Westminster Hall

14 October 2026

Westminster Hall Actual start House of Commons

Follow its sittings
15:26 - 15:27
Order. 
15:27 - 15:33
Speaker 1
Marie Goldman to move the motion. 
15:33 - 19:30
Speaker 2
Thank you very much, Chair.  It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I beg to move that this House has considered government oversight of underperforming NHS trusts.  Now, I should start by saying that I am the MP for Chelmsford, which is an Essex-based constituency, and my local trust is called the Mid and South Essex NHS Foundation Trust.  It decided a few years ago to kind of have three hospitals all under the same trust. 

My local hospital is called Broomfield Hospital.  It is not actually in my constituency, it is in the neighboring constituency of Northwest Essex, but for all intents and purposes my hospital because it's the main hospital that serves my constituents.  And it fills up my inbox every single day with tales of woe both from patients and from staff.  Now back in, I should say as well that there are other members around the room and I thank them very much for coming along today who I know are also part of the same trust.  But there will be other honorable members from across the house who are served by other NHS trusts and will be probably experiencing very similar unfortunate things. 

And I look forward to hearing the stories from them because this is really important. 

Getting NHS trusts that perform properly and serve their patients and look after their staff well is incredibly important.  It underpins everything that we do in society, looking after the most vulnerable, and we aren't getting it right at the moment.  And I'm afraid to say I don't feel that the government is getting it right, and that's what I'm here to talk about today.  I should say that the Mid and South Essex Trust, it was recognized as somebody said to me earlier not too far away from me here today, they said to me, "Oh, I think I'm in the worst trust in the country."  And I said, "I'll go round for round with you on that one." 

And I'll give you some details about why I believe that later on.  But it was announced back in March, the Mid and South Essex was going to be placed into an intensive recovery program.  That was announced, I think, on late in March by the then health secretary.  And we waited to find out what the details of that was going to be.  Now, the reason for that is that over several years, Mid and South Essex has been massively underperforming. 

There have been huge issues, and I don't exaggerate when I say that it fills up my inbox every single day.  We're talking about long waits, we're talking about delays to treatment, we're talking about difficulty accessing care, but we're also talking about when they do access that care, patients are not getting the service that they need, they're not getting the outcomes most importantly that they need and deserve.  I'd like to pay very early on tribute to the staff who work at Broomfield Hospital and across the Mid and South Essex Trust, indeed across all of the trusts across the country.  They are working in very difficult circumstances, quite a lot of the time in using infrastructure that isn't fit for purpose, that hasn't been invested in properly over many years, and they are doing their very, very best, but unfortunately they are not getting the support that they need.  I have met with staff and patients and the Mid and South Essex Foundation Trust leadership many, many times over a sustained period of time, and I know honourable members around this room from across the House have done the same thing as well. 

I do believe it is unfortunately one of the worst trusts in the country on both patient and staff measures.  We pushed for change, we pushed for changes locally, but national support is needed.  Now let me talk about some of the range of issues that have been raised with me.  Now, I've walked around Broomfield Hospital, both with the senior leadership team and with some of the, shall we say, less senior leadership at the hospital.  And I don't think it should be possible, actually, for me to be able to walk around a hospital and point out things that are so obviously wrong, and yet I could. 

There were lights outside theatres that hadn't been working, I was told, for ten years.  Now these are things that should be relatively easy to fix. 

19:30 - 23:14

Marie Goldman

But when patients have to write to me and tell me about mould that is growing on the walls and on the windows of a children's ward, something is going seriously, seriously wrong. When an 80-year-old gentleman told me, not a long time ago, but two weekends ago, he told my staff that he had been queuing out the door at the emergency department on a Saturday for an hour, and he's in his 80s, and nobody even bothered to offer him a seat to sit down on. Something is going drastically wrong when we have lost sight of the importance of just common decency, of human compassion, looking after patients. And when consultants retire, waiting lists are being disbanded. They're not being replaced, they're just being disbanded.

People are writing to me about those sorts of things all the time. And patients have very little way of raising the concerns that they have.

They can go to PALS, but unfortunately the delays in getting responses back from PALS are enormous. And MPs don't, while we can raise it with the trust leadership and we can go through PALS as well, we still don't get the responses that we need. There seems to be a lack of communication between leadership and staff. And there seems to, we seem to have lost sight a little bit of what's important and things that just make sense to keep on doing. Now I had a, there was a round table for the Mid and South Essex Trust, the leadership there and Essex MPs who are in that trust just earlier on this week.

And while not all Essex MPs could come along, I know many of them sent their staffers. I was certainly there and we talked about heat. We talked about this very long hot summer that we've had recently.

And we talked about how that had had an impact on the running of the hospital. And one of the things the chief executive told me in that meeting was that it meant that some of the theaters had had to be closed because there was too much humidity in the air. And they said to the theaters had to be closed. Obviously that has a knock-on effect to patient waiting lists and patient outcomes as well and patient experience as well, I would say, increases the waiting lists and etc. They said that they had been gifted some air conditioning units by, I won't mention the name of the company, but a very generous national company who'd gifted some air conditioning units.

That sounds great, doesn't it? But they can't plug enough of them in because the electrical, because the electrical circuits won't cope with it.

So we have an infrastructure and this is actually a fairly new build hospital, it's a kind of combination of PFI and some older buildings. But this is a fairly new hospital and yet we can't plug in enough air conditioning units to keep our theatres open, to keep I was told by the way that humidity isn't reduced by air conditioning units, I'm not too sure about that, I'm sure there are other ways of reducing humidity, but anyway. So I said okay. Well, you know, it was a really hot summer and with El Niño happening next year, we are expecting possibly to see another hot summer next year, possibly even hotter. And what contingency plans are being developed to make sure that we can deal with it because we know that this is just going to keep on happening, long hot summers.

Can I make this one final point and then I will absolutely give way because I want to tell you what the chief executive's response was to my question about whether they were developing contingency plans for next summer and he said, no, we're not.

I just... I... my mind is blown by that answer that it was actually said out loud. It is obvious, and I want to say this as gently and as courteously as possible, I think it is obvious that this is a trust that is massively struggling and it is not just the staff working day-to-day, it is obviously the leadership. This is actually a new leadership team there. They obviously have lost sight of the importance of focusing on some things. And I will give way to the honorable gentleman.

23:14 - 24:12

John Richard Holden

Thank you very much. And the honorable lady makes some important points. We share a hospital trust. Many of my constituents from Basildon and Billericay go to her hospital in Broomfield, some of them will go down to Basildon in my honorable friend's constituency and also down into Southend as well in neighboring constituencies too. I just wanted to pick up on that point around contingency planning because Basildon Hospital is particularly bad as part of that trust in corridor care.

And it's very clear to me that that is a major issue which is now really hammering people at home.

And I just wanted to also just make a very brief point around that care, Mr. Stewart. Thank you for your indulgence. I had a constituent who came to me who was handed a second-hand book on grievance after he'd just lost his wife with notes in from a previous constituent. And it just really struck me that whether it's corridor care or that sort of almost thoughtlessness that actually care is missing in part of Mid and South Essex NHS Trust.

24:12 - 25:44

Marie Goldman

Yes, thank you. And I thank the honorable gentleman for his intervention, for his contribution. He's right to point out that we are in the same trust and our constituents experience each other's local hospitals as well.

I want to build on actually what he said about the experience of patients, because I think it's really important that we remember the patients in all of this. Now, we can talk about financial planning and keeping budgets down and sticking within the envelope of how much we're supposed to spend and stuff, but at the end of the day, it's patients that are suffering. One patient wrote to me in February, just to give you an idea of how long this has been going on, but I mean, this February this year, this could have been February two years ago, three years ago, five years ago. They said, "I waited four hours for triage and it was eight hours until I was admitted to a ward." "I spent much of that time sitting on the cold floor by the open doors or standing as there were not enough seats."

But it's not just about patients, it's also about the staff who work there. A nurse who wrote to me just last month in September 2024: "I have worked at the trust since 2008, and when I first joined, I was so proud to say I worked there."

"The next few years this feeling remained, but for the last eight years or so things have definitely taken a nosedive." "The trust seems to run on broken promises and the goodwill of frontline staff." "I am no longer proud to say where I work." "I know many staff feel the same and worry for the safety of the patients, the staff and the trust."

25:44 - 26:26

Mark Francois

I'm very grateful. The merger of Basildon, Broomfield and Southend hospitals six years ago has turned out to be an abject failure.

That's not the fault of the patients, it's certainly not the fault of the very hard-pressed staff, it's the fault of the management. And we've seen endless revolving door changes of management. Does the honorable lady agree with me it is now time for Clare Panniker, the Eastern Region Director of the NHS, who was the first Chief Executive of the trust and indeed the cheerleader for the merger, to step in, intervene, and finally put this problem right once and for all?

26:26 - 28:07

Marie Goldman

I thank the honorable gentleman for his intervention. I think this is bigger than just one person is what I would say. And I think this needs much more attention from government and across the board actually, and by across the board I don't just mean the local trust board, I mean, you know, it needs a lot of oversight and it needs a lot of intervention and really quickly as well. We're talking about an intensive recovery program, it was first billed by the then Health Secretary as being a rapid recovery program, rapid improvement program. I've not seen anything rapid yet, I'm afraid.

I'm still waiting, it was announced in March, I'm still waiting to see, you know, kind of some real outcome from it. It's supposed to deliver stuff within six months.

I know they waited until the new Chief Exec got in place in June, so we're now a few months into it. But, you know, but I'm, you know, my patients are really, you know, my constituents' patients are really suffering. Look, to give an example of, you know, some stats. Cancer treatment. Cancer diagnosed or ruled out within 28 days.

The median average nationally is 78.6%. Mid and South Essex is 64.3%. It's 114th out of 117 trusts. Elective patients waiting under 18 weeks. This is where higher is better.

The median average is 65.2%. Mid and South Essex, 50.4%. 117 out of 117. And again, elective patients waiting over 52 weeks. Lower is better.

Median 1.5%. Mid and South Essex 8.1%.

Again 117th out of 117. And this is where I would rather actually not claim the prize to having one of the worst in the country, but here we are. The numbers don't lie. I will give way. I will give way, yes.

28:07 - 28:27

Sarah Edwards

Thank the member for giving way. And she's making an excellent speech about the importance of NHS trusts being able to meet their targets and provide care. My local trust similarly isn't in my constituency. It's the University Hospital of Derby and Burton. And they've been missing their cancer targets by so people are waiting two months.

28:27 - 28:45

Speaker 6

So that's 40% of the patients, which is just not good enough.

And I wondered whether or not you would agree that despite the fact there has been obviously announcements and increased funding I think this is bearing the brunt of the cut after cut after cut that we saw under the previous government and that it's going to take a long time to turn this around unless we have increased intervention from government.

Mary Colvin.

28:45 - 30:00

Marie Goldman

Yes absolutely. She makes a really important point. Um I have no problem making cuts if they are genuine efficiencies. If we look at a system and go do you know what there is wastage over here so we can cut it from over here if we're confident that things are going to continue to do well over here. But that never seems to be the case.

It just seems to be a case of we just cut and hell the consequences. Now I find that really really frustrating and the bottom line is that patients suffer from it. And and that is never good for the economy if we want to boil it down to money and economics and finances and stuff that's never good for the economy because when people have worse outcomes they tend to need to stay in hospital for longer and that costs more money in the first place. So it's ridiculous it's a crazy way of running things. Look there was a staff survey that happened that was done in the trust in November last year the results speak for themselves you can look it up.

This is the money answer. This is the one that tells you pretty much everything you need to know if you read nothing else and you listen to nothing else. If staff are asked, if a friend or relative needed treatment, I would be happy with the standard of care provided by this organisation. Nationally, the average is 60.83%. Mid and South Essex, 38%.

29:36 - 29:36

Speaker 7

This is the money one.

