Lords Grand Committee
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Lords Grand Committee House of Lords
Follow its sittingsChris Grayling
And you have to remember that the network back in Victorian times, when it was twice as long, ran far fewer trains than was the case in that period. Now, it's settled down somewhat since the pandemic, but the reality is there are still parts of the network that are immensely overcrowded and where the ability of politicians to simply say we're going to do that is limited. So my first elements of my first series of amendments, 151, 150, 149, are simply designed to say to the government, this legislation must put something of a brake upon what the Secretary of State can actually do. Regardless of where the service is designated from, it is simply not practical to have people sitting in the DfT deciding what train services should run. And indeed, I thought the whole point of this legislation was not to go back to a situation where politicians had control or carried the can for what went wrong on the network.
It was designed to make this independent of politics. So why is the Secretary of State actually able to designate services at all? It is surely the job of GBR to balance all the competing needs of passengers, of freight, of capacity to work out what is the most realistic package of services to run. And I'm intrigued to hear the Minister's defense of the fact that there's any ability by politicians and the Department for Transport to designate services at all. I then move on to the other amendments in my name here.
And here I want to drive to the complete inconsistency in this legislation in a couple of areas. Why is it that the Mayor of London can continue to commission services from a private company? Why is it that the Mayor of Merseyside, I believe, can continue to commission services from a private company, but no one else can?
Whether it's GBR, whether it's the devolved authorities in Wales and in Scotland. If it is actually the case that the Scottish government decides in future that it wants to commission in exactly the same way that the Mayor of London does, why should that not be possible? Why does this legislation rule that out? And I really do think the minister needs to explain in detail why this is the case. Either we have a situation where every railway in the entire country is publicly owned and run, which we might disagree with, but let's have at least a degree of consistency in this.
Or we have a situation where different bodies have the ability to commission from other providers as long as they can demonstrate best value in doing so. So why is it that it's one rule for one and another rule for another in the way this legislation is set up? I look forward to hearing the minister's explanation. But to me, actually, the most important amendment here is 153A. Because when I commissioned the review back in 2018 after the timetable fiasco, when it was quite clear to me what I'd already pretty much worked out, which was that franchising no longer worked and we needed a fresh approach.
And I invited Keith Williams to carry out the research. The reason I did so was because my own belief was that one part of the future of the railways needed to be through employee-owned businesses. And indeed I envisaged regional public interest companies with the employees having a substantial stake. So rather than feeling free to go on strike all the time, they actually had a stake in what they lost through revenues if they did go on strike, so that they could actually benefit from working together to improve capacity, to improve reliability and the rest. And it is a matter of great regret to me that in the end we did not reach that point and the current government hasn't reached that point.
But I am, I think, as long as I remember correctly, addressing a minister from the Labour and Co-operative Party. So why is it not possible for a co-operative to run part of the railway? Why is it not possible for an employee-owned business to actually run services on the railway? That seems to me to be completely incongruous. It runs against 150 years of Labour history and it also is missing a great opportunity because employee participation generally speaking improves the performance of a business or an operation.
And I can see absolutely no reason why in future the government should not have the freedom to, or Great British Railways should not have the freedom, or indeed the mayors of devolved administrations should not have the freedom to commission rail services from companies that are wholly or substantially owned by their employees, co-operatives. So if the minister genuinely is a minister representing the Labour and Co-operative Party, perhaps he could tell me why he doesn't seem to believe and this government doesn't seem to believe in co-operatives anymore.
Richard Faulkner
My Lords, I am speaking to amendment 158 in this group, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay, and me. We both have unpaid interests as chair and president respectively of the Heritage Railway Association. We are concerned by the wording at clause 32(4), which describes an additional railway asset as, quote, "any network station or light maintenance depot". Is my noble friend the minister able to confirm that the powers of the Secretary of State relating to assets do not apply to assets on or owned by heritage railways?
It is a simple and I hope non-controversial issue.
Mark Harper
My Lords, the noble lady Baroness Jones was seeking my support for her amendments earlier. And although we fundamentally disagree and I suspect always will on whether railway services should be provided by private companies or not, her amendments actually do a very useful service though I think for the committee. And I very much wanted to just reinforce what my noble friend Lord Grayling said. I genuinely don't understand two things from the bill, very much supporting what he said. In clause 25, which is referenced by amendment 148 which the noble lady has tabled, talking about designation of services by the Secretary of State.
I agree with my noble friend. I thought the whole point of setting up GBR was to get the Secretary of State out of the business of micro-managing services and deciding which services should be provided and which services should be not. Now my reading of it and what's set out in the explanatory notes is this is about deciding what services GBR should do. But I'm not entirely certain once you start the Secretary of State doing that process, politically they will come under an enormous amount of pressure to start deciding which services are run or not, rather than GBR doing it at arm's length. And that just if anything increases the political control of these matters rather than reducing it.
So I'm not entirely certain why I thought the whole point of this was to get the Secretary of State out of the detail of running the services rather than inserting them back in the picture. So I would welcome the Minister explaining the thinking behind that power in clause 25 for the Secretary of State. The linked clause, which is 31, which is about then securing those services, I agree with the amendments, the thrust of the amendments tabled by my noble friend. Whilst it may be the case, I happen to be very comfortable with services being provided by private companies under all sorts of models. But even if you think it's important that the services are specified and tightly managed by a public sector provider, there's no reason why a private company can't actually provide the services under a contract.
As my noble friend said, the model in London for example where TfL sets out in detail what services should be provided but can award those contracts to provide those services to private companies. It doesn't have to own all the trains, employ all the staff and run all the services. Seems to me a perfectly sensible option that should be kept on the table rather than ruled out. Now it may be that GBR finds that there aren't any attractive companies that offer such services at a competitive price and it ends up awarding those contracts and to operate those services to GBR-owned businesses. But to rule out giving it the option of doing so just seems to me rather perverse.
And as my noble friend said, it seems to me also having the option of having a business which is at least partly owned by the employees or fully cooperative, again ruling that out seems to me overly prescriptive.
And you can take the view the government has about not wanting to have the franchising model and you can stick to that, but not allowing yourself, for example, to use the model that's used very successfully in London and as my noble friend said will still be able to be used in places like Liverpool seems to me rather unwise. And I don't know why ministers are not giving GBR at least the freedom to do that where that is cost-effective for taxpayers. The final point is...
Daniel Moylan
Of course. On that point, may I ask my noble friend if he agrees that circumstances might arise where in fact the GBR wishes to run a service but doesn't have adequate rolling stock, and yet you have a private sector company that actually has rolling stock for which it has no use because of this service, and that would be a match made in heaven but would appear to be precluded by the way the bill is drafted, and be another instance of where making use of the private sector to run the service would be in the public interest.
Mark Harper
I think my noble friend makes a very good point. And it seems to me if you're going to set up GBR and give it the job of doing the detailed day-to-day management, you want to give it the maximum amount of freedom to do so. You can, of course, rule out certain models. If you don't want to have the franchising model, for example, you can say that's not appropriate, but to say you can't use the private sector at all seems to me not sensible. It's also not very consistent with other decisions that ministers have taken.
For example, they have no plans as far as I understand it to get rid of the Roscos, the companies that own the rolling stock. Those are private businesses that make profits that are going to be paid for from funds both from passengers and taxpayers for the rolling stock. Ministers are not getting rid of those because they can't, because they have no ability to put all of that debt onto the public balance sheet, otherwise I suspect they might be tempted, but they can't. But ruling out people running services when as my noble friend said they might have the rolling stock, they might have the ability to do so, it misses the point about what the point of GBR is. The point of GBR is to run passenger services to deliver good services at the lowest possible cost both to passengers directly through ticket prices but also the taxpayer, and to invest in infrastructure so that other operators, open access operators and rail freight can also operate on the network.
And again, government says it supports open access, those are private companies. Government says it supports rail freight, those are private companies. So it seems having this blanket ruling out of private companies even under a concession model operating services doesn't seem to me enormously sensible. And I'd welcome the minister just taking us through the thinking about how the government's arrived at that conclusion, even ruling out concessions, for example, where it's comfortable with them happening in other parts of the country like London.
Anthony Berkeley
My Lords, just a question or two for my noble friend resulting from this very interesting debate, because I suppose my first question is, do you have to be designated in order to be able to run a passenger service? It's not quite clear to me therefore whether the status of the current open access operators will survive, or if anybody else wants to show up and become an open access operator, will they be allowed and on what basis?
Clearly, if it involves any state support or from GBR, that's a different matter, but it is possible for open access operators actually to operate at a profit. And what is therefore the role of GBR and the Secretary of State in if at all in designating what they may or may not do and when? Or is designation purely a means of providing, as my noble friend may say, a fair appointment of an operator to operate a particular line? Freight doesn't come into this, but I think open access passengers will be very interested to know whether the Secretary of State under this or another clause will be able to prevent them from operating. Nothing to do with capacity or charges or anything, but it seems to me to be a bit woolly at the moment.
Lucy Neville-Rolfe
My Lords, I wanted to make three quick points. I think this has been a very good discussion, so thanks to the noble lady Lady Jones for introducing it. First of all, I think my noble friend Lord Grayling is completely right to worry about freight. As noble Lords will know, my background's in the retail industry and using rail for freight was a big headache in terms of conflicts on the line. Secondly, I wanted to support Lord Faulkner on heritage railways because we have campaigned together to make sure that heritage railways are continue to be vibrant.
And I think the question he's asked about their assets is a very important one. But finally, I'd like to support the opt-out for TfL and Liverpool. I think if things are being run well, you should continue them. And the question is why are things like Chiltern Railways condemned to being wound up and put in the public sector when they provide a very useful competition and good, you know, an alternative for people going to Birmingham.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, this feels that there's a lot of kind of confusion in this group and trying to understand the government's intention. Amendment 160, which we're to hear from Lord Moylan on, caught my eye in this group because it's basically about repealing the Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Act from 2024. We will debate things like open access and other areas where I know members think there is room for some improvement and clarity in the legislation. But I do welcome Lord Grayling admitting that franchising no longer worked. And I think it's actually good to have that on the record because sometimes when we're debating the railways, it feels like people are saying that everything has worked perfectly well in recent years.
Chris Grayling
That clearly is not the case. The railway has a long way to go to run with the passenger at its heart and delivering the quality service that we all want to see.
Speaker 7
Would the noble lady allow me? I'd simply say that I don't think me saying that this afternoon is new. This is the whole reason the Williams Review was set up in the first place, back six, seven, eight years ago. So I don't think me saying that franchising isn't working is somehow a new thing on the record. I've said it many, many times.
Caroline Pidgeon
In my view, it's new in our debates that we've been having on this. And I absolutely accept the Williams review that was set up, which, you know, I met with Mr. Williams at the time and talked through how London worked, and we all fed into that review. The challenge then is we've got amendments before us today about allowing the private sector to operate some train services on behalf of the Secretary of State. Well, the preferred model that came out in that review was for a concession model, as we have in London, as we have in Merseyside, and the success of that. But the previous government didn't implement that, and this government has chosen not to implement that.
And that is the challenge we're in, and it would be interesting to hear how the noble lord the minister responds to those points that were made earlier. I fear that as we move forward, open access, assuming open access can carry on running the passenger services that they can at the current time, is that that's the only way we're going to see growth on the railways, because I think the budget for transport is going to be under so much pressure, we aren't going to see the railways grow in the way perhaps that had been envisaged with this legislation. But I look forward to hearing the minister's response to the points that have been raised.
Daniel Moylan
My lords, if I could begin by just responding briefly to the noble baroness, Lady Pidgeon. If we go back to the debates we had on the Passenger Rail Services Bill two years ago, she might remember, because I think she was already dealing with transport from the front bench at that stage. No? Well, maybe she has every excuse for her not to know, but she will find quite a detailed analysis there from me as to why the franchising system had ceased to be effective. So I think it has been fully acknowledged throughout that the franchising system, for a number of systemic reasons to which COVID was added as a practical sort of final nail in the coffin, meant that that didn't work.
That didn't mean there was no role for the private sector. The concession model was available as an alternative. There is no rationale, we believe, and we're quite right in saying this, for going for a fully state-owned, which I've referred to in committee previously as a fully Soviet-style railway, run by the government and provided by the government and wholly excluding private sector competition, except at the moment certain residual open access routes. I wanted to thank the noble baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb, who, with her customary textual acuity, has put her finger on something which I think the government does need to explain, which is that on the one hand the Secretary of State must designate routes, must, no choice, but then may procure them, and only may procure them. Now, there are a number of objections that have been raised to this.
Former Secretaries of State for Transport, two of them, have said they think it is undesirable for the holder of that office actually to have this power. I'm not going to dissent from that argument, but I have my own question, which is I'm not entirely sure what it means to designate a service. And this was a question raised by the noble lord, Lord Berkeley, I believe, that the nub of what he was asking was what does it mean to designate a service, especially if you don't have to provide it? It is only may provide it if you choose. Does it mean that Great British Railways can only provide services that have been designated?
If it doesn't mean that, and they can provide other services over and above those that have been designated, well, what is the point of designating?
Or does it mean that a designation of a service, which may not then be procured, but the designation of a service relates only to services that Great British Railways doesn't want to run or doesn't have a financial incentive to run? So that it is a sort of obligation on Great British Railways, which then may be procured from Great British Railways, thus forcing them to provide them. Now, these might be loss-making commuter-type services that need heavy subsidies that Great British Railways would close down if they were only interested in in covering their own costs. I mean, nobody I think quite grasps the point of of the designation in the first place, whoever makes it, and and what the consequence of it actually is. So we'd like to hear more about that.
But we'd also like to hear more at the simple textual level of what may and must and must and may actually mean and how they interact between clauses 25 and clause 31, which was Lady Jones' point. And although I don't agree with her as to what the effect should be, I think we would all agree that the text should make some coherent sense. So the government has, I think, quite a big job to do in explaining all this to us at this stage. I want to express, before I move on to my own amendments, I want to express support for Lord the amendment standing in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Faulkner of Worcester. The power of, and it doesn't apply only to heritage railways, we will come to it again, I think, later on.
This power on the part of Great British Railways to go around seizing private assets. I mean, of course, it'll only be possible, I imagine, after the government has come around to supporting the Conservative policy of leaving the European Convention on Human Rights, because I believe that would preclude going around seizing private assets. So what is it the government intends here, and why should it be trusted with such broad and unlimited powers if it has only a very limited and specialist focus in view? I think that is to some extent the question being asked by the noble Lord, Lord Faulkner. My own amendment 157 is slightly is a detail sort of amendment.
There is in in clause 32, subsection 3, exempts Great British Railways' award of contracts from publishing the awards in advance, or publishing the the contracts in advance. Now, I can certainly see the main point of publishing contracts that are going to be awarded in advance in a competitive tendering situation is to allow people access, people who wish to bid for them, to have a fair and equal knowledge of what is coming up so that they can make a decision whether to bid and put the resources into doing so. And if you're only allowed, for some reason, ideological reason we don't understand, to award the contract to one party, then obviously there isn't going to be any competition. But there is actually considerable public interest, and I would say parliamentary interest, in the contracts that are going to be awarded. And they should be exposed to the light of day before they're awarded, and we shouldn't simply find out after they've been awarded what they contain, because it might be the case that public scrutiny could have improved the terms of the contract considerably.
So this blanket exemption should be removed and the status quo maintained, and that's the effect of amendment 157.
My amendment 160 to leap the existing Passenger Railway Services Bill to cause some excitement on the part of Noble Baroness Lady Pidgeon, but it's there simply because it is a necessary consequence of the amendment tabled by my noble friend Lord Greely allowing for private sector or corporate sector operation on the railway. Since the sole effect of that bill is to prevent the Secretary of State from awarding new or renewed franchises to anybody other than a state railway company, clearly it has to be annulled before my noble friend's amendments could be brought into effect. So it was simply there as a necessary consequence rather than the attempted revolution that she spies. But nonetheless, it would be a very good thing indeed to do.
Gerard Peter Hendy
My Lords, may I deal first with amendments 153 to 155 and 160 and 153A, 154A, 155A and 155B. As has been made very clear since the government since this government came into office, it was elected with a clear mandate to nationalise the railways, a policy that's supported by three quarters of the public according to recent surveys. We're ensuring that GBR is owned by the British people and run in their interests and not in the interests of private profit. Repealing the Public Ownership Act or allowing ministers to award service contracts to private companies, even those that are employee-owned, would return franchising to our railway. And as the noble Lord Greely and others have said, franchising as it has evolved has failed passengers, it's caused costly inefficiency and created a system focused on attributing blame between multiple operators and the infrastructure manager rather than fixing the problems that plague our railway.
Chris Grayling
Will the Minister allow me? I hate to correct him, but he's talking about franchising. Everyone on this side's been talking about concessions of the kind that happen in London. Could he confirm that under this legislation or after this legislation, the Elizabeth line will still be able to be operated by a private company?
Gerard Peter Hendy
Noble Lord stood up before I'd got time to move on to the concession model, so perhaps I'd better do that. The Williams Review looked for a concession model for operating passenger services and the last government had that review in draft in 2021 and published it in 2022. It could have taken forward that model for the four operators then in public ownership, including indeed any version of employee ownership it chose, but it didn't. And the reason why it didn't is that the private sector owning groups at that time were opposed to that model and continued to be so until the election of this government, whose manifesto commitment is for public ownership which the public supports. Concessions would mean the taxpayer continuing to fund profits of private sector operators and their shareholders and money that could instead be spent on improving or reducing the subsidy.
Concessions are inflexible, they're suitable for metro-style services like London Overground or indeed a big city's bus network, but not the national railway network which will benefit from the flexibility of a directing mind able to enact change through new timetables, tickets and fares and is regarded by passengers as a network.
Daniel Moylan
My Lords, I suspect the noble Lord will be interrupted several times during the course of this. And I don't really wish to interrupt him here because he may come on to answer my question, but he may well do so. But how is designation of services by the Secretary of State compatible with the flexibility, not excessive flexibility I hope because otherwise passengers wouldn't know where the trains were from one day to the next.
But how is designation by the Secretary of State, which suggests something that is put in place for a reasonably long term, compatible with flexibility?
Gerard Peter Hendy
I think I'll answer the noble Lord's point in due course, but I just wanted to finish on the basic model to start with.
Mark Harper
So if you'll just forgive me, well no, no, no. I want to finish a sentence. I want to ask him, the Minister, the noble Lord the Minister, a specific question about something he said, which I think I'm perfectly entitled to do, and I didn't want him to move on to the next section. So he was quite clear that he doesn't want to have a model of any description, including concessions, where private companies are making any profit at all. So can I ask him to explain then the point that I raised, which is why in that case is the government content to continue to have rolling stock owned by Roscos, which make significant profits, if by his definition, one which I do not agree with, but by his definition, those profits are then being taken out of the system and not used to reduce taxpayer subsidy.
Gerard Peter Hendy
Well, I will deal with that point if I may, just in passing, before I finish on the original point, just to say that actually the other reason why the government is committed to the course of action it's embarked on is to stop the friction between train operation and infrastructure operation, which is at the root of many of the problems. The rolling stock companies are not in that position. People don't spend hours and hours and huge volumes of money circulating around the system compensating for delays, and it's a much simpler process. But the noble Lord will also have seen the Secretary of State's recent comments on rolling stock, where she said that in appropriate cases in the future, we'll consider whether in future leasing is the right thing to do. Let me finish on the point about franchising and concessions.
I would just say one thing to the noble Lord Grayling about cooperatives, which is that there will be nothing to prevent a GBR subsidiary having an element of cooperative ownership so long as GBR has a controlling interest. And although I think he's wrong about the need to adjust the legislation for it, it is an interesting proposition, and this model doesn't rule it out. Let me look at amendments 148 to 152, which is at the heart of the designation issue if I may.
Chris Grayling
Before he moves on, could I just ask one of those three questions that results of that, just in terms of categorization of GBR companies. Would a GBR company be able to be a private but public interest company with employees having a stake?
Gerard Peter Hendy
Let me answer that in correspondence because I think that deserves a careful response.
It is worth clarifying what this designation issue is all about and what the designation of passenger services by the Secretary of State is for. It's designed to set the limits of the services that may be delivered by GBR, in other words, the services that the Secretary of State has not devolved to mayors. The designation of passenger services will not be a detailed document like a timetable, instead it will broadly set out the responsibilities for the running of services between relevant authorities. For example, exemption from the Secretary of State's designation is the method by which passenger services were devolved to Transport for London. A draft Secretary of State designation was published on gov.uk on the 20th of January, which helps demonstrate what it would look like, and if noble lords would like to see a copy, I will send it to them after this debate.
It's the public service contract that the Secretary of State will issue to GBR under clause 31 that will require passenger services to be provided and through which those services will be funded. The contract will define the services in more detail for the purposes of describing what is being funded. That's a separate process to the designation, which is really all about devolution. This is relevant to the noble Lord Lindsley's point the other day about how passenger services are funded, and I thank the noble Lord Lindsley for a productive conversation on that during the recess. There is nothing in these clauses that can be used as a backdoor for the privatization of passenger services, and nor does designation affect open access or freight services.
I hope this reassures noble lords that this is what it is and no more, and I hope the noble baroness can withdraw her amendment. On amendments 149 to 151 from the noble Lord Grayling, I agree with him in the first part of his speech, and I hope that he's already reassured from that explanation I've just been through. But let me be clear, designation is not a detailed service specification, nor does it determine network access nor capacity allocation. It doesn't interact at all with the question about whether freight or open access services can run on the network, and it doesn't prevent any of those services from securing access, which is a separate process. Ministers' designation powers do not override or conflict with GBR's role in making access decisions, and they do not interact, conflict with, or undermine the safeguards for freight or other operators.
