dales and our rural communities. Public transport is often limited, particularly in the evenings and at weekends. A young person living in a village outside Matlock, Ashbourne, Bakewell, or Wirksworth may find that a job, apprenticeship, or college course is technically available, but practically inaccessible. Transport costs can make low-paid entry-level employment financially unviable.

Limited local provision can also mean young people have to travel considerable distances to access further education, vocational training, or specialist support. Any effective measures must recognize and address these challenges.

There are real opportunities in Derbyshire Dales: our tourism and hospitality businesses, agricultural sector, construction industry, care services, and growing green economy all need skilled and enthusiastic young people. We should be connecting local people with these opportunities, rather than allowing vacancies and skills shortages to exist alongside young people struggling to find their first job. I welcome the steps the Government's already taken: the additional £2.5 billion investment in the youth guarantee and this the growth and skills levy, the ambition to create 500,000 opportunities, expanded youth hubs, apprenticeship support and local jobs guarantee are important interventions, as is the commitment to removing barriers for disabled young people and those experiencing mental health difficulties. We must recognise that people need different kinds of support, and that a one-size-fits-all approach will not work. But there is so much more to do.

In particular, I want to see the expansion of successful local initiatives such as Yes Derbyshire, which provides young people with careers advice, training and one-to-one support, and the Unstoppable Derbyshire programme, which helps 18 to 21-year-olds overcome barriers, including mental health, financial difficulties, and housing problems. These initiatives demonstrate what can be achieved when support is tailored to individual circumstances. We should build on them and ensure that young people in Derbyshire Dales can access comparable support, regardless of where they live.

01:01:28 - 01:01:31

Speaker 38

Al Carns.

01:01:31 - 01:03:40

Alistair Scott Carns

Thank you, Madam Chair. Nearly a million people now are outside education, employment, or training, and we call them NEETs. I think we should consign this term to history. It defines a young person by entirely what they are not. It tells us nothing about what they can do, or indeed how they can get there.

I've been spending a lot of time in Selly Oak. Earlier this year, I brought local employ- employer- employers together to talk about what they were seeing.

They told me too many young people were reaching them without the confidence or the basic communication skills they needed to get into work. Some of those problems start exceptionally early, 10 to 16, not just 16 to 24. And I've spoken before about boys and young men, just 62% of boys now school-ready, compared with 75% of girls, indeed, they fall further behind through school. Then at 18, the NEETs rate nearly trebles just as a statutory partic- participation age ends. And if schools have has not worked for you, and there's no obvious step, it's disappointingly easy to drift out of sight.

I'm indeed convinced we need employers involvement much earlier, work exposure to inspire, embolden, enlighten, and close the gap between expectation and the jobs uh job reality across the market. Indeed, government should be obsessed with closing this gap.

As we invest in rebuilding British industrial capacity, we need to think about where the workforce will come from. If a company is expanding a factory with public support, who are we training to work there? If it knows we need technicians in 5 years, it should be working with schools and colleges much earlier. Now an apprenticeship will not be the immediate answer for everyone.

Some young people will need help before they are ready for one, or an employer willing to give them their first experience of work. The youth guarantee needs to reach those people. Alan Milburn estimates the annual cost of youth inactivity at 125 billion. That's an extraordinary amount of money. So I'd like to ask the minister: are we working cross-department: education, health, DWP?

Are we working earlier, between 10- and 16-year-olds? And indeed, are we closing the gap between the expectation and the reality of the job market?

We should be much better at bringing the two together, employers and education, and in doing so, consign the term NEETs to history.

Gareth Snell.

01:03:40 - 01:05:42

Craig Gareth Snell

Thank you very much, Mr. Betts. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I want to thank my honorable friend for Wrexham for securing this debate. Lots has been said by honorable members across the House, so I will seek not to repeat it, but I would like to push the minister on a couple of points, if I may, that come out of the review. I think the diagnosis that the Milburn review has shone a light on is something that was known to most of us. Indeed, Stoke-on-Trent has quite often been seen as both an example of where things were terrible, but where things are getting better.

Our NEET rate has dropped from 16% down to below 10% because of work done by our partnerships, but we still have more to do.

Part of that is because our local environment has flexed to do what it needs to do, sometimes against the guidelines provided to it by Ofsted and the Government. I would commend to the minister the work that's been done by the CEO Futures Forum, which brings together MATs from across the city to look at the pathways that young people need now for the jobs that exist in the future, much like the comment that was just made by my honourable friend from Birmingham, Selly Oak. But we are also constrained by the fact that good apprenticeship providers are finding themselves unable to take on the numbers of young people that want to do apprenticeships because they are held back by the de minimis rules under the APAR regulations.

And I would urge the minister and her department to look at how we can use every aspect of our arsenal available to us if this is a moral crusade to ensure that every young person has that right pathway, including, if needs be, liberalising some of the rules around registration of apprenticeship providers so that groups like Diane Cadman Spark group can take on the young people that they want to. But I would end with Ms McVey, could I urge the minister not to fall back on some of the rudimentary politics that suggest that

But I would end with Ms McVey, could I urge the minister not to fall back on some of the rudimentary politics that suggest that artificially capping the wages that we pay young people as opposed to the wages we will pay a full-time adult is a way in which we can address this NEET problem. If you are in work you should be paid fairly for the work you do regardless of the age and the way you're doing it. And I know the government is committed to this and it was a manifesto commitment, but the siren voices are calling for that to be slowed down and I would urge the government to resist that as much as they can.

01:05:42 - 01:05:43

Joani Baxter.

01:05:43 - 01:07:59

Johanna Baxter

Thank you, Ms McVey, it is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I congratulate my honourable friend for Wrexham on securing this vital debate. The interim report set out by the Milburn review is as stark as it is comprehensive.

It's a damning indictment on a broken system that has left over a million young people across the country not yet in employment, education, or training. That's over a million young people whose talents, aspirations, and potential are at risk of being wasted, leaving long-lasting scars on themselves, their families, their communities, and the taxpayer. A figure like that does not reflect individual failure, but rather a systematic failure at the heart of government policy over many years. For too long, young people have been failed by governments that lacked the very ambition that they themselves hold. Conservative governments in Westminster and the SNP government in Holyrood have presided over a steady erosion of opportunity, and it's in their level of interest in this debate today is instructive.