30:00 - 34:10

Marie Goldman

38%. My word. That's just over, that's nearly two thirds of staff working in the trust saying, I wouldn't want my friend or my loved one to be treated there. That has got to be ringing enormous alarm bells, enormous alarm bells.

If we're not throwing everything at making sure that we turn this around right here right now, I don't know what, I don't understand the point of government, I really don't. There have been six years of intervention, I'm very conscious of time, I've taken a few interventions so I'm just going to go on for a few more minutes. There have been six years of intervention at this trust, first after the merger in 2020 when a CQC rating required it, said it requires improvement. April 2024 we had a recovery support programme which was a successor to special measures, and then in March of this year as I've already said we have the intensive recovery programme. Six years and two programmes with no CQC improvement.

We have had so many health inquiries in this country, so many inquiries into maternity services, into other departments across the health service. They've all made loads and loads and loads of recommendations.

I would like to ask the Minister how many of those recommendations have actually been implemented across the country, frankly, but in Mid and South Essex, how are we keeping track on that? Let's not reinvent the wheel. We've had inquiries saying what's going wrong. Let's make sure that we are implementing those recommendations from previous inquiries. I've written three times and three times I've had a response back from the Minister.

I welcome the announcement. I've asked questions around the detail, but I've had different details back each time. In June and July, I was told that the responsibility lies with the trust's own board with targeted external expertise. In my July letter, I said, or I was told, so in the July response I got, I was told there was a recovery compact and a six to 18-month recovery period. In the September letter, I was told we would be getting enhanced support from NHS England regional and national teams.

It struck me rereading those letters just earlier on today, actually, that there's very little reference in these letters to improving patient outcomes or experience.

It focuses a lot, a lot on money. I think we need to get things right and then we deal with the money afterwards. I genuinely do because sometimes you have to invest to get things to the point that they need to be and then you step back and you make those savings. But you can't do it all in one go. It won't work.

I tell you right now, it just won't work. So there is too much I think a focus on financial performance right here right now. Get to that later but sort it out for patients right now who are suffering right now. The September response that I got promises long-term sustainability. I just have to point out that NHS England is reportedly set to be abolished in April 2027, which is inside the recovery window that I've been told about.

I'm that creates a certain amount of confusion and uncertainty. Where will we be getting the consistency from this?

So, I hope you'll be pleased to know I'm on my last page, but I do have a list of questions for the Minister. And they are: so where, I'd really like to know, where is the external expertise coming from that's going to be helping Mid and South Essex? And genuinely, I get fed up with this merry-go-round of chief executives moving from one failing trust to another failing trust. Why on earth do we think we're going to get a different answer or a different outcome if they didn't fix it over here, why do we think they're going to be able to fix it over there? So where is the genuine expertise with a tried and tested track record coming from?

Who chooses the expert? Who reviews whether the support is working, or are they going to be marking their own homework? Who holds the trust to account? Don't just tell me the board, don't just tell me MPs, that's not the answer. What specific support is Mid and South Essex getting?

If there's no improvement within the 6 to 18 month window, who intervenes then, and what are the consequences?

How is this long-term if NHS England goes, disappears in April 2027? And finally, where is the commitment to making things better for the people it really matters for, and that's the patients and the staff? I want to conclude by paying another tribute to the staff who do amazing work in very difficult circumstances. Patients, my constituents, deserve better. Thank you.

34:10 - 34:23

Graham Stuart

I remind members that they should bob if they wish to be called in the debate. The question is that this House has considered government oversight of underperforming NHS trusts. And I call Rebecca Long-Bailey.

34:23 - 34:26

Rebecca Long-Bailey

Thank you, Mr. Stewart. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship.

34:26 - 34:33

Graham Stuart

And I need to introduce a time limit of three minutes from now on. Apologies for that.

34:33 - 37:32

Speaker 10

Thank you, Mr. Stewart, and thank you to the honorable member for Chelmsford. The staff at Salford Royal are absolutely amazing. I've seen their dedication, I've joined them on picket lines as they campaign to improve patient safety as much as their own workplace conditions. I've also met whistleblowers ringing the alarm on patient safety, and I've repeatedly raised both theirs and patients' concerns and called for them to be listened to by trust management. But sadly they've been let down and now the situation is critical.

The minister may know that Salford Royal was the poster child of NHS safety, it was one if not the best hospital in the country.

And of course savage austerity and round after round of cuts have undoubtedly brought our NHS to the point of collapse right across the country. But the fact that an individual trust's services can fall from outstanding in 2018 to requires improvement a few years ago, a few weeks ago, warrants her personal oversight and intervention. Now, in the time I've got, I'll very briefly canter through how matters got to this point. Obviously in 2018, the CQC rated Salford Royal NHS Foundation Trust as outstanding. It was a standalone hospital trust which then merged to form a super-trust across Greater Manchester called the Northern Care Alliance.

Just a year after the merger, the CQC rated the newly formed trust as requires improvement, a long way from Salford's previous position. And then between 23 and 24, worrying reports about patient safety started to emerge. There have been various interventions.

In 2025, there was a rapid quality review process. The CQC then issued its first Section 29A warning notice in the September regarding surgical services, citing inadequate staffing arrangements and ineffective systems for identifying and managing patient safety risks. Then later, a few months later, another warning notice had to be issued in August 26 due to significant concerns about the trust's management of risk, patient safety complaints, freedom to speak up, and workforce wellbeing and inclusion, which brings us to the latest CQC report a couple of weeks ago, which rated the hospital as requires improvement and identified 12 regulatory breaches relating to safe care and treatment, governance, and staffing. Now, all of these are very worrying.

Now, all of these are very worrying, but one staff member recently said to me, it's really getting worse, especially in theatres, and they'll try to blame the current industrial action, but it's not those days, it's normal days, they're just horrendous, staff crying, staff exhausted, increasing sickness rates. It's clear there's a crisis unfolding, staff are exhausted, and I'd urge the Minister now to meet with me to discuss what action she can take going forward to get this trust back on the steady and safe footing that its staff and patients deserve.

37:32 - 37:36

Speaker 11

Tim Farron.

37:36 - 40:34

Timothy James Farron

Thank you, Mr. Anderson, for serving this afternoon, and indeed to follow the previous speaker and my honourable friend, the member for Chelmsford. I've got four NHS trusts serving my enormous constituency, which is the second biggest in England. The North Cumbria Hospital Trust, which is ranked 117th out of 134.

The Cumbria, Northumberland, Tyne and Wear Foundation Mental Health Trust, ranking 39th out of 58. The University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay Trust, ranking 97th out of 134. And the Lancashire and South Cumbria Care Mental Health Trust, ranking 54th out of 58. What those four trusts have got in common is they are run and staffed by outstanding people. Wonderful, compassionate, committed, capable people.

And the other thing they have in common is they struggle with an underlying common challenge, and that is rurality, that this government and its Conservative predecessor failed to understand or indeed to tackle. Let me just start with the Morecambe Bay Hospital Trust, Mr Stewart. A trust which has three hospitals but which is funded as if it had just the one.

This year, the National Health NHS England and the Department for Health are therefore forcing 32 and a half million pounds worth of cost savings on the Morecambe Trust, and that means that that trust is having to close 42 beds, despite the fact that over the last 12 months, they have been in OPEL 4, the highest level of alert and extreme pressure upon their services, a total of 14 times, including three times during July and August. Moving on, we have the worst cancer waiting times, some of them in the country, and it will be no surprise that that's because in South Cumbria, we have no direct or close access to radiotherapy treatment. The OECD average for people with cancer having radiotherapy is 53%. That's the target. In the UK, it's a mere 36%.

In Lancashire and South Cumbria we're the worst in the country, in the worst country in the OECD, at only 29%. In North Cumbria we have people who use Penrith Urgent Treatment Centre, which is brilliant, but is so often under enormous pressure because the nearby Keswick Urgent Treatment Centre in my honourable friend's constituency is so often closed because of understaffing. Mental health provision, the two mental health trusts under enormous pressure when you think that Cumbria has a suicide rate twice the national average. This is unacceptable. We think about the local council proposing to close Abbeyfield Green care home in Windermere because of a 31% cut the government has given the council's funding this year.

Why? Because the government doesn't get rurality and doesn't fund services in rural communities. I want to finish by just quoting a report from Policy Exchange which was a foreword written by my honourable friend the member for Oxford West and Abingdon which read that the rural penalty is of how NHS funding formulas are disadvantaging rural and coastal areas and putting health devolution at risk.

I would add it's not just putting health devolution at risk, Mr. Stewart, it's putting the health and the lives of my constituents at risk. And I hope the minister will put this right.

40:34 - 40:36

Speaker 13

Jack Abbott.

40:36 - 43:39

Jack Abbott

Thanks very much, Mr. Stewart. It's a pleasure to serve under you this afternoon. And thank you to the honorable member for Chelmsford as well for bringing this important debate. Too many communities have paid the price when NHS trusts fail. And in my own constituency of Ipswich, we know that reality all too well.

There are two trusts that serve my community in terms of East Suffolk and North Essex Foundation Trust, which provides our acute hospital services, and of course, Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust, who are responsible for our mental health service. Both, unfortunately, particularly the latter, have had a history of patients enduring long waits, inconsistent standards of care, and services that fall well short of what they have every right to expect.

Families were sidelined and concerns went unanswered. I wish to begin with NSFT. For many, many years, NSFT has been synonymous with failure. It was the first mental health trust in the country to enter special measures in 2015 and was later put into an NHS recovery support program. Two years ago, I stood in this very room and described NSFT as arguably the worst performing mental health trust in the country, and that judgment was reflective of a litany of failings stretching back many, many years.

But it's also important to acknowledge that genuine progress has been made. The picture today is markedly different from the one we saw even just a few years ago, and the number of patients waiting more than 18 weeks has fallen by over 80%. Crisis services have improved, and more than 95% of patients experiencing a first episode of psychosis now begin treatment within two weeks of referral, now outperforming the national standard.

And so while the trust is still rated as requiring improvement overall, several services are now rated as good. And that is in part a testament to the leadership of NSFT, who have brought stability to the trust after years of disruption. And I'm grateful to be hosting a quarterly meeting between NSFT and MPs in the region to ensure progress is being made. And so what we can learn from this is that improvement is possible, even in the organisations with the most difficult legacies. But we must not confuse progress with success.

This is a first step and the beginning of a recovery that has a way to go as well. I would also just finish on saying that the reforms the government are making are finally starting to turn the page of years of failure. And we have invested record-breaking amounts into our health service, reducing waiting lists and cutting ambulance response times in my area and expanding our workforce.

But we should be tentative, but indeed hopeful as well. NSFT and indeed SNFT if I had more time to talk about today, neither yet are where patients deserve and need them to be. But there are reasons to be optimistic and I'd make just the plea to the health minister with us today is to ensure that we are fully funding mental health in the way that it desperately needs to. Our trust never recovered from brutal cuts in 2014 and massive redesigns. We are on the path to recovery.

We now do have stability. But while recognizing the progress so far, we must build upon it, maintain a relentless focusing on delivering the improvements that all of our local patients deserve.

43:39 - 43:46

Graham Stuart

James Wild. Can I note that Steve Darling will be the next to speak on the opposition side.

43:46 - 46:46

James Wild

Thank you, Mr. Stewart, and I congratulate the honorable member for securing this important debate. I represent the Queen Elizabeth Hospital Trust, King's Lynn, which serves 300,000 people across Norfolk, North Cambridgeshire, and South Lincolnshire, which was ranked 134 out of 134 trusts in the league table released in September last year. And that very disappointing result was uncomfortable for trust and staff, but transparency can be used to galvanize action. And performance is simply not good enough at the moment. Only 65% of cancer patients were treated within the 62-day timeframe against a standard of 85%, and only 64% of patients at A&E are seen within four hours.