Designation powers are simply a method to demonstrate where devolution to local authorities such as TFL has occurred, and that is all. Moving to the topic of public service contracts, as in amendments 157 and 158, the government is required to transparently publish relevant information about the contract, such as contract dates and the parameters of financial compensation, within two months of entering into the contract. Publishing pre-award information for a public service contract a year in advance would be unnecessary and impractical, and in fact this requirement was already disapplied in the Public Ownership Act 2024 as this is no longer appropriate to the new model. In the old system, publishing such information in advance provided transparency and allowed prospective operators to challenge a proposed direct award and argue a competition should be held instead. In the new system, such challenges would serve no purpose as the Secretary of State is required to only award the service contract directly to a public operator.
The focus for public service operators should be delivering for passengers with efficient and clear reporting and not building in unnecessary delays. GBR's business plan will ensure transparency as it will describe GBR's passenger service intentions and this will be consulted on before it's funded and implemented. Public and industry will have ample time to review it and the ORR will be able to provide comments on it before being signed off by the Secretary of State. As I explained during the funding groups, the business plan is the method through which GBR activities are made transparent and it's held accountable for them. This ensures appropriate scrutiny can take place ahead of the contractual process.
Daniel Moylan
My Lords, before the noble Lord moves on, the business plan operates at one level of generality. It's most unlikely, I think, that the business plan is going to contain detailed specifications of what stations are going to be served on such services as may be provided, say, on the Chiltern line or on the Brighton main line, what the frequencies are, when they might stop, and so forth. But those things would be... are of deep interest to passengers who make use of those services, and indeed potentially to others. And they would be contained, I imagine, in any contract that was issued for carrying out those services. And so I think there is a great public interest in seeing this before, and indeed the noble Lord more or less admits that there is a public interest in seeing these things beforehand, but he thinks they're available through the business plan.
Daniel Moylan
I don't think there's any reason to think that. Wouldn't the noble Lord agree that simply allowing the public to see in advance what the contract is that is going to be awarded would allow appropriate feedback and comment that may actually improve the service and do what he wants to do, which is to produce... to create a railway focused on passengers?
Gerard Peter Hendy
So I would completely agree with the noble Lord that it's important that passengers know what... what potential service improvements or changes are to be made, but I don't agree with him that that's the... that... that publishing pre-award information for a public service contract a year in advance would satisfy that... that aim. It's a very... it would be a very cumbersome way of doing what a decent operator should do, which is to consult people in advance of service changes.
Daniel Moylan
But nor would the business plan... nor would the business plan. So is he... it may be that the noble Lord can satisfy my concern by saying that there is an alternative and a better way of doing it, but the business plan is not that way.
Gerard Peter Hendy
I think my answer to the... to the noble Lord is this, which is that the business plan will have quite a lot of detail in it. It may not have every single service change, and it may not be reflective of the future flexibility with which services can be changed. But what I would say to the noble Lord is that it's quite clear to me that actually a responsible operator, and GBR and its subsidiaries will be responsible, will consult people at a time when actually the service specification is capable of being altered. If you publish the contract at any stage before it comes into effect, that is actually a stage after... after changes ought to be made. So, let me turn to amendment 158 from the noble Lord, Lord Parkinson, which was spoken to by my noble friend, Lord Faulkner.
I confirm for the noble Lords that these powers cannot be used to seize heritage assets. Clause 31 makes clear that public service contracts must be awarded in accordance with the Public Service Obligations in Transport Regulations 2023. Heritage passenger transport services are explicitly excluded from the scope of those regulations, meaning a contract cannot contain terms about heritage services or their assets. Clause 32 then explains the terms and conditions that may be included in the public service contract between the Secretary of State and GBR. It says that the contract may require GBR to operate or secure the operation of any additional railway asset, such as a depot.
This is aligned with the existing drafting in the Railways Act 1993 to ensure that GBR can own and operate things that are necessary to run passenger services, such as depots, as operators can today.
This does not, however, give GBR the right to compulsorily seize or take over such assets. There may be exceptional circumstances in the case of shared usage assets between mainline and heritage services, where I would expect that GBR and heritage railways would establish practical arrangements between them, as is done today, but the bill does not give ministers any new powers in this in this area. I hope noble lords are reassured to to...
Chris Grayling
Before the minister sits down, he hasn't actually answered my question about the Elizabeth line. Why is it okay for a commuter from Reading to London to travel on a train which is a private sector concession, but if, for example, the mayor of Manchester wants to run a service from Knutsford to Manchester Piccadilly, that can only be a state-run railway?
Gerard Peter Hendy
I think the mayors of combined authorities with the powers that they've been given are responsible people and how they how they want to do that part of their business which is operating railway passenger services, they should have some freedom freedom to do. The point of this legislation is to deal with the is to deal with the largest part of the railway network and deal with it in a way that produces a network produces a network that's easy to understand and produces a network that the that the public can rely on.
Jones
My lords, well, I thank all noble lords who've contributed to this debate. I feel I haven't really played a full role because I didn't actually interrupt the minister when he was speaking, so sorry about that.
Jones
True. And I'd also... don't interrupt me as well as... And I'd also like to reassure the noble lord Lord Harper that I was not serious when I wanted him to support my amendments. I've had a tough few weeks for various reasons and I think my sense of humour is slipping, my jokes aren't landing quite as well. On the... and perhaps because I'm tired, I'm actually a little bit sympathetic about some of the things that Lord the noble lord Lord Grayling has said.
I don't have much faith in politicians either, really, particularly secretaries of state who seem to think they've got all all the answers. So, you know, I can I can sympathize with that. And on the devolved mayors and the and so on, the devolved assemblies, that's a very good point as well and perhaps needs clearing up in subsequent... I do feel there's gaps in the bill, which is the point I was trying to make originally. I note the minister's the noble lord the minister's commitment and his commitment for the government and so on, but really these are drafting issues that ought to be mopped up and I don't see why that that hasn't been done.
The bill has to be clearer. I'd also like to thank the noble lord Lord Moylan for talking about my textual acuity. I'm sad to say this is other people's textual acuity, I'm afraid to say, and I stand up here as just a puppet, obviously caring very much about the issues. But I I seriously think that there's bits in this bill that need or gaps in this bill that need filling in. And I'm I think I'm going to have to keep coming back to this.
Speaker 1
Is it your lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? It is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 149, Lord Grayling, not moved. Question is that clause 25 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say content.
Contrary not content, the contents have it. In clause 26, 150, Lord Grayling, not moved.
Not moved.
Speaker 1
The question is that clause 26 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. Clause 27, amendment 151, Lord Greyling, not moved.
Speaker 1
The question is that clause 27 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. The question is that clauses 28 to 30 stand part en bloc.
As many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. In clause 31, amendment 152, Baroness Jones, not moved.
Speaker 1
155A and 155B, Lord Greyling, not moved. The question is that clause 31 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.
After clause 31, amendment 156, Lord Moylan, not moved.
Not moved.
Speaker 1
158, Lord Parkinson and Lord Faulkner, not moved. The question is that clause 32 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.
After clause 32, amendment 159, Lord Moylan, not moved. And 160, Lord Moylan, not moved. We come to clause 33, amendment 161, Lord Moylan.
Daniel Moylan
My Lords, I shall be fairly brief in opening this debate, although it contains a large number of amendments in my name, because the real purpose is to give the government an opportunity to set out its policy and its plans on two crucial areas. The first, which is connected to amendment 161, relates to fare evasion, which has become, as I think everyone is aware, a very much more a social issue, a problem of widespread crime, than it ever has been in the past and needs tackling, it needs attention given to it. Government information estimates that between 350 million and 400 million a year is lost through fare evasion and ticketless travelling. And fare evasion is associated with another great social evil which concerns me, and I know concerns the noble Lord the Minister, which is assaults on railway staff. They remain a significant concern and fare enforcement can itself be a trigger for threatening or violent behaviour.
No longer the solitary ticket collector wearing his uniform wandering up and down the corridor of the railway collecting fares. Now it is of necessity a group of three or four revenue protection officers working closely together as they go through the railway car seeking to collect fares. And that is because of the potential for violence which now has to be reckoned and taken very seriously in a way that was never the case in the past.
Last month the government confirmed that it's developing a new cross-industry framework supported by improved data sharing to identify persistent fare evaders, deter repeat offending, and recover unpaid fares. Can the minister shed some light on what that framework is going to involve? Will it form part of the long-term rail strategy? My amendment 161 requires the long-term rail strategy to include credible plans for dealing with fare evasion, um, and for the protection of staff, particularly in that connection. When does the government expect the framework to be published and implemented?
Turning to 161A, I want to explore a question of some political interest. Both the noble lord and I were closely involved for a number of years in Transport for London in different capacities. One of the features was that the fares were set by the mayor. Not many people always realize this. TfL made many operational decisions, but they did not in fact have the power to set the fares for their own services.
You might find that, might say that's a little bit odd. But the advantage of giving that power directly and personally to the mayor was of course political accountability, that the mayor could be held responsible for the fare setting by Transport for London for its passenger services. Now I know there are pros and cons to that. In my amendment here opens the discussion as to the role of the Secretary of State in setting fares. As far as I can see under the bill as drafted, the Secretary of State has no role in the setting of fares, and therefore there is no accountability for fares to the public or to Parliament.
Of course it could be said in a normal business that if you set your fares or your prices too high, your customers will go elsewhere. But in this sort of Soviet model, there is nowhere else to go except for the odd residual open access service that might be allowed to continue in operation for a short time. So how do we square this circle? How do we have fares set in a way which isn't directly and obviously open to political manipulation, but has a degree of accountability so that the customer cannot simply be ripped off? The customer who has nowhere else to go, no choice to make, cannot simply be ripped off.
I don't think that the bill, because it's followed this ideological route, that the bill has given a satisfactory answer to that question. I'd like to hear what the noble lord the minister has to say about it. I'm sure he's given very considerable thought to it, but um, it's not, not in my view satisfactorily resolved. I then have a number of other amendments in the group: 162, 163, 164, 166, 167, 168, 169, 170, 171, 172, 173, 174, and 175, which I will speak to in one go very briefly. These concern discounts on fares.
Now the government has given verbal assurances that for example veterans, former members of the armed forces, are going to have their discounted travel on the railways maintained. But there is nothing in the bill that protects the categories that exist at the moment. And indeed should they be protected?
Is it the government's intention that they should be protected? We don't know. If you want to book a ticket using a railcard and you click the drop-down box, I mean I have, should say at this point, I am the possessor of a senior railcard. If when I book my ticket I click the drop-down box in order to find the senior railcard so I can take advantage of it, the list of railcards that drops down from which I could potentially choose is huge. It's very large.
Is it the government's intention, some of them are quite regional cards, some of them are for strange categories of person, they've obviously been built up over a long history and never really been weeded. Should they be weeded? What is the government's intention? None of this is safe to us in the bill and no protections are put in place for those persons we believe should continue to benefit from those discounts. So these amendments are there to explore all of that and to give the government the opportunity to put on the record now at the dispatch box, if not on the face of the bill, what their clear intentions are, what commitment they're making to those who benefit from discounted rail travel at the moment.
Speaker 30
Amendment proposed, clause 33, page 18, line 37, at end insert the words as printed on the marshalled list.
Caroline Pidgeon
I think I'm going to speak at this point because I've got quite a lot to say and want to set out my amendment in this group. But one of the most important areas for passengers is fares, and the cost of catching a train is often key to the decision to choose the train rather than a different mode of transport or indeed not to travel at all. And the fare system as it currently stands is incomprehensible to most people, probably even the noble lord the minister. And it's not trusted. And people always feel they could have got a better deal somewhere else, perhaps on a different app or if they'd gone and bought their ticket in person, they often feel they're being ripped off.
So we strongly believe that for the railway to be truly passenger-centered, it needs to offer incentives for passengers to try the railway and a loyalty scheme for regular passengers. And we believe Great British Railways needs to look at how to get more people using the railway rather than cutting trains to reduce costs. And there are good initiatives in other European countries such as the Netherlands, including they have tap-in and tap-out for their whole network. And I'm aware there are some innovations in the UK which I'll come on to. But we've seen in London, Transport for London is a trusted brand and its fare caps are trusted and there's great transparency.
And I think there's a lot we can learn from that. So my amendment 165 today, which has also been signed by the noble lord Lord Hampton, is about amending the bill to establish a rail miles scheme which would allow for discounted fares for frequent travelers. So our rail miles scheme would extend the concept of air miles and promote greater use of the railway and domestic tourism by making journeys on our railways as valuable a commodity as air miles are seen to be today. So many people I know talk about air miles in conversation and their accumulation of them. So why not have rail miles as well?
It would promote the railway network, reward loyal passengers, and be a brilliant way of promoting domestic tourism where passengers are able to accumulate rail miles as they currently can air miles. And it would be a really good way to promote lower carbon transport. So our new clause would be a step change for the railways, rewarding frequent passengers and surely would be part of the added value of this new publicly owned railway.
Now, a similar scheme is currently in operation on Eurostar for international travel. Passengers can join Club Eurostar and earn points that can be used to pay for journeys, discounts on bookings, and upgrades to seats, amongst other benefits. But there are also excellent schemes run internationally, and I thank the library for some information on this. SNCF have a scheme in France which allows you to earn points with every booking, which can be used for complimentary tickets, discounts on services, or donated to environmental organisations. DB BahnBonus operates on Deutsche Bahn services throughout Germany and for business in the Netherlands, Sweden, and Croatia.
Loyalty points can be used for free e-tickets, partner vouchers, and first-class upgrades. In Italy, they have a scheme that's available on high-speed rail, and points can be used for free travel and other awards. In the US, Amtrak customers can access Amtrak Guest Rewards program, which lets customers earn points for train travel and other purchases and services. And even in China, the China Railway loyalty program enables passengers to earn points by buying tickets for railway journeys, and under their program, young members and senior passengers can also earn additional points, which customers can redeem for free tickets. And we have seen innovation in this country.
Avanti West Coast has its Club Avanti scheme, which has a tiered program for loyal travellers. And with that scheme, I think now, and I looked on their website over the weekend, I think they've now got a million members, and it's hugely successful. Members can make nine journeys within 12 months, they get elevated to a different sort of level of standard, and they receive certain free travel tickets, a welcome hot drink, and so on. So, really making it a joy to use the railway and to encourage people to frequently use the railway. And the benefits of such a RailMiles scheme would be to encourage people to return to the railway time and time again, and reward passengers for regular use, and provide additional flexibility and discount.
I commend this idea to the Minister and hope that he will give this serious consideration. The retail sector uses loyalty schemes to keep customers and to understand their interests, their spend, and their patterns. This is something the railway should be embracing, as countries are across the world. The other amendments in this group support the continuation of discounted fares for various groups. I should declare now, I don't yet have a senior railcard, as other noble friends may have here.
I do have a family and friends railcard. And whilst, you know, all of these are really important, obviously they haven't stopped, as we've seen, some of the trains moving over into public ownership. So perhaps the noble Lord the Minister can confirm the situation here, because these also are really important schemes that encourage people to use the railways. I look forward to the Minister's response and to our important RailMiles amendment, which we think would be a game-changer for passengers and for the railway.
Anthony Berkeley
My Lords, I have a couple of questions for my noble friend on this group of amendments. The first is on amendment 161, which obviously the content of the amendment I support, needs to be done, it would be done anyway, one hopes. But it is a question of whether issues like the recovery of unpaid fares and detection and enforcement would apply to open-access passenger trains, or does somebody else do that, and if so, whom? I'm pleased to see the British Transport Police mentioned there. And for amendment 161A, the level of fares and the comments from the noble Baroness and others on the level of discounts is very important.
I don't think that it's all that complicated. As my noble lord Lord Moylan said, there may be lots of buttons, but certainly in Devon and Cornwall we have, you might call them regional buttons. They only apply there, and they only apply to fares which are able to be used within the area. But on all these things, how much involvement is there by the Secretary of State? Because this is something that's come up several times today.
Is this going to be controlled by the Secretary of State personally, or is actually what I think ministers have been trying for a long time to avoid, is to have micromanagement from Marsham Street and let the people who are running GBR or the open access people do what they're able to do within the legislation.
Speaker 32
I'm standing up partly to add my name to Baroness Pidgeon's very fine amendment, and partly because I hope by standing up I get a bit warmer in this remarkably cold room. My lords, I was going to describe it as Baroness Pidgeon's excellent idea, but from her introduction, it's obviously been used a lot in Europe anyway. So, it's a really, it's good news. Quite a lot of what we've talked about in the last few days has been quite gloomy, and it's just a way to cheer people up with such a good idea. I mean, we know from the lessons from Beeching that if you take people off the railway, they stay off the railway, and if you get people on the railway at the source, they stay on and make longer journeys.
Speaker 31
And we are constantly being told that information is the new gold. This would be a brilliant way to get passenger information so we can start selling them other journeys, perhaps, you know, predicting loads of stuff, which I think is such a good way of doing. We could even link delay repay to it, perhaps, which anybody who's been struggling like me with Avanti's delay repay and its Byzantine system will, it can only be a good thing. Um, also we talked about railcards, and I'd like to associate myself with Lord Moylan's remarks about retaining the armed forces, really important sectors of the community that need free travel. But if we could, and I again, I was shocked to hear Lord Moylan has a senior railcard, and I have just, I have just taken advantage of that myself.
The one question I'd like to ask the minister is why transport is the only sector that seems to be that you have to pay for a discount card after a certain time, students, senior citizens, whereas most places you get it for free, but I think that's another thing entirely. But I, my lords, I think this is part of the brave new world of rail travel in the UK, and I really think we should go with it.
Mark Harper
My Lords, a couple of areas I wanted to focus on. First of all, I strongly support the noble Lord Lord Moylan's amendment 161, insisting that in the rail strategy, ministers must include proposals for preventing and reducing the evasion of fares. I think for two reasons. One, there's clearly a revenue purpose for doing this. But there's also a basic fairness purpose.
There's nothing more irritating for passengers that pay their fares than seeing people that don't, and then nothing happens as a result. The one point I would add is just to look at ways you can build into the system making it more difficult for evasion to happen. There was nothing more irritating, well, there were many more irritating, but on this particular aspect, one of the most irritating things, particularly when I was Secretary of State, was turning up at a station and finding all the ticket barriers were open and people could just wander in and out without having to demonstrate they had a ticket. And I'm afraid when I saw that, I used to take a photograph of the said ticket barriers that were open, send it to my special advisor, and he used to then make the appropriate comments to the appropriate rail company about why they were giving away free money. And it is just irritating.
So I would strongly support my noble friend's amendment, and particularly design in or design out the ability for people to evade tickets. The last thing you want to do is spend a huge amount of money on staff and British Transport Police having to do the enforcement. The best thing is to work out a system where you make it as difficult as possible for people to evade paying in the first place. So that I think is a very good amendment. The second area of amendments which my noble friend has tabled are the ones about discounts and his specific focus on veterans.
And the plea I would make to the minister is this. In clause 34, the government clearly feels that discounted schemes are a good idea, but it's done that thing which often happens in legislation, which is as soon as you have a list of something, the undue specificity problem, because it refers to young, elderly, and disabled people. Although it does have a section which then says there's no prevention of other people being included, the fact that it's only specified those three groups of people inevitably will, I think, focus discounts in those areas. And so I think my plea to the minister would be to reflect on whether, without making the list excessively long, whether that specific proposal from my noble friend to include veterans who are not necessarily otherwise included in one of those other sections would be a welcome addition to the bill. And it would be helpful if the minister, if not today, could indicate whether he would do so and would bring forward an amendment at report stage, and then that would save my noble friend having to retable his amendment.
I suspect his amendment on veterans would get a lot of support. I was taken with the amendment moved by Lady Pidgeon. My only reason for not immediately supporting it has got nothing to do with the quality of the amendment, it's just that I am a bit loath to just have lots of specific things set out in the legislation. I would prefer, frankly, that the discount fare scheme clause was much less specific or was written in a way that would encompass the sort of scheme that she has set out. And so it may be worth the minister considering whether that clause could be better drafted to encompass what the noble lady wants to do with a scheme that reflects somebody's usage as opposed to their characteristics, but also whether it should encompass, if it's going to cover characteristics as well, whether it should encompass the one set out by my noble friend Lord Moylan.
The final point I wanted to make was just to come back to his point, my noble friend Lord Moylan's point, about who is accountable for setting fares. Because clause 33 allows ministers to use their power of direction to give direction to GBR about the level of fares and the structure of fares, but it doesn't require ministers to do so. My noble friend's amendment makes that more explicit. So there is a genuine question here about accountability, and you could make an argument that that runs counter to the point I made about GBR owning these responsibilities and ministers getting out of the business. But equally, ministers are in the business of setting fares.
The government's made a great deal about its policy of freezing rail fares. We made a great deal of limiting rail fares at particular levels and keeping them at the rate of inflation when we were in government, and it seems unlikely to me that ministers are going to not want to get involved in setting fares. So actually, the bill should just be amended, reflecting my noble lord's point, just to make it explicit that it is ministers who set fares and will do so and will give that direction to GBR at the top level, and then GBR will do a lot of the detailed work. And the reason why I think it is inevitable that ministers will end up setting fares is particularly in a nationalised rail industry. The rail industry requires a great deal of subsidy.
