House of Commons
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Live capture
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Actual start House of Commons
Follow its sittingsAngela Rayner
Well, Mr. Speaker, I'm very happy to join the right honorable member in paying tribute to the Swaledale Mountain Rescue and its dedicated volunteers. The rescue the right honorable member references demonstrates, I think, the vital work they do alongside the Fire and Rescue Service, and I thank them for everything they do to keep us safe.
Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This Government is determined to achieve high and sustainable rates of housebuilding, which is precisely why we've undertaken the most rapid, holistic and radical overhaul of the housing and planning system in decades. The headwinds are, without question, severe, but there are encouraging signs of progress, not least the 15% increase in housing starts that we saw over the last 12 months ending in June of this year.
Cooper.
John Cooper
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Statistics are like bathing costumes, Mr. Speaker. What they reveal is interesting, and what they conceal is absolutely vital. And the statistics— The statistics we've heard there conceal the fact that this Government is on line to build fewer houses than the last Conservative Government did in a parliamentary term blighted by COVID when many building sites were completely shut down.
When it comes to housing, this government's drowning, not waving, isn't it, Minister?
Matthew Pennycook
This government is building and that 15% increase in starts is testament to that. I've, Mr. Speaker, lost count of the number of times I've made clear in this Chamber that our 1.5 million new homes target is an incredibly stretching one, but we remain committed to it. But we won't take lectures. We will not take lectures from a party that fell short of its own distinctly unambitious 1 million homes target in the last Parliament.
Neil Duncan-Jordan.
John Neil Duncan-Jordan
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. In coastal communities like mine, the issue isn't the rate of housebuilding, but the rate of affordable housebuilding. In 2024-25, BCP Council built just 89 affordable homes.
So what plans do the Government have to take back land that developers are banking and start building the council houses we need?
Matthew Pennycook
Well, I would say to my honourable friend he doesn't have to wait long for a package of build-out transparency measures that will include the right for local authorities to refuse permission in instances where particular developers repeatedly get planning consent and don't build out those sites.
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Mr Speaker, in answer to my honourable friend, the Minister said that there are encouraging signs of progress, but the truth is, the housing industry faces a bleaker and bleaker future under this Government. Housing completions are at their lowest for over a decade, planning permissions are down 31%, output is down 6%, London is at a standstill, and the Government are just 29% of the way through their target in nearly half the time they're allotted for it.
Does the minister agree that this broken record of failure needs urgent repair?
Matthew Pennycook
There's no record of failure, Mr Speaker: 15% increase in housing starts over the last 12 months up to June. We will remain committed to that target. But what is the what are the honourable gentleman and his colleagues' answer to this problem? Mr Speaker, it's worth noting that the OBR in their recent assessment made clear that the changes we've made to the National Planning Policy Framework will, on their own and I quote, "boost housebuilding significantly." Yet, the party opposite oppose them.
Are they going to change their position on that in light of the macroeconomic challenges facing housebuilders across the country?
Andrew Gareth Bacon
Mr Speaker, the minister wants to talk about the OBR, so let's do that. Last week, the OBR was damning in its assessment of the viability of housebuilding in England. It highlighted how regulatory and fiscal burdens are crushing viability.
The Chancellor promised no new building regulations, but that isn't enough. The minister knows that viability, or rather the lack of it, is killing the house building sector. It's existing environmental and net-zero regulations and taxes are what is causing the viability crisis. So will the minister join me in supporting my honourable friend, the Shadow Secretary of State, in her plan to cut £50,000 of regulation and taxes off the cost of building new homes to make sites viable again?
Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Mr Speaker, viability pressures are acute across the country, there is no doubt about that.
But I draw the shadow Minister's attention, and I know he agrees with me on this, that many of the regulations that the OBR highlighted in its recent assessment were regulations introduced by the party opposite in the last Parliament, whether they're building safety measures or biodiversity net gain. Now, we know that party opposite would now scrap the future homes standard, Mr. Speaker, ensuring customers pay higher bills and that we have to retrofit even more homes in the future. Perhaps he can tell us what other safety, decency or environmental requirements the party opposite now plans to slash.
Gideon Amos
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The increase in starts is welcome, but the Government's package of reforms was designed to increase consents.
And the most recent quarterly figures show that while consents are down, the rate of consents remains high, at 88%. It's actually over 90% when counselors are involved in making those planning decisions. Doesn't that show that taking away to sit powers to make decisions on major applications from counselors in the NPPF and over those over 150 homes has made no difference whatsoever to the number of consents? And will the government agree to give those powers back to counselors who are supporting over 90% of applications when they come to committee?
Matthew Pennycook
I think the honourable gentleman is talking about the national scheme of delegation. Those powers were only commenced on Saturday, so he's a bit premature in saying they've had no impact.
Gideon Amos.
Gideon Amos
If the minister had heard, which he clearly didn't, I referred to the removal of powers from counselors for decisions over 150 homes that happened earlier early stage of the year. However, moving on, Mr Speaker. The Warm Homes Grant has come in for cuts. We've now discovered that not only has £1 billion been cut from the scheme, but an extra 1.5 billion will be cut from the grant system, the loan system towards those warm homes. How will people get the renewable energy and efficient homes they need if the scheme is being dismantled in this way?
Matthew Pennycook
Mr. Speaker, I'll leave my ministerial colleagues in the Department of Energy Security and Net Zero to answer on the warm homes plan specifically, but I hope he would agree with me that when it comes to decency and safety and quality, this government have taken a number of steps: Awaab's law, a new decent homes standard, new minimum energy efficiency standards, and a new future homes standard. And I know he agrees with me that future homes standard should be kept in place, not abolished like the party opposite would have us do.
Martin Wrigley.
Minister.
Florence Eshalomi
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We are grateful to everyone who's opened their homes to Ukrainians. Over 1.8 billion pounds has supported the scheme.
Funding changes for Homes for Ukraine is sustainable. Thank you payments continue in recognition of the hosts' generosity, and host retention depends on individual decisions, and cannot be reliably estimated. And our councils retain the funding for rematching and homelessness prevention.
Martin Wrigley.
Martin Wrigley
Thank you, Mr Speaker. With the dropping of the thank you payment from £350 to £100 on January the 1st, many hosts find their costs are no longer being covered and are considering evicting their guests. Hosts and guests are being encouraged to move to a lodger scheme using the rent a room scheme. The going rate for a room, I'm told in my constituency, is around £600, and universal credit would pay a lot more than the 350 saved from the thank you payment. In addition, the Ukrainian guests would lose the available help from the local authority on moving on to a first private rental.
All in all, this reduction in the thank you payment looks likely to cost the state more than it might save and would reduce the help on offer to our Ukrainian guests. Will the minister meet with me and the local Ukrainian hosts, or would he prefer to think again, she prefer to think again, about this reduction?
Call the Minister.
Florence Eshalomi
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I thank the honourable gentleman for his question. The Government remains committed to supporting Ukrainians in the long term. The funding changes are designed to ensure that the long-term sustainability of the scheme, councils can retain flexibility for funding and rematching and looking at homelessness preventions. This includes helping guests to find accommodation and overcoming any private renting barriers.
Existing host arrangements can move to lodging or rental agreements, and we'll continue to monitor any issues around homelessness and work with councils to respond as emerging pressures exist.
Ben Goldsborough.
Jim McMahon
Thank you.
Standards in local government is important. The Localism Act requires every local authority in England to adopt a code of conduct that conforms to the Nolan principles. The government is committed to a whole-system reform of the local government standards framework to make it stronger and more efficient, including stronger sanctions, and we'll legislate when parliamentary time allows.
Ben Goldsborough.
Ben Goldsborough
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Despite concerns, Reform rushed through the appointment of Norfolk County Council's new CEO, Dennis Bacon. Thanks to Councillor Ben Weston, we now know that Mr. Bacon hosted senior Reform councillors at his luxury B&B the day before job applications opened. Norfolk Reform have failed on three Nolan principles: selflessness, integrity and objectivity.
Does my honourable friend agree with me that a slap-up meal shouldn't get you a £215,000 job?
Jim McMahon
Listen, the point he raises, it does raise concern, doesn't it? And I thank my honourable friend and also Councillor Ben Weston for raising this issue. I can't obviously get into the specifics of the case. Local authorities are independent employers and so individual employment decisions are a matter for them. But I will say I am concerned that in Reform councils there is a pattern of conduct and behaviour that we would not usually find acceptable and we should not allow to be normalised.
Lee Anderson.
Lee Anderson
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Kimber Business Solutions have secured over £1 million in project management fees from Ashfield District Council. Now, it turns out that one of the project managers is actually the son of the chief executive of Ashfield District Council.
Now I thank the Department for arranging an appointment this week. But does the Minister agree with me it's time now to send the commissioners in to Ashfield District Council? There's not a minute to spare.
Jim McMahon
The point he raises, I know he raised the same point at Prime Minister's Questions last week, is clearly concerning. There shouldn't be that type of conflict, and I can say and I think I've written to him today, so he should have a copy of the letter in his office, that we take this very seriously. I've asked our Department to conduct an urgent best-value assessment of the local authority, and I know that there are meetings taking place with officials and the council's chief executive to find out exactly what's going on.
Michelle Welsh.
Michelle Welsh
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Firstly, can I thank the minister for the intervention his department has made with the rapid best-value assessment at Ashfield District Council after response of my representation for the last two months. These are extremely serious allegations, and my constituents in Hucknall have been let down badly by the council. So will the minister confirm that urgent action is being taken? Can the minister say what more can be done to prevent further inappropriate decisions, especially on planning?
And does the minister agree with me, given the severity of the allegations, that it now warrants a referral to the police for an independent investigation?
Jim McMahon
Again, the member for Sherwood Forest has raised this on a number of occasions, actually, and hopefully she had a copy of my letter on Friday after raising this further.
This is a very serious issue that's been raised. In addition to the points I made about the rapid best value review and the conversations that have taken place with the council's chief executive, I can say that our officials will also be contacting the external auditor to understand more details of the case that she refers to.
Suella Braverman.
Suella Braverman
Mr Speaker, the Prime Minister has made clear that Labour councils should end their power-sharing agreements with local Green parties following the disgracefully anti-Semitic motion that the national Green Party passed that Zionism is racism. However, the Labour leader of Havant Borough Council has refused to condemn her Green Party coalition partners for supporting that motion and has refused to withdraw from this coalition.
Will the Minister agree that this is not only a breach of the Nolan principles, but will he also clarify who is right: the Prime Minister or the Labour leader of Havant Borough Council?
Jim McMahon
Well, needless to say, the Prime Minister is always right. Well, listen, we take no lectures from the party opposite on standards and conduct in local government. We get repeated complaints about the conduct of Reform-led councils across the country, in the way that they're treating their staff, the way that they treat each other, and the way that quite often the toxicity that we see online is brought into council chambers. So I'll take no lectures from that side.
Speaker 29
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The first of the Nolan principles is selflessness: acting solely in the public interest. But councillors across the country fed back that in the botched local government reorganisation process, they felt put under pressure to put political considerations first, pressure that came from the previous Secretary of State.
Now, the new Secretary of State has already told the House recently that she cannot say whether his decision making was even lawful. So, can she now tell the House whether the pressure that was put on those councillors to submit to his reorganisation agenda left them at risk of breaching the Nolan principles, as well as the law?
Jim McMahon
I can say to the shadow Minister that the only pressure that is on us is the pressure that we place on ourselves to do the job well. And as I said in the statement last week, there are no easy decisions on local government reorganisation, and there is no perfect solution to most counties in England. What the Government has to do is to balance competing interests and make sure that we objectively assess the evidence base supporting it, that we challenge where there might be gaps in the information being provided, and ultimately, we make the best possible decision, and that's what we'll run with.
Thank you, number five, sir.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr Speaker. The housing delivery test is an annual measurement of housing delivery in local planning authority areas over a rolling, historical three-year period. Chesterfield Borough Council achieved a HDT result of 168% last year, indicating very strong delivery against the number of homes the area requires.
Toby Perkins
I thank my honourable friend for sharing that good news. And in Chesterfield, we have a council that are keen to assist the Government in achieving those housing targets.
But in areas where there's been industrial blight historically, and coal mining as there has in Chesterfield, it is more expensive to bring some of these projects forward than in other areas without those challenges. The ability to achieve the housing targets in the east of our town were dependent on bringing forward the Staveley bypass, and we were disappointed to recently hear that wouldn't be going ahead at this stage. Can my honorable friend say how he is working with other government departments to ensure that the industrial blight of the past doesn't make these projects too expensive to bring forward in the future?
Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
I thank my honorable friend for his question. I know that his council wants to play its full part in our housebuilding ambitions. He will know that the Government provides financial support for essential infrastructure in areas of greatest housing demand. While he will know that I can't express an opinion on specific plans or schemes for the reasons I know he'll appreciate, my understanding is that Chesterfield Borough Council foresaw the site in question coming forward later in the plan period, and in light of the DfT's decision in respect of that particular transport upgrade, it may be that the authority needs to look again at the allocation when developing their next local plan. But I'm happy to discuss the matter with him further.
Chris Webb.
Minister.
Matthew Pennycook
Mr Speaker, the government is committed to improving protections for renters and owners of park homes. On the 5th of March this year, my department published a call for evidence with a view to establishing the rationale for the required payment of a commission of up to 10% of the sale price when a park home is sold. We continue to analyze the feedback received. I hope to be able to publish a detailed summary of responses in the near future, and as per the commitments I've previously given, we will set out the government's final position on this matter by the end of the year.
Christopher David Ward
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Tudor Rose Park in Peacehaven in my constituency is a park home with 107 residents. Many are elderly and vulnerable. All have suffered years of unfair charges, crumbling buildings and poor maintenance.
Just this morning at my surgery, two residents told me of, and I quote, "the despair, exploitation and intimidation many residents feel at the hands of owners of the park". Now, I know the minister is looking at this closely, so can he tell me, when will the government act to bring forward changes that will end the Wild West and park homes and protect my constituents in Tudor Rose Park?
Matthew Pennycook
Well, I thank my honorable friend for that question. I'm very sorry to hear about the experience of the park home owners and renters at Tudor Rose Park in his constituency. We are acting, not least in respect of the commission and, as I said, will confirm the government's final position on that matter by the end of the year. Mr. Speaker, park home residents who believe that they've been bullied or intimidated should contact the government-funded Leasehold Advisory Service for free, independent advice about their rights and the most appropriate course of action. I would like to meet with my honorable friend to hear a bit more about why some of the powers that local authorities have in this area, by the sounds of it, aren't working in this instance.
Mark Francois.
Mark Francois
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I have over half a dozen park home estates in my Rayleigh and Wickford constituency, so I welcome the fact that the minister and the government are reviewing whether or not to get rid of this 10% charge that park home owners have to pay if they sell their park home. No other property owner that I know of has to pay such a charge. My constituents feel very strongly that this is iniquitous, so on their behalf, can I make a submission to the review, that they'd be very grateful if the minister were to abolish it?
Matthew Pennycook
Well, I take that submission outside of the consultation period, but I'm sure we can gratefully accept it. I know there's a range of very strongly held views on this issue. The previous government looked at it, concluded it didn't have the necessary evidence and that we needed to go out again.
We've done that, but as I say, we will make a decision by the end of the year.
Catherine Fookes.
Jim McMahon
Thank you. 22 local authorities in Wales, including Monmouthshire, have received £34.5 million through the Pride in Place Impact Fund, resulting in over 200 projects to support high streets, public spaces and community facilities. The Pride in Place programme is also supporting £280 million to areas in Wales over the next 10 years with local communities deciding how the money should be spent, helping to restore pride in local places.
Catherine Fookes.
Catherine Fookes
I thank the minister for his answer and for the funding in Monmouthshire. And construction is beginning now at Caldicot skatepark. And I'm delighted it's just one project that Monmouthshire County Council is delivering and it's has been made possible by pride in place funding from this Labour government. We're also going to see new public toilets with Changing Places facilities in Abergavenny and Usk, improvements to Monmouth bus station and communal gardens at Thornwell in Chepstow. And I want to see, as I'm sure the minister does, all Monmouthshire towns thrive.
And I really hope that this is only the beginning. So can the minister tell me when more pride in place funding will be made available to Monmouthshire?
Jim McMahon
Can I thank my honourable friend for her question?
She is a fantastic champion for her constituency and she shows, actually, just what a difference a local MP can make when they have a real vision for their constituency and they support the local community to realise their potential. The Government is committed to making sure that communities across the UK have the tools that are needed to get things done in their area and, in addition to the Pride in Place funding programme, we've announced a further £210 million package to support high streets and community assets. While that relates to England, the Welsh Government also receives corresponding funding through the Barnett formula to allocate on its own priorities.
Florence Eshalomi
It is Ireland. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Responsibility for supported accommodation in Northern Ireland is devolved, as the honourable gentleman knows. In England, we are implementing the Supported Housing (Regulatory Oversight) Act 2023 to strengthen local oversight, improve quality, and ensure councils assess local needs, and we will continue to work with our devolved Governments.
Jim Shannon.
Jim Shannon
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank the Minister very much for her answer, and she probably knows what my question is going to be. Veterans across Northern Ireland and indeed across this United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland are suffering trauma. They're finding it very difficult to find accommodation. And as mental health is so complex, no two people have the same needs making a case-by-case assess assessment essential. So what discussions has the Minister been able to have with the relevant department in the Northern Ireland Assembly to ascertain what help can be given to veterans, but it's specifically the Barnett consequential I understand has set aside moneys for homelessness, so therefore there might be a methodology whereby we can help.
Florence Eshalomi
Minister. I thank the honourable gentleman for that question, and I think indeed I agree with him in terms of people suffering complex mental health needs and some of the issues our veterans face.
Each case has to be assessed on a case-by-case basis. I will come back to my original response in that, as the honourable gentleman knows, this is a devolved issue in Northern Ireland, but I'm always open and unable to look at learning and options that we can share across England to ensure that we end rough sleeping and homelessness for good.
Question number nine, Mr Speaker.
Matthew Pennycook
Thank you, Mr Speaker. The new National Planning Policy Framework, published on the 17th of August, includes a more flexible and proportionate pol- policy designed to provide greater clarity on the circumstances in which Article 4 directions may be appropriate, including where's where there's an over-concentration of small HMOs. We do want to ensure that councils can act properly to regulate HMOs where it's necessary to protect the amenity or wellbeing of an area, and we will continue to keep the powers to regulate HMOs under review.
Antonia Kay Bance
Thank you, Mr Speaker. I thank the Minister for his answer.
Residents in Wednesbury and Tipton are absolutely sick of family homes being turned into HMOs and now that is getting more difficult, into supported exempt accommodation, too. Now, I've campaigned on for more controls on HMOs since the day I was elected, but supported exempt accommodation is essentially unregulated, so when will this government bring in further controls on supported exempt accommodation?
Matthew Pennycook
I thank my honorable friend for her question and for all of her campaigning to ensure that an article 4 direction is finally being introduced in Sandwell. In respect of supported accommodation, Mr. Speaker, we published guidance for local authorities earlier this year on developing supported housing strategies. On the 15th of October, we launched a consultation on draft regulations for a supported housing licensing regime. That consultation closed on the 10th of December. My honorable friend the Minister for Homelessness, who is responsible for this policy area, will, I am sure, have heard the calls to expedite their laying.
Gagan Mohindra
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Earlier this year, Liberal Democrat run Three Rivers District Council put in a notice for an Article 4. However, that won't come into effect until June 2027, citing financial concerns. Despite repeated calls from myself and local conservative councillors to do it sooner and protect my residents from overcrowded, unwanted HMOs, what advice can the minister offer my residents, such as those who live at Moorfield Road in South Oxhey, who have been already been affected by this issue?
Matthew Pennycook
I thank the honourable gentleman for his question. HMOs, all of them are obviously subject to management regulations. Local authorities must license HMOs in certain cases. But an Article 4 direction is often the way for local planning authorities to get control, by the sounds of it should have come a lot earlier in his local area.
Speaker 53
Mr Speaker, many communities, including in my constituency in Erith and Thamesmead, are concerned about the concentration of HMOs. There is a perception that local authorities do not have the powers to be able to tackle this. So Mr Speaker, I want to be very clear that I'm not against HMOs in principle. It's about how they're abused. So I know the government has carried out a consultation, but does the government feel that local authorities are able to strike the balance right when meeting the housing needs and also maintaining community cohesion?
Matthew Pennycook
I thank my honourable friend and constituency neighbour for that question. Mr Speaker, we do keep the powers to regulate HMOs under review.
I do want to know from any member of the House where local authorities don't think those powers are adequate. But what I would say is the key to ensuring that HMOs are properly regulated, particularly where it's necessary to protect the amenity or well-being of an area, the best way is to ensure there are strong policies in an up-to-date local plan and I know that our local authority is putting those strong policies in place in our area.
Wera Hobhouse.
Benedicta Wera Hobhouse
Mr. Speaker, yes, HMOs are the only way many young people can afford to rent, but their unregulated growth leads to the loss of family homes. Bath Council has taken action and included in its draft local plan a ban on the conversion of homes, and which was otherwise be the loss of three-bedroom homes in Southdown, Twerton, and Oldfield. Will the Minister congratulate Bath Council?
Matthew Pennycook
Well, I will congratulate her local authority.
As I say, it is through up-to-date local plans and strong policies on HMO that they can ensure they are properly regulated. After all, development plans are the basis on which decision-makers, irrespective of whether they're officers or committees, will make their decisions, and there is good practice out there in the country, including my own local authority area as I said, and I'd encourage any local planning authority with concerns to familiarize themselves with that good practice.
Lewis Cocking.
Shadow minister.
Lewis Cocking
Thank you, Mr Speaker. To residents across the country, a standard family home being converted into a HMO for a large number of adults is a material change. It changes the character of an area, and it places pressure on parking and local services. And too many HMOs are being used to house people who come to this country illegally, and we know for a fact that many of these men are dangerous. But the current rules do not reflect the negative impact a HMO can have, with landlords not needing to apply for planning permission if it's for less than five occupants, and the article 4 direction does not go far enough.
What work is the minister doing to investigate changing the rules so that all HMOs, regardless of size, require planning permission so that local people's voices can be heard?
Matthew Pennycook
I feel for the Shadow Minister in the sense that question was clearly drafted before the set of answers I've just given. We have acted to strengthen we have acted to strengthen national planning policy in this area. I've made clear how important it is to have up-to-date local plans in place to get those strong policies. If he's got any particular instances of where the existing powers don't go far enough, more than happy to hear from him.
Sonia Kumar.
Secretary of State.
Angela Rayner
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Alongside the budget, we announced our new cross-government high streets strategy to breathe new life into our town centres.
This was backed by £210 million, Mr Speaker, of new funding to reinvent our high streets with new shops, public services and community spaces. And my honourable friend is a tireless campaigner for her high streets and the traders in her constituency, and I'm aware, and I'm pleased that she managed to get £3 million secured for Dudley for our derelict buildings fund.
Sonia Kumar.
Sonia Kumar
Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I'd like to thank the Secretary of State for her answer. I know that Dudley high street has enormous potential to thrive and prosper once again. Yet years of inaction from the Conservative-led council has left too many empty shops on our high street and too many businesses struggling. So, can my right honourable friend outline what steps the Labour government is taking to revitalise the area and reverse the trends of empty shops dominating our high street?
Angela Rayner
Well, Mr Speaker, she's absolutely right to talk about the years of failure by the Conservatives where we saw boarded-up shops, closed pubs and places feeling in decline. We're turning the page with a £125 million fund that will be invested to bring derelict buildings back into use for the community, like abandoned cinemas and shopping centres. And we're putting power back, Mr Speaker, in the hands of local communities like Dudley so that they can have a real say over what their high street looks like.
Jim McMahon
Thank you. We're giving local leaders and communities more control over their high street, makes the shops and their high streets through the hope on the high streets strategy that the Secretary of State has just referred to.
We're also consulting on requiring planning permission for new vape shops and on a new licensing regime for vape shops and tobacco retailers, and the budget confirmed that we'll remove business rate relief from vape shops and adult gaming centres to better target these reliefs at businesses that support thriving high streets. Furthermore, we're investing £30 million in funding per year for agencies like Trading Standards to tackle these dodgy shops.
Robbie Moore.
Robbie Moore
Thank you, Mr Speaker. This year alone, West Yorkshire Trading Standards have raided 20 premises in Keighley. They've seized illegal and counterfeit goods, but yet residents watch those same dodgy shops reopen within days. And our local trading standards have received well over 3,000 intelligence reports about dodgy shops such as mini-marts, vape shops, takeaways, barbers, with reports linked to money laundering, drug supplying, modern slavery and illegal working, and this is just within Keighley.
So, why, despite this government's rhetoric of wanting to take a tough stance on this issue, was West Yorkshire Trading Standards not included in the latest round of funding to support local trading standards with law enforcement action against organized criminal activity? And will the minister look to resolve this issue?
Jim McMahon
Minister. Well, I think the point he raises is exactly why the government is taking action. I think people look on the way that our high streets and town centres have been transformed, and they see in plain sight that something just isn't right. They see the type of convenience stores that he's talking about, the barber shops and the vape shops, and they know, like we know, that what's going on inside those premises is not lawful, and the connection to human trafficking and other illegal activity is quite clear from the investigations that have been taking place. The additional funding that we provided is about targeting it where to where the assessed need was.
But to be clear, every police force and every trading standards department should be prioritizing this as a matter of course. Melanie Onn.
Melanie Onn
Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker. The Minister will be aware of my campaign to shut down dodgy shops that's got the support of over 60 MPs in the House, and I'm aware that the Government has taken steps to extend the powers available to local authorities that has finally seen my local authority take steps to shut down one shop. There are many more that they can come for in the coming days. Interestingly, when the Conservatives were in power, they changed the rules for trading standards to require them to give 48 hours notice before they visit some premises. Is the Government looking at changing that in order that there can be more activity taken by trading standards where shops are then not prepared?
Jim McMahon
Well, I think she raises a fair point here. I think there is a world of difference between a routine trading standards visit that is about assessing routine compliance and not giving criminals, organised criminals, a heads up to clear the store out of any evidence that might be in place. So I'll certainly take away the point that she raises and confirm in writing next steps, and also to put on record my thanks for the work that she's been doing on this for a long time.
Angela Rayner
Thank you, Mr Speaker. With your permission, I'll take questions 12 and 22 together. The Government will introduce the commonhold and leasehold reform Bill this year, making marking the beginning of the end of the feudal leasehold system. We will continue implementing the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act of 2024 as quickly as possible and will bring forward further legislation for the independent statutory regulation of property agents.
Secretary of State.
Gregory James Stafford
Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. I recently met constituents in Grayshott and in Haslemere who face poor communication from managing agents, little transparency over where their service charges and costs are going that they're forced to pay. Meanwhile Surrey and Hampshire are set to lose out under the government's funding review, leaving many of those same residents facing higher council tax bills. So will the Secretary of State finally tell us when the Leasehold Reform Bill will be published, and can she give a guarantee that any savings delivered through that reform will not simply be wiped out by higher council tax bills caused by her government's own funding decisions?
Angela Rayner
Well, Mr Speaker, first of all, we've promised that we'll bring that legislation forward soon, and that should be happening before, possibly for a Christmas present, Mr Speaker, you never know. You never know. And in terms of council tax, Mr Speaker, council tax went up every single year under the Conservatives. They left local government without the funds that they needed.
What we've done is funded councils on the basis of need. We support the councils Mr. Speaker, the party opposite didn't.
Elizabeth Helen Hayes
Leaseholders living on Barington Road and St James's Crescent in my constituency in buildings owned by Metropolitan Thames Valley Housing Association and built by contractor Guildmore have been trapped in limbo for more than four years, unable to sell and worried about fire safety while MTVH and Guildmore continue to argue between themselves about who is responsible for fire safety defects in the building and who will complete the remediation and who will pay for it.
There is still no plan or timescale and communication has stalled and the last substantive update I received was it back in May of this year. So, can I ask my honourable my right honourable friend for her personal support and intervention in unlocking this completely unacceptable dispute so that my constituents can at last sleep soundly in their homes and make plans for their future?
Angela Rayner
Mr Speaker, the building safety crisis must be resolved. Homes must be made safe, and resident residents must be allowed to move on with their lives. We brought forward the remediation acceleration plan, and I was in the House only last week, but I'm happy to meet with the Member and Mr Speaker, I've met with many different organisations as part of this, because what they're some are doing well, but most of them not good enough.
Andrew Cooper.
Matthew Pennycook
Mr Speaker, the government remain determined to revive the dream of home ownership.
At the budget last week, the Chancellor confirmed £4.7 billion for the Your First Home scheme, providing equity loans to help those who can't rely on the bank of mum and dad to buy their first home. In the budget, the Chancellor also announced a new first-time buyer ISA and reduced the Lifetime ISA withdrawal charge to 20%.
Drew Cooper.
Andrew Graham Cooper
Thank you, Mr Speaker. House prices in Mid Cheshire are nearly £20,000 higher than the regional average, and have continued to rise over the last year. The Your First Home scheme will be a big help for my constituents, but it's also important that we increase the number of affordable homes being built. The National Housing Federation estimated that in the latest round of the Social and Affordable Homes Programme, it we could have delivered an additional 41,000 homes outside London. What steps is he taking to increase the funding available to the Social and Affordable Homes Programme in the early years of the programme?
Matthew Pennycook
I thank my honourable friend for that question.
As he'll be aware, the Chancellor committed an additional £1.5 billion for the Social and Affordable Homes Programme at the budget last week, taking its total allocation to over £40 billion. In August, Mr Speaker, we announced initial funding allocations for the programme, with 9.58 billion being awarded to 33 strategic partners outside London. Over £16 billion of pounds remains over the lifetime of the programme outside London. Homes England will, of course, confirm scheme by scheme allocations via the continuous market engagement route in the usual way.
Vikki Slade.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Mr Speaker. I welcome the government's focus on first-time buyers as so many young people that can't get their first step on the ladder. But my concern is that very often the properties that are being built not on the green belt, but on areas that are, you know, within town centre boundaries, the first-time buyer properties are being manipulated out of the system in the same way as affordable homes have been on green belt.
I know the government has done some stuff around green belt rules, the golden rules, but what are they doing to ensure we have first-time buyer homes on every development?
Matthew Pennycook
I thank the honourable lady for her question. I'm not sure I quite understand what she means by homes being manipulated out of the system. I'm more than happy to sit down with her and have a conversation about it.
Paula Barker.
Matthew Pennycook
Mr Speaker, with permission, I'll take questions 14 and 16 together. Our transformative Renters' Rights Act is changing the experience of private renting for millions of tenants across England, not least by empowering them to challenge unfair or above-market rent increases.
Paula Barker.
Paula Barker
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
In Liverpool Wavertree research by Crisis and Zoopla show just 3% of homes for private rent are affordable for people who claim Local Housing Allowance. The OBR has warned that the increase in tax on property income announced in the budget could feed through into rents making an increase in LHA more necessary than ever. What discussions has the minister had with colleagues in other departments on that, and rent regulation linked to inflation and wages to ensure the pressure on private renters and reduce the cost of increasing LHA?
Matthew Pennycook
I thank my honourable friend for that question. At the budget last year, Mr Speaker, the OBR assessed that there would only be a small impact on rental prices of 0.2% as a result of the two percentage point increase to property rates from April 2027. We expect that the further two percentage point increase announced in the budget last week will have a comparably small effect. Households who need additional support can apply to their local authority for help via the Crisis and Resilience Fund. On rent controls, Mr Speaker, as my honourable friend knows, the government does not support their introduction.
Sam Carling.
Samuel Carling
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Too often, constituents contact me about horrific behaviour from private landlords and lettings agents, including one lady who told me recently she'd been left with broken heating for 6 months and her daughter developed pneumonia as a result. Adding insult to injury, the lettings agency has continually refused to provide contact details of my constituent's landlord to her, in violation of the law. So, can the Secretary of State set out what this Labour government is doing to crack down on rogue landlords and lettings agencies that are totally failing in their responsibilities?
Matthew Pennycook
I thank my honourable friend for his question. I'm really sorry to learn that his constituents have been so badly treated by their landlord.
Through our Renters' Rights Act, we've strengthened the enforcement powers of local authorities in respect of relevant breaches and offences and we're extending Awaab's Law and the decent homes standard to that sector. We also, as the Secretary of State just mentioned, intend to legislate to regulate property agents, including by requiring agents to obtain a licence to do the job and appropriate qualifications to operate.
Paul Stephen Barclay
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Jim Shannon. The Independent Office for Budget Responsibility in their Economic and Fiscal Outlook published alongside the budget say at page 77 that the consequence of the 4p hike on property income tax will be fewer rental properties and higher rents as landlords pass on those costs. Why does the Minister think the OBR is wrong or if not is he accepting that rents will go up as a result of these measures?
Matthew Pennycook
Well, I refer the right honourable gentleman to my opening remarks. At the budget last year, the OBR assessed that there would be a small impact, 0.2%, on rental prices as a result of their increase.
We expect a similarly small impact from this increase. The obvious answer to affordability challenges in the private rented sector, as well as everywhere else, is to build more housing supply, which is why it is so disappointing that honorable members on the Benches opposite, despite what their Front Bench say, consistently complain about new housing developments coming forward in their constituencies.
Sir Desmond Swayne.
Desmond Swayne
The question is about reducing the cost of renting. So, what is the contribution of the 4% to a reduction in the cost of renting? Mr Speaker, my interest is in the register.
Matthew Pennycook
Well, affordability, as I've said to the right honorable gentleman, is dependent on a number of factors. Ultimately, the only way we bring affordability down is to increase the supply of new homes, and so I look forward to his full-throated support for new housing developments in his constituency.
Jim McMahon
Thank you. Under this Labour Government, rural authorities in England will see a total increase in core spending power of £958 million from 24/25 to 28/29, an increase of 21.1%. As a result of the fair funding reforms, nine in 10 councils will receive funding that broadly matches their assessed relative need by the end of the multi-year settlement, up from around a third before the reforms took place.
Helen Morgan.
Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan
Thank you very much, Mr Speaker.
Shropshire Council is in receipt of exceptional financial support following 16 years of disastrous Conservative mismanagement and a settlement from the government that reduces their central allocation over the next 3 years. The issue they have is that any council tax rises that they go for in future will only cover the repayment terms of that exceptional financial support and won't allow for any financial restructuring. Will the minister meet with me to discuss the terms of the exceptional financial support, because we're clearly in an unsustainable situation?
Jim McMahon
Well, as I said, the average rural council will see an increase of core spending power of 21.1%, and Shropshire itself sees an increase of 13.8%. But I do get, for those councils that find themselves in need of exceptional financial support, that they are at the point of which they do need government to stand behind them in one form or another. So, I'd be very happy to meet with her and talk in further detail about what more we can do. Markus Campbell-Savours.
Markus Campbell-Savours
Speaker, in rural Cumbria, those without a car struggle to access education and jobs. It's why families on the lowest incomes prioritise car ownership.
However, our councils lost out on significant financial support because funding formulas used car ownership as a determinant of income. Can the Secretary of State carry out a review of this approach and maybe ask if civil servants privileged enough to travel to work on one of the world's finest public transport systems have given us duff advice?
Jim McMahon
The fair funding review deliberately took into account the different types of local authorities that were funded through the settlement, whether they're London authorities, urban authorities, coastal communities or rural communities. And what we did for the first time was to make sure that deprivation was being picked on the on in the funding formula. And the level at which that we do that is in the hundreds of households, not in thousands or tens of thousands. And the idea of that is that we can really hone down on where deprivation exists right across the country.
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
Angela Rayner
There is nothing duff in the budget last week, Mr. Speaker. It delivers a major boost to council housing, with an additional 1.5 billion pounds for Social and Affordable Homes Programme, and this investment will take the total funding for the programme to more than 40 billion pounds, Mr. Speaker, over 10 years.
Clare Young.
Claire Louise Young
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The Housing Minister promised me in January protection from fleecehold exploitation in this Parliament. I think the government is running out of time, so when can my constituents in freeholds expect unfair service charges to be properly regulated?
Angela Rayner
Again, Mr. Speaker, I said this earlier, I'm hoping for an early Christmas present for the honorable lady, where we will set out our leasehold bill, and hopefully by the end of this Parliament we'll be able, with the secondary legislation, to get things through.
Toby Perkins.
Toby Perkins
Thank you, Mr Speaker. In Chesterfield, we've already made good progress in building council homes. We have plans for 89 new homes over the next 3 years. But the council tell me that they need access to lower-cost, longer-term borrowing. So can my right honorable friend tell me any ways the Government can help the council get access to that lower, long- longer-term, lower-cost borrowing?
Matthew Pennycook
Well, I can say to my honorable friend that the Chancellor extended the preferential Public Works Loan Board rates for a further year until '27/'28 in the budget, we'll continue to keep under review what more we can do to help councils once again build at scale.
Katie Lam
Last month, it was reported that money from the department's Community Recovery Fund had been funneled to explicitly partisan groups, including to train activists on how to influence the public to make them pro-migration and against the Conservative party, which was named in training materials. Can the Secretary of State please explain how on earth taxpayer money was spent on this kind of partisan political activity?
Angela Rayner
Well, Mr. Speaker, I'm not aware of the government spending money on partisan-type material. I'm happy for her to send me, I think she might have written to me on this recently and I'm happy to respond to that.
Katie Lam
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I thank the Secretary of State for her answer.
In a department-issued in a statement issued by the department last month, we were told that this money, which has been spent on partisan political campaigning, can be recovered if used improperly, but that's not the same as doing it.
So, will the Secretary of State confirm that she will investigate and recoup every penny of taxpayer money funneled to those partisan groups, either directly or through instructing councils?
Lloyd Hatton.
Lloyd Hatton
The Riviera Hotel is an iconic building overlooking Weymouth, but its current Saudi Arabia-based owners have let it fall into woeful disrepair.
What was once a thriving hotel is now turning into an absolute eyesore.
And while Dorset Council is doing its utmost to convene a reasonable sale, we can and must do more.
Will the Minister meet with us to explore every option, including compulsory purchase as a backstop, to bring this hotel back into local hands?
Matthew Pennycook
Mr. Speaker, local authorities have powers to take action where a designated heritage asset has deteriorated to the extent that its preservation may be at risk. These powers include carrying out urgent works to preserve a listed building, requiring an owners carry out repairs and, if appropriate, compulsory purchase. I'm more than happy to meet my honorable friend to discuss these powers further.
John Cooper.
John Cooper
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. This Government is facilitating a property grab by allowing councils to seize properties that have been left vacant for as little as six months. Rather than stealing properties, wouldn't the Secretary of State be better using the powers of state to cut regulation, cut taxes and get more houses built?
Jim McMahon
The fact is that there is not a community in the country, a high street or town center in any part of the country, that isn't blighted by buildings that stubbornly will not be brought back into use. And it's right, if the owners aren't willing to take action, that we do.
Josh Newbury.
Josh Newbury
Thank you, Mr Speaker. This summer's wildfire showed us how incredible, but also how stretched our firefighters are. Their ability to prepare for and confront fires and floods will only match the ferocity of what they're facing if we in this House do our part. So following the budget and ahead of the spending review, will MHCLG make strong representations to the Treasury so that wildfire risk can be taken into account when fire and rescue budgets are set?
Florence Eshalomi
I agree with my honourable friend. Our firefighters worked tirelessly to protect lives, homes and critical infrastructure during the wildfires this summer, and they responded on that, and they should have the equipment to respond to this risk.
That's why the Government recently announced the 45 million investment for wildfire-specific PPE for firefighters in England and a UK-wide aerial capability at the wildfire summit last month. We'll continue to engage with the Treasury post-budget and ahead of the next spending review to ensure that we are working towards meeting the needs of fire and rescue services.
Tim Farron.
Timothy James Farron
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Westmorland and Furness Council is England's most rural unitary authority, but the Government's new formula means that we have been punished for being rural with a crushing 31% cut in our funding, putting care homes, help for the homeless, and support for schools all at risk. Does the Secretary of State think that this is fair? And will she revisit this travesty urgently and provide urgent emergency support?
Jim McMahon
Well, I know he's raised this a number of times before and the answer is the same as before, which is that the fair funding review, for the first time, took into account the assessed need in each area, the resource available by each council to meet that need, and where government had to act as equaliser to the system. And that's what we've done. But if there are examples of where it's not quite working and the application isn't as it is meant to be, then I'm happy to receive representations and happy to meet the honourable member.
Claire Hazelgrove
Number 17. Oh, thank you, Mr Speaker. My constituent, Mr Welch, and his sister have been left completely trapped by the death of their mother last year. Despite slashing their price for the assisted living flat from £200,000 down to £60,000, the market has collapsed and the flat remains unsaleable with a £1,300-a-month service charge risking wiping out their savings. Will the minister urgently review the guidance and support available to bereaved executors in this position and meet with me to discuss recourse available to families like this?
Matthew Pennycook
I'm really sorry to hear about the situation that Mr Welsh and his sister find themselves in following the death of their mother last year. Our reforms to the leasehold system, Mr Speaker, will make service charges more transparent and easier to challenge, and I can assure her that work is under way in the department to better understand the market around poor resale values. I'd be happy to meet her to discuss.
Michael Peter Martin
Bob Blackman. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Recently, I visited Standing Joint Command in Aldershot. SJC are responsible for coordinating military support to the civil power, working through local resilience forums and councils. What conversations has the Secretary of State had with the Cabinet Office and the MoD to make sure that devolution and LGR strengthen resilience of the country rather than weaken it?
Jim McMahon
Yeah. So, the department will support local councils going through the transition through local government reorganisation to make sure that those partnerships are maintained.
And I should say that the Local Government Association have a good toolkit available for councils to make sure that the transition is managed in the way that he speaks.
Kim Johnson.
Kim Marie Johnson
Thank you, Mr Speaker. For decades, Liverpool has lived with the consequences of Thatcher sell-off of council housing and the large scale stock transfer of properties, leaving too many families without secure and genuinely affordable homes. Mersey, Rotheram's North Docks Mayoral Development Corporations that sell out a bold vision with strong public backings.
public backing, will the Minister back the work of the MDC to support a large-scale council house building to reverse the legacy of the past and tackle the housing crisis?
Matthew Pennycook
I know the Mayor is consulting on that Mayoral Development Corporation, so I won't prejudice that consultation by giving my view on it, but in general, Mr Speaker, the Government absolutely supports the use of Mayoral Development Corporations and locally-led development corporations as a means to master plan, assemble land, and regenerate areas.
Dr Kieran Mullan. I'm doing a few.