The trust has also had worrying reports from the Royal College of Surgeons about culture and management weaknesses and in August the CQC rated emergency care as requiring improvement. And when that league table was published I was told by health ministers that intensive help would be made available to deliver better care but it's not clear what extra support has actually been provided. Cancer and elective waiting times have improved slightly, A&E and diagnostics have not. There's certainly been more reporting requirements but that will not drive improved performance and productivity nor will requiring a 10% budget saving. Nor will management instability.

We've had a temporary chief executive then a supposedly permanent appointment. We currently have no recruitment for a managing director, the post is being covered by the Norfolk and Waveney Hospitals Group deputy chief executive. You need to have visible active leadership full-time on site to deliver better care.

So what support is the national performance framework actually providing? A year on from that league table, how are ministers holding the trust to account? And delivering dedicated staff and working in a hospital that isn't fit for purpose, which is why we secured a commitment honored by this government as well to a new QEH. But new facilities and improvements go hand in hand. But that should be about improving services, not removing them.

That's why I'm extremely concerned at leaked proposals from the Norfolk and Waveney University Hospitals Group that it's considering downgrading A&E, maternity and ICU services. These plans have been drawn up behind closed doors with no transparency, made by organizations that seemingly are unaccountable, that fail to recognize the needs of my constituents and those across the area.

Clinicians have warned of the impact on patient safety and these proposals are completely unacceptable and should be ruled out now. Indeed, the group leadership has repeatedly said publicly it wants to have more services closer to home. If that's the case, it must include a proper 24/7 tier 1 A&E, maternity services and ICU in King's Lynn. QEH is at the heart of my community. We all want to see sustained improvements.

And I urge the Minister to give my constituents and the staff at the hospital the reassurance they want and rule out any notion of downgrading the services at QEH on this Government's watch.

46:46 - 46:48

Speaker 16

Alison Gardner.

46:48 - 49:58

Allison Claire Elizabeth Gardner

Thank you, Mr Stewart, and I thank the Member for Shrewsbury for securing this debate. I wish to raise a serious and long-standing problem of ambulance delays at the Royal Stoke University Hospital, run by the UHNM Trust and situated in the neighbouring constituency of Stoke-on-Trent Central.

Many of my constituents in Stoke-on-Trent South, local campaigners such as Ian Syme and West Midlands Ambulance Service have repeatedly raised concerns to me regarding this crisis. An ambulance handover is the point at which responsibility for a patient transfers from the ambulance crew to the hospital team. Guidance set by NHS England specifies that this should take place within 15 minutes of an ambulance arriving at a hospital. Between April and September this year, the average wait at the Royal Stoke was one hour and 33 minutes, and the longest was 17 hours and 41 minutes. Only 16% of handovers met the 15-minute standard, making Royal Stoke the worst-performing hospital in the West Midlands on that measure, and House of Commons research indicates it's the third worst in the country.

We know that such handover delays cause harm and increase the number of avoidable deaths. This is not a recent problem.

The trust handover times have been some of the longest in the country most months since 2023. And I want to be clear that this is not an attack on frontline NHS staff. Our paramedics, ambulance crews, and emergency department staff are working under immense pressure, often to the point of burnout, and I also acknowledge some of the outstanding work that does happen at the Royal Stoke. But I also want to correct the false narrative that this is a result of more people turning up to A&E. It is not.

A&E attendance figures at the Royal Stoke remain broadly stable.

So I believe deeper questions need to be asked regarding the overall culture and patient flow through the system and response of senior leadership. In August, CQC conducted an inspection of A&E and correctly instructed that the 15 corridor care spaces at the Royal Stoke were closed. And I support the principle behind that decision. But closing those spaces does not address the problems that led to patients being treated in corridors in the first place, nor have those closures caused these long-standing ambulance delays which existed before. In September 2025, NHS England took enforcement action against UHNM, yet a year later, average ambulance handover delays at the Royal Stoke still hit two hours this September.

So there has been a failure of oversight and accountability. Having attended the recent UHNM board meeting and spoken with the ICB chair, I acknowledge that actions are being taken to address the problem, and I am pleased that on my suggestion, the ICB chair has agreed to convene a joint meeting of senior people and MPs to address the issue of ambulance handover delays. However, I feel more needs to be done and questions raised as to how we got to this situation in the first place.

My constituents deserve safe, timely treatment. Our frontline staff deserve a system that allows them to do their job properly. So I ask the Minister directly: will she commit to taking direct oversight of ambulance handover delays at the Royal Stoke, commission an independent inquiry, and set a clear timetable for improvement?

49:58 - 52:49

Matthew Stephen Darling

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I may I congratulate the member for Chelmsford in securing this extremely important debate. I serve a population of frail elderly people. Well, one of the most, we have the highest numbers of frail elderly, and the irony is that our hospital is frail and elderly. It's the third oldest in the country.

It's the third oldest in the country and the estate here, the poor quality of it massively impacts in the service that's able to be delivered to my community. Over 80% of it is not fit for purpose. We were one of those new hospitals that was promised under the previous Conservative government, sadly we are now in wave two. I'd also like to reflect on how this has impacted on over 700 sewage leaks across the hospital in recent years that impacts on clinical areas and you can just draw your own conclusions how this has shunted treatment for patients down the line. I'd like particularly now to focus on the tower block at Torbay.

It is swathed in scaffolding, but it's to stop bits of it falling off and braining patients. And in February this year, myself, the member for Newton Abbot and the member for South Devon all wrote to the hospitals minister backing our NHS managers where they were desperate in need of the tower block being sorted out and 8 million pounds being invested in it. We wrote again, I met with the minister, the hospitals minister in September and again banged the drum. We got 1.8 million pounds rather than the 8 million pounds. Somerset and Devon Fire Service have now served a fire safety notice on our trust saying that they have serious safety concerns for patients.

The CQC have served another warning notice just in the last few days. The chickens, Minister, have now come home to roost and we need action. We need the cheque in the post as I asked previously earlier in September to back this fire safety within the tower block. The staff are doing incredible work. The patients deserve better.

Will the Minister please meet with myself and other colleagues from South Devon constituencies to explore what the impact of this fire safety certificate is and also the CQC because there are rumours swirling around the internet about closures of beds in Torbay Hospital. Thank you.

52:49 - 53:35

Speaker 19

It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I'd like to commend the member for Chelmsford for bringing forward this debate, which is named politely on underperforming trusts. Breast cancer awareness month and I'll be talking about the breast cancer failings at my local trust, County Durham and Darlington. In April 2025, the trust began going through case files of women who'd been patients of their breast services between 2023 and 2025. Of the 538 women whose cases have been reviewed, 321 of them experienced some form of harm. 77 women suffered significant harm.

52:49 - 52:49

Thank you, Mr Stewart.

53:35 - 56:02

Speaker 19

20 women underwent unnecessary mastectomies and the trust has confirmed that one woman has died and are currently investigating the situation around that.

Can we just take a moment to reflect on that? The women in this room know rightly what pain is deemed for us to endure and put up with, but to hear that women put their trust in our NHS at a time of great stress and anxiety and had their breasts removed unnecessarily is truly abhorrent. The trust has rightly changed leadership and are now undertaking a further review of the treatment given to women by the breast services from 2015. There are a further 4,500 women whose cases need to be reviewed by specialists.

The current rate of review of 538 cases a year is going to mean that without further resource to fund more specialists to review these cases, the process could go well into the 2030s. Recent Health Service Journal modelling estimates that the work could cost the trust 4.5 million pounds, and the trust does not get any financial support for this work, which I find counterintuitive as the victims need answers and justice and the trust must learn the lessons of what went wrong whilst also carrying out their vital duties. Campaigners are calling for a full public inquiry and I support them, I understand why, but I fear it will take years and years for answers and lessons to be learnt. The Prime Minister recently agreed in a BBC interview that of course there needs to be the fullest possible inquiry and those affected will get the answers they need. He said that there are different routes to the truth, but the question I would ask of the Minister is how, without additional resources, can the trust be expected to keep the other services running effectively while conducting this inquiry?

They will inevitably go into debt and probably be bailed out by the Department for Health and Social Care, so the taxpayer. Surely, given that we've got the Health Bill going through the House, a bill that's focused on abolishing NHS England and giving direct powers back to the Secretary of State, we have the right legislative opportunity to change the culture from fearing and fighting for scrutiny to funding it and facilitating it. Those trusts, our trust, needs to provide the answers and support the affected patients in a timely and compassionate manner and to improve and change their services to gather the information needed and necessary to do that. And I think we all in this House agree that across the country patients deserve better.

56:02 - 56:03

Richard Foord.

56:03 - 59:04

John Richard Foord

Thank you, Mr Stewart, and it's an honour to serve with you in the chair, and I'm grateful to the honourable member for Chelmsford for securing this debate.

When we discuss underperforming trusts, we must recognise that some NHS trusts are operating in circumstances that would challenge even the very best management teams. The Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust serves a largely rural and coastal population with an ageing demographic, workforce pressures and significant barriers to access. So I don't in my speech want to blame the Royal Devon leadership team. And this is certainly, very certainly not about blaming the hardworking staff, because they are doing a brilliant job in very trying circumstances. But let's face it, the geography and the demographics are stacked against them.

The Chief Medical Officer, Sir Chris Whitty, has repeatedly highlighted the unique health challenges facing rural and coastal communities, including when he visited Devon in May this year. Sir Chris has warned, quote, 'The health challenges of coastal towns and attracting staff in these areas is significantly harder,' noting that transport links are often limited. In his 2023 report, Sir Chris warned that people living in peripheral areas experience issues relating to accessing primary and secondary healthcare, domiciliary care, medicines, shopping, and transport. The response times, he went on, of healthcare professionals are often longer because of the distances involved, which is particularly important for emergency presentations.

Steve Brown, who is the director for public health Devon, said in Devon our records show that some people are dying up to 15 years earlier than they should because essential building blocks of health, like reliable transport and services that people can reach, are missing. I have a constituent, Hillary Roberts Arnold from Seaton, who wrote to me to describe the lack of transport and the difficulty of getting services in East Devon. Her husband is increasingly frail and suffers from skin cancer. Until recently, he attended dermatology services at Axminster Hospital, seven and a half miles away. These local services are now gone.

Patients are forced instead to trek to Exeter, if they can. For her and for her husband, that would be 22 miles away and is simply not possible. It's just too challenging a distance for them to trek.

So his cancer is not being dealt with as a result. And the RD&E told me that this is a workforce and capacity issue, not a reflection of the clinical priority we place on patient care. If government oversight of NHS trusts is to be meaningful, it must recognise the realities of rural and coastal healthcare and weight the funding accordingly. Thank you.

59:04 - 01:02:11

David Chadwick

Thank you, Mr. Stewart. It's an honour to serve under your chairmanship and thank you to the honourable member for Chelmsford for securing this vital debate. The debate could not be more timely for my constituents and I want to use my contribution to offer a warning from Wales about what happens when governments distance themselves from the decisions being taken by NHS trusts or boards under their control.

Community hospitals across Powys, including in Knighton, Llanidloes, Llandrindod Wells, Ystradgynlais, Welshpool and Machynlleth face a perilous future with vital local services potentially being lost. Powys Teaching Health Board is currently running a consultation called Better Together, which proposes that the number of hospital beds be slashed from 146 to as few as 60, whilst minor injuries units, with further cuts being made to minor injuries units, mental health services and X-ray units. My constituents and I fear that these proposals essentially amount to closure by stealth for some hospitals, particularly Llandrindod Wells and Ystradgynlais.

All of the GP practices in Powys have written to express their concerns about these proposals. The proposals have provoked enormous public opposition, with nearly 10,000 people signing my petition against the cuts and hundreds attending public meetings that I've organized across the county. At the same time, in order to save money, the same health board has been slowing down treatment times for patients awaiting surgery in neighboring health boards and trusts in Shropshire and Herefordshire. Yet despite this, the new Plaid Cymru Welsh government has repeatedly refused to intervene, insisting that these are operational matters for the health board. So we now face the extraordinary situation where a health board is putting forward proposals that appear to directly contradict its government's own stated policy to improve step-down care, and those Welsh ministers refuse to take responsibility and step in before it's too late.