That subsidy has to come from taxpayers. The Treasury will set the department a budget, and inevitably rail fares will have to be set to balance the contribution made to running those services from passengers through the farebox and the contribution made by taxpayers coming from the money from the Treasury that goes to the Department for Transport, which then goes to GBR. So inevitably, ministers have to make decisions about fares, and so the bill might as well just reflect the fact that that is going to happen and have a more explicit either a must give this direction to GBR or a clause along the lines of an amendment along the lines of the one set out by my noble friend Lord Moylan, making it explicit that it's not GBR that sets the level and structure of fares, but that is properly a decision for ministers who are democratically accountable. That is what is going to happen, and I think the legislation should therefore reflect reality rather than pretending in some way that ministers are not actually accountable for the fares that are charged to passengers.
Gerard Peter Hendy
My lords, this government wants to make train travel more affordable for everyone, which is why we've announced the first freeze in rail fares for over 30 years. Affordability will also be a key consideration for the Secretary of State in setting the strategic parameters for fares. That's why on the 15th of September we published a fares fact sheet setting out the objectives the Secretary of State will pursue and how this will enable wider fares ticketing and retail reform. Looking at amendments 161 and 161A, I completely agree with the figures that the noble Lord Moylan raised on the rough levels of fare evasion.
But whilst the long-term rail strategy will reflect the need for GBR to protect its revenue, contrary to amendment 161, I don't believe the strategy is the appropriate place to propose exactly how it will do this. The Secretary of State and I announced in July an additional 33.4 million to crack down on fare dodgers with new ticket gates at stations across England, but we must allow these decisions to be made at the right level in an agile manner. And for example, having provided that money, I think it's the job of railway operators to decide which gates go in which stations and will have the most impact. But the noble Lord Moylan is right to raise fare evasion, and I agree with him absolutely, we don't tolerate any assault on any member of staff for any reason, including fare evasion. But decisions on how to tackle fare evasion must be a matter for Great British Railways in collaboration with the British Transport Police and other stakeholders, including mayoral strategic authorities.
Noble Lord Moylan referred to the framework, and in that respect, it will be in place by the end of 2026. I think it's preferable for the operators of the railway to formulate their detailed approaches to fare evasion because we know that this is evolving and it's fast-moving, and it's certainly not something I think you'd want to see in a 30-year strategy. In answer to my noble friend Lord Berkeley, open access operators collect their own fares, they make sure, as should all operators, that the people who travel with them have paid. On amendment 161A about the fare structure, I think it is clear from the bill that the accountability and transparency sought by this amendment are already there. Secretary of State will set fares objectives and controls within which GBR must operate.
Guidance on how GBR should set fares will be periodically reviewed alongside funding decisions, quite clearly because, as noble Lords have remarked, the railway consumes a great deal of public subsidy and it will be reflected in GBR's five-year business plans. GBR would then manage fares within that framework. The fares policy will also be aligned with the long-term rail strategy, meaning GBR will be expected to run the railway on a financially sustainable, efficient, and value-for-money basis, balancing fare income with public funding while supporting an affordable and accessible railway. I believe this gives the Secretary of State appropriate oversight of fares policy, reflecting her accountability to Parliament for the overall objectives and public funding of the railway, whilst allowing GBR to take day-to-day fares decisions. Any significant changes would need to be consistent with the business plan, which the Secretary of State will have already signed off.
This is clearly a superior model than requiring the Secretary of State to approve changes to the structure and level of fares, which would duplicate the existing provisions and potentially reintroduce the very ministerial involvement, detailed involvement in the railway that this bill is seeking to prevent. Turning to amendments 162 to 179 inclusive, save for amendment 165, which I'll come on to, discounted fares are vital in keeping rail travel affordable for many passengers. Under clause 34, as has been remarked, discounts for young, senior, and disabled passengers will continue to be protected in statute. We know that the cost of rail travel can be a significant barrier for these groups, given they're likely to be on lower incomes than other adults, and maintaining these concession schemes in primary legislation ensures that we continue to have an inclusive railway.
It also supports access to employment, education, training and vital services. And that's not to say that the other concessionary schemes are not important, nor that they won't be continued. But the noble Lord Harper had it, which is that actually there is a question about specificity in here, and I agree, and let me explain why, particularly in relation to veterans. The government fully recognizes the enormous contributions that have been made by members of the UK armed forces, veterans and their families. The UK armed forces railcard is one way in which we honor the sacrifices made by this community.
Meanwhile, the 26 to 30 railcard, for example, was introduced in 2018 in recognition of the comparatively high living costs and low earnings of this age group, challenges which remain nearly a decade later. There are no plans to withdraw any of these concession schemes, nor reduce the level of discount. But let me explain why we don't see the desirability of putting this in the statute. Clause 34 has been drafted to provide flexibility in the design and operation of discount fare schemes. By minimizing the number of schemes listed on the face of the bill, we enable GBR to update and evolve concessionary offers as the needs of passengers change.
Amendment 166 would undermine the ability to develop these offers, even when changes would plainly benefit passengers. Take for example recent changes to the non-statutory 16 to 17 saver railcard, which gives young people half-price travel. Saver railcards bought on and after 17th of August 2026 are now valid for a full 12 months from the date of purchase. They will no longer automatically expire when the holder turns 18. Similarly, we expanded eligibility for the statutory disabled persons railcard in September.
Passengers with a long-term impairment, health condition or neurodivergence that has lasted or is expected to last at least 12 months and significantly affects their ability to use rail services will now be able to apply. These kinds of beneficial and common-sense adjustments are more difficult if amendment 166 were voted into the bill. Coming back to the UK armed forces railcards, I should point out that there are currently two railcards in this space. His Majesty's forces railcard costs 21 pounds a year and offers one-third discount to serving personnel, their spouses and dependent children. The veterans railcard is 35 pounds and gives one-third off adults' fares and 60% off for accompanying children, something I hasten to add that would not be possible under amendment 179, which rigidly sets discounts at one-third off, no more and no less.
In future, it might be desirable to combine these railcards to ensure consistent terms and conditions between veterans and serving personnel and their families, or else update the terms to make the railcards more relevant to the people who use them. GBR should be able to consider options like this. If we enshrine more schemes in primary legislation as the noble Lord proposes, it becomes rather difficult to amend and improvement. But for the avoidance of doubt, and from this dispatch box, the government is committed to continuing these entitlements, and indeed as I've just described will endeavor to improve them. On amendment 165 from the noble Baroness Pidgeon, I expect GBR to continue providing current railcard schemes while as I've said innovating to develop new options.
And that's why I welcome the intent of the noble baroness in tabling amendment 165 and also the remarks of the noble Lord Hampton. Once established, GBR will be able to consider, I'm sorry, various means of encouraging more people to travel by rail. Customer loyalty schemes are one of many possible tools, but the noble baroness is right to draw attention to the potential benefits of such schemes, and where they've succeeded, it's generally been through careful commercial design and by responding to customer behavior, as demonstrated by LNER's domestic model and various international programs as she described. Now I should say that, unless I'm mistaken, those certainly those international examples don't rely on specific legislative provision. Loyalty schemes are simply one form of discounting and do not need to, in our current view, to be expressly provided for in this bill.
But I want GBR to have the opportunity to assess the evidence and determine what works best for passengers before we prescribe it. Any loyalty scheme would, for instance, need to reflect the diversity of rail users. The needs of regular commuters may differ significantly from those occasional leisure travelers, and different market conditions might apply in each case. But I agree with the noble baroness on the potential benefits loyalty schemes can bring, and I'm grateful to her for raising this issue. I'm very happy to discuss it with her further outside this committee.
Speaker 33
I hope that what I've said enables the noble Lord and noble baroness to withdraw their amendment.
Daniel Moylan
My Lords, I'm grateful to noble Lords for what I think has been a useful debate and also to the noble Lord the Minister for his response. I understand the framework is to be published in the not too distant on fare evasion is to be published in the not too distant future. I'm happy to wait to see that. It is a great pity, we say this all the time, that we're asked to pass this legislation irrevocably without being able to see the documents that accompany it and that give effect to it. So I'm grateful for his answer on that.
But on the question of what is the right level at which to have a fare evasion strategy, my amendment is clearly a strategic amendment. It asks for a strategic response, and that it should be in the long-term rail strategy seems appropriate. The Minister's view is that these matters should be dealt with by individual train operators at more or less the station level. Now, there are very important things to do at the station level, of course, but there is something missing, and that is the strategic layer, the thing that brings it together, the single directing mind, the source of best practice, the pattern which gives commonality to the way in which enforcement is carried out. That doesn't happen if everything is left to individual rail subsidiaries working at the station level.
So when the Minister said, when the noble Lord said that the right level at which this should be carried out was not in the strategic rail plan, I expected him to go on and tell me what the right level was at which you could have a strategic plan articulated, because that might be a positive response. We generally agree, we did agree that things something must be done, but where is it to be done? Where are those strategic elements of it to be done? And there came no answer. So I suspect this is something we will have to refer to return to when we reach report stage.
I still think there are serious issues about accountability for fares on a no-choice railway, which is what the government is imposing on the country, a no-choice railway. One provider, one decision maker, one single directing mind. While the Secretary of State can give guidance on fares, I would expect that to be at the level of telling Great British Railways how much it has to generate in fares given the level of subsidy that is available, which will be a decision made on a, we hope, on a five-year basis, and giving indications of that sort. If it is left to Great British Railways to decide what to do with those instructions, then it will be for Great British Railways to decide, without accountability, whether the pain of such direction, as there's always pain with fares, there's always pain, how that pain is allocated. Should it be that commuter fares should be higher and that long-distance fares should be eased to encourage more long-distance travel and compete with the domestic rail services?
Should it be that there should be more discount schemes and more encouragement for the young, but at the expense of passengers who don't benefit from discount schemes? Should it be a greater burden of fares on first-class travelers and less so on those traveling in standard class? Now, I'm not suggesting there are right or wrong answers to questions like that, that's not my point at the moment. My point is decisions like that have to be made, and they are the decisions which allocate the pain. And there is no accountability about all of this, and there is no choice.
There is no other railway to use, apart from a few residual open access services which will eventually wind down. I don't think this can be left. I think the bill has to have some notion of how this is addressed so that we have proper accountability. And again, we're going to come back to it. On discounts, I understand what the noble lord says.
I must say I think there is some confusion on his part. On the one hand, we should trust GBR to do this, to make these decisions, because they are part of a broader picture of stimulating demand and indeed rewarding usage, as the noble Baroness Lady Pidgeon suggested, through loyalty schemes and so forth, which she gave many examples. But on the other, he is tying himself now at the beginning and possibly for years to come to the existing discount schemes and not being willing to be open about them, whether they really, I mean, if you've tied yourself to those, there is not going to be a lot of scope, unless the Treasury is very generous, for additional discount schemes over and above that. So I think there is a bit of a problem, but there's a particular problem, I think, in relation to former members of the armed forces. And I think that is something that we are likely to return to on report.
But in the meantime, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Speaker 30
Is it your lordship's pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 161A, Lord Moylan, not moved. The question is that clause 33 stands part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content.
Content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. In clause 34, amendment 162, Lord Moylan, not moved. 163, Lord Moylan, not moved.
164, Lord Moylan, not moved. 165, Baroness Pidgeon, not moved.
Lord Moylan, amendments 166 to 179, not moved. The question is that clause 34 stand part of the bill, as many as are of that opinion will say content. Content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.
After clause 34, amendment 180, Lord Moylan, not moved. 181, not moved. 182, Lord Holmes, not moved. The question is that clause 35 stand part of the bill, as many as are of that opinion will say content. Content.
Contrary not content. The contents have it. Before clause 36, amendment 183, Lord Evans.
Evans
My Lords, I rise to move amendment 183 and to speak to no fewer than 10 other amendments that I have in this group, although I hope to be relatively brief for you. First of all, these amendments all concern the powers and duties of the passenger watchdog, the Passenger Council, which is referred to here. And I have a fairly lengthy interest in passenger representation which goes back to 2004 when noble Baroness Featherstone became chair of the London Assembly's Transport Committee and I was appointed her deputy. It was a very wide-ranging role that the committee had, so she asked me to take on the role of reviewing the performance of what was at the time the London Transport Users Committee. And when I went to see them, they were an unusual organisation.
They covered a much larger area than Greater London because they went out to cover the airports as well. They were unusual in my experience because their management board, their supervising board, had more members than they had members of staff, which is quite unusual for an organisation. And although they were very committed to improving transport services in London and very interested and very well informed, a lot of those people had backgrounds in the transport industry and particularly in the rail industry. And they often seemed to feel that the interests of the rail provider were exactly the same thing as the interests of the passengers. They couldn't really discriminate between the two.
They were products of what my noble friend Lord Moylan, who sadly is not in his place at the moment because I'm sure he would agree with me, they were products of what he calls the no-choice railway or the Soviet-type railway. They'd been in public service for so long that they thought they knew exactly what the passengers wanted without actually asking the passengers themselves. So the amendments here are designed to bring a little more focus to the Passenger Council and also designed to give it more powers as well, so that it becomes a body which has some real teeth on behalf of passengers and to differentiate between what might be in the interests of the railway providers and in the interests of their passengers. So the amendment I'm moving, 183, introduces a new clause which will define the purpose of the Passenger Council with six different sub-clauses. First of all, to champion the interests of all users and potential users of the railway, of course in particular the needs of disabled passengers.
Then to advocate for reliability, and we list the various measures of reliability of passenger services. To advocate for safety and security of passengers on the railways. A broad heading to advocate for passengers' comfort and onboard experience, and I briefly touched on this at the last meeting when we debated this, including things such as the availability of power sockets and the provision of Wi-Fi for passengers, which is not something which was important in the past but certainly is going forward into the future. There's a clause about advocating for affordability and value for money, and there's a clause looking forward to advocate for passenger growth and coverage. So I'm pleased to move this amendment which spells out the function of the council and aligns it better to what we know are passengers' priorities.
Now I also have, as I stated, 10 amendments and very briefly I will visit those. 186 amends paragraph B of clause 36 to change making efficient use of funds to making ensuring value for money through a cost-benefit analysis, which I think is a stronger and more focused definition. Amendment 187 adds a requirement for ministers and GBR to respond to Passengers' Council representations within one month. And I think that's important because otherwise these things can drag on. It actually requires a timely response.
Amendment 188 adds a requirement for the Passengers' Council to assess user satisfaction every 12 months. And this is particularly intended to deal with the tendency of organisations like this to conflate the needs of the provider with the need of the users, and a survey will actually give them a clear steer about what they should be looking for. Amendment 189 effectively gives the Passengers' Council the role and power of dealing with unsatisfied requests rather than referring them to the ORR. It's a faster process, it's less bureaucratic and it makes the Passengers' Council stronger. Amendment 190 means that contraventions of the license or condition of any passenger license will have to be referred to the ORR and to the Secretary of State.
It removes a potential loophole which would have the potential to be commonly used to avoid doing that. Amendments 191, 192 and 193 are all designed to ensure that where a contravention of a license is referred to, action is actually taken by the ORR.
So we leave out particularly option two which is to take no action if a contravention has been referred to them. And amendment 194 replaces may with must in line 12 to again ensure if the Passenger Council prepares a report of an investigation, then it must publish it. This will ensure more openness and accountability for the passenger watchdog. And finally amendment 195 adds a requirement to publish such a report within six months of the investigation again providing a deadline. So that is a brief run through the various amendments that I've moved here and I look forward to hearing the minister's comments and indeed comments of other members of the committee.
Speaker 30
Amendment proposed before clause 36 insert the new clause as printed on the marshalled list.
Jones
My Lords, I have seven amendments in this group. I'm not sure I'm going to be brief but I'll try. So I heard a groan there, was that right? My amendments 18... well, my amendment 204A is rather daring because it's trying to improve on the amendment by the noble lady Lady Brinton and the noble lord Lord Holmes who could be said to have more experience of what they're trying to do. My amendments 183A and 204B seek to put strong rights-based duties for passengers and disabled people as well as the general duties of both watchdogs, the Passengers Council as well as the London Transport Users Committee.
These are to protect and promote the rights of interests of users and potential users of railway services and to protect and promote the rights and interests of disabled persons. These general duties are very important as discussed on day four regarding my amendments 330K and 334A. The bill will deregulate the condition in current legislation that railway licenses, all types including GBR's license, must have a regard to general duties. The rail minister has suggested that this won't matter because the ORR and the Secretary of State would still be bound by license conditions when setting the license conditions. However, passenger-related and accessibility-related conditions will not be set by these bodies as they're moving to the Passengers Council which will not itself be subject to the general duties.
It is in this sense a two-step deregulation of standard setting which will sever all links between the general duties and the setting of passenger-related license conditions. And this is not to mention the fact that all monitoring and enforcement is also moving from ORR, the much stronger regulator, to the Passengers Council, a much weaker body without any enforcement powers of its own. So the general duties of the council become of pivotal importance. Yet it has just two duties: a duty to be cost-efficient in all its functions and a duty for disabled people which is nowhere near strong enough and might merely be seen as a way of shifting statutory responsibility for accessibility to the council away from the ORR. It's extremely odd to see that there's no duty to promote the interests of passengers.
If you compare these to the clause 18 passenger and disability duty of 18(2)(a), it is very clear that these duties are the most minimal possible version. Returning to my amendments 183A and 204B, it's vital that these lay down the need to protect and promote the rights and interests of passengers and disabled people.
And ideally this model would also be used in clause 18, which would be a much needed strengthening of the language there too. Protect and promote is a rights-based formulation that ensures not just improvement, but also protection and non-regression of existing standards. And rights and interests is much more powerful than simply needs and interests. In particular, why should disabled people have anything less than a rights-based standard? And it's also important that passengers and disabled people have separate subsections.
This would be a crucial part of legal clarity, ensuring that each group has equal standing and preventing the possibility of any trade-offs overall between different groups of passengers. On 184A and 204C, as part of this stronger rights-based approach, these amendments would omit the cost-efficiency duty from both watchdog's general duties, which is essentially an overarching duty to all their functions. Again, it shouldn't be possible to compromise rights standards or enforcement based on cost. The concept of rights creates its own minimum baseline. And 188B and 204A, to move to the Passengers' Council itself, let's be clear that this is little more than the existing watchdog Transport Focus, with largely the same provisions as in current legislation, a model that hasn't been updated since 2005.
The government's cost impact assessment for the Railways Bill is illuminating as to the thought processes behind this. Pages 65 to 66 explain that it chose to use Transport Focus because this required the least change. It acknowledges that the simplest governance and oversight arrangements would have been for the ORR to retain and expand its passenger regulatory duties, powers, and that a new body would have been best placed to develop an independent culture. The only new power is to set deadlines when conducting investigations, that's in clause 40. However, this is extremely limited, requiring consultation with the person on what deadline should be specified and limited to investigations only, not the collection of information for other functions, review.
Yet, this is the body intended to take on all passenger-related standard setting, monitoring, enforcement from the much stronger regulator, the ORR. So I would say that quite a bit needs to be done to make this situation anywhere near adequate. And my amendment 188B expands the power to request information for any of its functions, not only when an active investigation is underway. And my amendment 202A requires the council to publish any substantial written advice it gives under clause 40, that would regard the most important kind of advice given to ministers, the ORR, GBR, or operators, often regarding high-level issues of policy, and for which there's currently no duty of clarity, no duty of transparency towards the public. I'm also in favor of amendment 194 from the noble Lord, Lord Evans of Gieseborough, roughly, which would require the council...
Almost. Exactly. ...which would require the council to publish its investigation reports. Currently the council has only an optional power to publish or even to prepare reports of its investigations, and if the minister was referred by ministers, must obtain their consent before publishing or disclosing that report. Now, I'm so keen on this bill going through, but I just think it needs some holes, gaps closed, and these amendments cover some of them.
Mark Harper
My Lords, relatively a couple of brief interventions.
So I think my noble friend's amendment, Lord Evans's amendment 183 to set up clear purposes for the Passengers' Council. Now, I'm sure the Minister will argue that because the Passengers' Council, Transport Focus its operating name, has been set up under statute and then amended by a number of other statutes, it does have clear purposes to advocate for passengers. But there may be an argument about bringing it up to date and setting it all out and balancing those needs, because actually Transport Focus's, or the Passengers' Council's, depending how we want to refer to it, remit is now actually quite broad and doesn't just cover rail, but also encompasses multi-modal travel and also roads as well. So there is an argument about just being clear about what we want it to do. That's the first point.
The second point is I'm afraid I really can't support amendment 184A, which removes the Passengers' Council's responsibilities to take into account costs and the need to make efficient use of them. And the reason why I can't support that is if you actually look at some of the statutory roles that it's given in this legislation, there are two very important ones. One is on setting standards that have to be complied with and also improvement plans. Now, I don't think you can have a body that's setting standards that have to be complied with by railway passenger services and station services providers, which, of course, because of other legislation, basically means a body that's entirely funded by the taxpayer, and also improvement plans that effectively have to be delivered by a body funded by the taxpayer. I don't think the Passengers' Council should be able to set such standards and improvement plans with no regard at all for how much those things are going to cost.