John Kieran Mullan
Mr Speaker. Mr Speaker, in Bexhill and across the country, homeowners are being fleeced out of thousands of pounds by a company called Asset Invest Limited that bought titles with restrictive covenants affecting thousands of homes for just £1. This exploitative practice has to stop. Will the Minister agree to meet with me and a cross-party group of MPs who want to see the new Leasehold Bill bring forward better protections for homeowners in this terrible situation?
Matthew Pennycook
Mr Speaker, the honourable gentleman has been campaigning on this issue for a long time. I recognise his concerns. I'm more than happy to meet him. He should have had that confirmation already, but I can give it to him on the floor of the House now.
Naushabah Khan.
Naushabah Khan
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
Hundreds of people are being placed in my constituency in Gillingham and Rainham by London councils, moved away from their support networks through out-of-borough placements and without proper notification. Often, these are vulnerable families with high needs which then have to be met by overstretched services at Medway Council. Will the minister meet with me to discuss how we can improve this system and support the authorities that are dealing with the bulk of out-of-borough placements?
Florence Eshalomi
I thank my honourable friend for raising that. This is an issue that many honourable members have raised in terms of local authorities using their TA discharge narrative, and I'm happy to meet with her and other members to discuss this further.
Paul Holmes.
Paul Holmes
Since I last asked the minister about the Liberal Democrats' £620 million worth of debt at Eastleigh Borough Council, it's got bigger, and now external auditors have said there have been financial misstatements and a lack of management financially. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And now the government have given them £150 million for social housing.
What will it take for this minister to come down on Eastleigh Borough Council and get that debt down?
Jim McMahon
Well, we have a established best-value regime that assesses all councils objectively based on the evidence, and of course, the audit position is one of the matters that we take very seriously. I'll confirm in writing exactly where we're up to with that local authority. But to be clear, just because the state of that local authority is in the way that he describes, does not mean that the community that it serves should be denied funding.
Dr. Marie Tidball.
Marie Tidball
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
For over a year, I've argued for changes to Sheffield's local plan, a fairer distribution of green belt sites across the authority, greater use of brownfield sites, high streets and retail spaces, densification on transport routes, and a better application of the government's golden rules and strengthened powers to utilize long-term empty properties to ease the pressure on Grenoside, Chapeltown and Ecclesfield. Consequently, I'm calling for a pause to the local plan process, especially so that new evidence demonstrating that all of the green belt parcels in my constituency are now assessed as containing our best agricultural land, including Town End Farm. Will the minister meet with me and Sheffield colleagues to discuss the local plan to ensure that Sheffield builds more homes, especially the social and affordable homes we need?
Matthew Pennycook
Mr Speaker, due to my quasi-judicial role in the planning system, I can't comment on the detail of the emerging plan. I'm afraid I can't meet her to discuss it. The plan, the sites included in it, and the proposed main modifications have been subject to several rounds of consultations throughout the examination process.
It is for the independent inspectors to consider the responses to the consultations and set out next steps.
Liz Roberts.
Liz Roberts
Following this summer's wildfires, we saw that devolution of fire policy was no barrier to mutual aid cooperation between the UK government and Welsh government. Could the Minister tell me how any additional air fighting, fire fighting capability will be allocated fairly across the nations of the United Kingdom?
Angela Rayner
Well, Mr Speaker, can I commend the fire services across Wales, and across England, and Scotland with the challenges that faced over, and I know that the aerial support was needed in Wales, and we looked at that as part of the wildfire summit that we had, and we'll continue to work with them. But that aerial support will be available across the UK so that people can use it when they need it.
Assaf.
Speaker 106
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
A week ago, three blocks of flats in Canning Town underwent emergency evacuation after serious structural flaws were found. A further two blocks have subsequently been evacuated, and with over 300 flats now evacuated, no timeline or indication of when this will be resolved, when residents can return, this is causing a huge amount of distress and serious financial worry. Can I ask my honourable friends if they can take whatever action they can to help resolve this appalling situation, with a particular eye on support for the families and businesses who have been displaced?
Florence Eshalomi
Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I can recognise how distressing this situation will be for the many residents who've had to leave their homes with that fear of evacuation and that building collapsing. The buildings have been evacuated following the defects identified by transfer slabs. My officials are supporting the London Borough of Newham and the right to manage companies and are engaging with the developer, Galliard, and the warranty providers to ensure that they respond to this situation as swiftly as possible.
Julian Lewis
How does the abolition of a rural district council like New Forest and its absorption into a unitary authority dominated by an urban center like Southampton increase devolution and local democracy?
Jim McMahon
Obviously, we take decisions on local government reorganisation on a county-by-county basis. When we're in a position to issue a minded to notice, we explain at length why we've, how we have balanced those competing interests to get the right balance. I accept his point, you know, the identity of place matters and places that are urban have quite a different character and economy than those that are rural. And by and large, I think we try and strike that balance well in the decisions that are taken.
Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Earlier this year, a young puppy was found in South Derbyshire, with its suspected mother discovered in squalid conditions on a farm in Derbyshire Dales alongside numerous other dogs, some of which were dead. The conditions were so horrific that one environmental officer was physically sick. This incident has stayed with and haunted me and the member for Derbyshire Dales, particularly given that the environmental team officer was subsequently suspended and dismissed after putting animal welfare first. So, will the minister meet with us to discuss how we can empower local authorities to prioritise animal welfare without fear of jurisdictional disputes, conflicting local policies, or the risk of prosecution failure?
Jim McMahon
She makes a very important point, actually, about the wide, varied role of local government and just how connected it is to communities. And I know that actually many local authorities take pride in reaching the gold standard from animal welfare charities. Well, I'd be very happy to take up the point that she raised and maybe respond in writing.
Kit Malthouse.
Kit Malthouse
Thank you, sir. As the housing and planning minister knows, I've had some frankly outrageous decisions by the Planning Inspectorate within the national landscape within my constituency over the last few months. So, from the dispatch box, could he please confirm for the benefit of all those planning inspectors out there that his intention in the latest edition of the NPPF is to strengthen protections for our national landscapes?
Matthew Pennycook
What I will do for the right honorable gentleman is go away and review whether further guidance for the Planning Inspectorate in this particular area would be helpful.
Sarah Smith.
Madeleine Sarah Smith
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Hyndburn has incredibly high levels of HMOs, which is driving up rents, taking family homes off the market and causing an increase in vulnerable people moving to our community.
How is the Government acting to enable councils like Hyndburn to reduce HMOs in their areas?
Matthew Pennycook
I thank my honourable friend for her question. She may have seen my answers to a previous question setting out how we've strengthened the national planning policy framework in this area, and more than happy to discuss with her areas particular policy where her council may think more powers are required.
Adrian Ramsay.
Adrian Philip Ramsay
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Suffolk County Council is proposing significant cuts to its healthy child services. This is deeply worrying to new parents like Chloe, who became a mother at 18 and, without the help of family, relied on the young parent pathway to develop the skills and knowledge to raise her baby boy. What assessment has the Department made of the positive impact of the healthy child services, and will the Minister intervene to protect these vital services?
Jim McMahon
Well the government doesn't intervene on individual budget-setting decisions by local authorities. We also recognize that authorities at a local level are doing their best to try and wrestle competing interests in huge demand areas like adults, children's, SEND and temporary accommodation. What I will say, though, is he rightly points out the success of that program, and I hope that all councils really do look to make sure that the impact of the budget decisions are being adequately managed when it comes to the community impact.
Callum Anderson
Does the minister share my disappointment, due to the political game-playing by the Central Bedfordshire council leader, that Milton Keynes and Bedfordshire will have to wait to enjoy the benefits of devolution, and can he set out how this government will be working to ensure that constituencies like mine will not miss out on the investment and opportunities that it promised?
Speaker 119
The government is determined to make sure we have strategic authorities everywhere by the end of 2028, and myself and other ministers in the department will work with him and council leaders from across the region to make sure that they also get a strategic authority in that time as well.
Lincoln Jopp
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. The West Surrey unitary authority wrote to the Secretary of State asking her to change the name of that authority from West Surrey to West Surrey and South Middlesex, a move that I thoroughly support. The local government minister wrote back to them and said, it's none to do with me, just change your name yourself. Would the minister like to confirm what his spokesman said to the BBC, that the West Surrey Council has the power to change its own name to include Middlesex if it chooses to do so, and we have set that out to them in a letter?
Jim McMahon
Well, as explained in the letter, it's not for the Secretary of State to determine the names of local authorities. Local authorities have the legal right and ability to change them themselves. So, my advice is crack on with it.
Perran Moon
Meuras, Mr. Speaker. The budget brought welcome news for Cornwall last week, recognising our national minority status through a Cornwall-only single foundation strategic status without a mayor. While I understand the principle of a mayro-combined authority with a single figurehead to sit above several authorities, does the minister agree that it would be a pointless waste of taxpayers' money to establish a mayor in parallel with one single strategic authority?
Speaker 119
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. And we had an excellent meeting with Cornwall leaders and MPs in Number 10 North not long before that decision was taken. And I thank him for his contribution to that and understand the distinct status that Cornwall has.
And we'll continue to work with him to make sure that Cornwall can make the most of their FSA in the future.
Ayoub Khan.
Ayoub Khan
Mr Speaker, Birmingham City Council is now officially out of bankruptcy. So, will the Government remove the Government-appointed commissioners, which are costing the taxpayers millions of pounds, money that could be better used elsewhere?
Jim McMahon
The involvement of commissioners in any local authority, or envoys for that matter, are a last resort after all else has failed, so no Government takes the interventions on in a light way. And we also want to make sure that there's an exit for intervention, and actually, we've proven that in Liverpool and other places that where the council shows sustained improvement, we are happy to review that. But I will say, although Birmingham has taken significant steps at improvement, there are still steps yet to take.
Sean Woodcock
Thank you very much, Mr Speaker.
I welcome the news last week that local government reorganisation will finally be taking place in Oxfordshire and that the Thames Valley will have devolution. However, can the Minister confirm that it's the intention of this Government that the new, these new authorities will all be in place by the end of this Parliament?
Jim McMahon
So, it's our intention that all the local government reorganisation areas have an election in '28 and have a vesting day of April '29.
Gillian Keegan.
Marie Goldman
Mr Speaker, the issue of restrictive covenants raised so ably by the honourable Member for Bexhill and Battle is also affecting my Taunton constituents, some of whom have been extorted out of tens of thousands of pounds. Will the Government give any comfort to the residents who are campaigning so hard on this that the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill will have provisions in this to stop this awful practice?
Matthew Pennycook
I thank the honourable lady for that question. As she may be aware, we are looking through that legislation to introduce caps on administration and permission fees that may help some of the residents affected by it. I'd be grateful if she could write to me and set out a bit more detail about how it's issues affecting her constituents.
Euan Stainbank
Further to the planning powers and the rate relief exemptions announced in the budget last week, what does my honourable friend's department define as a vape shop?
Jim McMahon
Well, I would hope that the clue's in the name really: it's a shop that primarily sells vapes.
Daniel Danny Rayner Kruger
Thank you, Mr Speaker, thank you.
Swindon and Wiltshire councils are building a lot of new housing, which is excellent, but the Government has now abolished an essential safeguard for communities against inappropriate planning, which is the power of councillors to call in applications. What steps is the Government taking to review that particular measure and will they reconsider if it turns out that it's not working?
Matthew Pennycook
I'd say to the honorable gentleman that particular reform was only commenced on Saturday. We have already committed to review it after a 2-year period, and that's what we'll do.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Jane Kirkham. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. DCMS is bringing out a short-term let registration scheme in March. Unfortunately, due to data protection rules, this can't be more of a licensing scheme, so owners of properties are not obliged to file liability insurance documents or fire safety documents. DCMS tell me that MHCLG will be the department who can actually do this and set up a licensing scheme.
Is it something he will consider?
Jim McMahon
So, we're bringing forward legislation for the overnight visitor levy and a central part of that is to make sure that all short-term lets are on the register, and that we know in a sense who should pay that taxation in areas where the mayoral foundation authority agrees that. So, we are in conversations with DCMS about what the register needs to look like and its implementation.
Ian Roome
Now that the Government have withdrawn plans for local government reorganisation in Devon, the law still requires councils like North Devon to change from a committee system to a cabinet system by June 27. Six months have been lost and the Secretary of State can only grant a year's extension. Can the Minister tell us whether councils like North Devon will be given extra time or extra funding to help make that change?
Jim McMahon
We've agreed as part of the transitional arrangements that an extra year will be allowed to continue the committee system in the way that he describes.
Christopher Vince.
Christopher John Vince
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Can I welcome the announcement by the Chancellor last week for supporting our high street, which is really welcome? Can I ask the minister though what conversations he's had with Cabinet colleagues about the future of Poundland? We have two shops and one depot in Harlow, so this is huge importance to my constituents.
Jim McMahon
I think all of us are concerned about the announcement for Poundland and its 30,000 staff. These are people in every one of our communities, and I don't think there's merely a high street in the country that hasn't got a Poundland feature. As confirmed this morning, the government are in conversations with Poundland to make sure that is supported where it can be supported, but absolutely understand the community impact in the way that he speaks.
Philip Maguire.
Ben Maguire
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
The government has now baked in the £20 million a year second homes council tax premium to its core government funding. However, business rate loopholes, which were increased in the recent budget, make these payments easily available avoidable, so the revenue cannot be relied upon consistently. Will the minister meet with the six Cornish MPs to ensure Cornwall benefits from this second home council tax premium?
Jim McMahon
Yeah, there's definitely a pattern of particularly short-term lets transferring onto the business rate list to avoid paying council tax. And that's exactly why we need the short-term lets register in the way that members have spoken about today. Well, I'd be very happy to meet with Cornish MPs as a group to talk it through further.
Robert Jenrick.
Edward Robert Jenrick
This summer was a very difficult time for Nottinghamshire fire service.
They battled with wildfires and a lot of heat-related incidents. The fire men and women had to wear protective equipment, clothing, with for which it was simply unbearable to work during that type of heat. I know that the Secretary of State has made available some funding. Could she work to ensure that by next summer, if we see the same type of hot weather and wildfires, brave fire men and women have the clothing, the protective equipment that they need to work in those conditions?
Angela Rayner
Well Mr. Speaker, he's absolutely right. And I commend all those that fought in the wildfires over the summer. He's right to recognise that the PPE that firefighters need is different for those types of circumstances. That's why we've put £45 million extra in, on top of the additional, I think it's £97 million on top of that for equipment. So we're working to ensure that our firefighters have the equipment they need.
And of course we announced the aerial support.
Tessa Munt.
Tessa Munt
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Councils spend far more enforcing against breach of planning control than the offender is ever fined, and even then, the money goes to the Treasury. When it's cheaper to break the rules than to follow them, enforcement loses any deterrent it has, and there's a perception that breaches have few consequences. Will the Secretary of State look again at the level of fines, whether councils can receive the proceeds of fines, and recover their costs, as well?
Matthew Pennycook
Would the honourable lady write to me with some further details to illustrate the precise problem she is trying to get at?
Joshua Thomas Babarinde
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
Two brave Eastbourne families are fighting for improved regulation of supported accommodation after their respective relatives were found dead in the accommodation that was meant to be supporting them. Will the minister meet with them and with me to discuss how we can better protect vulnerable people in supported accommodation?
Angela Rayner
I'm absolutely devastated to hear the honourable gentleman's description of what happened to those constituents of his, Mr. Speaker, and I'll make sure he gets a meeting with the minister.
Speaker 140
Completes questions. Let the front bench change over. We now come to the statement. Home Secretary.
Speaker 141
Thank you, Mr Speaker. With permission, I will make a statement on this government's policy of earned settlement. A little over a month ago, at Labour party conference, I promised that we would adopt a policy on this issue that is guided above all by fairness: fairness towards those who come here legally and play their part, and fairness towards British citizens already here, who should not be asked to bear a greater burden. Mr Speaker, the question of fairness matters to me because it matters to my family. Over 50 years ago, my parents came to this country from rural Kashmir.
They came here knowing one thing above all else: that they would be treated fairly here. They came from a place where power was often arbitrary and where the dice were always loaded.
They came to this country because they knew we do things differently here, and that we value, above all else, fair play. Mr Speaker, it is my responsibility to ensure our migration system lives up to that ideal. I believe doing so depends upon a contract between those who come and those already here. This country welcomes those who seek a new and better life within it, but I also know there is an expectation of those who do, that they will play their part, contribute to their community and become a part of our national life. I do not think this despite being a Labour politician, I think this because I am a Labour politician.
If we are to ask our fellow citizens to buy into a system of shared taxation and universal public services, they must know that everyone is playing their part.
Solidarity is the precondition for social justice. Creating a fair migration system demands reform to settlement, the ability to live in this country forever. Settlement confirms confers some of the most valuable rights that this country can offer. At settlement, a migrant receives the right to free education, our NHS, and, should they fall upon it, the welfare state. Until now, settlement rights have come at 5 years, almost exclusively as a result of time spent in this country.
It has therefore been a right accrued with little expectation of responsibility. I do not believe this represents true fairness. Instead, I believe these considerable rights should come after responsibilities have been met and a contribution has been made. Settlement should not be automatic, it should be earned.
Mr Speaker, today the Government publishes a policy called earned settlement. It ensures the period someone must live in this country before they settle is determined by the contribution they have made. That starts by setting out clearly what we consider to be disqualifying criteria. Firstly, a criminal record; secondly, a failure to speak English to a high standard;
thirdly, any unpaid debt to the British taxpayer; and finally, a failure to have made three years of national insurance contributions. This is the foundation of settlement, the non-negotiable expectations that we make of anyone who seeks to live here permanently.
For those who clear these bars, settlement then varies based on the contribution made rather than simply time served. This contribution is judged crucially not just financially, but also in terms of public service. A five-year path will remain open to all higher earners on salaries of over £50,000 and those who have contributed in healthcare and education in professions like doctors, nurses, and teachers. For those who make an exceptional contribution, even faster routes are available. The highest rate taxpayers earning over £125,000 will, over the course of their lifetime, contribute 1.5 million pounds.
This funds the critical services that many, including the poorest in these in this country, rely upon. So under these reforms, they will be able to apply for settlement after three years, as will those who arrive on our highest talent schemes.
Everyone else will be placed on a 10-year path, including all those earning less than £50,000. Settlement will still be available to them, they will simply have to show a sustained contribution to this country, and they will be able to renew their existing temporary visas until that point. Conditionality runs both ways.
Those who commit an immigration breach will see settlement pushed back to 20 years, while those who have claimed benefits must have had five continuous years without falling on the state before they make their application. A number of groups will see their path to settlement remain as today. These include Hong Kong British Nationals (Overseas), members of our armed forces, those with a British connection, and those on legacy routes such as Windrush. Before we finalise this policy, we first took it to the country through a consultation.
Over 200,000 people responded, and I thank them for doing so. Many of the responses were focused on one particular group, social care workers. Between 2022 and 2025, 250,000 people and their dependants arrived on or switched into the social care route. They came at a time when the sector was at under considerable pressure, following the COVID-19 pandemic and the unique challenge of that moment. It is also, however, the case that this route was abused.
The last Conservative government may have talked of restoring control to our borders, but in truth, they lost control entirely.
Never was this more obvious than when the shadow Home Secretary was an immigration Minister in the Home Office. Delegations were sent across the country to encourage ever more businesses to sponsor foreign workers with little apparent interest in their suitability to do so. As a result, there was significant abuse of the care route: sometimes because of fraudulent and exploitative companies, and sometimes because individuals themselves came here knowing there was no job they could fill. A fair solution must address both sides of this: recognizing the service of those who cared for our sick and elderly at a time of immense national need and also addressing the abuse that was present on this route.
The government's solution does so in two ways. Firstly, by providing a five-year path to settlement for care workers who lived up to the promise that they made on coming to this country, worked hard and answered our call when we needed them. Those who earned £25,000 a year, working in the social care sector, which was the condition of their visa, will therefore be able to settle on their existing five-year path. The second group, who have not fulfilled the conditions of their visa, represent around a quarter of those who came between 2022 and 2025, or switched into this route. We will offer them a second chance to make the contribution that they came to this country to make.
They will be able to apply for another five-year care visa, and they will not be tied to their old employer, allowing those with rogue sponsors to break away from them.
The Government has already stripped around 1,800 exploitative employers of their licences, and we are lifting standards in care with our fair pay agreement across the sector. The Government will now help workers to find a new position with a legitimate provider, and we will give them a longer period of time to do so before their existing visa is curtailed. There remain tens of thousands of legitimate vacancies in the care sector today, so those who seek a new job in care and have the requisite skills should be able to find one. At the completion of their new five-year visa, these workers will be able to apply for settlement once more. Everyone will have a fair shot to make their contribution, and no one will be punished for the sins of their employer.
But we will also preserve the critical element of this reform, that settlement must be linked to contribution.
The same transitional arrangement will be applied to public sector workers in roles identified by the Migration Advisory Committee in healthcare and education, such as auxiliary nurses. This country has been highly dependent upon them, and their contribution will be recognized. Mr Speaker, these transitional arrangements apply only to those who join this who joined before this Government published the immigration white paper in May 2025. After that point, as our consultation shows, the Government's position of a 10-year path to settlement was widely understood. These are exceptional exclusions for exceptional circumstances, and it remains the case that the rules around settlement are determined when a settlement decision is made, not at the point when someone arrives.
This is a position that is long established in this country, and it is one that has been tested conclusively in our courts. Mr Speaker, the responses to our consultation focused also on settlement rights for refugees.
I know the people of this country wish to continue welcoming genuine refugees. However, I also know there is nothing fair about allowing unsafe and illegal entry into this country. It is not fair that our borders are run by people smugglers. It is not fair that women and children are dying in the Channel. And it is not fair that, after historic levels of illegal arrivals, British citizens are paying £4 billion a year to fund asylum support.
So, as we open new safe and legal routes for genuine refugees, we must also discourage dangerous, unsafe and illegal crossings, and settlement plays a key part in this. We will place those who come to this country on one of our new safe and legal routes on a five-year path to settlement.
This is as fast a path as higher earners entering Britain today. At the same time, we will discourage the use of unsafe and illegal routes. The standard disqualifying period for all refugees who have not come by a safe and legal route will become 20 years. A further 10 years will be added for those who enter the country by an illegal method, such as by small boat. We do want to promote integration into this country for all those who are here.
For that reason, those who enter work or study will be able to earn settlement 10 years earlier. This means a refugee who did not arrive by small boat, who is working and studying could qualify for settlement at 10 years.
Let us not forget, regardless of the question of settlement, for as long as a genuine refugee requires protection in this country, we will provide it. I know the British people's sense of fair play means they welcome refugees and those who seek to contribute to our society once they are here. But at the same time, there is nothing fair about incentivising unsafe and illegal routes into this country, and I will not do that. These reforms, Mr Speaker, are the right thing to do, both morally and financially. While a full impact assessment will be completed and published as we implement the reforms, our changes ensure those who are net contributors are encouraged to this country to come to this country and stay here.
Meanwhile, the cohort who are most likely to impose a cost at settlement must instead seek work and meet the conditions of their visa before they can apply. As a result, the Department for Work and Pensions estimates that our reforms will reduce the benefits bill by billions of pounds. This is a solution that is fair to those who came here legally and play their part and fair to British citizens already here who should not be asked to pay a greater burden. Mr Speaker, earned settlement institutes a new paradigm in our migration system long overdue that one of our greatest rights that we can offer now depends upon a contribution made and responsibilities met. The right to live in this country forever must now be earned.
It will no longer be automatic. It is, Mr Speaker, a fair settlement for all. And so, I commend this statement to the House.
Brian Christopher Ian Mynott Philp
Thank you, Mr Speaker, and I thank the Home Secretary for advance sight of her statement. Mr Speaker, it took a year for the Home Secretary to build her reputation as tough on immigration. But what took a year to build, she has just dismantled in 12 short minutes. Now I don't judge her by the actions we think she should take. I judge her by what she herself previously said.
She made announcements from that despatch box on November 20th last year and doubled down in a speech to the IPPR on March the 5th this year. She repeatedly singled out social care workers as a particular problem.
She said on March the 5th that fraud in the social care sector was rife with bogus sponsors. She said at that dispatch box that it was right, and I quote, that more "stringent restrictions", her words, should be applied to social care workers. Now she stands there and says the exact opposite. A Home Office document which she published on March the 5th said that social care workers alone, because they work on low wages and have brought in many dependants, will actually cost the taxpayer £10 billion. Those are her figures that she specifically chose to publish about social care workers.
She went on to say on March the 5th that failing to implement her plans would be, and I quote, "an affront to the idea of fairness in our society", her words.
Well, in the changes she announces today, that is exactly what she has done. The Home Secretary now proposes to allow every single care worker and their dependents who arrived prior to May 2025, a number running into hundreds of thousands, to stay in this country, to stay in this country beyond the expiry of their visa, and in the case of 75% of them, to stay permanently. Even though she acknowledges that many of them arrived fraudulently,
how is it she can justify allowing people that she acknowledges arrived here fraudulently can stay forever at a cost that she, herself, has admitted costs £10 billion? That is the cost.
That is the cost, that is the cost of today's U-turn: £10 billion. And outside of care workers, many of the so-called highly skilled workers recently arrived are not highly skilled at all. The Home Secretary didn't mention this in her statement, but in her document she is proposing to extend the soft terms on which they can stay until 2035, extending the previous sunset by five years. Her own document, her own document published today, which she didn't refer to, forecasts there will be a staggering 1.9 million permanent settlement rights granted between now and 2030.
And an FOI request revealed where some of those people work: a chain of kebab shops called German Doner Kebab, 106 skilled worker visas, or Khan's Middle Eastern Restaurant, 28 high-skilled visas, or a Domino's Pizza franchise in South Yorkshire sponsoring 78 high-skill visas. You get the picture. And just a year after getting ILR, someone can easily get full citizenship.
And we know what that means: benefits, social housing and free NHS children. So, when the Home Secretary said in March failing to implement her changes was an affront, she was right, but now she has done exactly that. And she also plans, she also plans to give illegal immigrants who arrived on small boats ILR and citizenship. We disagree with that. Now, why is it she's made those changes?
Well, it's because the Communities Secretary, I notice, has run out, and the Energy Secretary, and the Labour open borders left, oppose what she previously announced. They oppose what she previously announced. The Home Secretary is no longer running the Government's immigration policy, the Housing Secretary is, and her position is looking increasingly untenable. She's done she's done she's done no better with her announcements last year than Keir Starmer did with his welfare announcements, and we know what happened to him. Mr Speaker, we would go a lot further than her previous announcements, although they were a good start.
So if she wants to implement her previous announcements in full, we will vote for them, because mass low-skill migration must end.
Those people who came here on a temporary visa and are working in low-skilled, low-wage jobs must leave when their temporary visa expires. We cannot allow them to stay forever claiming benefits and social housing. And yet that is what her proposals today will allow to happen. 10 billion pounds, that is the cost of today's U-turn. And to those who ask where we'll find the workers, there are 9 million economically inactive adults in this country.
There are now, thanks to this Labour government's high-tax, high-regulation policies, a million young people not in education, employment or training.
So, if they had the courage to toughen up the welfare system, we'd get some of those people into work instead of relying on mass low-skill migration. So, Mr Speaker, if the Home Secretary wants to face down her nemesis, the Communities Secretary, and implement her own plans, we will vote for them. But if she capitulates to the open borders left, her credibility as Home Secretary will not recover.
Speaker 141
Thanks Mr Speaker. I'll tell you what is an affront, Mr Speaker, and that is the shadow Home Secretary's response. He might have amnesia, but actually, given the muted response on his own Back Benches, they clearly still remember what happened on their watch when they were in government, as does the country. When he was immigration Minister, Mr Speaker, it was his Government that ran around the country signing up people to become sponsors of foreign workers. If he's got complaints about the work the companies that are on the register, it's his Government that signed them up.
Maybe an apology for that would have been appropriate. It was his government that was responsible for a number of arrivals in four years that we had previously seen only in four decades. So before he starts trying to lecture anybody on being tough on immigration, perhaps an apology for the abject track record left behind by him and his government would be appropriate. It is this Government that has cut net migration by 82%. And it is this Government, and me as Home Secretary, that has found a fair solution for the mess left behind by him and his colleagues.
Speaker 141
Let me tell him, if he had been paying attention to my fair solution and had, in fact, paid attention to the detail in the consultation document response, he will know that the cohort most likely to impose a cost will now, as a result of my measures, wait longer for settlement. And that is why the DWP say that these measures will save billions in the benefits bill, and half a million people, 500,000 people will settle later as a result of these reforms. That is a fair solution to the mess that I have inherited from those who sit opposite.
Mr Speaker, he talked about the arrangements for those workers on low pay who are allowed by the previous conservative governments to extend their visas up to 2030. That was in order to allow them to attain settlement in 2030 in order to honour the promise made by the previous government. I have extended that period to 2035, reflecting the changes in the earned settlement consultation. Again, a fair solution, honouring promises made previously as well as exceptional cohorts and exceptional circumstances in order to clean up the mess left behind by those who sit opposite. Mr Speaker, I would have answered more of the detailed questions, but apart from political rhetoric, he had nothing else to say, so I have nothing more to say to him either.
Diane Julie Abbott
It's extraordinary that the opposition sees migration issues as some kind of political football.
This is people's lives we are talking about, whatever your idea about policy and programs, and I think people's lives deserve more seriousness. It is right that care workers are exempted from the new arrangements for ILR. But for the rest of the workforce, the retrospective nature of these new arrangements still seem to be unfair because you can come in legally, you can work legally, and then have your residency rights turned upside down. How can that be fair?
And I would ask the Home Secretary whether she has read the 276-page long Lessons Learned Review of the Windrush scandal published by the Home Office in 2018. Because if she had read it, she would realize that she's in danger of finding herself in the same position as Home Secretaries who were in office at the time of the Windrush scandal. And just let me say this, finally. I have heard members of this House talk about people just coming here to claim welfare. I have heard members of this House saying that people aren't making a contribution.
I have heard members of this House saying that, you know, we have to look at the rights of British nationals as opposed to migrants, as if many British nationals are not themselves immigrants. But let me say this, finally. My parents were immigrants.
My mother was a nurse. She was one of that generation that came to this country to build the NHS after the war. And it remains the case that immigrants play a very important role in our NHS. And I say to the Home Secretary, and I say to the House, we should always remember the contribution that immigrants made and continue to make to our society.
Speaker 141
Well, let me agree with the honorable lady on the contribution made by immigrants. As she knows, as I said in my statement, I too am the child of migrants and that also informs my experience as I think about policy and how to strike the right balance between all of the different communities in our country, and that is what I have sought to do. Let me just say to her on indefinite leave to remain and what she calls the retrospective nature of the changes, as she will know, I do not agree with that characterization of those changes. Any government needs to be able to make changes to immigration rules to reflect things that are happening, to reflect abuses that we can see in the system, to also be able to make additional changes based on assessment of numbers and costs. That has always been the case.
As I said in my statement, these matters have been litigated before in our courts and the courts have upheld the principle that the rules that apply to settlement applications are those that apply at the point of application and decision, not at the point at which somebody entered the country.
And that is an important principle that will be upheld and is upheld by the changes that we are making. And let me just say to her also on Windrush, I've seen a number of people try to suggest that these changes to settlement are akin to what we saw during the Windrush scandal. Again, respectfully, I do disagree with her on that. The issue relating to the people that were caught up in the Windrush scandal was a scandal precisely because the country already had obligations to those individuals that related to their right to be in this country, and failed to honour the obligation that we already had. That is different to workers arriving in this country on temporary work visas, and the rules that apply to them for settlement itself.
The two are not the same. But let me assure her, I will always be mindful of the lessons that were revealed during the Windrush scandal and I will make sure those lessons are learned.
Thank you Mr Speaker.
Max Wilkinson
It's a year on from the Home Secretary's initial statement on her immigration reforms, and we still disagree with the Government and with the official Opposition. Just as we predicted, the Government's immigration reforms are unravelling. By prioritizing tough rhetoric rather than a system that works, the Home Secretary has apparently split her party and the Cabinet, and has alienated people on all sides. Viewing immigration simply as a matter of raw numbers and images of small boat arrivals is degrading this nation's ability to have the informed national discussion that we need. Immigration reforms must, of course, bring greater control and they must prevent small boat crossings, too, but crucially they must also serve our economy and public services.
Mr Speaker, the Home Secretary previously claimed that ILR for care workers will cost us £10 billion.
The shadow Home Secretary made much of that today. Yet the IPPR, using the same methodology, estimates the net benefit of skilled migrants settling in the UK under the current rules is £115 billion. So, will the Home Secretary be publishing the full economic impact of the changes that she is suggesting? Mr Speaker, as the Prime Minister has acknowledged, being an EU member brought more order to our migration system. It prevented small boat crossings, and it meant many who came to work here went home again in due course.
But this is not all down to the Government. They simply would not be considering the changes to ILR today if it weren't for the Conservatives' botched Brexit deal and the record levels of immigration they allowed while promising lower numbers. It is no wonder so many people in this country are confused. Now the Conservatives are the official opposition, their number one policy on immigration is leaving the ECHR.
But something doesn't add up, Mr Speaker. The Conservatives tell us also that their Brexit deal is settled and must never be reviewed. The fact is that the Brexit deal they negotiated with the EU would be ended if this country leaves the European Convention on Human Rights, and that would send the UK into further chaos. They look confused and they're disputing this, Mr Speaker, but perhaps that's because Conservative MPs have no idea what they are actually arguing for. They're either misinformed or they are misleading the public.
But back to this Government, Mr Speaker. Today I have two further questions for the Home Secretary. Firstly, why does she think so many of her backbenchers disagree with her about immigration? And my second question relates to Europe. Our future clearly lies closer to Europe, which will bring opportunities to fix our migration system.
So why does the Home Secretary disagree so strongly with the Prime Minister about this?
Speaker 141
Thank you, Mr Speaker. I mean that was a very classic Lib Dem response, I have to say. All very, I agree this is a problem, this is a problem, this is a problem, but, but, but, but, but, which leads to no solutions whatsoever, Mr Speaker. Let me say to him again, I'm not going to engage with ridiculous political rhetoric. We consulted and I've presented the House with a fair solution that does right between all of the different cohorts: those who came to this country, those who are already here, recognising the exceptionality of care workers in particular, given that they arrived in a very specific post-COVID moment when they were needed for gaps in our care sector.
I think that's a fair settlement, and that has taken place after a genuine consultation. Usually, the Lib Dems are so in favor of consultations, they should be applauding the fact that this was a genuine consultation. And we ask questions, and we have considered the responses, and we have formulated the policy as a result of those responses. He mentioned the recent IPPR report. He's right, it does use the same methodology as I have used before, but what he's failed to say is that they are looking at a totally different cohort of people in order to talk about their numbers.
Perhaps he'd like to go back and look at that detail, and I'm happy to engage with him once he's acknowledged the difference in cohorts there. He made some points about the EU. It's another sort of a very classic thing for him to do, to assume that all of these matters relate only to our post-Brexit reality. But settlement is a policy of this Government and all of our predecessor Governments.
It is a right conferred on people who then obtain the right to live in this country permanently. It is right that this Government considers what those rules should be, as every previous Government has also done so. He will, of course, know that after we left the European Union over 5 million European citizens settled in this country under the EU Settlement Scheme. So, that is also another of our post-Brexit consequences. I'm always happy to discuss with him the position in relation to the EU, but I don't think that has anything to do with settlement.
Peter Richard Prinsley
Thank you, Mr Speaker. I welcome this statement and its greatly imaginative measures. I particularly welcome the fact that the care worker will have a second opportunity to apply for indefinite leave to remain.
Does the Home Secretary not agree with me that the care workers that we welcome to this country are every bit as valuable as the highly paid doctors, entrepreneurs, and industrialists who come here with high salaries?
Speaker 141
Thank you, Mr Speaker. I agree with my honourable friend. In acknowledgment of the very specific circumstances of the care worker cohort in the unique position in relation to the COVID-19 pandemic, we have the transitional arrangement for care workers who arrived before May 2025. And he's right, it is appropriate to give a second chance to those who have been unable to meet the requirements of their visa, who would normally be expected to leave the country now to have a second chance at gaining employment within the care sector with a legitimate employer and a chance to meet those visa conditions, so that they can once again consider settlement in another 5 years' time.
Edward Leigh
The Home Secretary is right to say that government is about a social contract, and I can see where she's coming from.
And some of us don't have amnesia. Many of us in that period in 2023 were putting this to our then government, and anybody who was serving as a Home Office minister at that time should wear sackcloth and ashes. And frankly, as a party, we will never, we will never move on until we accept that, although there was a very difficult situation after COVID. But there's a couple of things I worry about still. I'm still not entirely clear, apart from political pressure, why she's watering down her proposals from last time, if she is.
I'm worried, I can see what she's trying to get at with care workers and they're earning their right, but surely we should really establish a firm principle that you have to come here honestly to work in the care system and go on working. And the last point, I agree with her that if you come here illegally, you shouldn't be allowed to claim indefinite right to re- to stay till after 20 years, but are we going to have people in hotels for 20 years? Surely this underlines the fact that we have to arrest people, detain them, and return them, otherwise there is no deterrent.
Speaker 141
Well let me thank the father of the House. Let me say I agree with him, it is high time that his front bench took responsibility for the reality of their government's time in office, something the shadow Home Secretary once again failed to do so today.
Let me tell him on care workers, in particular, this is reflecting the consultation responses and the recognition of the unique circumstances of this cohort, not just what they were asked to do in the post-pandemic period, but also that this abuse, this route was subject to a huge amount of abuse. The Home Office has revoked the visas of over 1,800 employers, primarily from the care sector. So, recognising that, if though, if there are people in this country today who came on this visa, who have fulfilled the terms of their visa, they've done their £25,000-a-year earnings and they are with an employer in the care sector, that is why they will be able to settle, and that is also why we are providing a second chance at making that contribution to those who have not been able to meet the terms of their visa. I think that's a fair settlement.
It gives a second chance to those who are exploited, but doesn't create a new immediate right to settle if they were not able to fulfill the terms of their visa. On those who've arrived illegally into this country, he will also know that, in addition to the new core protection model, which means that people can't settle before 20 years, we will be creating the work and study route, which will allow those who are integrating in the into this country by working or studying to settle earlier, which, again, I think is the right thing to do.
Dame Meg Hillier.
Margaret Olivia Hillier
Thank you, Mr. Speaker, and I welcome the Home Secretary's focus on fairness. People know that this country has a set of rules and we all should adhere to it whether we arrive in this country or are born here. One of the issues she raised is about English language. There are many people settled already and some who come in as spouses without good English.
This is a very gendered issue with many women particularly trapped because they haven't got access to English. Is she working with colleagues across government and social society and society generally to try and make sure that we are getting better English language teaching available so that people are not excluded and are able to participate fully?
Speaker 141
My right honorable friend raises an incredibly important point, and she's right to talk about the gendered nature of those who are able to access English learning in this country. This government has raised the English level that is expected of most migrants coming into this country including refugees apart from those on the UK resettlement route precisely because we believe a good standard of English is absolutely critical to the ability of people to integrate fully into this country. Let me assure her that those cross-government conversations are happening, and I'd be happy to meet with her to update her in due course.
Karen Bradley
Thank you very much Mr Speaker. The Home Secretary will know that the committee conducted a piece of deliberative democracy work where we worked with the public to find out what their attitudes were to people who are coming on work visas. It was very clear from that the public wants to see skills and training for the domestic population to take vacancies. So, can she confirm what work she is doing across government to make sure that there is appropriate skills and training for those that are here to take the jobs that are available? And can she also confirm when she expects these new provisions to start?
Speaker 141
Let me thank the Chair of the Home Affairs Select Committee and thank her and her committee for their work in this area. I will be responding officially to their recent report on settlement.
She'll know that I've obviously waited until the policy has been settled, but I will set the government's full response to the committee's very good work in this area and I thank them for it. Let me say to her that she is absolutely right on the need to make sure that domestic workers can access the skills they need in order to get jobs that are available in this country. She'll know that I'm flanked by many members of the government, including the Secretary of State for Education, who I know is very alive to the issues of skills and training, as are my colleagues in DWP and elsewhere. That will be an important piece of work going forward, especially in the care sector, where the government has already recognized that there is a need for an improvement in pay and conditions for care workers with our fair pay agreement expected by 2028. That is a recognition that things need to change in that sector to make it more attractive to domestic workers as well.
So, let me assure her on that point, and let me also say the changes that have been announced will begin to be laid from the December immigration rules, they will be implemented over the course of 2027, and I will be providing impact assessments and other detail guidance as those changes are rolled out.
Navendu Mishra
Mr Speaker. Mr Speaker, a large number of people from Hong Kong have chosen to make Stockport and Greater Manchester their home. They make an invaluable contribution to our town and our city region, and many of them have been worried over the last couple of years in terms of the changes, upcoming changes, potential changes to indefinite leave to remain. I have met with many of them over the last few months,
and can I ask the Secretary of State what more can she say to reassure the people who've used the BNO scheme, the Hong Kong community, that they are welcome in this country and they will have a fair shot in terms of ILR?
Speaker 141
Well, let me confirm for my honourable friend that those who have arrived on the BNO route are exempt from these changes. He knows that they have to meet the minimum requirements on English and no criminality and so on, but he should also know that on English, of course, the over-65s are exempt from that change, which I think, again, provides a fair resolution for those who arrived on that route.
James Cleverly
Thank you, Mr Speaker. A Home Secretary clearing up the mess of her immediate predecessor, who would have thought it? When I brought through when I brought through changes to the visa regime, the chorus of disapproval from the then opposition that now sit on the government side of the House was deafening.
She has already conceded that her proposals are not as robust as the announcement she made this time next year. So what confidence can the House or the country have that she will not further water down the proposals that she has announced today as it goes through the legislative process?
Speaker 141
Well, let me say to one of my many predecessors as Home Secretary, the proposals I have announced today are far more robust than everything he and his government left behind and it is their mess that this government has been cleaning up. He will know that both myself and my immediate predecessor as Home Secretary are responsible for a number of changes, including closing the care worker route to overseas workers, having a requirement for sponsors to be CQC rated. We've suspended family reunion for refugees while we set all family migration policy next year, and we've raised salary thresholds.
This Government, both myself and my predecessor, have been taking the action that is needed, and that is why net migration is down 82%.
Speaker 162
Clerk. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Those who come to our country and genuinely work in our care sector looking after our elderly and vulnerable do our country a great service. However, unfortunately, some are working in poor conditions, they're exploited and underpaid, partly due to the sponsorship system currently in place. Will the Home Secretary seriously consider looking at an umbrella sponsor system working with the Health Department?
Speaker 141
I thank the honourable member. Let me tell him and the House that I've had discussions with the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care.