They've failed to equip young people with the skills they need, failed to provide the support they deserve, and failed to recognise that a lack of opportunity is a driving force behind rising youth joblessness.

We see the weakening of the career ladder everywhere. Entry-level jobs have declined dramatically with 1.6 million fewer opportunities available across the country. And the traditional Saturday jobs that many of us had when we were growing up, I worked in our local veterinary surgery, those have been disappearing for years whilst apprenticeship starts have fallen by 35% over the last decade. And the hiring process itself is broken. Young people desperately want to work and they need to be given the opportunity to do so.

These complex, multifaceted challenges deserve a comprehensive plan equal to the generational scale of the crisis. So I urge the Minister and the Government to set out a clear direction, which fixes youth mental health services, reforms technical education, bridges the gap in transition between compulsory education into employment, and transforms the culture within our jobcentres.

01:07:59 - 01:08:00

Laura Kirksmith.

01:08:00 - 01:10:01

Laura Kyrke-Smith

Thank you, Chair. And I congratulate my honourable friend for Wrexham for this debate. Across my constituency of Aylesbury and the villages, there is no shortage of talent or ambition among our young people. What they lack is opportunity, confidence and sustained trusted support. I want to share three points that I think will help, and I look forward to the Minister's response.

The first is that we have to recognise the multiple different pathways to success in work. Both national and local policy should better recognise and support self-employment and entrepreneurialism as legitimate employment pathways.

We have a fantastic example of this in Aylesbury, which is the Making It programme run by Youth Concern, which combines leadership development with guidance on self-employment and the chance to gain direct experience working in the creative industries. And they've had really strong interest in this from young people, particularly from those for whom traditional employment feels too inaccessible or unattractive. The second is that we have to measure success not just by how many people enter jobs, but by whether they stay in them. Bucks College Group offers a positive steps programme in collaboration with Jobcentre Plus and Buckinghamshire NHS Trust. The Jobcentre identifies people who are unemployed, the college provides training through its immersive healthcare suite and its work preparation support, and the NHS Trust provides a placement and a guaranteed interview.

But the important point is that it doesn't stop there. The colleges' program data shows that 85% of participants are not just getting jobs, but progressing into that permanent, sustainable NHS employment. The third point is recognizing that employment is of course just one part of young people's lives. Too many young people experience poor mental health, family difficulties, exclusion from education, or other challenges. And as a result, they lack the confidence to progress into education, training, or employment.

So, what's needed is not just the job interviews and the work prep, but access to mental health support, and also that wider support for young people to help them actually recognize and articulate their strengths and their skills in the first place. So, I really look forward to the Minister's response, and I look forward to making Alan Milburn's recommendations a reality for young people in Aylesbury and the villages.

01:10:01 - 01:10:07

Esther McVey

We now come to the front bench, Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Ian Sollom.

01:10:07 - 01:11:06

Ian Sollom

Thank you, Ms McVey, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairship today, and I congratulate the honourable Member for Wrexham on securing this debate.

Alan Milburn's interim report is a thorough and, in places, uncomfortable piece of work. Then it is an important foundation for anyone serious about tackling the waste of a million young people's talent. Not least because it takes apart some myths. Some 54% of young people who are NEET told the review that they want to work, and another 30% want to get into education or training. These are not lazy young people; as the report puts it, they are exhausted.

The mechanisms that used to bring young people into work are working less well. The first rung has thinned. The share of 16- and 17-year-old students doing any paid work has fallen from 35% in 2006 to just 19% today.

01:11:06 - 01:11:07

Will my right honourable friend give way?

01:11:07 - 01:11:08

I will give way.

01:11:08 - 01:11:36

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you for giving way. Thank you, Chair. UKHospitality highlights how over 100,000 jobs have been lost in the sector, particularly in areas such as Torbay, where hospitality can be the first rung in employment. Does my right honorable friend agree with me that actually, what we're seeing is a crisis of opportunity for young people than a NEETs crisis?

01:11:36 - 01:18:06

Ian Sollom

I thank my honorable friend for his intervention, and I agree the opportunities that have been thinned for a long time now are a big part of the issue.

Employers do ask for experience, but the pathways through which it was once gained have narrowed or gone. And the report is blunt on why the system fails. Britain has not ignored youth unemployment. It has had the New Deal for young people, the Future Jobs Fund, the Youth Contract, and Kickstart, and each has been abolished once the immediate crisis has passed. Milburn also describes what we have as "parallel play": education accountable for attainment, welfare for benefit flows, health for treatment, and nobody in the pathway for nobody for the pathway from childhood to working life.

The clearest sign of that is what the report calls the hidden cohort.

Around 314,000 NEETs, aged 18 to 24 in England, nearly half claim no benefits at all. They're on no case load and no institution is responsible for them. What the system needs is a long-term commitment through a permanent architecture. That's why the Liberal Democrats advocate for a wholesale overhaul of jobs coaching so that every young person has a real person who sits down with them several times a year and helps them plan where they want to get to, building on models in from the Netherlands and Germany. Now we know that support like that has to be delivered locally because labor markets, transport, and employers operate locally.

The risk Milburn warns us is that without a national framework, devolution becomes a delegation of failure.

Skills England ought to be part of that national framework, but in its short life, it has already been moved from one department to another, and it remains simply an executive agency. It needs supercharging. It should become a genuinely independent body, with the standing to work across government, including local government. Ms McVey, the review estimates that for every £1 the department spent on employment support for young people in 24-25, around £25 was spent on benefits. In its words, the UK's approach for decades has been to pay the bill for youth inactivity, rather than invest in preventing it.

Milburn argues that the Treasury's usual value-for-money tests do not look far enough ahead to capture the lasting damage of time out of work or training at a young age. And that once that is counted, early intervention pays for itself many times over. And I note that the Chancellor announced at the budget last week that from the next spending review, there will be a ring-fenced budget for prevention. So, the question is whether support for young people at risk of becoming NEET goes in that ring-fenced budget. The report shows that we can already identify many of those most at risk while they are still at school.

But the pupil premium stops when a young person turns 16 at exactly the point the risk peaks.