Because if you don't have to have any regard for cost, you will specify a massively expensive gold-plated service, which we might all be lovely, which we might all want to see, but would be at a sufficient cost that it would drive people off of the railways. These things are always a balance. You have to look at the services that you want, the services that may be required by passengers, but you do have to look at the cost of providing them. And there is a balance there to be struck, and also once you've specified the cost, whether it's the farepayer that's paying for them, the taxpayer that's paying for them, or a balance of the two. So I think it's really important that the Passengers' Council, when it's exercising its statutory responsibilities, has to look at the cost of these things.
Now, that doesn't mean it can't say, "Here are the standards or the improvement plans or the things we want to see." We recognize they're going to have a significant cost to them. There are some provisions in the legislation which require that the Secretary of State has to sign these things off. So it may be that there is a choice to be made, and it may be that there is a choice to improve the services at a significant cost. But the Passengers' Council can't just make these decisions with no insight or thinking into how much the costs are going to be.
That doesn't make any sense at all, and in fact will likely be self-defeating because it will drive up the cost of delivering rail services, which will actually price people off of them.
The final, the final point I would make is on amendment 333A, which is the requirement to have, which doesn't allow the Secretary of State to appoint a, in the name of my noble friend Lord Moylan, it says that the Secretary of State cannot appoint a person as chairman of the Passengers' Council. So not, not all the members, but the chairman or chair, without the approval, without a pre-appointment scrutiny having taken place by the Transport Committee of the House of Commons and that having been put forward to the Secretary of State. As with all of these things, that doesn't mean the Secretary of State can't go ahead and make an appointment even if the House of Commons Transport Committee says it's not a very good idea. That's always open to the government to not take any notice of the committee and bear the political consequences. But this amendment says that it can't make the appointment without that process having taken place.
And it seems to me, given the importance of the role, given the fact that under this legislation it's having some extra powers to make some significant recommendations, having pre-appointment scrutiny take place of the person that's going to lead the council seems to me a very sensible point, I think. It doesn't, doesn't tie the Secretary of State's hands excessively. It doesn't say they can't appoint their preferred candidate even if the House of Commons disagree. But it just says there has to be a process. I think one of the things we've found, as a final point, from the pre-appointment scrutiny processes that have already taken place, sometimes with ministers following the recommendations, sometimes them not, is the transparency and the scrutiny that takes place and the ability for questioning to take place about the priorities of the candidate, what it is they want to do with the job.
That is an unalloyed good thing, that transparency. And I don't see why ministers wouldn't be able to either support this amendment or, if they think there's something defective in my noble friend Lord Moylan's the drafting of his amendment, bring back one of their own. I think this would actually be an important improvement to scrutiny and the operation of the Passengers' Council, and I certainly would give it my support.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, this group of amendments starts to look at the Passengers' Council, which we think is actually one of the stronger parts of the bill. At the other end, we were keen to try and understand best practice in terms of complaints, and we did table a probing amendment to ensure that a complaint would first go to the operator, so mostly Great British Railways, before the Passengers' Council could intervene, which was generally seen as best practice. But the government did respond explaining that there may well be circumstances where the watchdog would need to investigate before or instead of operators, such as if the issue is systemic or cross-industry. So we have accepted that point and therefore we haven't tabled any amendments in this particular area. Clearly these amendments before us are trying to really tease out the powers of the Passengers' Council.
But for me, from the earlier group that I spoke to some weeks ago now, I really want to understand how London TravelWatch fits within the Passengers' Council in all aspects of this work, because issues relating to the London TravelWatch area, which as we've heard goes far beyond London, those passengers should have the same level of service and engagement and representation as those outside would with the Passengers' Council.
So I think really getting some understanding about that and that might be something that we have in discussion after committee stage to make sure that London TravelWatch's role is equal where it should be with the passengers council to make sure all passengers are strongly represented.
Speaker 37
My Lords, I would like to thank all noble Lords who have spoken in this debate. If the government are going to create a new passengers council funded with public money, then value for money must be built into its operation from the outset. That is why we strongly support amendment 186 tabled by my noble friend Lord Evans of Gilsland. For the same reason, we cannot support amendments 184A and 204C from the noble Baroness Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb. These amendments would remove the cost efficiency duties from the passengers council and London TravelWatch respectively.
If these bodies are spending taxpayers' money, we see no justification for removing an express requirement to consider the efficient use of those funds. There are other amendments in this group which discuss the relationship between the passengers council and the ORR. The government repeatedly tell us that the ORR will remain a strong and robust independent regulator. Yet under clause 42, when the passengers council refers a contravention to the ORR, the regulator can simply report back on what action, if any, it proposes to take, including its reasons for taking no action. Amendments 191, 192 and 193 tabled by my noble friend Lord Evans give that relationship some actual bite by requiring the ORR to take action where a contravention has been referred to it by the statutory passenger watchdog.
If the passengers council has identified a genuine contravention serious enough to refer to the regulator, why does the bill expressly contemplate the supposedly robust regulator doing nothing? Amendment 187 from my noble friend Lord Evans requires the Secretary of State and GBR to respond within one month to representations from the council. Amendment 188 requires an annual assessment of passenger satisfaction. Amendments 194 and 195 require investigation reports to be published and impose a six-month deadline for publication. Noble Baroness Lady Jones also makes a reasonable transparency point in amendment 202A, requiring substantive written advice from the council to be published, subject to a sensible public interest exception.
One would hope that much of this is what the government intend to do anyway. Finally, amendment 333A in the name of my noble friend Lord Moylan concerns the appointment of the chair of the passengers council. The Transport Committee recommended in February that the preferred candidate should face a pre-appointment hearing, specifically to reinforce the watchdog's independence from both the Secretary of State and GBR. It pointed to comparable arrangements for bodies including the Patient Safety Commissioner, the Housing Ombudsman and the Children's Commissioner. The Transport Committee already conducts pre-appointment scrutiny of the chairs of the ORR and the Civil Aviation Authority.
I therefore very much welcome the minister's decision confirmed this week to accept the committee's recommendation and pursue adding the chair of the passengers council to the list of posts subject to pre-appointment scrutiny.
Amendment 333A simply puts that safeguard into legislation. Given that the government now accepts the principle, I would be grateful if the minister could explain whether he is prepared to accept the amendment or how and on what timetable the government intends to give effect to its new commitment.
Seb Dance
Right, my lords. Before turning to the amendments, I will say a few words regarding terminology. Transport Focus is operating under the name of Passengers Council. Under this bill, it will become the Passenger Watchdog with strengthened powers to make it more effective as a champion for passengers. Although the amendments use the legal name of the Passengers Council, I will be referring to it as the Passenger Watchdog more or less throughout.
Likewise, I will refer to the London Transport User Committee as London TravelWatch. And I would like to just add that the Passenger Watchdog has an accessibility duty which applies when setting standards, as this was brought up by the noble baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb. The watchdog has a duty to make efficient use of public funds. The ORR and the Secretary of State also have to agree to the standards set by the watchdog and are bound by the clause 18 duties, so this provides protection. The reason the watchdog is being given the standard-setting role is because the ORR is a regulator and as such must be fair, impartial, and objective.
We want the watchdog to be a genuine passenger champion, to advocate for its passengers in all things, and this is different from the roles that she was requesting, but the roles are complementary. Now on to amendment 183A and 204B tabled by the noble baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb. These concern a rights-based duty for Passenger Watchdog and London TravelWatch. And as the noble baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb, had mentioned London TravelWatch, I would just like to confirm that London TravelWatch are given largely the same powers under the bill as the Passenger Watchdog, except for standard setting, and they will be consulted on this setting of standards. And this is solely because the because the TravelWatch, because the TravelWatch, but because the Passenger Watchdog applies its standards across the network, whereas London TravelWatch is London or, as some have pointed out, slightly bigger than London remit, so we want to make sure we have a group of standards across all networks.
Mark Harper
Just before the minister moves on, can I can I just check? I know it sounds a bit picky, but it's quite important because it's how the public will understand it. Can I just check the the body that is referred in the bill as the Passengers Council, what is it actually going to be called? Its operating name at the moment is Transport Focus because it has a remit that also covers the operation of the strategic road network. Ministers have referred in various documents that they've published to the Passenger Watchdog, as she has, capital P, capital W.
So is that what it's going to be called? Just I think for the public it would be quite useful just to know what is it called, what is it called legally, are those two things different, just so there's some clarity because actually it's important for passengers to to get their rights that they actually know what the body is they're supposed to be referring to. If it's complicated and difficult and people aren't clear, that will actually reduce its effectiveness, so there's a real-world consequence, I think, for some lack of clarity.
Seb Dance
Thank you for your comments. I think, you know, you make a valid point which is why I brought up the the point about the point regarding what the terminology is because people have been calling things different things. At the moment we're using Passenger Council, Transport Watch. The intention is that it becomes the passenger watchdog because that is all-encompassing. So I'd like to move on.
The drafting of the accessibility duty in the bill ensures that disabled passengers are actively considered even where no specific legal right is engaged. Interests are broader than rights. We are creating a body that can monitor the outcomes seen by disabled passengers, set accessibility standards and advocate for improvements whether they are strictly related to disability rights or not. We are doing this because we want the watchdog to ensure a high standard and a high quality experience for disabled people throughout their journey. By contrast, these amendments risk narrowing the watchdog's scope for advocacy.
The watchdog accessibility's accessibility duty sits alongside wider protections. I will remind noble lords that GBR will be subject to the public sector equality duty as provided for in schedule four of the bill. This will require GBR to proactively consider the rights of disabled people across everything it does. The watchdog's duty to consider the interests and needs of disabled people is complementary and additional to GBR's obligations, meaning that disabled people's rights, interests and all needs are enshrined in the bill. I think we can agree that this is how it should be.
And just to go back on the point that Lord Harper made, as we get move forward with the bill we'll be able to settle on exactly what that name is. I think it's more important to know what the objective of the body will be going forward. Now onto amendments 183 in the name of the noble lord, Lord Evans of Gaisford. The government agrees that the watchdog should be a strong and independent champion for passengers across the rail network. The principle is already at the heart of this bill.
The bill establishes the watchdog with a broad statutory remit to represent passengers, review and investigate issues that affect them and advocate for improvements across the railway. The watchdog's function already encompasses all areas of passenger experience including service quality and the accessibility of passenger services. For example, the watchdog is required to keep a watching brief on passenger matters and collect information relating to passenger experience at clause 37. For the benefit of the passenger, its investigations and standard setting powers are similarly broad. The government has deliberately avoided prescribing a detailed hierarchy of passenger priorities in primary legislation.
The watchdog must have the flexibility to focus its resources on the issues that matter most to the passengers at any given moment. The amendment also risks narrowing the watchdog's focus to a specified list of issues, potentially limiting its ability to respond effectively to new and emerging concerns that are not expressly identified in the legislation. The watchdog's main purpose is to engage with passengers, monitor their issues and understand their experiences.
Passengers' need and expectations evolve over time.
Mark Harper
Can the minister just, just on that point? So, the reason why I was raising the point about what it was called was because under the legislation, Transport Focus, which is what the Passengers Council operating name is, it also represents users of England's major roads, the strategic road network, and it's supposed to get the best deal for them as well. She seems to be saying it's evolving into a body which just does passengers. So I just want to understand, is it still going to have that responsibility for representing the users of the strategic road network? In which case you can't really call it a passenger watchdog because they're not passengers in that sense of the word, particularly if they're driving themselves.
Or is it going to only do passengers on rail, bus and tram services? Because those are very different organisations. And I just want a clear answer. She may not have it with her now, in which case I am perfectly content if she writes to me and members of the committee. I'm perfectly happy to hold that, but I do think this is quite important.
Seb Dance
Thank you for clarifying what exactly you'd like to know because initially you was talking about names and conventions rather than the actual duties. So I think it may be best if we write to you in respect of that now that you've made that much more clearer. The watchdog's main purpose is to engage with passengers, monitor their issues and understand their experience, so it would be best placed to determine where and how to advocate for them. That is clear in every clause of these chapters of the bill. For that reason, I do not believe that it is necessary to place a statutory purpose of this kind on the face of the bill.
I move on now to amendment 186. The watchdog's cost-efficiency duty in the bill is consistent with the duties of the Secretary of State, the Office of Rail and Road, Scottish ministers, Welsh ministers and GBR. The revised duty proposed by noble lords would achieve the same outcome as existing duty. The watchdog is already, will already need to undertake analysis to ensure it is making efficient use of funds when deciding which issues to investigate. This would naturally involve examination of the cost of the investigation comparative to the likely gains for the passengers and the public.
Amendment 186 is therefore duplicative and unnecessary. Amendments 184A and 204C tabled by the noble baroness Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb would remove the duty to consider cost efficiency from both the passenger watchdog and London TravelWatch. I do not consider this to be appropriate. These bodies need to be focused on resources, their resources on passenger priorities and act in a way that makes effective use of public funding. To be clear, we are suggesting that the watchdog should act efficiently, not that they should prioritise cost over passengers.
I cannot understand why we would not want a public body to act efficiently. Of course they must.
I hope the noble Baroness will withdraw her amendment. Onto amendment 187 by the noble Lord, Lord Evans. Clause 37 requires the passenger watchdog to proactively monitor passenger issues and maintain a good overview of any problems with passengers and station services. It can then use this information to make representations to the Secretary of State and GBR to advocate for passenger improvements. However, some issues may be complex, requiring careful consideration of funding implications and wider priorities for the railway.
A statutory deadline, such as the one in this amendment, risks prioritizing speed over substance and may not lead to the best outcomes for passengers. The result of this amendment would likely be to bring about problems which cannot be solved quickly, or will never be solved at all. Of course representation should still be considered and responded to as promptly as possible, and I can assure the noble Lord, Lord Evans of Guysborough, that we are working with Transport Focus and the ORR to ensure that will happen. The next amendment of the noble Lord, amendment 188, assessing passenger satisfaction is a well-established part of Transport Focus' work. It will remain so once it becomes the passenger watchdog.
The Rail Customer Experience Survey already provides regular, robust and consistent insight into passenger experiences across the railway. Transport Focus currently accesses the underlying data and conducts its own independent analysis, publishing regular assessments of passenger experience which fulfills the reporting proposal in this amendment. The passenger watchdog will continue to work once established, but the bill will also give the watchdog oversight of passenger complaints and the power to increase its passenger insight further, which will increase the usefulness of these reports. I therefore think the bill goes a good deal further than this proposed amendment. With regard to amendments 194 and 195, the watchdog will routinely publish reports of its investigation within a reasonable timeframe.
However, it is important that it retains some discretion. The watchdog's investigation may uncover issues that need to be kept confidential, for instance commercially or personal sensitive issues which requires careful handling. That is why the bill provides for the watchdog to publish its investigation, but gives it some discretion on about how and when it does so. I do agree that investigation should be published promptly, however some investigations will naturally be more complex and time-consuming than others. In some cases reports may benefit from being shared in draft with time allowed for those impacted to consider improvements and suggestions.
The watchdog should be able to determine when and how publication best serves passengers.
Amendment 202A from the noble Baroness Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb would commit the passenger watchdog to publish all its advice to government, operators and other bodies. The watchdog will be transparent about its advice and representation on behalf of passengers. Nonetheless, a statutory obligation automatically to publish all its advice is not appropriate. This could make some bodies cautious about consulting the watchdog about early ideas and proposals and might not deliver the best outcomes for passengers. Moving on to amendment 188B and 189 through to 193 and amendment 201A, the government's view is that there should be one independent enforcement body for the rail sector, the ORR.
The passenger watchdog will have significant powers to investigate issues, require information from GBR to a deadline, set mandatory standards for operators in their license and demand improvement plans from operators. Amendment 188B seeks to amend the watchdog's powers to obtain information during investigations. However, in practice, it replicates the broader information gathering powers the watchdog has in the bill already under clause 37, subsection 2 and is therefore unnecessary. Contrary to the noble Lord Lord Evans' amendment 189, it is important that enforcement decisions remain within ORR as the independent regulator. Having a single enforcement body for the sector avoids duplication, conflicting decisions and uncertainty for industry.
This also provides consistent and fair oversight for all operators. That is why the ORR will enforce against GBR and other license holders. To reassure noble Lords further, however, I will say that we intend to consult on the GBR licensing later in the year and expect our proposals will include a license condition requiring operators to cooperate with the passenger watchdog. This will ensure licensed operators will cooperate with the requests from the watchdog. The bill has also been drafted so that concerns identified by the watchdog can often be addressed through constructive engagement and improvement plans before formal regulatory action becomes necessary.
In many cases, that is likely to deliver faster and better outcomes for passengers than immediately escalating every issue to enforcement proceedings as required by amendment 190 through to 193. The bill also already contains safeguards to provide transparency on enforcement decisions sought by these amendments. Where the ORR receives an enforcement referral, it must explain to the Secretary of State and the passenger watchdog what action it has taken or why it has decided that a different approach to enforcement action is appropriate. With regard to amendment 201A, we expect the watchdog to work closely with the ORR as compliance issues are identified and as the watchdog takes steps like requesting improvement plans from operators to address this. A memorandum of understanding is being developed between ORR and the watchdog and will cover how referrals for enforcement actions are to be dealt with.
A heads of terms document for the MOU was published in June and with the final MOU to be published after Royal Assent.
I therefore do not feel that the need to do anything further on referrals for enforcement actions in this bill. As the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, highlights within amendment 333A, the Transport Select Committee has recommended that the chair of the future passenger watchdog will be added to the list of appointments subject to pre-appointment scrutiny. The government agrees that the future passenger watchdog must command confidence and be seen to operate in representing passenger interests. The government has considered the recommendations of the Transport Select Committee, and Lord Hendy has written to confirm that he will intend to follow this through with approval from the Cabinet Office. My Lords, these amendments raise important questions about how best to champion passenger interests, and I leave no more to say and ask that I hope that we have covered all the points sufficiently that the noble Lords will therefore withdraw their amendments.
Evans
My Lords, I'd like to thank everyone for taking part in this debate, which I think has highlighted a number of shortcomings in the legislation at the moment, which we will probably return to in future. I should perhaps complete the tale I was telling about the London Transport Users Committee, because I realized that I didn't complete it when I spoke up last time. It's a discourtesy to leave noble Lords in suspense, and anyway it contains a number of lessons which might be useful for the minister and for the committee. In that our recommendations around the London Transport Users Council were to reduce the size of the board considerably, and in the course of doing that we found we needed a new chair, and the assembly appointed a man called Brian Cooke, who some people here will remember. And one of the first things that he did was actually change the name of the London Transport Users Committee to London TravelWatch.
The committee may be interested to know that that is the origin of those two different names. The reason he chose London TravelWatch was that it reflected the responsibility of that body for road users as well as for public transport users. And therefore he had very much in mind the concerns my noble friend Lord Harper which he has raised, and perhaps that's something that could be looked at by the chair of the transport watchdog when they're appointed. I think the second lesson from this, of course, is that the chair of London TravelWatch was appointed by a committee of the London Assembly, the scrutiny body, rather than directly by the mayor. My noble friend Lord Moylan's amendment asks merely for effectively a confirmation hearing in front of the Transport Committee, not for full appointment.
And I think it is an amendment that is well worth considering and supporting. I very much agreed with the noble Baroness the minister and my noble friend Lord Harper in their support for value for money to be a part of the terms of reference here, and I'm touched by the noble Baroness. But I think if the organization wishes to be treated seriously within the industry, it needs to make recommendations which are financially viable.
Otherwise, it will start to look like any of the other campaigning organisations that we see and that make recommendations which are perhaps less viable. The noble Baroness Jones asked me about the pronunciation of the town in my in my title, and I'm going to I'm I'm just going to let everyone know what the correct pronunciation is, not least because I have six more amendments in the next session. And I think we can probably do without three different pronunciations. It is in fact Guisborough, the U is silent. But I have heard all three pronunciations in other places.
So I hope that's helpful to the committee. But the debate has, I think, exposed a number of shortcomings in the legislation which we will return to at third reading. Meanwhile, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment number 183.
Speaker 41
Is it your Lordships' pleasure this amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. In clause 36, Baroness Jones, amendment 183A, not moved. Amendment 184 is withdrawn. 184A, Baroness Jones, not moved.
Amendment 185, Lord Berkeley, not moved. Amendments 186, 186A, Lord Evans of Guisborough.
Not moved.
Speaker 41
Set by a Lancastrian to a Yorkshireman. The question is that clause 36 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content, the contents have it. In clause 37, amendments 187 and 188, Lord Evans, not moved.
The question is that clause 37 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content. Contrary not content, the contents have it. The question is that clause 38 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion will say content.
Contrary not content, the contents have it. After clause 38, amendment 188A, Lord Moylan.
Daniel Moylan
My Lords, I rise to speak to amendment 188A standing in my name. This is not the first time, I think, in the course of the afternoon that reference has been made to the Transport Select Committee in the other place, and this amendment too was inspired by the deliberations of the Transport Select Committee as they sat in consideration on the issues in the bill. The issue was raised directly in evidence taken by the Transport Committee. Transport for All told the committee that lived experience of disability needed to have a formal role, a formal role within the new passenger watchdog, and argued for a statutory requirement for disabled representation on the council. The committee itself subsequently concluded that the bill needed to give its accessibility duties greater teeth and recommended the Passenger Council should exercise its functions in a way that actually improved accessibility across the network.
The Minister has previously said that the current Transport Focus board already includes members with direct experience of accessibility issues and that the government expects that representation to continue. If that's the government's expectation anyway, I struggle to understand the objection to putting a reasonable minimum guarantee in the bill. I hope the Minister will look favourably on my amendment, which requires two places on the council to be reserved for people with those with that experience.