She's also very clear that conditions for employees in the care sector must improve and there should be minimum standards in the future. That is work that she is undertaking as Health Secretary. It will also be part of the wider reforms to the care sector that the government is undertaking. And what I have undertaken is that the immigration system will reflect any changes made to improve standards in the care sector and that we will follow those changes. It would be inappropriate for us as an immigration department to change licence routes ourselves without the wider work that is required to improve the functioning of the care sector, which the Health Secretary is undertaking, and once that work is complete, I will be making the relevant changes then.
Paul Kohler
Mr Speaker, as a member of the Home Affairs Select Committee, I proposed an amendment to our recent report on earned settlement that included a plea to only make changes to indefinite leave to remain for those not already embarked on a pathway to settlement. Whilst my amendment was defeated, only three Labour MPs on the committee voted against it, with four of her Labour colleagues voting with me or abstaining. The Home Secretary, in her statement which I applaud and welcome, rightly lauds the UK's reputation for playing fairly. So will she join us in agreeing not to make any retrospective changes to the time required to achieve indefinite leave to remain for all those already on pathways to settlement, not only care workers, or do others' contributions not count?
Hear, Mr Speaker.
Speaker 141
Well, I just repeat for the honourable member an answer I've given many times including to the Home Affairs Select Committee, he will know I profoundly disagree with the point that he's making, that it has been long-established principles that the rules that apply to an application are the rules that are in place at the point of decision, not at the point that somebody arrived in the country. And I'm afraid to go down that road would render this government and all future governments unable to effectively manage the migration system. It would be the wrong step. It is not a step required of us by our own legal system and our own courts and we will not be taking it.
Well, I just repeat for the honourable member an answer I have given many times, including to the Home Affairs Select Committee.
John Martin McDonnell
Because of the nature of my constituency, I work with a large number of people who have come here often by the boats themselves as well, and they're often their families as well. The years of waiting for security does have its impact particularly on the mental health, but could I ask the Home Secretary to look at page 4?
I just would like some clarity about the third paragraph where she says, "The standard qualifying period for all refugees who have not come by a safe and legal route will become 20 years. A further 10 years will be added for those who entered the country by an illegal method, such as by small boats." I haven't misread this. Does this mean it's 30 years for some?
Speaker 141
Yes, that is right, Madam Deputy Speaker. Let me say to my honorable friend, we consulted on whether an additional period should apply to those who arrive in the country through unlawful means, such as by boat or on the back of a lorry, for example, and the, it was an overwhelmingly positive response on the need to add additional time. He will know that the Government wishes to incentivize people to enter this country through safe and legal means. And as I said in my statement, Madam Deputy Speaker, there is nothing fair about our border system being run by people smugglers.
Speaker 167
I really urge colleagues to keep their questions short and for the Home Secretary to be on point as she can. Bradley Thomas.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
Madam Deputy Speaker, one of the criteria that the Home Secretary set out is no debts being owed to the state in order to gain settlement long-term settlement rights. What does that look like in reality? I've advocated for a student loans-style system for debts to be repaid, and will she address the House on what steps she's taking to abolish the impact of rogue sponsors, namely chicken shops, Turkish barbers, vape shops that all exist in plain sight and are an acute problem in the illegal immigration web?
Home Secretary.
Speaker 141
Well, he's right to acknowledge that there is a huge explosion in the number of people that are sponsors on the sponsorship register that happened under the previous government, I will be setting out policy for how we will resolve issues within the sponsorship register. He will know already that we are revoking licenses where appropriate, and where somebody should not be able to bring workers into this country. And on debt, that will include NHS debt, tax debt, and litigation debt. It will also, for refugees, include asylum support. It will either be a payment of asylum support costs or, at least, to be complying with a payment plan.
Jess Phillips.
Jess Jessica Rose Phillips
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Victims of domestic abuse who have come over as dependants currently can apply for settlement immediately. Will that change under these new rules?
Speaker 141
It will not change. Victims of domestic abuse will still be able to obtain immediate settlement.
Julian Lewis
Like the Home Secretary, I come from an immigrant family that came here legally, but I fail to understand why she thinks it will deter people from coming here illegally if they are not able to get settled status for 20 or even 30 years provided that there is no prospect of them being removed from the country because of laws like the ECHR.
Speaker 141
Well, he and I disagree on the ECHR. This is a debate we've had many times before.
Let me say to him, I think that the time period at which you attain settlement should reflect both the means by which you've come to the country, but also should incentivise the behaviour that we want to see, which is people working or studying, contributing to society and taking steps to integrate themselves. I think that will have an impact on behaviour of everyone who's in this country, whether they've come on a work visa or whether they are in the asylum system as well. I think that's a fair solution for everyone.
Speaker 172
Can I thank my right honourable friend for her statement this afternoon? But she will also be aware of the ongoing concerns I've been raising with regards to Turkish business people who have made their life in the UK under the European Communities Association Agreement, also known as the Ankara agreement. Can she set out how her announcements today affect that group?
Speaker 141
Well, I can confirm from for my honourable friend that those who arrived those who arrived on the ECAA, because that is a closed route and reflects the particular agreement that we were part of then, will have no changes to their settlement. They are outside of the scope of earned settlement.
Sarah Olney
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I have constituents who are waiting for their ILR, are on their on the five-year route. They brought their spouses and their children with them to this country and they've taken up high-skilled, high-paying roles, but their spouses will now have to apply separately and will be on a 10-year scheme. If their children reach adulthood before both spouses have achieved their ILR, they will not be eligible to remain in this country despite the fact they've been here since childhood.
Can the Home Secretary give any reassurance to those families in my constituency who are deeply worried about their children being left without citizenship?
Speaker 141
Let me encourage the honourable member, she probably hasn't had the opportunity yet to look at the dependence chapter within the consultation document response, where we confirm that the position in relation to children is largely unchanged from the previous position, and as for spouses, they will normally settle at the same time as the main applicant if they arrived at the same time, or they will do if they've arrived after the main applicant just the same time period. We've also, because we consulted specifically on this point when looking at income, have said that for those who are lower incomes or to reflect the fact that sometimes one partner might take time out for caring responsibilities, you can take combined household income rather than individual income.
Frances Olivia Blake
Olivia Blake. I thank the Home Secretary for the changes she's announced today, but I do have remaining questions about the impact of these changes on children in particular, children, Madam Deputy Speaker, who are not responsible for the choices of their parents, and who we must ensure do not face greater poverty or instability as a consequence of any changes. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
The Home Secretary did not say much about children in her statement today. I have had a brief look through the consultation document, but I have a few specific questions. First of all, will she publish a children's right impact assessment ahead of implementation? Will she provide greater clarity in the house on the situation for children, including whether the existing private
Speaker 141
Again, just appreciating the fact that not everybody will have had a chance yet to look at the whole of the consultation document response, let me say to my honorable friend, the position in relation to children is largely unchanged. The rules about whether you've been here for seven years or the majority of your life in order to be able to settle still apply. And children will normally settle when both of their parents get ILR, which is the same as the position as it is today.
Wendy Morton
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Well, what a missed opportunity to strengthen the rules, strengthen the illegal immigration policy and strengthen our borders. How does she reasonably think this is fair to the British people?
Wendy Morton.
Speaker 177
I think that was just actually a missed opportunity to apologize, which nobody on the opposite benches has done.
Speaker 53
I'd like to thank the Home Secretary for her statement. As she knows, I've written to her about this matter, and I met with migrant workers in my constituency. She has mentioned that the Health Secretary is going to be carrying out a review, particularly in terms of looking at fraudulent and exploitative companies.
I would urge the Home Secretary to make sure that there are strong, robust action taken against these companies to deter them from behaving the way that they do. And also, I would like reassurance that the Home Secretary will meet with migrant workers as part of this consultation, this review being done, to make sure that their concerns are addressed and taken forward.
Speaker 141
Let me thank my honorable friend for her question. Let me say to her, the immigration aspects of this, I think I've covered in the statements that I've made today. It is the case that exploitative and rogue employers have had their licences revoked. My colleagues in the in DBIS in that department have agreed that they the fair work agency will specifically be looking at the care sector and the behaviour of employers within the care sector, and my colleagues in the Health Department are looking at the wider reforms that are needed for the care sector, and my honorable friend the Health Minister has kindly agreed to meet with the member.
Peter Wishart
I was hoping, when I turned up today, that I would hear the Home Secretary say she was abandoning all the proposals around ILR. Where it's positive she's responded to the cross-party campaign on social care workers, she still has a long way to go to address the unfairness at the heart of these proposals. The un-British retrospectivity is still in place, and those that thought they had a contract with the UK will still be let down. When is she going to be positive about immigration, including the economic benefits that immigration brings and the value it brings to our communities?
Thank you, Mr. Speaker.
Speaker 141
I've literally been talking about the positive impacts of migration, including for me personally. I wouldn't be in this country if there wasn't migration into our country. And let me also say to him, what he has to say about the ability of the Government to change the rules, if we followed his approach, no Government would be able to run an effective migration system.
We will not be doing that. It is a long, this is a long-settled position that has been upheld by the courts, so we are fully complying with our legal obligations, and the Government has set out a fair policy for all.
Dame Emily Thornberry.
Anne Emily Thornberry
Thanks very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to ask a question on behalf of a constituent of mine who's been in touch today. He came across the world from Pakistan and has to Islington to work as a care worker, so he's greatly relieved that, and that was nearly five years now, that he'll be able to get his ILR quickly and his family will get some security. But that family has now been joined by a little boy with a rare genetic condition.
What I'd like to have confirmed is, will the family be able to apply for additional support once dad has got his ILR or will it be necessary for them to wait until he's actually a citizen?
Speaker 141
Let me say to her that if her constituent has met the terms of his visa, as I set out in my statement, he will be able to apply for indefinite leave to remain at five years and, at the point of settlement, people are able to access the benefits system.
Sir Gavin Williamson.
Gavin Williamson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Restricting access to public funds for those with a with the settlement right will most likely require primary legislation. When will such a bill be planned to be brought forward?
Speaker 141
Well, the government is not restricting benefits for those with settlements rights, because he is absolutely right: not only does that require primary legislation, but it would create two-tier settlement rights.
The rules on no access to public funds are before somebody can achieve settlement, to make sure that those who have had to fall upon the state to seek assistance are still working for a period before they apply for settlement.
Stella Creasy.
Judith Stella Creasy
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. It is heartening to hear the Home Secretary dispel the lump of labour fallacy that people who come to this country simply take jobs. She is talking about the benefits of people coming to this country through immigration and that is welcome. But if we are to help our constituents understand the new scheme she's proposing, we do need some clarity. If I am to understand what she's proposed rightly, there are still around 200,000 people who do not earn more than £50,000 but are in work, who do not have a British spouse or connection and are not working in the care sector or public sector, for example scientists, researchers, skilled technicians, who will now face a 10-year wait to get settlement in this country.
Judith Stella Creasy
Does she expect these proposals to have a positive or negative impact on our economy?
Speaker 141
Well, let me say to her that obviously she raised a number of different professions. It will depend on entry levels and whether they fall within a transitional arrangement, but the default period for settlement has moved from five years to 10. I do expect there to be economic benefits, not least the billions saved to DWP from people waiting longer before they're able to access benefits.
Hannah Kathrine Spencer
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. By allowing those with more money to jump the queue and receive earned settlement status faster, these changes amount to an attack on lower-paid workers and, by extension, lower-paid British-born people too. Because time and time again, the working classes, whatever their nationality or migration status, have been looked down on and left behind. So, does the Home Secretary agree that her changes send a clear message to people who've come here, or people who were born here, that they are worth less if they don't earn enough?
Speaker 141
I absolutely reject that entirely. Firstly, let me say to her, for lower-paid British workers, they're already British. They do not need settlement in their own country. Let me also say to her that as I have set out the policy, including with all of the transitional arrangements, the Government has recognized public service alongside earnings for faster pathways to settlement. And I would just ask her to bear in mind that the highest earners, of course, pay the highest in tax.
And it is our taxpayers' money that funds our public services that we all rely upon.
And what the Government has done is found a fair solution between everybody, rewarding those who make the biggest contribution, including in public service roles.
Euan Stainbank.
Euan Stainbank
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the fair solution for existing migrant care workers because they did nothing but respond to the need for their labour caused by a care recruitment crisis caused by low wages and inadequate training. What is the Government doing cross-departmentally to prevent future care recruitment crises, and how will future care worker contributions be weighted in the framework for those who arrive after May 2025?
Speaker 141
Well, look, I thank my honourable friend for that. And, as I say, the Health Secretary and her team are working hard on all of the reforms that are needed to make sure that the care sector is functioning properly, including a workforce plan, which I believe is due before Christmas. The fair pay agreement will be in place in 2028 and he also knows, of course, that the Government has a wider review on the country's care needs and how they need to be met being carried out by Louise Casey.
Taken together, all of that work means a fundamental change to how the care sector works in this country.
Alec Shelbrooke.
Alec Edward Shelbrooke
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, it's been weeks since I wrote to the Immigration Minister, and not had a response, but out of generosity of spirit, I will say that they have been busy. So I may take this opportunity to invite the Home Secretary herself to come to the Linton-on-Ouse proposed site. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is an integrated village, and I think that the Home Secretary herself would be quite surprised and shocked if she was able to come to see it for herself. I do this with full open spirit of working cooperatively.
I don't even mind if I can't be there that day, Madam Deputy Speaker, but I really want the Home Secretary to come see for herself with the Linton-on-Ouse Action Group, just how inappropriate that site is.
Speaker 141
Well look, I hear the passion point that he makes as a constituency Member of Parliament.
He'll know that no decisions have been made yet. I'll ensure that his letter is responded to promptly. He will also know that this government has saved a billion pounds a year from our closure of asylum hotels, and he also knows that we will go further to close all asylum hotels in this Parliament, and it is important as we do so that we move to a new model of providing asylum accommodation that does include more use of military sites. But as I say in relation to the specific one that he mentions, no decisions have yet been made.
Speaker 189
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker.
This country owes the Gurkha Regiment a debt of thanks for their continued service. Can the Secretary of State outline what will happen to them and their dependents with this bill? Thank you.
Speaker 141
I can confirm for my honourable friend that the position in relation to Gurkhas is the same as all of those in our armed forces, that is to say they have their own bespoke route to settlement, which is usually four years after service. They are exempt from the changes that we've made today.
Manuela Perteghella
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Does the Home Secretary believe that is it fair to change the rules retrospectively for people who are not earning in excess of £50,000, but nevertheless, build careers, raise families, pay taxes based on the settlement pathway that existed when they arrived? Does this not violate the British value of fairness, risking real damage to our economy and to our social fabric?
Speaker 141
I absolutely disagree with the honourable lady, and I simply repeat the point I made to many honourable members on the Lib Dem benches. A government needs to be able to change the rules to the immigration system to reflect emerging circumstances, and if they had their way, the immigration system would be in absolute chaos, which we will not do. And the resolution that we have found between the different cohorts, including those that will be now eligible for a transitional arrangement, does represent a fair solution for everyone.
Chinyelu Susan Onwurah
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I commend my right honourable friend for consulting so widely in developing these earned settlement proposals, and listening to the representations of care workers in particular? And can I express my absolute astonishment at the party opposite refusal to accept moral, social, financial, or political responsibility for its failed immigration policies?
Now, these policies, these proposals will nevertheless adversely affect many. Can I raise particularly the issue of early career researchers, postdocs, etcetera, who will not be earning £50,000 a year, but will be contributing to our scientific understanding? Can I meet with her to discuss the impact on our science base?
Speaker 141
Well, look, I'm always happy to meet with the honourable lady and I'll happily discuss those issues with her, but the proposals that the Government has set out, including transitional arrangements for those cohorts in health and in education given our reliance on foreign labour in those sectors, and also the Migration Advisory Committee's specific treatment of those two sectors, I think that the Government has found a fair resolution for everyone.
Liz Roberts.
Liz Roberts
Thank you, Madam. The list of public sector jobs eligible to apply for the five-year settlement route does not appear to include prison officers.
What assessment has she made of the changes and the effect that they will have on the crisis-hit prison service?
Speaker 141
They don't include prison officers and that is because those transitional arrangements apply to those cohorts of workers that the Migration Advisory Committee recognizes on national pay scales in health and education for the purposes of the immigration rules. She'll know that it's a very small number of prison officers who will settle at 10 years, but let me confirm to her and the House that I have been discussing these measures with the Secretary of State for Justice and I will do everything I can to make sure that the prison service has the labor it needs in the future.
Julie Minns
I thank the Home Secretary for her statement. The previous Conservative government's approach to net migration can at best be described as marrying in haste and repenting at leisure.
Speaker 197
So, will the Home Secretary please ensure my Carlisle constituents that the new settlement rules will ensure that future immigration is built on long-term commitment and not on impulsive short-term fixes?
Speaker 141
Well, my honorable friend is absolutely right, and let me also say, repent at leisure would apply if there was, in fact, any repentance from the other side.
Ayoub Khan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Madam Deputy Speaker, the Home Office, Home Secretary said that anyone exploiting or abusing the system must be penalized, and I suspect the whole House agree. But in our constituency and certainly West Midlands region, Prestige Dental Practice, which has more than half a million patients in the West Midlands region, sponsors more than 40 skilled dental workers.
Last week, they've had their license revoked not because of exploitation or abuse, but because there's been an admin error in relation to three of the 40 employees. So will the Home Secretary please urgently look into this matter so patients, more than half a million, are not put at risk?
Speaker 141
Well, what I would say to the honourable gentleman is if he wishes to write about that specific case, he's welcome to do so. I would caution anybody making assumptions about why a license is revoked and I'm sure if it was a mere admin error, that will be looked at, but license revocations have happened at record numbers because, given the approach taken by the previous government, there was a desire to sign people up, but without much of an expectation of what standards should be met by those people.
Derek Twigg
I supported the Home Secretary's original proposals and also the tougher measures she's been taking since she became in post. I'm also pleased to say that she made it very clear about disqualification in terms of a criminal record. But can I ask her, has any assessment been made within the department about how many care of these care workers will remain in the care sector after the qualifying period?
Speaker 141
Well, let me say to my honorable friend, given the responses to the consultation, the majority of which from visa holders were from care workers, roughly 50% of those people said that once they achieve settlement, they will look to leave the care sector.
I think that is a recognition that they will then be able to get higher paid jobs elsewhere, and that is why colleagues across government, including in the Health Department, are looking carefully at standards in the care sector so that we can lift those standards, such that people wish to remain in the sector, and such that we're able to recruit other workers into that sector. Dr Andrew Murrison.
Andrew Murrison
Will migrants who come to this country and set up small businesses, legitimate small businesses that employ people who pay taxes, be advantaged in the scheme that the Home Secretary has announced for earned settlement? Or will they be excluded because they are not working people, according to the Chief Secretary to the Treasury's definition announced this weekend?
Speaker 141
Well, they'll need to meet the terms of their visa, which is the most important measure of how to ensure that people have come on terms and then fulfill the contribution they were always supposed to make.
Alexander Forbes McIntyre
Alex McIntyre. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. There was a certain irony to hear the shadow Home Secretary lecturing the House on who should be defined as highly skilled.
He certainly was he certainly was highly skilled at opening asylum hotels, including one in my constituency. And can the Home Secretary confirm that the proposals she's made today, with the other work she's doing in the department, will mean that hotel is closed by the end of this Parliament?
Speaker 141
Let me assure my honourable friend, the Government has already closed a number of asylum hotels. We've made a billion pounds worth of savings for asylum accommodation, and we will fulfill our manifesto commitment to close all hotels in this Parliament.
Robert Jenrick.
Edward Robert Jenrick
I respect the Home Secretary, but these are not the reforms that she wanted. When she said that the Boris wave was destabilising, unprecedented, when she agreed that it would cause incalculable damage, she was absolutely right. The Boris wave was the worst public policy failure of the 21st century, and now she risks locking it in for generations to come.
When the last Prime Minister, my Prime Minister, ignored my advice on immigration, I resigned. Her Prime Minister has ignored her advice on immigration, and the damage is going to be disastrous for this country. Why has she not considered her position?
Speaker 141
Well, I'll say to the honourable gentleman, he I mean, he too could do with more honesty about his own track record and more contrition, including the difference between some of the positions he took when he was a government minister in the Tory government, and those that he takes now.
But let me simply say to him, this, these reforms and the package that I have announced today and this is set out in the consultation document represents a fair solution for all of the cohorts that are caught by the new earned settlement proposals. We have made targeted exemptions where the circumstances justify it, and it is this government that is cleaning up the mess that we inherited from the previous lot.
Barry Gardiner.
Barry Gardiner
The Home Secretary is right to set out fairness as the guiding principles for her reforms. Does she accept that taking into account contribution and integration as a means of reducing the wait time are in fact subjective criteria whereby caseworkers might come to different conclusions and that would not be fair?
And does she agree that actually the unfairness on the British people here comes from a successive erosion of the difference between settlement and citizenship, so that all the benefits come with settlement and the only thing you get with citizenship is the blue passport and the right to return to the country within two years after two years?
Speaker 141
Well, let me say to my honorable friend, I mean, many rights do accrue at point of settlement. That has been government policy for successive government over many years and indeed many decades. And I don't wish to be creating a new system that has a two-tier approach to what settlement means: one for historic cohorts and a new one for those going forward, not least because there are those in this country, including on benches opposite, who wish to rip up the status of those who have indefinite leave to remain altogether.
I think that would be the wrong thing to do and it is unconscionable to throw into chaos the long-term residency arrangements for millions of people in this country, and this Government will not do that. Let me say to him on contribution and integration, the tests that need to be set are made clear in the consultation document. They are not subjective criteria. They are detailed criteria that will be applied by case workers in the future.
Bell Ribeiro-Addy.
Benjamin Obese-Jecty
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Home Secretary didn't address the issue of dependents for Armed Forces personnel. I know that in June, the majority of Members opposite voted down my amendment that would have included the waiving of visa fees in the Armed Forces Bill. I know that has now been overturned in the House of Lords and will be coming back here. Could she clarify exactly what will happen to the spouses and children of Armed Forces personnel?
Will their visa fees be waived, but if they earn less than £50,000, don't work in healthcare or a professional job, will they have to find themselves, sorry, lost my train of thought.
Speaker 141
I know what the honourable gentleman means. Let me assure him this situation in relation to all members of the armed forces is unchanged by the package of earned settlement measures. They have their own bespoke regime. On the waiver on the waiver of fees, let me say to him I will meet with him to discuss those matters.
Gareth Snell.
Craig Gareth Snell
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I wonder if the Home Secretary can set out what internal changes she is going to make inside the Home Office, because one of the complaints that I often get from people waiting for their ILR decision is the length of time it takes to get that outcome from the point of application.
So, as part of this new package to improve the system, what's going to happen to reduce that waiting time for those applicants?
Speaker 141
Well, I say to my honourable friend we've already made significant progress in improving Home Office processes. That is already evidenced by the fact that the backlog for initial decisions after an asylum application has decreased considerably. We've got removals up to over 80,000 since this Government has been in power alongside many other changes. So, what I would let me assure him that as these changes are rolled out and they will be rolled out over a period of time so that the systems are ready for each of those changes as they are made, I will ensure that the Home Office is equipped to be able to make timely decisions under the new rules.
Bernard Jeremy Corbyn
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Where is the fairness in prioritising very wealthy people and very high earners over much lower-paid care workers, who are obviously doing a very valuable job and helping all of our communities?
Speaker 141
Perhaps he missed the bit of my statement where I set out transitional arrangements for care workers.
Speaker 209
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Home Secretary will be well aware that the need for migrant workers varies throughout the country. Can I ask her what assessment her Home Office has made of the impact that these rule changes will make on areas like mine, in Lanarkshire, where the gap between the numbers of healthy working-age people and retirees is widening exponentially?
Speaker 141
Well, she'll know that immigration policy is a reserved matter and applies UK-wide, and the rules that we have announced today apply to everyone, everywhere. The Government will be publishing an impact assessment in the normal way around the same time as when the immigration rules are laid.
Ashley Peter Fox
Madam Deputy Speaker, whilst I welcome the earned progression model, it is disappointing that the Home Secretary has watered down her original proposals under pressure from Cabinet colleagues. Her plan to make illegal migrants wait 30 years for permission to remain will not deter any small boat crossings. Does she agree that the only way to stop the boats is to deport all those who arrive illegally?
Speaker 141
Well, firstly, what I would say to him is we have listened it was a genuine consultation and we have listened to the unique circumstances of those who came to work in the care sector, and I think it's right that we have arrangements recognising those unique circumstances.
And then, let me say to him, on illegal migrants, it is this Government that this year has overseen a 40% decrease in the number of people arriving by small boat. We've made a huge amount of progress, especially through our deal with the French Government and the law enforcement response trying to go after the gangs that, in the end, put people in those boats. And we will not rest until we have stopped people from arriving in this country by boats. And I do think that the settlement offer that people get when they arrive does make a material difference.
Dan Carden
I just wanted to say something that I think everybody in this House recognizes, which is that the Home Secretary is probably the first person in this job for two decades or more that is really got to grips with this system. Thank you. And she has achieved a great deal, and she also puts up with people projecting onto her what they think her view should be about immigration.
I wondered if she'd say a little bit about why rebuilding public confidence in the immigration system is so important for social cohesion.
Speaker 141
Well, let me thank my honorable friend for those remarks. He's absolutely right. There's quite a lot of projection that happens when you're a brown Muslim woman in the world of politics, but I am, alas, used to it. Let me say to him on rebuilding public trust, as I said in my statement, solidarity is a pre-condition of social justice, and if we are to have a system based on taxation of universal public services, people do need to know that everyone is contributing into the same collective pot that we then all can rely upon when we need to.
And I think that is how we maintain social cohesion in this country. A managed system where the government is in control, where it is not people smugglers who decide who gets to come into our country, but the government makes that choice with the consent of the British people, is absolutely the way to ensure that we have social cohesion and strong communities all over our country.
Kate.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'm aware that there are businesses that are not offering high-quality employment, and they are still able to get sponsorship licenses. And that's businesses like minimarts, barber shops, vape shops, nail bars. Will the Home Secretary make a commitment to review the type of businesses that can access these and stop these people being able to exploit people who are not high-quality employees?
Speaker 141
Let me tell the honourable lady and the House I am already reviewing the way in which the sponsorship register works and the conditions required of companies before they can sponsor workers into this country and I will be reporting to the House with set up
Rachael Maskell
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I will read the detail in the consultation, but I am concerned about retrospective changes because our word should be our bond to people coming here. But also in an economy where skills and contribution do not correlate with wages, I do find her proposals prejudicial on that basis.
Will she look at that again in the light of the consultation, so we can really put fairness at the heart of this?
Speaker 141
I disagree with at, my honorable friend as she knows from at, my statement today, which has listened to the consultation responses in detail, as I've set out for in answer to other honorable members, the position for settlement applications, the rules that apply at the point at which the decision is made, not when someone has come into the country. That has been settled law and settled policy for a very long time and it will not change.
Shockat Patel
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Home Secretary in her statement uses the word "fair", or different iterations of the word "fair", 20 times. In fact, it says that the Home Secretary's own parents left a place where power was arbitrary and the dice was always loaded, and came here because they would be treated fairly. Yet now a worker earning £40,000 who came here legally, paid their taxes, and played their part has now been moved from 5 years to 10 years, halfway through. Can I ask the Home Secretary, is changing the rules mid-game fair, or is it exactly what a loaded dice looks like?
Speaker 141
They're absolutely fair. He will know, of course, that for people that arrived around the time my parents and my grandad did, the rules changed often very regularly. And so, it is, as I said before, it has been settled policy that the rules that apply to an application are those at the point of decision, not at the point when someone arrives in the country. And it's actually made clear to people arriving on a temporary work visa that does not necessarily indicate settlement rights will follow. What we have done in our statement, in my statement today and in our consultation document responding to the consultation we carried out, is a fair resolution for all of the different cohorts that are affected by earned settlement, reflecting unique circumstances where appropriate, but also making sure that the default period does move to 10 years, which has been settled policy since last summer.
Kerry McCarthy
Kerry McCarthy. Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
I welcome the change on care workers, but can I just ask a bit more about those who, for one reason or another, their five years hasn't worked out? I know she says there'll be another five-year route. I met a care worker the other day who's basically injured her back because her employee didn't respect health and safety rules. She now can't do that job. She has a master's in financial management, she's a specialist in AI.
She knows she has to work as a care worker. Is she really going to have to start again once her back's healed?
Speaker 141
Well, the position for those who arrived on the care visa was that they needed to work within the care sector. I think it is fair to expect those that were unable to meet the terms of that visa to have a second shot at working again in the care sector. There are a number of jobs that are available in the care sector, not all of which require heavy lifting, and I'm sure that can be taken into account.
As I say, the government will assist care workers who've been unable to meet the terms of their visa to have that second chance at finding work with an appropriate work with a legitimate provider.
Tessa Munt
The 2009 Gurkha Justice campaign, spearheaded by Joanna Lumley, achieved settlement rights for British Army Gurkha veterans. My understanding is that many progress to settlement here by virtue of the access to indefinite leave to remain. So, can the Home Secretary reassure the House that none of these changes will adversely affect the ability of these heroes from being able to settle in the UK when they retire?
Speaker 141
Yes, as I said in response to a question from my honorable friend on the benches behind me, Gurkhas will have settlement under the armed forces rules, which are entirely exempt and different from earned settlement.
Kevin Bonavia
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the principle of earned settlement, where contribution to our society is rewarded, so it's right that we reward our care workers. In our schools, our teachers need to support their assistants. Can the Home Secretary tell us what support will be there for our teaching assistants?
Home Secretary.
Speaker 141
Yes, let me say to my honourable friend, those who are in the health and education sectors on below-degree-level jobs with national pay scales, such as teaching assistants, will be subject to the same transitional arrangement as I have set out for care workers who have met the terms of their visa today.
Sarah Green.
Speaker 223
Madam Deputy Speaker, in August last year, the Government admitted it had no idea how many people that came in on care worker visas were still working in the care sector.
How can she make an informed decision on their settled or earned settlement when she has no idea whether they're still here doing the jobs they came in to do?
Speaker 141
Well, when applying for settlement, people will need to evidence that they have been working and earning within the care sector. And based on analysis of HMRC data, we expect that three quarters of care workers will meet the test, the conditions of their visa, and be able to settle at five years.
Gurinder Josan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Home Secretary's statement and particularly the provision for care workers to obtain settlement on the existing five-year route.
Can the Home Secretary detail what support and provision is being offered to those who came here on a care visa and are tied to exploitative sponsors, or have not been able to continue working as care workers because of exploitative sponsors?
Speaker 141
The individuals he refers to will have a second chance, so will be able to apply for a new 5-year visa in the care sector, and the Government will double the amount of time that is normal to allow people to find another job with a legitimate employer. And the Government will help those individuals be matched with legitimate employers so they can work in the care sector.
Iqbal Mohamed
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. In my constituency, everybody that I've met and spoken to oppose any kind of illegal immigration into our country, but many people are in desperate need of help, and they are forced to come across via illegal routes.
So will the Home Secretary explain, just like the care workers workaround dispensation where they've been exploited, they have a second chance to get earn the status, will genuine refugees who came here in the absence of safe and legal routes be offered the same?
Speaker 141
No, I think the position in relation to those who enter the country unlawfully is different, not least because those who are arriving on a boat are doing so from the north of France, which is a safe country underpinned by the European Convention on Human Rights. I just have to say to him it is right to treat these different cohorts differently because their method of entry into the country is different, and it is right that a government is able to incentivize the behavior we wish to see and disincentivize those who pay people smugglers and who risk their lives in the Channel. I would hope that we could have agreed on that.
Kirsteen Sullivan.
Ann Kirsteen Sullivan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my right honourable friend for her statement today.
We continue to have acute workforce pressures in social care in Scotland that often see people stranded in hospital when they're fit to go home. So what conversations has she had with the Scottish Government around the need for robust workforce planning that has been absent for so long, to ensure that existing skills gaps are not exacerbated by these changes?
Speaker 141
I thank my honourable friend. She raises an important point. She'll know that, of course, workforce planning is not what we in the Home Office are responsible for, but she'll know that ministers in the health department are, of course, working very carefully on a workforce response, and I'm sure they are discussing these matters with their counterparts in the devolved administrations.
Jim Shannon.
Jim Shannon
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank the Minister for her statement. I broadly welcome the principle that permanent residency in our United Kingdom must be properly earned and the this Home Secretary has drawn the differential between those who immigrate and come and pay their taxes and national insurance and make a contribution, as against those who jump in a rubber raft at Calais and come across, economic migrants usually very healthy. The Minister's right to do that. Our public services, particularly the health and social care trusts in Northern Ireland, rely heavily on dedicated international workers who pay their taxes and play by the rules. So can the Home Secretary reassure my constituents that the policy will firmly reward legal, working contributions while cracking down on those who queue-jump the system?
Speaker 141
Well, he's absolutely right. The point of earned settlement is to reflect and provide settlement for those who contribute to this country and who meet the new minimum requirements, which includes no criminality and no debt. I think that is a fair deal for all concerned, not least the taxpayers, whose taxpayer money is what underpins all of the public services that we rely upon.
Gareth Davies.
Jonathan Peter Tom Davies
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I look forward to chewing through the details of what the Home Secretary has published today, but it is good to hear her talk about the role of societal contribution as a route to residency, and also the allowances that she's making for care workers. 4.2 million people, economic migrants came to this country under the previous government, whilst we had hundreds of thousands of British young people not in education, employment or training. What conversations is she having across government so that our immigration intake marries up to what we need in our labour market and economy?
Speaker 141
Well, it is absolutely right that, whilst we should be able to bring in workers from abroad when we need to fill market gaps in this country, we do, of course, have to make sure that we're always providing opportunities for domestic workers, not least the 1 million young people who are not in education, employment or training. We have an obligation to them, too, and it is important that we strike the right balance. The earned settlement reforms, I believe, strike the right balance for migrant workers and for British taxpayers, and let me assure him I am talking to colleagues across government. Immigration is not the only part of the answer. Skills and training here at home is also necessary, too.
Charles Noah Law
I welcome the recognition today by the Home Secretary of the crucial work made by overseas care workers. And does she agree with me that this approach is needed not just practically, but in also principally the right thing to do to ensure that those who contribute the most in those most underserved professions in our country are rewarded?
Home Secretary.
Speaker 141
Yes, let me tell him it was clear from the response to the consultation that of course, the position in relation to care workers was unique. They came at a specific moment post-COVID with those very real challenges in the care sector, and it is right to reflect that and to provide a five-year path to settlement for those who met the terms of their visa.
Markus Campbell-Savours
Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank you to the Home Secretary for her leadership on this issue. In the Lake District, due to housing shortages, there's been a long-established policy where social housing is subject to local occupancy restrictions, where only those with a local link, for example local employment, are eligible for housing. Does the Secretary of State agree that beyond the Home Office, her Cabinet colleagues also have power and responsibility to reduce the pull factors on immigration, not least those responsible for the fairness of housing policy?
Speaker 141
Well let me say to my honorable friend, I was not aware of those arrangements in the Lake District. He's right about the broader point that it is incumbent on all government departments to think about these issues in the round, and to strike a fair balance, and all of the conversations that I've had with my colleagues in Cabinet reflect that as the government position.
Patricia Ferguson.
Patricia Ferguson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I thank my right honorable friend for her statement today. I wonder if she could consider, however, the disparity that sometimes arises across the UK in terms of salaries. And I would point her to information published by the Royal Incorporation of Architects in Scotland just last month, which indicated that those in Scotland were likely to be earning up to 9% less than their counterparts in the rest of the UK.
We clearly wouldn't want people who are caught out by this anomaly to be caught out in the immigration system, too.
Madam Deputy Leader.
Speaker 141
My honourable friend makes an important point. She will know that those who are already in-country on lower salaries were given an exemption by the previous Government to be able to extend those visas at the same salaries, which is a we have agreed that we will extend that further to 2035 to enable those people to be able to achieve settlement. More broadly, she'll know that some of the changes in the Budget reflect Migration Advisory Committee advice on regional pay as well.
John Neil Duncan-Jordan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Given that someone earning over £50,000 will have a 5-year route to settled status while those earning less than £50,000 £1,000 will have a 10-year route, how will we assess whether a lawyer offers more value to our society than a teaching assistant apart from how much they earn?
Speaker 141
Well again, my honourable friend will know that there is a specific transitional arrangement for teaching assistants, because they are defined by the Migration Advisory Committee as being within the health and education sector on national pay scales and in those routes they will have a 5-year path if they arrive before May 2025.
Kirsty McNeill.
Amanda Martin
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome my right honourable friend's statement, and the distinction between illegal migrant and those who came legally to work and contribute. We must also confront, Madam Deputy Speaker, the mess left by the Conservatives, whose failure and mismanaged our immigration system is nothing short of a national scandal. Settlement should be earned through contribution and in Portsmouth I've seen this first hand through care workers looking after our most vulnerable.
So, can the Home Secretary reassure those who have already contributed so much that their contributions will be recognised, and those who haven't contributed and have tried to play the system will need to do so to remain?
Speaker 141
Well, let me reiterate to my honourable friend the transitional arrangement agreed for care workers reflecting the unique circumstances of that cohort. Those who have met the terms of their visa will be able to settle at five years. Those who haven't will get a second chance to make the contribution they originally came to make.
Chris Curtis
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and can I welcome the changes announced today and thank the Home Secretary for the way she's reached out during the consultation process, particularly listening to about our responsibility to those BNO visa holders? I just wanted to ask, particularly given this move towards a contributory system today, one of the challenges to doing this in the past has been with the OBR. They have struggled to correctly model the importance of contribution in our welfare system. They've made some changes, but those changes should continue.
Would the Home Secretary like to call on the OBR to continue to improve the way they model the economics of migration?
Speaker 141
Well, my honorable friend tempts me, but he knows that the OBR are independent. I'm sure they've heard his point on how the contribution of migrants is measured for the purposes of the forecasts that they make and the scoring decisions they make ahead of fiscal events. He will know that the approach taken by the Home Office, of course, is to look at settlement as a lifetime benefit, and therefore lifetime cost is what we have considered, as well as unique circumstances for particular cohorts. As he mentions the BNOs, he knows they are of course exempt from any of these income changes, reflecting our long-standing commitments to them. They do of course have to meet the new minimum requirements.
Steve Witherden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
I welcome the retention of the five-year ILR pathway. I've met with Nigerian and Zimbabwean social care workers in Newtown and in the Dyfi Valley, who will be greatly assured and relieved by today's statement. Will my right honourable friend join me in celebrating the huge contribution that these workers make to our health and social care system every day?
Home Secretary.
Speaker 141
Yes, my honourable friend is absolutely right. These workers have been making a contribution, and that is why, given their unique circumstances and the fact that many of them have met the terms of their visa, they will be able to settle at five years.
Josh Newbury.
Josh Newbury
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Home Secretary is absolutely right to talk about the British people's sense of fairness.
I heard exactly that on the doorsteps in Cannock Chase just this weekend. Not only did the Conservatives let millions into Britain over just a few years, they left indefinite leave to remain at five years, regardless of someone's contribution. So, does the Home Secretary agree with me that these changes will introduce fairness, so that those who want to settle here make a fair, positive contribution?
Speaker 141
My honorable friend is absolutely right. Fairness is what underpins these reforms, and fairness to all those, not just those who've arrived here to work lawfully, but also those who are already here, who pay for the systems we all depend upon.
Chris Hinchliff
Madam Deputy Speaker, almost everyone who speaks to me about immigration in my constituency say they welcome those who come to work hard in our country and play by the rules. But as the Home Secretary will know, there are many of those workers across multiple sectors of the economy who face significant exploitation from their visa sponsors.
The Home Secretary referred to helping workers break away from rogue employers in her statement. So, will she meet with those of us who are interested in a certificate of common sponsorship to resolve this problem?
Speaker 141
As I've said, the government will assist people who have been with a rogue employer in the care sector to be able to get legitimate work within the care sector for their renewal of their five-year care visa. Let me say to him the Home Office will of course amend sponsorship regimes following changes made by the Health Secretary and her team. They're looking carefully at what the minimum conditions and standards should be in this sector and I have already undertaken that we will follow that once those changes are made.
Connor James Naismith
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Framing this statement today is the fact that net migration is down 82% under this Labour Government, under this Home Secretary, compared with the peak under the previous Conservative Government. But alongside the changes that she is making on legal migration, can she confirm that there will be serious consequences for settlement for those entering our country via dangerous and illegal means?
Speaker 141
I thank my honourable friend for that contribution. He's right, net migration is down under this Government, and we are taking steps to make sure that we bring coherence and rationality to the migration system, and fixing the mess left behind by the previous Government. Let me say to him, on illegal migration, that is why there is an additional waiting period of 10 years. We did consult on this matter, and there was plurality of support for this measure.
And it reflects the fact that, in the end, a Government and its people have to be in control of our migration system, not people-smuggling gangs.
Speaker 248
That is the end of the statement on earned settlement. I'll give the Front Benches a very quick moment to shuffle over. Presentation of bill, Mr Richard Holden.
Second reading what day?
Speaker 247
Friday the 15th of January 2027. We now come to the 10-minute rule motion, submarine recycling strategy, Graeme Downie.
Graeme James Downie
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move that leave be given to bring in a bill to require the Secretary of State to prepare and publish a strategy for recycling decommissioned submarines and connected purposes. Madam Deputy Speaker, every time I drive back to my constituency, there is one sight that tells me I'm nearly home. It's not a cathedral or a castle, it's a Goliath crane that stands above Babcock's dockyard at Rosyth. This crane came to the area just over 15 years ago to help put together the Queen Elizabeth-class aircraft carriers, and it's been part of the West Fife skyline ever since.
The dockyard underneath the crane has been a good deal there a good deal longer, more than a century, and the people who work there are some of the most skilled that I have the privilege to represent.
Right now, they're doing something nobody in this country or any other has done before. HMS Swiftsure, a Cold War hunter-killer submarine that left service in 1992, is on track to become the first Royal Navy nuclear submarine ever to be fully dismantled, with the work due to finish by the end of this year. And around 90% of her is expected to be reused or recycled. Madam Deputy Speaker, more than 500 tons of material has already been stripped out and recycled, cabling, circuit boards, insulation, electrical equipment, each sorted into its own waste stream.
Her fin has been lifted off whole so its steel can be recovered, and the best of that high quality steel from these boats is already being turned into components for future Royal Navy submarines, such as the Dreadnought class. Put simply, Madam Deputy Speaker, the submarines that kept us safe through the Cold War are helping to build the ones that will keep us safe for decades to come.
