Highways (Financing) Bill
Legend
Transcript markers
- text Sentence being played
- text Search result
- text Intervention cited by the link you opened
Click a sentence to play the video from that moment. Select text to quote it with the speaker, timestamp and link.
More options
Offset
Transcript offset
Export
Replay
Versions of this video
Transcripts may differ slightly from one version to another.
Highways (Financing) Bill House of Commons
Follow its sittings




Jacob Collier?
Jim Dickson?
Olly Glover?
Aye.
Alison Griffiths?
Douglas Lumsden?
Justin Madders?
Amanda Martin?
Tristan Osborne?
Dr Peter Prinsley?
Richard Quigley?
Shivani Raja?
Mike Reader?
Greg Smith?
Michael Wheeler?
Emma Lewell
The ayes were 1 and the noes were 9. So, the noes have it. The noes have it. Unlock. We now come to the question that clause 4 stand part, which was debated with amendment 45 in group 4.
The question is that clause 4 stand part of the bill. As many as of that opinion say aye. On the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.
We now come to group 5 and the question that clause 5 stand part of the bill with which it'll be convenient to debate amendment 49 and clause 6 stand part. The question is that clause 5 stand part of the bill. Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Ms Lewell. It's a pleasure to see you in the chair this afternoon. You've missed some exciting debate this morning, I hope we can maintain the standards set this afternoon. So, I'll begin by addressing the provisions in this group. It is primarily related to the licensing regime.
It's about making sure the licensing regime works not just when the license is granted, but of course, throughout its life. The bill provides a clear process for applications, the duration of licenses, and continuing regulatory oversight to make sure license holders are properly held to account.
Clause 5 makes provision for applications for licenses under the new licensing regime. It allows the Secretary of State to make regulations setting out how applications must be made. Those regulations may cover the form and manner of an application, the information and documents that must accompany it, and any application fee. The Secretary of State must consult the ORR before making such regulations. The clause also enables a licensing authority to require an applicant to provide any further information or documents that it reasonably needs to determine the application.
This will help ensure that licensing decisions are made on the basis of sufficient and relevant information. Once a decision has been made, the licensing authority must notify the applicant as soon as reasonably practicable. If the application is refused, the notice must explain the reasons for that decision and give the applicant at least 28 days in which to request reconsideration. This ensures that the applicant understands the basis for the refusal and has an opportunity to ask the licensing authority to reconsider it. If the licensing authority upholds its decision not to grant a license after the reconsideration period, the applicant may then appeal to the Competition Appeal Tribunal.
Clause 5 therefore establishes a clear and transparent application process whilst providing flexibility to specify detailed requirements in regulations and appropriate safeguards where an application is refused, so I therefore commend clause 5 to the Committee. Clause 6 makes provisions for the duration of licenses granted under the bill. A license may be granted for a specified period, where no period is specified, the license will remain in force until it is revoked. This allows the duration of a license to reflect the circumstances and requirements of the particular project. Where a license has been granted for a specified period, the ORR may extend that period with the approval of the license holder.
This ensures that a license cannot be extended without the agreement of the license holder. The clause also requires the ORR to give the license holder appropriate notice of its intentions. At least one year before the end of a specified license period, the ORR must tell the license holder whether it proposes to extend the license. This requirement provides a license holder with certainty and sufficient time to plan for the extension or expiry of the license and the future operation of the highway. Clause 6 therefore establishes a clear and flexible framework for the duration and extension of licenses whilst ensuring that license holders receive suitable notice before a time-limited license is due to expire.
Therefore, commend it to the Committee. I will turn briefly to amendment 49, possibly my closing remarks once we've heard from the shadow minister.
Greg Smith.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Ms Lewell. Pleasure to serve with you in the chair this afternoon, and let's see if we can rise to the minister's challenge of maintaining this morning's quality of debate on this bill. I particularly wish to speak to amendment 49 standing in my name and that of my honourable friend. 49 is essentially about requiring the ORR to review each license at least every five years and publish that review. The review includes compliance, user satisfaction, value for money, financial performance and resilience, toll returns and a continuing theme of some of the amendments we discussed this morning that flow through this entire bill, that review should include the effects on surrounding roads of the trunk road network, strategic road network that are the feeders to the new infrastructure, the Lower Thames Crossing and potentially others, that this bill enables.
And I put it to the committee, and particularly to the Minister, that why should a long-term license not be subject to a mandatory review period, published at least, our position would be every five years? I am open to other suggestions on that period, because this is something that is going to impact motorists from across the whole country, particularly in the case of the lower Thames crossing,
the honorable gentleman from Dartford has already expressed concerns about the impact on local roads. If a license is granted for much longer than that, and I can't see how it wouldn't be in order to bring a realistic, commercial payback under the tolling arrangements, what if it is a complete disaster? What if things don't pan out as everyone expects them to? We don't want things to go wrong, but, let's face it, sometimes they do.
And they often don't go wrong for any eventuality that has been foreseen, we wouldn't have done it in the first place, if there was a plan that saw things going wrong. But when things go wrong, we need clear answers that are accountable to those that will be paying the tolls on these roads, and indeed the Government who will have set up the whole scheme in the first place. And actually that goes, in many respects, to some of the conditions that the Minister spoke to, in section six, clause six of this Bill around timely notice. I gently say to the Minister, yes, it's important for any operator to get timely notice of any change, be that termination of a license as it's coming up to its expiry anyway or indeed an extension,
but what is missing within clause six of the Bill is anything that talks to this point of what if things are going wrong? What if the Government needs to step in and salvage a pretty horrendous situation that you might be able to conceive in the future? Of course.
Jim Dickson
The honorable member is making a good case that clearly the thing needs to run well in the interests of road users and the infrastructure provider and local residents as well. There is already in the Bill, clause 11, which provides for the modification of the license after the grant, which surely includes most of the things you're calling for, i.e. the ability to issue a notice and say that the license needs to be modified for some reason to do with the operation of the infrastructure.
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman for that intervention. He is right that there are parts in clause 11 that would speak to that, but we're talking about clauses five and six here, and in particular on six. And the Minister's comments reflected this. It was talking only about extensions of a license, as opposed to reviews of a license.
And I can't imagine any of us, no matter in what walk of political life we find ourselves at any one moment, why we wouldn't want to have a statutory review period put in so that all of us can question: is it working as well as we want it to? There are many things I can think One second. There are many things I can think of that I frankly wish we had review periods on in the past, and we might have been able to pick up things that were going the wrong way. So, if the Minister and the Government wish to not have a five-year review period, I would very much welcome suggestions of what sort of review period would be acceptable to the Government.
And if they don't want a review period at all, there needs to be a pretty good case for that. And I'll give way to my honorable friend.
Rushanara Ali.
Speaker 22
Thank you, Chair. And I thank my honorable friend for giving way. And he's making a compelling point here. Once a company gets a road license, they shouldn't just be left to run it indefinitely with no checks. A review every 5 years forces the regulator to look at the facts and whether drivers are actually getting value for their money and whether the tolls are pushing extra traffic onto the surrounding local streets, and publishing those findings will keep the operators accountable to the public.
Greg Gregory Smith
Greg Smith. My honorable friend makes the case incredibly well. This is about transparency. It's about openness. It's about saying to those that may receive in the future a license to run the Lower Thames Crossing, to run any other road infrastructure that might be financed through this model that they are still accountable to the public.
They are accountable to the government, be that the current government or any future government. And it is those reviews that will give us that transparency and that clear light on what is going on so that future decisions can be made so that, you know, going back to the earlier debate of today, any future schemes that no one can name one of yet that might be financed under the scheme brought about by this bill could be improved upon from the reviews into the operation of the Lower Thames Crossing in let's not put a date on when it will actually get built. Every state project ends up being slower than originally intended, but 5 years into that operation of the Lower Thames Crossing, why wouldn't all of us collectively, be us parliamentarians or the general public want to know how is it going?
Alison Louise Griffiths
Alison Griffiths. I thank my honorable friend for giving way and thank you, Chair. And I was also reflecting upon the fact that the tolling is almost open-ended, and surely from a competitive perspective, in any regular private sector organization, you would expect that at the end of a period of a license or of a contract that there would be a competitive tender period. So if a road has already been built, and as we now know, if the maintenance of that road will then become part of a tolling operation, surely we should be on a regular basis, as my honorable friend says, potentially 5 years, but open to other suggestions, we should be looking at from a competitive basis on who which companies should be operating that going forwards, because once the road is built, there's no reason why it should be the original road builder who does that.
Greg Gregory Smith
Greg Smith. I'm grateful to my honorable friend. She puts some interesting suggestions into the debate here that I reflect the government I challenge the government to reflect upon. We've lost one of the government backbenchers already, it seems, but maybe this isn't It's getting closer. Maybe the government can come back and reflect on this, and ahead of report stage when we go back to the main house, can have a sensible suggestion or counter proposal on the table for how we properly monitor, properly review the operation of these licenses.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Ms. Fookes. I'm grateful for the shadow minister for his contribution there and I do enjoy when he and the opposition whip sort of riff off each other. If there's a if there's a remake of Dempsey and Makepeace, I hope they put themselves forward for the leading characters in that.
I do think, to be fair to the shadow minister, he's coming from the right place on this. It is important that we have assurances that the licences work and deliver the appropriate standard of service. And absolutely, I agree with him that we do need to hold licence holders to account. But actually, I'll explain why I don't believe this amendment is the right vehicle for doing that, if pardon the pun. Firstly, I don't think we should fix a five-year review cycle into primary legislation.
The appropriate level and frequency of any regulatory scrutiny could of course change over the life of a licence. A newly established licence may require a different approach from a mature licence, and different projects may present different issues. Of course, it is the case, if this was accepted, five years into the licence, we may not actually have Lower Thames Crossing operational. So, when we looked at how best to frame this, because it is an important matter, the shadow minister has raised it-
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to the minister for giving way. The amendment is very clear in saying review each licence. That's not to say treat each licence as if they are identical, because, of course, as time passes, there might be different regulatory setups that a new licence is granted under, new safety standards or whatever it might be. We're very clear in saying each licence reviewed every five years, as opposed to something that as I think the minister is trying to argue back would just treat them all the same.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
I'm grateful for that. I think he may be unwittingly making my point for me, which is that we actually do want to have a regular consideration, in fact an ongoing process from the regulator. And we did look at how existing licensing regimes work, for example, the Civil Aviation Act of 2012, and in there, I'm sure the honourable member will realise that there is no review period specified in that particular act, because in practice the Civil Aviation Authority regularly reviews and updates licences that it has issued. And the fact that there is no specified review period has not hindered them in carrying out that role. Indeed, what we're trying to do here, what we would say is apparent from how the Civil Aviation Authority operates, is that actually they take a proactive approach.
They don't wait five years to spot a problem and deal with it. They actually deal with issues as they arise. And I'm sure honourable members will see why that is actually a preferable approach to waiting for five years between reviews. And secondly, I'd just say that a number of the issues listed in the amendment are already reflected in the ORR's statutory duties. Clause 1 puts the interest of road users at the heart of the ORR's role.
It also requires the ORR to have particular regard to efficiency and economy, and the ability of the licence holder to finance its activities, and to have regard to matters, including safety and impacts on the strategic road network. Under clause 1, subsection (5), the Secretary of State can provide guidance to the ORR about how they would like them to interpret or carry out their duties, and the Secretary of State can update that guidance if they're not satisfied about the interpretation. So, those duties are continuing duties under clause 1; they do not suddenly trigger after five years, or at any other arbitrary points. And compliance with the licence is already covered by the bill's regulatory regime. Part 4 gives the ORR powers for monitoring and information gathering and provides for enforcement when licensing conditions are not met.