The health boards and trusts in Wales are accountable to the Welsh health minister, yet we've seen successive Welsh health ministers refusing to take responsibility over their funding.

Welsh ministers are responsible for the financial contributions of health boards. They cannot wash their hands of the consequences when those boards propose deep cuts to frontline services. And it's striking that while governments elsewhere in the UK have sought to strengthen scrutiny and intervention in struggling NHS trusts, the approach in Wales has too often been to place greater distance between the ministers and the local health boards.

And that's why it's important for the Welsh health minister to take responsibility for his job and the Welsh health service that he runs, listen to the people of Powys, and scrap these proposals for the bed hospital beds across our communities to be removed.

01:02:11 - 01:05:11

Jim Shannon

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. A real pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. A big thank you to the honorable lady for Chelmsford for raising this issue and for giving us a chance to participate. The new intensive recovery program has identified several NHS trusts in England which are underperforming as a result of waiting lists, persistent financial difficulties, and leadership instability. The trusts identified include North Cumbria, Mid and South Essex, Hull, Northern Lincolnshire, Goole, and East Kent.

The performance across these trusts and beyond has raised serious questions about whether patients in England are receiving consistent access to cancer treatment. I want to focus, if I can, Mr. Chairman, on cancer treatment in particular.

NHS of course has a long-standing target that 85% of patients should begin treatment within 62 days of an urgent referral for suspected cancer. However, performance at many trusts is substantially beneath this, which is having serious consequences on patient outcomes. Just as one example, in 2023, a patient in Mid and South Essex Hospital died and this was linked to the trust's failure to meet any of the NHS England's cancer waiting time targets. At this trust, only 47.7% of patients began treatment within 62 days. By 2025, the number was further declining, so it was getting worse.

County Durham and Darlington, the honourable lady has referred to it, trust that the situation is similar. Significant failings were identified in breast cancer care, the honourable lady illustrated incredibly well.

A review of care received by women between 2023 and 2025 found that 32 women had undergone unnecessary surgery, 20 had experienced delayed diagnosis, and a further 78 patients were found to have suffered moderate or severe harm. The review has been committed and demonstrating that the true scale of this issue is likely much bigger than we know of. Analysis of NHS cancer waiting time performance found that nearly every English NHS trust missed cancer targets. In Northern Ireland, we've also experienced serious concerns regarding cancer care. One example is the recently called for public inquiry into urology services at the South Southern Health and Social Care Trust, where it was identified that cervical screening services had reported some results incorrectly.

To be told that it was clear, and then shortly after that to be told, no, it isn't clear, is an absolute scandal. This caused patients and families considerable distress.

Northern Ireland's waiting time statistics further illustrate the pressure on cancer services. Some 30% of patients began treatment within 62 days. The percentage has been a downward decline. So I look to the Minister, although she hasn't responsibility for Northern Ireland but has responsibility for the trusts here, to ensure that they promote effective oversight, accountability in all our trusts. This is a widespread underperformance.

It must be addressed. These failures are undermining public confidence in the health service. As I suspect, cancer diagnosis is already a distressing experience and patient outcomes are not being helped by lack of clarity and reassurance. Thank you.

01:05:11 - 01:05:15

Speaker 23

And last but not least from the back benches, Adam Dance.

01:05:15 - 01:08:16

Adam Dance

Thank you, thank you Mr. Stewart. And I'd also like to thank my honourable member for securing this debate.

Because despite the hard work of staff, the performance of our NHS trust from maternity to stroke has been at the forefront of people's minds due to underperformance. Since the merger, Yeovil Hospital has been the poor relation. Thankfully, we managed to get our maternity unit in Yeovil safely reopened after CQC report found serious failings and the trust closed the unit. We've got government oversight as Baroness Amos refused our trust maternity services during the closure. And she concluded, from evidence we collected during our visit and the concerns expressed by staff, we remain concerned about patient safety at Yeovil District Hospital.

I am hearing this too. And so I really want to hear from the minister about particular steps being taken now to improve oversight and supporting patient safety and staff in rural maternity units.

Another issue that has been a real priority for people in Yeovil has been stroke services. After not meeting targets, the NHS in Somerset closed Yeovil hyper-acute stroke unit as part of the service restructure. Patients will now have to travel to hospitals in Taunton or Dorchester. Local campaigners and I have kept being told that there is a strong evidence base to suggest a restructure would improve the service. But when we did a freedom of information request, we found data suggesting that in 2024, if stroke patients from Yeovil were taken to Taunton, only 13% would have made it within needle, within the target call to needle time of 180 minutes.

And only 30% would have made it to hospital in Dorchester in time. Campaigners and I have been working with the NHS in Somerset to get things like pre-hospital video triage to help cut waiting times and a refurbished acute stroke unit at Yeovil Hospital.

But we are still really concerned about the travel times and the outcomes. That is why I think we really need government oversight, specifically a review of stroke services in rural areas, focusing on the evidence at the consultation process around service provision, health outcome for patients, and travel times. What we need is a proper national picture of how rural areas are being impacted by these service restructures and mergers, because what works for somewhere like Bristol or London will not always work for South Somerset and rural areas.

Sadly, across our entire NHS trust, I have heard really concerning reports of bullying and poor work culture. That is why I believe the government urgently needs to improve oversight of working cultures and bullying in NHS trusts, and that this should start with training for leadership teams across the NHS trust on bullying, because where there is poor performance, work culture is often a key factor. So there is real scope for improved oversight of the NHS trust like ours in Somerset. Ultimately, however, without government support, without funding, we are not going to be able to improve our NHS services.

01:08:16 - 01:08:18

Speaker 25

James Murdoch.

01:08:18 - 01:11:26

James Murdoch

Thank you, Mr. Chair. I appreciate you allowing me to speak at the last moment, and it's an honor to speak under your chairmanship. And also thank you to the honorable member for Chelmsford for bringing this very important and very timely debate to this House.

So I want to be clear that while the list of figures I'm about to bring forward are concerning, I do not place any of the burden or blame on the shoulders of the frontline staff. Indeed, the more concerning the figures, the more gratitude and appreciation I show to the staff for enduring these challenging work environments and the challenging circumstances in which they turn up each day giving the highest quality of care. Indeed, so much so that whistleblowers have brought to my attention at great personal risks to their career concerns and details about the state of care and operational functionality at Basildon Hospital. And if I can give you a very quick example of that, I had a surgeon reach out to me stating how senior management had come in and put into place an organization and a throughput practice that they thought was best, while the surgeon was sat there with his own experience seeing that surgeries were very often left empty because of the way processes were being put forward and forced upon them.

And indeed, since some changes have been brought in place, although I have not been able to personally verify this, it was brought to me by a consultant, said that they've actually hired more management staff than they have hired consultants in the last couple of years. So first, just some figures. Now, while I have almost a dozen bullet points here and almost every single one's rather concerning, I think it's safe to say that South Essex, Mid and South Essex Trust, of which Basildon Hospital is part and which is in my constituency of South Basildon and East Thurrock, it's suffice to say that it ranks 131st out of 134. The Care Quality Commission ranked them as inadequate. So concerned were they with the state of affairs there that they actually performed multiple repeat visits to try and improve the state of things.

Now, complaining alone is not enough, but there are two points that the honorable member for Chelmsford raised that I think are really quite striking. The first is problems should not be obvious. I should not turn up as a layman to medical practice and be able to spot clear errors. Now, I remember visiting the mental health ward there. There was a foyer in which there was just overgrown grass, weeds up to your chest, garbage and concrete strewn everywhere.

And I was walking around with the CEO at the time and I said, "Oh, what's happened here?" And he turned around in complete shock as if he'd never seen it before and said, "Oh, I'm not sure, you know, sometimes you just go nose-blind." Staggering. Staggering.

So, so that's where the problems, I think, don't just start, but that's the standard of things. And I want to say on top of that, while a lot of my constituents will be concerned to hear that Basildon Hospital is ranked poorly, I do also want to stick up for the staff there and say that I personally will continue to use that hospital because I recognize how important it is. So I'll just thank this. One last point as I'm being encouraged to close down.

01:11:26 - 01:11:29

Speaker 27

Order, order. Liberal Democrat spokesman, Helen Morgan.

01:11:29 - 01:12:26

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

Thank you very much, Mr. Stewart. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I congratulate my honorable friend, the member for Chelmsford, for securing this important debate. Tackling underperforming NHS trusts is essential if we're serious about taking the necessary strides forward for patient safety and experience, as well as the wellbeing of NHS workers who are suffering anxiety and burnout at an unprecedented and frankly unacceptable scale.

Liberal Democrats have put forward our robust plan to end corridor care and transform patient safety, essential measures needed to relieve pressure and fix our NHS, and indeed relieve the pressure at both the front door and the back door of the service. Years of Conservative mismanagement and neglect of the NHS left many trusts on their knees with huge challenges from which to recover. And the onus is now on the new Labour government with their intensive recovery programme to finally create the right conditions for failing trusts to succeed where its predecessors have failed. I will give way.

01:12:26 - 01:13:03

Caroline Jane Voaden

Thank my honourable friend for giving way. You talk about the challenges NHS trusts are facing. My local hospital, Torbay Hospital, has an ageing tower block which has now received a fire enforcement notice which could affect up to a quarter of the beds in the hospital. Panic is spreading today in the local community about what this means for future treatment.

Would my honourable friend agree with me that when things become as urgent as this, that a quarter of the beds in the hospital might be closed by the fire brigade, that the government desperately needs to bring forward the new hospitals funding program so that repair and remedial work can begin immediately to restore this part of the hospital?

01:13:03 - 01:18:21

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

I do agree with her and I echo her call and I think that the estate that people work in is really part of the fundamental problem that we're trying to tackle across the NHS. But I hope all the members here who've made excellent speeches highlighting shocking failures in their own trusts can take heart from the fact that it is possible to tackle underperforming trusts. In my time as MP for North Shropshire, I've seen meaningful changes for my constituents. From 2018 to 2023, Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital Trust was obviously underperforming with CQC inspections consistently rating it as inadequate.

That included inadequate levels of safety and services, something reflected in absolutely horrifying stories received at the time in my inbox and those of the other Shropshire MPs and on doorsteps. And as well as a churn in the management team that led to constant uncertainty about what was going to happen there. The human consequence of these stories was devastating. When I was first elected, the overwhelming issue was the abysmal ambulance waiting times related to poor handover times, as the honourable lady for Stoke-on-Trent South has highlighted at Stoke. I'll never forget the letter I received from a school's headteacher after a pupil dislocated his knee playing football.

He and the teachers had waited so long for an ambulance in the dark and cold on a winter night that the pupil was at risk of developing hypothermia by the time the ambulance arrived.

We heard countless devastating stories, including ones where the ambulance had taken so long to arrive that it was too late, that the outcome was fatal. Now, following a targeted campaign, including joining the West Midlands Ambulance Service team for an eye-opening shift, wait times have significantly improved and we see far, far fewer of these cases in the inbox. But challenges remain, not least in corridor care in the accident and emergency department, which has been at times rated as one of the worst in the country. A constituent told me of the shocking experience of her aunt Kath during this period, who was admitted to Royal Shrewsbury Hospital following a serious stroke. One night, Kath fell out of a hospital bed and broke her hip after staff failed to put the necessary guardrails up on the side of her bed.

She spent nearly half an hour trying to attract the attention of the staff on the ward with the alert bell, but they were so overworked they didn't respond. And in the end, she was forced to dial 999 from the floor of the ward.

She was left in the ridiculous position of explaining to the call center staff that she was actually on the floor of a ward in Royal Shrewsbury Hospital before the staff reached her. That can't be right. We heard of many heartbreaking situations where cancer patients' scans were unable to take place because waiting lists had meant that they were booked in the wrong order, and fatally long waits for diagnosis in some cases, with the trust failing to hit key targets across the board. And then finally, the Ockenden report in 2022 struck my community with its devastating finding of over 200 preventable deaths of babies and unimaginable harm done to families. Campaigning and voicing justified anger, which everyone has done today, and working with these ministers at the failings can bring about change.