I've been to see this work for myself. I've been inside HMS Swiftsure and seen the incredible care, diligence and professionalism that the workforce bring to their jobs. I want to thank everyone who's involved in the work, in particular Ken Dyce, the nuclear operations director, Gary Thomson, who supervises the lifting and Dean McGuinness, one of the welders on the project. They and their colleagues have made an incredibly complex process look very straightforward, but it is anything but. Madam Deputy Speaker, other countries are watching our work.
Australia, our AUKUS partner, will one day have to retire its own nuclear submarines and it will not be the only one. If we can get this right, what is being learned at Rosyth is something we can sell and export to the world. But in the end, this is a story about people more than these old boats.
It's about the apprentice starting out, the engineer picking up skills that very few people have, and families who can find a good job without ever having to leave Fife. Madam Deputy Speaker, governments of every color have known about this problem for a very long time, indeed going back to the first nuclear submarines that were commissioned. In 1995, a Conservative defense minister stood at Rosyth and promised that the dockyard would not become a graveyard for old submarines. Thirty-one years on, six submarines are still waiting, and the seventh is only now being finished. Dreadnought, Britain's very first nuclear submarine, has been tied up at Rosyth since 1980.
She has now spent far longer waiting to be recycled than she ever spent at sea. In 2019, the National Audit Office found that not one of the 20 retired submarines since 1980 had been disposed of.
The Ministry of Defence that had hoped to begin working in this process by 2011, and it has missed that by years. Promise after promise and far too little delivered, and that is a gap that this bill seeks to close. Madam Deputy Speaker, alongside Swiftsure, six boats at Rosyth are awaiting their turn: HMS Dreadnought, Churchill, Resolution, Repulse, Renown and Revenge. Another 16 are at Devonport.
Madam Deputy Speaker, about 200 people are currently working on the program at Rosyth today. Carry that work on to the next phase, and Rosyth could support around 300 skilled jobs for 20 to 30 years and, perhaps, even longer. That is not an offer you get in many areas of industrial policy.
Since I was elected, I've raised this with ministers more times than I can count, and I'm sure ministers are probably fed up of answering written questions about this topic. But I will keep doing so because Rosyth should be the place the country, and indeed the world, turns to carry out this work. We talk a lot about in this place about growth, usually in percentages and forecasts, but growth should not be abstract. Growth is a young person getting an apprenticeship. Growth is somebody landing a skilled job.
Growth is a family feeling secure enough to buy a home. Growth is a community knowing that investment is coming and jobs are being maintained. Every boat dismantled means work for welders, engineers, project managers, technicians, and orders for local suppliers, and places on courses at Fife College and Forth Valley College.
And yet, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm sad to say that some on opposition benches have opposed this work. At the very moment the Rosyth workforce is showing it can be done safely and to higher standards, some in the SNP have chosen to peddle unnecessary scare stories, instead of trusting the skill and dedication of local people doing incredible work. Madam Deputy Speaker, that's scandalous. It means turning their backs on hundreds of skilled jobs, and on apprenticeships for young people in Fife. The men and women at Rosyth are not a risk to be managed.
They're the reason that this is working. So, I would say to anyone in the SNP who opposes this programme, come to Rosyth, meet the workforce, and then explain to them why you would rather their jobs went somewhere else, because some other country will attempt to crack this. What the Rosyth workforce needs more than anything is certainty.
You cannot switch skills like this on and off. Leave a long gap between one boat and the next, and the experienced people retire or move on, the apprentices find work elsewhere, and we end up starting from scratch: further delays, further cost and further nuclear submarines sitting in Rosyth not being handled. Madam Deputy Speaker, this Bill would place a duty on the Secretary of State to publish a strategy for recycling the UK's decommissioned submarines. It would have to include a timetable for the boats waiting at Rosyth and at Devonport, a plan for the skills and supply chain the work relies on, the arrangements for safe regulation and waste, and regular reports back to this House. Madam Deputy Speaker, we don't need any more open-ended promises; a published plan and ministers answerable to Parliament for delivering it.
Madam Deputy Speaker, there's a security argument, too. Being able to look after a nuclear submarine from the day it is built to the day the last piece of it is recycled is part of having a sovereign nuclear capability, and we should keep that capability in this country.
For more than a century, Rosyth has helped keep this country safe. The six submarines still sitting in the Forth represent years of work, hundreds of careers and a chance to build something here that the rest of the world is going to need. Madam Deputy Speaker, this bill is for Ken, Garry, Dean and the people they work aside alongside, and for the young people of Fife who could follow in their footsteps, and I commend this bill to the House.
Speaker 247
The question is that the honourable Member have leave to bring in the bill. As many of that opinion say aye. Contrary no. The ayes have it. The ayes have it.
Who will prepare and bring in the bill?
Graeme James Downie
Mike Martin, Sarah Hall, Damien Egan, Alex Baker, Alex Ballinger, Richard Baker, Michelle Scrogham, Lincoln Jopp, Al Carns, David Taylor, Luke Akehurst and myself.
Speaker 247
4th of December 2026. The Clerk will now proceed to read the orders of the day.
Speaker 247
Now, the question is as on the Order Paper, and I call the Secretary of State, Angela Rayner.
Angela Rayner
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This is a budget with immediate action today and clear direction for the future. If we want to build a Britain where all people can live a good life and live it well, where everyone has control to shape their own lives for themselves, and where no one's future is limited by where they're from, because only the ceiling of their ambition, then what we need is good growth in every postcode.
But we also know people need a bit of breathing space right now, Madam Deputy Speaker, which is why we've announced targeted support for households this winter and action to bring down the cost of essentials. We are a government with a clear theory of growth: retake control and devolve power to places. We're making a fundamental shift of where and how decisions are made by transferring powers, resources and functions to mayors, strategic authorities and local authorities across England, and we're working with the devolved administrations of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.
This shift means local leaders with skin in the game can target spending towards the biggest issues in their communities: new housing projects, infrastructure that cuts workers' commutes and investment in our town centres. The Fiscal Devolution Roadmap, Madam Deputy Speaker, published alongside the budget, sets out a new funding model so local leaders can rise to this challenge, so that by the end of the decade, local and regional government will retain a hundred per cent of the business rates income. It sets out plans for mayored strategic authorities to receive a share of local income tax revenues from 2028 and details how the overnight visitor levy will work, as well as our plans to explore further fiscal devolution. I'll give way.
Andrew George
I'm very grateful that the right honourable lady has given way.
She said that she wants to ensure there is good growth in every postcode, refers to the business rating system, but of course, in the budget, the Chancellor has extended the tax loophole available to holiday lets in places in postcodes like those in Cornwall and in other tourist areas. So, is she aware that billions of pounds is handed out to second home owners who flip their property to holiday letting in order to take advantage of a tax loophole and wouldn't it be far better to invest that money in social housing for local people in desperate housing need?
Angela Rayner
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The honourable member, I know he's got a Private Member's Bill, but I would gently say to him, in this budget as well, was an extra 1.5 billion homes towards social housing, which I welcome. That takes it overall amount up to 40 billion in the next 10 years. We should be welcoming that investment.
And at this budget, we have also announced £285 million of core growth funding, including incubator funding for areas that are yet to have a mayor, and plans for the 1.5 million of borrowing facility for mayors from 2028. This will give them access to capital needed to back their local priorities and deliver growth in every postcode. We have also confirmed an uplift to mayoral capacity funding of £150 million in 2027-28 to give them the resources they need as their range of powers grow. And to support mayors, we are publishing guidance on place-based business cases. This represents a new approach to appraisal that puts local objectives and potential at the heart of decision-making.
We recognise that right now too much of England is not covered by strategic authority, and so we remain committed to filling the gap. This is why I was delighted that the Budget we announced we are in the final stages of agreeing devolution deals in Devon, Plymouth and Torbay, Hertfordshire, Lancashire, Leicester, Leicestershire and Rutland, Stoke and Staffordshire, Surrey, Thames Valley, Kent and Medway, Wessex and Cornwall. And these areas will join Cheshire and Warrington, Cumbria, Sussex and Brighton, Hampshire and the Solent, Greater Essex and Norfolk and Suffolk at the forefront of the Government's ambitious programme to expand devolution.
Together, Madam Deputy Speaker, these agreements will mean over 90% of England's population is covered by a devolution agreement, with mayoral devolution reaching every part of the north. And we will continue working with all remaining areas, including Bedford, Central Bedfordshire, Luton, and Milton Keynes, where there is broad agreement, but not yet local consensus. I will give way to the honorable lady.
Alison Louise Griffiths
I thank the Secretary of State for giving way. The one county she hasn't mentioned in that very long list is West Sussex. And West Sussex has been waiting for 2 and 1/2 years of dither and delay. So, will the Secretary of State take this opportunity to tell me now, what is the plan for West Sussex?
Angela Rayner
Well, again, Madam Deputy Speaker, I did just say that we're working with all other remaining areas.
Again, Madam Deputy Speaker, I did just say that we're working with all other remaining areas, and we will continue to do so where we can find that local consensus, because we're the party of devolution who believes with working with local leaders. And later this year we will also publish our full plan for rewiring the state, outlining the vision for devolution in England. The changes that we have announced are about devolution, not delegation. Where powers and functions are transferred, they will not be duplicated at the centre. This means that over time Madam Deputy Speaker, central government will become smaller, but more strategic.
I'll give way.
Shockat Patel
Secretary of State, thank you for giving way. And she mentioned Leicester, Leicestershire and Rutland.
Can the Secretary of State please give a defining date of when this devolution will happen, because we are severely missing out on the funds and pots of money that's going elsewhere?
Angela Rayner
Well, again, Madam Deputy Speaker, we are working with the local areas to make sure that we could do that as quickly as possible, and we're happy to engage with local leaders as part of that program. And as we move towards a local government finance settlement, we will continue working with local leaders to plan and invest for the long term. And I am clear that local government is the foundation of the public services that neighborhoods and communities rely on are an essential to wider ambition to rewire the state. I'll give way.
Ayoub Khan
Secretary of State, for giving way, and I wholeheartedly support the regional mayors delivering to local communities, but the Labour government is always promoting localisation and devolution. How will she ensure that regional mayors interact and work with local councillors? After all, local councillors are elected and re- represent their local neighbourhoods.
Angela Rayner
Well, again, Madam Deputy Speaker, our plans and what we're putting forward is about making sure that mayors work with local authorities. In fact, in my area in Greater Manchester, we've seen the combined authority have a real good pulling power where our economy is doing better than other areas. So, we want to see that across the whole of the nations. This is why the cabinet statement on Rewiring the Estate committed to the financial sustainability of local authorities and this budget is the next step towards that. The upcoming local government finance policy statement will set out our next steps alongside the Rewiring the Estate delivery plan.
And good growth is growth that you can see and feel. We need to draw a line under a decade of drift where the public realm had been seen as a sideshow to politics.
At this Budget, at this Budget, you should know about sideshows. Our high streets are where we catch up with friends for a coffee, the businesses from them provide solid jobs and at the heart of our communities. These small moments of joy give you real hope, and that's why our strategy is giving hope back to the high streets, Madam Deputy Speaker. New powers, new funding and changes to the business rate system will provide much-needed relief for thousands of cafes, pubs and high street shops.
We're freezing all retail, hospitality and leisure bills in real terms to protect them from above-inflation bill increases for the next two years, and we're lifting the small businesses rate relief thresholds for qualifying properties.
And I'll give way.
Connor James Naismith
I thank my right honourable friend for giving way, and my constituents will strongly welcome the decision to extend small business rate relief to many more businesses in the Crewe and Nantwich constituency, but they'll also welcome the decision to remove small business rate relief from adult gaming centres and vape shops. Will she join me in saying that this is an important step to incentivise the kind of business that we want to see, and disincentivise those that we don't?
Angela Rayner
He's absolutely right, Madam Deputy Speaker. We are removing business rates relief for vape shops and adult gaming centres, and giving local authorities stronger tools to tackle business rates avoidance.
And at the budget we announced an extra 20% business rates cut for pubs and all but the largest live music ven- venues. And we are also introducing a general anti-avoidance rule for business rates at the earliest opportunity, and expanding what legal costs local authorities can claim when they are unsuccessful. I'll give way.
Jade Jessica Toale
I thank my right honourable friend for giving way, and I really welcome the change to the business rates threshold. It's taking hundreds of businesses in Bournemouth town centre out of paying rates. But I wondered if she considered the knock-on impact on business improvement districts, who are often stepping up to fill the gap where councils can't keep the streets clean, or keep the shopfronts looking nice.
So as more are coming out of rates, can she say what more the government is doing to look at the impact on BIDs? Thank you.
Angela Rayner
Well, again, there's a number of measures that we've been taking forward, like the overnight visitor levy, working with businesses, and hopefully as devolution pushes down into local communities, there is a role for the public realm, as well as business and innovators and those in the community and voluntary sector that do so much, and volunteers in our local community. But more broadly, Madam Deputy Speaker, we're also moving government buildings on to the high streets and improving design standards, a whole government plan to show the public that the best days of our high streets are yet to come. I'll happily give way on that point.
Claire Hazelgrove
I'm grateful to the Secretary of State for giving way. Gravesham is one of the youngest boroughs in Kent, but it has it is the fourth highest in the South East for NEETs, for young people in unemployment.
Does she also agree with me to welcome the youth hub in Gravesham on our high street so that young people can find a way back into education, training and employment?
Speaker 247
Before the Secretary of State responds, there are over 84 colleagues hoping to contribute, so every minute we can give to backbenchers will go down well. Secretary of State.
Angela Rayner
Noted, Madam Deputy Speaker. Absolutely. I really applaud what Gravesham is doing, especially towards the young people as well. And, Madam Deputy Speaker, the strategy is backed by £125 million to transform derelict buildings in our high street, £65 million for community ownership funding and £10 million to deliver high street rental auctions. Alongside this, we're cracking down on illegitimate and illegal businesses, giving councils powers to limit vape shops and adult gaming centres and reforming licensing.
The state of our town and city centres say so much about us, who we are as a country and whether we are on the right path. Getting our high streets back on track is a crucial step to getting Britain hope again. But this strategy is it's one part of our plan to make people proud of their local area. And alongside this, we have confirmed plans for a new Number 10 North priority projects programme. This will unlock homes, jobs, investment and long-term economic growth, with Number 10 North working directly with new strategic authorities.
The budget will also accelerate the delivery of priority projects in West Yorkshire, the west of England, and South Yorkshire.
This includes investment to expand the Leeds College of Building to accommodate over 2,000 new learners, crowding in around £350 million of private investment into Bristol Temple Quarter, and match funding incubator space in the Don Valley corridor. And we will continue to support growth in London as one of the world's most important cities. Working with the Mayor of London to bring forward improvements to the transport network and towards a global city productivity plan. And more widely, we have also confirmed that all 20 strategic authorities will be eligible for funding in the new co-operative development program.
This £10 billion program is the biggest government-backed boost to co-operatives for decades, and it shows how we're steamrolling onto meet our commitment to our sister party to double the size of the co-operative economy. Madam Deputy Speaker, in the years ahead, we will continue to deliver the £5.8 billion Pride in Place programme, putting local residents in charge of change across almost 300 neighbourhoods. And this month, we will see the next major milestone of the programme as we reach the deadline for phase two neighbourhoods to submit their 10-year plan. And we will continue to work with the devolved Administrations in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland too, confirming at the Budget, Madam Deputy Speaker, the investment in the Edinburgh-Glasgow central belt, funding for the expansion of the M-SParc science park in Anglesey and Cardiff Parkway station, and the £7.5 million of investment to grow AI and cyber industries in Belfast.
Our plans for good growth will shape the future of this country, but we also know that people need breathing space right now. Alongside radical reforms to reduce bills in the future, we have also announced a series of measures to tackle the cost of living and help make everyday life easier. We know that rising energy costs are going to be tough for a lot of households this winter. This is why we are removing VAT and standing charges from bills, freezing fuel duty, and providing a £100 per household energy payment in council tax bands A to D in England.
Madam Deputy Speaker, this is supporting up to 80% of households in England and local authorities will get a discretionary fund of a £100 million to provide further support to households most in need. And on top of this, we have taken action to make groceries cheaper by cutting import duties, increase the living wage and the minimum wage, extended parental leave, and ended the carers allowance cliff edge. We brought in higher tax-free mileage rates and boosted support for nurses, and we are making sure that pensioners in receipt of full state pension won't have to pay tax. Madam Deputy Speaker, Britain is a kind, caring nation, where people take pride in looking out for each other. And in 2026, the world's fifth richest economy, everyone should have a roof over their head.
That is why we will make sure that by Christmas this year, everyone sleeping rough will be offered a route off the streets. And earlier this year, I announced £442 million for new rough sleeping program to meet that milestone. But support off the street shouldn't be just for Christmas. So, now we're almost doubling that figure to £432 million to keep that offer going for the next two years. That means continuing to help people off the streets while preventing people from returning to them and giving them support that they need.
And that's why we'll make sure there's wraparound support for those people, as well. The budget makes progress towards our commitments to deliver the biggest booth boost in council house building since the postwar period, and we have announced that we will extend the preferential borrowing rate for councils on top of the 1.5 billion pounds that I mentioned earlier. Our message to local leaders is get ambitious and will back you all the way. And MHCLG's Plan Assist AI tool will be available to all councils in England by the end of 2027. Madam Deputy Speaker, we also announced the Your First Home scheme to help around 70,000 first-time buyers to get on the ladder.
And good growth in every postcode isn't just about fairness, it's a simple point that Britain is at its best when every part of the country can play their part. I'm proud of this Government's action, Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm proud of our history, and I'm proud of this budget, and I commend this statement to the House.
Andrew Bowie
Madam Deputy Speaker. Growth in every postcode, breathing space, that's the theme of today's debate, apparently. That is what we're told that this budget will deliver. But the sad fact is, Madam Deputy Speaker, is that it could have been, it really could have been an opportunity to focus on growth, to support British businesses and the British people. It really was an opportunity to fix the mistakes of the past two years, an opportunity to get the back to back business and unleash Britain.
But they didn't take it and all we appear to have from the Secretary of State today is more government will solve all of our problems.
It was an opportunity to end the smash-and-grab tax policies on working people, including, by the way, employers, Madam Deputy Speaker, but Labour doubled down. The Chancellor could have demonstrated when he resigned as Defence Secretary that he did so out of principle and set out a road to 3% of GDP on defence, but no, we didn't get that either. They could have taken steps to cut welfare and get Britain working, but, too scared of their backbenchers, they are allowing the welfare budget to continue to spiral out of control. Madam Deputy Speaker, this budget was a total missed opportunity. Far from growth in every postcode, far from breathing space, we saw a steady-as-she-goes budget: a change of captain, a rearranging of the deckchairs, but no change of course, which would be fine if the vessel we were on were not the Titanic.
One area we did see some action, and one issue that was mentioned considerably in the budget was energy, Madam Deputy Speaker, the cost of energy and our energy security, or lack thereof, and albeit slight, but definite acknowledgment that the energy policies being enacted by the Labour Government up to this point have been having a negative impact on the people and businesses of Great Britain, which is why I was more than a little surprised not to see energy as a theme of this budget debate, and why I was surprised not to see the Secretary of State for Energy speaking as part of this debate. Or is it that she actually isn't too keen on this change of direction?
That this moderate shift towards something resembling common sense from the government doesn't sit well with her. I mean where is she? Absent from Parliament when they announced Jackdaw, absent from the budget debate, either in hiding, or being kept hidden.
The words of the Chancellor last week that his right honourable friend had opposed, rather than approved, Jackdaw wasn't so much as a slip of the tongue as a lifting of the veil into the division at the heart of this Government when it comes to energy policy, because that's the truth of it, Madam Deputy Speaker. We have a Government today totally divided on energy policy, between a Chancellor and a Treasury desperate for growth and for some good news on one side, and an Energy Secretary and a parliamentary party still wholly signed up to a Milibandism approach to energy that is net zero, clean power 2030, above all else, above jobs, above costs, and above our security. I mean, Madam Deputy Speaker, we have an Energy Secretary briefing out she's inclined not to approve Rosebank, presumably on the basis that growth in every postcode doesn't include postcodes that begin with AB, and a Chancellor briefing that it will be approved soon.
We have Labour backbenchers claiming Rosebank is oh so different to Jackdaw because it is oil and that is exported, not like gas that we use at home, as if somehow generating revenue from exports displacing Russian oil from the European market and backing British jobs is a bad thing. But we also have a budget for office, an Office for Budget Responsibility that includes revenue from Rosebank and future discoveries as part of its projections for government revenue over the next year. We have a Treasury cutting funding from CCUS projects and energy ministers scrambling over themselves to insist that funding hasn't been cut, a Treasury announcing a cut to the warm homes fund of £1 billion, and an energy department insisting that the warm homes fund remains at the heart of the government's plans to support those on lowest incomes insulate and decarbonize. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is utterly chaotic.
No wonder the Energy Secretary is being hidden away or in hiding. For over two years now, we have been listening to various ministers lecture and patronize us on this side that we were wrong, that we didn't need more gas from the North Sea, that it was clean power that mattered over the cost of energy, that we must have consensus on energy policy. Well, we on this side of the House have been clear from day one: The cost of energy, the security of our energy supply, the future of our North Sea, these are the issues that should guide and shape our energy policies. And it is good to see that consensus may be returning, and not just on the entirely reasonable and sensible step of ensuring one has a well-stocked fridge of Sauvignon Blanc ready for emergencies.
And on that, I will certainly give way.
Iqbal Mohamed
I thank the right honourable member for giving way. Would he agree that unlike Norway who kept its crown jewels and North Sea oil and gas and is funding public services, that it was absolutely disastrous and wrong for the Tory government to sell off the North Sea that belonged to the people who are now paying through their nose for energy?
Andrew Bowie
Well, no, I it won't surprise the honourable gentleman to to to to to learn that I do not agree with him. In fact, what we have seen is the billions of pounds generated since the 1960s for this country, driven by the private sector investing in jobs, investing in this country, creating wealth, and making the North Sea one of the cleanest and safest basins in the world in which to invest. I'm very proud of the companies and the men and women who've driven this oil and gas industry to be the best in the world. And unlike him, and unlike the party opposite, we want to see that go further, and we want to see further investment in our North Sea and our oil and gas industry. But as I was saying, consensus, Madam Deputy Speaker, is welcome, because we are in an energy crisis, and there is and there is no and there is no escaping that.
The people and businesses of this country face some of the highest energy bills, domestic and industrial, in the developed world, and it is getting worse. Under Labour, our energy system is becoming increasingly unreliable and intermittent, and more reliant on imported energy. The burden of expensive energy is bearing down on Britain, on households, on businesses, and industry, and is having severe consequences. And whilst the Chancellor did acknowledge this, which was as welcome as it was surprising, it was entirely underwhelming. Some of the announcements may have seemed impressive, but they won't even touch the sides, £100 for certain households, when people's bills are set to increase by over £500 in January, many will ask what was the point?
Will they even notice it? But it's clear the Chancellor had at least noticed the Conservatives' cheap power plan: cutting VAT on energy bills, scrapping levies on bills. I wonder where they might have gotten the idea to do that, of course.
Jim Shannon
I thank the shadow minister for giving way. And one of the things which, have to say with respect to the Labour Government, missing in the budget is the working middle class. They're caught in a devastating pincer movement between the frozen thresholds and rising surcharges. They've worked extra shifts, have been responsible in the way they've lived, have put a modest amount of savings aside. In this budget today, the working middle class find themselves being penalized for their aspiration, forced to pay out more of their hard-earned pockets while watching inflation erode their savings.
Does the honorable gentleman agree with me what's missing today is any consideration for the working middle class?
Andrew Bowie
Well, my honorable friend is absolutely right, but, as usual, the Labour Party gives no regard to those with aspiration or that want to succeed and get on. All they care about is handouts and subsidies for Benefits Street. We are the party that will support those who are working hard to do the right thing and move forward. But to return to consensus, cutting VAT on energy bills, yes, of course.
Connor James Naismith
The honorable member talked about the opposition's Clean Power Plan and how marvelous, apparently, it is. If those ideas were so good, why did his party not implement them when they had 14 years?
Andrew Bowie
Well, it's the cheap power plan, not the clean power plan, but I don't want to be a too much of a stickler for detail. It might not have escaped, it escaped his notice that we are under a new management now in the Conservative Party, and I look forward to implementing our plan when we win the election. Madam Deputy Speaker, there was also the surprise announcement of the removal of standing charges on gas bills. Well, only surprising for the SNP group leader for Angus and Perthshire Glens, who didn't know if he still supported the move that he called for back in 2024. But Madam Deputy Speaker, on the face of it, yes, this may appear to lower bills, but as ever, the devil is in the detail.
Because if you're a higher consumer, one that uses gas for heating, cooking or hot water, then your energy bill is going to go up. Now, across Britain, temperatures are beginning to drop as we head into winter, and in large parts of this country, in the north of England, in Scotland, it just got more expensive to turn your heating on, thanks to Labour.
Madam Deputy Speaker, 80% of houses in Britain rely on gas to keep them warm, which is why the delay to make a decision regarding Jackdaw were so maddening. When the Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero approved the decision through gritted teeth, it was justified, rightly so, on the basis of energy security. Getting gas out of the Jackdaw field is what is best for Britain, because every bit of gas from that field will go directly into the British gas network. As I said, Madam Deputy Speaker, the devil is in the detail, because as I have already said, we are all very surprised to see that revenue from Rosebank is still being accounted for in the OBR's projections for revenue. Considering the Secretary of State has suggested to the press she is not minded to approve Rosebank, despite it being quasi-judicial, does that mean that the forecasts are possibly misleading, or wrong, or is the Chancellor about to get his way again, and is Rosebank about to get the go-ahead?
We need to have this cleared up, we need to understand.
Madam Deputy Speaker, the theme for today's debate is growth in every postcode, breathing space, but this budget did nothing for growth. It gave no breathing space except for a couple of gasps of cold air from those who are too scared to turn on their heating this Christmas. It could have. We could have seen a bold budget, one that said without equivocation we support our North Sea oil and gas industry, that would have gotten Britain drilling by removing the energy profits levy and today, not in three years; one that reduced the cost of energy by slashing levies, charges, and taxes that still make up too much of an individual or business's energy bill; one that could have re-industrialized our country by incentivizing investment and growth, not one that doubled down on net-zero and the linkage of the ETS with Europe. That's the budget we needed to see, Madam Deputy Speaker.
That's the budget the Conservatives would have presented. And that's the budget we will present when we win the next general election.
Speaker 247
And because we have so many colleagues wishing to contribute, backbenchers are on a five-minute speaking limit. Helen Hayes.
Elizabeth Helen Hayes
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The government's commitment to children and young people is clear in the scale of reforms to education that they are bringing forward, from the restoration of early years services through Best Start family hubs, the expansion of childcare, rollout of free breakfast clubs, curriculum reform, SEND reform, technical and vocational qualifications from the age of 14, work experience, social media regulation, and apprenticeships.
It is the Education Select Committee's role to scrutinise the detail of the government's policies and its delivery, but there can be no doubt about the scale of its ambition for children and young people across our country. I welcome the announcement in the budget of the establishment of a new parental allowance for self-employed fathers, partners, and adopters, which will enable parents who have previously been excluded from parental leave and pay to have precious bonding time together as a family with their baby or adopted child. Earlier this year, my committee published a report on reading for pleasure, which documented the immense benefits of reading for pleasure for children and young people for the development of empathy and compassion, good mental health and wellbeing, language skills, and attainment at school. We also highlighted the concerning drop in the number of children and young people choosing to read for pleasure, and a range of interventions that are needed to turn this situation around. I therefore welcome the addition £15 million, the additional £15 million that the government has allocated in the budget to increase access to books for young children.
I would, however, add that the most concerning decline in reading for pleasure is amongst teenagers and that school libraries can play a hugely valuable role in supporting children to sustain reading at secondary school. My committee has called on the government to extend its important pledge to deliver a library in every primary school to secondary schools as well. This can be done for an investment of £50 million and I hope the government will continue to look at how this important pledge can be extended. My committee has examined the delivery of apprenticeships and we noted that children and young people are not provided with nearly enough information about apprenticeships and that this information often does not come in time for them to consider apprenticeships properly as an alternative to university.
I therefore welcome the expansion of the mayoral apprenticeship brokerage pilots, which have the potential to ensure both that employers are supported to offer more apprenticeships and that young people have access to information about these fantastic opportunities in their local area. And I welcome the increase of £60 million per year for new PE and sport partnerships to increase the availability of high-quality opportunities for children and young people to participate in sport and physical activity in school and in their local area, directly contributing to better physical and mental health. But there are some areas of interest to my Committee which were not covered by the Budget and about which we remain concerned. Our report on higher education and funding raised concerns about the impact of the international student levy on higher education institutions and a lack of join-up between the Home Office and the Department for Education.
The Government's impact analysis for the proposed international student levy now suggests a loss of income to the higher education sector of £280 million, over £100 million higher over three years than originally estimated. Universities consistently told us that the international student levy was going to prove to be relatively inelastic to increases in fees, and the impact analysis supports this. We can be enormously proud of our universities. They are internationally renowned powerhouses of economic growth and anchor institutions in their communities, and they offer life-changing opportunities to thousands of young people and mature students every year. But they are facing extreme precarity in their financial sustainability, and it is vitally important the Government policy seeks to bolster them and not to push them over the cliff over a cliff edge.
So I urge the Government to look carefully again at the international student levy to ensure that it is proportionate and fit for purpose.
Madam Deputy Speaker, my committee has long been raising concerns about the disparity in the treatment of further education colleges with regard to VAT compared to schools. Further education colleges have a critical role to play in the government's important objective of reducing the scandal of almost 1 million young people who are not in education, employment or training. Colleges are places of hope, inspiration, support and inclusion where young people can find their passion and gain the skills they need to pursue it. Yet, unlike schools, they cannot claim VAT. Government Ministers have written to me with a technical explanation of the rules on VAT exemptions, but they are looking at this issue the wrong way round.
Whatever the technical justification, the reality is that schools and colleges are not on a level playing field on VAT, and the response should not be, "This is what the rules say," but how can we change the system to make the rules fair?
This budget represents the Government's excellent commitment to children and young people, but there is more to there is further to go and my committee will continue to press the Government and to scrutinise its commitments going forward.
Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Zoe Franklin.
Louise Zoë Franklin
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the Government's recognition that economic growth can cannot be driven solely from Whitehall, and that local leaders and communities must have a greater say in shaping their future. Liberal Democrats have long argued that decisions should be taken as close as possible to the people they affect. We support genuine devolution, greater fiscal autonomy for local government and empowering communities to shape their own futures. But the real question before us today is whether this budget will actually deliver the Government's ambition of good growth in every postcode.
Sarah Gibson
I'm sure the honourable member will agree with me that rural economies rely on transport and, in my constituency, we have seen colleges have to cut their hours because the bus doesn't come that late.
We have seen employers have to put on their own buses in order to get shift workers. Would the honourable member agree with me that for rural economies to thrive, we really need to be looking at transport?
Louise Zoë Franklin
I thank the my honourable friend for her intervention. She's absolutely right. We do need that support to make sure that people can get, where they live in rural constituencies, to other areas for work and education. So, growth is not measured by the number of new governance structures that we create; it's measured by whether people can find an affordable home, access to a GP appointment, travel to work, start a business, build a secure future in the place that they call home. And for the Liberal Democrats, this Budget must meet three tests: democratic consent, sustainable local government finances, and tangible improvements in everyday lives.
First, democratic consent. Devolution should bring power closer to communities.
We should be careful not to mistake devolution for decentralisation. Power removed from Whitehall, but concentrated a single regional office, such as a mayor, is not necessarily power shared with local communities. In Surrey, the home of my Guildford constituency, that distinction is becoming increasingly apparent. The budget confirms the Government is in the final stages of agreeing arrangements for a Mayoral Strategic Authority in Surrey, yet ministers previously assured this House that no area will be forced into a mayoral model. So, what has changed?
There has been no vote of the councils that will have to operate within this structure. Residents have not been given an opportunity to express a view that on the model that they want. In fact, the bulk of the discussions appear to have been had with Surrey County Council, a county coun- a council that will be defunct in just six months, rather than the new East and West Unitaries.
So, how can the Government claim to be bringing power closer to communities when those same communities have had so little say? And of course, a mayor is democratically elected, but representing an entire county or region is very different to representing a specific town, village or ward. Local councillors understand character, challenges and priorities of the communities they serve. They're often the first people residents turn to when problems arise. So, I ask the Minister, what's I ask the Secretary of State, I apologise,
what meaningful influence will locally elected leaders retain, and how the voices of villages, rural communities, be protected under the new arrangements? Because devolution shouldn't be forced upon communities. It should happen with them. Our second test is whether it this Budget delivers sustainable local government finances.
The budget contains announcements on strategic authorities, borrowing powers, business rates retention and new fiscal freedoms. Some of those measures may prove beneficial. But we must not confuse devolution with funding reform. Local government's central challenge is not governance, it's financial sustainability. While ministers talk enthusiastically about new structures and powers, councils across England face profound financial pressure.
The Local Government Association has warned of a billion pound funding gap over the coming years. Against that backdrop, many councils are struggling simply to maintain core services. And I return to my own area of Surrey. The six councils coming together to form West Surrey inherit 4.5 billion pounds of debt while simultaneously facing rising demand for adult social care, children's services and support for children with special educational needs and disabilities.
So, my concern here is how does implementing mayors without funding reform solve any of those problems? How does the new governance structure address historic debt? How does it ease pressure on social care budgets? How does it help councils meet rising demand for frontline services? The budget announces 1.5 billion borrowing facilities for mayoral strategic authorities.
And while borrowing may help investment, borrowing is no substitute for financial stability. And we have to recognize that we must learn the lessons from councils such as Woking, where serious financial failures have left residents paying the price, failures caused by previous Conservative administrations. And nowhere is the gap between structural reform and real-life outcomes clearer than in special educational needs. On that point, I will give way.
Christopher John Vince
Thank you. She is right to talk about local government finances.
My local government, my local council, Harlow, faced 70% cuts to core funding by the Conservative Government. Would she recognize that when the Lib Dems were in coalition, the funding was cut by nearly 30%? And would she also recognize what this Government's doing to introduce multi-year funding for local councils, something that local councils and leaders in Harlow and officers have been crying out for a long time?
Louise Zoë Franklin
I thank the honourable member for his intervention. I think we need to recognize we are looking forward. Multi-year settlements are a positive step, but there's still ultimately no fix here for local government finances, which is causing enormous problems for local councils. Returning to the issue of SEND, families don't lie awake worrying about governance models. They worry about whether their child will receive the support they need.
they worry about delays to assessments, they worry about whether an EHCP will be delivered in time. And I welcome the Government's commitment to cover 90% of eligible historic high-needs deficits accrued by March, but uncertainty remains about whether deficits accumulated in subsequent years will also be covered. Nor does this Budget provide the scale of additional adult social care funding needed to address rising demands.
So finally on local government finance, I want to address business rates. I welcome the principle that more locally-generated revenue should remain in local areas. Giving councils a stronger stake in local economic success is sensible. However, retaining more revenue does not necessarily mean receiving more funding. The reality is that councils only benefit from the share of business rates they're allowed to retain.
If national policy decisions reduces revenues, local government must be appropriately compensated.
And we must ensure that areas with fewer financial with fewer opportunities for growth are not left behind. Rural communities in particular should not find themselves disadvantaged by a system that increasingly relies on local-generated revenue. So, my test my second test, the jury very much remains out. And my third is whether this budget will deliver tangible improvements for people's lives,
because good growth should be growth that people can actually see and feel. It means a young family being able to afford a home. It means securing a GP appointment. It means reliable public transport. It remains thriving town centres.
It means ensuring infrastructure arrives alongside development rather what we're seeing in reality, which is years afterwards. My constituency of Guildford is home to a strong local economy, world-leading innovation, and enormous potential, but beneath that prosperity, families are struggling with housing costs, children growing up in poverty, and residents are frustrated by pressures on local services and infrastructure, and that experience is not unique, it's happening across the country. So, if the Government genuinely wants growth in every postcode, investment must actually translate into improvements. So, that includes ensuring the infrastructure that comes with housing development, because people will actually support that development if they can see it. It also means growth beyond our major cities, as my honourable friend mentioned, it has to include our rural communities, and our high streets, of course, must be central as well to that vision of growth.
So, in conclusion, Madam Deputy Speaker, Liberal Democrats believe that genuine devolution must mean more than transferring powers from Whitehall to equally centralised regional mayors. We want decisions to take closer to the communities, and we want growth that reaches every community. The Government recognises these things, but there's still so far to go.
We actually want to see tangible change for our residents. I thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
James Jonathan Hinder
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Like many of my colleagues, I am delighted with the new Prime Minister's clear ambition to reindustrialise Britain, which can drive economic prosperity in areas which really need it. My own constituency, Pendle and Clitheroe, is an example of somewhere that can drive and reap the benefits from this reindustrialisation. We don't trade financial derivatives in Pendle and Clitheroe.
We make aeroplanes, furniture, chemicals, cement, we produce food.
and not only is manufacturing over a quarter of the jobs, but they are often the best jobs, too. However, the truth is that, as I speak, Britain is still de-industrializing, as vulnerable to global supply shocks as any major economy, without the sovereign capability in key sectors to look after our basic needs. I'm glad to see the Chancellor deliver immediate relief for households, but in the long run, we must not just treat the symptoms of this failed economic model with fiscal transfers patching up the gaps, but overhaul it entirely.
The British economy remains too reliant on the city, foreign money and importing increasingly expensive essentials.
True economic security can only come from the British economy being productive enough to convert world leading innovation and research into valuable industrial output. And I was pleased to see some of the announcements at the budget last week reflect this challenge: serious public investment into productive British industries via the National Wealth Fund and the British Business Bank, an acknowledgment of the need for cheaper power and the protections offered to energy-intensive manufacturers, support for vocational apprenticeships essential for skills development in manufacturing and aligned sectors, and a long-term partnership with Rolls-Royce, whose Barnoldswick site in my constituency provides well-paid jobs for hundreds of my constituents, a reminder that Britain can still be home to world-leading industrial champions in highly competitive sectors.
But there is a lot more to be done. We must be clear about what we mean when we talk about reindustrialisation and the clue is in the name. It's about industry. Reindustrialisation must mean increasing physical production of goods needed at home and abroad. And I hope we will see more detail on how we will achieve this in the forthcoming 10-year plan.
As a short-term measure, I would like to see an expansion of the British industrial competitiveness scheme to a much rider wider range of manufacturing firms in Britain. We cannot expect our productive sectors to thrive and grow with energy costs as high as they currently are. Over the long-term, we must improve our energy sovereignty, make it cheaper to build nuclear power stations urgently and reducing our reliance on gas imports by using our own North Sea supply. I would also urge the Government to put an ambitious plan for rebuilding our defense industrial base into the 10-year plan alongside a continued commitment to British procurement.
Building our domestic capacity for defense and other critical sectors can be supported beyond procurement through investment in equity stakes, taking control of essential inputs as the government did with British Steel, and accelerating planning decisions for key sectors. So many of our challenges stem from a lack of quality work in productive industries. It doesn't get talked about enough. I'm rushing through, sorry. Oh, go on, I'll give way.
I'll give way.
Ayoub Khan
Can I thank can I thank the honourable member for giving way? And I agree with his reindustrialization. He talks about all the different jobs and many of them require academic students which get degrees. Does the honourable member agree that in the budget, there should have been something about student loans because students are suffering at this moment in time?
James Jonathan Hinder
Well, I definitely agree that we need to come back to plan two loans.
I think that's going to become a bigger and bigger issue, and we definitely need to come back to that as a House.
As I was saying, so many of our challenges stem from a lack of quality work and productive industries. We don't talk about the link enough, but high streets crippled by a lack of good jobs that provide a decent income, so people have got money in their pockets to spend in their area. Young people stuck at home, unable to get a place of their own and start a family. The selling-off of British assets to fund a current account deficit. And there is something even more fundamental at play here when we talk about reindustrialisation.
Sometimes, in these economic policy debates, I think we lose a sense of what really matters in life. Why is it that so often those jobs which appear to be the most socially useless are paid the most, and those which contribute something so important to our society are often paid the least? If our economy is driving these perverse incentives which push bright young people into careers trading securities, some people call them BS jobs,
well we'd better change those incentives, hadn't we? We need an economic framework that instead of incentivizing rent-seeking incentivizes productive, meaningful work. So it's not just providing people with a sense of satisfaction, pride, and a good living, but providing something useful to society, imagine that. Finally, let me say,
I know that this is not easy, for our economy cannot go on consuming too much and producing too little.
I urge the Chancellor and his ministers to ensure that reindustrialisation, which has struck such a chord with the British people, is now turned into a fully fledged plan for national reconstruction. Thank you.
Edward Leigh
I agree with the honourable gentleman about reindustrialisation, but you don't reindustrialise Scunthorpe, in my neighbouring constituency, by screwing it with the highest energy costs in Europe. Nor do you reindustrialise by simply exporting our carbon by importing oil, and that's why we need to get on with Rosebank. Now I came of course with a load of figures about the rising tide of debt, that the tax burden rising to 38% of GDP, the 4.3 billion tax raid on landlords, but we know all these figures. What are we going to do about it?
Now traditionally governments, and I've seen so many governments come and go, get the bad news out first, and this government still has three years to go. I don't quite know why we got over a hundred tiny policy changes, but we're not actually fixing the fundamental problems of this country now. So get out the bad news now. I was told by a colleague today that actually the Prime Minister is being very shrewd about this, we live in a TikTok generation so you just let out a little policy announcement every week, you keep people happy, you delay decisions. But is that good government?
It may be good politics, but is it good government?
We all know that society is breaking down because people feel that some people are abusing the system. We had the whole statement this afternoon about legal and illegal migration, and we know what how strongly people feel about that. But they feel very strongly in working class constituencies about so many people abusing the system. And they feel particularly strongly about young people who are not in work and education or in training. Now, I agree with the government, you can't solve this problem with what they call crude benefit cuts, but there has to be some balance in the system.
Work, training, has to be worthwhile. And therefore, we cannot dodge this issue of the amount of benefits and the level of benefits paid to young people.
But I was reassured by the front page of The Times today that the Government is looking at what's going on the Netherlands. So great. We're not going to have just crude cuts. We've got to get these people, young people into training, given medical help, helped into work and not just dismissed by the system, by a tick-box exercise filling in paper, but actually seen by a real person and helped into education or training, or if they can't get into that, some form of workfare.
The trouble is that half the benefit bill, half the benefit bill is taken up with the state pension. Now for years I've been one of the few people who's questioned the triple lock. It's amazing how while people are ministers, they defend the triple lock; the moment they cease to be ministers, they say it's unaffordable. So we know that the Government, and they've listened to all the economic advice on this, that eventually the triple lock has to come to an end.