Also, clause 7(5) requires the ORR to keep tolling conditions imposed on a licence under clause 7 under review. And as my honourable friend the member for Dartford has referred to, clause 11 gives powers to amend licences. And then the shadow minister talked about the absolute disaster scenario, which we hopefully not see here, but of course clause 12 does give existing powers to revoke licences, so there wouldn't be a need to wait five years. I think it's clear that actually the flexibility and ongoing review that this bill sets out is the correct approach.
Douglas Lumsden
I thank the Minister for giving way. I'm just looking at the amendment, and it is asking for a couple of specific things: the financial performance and resilience of the license holder, including the returns generated from toll revenues, and also the impact of the operation of the highway under tolls charged on traffic volumes and congestion on surrounding areas. So, in the, you know, in the interests of transparency, does he not think that this would be good for the general public to see those main criteria that's in the amendment?
Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Well, I'm grateful for the intervention. I had almost sat down, Ms. Ms. Lewell, but there are publication requirements in clause 78. Ms. Lewell-Buck. Sorry. There are publication requirements in clause 78, which I think will deal with a number of the issues that the honourable member has referred to. So, I would require the, or request that the Committee reject the honourable member's amendment.
Emma Lewell
The question is that clause 5 stand part of the Bill. As many are of that opinion say aye.
Aye.
Emma Lewell
Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. Before we move on, I need to apologize to the Committee, because on amendment 87, which was voted on at the start of this afternoon's session, it was actually 10 noes, not 9. So, just correcting the record there.
My apologies. We now move on to amendment 49 to clause 6, which was debated in group five with clause 5 stand part.
Greg Gregory Smith
Ms. Lewell, I am content with the permission of the Committee to withdraw that amendment.
Emma Lewell
Amendment withdrawn. Clause 6 stand part has just been debated. The question is that clause 6 stand part of the Bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Aye.
Emma Lewell
Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. We now come to group six, which is led by amendment 39 to clause 7, with which it will be convenient to debate amendment 40, clause 7 stand part, and amendment 72. Olly Glover to move amendment 39.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Thank you, Ms. Lewell. Pleasure to serve under your chairship. Our amendment 39 would create a mechanism for compulsory compensation to local councils as a result of additional traffic due to people avoiding tolls. Local council taxpayers must not be forced to subsidize private toll road profits by picking up the repair bill for local roads damaged by heavily diverted traffic. As Declan Pang of the Road Haulage Association noted in front of this Committee last week, local A and B roads are heavily used by small businesses and hauliers, and severe wear caused by toll evasion can hurt the white the wider local economy.
Placing compensation in clause 7 would make it a binding legal condition that private operators cannot bypass or negotiate away these wider impacts. And one of the reasons for tabling this is the problem with the current road funding formula is it's based overwhelmingly on miles rather than use levels. And therefore, without a mechanism like this, because a higher use of existing roads wouldn't necessarily lead to more funding to local authorities as a result, we need a mechanism to deal with that. Our amendment 40 would, in effect, introduce extend the delay repay concept from the railway to toll roads and would mean that an automatic toll refund scheme that issues partial or full refunds to drivers trapped in severe congestion, road works, or operator-induced disruptions would come into existence. Motorists preying paying premium commercial tolls expect a reliable, free-flowing journey, and should not be charged full price when the operator fails to maintain traffic flow.
Drawing on European tolling models like the Italian network, there is a motorway refund system there, which creates a direct financial incentive for operators to clear incidents and manage road works efficiently, which is not always what they manage to do currently. Now, we're not necessarily saying that's the right system for the UK context, but it is an illustration of what is possible and an example that the Minister may wish to consider. Now, as Edmund King told us last week in the Public Bill Committee, if drivers pay a higher toll under an independent business model, it must work both ways, giving drivers money back when the roads when the road fails to operate properly. And I look forward to hearing the Minister's comments.
Emma Lewell
Amendment 39 to clause 7 as on the amendment paper, the question is that the amendment be made.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Ms Lewell. I largely wish to comment on amendment 72 in my name and that's my honorable friend, but before I do so will speak briefly to amendments 39 and 40 that we have just heard about from the honorable gentleman from the third party. On the point on the use, or increased use, of local roads that feed vehicles on to new infrastructure like the Lower Thames Crossing, or indeed, bring motorists, be they private motorists, or haulage operators, off those pieces of new infrastructure, he makes a very good point because the current modeling that finances local highways authorities, predominantly councils, up and down the land has no mechanism whatsoever for acknowledging the point that the honorable gentleman makes. And when traffic flows are massively increased on an existing road, I'm sure we literally all see it in our own constituencies, those road surfaces very quickly degrade, they very quickly start to resemble the surface of the Moon, and that is something that drives all of our constituents absolutely potty, myself included, on a daily basis. And I can see that in my own constituency where we've seen a large amount of big infrastructure being built over recent years such as East West Rail, where compounds are put in for HGVs, groundworks vehicles, etc, to come in and out of those compounds to go to site, to move earth away, bring aggregates in, the traction zones in and out of those compounds where the trucks are accelerating to pull out, or braking to come in, very quickly degrade.
And it makes absolute sense to me that where an existing local road is suddenly being asked, as they will be in the case of the new Lower Thames Crossing, and potential other schemes in the future, those roads that are owned by a local highway authority that are the responsibility of local council tax payers should be taken into account and that there should be a flow of funding either from the licensee or something that the government acknowledges to the Department for Transport and ultimately the Treasury that ensures that council tax payers in local areas aren't asked to pick up the bill as my council, for example, has been asked to pick up the bill for roads broken by HS2 construction around both the construction of the Lower Thames Crossing and other schemes under this bill and indeed the ultimate operation of it. So, I do have some sympathy with the honorable gentleman's amendment 39. On amendment 40, I think it is a more problematic proposition. I don't disagree with the sentiment of the honorable gentleman's amendment. I think it is something that makes eminent common sense that if somebody has been asked to pay a toll, no one can tell us what the toll on the Lower Thames Crossing will ultimately be, but if we presume it to be commensurate with the M6 toll, for example, where an average vehicle is paying seven, eight pounds to use that toll road at the moment, that if they then get snarled up in a traffic jam, if they've paid their money and just sit in a queue that they could have sat in on the original M6 anyway, and I sat in that traffic jam on that road many times over my life, well it's surely
Where I think there is a problem with the proposition that the honourable gentleman from the third party has put forward is how that would actually be determined, because with trains Delay Repay, it's very straightforward. What time does the train ultimately pull in to the destination station? That is very clear. It is either on time or a number of minutes late. Certainly, since Chiltern Railways was nationalised, I think I've been on late trains every single day from my constituency, but that is beside the point.
In a private vehicle, how is that level of delay really determined? Everyone's journey will be slightly different. What is to stop someone driving deliberately slowly in order to avoid paying the full toll and making their journey artificially seem longer? Is it for the ORR to determine whether someone has had a longer than usual journey, and how will they determine that without some level of, and I don't want to sound all conspiracy theorist here, but some level of state snooping on their exact movements in order to determine how long that journey actually took them? I would be delighted to give way.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
I thank the shadow minister for giving way. He's give me an opportunity to say something that was I'm omitted from my notes, because despite everyone's obsession despite everyone's obsessual obsession with Google, it's incapable of formatting a document properly when it's printed. But anyway, that's what's one for another day. The Italian model, their method of doing this, is they calculate a base amount for a roadwork, plus an extra amount for time lost. One qualifies on any trip up to 30 km, after a 30-minute delay on trips of 30 to 50 km, or after a 15-minute delay on trips over 50 km.
Now, I don't know the answer to his question about how they determine that, maybe it is through some sort of monitoring system. Of course, we already have that in many formats, ANPR, etc. And Italians are not generally well known for welcoming state surveillance. So, that's just one mechanism, but I'm sure the there are many options that are available using 21st century technology.
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to the honourable gentleman for that clarification. I'm sure the Italian model works very well in terms of its scheme of number of minutes delayed, commensurate to the compensation paid, but he himself acknowledges in his response that he doesn't know the manner in which that is actually determined either. And I would be happy I would be happy, Ms Lewell, to work with the honourable gentleman to look at options as to how there's no coalitions here, thank you very much. I think there's only one audition going for the next general election and it's not looking towards our side of the House. The point I would make is if there is a sensible solution that doesn't involve state snooping on our motorists as they use this new infrastructure, that principle, that if someone has paid their money they should expect a quick journey time, is a fundamentally good one and should apply.
So, turning to Amendment 72, this amendment prevents the Act from coming into force until after the Secretary of State has published a report setting out the proposed license conditions, including, and this is the $64,000 question, I hope not literally, tolling arrangements.
We've had throughout the debates so far a number of questions asked and I understand the technical nature of the answers, but that bluntly doesn't cut it with our constituents. No one can answer how much, how much will these tolls actually cost motorists to use the Lower Thames Crossing, or indeed how that tolling mechanism will give very will be regulated to give clear, unambiguous rules around how a toll must be set, any caps on that toll, so that drivers, motorists, private cars and hauliers alike can have confidence that they know what is coming. And that is simply what amendment 72 seeks to do. The public should know how tolls will be set and how any increases, and I think that's as equally important a point, will be approved before the regime starts operating.
It's not good enough for the road to be built and then people to find out that they can't actually afford to use it. Why should Parliament commence this Act before those conditions are published? I simply say to the Minister on looking at that, if he can come back with some clear guidance and rules around that, I think we will be much closer to having a full-throttled support of what he's trying to do on this than is currently the case. We want the Lower Thames Crossing, but we don't want it at a rate that nobody can afford to actually use.
Alison Griffiths.
Alison Louise Griffiths
Thank you, Ms Lewell. And I wish to speak purely to our amendment 72. And when I spoke earlier to our amendment 82 to clause 3, it was really with this exact issue in mind that we have now passed that we failed to get our amendment passed, so the way that the improvement and maintenance of these roads will be paid for will be through tolling, and yet we also know that the fair and transparent code that the ORR will decide on won't be put to a vote in Parliament. And so it becomes even more important that when we are looking at the tolling for these roads, that we are putting in place a report from the Secretary of State setting out the conditions and the proposed arrangement arrangements for toll levels and the approval of increases, because without that there is really no control and no stopgap to these tolls. What we do know is that, you know, the tolling doesn't end when costs have been recovered by the operator.
So, we could have a very open-ended tolling situation. And with maintenance we won't we won't know, given that it's going to one operator, how cost-effective it's going to be. Will they be required to go out tender on this? And so I think we if it is coming back to the Secretary of State to actually to have a report before we set tolling, it creates a position where we have greater control.
Gregory Stafford.
Jacob Collier
I thank you for giving way. I'm just trying to understand the opposition's position because it seems that they want the government to intervene in setting the tolling price, but they've also called for a strengthened regulator and for that to be independent, so I'm just trying to understand the position that they're proposing today.
Alison Louise Griffiths
I thank the honourable gentleman for his inspection, but what we're looking for is clarity and making sure that our constituents are looked after in this process because, at the moment, our constituents are left liable for whatever costs are coming down the track with only the ORR's code, which this place won't have any say in, to set what these costs are going to be. And given that we have also just agreed that, well we haven't agreed, but the opposition has, sorry, the government has, that they don't wish to put in place a limit on the length of a license. All of these things concurrently are creating a situation where constituents, quite rightly, maybe wondering what exactly it is that they're paying for.
Shivani Raja.
Speaker 22
Thank you, Chair. I think we are all in general consensus that the absolute, you know, it's absolutely essential that transparency and cost control, that those two things sit at the heart of this framework. Drivers and local businesses deserve to know exactly what they are being asked to pay before any tolling arrangements are introduced. We cannot expect motorists to accept potentially significant and unexpectedly costs without first having clear understanding of what those charges will be and of course how they will be determined. And this amendment Clause 72, is about ensuring proper scrutiny before decisions are made and effectively locked in by requiring licence conditions and proposed toll rates to be published before the Act comes into effect.