Extending it to post-16 learners, including those in further education, is a long-standing call of the Lib Dems and I hope that we see that in Milburn's prescription. And we would also like to see a guarantee to every young person of 100 hours of work experience before they turn 18, so that it no longer depends on who their parents happen to know. And that brings me to who else needs to be part of the solution. Milburn has said that there is a contract at the heart of all this, referring to the relationship between young people and the state. But I would suggest that the contract is missing a signatory.

For most young people, the first job is offered not by the state, but by an employer. In the final report's recommend- dations, if the final report's recommendations are to work, employers have to be part of the bargain too.

Milburn's own evidence makes the case. He argues that as the cost of employment rises, the case for taking on someone inexperienced becomes harder, unless employers are given the support to offset the risk. On cost, the national insurance changes of this government's first budget undoubtedly added to the pressure on part-time, entry-level roles, especially in retail and hospitality. That's why we, Liberal Democrats, have called at the very least for a lower rate between £5,000 and £9,100. The cost is only half of it.

A large employer can absorb the risk of a young recruit who needs supervision and support.

A small firm often cannot, however cheap the hire. That's why we've also proposed skills cooperatives as part of the solution, SMEs pooling training and pastoral support so that no single business carries the whole risk of giving a young person their hot first start. Now, I realize the minister will not pre-empt the final report, so I have three questions of principle. First, as I have said, the report highlights that no institution is responsible for this. So does the minister accept in principle that someone must be, and should that responsibility be with a named local body working within a national framework that guarantees a minimum standard?

Secondly, will employment support and post-16 provision for disadvantaged young people count as preventative spending when that new ring fence budget is set?

And thirdly, before any new obligations are placed on young people, will the government ensure that the support offer is actually in place first? The report says that inaction, or tinkering at the edges, is itself a decision and costly one. I hope the minister will tell us that the final report will be met with something much more than that. Thank you, Chair.

01:18:06 - 01:18:08

Esther McVey

Andrew Snowden.

01:18:08 - 01:19:50

Andrew Snowden

Thank you very much. It is a pleasure to serve with you in the chair for this debate, Mrs McVey. And I congratulate the member for Wrexham on securing this debate, and I thank all members who have contributed this afternoon, including the honourable member for Horsham, who referred to the thoughts of even the most zealot right-wingers.

Now, I'm not sure where I sit on his zealot-ometer at this moment in time, but maybe we can see by the end of this speech, and I'm sure I will sure I will wear it with pride. And it's great to be shadowing the minister, who, as always, wonderful to be debating with a fellow Boltonian. So, the issues raised by the interim report are made all the more topical by the delay in publishing the final report, and by last week's budget, which was notable for the absence of any action on the number of young people not in education, employment or training. Alongside the budget, the Office for Budget Responsibility published a figure that should give every member pause. Over this Parliament, this government will spend 911 billion on working-age welfare.

That is more than £48,000 for every one of Britain's over 18 million working households. There are few subjects this House debates that matter more to the future of our country. Behind every figure in Alan Milburn's interim report is a young person whose working life is either not starting well, or not starting at all. And those

01:19:50 - 01:20:19

Jim Shannon

Can I thank him and, in my contribution, I highlighted the issue for those young people with mental health issues, the fact that the percentage has went from 21% up to 35%, which is an indication of a special issue for young people today. The honourable gentleman will know that through his own constituency, as I do as well.

Does the honourable gentleman feel that it must be a priority and a focus upon young people with mental issues, in particular to ensure that they can get the employment and the focus that they need on something and a purpose in life?

01:20:19 - 01:22:21

Andrew Snowden

Thanks. Andrew Snowden. Speaking of badges of honour, it's always a badge of honour to be intervened on by the honourable member in this place. And yes, I totally agree with the point that he makes. And the figures that I just referred to are stark.

Youth unemployment reached 15.6% in the first quarter of this year. That is 715,000 young people, 139,000 more than when this Labour government came to office. Almost a million young people, 981,000, are not in education, employment or training. Our youth unemployment rate is now higher than Hungary, Slovenia and Bulgaria. Perhaps the most telling finding of all is this: six in 10 young people without a job have never worked.

For them, this is not about getting back into work. It is about getting a start in the first place. We on this side of the House welcome the review and we recognize much of its diagnosis. Work is not just a wage, it brings structure, confidence and purpose, and prolonged unemployment early in life leaves a scar on earnings, on health and on life chances that can last for decades. The Conservatives in government understood that.

It was a Conservative government that introduced the Kickstart Scheme during the pandemic, helping more than 150,000 young people into paid work. It was a Conservative government that introduced the apprenticeship levy and supported millions of apprenticeship starts.

We acted because we knew that the first job matters most. It teaches the value of punctuality, the necessity of taking instructions; it builds social skills in a personal setting. Since this hit the election, this Government has had more than two years to get to grips with the post-COVID youth unemployment and rising cost of welfare. Instead, we have seen a culture of dither, delay and U-turn, and I'll happily give way.

01:22:21 - 01:22:43

Charlie Maynard

Charlie Maynard. Well, thank you, Mr. Chair. Does the honourable member agree that making it easier for young people to get functional skills qualifications rather than being stuck in an endless cycle of resits would allow them to get those qualifications and then onto an apprenticeship and into work, exactly as they do at the Aspire Youth Hub in Witney does so well? Thank you.

01:22:43 - 01:25:17

Andrew Snowden

I thank the honourable Member for his intervention and on tailored support is something I'm going to come on to shortly. And worse still, the government's own choices have made the problem harder. The rise in employers' national insurance and the new burdens of the Employment Rights Act have made it more expensive and more risky to take a chance on a young person. The government cannot tax the first rung of the ladder and then access- expect express surprise that fewer young people are climbing it. At the same time, spending on personal independence payments for 16-to-24-year-olds has risen from 1.3 billion to 3.2 billion in 5 years.

45% of young people who are NEET now report a disability. And of those who fall out of work or study through ill health, 8 in 10 are still NEET 2 years later.

New analysis from the TaxPayers' Alliance shows just how deep this runs. In April this year, more than two thirds of universal credit claimants in their 20s, some 870,000 young people, were not in work, and in just 2 years, PIP claims rose by almost a quarter among 20-to-29-year-olds and by nearly as much among 16-to-19-year-olds. These are not numbers to be managed. They are young lives being put on hold.