But again, why delay it? And you can't get rid of the triple lock and imagine that's going to pay for a national care service. The vast cost of a national care service, the NHS writ large. It would be better actually to say to pensioners, and this is a fair deal which I think they would accept, that your state pension should as a proportion of the economy stay roughly the same.
So, we're not bankrupting the nation. The state pension will go up with just how much the economy rises every year, which is a fair system. And if you're going to save money, what we need now is not a we don't delay these decisions till 2030. What we need now, surely, is to get old and frail people out of expensive hospitals and get them into sort of new cottage hospitals.
You don't need to put them into all-singing, dancing, PFI, hugely expensive hospitals. Have more cottage hospitals where old people can be looked after in a caring and loving way, and to relieve the health service. And if you were going to save the National Health Service, if you're going to save one thing, the average price of houses in my constituency is just #200,000. What really upsets people, actually, what really upsets them is that their whole inheritance that they want to pass to their children is going to go on care costs. So let's go back to the old idea of having a cap on the total amount you pay for your care.
There is a, there is a, there is a way forward, Madam Deputy Speaker.
I think we can work together to get young people back into work, back into training and we can all also reassure old people that they will be looked after in their old age.
Catherine Atkinson.
Catherine Helen Atkinson
Deputy Speaker, this budget was great news for Derby particularly the 2.5 billion pound investment with Rolls-Royce to develop the next generation of aircraft engine and keep us at the forefront of the re-industrialization of this country. But I rise to speak about justice. Because whether it is growth in every post code or high streets being brought back to life, or getting everyone in and off the streets for Christmas none can be achieved without investment in and reform of our justice system. The Prime Minister's first instruction on entering Downing Street was to end rough sleeping, an objective that is inspiring and ambitious and right.
And the near doubling of the 442 million to 874 million in the budget showed intent. But here is where our justice system comes in. Because 1,000 people every month go straight from prison into homelessness, many rough sleeping. And that has gone up and has outpaced the increase in the number leaving prison. Being homeless doubles the risk of reoffending, and makes the goal of ending rough sleeping unobtainable.
And that's why we need a duty for rehabilitation services to ensure that on leaving, they do not go onto the streets and into worklessness.
Jim Shannon
I thank the honourable lady. I commend the honourable lady for what she's putting forward and Government for what they're doing for the homelessness in particular, but does the honourable lady agree that there should be a priority for those veterans, and especially who come out of prison and get lost in the system and nobody catches them where they are? Because I see that happening in my constituency regularly. So, we have addressed that issue. Should veterans be given the priority within the homelessness scheme that's coming forward?
Catherine Helen Atkinson
I thank the honourable member for his contribution and I do acknowledge that there are many categories of people that we want to ensure have a real priority. But the Government has already got the ambition to halve the number of prisoners who are released into homelessness.
But if we are to end rough sleeping and break cycles of offending, then that ambition isn't ambitious enough. Madam Deputy Speaker, just as it's morally offensive to us when we see someone who is sleeping rough in the doorway of a really high-end hotel, it should also offend us when we see the global elite and blue-chip companies coming to Britain for our world-class justice, while our own citizens are often left outside that justice system, getting rough justice. We should be rightly proud and the Treasury mindful of the huge contribution that international cases make to our country's economy. In 2024 alone, the UK legal sector contributed £42.6 billion to the economy. The UK is the largest legal services market in Europe, and second only to the US globally.
But we should be using some of that revenue to improve access to early legal advice, to legal aid, and to address the dire shortage in duty solicitors for our own people. Lastly, there was positive news for our high streets with the budget taking many of our cafes and pubs and beauty salons completely out of business rates, and Home Secretary is putting police back on the front line, and we have reversed the effective decriminalization of shoplifting under the previous government. But the justice system needs to work much faster for all of us, including our high streets and town and city centers, where people need to feel safe in order to want to be there and spend money there.
But as well as fast, it needs to be fair.
And it is not right for people on minimum wage to face custodial sentences, potentially going up to two years custody, and not qualify for legal aid, leaving them unrepresented in court.
Will the honorable lady take a point?
I'm conscious of the number of people that want to speak in this debate, so I will continue. Mr Speaker, it is not said often enough that it's this country's dogged belief in fair rules for everyone that is also a secret ingredient to business success. If your assets are protected, your contracts enforced, your disputes decided, that's one less risk. But access to justice needs to be there for our smaller business as well as larger multinationals. So there is more to do in our justice system, there is more that is needed.
And I acknowledge that in the last spending review, the budget for justice was increased by an average of 2.4%.
But in the 2010s, justice spending was cut by 33% in real terms. Spending today is only on par with what it was 24 years ago in 2002 and it is lower per person than it was at that time. The IFS have said that the Ministry of Justice would need an additional £3.6 billion just to equal its spending per person before austerity. Many of the challenges facing the justice system today have their roots in that period of austerity. So, I will be knocking on the Treasury Minister's door as hard as my children were knocking on our neighbours' doors last week at Halloween, because it's not trick or treat, it's common sense and essential that we need to act now to avoid a jump scare later on.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Well, this budget was a missed opportunity for the residents of Bromsgrove and the villages, and there was next to nothing in there for my residents, nor for the hardworking business owners and businesses across the constituency. The frank reality is that businesses across the country and in my area, they're really struggling right now, Mr. Speaker, and we've heard in recent months the true colours come out from Labour ministers.
We heard over the weekend the Chief Secretary to the Treasury stating that those who employ people are not workers themselves. Well, I'm not sure that the carpenters, the plumbers, the cafe owners, the florists in my constituency would agree with that. They're frankly insulted by it.
And we heard the Work and Pensions Secretary reveal earlier this year that all Labour MPs want to do is ask the question: who can we tax more to spend more money on welfare? And how businesses and how people feel actually matters, Mr. Speaker. That's the biggest litmus test of all for the government. We know that, you know, inflation is up, government spending is up, unemployment is up, welfare is up, debt is up. How people and businesses feel is what matters and that will be the ultimate litmus test for the government.
Following the budget, we heard Hospitality UK give the reality that despite the government's announcement on business rates, only one in 10 will be affected. The government needs to go further.
They need to endorse the Conservatives' full exemption for hundreds of thousands of retailers, pubs, hospitality businesses, because wherever I go in my constituency, I am repeatedly being told that businesses operating in these sectors are not recruiting. They're not recruiting because the cost of employment has gone up dramatically, red tape has gone up, and even the voice of business through organisations such as Make UK are clear. Make UK have said that the budget was a failed opportunity to reindustrialise, and the Federation of Small Businesses said that there was nothing in this budget to make hiring more affordable. So, despite seeing unemployment go up by 276,000 in the last two years, we are destined to see it go up even more. The government needs to get off the backs of businesses and get on their side.
And I'd like to, if I can, Mr. Speaker, briefly touch upon the Government's proposals for devolution and local government reorganization. The Government announced something last week for Worcestershire that will not improve the quality of people's lives. It will increase the cost and bureaucracy of delivering local government services. It is not in Worcestershire's interests. And on the topic of devolution, Worcestershire hasn't got a mayor.
It doesn't want a mayor. It's not a geography that would best suit a mayoralty. We don't need more politicians in this country. We need fewer, Mr. Speaker. And devolution, de- de- devolution,
I say that as a politician, we need fewer politicians in this country and we need the system to work better. Devolution as the Government have outlined is a complete--
I will give way.
Margaret Rachel Taylor
I thank the honourable I thank the honourable member for giving way. But with the Government's local government reorganisation will be abolishing the two-tier system that he has in his constituency of Bromsgrove, thereby reducing the very number of local councillors, so reducing the number of politicians. Which part of that did he miss in the announcements that have been made over the last 12 months?
Anthony Bradley Thomas
If the honourable lady had listened to what I was saying, I was saying Worcestershire doesn't want a mayor. The Government's proposals for devolution are nothing more than a cop-out to absolve Westminster of its failures to tackle the big issues facing this country. And that's the theme that runs through this budget, Mr Speaker. Politicians don't create jobs. I read in The Times this morning that the Government believes that mayors and local leaders can be empowered to create jobs.
It's absolute rubbish.
It's businesses that create jobs. Every single penny and pound of taxation received by the government is generated ultimately through the endeavors of private enterprise. We have to get to a point where once again, risk taking and entrepreneurialism are not frowned upon. It should be embraced. It should be encouraged.
So, if the government wants to tax something, it has to create that wealth and prosperity first. The government needs to get off the backs of businesses, get on their side.
Sagal Abwali
Thank you very much, Mr Speaker.
Thank you for giving me the opportunity to make my maiden speech during a budget debate, a Labour budget that speaks directly to some of the challenges that first brought me into politics and public service. It's a profound honor to rise for the first time in this House as the Member of Parliament for Holborn and St Pancras, the place that has been home for most of my life. I came to Camden with my family as a child refugee. It's where I grew up, where I went to school, made friends, and discovered the opportunities that would shape my life.
This budget speaks to the issues that matter deeply to the people I represent, from the security of a home to the opportunities available to the next generation. Like so many young people growing up in Camden, I spent my time making friends through the universal language of football. On the football pitch, you quickly learn that it does not matter where someone comes from, what language they speak, or what their family does for a living.
what matters is whether they turn up for their teammates. Those friendships taught me something important about community, long before I entered politics: that we are stronger when we look beyond our differences and recognise that we have what we have in common. As I came of age, Camden continued to give me opportunities and a sense of belonging, and it gave me the responsibility to give something back. From the, I'm sorry.
Thank you. Thank you very much. For more than 20 years, I've tried to honour that responsibility through community work and public service, campaigning for change and serving in local government, ultimately as leader of Camden Council. That experience has taught me that, beyond every policy and every budget line, and every statistic, is a person whose life can be changed by the decisions made in this House. Mr Speaker, Holborn and St Pancras is a place of extraordinary character.
What makes our constituency so special is not just the landmarks, but the extraordinary variety of places and people. From the leafy streets and village feel of Primrose Hill, through the independent spirit and community life of Kentish Town, to the neighbourhoods and estates of Haverstock, and the historic streets, theatres and cultural institutions of Covent Garden, every part has its own story to tell. We are home to thriving local businesses, historic markets, places of faith, and community centres. We are students and academics, artists and entrepreneurs, and families who've lived here for generations, and people who've made this place their home from every corner of the world. That diversity is our strength.
It's one of our greatest strengths. It's reflected in our languages, our food, our festivals, our music, and that everyday way that we all come together to look out for one another.
It is what makes Holborn and St Pancras not simply a collection of neighbourhoods, but a community. The Roundhouse in Chalk Farm began life as a railway engine shed, before becoming one of the country's most well-known cultural venues that also provides creative access to young people. Legends from Led Zeppelin to David Bowie have played there. It's a reminder that places just like people can be given new opportunities and go on to achieve remarkable things. And in King's Cross stands the historic German Gymnasium, where sporting events were held at the National Olympian Games in 1866, long before the modern Olympic Games came to being.
And with a sporting legacy stretching back over a century, Mr Speaker, I'm pleased to make a little history of my own as Holborn and St Pancras' first Tottenham Hotspur MP. Bringing an end to a rather lengthy period of Arsenal and West Ham dominance in this House.
Mr Speaker, if supporting Spurs had a dictionary definition, it would read something like: to remain eternally hopeful despite overwhelming evidence, and to return every season convinced that this will be, finally, your year. I hope that combination of optimism and sheer refusal to give up will serve me well in this House. Of course, the West Ham and Arsenal dominance I mention came from the distinguished Labour MPs who've represented this constituency before me.
I'm immensely proud to follow in the footsteps of two men who've given so much to Holborn and St Pancras, and whose contributions to our community and to my party deserve to be celebrated. The late, great Frank Dobson represented Holborn and St represented Holborn and St Pancras for more than 33 years. He was a tireless champion for local people and a proud defender of our NHS and public services, and a politician who never lost sight of the people who were behind the policies. I have a childhood memory of meeting Frank at a community event. I had no idea at the time how much of an important political figure he was.
To me he was simply a nice, bearded man who took the time to speak to a child. And looking back at that small encounter captures something important about his connection with the community. He was a familiar face to generations of residents, someone who understood the challenges facing working people and was never afraid to stand up for them. Sir Keir Starmer continued that tradition, representing our constituency for more than a decade from leading the Labour and leading the Labour Party back from opposition back into government, introducing generational reforms to renters and workers' rights and lifting half a million children out of poverty.
I've had the privilege of working alongside Keir through our local Labour movement, and I've seen another side of his public service, watching him quietly console bereaved families who've lost loved young loved ones, and hearing his determination to end youth violence. I pay tribute to both men with enormous gratitude and respect. I will do my utmost to honor the trust that generations have put into them, have placed in them, and the residents have now placed in me. It is also an extraordinary honour to become the first woman, Black person and Muslim to represent Holborn and St Pancras in Parliament and the first British woman to sit British-Somali woman to sit in this House.
I take great pride in those milestones, and being elected during Black History Month in a constituency whose town hall proudly commemorates Claudia Jones, a pioneering black woman who founded and hosted Britain's first Caribbean Carnival there. I take pride in them because of what they might mean to a young woman and a young girl growing up in our constituency today. I want her to see that her background does not define the limits of her ambition, and there is no ceiling to what she can achieve, and what public and that public life belongs to her too. Mr Speaker, one of the issues that first drove me into politics 10 years ago was seeing the rise in homelessness. Alongside people sleeping rough on our streets, families and young people are facing a housing crisis that leaves too many struggling to find secure affordable and affordable homes and a place to call home.
This is why I strongly welcome my right honorable friend, the Prime Minister's determination to end rough sleeping. This budget turns that determination into action, with nearly £900 million to tackle rough sleeping and an additional one and a half billion to support the delivery of social and affordable homes. For a constituency such as mine, this investment is essential. Mr. Speaker, there is another issue that matters deeply to me. The strength of our communities and the bonds that hold us together.
Growing up in Camden, I saw different people from different backgrounds, cultures, and faiths build support networks and look out for one another. I saw how diversity enriches us, our lives, and how cohesion is built through everyday acts of kindness, friendship, and solidarity. For that cohesion is hard-won, and we cannot take it for granted. During the election campaign, I experienced attempts to question people's belonging, to sow division, to turn differences into reasons for suspicion and hostility. We must stand firmly against the hateful and divisive forces that seek to pull our communities apart.
Sagal Abwali
It's what gives us the courage to change lives for the better. Mr Speaker, my parents taught me that hard work, to work hard and always give something back to the community that has given me so much. I want every young person in our constituency to have the opportunities I had. I want families to have secure homes, young people to have access to good jobs and apprenticeships, and I want them, and our public service to always be there for people when they need them most. To represent this community in Parliament is an extraordinary privilege.
Mr Speaker, Camden gave me hope and opportunity. Now, as the MP for Holborn and St Pancras, I will pass that hope and opportunity to others, and give them the same chance. Thank you very much.
Alec Edward Shelbrooke
Thank you, Mr Speaker, and may I say it's a genuine pleasure to follow the honourable lady for St Pancras and Holborn on an excellent maiden speech. As a West Ham fan, Mr Speaker, I understand the "it's the optimism that kills you", but she's a Spurs fan, I think I'll leave it right there after last season. May also congratulate, it is not easy following in the footsteps of a Prime Minister, fighting against the leader of another national party, but as she also pointed out Mr Speaker, the racial attacks on her leading up to that election were absolutely disgraceful, and I'm sure that the vast majority of people in this House stand in solidarity with her.
But I wish her a successful career in this House, and I'm sure she'll be of a great asset to it. Now, Mr Speaker, today's debate is about growth in every postcode, but I But I have to say, Mr Speaker, that what I want to focus on today is the genuine threat of war that threatens this country. And that the Budget has not addressed the defence issues that must be addressed, because we could carry on saying we've got a plan to have a plan and kicking things off down the road, but that hides itself from the reality of what is going on in the world.
Just today, we have seen a cyberattack across at least six European countries that has destroyed tens of hundreds of millions of pounds of frozen and refrigerated stock through a cyberattack, and we know those cyberattacks are taking place every day, and yet, we are still delaying the real investment that needs to take place. Now, I was in Australia with the NATO Parliamentary Assembly recently. They have 4% inflation. They have a cost of living as the number one priority, and 55% say immigration is too high. And yet, they have taken that decision to make sure they invest in their defense investment plans, because they have recognised, and it was the last time they did this was in the 1980s, they felt that their geography gave them the security.
And now they recognize that it does not. And they are in the process of doubling their navy. They're going for three air defence destroyers, six frigates, submarine hunters, 11 general purpose frigates, six large barge missile barges, eight launching vessels to protect army capability, and of course with AUKUS, they built in a 50% contingency.
Germany is going to have 15 extra frigates by 2035. Finland is going to have four new corvettes by 2035. Norway is going to have five new frigates, six new submarines and 28 standard vessels by 2035. And yet we say we are aiming to get to 3.5% by 2035. Now, I have said it before, and I will say it again in this House: I think the target of percentage GDP is a false and wrong target.
And it was only brought in 2014 to satisfy the Americans. And actually, you know, there's plenty of us have a lot to complain about President Trump, but at least he actually did get European countries spending, because as far back as Eisenhower they were saying that Europe needed to spend more on defence.
George Bush made the speech in 2007, and Barack Obama made the speech in 2014 when it came in. What really matters is article 3. Everybody talks about article 5, about the defence. Let me just point out to the House, Madam Deputy Speaker, that article 5 being triggered, it is the choice of a nation as to what they contribute to collective defence. Everybody thinks America will pile in with its troops, and its tanks, and its planes, and its warships.
It could simply say, "We will provide the intelligence." That would satisfy article 5. Article 3 says you must be able to defend your borders for three weeks.
NATO is a reinforcement thing. And so, we simply cannot carry on by saying we're going to do a defense review, an investment review, in a year's time, doing the review in a year's time, not actually getting there. I mean it's welcome news today that perhaps there is going to be double shifts done at the dockyards to try and produce more frigates, but this should be happening now. And in the time I've got remaining, I will say this. I have stood in this House before, and I have said that when we cut from 5% of GDP, which was just the consequence of what we needed to spend it on, that 3% of GDP went into health and welfare, and that it would be a brave politician who stood up and said we should cut those things, especially welfare, to invest it in defense.
Well, that is exactly what the Leader of the Opposition is now saying, because the time has more than passed that the threat of war in this country is absolutely on the horizon. And yet, we don't want it to happen, so we bury our head in the sand, and so we can delay spending costs. It cannot carry on. The threat is imminent. Yeah.
Lorraine Beavers
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. When I ask people in my constituency how they feel about the economy, they tell me that their bills are too high and their rent or mortgage takes too much of their pay. I am glad that the Budget takes some first steps to address these issues. Four years ago, the party opposite, led by Liz, crashed the economy and sent mortgages and bills soaring. Before that, the party opposite spent more than a decade cutting our armed forces and public services.
They left us poorly defended in every sense.
The Chancellor's budget makes a good start in addressing these problems. The immediate help for the 20 million households towards their energy bills this winter is a welcome relief. The changes to business rates will also have a huge impact on businesses in my constituency. On devolution, I can only hope that Lancashire will have a mayor by 2028 to share in the proposals that were announced. I would urge Reform-led Lancashire County Council to grab this amazing opportunity for Lancashire.
We have been left behind for too long. Reform-led Lancashire County Council needs to stop infighting and start fighting for Lancashire instead.
How I want, however, I want to come back to how much further we need to go to rebuild Britain. The Prime Minister rightly identified the deindustrialisation of Britain as one of the reasons places like Blackpool North and Fleetwood have not shared in the proceeds of growth as much as they should. He is right that a change of policy is required. But right now Britain is deindustrialising faster than any of our neighbours. Domestic manufacturing capacity is an essential source of our national security, yet British manufacturers face the highest electricity prices in Europe.
I know many colleagues on these benches have asked the Chancellor to look at the merits of extending the British Industry Supercharger to all manufacturing firms.
I hope the Front Bench looks carefully again at the proposals and sits down with the TUC and others to discuss how this could be implemented. I will finish by saying that this budget offers practical help with people's bills this winter. The 10-year plan and the spending review must do the same for their jobs. Thank you.
Pippa Heylings
Thank you.
As we head into winter with bills rising again in January, households and businesses across the country are really worried and this budget needed to match the scale of the energy and climate challenges, but we as Liberal Democrats are really concerned that it doesn't. While the standing charge removal and the proposed energy bill cost control framework are welcome, struggling households can't wait until the next spending review in 2027 for policy costs to be taken off bills, one of the quickest ways to reduce bills whilst supporting electrification. And you could also, the government opposite could also have introduced the Liberal Democrat Essential Energy Guarantee to protect basic household energy needs. If we're truly to break free from the volatile fossil fuel prices driven by despots and Trump's stupid wars, we agree we must accelerate renewables, grid connections and electrification, and that's why I am disturbed by the seeming inconsistencies in the budget with this approach.
Firstly, the Treasury says it's setting, quote, an entirely new path on energy whilst ministers are telling us its clean energy ambitions remain unchanged. With the AR8 auction budget due within weeks, ministers must urgently clarify what this means for investment certainty in floating offshore wind, in port regeneration, which is critical for supply costs and supply chains. Secondly, cheaper energy doesn't automatically lead to electrification on its own. So as winter approaches, I'd like to ask why is the Treasury cutting the flagship warm homes plan, the surest way to electrify heating in our homes and reduce wasted wind energy? The budget slashes one billion of capital funding from the programme.
The budget slashes one billion of capital funding from the programme and it reintroduces VAT on clean technologies from 2027, effectively creating a solar panel and heat pump tax. Madam Deputy Speaker, I would also like to ask the minister to confirm or deny reports that a further £1.5 billion could be removed from the Warm Homes Plan financial transactions funding, that's the very zero-interest loan scheme that's just been launched and lauded.
Madam Deputy Speaker, with 90% of domestic bill increases since 2020 linked to wholesale gas price spice spikes, despite and contrary to all the protestations from the Conservatives and Reform, the answer is clear: a national electrification strategy making it easier not harder for households to move away from fossil fuels. This budget should have advanced that mission; instead, it risks setting Britain back.
Chinyelu Susan Onwurah
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. And it's a pleasure to speak in this debate. And let me add my congratulations to the honourable member for Holborn and St Pancras for her excellent maiden speech. Now this is a budget to create growth in every postcode, and nowhere is better placed than Newcastle to manufacture, innovate and grow, if given the tools and opportunities to do so.
My right honourable friend, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, has clearly recognized this, allocating funding for investment and giving welcome attention to our region's economic potential with announcement of the International Investment Summit in Gateshead next spring. So we have always been a city that builds, that innovates, that delivers, whether it's in advanced manufacturing, engineering, digital technology, energy or professional services. And it was growing up in Newcastle surrounded by the legacy of great Geordie engineers and inventors in a culture that championed making and building things that inspired me to become an engineer.
Now, the North East holds world-leading companies and research institutions, but after 14 years of Conservative austerity, my constituents still find significant barriers to social mobility and opportunity. Newcastle Central and West ranked bottom of 543 constituencies for attainment and outcomes in the Crossing Paths report of 2026. Having grown up on a council estate myself, I am heartbroken that the life chances of disadvantaged young people are so curtailed. One fifth of those aged 16 to 24 are characterized as NEET in the North East, and I echo the Chancellor in saying that I refuse to write them off, unlike the last Conservative Government. I look forward to the upcoming publication of Alan Milburn's report.
He was recently in Newcastle, and I know that he seeks to make a real difference to the intelligent and ambitious young people I meet regularly across Newcastle Central and West.
And it's a really difficult time for so many families across my constituency, squeezed by increasing bills in energy, housing, etc. So it's great to see the budget directly addresses this. 60,000 properties in the constituency will receive £100 towards their energy bills this winter. And I welcome the 1.5 billion in additional funding to deliver social and affordable housing, and of course the 20 million in Pride in Place funding for Elswick in my constituency.
After years of fighting for the investment we deserve, our region will no longer have to pick up the crumbs from the Whitehall table, with the new North East Good Growth Fund helping our fantastic Mayor, Kim McGuinness, to directly improve our public transport and deliver major regional projects. By giving 20 billion for the National Wealth Fund and the British Business Bank, I hope that this supports start-ups, spin-outs and research facilities in the north-east, not simply in the golden triangle. But I do wish there were two further areas that the Chancellor could have gone, have got, have provided more support. Again, the north-east has the highest attainment gap in education with London since records began, and to challenge this, I would like to see fur further investment on the scale of the London Challenge from 2003, in the incredible young people in Newcastle Central and West.
Secondly, there was significant support for businesses, particularly small businesses, in the budget, but I would have liked to see even more. Growing businesses will provide jobs for our young people, and small businesses have been heavily hit by higher taxes and less disposable income from many constituents. But finally, I hope the government's the Chancellor's 15 billion defence investment plan will be used to support regional growth and investment, as he has promised, and particularly to address the unacceptable truth that the North East sends the highest proportion of young people into the armed forces, and yet receives the lowest proportion of defence investment spending, something that I will be thinking of in this remembrance week.
They, like the young people and everyone in the North East, deserves growth in every postcode, and I'm grateful to the Chancellor of the Exchequer for providing the first steps in achieving that. Thank you.
Aphra Brandreth
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This budget was a missed opportunity for our rural economy. Yet again, this Government has failed to back it. And my message to the Prime Minister and the Chancellor is simple. Stop saying every postcode matters and start showing it.
In Chester South and Eddisbury, around our farms sit the contractors, vets, farm shops, pubs and family businesses that keep our villages alive.
Jim Shannon
Can I commend the honourable lady on bringing agricultural and the farming life to this debate today? It's really important and the honourable lady is the first person today to do that so I congratulate her on that. The family inheritance tax is has will have a very destructive impact upon farming in Northern Ireland. The Ulster Farmers' Union, and I declare an interest as a member of the Ulster Farmers' Union, will be forced into a tax bracket not because the family is wealthy, but because the value of the land and the buildings has risen on paper. Hardworking families are asset-rich, cash-poor, and the family farms that I live amongst and represent in Northern Ireland will be the ones that will feel the pain of this Government.
Aphra Brandreth
I thank the honourable member for giving way. He is a champion for farmers in his community and he is absolutely right.
The Chancellor had the chance to repeal the vindictive family farm tax and family business tax, but chose not to. Nearly nine in 10 rural businesses have paused investment. And when investment stops, the consequences ripple through the whole rural economy. Conservatives would scrap these damaging taxes. Madam Deputy Speaker, they also had the chance to give small businesses some much-needed breathing space.
They didn't. Our rural businesses, particularly in hospitality and tourism, are being squeezed by rising costs, higher taxes and more regulation. And when businesses are struggling, they stop investing, they stop expanding and crucially, they stop taking on staff. These are the businesses that give so many young people their first step on into work. We should be making that easier, Madam Deputy Speaker, not harder.
That is the difference between the government and the Conservatives. We would halve the jobs tax for under-25s and create 100,000 new apprenticeships, because the best way to get young people into work is to back the businesses willing to employ them. This budget did neither. Then there is the cost of fuel.
The fuel duty freeze is welcome, but the Conservatives kept it frozen for 14 years because we understand how much rural communities rely on their cars. And it's not just fuel for transport. On Saturday, I was out chatting to residents in Audlem, and so many of the people I spoke to are living off-grid. Heating oil has nearly doubled this year in price,
and families are wondering whether they can afford to fill their tanks before winter. Rural communities are being left out in the cold quite literally,
and this budget offered them nothing. That is the real cost of this budget in the countryside: investment on pause, young people not taken on, homes going cold and family farms wondering whether they will survive.
The contrast could not be clearer. Conservatives would back our family farms, cut taxes on jobs, bring down energy bills through our cheap power plan, and get our rural economy growing again. The NFU president described this budget as tinkering while Rome is burning. And he was right. Our farmers, rural businesses and families don't need more promises, more consultations or more plans for the future.
Madam Deputy Speaker, rural Britain needs action now and this budget has failed to deliver it.
Patricia Ferguson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And if I may, I intend to speak on behalf of my committee, the Scottish Affairs Committee. However, there is one point I would wish to make from my own constituency perspective, and that is that Glasgow West that I represent, and am proud to do so, has a relatively high level of youth unemployment, a lower than average level of educational qualifications, and a fairly high number of unemployed related benefit claimants. We also don't have access to a youth hub. There are three in the city of Glasgow, but none anywhere near my constituency.
So my plea to the government is: can we please have a youth hub? But today's debate is about good growth in every postcode. And I want to look at a particular issue that the Scottish Affairs Committee have spent some time on, and that's about Scotland's space launch sector. We visited the SaxaVord Spaceport last year, that's on the island of Unst in Shetland, and we saw for ourselves the potential of the UK's first fully licensed vertical spaceport. What we heard reinforced our view that Scotland is uniquely placed to further the UK's space ambitions, while delivering economic growth.
Unst's northerly location allows for launch routes over the North Atlantic Ocean, making it particularly well-suited to putting satellites into polar orbits.
That, combined with our expertise in satellite manufacturing-- City of Glasgow, you may be surprised to hear, produces more satellites than anywhere else in Europe-- and Edinburgh's expertise in data in space, make us uniquely placed to benefit from this. But SaxaVord also provides a strong foundation for end-to-end space services. For Shetland itself, the economic opportunity is hugely significant, and this budget talks about the importance of creating jobs across every nation and region of the UK. SaxaVord could help sustain an island community by creating skilled jobs and giving young people more opportunities to establish careers locally. In a remote community, where unreliable connectivity makes economic development and life in general more difficult, this new industry could deliver growth in Shetland's postcodes too.
However, the economic growth potential of a space launch capability in Shetland would extend beyond Scotland. A successful spaceport could attract international investment and create opportunities for suppliers across the whole of the UK. And there is also a national security interest here. Developing a sovereign launch capability would reduce our reliance on overseas providers. But we can't afford to be complacent, and SaxaVord has yet to achieve a successful orbital launch.
In September this year, Norway's spaceport at Andøya successfully launched satellites into orbit.
Now we should welcome that because it's progress for the European sector, but it raises an important question about whether Scotland has lost its first-mover advantage and what more the Government can do to support innovative businesses like SaxaVord to realise their economic potential. During our inquiry, we heard that there is sufficient demand to sustain, rather, more than one European spaceport, and a successful launch from Scotland will be important, but the real test will be whether that can be scaled up into a commercial launch service. And that is why I welcome the Government's space strategy and their £30 million investment in SaxaVord. It's a significant public investment, but it must be wisely spent. Deputy Speaker, we have also looked in our committee at fixed links.
For an island with these great ambitions, there are two ferry journeys before you ever get to SaxaVord.
And with those ferries not always being reliable, with the weather often being against us, the islands in Shetland have been looking at whether fixed links will work for them. We think it's something that the Government should look at, working in conjunction with the Scottish Government and with the Shetland Islands Council, because we think it's absolutely the kind of thing the Government's ambition should be looking at.
Speaker 296
And with an immediate three-minute time limit, I call James MacCleary.
James MacCleary
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Chancellor has promised growth in every postcode, but those of us in the South East could be forgiven for thinking that the Government's forgotten us altogether. Take London out of the equation and the South East, and Sussex in particular, doesn't seem to be part of the Government's infrastructure strategy at all.
While London has the highest per capita public transport investment in the country, the South East, by contrast, has the lowest of any English region, 11% below the national average. Where I live in Newhaven, nothing stands out more than the A259, the main coastal road that runs the length of East Sussex, passing through Seaford and Newhaven, as well as serving the hugely popular Seven Sisters Country Park, which attracts visitors from around the world. The road is vital to the local economy, but DfT figures show that more than 19,000 vehicles squeeze along South Way in Newhaven every day, having a massive impact on neighborhoods and businesses. The traffic system designed in the 1970s is now, fundamentally, failing our coastal communities.
Newhaven is a strategic port and Seaford a town of over 25,000 residents that attracts tens of thousands of visitors to its beautiful beach and serves as a major access point to the famous Seven Sisters cliffs. The road is a critical artery for our area and like all coastal roads is hard to expand on its current location. In 2023, a multi-year road Major Road Network study recommended a package of upgrades, including safety improvements to junctions like Bishopstone Road. The county council submitted its business case to government to fund the upgrade package, but that's where it stopped. So my question to the minister is this, will the government commit the money necessary to get the A259 finally moving and press the Reform Conservative administration at East Sussex County Council to get on with funding immediate improvements like the Bishopstone Road junction to boost growth in our area?
The Chancellor has said that he wants more houses to be built as a result of this budget, but building more houses without necessary infrastructure is a road to nowhere. I'm very clear about this. It is not reasonable or fair to ask residents in my community to just accept more and more housing while they watch their roads clog up, public services deteriorate and can't get access to a GP.
Take Ringmer, a beautiful village in my constituency where over 1,600 new homes have been proposed as part of the district council's local plan process. It's worth knowing the village currently only has 2,000 households. I have heard ministers refer to people in villages like Ringmer, who are concerned about how their communities can possibly cope with so much new housing, as nimbys. That is grossly unfair and frankly insulting. If we want house building and growth, then government needs to be offering communities a fair deal, not calling them names.
House housing plans must be led by need. Too much house building is just waved through, and sometimes it's not even built at all. If the Chancellor wants to build Britain, he needs to invest in roads, schools, health facilities, public transport to make new houses and the communities for which they are built truly sustainable. Otherwise, we're just building problems for the future. Mr Speaker, this budget contains many warm words, however, the residents of Lewes, Seaford, Newhaven, Polegate and our local villages will judge it based on what actually changes for them.
Gurinder Josan
Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm pleased that this budget sets a clear priority to address cost of living. Over 44,000 households in my Smethwick constituency will receive the £100 payment to help with energy bills, and the business rates freeze will benefit 52% of retail, hospitality and leisure properties in the West Midlands, including 1,198 properties in my constituency.
Madam Deputy Speaker, it is clear that decisions taken by this Labour government and the current and previous Chancellor have been instrumental in keeping UK growth at the top end of growth in all new G7 countries. Furthermore, the government has set out an ambitious program of investment in the key industry in the last two years: nuclear, green energy, defence, to name a few. But alongside that public investment, these industries will need crucial private investment to grow to their full potential. For this reason, I would have liked to have seen the restoration of the 30% upfront income tax relief for venture capital trusts, which was reduced to 20% at the last budget. This relief is vital for supporting British SMEs in their early stages of development.
Venture capital trusts already support over 1,100 British companies, predominantly in tech sectors, employing over 100,000 people, generating £21.8 billion in revenue in the last year alone. These businesses often have high upfront costs, long development cycles and uncertain terms, which can make conventional finance difficult to secure.
Previously, in 2006, when relief was reduced from 40% to 30%, fundraising reduced by around 65% and took 16 years to recover. At last year's budget, the relief was reduced further, from 30% to 20%, and as a result the industry estimates suggest anywhere between a 30 30 to 60% decline in fundraising, which is equivalent to between 1.25 and 2.5 billion pound less growth equity for UK scale-ups over the next five years. Restoring the 30% relief would incentivise investment in SMEs across the country,
to support government investment by allowing investment into firms that are crucial to the supply chains that will help secure our place as global leader and build our national resilience, and deliver growth in every postcode.
Every pound invested by VCTs unlocks an additional £2.33 in funding from additional sources. The Treasury has already shown a willingness to support small businesses. Indeed, the Chancellor last year did listen to the industry and implemented changes requested by the industry for many years. I hope that the Treasury will consider restoring the relief to 30% as part of a wider industry strategy that supports our ambition for growth in every postcode.
Graham Leadbitter
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
Scottish voters were promised change, instead, this budget delivers a real terms cut to Scotland's block budget of £650 million. It treats Scotland as an afterthought, siphons off our energy wealth, and fails to protect hard-working families facing a bitter cost of living crisis this winter. Rather than delivering economic growth or protecting the vulnerable, this is a budget of broken promises. Turning first to the cost of living crisis, Madam Deputy Speaker, during the election, Labour explicitly promised to cut household energy bills by £300. Yet under their watch, energy bills are forecast to surge by 27% this coming January, taking average annual bills to £2,192 before climbing further to £2,389 by April.
Scottish families will face energy bills a whopping £1,275 higher than Labour promised. Even worse, the Chancellor's decision to replace standing charges with higher gas unit prices creates a deeply unfair geographical penalty.
Recent YouGov polling shows that 84% of people in Scotland already had to turn the heating on this year compared to 59% in London. And independent analysis from the Scottish Parliament confirms over 800,000 Scottish households face higher gas bills under these changes. Scots are effectively being forced to pay higher bills to subsidise warmer homes in the south of England. This budget ignores the 142,000 Scottish households who rely on heating oil, leaving them exposed to soaring fuel costs with negligible support. At the pumps, drivers face a similar squeeze.
Since July, diesel has rocketed by 34p per litre to over £2 a litre in many locations, leaving diesel drivers £130 worse off each year. Regrettably, the Prime Minister and the Chancellor are frankly asleep at the wheel.
Madam Deputy Speaker, nowhere is Westminster's contempt for Scotland's economic future clearer than in the decision to axe grant funding for the Acorn carbon capture project in Peterhead. Despite explicit promises that capital was secured, the Government has removed Acorn grant funding. Out of the 200 million promised by Ministers, a mere 12 million in grant funding was delivered, with the rest now being converted to a loan or possibly, maybe, equity proposals. This continues a 20-year history of Westminster betrayals from Gordon Brown to the Tories, to Acorn being snubbed, carbon capture projects left to, left on a scrapheap all over the place.
Madam Deputy Speaker, this deals a direct blow to just transition. The Treasury, in its budget documents, has banked 5.1 billion in revenue from Scottish oil and gas fields. Over decades, more than 400 billion pounds in oil and gas revenue flowed from Scotland's waters into Westminster's hands, with the Chancellor admitting that a Scottish sovereign wealth fund would today be worth 1 trillion pounds had that wealth been properly invested, as Norway chose to do. Hear. Every single penny generated from Scotland's natural resources should be reinvested in Scotland to secure a genuinely just transition to a renewables future.
Costigan.
Deirdre Theresa Costigan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Now, it's fair to say my constituents in Ealing Southall won't all have been glued to the telly last Wednesday to watch the Chancellor speak. Instead, due to wars abroad, many of them will have been trying their best to feed hungry kids off at the half-term or stressing about whether to turn the heating on or not, because after years of austerity, my constituents have spent more than a decade too worried about their daily lives to be able to pay much attention to budget day. And all the talk of GDP, and OBR, and CPI doesn't seem to have any impact on their lives.
But this budget changes that. By cutting energy bills and giving 34,300 households in my constituency a £100 council tax rebate, this budget recognizes the families in Ealing Southall worried about getting through this winter and the next. By reducing tariffs on everyday items, this budget recognizes the hard choices mums in Ealing Southall have to make every day. By permanently raising the tax-free mileage rate to 55p, this budget recognizes the many nurses, plumbers and care workers in Ealing Southall who use their car for work. And by allowing carers to work more hours without losing their entire benefits, this budget recognizes the situation of many carers in Ealing Southall.
Now, the Leader of the Opposition dismisses these changes, but in doing so, she simply shows how out of touch she is with the reality of working people's lives.
Small changes like this matter. But Madam Deputy Speaker, as well as giving people breathing space, this budget also takes the big decisions needed to finally undo the damage of 14 years of the Conservatives. Investing in skills and apprenticeships so that my constituents in Ealing Southall can get better-paid jobs is the best way to protect them from the uncertainties of foreign wars and global crises. And this budget's £15 million investment to restore the Union Learning Fund is one example of this. Now, the Leader of the Opposition dismissed it as a random new scheme employers don't want.
In fact, it's a brilliant old scheme that 78% of employers said they were hugely supportive of until the Tories got rid of it. So yet again, the Leader of the Opposition shows how out of touch she is.
The new learning Union Learning Fund will address the challenges of today and will help reskill the workforce to take on jobs in AI and advanced manufacturing. It will help Somali Uber drivers in my constituency to get help from their union GMB when they fear losing their jobs from driverless cars. This budget also invests in apprenticeships like Jack and Aiden who I met when I visited West London College earlier this year. They can see buildings being built outside their window, and the new apprenticeship brokering scheme will help them to work on those sites. Madam Deputy Speaker, although they might not have been glued to the telly last week, when the kids have all been fed, and the elderly parents have been looked after, and the working day is done, people in Ealing Southall switched on their telly and their heating, and they saw a government that is giving them not just the breathing space they need to make their lives a little easier right now, but the tools they need to face the future with confidence.
Blake Stephenson.
Blake Stephenson
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. What incentive is there for hard-working families and young entrepreneurs to remain in Britain after this budget? That is the question a constituent put to me at a community meeting I held in Wixams in Mid Bedfordshire last week. So, I'd like to start with what I think is the main test that really matters for any budget. Will it make my constituents richer in five years' time than they are today?
And having listened to the Chancellor and to the reaction over the weekend, I'm afraid the answer is no. There is simply no confidence whatsoever that this budget will deliver growth in their postcodes and it certainly doesn't give hope in their hearts.
Given the Prime Minister is extremely comfortable looking to the past, whether it's the 1970s or 2016, than to the future, I did a little reflecting myself over the weekend. And it's fitting that we debate today this budget 40 years on from the big bang in 1986, when regulations that were strangling our economy were swept away, making London the powerhouse of global finance it remains today, opening the city of London to the world and delivering prosperity here at home. The courage of this decision in 1986 benefited every corner of Britain, delivering more jobs, investment and tax revenues that paid for schools, hospitals and public services. During my 15 years in the city before coming to this place, I saw firsthand how EU regulations after the credit crunch steadily ratcheted up costs and risk and de-risked our entire economy.
The courage and ambition of 1986 has slowly given away to the caution and complexity of 2026. And that is why my honourable friend, the Leader of the Opposition is right to say that Britain needs a new economic revolution even bigger than the Big Bang. But where are we today? The OBR says that the tax burden will reach a record 38.6% of GDP. The budget raises tax on savings, rental income again, doubles the bank surcharge and leaves Labour's damaging that jobs tax untouched.
After Labour's first budget, I told the House it was a jobs cutting budget. 1.7 million people older than 16 are now unemployed, up 276,000 under this Government, and vacancies are the lowest level since 2014. And last year, about 136,000 more British nationals left the country than came home, two-thirds of them under 25.
Correct, under 35. The Prime Minister and the Chancellor may have changed, but this budget makes clear, Labour haven't. They are still picking the pockets of working people to pay for welfare. This was plain to hear this weekend, as the Chief Secretary to the Treasury redefined working people to exclude employees. It may be a new team at the Dispatch Box, but their contempt for British business, and British business owners in this budget is as strong as ever.
Peter Dowd
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The motto of my constituency, the old Bootle County Borough, was Respice, Aspice, Prospice, and in English, that means reflecting on the past, considering the present, and providing and looking to the future. So, I want to look to the past a little bit. 2010, David Cameron, "I'll cut the deficit, not the NHS."