That brings me to the important amendments from the noble baronesses, Lady Grey-Thompson and and Lady Brinton. Amendment 198A addresses some of the very practical problems that disabled passengers continue to face, in particular the provision of passenger assistance during disruption. Amendment 200 similarly probes the availability of sufficiently trained staff at stations to assist disabled passengers. I also think that amendment 204 tabled by my noble friend Lord Holmes of Richmond makes an entirely reasonable proposal. Where the passengers' council identifies a systematic failure to provide accessible services or infrastructure, it would be able to issue an accessibility improvement notice, requiring GBR to rectify that failure within a specified period.
That seems entirely consistent with the government's stated ambition to create a passenger watchdog with real influence. The difficulty is that one isn't entirely convinced that the government does intend to create a passenger council with real influence. I turn finally to amendments 198, 199, 201, 202 and 203 tabled by my noble friend Lord Evans of Gisbury, to which I've added my name. 198 would require standards to cover the things passengers actually experience every day: reliability and cancellations, safety and security, cleanliness, overcrowding and facilities on board, and affordability and value for money. These are the issues that really matter to passengers.
If the passengers' council is intended to be their champion, why should these matters not be clearly stated in the bill? Amendment 199 concerns the requirement for the council to obtain the ORR's consent before setting or revoking or varying standards. If the government trusts the council to represent passengers, why does another organization need a veto over the standards it sets? Amendments 201 and 202: under the bill, the passengers' council can identify a contravention, demand an improvement plan, and ultimately refer matters to the ORR. But it cannot itself enforce that improvement plan.
The government says that they are creating a powerful passenger watchdog, but without enforcement powers, there is a risk of creating a watchdog with no teeth. The government's answer in the other place to these amendments was that there should be one clear enforcement body, and indeed at the end of the last debate that was the message that the noble baroness, Lady Dacre of Lewisham, was broadcasting. But why? Why should there be one clear enforcement body? Who actually benefits from that?
Having one clear enforcement body simply makes what might be called regulatory capture more attractive to Great British Railways. What is the what is the drawback in having two enforcement bodies? After all, there are other bodies outside the architecture of this bill which can enforce their decisions on Great British Railways. The police is one of them. Another is the courts, and and if a decision in the courts went against Great British Railways, I'd expect them to comply with it and there would be mechanisms for enforcing it.
So in the broader architecture of society, Great British Railways is not subject to one enforcement body, but to a number. And why shouldn't the passengers' council with its particular remit have those enforcement powers if the government means it to be a serious body? My lords, I beg to move.
Speaker 42
Amendment proposed, after clause 38, insert the following new clause: Passengers' Council Board, as printed on the marshalled list.
Jones
My Lords, I've got a few amendments in this group as well. I strongly oppose clause 46 because it's a central part of how the bill deregulates passenger and accessibility-related duties, moving all responsibility away from the much stronger regulator, the ORR, to the weak Passengers' Council, which as previously discussed is little more than the existing Transport Focus, or whatever. The first issue is the way this works within the internal mechanics of the bill. It's complicated but vital that this two-step deregulation is spelled out on the record. Firstly, all forms of licensing are deregulated because they no longer need to have regard to the general duties.
And next, the role of standard-setting is moved away from the ORR to the Passengers' Council, which is not itself subject to the general duties. Clearly this severs all links between the general duties and the standard-setting. And then of course the ORR is the much stronger regulator, and so there's a significant safety dimension here too, especially when it comes to accessibility, which has many crucial links to safety and operations. The ORR has years of institutional knowledge and a much superior perspective on how this system fits together. So even if it could be justified to move consumer rights and passenger standard-related issues away from the ORR to the Council, it could never be justified to sever this link between accessibility and rail operations.
If anything, accessibility needs to be treated with the same seriousness as safety from a regulatory perspective. The same point about safety should be made even more strongly about monitoring and enforcement. Under current legislation, serious issues such as license breaches are dealt with by the ORR, meaning they get the oversight of the regulator most expert in safety and operations. According to this bill, such issues can now be dealt with by the Council alone, a body with a much weaker negotiating position, under an overarching duty of cost-efficiency, and much less knowledgeable about how the operational aspects of the railway fit together. The watchdog's only recourse where an operator fails to comply would be to refer the matter to the ORR, without any standards or timescales for this referral.
It creates scope for operators to delay, obstruct, or exploit a non-enforcement stage before the ORR can become involved, potentially more than doubling the timescales and meaning that later enforcement action would take place according to much weaker standards. For these reasons, amendment 190 from Lord Evans of Gilsland is important because it would make sure that referrals are always made to the ORR, while his amendments 191 and 192 require that the ORR always acts on these referrals. My amendments 201A and 202B... my amendment 201A adds to this approach with a backstop to ensure that any serious issues or license breaches relating to rail operations, safety, or accessibility are always directly referred to the ORR and never diverted down the much weaker route of the Passengers' Council.
And 202B addresses the main weakness in clause 49, in which GBR must consult the Passengers Council when it appears to GBR that the changes will significantly affect the affect the interests of the public. This is clearly a subjective standard, and this this amendment makes it an objective standard, when the change would reasonably be expected have a significant effect. On this note, I'm strongly in favor of noble lady Baroness Pigeon's amendment 209, the wording of which also removes this subjective standard, while ensuring that the London Transport Users Committee is also a statutory consultee when it comes to services operating within the London area. 330JA concerns the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee. This is a very credible and active statutory body which is an advisor to the Secretary of State on rail policy matters.
And as I understand it, it was previously thought to be given that DPTAC's role in rail policy would be expanded to GBR. And this was included in the Conservatives' draft rail reform bill in 2014. So they did something right, I suppose. The alternative would be to greatly reduce its statutory role in policy, since most decisions relating to rail policy and operations and many of the strategy functions currently held by the DfT will move to GBR. Hence my amendment 330JA amends the Transport Act 1985, which originally established the role of DPTAC.
It mirrors exactly the amendment that was previously used in the Conservatives' draft bill. Considering that the bill has no requirements for disability-related advice or the participation of disabled people, extending the role of DPTAC is really the minimum that should be done. The committee already exists and is well thought of, so extending its statutory role in this way would be minimal cost and change. And if any explanation exists to justify this deregulation, I'd really like to hear it. In the previous group, I did mention my amendment 204A, which I shouldn't have done, I'm sorry about that.
But it is a crucial amendment solving another major issue with the Passengers Council, the fact that there is no link to real-life passengers whatsoever. Public engagement and consultation is not only necessary for the fairness and openness with the public and disabled people, it's also one of the most valuable possible forms of input for the benefit of the council itself. Passengers and campaigners are crying out for a proper system of engagement, and this would finally establish a much-needed link with what passengers are actually experiencing and their priorities for change. And with all due respect to the noble Lord, Lord Hendy, who is more expert than the people using the network every single day? This amendment introduces a new clause that would require the Passengers Council to establish arrangements for the input of passengers, ensuring they can contribute to its work programs, priorities and input on national policies and receive transparent information about its activities and the outcomes of its work, and also prioritizing arrangements for engagement with disabled people and their organizations, as well as other groups protected under the Equality Act 2010.
I'd like a fair world, and what I'm trying to do with with my amendments is to create a fair bill.
Sal Sarah Brinton
My Lords, I have amendment 200 in this group, and it's also signed by Lady Grey-Thompson and my noble friend Lady Pigeon, which is a probing amendment to try and provide a mechanism to ensure that disabled passengers are not left stuck on a platform or worse, a train, because there aren't sufficient staff to assist disabled passengers on and off trains and on some occasions to help them get on and off the station too. More detail on that in the next group. But that's where this amendment comes from.
This amendment also mentions access to ticketing information and other facilities, especially accessible toilets. It specifically identifies the monitoring of compliance with the service for disabled people with the Passenger Council, which is why it's in this group. And I thank Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb for recognizing that putting accessibility on the same footing as safety is really important. And I'm interested in her amendment 330JA, which makes DPTAC an official advisor to the Passenger Council. My Lords, I know that both Lady Grey-Thompson and Lord Holmes and I talk about co-production frequently, but co-production with disabled people before policy is formulated is absolutely vital.
And someone who's never had to rely on the services for people with reduced mobility, known in the trade as PRM, will often not understand how precarious travel can be for a disabled person. Lady Grey-Thompson and I have recounted our own experiences in this and other bills. The easiest way to describe what it's like to be on the receiving end of an assist that goes wrong because of a failure of staff, either on the platform or on the train, is that firstly, you lose all your independence. Secondly, you have to try and find someone to help you, and people may not know what to do or worse, just won't. I live in Watford, and the train from Euston to Watford Junction is often full of visitors to the Warner Brothers Studios.
It's transformed my hometown, which is lovely. But many of the visitors don't speak English. And if you're sitting with the doors open but about to close and no sign of any staff member with a ramp, wondering whether I'm going to get off at Hemel Hempstead or possibly even Milton Keynes because I can't even find the controls easily to let them know I'm stuck on the train. The problem, my Lords, is that staffing can be patchy. And that's a real issue.
Some stations no longer have any staff at all, and some larger stations end up without their full complement of staff. And frankly, that's often when things start to go wrong. But I want to emphasize, for me this is rare, and when we move to the next group and I talk about the percentage of assistance that it works, which is really important, I want to thank the thousands of staff at every station and on every train who give a smooth and friendly service to disabled people, enabling us to get from A to B. That's not what this amendment is about. This amendment is ensuring that when planning for staffing, the needs of assistance are taken into account.
My Lords, I've been left on a train twice at King's Cross at around midnight on a Sunday when staff dashed off and there were no accessibility staff left on the station, no answer from the King's Cross or the assistance number. What do you do then? Do you call 111? Possibly. Well, no, I have an answer to this.
Lady Jones gets ahead of me. Call a Paralympian. Call a Paralympian. That is the answer. Actually, I tweeted, what do I do now?
By this time it was about half past twelve. It's an interesting question, but there we go. My answer is you need a Lady Grey-Thompson who reads her Twitter at half past midnight on a Sunday night. Because she knew the CEO of LNER. She rang him, poor man, and he called someone, he found someone.
I could not have seen them from the train. But in the half an hour before that happened, I wondered how long it would be before the cleaners arrived for the early shift or the train driver arrived to take the train out.
I literally did not know what I could do. Nowadays, on some lines, there are never any conductors on the train or staff on the train, on the station, because they just, and if they don't have level boarding access either, that means wheelchair users are reliant, believe this or not, on staff travelling from other stations when they are free to do so. This can cause delays. There was a by-election nearly a decade ago in Lewisham, and might have travelled a few times down to help out. Lewisham has an accessible toilet on its platform, which is wonderful, but the door is locked.
It's not even locked with the standard radar key. That's because apparently it had been used for people to trade in drugs, but no staff. So if you either need to get hold of the key to use the toilet while waiting for a train, or you want staff to put you on a train, you have to call Hither Green, who finds the staff manager, who finds who might be the next member of staff who could possibly jump on the next train to go from Hither Green to Lewisham, and then they'll put the ramp down for you and off you go, in my case back towards Charing Cross. That is not a turn-up-and-go service. It's not even a booked service.
It just ruins your working life. I could never ever live near that station because I would never know when I could get to and from work. I also signed Lord Holmes of Richmond's amendment 204 that sets out accessibility notice where there are systemic failures to deliver PMR service. Now, I'm not talking about that in my amendment so far. I've talked about staffing also being a deal-breaker, but I support his amendment completely.
Now, I admire this government and specifically Lord Hendy for having strong aspirations for Great British Railways to offer an excellent service to all passengers. Passengers who need assistance should also be considered at all times. So can I ask the minister if she wants to resist this amendment, what guarantees can be given to ensure that when staffing is considered at whatever level that will happen under Great British Railways, the service for passengers who needs assistance will be part of the calculation and that the Passenger Council should monitor that performance. I look forward to hearing the minister's response.
Lord Holmes of Richmond
My Lord, I rise to speak to amendment 204 in my name and to thank Baroness Brinton for signing that amendment. But we'll come to that. It's a pleasure to follow Baroness Brinton. Could there be a greater, clearer, and unarguable case that lived experience is invaluable, vital, and should be in every decision, in every committee, in every consultation set out on the face of every bill? Nothing about us without us.
Baroness Brinton and Baroness Grey-Thompson bring their experiences to bear and they need no garnish. The case is clear. That's not accessibility. It's certainly nothing which gets anywhere near the first letter I of inclusion. I'd also like to thank Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb for all of her continuing work on disability access and inclusion over many years.
It's unstinting, clear, and committed.
What the noble lady said about safety and accessibility and disability is critically important, not least because safety and accessibility should have equal standing, but also because all too often, even in 21st century Britain, health and safety can still be used as a reason not to do disability, if you will. Unacceptable, but still occurs. My Lords, 204 talks about accessibility improvement notices where systemic accessibility failures occur. We're talking the infrastructure, we're talking the kit. We're looking at this through the lens of experience, the experience of disabled passengers, or one might say those who would really like to be disabled passengers if they got a chance to get onto the transport itself.
There has to be an ability to make change through this bill in the form of improvement notices so things don't just continue, don't just get reported upon, lessons will be learned, change will happen. Well, let's have improvement notices to not just suggest, but to ensure that that change does occur. Because travel by train for disabled people all too often isn't a luxury, it's a necessity for leisure, for pleasure, for appointments, critically for work. And there's more than a correlation, there's all too often causation between the employment levels of disabled people and the accessibility of public transport. Tragically still in this country, we don't have public transport.
We have transport which is accessible to some of the public some of the time. Public transport must be accessible by all, inclusive by design. A measure of the distance to travel, well, the employment rate for non-disabled people in the UK is 83%. For disabled people, it's 41%. For those of us who are blind and partially sighted, it's 27%.
That's almost three quarters of blind and partially sighted people of working age not in work. Inaccessible public transport is part of that problem. This bill needs to be part of the solution. I look forward to the Minister's response.
Evans
My Lords, I'd like to speak briefly to the amendments that I've tabled in this in this section. I'm not going to say a great deal because my noble friend Lord Moylan has actually explained the purposes of the amendments very clearly, and the noble Baroness, Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb, actually hammered the points home very clearly when it comes to the the independence and the strength that we want the passenger watchdog to have. I would like to say something in in support of Baroness Brinton on disabled access, because she brings to us some some valuable experience of her own here. But I I think it's worth the committee being aware that it's not just a problem on the worst railway lines, it's it's potentially a problem everywhere.
I regularly use the Elizabeth line, which is an excellent line. Most of the stations are accessible for people with disabilities. All of them have lifts. Most of the stations, the gap between the train and the platform is taken care of, except for on the branch which leads out to to Shenfield, because that's a a place where the platforms are historically lower. And TfL staff are normally in place to help passengers in wheelchairs off the trains.
I was on the service a couple of weeks ago when they weren't there, and a passenger in a wheelchair was effectively trapped aboard the train at Romford, and would have gone to to Shenfield at the end of the line, but for one of the very quick-thinking other passengers who actually pulled the emergency handle and made the train stop at the station until a member of staff came up and provided the ramp. Now, that of course was an entirely justifiable thing to do, but it delayed the train for everyone else and impacted the rest of the line's services. So disabled access is not just important for disabled people, it's important for everybody. And I know how the noble minister Lord Hendy took this incredibly seriously when he was the commissioner for Transport for London. Buses which didn't have disabled access ramps working were not actually allowed out of the depot to provide the service if they couldn't demonstrate they had that facility.
And I suspect the noble lord, if he travels on London Underground these days, must be disappointed to see and embarrassed really to see the state in which some of our underground trains are allowed out of the depot in these days. So I very much support support Baroness Brinton's amendments, and I hope the committee will consider supporting mine.
Anthony Berkeley
Lord, I'd like to rise very briefly and support all the speakers who've moved these amendments and talked about the problems of accessibility, toughly led by Baroness Brinton. But it's it's been really an eye-opener, because we're trying to adapt a Victorian railway, or much of it's Victorian apart from the Elizabeth line as the noble lord has said. But to what we're what we want to expect and aim to get. And I mean, when I go to my little station in Cornwall, there's so many people who can't lift their luggage over the over the bridge. Are they going to build a footbridge?
Well, sometime. And last time I heard somebody ask for a lift over the bridge, the person in the booking office, and there was somebody there, said, "Well, I can't do it because I've got a bad back." Which is fair enough. But I think the problem we've got is we there are many footbridges and other things which need to be either have lifts added or or whatever whatever they want. But we've also got to make sure that what we do have works, as many noble lords have said.
It's fine going to a toilet on a station and finding it's out of order. It's fine when the train gets cancelled, and there's been many of them recently. And it's just generally uncertain uncertainty which I which I really worry about. Because I think putting it right, getting the right number of staff in these different places, as well as improving the infrastructure like bridges or whatever whatever they want, is something that we should be doing, but it's going to cost us money. Cost the taxpayer a lot of money.
And I think that's fair enough because it, it does need doing, but we can't always have our cake and eat it. So I, but I hope we can go on and continue to improve services and the availability of staff, which as the noble Lord has said, is absolutely fundamental to give some certainty to those who need help during a, across the journey. In the meantime, let's have a few more footbridges as well.
Charles John Fuller
My Lords, I rise briefly to support amendment number 198 in the names of my noble friends Lord Evans and Lord Moylan. Now, it is said that third-class riding is better than first-class walking, but that doesn't mean that it should be an excuse for poor service. Now, the four examples enumerated in 46(2) of the bill, I think can be viewed through the lens for the convenience of the state, of the operator, the effective administration of the ticketing and the transaction. It's incomplete. Now, competition is a device that should be used to improve service, but instead this bill provides for the dead hand of the state and the provision of a monopoly operator in this nation, and that's to be regretted.
I particularly regret that it could see the end of the Grand Central service from King's Cross to Sunderland, one I use frequently. It's direct, it's much better value, and it's quicker, but it's all to be swept away, and I think it's a shame that this Railways Bill takes us backward in the terms of service. So I welcome the focus provided by the amendment 198 and the additional three paragraphs that are proposed in that amendment, which bring service for passenger experience and comfort, rather than the bill as laid through the lens of the operator. Lord Evans and Lord Moylan bring it through the lens of the customer: comfort, the lack of overcrowding, the speed of the internet, and the cleanliness of the toilets. These are things that really improve the experience, the provision of a first-class service, not a third one.
So these things laid out in paragraph three should absolutely be within scope, and I hope the ministerial team will adopt them, because if they want to be seen on the side of passengers who pay the fares, rather than for the administrative convenience of the state, then they need to be seen to be on the side of all of us, people who pay the fares, not just the government. I commend this amendment to you all.
Mark Harper
My Lords, I wanted to speak to four aspects of the amendments in this group. The first one is amendment 188A in the name of my noble friend Lord Moylan, and I think I can be very brief on this one, which is it makes the point very clearly that there should be at least some members of the Passengers' Council who have lived experience of being disabled people. And I think both Lord Holmes and Baroness Brinton set out very powerfully why that is important, and I don't think I can put the case better than they did, but I strongly support that.
The second amendment I support is, or I support the principle of it, is amendment 200, which is the one about minimum staffing. Now, the point I wanted to make here is that the amendment as drafted very sensibly sets out the things that you want the staff to do. And it was one of the things that, and I regret this didn't happen in the end, it was one of the ideas that was behind the proposal to get staff out of ticket offices and into the station, partly to assist disabled passengers and those that required more support to do their journeys, rather than sitting in a ticket office where in many stations very few people purchase tickets, paper tickets anymore. The vast majority of tickets are purchased online, and in a railway which does not have infinite resources and you have staff, I want the staff to be deployed in the best way that they can to serve customers. And I think that the, let me just finish the point and I can see Baroness Brinton wants to intervene.
And so actually I think her amendment here, which sets out there are some services that need to be delivered at a station, I think is very sensible, and then it leaves the service provider the flexibility to work out where the staff need to go to deliver those services, rather than prescribing where they sit and what job they do. And I think it's therefore worthy of support. And of course I will take her comment.
Sal Sarah Brinton
I'm very grateful for the noble Lord for giving way. If Lady Grey-Thompson were in her place, she would immediately say, and I would agree with her, that one of the problems of removing staff from ticket offices was that any disabled person with a disabled travel card cannot buy their ticket at a machine. So by removing the member of staff, actually it's costing disabled people more to travel.
Mark Harper
No, I take that point. The point was though, it wasn't to remove staff from the ability to sell tickets, it was to enable staff to be more flexibly deployed. So for example, one of the things staff would have done is been able to do exactly that transaction. What they wouldn't have had to do was sit in a specific place unable to interact with passengers. But I absolutely accept her point that some people still either prefer, which is their absolute right, or have to, in the cases that she set out, purchase a physical ticket, and we should make sure they're able to do so.
But in many stations you literally have staff who sit there for an entire shift interacting with almost nobody, which frankly isn't a very good job either. It's not a very satisfying job. And I just think they could be better deployed, and her amendment sets out actually how you could better deploy staff to serve particularly disabled passengers, and I think it's therefore worthy of support. Amendment 204 in the names of both my noble friend Lord Holmes and Baroness Brinton about accessibility improvement notices. I'm not sure whether that is the particular correct solution, but I support the thrust of the amendment because I've sat in now a number of debates, both on this bill but on other occasions, where I have completely seen the frustration that lots of things are set out as objectives, but they don't happen in practice.