One of the Ministers of State in the DWP has told us that PIP is not fit for purpose, yet he has also said that the current level of spending is not of great concern.

The House is entitled to know which of these statements reflects the Government's position accurately. Nor is it reassuring that the Secretary of State is reported to have writ written to Peter Mandelson that, "Every meeting I have is with who we can tax in order to pay benefits to others." All of which raises some simple, but urgent questions for this Government that I would like to put to the minister. First, can she confirm exactly when Milburn's final report will be published and when the Government will respond to it in full? Can the minister also explain why neither the Milburn Review, nor the Timms Review, was allowed to report before the budget?

Second, will the minister set out precisely how these two reviews will be brought together? Will there be a single package of welfare reform and when will it come before this House? Third, does the minister accept that the rise in employer national insurance has reduced entry-level hiring?

01:25:17 - 01:25:18

Alex McIntyre.

01:25:18 - 01:25:29

Alexander Forbes McIntyre

I thank the honourable gentleman for giving way. I wonder if he might remind the House how much employer national insurance contributions there are for a under-21-year-old earning less than £50,000 a year?

01:25:29 - 01:27:33

Andrew Snowden

I thank the honourable member for his in his intervention and actually in this section, which is precisely why we have pledged as a party to reduce it by 50% to take it down even further. So, we are talking about the 21 to 24-year-olds and I thank the honourable member for his intervention.

Fourth, on the youth guarantee and the youth jobs grant, how many young people have actually started a job so far, what cost per place and how many remain unsubsidized work once the subsidy ends? Fifth, can the minister tell the House how many apprenticeship starts there have been for those aged 25 since the growth skills levy replaced the apprenticeship levy, and how that compares with the year before? And finally, will the government accept at last the offer made by my right honorable friend, the leader of the opposition, and repeated at Prime Minister's Questions in June, to work with us on serious welfare reform? Chair, that offer stands because we have a plan. Our Get to Work scheme rests on a simple principle: that no young person who can work should leave education and drift straight onto benefits.

Every young person would have a dedicated Get to Work manager and work requirements from day one.

It would cost a net £303 million, paid for by streamlining existing employment schemes and as part of the broader £36 billion of welfare savings set out by my right honourable friend, the Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary. To conclude, we all share the objective of giving every young person the dignity and opportunity of work, but good intentions are not good enough and another review is not a plan. A working age welfare bill of £911 billion in a single parliament is not the mark of a system that works. It is the mark of one that is failing both young people trapped in it and the working families who pay for it. So, I press the Government for straight answers today.

When will it act? How will it pay for it? And how will it measure success?

01:27:33 - 01:30:08

Speaker 51

Thank you, Ms McVey. It's a pleasure to see you in the chair, as ever.

I begin by congratulating my honourable friend for securing this important debate. I know that he has paid significant attention to the NEET crisis, and he's rightly said before it cannot be treated as just another political issue. It's one of the most serious social and economic challenges facing the country, and I think that's clear from the number of backbench members speaking in this debate, 20 speaking. It's just perhaps disappointing that the official opposition spokesperson is the only representative of his party here today. This is a challenge that requires government, business and others, including the third sector, to come together to tackle it, and to treat doing so as a national cause, a moral mission, as my honourable friend said.

It's for these reasons that the government commissioned Alan Milburn's independent report. We asked him to get under the bonnet of this issue, looking across the piece at the deep-rooted causes of long-term trends which have led to almost one million young people being stuck on the sidelines, not in education, employment or training. And I gently remind the opposition spokesperson that number rose by 250,000 between 2021 and 2024 and youth apprenticeship starts fell by 40% over a decade. Young people with talent, ambition and potential who for too long have not had the opportunities or support they need to succeed. As the interim report makes clear, the challenge goes deeper than that headline figure: around 60% of young people who are NEET are economically inactive and six in ten have never had a job.

This government will not accept a generation being left behind. We recognise that there is no single cause of rising economic activity among young people. Poor physical and mental health, disengagement from education, a lack of qualifications, limited work experience, and difficulty navigating a changing labour market can all play a part, and that's why our response must be comprehensive, coordinated across education, health, welfare, skills, employers and employment services. Alan Milburn's final report and recommendations are coming soon, but this government is already taking action. At the heart of our current

01:30:08 - 01:30:10

Speaker 53

Very briefly.

01:30:10 - 01:30:11

Dr Scott Arthur.

01:30:11 - 01:30:34

Scott Arthur

Thank you, Chair. Thank you. I do thank her for giving way. She listed some of the drivers for this problem. Many members have mentioned transport links, particularly for people in rural communities. She will remember the Transport Select Committee recommended that the government look seriously at Scotland and institute free bus travel for young people in England to help solve this problem. Will the government look at this again?

01:30:35 - 01:36:19

Speaker 51

Well, I thank him for his intervention, and I agree with him that provision of transport and affordable and convenient transport is vitally important. I shall leave that to my colleagues still in the Department for Transport. But at the heart of our current approach is the youth guarantee backed by an additional £2.5 billion by 2029 alongside investment in the Growth and Skills Levy.

Together, this funding will support almost 1 million young people and create up to 500,000 opportunities to earn or learn. We're strengthening support for every stage of a young person's journey. Through an expanded network of youth hubs and the new Youth Guarantee Gateway, young people will receive earlier and more intensive support. And we owe young people that. As my honourable friend said, this generation is facing and has faced a unique combination of challenges.

They're not to blame for the predicament they are in, it is the system that has failed them. And as many honourable members have said, the report found 84% of NEET young people said they want to find a job, education or training.

I agree that we need to find a better acronym. The will is there, but it needs to be matched by support. And it also needs to be matched by opportunities. So, we are giving employers practical incentives to create them, including the £3,000 Youth Jobs Grant, and a £2,000 apprenticeship hiring payment. And I remind all honorable members that employers pay zero National Insurance on employees under the age of 21, earning less than £50,000.

And our wider reform of employment support matters, too. The new Jobs and Careers Service will bring together employment, skills, and careers support with stronger links between employers, local areas, and the people looking for work. The objective is simple: a service focused not on processing people, but on helping people to find work, to build skills, and progress. Personalized support will be at the heart of our approach, helping people access the support that best meets their needs.