Well, that didn't age well, did it? In 2010, the national debt was 64.7% of GDP. By 2024, it was 96.5%. What about the NHS? Waiting lists: 2010, 2.6 million; 2024, 7.6 million.
Satisfaction ratings down. Rough sleeping up. Wage growth down, didn't recover for many years under the Tories.
Food bank use: 100,000 food parcels in 2010, over 3 million by 2024. Child poverty: 3.6 million in child poverty in 2010, 4.3 million by 2024. Zero-hours contracts: 2010, 168, by 2024,
168,000, by 2024, over 1 million. What about the present? So let's look to the present. Over 4,500 more secondary, FE and special school teachers. Over 1,300 schools have joined the free breakfast club.
That impacts upon my constituency in a very practical, positive way. Waiting lists down. The Renters' Rights Act protecting 11 million renters. Creation Great British Energy, cutting bills for schools and hospitals, and planning clean power for 10 million homes. Raising the national minimum wage to £13.21,
3.9% increase.
£100 discount on energy bills for A to D homes, impacting 20 million households. That's 99.8% of homes in my constituency get that, affected by that. Standing charges on household gas scrapped, and so it goes on Madam Deputy Speaker. And what about the future? Decreasing annual borrowing forecast to drop to a hundred from 134 million billion down to 67 billion by 2031.
Share of GDP, annual net borrowing expected to decline from 4.2%. Fiscal rules on track. Real wage growth going up, etc.
Child poverty down. That's what you get from a Labour budget. In addition to the impact upon devolution in all our communities, which will be of great benefit to my constituency. Thank you very much, Madam Deputy.
Siân Berry.
Siân Berry
Many thanks, Madam Deputy Speaker. And I cannot not congratulate the honourable member for Holborn and St Pancras on her speech. It's a constituency I know well and she's a distinguished former colleague of mine on Camden Council. But I am here today to speak about council housing and the government's priority still not being right on this, despite the Chancellor himself in his budget speech explicitly naming the loss of more than two million council homes since the 1980s and the focus on rough sleeping from the Prime Minister. We have millions of people waiting in overcrowded homes or rented homes they can't afford, waiting in temporary accommodation that councils can't afford.
Siân Berry
So what has the government given us in this budget? We have new money: 1.5 billion pounds added to the pot for councils to bid from for affordable home building. In paragraph 5.4 of the budget, the Chancellor says this will help build, potentially, 10,000 more real council homes over the next four years. Not terrible, but in the same document, in paragraphs 5.5, we get another 4.7 billion for the government's new version of the Help to Buy scheme, and the Chancellor explains this will support private, profit-making developers to sell an extra 20,000 new builds. And I presume without expecting developers to cut their prices or their profits, or possibly to increase them.
I note that the government is planning to collect some small fees from house builders, but I assume they've been agreed with them. And I note that one impact of the previous government's help to buy scheme certainly was to keep house prices rising out of many people's reach, and to boost profits and profit margins for developers, as the recent government evaluation of the scheme itself concludes. So, can the government ministers tell us today whether 4.7 billion for loans they don't expect to be paid back for many years to support 20,000 extra private sales by developers really represents better short or long-term value for the public purse than 1.5 billion to enable 10,000 new-build council homes? Three times more funding out of the door for just twice as many new homes. Even under the government's broad housebuilding target, is this really the best use of public money?
Siân Berry
It may not be that simple, so can I ask the Government to give us its workings on these choices, especially if I'm wrong in my assumptions? Can the Government commit to publishing for comparison the Green Book assumptions and appraisals for each of these investment decisions, and the time taken for money to move out and back into its loan scheme? We need to see much more investment in real council housing. We need to see buy the supply, the funding of acquisitions as well, and I cannot see why the Government isn't putting together an equity loan scheme for councils to help them buy the supply instead of going again with a Help to Buy scheme just as the last Conservative Government did.
Adam Thompson.
Adam Thompson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I start by thanking the Chancellor for presenting us with the budget and the Secretary of State for introducing today's debate on growth in every postcode? When the Prime Minister began his tour of the country in August, he started in Ilkeston. There, he, the Secretary of State, and I listened to people talk about the loss that they feel having watched our town center decline over decades. But whether I'm in Ilkeston or Long Eaton, people in my constituency share that same sense of loss.
They remember how our town centers used to be: vibrant high streets and markets, great pubs, bustling centers of commerce and the beating heart of our community, all at the same time.
That's why the Chancellor is absolutely right to help level the playing field, recognising the fundamental shifts in our economy, helping out the struggling small, local businesses, and asking thriving online giants to finally pay their fair share. Following the Chancellor's announcement, almost 400 Erewash businesses will no longer need to pay a penny in business rates. That's money that they can now spend creating jobs, passing back to their customers, reinvesting, or keeping a hold of to reacquire some breathing space themselves. More than 80 additional shops in my constituency no longer paying any business rates at all. And I know the Chancellor will be very glad to hear this, 10 great pubs given full business rates relief, including the fantastic Dewdrop in Ilkeston and the Mill & Brook in Long Eaton.
Speaker 315
Mark, colleague, because so many people want to speak tonight, thank you.
Adam Thompson
So, if the Chancellor is looking for somewhere to celebrate his first budget, I'd love to invite him to come to Erewash to try out the newly done-up function room at the Mill & Brook or perhaps to enjoy one of the Dewdrop's famous cheese and onion cobs. Turning, Madam Deputy Speaker, to measures that my right honourable friend the Chancellor has extended for families, I'm very heartened indeed to hear him present such an extensive raft of measures to help pull back the cost of living for so many people across Erewash and the country. Alongside the removal of VAT on electricity costs and scrapping standing charges on gas, the direct £100 payment this winter is an enormous step, pulling down energy bills for more than 40,000 families from Sawley to Sandiacre to Shipley View. Can I also thank the Chancellor for his continued investment in Rolls-Royce? Royce's is a huge employer in my constituency, and it's a great point of pride for us in Derbyshire that the most ground- groundbreaking innovation in the world happens on our doorstep.
The Chancellor has recognised how much Rolls-Royce and my constituents have to offer our country. That, Madam Deputy Speaker, is what a Labour budget is all about. Rooting our economy in society and making them both fairer. Supporting working families, pensioners, carers, small businesses, all. It's great to have a Chancellor and a government that listens to people.
A Chancellor and a government that will allow our communities to hope again, and a Chancellor and a government that will put our communities back at the heart of our economy.
Iain Duncan Smith
Madam Deputy Speaker, it's worth reflecting on three things although we've got very little time, so I just want to spend one comment on welfare. Thank you. It is necessary for us, or the government that is to say, to reduce welfare spending because as we don't reduce welfare spending, you see what the forecast says that debt and borrowing will now be higher in every single year of the government's own forecast.
And that is hugely down to the fact the growth in welfare spending is running out of control. I simply lay that as a point because it was avoided during the budget. I was astonished. And then we heard the confusion when the Chancellor went on the radio the following morning saying that welfare would be reduced during the course of the Government. He was overridden by the Treasury who said, no, it won't and he didn't say that, but he did.
And that's the confusion. I don't doubt that he wants to do it appears that he's not going to be able to do it. But the main thing I want to say here is that the this budget has not been good for working families and middle income earners and those who even bother to save.
It's really hard on them. Tax is the highest on record. Tax burden is hitting historic high next year at 37 nearly 38% of GDP, and will surge to over 38.6 maybe 37% by 2030-31. And the reality is growth next year has been cut from 1.6% to 1%,
and real household and disposable income per person, as a result of this budget, is forecast to fall by 0.8% the year. They're just stark figures. They're figures that economists have produced in their forecast. And I simply say the effect of that is to have fewer choices for government. And not one word was spent, and I want to say this about defense.
Defense is important for two specific reasons. Number one, the threat that we face now is astonishing from China, North Korea, from Iran and Russia, all linked together in an axis of totalitarian states. And that needs therefore our defense spending to rise. Every other government in Europe is raising defense spending.
We used to be the lead on this.
They would all look to us. Not anymore, because we've avoided that and even the defense review won't take place until well into next year, and who knows what will happen next. And I simply say this is a, this is a failure really of the government. It's an opportunity that is missed. And let me just quote what Helen Miller, the economist at the IFS said.
She said it feels like a lot of fiddling short-term things, new complications, a young allowance for entrepreneurs, start-up ISAs, etc. I didn't hear a clear coherent vision or a simplification of the tax system, which is necessary. And that is the reality. This was an opportunity missed and future generations will look back at this moment and say, where were you?
"Where were you, why didn't you take those decisions that were necessary?"
Baggy Bhagat Shanker
Madam Deputy Speaker, can I first refer the House to my Register of Financial Interests specifically relating to Rolls-Royce? This is a Budget that backs grafters, not just in Derby, but in towns and cities across the whole country. It backs hardworking families struggling to make ends meet with £100 of breathing space on their energy bill. It backs the landlords behind the pubs we know and love with changes to business rates helping balance their books. And it backs good growth, not just in DE1 and DE2, not just in our great city of Derby, but in postcodes all over the country.
And at the heart of that is good growth and reindustrialisation driving the jobs, investment and opportunities our communities need. In Derby, we know a thing or two about making things.
For generations we have built, engineered and supplied the technologies that keep our country powered. We are proud of that heritage, but we know that our industrial future can't be built on nostalgia. We need investment that match the scale of our ambition for British workers and British industry. Investments like the whopping £2.5 billion joint investment delivered in the budget to keep the next generation of narrow-body aircraft engines right here on our home soil.
Last week, I was proud to welcome the Prime Minister, the Chancellor and our brilliant Business Secretary to Derby to meet people making that possible. People like Rolls-Royce apprentices Will, Elliott, and Lucy, young people putting in the hard yards, learning their trade and building the skills that will secure not just their own futures, but the future of British manufacturing. And the investment will create thousands more opportunity like theirs from the design office to the factory floor, and for our brilliant small and medium businesses right across the supply chain. Because reindustrialization isn't just a headline, it's about creating good, stable jobs close to home. It's about opportunities for our suppliers, services, skilled crafts, people who support our growing factories.
And it's about giving local communities a share in that manufacturing success which they helped to create.
But that hasn't always been the case, and in Derby we know that better than most. The manufacturing success Derby residents have helped to create has not been shared with them. But things are changing, because with £10 million of Government investment behind Team Derby, we're putting that right. We're making sure that every pound of investment works and hard, works as hard as it can, making it better for our city and our residents. Reindustrialisation is about putting the work that the people and the place benefits from, and that's why this Budget backs our communities.
Chris Coghlan.
Chris Coghlan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
When my grandfather, Lieutenant Austin Coghlan, a naval officer served in the Battle of the Atlantic, he did not expect to survive. That he did was in no small part due to the code breakers at Bletchley Park who diverted convoys away from U-boats. In the process, the code breakers invented the world's first computer, Colossus, which powered the economic development of the post-war world. The spillover effect from military technology to civilian use is one of the most powerful forces for economic growth. We can use it now.
Many have said that there is not much that is transformative in this budget, that overlooks the Chancellor's decision to invest five billion, up to 5 billion in dual use military technology through the British Business Bank and the National Wealth Fund, and to borrow jointly with our allies through the multinational defense mechanism.
I have called for this for the last two years on the Treasury Committee, so I'm grateful to the government and the Liberal Democrats for embracing this policy. Academics now recognize that the economic dominance of the United States has been powered by public research and development, especially in defense. In my budget speech last year, I called for five billion more on public research and development to just take us up to US levels as a share of GDP. The five billion in this budget, while over four years, is a start. Public investment in research in universities and laboratories is powerful because it de-risks the costs of developing new technologies, enabling private investments to take it forward into start-ups.
London Business School's Paolo Surico has found that innovation which is funded by the government, but taken forward by the private sector, generates productivity and growth which is eight times larger than innovation taken forward by the private sector alone.
Now, of course, more borrowing is a concern in the current fiscal environment, but as the Government has correctly identified, borrowing jointly with allies can deep remove most of the credit risk. And the latest academic research enables us to forecast returns with confidence. If this program was scaled in increments of 2 billion a year annually over the next 10 years, it could lead to: 1, growth finally returning to pre-2008 levels, transforming living standards; 2, debt to GDP 2 percentage points, or 60 billion pounds, lower; and 3, meeting our NATO defense spending commitments. Madam Deputy Speaker, British politicians in the 1930s were labeled "the guilty men" because they failed to prioritise defense over the deficit.
My grandfather's generation paid the price.
As reservist infantry officer and an MP, I want to ensure that our generation does not.
Ashley Dalton.
Ashley Dalton
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome the measures taken by the Chancellor in this Budget. It is a Budget clear-eyed about the pressures people and businesses continue to face, but equally clear about our plan of action: support households to keep more of their money, reduce costs for businesses, and create the conditions for economic growth. Now, people across West Lancashire, Madam Deputy Speaker, are working hard to make ends meet. There is no dearth in the ambition or talent that exists in our local communities.
But when conflict in the Middle East drives up global energy prices, my constituents feel the effects in their household budgets. The extension of the 0% VAT rate on electricity until July 2027, the removal of standing charges from household gas bills, and the £2.6 billion energy bills breathing space scheme are all welcome steps. In West Lancashire, 37,000-plus households will benefit from the £100 payment this winter. The costs of global volatility are not only felt in the home, however. The conflict in the Middle East has once again demonstrated how vulnerable motorists are to fluctuations in global fuel prices.
I welcome, therefore, the extension of fuel duty tax cuts until July next year.
I've spoken repeatedly about the need to improve public transport and rail connectivity in Skelmersdale in my constituency, ensuring that our communities are better connected to neighbouring towns, cities and economic opportunities. And while I continue to encourage Reform-led Lancashire County Council to work constructively with me to improve local transport for my constituents, I also recognise that in many parts of a rural constituency such as mine, owning a car is currently a necessity. And that is why measures to ease the pressure on motorists are particularly welcome in rural constituencies like mine, where the price at the pump is piling additional pressure on already overstretched families. But this budget is not only for families. Our high streets are at the heart of our communities.
They bring employment opportunities, economic growth, and a sense of community, character, and identity. As co-chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Theatre, I'm particularly conscious of the important role that our cultural venues play in supporting our local economy, touring productions in particular. The economic contribution of touring theatre extends well beyond the theatre itself, with every pound spent on the theatre ticket generating a further £1.40 in local spending. So, I look forward to seeing how the Government can further support the touring sector and creative industries, ensuring theatres can reach audiences across the country. I welcome this budget that recognises the importance of our high streets and the contribution of small businesses.
It's how we create jobs, strengthen our communities, and deliver growth that people feel in every postcode, in every day of their lives.
Iqbal Mohamed
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
The most critical issue facing my constituents in Dewsbury and Batley is affordability, cost of living, cost of living. The budget should not be an annual announcement to appease markets, protect and enrich corporations, executives, shareholders, the rich and the super-rich, or even those in this place. It should not look after the wealthy at the expense of the poor. It should be about making the lives of the vast majority of people in our country better and more affordable, and for some, just bearable. I met one of those people who lives in Batley, who works full-time, pays her taxes, and does everything we tell people should do.
And she showed me her budget and asked a question that no one in modern Britain should have to ask: Should I pay my rent? Should I pay my bills? Or should I buy food? Not because she's unemployed, not because she has mismanaged her finances, not because she lacks ambition, but because the weekly shop costs more, the gas bill costs more, the rent costs more, the journey to work costs more.
Everything that a human being needs to live a simple, dignified life costs much more. And her wages will simply not keep up. That is the reality of the cost of living crisis. And this budget, although there are some welcome measures, does not do anywhere near enough to make life bearable, let alone affordable, for the many, by making the few contribute a bit more.
We in this place earn over £98,000. We will not feel the impact of the energy prices that are 70% higher than 2020, rising by 4% this month and by a quarter in January. The 60 to 70% increase in petrol and diesel prices will be a blip that will have little impact on our driving or lifestyle. The cost of food, according to the Commons Library, grocery prices have increased by about 38.6% since 2020, meaning a weekly £100 shop now costs roughly £138.60. Car insurance has risen 82% between 2021 and '24 and insurance premium indexes have increased by 126% since 2020.
And national, nationally, the average rents have climbed from roughly 975 a month to £1,375 a month. Madam Deputy Speaker, too often we, ministers speak about future economy, economic improvements while households wonder how they will get through the next week. And Parliament must take some responsibility, because our duty is not to simply debate suffering. It is not merely to acknowledge hardship. It is not enough to express concern.
Our duty, you know, is to act, and this Government has let the people down. Thank you.
Mary Glindon
Madam Deputy Speaker, and I welcome the positives in the Chancellor's budget, many of which include the freeze on fuel duty, increases in the minimum and national living wage, as well as in small business rate relief threshold for RHL properties, and the fact that almost 56,000 households in my constituency will benefit from the £100 payment for properties in council tax bands A and D, A to D. However, I must advise the Chancellor that there won't be good growth in postcodes NE6 and NE28 unless ministers pull every lever at their disposal to support industry on the Tyne. The overhead electric cables are a constraint on investment as they prevent movement of large structures used in the offshore energy sector.
News that the project to underground the cables is now effectively paused will push the 2034 completion date even further into the future. International yards are already capitalising on our offshore wind leasing rounds, fixed-bottom assets are increasing in size and investment in floating offshore wind, which will see integrated units towed to sea, is set to overtake fixed-bottom by the early 2030s. My constituency has the skills and the infrastructure to sit at the forefront of the UK's green future. It is the home to a cluster of offshore supply chain firms, an expanding energy skills academy and less than a 100 nautical miles from the world's largest offshore wind farm. Ofgem, the National Grid and Ministers must act decisively.
Tyneside can seize the opportunities that the green transition offers if they do.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
For all the positives of this budget, it's the real disappointment is that it doesn't match the radicalism and claims of the now endless Government social media and TikTok barrage. It's extraordinary, given everything that was previously said when he was Secretary of State for Defence, that the Chancellor has kicked the big defence spending decisions down the road. There are only warm words, but no plan for helping people back into work and, of course, nothing concrete on Europe, something even the previous Chancellor has acknowledged over the weekend needs addressing. A big theme for my constituents is the need for infrastructure to support housing. I believe there would be less despair and opposition to new houses if central Government listens to calls for transparency and ambition when it comes to infrastructure and public services to support housing growth.
Setting and publishing targets for the amount of primary healthcare, transport, large-scale leisure or policing per head of population based on an analysis of local demographic needs and showing progress or otherwise against those metrics would help to restore trust and highlight where investment is needed. This is all the more important as local councils do not have direct control of most of these areas. The lack of acknowledgement of these challenges, let alone action on them in the Budget, is disappointing. It's also regrettable that there are no rolling funds or investment programmes for major transport investments. Without them, no hope has been created for a new railway station serving Grove and Wantage, accessibility improvements to Cholsey station, or railway electrification from Didcot to Oxford.
Now, the Government's slow embrace of devolution amidst the utter shambles of local government reorganisation, we have to hope, will fill some of this void, but that very much remains to be seen as the result of so many unanswered questions.
Now, there's some welcome measures supporting hospitality, but small producer relief for small scale producers of alcohol still excludes small vineyards such as Hendred Vineyard, which produces just a few thousand bottles a year. This makes little sense. The alcohol intensity of a drink does not inherently correlate with how much it is abused, and English wine has a promising future. But I want to finish my remarks with what the budget says about science and high-tech. Now, despite some positive measures on AI safety and a capital gains tax for founders' relief, the government's previous decisions on science mean that this is the area of biggest disappointment.
My constituency is a wide range of science and technology organizations, but the government's decision to significantly cut the Science and Technology Facilities Council funding is incomprehensible and unforgivable.
No wonder after three months the government still has not had the basic courtesy to reply to my letters on this. 15% funding cuts to Harwell campus's three national and globally significant research facilities, a Diamond Light Source, ISIS Neutron and Muon Source and the Central Laser Facility, will lead to significant decreases in operating time of up to 25%. Now I'm used to the government ignoring me, but maybe they'll listen to Deputy General Secretary of Prospect, Sue Ferns, Liverpool City Region Mayor, Steve Rotheram, and the physicist, Brian Cox, who have all warned that these cuts would cause lasting and possibly irreparable damage to the UK's scientific capabilities.
Kirsteen Sullivan.
Ann Kirsteen Sullivan
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The real test of this budget are the families who notice every extra penny at the petrol station, every increase in energy bill and the pounds adding on to the weekly shop.
The war in Iran carries a price tag for the whole globe and that is clear at the petrol pump and on our energy bills. For motorists and over three and a half thousand workers in transport and logistics in my Bathgate and Linlithgow constituency, the price at the pump matters, so I welcome the continued freeze to the fuel duty cut until July 2027, a measure I've called for throughout this year, and also welcome the end to standing charges for gas and the 100-pound payment to those in council tax bands A to D. Again, this will make the thought of bills during the upcoming winter period that bit less stressful. If the Scottish Government passes it on in the same way, over 119,000 households across West Lothian and Falkirk council areas will benefit, and it must be passed on.
Our constituents cannot afford for it to disappear into the black hole created by the SNP's mismanagement of Scotland's finances. These measures mean real reduction, reductions in bills, shifting the brunt of levies and standing charges away from the consumer, just as the worst hits. However, I'm just going to continue so that colleagues can get in. However, I'm mindful that many people have high energy usage due to health conditions and disabilities, so I'd be grateful if the Minister could outline what kind of support those with health vulnerabilities will receive. And I'm also aware that many businesses continue to struggle with a high level of energy costs, especially those manufacturers in energy-intensive sectors, so I would have liked to have seen an expansion of the eligibility for the BIC scheme, and I hope that's something that the Chancellor will consider.
But I also hope that the Scottish Government takes a leaf out of the Chancellor's book and replicates the cuts to business rates to give our high street businesses a boost. This budget also delivers a further 600 million for Scotland, adding up to over 18 billion more since Labour was elected in July 2024. So, I'm calling on the Scottish Government to use that 600 million extra and invest in the services in which my constituents rely and use day in, day out. Madam Deputy Speaker, whilst we can't predict every shock that comes from overseas, we can choose how we respond to them, and we chose to protect families at petrol pump and on their energy bills, and we chose to back British workers, British businesses and British manufacturing.
This is what this budget is about, giving my constituents greater security today, whilst building a stronger and more resilient economy for tomorrow.
Charlie Maynard.
Charlie Maynard
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Chancellor said in his speech last week that people are looking to government not to solve their problems, but to give them a bit of breathing space. Well, this may be partly true, but I think it demonstrates a lack of ambition which sits behind this budget. Government should be solving or at least making a much more serious attempt than we saw last week about the systemic problems in our economy.
These are at the root of why so many families are struggling to make ends meet and so many businesses are failing. When the economy is as damaged as it is, when public sector debt sits at 104% of debt-to-GDP as per the IMF, productivity is decreasing, consumer confidence is down, housing costs continue to rise, then I absolutely think it is the job of the government to do something substantial towards solving the country's problems. Make no mistake, the various incremental measures the Chancellor announced, such as household energy bills, will be welcome, but they are not sufficient to move the dial on growth, to quote the IFS. With bigger, more difficult decisions kicked down the road for another time, what my constituents in Witney want to know is how they're going to absorb another year of no real earnings growth,
mortgage increases coming down the pipe on the back of a likely Bank of England rise this week.
My constituents want to know that the public services are safe that we all rely on and they're not. They want to see genuine hope for a future with better jobs and more opportunities and they want to know that our food supply is secure and our rural economy will be supported. But across the board, this budget was too unambitious and ducked the big decisions our country is crying out for. I'm going to give two areas that could move the dial. First, the Chancellor's speech was silent on Britain's relationship with our biggest trading partner, the EU.
Our country prospers when fair, dynamic markets for goods, services, capital, and labor operate effectively. If the government is serious about our economy and wants growth, get on and open negotiations for our country to rejoin the European Union now. Secondly, if we are serious about getting our national debt under control, we have to look at reforming our fiscal rules. Why? Because they do not work.
This is demonstrated by the fact for the last 25 years, we have not had a single year where tax receipts exceeded spending. Our fiscal rules are front-loaded front-load spending in the early years and difficult decisions, as epitomized by last week's budget, are put off, often the other side of an election. There are good international examples we can learn from here that where other countries do it better, such as Switzerland and Sweden. So I urge the Chancellor to take steps to rejoin the EU and to establish a cross-party commission exploring more prudent fiscal rules.
Amanda Martin
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. We live in an ever-changing world where global issues impact on our everyday lives, so I'm pleased this budget is about making a difference to working people and families in Portsmouth North, little changes making a big difference.
People in my city are worried about the cost of energy. This budget responds by extending the removal of the VAT on electricity until July '27, removing gas standing charges and putting a hundred pound directly into the bank of 40,000 households across Portsmouth North. That's alongside the new business industry competitive scheme for businesses. But energy isn't the only cost putting pressure on families. For many people in Portsmouth North, getting to work or school means getting in the car and the cost of filling up hits hard.
Extending the 5p fuel duty and cutting fuel duty, keeping fuel duty frozen, helps motorists and businesses manage these every day. And Madam Deputy Speaker, the cost of living is also about where people can still enjoy life and that, so people coming together. So I'm pleased to see that change in this budget will mean half of retail, leisure and hospitality in our region will pay no more business rates at all. Madam Deputy Speaker, we must invest in our future, and the Your First Home scheme means lower deposits and more opportunity for young people, and I look forward to more details.
And we must keep our country safe. In Portsmouth, our naval city, defence means more than national security. It means jobs, skills and opportunities for local people. And the government's spending 14 million billion more on defence than the previous government, but 3. billion for the naval def- dockyard is brilliant. This Madam Deputy Speaker, alongside the investment from previous governments, is great.
But Madam Deputy Speaker, one announcement especially close to my heart, and that is paternity pay for the self-employed. For too long, self-employed men have faced impossible choice: spend those precious first few days with your newborn or return to work, because those bills won't wait. Labour introduced paternity leave, but self-employed dads and non-birthing partners were left behind. This budget takes an important step. For the first time, they were able to receive paternity pay, something that is a point of principle.
For a builder, a plumber, a taxi driver, a shopkeeper, and a farmer, this means real support at the most important moment of your life. Up to £194 a week for 2 weeks might not be enough, and the Treasury minister will not be surprised to know I want to see longer leave and more generous pay. But for someone who currently gets nothing, this change means real help with the bills, less finances, pressure and, more importantly, more time with their newborn child, because being there for your child should not be a luxury reserved for those who can afford it. I want to quickly thank the incredible campaigners who have helped: all at The Dad Shift, On The Tools and Movember.
And most importantly, the hard-working tradespeople across the country who have made their voice heard and have trusted me to bring their voice to this place. This victory is theirs, and they should be so very proud, as I am so very proud of them. How, Madam Deputy Speaker, can we allow young men and ask them to be take up apprenticeships in our trades if we do not protect their future and their families?
This is personal for me. My dad was a tradie, my brother is a tradie, and so is my grandad. And I'm incredibly proud of both of them, and I wanted something different for my own sons. Thank you very much.
Ashley Peter Fox
Madam Deputy Speaker, I was disappointed that the Chancellor did nothing to change the Gift Aid rules that would have helped Bridgwater Carnival and so many other community organisations and charities. Bridgwater Guy Fawkes Carnival is the most magnificent spectacle. It is Britain's oldest carnival, and the largest illuminated carnival in Europe. And it's on Saturday.
Like so many good causes, the carnival raises much of its funds in small cash donations, often loose change collected in a bucket on the night. Yet they can only claim Gift Aid on a maximum of £2,000 on these small donations, a figure that hasn't been increased for ten years. So I ask the Chancellor, please will he consider increasing this limit, which would make a huge difference to organisations that collect so much of their funds in small cash donations. Madam Deputy Speaker, despite making so many changes in his budget, the Chancellor has not reinstated the Listed Places of Worship grant scheme that his predecessor abolished. This means that communities who worship in a listed building, like the parish of St Andrew's in Burnham-on-Sea, will have to bear the full cost of VAT on the repairs their historic church requires.
The scheme that replaced it is less generous and has a capped budget.
We should cherish our beautiful, listed churches and take care of them for future generations. I will continue to press the Chancellor to renew this scheme in full to make sure that our congregations are not charged an extra 20% for vital repairs. Now, there are 98 separate measures in the Red Book, many of them which will further complicate Britain's already Byzantine tax code. Do we really need a new founder's relief from capital gains tax, which we are told will be for qualifying founders of high-growth, innovative companies?
Now, it sounds good perhaps for Labour tax relief, but wouldn't it be better to lower the rate of CGT for everyone, rather than add another carve out for accountants and lawyers to argue about? Britain needs lower tax rates with fewer exemptions, not additional complications that drive up the cost of compliance. The fundamental problem Britain faces today is simple. We are running out of money, and unless we change course soon, every other problem will become harder to solve. Our national debt is now £3 trillion, and every year, Labour is adding tens of billions more.
And at a time of international uncertainty, we must spend more on defence, but this does government won't and can't, because they refuse to cut welfare. So, we need a plan to cut debt, fund defence, and get Britain growing again.
Chris Curtis.
Chris Curtis
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I want to speak today about the devolution measures announced in the budget and the fiscal devolution pathway that's been set out. We normally hear two arguments for devolution: that decisions should be made closer to the people they affect rather than in Whitehall, and that investment should be spread more fairly beyond London and certain pockets of the south-east. Now, I agree with both of those arguments, but I think there is a more important argument. Devolution can help us grow the economy and make the British state work better.
After nearly two decades of stagnation, we desperately need to raise productivity, build infrastructure faster and unlock growth across the country.
I believe devolution can be one of the best ways of doing that. Well, I think that needs to come with fiscal devolution. 95% of tax revenue in Britain is raised by central governments rather than regional or local level. Meanwhile, France raises three times as much at a sub-national level, Germany much higher still. Centre for Cities has found there is a strong relationship between fiscal devolution and wages across devolved economies.
Correlation is not always causation, but there are obvious economic reasons why that relationship exists. Today, when councils approve new housing, attracts employment or investment or builds infrastructure, they take the political risk and bear many of the upfront costs, but much of that additional tax revenue goes straight to the Treasury and eventually gets redistributed elsewhere. And even when they do retain that money, it can disappear at the next funding reset, as we saw happen earlier this year.
Local leaders bear the cost of growth, while the Treasury collects the proceeds. That is why I welcome the Chancellor's commitment to increase business rates retention, giving mayors a share of business rates growth from next year and income tax receipts from 2028. If we want local leaders to take difficult decisions in favour of growth, their communities need to share in the rewards. Stable future revenues can also allow local areas to borrow against to borrow against that future growth to pay for the infrastructure needed today, and it's good to see the government looking at how that can happen with places like the Cambridge Greater Cambridge Development Corporation, and I hope it's something we can look at in Milton Keynes in the future.
I just want to finish off, as well, by saying that, while I know many areas across the country are going to be benefiting from the proceeds of the devolution announcements announced by the government, I'm disappointed that, at least in the announcement my this week, my local area is not going to be one of them. That is not because of the real hard work and determination by many MPs across this chamber to get devolution across Bedfordshire and Milton Keynes, or, indeed, from government who came forward with nearly a billion-pound package in order to get this over the line. It was, unfortunately, vetoed by one local government leader in Central Bedfordshire who decided to put politics ahead of the people that he was elected to represent. He has let the local area down, and I hope the government will continue to work with all local leaders in the area to see if they can find a solution.
Jim Allister.
Jim Allister
Thank you, Deputy Speaker. Taken as a whole, this budget is really rather insipid, because it deliberately avoids many of the big-ticket areas like our runaway benefits budget, which it does nothing at all about, and the need to put together a properly funded program to adequately build the defense of this nation, again, an issue that this budget leaves untouched. But I suppose at least we have a budget. I say that because in my part of United Kingdom, we're now entering the eighth month when because of a catastrophic failure of devolution in Northern Ireland, we don't even have a budget for this year, never mind next year.
And I do say to the Treasury and to the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, this can't go on. You need to bring that budget through this House so that there is the money to pay the public service pay rises and everything else, which is now at risk because of the dysfunctional failure of the Stormont Executive. One of the other things that this budget is silent about, and yet it's something, if the government has its way, which will be very important going forward, and that is the cost of the government's intended reset with the EU. I take but one example of that,
the proposition that the United Kingdom should participate in the EU's electricity market.
When you go to the Council decision of the EU, which created the mandate for the EU to negotiate with the United Kingdom about the United Kingdom entering the EU's electricity market, you find that mandate includes these words: "An agreement on the financial contribution of the United Kingdom towards reducing economic, social and territorial disparities between the regions of the Union." In other words, the United Kingdom, as a cost of joining the electricity market of the EU, is going to be required to make a contribution, no doubt a sizable contribution, to the EU's cohesion fund. It's the same with SPS. It's the same with all the targets of the reset.
And yet, this budget fails to tell us what the cost of any of that is going to be. So, the government needs to front up on this. It needs to tell the public, not the glossy impression it would like to create of advantage, which is phony in re- in the reset, but the actual monetary cost. What is it, Minister?
Catrin Emily Darlington
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Milton Keynes MPs must be like buses: you wait a long time, and two come at once. 113 billion. 113 billion is the cost every year because women are excluded from paid work on equal terms with men.
I worked very closely with members from across these benches, as well as the Women's Budget Group and the Good Grief Trust, to put together an unashamedly female agenda around how we get to realize the 113 billion of gross value added every year, if women could fully participate in the economy. And I want to thank my honourable friends, the ministers, at the Treasury for their engagement on this really important document. Now I want to talk about what this budget delivers for women. It bolsters us, it promotes us, and it protects us.
It bolsters us with paternity leave and a and leave for adoption for self-employed people, breakfast clubs and VAT cuts on energy bills. We know that women, more often than not, are the ones that are trying to make the household bills add up at the end of the month, and they are the first person in the family to go without when there isn't enough. The commitment to the gender pay gap and pay transparency is so important. But women are business owners too, particularly on our high streets, our hairdressers, our nail technicians seeing business rate cuts, but also in those high-tech, high-investment, science-based industries where we're going to have fair investment practices, TechForward standards to replace workplace to improve workplace culture, and 200 million, double the commitment, for women-led businesses through the British Business Bank and a scale-up programme to help them to help them flourish.
And finally, this budget also protects women and girls. It establishes, for the first time, a misogyny taskforce which is looking at tackling the core issues that are holding women back and keeping them scared and destroying equality in our society. And £55 million worth of funding over two years to meet the commitment to halve violence of against women and girls in the decade. It will strengthen our law enforcement activity, improve protection for victims, and identify and disrupt harmful behaviors. This is a budget for women, because if women succeed, our country succeeds.
Speaker 296
And before I call the next member, members are being very disciplined with interventions, but they may wish to know that there are several colleagues who have absented themselves from the Chamber without any notice. Charlotte Cane.
Charlotte Cane
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Growth in every postcode, the Chancellor seems to have forgotten the people in Ely and East Cambridgeshire. Nothing in the budget, no funding for the Ely junction improvements, which would increase capacity on that rail line for freight and for passengers and make it more reliable. Nothing to reduce rail fares, which are getting out of many people's reach. Nothing to help the county council with the phenomenal cost of mending our soil-affected roads.
They estimate the cost to be £500 million, an amount no county council can find.
It's roughly 10 times their annual budget for road repairs. We have roads that over this summer actually have no earth underneath them anymore and when they go out to repair them, they have to instead close the road because there is no earth on which to repair it. Buses, it's great that we've got capped bus fares, but many of my villages don't have buses at all. Nothing in the budget about improving bus routes and getting more buses. And nothing on the A10.
The money's been removed for that, and nothing's been put back in the budget. So, really, for every postcode, not for mine. As for the farmers who had that catastrophic SFI, where it closed within hours, nothing for them. Nothing to recognise the problems they had over this long, hot, dry summer.
We need to back our farmers. They are in my postcodes. They feed all of us. And then you come to breathing space. There are some good things in the budget to help people with the cost of living, but not for people who are on heating oil.
I've had a letter from a young mom who is telling me that she has to find £650 just to buy the minimum amount of oil that can be delivered, and that wouldn't last her the winter. She can't ask for money from the Crisis and Resilient Fund, because she had that back in spring and she's told she can't ask again.
Yes, she'll probably get £100 in January, but she needs £650 now. And then to add insult to injury, the Chancellor has cut the money in the budgets for getting people helping people get away from their dependence on oil heating. So, I can't even be sure that all my constituents can take advantage of moving on to heat pumps or other technology. At the very least, will the Chancellor please look again at how he can help people on oil central heating because they desperately need it this winter. And please we cannot just tell them to eat gherkins.
Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett
Madam Deputy Speaker, there are many welcome announcements in this budget to help give people a little breathing space. From 100 £100 for households in council tax bands A to D, to paternity leave payments for self-employed fathers.
And something I personally really welcome was the investment in getting more women into tech, as recommended by the government's Women in Tech Taskforce. At a time when trust in the tech industry is low, we need women in tech more than ever. And I would refer people to my register of interest. You'll know I've got quite a focus on this. However, following a meeting yesterday at Gresley Old Hall with members of the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme in South Derbyshire, I want to focus on them.
And I speak today on behalf of 1,141 scheme members and their families in my constituency. These men spent their working lives doing some of the hardest and most dangerous jobs in our country. They kept our lights on, our homes warm, and our industries running.
Their pensions are deferred wages earned through years of dangerous work, not a taxpayer handout. Now I welcome the transfer of the 1.5 billion investment reserve in 2024 and the Chancellor's announcement to end surplus sharing so that 100% of future surpluses go to the members. But the job isn't finished. There's still approximately 1.2 billion in the Guarantor's Fund. Members need certainty that it will be transferred in full without further delay.
Yesterday, what I had hoped would be a meeting to celebrate progress became a meeting where I found myself apologizing because, once again, people who have waited decades for justice are being asked to wait again. And time is running out. Around 100 former miners die every week. Some will never live to see the justice they have spent years campaigning for. This is also about our former coalfield communities.
That money will be spent in our towns and villages, supporting local shops, businesses and families, helping growth in postcodes in South Derbyshire.
And I've raised this directly with Treasury ministers and the Prime Minister's Office. I've also pledged to donate my next annual parliamentary salary increase to charity until miners and their families receive what they are owed. I stand in solidarity with them not just in words, but in deeds too. Madam Deputy Speaker, I want to finish with words of Gary Chamberlain, who I met yesterday. His words were, "If you think this is a storm in a teacup, think again, this is just the start of it."
And Gary is right. For Gary and for my 1,141 MPS member constituents and their families, and for mining communities across the country, I say this to Government. Please release the remaining £1.2 billion, give members the certainty they deserve and ensure their bonus payment arrives on the 23rd of December, as originally planned, in time for Christmas. We are the Labour Party. It's only a Labour Government that will deliver justice for our miners, and we must not be a Labour Government that asks them to wait yet again.
Our miners have given enough to this country. It is time for this country gave them what they are owed.
Andrew George.
Andrew George
Thank you, Madam Speaker. And it's a pleasure to follow the honourable Member for South Derbyshire, and as she refers to the fact that this is a Labour budget, but I want to really highlight the way in which it doesn't contribute, as I would hope it would do, of course, good growth in every postcode is a good thing, but combating widening inequality, I'm not sure it lives up to what I believe that the Labour Party argues for.
I submitted a number of EDMs, 939, 940, 963, to give constructive proposals to the Chancellor with regard to addressing widening inequality, constructive proposals as you expect me to provide. And whereas the Conservatives want to focus on the benefits bill, and of course we should, they don't seem to want to focus quite so much on the benefits bill of tax benefits for the wealthy, and it's that area that I wish to concentrate on most, because 23% of government tax take, which is two, 217.5 billion pounds, is available in tax relief, as the Treasury ministers know full well. The Treasury Select Committee identified that 80% of those tax reliefs have never been publicly costed or evaluated.
and I would hope that the government will be looking at these matters, as I'll come on to one in housing in a moment. The Secretary of State referred to my private member's bill, which is after debate on the Friday the 13th, so next week, and that will be addressing both the need for first before second homes and also need before greed within the planning system, and I hope that Labour members and others will be coming along to support that bill. Well, what concerns me in particular is that the business rate relief system contained on page 130 of the Red Book refers to the cut in rather, the availability of the Small Business Rate Relief for the RHL sector. And this includes, of course, holiday lets.
And the problem is that because holiday lets are invariably have been second homes before people have flipped their property from council tax to business rate, apply for small business rate relief, and then pay nothing at all. And what the government have done is extended the valuation from £12,000 to £18,000, which has then made a larger group of people who are wealthy enough with their second properties now able to take advantage of this particular loophole. And in areas like mine with large numbers of second homes, we would like to see that the half a billion pounds that has gone from taxpayers' money into the pockets of second home owners, put that money into social and affordable housing. It's driving inflation in the system, it's creating further inequality. I do hope the government will look at this again, think again, and address this issue.
Linsey Farnsworth
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This budget contains a series of practical measures that will make a real difference to families across Amber Valley.
While some may dismiss individual announcements as small measures, it is their combined effect that matters. Taken together, they provide genuine breathing space for thousands of people across Amber Valley. This includes expanded childcare and free breakfast clubs for families, support for households worried about energy bills and measures to help people with transport costs for work and for leisure.
Will she give way?
I will give way.
Speaker 342
I thank my honourable friend for giving way. That's really important what she's just said there about lots of cumulative announcements making a difference. I know for my constituency of Clwyd East in North Wales, we pay some of the highest standing charges of anywhere in the country with people in North Wales having paid 68p a day standing charge in comparison to the 43p paid each day by people in London. Does she agree with me that not only is this welcome, but this is a huge step to fairness in our energy system as well as creating that breathing space?
Linsey Farnsworth
I do agree with my honourable friend. It is very important that there is breathing space right across this country, just like growth in every postcode. Madam Deputy Speaker, the budget is only one part of a much wider programme of reform. The high street strategy, the modern service framework for dementia and frailty, reforming social care, bringing decision making closer to our communities through devolution and, of course, our 10-year plan will all be transformative for my constituents. But now, I want to turn to another matter addressed by the budget.
It's a matter that is probably echoing my friend for South Derbyshire, it's a big issue in our local community.
It's a and it's extremely personal to me and it and to hundreds of people in my constituency also. Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm proud to be a former coal miner's daughter, and I'm proud to be a Labour MP with a government committed to finally delivering justice for mineworkers. Because, let's face it, only a Labour government will do so. Now, since Labour came into office in 2024, we've seen real progress on this topic.
The MPS investment reserve has been transferred to scheme members, increasing annual pensions by around £29 per week. Last week the Chancellor announced that every penny of the surplus from the mineworkers pension scheme will remain in the scheme, sorry, will remain with the members rather than being split with the Government. And the standstill rule has been abolished. Those are important improvements, but as the Chancellor himself said last week, the job is not done. My dad suffers from emphysema, white finger, white fingers and damaged knee from years of working on the coal face.