And the real challenge is, and this is not just a challenge for passengers but it's also a challenge for ministers and operators, how do you make sure that the things that are required, that are responsibilities of these operators, are actually delivered in practice? Because lots of these things are delivered in theory, but as both of my noble friends, I'm here to call Baroness Brinton one of my noble friends on this occasion, set out, they don't always happen in practice.
And getting them fixed shouldn't depend on Baroness Grey-Thompson having the telephone number of the person in charge of an operator. It's a very effective solution, I think, but that shouldn't be the way that we make sure these services are delivered. And so I think having the ability of the Passengers' Council, where it finds there's a systematic failure, so not just a failure of a specific circumstance, but a systematic failure means there's not the staffing, there aren't the policies, there aren't the processes to deliver this, I think being able to direct that something happens as a result is very valuable. The final thing, which is one of those relatively rare occasions where I can be in agreement with Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb, is the excellent amendment she's tabled, 330JA, which I can't really fail to agree with since it broadly replicates what was in the draft Rail Reform Bill, which I was responsible for. And it doesn't go as far as our draft bill, but it does half of it.
So it does one very important thing, which is to, as she said, make the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee not just a statutory advisor to the Secretary of State. And I should say in passing, I found the work they did extremely helpful, both providing direct advice, but also the work that they and their chair did in the department in ensuring that parts of the department were listening properly to the experience of disabled people and reflecting that in the policy and operations of the department. So her amendment makes the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee an advisor to GBR as well as the Secretary of State. I clearly thought that was the right thing to do. It was in the draft legislation that I was responsible for.
I think it's the right decision. I would be interested to understand the reason why, given it was in the draft legislation in the first place that we were responsible, I'd be interested to know why effectively somebody's decided to take it out and why they don't think that's helpful. And I would genuinely say to ministers, having the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee providing that advice to GBR will actually be helpful to GBR in making sure that it delivers a better service for disabled people, but also helpful for ministers because that will stop ministers effectively having to be the conduit. Because what will happen now is that that advice will be provided by the Transport Advisory Committee to ministers, and then ministers will end up having to issue directions to GBR. It'd be much better if the Transport Advisory Committee could just advise GBR directly.
The second thing that isn't in Lady Jones's amendment was the draft bill I was responsible for also had collaborative enforcement, which specifically gave the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee the ability to work alongside the passenger watchdog to safeguard the rights and interests of disabled rail passengers and directly influence GBR's licensing agreement and accessibility standards. So actually, it would perhaps have either been an alternative to the amendment put forward by Lord Holmes and Baroness Brinton as a mechanism, or perhaps an adjunct to it, but it would have meant that the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee could have taken evidence and listened to some of that first-hand testimony from disabled passengers who have poor experience, and then they would have had a direct role in working with the passenger watchdog, Transport Focus, in actually the licensing conditions that GBR had.
And I think that would have been very helpful. And again, I would like to hear why ministers decided that that aspect of the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee, which was in the draft bill that I was responsible for, why they decided to take that out as well. And I look forward to hearing the minister's reply.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, many amendments in this group are really just trying to tease out the different responsibilities of the ORR versus the Passengers Council and what should sit where. I want to endorse my noble friend Lady Brinton's probing amendment, which I've added my name to, which my noble friend has set out so clearly and passionately and given real examples of why staff are needed so that disabled passengers can have the same service we all expect. We all expect to be able to turn up and get on a train and be able to travel somewhere, and so should disabled passengers. And it's really, really important that we hear that as we consider this legislation. Lord Holmes of Richmond's amendment 204, also signed by my noble friend Baroness Brinton, requiring an accessibility improvement notice to be issued by the Passengers Council in response to systemic failure in accessible services or infrastructure.
I think this is a really interesting proposal, and it certainly would focus minds and efforts in this space. Lord Moylan's amendment 188A, also supported by the Transport Select Committee, is of course something we should support: two board members who are disabled people with that lived experience they can bring to the board. And of course the board must be representative of different types of passengers to ensure that breadth of thought. And I would have thought any Secretary of State would want to ensure the board is diverse. Amendment 330JA from Baroness Jones about DPTAC advising Great British Railways as well as Secretary of State.
Obviously we have lots of former Secretaries of State in the room as we debate this legislation. It's interesting to hear about draft legislation and what was in that and what hasn't materialized. So that will be interesting to hear from the minister. And I also just want to clarify amendment 209, which is in my name, which was mentioned earlier. We debated that in an earlier group on London TravelWatch, which is why it's not sitting in this group now.
Seb Dance
Well, these amendments concern the passenger watchdog's role in setting standards and improving accessibility outcomes for passengers. I will begin with the amendments in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb, probing that the clause 46 stands part of the bill. As set out in the previous group, the ORR will remain the sector's independent enforcement body, but the watchdog will take an important responsibility for setting and monitoring minimum consumer standards. These standards will be included as mandatory license conditions for all operators, including GBR, and the ORR will enforce them. The clause also sets out what the standards may cover, including, for example, passenger assistance, provision of travel information, the process for compensation if services are delayed or disrupted, and complaints about passenger services.
This is not an exhaustive list, just an indicative one. The watchdog can set standards across any aspect of passenger experience. The watchdog must seek the Secretary of State and the ORR's consent before setting new standards or varying or revoking existing ones. The standards and any variation must be published and the watchdog must monitor how operation operators are complying with them. Consumer standards in operator license are currently set and monitored by the ORR.
We want the watchdog to take over this function to ensure most consumer functions sit in one body, our passenger champion, which can monitor the outcomes passengers are seeing and use this intelligence to drive up standards, advocate for improvements for passengers and uphold operators and make them accountable in a meaningful way. To be clear, we are creating a body that is able to see real life experience of passengers and translate this into real action to ensure operators make improvements where needed. The ability to set standards is a key part of this. The drafting of clause 46 allows the watchdog to develop standards covering areas of passenger experience. The list in subsection 2, as I said, is not exhaustive and does not prevent additional standards relating to passenger experience from being developed in future.
Therefore, amendment 198 makes no practical difference to the watchdog's powers. Our proposal is for the passenger watchdog to focus on passenger experience, whereas some of the areas for standard proposed by the noble Lord, Lord Evans, are more appropriately overseen by specialist bodies such as the ORR. For example, safety should be overseen by the ORR as the safety expert, although the watchdog could have a role in with respect to passenger security and personal safety. Next, amendment 199. Because of the ORR the ORR remains responsible for enforcement, it is important that it is satisfied that the standards are clear, proportionate and enforceable before they take a bind take binding effect.
This arrangement reflects the separate but complementary role we envision for the two bodies, with the watchdog setting and monitoring standards as passenger champions and the ORR acting as the independent and impartial enforcer. Amendment 200 tabled by the noble Baroness Lady Brinton raises the important issue of accessibility and station staffing. I'd like to thank her for sharing her experiences and others because this is something this government takes very seriously indeed. As was discussed in earlier in an earlier debate, well-trained staff play a crucial role in delivering an accessible railway and providing confidence to passengers who require assistance. That is why we are already taking action to improve staffing outside of the bill.
Next month, we are launching a single industry training framework for passenger assistance across the rail network. Shaped by frontline staff, operational experience and customer customer needs, it will drive greater consistency, reduce failed assistance, strengthen handovers between operators and building build staff confidence, giving disabled passengers a more reliable, joined up and inclusive journey.
I would like to reassure the noble baroness that it is already possible for the watchdog to develop accessibility standards, including on staff levels or the quality of training, if this is deemed necessary and appropriate through consultation. But the watchdog will have those powers to set standards and ensure that they are met by any means necessary, which includes enforcement by putting it forward through to the ORR, but it also allows that dialogue to take place so that rail operators can put measures in place quickly and effectively, but if they don't, they can then escalate it to the ORR. The bill ensures this because it specifically enables the watchdog, as I said, to set standards which help passengers who need assistance. If it did create such a standard, it would then monitor compliance with it, and the ORR would enforce any failures to comply. I hope this reassures noble baroness that the bill is set up to enable precisely the kind of improvement she is suggesting.
On a related point, it's not necessary to provide the watchdog with additional powers, such as accessibility notice or civil penalties, as proposed by the noble lord, Lord Holmes, in amendment 204. There is already a clear enforcement route in the bill that should achieve the noble lord's aims. The watchdog will set accessibility standards and hold operators to account for meeting these standards. Where it finds any failures, it will require operators to produce an improvement plan setting out how these failures will be addressed. If an operator does not produce a plan or does not follow the steps in it, the watchdog will refer the operator to the ORR for enforcement action.
The ORR has all the usual enforcement powers available to it, including mandatory directions requiring operators to take specific actions. This approach preserves the watchdog's role as a passenger champion while ensuring there remains a single independent enforcement body. It also recognizes that direct engagement and improvement plans will often secure improvements more quickly than formal enforcement proceedings. With respect to amendment 188A tabled by the noble lord, Lord Moylan, Transport Focus's board is already comprised of eight members, two of whom have direct experience of accessibility issues. One has lived experience as a disabled passenger, the other is the chair of the National Centre for Accessible Transport and the former chair of the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee.
This will remain the same as Transport Focus transforms into the watchdog. The Secretary of State also has accessibility duties in clause 18 of the bill, which will apply when making future decisions relating to board appointments for the watchdog. This will ensure that the future composition of the board continues to be suitably representative of disabled passengers. While we are not directly mandating specific disabled representation in legislation, I want to be very clear that this government is committed to continuing the strong disabled representation that already exists on the Transport Focus board. Disabled voices will be central to the watchdog's work, and setting a specific quota in statute is not necessary to achieve this.
Amendment 330JA in the name of the noble Baroness Lady Jones requires the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee, DPTAC, to act as the statutory advisor to GBR. My Lords, this same proposal was explored by the Transport Select Committee during its scrutiny of the bill. When asked why the bill does not give DPTAC a formal advisory role to GBR, DPTAC highlighted that their purpose has always been that of an expert advisor to the Secretary of State on accessibility across all transport modes. DPTAC endorsed the government's decision for it to retain this remit, noting that the passenger watchdog will be better placed to act as the day-to-day passenger champion, while DPTAC continues its broader strategic role advising the Secretary of State. The watchdog will be in a unique position to monitor the day-to-day experience of disabled passengers and identify barriers facing them on our railways.
It will also have the connections and structures to engage directly with disabled passengers and the groups representing them, ensuring their voices are never ignored when it comes to accessibility on our railway. DPTAC meanwhile will continue to play a vital role. It has a 40-year record of advising on accessible transport infrastructure. Nothing in this bill will change that. The Secretary of State values DPTAC's advice as much as ever and its members will continue to be critical influencers as we develop GBR.
There are advantages in maintaining these distinct roles. There may be times when the Secretary of State wants advice from DPTAC on GBR actions. This may not be appropriate if DPTAC were advising them both as proposed by this amendment. Turning next to amendments...
Mark Harper
Hang on, just before the minister moves on. I really don't follow this argument at all. If DPTAC has two advisory roles, advising both the Secretary of State and GBR, having an extra advisory role does not in any way stop it still having the full range of advisory roles that it does with the Secretary of State across, as the minister rightly said, the whole range of transport providers. It's an additive role, not one that takes away from it. And I really don't think that if the Secretary of State were to ask the either the committee as a whole or the chair for advice about GBR, that is in no way precluded by the fact that DPTAC also provides advice to GBR.
I really don't follow that. And having had actual ministerial responsibility for working with DPTAC on some very sensitive areas, they're perfectly capable of doing that work. I really don't think that's a strong argument for not giving them the extra responsibilities that were in my draft bill and which are in Lady Jones's excellent amendment.
Seb Dance
Well, thank you for your observations and your experience, but I think your experience kind of highlights exactly why it is perhaps more prudent for DPTAC to be able to advise the Secretary of State. We do not want to put a organization or advisory group in a position of having a conflict of interests.
And I gave a very good example in what I said earlier regarding that matter. I will reiterate that we intend to consult with GBR licensees later on in the year and expect our proposals will include a license condition requiring operators to cooperate with the passenger watchdog. This will ensure that the ORR can take enforcement actions if other license operators, oh sorry, let me just step back a minute because I don't want to be accused of missing any of the amendments. So I'm referring to amendments 201, 202, 203, and 341, which I thank the noble Lord Evans for placing them. Many of these amendments return to the issue that we debated in the previous group, and the government's view is that the railways should continue to have a single independent enforcement body.
I'll continue with my next point, which is that we will ensure that ORR can take enforcement actions if GBR and other license operators do not cooperate with requests from the watchdog, including requests for improvement plans, making amendment 201 unnecessary. The next two amendments concern GBR's consultation of the watchdog. They are amendments 202B tabled by the noble Baroness Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb and amendment 203 in the name of the noble Lord Lord Evans of Giesborough. The intent of these amendments is already achieved as the bill already ensures that GBR will consult the passenger watchdog on all significant passenger matters. Under the paragraph 4 of schedule 2, GBR will set out its proposed activities over a five-year period via its business plan and will consult the watchdog during its development.
In addition, clause 49 puts a requirement on GBR to consult the watchdog when developing policy and procedures affecting passengers. Subsection 2 gives an indication of the activities GBR should consult the watchdog on, but this once again is not an exhaustive list. There is a catch-all provision at the end of this subsection covering all matters impacting on passengers. I will conclude by addressing amendment 204A tabled by the noble Baroness Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb. This bill includes a requirement for the passenger watchdog to keep passenger matters under review at clause 37.
In order to do this, they will need to ensure that there is wide engagement, including with passengers and passenger bodies. Transport Focus already has an arrangements to consult and engage with passengers, including rail customers experience surveys, which is based on a large-scale research directly with passengers. We expect these arrangements to continue and be strengthened further as Transport Focus becomes the passenger watchdog, such as through its oversight of complaints and disputes. And while I sort of bring to my recollection, Baroness Jones, you was talking about, you mentioned about deregulation. So I just want to absolutely confirm that there is no deregulation of consumer rights or weaknesses of enforcement under this bill.
Compliance with consumer standards such as provision of passenger information or minimum accessibility requirements will continue to be a requirement in train operators' licenses and will remain enforceable through ORR as they are today.
This will apply to GBR and to all other operators. What will change is that the passenger watchdog, as the new champions for passenger interest, will become responsible for setting and updating these consumer standards rather than the ORR. So I hope that the noble lords who've put through amendments will see fit to withdraw them.
Daniel Moylan
My lords, I'm grateful to all noble lords who've spoken in this interesting and broad debate. I don't intend to respond at length to the remarks of the noble baroness, Lady Deech of Lulworth. I'll simply say that I think many in the committee will have heard those remarks with a great sense of disappointment. And that it's almost inevitable, I'm sure, that a number of these amendments, and I'm trying not to anticipate the coming group, the debate on the coming group of amendments, but quite a lot of these amendments will, I think, almost certainly return on report stage, and I imagine a division on them will be almost certain. In the meantime, therefore, rather than go on at length, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Ilora Finlay
Is it your lordship's pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. The question is that clause 39 stand part of the bill, as many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.
Amendment 188B, Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb, not moved. Amendment 189, Lord Evans of Gisborough, not moved. The question is that clause 40 stand part of the bill, as many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.
The question is that clause 41 stand part of the bill, as many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. In clause 42, amendment 190, Lord Evans of Gisborough, not moved. Amendments 191, 192, and 193, Lord Evans of Gisborough, not moved.
Thank you. The question is that clause 42 stand part of the bill, as many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. In clause 43, Lord Evans of Gisborough, 194, not moved, and 195, not moved.
The question is that clause 43 stand part of the bill, as many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. And the question is that clause 44 stand part of the bill, as many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content.
The contents have it. After clause 44, Lord Moylan, 196, amendment 196, not moved. The question is that clause 45 stand part of the bill, as many as that opinion will say content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.
Amendment 197 was withdrawn, so in clause 46, amendment 198, Lord Evans of Gisborough, not moved.
That brings us to amendment 198A, Baroness Brinton.
Sal Sarah Brinton
My Lords, amendment 198A in the name of Lady Grey-Thompson and which I have signed is the first in this large group of 25 amendments submitted by Lady Grey-Thompson, Lord Holmes of Richmond and myself, and they often tackle overlapping issues. So I don't think it will take Grand Committee very long to work out that these amendments are all about improving the experience of passengers who need assistance on trains and stations. Unfortunately, my Lords, Lady Grey-Thompson is unwell and has asked me to lead on her amendments in her absence. I hope colleagues will join me in wishing her a very speedy recovery. I also want to thank the Minister and his officials for the meeting that we had last week or the week before, I lose track of time in the spell, and also for the conversation that we wouldn't meet about this specific group, but perhaps we would do that between committee and report stage, and I'm very grateful to him for that suggestion.
I think it's helpful given how many amendments there are here. And if noble Lords will allow me, I would like to use Lady Grey-Thompson's excellent amendment 198A, which summarizes most of the issues that she, Lord Holmes and I would like the government to consider through amendments in this group. So in the last group, I raised the issue of an effective and properly staffed service for people with mobility reductions, not all of them disabled, by the way. I say that because we have to recognize with our changing demographic, there will be elderly people who would not describe themselves as disabled. But amendment 198A specifies nine different areas that need addressing, and I'll use Lady Grey-Thompson's notes to guide us through them and the amendments in this group.
The first areas are easy to access stations, platforms and trains. So starting with level boarding, Tyne and Wear, Greater Anglia and Merseyrail have really started to move towards level boarding, which is encouraging. I've used level boarding and exiting at St Pancras on Greater Anglia and Heathrow on the Heathrow Express. Now it's just transformative for a wheelchair user as it makes you completely independent, but not if it only works for part of your journey. And in the last group, Lord Evans of Gisborough talked about good lines and bad lines.
The difficulty is that when one bit of your journey goes, it doesn't matter whether it's a good line or a bad line, your day becomes a bad day. A disabled passenger only needs one element of the journey to go wrong to lose their independence and frankly, often their confidence, that's me also speaking personally. We know that over the last decade, a number of train companies have bought new rolling stock that will require ramps on those lines for many years to come. I think it was Lady Grey-Thompson about four or five years ago who said that when she and I first came into this House almost within weeks of each other in 2011, the target for level boarding was in the late 2020s or possibly early 2030s. But much of this decade's new rolling stock isn't suitable for level boarding and it'll have a working lifespan of probably about 30 to 40 years based on the previous ones.
So our grandchildren will be approaching old age before there is universal level boarding across the UK. That, my Lords, is ridiculous. I hope that one of the aspirations of GBR is that we move away from the idea of each area having completely different rolling stock that means level boarding is impossible. Instead, level boarding should be a goal for all trains, which in turn will reduce the need for some staffing.
By the way, it will also reduce lawsuits when passengers end up stranded and no help. Even better, a smooth level service will encourage more disabled people to use the trains even more regularly, and frankly, given what Lord Holmes said in the last group, will open opportunities for them to have regular employment as well. Many don't do that now because of the risks of problematic journeys, so more passengers will bring good economic benefits too to GBR. Shockingly, new stations are still being opened at the moment that are not accessible because they are not step-free. The data is very depressing.
Up to 1,001 stations, that's 39%, are not listed as fully step-free. This is not acceptable and needs to change fast. Looking at the type of station, as you would expect, category A national hubs are 100% step-free. Category B regional interchange are 97% step-free, and category C 80% free. But categories D, E, and F are all between 54 and 57%.
And finally, interestingly, small unstaffed category F stations are 60% step-free, so an increase on the previous groupings. And my Lords, there are also variations by region. Can the Minister say what are the government's plans to improve the number of step-free stations and regularize issues over regions? My Lords, lifts at stations are also a really thorny issue. Even if the station has lifts, reliability has plummeted in the last decade, as I know the noble Lord the Minister is well aware because he has heard this from a number of us on a regular basis.
The key data is that 57% of lift faults are due to wear and tear, and when spare parts are needed, the lifts can be out of order for months on end because the lift suppliers are not based in the UK. St Pancras is a regular case in point, but I get ahead of myself. GBR must ensure that there is a proper assessment of lift life and that built lift repairs and replacements into regular maintenance and not wait for things to go wrong. That really doesn't happen consistently at the moment, and far too many lifts are failing repeatedly and then out of service as spare parts have to be made abroad. The Thameslink lifts at St Pancras have been a nightmare for years.
The consequence of them not working is as follows. You have to stay on the train, you get off at Farringdon, assuming their lifts work, assistance staff will help you leave the rail station, you cross the road, go into the Farringdon underground station, get a lift down to the platform, wait for assistance to join you to get you on the tube, which takes you back to St Pancras. I am not alone in having nearly missed a connecting train because of this nonsense. We can all tolerate the occasional problem, but this is so frequent that the service is now unreliable and I try to avoid it. In my hometown of Watford, all the lifts had to be replaced recently, that's within the last five years.
Each of them took, well they did them in pairs, took the best part of a year with absolute chaos. Last year, the new two-year-old lift on the island platform had a major part fail. For three months, my Lords, that lift was out. So instead of commuting home late at night after leaving your Lordship's house on a 20-minute journey from Euston, I faced either an overground that took well over 55 minutes, but at that hour of the night there weren't many of them, or trains that had to be diverted to the downline, causing chaos to the scheduled services, and believe me, they did not shy away from voicing it, irritation to fellow passengers. And they're cross with me, they weren't cross with the network.