We've launched new digital tools, expanded community-based delivery and strengthened our employer offer. We're also increasing access to work experience and training, which has a critical role to play in breaking that age-old cycle of no experience, no job, no experience. My honourable friend for Paisley and Renfrewshire got her first chance in a vets. My Saturday job was working in Bolton's newly opened Superdrug. These are the opportunities that help you to learn what work is like, but we know that far too many young people haven't been getting these sorts of opportunities.

So as my honourable friend for North West Leicestershire highlighted, work experience is as, if not more, important than ever.

But where unemployment becomes entrenched, we must go further. That's why the jobs guarantee will offer eligible 18 to 24-year-olds who have been claiming Universal Credit and looking for work for 18 months, a fully subsidized 6-month paid job. And this is already changing lives for the better. In August, the Secretary of State came to Nottingham, to Boots, to meet young people benefiting from the jobs guarantee. And he's spoken about how remarkable it was to see the transformation in their sense of self-belief and their confidence, in the hope they now have for the future.

Well, we're going to see more of that. Following the first phase, national rollout of the program begins across 25 areas this month and is expected to support more than 90,000 young people over the next 3 years.

Crucially, we're also extending that opportunity to eligible young disabled people and young people with long-term health conditions. And the honourable member for Horsham will be pleased to hear that from April 2027, eligible young people receiving health-related benefits will be able to take up the offer voluntarily shortly after their work capability assessment. So, they're going to the front of the queue, because nobody should be written off because of their health. Now, through programmes, including Connect to Work Well, Access to Work, and disability employment advisors, we're bringing employment and health support closer together. Our approach recognises that different people face different combinations of barriers and that we have to see people in the round and take a joined-up approach to how we offer support.

We also know we can't solve this challenge only when a young person walks through the Jobcentre door.

Prevention must begin much earlier. There's a strong relationship, as other people have said, between disengagement from school and becoming NEET later in life. That's why improving attendance is fundamental to our approach. We've set a national ambition to increase school attendance to over 94% by 2028-29, and we're supporting schools through clear expectations, better data, and new RISE attendance and behaviour hubs.

Alongside this, we're fixing the broken SEND system, reforming careers provision, so young people have better, greater exposure to the workplace before they leave education. Now, I mentioned earlier how crucial work experience is.

That's why our ambition is for every young person to receive two weeks of meaningful workplace experience during secondary school, building progressively through key stages 3 and 4. There are forty-four 1-second Careers Hubs supporting that work, while additional provision is being targeted towards young people who face the greatest barriers. Gareth.

01:36:19 - 01:36:53

Craig Gareth Snell

Gareth Bacon. I do thank the Minister for giving way and the aspiration of work experiences is laudable. However, the guidance that came out in the recent Keeping children safe in education update now requires a young person if they're spending more than three days in a workplace, for that workplace to have a DBS check as part of it being an unregulated activity. That puts a significant barrier on a lot of small businesses, particularly those that have previously hosted young people, who now have to go through this burden of getting a check. Could she take that back to the department and work with the DfE to find a way of ironing out that kink so we keep children safe, but don't preclude the opportunities that they previously had?

01:36:54 - 01:38:58

Speaker 51

I can assure my honourable friend that is an issue we are aware of and we are setting about addressing it. So alongside that, we're reforming post-16 education so young people can have clearer academic, technical and vocational routes. We're transforming the apprenticeship levy backed by an additional £1 billion, supporting 50,000 more young people into apprenticeships. New foundation apprenticeships, fully funded apprenticeships for eligible under-25s, and additional support for employers will all create more routes into skilled employment. And as my honourable friend for Basingstoke rightly said, the skills needs are changing in the world of AI.

Ms McVey, these reforms represent significant action, but we recognise that the government must continue to listen and learn.

Alan Milburn's interim report set out starkly the scale and complexity of the participation challenge facing this generation. Our ambition is straightforward: wherever a young person starts from, whatever barriers they face, they should have a genuine route into education, training, or good work. And I hope that reassures my honorable friend for Stoke-on-Trent Central. It means intervening earlier. It means joining up services across departmental boundaries, as my honorable friend for Birmingham Selly Oak said.

It means working with employers, colleges, and local organisations, like that those highlighted by men- many honorable members, including Saints4Sport in Southampton, the Spear Programme in York, and Making It in Aylesbury. Because, as my honorable friend for Southport said, a place place-based solutions show great results.

And it means refusing to accept that any young person is destined to remain outside opportunity. And I should have said it also means better public transport, especially in rural areas, as my honourable friends for Hexham and Derbyshire Dales emphasized, because tackling the NEET I won't, because I'm a bit short on No, I can, go ahead.

01:38:58 - 01:38:59

Danny Chambers.

01:38:59 - 01:39:28

Danny Chambers

I very much appreciate the minister giving way. It's worth noting that 13% of NEETs are actually university graduates, and I'm meeting so many people who have just graduated with good degrees from good universities who are applying for over 300 jobs and not even getting a response.

There's very little talk about support for graduates, and we are very disappointed that in the budget there's no mention of reforming of the student loan system that is adding pressure to these graduates. Will the minister assure us that the government is looking at the student loan system?

01:39:29 - 01:40:15

Speaker 51

Well, I can assure him that we are considering the issues for graduates as well as for younger young people who are leaving school with lower levels of qualifications. So, tackling the NEET challenge is not only an economic imperative, important as that is, it is about fairness, it's about aspiration, and it's ensuring that every young person has the chance to build a better future. We look forward to the publication of the final young people and work report in the coming weeks. Its findings will provide an important opportunity to consider what more must be done to address the challenges facing young people today, and to ensure that every young person has the opportunity to participate, to progress and to thrive. Thank you.

01:40:15 - 01:40:19

Esther McVey

Andrew Ranger to wind up.

01:40:19 - 01:41:32

Andrew Steven Ranger

Thank you, Ms McVey. I want to thank all honourable members for coming today, for their valuable contributions and sharing their experiences and the work that's going on in their areas. I think it's by doing that is what is so vital because we can all learn from each other and take this forward. And I also want to thank the minister as well, my honourable friend the minister, and the spokespeople from the other parties for their responses. You know, the number of people here today and contributing just shows how important this is across the UK.