And now also late-stage dementia. When I learned that a final settlement for MPS members would not be reached in this budget, I made it clear to ministers what this means. It means that there's a very real possibility that my dad will not live to see the justice that he deserves. And this is not unique to our family. Around 19 former miners die every single day.
That means that since the budget, 85 miners will already have passed away without seeing this issue resolved. Let us be clear, this is not government money. This is not taxpayers' money. This is the miners' money. Now, the Chancellor has committed to ensuring that the full transfer of the guarantors' fund will be returned, and I welcome that completely.
But we cannot wait any longer. We cannot wait until a new fiscal event. We must finish this job and we must do it now.
Speaker 344
And I'm sure honorable members will be delighted to know that I'm putting the time limit back up to 4 minutes. Manuela Perteghella.
Manuela Perteghella
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I welcome aspects of this breathing space budget. Additional investment in our in council housing, support for rough sleeping programs, some positive news on business rates, with action to revive our high streets are all steps in the right direction. But for many families and businesses in communities like those in my constituency, this budget does not go far enough to address the pressure they face every day, including the brutal cost of living.
People in Stratford-on-Avon worry about the future of their local high streets, about heating their homes this winter and about whether their favourite shop, pub, café or restaurant that give our towns their character will still be here next year. That is why I believe that this budget misses opportunities in a number of important areas. First, our small businesses and high streets: the independent businesses that make our towns unique and create jobs for local people are facing pressure from every direction. Under this Government, rising employment costs, energy costs, business rates and regulatory burdens are all taking their toll, and we are seeing empty units blight our streets up and down the country. We need stronger powers for councils to bring long-term vacant properties back into use, and more support for the independent businesses that give our towns their character.
Business rates discounts will help some, but many will be left in the cold. Hospitality is of particular importance for Stratford-on-Avon;
One in nine constituents are employed in this sector. This is why I'm disappointed that the Government did not go further on VAT for hospitality. A temporary reduction in VAT would have provided immediate help to businesses, while helping consumers who are also feeling the squeeze. And businesses in my constituency tell me a VAT reduction for hospitality would have allowed them to keep the lights on after the busy Christmas period. I also wish to raise fuel poverty.
The £100 payment is welcome, however we know from the Resolution Foundation that 1.4 million low-income households are in higher council tax bands, and they will miss out on this untargeted payment.
So will the minister look at this cohort urgently so they do not fall through the cracks? And while I'm here, council tax is a deeply unfair tax, we know it, the minister knows it needs change. Many households remain vulnerable to high energy costs, which is why I am concerned about the reduction in funding for the warm homes plan. Investing in warmer homes cuts bills and reduces carbon emissions, it's the one of the smartest investment any government can make, particularly for families and older residents already struggling with the cost of living. The budget and the government's wider plan place considerable emphasis on devolution.
Warwickshire is a long way away from a mayor.
People in my constituency want local services that are responsive and rooted in the places they serve. Any reorganisation or devolution must strengthen local democracy and local voices, because whether we are talking about high streets, fuel poverty, housing or hospitality, the people closest to those challenges are often the people best placed to solve them. For my constituents in Stratford-on-Avon, this budget does not go far enough to support small businesses, tackle fuel poverty and help communities thrive.
Margaret Rachel Taylor
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This budget puts families and businesses at its heart, providing breathing space with the cost of living today while giving people fresh hope for the future.
Now, I am also proud to be the granddaughter of a coal miner, and this Government has done so much already to right historic injustices in the mineworkers' pension scheme. I welcome the commitment to end the surplus sharing arrangement and standstill mechanism, but this only rights part of that injustice. Since 1994, successive Governments have taken more than 4.4 billion from the scheme in return for a guarantee that has cost the public purse nothing. It cannot be right that the remaining 1.2 billion in the guarantor fund has still not been released to benefit former miners and their widows. For many, time is running out, and I ask again, as I have before, that the Chancellor looks at this to deliver justice for mineworkers across the country.
I particularly welcome the measures to tackle rising energy bills, though.
With conflicts overseas pushing up prices at home, families are understandably worried about how much it costs to heat their homes. That's why the £100 household energy payment is so important. In North Warwickshire and Bedworth, around 37,920 properties will benefit. In a constituency like mine, driving is not a luxury. For so many people, it's the only reliable option to get to work, take their children to school and go about their daily lives.
It's why my parents made me learn to drive as soon as I turned 17. I made sure residents' concerns were heard about fuel costs, and I'm delighted the Chancellor has listened, extending the 5p fuel duty cut until July 2027.
For a family already struggling to make ends meet, every extra pound at the pump matters. And the impact of fuel duty goes beyond families filling up their cars, it affects the lorry drivers delivering food to our supermarkets, the businesses transporting goods across the country, and ultimately the prices we all pay at the checkout. Now, before coming to Parliament, I spent 20 years working as a property solicitor in a high street firm in my constituency. One of the things I loved most about that job was helping first-time buyers. I remember the happiness of seeing young people come through my door, proud of the amount they'd saved for their deposit.
They'd tell me about their plans for the future. These were people putting down roots in our communities, and there was nothing quite like the moment they finally collected their keys. But the longer I did that job, the fewer first-time buyers came through my door.
I watched as owning a home became increasingly out of reach for young people, particularly those who didn't have the bank of mum and dad to fall back on. That's not the future I want for the next generation in North Warwickshire and Bedworth, and that's why I'm delighted that the Chancellor has announced the new £4.7 billion Your First Home scheme, which is expected to help around 70,000 first-time buyers onto the property ladder. This budget is taking action on the very issues my constituents have raised with me: the cost of heating their homes, filling up their cars, supporting the industries they work in, and helping their children and grandchildren onto the housing ladder. It's a budget that gives families breathing space today, supports the businesses and workers who keep our country moving, and offers young people fresh hope for the future.
Gagan Mohindra
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. Can I firstly thank Nick Coombes from my office for his help in this speech. Unsurprisingly, I'm disappointed by the Chancellor's first budget for a new administration that spent a by-election and leadership campaign claiming they had all sorts of plans, excuse me, and ambitions to fix the economy after the previous Labour administration were constantly talking us down. We now have a do no harm budget that does decidedly little to help pensioners, fund our armed forces, support young people, nor to back the businesses who are essential to creating jobs.
The tax burden is continuing to rise above record levels. Inflation has not been at the 2% target since before the budget of this Labour government, and the welfare bill is set to go up by another £60 billion, with neither the Prime Minister nor the Chancellor willing to commit to reducing even that in this Parliament.
As the Leader of the Opposition said, we are now spending more on debt interest than on the army and schools combined, which is clearly wrong, especially at a time when we face some of the biggest and most rapidly evolving threats since the Cold War. And yet, the Chancellor, who resigned as Defence Secretary over the refusal of the previous administration to increase defence spending to 3% of GDP, has now delivered a budget that has deferred the difficult choices necessary to keep our country safe until next year, in favour of the Prime Minister's plan to prioritise social security over national security. Young people are already struggling for support to get into education, employment, or training.
The increases in employer National Insurance contributions and now the further increase in minimum wage will make young people even more expensive for small businesses to hire, while pushing more and more workers into higher tax brackets. This was the Chancellor's first opportunity to take bold steps to correct the errors of previous Labour budgets, and provide support for businesses and entrepreneurs, which would have been a noticeable break from the massive tax hikes and regulatory burdens that have continued to fall on businesses under this Government so far. The Prime Minister and the Chancellor needed to use this opportunity to take drastic action to slash the size of the state and get Britain working again, to support those who are working, and encourage those who are not working to be able to do so, and get into work. My constituents are happy to support those in genuine need,
But every year, this Labour Government is coming back for more money from the same hardworking people they promised not to raise taxes on, to fund an ever-increasing welfare state. This "do no harm" Budget has led to the OBR forecasts on inflation, economic growth, unemployment, living standards all worsen, and has left my constituents disappointed. I hope, in conclusion, I hope that the Prime Minister's 10-year plan and the upcoming spending review has some good well well-needed good news and serious economic support for businesses and young people in South West Hertfordshire.
Euan Stainbank.
Euan Stainbank
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Firstly, in my speech, I want to rebut some of the nonsense we heard from the SNP earlier. The budget is going up by 600 million because the choices made in this Budget for Scotland's public services, or up by 1.8 billion since Labour came into office. And this 650 million cut is inadvertently misleading this House, and I may say something outside the House which is a wee bit ruder.
This budget abolishes standing charges. It abolishes VAT on electricity bills and gives a £100 to 1.8 million Scottish households between band A and band D if we get it confirmed that the SNP choose to hand it over in that way. The price in the pumps that our constituents have complained about have been directly funded by the US and Israel's current war in Iran, but we have made a choice to freeze fuel duty, which I welcome, and maintain the 5p fuel duty cut till June, alongside a red diesel duty cut which would be welcome to many sectors who are eligible, especially agriculture. For working people in Falkirk, the permanent increase to tax-free mileage should help traders working from their own vans in my constituency, and I will also welcome the training allowance has been tripled to 3,000. This budget also supports pensioners, rightly, for the many pensioners in my constituency who live on simply the state pension.
This budget also so- supports pensioners rightly, for the many pensioners in my constituency who live on simply the state pension, as it has risen, too many have ended up with the administrative irritation of paying small amounts of income tax, with the paperwork and worry that brings, and especially for those in the lowest income. I welcome the new pension tax allowance from April 27 in this budget addresses that directly and that pensioners whose only, sole income is no more than the full state pension will not be paying income tax. To deliver good growth in every in my postcode, we, as I said last week, it is vital that we invest in the Grangemouth industrial complex. I welcome the BICS scheme and the backdating to 2026, but as other colleagues have said, I do think, whilst acknowledging the height and cost of extending it to every manufacturing business, I believe about 3.5 billion, I do believe we should look at extending it, especially for manufacturing businesses who are reliant on gas and whose decarbonisation timescales are not as quick as we may like.
I also welcome the restatement of the government's intent to include refined products in the carbon border adjustment mechanism. It will be a vital tool in connecting the unlevel playing field that undermined domestic refining, the same unlevel playing field that led to the closure of Grangemouth because it was not dealt with over multiple years. A cross-party group wrote to the Treasury regarding this, and I do think it is important that we put a deadline on when we're going to be introducing this because this positive signal does need to be translated into real protection for our existing refining sector, as well as the biorefining sector that the Prime Minister rightly believes has huge potential to deliver for Grangemouth.
Now to turn to the point about Project Acorn, I agree with the principle of getting better value money for taxpayers across government capital plans so that we can free up money for defence, and I do agree that should include energy projects in our constituency. And some of the rhetoric that we have heard from the SNP and their ministers on this has been downright reckless and self-defeating on actually supporting the project. However, I hope the minister can acknowledge that much of the reasonable scrutiny and on this has not been met with the clearest of answers. Therefore, I'd like to hear confirmation the new route for previously committed funding has the support of all currently existing and committed commercial partners, confirmation on the amount of funding that's been committed already that is not being changed, why funding has been changed for Acorn, but not for other CCUS projects such as Viking in Humberside, and more broadly, what changes will mean for the practice of re-industrialisation in communities such as Grangemouth who are supposed to benefit from this infrastructure, especially considering they do not yet have, let's say, a fantastic experience with the debt equity model of the National Wealth Fund. This budget does create breathing space for families in Falkirk worried about the end of the month, and for people and for the poorest pensioners dreading a tax letter.
It lifts some of the pressure.
This government has shown in this budget it will act for working people, pensioners, and industry. I would ask ministers to turn that breathing space into future certainty, particularly for the industry that can define the next 50 years positively with new jobs as it has done in the last 50.
John Milne
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. This budget has around 100 separate measures, but most would never have featured in previous Chancellors' budgets, not because of any particular policy difference, but because they're just too small. Less 'steady as she goes', more 'let's see, let this grind to a complete halt'. As far as taxation goes, by far the biggest impact comes from a policy that wasn't even mentioned, and that is the continued freeze on personal tax thresholds.
This year alone, it means another half million people will start paying tax for the first time, and a further half million will be pushed into a higher tax bracket, all a function of that handy Chancellor's trick, fiscal drag. Understandably, conservative opposition gives the government an easy ride on this, as it was their idea in the first place. Now, when it comes to welfare, the critical Milburn review and Timms review have both been conveniently kicked down round to the other side of the budget. But here, the issues we face are not what people think. It's been said so many times that everyone assumes it must be true that millions of people are getting PIP or UC health awards for mild anxiety.
The appeal of this story is that we can slash social support for vulnerable people and actually feel morally good about it. Unfortunately, it's just not true.
In reality, absolutely no one gets PIP for mild anxiety or severe anxiety, or any form of mental health condition. That's because PIP isn't awarded according to your condition. Rather, applicants are assessed according to their daily abilities or lack of them, whether they can wash themselves, cook for themselves, or manage short distances walking. There isn't even a category for mild anxiety.
I find it incredible that politicians, including members who are the actual spokesperson people for their parties on welfare, can continue to ask for something which they must know by now is not possible. What chance have we got of making smart reforms of the economy if politicians can't even get the basic facts straight?
So, while we continue to wait for all the missing parts of this budget over the coming weeks and months, I would urge caution. Welfare cuts are just a right-wing version of the magic money tree. As a proportion of GDP today as a proportion of GDP, today's spend on non-pension welfare is roughly the same as it was in the mid-80s when a certain Margaret Thatcher was Prime Minister. And at that time, the defence budget was twice what it is today. So, clearly, the current level of welfare spend is perfectly compatible with meeting our defence targets.
And welfare isn't the reason that our defence budget is in such trouble. The peace dividend didn't go to UC and PIP, it went to the NHS and pensions.
Above all, this is a challenge caused by a general decline in the economy, not welfare. Yes, it's always important to control welfare spend, and I support that. But slashing welfare on the basis of an arbitrary financial target invented simply so it's enough to pay for some dramatic manifesto pledge is not a credible path to anything. So to conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, what we have is a budget that doesn't seek to do anything very much about anything. The real battles have yet to come.
Joshua Fenton-Glynn
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. For my constituency of Calder Valley and across the country, life is hard and it hasn't shown signs of getting easier.
The last government was the first in decades to preside over a fall in the standard of living, and with Trump's war in the Middle East, things are unlikely to get better as quickly as we'd like to see it. That's why I welcome support being provided to households facing higher energy costs. For many families, an extra £100 will not transform their circumstances overnight, and no one is pretending otherwise, but every pound matters and this support matters, too. In Calderdale, almost nine out of 10 houses are expected to be eligible for the £100 household energy payment. That means the overwhelming majority of my Calder Valley constituencies will receive direct support this winter.
For many people, the support will ease some of the pressures on their household budgets at exactly the moment they need it the most. I welcome the expansion of the Warm Home Discount, too.
By widening the eligibility, the government has almost doubled the number of households in the scheme to 6 million families. That means millions more families receiving £150 off their energy bills this winter. Too often, those on the lowest incomes faced what is known as the poverty premium, made famous by Terry Pratchett with his Captain Vimes' boots theory of economics. The less money you have, the more things cost. We see it in our insurance costs, we see it in the cost of credit, and importantly, we see it in the cost of fuel.
That's why it'll make a difference to end standing charges. It means that those who use less energy will pay less. Helping those households is not simply about fairness, it's also good economics.
The money from these measures will not sit unused, it won't be stored in the Cayman Islands thousands of miles away, it will be spent in local communities, on local high streets, helping local people. People will pay bills with it, they'll buy essentials, they'll support local businesses, and they will contribute to their high streets. The same principle applies to our businesses across Calder Valley. Business owners are ambitious to innovate, they're determined to succeed, and they want it to be easier to invest, grow, and create jobs. And whether it's energy costs, red tape, or being locked out of government contracts, for many, their main concern's been staying afloat, not growing or taking on new people.
And that's why I welcome some of the changes to business rates announced in this budget.
Rising the thresholds for small business rate relief for retail, hospitality and leisure from 12,000 to 18,000 means that 70,000 additional businesses will pay no business rates at all. And in Calder Valley, that will make a huge difference to our collection of independent shops, cafes and pubs. Speaking of the pubs, I'm proud to see support for Britain's small independent breweries. Calder Valley is home to fantastic independent breweries including Eagles Crag and Vocation, ones that I'm proud to have made a significant contribution to over the years. But finding room to grow hasn't been easy and the support announced in this budget will be welcome across the brewing sector.
While some budgets look worse as time goes on, the famous omnishambles and Liz Truss budget being one of those, this is one that will look better. The help for small businesses, the support for households. This budget backs working people. This budget backs British industry.
It backs communities in Calder Valley, and I'm proud to back it.
Bobby Moore.
Robbie Moore
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Chancellor's big phrase in this budget has been "breathing space". It has been said time and time again. But it's utterly false, because the Chancellor hasn't given businesses any breathing space at all. There is no breathing space on employers' national insurance.
Labour's jobs tax stays exactly where it is, punishing employers for yet another year. No breathing space on wages. The national living wage has actually gone up by 3.9% from April, on top of the Employment Rights Act, with nothing announced to help employers meet the cost. Even the OBR itself warns that these policies will seriously damage job creation in this country.
And there has been no breathing space on business rates, no real breathing space. The Chancellor says that he is freezing business rates for retail, hospitality and leisure in real terms, but yet the British Retail Consortium has quite rightly pointed out that this is just all smoke and mirrors. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is not breathing space at all. This is our businesses being stifled yet again by this Labour Government. And I ask the Minister, what are their ambitions for British businesses?
Because it seems evidently clear from this Budget that they don't have any. They are taxing our British businesses again and again.
And this all matters Madam Deputy Speaker because it is impacting people in my constituency across Keighley and Ilkley. It is full of hard-working people and I think of those independent shops on Cavendish Street and Low Street fighting to keep Keighley a thriving place, the cafes, boutiques and family businesses on the Grove and Brook Street in Ilkley and those businesses right across Silsden, Steeton and Riddlesden and our wider area who are working incredibly hard. The pubs, the trade tradespeople, the hairdressers, the start-ups, all of which are hard-working people. Yet, this Government thinks that employers of those small, independent businesses are not workers Madam Deputy Speaker. They put out that narrative as if they need more tax.
And let me tell you about one of those businesses that I met just yesterday, The Turkey Inn in Goose Eye, a much-loved local pub by visitors alike. I called in there last night to have a meal with them.
The owners of this pub, Madam Deputy Speaker, are grafters. They produce excellent food, second to none. They support our local community with many local activities. They do everything right, working day in, day out to support the community. But yesterday, on the back of this Budget, they announced that they are cutting their opening hours from seven days a week to just four.
And they were clear about why. In their own words, they said, "With no measures in this Budget to help small hospitality businesses and local pubs like ours, we must take this step." That is the verdict, Madam Deputy Speaker, not of a politician, not of a Labour think tank, but hardworking people in my constituency that have been impacted by now the third Labour Budget.
And the Turkey Inn are not alone. I speak to pubs and small independent businesses every single week in my constituency, and they are telling me the same thing. Labour is not on the side of our hardworking businesses, and it is impacting them. This Labour budget has not provided any breathing space at all. So this Government must wake up and listen to our small and medium-sized businesses who are the backbone of our communities, the backbone of our local economies, because they are pushing them to breaking point.
If they don't wake up and listen, I fear for all of them.
A simple tax policy of tax on our businesses with more regulation is stifling businesses, not helping them thrive.
Sureena Brackenridge
Madam Deputy Speaker, for most people in Wolverhampton and Willenhall, the real test of a budget is simple: does it make life a little easier? And I hear and absolutely understand the pressure of household bills, the cost of raising a family and the challenges facing our local businesses. That is why I will continue to take their concerns right here in Parliament and make sure that their voices are heard at every level of government at every opportunity that I get. Of course, everyone would like more giveaways in a budget, but many people also understand that the Government has a responsibility with the state of our public finances, and we've seen the consequences of getting that balance wrong.
The wider energy and cost of living support package during the 2022 energy crisis cost taxpayers around £51 billion net in one year alone. That required extraordinary borrowing, adding to our national debt and the interest payments that taxpayers, including future generations, will continue to carry.
This budget takes a very different approach to providing immediate support. Around 44,900 properties in Wolverhampton North East, almost 99%, are in council tax bands A to D, and that means a large number of local households will benefit from the £100 household energy payment from January, alongside the extension of 0% VAT on electricity expected to take around £50 off the annual Ofgem price cap. So, that means around £150 in combined support. Martin Lewis, the famous consumer champion, has highlighted that the £100 payment could broadly cover the forecast increase in energy costs for a typical household over the three winter months. And I'm also pleased to see the end of gas standing charges, especially for low gas usage households.
Importantly, the government is asking banks to contribute more and that helps pay for this support, rather than relying on borrowing. I particularly welcome the help for our high streets. Raising the small business rates relief threshold from £12,000 to £18,000 means many more independent shops, cafés, and restaurants will pay no business rates at all. For some owners, that could mean a saving of around £300 a month. Across the West Midlands, around 52% of retail, hospitality, and leisure properties will pay no business rates, and for qualifying businesses that still have a bill, there will be a real-terms freeze in the business rates multiplier.
Here in Wolverhampton North East, around 975 premises will benefit.
And I'm also pleased that 10 schools in Wolverhampton North East now have secured free breakfast club funding. That means more children starting the school day with a good breakfast, ready to learn, and parents having a little more help with the pressures of family life. People are still feeling the pressure, and no one pretends otherwise, but we have to be able to afford the support that we offer, and pay for it responsibly. There is more to do, and I will keep making that case here in Parliament.
Claire Louise Young
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. The Chancellor has called this a breathing-space budget, but it only seems to be a breathing space for the Government to put off the hard decisions. It's not a breathing space for my Thornbury and Yate constituents, with frozen tax and student loan repayment thresholds.
It's not a breathing space for my local businesses. The rise in employer national insurance contributions has not been reversed. There is no emergency VAT cut for hospitality to help our high streets. And on business rates, which I've repeatedly raised in this House, the budget just tinkers with a system that needs wholesale reform. It's not a breathing space for farmers: no change in the family farm tax.
The cut to fertiliser tariffs will make little difference when, as the NFU has pointed out, much already arrives tariff-free. I'm disappointed the budget does not treat food security as national security. It's not a breathing space for local transport users. In a budget that mentions the North repeatedly, the West barely gets a look-in.
South Gloucestershire is mentioned once, a brief reference to a mass transit system we've been hearing about for decades and is unlikely to touch our rural villages. A £1 bus fare cap and discounted rail fares would have helped families in the short term, and investment in rural transport would help them in the longer term. The west of England is a growth engine outside of London, it deserves more ambition than this. It's not a breathing space for energy bill payers. Suppliers forecast that the price cap will rise by around a quarter in January.
While welcome, the £100 for this winter and the promise of scrapping gas standing charges in the future does not touch the sides. Scrapping the standing charge will save people just £45 on average and only for those who actually use gas. One in five properties in Thornbury and Yate heat their home with oil.
They have no price cap at all, and there is nothing to make sure the removal of import tariffs on kerosene gets passed to consumers. The surest way to bring down bills is to insulate homes and move people off volatile oil and gas. So why is there a one billion pound cut in the Warm Homes Plan? And what of the promise of growth? When will we hear about plans for new nuclear at Oldbury?
The outcome of GBN's review was promised this autumn. If data centres that meet the new British Data Centre Covenant get priority grid connections, then given the problem with providing new grid connections, where is the grid capacity for new homes to meet the government's own housing targets?
And where is the investment in skills in the rural west of England, so that our local young people can access the technical jobs available? To conclude, this budget is a missed opportunity to provide a real breathing space for our constituents, our businesses and our economy.
Amanda Hack.
Amanda Hack
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and thank you for giving us breathing space with a little bit more time. It's a pleasure to be responding to this budget taking, talking about growth in every postcode. North West Leicestershire is a former mining area, so welcome, I welcome the progress made on the miners' pension. I welcome the confirmation that surplus sharing and the standstill will be abolished to protect bonus pensions, helping members benefit from the success of their pensions. No government has ever done more on pensions for former mineworkers than this one, but as the Chancellor said himself, the job is not finished.
It is clear that more work is needed to resolve the substantial undistributed guarantor fund surplus currently held within the MPS. The miners who powered our country and our homes, who supported us, deserve our support now, and I want to reassure my constituents in North West Leicestershire that I will do just that. Madam Deputy Speaker, North West Leicestershire is also home to one of three sites in the only inland freeport in the UK.
However, the site in Leicestershire has created considerable concern, which I share, particularly for Diseworth, an 825-year-old village with heritage status. So, whilst the new data centre covenant is helpful, I worry that this will only apply to AI and not the creation of the new megasheds, which more broadly impacts communities, such as mine. The other two sites in the Freeport are covered by the East Midlands Mayor, so I welcome the Chancellor's announcement on devolution and the settlement for Leicester, Leicestershire and Rutland, something I have long called for. And I look forward to continuing those discussions on how devolution will deliver greater benefits and strategic powers to make sure the Freeport site for Leicestershire has a mayor fighting their corner. The power offered to mayors on transport could be transformational for Leicestershire.
Transport connectivity is a significant barrier to growth locally. My constituent, Eli, spoke to me recently about the poor public transport had on their access to further education. They said, "I wake up before 6:00 in the morning to catch my 7:00 a.m. bus to college.
It's always packed, standing room only, and there's too many students for the capacity of public services. Even if I do get everything right, the bus is then unreliable, either being late or completely absent. It's treated by as my responsibility by my college." A lot is said about demand in rural areas. In fact, Arriva increased their patronage by 30% for one of my local routes because they started a bus earlier, connecting the route to another village and allowing more kids to get to college.
Just think about what we could achieve if we want to grow even further. North West Leicestershire still has no passenger rail service anywhere in my constituency, making us home to the two largest towns in the country without any access to rail, restricting growth and investment. If we want growth in every postcode, then transport has to be a priority.
Madam Deputy Speaker, North West Leicestershire has so much potential, including our SME sector. I know this will surprise you, but nearly 30 years ago, I wrote my dissertation on small business support, so I know how much we limit our own growth if we fail to invest in small businesses. I've always advocated for dedicated business support, just like we saw in the universal offer that we had from Business Link. Now what we have is a patchwork, which is now devolution-dependent, another reason why devolution for Leicestershire is so vitally important. And finally,
Of course.
Will you give way?
On that point.
Margaret Ruth Samantha Niblett
I thank the honorable member for giving way. We are neighbors and friends in our neck of the woods. I benefit from being part of a mayoralty that can have money devolved to my region, and she does not.
And so, does she agree with me that, as well as we work together now, it could be even better if we perhaps were part of the same pot of funding and same overall leadership?
Amanda Hack
I thank my honourable friend for making that incredibly important point. The East Midlands mayor doesn't cover the whole of the East Midlands, and I think this gives us an opportunity to continue to talk. Because I've got a little bit left, the Chancellor confirmed that the that land sold to social housing providers will now be VAT-free. After two decades working in the social housing sector, I cannot tell you the difference this will make to social homes and growth in our communities, but also, as a builder for growth, house building is massive step forward that helps the brick manufacturers in my constituency, and it has builders and local tradespeople to grow.
I think this is an important step forward that we shouldn't underestimate.
Jim Shannon.
Jim Shannon
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's a real pleasure to speak in this debate, and thank you for calling me. I wish to first of all welcome some of the good things that there are in the budget, because it's not all bad news, by the way. Well, but I'm going to put my thumb Don't put your thumb up just yet, you know, and I'm coming to the parts where I have some concerns,
and the concerns are real, the concerns are important, and the concerns are Northern Ireland-based.
First let us look at the I'm concerned for the squeezed families of Strangford, who look at this autumn budget and have little cause for celebration. First, let us look at the absolute uncertainty facing our local businesses community in Northern Ireland. We see standard small business rates relief being permanently expanded in England, yet there's no, zero, certainty that our small and medium-sized enterprises back home will see an equivalent benefit. Our highly capable SMEs, who form the bedrock of the Northern Irish economy, need ironclad guarantees, not vague hopes. The working middle class, they go to work, they pay their taxes, they try to build something for their children, and yet they're treated like a bottomless well of revenue by this Treasury. Take, for example, a hardworking family in my constituency of Strangford, the school teacher, the mid-level nurse.
They've managed to put away a modest amount of savings to help fund their children's university education.
They will get no help for their children's education and future, and yet will be forced to work on past retirement to ensure that their child has a chance at a future. And nowhere is that clearer, Madam Deputy Speaker, than in the cruel and punitive approach to family inheritance tax. Our agriculture sector in Northern Ireland is in a state of absolute panic. I've spoken with the Ulster Farmers' Union, they tell me that generations of family farms, the very lifeblood of our rural communities, are now halting investment decisions because of inheritance tax fears. Passing a family business or a family farm down to the next generation isn't a luxury,
it's a way of life, and this budget threatens to dismantle just that. And the Barnett consequential and the Barnett formula, but let us be entirely realistic, these Barnett consequentials are totally inadequate. And why is that the case?
Throwing a general lump sum at the Northern Ireland Executive and hoping it covers police, health and education is a failure of governance. We need an allocation method like the Welsh equivalent, not a funding that is not fit for purpose, and that has to be sorted out. We need a local genuine need, not a rigid, detached mathematical formula. And we've got to protect our middle-class, safeguard our family farms,
and give Northern Ireland the specific, targeted support it desperately needs. Our hard-working middle-class, they see absolutely no benefit for themselves, even less for their children. When a parent works 50 hours a week, Madam Deputy Speaker, pays their taxes, pays big taxes, plays by the rules and still cannot see a path to a better future or a stable inheritance for the next generation, that social contract is broken. If this Government continues to bleed the middle class dry to paper over the cracks of their own fiscal failures,
If this Government continues to bleed the middle class dry to paper over the cracks of their own fiscal failures, they will destroy the very aspiration that keeps this nation moving forward, this great United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. The Budget offers no security on defense, no reason to build a business, to work hard. It relies on the ethic of some to make up for the lack of ethic in too many, and Government must look closely at the people it punishes, because they need to breathe. And I don't believe that this Budget provides just that. Thank you very much.
David Edmund Burton-Sampson
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
And I want to start by thanking my right honourable friend, the Chancellor, for the measures he laid out in his budget last week and his focus on giving my constituents some breathing space as we navigate through tough global headwinds. And like him, I too want to pay tribute and offer my thanks to the former Chancellor, my right honourable friend for Leeds West and Pudsey, as it's clear through her work and clear focus on fiscal discipline she helped stabilize the economy despite significant headwinds and created the headroom to enable us to take the positive action we are in this budget. I'm lucky to have my office on Leigh Road in Leigh-on-Sea which is, along with Leigh Broadway, a thriving high street full of independent small shops and hospitality businesses like Tiny, a sandwich shop, or Juice Bay which does fantastic smoothies and juices, and Float On Records, all new businesses. It's great to see so many new businesses opening despite the challenges we are facing of late.
This shows me confidence in our economy and belief in our country. And it's not just Leigh: Mez, a delicious Turkish restaurant, which recently opened in Westcliff, and I can vouch for this as I had my dinner there on Saturday. However, I have listened to businesses in my constituency who tell me that sometimes things can be challenging. That's why I'm delighted by the Government's announcement that more retail, hospitality, and leisure businesses will be completely exempt from business rates. That means that around 52% of these type of businesses in the east of England will pay absolutely no business rates whatsoever.
That's help for businesses.
An additional 800, sorry, 484 businesses in my constituency will have their business rates frozen in real terms until 2029, giving business owners time to plan ahead whilst many others will see their business rates reduced. And when my constituents get back home from their days out shopping, they will know that they have support with paying their bills. In addition to extending the zero-rate of VAT on electricity, an enormous 39,520 households in my constituency will benefit from the £100 payment to combat rising energy costs. I know this will help so many people, from young families through to pensioners. And speaking of pensioners, I want to welcome the excellent news that pensioners on low incomes will not have to pay income tax on their state pension.
And I'm so glad to hear the announcement that pensioners who rely solely on the state pension income will get to keep all of it. The budget also provides the security that pensions will continue to rise in line with earnings, while the adjusted triple lock will mean we can focus on providing a high-quality national care service. Finally, I was really glad to hear that self-employed fathers and partners will now get statutory paternity pay. This is something I've personally championed alongside many colleagues, and I want to pay a particular tribute to my honorable friend, the member for Portsmouth North, for her work in this area in championing this cause.
This budget shows the government is listening to people in my constituency, and it's taking action to fix the issues they have raised. The constituency The constituents I spoke to at the weekend know just how difficult the times are that we are in and that we face, and they're grateful for everything this government is doing to support them. Thank you.
Paul Kohler.
Paul Kohler
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I refer members to my entry in the Register of Interests. This country faces fundamental problems. Faces at the top may have changed, but once again, Labour has shown itself incapable of making the tough calls. This morning, I hosted a post-budget roundtable to meet local employers in my constituency.
I regret to report the business community in Wimbledon shares my concerns about this short-term, lackluster budget. By kicking the can down the road, this mañana budget has failed the businesses that are critical to growing the economy.
Rather than providing business with a breathing space, the Chancellor has left many of them drowning with crippling taxes and excessive regulation. Raising the business rates relief threshold to £18,000 is of course welcome, but high streets across my constituency in Wimbledon, Raynes Park, New Malden and Morden will see little benefit. Craig Hurring, the CEO of Love Wimbledon informed me today this change will benefit an estimated 1% of the businesses in his BID, whilst other changes in the pipeline are making matters worse.
A company who manages fantastic serviced office space for new businesses in Wimbledon tell me new restrictions on business rate relief mean they will have to increase rents by up to 25%, a huge cost for start-ups. Business rates are crippling my local businesses.
Gina Conway runs an award-winning hair and beauty salon in Wimbledon. She employs 38 people and trains up to 20 apprentices every year. But Gina tells me pressure for most salon owners is too much to bear, the long shadow of COVID, soaring energy bills, VAT and crippling business rates are killing High Street businesses. I was honored to be present for the excellent maiden speech from the member of Holborn and St Pancras.
I own a bar in her constituency in Covent Garden, so the member feels a bit like my MP. It also, and I will invite her one day to it. It also means I know first hand how the night-time economy is suffering.
Since 2020, the UK has lost almost three in 10 late-night venues, and across the sector, we continue to lose the equivalent of 13 businesses every week. The changes for self-assessment taxpayers are just as worrying. The Chancellor said he would champion the small British firms that give character to our communities. Instead, 2029 risks becoming a brutal cash crunch, with 18 months of tax squeezed into 12. Increasing the tax on rental income is also misguided.
As the OBR has outlined, this will inevitably result in fewer homes to rent and higher rents. I fear the new Prime Minister is repeating his predecessor's mistakes. His only plan is to have a plan, as the budget makes no substantive progress addressing welfare spending, social care, or defence readiness. The only glimmer of hope is the Prime Minister's recent comments on Europe.
Yet even here, my constituents in Wimbledon still do not know what he really intends. According to Goldman Sachs, a close relationship with the EU could boost our economy by at least 60 billion pounds per year. So the PM must be bold. He must tear up his predecessor's red lines, seek unfettered access to the world's largest market, and let British business realize its full potential. Thank you.
Josh Newbury.
Josh Newbury
Thank you very much, Madam Deputy Speaker. In this third day of the budget debate, you worry about repeating what has already been said, so I will focus on two issues of particular importance to my communities in Cannock Chase. But briefly before those, I want to first welcome the cost of living support in this budget: £100 back on council tax, VAT kept off electricity bills for longer, standing charges taken off gas, and the continuation of the fuel duty freeze.
These measures won't solve every financial pressure, but they will provide welcome relief at a time when it is needed most. Now, turning to my beautiful home county of Staffordshire, which will, thanks to this Government, soon be able to catch up with the likes of Derbyshire and Nottinghamshire with the announcement of a Mayoral Strategic Authority. This is a massive opportunity, particularly for our towns, which as my honourable friend, the Member for Stafford always says, must be at the heart of that national growth and renewal that this Government stands for. Our big cities have done well, but it's the turn of the towns. And having those powers and funding that comes with devolution gives us the tools that we need to turn our potential into reality.
Perhaps surprisingly to many, our towns have on average more than twice the proportion of their workforce employed in manufacturing as our cities, at around 9% compared with 4%.
Yet employment growth over the last decade has been almost twice as high in cities, at 10.7%, compared with just 5.4% in our towns. We can't seriously talk about rebalancing our economy whilst allowing that gap to persist. But that requires investment and crucially proper transport connections. For too many people, particularly young people, and those without access to a car, getting to work, college, or an apprenticeship remains unnecessarily difficult. And that's where devolution matters, because a mayoral authority with meaningful powers over transport, skills, and economic development gives Staffordshire the opportunity to join those things up and be the masters of our own destiny.
I hope it will also bring some much-needed stability to our county's leadership. Since last May, Staffordshire County Council has had not one, not two, not three, but four leaders courtesy of the chaos of Reform UK.
Staffordshire needs a little less political musical chairs and a lot more long-term focus on the priorities of our communities. Turning to the second issue, the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme, as the proud representative of nearly 1,000 MPS members, I will always raise my voice in support of those who risked their lives to power our nation. Alongside them and my fellow coalfield Labour MPs, we press the government to release the £1.2 billion Guarantor's Fund, end the standstill mechanism and make sure all future surpluses go to those who earned that money in the first place. The MPS Investment Reserve was returned to members by this Labour Government two years ago and the Chancellor's decision in this budget to end surplus sharing and the standstill are major steps forward. However, we are deeply disappointed that the budget didn't include the transfer of the Guarantor's Fund, a measure that would have put money back into the pockets of our retired miners.
There was a clear expectation that this was going to be done, finally righting the wrongs of the last 32 years. I welcome the Chancellor saying at that despatch box that this will be done. But we must never forget that this money came from the graft of our miners. It's their deferred wages and it belongs in their bank accounts. With 100 MPS members passing away each and every week, we must move as quickly as possible, and we certainly cannot wait for next year's budget.
Madam Deputy Speaker, this budget brought forward support with the cost of living, and it's allowing Staffordshire to take control of its own destiny. I wish it had sealed full justice for our MPS members, but we are so close now to ending their fight, and they can count me as an ally right until the very end. Thank you.
Johanna Baxter.
Johanna Baxter
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
The cost of living is the number one issue that's raised with me on the doorsteps by constituents across Paisley and Renfrewshire South. So there is much to welcome in this budget which gives much-needed breathing space for many working households. The increase to the national minimum wage is not something that we on these benches think is a bad thing. It's a good thing. The increase to the mileage rate which will help working people, and I'm glad the Chancellor has extended the VAT cut on energy bills and will look to abolish gas standing charges.
I also welcome the £100 household energy payment for households in council tax bands A to D, and I'm hopeful that the SNP will pass this on to constituents across my constituency.
Will the honourable friend give way?
I'll happily give way.
Euan Stainbank
I thank my honourable friend for giving way. Does she also call on the SNP to extend the business rates relief that our Labour government have provided, especially considering they've maintained a stricter system for high streets, such as in Paisley and Falkirk, historically?
Johanna Baxter
I thank my honourable friend for his intervention and I absolutely agree that they should pass on this much-needed change. I also note that the budget provides an additional £600 million for the Scottish Government and hope that they will actually spend it improving our public services. Today's debate focuses on achieving good growth in every postcode, an ambition I wholeheartedly support. One route to growth in postcodes PA1, PA2, PA3, PA4, I could go on, but you get my drift, is by revitalising our High Street in Paisley.
Paisley is Scotland's largest town. We have a shovel ready project in the middle of our high street. It received planning permission four years ago and it is regenerating the Paisley Centre. It needs governments to come together to realise that ambition, but it could bring 330 jobs to our area and breathe life into our high street. So, if colleagues in the Treasury would like to see that potential for themselves, I'm very happy to show them round the area.
Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, our government was elected with a clear manifesto commitment to ending the need for emergency food parcels.
As chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Ending the Need for Food Banks, I know that they provide a lifeline whilst people have nowhere else to turn. But emergency food provision should never become a normal part of life in Britain. A report published last week by the Trussell Trust laid out the scale of the challenge. 9 million people across the UK, that's more than the entire populations of Wales and Scotland combined, are at severe risk of hardship and needing to turn to a food bank. Hardship does not happen in isolation.
It's driven by inadequate incomes, high costs of essentials, and a lack of support people need in their communities. We also know that some groups of people are at higher risk of hunger and hardship than others.
People who have disabilities, are in low-paid or insecure work, and children remain disproportionately affected by severe hardship. So I hope that my honourable friend, the Chancellor, will reaffirm this Government's commitment to ending the need for emergency food parcels and ensure that the upcoming 10-year plan sets out a clear path towards tackling the severe hardship that blights our communities. Now, the Government is rightly steadfast in our support for Ukraine. This House will be aware that I have campaigned extensively on the issue of the forced deportation of Ukrainian children by Russia.
It was a pleasure to work with my honourable with the honourable member for Cardiff South and Penarth when he was the minister for that issue. We worked on establishing a tracing pilot providing vital intelligence on the whereabouts of thousands of the Ukrainian children who have who had been taken by Russia. When I met with Save Ukraine in September, Save Ukraine are the leading NGO working on the return and rehabilitation of Ukrainian children, they told me that the UK has been a leading partner on the practical support, which, as of this morning, has helped them return 1,887 children. So I therefore warmly welcome the announcement in the budget that the Government has committed an additional £3 million to support the tracing programme until at least 2028. Because the defence of Ukraine must also ensure the defence of its future, and by committing to this vital work, we are doing just that.
So, I thank the Chancellor for those measures.
Jayne Susannah Kirkham
Thank you Madam Deputy Speaker. This Labour government is helping families in Cornwall with their energy and their fuel bills. Nearly 37 and a half thousand households in Truro and Falmouth will get a hundred pound directly into their bank accounts. The drop in VAT and standing charges going will also really help. And in a rural and coastal constituency, where a car is not a luxury, that extension of the 5p fuel duty cut will help, as will the extension of the red diesel cut for our farmers, and the rise in those travel rates.
We're also tackling the specific challenges facing rural, off-grid communities.
14% of Cornish households rely on heating oil, including 5,000 families in Truro and Falmouth, which is a lot above the national average. Suspending those tariffs alongside over 50 million of support for low-income households heating with oil will make a real difference to those homes, as will regulating the market. And by pairing that short-term relief with the warm homes plan, this Government's helping rural families move towards cleaner, cheaper heating on their own terms. I've been working with DESNZ on a medium-term solution to license HVO for use in heating. It's been trialled in Kehelland village in Cornwall with great success, and I hope to engage further with DESNZ to get that rolled out further.