Parliament has the opportunity to examine the arrangements and understand the potential impact on road users and motorists. Ultimately, people deserve transparency, accountability and certainty. We must ensure that the interests of drivers and local businesses in all of our constituencies are properly protected and that nobody is left facing unexpected costs without having the opportunity to having had the opportunity to understand them.
Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you. Thank you to honourable members for their amendments. In terms of the honourable member for Didcot and Wantage's amendments, I think he is he's trying to make a noble case for something that I think this government is actually already dealing with the record funding for highways maintenance that we have announced and are already delivering on. But I can understand the thrust of his argument about compensation for local highway authorities around displaced traffic. The right approach that we need to take is to undertake an assessment of the whole of the Strategic Road Network and understand what improvements, likely increases to overall capacity, could achieve more widely.
And then we should assess what happens to the impact if we don't proceed.
Of course, the whole thrust of this is to actually reduce congestion, not increase it. And we know, as the honourable friend for Dartford has said on many occasions already, that part of the country is already at bursting point. We know what happens when things go wrong at that vital section of the strategic road network, and there are already local problems as people try to find alternatives and avoid the congestion caused. And that is clearly not because people are trying to avoid the toll, because the toll is already there, has been there for many years, but it's actually about the lack of reliability at that vital pinch point. So, the answer to that is not to compensate people for delays trying to avoid that unreliability.
The answer is to make the Dartford Crossing more reliable, and make it a road that people actively want to choose. I will.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
I'm very grateful to the minister for giving way. This he What he's doing now is something that he's done a few times in his speeches. He's talking as if the bill is only about the Lower Thames Crossing. It's not. It's much broader than that, as he has acknowledged, although it's focused on the Lower Thames Crossing.
If the bill was just about the Lower Thames Crossing, might very well agree with his argument in that particular case where there are no other alternatives, but it isn't just about the Lower Thames Crossing, is it, as in terms of how it's drafted in its current form?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Well, the opposition member is absolutely correct that this is this bill is scheme-agnostic. But as it is the only scheme that we currently have in mind, I think it's helpful to draw examples from the proposals there as to why the amendment wouldn't be acceptable. I think it's probably also worth pointing out that I'm not aware of any other tolling schemes in the country where such as such a scheme actually operates at the moment. I don't know whether it's his position that these compensatory measures should be extended to, for example, the Mersey Tunnels or the Mersey Gateway Crossing. I think my local transport authorities might be interested to hear that, and wonder where the funding for that would come from.
But as I've said, the whole purpose of the bill is to create the RAB model, which will fund the crossing. It will be about a separate income stream. It won't be about the general roads budget. And it will be those who benefit directly from the new infrastructure who will pay for that new infrastructure. It will improve the reliability of the whole network, and that is far more effective.
That is the correct approach, rather than trying to compensate people for an already overstretched and failing network. Yes.
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to the minister for giving way. I genuinely don't think we are actually that far apart, so I don't disagree with anything he has just said in terms of getting the new infrastructure to work in the interests of motorists. Where I think he perhaps has either missed the point of the honourable gentleman's comments or mine, is that in order to get flows of traffic onto that new infrastructure, in many cases it is conceivable that local roads will see a much higher level of use than they do today. Therefore, does he acknowledge that, within the interests of getting new infrastructure up and running well, in the interests of motorists at a price they can afford, that will have an impact on the rest of the roads ecosystem, mainly falling on those local authority-owned and financed roads?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
I understand the honourable member's point. I can't say I agree with it, because this is traffic that is already there. This is traffic that is already on the local road network, and it is the whole purpose of the bill to actually take traffic away from there. And I think it's worth just reiterating, Madam Chairman, that we're not intending to do a deal at any cost. We need to do the right deal for road users, make sure this legislation has the necessary protections in place for road users.
And actually heaping more costs onto the project by bringing in a wide and broad compensation package would I think have unintended consequences. The honorable member did mention the perceived unfairness with the roads maintenance formula. It is something that the department is committed to reviewing, but I can't accept his amendment. And I'll say the same about amendment 40, because of course this would insert a mandatory licence condition, requiring an automated refund system to be provided by a licensee. And as I've already stated, this would actually go contrary to what we're trying to achieve here.
I did find it quite amusing, the shadow minister is talking about people driving deliberately slowly to try and get some repayment. I'm not quite sure that the people would be that Machiavellian, but maybe those are the circles he mixes in. So it's fair to say that road users rightly expect a well-maintained road, and operators to minimise disruption in line with their network management duties. Safe roads require maintenance, and maintenance of course sometimes requires road works. So, to actually put in an automatic refund requirement would actually disincentivise the operator to undertake that necessary maintenance and road work.
It would give them a financial incentive to postpone what might be necessary maintenance. The better approach I would suggest is to hold operators to account for how they manage expenditure and deliver the service, rather than create an incentive to put off essential work. The bill does provide for independent regulatory oversight of expenditure and performance. It is backed by enforcement powers where performance falls below acceptable levels. And I believe that is the correct approach to take, and we would ask the honourable member to withdraw his amendment.
I'll turn briefly to clause 7 stand part, which sets out the two types of condition that must be included in every licence. First, every licence must include conditions controlling the tolls that the licence holder may charge. Those conditions may set the amount, or the maximum amount, of the toll. Alternatively, they may require the toll to be approved by the ORR. This does mean a licence holder will not have an unrestricted power to set tolls.
The licence will set out how tolls are controlled. Toll conditions must also state how long they will apply. They may set different arrangements for different purposes, and the ORR must keep these tolling conditions under review. This will help ensure that they remain appropriate over the life of the licence. Secondly, every licence holder must require to maintain suitable arrangements, so they can carry out their functions as a highway and traffic authority for any roads covered by the licence.
This is an important safeguard, and ensures the licence holder has a proper arrangement in place to carry out its responsibilities. And, taken together, these requirements provide clear controls over tolling, and help ensure that licence holders remain capable of carrying out their functions. I briefly address amendment 72, and the points put forward by the Shadow Minister. This would be over and above the requirements already in the bill. The bill does allow for both standard licence conditions, under clause 7 of the bill, and for individual licence conditions, under clause 8.
We will come to those clauses in a moment, but this It's not clear from the amendment specifically what it's referring to in licence terms of licence conditions, because of course this bill is scheme agnostic, as we've just established. So, referring to an amendment for a licence actually doesn't take us further forward. Clause 4 of the bill already requires the licensing authority, be that the Secretary of State or the ORR, to consult on a licence before it can be granted. In my view, this is adequate consultation on licence conditions that may include and consult and consultation at an appropriate time. I'd also add that requiring publication of a report about a licence before that can come to force would actually delay and add inefficiency into the process.
It's also duplicative, and I think we've already said several times, we've been waiting an awful long time for this project to proceed and, I'm afraid, the honourable gentleman's amendment would add further delay into an already truncated process.
Olly Glover.
Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover
Thank you, Ms Lewell. Grateful for the Minister's comments on amendment 40 to delay repay for toll roads. I just want to briefly respond to something the Minister said, where he said it could incentivize operators to do less maintenance. I would disagree. I would say it would incentivize them to do maintenance efficiently and at appropriate times, for example, overnight, rather than as one sometimes sees on the roads, almost as if there's a case for recreating the shadow minister's party's Cones Hotline of the 1990s, where one sees plenty of cones out there, but very little taking place with lane closures for little purpose.
However, in light of the offer from the shadow minister to work collaboratively on a proposal and my offer to him to help him deal with his conspiracy theories and state suspicion, we will leave amendment 40 for another day. However, with your permission, Ms Lewell, we would be grateful to push amendment 39 to a division.
Emma Lewell
Amendment 39, clause 7, as on the amendment The question is that the amendment be made. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye". Aye. To the contrary, "No". No.
Division. Lock the doors.
Jacob Collier?
Jim Dickson?
Alison Griffiths?
Sarah Hall?
Douglas Lumsden?
Abstain.
Justin Madders?
Amanda Martin?
Richard Quigley?
Shivani Raja?
Mike Reader?
Greg Smith?
Abstain.
Michael Wheeler?
Emma Lewell
The Ayes were one, and the Noes were 10, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock. Clause 7 stand part has just been debated. The question is that clause 7 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye".
Aye. Of the contrary, "No". I think the Ayes have it. The Ayes have it. We now come to group seven, which is led by government amendment one to clause eight, with which it will be
Emma Lewell
Not yet, no. Not yet, no. We now come to group seven, which is led by government amendment one to clause eight, with which it'll be convenient to debate clause eight stand part, clause nine stand part and clause 10 stand part. I call the Minister to move amendment one. Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Ms Lewell. As you said, I will start with amendment one in my name on the Order Paper. This is a small amendment to clause eight, which I will go on to discuss in a moment. The government's proposal is to remove an unnecessary paragraph in clause 8(2). Paragraph (l) under clause 8, subsection 2 currently specifies that a license may have a condition prohibiting transfer of the licence unless done so under the provisions set out at clause 14.
This is not necessary, as compliance with these provisions is already required by clause 14 itself. The amendment is, therefore, a minor tidying-up amendment to remove an unnecessary provision, which I'm hopeful that the shadow Minister will be able to support. Now, turning to clause eight in itself and its stand part, this provision allows a licensing authority to include additional project-specific conditions in a licence. These sit alongside the conditions that must be included under clause seven. The flexibility is important because each project will be different, and the licence needs to reflect the particular road works and arrangements involved.
Conditions may set out what the licence holder must, may, or must not do. They may also control how the licence holder carries out its activities. For example, conditions may cover the use of land, the licence holder's financial arrangements, and requirements relating to the design or operation of the highway. A licence may also require the licence holder to follow directions from the Secretary of State or ORR on matters specified in the licence. Conditions may cover the provision and publication of information, co-operation with highways and planning bodies, and the referral of particular matters to ORR for a decision.
A licence may also require the licence holder to meet costs incurred by the Secretary of State in carrying out functions connected with the licence. The list in the clause is not exhaustive and not designed to be. This ensures that a licence can include any of our appropriate conditions needed for the project. I think it is pretty clear from the list included in the bill at clause 8, subsections 2(a) to (k), what the overarching principle is, but to just give the Committee a bit more detail, subsection (a) is about making sure the licence holder is financially stable and resilient. This gives the ORR the option to lay out things like the level of debt that the licence holder can have.
Subsection (b) is about making sure the licence holder has all of the things it must or may do in respect to the road, spelt out in the licence, such as that they must construct the road, for example. Subsection (c) is about how they do things spelt out in a licence. For example, it might be abiding by planning conditions laid out in the planning permission for a scheme. Subsection (d) is about detailing the consents the licence holder will and will not need for certain actions. Subsection (e) is to make sure it is clear the licence holder must abide by directions from the Secretary of State or the ORR.
Subsection (f) is to make sure the licence holder refers appropriate matters to the ORR. G is to make sure the licence holder is clear that they have to pay the Secretary of State for any costs incurred by the Secretary of State on their behalf. H is to make sure the licence holder co-operates with, for example, National Highways or a local highway authority when fulfilling their own duties under, to give one example, the Highways Act 1980. I is about information the licence holder may require to share with the ORR or others. J is about making sure the land required acquired for the building of any scheme under the draft model, for example on the Lower Thames Crossing, land acquired for environmental mitigation is used for its intended purpose and not for some other purpose.
For example, the land is designated for a wider mitigation, but the licence holder tried to build a housing estate on it, instead this would be a breach of the licence. And lastly, K is probably easiest to explain, because it is there to ensure the licence holder binds by other licences in particular regarding making sure the correct standards of road construction and operation are used. Clause 8 therefore provides the flexibility to tailor each licence while ensuring that the licence holder's responsibilities are clear. Because the licence will change over time, depending on the stage of the project, the clause needs to reflect that. The road the licence holder is required to construct will be completed at some point, for example, and then they will no longer need to have a construction condition in the licence.