We're at an important moment coming up when the Milburn Report is published and how we respond to it here is vital. It's going to define our country and our legacy here for many years into the future, and it's going to need all of us to fix this.

And I hope we can work across the House and beyond to do that. You know, it's quite clear from everyone's contributions here today that we need a whole system approach, you know, covering things such as transport, the economic approach, the early intervention, that local design and delivery, and so many other things that other, the honorable members have mentioned. So, you know, once again, thank you all for today's debate and contributing. And thank you, Ms. McVey.

01:41:32 - 01:45:18

Esther McVey

The question is that this House has considered the findings of the Milburn Review into Young People and Work interim report published on the 28th of May 2026. As many of that opinion, say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.

Order.

Order. Afzal Khan, to move the motion.

01:45:18 - 01:48:18

Afzal Khan

I beg to move that this House has considered prevention and public awareness of strangulation.

It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Ms McVey. 27% of women killed by men in the UK were strangled to death. That is a shocking statistic, and one that should concern us all. But behind the statistics are the stories of victims and survivors, many of whom have bravely shared their experiences. I want to recognise their courage today, and thank everyone who has helped to bring this issue to Parliament, particularly the Institute for Addressing Strangulation.

One of the reasons I'm grateful to have secured this debate is that far too few people understand how prevalent non-fatal strangulation is or the devastating harm it can cause.

But let me start where I believe we must begin, by listening to survivors. Last month, I attended the IFAS conference where I met an inspirational woman, who I will call Rose to protect her identity. I want to share her story because it brings home far more powerfully than any statistic could the devastating impact strangulation can have on someone's life, not just in the moment, but for many years afterwards. In 2021, Rose was raped in an ordeal that lasted several hours. During this already horrific attack, she was also subjected to strangulation.

It was the moment she thought that she was going to die. As Rose herself explained, the strangulation was not a minor detail within the attack.

it was central to the violence that she experienced. In the aftermath, Rose sought medical help at several hospitals, but struggled to obtain an appropriate assessment, having her injuries documented, or receive the compassionate, trauma-informed care she so desperately needed. At one hospital, she waited alone for hours before eventually leaving. At another, her request for photographs of her injuries was not acted upon, and she was questioned about why she had not reported the rape. Rose had already endured a horrific attack, yet when she turned to the very services that should have helped her, she was left feeling dismissed and unsupported.

And the consequences of that failure were significant.

Rose waited almost a month before reporting the attack to the police. Even today, she continues to live with the physical and psychological consequences of what happened to her. Rose's attacker was eventually sentenced to 20 years' imprisonment with a further five-year extension period. But despite that outcome, Rose describes having to fight for the strangulation itself to be properly recognized as central to the violence she experienced.

01:48:18 - 01:48:20

Speaker 57

Will the honourable lady give way?

01:48:20 - 01:48:21

I will give way.

01:48:22 - 01:49:08

Jim Shannon

I'm delighted to, first of all, can I commend the honourable lady for bringing this incredibly sensitive and difficult subject for consideration.

We in Northern Ireland of course have brought in legislation for a stand-alone criminal offence back in 2022, carrying a sentence up to 14 years. It's a terrifying, accurate indicator of escalating abuse and potential lethality, but does my honorable friend, and I believe she is a friend, that we are truly to protect victims, government must work hand in hand with the Department of Justice in Northern Ireland and support local charities to launch a robust, targeted public awareness campaign, ensuring that healthcare workers, police officers, and victims themselves can recognise the signs of non-fatal strangulation before it turns fatal? Thank you.

01:49:08 - 01:49:09

Aphra Brandreth.

01:49:09 - 02:01:45

Afzal Khan

Thank you. The honorable member makes an important point, and I will come on later in my speech to the work that's already happened in Northern Ireland to raise awareness, but certainly there is much more that needs to be done.

Just to return to Rose and her story, and the message that she gives us today, which is really clear, do not wait for a perfect disclosure, a police report, or visible injury to take strangulation seriously. Ms McVey, I do want to recognize the positive steps that have been taken to recognize the seriousness of this offense. The introduction of a standalone offense of non-fatal strangulation and suffocation under the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 was an important step taken by the previous Conservative government. It recognized that strangulation should be treated as a serious crime in its own right. But legislation is only part of the answer.

My question to the minister is whether it is working effectively in practice, and whether we are doing enough to close the gaps between healthcare, safeguarding and criminal justice that failed victims like Rose. Chair, Rose's experience is sadly far from an isolated case.

Strangulation is reported in around one in five rapes and sexual assaults. But it is also a particularly serious and dangerous form of domestic abuse, with a quarter of women accessing domestic abuse community and refuge services reporting having experienced strangulation or suffocation. What makes this particularly frightening is that strangulation is also a major warning sign of potentially fatal violence. Research has found that women who have experienced strangulation by an intimate partner face around seven times the odds of being killed by that partner.

That is why strangulation must be treated as a red line. It is not simply another act of violence, it is a warning sign that must be recognized and acted upon before it is too late. Chair, I want to pay tribute to the Institute for Addressing Strangulation led by Bernie Ryan, which has worked tirelessly to give victims a voice and improve our understanding of this crime. IFAS has made an invaluable contribution to improving recognition of strangulation and the response to those who experience it. And the evidence it has uncovered is staggering.

Between June 2024 and June 2025, police recorded 44,426 strangulation and suffocation offences in England and Wales, up 13% on the previous year, and 87% since the standalone offence was introduced in 2022. Some of that increase may reflect better recognition and reporting, which is welcome, but we must not lose sight of what these figures represent.

Behind every recorded offence is a victim of an extremely dangerous act of violence. And for too many women, strangulation forms part of a wider pattern of domestic abuse and coercive control, with potentially devastating consequences. Chair, the Government has set itself the ambition of halving violence against women and girls, and that is an ambition I am sure members across this House will want to see achieved. But if we are serious about preventing violence against women and girls, we must be serious about recognising strangulation as one of the clearest warning signs of potentially fatal abuse. That means recognising it early, supporting victims, and ensuring police, healthcare and safeguarding professionals understand the risks, and act.