That was essential in Shropshire.

And although things aren't perfect, it's encouraging to see the improvements that have been made so far. It's been a really difficult environment for staff to work in, and I'd like to pay tribute to them and the new leadership team for all the hard work that they have put into place into turning this extremely difficult situation around. The trust's CQC rating has recently been upgraded, although this still requires improvement, with emergency department waiting times and understaffing key focuses. But there is much to be pleased with. Reviews have noted a positive culture, and the trust has recently been shortlisted for several awards due to its performance improvements.

So we must celebrate the many trusts in the UK that provide the high levels of care and innovation and support those making significant improvements. For underperforming trusts, it's our duty to our patients and our constituents to make sure that we campaign to bring them up to good standards, and I congratulate everyone here today for doing just that. But if conditions for care are stretched and staff are expected to deliver the impossible with limited time and resources, it's patients who suffer.

And how can we transform patient safety? To start, we need to hold failing leaders to account, as I've discussed. Reports have pointed to a culture of unaccountability among NHS leaders, which have accompanied recent scandals and undermined public confidence. Failing trusts need to be able to be held to account, and our amendment to the Health Bill would help to do this by retaining the necessary structures for this accountability. First of all, we must retain the independent patient voice, Healthwatch, which was established in the wake of the Mid Staffordshire scandal.

And HSIB, while in its infancy, should also be retained because it promises to improve that patient safety environment.

Our amendments would also introduce duties and a standardized framework for the reporting of suspected health system failings and medical malpractice by coroners, medical examiners, and members of ICB and NHS trust boards. Whistleblowing routes to the CQC, the Department for Health and Care, HSIB, and the police would be accompanied by statutory protections, and we'd also place a corresponding duty on senior leadership to escalate concerns they have regarding safety or malpractice to the relevant boards. My colleagues in the other place will be retabling these amendments at the next stage of the Health Bill, and I urge the government to accept them. The Thirlwall inquiry...

01:18:21 - 01:18:37

Jim Shannon

I'm a believer in whistleblowing, as the honorable member from the backbenches has spoke before. Does the honorable lady agree that there should be more encouragement for those who do want to whistleblow, but there also needs to be protection for them to ensure that their jobs are protected?

01:18:37 - 01:19:49

Helen Lilian Margaret Morgan

I think that's why HSIB has a role to play because it provides that safe space for people to raise concerns without fearing for their jobs. And also the Office of the Guardian, which is also being removed in the Health Bill, enables and encourages safe whistleblowing across the NHS, and I think it's important that we retain it. The Thirlwall Inquiry highlighted constant reorganization as a problem as well. And I received in my inbox this week notification that Shropshire, Telford and Wrekin ICB, which has clustered with Stoke and Staffordshire ICB in order to get ready for a merger of those two ICBs, that that's all on hold now because it doesn't line up with local government reorganization. This is really, really problematic for local health services when their management teams don't know whether they're coming or going from one month to the next.

I fully agree with him.

And I would urge the Minister to deal with that problem as well.

It's clear that urgent action is needed to turn around underperforming trusts for the safety of their patients, the welfare of the staff, and the value that's delivered for the taxpayer. So I hope the government will look at the measures we've outlined and accept some of those in the Health Bill as it passes through the House of Lords, so that we can really affect people's lives and put back their confidence in the NHS that it will be there for them when they most need it.

01:19:49 - 01:19:53

Graham Stuart

His Majesty's opposition spokesman Dr. Caroline Johnson.

01:19:53 - 01:21:25

Caroline Johnson

Thank you, Mr. Stewart. And it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship this afternoon. I'd like to congratulate the honorable lady on securing the debate on a very important subject. It's clearly important to her constituents, but is important to all of us right across the country. The performance of NHS is key to the health of the nation.

It gives us all the best chance of good health, of recovery, which is important for our social well-being and brings economic benefits too. The first question is, how do we know which trusts are performing well and which trusts are not?

First we need to decide what good performance looks like. And we can look at that in a couple of ways, particularly in relation to outcome and experience, and both are important. The outcome, for example, may be a death. This will come to us all eventually, and the experience may be one that's in comfort, in line with the wishes of the individual, so the experience may be as good as it can be delivered. Conversely, one could have on the face of it a very good outcome from the trust in terms of, you know, a surgical outcome could be very good, but have a very poor experience of care during that experience.

So there are various ways to measure it. Experience is measured in a number of different ways. Individual staff, such as consultants, have as part of their appraisal and revalidation patient feedback.

There is the friends and family test enabling people to give anonymous feedback. One can measure the number of complaints or compliments, and trusts can do their own surveys, but these are all to some extent internal processes.

01:21:25 - 01:21:27

Speaker 32

I wonder if the member would give way to a point of order.

01:21:27 - 01:21:28

I will briefly, yes.

01:21:28 - 01:21:38

Speaker 33

Thank you, and I'm pleased actually, I'd love to hear more of what she's saying, but none of us can actually hear her very well back here. She might be prepared to speak up a bit more, thank you.

01:21:38 - 01:27:23

Caroline Johnson

Sorry, the microphone went off a bit, but it has just come back on again, so I hope that it will be a more, more effective, thank you. Okay, okay, okay, okay, okay. Right. So, um, they're mostly internal.

The Healthwatch itself is an independent patient voice looking at people's experience across the health service in a way that's independent of government. Now the government plan to, as part of the Health Bill, abolish Healthwatch and bring it inside the department. And I wonder if the government could comment on whether or not they're still planning to do so. We know that the Prime Minister, when he was Mayor of Greater Manchester and in charge of the ICB there, wrote to the government suggesting that may be the wrong path. Does he still think so as Prime Minister and what instructions has she had in relation to that?

Because I think people are sometimes frightened to provide feedback to trusts and they will be more willing to do so in the event that they have confidence that they're being heard independently. The other ways of measuring experience that the government do are related to waiting times.

So how long it takes to be seen in clinic, how long it takes to be seen in A&E, how long it takes from the decision to admit a patient to actually admitting them, how long it takes for a procedure or an operation. And the government produce lots and lots and lots and lots of figures, but a lot of them I'm afraid, Chair, are going in the wrong direction. So they have a dashboard where they look at the referral to treatment statistics. And I'm afraid the waiting lists are rising actually. They had reached a low point in March 2026, just after you'll remember the reports of exceptional numbers of removals, but they've now risen 222,000 in the last four months.

For those requiring a procedure or an operation, I'm afraid to say the numbers waiting are actually higher than they were at the general election. For people waiting more than 12 hours in A&E after a decision to admit them from the emergency department, there are more, many more waiting this year than there were in 2024. And staff sickness rates, which were mentioned by an honourable member earlier in the debate, are also consistently higher than they were before the general election. So statistics are not going in the right direction across the NHS. Other ways that the government measure outcomes include financial management of a trust, leadership and government metrics, the number of procedures performed, the number of never events, and CQC inspections.

But again, with the CQC, they're planning to fold HSIB into the CQC, which so many commentators have guarded against, and I know the Liberal Democrats and us as the opposition have guarded against the abolition of HSIB.

And I hope the government, when it takes this through the Lords in committee in the next week or two, will think again. They're also planning to roll the number of other things into the CQC at the same time, including events management. And I wonder if they're asking an organisation which the government acknowledges has been struggling to take on too much. So if poor performance is identified, who is responsible? Is it the consultant or the matron?

Is it the director of sleeves? Is it the chief exec or the chair? If ultimately the trust is underperforming, at the moment there are governors that are supposed to hold the board to account. Well, the health service, the health bill abolishes those. The ICBs, the commissioners, can hold the trust to account.

But their budget's been halved, so will they have the capacity to do so? Many of them have merged. Some of those mergers have been caused by government. This is all a distraction.

NHS England has a role, but they are being abolished too. And the headcount in DHSC and NHS England overall is apparently to be halved. How will they have the bandwidth in order to be able to provide the scrutiny that the government says it's going to have? Having identified the management of poor performance, the government chose five trusts: North Cumbria, Mid and South Essex, Hull University Teaching Hospitals, Norfolk and Lincolnshire and Goole, and East Kent, to have special intensive recovery program in March 2023. But it's not clear what has been instituted in these trusts, and it's also not clear what outcomes this is developing, how long this will last, and what the government will do for those trusts who fall just outside this group of five.

How will they improve variability between trusts that don't fall into the bottom cohort? And how did they choose the five trusts that they've chosen? Because as we've heard earlier, there are a number of metrics by which some trusts could be considered in the bottom five and that they weren't chosen, and some metrics by which those that were chosen may not be in the bottom five. So how has the minister chosen those trusts and how does she intend to improve those that don't fall into her chosen few? The other thing I wanted to raise was the workforce.

So the government has promised a workforce plan, but workforce is the most important thing. We've heard much, many, many honorable members and right honorable members today have spoken about the really good staff that they have in their trusts working extremely hard in very difficult conditions.

And the government, previous Conservative government had developed a long-term workforce plan. Now this government decided it wanted its own workforce plan and it won the election, it's very much entitled to do so. But it still hasn't written it. It promised it by the end of 2025, we're rapidly approaching the end of 2026 and it's still not with us. So can the minister...

01:27:23 - 01:27:24

Order. The sitting is suspended for 15 minutes for a division in the House.

01:42:23 - 01:42:27

Speaker 34

Order. Dr. Caroline Johnson.

01:42:27 - 01:45:28

Caroline Johnson

Thank you, Chair. And before the interruption, we were talking about the importance of workforce to the health service and to any improvements that we wish to make into services.

The previous Conservative government had developed a long-term workforce plan, and this government decided to develop its own, which is fair enough, but it's very much delayed. So can the Minister tell us, without using the words "in due course", "imminently", or "soon", when it's going to be published, preferably giving a date? And in return to other plans, the government says its maternity and neonatal care is its priority, which is good. But when they came into government, they said they had a plan to improve it. They spent the first 12 months writing their 10-year plan, which said it would have a maternity and neonatal plan to be produced.

They did this review, which took six months longer than it was supposed to do, taking up now two years of a parliamentary term.

And that plan says they're going to have a commissioner that they've yet to appoint and another plan, this one called a modern service framework, which will be due apparently by Christmas. So can the minister guarantee that two and a half years into their parliamentary session, they will have a delivery plan for maternity improvements? The bottom line, chair, is I'm very concerned the government is too busy reorganising the NHS to deliver on its promises. NHS performance is declining in many areas. There's huge variability between trusts and departments.

Picking five for intensive treatment, what about the others and how can she clarify that it works? She's internalising patient experience, which means that it may suddenly look much better, but how will anyone have confidence in the figures if they're produced by the government marking its own homework? The government reorganisation, the abolition of NHS England has been badly planned. ICB cuts, mergers and paused mergers are simply a distraction.

And the removal of the need for governors adds, removes another layer of accountability and scrutiny. The government say they're working at a pace, but it's a very slow pace, Chair. The workforce plan, the maternity plan have been delayed, but also things like the Hughes report. Those people with the valproate and mesh who are suffering have been waiting and waiting and waiting. It is now well over two years, getting towards three years since that report was published.

They've waited long enough. I urge the minister to say when the government intend to respond to that report.

The government essentially need to get a grip of who's holding to account the trusts so that when the health bill comes out the other side of the Lords, it is very clear, there is a very clear chain of command leading up to the Secretary of State perhaps. But it's clear that he's not going to be able to micromanage every detail and there needs to be a clear path so that people know who is accountable, who is going to drive improvement, who to congratulate when the improvements are made, but also who to hold accountable when it goes wrong.

01:45:28 - 01:45:41

Graham Stuart

Thank you, Minister, and thanks to the discipline of the speakers so far. There are some a small number of minutes, extra minutes, Minister, which would allow interventions if the Minister so chose.

