Highways (Financing) Bill

12 November 2026

Highways (Financing) Bill House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:01 - 00:23
Speaker 3
Order.  We are now sitting in public and the proceedings are being broadcast.  We now come to group 17 led by amendment 58 to clause 30, with which it will be convenient to debate amendment 43, clause 30 stand part, and amendment 63.  I call Greg Smith to move amendment 58. 
00:23 - 02:32
Speaker 5
Thank you, Mr. Dowd. Pleasure to serve this afternoon with you in the chair.  In group 17, I largely speak to amendments 58 and 63 in my name, 58 being an amendment that would ensure powers for immobilising vehicles rest with the police, and 63 a debate that we had earlier on a number of other amendments, ensuring that regulations to do with immobilising and destroying rogue vehicles were subject to the affirmative procedure.  The fundamental argument here is why should a private license holder be able to immobilise that's quite a severe tactic immobilise a motorist's vehicle.  The rules for immobilisation should, at the very least, be approved by Parliament, not left to a process with limited scrutiny.  But we have been through the arguments on the affirmative procedure perhaps at too much length earlier in proceedings today, so I won't repeat the core arguments for that, simply to repeat for the record, we are not talking about minor issues here. 

We are not talking about things that are inconsequential.  We are talking about the immobilisation a severe change to somebody's private property and I would argue that should at no time be left to a process that does not have scrutiny.  But the thing that runs across this section of the bill and that these amendments seek to talk to is the challenge on what prevents the measures currently listed in this bill from being used disproportionately and who independently authorises it.  Many of the arguments are the same, and I gently put them to the minister as things to reflect on as he takes this bill to its next stage.  Very briefly, on the Liberal Democrats' amendment 43 as part of this group, we have a lot of sympathy with this point around due notice. 
02:32 - 03:00
Speaker 7
It is unreasonable for somebody to have their vehicle immobilised, stopped from working, being unable to use it without fair, prior warning.  And that due notice point is one that I hope, as a reasonable point to anyone, the government would consider, at least, if they won't accept the amendment this afternoon, thinking about how the bill can better reflect that as it comes to its later stages in this House.  Thank you. 

The rest of the transcript is for Pro customers

Unlock the full transcript, chat, and every analysis feature with Polyfact Pro.

The video itself stays free to watch, in full, no account needed.

Start a free trial