Because this is not just about securing justice after a crime has been committed;

it is about preventing further violence and potentially saving lives. IFAS has done remarkable work since the standalone offence came into force in June 2022, and I hope that the Minister has read their recent impact report, which sets out clearly what still needs to change. Let me start with the medical response. To understand why this is so important, we need to understand what strangulation actually does to the body.

Strangulation can restrict the flow of blood to and from the brain.

It can cause hypoxia, brain injury, and stroke, with symptoms that may not become apparent until after the attack. For pregnant women, it can also have serious consequences for their pregnancy and their unborn baby, and it can leave lasting psychological scars that survivors carry for years. Yet in many cases, there are no visible signs of injury at all. That means a woman who walks into A&E, looking on the surface as though she is fine, may be anything but. If our response depends on what can be seen, we will continue to fail women who need help.

I recently met my constituent, Dr Helen Bishard, a clinical neuropsychologist whose research includes the effects of non-fatal strangulation. What she made clear is that health care professionals need the right guidance and training to recognise the danger and to respond with the compassion that someone like Rose was denied. So I would welcome the minister's thoughts on how we can ensure that happens consistently across health care services.

But there is also an inequality at the heart of the current system that must be addressed. If a woman is strangled during a rape or sexual assault, she may be able to access a sexual assault referral centre with specialist medical, psychological and forensic support. But if a woman is strangled by her partner in her own kitchen without sexual assault, she does not necessarily have access to the same care or to forensic medical examination.

The medical risk doesn't disappear because of the circumstances in which the attack took place, and nor should a woman's access to proper assessment, documentation of her injuries, and ongoing support. That is why I support IFAS's call for a national pathway so that wherever a victim first seeks help, they can access the care and support they need, and I would welcome the minister's response to that proposal. The same applies to the criminal justice system. Now that non-fatal strangulation is a stand-alone offence, we must ensure the police have the training and resources to investigate it effectively. So can the minister update us on how the government is assessing its implementation and what more is being done to improve consistency in police investigations and evidence collection?

Ms McVey, improving our response to offences that have already happened is vital, but we must also stop them happening in the first place, and that means confronting an uncomfortable truth. Strangulation is increasingly being normalized.

Young people are encountering depictions of strangulation through pornography and social media, often without the information they need to understand the very real dangers involved. We need to get the message across. There is no safe way to strangle. And sadly, it's not only pornography where strangulation is being portrayed in ways that risk normalising it. This year, the BBC broadcast Armenia's Eurovision entry, a song called Choke Me, in which the phrase is repeated around 30 times.

I find it deeply troubling that a song appearing to glamorise such a dangerous act was broadcast into family living rooms across the country. And I'm particularly disappointed that the BBC, funded by licence fee payers, did not heed the concerns raised about the dangerous message this song could send.

I want to be clear: this is not about censorship; it is about the messages we are sending to young people and whether we are doing enough to educate them about the very real dangers of strangulation. YouGov research found that, among sexually experienced 16 to 34-year-olds, almost two-thirds reported having been strangled during sex. That is a deeply concerning finding.

We need to be talking to young people about healthy relationships, making sure they understand the very real risks of strangulation. Our public institutions have a responsibility to take these issues seriously, and I would ask the minister whether the Government will raise concerns about the portrayal and normalisation of strangulation with broadcasters. Chair, this debate is particularly timely because this Friday, new criminal offences will come into force in England and Wales making it illegal to possess or publish pornographic material depicting strangulation or suffocation. I very much welcome this change, which follows important work of Baroness Bertin and her review of pornography regulation. But legislation must be effective in practice.

So, can I ask the minister how the Government intends to ensure that these new offences are enforced? Alongside education, legislation and education, we need to raise public awareness more widely. When Northern Ireland changed its law, it ran a broadcast and poster campaign so that the public understood what had changed and why.

Yet, there has been no equivalent national campaign in England and Wales. A well-targeted public awareness campaign could help challenge dangerous misconceptions, encourage victims to seek help, and make sure people understand the risks. Will the minister commit to that today? Finally, Ms McVey, let me turn to the future of IFAS itself. And let me acknowledge the minister's letter, which arrived, as if almost by magic, yesterday.

I welcome her commitment to meet with IFAS and discuss its future sustainability and funding opportunities. But unfortunately, there was no commitment to continued funding, let alone the long-term certainty that IFAS needs.

Since October 2022, IFAS has brought together clinical, forensic, research and policy expertise that simply did not exist in this form before. The government has invested more than 2.1 million pounds in that work and I believe it has been money very well spent. But IFAS has been kept going on short-term funding arrangements, sometimes for as little as six months at a time and with very little notice. No small specialist organisation can retain staff, plan its work or protect hard-won expertise under that kind of uncertainty. We have invested in building up this expertise, surely we cannot now allow it to be lost.

That would not just be a loss for IFAS, it would be a loss for the victims who depend on better awareness, better training and better support, and for the police officers, healthcare professionals, and others who rely on its expertise to help them do their jobs effectively. So, while the minister's letter did not provide the reassurance I had hoped for, I'd like to give her another opportunity today. Having heard the evidence, will she commit to working with IFAS to secure the long-term funding it needs to continue its vital work? Chair, I want to finish by returning to where I began. Rose survived.

She found the strength to tell her story and the courage to share it so that others might be spared what she went through. She should never have had to fight to be believed and the next woman should not have to. I also want to say to anyone who is listening who has experienced strangulation, please do seek help.

There are organisations that can support you. You don't have to wait until you have visible injuries or have reported a crime to seek medical advice and support. Ms McVey, the previous Conservative Government took an important step by making non-fatal strangulation a standalone offence. We must not lose the momentum that legislation created. We have recognised the seriousness of strangulation in law.

Now we must make sure that recognition makes a difference in people's lives. Thank you.

02:01:45 - 02:01:55

Esther McVey

The question is that this House has considered the prevention and public awareness of strangulation. Minister.