The UK rail network has 1,403 lifts. My Lords, that should give us some purchasing power in the matter of lifts and lift spares. I just don't understand why spare parts are not planned for and kept in the UK.
So can the Minister provide reassurance that purchase of and maintenance of lifts will be improved? And again, this is not just for people in wheelchairs, it's actually for many passengers, especially those with large cases as well. The space in trains for wheelchairs and other mobility aids has not caught up with current practice. Specifications for the future should include enough space for both larger wheelchairs and also for wheelchair scooters. You can no longer just say scooters anymore, it means something different, as many people now use them.
With an ageing demographic using wheelchair scooters by preference and expecting to travel, this will only increase and get worse. So changing the reference size wheelchair is important when new rolling stock is being designed and ordered. More irritating, all the rolling stock has different sizes of wheelchair spaces, some with very limited turning or manoeuvring spaces. Secondly, please will train designers ensure that there are places for other passengers to store their damned suitcases. Even with the new rolling stock on LNER it is a problem, and if there are staff handy they are really good at shouting down the carriage, but if they are not, the person in the wheelchair has to shout for themselves, and sometimes people deliberately don't answer and we cannot get further down to start to find out where people might be.
Replacement services and alternative transport remain consistently poor, especially about the carriage of wheelchairs and other mobility aids. Only 2.8% of surveyed disabled passengers say replacement services are fully accessible. Nearly a third of disabled passengers are left without a viable alternative when trains are cancelled. My Lords, that happens to me too, and quite often that's when I have to use the remote Parliament, but I'm lucky I can do that. Most worrying of all, 66% of passengers say their experience during disruption has deteriorated over the past year.
Other replacement service issues include unclear and inaccessible signage, that would include for visually impaired, inconsistent staff support and limited accessible information. My Lords, it's not the first time I've said this in this speech, this is woeful. So can the Minister say how the government is planning to improve the rail replacement services system? I was shocked to discover that only 19% of stations have an accessible toilet. I recognise that for older stations space may be difficult, but many disabled and elderly people need a toilet that has a higher toilet seat with rails and access into and out of the toilet.
Those with hand problems, including many of the elderly, can open easily. So a compliment to Network Rail. The changing places disabled toilet at the new station of Cambridge South is wonderful. Now I say that, my Lords, I haven't seen it yet, but a disabled friend of mine specially rang me to tell me about it, she was so thrilled. However, can the Minister say what the plan is to increase the number of disabled toilets across the network, including changing places toilets on stations over the next decade?
And he probably won't have this to hand, but what might the budget be for the next decade? Only 61% of stations have accessible ticket machines. That's just astonishing. Are there plans to increase the number of accessible ticket machines? Despite some problems, passenger assist continues to perform.
Over the year 25-26, 87% of UK customers were satisfied with the whole journey from booking to receiving assistance. That satisfaction level is broadly the same since 2018-19.
So that's a good baseline. However, improvements do still need to be made. Gaps in delivery are a shocking 10% where customers receive none of the type of assistance they'd booked, and 12% only received some. It is important to note that passengers with non-visible disabilities often have the worst experience. And I wonder if that's something to do with training for staff, which actually, does it cover non-visible disabilities well enough?
There's a suspicion sometimes from staff about whether the person is deserving of assistance. Finally, amendment 198A repeats the point that I made in my amendment in a previous group about the involvement of disabled people and organisations representing disabled people in the development and review of accessibility standards. That's absolutely vital. The disabled community talk about co-production so that the wide and varied experiences of people with differing disabilities, and therefore with different types of help needed, that must be taken into account when developing new services, not after all the design has happened. Will the minister undertake to ensure that in future this is the case?
Ilora Finlay
Amendment proposed, in clause 46, page 25, line 17, insert the words as printed on the Marshall list.
Lord Holmes of Richmond
My Lords, I rise to speak to amendments 214, 15 and 16 in my name and signed by the noble Baroness, Baroness Brinton. We'll come to them. It's a pleasure to follow Baroness Brinton, who set out all of the issues in this group. As I said in the previous group, planning should be experiential, not operational. It's about a passenger journey right from the point that she or he leaves their home, or even before that point when she or he decides they want to try and purchase a ticket online.
If you plan operationally, it's never going to work for the passenger, and it's certainly never going to work for the disabled passenger. Worth reminding the committee, I think, at this stage of the progress of the bill, what we're all talking about when we talk about accessibility. Accessibility isn't for disabled people, accessibility is for all people. Inclusive by design, not for disabled people, for all people. Because one would imagine it's self-evident, but seemingly it needs restating, if you make a change which seemingly has to be purported to be said for a disabled person, everybody benefits.
Suitcases, toddlers in pushchairs with parents, older people, younger people, all people. Accessibility for all people, inclusive by design for all people, planning and thinking through in a co-produced, co-creative way the passenger experience, and only having done that move into the operational. What's extraordinary in some of Baroness Brinton's testimony is that even when a railway plans operationally, it's not even planning operationally, because if it were, the issues that we've heard about, not least around lift provision, wouldn't happen.
And yet it does blighting lives. To rehearse the statistics I set out in the previous group in terms of employment only 41% of disabled people of working age in employment set against 83% for the broad population. And that's hardly surprising if you take the examples which Baroness Brinton has set out. Going through all of that exhausted before you've even got to work before you've even begun the first minute of your working day is it any wonder that it's 41% in employment for disabled people and 37% for those who are blind and partially sighted. My Lords my amendments 214 through 216 do some of that experiential thinking.
And I must as others in previous groups have done commend the Minister of State Lord Hendy for all of the work that he has done whilst being in post as Minister. But before that all of the work that he did as commissioner across London because he showed what is possible and he never took no for an answer or accepted the status quo or accepting just because you can't make 100% of something accessible doesn't mean you shouldn't make part of it accessible so by doing that you've made an accessible service. And this goes to the heart of 214 around level boarding because he and I and others were told it's impossible to make the London Underground accessible for wheelchair users. How's that doable? But he and others worked on the whole concept of platform humps.
And the underground not every door of every train of every station but nor did it need to be it was a practical effective accessible inclusive solution where the trains could pull up the disabled passenger would know from information from the station they were coming from that they would arrive where the platform hump was at that station and not only could they access and egress the train they could do it independently with dignity as with any other passenger. Why was that possible? It was possible because we had the most immovable of deadlines. Nobody would have said what a great accessible Olympic and Paralympic Games I had in 2013. The most immovable of deadlines having a target having that vision and putting it into a mission is the way to get things to happen.
That's why I suggest for level boarding 2036 year end what a phenomenal celebration that would be achievable if the same logic and approach is taken as was taken in that London 2012 planning not that every door of every station of every platform but that every station in that way would be accessible for disabled passengers. Achievable London 2012 showed what could be done. We only had fewer than seven years to achieve that. This amendment suggests over 10 years. And no matter how good the celebrations were 2012 sport is fantastic but what a celebration to have a level accessible rail network across the whole country enabling empowering what possibilities not for disabled people for all people.
My amendment on the accessibility of the rolling stock follows a similar logic. Why should it be that if you're a wheelchair user and you're fortunate enough to be able to get on the train, that you can't sit with your friends, your family, your colleagues, with access to the buffet, as Baroness Brinton rightly highlighted last week, and with access to the accessible toilet facilities? It's extraordinary that this is having to be asked for in 2026. It's basic, it's fundamental, and yet disabled people still can't rely on this on the rail network. My final amendment goes to the question of staffing, which Baroness Brinton's already touched upon.
This is about enabling, empowering, training and supporting all our fabulous staff across our rail network, so they have the comfort and the confidence to act, to provide support and assistance to disabled people, and that they are there on the station in operating hours. Again, this isn't about making a change for disabled people. This is making a change for all people, and it goes to the heart of demonstrating how this change would of course benefit disabled people, but would have benefits in terms of the safety of all passengers on that station by dint of having staff, humans, at all times of the operating hours of that station. Again, this is basic stuff, but it's not currently the case. And finally, my Lords, if we don't plan experientially, if we continue to so chronically insufficiently plan operationally, we can get results such as this, which were the case, and I'll ask the Minister whether this is still the case.
We had stations on the network that were described as fully accessible. And indeed, those stations were fully accessible. The wheelchair user could enter the station, take the lift down to the platform, position themselves by the train with no hope whatsoever of being able to get on that train because there was no accessibility at that point. Can the Minister confirm that there are no stations at all on the network where the station describes itself as accessible, but it is not actually possible through all hours of the operation of that station for disabled passengers, and indeed for all passengers, to board, to access and egress the train service itself? I look forward to the Minister's response.
Mark Harper
My Lords, Committee I hope will be pleased to know that I'm not planning on speaking to all of the amendments in the group.
I, there were a couple that leaped out at me, I thought worthy of comment. But first of all, I'd just like to say it's a great pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord Holmes, because I think he repeats something which bears repeating, which he said before, and which I have said, which is that if you make services, all services, but we're talking here about railways, more accessible for disabled people, you are making them better for everybody. And I think Baroness Brinton also mentioned in her remarks that we're not just talking about wheelchair users, but we're talking about people with visual impairments, there are people with hearing impairments. I notice in some of her amendments she also talks about wayfinding, because it's also about people, for example, with learning disabilities, who may not have any physical disabilities themselves, but need better signage and clearer ways of navigating a station. And all of that's about making sure that disabled people can have the same life experiences as everybody else.
And my noble friend Lord Holmes also refers to the very important point about making sure that people that are able to can work. And if you're not able to, if you're not able to use a car, you depend on public transport, well if the public transport doesn't work for you, you're going to find getting into the workplace and staying in the workplace very difficult. And that is of course a big focus of public policy at the moment, both the government and opposition are talking about it, and this I think will make a critical improvement. So the two amendments I wanted to talk to briefly, first one is amendment 219 about the single accessibility digital service. And two things I wanted to say, one was I absolutely see the benefit of trying to bring together all of the digital tools that people need for all aspects of the service.
The bit I would particularly commend Baroness Brinton and her colleagues for is that it says that GBR must provide or secure the provision of, which I think is incredibly important. I, she'll know, am somewhat skeptical about the ability of GBR to be at the cutting edge of innovation on digital technology, but it absolutely does have a responsibility to make sure this stuff happens. And what I think is much more likely is if it makes clear, as we discussed at the time, the data that's necessary on a number of these facilities, for example it's referred to here about lifts, ramps, escalators and other accessibility equipment are in working order, that means the data about whether they're in working order needs to be available. My sense is if they make sure all of that information is available, we know from other services that nimble, agile providers will provide the technological solutions to use that data for customers, and will probably do it more quickly, more cheaply, and in a more accessible way than a monopolistic state behemoth will. So I think the key thing for me is that it's about providing the service and making sure the data's available, but it isn't wedded to this amendment that GBR has to do the delivery itself, which I think is incredibly important and much more likely to be successful, but it does have to make sure the data's available for other people to produce the app.
The second one, and final one that I'm going to comment on, is amendment 220M in the names of my noble friends Baroness Grey-Thompson and Baroness Brinton about passenger assistance, and making it a statutory entitlement so that passengers who need help to use the railway are effectively put on a level playing field with everybody else.
And I think the very important part of the wording of this amendment is that it should also be an entitlement for passengers who have not booked assistance in advance. Now, clearly, if you book the assistance in advance, it does help with providers to do that, but it shouldn't be necessary for disabled people to have to over-plan and micromanage their lives in a way that non-disabled people don't have to just to get around. Now, I know they do, and I see Baroness Brinton nodding in a knowing way, and they do at the moment. And it may be that it's never going to be possible to have no planning and no forward thought, but it shouldn't be necessary to do it to the extent it is now. And I think to have that statutory entitlement and to have as at least an aim that you don't need to have booked the assistance will make people think about not just providing enough assistance, also to think about smart ways of doing it to make sure that staff are flexibly deployed, trained.
Baroness Brinton referred to the training, whether they cover the breadth of disability, so that you've got people who are able to respond. What you really want are staff that can talk to the passenger, understand what the needs are, and then have the skills themselves to deliver what is required, or the ability to call on the help of others to deliver what is required without everything having been prescribed in advance. So, I'd be interested to know from the Minister whether this is an aspiration of the government. I suspect it's an aspiration of his. And if this amendment doesn't do the job, whether the government would think about bringing back an amendment at report stage to make the provision of assistance a statutory entitlement, which would improve the circumstances for disabled people.
And as I said, I am particularly, I think, struck by the need to not have to book everything in advance. That clearly makes the delivery of services better, but it shouldn't be a requirement. Disabled people should have the same right to be spontaneous, to turn up for a journey, to not have to plan everything in advance, and also to be able to change things on the fly depending on what happens during their day. Now, it may be that you can't get to the same level of flexibility for some people with particular needs. That may just not be possible, but we can do an awful lot better than we do at the moment.
And I was therefore struck by this amendment, and I think it worthy of the Committee's support.
Caroline Pidgeon
My Lords, my noble friend Baroness Brinton has spoken in great detail and so eloquently about the issues and thinking behind the detailed amendments in this group that I only wish to really add my complete support to it. We do need our railways to be accessible to all passengers and reliable for all passengers, so people are not left stranded, can travel around with ease and without fear of something going wrong. And just as we've had this debate, it reminded me yesterday as I was sitting at home planning my trip to Kew Gardens to suddenly discover there's a rail replacement bus for part of the journey. I could quickly use a few apps and work out a way around that I could avoid using that rail replacement bus. But actually, if I had a mobility issue, that would have been so much harder and actually probably you would have had to have cancelled the planned trip.
The point about lifts is really important, about parts. And I recall, racking my memory back to the 2012 Games, there were lots of spare parts and we had teams all over to make sure, certainly in London, that the lifts did not break down. But also there's the issue of having trained staff at station able to help with lifts, and a number of them on the Underground in the past have been closed because they didn't have trained staff at station. So it's a double issue there. But I really think this debate has teased out a lot of issues around this accessibility agenda, and I really hope that the Minister will be able to talk to us about a way forward before report stage on these important issues.
Speaker 37
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords for their contributions to this important debate. Disabled passengers deserve a good, reliable and dignified service from our railways. What we have heard today and what the evidence shows is that too often this is simply not the case. The government's own accessibility roadmap found that disabled people make 53% fewer rail journeys than non-disabled people. It also found that more than a third of disabled passengers would use rail more if accessibility improved.
A number of these amendments dealing with step-free access and level boarding. There is an important distinction between being able to reach a platform and being able to board a train independently. The government's own figures suggest genuine level boarding is available only at a very small proportion of stations. I therefore understand why my noble friend Lord Holmes of Richmond and other noble Lords have tabled amendments seeking greater ambition on level boarding, accessible rolling stock and new stations. I hope the minister can tell us what the government's own timetable and ambition are in this area.
Passenger assistance is another major concern. The latest ORR figures show that 1.9 million pre-booked assists were made last year, alongside at least 1.5 million turn-up-and-go assists. Yet 10% of passengers surveyed said they received none of the assistance they had booked. Disabled passengers should not have to plan every journey around the possibility that promised assistance might not arrive. The amendments tabled by the noble Baroness Lady Grey-Thompson on accessibility standards, enforcement, senior accountability and reporting raise important questions about how these duties will work in practice.
I do not propose to commit to the precise structures they have proposed, but the underlying point is an important one. Accessibility duties must mean something in practice. There must be clear responsibility, proper reporting and effective consequences when standards are repeatedly not met. There is a strong case for greater consistency. Disabled passengers should not face different rules on wheelchairs, mobility scooters or assistance simply because they change operator.
Nor should they be disadvantaged when disruption occurs and replacement service is inaccessible. The noble Lords who have tabled these amendments speak with considerable authority and experience on these issues. I hope the minister can provide reassurance that disabled people will be a genuine priority for Great British Railways and that accessibility will be embedded in its operation from the outset rather than treated as an afterthought.
Gerard Peter Hendy
My Lords, I'm bound to say to start with that those who question the concept of Great British Railways and the reform of the railway have to explain why the previous system so conspicuously has failed to deliver the consistency that all passengers, including disabled passengers, deserve.
It's one of the best reasons to create GBR as a, as a, as a controlling mind because the, it's consistency that will allow the freedom of travel that Noble Baroness Brinton, the Noble Lord Holmes, and indeed the Noble Baroness Tanni Grey-Thompson when she tabled these amendments, is looking for. I, I add to the Noble Baroness Brinton my good wishes to Baroness Grey-Thompson and hope she'll be back shortly, though she did send me a picture of the lifts at Eaglescliffe yesterday, so she's not, she was mobile then. She said, she said to me colloquially last week that her amendments amounted to a, to a bucket list, but I can't argue about any of the, any of the content of it, and I'm determined to change the experience that people have and make sure this bill leaves accessibility on the railway in a better place than it is now. I'm going to try to deal with these amendments by theme and quite quickly, because what I want to say to Noble Baroness Brinton and Noble Lords here is that I am, as I said at the previous committee session, very keen indeed to meet about all of these amendments to see what it is that we actually need to put into the bill at the report stage and what can be left to the various other devices that will allow things to happen on the railway. If I might deal with 214, 5, 7, 8, and 220J, which are all about accessibility of rolling stock.
It is clear to me that progress on level boarding has been hindered because decisions about trains and stations have historically been made in silos, and many of them even recently have not been taken with a view to accessibility at all. With its coherent whole-system view, GBR can and will fix this. The rolling stock and infrastructure strategy published on the 28th of September sets out how GBR will approach rolling stock design and procurement, and it is quite clear, and I'm happy to say so, that unassisted level boarding and alighting will be the baseline expectation for all new trains on Great British Railways. They'll use low-floor designs, doors will be aligned with the standard platform height of 915 millimeters, and the only problem with that is that platforms vary all across the network, so a nationwide platform study, a network-wide platform study is already underway, which will identify what else will be needed to achieve level boarding. And as an aside, but an important aside, His Majesty's Treasury agreed to the publication of the rolling stock strategy.
Beyond boarding, passengers need to also be able to move through trains easily, use the facilities with greater independence. Toilets, internal layouts, aisles, signage, dedicated wheelchair spaces, multi-use spaces for wheelchairs, scooters, buggies, and bikes all need to be considered as part of this strategy, and it commits GBR to engaging directly with passengers, disabled passengers, the passenger watchdog, and other representative bodies on rolling stock design. The business plan for GBR will set out how it will meet the strategy along with its accessibility duty and any accessibility standards set by the watchdog. We expect the business plan to be updated annually to provide a transparent record of GBR's progress towards its accessibility goals, exactly as proposed by the Noble Baroness Brinton's amendment 217. On 198A, 220B, G, S, and 330F, and the topic of accessibility standards and governance, the bill gives the passenger watchdog new powers to set passenger experience standards, including on accessibility.
They will be binding on all operators via their license conditions and enforced by the ORR.
Amendment 198 proposes that the watchdog sets standards relating to passenger information access for disabled passengers, and I absolutely expect the watchdog to set standards in those areas. I don't think the list in subsection 2 of Clause 46 is exhaustive, and it is wide enough in my belief to cover all the areas proposed in the amendments. I also agree that accessibility must be represented at the highest levels of railway leadership, the object of Amendment 220S. I'm pleased to confirm that GBR will have a board-level accessibility champion and a senior leader accountable for accessibility, achieving the outcome sought by this amendment. On 220B, G and 330F, I would say that the Bill already provides a clear framework for accessibility oversight and enforcement.
The watchdog will research and investigate problems, consult with passengers, design standards and publish evidence on passenger experience, including passenger assist data to ensure transparency. If operators fall short of these standards, the ORR will take enforcement against them. I think that's clearer and better than creating an additional independent commission or revisiting the enforcement arrangements. On station accessibility, 220, 220F, 220T and 220Q, the Access for All programme has of course been designed to improve accessibility at stations and there are now 1,484 with a further 12 to come. But we're committed to reforming Access for All into a rolling programme of improvements, informed by consultation with disabled people and local transport bodies.
That should result in sustained funding to enable more efficient long-term planning and delivery, providing greater certainty for the programme and the supply chain that supports it. And I have to say I'm frustrated myself at the length of time these things take to deliver and the individuality of the solutions proposed in circumstances where you would imagine that they should be done on a more consistent basis. Whilst funding decisions beyond 2030 will be a matter for future spending reviews, I do absolutely expect the improvements to continue and GBR, the ORR and the Secretary of State will all be bound by the accessibility duty every time they develop another five-year business plan, propose new investments or design and refurbish stations. I hope that's a better way of embedding accessibility into long-term decision-making on the railway. We also recognise the importance of integrated journeys.
We published Better Connected this April, our strategy for integrated transport, committing 616 million to improving walking, wheeling and cycling routes to stations. And it also sets out that GBR should work with local authorities to connect stations to other transport modes. Additionally, we've committed to deliver a new accessible journey planner that will be integrated with Passenger Assist. In time, it will incorporate first and last mile connections such as buses, trams and active travel options, creating an end-to-end travel experience. On passenger information, which is 220E and 220N, I completely agree that all passengers should have access to clear and reliable information.
We've completed a national accessibility audit of all stations and have undertaken a major redesign of station pages on National Rail Enquiries, making significantly more information available for passengers. And we're taking forward welcome points and a national British Sign Language service to improve how passengers access information and assistance. But I recognise that there's more to do. I've mentioned the accessibility standards set by the strengthened passenger watchdog, and I would reiterate that these will include standards relating to passenger information.