So I commend the clause, as amended, to the Committee. As I've said, the clause is not an exhaustive list, but it is designed to ensure that the licence can include any appropriate conditions needed for the individual project brought forward. I commend it as amended. So turning to clause 9 stand part now, this provision enables the Secretary of State to determine standard conditions for licences granted under the Bill. These conditions will provide a clear, consistent baseline across the new licensing regime.
That will give licence holders, investors, the ORR and road users certainty about the core obligations that apply, while avoiding unnecessary repetition in individual licences. These standard conditions must be published and provided to the ORR.
They will then be incorporated into each licence by reference, unless the Bill provides otherwise. Conditions published after a licence is granted will not apply to that licence automatically. This clause also preserves appropriate flexibility. A licensing authority may exclude or modify a standard condition when granting a licence, where that is justified for the project. Clause 10, which I will go into more detail shortly, requires publication, consultation, and protections against undue competitive disadvantage before it may do so.
Clause 9 therefore has a combination of regulatory consistency, alongside proportionate, project-specific flexibility. I'll now briefly address clause 10 stand part. This sets out the safeguards that apply where a licensing authority proposes to exclude or modify a standard condition when granting a licence. Before or excluding or modifying the condition, the authority must publish a notice, setting out the proposed change, its effect, and the reasons for it. The notice must be sent to the other licensing authority, each relevant strategic highways company, and any other appropriate persons.
At least 28 days must be allowed for representations. The licensing authority may proceed only if it considers that the change will not unduly disadvantage either the licence holder concerned or any other licence holder competing with the others. If it proceeds, it must publish the final change, explain its effects and reasons, and state how representations were taken into account. This clause therefore ensures that project-specific flexibility is exercised transparently, proportionately, and without distorting competition. I therefore commend these clauses to the Committee.
Emma Lewell
Government amendment one to clause eight. The question is that the amendment be made. Greg Smith?
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Mrs Lewell. I am grateful to the Minister for his explanation of those clauses and government amendment one. He will be pleased to know that His Majesty's loyal opposition does not object to government amendment one. We might ask why it wasn't such a such an obvious duplication in the Bill wasn't picked up before it was published, but we will perhaps leave that up for another day. Speaking more widely to clause 8, 9, and 10, probably more in the realm of clause 8, I'd be grateful if the Minister to could visualize some of these seem schemes-specific variations that he spoke of in the with only the Lower Thames Crossing really in anyone's eye at the moment under the provisions of this Bill.
To help the House, the Committee, and our constituents watching understand, can he give some practical, concrete examples of where those scheme-specific variations may well come about so that we can fully understand the scope of this? But my main question to him is that in clause 8 in section two talking about the financial resilience of the holder of the licence or otherwise relating to the holder's financial arrangements, in his comments, the Minister directly referred to how much debt a licensee might be allowed to have under the scheme of a licence. I don't object to that as a core principle. However, if it is to be the case that something can be laid down as clearly as how much debt gearing an operator, or licensee is permitted to have, then surely, it can also be written in to any licence, not necessarily the exact pounds and pence of what any toll may be, but some sort of ruling that says a toll must be proportionate to, for example, the overall build cost over a certain number of years, or maybe even, as we're talking about debt gearing to build any infrastructure such as the Lower Thames Crossing, that the toll mustn't be any more than the total debt divided over however many years the Secretary of State or the ORR deems that licence to be.
That's the crux, the most important question, flowing through all the amendments and all of the debates we've got on this bill. How much? How much is it actually going to cost people to use these tolls, to use these roads and pay in tolls? And I accept, I fully accept,
that a pounds and pence figure is a very difficult one to conjure up. But the rules, the rules around it, in clause 8, part 2,
letter a, surely would give us the ability to set the parameters of what that toll may be. If we can set what the debt limit is, can set where the limits are around the tolls,
surely.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Grateful Mr. Speaker. I think that the shadow minister is in support of the amendment, which is good to hear. In terms of his question about other potential variations, this could cover the use of land, the design or operation of the highway, information, cooperation with other bodies, because this is obviously a scheme-agnostic bill, and it's a framework designed for the long-term, it's really not possible to sort of be any more specific than that, and indeed I think it is prudent for us to keep that broad thrust in the bill.
In terms of his other point, it's already in the bill that there is safeguards in terms of tolling levels. He only needs to look at clause 7, which sets out some of the safeguards through the ORR on tolling conditions. I hope that does give him some reassurance, and I am acknowledging that he does, I think, recognise that we aren't going to be able to set a precise toll in the legislation, but that there are I would say there are sufficient safeguards about that being proportionate level.
I suspect he will not agree that the safeguards are there, but I believe that it's clear on the face of the bill that they are.
Emma Lewell
Government amendment 1 proposes to clause 8 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many are of that opinion say aye.
Emma Lewell
To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Clause 8, stand part, has just been debated. The question is that clause 8 as amend- as amended stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Emma Lewell
Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Clause 9, stand part, and clause 10, stand part, have just been debated. With leave of the committee, I will put a single question on clauses 9 and 10 stand part. The question is that clauses 9 and 10 stand part of the bill.
As many are of that opinion say aye.
Emma Lewell
Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We now come to group 8, which is led by government amendment 2 to clause 11, with which it will be convenient to debate clauses 11 to 13 stand part, govern- government amendments 3 and 4, and clauses 14 and 15 stand part. I call the minister to move government amendment 2.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Mrs Lewell.
I'll start I think by if this is okay generally by generally addressing the provisions because I think if I dive straight into the amendments, it might overcomplicate matters in what is already fairly complicated piece of legislation. The sections that we're talking about now in the bill set out how licenses can end or be transferred where the license holder has requested. Further to amendments 2, 3 and 4, and 22 and 25, licenses can also be transferred under the provisions set out in schedule 1. For the regulated asset base model to function properly, it is important that transfers of licenses can take place and that the process be set out clearly. For some schemes under the RAB model, the same person might hold a license for a very long time.
At some point, however, the license may well need to change hands. These provisions allow for that to happen and set out clearly the conditions the regulator may deem appropriate to apply in granting its consent. So I'll turn firstly to amendment two in my name on the order paper. This amendment allows for licenses to be transferred under transfer schemes done under schedule 1, as well as under clause 14. This amendment ensures that amendments 29 and 35 achieve their objectives.
Those amendments allow for the transfer of a license through a transfer scheme, as well as under clause 14. It makes clear that the provisions relating to modifying license conditions post-grant do not infringe on the ability to make incidental modifications to a license when it is partially transferred under schedule 1 or schedule 3, following the amendments 29 and 35. When only part of a license is transferred under these schedules, incidental modifications to the license terms and conditions may be necessary to ensure that license can be split and continue to operate effectively. Clause 11 as hopefully amended will enable the licensing authority to modify license conditions after a license has been granted. That power is necessary because these licenses may govern major infrastructure over long periods of time.
Conditions may need to respond to changing operational, financial, or indeed regulatory circumstances. The clause provides a controlled process for doing so. What it does is that before making a modification, the authority must publish the proposed change, its effects and reasons, and allow at least 28 days for representations. If it proceeds, it must publish the final decision, explain how representations were considered, and give at least 28 days' notice before the change takes effect. A license holder may appeal specified modifications to the Competition Appeal Tribunal.
During the consultation period, the Secretary of State may also direct the ORR not to make a proposed modification. Clause 11 therefore balances the necessary flexibility, but also has transparency, accountability, and effective rights of challenge. So I would therefore commend clause 11 as amended to the committee. Clause 12 then provides a clear process for the ORR to revoke a license with the agreement of the license holder, or in accordance with the terms of that license. This is necessary because a long-term license may need to end before its stated expiry date.
The clause ensures that this can happen through an orderly, and importantly, transparent process. Before revoking a license, the ORR must publish its proposal, explain its reasons, and specify the proposed revocation date. It must allow at least 28 days for representations. If the ORR decides to proceed, it must publish the decision and the date on which the license will be revoked. The notices must be brought to the attention of those likely to be affected.
Copies must also be sent to the Secretary of State, each relevant strategic highways company, and any other appropriate persons. During the representation period, the Secretary of State may direct the ORR not to revoke the license. The clause therefore provides the necessary flexibility, whilst, of course, containing transparency oversight and an orderly transition. Clause 13 stand part provides for the revocation of a license where that is necessary in the interests of national security. Strategic road infrastructure may be of national importance.
The statutory framework must therefore contain a clear mechanism to act where continued operation under a particular license would present a national security concern. This power is deliberately narrow. The Secretary of State may direct the ORR to revoke a license only if it is satisfied that revocation is necessary in the interests of national security.
ORR must then publish a notice of direction in a manner appropriate to bring it to the attention of any persons likely to be affected. The ORR must send a notice to the licence holder, each relevant strategic highways company, and any other appropriate persons. The notice must specify the date on which the licence is revoked. This clause provides a focused national security safeguard, while the bill's wider provisions ensure that responsibility for the highway can continue after revocation. I, therefore, commend these two clauses to the committee.
Moving now to government amendment three, this proposal is intended to ensure that clause 14 refers to both licence conditions as well as licence terms in relations to transfers of the licence. I hope that wasn't a comment on my amendment, so, The amendment makes it clear that the licence transfers into clause 14 are subjected to the terms and conditions of the licence, as well as its licence transfers under clause 14 are subject to the conditions of the licence as well as its terms.
Conditions relating to licence transfers may be imposed on licences under clauses 8 and 9, which have, of course, have been covered in a previous debate. The conditions may affect how and when licence transfers are made, and it is thus important that licence transfers under clause 14 are subject to them. Turning now to amendment four, this ensures alignment between clause 14 and schedule 1, once amended by schedule by amendment 29. They're, therefore, interlinked. This amendment is consequential on amendment 20 29, which we will come to another time.
But as a re- brief word of explanation, amendment 29 allows for transfer of all or part of a licence through a transfer scheme. Without that, clause 14 would prevent transfer of the licence under schedule 1. The amendment fixes this and ensures clause 14 aligns with the amended schedule, which permits transfer of the licence through a transfer scheme. I will now move to clause 14, stand part. Clause 14, alongside the processes set out in schedule 1, establish the statutory basis for transferring the whole or part of a licence.
These licences may operate over long periods, it is therefore sensible to provide for a change of licence holder or a transfer of part of a licence's responsibilities where that is appropriate. However, transfer cannot take place without regulatory control. The licence holder must obtain ORR's consent and comply with the procedure in clause 15 and any relevant terms or conditions of the licence. The Secretary of State may direct the ORR not to consent where that is necessary in the interests of national security. But subject to that safeguard, the ORR may refuse consent only if it considers that the proposed transfer is not a fit and proper person to hold the licence, or the part that is being transferred.
And the ORR may also impose appropriate conditions. These conditions may ensure that the necessary property rights and liabilities are transferred or created between the parties. The clause, therefore, provides commercial and operational flexibility without allowing licence obligations to be transferred free from regulatory scrutiny. I, therefore, commend the clause to the committee. Finally, Ms Lewell, clause 15, stand part, sets out the procedure the ORR must follow before consenting to the transfer of a licence, or part of a licence under clause 14.
Before giving consent, the ORR must publish a notice stating that it proposes to consent and explaining its reasons. The notice must allow at least 28 days for representations about the proposed transfer. If the ORR decides to proceed, it must publish further notice setting out its decision and the date on which the transfer will take place. Both notices must be published in a manner appropriate to bring them to the attention of persons likely to be affected. ORR must also send copies to the Secretary of State, each relevant strategic highway company, and any other appropriate persons.
