Highways (Financing) Bill

29 October 2026

Highways (Financing) Bill House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:03 - 00:26
Speaker 21
This session is now being broadcast.  Before we start to hear from our witnesses, do any members wish to make a declaration of interest in connection with the bill?  We will now hear oral evidence from the Centre for Policy Studies and Britain Remade.  We have until 2:35 for this panel.  Could the witnesses please briefly introduce themselves for the record? 

Thank you. 
00:26 - 00:32
Speaker 2
I'm Ben Hopkinson.  I'm the head of housing and infrastructure at the Centre for Policy Studies. 
00:32 - 00:37
Speaker 3
I'm Sam Dumitriu.  I'm head of policy at the campaign group Britain Remade. 
00:37 - 00:39
Speaker 1
Thank you.  Greg Smith. 
00:39 - 01:14
Speaker 11
Thank you, Ms. Liddell.  Good afternoon, gentlemen.  Thank you for appearing before us this afternoon.  Clearly this is a bill of two halves, the specific stuff around the Lower Thames Crossing and then a pretty open-ended book for other projects going forward.  Can I have your initial assessment on whether this is the right model to both solve that question on the Lower Thames Crossing and actually getting it built and future trunk road projects that may be required or identified in the country? 
01:14 - 01:33
Speaker 10
Is this the right model?  Is it actually going to deliver value for the motorist and haulage businesses using the scheme?  Do we even know that it's going to deliver to certain metrics?  No one can give us an answer yet on what the toll would be on the Lower Thames Crossing, for example.  Perhaps Mr. Hopkinson first. 
01:33 - 02:08
Speaker 2
Sure.  Yeah, I think I've got quite serious concerns about the regulated asset base model.  This would certainly be the first time it's been used for roads.  And the main issue is that there's quite limited incentives for cost control within a regulated asset base.  So if you're the private contractor, you've got significant incentives to increase the capital expenditure on the regulated asset base to make it as large as possible because that means you get as large of a return to your investment as possible. 
02:08 - 02:59
Speaker 15
Now, the organisation standing in the way of that would be the Office for Rail and Road in this case, and they have never overseen a RAB before.  They wouldn't even be able to look at other organisations or regulators who have overseen a RAB for roads because there aren't any internationally.  And we have a better model through concessions.  So France has built more miles of motorway this century than the UK has in total.  They've done that through the private sector working through concessions. 

And under a concession, there are strong incentives for private contractors to keep their costs as low as possible because it directly impacts their bottom line, which is completely the opposite for a RAB model.