Mark Harper
Just before the Minister concludes, as I felt he was moving towards, can I just say two things? First of all, I'd agree with what many have said, including Lord Holmes, about his excellent track record in this space. He, although he was going through obviously not accepting the amendments, he did say, I think, that he was open to looking at what should go into the bill, perhaps to strengthen the position. And all I would say in response to that is, as well as meeting with Lord Holmes and Baroness Grey-Thompson and Baroness Brinton, perhaps if it's at all possible diary-wise, given my experience both as Secretary of State and also former disability minister, I'd welcome being involved in those decisions. And I'll try and play a constructive role with colleagues.
They obviously have lived experience that I don't, but hopefully I can help bring some of my experience in trying to get to what solutions might be sensible to include in the bill, if that's at all possible and if they feel that would be helpful.
Gerard Peter Hendy
I think I would just absolutely welcome anybody's contribution to this subject. I don't think it's solely a matter for people with disabilities. I think, in fact, that quite a lot of this is about the whole consistency of the journey, and it means as much to every traveler as it does to people who need specific assistance. So I'm very happy to take the noble lord's suggestion up with him. And I hope noble lords would recognize that I've tried as hard as I can to meet everybody on this bill, if only because actually it will be better for the interaction that we have in this committee and outside it.
I'll move on because of time.
Anthony Berkeley
Before my noble friend moves on, could I just ask him in respect of the level boarding which he mentioned, which he's made great progress and I congratulate him. But there has been a problem in the past that the level boarding height for trains using the HS2 route was different to the ones at the stations that they would go into in, say, Manchester Piccadilly or Glasgow. He mentioned a figure of 915 millimeters, which I think was the standard. But has this difference been resolved, and are HS2 passengers now going to be able to have level boarding on all the platforms they're likely to use?
Gerard Peter Hendy
Well, there's a subject. With about 40 minutes to go in this committee, I daren't even start that discussion. But the noble lord must recognize that the rolling stock order for HS2 was in fact, the order was placed some years ago. And the challenge with HS2 now is to make those trains both fit for the dedicated infrastructure they'll run on, but also for the existing network. And we will have to do absolutely our best with it.
I won't, there's more to say about the new GBR website and app, how much it will do, the fact that it should include, it will include an accessible journey planner and real-time updates on staff availability and the status of station facilities such as lifts, and also being able to book passenger assist alongside buying a ticket. On accessibility during disruption and with rail replacement, I completely agree, and in fact my noble friend, the Minister for Buses in the other place and I have spent quite a lot of the summer on a prolonged and I believe to be successful mission to make sure that rail replacement vehicles have the same accessibility requirements as other public service vehicles. It has not been easy at all, but we are getting there because it's quite unacceptable that when trains don't run accessibility becomes even worse than when they do run. And I completely agree, I can see the noble Baroness nodding, and we know that especially under a fragmented railway it was profoundly difficult actually to find out what really went on from each different train operator, but we do know that now and we are doing something about it because I think it's already a legal obligation to provide it. The accessibility roadmap that we committed to during the last bill has already begun driving improvements.
The National Rail Enquiries journey planner now includes real-time information on disruption and rail replacement services, and we have provided actually the thick end of a million pounds to develop technologies to improve audio and visual information on rail replacement vehicles in order to deliver real-time information in accessible formats. But the real difference made by this bill is that we're creating the passenger watchdog precisely to set national standards for operators to follow, including baseline expectations for provision of things like accessible rail replacement services exactly as the noble Baroness Grey-Thompson proposes in 220L. On staffing and training for staff, which is 216, 219, 220D, 220H, 220M and 342A, nobody could not be moved by the experiences described both in this committee, at previous committee meetings and to me in private by the noble Baroness and by others. There are many, many instances where the railway should have and must do better. And although disability and equality training is mandatory under operators' accessible travel policies currently, sadly it varies enormously between operators and we know that.
So we're piloting a new comprehensive training program co-designed in partnership with disabled people to improve consistency across the network. It will be fully in place in GBR day one and it will teach staff to understand the expectations and the legal rights of disabled people and best practice for providing passenger assist, and it will include supporting people with non-visible disabilities. We've invested more than 11 million in improving passenger assist, but I would be the first to say that clearly it isn't consistent enough at the moment. All of the things like handovers between station staff, the booking experience which differs between train companies and between apps, better integration of assistance requests, seat reservations and accessible journey planning all need to be made consistent.
And what I would say is that we are committed absolutely to GBR's future digital platform, whoever it's actually provided by, to provide a single unified offer allowing disabled passengers to plan journeys, buy tickets, book passenger assist, and access support in one place. And I think that's just one of many reasons why I strongly believe passenger assistance will improve under the direct mind of GBR. I would just conclude quickly by saying that I think much of what we've heard this evening and in other places and what I hear in private is that the railway seems to have had to have been kicked constantly into dealing with this. And what I'd like to see and what I believe this bill's going to provide is an organisation that's committed to actively providing accessibility without needing excessive punishment for so doing. I have listened very carefully to every point that's been made today.
I haven't addressed them all deliberately because of the time that we have. But as I said at the start, I am committed to having further meetings with noble lords and baronesses to discuss how best we deal with this both within the bill and outside it. And given the period of time that we've got before the report stage, I will endeavour to do that to all our satisfaction so that we can come to report stage understanding what the bill can do, what will be in the other supporting things like the GBR license and other documents, and move into a better future. In the meantime, I'd be grateful if the amendments could be withdrawn.
Sal Sarah Brinton
My lords, I want to thank everyone who's contributed to this debate. It was somewhat daunting to have 25 amendments in one group, even if they were covering the same theme. There was a lot of rich detail within that, and I think everyone who spoke has added value to the debate, including, if I might say so, the minister who has once again shown his interest in trying to improve the services where there've been problems in the past. He says what went on with rail replacement. I know what went on with rail replacement.
The traincos bought the cheapest system they could, and they went for coaches, not for buses, and it was just impossible for anybody in a wheelchair to get anywhere near it. And outside of London and Liverpool and Manchester, it's very difficult to get a wheelchair taxi in the evening, and it's very difficult to get a wheelchair taxi at going to and coming back from school time because the contracts are let to the local council. So they airily say, "It's all right, you can have a taxi," but you can't because there aren't any running at that time. So I'd be really grateful if that can be looked at. That's important.
I want to reiterate the point that I have great hopes for GBR. And I talked about procurement and the lifts. I do think that that will be a real benefit, that instead of being done on a much more ad hoc basis, for one organisation to be able to do it will give it enormous power. On the detail of what we need on the face of the bill versus how other things can be covered, I'm very grateful to the noble lord the minister for suggesting a meeting. I suggest that we might need more than half an hour to go through it.
Speaker 50
Very glad that the minister agrees with me. In which case, can I thank everyone for their contribution, and I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Ilora Finlay
Is it your lordship's pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 199, Lord Evans, not moved.
Not moved.
Ilora Finlay
The question is that clause 46 stand part of the bill.
As many as that opinion will say content. The contrary not content. The contents have it. Amendment 200, Baroness Brinton, not moved. Amendment 201, Lord Evans of Gilsland.
Not moved.
Ilora Finlay
Moved. Amendment 201A, Baroness Jones, not moved. The question is that clause 47 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say content. Content.
Contrary not content. The contents have it. Amendment 202, Lord Evans of Gilsland.
Not moved.
Ilora Finlay
Moved. Amendment 202A, Baroness Jones, not moved. The question is that clause 48 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say content. Content.
Contrary not content. The contents have it. Amendment 202B, Baroness Jones, not moved. Amendment 203, Lord Evans of Gilsland.
Not moved.
Ilora Finlay
Moved. The question is that clause 49 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say content. Content. Contrary not content.
The contents have it. The question is that clause 50 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say content. Content. Contrary not content.
The contents have it. Amendment 204, Lord Holmes of Richmond, not moved. Amendment 204A, Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb, not moved. The question is that clauses 51 and 52 stand part of the bill en bloc. As many as that opinion will say content.
Content. Contrary not content. The contents have it. Amendments 204B and 204C, Baroness Jones, not moved en bloc. Amendment 205, Lord Berkeley, not moved.
The question is that clause 53 stand part of the bill. As many as that opinion will say content. Content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.
The question is that clauses 54 to 58 stand part of the bill en bloc. As many as that opinion will say content. Content. Contrary not content. The contents have it.
Amendment 206, Baroness Pidgeon.
Caroline Pidgeon
Thank you very much. If Great British Railways is to succeed, passengers need to see a real difference and have confidence in their train services. That is why I have tabled amendment 206 today. This amendment requires within six months of the act passing for the Secretary of State to lay a passenger's charter before Parliament. Passenger charters are not new.
Every train operating company has one of sorts, but this amendment would introduce greater consistency, cut the gap between good intentions and reality, and critically create a strong charter to put passenger experience first. The current rail system does not guarantee a seat for passengers with the exception of advance tickets, though numerous times I have found the onboard system is not working so people are allowed to sit anywhere, causing serious upset for those who have reserved seats for a long journey to find it's taken, and particularly it's an issue if you have mobility issues or you have children with you, and knocking confidence in using the railway services. Perhaps noble lords, if they want to have a conversation, could have it outside rather than when I'm speaking, please. Many trains lack the necessary space for storage of luggage and buggies, and the quality of Wi-Fi and mobile phone signal reception is highly variable, to say the least. So a new passenger's charter for Great British Railways would give confidence to passengers in the service they should receive across the network and should help to encourage more people to choose the railway for their journeys.
Now the areas we believe should be covered include guaranteed seating for journeys greater than 30 minutes, reliability targets, and over time clear improvements to trains including high-speed Wi-Fi, power outlets, storage for luggage, bikes, and pushchairs, cleanliness and accessibility standards, and an old favorite, onboard catering for services of two hours or more, something I still regularly discuss with the minister with regards to South West Rail and I'm hoping we get some progress soon.
Automatic delay repay, which my noble friend Baroness Lehman has spoken passionately about, and once the charter is established, a framework for compensation for failing to comply with the charter. Now, we understand the train designs will take longer to come on board, so a timetable for that would have to suffice in the short term. And in addition, following the discussion in the last group of amendments, a guarantee relating to improving the accessibility of trains, stations, areas immediately surrounding stations and interfaces with connecting transport modes and replacement road services for passengers with disabilities. But once train fleets are upgraded consistently and have the amenities the modern passenger expects, the charter can be properly expanded to include the principle that what is offered on a given train fleet, whether that's seats, toilets or Wi-Fi, should be working. Now, in the European Union, rail passengers' rights are protected in the following areas: compensation for train delays, right to self-rerouting where passengers have not been offered a solution within so many minutes of a disruption, through-ticket rights where passengers have rights if they miss a connection, improving accessibility rights for people with disabilities or reduced mobility, and dedicated places for bikes, and this is dedicated spaces which are mandatory for all new trains that have been ordered or upgraded after June 2025.
Now, various operators across the world have their own terms and conditions, sometimes they call them charters, which outline different service levels that they're prepared to provide. So you've got the Public Transport Victoria in Australia, which has customer service charters, and Amtrak in the US has a 10-point pledge to their customers. And of course, domestically, we have a number of charters, whether it's LNER, Southern Railway, South Western Railway or TransPennine Express. And we strongly believe that there should be one Great British Railways passenger charter to constantly improve services and the standard of service passengers should receive on every journey. And we hope the government will be sympathetic to this amendment and its aims.
Now, the other amendments in this group from my noble friend Baroness Lehman cover the issue of the use of electronic audio devices on rail services, and we welcome the government's announcement today. The world is a very different place to certainly when I started commuting and traveling around by rail, where people used to read newspapers and books. Most of us are working on devices or listening to podcasts, or people are watching or scrolling, looking at videos, even catching up on shows. And this all requires the Wi-Fi infrastructure as I mentioned earlier, but some passengers choose to let us all share whatever they are doing on their phone. Occasionally it's a phone or video call, but more often whatever show they are enjoying or music.
And this can also apply to children and adults gaming too. Many of us do still enjoy the quiet carriages on our long-distance journeys, and I have to say I have seen them enforced in recent weeks by South West Rail staff. But these amendments have really been tabled to probe the government about what action they will take in this area, and obviously the announcement today is part of that. It's increasingly a real problem for passengers who don't want to be disturbed on their journey. I look forward to the minister's response to this group on the passenger experience.
And I beg to move.
Ilora Finlay
Amendment proposed after clause 58, insert the new clause, the words as printed on the Marshall list.
Speaker 32
My Lords, I rise incredibly quickly to back up Baroness Pidgeon on what she said so excellently. But it occurred to me that as we are in the Moses Room and we have Moses bringing down the table of the law of the Israelites, it might be apt if from here comes a passenger charter that people can take seriously. I think there's a lot of cynicism about Great British Rail, and I think this would be a perfect way to actually make it, here is what we believe in, here is what we are going to do.
Mark Harper
My Lords, I just wanted to speak and ask the Minister some questions about amendment 311, which is obviously linked to the government's announcements today. Now, the Minister will know that there's been a considerable amount of cross-party support for the announcements today, both my party last year for both buses and trains, and the Liberal Democrats, in the spirit of sharing the benefit of both campaigned for these measures. So I think in principle I support them. And I'm a rail user, and I, if I ever use my devices for sound, I always use my headphones, which I think is appropriate. And in fact, just last week I was using the train and I politely asked somebody who was scrolling through her phone and we were having little snippets of every little video that she found if she could possibly not do that, and that polite injunction did the trick.
Now, the problem is it doesn't always do the trick. And some of the people who are the worst offenders are the sort of people that firstly you probably wouldn't want to speak to directly for fear of what might happen. So I suppose my question for the Minister is, given that there have been laws or regulations or rules in place for a really quite considerable period of time that says people shouldn't play music loudly or other noise, this is primarily either an enforcement question or a culture question. And I suppose that the two questions I would have for the Minister are, if you raise the profile of this issue and you have more signage, more announcements, as long as there aren't too many announcements because frankly lots of announcements are just as bad as people playing devices to be perfect honest, if they're not very helpful announcements. Announcements about your journey are very useful, but lots of other stuff's not really very helpful at all and is annoying.
How much does that shift the culture? And to what extent is the annoyance caused done by a relatively small number of hardcore offenders? Now, I don't know what the answer is to that question, and I don't know whether there's any good data on it. Because the question is how do you enforce this? Because, you know, it's not always reasonable for train managers to do this.
They can have a go, but again if somebody refuses to take any notice or behaves aggressively towards them or violently, that's a bit of a problem. And I'm not sure, given again we had this discussion last week that British Transport Police have limited resources, I'm not sure they may have to do it in extremis. I'm not sure I want them to be the first port of call to enforce noise regulations given the very important job they have to do, the conversation we had last week about combating, for example, violence against women and girls. I think that in my book that would be higher up the list of things for BTP to be focusing on than noise, important though that is. So I suppose my question is on both buses and trains, and obviously we'll keep it train focused here, how does the government actually see this working in practice?
Because the danger with announcements that I think pretty much everybody would agree with, I don't think there's anybody that's going to disagree with it, and I think I saw some polling that said I think 100% of people agreed with it, is how do you actually make it happen in practice? Because if you talk about things that we think are desirable, that are good, and you don't actually have any specific concrete plans to make them happen, all you do is increase cynicism and make people even unhappier than they were in the first place.
So I think this is primarily an enforcement question. So in response to amendment 311, and no doubt the government will look forward to the opportunity to comment on their announcements today, I want to hear some very specific practical steps that ministers are going to take on trains to improve the passenger experience as far as unwanted noise are concerned, and specifics I think will be very helpful indeed.
Daniel Moylan
My Lords, could I start by saying that I welcome the amendments, the linked amendments tabled by the noble Baroness Lady Lehman on tackling anti-social behavior. It must be a coincidence that they arrived in the debate on the same day the government said they were going to do something about it. So there's a great danger that we're all going to be in violent agreement on this particular topic. But my noble friend Lord Harper makes a very good point. We have a government which I believe the Prime Minister has instructed ministers that they have to make one sort of improve your life announcement every day this week.
And it's the announcement, the policy is the announcement effectively. So what on earth is actually going to be done to make these effective and so they make a big difference to people's lives? On the question of the passenger's charter, I might just start with one little fact. I understand that in the latest four-week period, only 51% of trains between Guildford, Woking and Waterloo arrived on time. That's what South Western Railway is achieving at the moment.
This is the railway which when it was nationalized, the Secretary of State announced was a new dawn. But this is what nationalization is giving us. And it makes the case, the very strong case for a passenger's charter. Now the noble Baroness Lady Pidgeon has made that case. I don't necessarily have to agree with her on every detail of what it should contain, but I do agree with her on the principle that there should be a passenger's charter and that it should come not in detail from Parliament, because this amendment does not ask Parliament to write the charter, it requires as I understand it the Secretary of State to do that, and so that passengers know against which standards our new people's no-choice railway is going to be judged and that we should have a role in setting that.
Now the noble Lord the Minister I suspect will say no to the noble Baroness. And it's another instance of the government's or Great British Rail's attitude to this project. Not that they oppose that passengers have rights as such and they'll probably internalize it all, but they don't want to be told by somebody outside Great British Railways what to do. They want us to take the whole thing on trust and they will sort it out and they don't need to be told. The regulator apart from safety is being emasculated, the Passengers Council is to have no powers of direction, the Secretary of State's control is going to be extremely limited and attenuated and so forth.
We're told nothing about who's going to be on the board, what powers the board is going to have and so forth.
The Passengers' Council, we're not allowed to specify what sort of person might be on it. Everything has to be entrusted to Great British Railways. And I really think that is not going to wash. And a passenger's charter is so... so obviously necessary that I think, again, it's almost inevitable that we will return to these... this issue, unless the noble lord the minister defies my expectations.
Seb Dance
My lords, I'm going to take this opportunity to remind the committee that intervention should be brief questions for clarification, not speeches, and I ask noble lords seeking to intervene to keep their remarks concise. Thank you.
Gerard Peter Hendy
My lords, the best improve-your-life announcement I can make is that I'm determined to finish this group by quarter to nine. And I'll start by saying how wrong the noble Lord Moylan is. I understand the strong... the strong interest behind amendment 206, and I share the ambition of the noble Baroness Pidgeon for a railway that delivers better outcomes for passengers. Although I don't think the level of detail which is proposed in the amendment should be in the bill, I do agree with her that GBR should have a passenger charter. I can see her point that passengers want to understand what service they can expect from GBR, and we in this committee will also want to satisfy ourselves that GBR's passenger offer is fit for purpose.
It's important that GBR has a clear policy setting out what it aims to deliver for its customers, and I appreciate the noble baroness's thoughts today on what that charter might contain. So I'll be happy to discuss this with her in more detail in the coming weeks. On to amendments 311 and 343, we are, as I think noble lords said, in vibrant agreement because of the nuisance electronic devices can cause when they're not used responsibly. I should just say that bylaw seven of the National Railway Bylaws makes it an offence to cause annoyance through the use of sound-producing equipment and provides for fines up to a thousand pounds. And noble lords will have seen today the government's announcement, which is about a nationwide campaign about sharing the carriage and not the noise, encouraging passengers to use headphones and to be considerate of those around them.
The campaign will highlight the impact that playing music, videos, or phone... or phone calls aloud can have on fellow travellers and reinforce the message that existing railway rules already provide for enforcement action where behaviour causes nuisance or annoyance. We are... I'm sadly I'm bound to use this... we are going to make a noise about this.
Mark Harper
Just before the minister moves on to his next point, he mentioned there the fact that some specific regulations already prohibit this behaviour and referred to the fines. I don't know whether it's published... it's publicly accessible, but is he able to set out for the committee, I suspect not now, but if he could write to us with how many of those fines, you know, the data on the number of fines issued, the value of the fines, the extent to which the enforcement of the existing rules has been effective or not? And then we can judge ahead of report stage about whether further enforcement measures need to be put into the bill.
Gerard Peter Hendy
If there is such information, I will of course supply it to the committee. The noble Lord Harper did refer to a question about whether this is enforcement or culture. And of course, the truth is it's not a choice between one or the other, it's both. Making a fuss about this and bringing it to the wider attention of the public, which has really very successfully been done today, is part of the solution because we do need people to think about the convenience and comfort of people around them. And if we draw it to their attention, I've no doubt that some people will change their habits.
But there is also an enforcement point about it. And enforcement does need to be from railway staff where it's safe to do so, and sometimes by the British Transport Police where it's not safe for anybody else to do so. So this is the start of a campaign, including the use of 61016 where that's appropriate. And it's why, apart from any other reasons, it's another reason why the budget of the British Transport Police is being increased by 63 million pounds over the next three years, enabling recruitment of over 200 additional officers. I think that I've hopefully have adequately addressed these three amendments and that I hope that I will enable the sponsors to withdraw them.
Caroline Pidgeon
I'd like to thank the noble Lord the Minister for his answer and thank you for your support for a passenger charter and the work you're doing in the other area around noise on trains. I look forward to having discussions with you before report stage on how to take the amendment forward, and I withdraw the amendment.
Ilora Finlay
Is it your Lordships' pleasure that the amendment be withdrawn? The amendment is by leave withdrawn. Amendment 207, Baroness Pidgeon, not moved. Amendment 208, Baroness Lehman, not moved. Amendment 209, Baroness Pidgeon, not moved.
Amendment 210, Baroness Morgan of Cotes, not moved. Amendment 211 and 212, Lord Young of Cookham, not moved en bloc. We now reach the target from that group of amendments, and my Lords, the committee now stands adjourned.