On devolution, Cornwall will be designated a single strategic authority, hopefully bringing growth funding and further devolution, on top of the 30 million Kernow Industrial Growth Fund that was announced last year. A delivery plan will now be worked up and I look forward to seeing further devolution of powers to unlock housing, skills, and economic growth. Truro and Falmouth enjoys a vibrant local tourist economy, independent shops, bakeries, cafes, and pubs. Raising that small business rate relief to 18,000 means about 56% of retail, hospitality, and leisure properties in the South West will pay no business rates at all. Together with that real-terms business rates freeze, it will benefit six and a half thousand hospitality, retail, and leisure properties in Cornwall.
Crucially, for Truro and Falmouth, the right to buy community assets scheme, support for co-ops, and high street rental auctions will give local people the tools to take back vacant units and bring empty shops back into use.
I would like to see those powers rolled out to our town and city councils. The unitary authority has limited resources, and our town councils have grown to fill that gap. They are very capable and they could run those schemes in the absence of appetite from the unitary, and they know their high streets far better. We have about many towns of approximately 20,000 people, each with an expanded town council. In Cornwall, only 11% of our housing is social housing, against a national average of 18%.
And we have 26,000 houses, households on the social housing waiting list. That's why I'm well welcoming extending preferential borrowing rates for councils, but Cornwall's housing revenue account is struggling to put more investment into repairs, and rents are low in Cornwall.
Rent convergence here will take time. That means the HRA have had to reduce the annual amount of funds available for new homes. One of the barriers is that £90 million debt as a result of the self-financing arrangements dating back to 2012. If that debt was reduced, Cornwall could do more, and HRA and debt reform would allow council houses to be built once again in Cornwall. There are root causes for our housing crisis in Truro and Falmouth.
We have many holiday lets, which are a good thing for Cornwall, but I welcome the government's plans for registration system, but we need to go further to look at licensing as well to check that insurance and fire safety documents are seen and local authorities can inspect properties.
Tom Collins.
Tom Collins
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know that people in Worcester will be looking for two things. Firstly, some let up in the endless pressure on bills and a public services that keep on letting us down. And secondly, a genuine sense that there is a plan for things to improve, hope. I want to start by recognising that these two aims have been front and centre as the Chancellor and the Prime Minister have developed this budget.
I believe in politics that is focused on people, and I believe that this budget aims to do that. But we also know that the challenges we are facing require a deeper shift, not just adjustments to budgets, but something far more fundamental, an approach that recognises people's real lived experiences and puts them at the heart of our decisions and systems.
Madam Deputy Speaker, digital technology is reshaping our world. We need a fresh approach to digital safety. The Chancellor is right that we should build the data centers and AI models that keep us secure, but we should also be insisting on safety by design for AI and online social platforms, and holding providers responsible. And we also need an answer that matches the desperate urgency of the climate crisis. This budget starts to recognize gaps in energy policy, but it also risks creating new ones.
It is right to recognize the importance of gas, but by casting hydrogen projects into further delay and insecurity, we risk our energy future altogether.
The government has accepted new gas extraction in the North Sea at Jackdaw. It is concerning to see that it is hesitating on support for the most powerful technology in decarbonizing gas at the same time. I was watching David Attenborough before it was cool. My career has been spent developing green technology systems, so-- Thank you.
I urge the Secretary of State to work rapidly to resource, accelerate and provide certainty to the core hydrogen projects that the UK needs for reindustrialization and for a viable energy future. We are competing with other countries for investment, and we are at risk of losing. If we get it right, though, the UK cannot only be more energy resilient, we can even become energy rich, true renewal that will see the UK selling to Europe and the world. There are other challenges across our system.
Worcester's crisis in A&E is stark evidence of that. I recently hosted Worcester's rough sleeping summit, bringing 30 organizations together to end rough sleeping in Worcester, and it will create new forms of joint working. But we need that kind of approach across the board, in health, social care, education, skills, and justice, alongside the ambitious funding and goal setting announced by the Chancellor. So I welcome the government providing £163 million in this budget to write off 90% of Worcestershire County Council's accumulated debt to tackle provision for children with special educational needs and disabilities. This creates the breathing room that we need to recover delivery in Worcester, but I am determined to work to see this system deeply reformed in our county to put families at the center.
I would urge the Chancellor to work with the Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero and members of industry to urgently address the shortfall in funding for hydrogen projects. But Madam Deputy Speaker, with these corrections secured and with ambitious action, I believe we have the opportunity not only to create room to breathe, but to begin a journey that will give every single person real cause to hope again.
Simon Opher.
Joseph Simon Opher
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. And at the close of the third day of debate on this budget, I won't go into all the detail that I might perhaps have done, I'll just concentrate on support for our high streets and about the transfer of power away from Westminster and Whitehall. So over the weekend, I had the opportunity to go into our high street and talk to some business owners. I talked to Tom Berry, who owns probably the coolest record shop in Stroud, Sound Records.
His business rates have reduced from 400 quid a month to nothing. And so many businesses actually have lost all their business rates, because of the small business rate relief threshold. And this means quite a number of pubs also now pay no business rates. For other properties over 18,000, there will be a two-year real-term rates freeze, providing much-needed stability during a time of great global economic uncertainty. And I was also absolutely delighted because the small producers relief in alcohol duty systems became more generous so that Stroud Brewery, and particularly my village brewery, Uley Brewery, have benefited.
And in fact, their famous pint of Old Spot ale will soon be available in the Strangers' Bar, so I'd like you to do that.
I'd also like to say a little bit of something around pubs and about VAT. So this wasn't in the budget, but we are looking at perhaps trying to reduce VAT on hospitality and rather a blanket cut to 10% would cost 12 billion pounds and benefit organisations like McDonald's, but in fact, if we can have a targeted approach, this will really help pubs. So on devolution, I strongly welcome this government's intention to shift power out of Westminster, Whitehall.
In fact, we've got the most one of the most centralized countries in the world with over 95% of tax revenues going to central government. However, in Gloucestershire, we haven't got a devolution deal at the moment and I would ask all parties involved to form a consensus so we can benefit from devolution. It's one of the best things this budget delivered. So, very briefly, 98 measures to help with the cost of living. There's also £65 million in there for a community asset program, which will help community buyouts.
And a little hidden thing in there is probably the most important thing in this budget, this is prevention is ring-fenced and that will be transformative for preventative therapies, particularly in health and in other measures. So, I really welcome this budget and I thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, for including me.
Speaker 367
Which brings us to frontbench contribution. Shadow Minister Gareth Davies.
Gareth Davies
It's a great pleasure.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I'd like to thank all members from across the House for their contributions tonight, but in particular, my right honourable and honourable friends for Bromsgrove, Bridgwater, Keighley and Ilkley, Mid Bedfordshire, South West Hertfordshire, and the very thoughtful contributions, particularly on welfare spending, from my right honourable friend for Chingford and Woodford Green and my very good friend and constituency neighbour, the Father of the House. I particularly enjoyed his contribution. But most of all, let me congratulate the honourable lady for Holborn and St Pancras on delivering her maiden speech. I gave my maiden speech in a budget debate, it is a hard thing to do.
I was I still remember how nervous I was and I can tell her it doesn't quite go away, I'm afraid. But I enjoyed her speech, it was an excellent one and I know that her constituents and her family will be very proud to see her sat where she is.
I wish her the very best for the future. It is a genuine pleasure to be stood here closing this budget debate on behalf of the official opposition, a budget that has been billed as the breathing-space budget, ironically by the same people who have taken all the air out of the economy. The British people don't just want a breather. They want to get on and there is little in this budget for them.
Now, the subject of today's debate is growth, a subject apparently voluntarily chosen by the Government, which is interesting, because if you actually read the OBR's assessment of this Budget, it clearly says, on paragraph 2.48, that the next year's growth is downgraded to 1%, cut by a third. The Chancellor said this Budget would deliver growth in every postcode, but the OBR has read it and found that low growth is going to be across the country. I've got to know the honourable gentleman who is chuntering slightly here, and I know that he's about to stand up, and he's going to try and say that the OBR has upgraded growth for this year by 0.1%.
And don't get me wrong, that is great, I'm delighted for him. But in March 2024, the OBR expected growth under a Conservative Government not to be 1.2% this year;
they expected the Conservatives to deliver 2% in 2026. So, actually, I'm afraid to say, the OBR have downgraded their growth expectations and projections for this year too. Now, the right honourable lady who's very energised, is saying that the government has cut business rates. But these are the guys who inherited High Street relief at 75%, cut it to 40%, then abolished it altogether.
Now, under pressure from High Street businesses across the country, they're handing a little bit back, and think it's all fine. It's like a burglar returning your TV and asking for a thank you. My honourable friend for Keighley and Ilkley was absolutely right to highlight this point.
Then there's the high street bank tax. This is a tax on lending, on mortgages, on the high street branches that people rely on in constituencies across the country. I thought this government wanted to see more bank branches, not fewer, but that's exactly what is going to happen. The honourable gentleman is also probably going to stand up and try and claim that this budget is delivering for working families on the cost of living, but that is not the whole picture, is it? Living standards this year across every postcode are set to fall under a Labour government.
But it's okay, they can all live off cheaper gherkins.
They don't like to hear this, Madam Deputy Speaker, and no doubt I'll be accused of talking down the economy. So let me be very clear: I talk up my country, but I talk down this Labour government. And I'm not the only one, Madam Deputy Speaker, there's plenty of others. The IFS said the budget has very little that will move the dial on growth. The CBI said the budget lacked the bold moves that would have made it easier for firms to invest, hire and grow.
The British Retail Consortium said costs will keep climbing as the Chancellor failed to provide the breathing space he promised. And even their friends, the Resolution Foundation, said the budget did not live up to the scale of the challenges. Madam Deputy Speaker, don't get me wrong, I don't believe they are bad people.
I just don't think they have any grasp of basic economics and reality. Just this weekend, we heard that they don't even think that employers are working people, as rightly pointed out by my honorable friend for Bromsgrove. And in all of this, let's spare a thought for poor old Keir Starmer, who must have been sat watching the TV on Lord Alli's sofa wondering: What was it all for?
The new Prime Minister booted him out with a story of transformation, almost revolution. After years and years of trying, he finally becomes the First Lord of the Treasury. And we all eagerly await his first budget, his first chance to mold the country according to his Mancunian grand vision. But what we got was same old Labour. Higher taxes, no action on welfare and no real answers to the challenges facing our country today.
This is continuity Keir without the mandate. Tinkering little policies like a £2 bus cap is not going to keep us safe from Putin. It's going to take a family, it's not going to take a family out of poverty. It'll only get them to the bank branch that's closing, near the house they can't afford, with a mortgage that they won't be lent. When will they learn?
Madam Deputy Speaker, it doesn't have to be this way.
Instead of fueling a rise in unemployment and overseeing a spiraling benefits bill, the Government could reduce costs to businesses and cut the regulatory burden. We could get people off welfare and into work. We will happily work with the Chancellor in the national interest if only he could be brave enough to stand up to the people chuntering behind him. Madam Deputy Speaker, nothing has changed. Not the tax hikes, not the welfare bill, not the excuses.
All that's changed is the person holding the microphone. Now I accept the Prime Minister has been busy. We've watched him bounce from the Downing Street desk to the Gogglebox sofa and back home to Manchester. We know his favorite crisps, but we don't know his plan for the economy. He's a TikTok Prime Minister who chose a Chancellor on a tuk-tuk.
He's had a ride and now he's taking the British people for one too. A Chancellor who for some reason carried a miner's lantern to the Labour Party conference. Now he's leading the economy down a dark tunnel with no plan to get out. Back during the days of the coup, the Prime Minister told us with a nauseating dose of cheddar cheese, he wanted "hope in every heart". Well what we got was a hand in every pocket.
Tax at record levels, debt higher, debt interest higher, youth unemployment spiralling. This is not just a missed opportunity. It is a dereliction of duty.
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Madam Deputy Speaker, it is a pleasure to close this budget debate on good growth in every postcode. And I thank members from across the House for their contributions in today's debate. In particular, I want to thank the member for Holborn and St Pancras for her fantastic maiden speech today. My honorable friend spoke powerfully of the everyday way, in her words, that people in her part of London look out for each other. And I know that she will look out for her constituents every single day.
And I'm sure along with members from across the House, warmly welcome her to these benches today. Madam Deputy Speaker, the budget last week was a budget to provide breathing space now and fresh hope for the future.
It backed British business to unleash growth in every postcode, and it kickstarted the changes needed to put our country on a better course. It was also a budget, Madam Deputy Speaker, set against the backdrop of global economic storms with trade tensions acting as a drag on global growth, and Putin's illegal invasion of Ukraine approaching the end of its fifth year. These shocks may be global, but the effects are being felt here at home. According to the OBR, we will spend 14 billion pounds more each year on debt interest compared to the last forecast, and the government's responsibility is of course to determine how to respond to this. We've chosen to respond by using some of the headroom that was built up last year to absorb the impact of the war, and also to protect the economy and family budgets as much as possible.
We've also chosen crucially to meet the fiscal rules in full with borrowing falling in every year of the forecast. Madam Deputy Speaker, Britain's economic reputation was badly damaged under the party opposite, so badly damaged in fact that the IMF publicly warned them to change course and the contrast now could not be clearer. The IMF have said recently that the UK stands out as a country where, and I quote, "We are taking action to reduce the debt and deficit and that action has been taken decisively." And despite the warnings from forecasters and the gloomsters opposite that our economy would slow down, Britain has defied expectations this year.
The OBR have upgraded the UK's growth forecast, and in the first half of this year, we had the joint fastest growth in the G7. Productivity, Madam Deputy Speaker, is up at 2.2% a year, compared to an average growth rate of just half a percent a year between 2015 and 2024. I'll give way.
Ashley Peter Fox
Grateful to the minister for giving way. If everything is going so well, why is Britain paying more to borrow money than any other country in Europe?
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Well, the the honourable member is right to raise that we are spending a large share of our budgets on debt interest costs. One pound in every ten, Madam Deputy Speaker, is spent paying the interest on our debt.
That was an increase that took place under the Conservatives, after the spike in interest rates in 2022 under Liz Truss's mini-budget, and the apprentice to Liz Truss is now the shadow Chancellor. Madam Deputy Speaker, real wages have risen more since the election than in the first 10 years of the Conservative government. And members opposite have talked about the private sector in the economy, and I would point out to them that whole-economy investment and business investment have all grown by more in this Parliament so far than they did in the entirety of the last Parliament. We are turning our economy around from the hellscape that it was on under the previous government.
Madam Deputy Speaker, we are building on our recent economic resilience through this budget. We're delivering immediate measures to help with rising energy bills, a £100 household energy payment paid directly to those living in bands A to D in England alongside a 0% VAT cut on electricity along alongside a reduction to 0% VAT on electricity until July. We're also abolishing gas standing charges on household energy bills, while extending the 5p fuel duty cut and the cut to red diesel. We're reducing bills by up to 25% for more than 10,000 eligible businesses from next April through the British Industrial Competitiveness Scheme.
And I will give way.
Anthony Bradley Thomas
for giving way.
If the picture is so rosy, can he explain to me why, a couple of weeks ago, I visited six businesses in my constituency, all in the hospitality sector, every single one of them said that they are not recruiting, nor have they recruited since the government increased National Insurance contributions? Why is he painting a picture that's different to reality? Why does he think they're not recruiting?
Daniel Mark Tomlinson
Madam Deputy Speaker, I can't speak to the individual businesses in his constituency, but I can but I can point the honorable member to the forecast from the Office for Budget Responsibility that revise up employment by 200,000 and show employment forecast to increase in every year of the forecast. Madam Deputy Speaker, we are also taking changes to support workers, increasing the national minimum wage and the National Living Wage. We're increasing the higher mileage rate and making the increase to the standard mileage rate announced earlier in the year permanent.
And we're backing our high street businesses with retail, hospitality, and leisure properties seeing their business rates frozen in real terms, reduced, or cut to zero next year. Madam Deputy Speaker, my right honorable friend, the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities, spoke very powerfully and convincingly earlier of the changes that this government is making on devolution to drive good growth in every postcode. And so, I won't run through the points that were made in opening, but I was glad to hear from my honorable friends in constituencies where we will be extending devolution in England, particularly in those towns and communities that missed out on the first wave of devolution under the previous government, about their welcome for that continued roll-out. And it will mean that over 90% of England's population is now on track to be covered by strategic authority in the next couple of years. I would like to turn to focus on energy, if I may.
The opposition spokesperson raised this in opening, and I think it's worth covering for a few minutes before we wrap up. At the budget last week, the Chancellor set out a new pathway for energy, which the 10-year plan will build on, setting out, Madam Deputy Speaker, that our priority is to bring energy costs down to help business compete and to help families cope. Cheaper electricity will also boost electrification, increase our energy security, and help to decarbonise the whole economy. First, we are addressing levies and policy costs on bills. The party opposite, Madam Deputy Speaker, loaded £100 onto bills via levies, and this Labour government has already taken £150 off energy bills at the last budget, and the Chancellor went further this week by drawing a line in the sand on levies.
He's confirmed that there'll be no new costs added to energy bills, with a comprehensive cost control framework to follow at the spending review. He's also abolishing plans first set out by the party opposite to add a further £10 a year to bills to pay for hydrogen projects. Second, we're backing network investment, only adding new generation if it's affordable and the grid can keep up. Between 2016 and 2020, network investment declined in real terms under the previous Government just when it was clear that more intermittent power would need that we need more capacity. Now they are in opposition, Madam Deputy Speaker, the party opposite have no serious energy policy left.
Their only real answer now is to retreat in full from net zero, banning people from being parliamentary candidates for the Conservative party if they support net zero by 2050.
That is a big mistake, Madam Deputy Speaker, and it's one that I'm confident the British people will reject at the next election. In the Budget, we also committed to only procure clean power to the next auction round if we're confident it will lower bills. And we will reform contract for difference by AR9 to support building the lowest-cost system, fixing market distortions, and siting assets in the right place. To members in this House who are committed to net zero on this side and in the Liberal Democrats, let me be clear: it is only by getting electricity prices down and ensuring new clean power does not run ahead of the grid that we can credibly achieve our net zero goals. I just want to turn to a couple of points made by members in the debate, and then I will conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker.
My right honourable friend, the member for Falkirk, asked a number of questions about the Acorn project, and I want to reassure him, and members on both sides of the House, that the Government remains committed to Acorn and wants to see it succeed. The change announced last week switches funding from grants to loans or equity stakes, which could, we hope, provide a better value for money for the taxpayer. The existing partners confirmed last week, Madam Deputy Speaker, this approach, setting out that the budget announcement does not change Acorn's current development programme, and I know that the relevant minister in the Energy Department will be meeting with the developers later this week. The scheme is not the only one to be affected by recent prioritisation decisions,
and, in fact, Madam Deputy Speaker, some schemes in England have been stopped entirely. A number of members on this side of the House also raised the Mineworkers' Pension Scheme. They and others on these benches have been relentless in their advocacy for the mining communities.
I particularly note the speech this evening from my honourable friend, the member for Amber Valley. It was a really powerful contribution and it was heard loud and clear on the Treasury bench. As my right honourable friend, the Chancellor, said last week, he knows that the job is not done and that he will go on to ensure the full transfer of the guarantor's fund. I know he is working at pace to agree a way forward. Madam Deputy Speaker, this is a budget to deliver good growth in every postcode.
It is underpinned by fiscal discipline with borrowing falling in every year. It is the most decentralising budget in modern British history, pushing power and resources out across the country. It marks an important moment in the history of UK energy policy with a firm commitment to putting cheap electricity first.
They added £100 to bills. We've taken £150 off. And we're now drawing a line in the sand when it comes to new bill costs. This budget supports businesses on the high street, removing 70,000 smaller high street properties from business rates altogether, and in industry, by implementing a 25% discount to electricity bills for heavy users. And of course, we've prioritised helping families now with £100 off energy bills this winter for 20 million homes, funding this through higher bank taxes, which the party opposite oppose.
This is a big Labour budget built on strong Labour choices, breathing space for today, and fresh hope for the future.
Speaker 372
The question is that the debate be now adjourned. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it.
Tomorrow.
Speaker 372
Tomorrow. I will allow the frontbenchers to swap over if they so wish. We come to motion number three relating to the Environmental Audit Committee. Gen Kitchen to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 372
The question is as on the Order Paper. As many as of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.
Motion number four relating to the Transport Committee. Gen Kitchen to move.
I beg to move.
Speaker 372
The question is as on the order paper. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it.
The ayes have it.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I beg to move that this House has considered the registration of hairdressers and barbers. More than 60 years ago, this House passed legislation establishing a register for hairdressers. The purpose was clear: to encourage professional standards, support qualifications and training, provide consumers with confidence, and recognize hairdressing as a skilled profession. The principle was right then, and it remains right today.
What has changed is the world around it. The high street has changed, the labor market has changed, and increasingly, the sector itself is warning us that voluntary system put in place in 1964 is no longer enough to ensure a sustainable future for hairdressing and barbering. Tonight, I want to make the case that moving from a voluntary register to a mandatory one is not a radical step, it's a natural next step. And crucially, it is not a proposal to create a new register. Parliament has already established that principle.
The register already exists. I am simply seeking, through mandatory registration, to strengthen a framework that Parliament itself put in place when Harold Wilson was first Prime Minister. It would help tackle the collapse in apprenticeships. It would strengthen public safety.
and it would support the legitimate businesses that form the backbone of our local high streets. Indeed, what is perhaps most striking is that the sector itself has now reached this conclusion. The British Hair Consortium, the National Hair & Beauty Federation, the Hair and Barber Council, employers, educators and industry lead leaders are all increasingly united in calling for a mandatory registration scheme. This is not government regulation being imposed on an unwilling industry. It's a solution designed by them for an increasingly urgent problem.
Madam Deputy Speaker, as I'm sure you are aware, hairdressers and barbers are far more important than many people appreciate. We all know the feeling of walking out of a salon or barber shop feeling better than when we walked in.
Many people value the relationship they have with a hairdresser, like my cousin Jane and her daughter, Lucy, who traveled several hours every couple of months from Kent to see their stylist after he moved to Dorset. Or Nick, who supported my mum Lynn as she lost her hair through her chemotherapy, and still managed to make her feel a million dollars. These professionals improve confidence, well-being, and self-esteem. These businesses provide social connection. In an increasingly isolated society, they often offer something technology never can: genuine human interaction.
One survey found that 42% of young men had experienced weeks where visiting a barber or personal care professional was the only in-person interaction that they'd had.
Vikki Slade
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
In my constituency, one such barber is Mike Taylor of Bonds in Broadstone. He recently created a retro style, one-to-one barbering space specifically recognising the role that barbers play in supporting men's well-being and mental health. But barbering and hairdressing are not just socially valuable, they are economically vital. The wider beauty and personal care sector contributes more than £28 billion to the UK economy and supports almost 600,000 jobs. These are jobs that cannot be offshored, they cannot be replaced by artificial intelligence and they drive footfall to our town centres.
When people visit a barber or salon, they often spend money elsewhere on the high street too. They're anchors of our local economies in villages, market towns and city centres. And for generations, hair and beauty has acted as a ladder of opportunity.
It has provided first jobs for young people. It has offered flexible careers for parents and carers, and it's enabled thousands of people to build businesses of their own. Following the introduction of my bill in September, I was contacted by Nova, who owns Novaluxe Salon in Poole. She reminded me that when we first met 25 years ago, she was an apprentice at Karen's Hair Design in Broadstone where I was a customer and where I ran a business on the same high street. She trained, qualified, gained experience and, ultimately, has built a successful business of her own.
Hers is exactly the sort of journey that this sector has made possible for generations. Her story is the story of hair and beauty.
But she shared with me that professional qualified business owners who follow the rules increasingly feel they are competing against businesses that do not. People like Manover increasingly tell me that the profession they love is becoming harder to sustain. The concern I hear repeatedly is not about competition, it is about unfair competition.
John Hayes
Of course. I'm so grateful to the honourable lady and she's doing the House great service. My late sister, Joan, was a hairdresser. She did an apprenticeship of exactly the kind the honourable lady describes the London School of Hairdressing before I was born, actually. And she was proud of the skills she acquired and then later used for many years.
But there has been in recent years the emergence of some extremely strange, I would argue dodgy, largely foreign barbershops, who I suspect have much less to do with hairdressing than many other nefarious purposes.
Vikki Slade
I thank my honourable friend for his intervention. Indeed, the number of barbershops on our high streets have doubled in the last decade or so, and I'm fairly sure that the number of us requiring a weekly haircut has not. And the point isn't about competition, it's about unfair competition alongside what are, it has to be said, quite impossible trading conditions.
Will the honourable lady give way?
Of course.
Jim Shannon.
Jim Shannon
Madam Deputy Speaker, I'm one of those fortunate ones, perhaps, who never have to go to a barber, because I don't use a comb, I just use a chammy. And it keeps me it keeps me okay, you know.
In recent years there have been increasing reports across the UK of so-called beauticians carrying out invasive procedures without the necessary medical qualifications. Doctors across the country have warned of the serious, potentially life-threatening consequences of botched treatments. So does the honorable lady agree that stronger regulation of the cosmetic industry is urgently needed, particularly given that some are carrying out invasive, in some cases surgical procedures without the appropriate qualifications or training? And we must hold and Government must hold these individuals criminally responsible for the damage they're causing to public health. Thank you.
Vicky Foxcroft.
Vikki Slade
I thank my honourable friend for his intervention, and it's interesting, although this is specifically around hair and barbering, there have been some moves for a similar registration system for those sort of industries that do piercing and tattoos and things, but the industry themselves are struggling to work out exactly what it should look like. But there is a very big issue here around insurance, which I'll come on to. According to analysis commissioned by the British Hair Consortium, employee numbers in the sector has fallen around 23% in 2025, equivalent to the loss of 20,000 jobs, or put another way, the equivalent of 20 employing salons making all of their staff redundant every working day for a year. Industry estimates and estimates suggest that more than 70% of those working in the sector are now classified as self-employed. Of course, genuine self-employment is not a problem.
Many talented stylists and barbers have always chosen to rent a chair. They've always used it as a stepping stone towards their own business, but the concern is where self-employment exists entirely on paper. When I met representatives of the National Hair and Beauty Federation a couple of weeks ago, they described workers who were, in their own words, "employees on Friday and self-employed on Monday." Nothing about their work had changed, nothing about the business had changed, only their employment status. They continue to work in the same chair in the single salon, no control over their prices, no determining their own working practices, but now they no longer had sickness cover, pensions, or any rights.
It involved reduced tax receipts for the government and crucially, fewer apprenticeships, as without workers, you can't hire apprentices. And it's apprenticeships where the consequences are most serious.
The hairdressing apprenticeship starts in England have fallen from more than 13,000 in 2015 to just 4,000 in 2023. And forecasts suggest that recruitment could completely collapse within a couple of years if current trends continue. And this should concern every member of this House, because these are not just statistics. These are lost opportunities for young people, lost opportunities for the social mobility and for skills development. And the sector reports that around a quarter of these apprentices have special educational needs, significantly higher than the SEND rates across the wider apprenticeship sector.
Many of them have also been NEET. So for thousands of young people who struggle to access traditional academic pathways, this sector has provided a route to qualifications, employment, and independence.
Will the honourable lady give way?
Of course.
Kevin McKenna
I absolutely thank the honourable member for this really important debate. I recently visited Bodylines, a salon and spa in the middle of Sittingbourne, which is run by Liza with a Z, not Lisa with an S, just to confuse everyone. But she was making this point very strongly. This is a great salon that's been there for about 40 years, a very well-embedded business in the town. She used to offer lots of training places.
Now she simply can't because she's being out-competed by venues that rent chairs by the hour to the sort of pseudo self-employed. And I think the biggest thing that she was telling me was this is a real threat to the future of the industry.
I mean my mother trained as a hairdresser in the 60s before becoming a social worker. Those roles are vital for getting people, as the honorable member has said, into a whole range of different employment, but without businesses that can actually support this, they will just go forever. And this self- pseudo self-employed won't exist either. But the biggest thing she raised for me is just how much money the government is losing through VAT, because these other venues are not offering VAT, the responsible self-employed are not paying, and we're losing money that way as well. So on every front, this is something we have to confront have to change.
Vikki Slade
I thank the honorable member for his intervention.
It is about tax receipts. It is about genuine self-employed people that people This is not about stopping people from cutting their family members' hair. This is not about people who are running a startup from home. This isn't about where you trade, it's about whether you trade legitimately and how you sustain the next generation of this of the industry. And I'm really glad that the honorable member mentioned that because I want to tell a story that Mike shared with me, Mike Taylor shared, about an apprentice that has taken up his program.
He's got an incredible academy that takes on about a dozen young people, mostly NEETs aged 16 to 18 in Broadstone where I live. And he has an apprentice who is traveling from Kent. It's a long way from Kent to Dorset. He couldn't find a local training placement, and so every week he travels to stay with his auntie in Dorchester for his training, so that he can develop his skills. The reason is, he couldn't get an apprenticeship close to home, and the only opportunity available to him was working for an unscrupulous barber who paid him just £1 an hour.
£1 an hour, despite the employer charging customers for his services.
That is not entrepreneurship. That is not business. That is exploitation. That young man wants to learn a trade, he wants to build a career, and he should not have to choose between exploitation and abandoning his ambitions. And legitimate businesses, like those mentioned by my honourable friend for Sittingbourne, should not have to compete against them.
Which brings me to the issue of public safety. The House of Commons Library notes that anyone can practice as a hairdresser or barber without holding any recognised qualifications.
In a profession involving chemicals, blades and close physical contact with the public, that is increasingly difficult to justify. Now, Madam Deputy Speaker, most practitioners are highly-skilled professionals who take enormous pride in their work. But consumers deserve confidence that those offering professional services have met the appropriate standards and that they wield their scissors safely. Most members of the public would reasonably assume that someone advertising themselves as a professional hairdresser or barber has demonstrated some level of competence, but that assumption cannot always be made. Poorly applied chemicals can cause burns, overuse of bleach can lead to hair loss, poor hygiene standards, as we've heard, can contribute to skin conditions like ringworm.
A mandatory register would help provide the public with confidence that practitioners have achieved recognized qualifications. And just as importantly, it would enhance the reputation of those who've already meet those standards every day.
This proposal is practical, it's proportionate, and it's achievable. We are not trying to create a system from scratch, the register already exists, the Hair and Barber Council already administer it, the infrastructure is in place. We want to build on the infrastructure that's already there. Mandatory registration would simply strengthen and modernise an existing statutory framework for the realities of today. The sector estimates that costs would likely fall to hairdressers if registration was universal, and they believe that registration could become a recognised prerequisite for securing insurance and demonstrating professional competence.
It would improve standards for consumers, and it would support legitimate businesses. It could help enforce it help enforcement agencies tackle tax evasion, illegal working, employment status abuse and criminal activity associated with some rogue businesses.
Indeed, support for the proposal now extends beyond the industry itself. The APPG for Anti-Corruption & Responsible Taxation, chaired by the honourable member for Bolton West, has highlighted concerns around the extraordinary growth in barbering alongside declining tax enforcement activity.
On that point, will the honourable lady give way?
Of course.
Michael Philip Brickell
I thank the honourable lady for giving way and mentioning the APPG which I chair and the work that we are doing. Does she agree with me that government can't simply enforce its way out of this problem around illicit activity on the high street in this sector, given the NCA, when it conducted its November 2025 Operation Machinize, visited 2,734 premises up and down the length of the country, but only actually closed 10 of those down?
Of course, not all of those were hairdressers or barbering salons. And that therefore, a proportionate licensing regime is the right step to move forward, akin to what the Dutch have done with their Bibob Act, and that is the way of seizing control around who operates in these sectors, but also giving confidence to the public about who is cutting hair and who is operating on the high street.
Vikki Slade
I thank my honourable friend for his intervention. I mean, the vast majority of people in the sector are doing the right thing. The problem is that they're watching other people, also in the sector, with empty chairs all day and then wondering how on earth they're supporting four, five or six employees or people working in the space.
And the sector itself has said that they are very happy to share the information so that we know the scale of the industry, they know how many hairdressers are working, they we know, you know, where we need more training places. So, this is actually a means of using a register that already exists to professionalise a system and actually help the government to move it forward for the future. Rather than relying solely on expensive raids and investigation after problems have emerged, the register could allow standards to be established from the outset, and for the scale and shape of the sector to be mapped with sufficient training providers in place in the right place, such as my young man who needs to have training in Kent. A survey by the National Hair & Beauty Federation found that support for a mandatory register within the sector is at around 80%.
That figure should give Ministers pause. Industries do not often ask Parliament for registration, and yet this what regulation, this one is, not because it wants bureaucracy, but because it wants a sustainable future. Madam Deputy Speaker, I understand that some critics suggest registration could increase costs or unnecessary burdens. I disagree. The greatest threat to consumers and the industry is not professionalising it's the continued erosion of standards, it's legitimate businesses being forced from our high street by those willing to ignore the rules, it's the loss of apprenticeships, loss of public confidence, and the gradual devaluation of a skilled profession.
When this 1964 act was debated, its sponsors described hairdressing as both an art and a science. The Government of the day recognised the need for standards, qualifications, and public confidence.
They were right then, and those principles remain just as relevant today. Making the register mandatory does not create a new principle, it just brings what was considered a pioneering proposal in 1964 into the 21st century. It has the potential to increase revenues, make it harder for illegal businesses to operate in our town centres, and ultimately, it supports the next generation of hairdressers and barbers. If it succeeds, perhaps it will mean fewer bad hair days for all of us. When a profession, its employers, its training providers, and its representative bodies are all asking Parliament to act, Parliament should listen.
Parliament recognised the importance of standards in hairdressing in 1964. The time has come to finish the job that Parliament started more than 60 years ago.
I commend these proposals to the House, and I look forward to working with the Minister to deliver them.
Alexandra Kate Dearden
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, and I want to congratulate the honourable member for securing this debate this evening, and would like to thank her for the constructive and determined way in which she's championed this issue, both in this House and through her presentation bill. I also want to recognise her close work with her constituent Mike Taylor, who she referenced this evening, whose business is an accredited, outstanding provider of barbering apprenticeships, and I want to pay tribute to him and to the hairdressers and barbers whose experiences she has shared with the House this evening. I was brought up around this industry, Madam Deputy Speaker. My mum was a hairdresser, and I'm very lucky that I can still persuade her to do my hair today. So I recognise how important it is to be a voice in Parliament for hair and beauty and for this absolute powerhouse of an industry, and I'm proud to be the Minister responsible for personal care.
Hair and beauty isn't just a £28 billion significant contribution to the economy and almost 600,000 jobs. It's also the salon on the high street that brings people into town. As she referenced, it supports our local communities, helping them thrive. And for many women, often, it's what starts as a passion, a set of professional skills and the ambition to build something of their own and that can grow into a successful business creating employment and opportunities for others. And with over 85% of businesses in our sector owned by women, hair and beauty is a powerful example of female entrepreneurship, independence, and resilience.
And behind every salon is that story of hard work and skill, creativity and determination.
So I want to start with recognizing the significance of our industry, mainly women across the sector, and to thank them for all of the support that they give to women across the country. She referenced that often our therapists and we get our hair done and we walk out feeling amazing. So I wanted to start with that contribution, and also want to start with where we agree. The harms the honorable member has described are real. Customers should feel safe and protected in a salon chair, and good employers shouldn't be undercut by those who cheat and don't play by the same rules.
Young people need a route into this profession, and criminals should not be hiding behind barbershop fronts on our high streets. The question before the House is not whether these problems matter. Of course they do. The question is whether a mandatory register is the right way to fix them. And I want to take a number of the honorable member's arguments in turn and explain where I would like to hear more evidence and what will work instead and what we're prioritizing.
And first, it's worth being clear what a register is. As the honourable member mentioned, the Hairdressers (Registration) Act of 1964 already provides for a register of qualified hairdressers and barbers. Making it mandatory would record that an individual holds a qualification. And while it would improve visibility, it wouldn't inspect a salon, check who owns a business or where its money comes from, or decide whether somebody's genuinely self-employed, and it wouldn't create a single new apprenticeship place, because that matters, because each of the harms that the honourable member has discussed, many of them many members tonight, comes from something other than perhaps a missing qualification.
And on consumer safety, I want to highlight two examples: the cases of ringworm and chemical burns, because these are distressing, and I don't dismiss them for a moment. Madam Deputy Speaker, ringworm comes from poor hygiene and infection control. A qualified stylist working with unclean equipment poses the same risk as an unqualified one. Chemical burns come from the unsafe use of hazardous products, and every salon, whoever works in it, is already legally required to control these risks under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 and the associated regulations, such as the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 and the Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002. Local authorities already have the powers to enforce health and safety legislation and are responsible for managing hygiene standards in businesses.
Where there is evidence that risks are not being properly managed, local authorities are able to intervene and take appropriate enforcement action to ensure that employees and customers are protected. A register wouldn't send anyone through the door to check, but enforcement does. And where the evidence has shown serious risks of harm, the government has acted. Last month, we launched a consultation proposing that high-risk cosmetic procedures should only be carried out by qualified, regulated healthcare professionals, with providers registered with the Care Quality Commission, and criminal penalties for breaches. We've also committed to a licensing scheme for lower-risk cosmetic procedures,
and we act because there was strong evidence showing a scale of harm. So far, we've not seen comparable evidence for hairdressing, but if the honourable member has cases, and she's raised some tonight, I want my officials to see them.
The honourable member is right that bogus self-employment, too, is unacceptable. Self-employment, as she mentioned, is a legitimate and long-standing part of this sector, and many workers value that flexibility and that way of working. But no employer should deny the basic rights of people by calling them self-employed when they're not. Here, too, it's not clear how a register might help. A fully qualified registered barber could still be falsely self-employed.
What will make a difference, Madam Deputy Speaker, is fixing the employment status framework itself.
We've published a consultation on targeted reforms, including a proposal of worker status and stronger enforcement. These proposals are designed with workers like those in hairdressing in mind. Alongside this, the really important work of the Fair Work Agency now brings together employment rights enforcement into one place with a dedicated hidden economy team, and I know that Fair Work Agency officials have met with the sector. HMRC will investigate where people have been misclassified for tax purposes and take action to recover the tax and national insurance owed, and I'm of course happy to keep her updated on the employment status consultation and discuss further with her. The honorable member, too, spoke powerfully about apprenticeships, and I won't pretend that the recent figures that she alluded to, and that decline that we've seen in apprenticeship starts, is comforting.
It's not. Hairdressing businesses play such an important role, as she mentioned, in employment and training opportunities, particularly for young people, and that's why it's really important to strengthen the sector's skills pipeline for those opportunities for social mobility and career progression.
The challenge employers describe is the cost and capacity to take on and train a young person. It's not clear how a register that requires qualifications may help, and we are mindful of the cost that she referenced that small businesses that do the training. So that's why- Of course.
Vikki Slade
I thank the minister. In my discussions with the various agencies, they say the current cost of being in the voluntary register is about £75. They've suggested that if this actually was extended to all people working in the actual it would actually reduce to £25. So, actually, probably less than the cost of a haircut to actually be able to be on a register with an organisation would which would then itself be involved in some of those enforcement activities that would benefit the government.
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank her for her intervention and for sharing those examples from the representatives she meets with. We are really keen to engage with those and understand the impact, of course, and I've sort of given my reflections today around those concerns. But it adds to my wider point of we want to hear that evidence and pick that up. And that's why our focus in the meantime has been helping those employers directly on apprenticeships, whether it's that £2,000 hiring payment for smaller employers taking on 16 to 24-year-old apprentices, the £3,000 youth jobs grant, the no National Insurance for employers and apprentices under 25, and fully funded apprenticeship training for eligible under-25s. They're really important to help drive up apprenticeships across the country, in particular in this sector.
We're working with them on assessment reform so that hair and beauty apprenticeships are rigorous, they're proportionate, and trusted by employers. Finally Madam Deputy Speaker, on money laundering. Serious and organised crime damages our high streets and undermines honest businesses and I thank the honourable member and my friend for raising that this evening. Tackling this is a priority for this Government. A criminal front can employ a registered barber as easily as anyone else, and a register with reflections around how, who owns the business, where the money comes from, how it could even maybe lend it as respectability it does not deserve is a key consideration.
My honourable friend the member for Bolton West mentioned the Operation Machinise since March 2025, that's been led by the National Crime Agency. That's seen over 3,000 suspect high-street premises visited and nearly 1,000 people arrested. And we are building on that with a £30 million crackdown on cash-intensive businesses, including barber shops. That also includes £20 million for law enforcement, £6 million for trading standards, and a new cross-government high street organised crime unit.
We'll also double the maximum duration of closure orders.
Very briefly.
Michael Philip Brickell
I thank the minister for giving way. Will she heed the comments I made earlier about the fact that actually that's really good, but the fact of the matter is the scale of the issue is such that the government can't enforce its way out of it? And there's got to be another way that prevents enforcement agencies from playing whack-a-mole trying to close down premises that are operating in an illicit way.
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank him for his intervention, Madam Deputy Speaker. I know he is working closely with colleagues across government on this issue, and I thank him for his continued campaigning and advocacy. We've got to double that maximum duration of closure orders, Madam Deputy Speaker, so that criminal businesses can't simply reopen while investigations continue.
Kevin McKenna
It's been really interesting to listen to all of the points the minister has made about potential negatives about a registration scheme as a mandatory scheme and the things that might not work. I would just offer in terms of evidence, about a hundred years ago, nursing was not a registered profession in the early 20th century. All those arguments are very familiar, and people as notable as Florence Nightingale was opposed to nursing registration, it was seen as essential. And a lot of the challenges that the minister has identified were overcome. We wouldn't even conceive of nursing not being registered now, and I think this is true for these other intimate professions, like beauty and hair.
Alexandra Kate Dearden
I thank my honourable friend for his intervention and I hope he can hear that himself and the honourable member and colleagues in this chamber, we do want the same things. We want customers to be safe. We want workers to get the rights they're entitled to. We want young people to have a route into this brilliant profession and criminals to have nowhere to hide on our high streets. So, as colleagues will have heard today, I'm not yet persuaded that a mandatory register will deliver those things, but I am open to the evidence, so I thank honourable members for their offer this evening.
And what I am persuaded by, too, is that enforcement, employment reform and direct support for employers will deliver. As her bill is before the House, I it would not be right for me to comment on its specific provisions this evening, but I make her this offer: if she has evidence of harm that existing powers are not reaching, I would like my officials to look at it closely. I thank her for bringing this debate to the House this evening, for all colleagues for their contributions and for championing a sector that matters so much to our communities.
Speaker 372
The question is that this House do now adjourn. As many as are of that opinion say aye. The ayes have it. Order.
Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.