01:45:41 - 01:45:46

Speaker 35

Well, that's very kind of you, Mr. Stewart, to encourage. If I can just ask if I'm possible, what what is the timings now on on...

01:45:46 - 01:45:53

Graham Stuart

We will finish at 4:15, so if at 4:13 for the... ideally we would allow the...

01:45:53 - 01:57:00

Karin Smyth

Thank you very much. I do want to try and get back to most to most colleagues.

So it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr. Stewart. And I do want to thank the honorable member for Chelmsford for bringing forward this debate and the all members who have spoken about the experiences of patients, because this is absolutely about the experience of patients, families, and the NHS staff in all our constituencies. Because when an NHS trust underperforms, however we define it, the effects are very real in that patients wait longer, staff work without the stability and the support they need, and public money is not used as effectively as it should be. And I do think, and I've made this very clear since becoming a minister, that members of Parliament should be absolutely part of those conversations with those local trusts. And can I particularly commend my friend the honorable member for Ipswich for hosting in the way that he has the mental health trust and seeing that improvement in his constituency as he outlined, and mental health absolutely being considered as well as acute services.

And indeed, the Liberal Democrat spokesperson spoke about her work in supporting her local trust and seeing those improvements.

It can and it does happen. But many of the trusts that we've discussed here today have faced problems built up over many years. In fact, some of them I remember from when I was a manager in the health service, Mr. Stewart, over the past 20 years or so. So there is rarely one cause or a quick fix. There are variable problems, whether they be workforce shortages, poor estates issues, weak leadership, organizational change, and rising demand, and some of these can reinforce each other.

But let's be very clear for patients and public that are paying attention here today and for all our constituents that this government will not accept poor performance and we are determined to accelerate the recovery, particularly in the most challenged trusts.

Now if I can just sort of clarify some of the sort of the rules. Everyone knows that NHS England is an arms-length body. That was a decision taken by my good friends the Liberal Democrats and the Conservatives in opposition a number of years ago. And the Health Bill changes that arrangement to bring the NHS together with the Department of Health and Social Care. And that is progressing as we know through the House of Lords.

It was not opposed in principle by any political party because we all know that it hasn't worked. And as we bring these two together, it is important to maintain that distinction between running large trusts and running the system as a whole. That operational performance oversight is a skilled job. It's hard to run a big trust.

It requires good clinical and operational managers and leadership and knowledge. But the complete separation of the department from NHS England and from ministers meant that that oversight and what we could see as members of parliament in our constituencies was not linked up to the government and the previous government. So that is one of the things that will improve. And as the honorable lady has just said opposite, of course ministers will not be micromanaging. That is a skilled job.

The complete separation that removed oversight from local trusts is a dysfunction of the system over the last decade. So in my role, I do meet regularly with the teams to be very clear and with members of parliament. And I want to share some of that how that operational oversight works today. So two major areas I'd highlight.

One is the oversight framework. That provides what we'd see a clear and consistent assessment of every NHS organisation. And it looks at, and the honourable lady opposite again in her expertise recognised that there are many ways to judge performance, but it looks at what matters most to patients. And we're very clear in the the new oversight framework. It matters most to patients and taxpayers: waiting times, quality of care, use of staff and money, and leadership capability in order to have that good quality patient care.

You can't separate them in my view. And I have made sure that it's transparent for the public and for members of parliament.

That's quite controversial, some people don't like what they call league tables, but I think it's really important that people can see that. Secondly, the IRP. I'm going to move through some of these for the moment. For providers with the most entrenched financial, operational, leadership, structural challenges that do impact on patient care, because that's what these trusts are about, we are taking now a more holistic approach to that enhanced support for, as the honourable lady asked me in her comments, how do we choose? They are the most challenged long-term systems.

So the intensive recovery programme is providing from a national level a short-term intensive support for organisations to help strengthen their immediate operational and financial stability, but whilst also developing an organisation-owned plan for long-term sustainability, because we can't keep going round in this circle, and at the end of the day these organisations need to be well-run, well-led, and local systems need to own that problem. That is part also of our wider devolution issue. And I think I did outline that in my letter to the honourable lady for Chelmsford in September, but I'm very happy to meet again and go through that in more detail if that's helpful.

The first IRP cohort includes Hull University Teaching Hospitals, Northern Lincolnshire and Goole, East Kent Hospitals, North Cumbria Integrated Care, and Mid and South Essex. Each face very different circumstances, so there is not one size fits all response. And I'm going to touch on for those members that are here that have raised their own issue around that. Just I know there's an interest in Hull and Northern Lincolnshire and Goole, and following that independent review, the decision has been taken to dissolve the Humber Health Partnership arrangements. And different for in Hull, the focus is on strengthening core hospital services, making best use of specialist services, improving productivity, and reinforcing the clinical leadership and accountability.

And for Northern Lincolnshire and Goole, the priority is to look at more care in the neighbourhood and community settings, reflecting the demands in those areas.

And there are good signs of progress. With regard to Mid and South Essex, which the honorable lady has brought forward, and as was highlighted in some interventions, the 2020 merger of those three trusts has not delivered what was the planned benefit for 1.2 million people. The staff culture and morale remains a serious concern, with little improvement, as was highlighted in those terrible survey results over the past five years. And we've heard those. The trust has a long-standing performance problems linked to how demand is managed across the wider health system across that part of Essex.

And work is underway to reduce the long waits, improve patient flow, strengthen governance and make better use of the estate. Analysis identified, and I shared this analysis and productivity plans with with everybody earlier in the year, I'm sure you all looked at them in detail, I'm very happy to go through them again, but the analysis identified more than 122 million pounds of productivity opportunities. It's not simply about saving money.

Better organization across sites and stronger clinical integration should improve patient experience, reduce delays, and raise quality for patients. The clinical strategy will make greater use of neighborhood and community care in line with our 10-year plan and focus on maternity and planned care treatment. This is backed by 80 million pound for Southend Hospital's long-standing structural estate problems and support for a neighborhood health center in Maldon. I'll just touch on North Cumbria because the work that's going on in North Cumbria really highlights for members from Westmorland and Lonsdale and from Honiton and, sorry, I can't read my writing, Honiton and Tipton, thank you very much, and for member for Yeovil about, you know, what can be done and needs to be done in rural health cares. But again, if I remind honorable members that hospitals in some of those areas are funded additionally for tariff to cope with some of that rurality issues.

And again, we highlighted that in our 10-year health plan.

We absolutely understand across the country different issues with regard to rurality. Also, just to respond, I won't talk about Kent at the moment because I don't think that's been raised here today, but again, very different issues. But that is why those areas have been chosen because they are long-standing and deeply entrenched problems. My friend, the honorable member for Stoke-on-Trent South, raised the issue around ambulance handover delays. And I didn't know she was going to raise this today, Mr. Stewart, but just to assure you, in my oversight meeting yesterday with the team, this was raised with me, the continued problems with the ambulance thing.

So those issues are flagged by NHS England and their operational management across the country. They are long-standing, as she knows, but I just gently disagree with her, as she knows, about she's absolutely right in her assessments of history.

But it's not a failure of oversight and accountability, this issue. This is a responsibility of good cooperation, collaboration, and management between the services locally. The oversight has worked. We know it's a problem. We can see that.

Her constituents can see that. And we very much want them to work together to resolve that flow that comes through so that the ambulance handover works much better. My honorable friend, the member for Salford, again, she highlights what sadly is for her constituency a downward improvement trajectory. And she's asked to meet, and I'm very happy to do with that. Honorable friend, the member for Darlington, raises, and she does an incredibly difficult job in raising this terrible distress for women in her constituency.

It is of course a terrible, terrible case in which she's highlighted that and I absolutely will make sure that she has a meeting with the minister to absolutely go through how that can be supported on behalf of her constituents and I know she will work closely to make sure that they are served better. Now the early improvements that we are seeing as a result of what's coming through the IRP is is working, but we do need to demonstrate progress through safer care, better operational financial performance. We've got clear milestones, credible plans and stronger organisations. That's what we're after. Support nationally is is time limited but proportionate because trusts ultimately have to stand on their feet.

It is, of course, a terrible, terrible case, which she's highlighted that.

Intensive oversight is not about naming and shaming. Staff in challenged trusts as we've heard work exceptionally hard in difficult circumstances and we need to encourage people to go there so we need to show them that it can be better. The purpose is to remove barriers to improvement, provide the right expertise and hold boards and NHS leaders to account for the results. So the government will continue to work with NHS England.

I'm committed to keeping Parliament informed of significant developments. We will judge this approach by its effect on patients and staff, not by the creation of more processes. The oversight framework and the intensive recovery program provide a clear route, in my view, from identifying the risk to taking targeted action. There is much more to do. It can only be done in local circumstances with the work and cooperation and transparency, that includes working with Members of Parliament.

And where we hear examples of where trust chief executives don't do that, Mr. Stewart, I'm very prepared to call that out. I don't think that is acceptable. There is more to do, but we want practical, safer, and more timely care and stronger organisations. I'm pleased the opportunity to have this discussion today, genuinely. I do think it's important for MPs to be part of this discussion.

We want to improve them all. We are focusing on those really long-term, sometimes for decades, places.

Those people in those areas deserve better, and we're determined to make sure they get it. Hear, hear.

Reid Goldman to wind up.

01:57:00 - 01:59:11

Marie Goldman

Thank you, Mr. Stewart. I'd like to start by thanking all of the honorable members across the House who've taken part in today's really important debate. I'd also like to thank the Minister for her responses. But we've heard from across the House issues, honorable members pointing out that, you know, rural constituencies are not the same as urban constituencies and have very different needs, pointing out that we need investment in our infrastructure at our hospitals. Some of the hospitals are absolutely failing because they have been neglected from a building's point of view for, frankly, decades, and that needs to be fixed.

None of us are here today to just criticize. All of us are doing this because we want to, we are listening to our constituents, we're listening to patients, we're listening to staff, and it is our absolute duty to call this out and to demand better. And that's absolutely what we're doing today. You know, I don't like hyperbole, so sometimes when people talk about life and death, I think it is hyperbole. That is not the case here.

It is literally life and death. There are people who are on waiting lists who are there, as we've heard tragically, who have died because they've been too long on a waiting list or because they've been mistreated, misdiagnosed, as we've heard tragically from members across the House. I also just want to make a final plea just not to concentrate just on the finances. Yes, finances will help with rural issues and they will help with structural and infrastructure issues. They won't help with the cultural issues.

And I just want to finish with one final comment, which is that in the CQC did a well-led inspection of the Mid and South Essex Trust recently. And the really stark line that came out of it was that staff are afraid to speak up for fear of reprisal. That's a system that isn't about money. That's cultural, and we really need to do something about that. The Minister said that we could meet again.

I'd just like to gently say to her we haven't actually met yet, so I'd love to take her up on the opportunity to meet her for the very first time. So thank you very much for her response and thank you very much to everybody for taking part today. Thank you.

01:59:11 - 02:00:48

Graham Stuart

The question is that this House has considered government oversight of underperforming NHS trusts. As many as are of that opinion say Aye. Of the contrary, No.

I think the ayes have it. Order, order. Move over because the next debate will start at 4:15 precisely.

Order. I will call Lisa Smart to move the motion. I will then call the Minister to respond. I remind other members that they may only make a speech with prior permission both from the member in charge of the debate and the Minister. There will not be an opportunity for the member in charge to wind up, as is the convention for 30-minute debates.

Order, order. Lisa Smart to move the motion.

02:00:48 - 02:04:35

Lisa Smart

Thank you very much, Mr. Stewart. I beg to move that this House has considered school funding in Stockport. And it really is a pleasure to serve with you in the chair. I must start by declaring an interest.