When sending the proposal to the Secretary of State, the ORR must identify any conditions it proposes to impose on the transfer under clause 14. This clause therefore ensures that transfers are considered openly and on an informed basis, whilst providing a clear route for the approved transfer to take effect. I hope that's been clear to members that the clauses as amended provide the certainty licence holders need with regard to how their licence may come to an end, be transferred or revoked. It should also provide assurance to the ORR and to the public of the clear processes for how the end of the licence should be managed. I therefore commend clauses 11, as amended, clause 12 and 13, clause 14, as amended, and clause 15 to the Committee.
Emma Lewell
Government amendment two proposed to clause 11 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. Assuming his notes have survived, Greg Smith.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you. I've never been considered a Tory wet, but my acrobatics with my notes during that certainly mean my notes now are, for which I particularly apologize to the Hansard reporter when they eventually make it to the official journal at the end of the session. The Minister suggests they're an improvement. I certainly can't read them anymore. Now, the I don't think this is a section of the bill or a part of the bill that there's particular disagreement on between the official opposition and the government.
So, I really just want to pose a couple of questions to the Minister around clause 12 and 13 around the revocation of any licences. It is clear as anything that there may well need to be a revocation of a licence if things are going horribly wrong, or indeed as the Minister highlighted in his own remarks, if there is indeed a national security concern. The first duty of any government is to keep citizens safe, and if there is a national security concern, then it is absolutely right that there should be the power to revoke a licence. What is missing from clauses 12 or 13 is that if a licence is revoked, but there is nobody out there willing to take it on, where clauses 14 or 15 would come into effect, what happens? Who becomes the licensee by default?
Is it the Department for Transport? Is it the ORR? Is it somebody else? And I think that isn't a that isn't a disagreement with the clauses as they are. The clauses as they are seem relatively comprehensive.
Certainly, the power over national security concerns is absolutely right. But who takes over? What if there is no company that wishes to take on that liability, to take on that licence, to take on the cost of operating, be it the Lower Thames Crossing or anything else granted a licence? I think that is something that we need clarity on. And so whilst the procedure set out in these clauses is unobjectionable, the net result in some circumstances that I hope will never ever come to pass, but you have to plan for the worst, we need an answer on.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Well, I'm grateful to the honourable member for that important question. The simple answer is that National Highways would become the operator of last resort, and obviously, as they already operate the adjoining parts of the network, that would be an entirely sensible manoeuvre. I mean let's be honest, we obviously don't want to be in that position, and at this stage, it would it's very difficult to see the circumstances in which that would apply, because the whole purpose of the RAB model is to provide certainty over the long term. But of course, it's right that we have these safeguards in the bill. But I hope that my response has addressed his question.
Emma Lewell
Government amendment two proposed to clause 11 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Emma Lewell
To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. Clause 11 stand part has just been debated. The question is that clause 11 as amend- as amended stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Emma Lewell
Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. We now come to the question that clauses 12 and 13 stand part, which were just debated. With leave of the committee, I'll put a single question on clauses 12 and 13 stand part. The question is that clauses 12 and 13 stand part of the bill.
As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Emma Lewell
To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. Government amendments three and four to clause 14 have also just been debated. With leave of the committee, I will put a single question on these amendments. Call the minister to move the amendments formally.
Move formally.
Emma Lewell
Government amendments three and four proposed to clause 14 as on the amendment paper. The question is that the amendment be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Emma Lewell
To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. Clause 14 stand part has just been debated. The question is that clause 14 as amended stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Emma Lewell
To the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. Clause 15 stand part has just been debated. The question is that clause 15 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye.
Emma Lewell
Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. We now come to group nine and the question that clause 16 stand part of the bill, with which it will be convenient to debate clauses 17, 18, 19, 20 and 21 stand part. The question is that clause 16 stand part of the bill. Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Ms Lewell. As you've correctly identified, we've got a number of clauses in this grouping, clauses 16 to 21, which engage the fundamental legislative scaffolding required to operate the licensed highways by plugging it into the existing legislative framework. They establish clear responsibility for operating and maintaining licensed highways; they give license holders the legal status and functions they need whilst of course retaining specified statutory powers with a public body; they allow a licensee to delegate without removing its responsibility or the ORR's oversight; and protect continuity by allowing a strategic highways company to intervene when a license holder cannot properly perform its functions. The clause allows for relevant the clauses allow for relevant responsibility to pass automatically to the relevant strategic highways company when a license ends without replacement. I trust these clauses are uncontroversial, but I'm going to go into a little bit more detail for the benefit of the committee.
Clause 16 makes the license holder the highway authority and traffic authority for each highway specified in its license. This gives the license holder the legal status needed to carry out the day-to-day highway and traffic authority functions required to operate and maintain the licensed road. Clause is only concerned with trunk roads covered by a license, not with the wider responsibilities of highway or traffic authorities. A licensed highway is treated as a highway maintainable at the public expense for the purposes of the Highways Act 1980.
This keeps its legal status clear, even though the works and operation are to be privately financed. These arrangements take effect from the date stated in the licence, or if no date is stated, when the licence is granted. This provides a clear point at which statutory responsibility moves to the licence holder. Where legislation gives a strategic highways company functions because it is the highway authority or traffic authority for a trunk road, those functions will generally be exercisable by the licence holder for the licenced highway. Development consent orders under the Planning Act 2008 are expressly excluded from that rule.
This avoids the automatic transfer of project specific consents in a DCO. These consents will need to be considered separately as part of specific licensing decisions and can be dealt with separately as appropriate, either under the Bill's transfer provisions or under specific provisions under the DCO itself. This also gives much-needed flexibility when establishing a new scheme. Subsequent clauses also retain certain functions to the relevant strategic highways company, which is of course National Highways, and provide safeguards for delegation and operational continuity. Clause 16, therefore, places responsibility for a licenced highway with the body that will operate it, whilst preserving the wider statutory framework trunk roads and other highways.
Moving to Clause 17. This sets limits on the functions that a licence holder may exercise as the highway authority and traffic authority for a licenced highway. Although Clause 16 gives the licence holder of that status, certain functions should remain with a public body because of their nature and legal effect. The licence holder may not exercise functions relating to the making of schemes or orders under the Highways Act 1980. It may not exercise compulsory purchase functions under that Act, or functions relating to the making of orders or giving of directions under the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984.
These are delegated forms of legislation and I think it's important to have proper public scrutiny of their use. For those unfamiliar with the details of those pieces of legislation, it's an order making powers, including issues like changing speed limits, making trunking orders, restricting access to a road or introducing one-way systems. These functions will instead be exercised for the licenced highway by the relevant strategic highways company. This ensures that significant statutory powers, including compulsory purchase, and most traffic regulation powers remain with a public body. The clause also allows the Secretary of State to make regulations about who may exercise highway and traffic authority functions for a licenced highway.
It may, for example, be appropriate for certain functions to be exercised by a local highway authority, depending on the specific scheme. These regulations may provide for a specified person, other than the licence holder, to exercise one of the functions retained by this clause. They may also allow another specified person to exercise other functions instead of, or alongside, the licence holder. The regulations may also make the modifications needed so that existing highways and traffic legislation operates properly where functions are exercised under the new licensing framework. Clause 16, when read together with Clause 17, therefore ensure that a licence holder has the functions needed to operate the highway, while keeping specified statutory powers with an appropriate public body and allowing responsibilities to be allocated clearly.
Moving to Clause 18 now. This allows the licence holder to authorise another person to exercise functions conferred on it under this chapter, from Clauses 16 to 22. This provides practical flexibility in how the licence holder carries out its highway and traffic authority functions. It allows another person with suitable operational capability to exercise a function on the licence holder's behalf. Where the licence holder authorises a strategic highways company to exercise a function, the clause also allows that company to delegate the functions further under the Infrastructure Act 2015, subject to the modifications set out in the Bill.
Of course the ORR must be able to oversee all of these arrangements, the licence holder must therefore provide any information or documents that the ORR reasonably requests to review how a delegated function is being exercised. Importantly, delegation of the function does not transfer responsibility for it; the licence holder remains responsible for the exercise of the function even when another person carries it out. I therefore suggest clause 18 provides operational flexibility whilst also preserving clear responsibility and regulatory oversight. Moving now to clause 19, this provides an important safeguard to ensure that essential highways functions continue if a licence holder cannot properly perform them.
It allows the relevant strategic highways company to exercise a licence holder's function instead of a licence holder in two circumstances: the first is there an emergency that the ORR considers has seriously affected the licence holder's ability to carry out its functions; the second is where the licence holder has failed or is unable to discharge the function properly, that failure amounts to a breach of a licence condition and the ORR has issued a contravention notice. The ORR must, in those circumstances, both notify the licence holder and the strategic highways company when the function transfers. If the circumstances justifying the intervention continue to an end, come to an end, the ORR must notify both parties and the function would then return to the licence holder.
The strategic highways company may recover from the licence holder any expenditure reasonably incurred in carrying out that function. Clause 19 therefore protects road users and supports operational continuity, whilst ensuring that the responsibility returns to the licence holder when intervention is no longer required. Moving now to clause 20, this deals with the acquisition of land needed to carry out works under a licence. I must emphasize that this does not circumvent the normal planning process for major works, invariably the development consent order will set out the land to be acquired for the scheme in question. But it is possible that, in the course of a licence, the construction, operation, maintenance of a licenced road, that at some point additional land will be required to complete works required to fulfill licence obligations.
In some cases the land needed for those works may not be available to buy by agreement, the clause therefore allows the relevant strategic highways company to use its existing compulsory purchase powers to acquire land needed for the licenced works. This power is not going to be given to the licence holder, it remains with the strategic highways company as the accountable public body, and the powers of course may only be used where clear statutory tests are met.
The strategic highways company must be satisfied that the licence holder has made reasonable attempts to acquire the land by agreement; it must also be satisfied that alternatives have been considered, that compulsory purchase is the better course of action and, of course, that there is a compelling case in the public interest. Before requiring land compulsorily, the strategic highways company must also consult the ORR. Once acquired, the land must be transferred to the licence holder as soon as reasonably practical, whilst strategic highways company may recover from the licence holder the reasonable costs that it incurs in exercising that power. Clause that 20 therefore ensures that essential land can be acquired where necessary, whilst could be keeping compulsory purchase powers with a public body, and making their use subject to clear safeguards, which I'm sure the whole committee would expect.
Finally, Mr Lewell, clause 21 deals with what happens to the responsibility for a licenced highway where a when a licence expires or is revoked. It is important that the ending of a licence does not create uncertainty about who's responsible for the highway. This clause applies where the highway was covered by the licence immediately before it ended and is not covered by a licence. On the day the licence expires or is revoked, the relevant strategic highways company automatically becomes a highway authority for the highway. The highway is also treated as a highway maintainable at the public expense for the purposes of the Highways Act 1980.
The transfer takes effect automatically; this provides a clear and immediate change of responsibility when no replacement licence is in place. Clause 21 therefore ensures that there is no gap in highway authority responsibility when a licence comes to an end. I hope that added a little bit more detail to the question that I answered from the shadow minister earlier on. And on that note I move that the clauses stand part.
Greg Gregory Smith
Gareth Snell. Thank you, Mr Lewell. A couple of questions from me on this grouping.
