Defence Committee

27 October 2026

Defence Committee House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:11 - 01:42
Speaker 1
Order, order.  I call to order today's House of Commons Defence Committee one-off evidence session on Defence Medical Services.  I'm very pleased to say that we have with us two very esteemed individuals with a great deal of experience in Defence Medical Services, namely Lieutenant General retired Martin Bricknell, who is the former Surgeon General of the UK Armed Forces back in 2018-2019.  And also we're very, very pleased to have with us Major General retired Timothy Hodgetts, who was also the former Surgeon General of the UK Armed Forces, as well as being the chair of the NATO Committee of the Chiefs of Military Medical Services in 2021 to 2024.  Gents, we'll get on with the questioning very, very soon, but I also want to very warmly welcome our newly elected member of the House of Commons Defence Committee, the honourable member for Dunfermline and Dollar, Graham Downie. 

Graham, a very, very warm welcome to you.  Right, without further ado, we've got two different panels today, so we have one hour with yourselves.  There's a lot of questions, so please do try to be as succinct as possible because there's quite a lot of ground to cover in the next hour.  And without further ado, I'd like to ask my colleague Lincoln Jopp to kickstart the questioning. 
01:42 - 02:00
Speaker 3
Generals, thank you very much indeed for your time today.  When General Sir Richard Barrons was in front of us in July, I think it was, he described Defence Medical Services as the most hollowed-out bit of defence.  What, how would you describe the current state of Defence Medical Services? 
02:00 - 03:04
Speaker 4
So I'll start and then Tim will fill, will add in, and we'll balance this out between organisational aspects, which I will focus on, and Tim will talk about clinical.  I had the privilege of serving on the SDR panel for the Defence Medical Services.  And we wanted to put on record that the UK Defence Medical Services had been hollowed out as a result of a series of pressures on the Ministry of Defence over the past decade and a half.  And that because of the unique nature of the relationship between the military medical services and the civilian medical services, it's possible to take that as a saving in peace, but it means your foundational baseline if you need to expand and mobilise is at risk.  So from an organisational perspective, I would suggest it's a capacity rather than a capability dimension, but Tim will probably pick up on some specific aspects of risk. 
03:04 - 06:00
Speaker 2
Thank you.  So there are five principal risks I would say for casualties at scale and duration in the contested environment of war.  And we came to this conclusion after scrutiny within the NATO setting and codified in detail what the risk was across the whole of the NATO alliance.  And what we'll find is that there are broad risks across the alliance, but they vary in each individual country.  But they do fit into five main categories. 

So the first would be medical evacuation, having enough protected vehicles to get patients from the point of wounding to timely surgery. 

Now we can mitigate that in part by advances in prolonged field care when evacuation is delayed.  But be under no illusion, when medevac is not effective, avoidable deaths will occur and we have to accept poorer outcomes.  And indeed, the majority of avoidable deaths happen in pre-hospital care, not hospital care, so the focus has to be what happens far forward.  The second is around mass casualty planning, and it demands the military theater-level medical evacuation plan.  But we have to have a core focus within that plan to return to duty at every possible opportunity as we evacuate. 

The further away you get from the front line, the harder it is to get people back to the fight.  And we also need to recognize that the principles are different to conventional civilian major incident planning, and we have to address enduring high numbers.  The third issue is medical logistics.  And what COVID taught us, and we've seen it from previous military conflicts, is that just-in-time logistics don't work.  And that means we have to hold more stock, and we need decisions and action on what to further onshore or nearshore in terms of critical consumable items. 

The fourth is around regulatory and legal considerations, and we need the necessary freedoms in place ahead of conflict to support innovation at pace.  But also to be able to credential clinicians in a multinational setting, and multinationality buys out some of our medical risk.  And also to use allied blood and drugs on each other's patients.  But also remember that the enemy will not follow the law of armed conflict, so we have to change our tactics to take account for that.  And finally, it's workforce, and I know we're probably going to go into more detail about workforce. 

But we simply don't have the existing military medical capacity to deal concurrently with medical force preparation at scale, medical training at scale, and the predicted casualty estimates.