I'm in my 20th year of being an unpaid primary school governor, and I'm currently at Fairway, the wonderful Fairway Primary School in Offerton. I'm sure we'd all agree that being an MP is a real privilege, and one of the best things we get to do in this job is to spend time in schools. Young people get to the nub of issues. They have very, very little filter, and they always, always leave me feeling much more positive about the future of our country. But the school visits I've done since being elected to this place have included conversations with headteachers who, while they're doing remarkable things for their pupils and their school communities, they're having to explain which posts they cannot fill, which support they've had to cut, and which requests from parents they've had to turn down because the money just isn't there.

The chief executive of the Honeycomb Education Trust, which includes Mellor Primary School in my patch, told me he'd recently been left with three choices: lose three or four members of staff, lose a headteacher, or take early retirement himself. He chose retirement, and this is what the funding position is doing to experienced and celebrated school leaders like Jim in my constituency. Schools across Stockport are expected to provide the same educational experience for students as the rest of the country, yet schools in my constituency and across the borough are funded at disproportionately lower levels per pupil compared to other places, including neighbouring Manchester, and that's the case for much of the rest of the country. Now, funding for our education system can be complex. Education has two core funding streams: education services, which is a cash-limited budget that comes through the council, and the dedicated schools grant, which is the core funding provided by central government through the Department for Education for education purposes.

And that budget reaches schools mainly according to the number of pupils that are enrolled, with other considerations including deprivation, number of children on free school meals, English as an additional language, and low prior attainment taken into account. So the rate attached to each child and the number of children in the school decide almost everything about a school's budget. The primary school's unit of funding in Manchester is £6,404. In neighboring Stockport, it is £5,623. It does not cost almost £800 more to educate a child in Manchester than it does in Stockport, and it is hard to justify this big gap.

At secondary schools, the funding in Manchester averages at £8,452, and Stockport receives £7,320, which is a gap of £1,100 for every pupil. And that's £350 less than the national average.

We're not just a little bit below the average in Stockport. Among all the authorities in England, Stockport's secondary rate is one of the lowest in the country. Now, at the top of the table sit inner London boroughs, some receiving over £10,000 per pupil. The distance between the top of that table and for those areas near the bottom is hard to defend. Those differences in funding are having a dire effect in Stockport.

I've been told that 68 of the 78 schools in Stockport are heading for a deficit, and that the school reserves have fallen from £11 million to around £5 million. The schools that are attempting to remain financially resilient are joining multi-academy trusts based outside Stockport, and others are being pushed towards mergers.

Now when speaking to Jim from the Honeycomb Education Trust, he laid out the additional burdens that school leaders are facing in addition to limited funding. These include the removal of the trust capacity fund, national insurance contributions that were not fully funded, long-term staff sickness absence and a growing number of children with special educational needs.

02:04:35 - 02:04:36

On that point?

02:04:36 - 02:04:38

Speaker 41

With pleasure.

02:04:38 - 02:05:19

Jim Shannon

Mr. Chairman, I commend the honorable lady for bringing this forward and particularly the special educational needs. It's a very similar story in Northern Ireland where there's been historical underfunding. But does the honorable lady share my concern? Some of the public press, Mr. Chairman, are carrying stories about the numbers of those with ADHD, almost suggesting that the ADHD numbers aren't correct. In my constituency, I can see it very clearly that there are rising numbers of ADHD.

And I know I have six grandchildren of which three of them have some educational challenges. That's just an example.

Does the honorable lady share my concern that the ADHD figures are rising and they are correct?

02:05:19 - 02:08:57

Lisa Smart

I'm grateful to the honorable gentleman for his intervention. I too have family members with ADHD diagnoses. I think we as a society have got much better at understanding neurodiversity, understanding the strengths of those who are neurodiverse, but also how best to educate and work with those who are neurodiverse. And so I agree with him that a better understanding of our fellow citizens has got to be a good thing. And if that comes with a diagnosis, then let's welcome that.

Councils receive a high needs budget to pay for specialist places and for extra support in mainstream schools. And in Stockport, that comes to just over 56 million pounds this year, with over 1,100 students holding high needs places last year.

And that brings me to the deficit on the high needs budget, which hangs over councils across England and which Stockport knows well. By March 2027, the cumulative deficit on Stockport's dedicated schools grant is expected to reach around 68 million pounds. Now, because of the statutory override, that sum sits in an unusable reserve rather than on the council's balance sheet where it could be put to better use. The government has said that as part of its wider reforms to special educational needs provision, it will write off 90% of the accrued deficit at March 2027. Now, for Stockport, that's an estimated 61 million pounds, so of course I welcome that.

It's the right thing to do and councils have been asking for it for years.

However, the override is due to end in March 2028, with a new funding model due to begin in April 28. And in between, Stockport expects to build up a further deficit of around £60 million across 26-27 and 27-28. The government has said that more support will be confirmed. But this puts councils and schools in a difficult position as they have to set budgets without knowing whether a sum almost as large as the first write-off will be covered. Schools and councils want to work with a clear understanding of what they should expect.

The council and families across the borough deserve better than that uncertainty, and parents of children with special educational needs should be provided with the certainty that yes, school places will be available to them and no, you don't have to worry about whether they'll be funded. They should not be told that it depends on a funding model that is yet to be published.

So I'd be really grateful if the minister could update us on when schools should expect publication of the new funding model. Funding disparities can also disproportionately affect students coming from low socio-economic backgrounds. Stockport is one of the most polarized boroughs in the country. We have communities that are among the most affluent in the region and we also have the most deprived ward in the whole of Greater Manchester. Children in that ward start school with disadvantages that an average will never pick up.

A funding system that sees only the prosperous areas of a borough and sets the rate to match lets down those children. That's why Stockport is a founder member of the F40 group, the campaign of the lowest funded local authorities, which has pressed for years for a fairer distribution of education funding, and the case has not changed. These gaps mean that on average, sorry, that an average one-form entry primary school in Stockport receives around £164,000 less each year than a same school if it were based in Manchester.

Head teachers in my constituency cannot simply absorb a gap like that. The pressure, though, is not only on budgets. In Marple and the surrounding villages, families living in the catchment area of Marple Hall School are finding that their children are not being offered a place because the school is oversubscribed. And I've heard direct... I will happily give way.

02:08:57 - 02:09:30

Speaker 42

I thank my honorable friend for giving way, and she's making a really strong statement for the schools in her patch and in Stockport, wider Stockport. The point about schools being oversubscribed, this is an issue that's really impacting Cheadle as well.

Schools such as Woodford Primary School have been oversubscribed for some time. Do you think if we cracked this funding issue, if we made funding fairer, it would help the admission system a lot better and give parents that rest of mind that they could choose the school that is best for their kid?

02:09:30 - 02:11:25

Lisa Smart

Yes, and I'm grateful to my constituency neighbor and friend for raising this point. I think there are a number of challenges when it comes to admissions, and I think funding is part of the answer to that. I think when we have multi-academy trusts who are their own admissions authority working alongside local councils who have the responsibility for finding a place for a child, their wishes and desires don't always align. And I think there's work that I'm doing and I've been in correspondence with the minister about how we find a way through this, because every child deserves a brilliant education at a good local school, and parents should be able to choose the right school for their child. So I strongly agree with him on that.

Because I've heard directly from parents about the effect that it has on them that their child is having to get a bus that drives past Marple Hall to get to the school where they've been assigned a place. School funding challenges are also reaching organisations that work alongside our schools. One of my constituents, David from Romiley, runs a social enterprise with his wife that delivers educational activities in primary schools, and he came to see me because of the government's decision to end the PE and sport premium. He's now expecting to have to make redundancies among his staff. So I ask the minister if she will look again at how the national funding formula treats areas like Stockport.

A system that locks in historic allocations and averages out pockets of real deprivation does not match funding to need.

And I ask the Minister to say whether the Department will review the way the formula is built, and if so, to set out a timetable. Would the Minister also confirm what support will be available for the deficits that build up in 26-27 and 27-28 before the override ends? Councils really need that certainty now, not in the spring. Can she commit to publishing those figures in good time? I will happily give way to my neighbor.

02:11:25 - 02:12:04

Navendu Mishra

Mr. Stewart, can I thank my constituency neighbor for securing this debate? This is a very important issue, and I would go as far as to say that the three of us, although from two different political parties, work well together on issues like this.

But would she recognize that the Stockport Council has had two million pounds in the inclusive mainstream fund allocation under this government? The council has also had another just over two million for experts at hand program. And I wonder if she shares my frustration in terms of Stockport Council only meeting 18% of EHCP deadlines within 20 weeks, by comparison to the English average which is set to be 50% of deadlines within that timeframe.

02:12:04 - 02:13:34

Lisa Smart

More funding coming to our borough is absolutely welcome. He's entirely right. And he's completely right that the three of us, although not always ideologically aligned, work well when it comes to the shared ambitions for our borough. So I strongly agree with him on that. I also agree with him that the EHCP turnaround and the service that parents and families have been getting in Stockport has not been good enough.

And it is something that I know the three of us have raised with the council, and they have a clear aspiration and duty for it to improve. So I strongly agree with him on that.

I'd also agree that some of the funding discrepancies are historic and we need to work now to fix that. I agree with him strongly on that because the children who are now going through our education service deserve better. So I agree. Additionally, when will the detail of the new special educational needs funding model due to take effect from April 2028 be published? Will the department consult councils and schools before it's finalised?

The children of Stockport, Mr. Stewart, they are as bright, as hardworking and as deserving as any in the country. They should not be funded as though they are worth a little bit less or indeed £800 less than a child in the neighbouring borough. So I urge the minister to look again at how we fund our schools, to give councils certainty about special educational needs funding before the override ends and to give the children of Stockport the fair deal they deserve. Thank you.

02:13:34 - 02:13:42

Graham Stuart

Question is, that this house has considered school funding in Stockport. Minister.

02:13:42 - 02:17:34

Speaker 44

Thank you, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I really appreciate the honorable member for Stockport opening this really important debate. Sorry. Yeah. So, and yeah, and really apologize for giving away your job there, the honorable member, my honorable friend's job there.

But I would I also wanted to thank the honorable member for her commitment as a school governor for over 20 years, I think she said, which our school governors do such important valuable work and I can I can hear how passionate she is about these issues. And we are to investment in education and funding for schools is absolutely critical. It's a huge priority for for this government, as she set out I thought really powerfully, teachers do really important work around the country and we want to to back them. It's why we've prioritized investment in education by making a significant investment in the core schools budget in financial year 2026 to 2027 with an extra 2.3 billion for schools. This means that the core schools budget will total 67.6 billion compared to 65.3 billion in 2025 to 2026.

And this is a significant investment that shows how important education and schools are to this government. She also mentioned how important it was to to see that wider infrastructure around schools continuing to be funded. And certainly my experience as a as a council leader for many years working closely with schools is that, you know, through the the cuts we saw to local services, schools increasingly were picking up those wider pressures, whether that's cuts in in support for young people or for families. And it's why we're investing in all the the crucial services that sit around schools, whether that's investment in Best Start in Life hubs that that deliver early intervention, investment in Experts at Hand, as my honourable friend talked about, which provides much-needed speech and language therapists and educational psychologists to be able to support schools, investment in Family First partnerships that brings back that early help and early intervention that that was cut, and also investment in addressing child poverty, whether that is the extension of free school meals or the end to

Investment in Family First partnerships that brings back the early help and early intervention that was cut. And also investment in addressing child poverty, whether that is the extension of free school meals or the end to the two-child benefit cap. All of this reduces pressure on schools and builds that team back around schools. The honourable member also talked about the importance of supporting children with special educational needs and disabilities and stepping in to really support teachers, and that that was one of the main pressure points that they had heard. And that's certainly something that we have very deeply heard, how the extent of those pressures, both on families, young people, but also on educators.

And it's why we're taking forward the reforms around special educational needs and disabilities. We have consulted widely on the future model, which really overhauls the system, creating one that invests a lot earlier, brings funding directly into schools so that they are able to meet those needs long-term and invest in that early intervention. And we've started that investment ahead of full reforms. So we're putting four billion into early intervention, some of which is going directly into schools through the inclusive mainstream fund, some of it going to councils through experts at hand, and also a significant 3.7 billion capital investment in creating new specialist places. And as she also mentioned, we are supporting local authorities with those historic...