We have no problem with clause 16. On clause 17, the minister gave, for example, setting of speed limits as an example where functions should be exercisable by persons other than the license holder, the state, for lack of a better phrase, and I don't disagree with the premise of that. It would be unusual, to say the least, to allow a private company to set speed limits outside of the national scheme that we have for setting that. However, the question that then begs within the totality of this bill is if a scheme is built, and its original consent, set by the appropriate body, is, for example, the new scheme to have a 40 mph speed limit, if the license holder then makes a representation to the appropriate body, in conjunction with whichever is the local police force or local authority, and it is determined, for example, that scheme should be converted to a variable speed limit road, we are seeing a lot of those popping up across the country, and that involves quite considerable expense, of putting gantries up, of having repeater signs with whatever the new speed limit is, changing speed limits as motorists go along,
where does that fit in with some of the other things we've debated in the totality of this bill? Would that be a capacity change, because in theory variable speed limits are meant to speed up the overall journey time to manage congestion spots before they necessarily appear by slowing the whole road down for a little bit so that you don't end up with a pileup? Can the minister assure the committee that couldn't be a backdoor that a license holder could try and negotiate with the appropriate bodies to charge a higher toll with any change to a variable speed limit system? Then, my other question in this grouping, relates to clause 19 of the bill, of the exercise of a license holder's functions by the Strategic Highways Company. Part 2 of clause 19 talks about the subsection applying if the ORR is satisfied that the ability of the holder of the license to exercise the function is significantly impaired as a result of an emergency.
Now, emergency might seem straightforward to some, but when it comes to scrutinizing legislation, is a word that could have all sorts of definitions around it. I'm sure most would accept that something like a natural disaster, we hope that never becomes any of these schemes, or even worse an act of terrorism or something like that, would be an emergency. But what else could be brought into scope under that definition of emergency? We've all seen in our own constituencies, the extreme heat we saw earlier this summer caused significant damage to road surfaces.
There are certainly roads in my constituency that have almost completely sunk over the summer and have now got the dreaded failed road surface warning signs around every corner. Is that level of prolonged extreme heat that could potentially damage the surface of a scheme funded and financed through the provisions of this Bill be deemed an emergency? Or at the other end of that spectrum, the way it has been explained to me by highways engineers multiple times, virtually every winter over the past few years, that getting into a freeze-thaw-freeze-thaw-freeze-thaw rapid cycle, entirely down to natural factors, the weather, has caused significant damage to our road surfaces. Could that be deemed an emergency that a licensee could hide behind?
So I'm really not trying to be difficult on this point, but clarity, as we have discussed in previous amendments to this Bill, really does matter. Can the minister be really specific by the definition of emergency there so that we don't find ourselves in future operation with licensees trying to argue the force majeure rules around things that they want to argue are an emergency, but that are actually affecting everyone, whether they'd be a licensee under the provisions of this Bill once it's enacted or any other highways authority out there, that are all putting their hands up, that are all legitimately saying that it's not their fault, that it is something that has happened to them, not because of them, which could be argued to be an emergency position? Where does that word emergency really get defined within the scope of this Bill?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Ms. Lewell. Yeah, some interesting questions from the shadow minister there. On the first point about the operation of clause 17 and what were loosely described as capacity-enhancing improvements, it's of course the case that the gateway to licensing regime is through capacity-enhancing improvements in any event. So the eligibility for a license would already be considered to have been passed under the Act.
So I'm not sure what why additional capacity would create anything different, because the licensee license would already have been issued by that point. So unless I've misunderstood the honorable gentleman, yeah.
Greg Smith.
Greg Gregory Smith
I'm grateful to the minister and happy to explain further that my point is that with speed limits being set by other authorities rightly and properly, there's no disagreement on that point, speed limits could then be used to essentially create new conditions on that road, which could then be used as a springboard to either a higher toll, a different set of conditions, and the ORR and the licensee could find themselves in a vicious doom loop of disagreement on that point. And what I'm trying to get across to the minister is how something that is fundamentally set by a different authority, as I double underline, rightly set by a different authority, could end up becoming a point of disagreement within the whole set of license conditions with any licensee.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
I'm grateful for the honorable gentleman's explanation. I think I understand what he's now trying to say. I think what I would suggest is actually if there were I mean, we really are entering the realms of speculation at this point about and he's speculating well that actually any improvements of that nature would actually probably improve traffic flow, increase the number of vehicles actually going through the network, and actually I would say it's probably more of an argument to reduce returns rather than increase them. But I think it's probably rather too remote for us to sort of say anything more concrete than that at this stage.
And similarly in terms of his questions about the provisions of clause 19(2) about the circumstances in which an emergency might be called, I think it would be rather risky for me to set out every circumstance in which an emergency could be considered. It's important to remember that the clause is about what the ORR's view is of the license holder's ability to undertake its obligations under the license. There are obviously a number of provisions within the legislation already about the kind of things that they or I would be able to consider, so I think to sort of try and pin us down to specific instances where an emergency might be called would actually tie the ORR's hands unnecessarily in future, but I'll give way. Yes, Mr.
Greg Gregory Smith
If I may slightly confine the question down then, I understand why the minister doesn't want to give an exhaustive list of examples. Could he perhaps look at the wording within this clause and make it clear either in his comments or later at report stage of the bill that the ORR must have regard within that definition of what is an emergency, that it is specific to that licensee as opposed to something that is simply affecting everyone, such as extreme heat on the road surfaces?
Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
I will take that away. The test under the clause is the license holder's ability to undertake the license, and I think it's probably inappropriate for me to speculate as to whether that would be something that would apply to the rest of the network or just specifically to this license holder. My instinct is to say that actually that wouldn't be the question. It is about the ability of the license holder to undertake its functions, and if they are significantly impaired in the ORR's view, I would suggest that it's probably not relevant what where the source of that impairment has come from. If it's an emergency, and it's created that impairment, that actually the operation of section 19(2) would come into effect.
But if having consulted with officials, there is more to say on that, I will, of course, write to him.
Will the minister
Emma Lewell
Maybe next time. The question is that clause 16 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no.
I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. We now come to the question that clauses 17 to 21 stand part, which were just debated. With leave of the committee, I will put a single question on clauses 17 to 21 stand part. The question is that clauses 17 to 21 stand part of the bill.
As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.
We now come to group 10, led by amendment 79 to clause 22, with which it will be convenient to debate clause 22 stand part. I call Greg Smith to move amendment 79.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you very much. On amendment 79 standing in my name and that of my honourable friend, it tries to give more clarity as we've been trying to do in most of the amendments we have laid today around what happens in the eventuality of that scourge that is littering.
I cannot imagine there is a member in this house that has not been out litter picking along the roads and highways in their own constituencies, certainly not the motorway, but certainly parts of the strategic road network and A-roads, that is not entirely uncommon. I certainly see groups in my constituency doing that on a regular basis. And it's something that gets all of our constituents rightly upset when they see litter in the verges and on the side of the roads. It gets me incredibly angry too.
And the point that this amendment is trying to get to is that a motorist or local resident should not be left guessing who is responsible for litter on a licensed road. So will the Government accept a named, published, accountable body and a direct route for complaints under each license that is issued? And if work is outsourced, who remains legally responsible for ensuring the highway is kept clear? The public-facing accountable body should, in my opinion, be at least clearly defined within the regulations when they come to pass and provision to ensure that is the case, as amendment 79 does, should be written into this bill. It would be a disaster if these provisions are got wrong and an accident happens because of severe fly-tipping or litter on any one of these roads.
We've all seen severe fly-tipping in our own constituencies, and the impact they have particularly on safety. Certainly, in the previous grouping, when discussing the extreme heat, there were actually significant fires in that extreme heat, and glass dumped on the side of the road only exacerbates that particular problem. So, whilst I don't want to labor this point at length, I think it is incumbent upon the Government to properly consider this amendment and to see if we can strengthen the bill through its inclusion. Hear.
Emma Lewell
Amendment 79 to clause 22, as on the amendment paper, the question is that the amendment be made. Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Ms Lewell. I'm grateful to the honourable member for moving this amendment. It does give me an opportunity to promote an upcoming litter pick in my constituency alongside my friend the Whip's father, on Saturday morning. We will be doing our bit, as we always do, and pay tribute to all the volunteers up and down the country who do a fantastic job in showing great community spirit,
making clear that the trunk road network is not a place for such activities, and that it should be handled by an appropriate body, which is indeed what clause 22 seeks to do. But I'll just address amendment 79, and I think the shadow minister is right to raise the issue of clear lines of responsibility for litter clearance on these licensed highways. He's right there should be a clear responsibility, but that is why clause 22 exists. He will not be surprised that existing litter legislation was not drafted to account for privately operated highways under the new licensing framework.
Therefore, clause 22 allows the Secretary of State to make regulations so that existing litter duties can operate properly for licensed highways. That does not mean responsibility could be handed out arbitrarily. The purpose of these regulations is to ensure that litter functions sit with the appropriate body for the licensed highway with clear responsibility for them to carry out. So, my objection is not to provide clear information, as the honourable member wanted, it is about prescribing detailed requirements about contact details and complaint handling on the face of primary legislation, and clause 22 already provides a regulation-making power to establish how these functions will operate.
Turning to clause 22 itself, this provision ensures that the existing framework for litter under the Environmental Protection Act 1990 can be applied appropriately to the highways specified in relevant licenses. Therefore, the clause allows the Secretary of State to make regulations so that litter responsibilities can operate effectively on licensed highways. These regulations may apply existing duties to keep land clear of litter and refuse to highways covered by a licence. They may also allow the litter enforcement functions to be exercised by and from behalf of a licence holder. In some cases, those functions may sit us alongside another body's responsibilities, and, in other cases, they may be exercised instead of them, but that flexibility ensures that the responsibility can be allocated appropriately for the licensed highway.
The regulations may also make appropriate changes to how existing with the legislation applies to a private license holder, so that it works effectively with licensing frameworks. This will ultimately help ensure that there are clear lines of accountability and no gaps in the management of high, licensed highways. So, I, therefore, commend clause 22 to the committee.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Ms Lewell. I recognise the arguments that the minister has put forward in that, I still think that the bill would be stronger with the exact wording of my amendment, but I accept his assurances, and, at this moment, although we may return to it at report stage, I am happy to withdraw amendment 71.
Emma Lewell
Is everyone content for the amendment to be withdrawn? Amendment, by leave, withdrawn. Clause 22 stand part has just been debated. The question is that clause 22 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion, say "aye".
To the contrary, "no". I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. We now come to group 11, and the question that clause 23 stand part of the bill, with which it'll be convenient to debate government amendments 22 to 31, and schedule 1 stand part. The question is that clause 23 stand part of the bill.
Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Ms Lewell. I will take clause 23 and schedule 1 stand part together, as clause 23 simply introduces schedule 1. I'll then turn to the amendments put forward by the government in this group. Some brief introductory words on how clause and 23 and schedule 1 work. They basically set out how transfer schemes operate under this bill.
The provisions are necessary to make sure that the assets, rights and liabilities necessary for performing the role of a license holder can be transferred to them. It is vital to enable the seamless transition from a previous license holder to a new one. The amendments to schedule 1 will ensure that the provisions cover the scenarios that we envisage transfer schemes being needed. They enable the transfer schemes to be made from a strategic highways company to its wholly owned subsidiary to permit the transfer of a license under specified circumstances beyond those set out in clause 14, and allow for a transfer scheme to for provision for compensation to be paid to a transfer provision for a third party. I will turn to cause 23 and schedule 1 stand part now.
The detail of the clause 23, which introduces schedule 1, makes detailed provision for transfer schemes. A license holder may need property, contractual rights and other legal interests, in order to construct, operate, maintain or improve the highway specified in its license. Existing rights and liabilities may also need to move between the Secretary of State, a strategic highway company, a licence holder, or another appropriate person.
Transfer schemes provide an efficient statutory mechanism for making these changes. They can transfer existing property, rights and liabilities, and make the supplementary provision needed to ensure that a transfer operates effectively. The detailed powers, procedures and protections are set out in Schedule 1. Together, clause 23 and the schedule support an orderly transition into the licensing regime, as well as when a license is revoked, expired, or transferred to a new license holder. This ensures that responsibility for a licensed highway is matched by the assets and legal arrangements needed to discharge it.