02:01:55 - 02:11:23

Speaker 58

Thank you, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Ms McVey. I would like to start by thanking my honourable friend, the member for Chester South and Eddisbury, for securing this important debate alongside her tireless efforts in advocating for more prevention of strangulation and raising public awareness of the risks it poses. I, oh, was going to was going to thank the member for Strangford, but sadly he's left, for also his contribution to this debate as well. Before addressing the many points you raise, I did want to agree with you on why tackling this matters.

This Government has committed, like you said, to halving violence against women and girls within a decade, and improving our response to strangulation forms an important part of that mission. Like she says, it means recognizing it early, supporting victims and allowing professionals to know the early signs. We know strangulation is a life-threatening form of violence and abuse, and non-fatal strangulation is one of the strongest indicators of future serious violence and domestic homicide. The scale of the challenge is vast. She mentioned the statistics around 44,000 strangulation offences recorded last year alone, up 13% from last year, with research suggesting over half of young people aged between 16 and 25 having experienced strangulation or suffocation.

I thought nothing could shock me in this job anymore and that definitely did, with concerning evidence showing that strangulation now becoming more normalised among young people too.

Let me be clear, there is no safe way to strangle. We know, as she rightfully highlights, behind every one of those statistics is a victim living in fear, a victim dealing with trauma, a victim whose life has been put at risk. I want to thank the Member for sharing Rosie's story and for her bravery in coming forward to share it as well. It is shocking and unacceptable what she experienced and, clearly, those failures must be addressed and acted on. We also know that victims may experience serious physical and psychological consequences without displaying obvious signs of injury.

Opportunities to identify risk can therefore be missed, and victims left without the support they need, as she rightfully said. This is why prevention and public awareness are so important, and to reassure the member, this Government is taking action that is focused on prevention, but also, as she rightly states, legislation alone isn't enough, so including that must include education, health care and the criminal justice system to prevent and tackle strangulation. On the question of prevention, we are challenging harmful attitudes and behaviours that can underpin violence against women and girls through our "Enough" campaign, which is raising awareness of this abuse. I'm happy to send her more information of the campaign.

We are also supporting young people in and out of schools to understand healthy and respectful relationships through strengthening statutory relationships, sex and health education guidance, which now includes specific teaching on strangulation and suffocation, which will be part of the school curriculum and will be financially supported. As she rightfully said, it's so vitally important we get to children early. This Friday, she will know new offences criminalising possession and publication of pornography depicting acts of strangulation will come into force. We are taking decisive action to challenge content that can contribute to the normalisation of dangerous and abusive behaviours. The member mentioned health.

We are improving the identification of domestic abuse and sexual violence within healthcare settings, through the NHS Steps to Safety programme, helping to ensure victims are connected to specialist support at the earliest opportunity. She mentioned some really powerful examples of how it got missed and, hopefully, the rollout of Steps to Safety can act as a preventative measure, so we can get to victims as early as possible. We are also helping to improve research, professional training, clinical guidance, and public awareness through our support of the Institute for Addressing Strangulation since it since its inception, which has become an important centre for expertise. I will come on to funding with them in a minute. On justice, she mentioned the importance of it, and I'd like to add that bringing perpetrators to justice, even where there is no visible injury, through the standalone offence of strangulation and suffocation.

Police can already use domestic violence protection notices and orders to provide immediate protection following violence or threat of violence, including strangulation. I'm pleased to say, by the end of this year, we will strengthen those protections through the roll out of the new domestic abuse protection notices and orders, which can provide longer-term and more flexible protections against all forms of domestic abuse, including strangulation. And I wanted to add how an important part of that is multi-agency working, cuz she rightly identifies this is more than just the police doing their part, but everybody, really focused around the victim and how to support their needs most. We know there is more to do. Preventing abuse requires awareness, early intervention and a coordinated response across healthcare, policing, education, safeguarding and specialist support services.

So, hopefully, that multi-agency work that we're bedding in will make a difference. In response to questions around policing, she will be aware that we are introducing specialist teams to every single police force across the country, and, hopefully, the domestic abuse protection orders that sit alongside that will only go further in encouraging victims and survivors to come forward, but also be taken seriously, because I've heard far too often, as I'm sure she has as well, that, too often, they don't come forward because they don't think they're going to believed, and, hopefully, we can turn a corner with that.

In direct response to her comments on the Institute, the member of Chester South and Ellesmere mentions the important work of the Institute for Addressing Strangulation. I agree on how invaluable their work in this space has been, and the Government is proud to have supported them since their inceptions, investing, as she says, over 2 million in strengthening research, improving professional practice, and raising awareness of this issue. Through that support, the Institute has become a recognised centre of national expertise on strangulation, helping to improve understanding of these crimes across healthcare, policing, and the criminal justice system while providing training to more than 22,000 frontline professionals. On funding in particular, she will know and hopefully understand that I cannot comment on funding arrangements being currently considered.

What I can say is that I support her analysis of the exceptional good work that they do, and I will push for those decisions to be made as soon as possible so that we can offer the certainty that they so desperately need. To close, Ms McVey, I would again like to thank my honorable friend for the member for Chester South and Eddisbury for securing this important debate, and before this debate I offered a meeting, and I'm more than happy to follow up on that to talk about this further. This debate highlighted both the progress that has been made, but also rightly the challenges that still remain.

We know that strangulation is a serious and potentially life-threatening form of abuse. We know that its impacts are often hidden.

We know that improving awareness, identifying risks early and strengthening support for victims can save lives. While progress has been made through the introduction of a stand-alone offence, improving professional awareness and the work of organisations such as the IFAS, there is more to do. We must continue to improve understanding of the risks associated with strangulation. We must continue to challenge the attitudes that can normalise this abuse. We must continue to be working across healthcare, policing, education, safeguarding and specialist support services to ensure that victims receive the support they need and deserve.

Although it is action rather than words that will ultimately make the difference, debates such as this one provide an important opportunity for us to review our commitment to working together across political parties, hopefully, sectors and services.

Victims deserve nothing less, and by doing so, we can improve awareness, prevent harm, support victims and help ensure that this dangerous form of abuse is recognised, challenged and addressed wherever it occurs. Thank you.

02:11:23 - 02:11:37

Esther McVey

The question is that this House has considered the prevention and public awareness of strangulation. As many of that opinion, say "aye". Of the contrary, "no". I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.

Order. Order. The sitting is suspended until 2:30.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.