I'll now turn to Government amendments 22 and 23 in my name on the Order Paper. They allow for a transfer scheme to provide for transfers of property, rights and liabilities from a strategic highways company to its subsidiary. Amendment 23 adjusts wording to ensure that subsidiaries of strategic highways companies are referenced explicitly in the list of persons for whom the Secretary of State can make a transfer scheme for. This is vital to ensure that the transfer of assets, including the Dartford Crossing and the Lower Thames Crossing projects, from National Highways to its subsidiary can take place or before transitioning to the private sector. The current drafting of Schedule 1 only allows a transfer scheme to be made transferring assets to a subsidiary if that entity already holds a license or is intended to in the future.
This would not allow for scenarios in which an intermediate vehicle is set up to hold the assets before a further transfer. This amendment makes that possible and is essential for the proper functioning of these provisions for scenarios that are likely to occur. Turning now to amendment 24. This amendment follows on from amendments 22 and 23, and enables transfer schemes to provide for the transfer of property, rights and liabilities from the subsidiaries of strategic highways companies to license holders. This amendment ensures that where assets, rights and or liabilities have been transferred to a subsidiary of a strategic highways company, they can then be transferred onto a license holder or a person due to hold a license.
This, in combination with amendments 22, 23 and 25, provides for a scenario in which a strategic highways company sets up a wholly owned subsidiary to hold assets, rights and liabilities due to be the responsibility of a license holder. It allows for the Secretary of State to then transfer those assets, rights and liabilities onto the license holder or person due to hold a license. I will now turn to amendments 25 and 26. These amendments reflect the changes in amendments 22 to 24 to enable transfers to and from subsidiaries of strategic highways companies. They make consequential changes to ensure that the definition of subsidiary in paragraph 1 of schedule 1, and other references to subsidiaries in paragraphs accurately align with the new drafting in amendments 22 to 24.
Turning now to amendment 27. This amendment makes clear that transfer schemes can include provisions that come into effect at different times. This does not specify that different dates must always be included in provisions. In many cases, it may be more appropriate for the whole transfer scheme to come into effect at once. However, there may be circumstances where it may be appropriate for particular parts of a transfer scheme to come online at the point when the relevant responsibilities in a license do too.
For the, for instance, in the case of the Dartford Crossing, the existing DBFO contract will run beyond when the transaction to the private sector is due to take place. When the transfer scheme is made for the Dartford Crossing, the scheme will be able to set a later date for certain responsibilities under this contract to transfer, ensuring they can remain with the National Highways and its DBFO contractor until the end of that arrangement. Were this not possible, the license holder would need to delegate their responsibilities to National Highways, who would then delegate them to the contractor. While not infeasible, this is a complicated arrangement that can be avoided through this amendment. I'll now turn to amendment 28, which sets out the requirements for when transfer schemes transferring property, rights and liabilities away from the license holder can be made by the Secretary of State.
It means that the Secretary of State cannot make a transfer scheme without the consent of the license holder and the transferee, where that transferee is not the Secretary of State herself or a strategic highways company, except where the scheme is being made in connection with a license revocation or expiry.
Setting out conditions that must be met before the Secretary of State makes a transfer scheme will reassure investors that transfer schemes will not be made on an ad hoc basis. In circumstances where the licence is either not being revoked or has not expired, it is right that the Secretary of State be required to obtain the transferee's consent before making the transfer scheme. Turning now to amendment 29, this amendment allows for transfer schemes made under schedule 1 to provide for the transfer of licences granted under clause 3 of the bill. A transfer scheme may transfer the whole or part of a licence. Clause 14 of the bill already sets out a process for the ORR to consent to licence transfers, and where a licence is transferred under clause 14, the Secretary of State will have to make separate transfer schemes under schedule 1 to transfer the relevant assets, rights and liabilities alongside the licence.
In some cases, it will be more efficient to transfer a licence alongside the relevant assets, rights and liabilities, rather than run two separate processes under clause 14 and schedule 1. This will generally be where a licence transfer is initiated by the ORR, rather than the licence holder, for example to split the licence between two licence holders. The amendment will allow for more efficient and streamlined transfer licences transfers in appropriate cases where the ORR initiates a transfer. Where only part of a licence has been transferred, the amendment also allows for the apportionment of rights and liabilities under the licence and incidental modifications to the licence's terms and conditions. I'll now turn to amendment 30.
Paragraph 3 of schedule 1 allows transfer schemes to provide for the payment of compensation. Currently, schemes can only provide for the Secretary of State to pay compensation to third parties who are adversely affected by the scheme. This amendment extends this provision to also allow schemes to provide for the transferee to pay compensation. This ensures that transfer schemes can require the transferee to pay compensation if the Secretary of State considers it appropriate in any given case. For instance, in some circumstances, it may be appropriate for new licence holders to pay compensation instead of, or as well as, the Secretary of State.
Finally, turning to amendment 31,
Douglas Lumsden
I thank the minister for forgiving me, but I'm just trying to think of possible sort of compensation schemes, if, for example, your property has been blighted by a new road that's been constructed, who would actually be liable for that? Would that be the licensee that would be that, and then would that then transfer to a new owner as well?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
The clauses are about the transfer of assets, rights and liabilities, and that's why the amendment's in there, to ensure actually if there is an outstanding compensation claim, that there is a power for the transferee to actually pay that. Obviously, we don't want to be in a situation where a party who is trying to exit the arrangements is refusing to meet its obligations. So, I appreciate it's a it's a very complicated set of amendments, but that is effectively trying to cover all bases in terms of whether there is compensation. It's also about if a party leaving the agreement is seeking some compensation for perhaps some costs that they've incurred, but it is it's a fairly broad amendment, but it is necessary. I mean, we're hoping obviously not to have many situations where we're transferring licences in whole or part, but it's prudent that we have these provisions within the bill to ensure that those circumstances are catered for.
Douglas Lumsden.
Speaker 58
I thank the minister for intervening, it's really just specifically around property blight. I'm just trying to work out who is responsible for that. Would it be the licence holder, would it be highway agency, or who would it be?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Well, I think prop- property blight is probably something that would be dealt with by development consent orders in the planning process rather than this bill, which is about the financial and regulatory framework for operating highways.
So, I think it's probably something that would come before we got to the issuing of licences. I hope that answers the honourable gentleman's question. I will turn to finally amendment 31. This further extends the existing compensation provision in schedule 1 to allow transfer schemes to provide for compensation to be paid to transferors as well as third parties. In some cases, it may be appropriate for compensation to be paid to transferor, for example where a licence has been revoked on a non-consensual ground set out in the licence.
Under amendment 30, the scheme could provide for the compensation to be paid for or by the Secretary of State or the transferee, as appropriate. As I said, this drafting is not prescriptive. Compensation will not always be needed for either the transferor or third party. However, the provision is drafted in terms of to make it possible for all relevant scenarios to be covered. And on that note, I beg to move.
Greg Smith.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Ms Lewell. I won't speak on this at length. I merely ask some questions of the Minister at the end of schedule 1 around the taxation provisions. And I think many of our constituents would be surprised to find in the bill provisions that the Treasury may, by regulations, make provision for varying the way in which a relevant tax has effect in relation of a transfer of a scheme. And later on, it even talks about income tax being part of those taxes that could be varied on this.
Whilst I can conceive of a situation whereby the government, that the ORR finds themselves in a sticky spot trying to make a transfer of a licence where perhaps there aren't that many willing participants out there wanting to take it on, and trying to create an incentive for that to be taken on. Surely to be as explicit as varying various taxes, from income tax to corporation tax and beyond, within a bill, it is something highly unusual in the legislation that we are asked to consider. And our constituents would normally expect a tax to be a tax, to be a tax. And whilst there may be in budgets from time to time things that allow reliefs, to nakedly change corporation tax or income tax as my reading of part 7 of schedule 1 seems to do seems to me to be an extreme measure, and I'd be grateful for an explanation from the Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Well, I think I'm going to have to disappoint the shadow minister. I won't be able to give him a detailed explanation today. All I'd say is that the schedule does require such proposals to be approved by affirmative statutory instrument. But I will seek counsel from Treasury colleagues about what possible circumstances this may apply, and write to him.
Emma Lewell
The question is that clause 23 stand part of the bill. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it.
The ayes have it. Government amendments 22 to 31 have just been debated. With leave of the committee, I will put a single question on the government amendments. Call the Minister to move formally. Government amendments 22 to 31 to schedule 1 as on the amendment paper.
The question is that the amendments be made. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Aye. On the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it.
The ayes have it. Schedule 1 has just been debated. The question is that schedule 1, as amended, be the first schedule to the bill.
As many as are of that opinion, say "aye". Of the contrary, "no". I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it. We now come to group 12, which is led by amendment 50 to clause 24, with which it will be convenient to debate amendment 51, amendments 53, 54 and clause 24 stand part.
Greg Smith to move amendment 50.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Ms Lewell. As mentioned, in group 12, I wish to speak to amendments 50, 51, 53, and 54 standing in my name and that of my honourable friend. The crux of much of what we have spoken about today, and I'm sure we'll continue to speak about at length on this bill, is the way in which tolls are charged. And the amendments that we have put down in this grouping seek to get the clarity that many of our constituents I'm sure will want around that very question. So, amendment 50 is about removing the power of the Secretary of State to specify circumstances in regulations about how tolls must be paid.
51 is about removing the power from a license holder to specify equipment to be carried in or fitted to a road vehicle whilst it is on the licensed highway. 53, requiring consultation before toll tolls can be charged. And 54, requiring parliamentary approval of road user charging under this bill, presuming it becomes an act, on each occasion that it is implemented. The power to determine how a motorist pays should not be an open-ended power to require equipment in vehicles. I simply don't get the necessity or the proportionality of that requirement in the bill, which is why we are seeking to remove it.
It almost seems like the requirement for equipment in vehicles is taking 10 steps backwards in order to use a tolled road. Certainly tolls can have those little boxes in your windscreen that beep as you go through a barrier, but as has been now widely, over multiple decades, proven, it's just straightforwardly unnecessary. We are stood in our capital city where you cannot drive a vehicle in without paying the toll that is the Congestion Charge. That does not involve anyone to have a little box in their windscreen or to have any equipment in their car because we all have these very straightforward things that have been on our cars for many years called number plates. And the cameras can very straightforwardly pick any vehicle up as it has gone.
By law, you have to have a number plate, and if you haven't paid the tolls, the Congestion Charge, or the ULEZ, or the Birmingham clean air toll, or whatever it might be, against the registration of your vehicle, then you get a penalty charge notice in the post. It works. Some of us might not particularly like it, but it works. So, why on earth should any toll operator, or any motorist seeking to use any of these toll roads, suddenly be required to be sticking things in their windscreen or to putting chips in their car or whatever it might be? I will certainly give way.
Speaker 60
Thank you, Chair. Thank you for giving way. Does he agree that there is a problem with ghost number plates and other forms of avoiding ANPR, and what would his solution to that be?
Richard Foord.
Greg Gregory Smith
I take the honourable gentleman's point that there is certainly a problem with ghost plates, but that is an enforcement problem for the authorities, for police forces, for the government to cramp to crack down on and to stop that criminal practice that he is right to say is going on our streets.
Greg Smith.
Greg Gregory Smith
But I am not convinced, I am not convinced that we should legislate for a scheme that will involve the tolling of new infrastructure, like the Lower Thames Crossing, requiring the expense of technology
to be going into cars and technology to read that technology in cars in order to pay the tolls when we have the registration system on all of our vehicles in the first place. And those registration plates, we have agreements with many other countries that conceivably have driven to the United Kingdom from abroad to be able to ensure those are recognizable as well. So indeed, any visitors particularly to London driving over from France or Belgium or the Netherlands or wherever it might be, equally then won't need to start strapping devices to their windscreens in order to visit our country to spend their money here to enjoy the wonderful things we have to offer in England. So I put it to the Minister that this could be made a much simpler bill if we simply get rid of those particular provisions.
I would also argue that before any toll level is set, and I don't want to re-litigate the argument about exactly how much the toll is going to be, but we still don't know, affected road users, businesses, residents, local authorities should be consulted. Surely that is a straightforward ask. We heard a lot of evidence in our oral evidence sessions from the haulage sector. They already operate on tiny margins.
It is very common for a haulage operator, certainly the ones I visit in my own constituency, to be operating on as low as a 1% margin. It is absolutely vital that if they are going to be charged these tolls, and bear in mind these costs all get added to the ultimate cost of the goods that they are transporting around, so it is inflation-fueling as a measure, they should be able to have their say, to put it clearly on the record. You know, we all know how consultations go sometimes.
They don't you don't always get what you want. But there should be the ability of it to be clear and on the record the impact that any tolls could have, so that toll when it is ultimately set tries to take account, if nothing else, the market conditions that will dictate whether people are willing to use that road or whether they will take any measure conceivable to avoid getting on it in the first place. And any new tolling scheme and any increase to an existing toll, I very much am of the view, should require Parliament's approval. Why should that decision be left to operators or ministers or the ORR alone?
We need safeguards to prevent unnecessary equipment requirements, and parliamentary control to apply to the actual level of any charges. Hear.
Emma Lewell
Amendment 50 to clause 24, as on the amendment paper: the question is that the amendment be made. Minister.
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Thank you, Ms Lewell. First of all, thank the Shadow Minister for his amendments. I'll address each in turn. Amendment 50 would cede the ability of the Secretary of State to reassign responsibility for payment of the toll through regulation. The Shadow Minister argues that this would remove the power to specify any circumstances in regulations about how tolls would be paid.
The amendment would remove important flexibility from the tolling system, the ability to make someone other than the registered keeper responsible for paying a toll in specified circumstances. This does matter as it is not always possible to trace the registered keeper of a vehicle, and there may be situations where it is appropriate for another party to be pursued for payment.
This could include hired or leased vehicles, as I'm sure his witnesses from last week would attest to. It could also be important when vehicles are registered overseas or following change of vehicle ownership. Ultimately, it will normally be right for the registered keeper to be held liable to liable for any charges, but this will not always be the case for the reasons I've set out and it is important that we maintain flexibility on this. Clause 24(2)(b) allows regulations to address precisely those circumstances, providing for someone other than the registered keeper to pay the toll where the keeper liability would be inappropriate. The question is not whether tolls should be paid, but who should be responsible for them.
So we would retain the flexibility to make the distinction rather than impose keeper liability in every case, and I would therefore ask the honorable member to withdraw the amendment. Now turning to amendment 51, this would see the ability for a license holder to require equipment to be carried in or fitted to a vehicle to be removed, and I think it's worth just pointing out just because something is in the legislation doesn't mean that there is some dastardly secret plan to implement it. But I will give an a practical example of why this is this power is in there because we know at the Dartford Crossing, before the toll barriers were removed, those who wished to do so were able to set up an account and place in their vehicle a smart tag.
The smart tag would speak to the toll booth and open the barriers, charge the account registered to the account. It meant those who had the tag did not need to open their window to drop a coin into the bucket at the booth, speeding up the journey. Similar arrangement applied at the Mersey Tunnels. Of course, there are no longer barriers at the Dartford Crossing and the charges are based on the number plates of those who cross,
and we've already had them explain to us why that is not necessarily a foolproof process. But of course, and this is the point of having this clause in the bill, is we do not know what might happen in future in terms of technology and cars. It's possible we might not have number plates at all. Perhaps there might be chips attached to vehicles which have all the users data on them, and, actually, that would be something that would be very important to be able to Just in a second.
That would be very important in terms of trace tracing the registered keeper. The fact we do not know how vehicles will develop in the future is important to keep the bill technology-neutral, which is what the purpose of this clause is, and I give way. Douglas Lumsden.
Douglas Lumsden
I thank the minister for giving way, and he's right: we don't know what the vehicles of the future are going to look like, but it shouldn't be up to the holder of the license to dictate what should be in people's cars. And if we think of what this bill is, it's not just about the Lower Thames Crossing, this could potentially be used for schemes right across the country. Surely he's not suggesting that we would have a different piece of equipment in our car for every scheme we may be passing from one end of the country to the other?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Grateful for the interve- intervention, not suggesting that at all. What I'm suggesting is that it's important that we keep this bill technology-neutral because we don't know what might happen further down the line in terms of The minister's giving way on that point. Go ahead.
Alison Louise Griffiths
I thank the minister for giving way on that point. I think it's quite interesting that in an age of acute cybersecurity risk that he considers this a technolo- technologically neutral position, whereas actually we are in a position where we have an analog system that works very effectively. We have systems that could be controlled by government rather than the licensee, which would ensure appropriate cybersecurity,
And yet, by taking the position that he is suggesting is he is suggesting is technologically neutral, I suggest, actually, it is the reverse of that. Is it exposing us to acute cyber risk, of which we will have very little control?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
Well, I'm grateful to the honourable lady's intervention. I would actually say that she is making my case for me, which is that we do need to keep up with important changes and risks in the cyber security world, which is why keeping this bill as technology neutral as possible is important, because we simply don't know what will be coming next. And actually, giving operators the flexibility to be able to determine what technology is used is a really important part of cyber security moving forward. I'll now turn to amendment 53, which would insert specific consultation requirements into the bill before a toll can be set. I agree that local communities and those who use the tolls should have a voice.
The question is not whether they should have a voice, but is how best to secure that engagement within the bill's framework of independent regulation. So, as it stands, the framework places responsibility for the regulator to set tolling requirements for its code and licence conditions, and to enforce compliance. Consultation requirements should sit within those arrangements rather than be prescriptive within the bill. In exercising its functions, the ORR must have regard to the principles of transparency, accountability, proportionality, and consistently, and keep the interests of users at the heart of its decision making. And that is an important safeguard in the bill, which I hope addresses some of the shadow minister's concerns.
He will also know that the bill establishes a stakeholder group, which will directly advise the ORR, which, again, I think will address the point that a number of voices of users will be heard in this process. So, I don't believe that this amendment would improve engagement. It would actually constrain regulators' discretion to determine how best to take forward individual users' voices, and I therefore ask the member to withdraw. Yes.
Jim Dickson
Can I thank the minister for giving way? Without wishing to prolong the proceedings, it is very important that toll, the exact level of tolls, and the differential level of tolls between the Dartford Crossing and the Lower Thames Crossing, with this legislation being used to construct the Lower Thames Crossing, is properly considered. My constituents are particularly keen that there shouldn't be a differential between the two crossings so that a financial incentive isn't created to use one rather than the other, and thereby somewhat, you know, negates the fact that we've got the new infrastructure in place. We need to try and balance the traffic between the two crossings, and tolling will obviously be an important part of that. So, would the minister note that, and perhaps we all ensure collectively that's in the thinking of the licensing holder, the licence holder, going forward?
Justin Piers Richard Madders
I'm grateful for my honourable friend's intervention. He's absolutely right. And actually, we believe that it wouldn't be in the interest of actually, the licence holder to have a differential scheme. But he's right to raise the importance of that local voice, and we believe that the legislation, as it stands, will enable that to happen. I'll finally turn, Ms Little, to amendment 54, which would, if enacted, see a requirement inserted for Parliament to approve each new tolling scheme.
Making pricing dependent on parliamentary approval would introduce uncertainty for investors about the revenues on which a scheme depends. We need a framework that combines effective public controls with the predictability necessary to attract long-term private investments. The bill seeks to strike that balance through independent regulation. The ORR is a strong, independent regulator with a reputation for boosting investor confidence by fostering stable, predictable investment conditions. And it has responsibility for setting tolling requirements and enforcing them.
That is the right approach, I believe, robust regulatory oversight within a stable, predictable framework, rather than making pricing subject to a separate parliamentary decision. My concern is therefore not with scrutiny itself, but with the uncertainty this amendment could create for financing schemes under the bill. It would make those schemes, including the lower Thames crossing, less attractive to investors and harder to finance. I therefore ask the member to withdraw his amendment.
Greg Smith.
Greg Gregory Smith
Thank you, Ms Earle. I'm grateful to the minister's response to these amendments. I think on the equipment in vehicles point, as I said in my earlier remarks, we're in danger of taking several steps backwards, as he himself acknowledged that there were schemes in the past where we used to wind our window down, literally wind it down rather than press a button, and throw a few coins into a basket. That has gone. It's over.
And so should that be gone and over, and move to an ANPR system, albeit with the challenges we have around ghost plates to enforce against. And I just don't understand why we would have any interest, this isn't a party political point, this is just a practical point for all of our constituents, any interest in trying to bring about a scheme that involves boxes and chips and all sorts of things being required to be put into vehicles, heavy goods vehicles, private vehicles, rather than just using the number plate system that by law we are all required to have on our vehicles. On the point of consultation, I actually thought the honourable member for Dartford made the point incredibly well, preventing those disincentives to use a new scheme if the toll turns out to be higher than the existing Dartford crossing schemes. That is a sensible point. The honourable gentleman knows his constituency far better than any of us, and if he is reporting that is a live concern from his constituents, I would urge the minister to listen to that so that the good people of Dartford do not find themselves potentially with that disincentive to use a new scheme because it is priced higher than the existing one.
But Ms Earle, I am content to withdraw amendments 50 and 53, both of which I suspect we will come back to at report stage, and I really do invite the minister to think about how that consultation, in the interest of his colleague as much as any future schemes, could be addressed before we get to that stage. But feel that amendments 51 and 54, particularly this point on parliamentary approval, not for Parliament to set, but given the minister declined the rules that we suggested should be around tolling regimes earlier, if there won't be the guidance and there won't be the upper limits like there are on debts that any licensee may hold, then that only leaves the option for us as Parliament, as the House of Commons, to be able to take a vote on those tolling arrangements as they come along on each and every occasion.
Emma Lewell
Is everyone content for the amendment to be withdrawn? Amendment, by leave, withdrawn. Amendments 51, 53, and 54 to clause 24 were debated in group 12 with amendment 50 to clause 24. I believe Greg Smith has indicated he would like to push to a vote amendments 51 and 54. Move 51 formally?
Formally.
Emma Lewell
Amendment 51 proposed to clause 24 as on the amendment paper.
the question is that the amendment be made. As many as of that opinion say, "Aye". On the contrary, "No". Division. Lock the doors.
Lorraine Beavers?
Jacob Collier?
Jim Dickson?
Olly Glover?
Alison Griffiths?
Sarah Hall?
Douglas Lumsden?
Justin Madders?
Amanda Martin?
Tristan Osborne?
Shivani Raja?
Greg Smith?
Michael Wheeler?
Emma Lewell
The Ayes were 4 and the Noes were 9, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock. I now ask Greg Smith to move amendment 54 formally.
Formally.
Emma Lewell
Amendment 54 proposed to clause 24 as on the amendment paper, the question is that the amendment be made. As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye". The contrary, "No". Division.
Lock the doors.
Lorraine Beavers?
Jacob Collier?
Jim Dickson?
Olly Glover?
Sarah Hall?
Douglas Lumsden?
Justin Madders?
Amanda Martin?
Tristan Osborne?
Richard Quigley?
Shivani Raja?
Greg Smith?
Michael Wheeler?
Emma Lewell
The Ayes were 4 and the Noes were 10, so the Noes have it, the Noes have it. Unlock. Clause 24 stand part has just been debated. The question is that clause 24 stand part of the bill.
As many as are of that opinion say, "Aye". Of the contrary, "No". I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it.
Emma Lewell
The question is that further consideration of the bill now be adjourned. As many as of that opinion say, "Aye". Of the contrary, "No". I think the Ayes have it, the Ayes have it. Order.