02:17:35 - 02:17:38

Speaker 45

Mr. Speaker. And I thank the Minister for giving way on that.

02:17:38 - 02:18:12

Navendu Mishra

I appreciate the points she's making about the capital investment, but there isn't a week that goes by where a parent doesn't contact my office in terms of the frustration of the local council not meeting the assessment deadline. And can I encourage the Minister and the Department to engage with Stockport Council, because 18% is just not good enough. I also think there's a point to be made in terms of parents who come from a low-income background, who often just give up, rather than perhaps people of other backgrounds who will continue taking that fight and contact me, contact their local councillors, perhaps pursue legal remedies.

02:18:12 - 02:22:04

Speaker 44

I absolutely agree with my honourable friend that that is not acceptable performance. And we are, as a Department, determined to hold councils to account on their performance for children with special educational needs and disabilities. For too long that's been on individual parents, as he set out, and for some parents, with all the challenges they face, that's incredibly difficult.

So we have asked every local authority in the country to develop a SEND reform plan. We are monitoring the data within that plan quarterly. The money that we are supporting local authorities with to relieve 90% of their deficit, as the honorable member set out, is contingent on delivery of those SEND reform plans. And we are putting in capacity support, 200 million around the country to support that capacity, but also where needed intervention. And we will be working really closely with Stockport.

And I'm very happy to meet with the Stockport MPs to discuss that in greater detail. And in terms of future years of deficit support, we have said that we will take a similar proportionate response to supporting local authorities. But that is absolutely contingent on them being proactive about reforming the system, better supporting parents, and working with the authority. And we've been really clear those expectations and how we will be holding them to account for delivery. More broadly, the honorable member asked about the distribution of a national funding formula and how it allocates funding.

And as she set out, it allocates funding based on pupil numbers and pupil characteristics.

So it means a targeting of funding to schools that have the greatest number of pupils with additional needs. So in 2026 to 27, 11% of a school's national funding formula has been allocated through deprivation factors. 18% has been allocated for additional needs overall. And this corresponds to 5.6 billion for deprivation and 9.2 billion for additional needs. And so there is that focus on these the wide range of factors around the individual needs of children and young people that sit within within the formula across the board.

Across the board, but we are, we have committed to keeping both the NFF and the high needs funding under review as part of the system changes that we're, that we're working on more broadly. And then for Stockport, as the, my honourable friend said, there's the extra investment already going in through the inclusive mainstream fund, the experts at hand, and the, and the capital investment, also putting support into schools to be able to better manage their, their budgets and to support some of the collective buying power of schools. So our new energy for schools service, the supply teachers and education recruitment framework, a free banking comparison tool, and we're also developing a national procurement framework for management information systems, helping schools to reduce costs and ensure that more funding is directed into provision for children and young people that we absolutely want to, to ensure is focused on. So we are seeing that greater investment in education, but also in those wider services that support young people. We want to ensure that that is, that that supports early intervention, you know, support schools with the wide range of pressures that they are facing.

And I'm really committed to to working alongside members to to make sure that this works in every part of the country. So very happy to take forward that conversation about particular challenges that are facing Stockport.

02:22:04 - 02:22:17

Graham Stuart

The question is that this House has considered school funding in Stockport. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. Order, order.

02:30:25 - 02:30:30

Speaker 46

Susan Murray to move the motion.

02:30:30 - 02:33:19

Susan Murray

Thank you, Mr. Stewart. I beg to move that this House has considered the future of nuclear energy in Scotland. It's a pleasure to serve with you in the chair, Mr. Stewart, and I'm grateful to see so many members who wish to speak on the issue. And I'd also like to take the opportunity to welcome the Minister to her first debate.

I grew up in Aberdeen, the home of North Sea oil and gas. I was there while Aberdeen became a cosmopolitan city. Workers arrived to work on the rigs from the US and Australia at first, then from all over the UK, and local Scots developed the skills to join the offshore workforce. Our economy boomed, local businesses grew, businesses relocated, and new businesses emerged. New housing was built and the price of existing homes skyrocketed as incomes rose.

The oil extraction bandwagon arrived and communities thrived. Scotland benefited from the economic boost and Scotland became known as an energy producer.

Now those oil fields are in decline, the reserves are depleted and the oil and gas bandwagon is leaving town. And we must ensure that we don't lose the skilled workforce and we offer them an alternative future in Scotland. We need to move away from fossil fuels to low carbon energy sources because of the climate emergency, but no country has achieved this with renewable electricity alone. Scotland already produces the electricity it needs from renewables, including hydro, onshore and offshore wind, with the balance of demand coming from Torness nuclear power station, although this is due to end in 2030.

But with a much greater demand for energy across the UK, Scotland could again be known for energy production and the good quality, high-paid jobs this brings. Our green transition has been successful, and I welcome this and the continuing economic growth it brings. But the wind doesn't always blow, and we import much of the equipment, and we still rely on gas power stations to meet demand and keep the grid stable. Nuclear offers something different. Rolls-Royce is designing small modular reactors that could be built here by British workers, giving us steady, low-carbon power whatever the weather.

And it offers a future for the people who work in oil and gas, making sure they're offered real opportunities outside of oil and gas and we don't lose them to work abroad.

02:33:19 - 02:34:03

Jim Shannon

I will. Mr. Chairman, can I commend the honorable lady as I've spoke to her beforehand that this high potential for new nuclear development, the possibility of some probably thousand plus jobs and backing from the workers in the trade unions is good. But Northern Ireland has no nuclear modular reactors at all, but there is an opportunity for us perhaps to have more jobs and attract investment. So does the honorable lady agree that there's a significant opportunity for both Scotland and Northern Ireland together with energy security becoming increasingly important? This is an unmissable opportunity to both create thousands of skilled jobs and help secure a reliable energy supply not only for Scotland but also for Northern Ireland.

02:34:03 - 02:37:04

Susan Murray

Thank the honorable member for the intervention and I do agree. I think the important thing is that we identify suitable sites as well to take it forward.

Nuclear power generation offers skilled, well-paid jobs and a long-lasting, predictable energy supply. For the first time in history, more than 100,000 people work in the industry across the UK, but sadly not in Scotland. Since 2014, England has gained more than 47,000 nuclear jobs and Scotland just 661. One in 10 workers at Hinkley Point C is a Scot, forced to travel hundreds of miles each week to work in England. Compare that with Wales.

The Wylfa small nuclear reactor will bring an initial investment of 2.5 billion to sites like Anglesey and up to 3,000 jobs at peak construction, all at one site.

And the Welsh government has signed an agreement with Sizewell C that could be worth up to 900 million to its supply chain. The SNP have signed no such agreement, despite the UK government offering to sit down with them and discuss and put opportunities on the table. I welcome the recent attempt by the minister to start talks with the Scottish government to keep the Torness site producing beyond its current scheduled closure in 2030. So I would ask the minister to ensure that young people in Scotland can access apprenticeships at new sites like Wylfa. I don't believe that young Scots deserve to have their career opportunities limited by the short-sighted political games of the SNP.

Communities that already host nuclear know its value. East Lothian Council passed a motion asking the UK Government to investigate the possibility of a new power station on the Torness site. The community wants nuclear to remain. But the SNP's position will prevent them, regardless of the community's wishes, and how many families could be supported by jobs, how much it could reduce energy bills, or how much it would improve UK energy security. The SNP ignore the economic benefits low-carbon nuclear power generation could bring to Scotland.

This feels like the previous short-sighted approach of the Conservatives when they sold off the British National Oil Corporation, then Britoil, in 1982. So given the SNP are willing to sacrifice our energy security and the jobs that support nearly 800 families at Torness, can the Minister tell me what plans there are to balance the grid when Torness goes offline, how much it's expected to impact electricity prices, and how many of those employed at Torness have been offered alternative employment? But this is about...

02:37:04 - 02:37:46

Speaker 50

I will do. I thank the honourable member for giving way. Current cost estimates for Sizewell C are close to 40 billion pounds, and the necessary nuclear waste facility is currently estimated by the government itself to cost up to 60 billion pounds and described by one of the government's own departments as unachievable.

Independent experts are suggesting that costs could be closer to 70 billion pounds for the waste facility alone. Is it not unacceptable to pile these eye-watering costs onto bill payers and should we not instead be investing in cheaper and cleaner energy technologies like deep geothermal and tidal stream, which could deliver baseload?

02:37:46 - 02:37:48

Speaker 51

Susan Murray.

02:37:48 - 02:38:58

Susan Murray

Thank you to the honorable member for his intervention. I do believe that we should include other energy sources in the baseload. However, the strike price of wind has been lower than nuclear.

However, it is important that there is a geographically predictable source of energy for the grid, and that helps to reduce transmission costs. So while the investment is going to be significant, it is likely to be less than the minister, than the sorry, the honorable member has mentioned, but it is producing a stable, reliable source of energy which in time will bring down household bills. But this is about more than jobs in the nuclear industry. Nuclear can strengthen the UK's energy security and give heavy industry, from steel to ceramics and new tech companies, the steady supply of power that they need to grow.

02:38:58 - 02:39:20

Christopher Murray

I thank the honorable lady for giving way. She's given us a list of other parties which I agree with her criticisms of.

And does she think if they'd taken a different position then, we might be paying lower bills just now?

Susan Murray.

02:39:20 - 02:41:45

Susan Murray

Thank you to the honorable member for your intervention. I wasn't around in 2010 and I always take situations as they are and looking to the future. So I think what we have to do is take steps now and work on where we are now and not regret what's happened in the past.

So a stable, reliable power supply will bring down transmission costs and household bills. Siting new modern small modular reactors at Hunterston and Dounreay could also breathe life back into the Highlands and Islands, just as oil and gas once did for the North East. Where remote rural communities are losing their young people, a nuclear site brings the jobs and investment that gives them a reason to stay. We've seen what happens when a country turns its back on nuclear. Germany took an approach much like the SNP's of decommissioning and deindustrialising, and has gone from exporting 26 terawatt hours of electricity a year to importing 22 terawatt hours and relying on coal-powered plants.

Now more than ever, we have a responsibility to protect our environment. Personally, I'd rather follow the lead of France rather than shying away from nuclear. They chose to invest in a low-carbon energy supply and it's paid off. French households pay around a quarter less for their electricity than households in the UK, and the communities that host nuclear plants have seen the benefits directly in childcare, transport, hospital upgrades, and affordable housing. Scotland could see the same: well-paid jobs, new house building, increased tax revenue, and real community benefit, giving people a future and good, well-paid, secure jobs.

But the SNP say no.

At a time when Scotland faces chronic housing shortage, when bus services have been cut by a sixth in just five years, when Scots pay some of the highest electricity prices in Europe, and remote and rural areas pay exorbitant energy charges, the SNP refuse to even consider such a clear solution. Particularly when it's...

02:41:45 - 02:42:11

Speaker 54

I am grateful for listing the many failures of the SNP government over its time in Holyrood. I wonder if she might think about why once they'd decided not to invest in new nuclear, why they didn't take steps to make additional storage or other energy solutions available? We haven't had a pumped hydro storage solution in Scotland since 1965. Does she think at all about the other failures the SNP have had in trying to have a sensible energy policy?

02:42:11 - 02:44:04

Susan Murray

Thank you to the honorable member for the intervention. And I, today we're considering the situation for nuclear, but I do accept... I know that there is new pumped hydro storage coming online from Loch Sloy and there are other projects in the pipeline.

So, but absolutely, and yeah, but today we're just really talking about the nuclear position. Where the SNP refuse to even consider the nuclear solution, even when it's funded by Westminster. When I speak to my constituents in Mid Dunbartonshire about energy, their position is clear. They want to tackle climate change, they want government to look after environment, and they want the government to deliver net zero, and they want cheaper bills. I want the same, and I believe so do most people living in Scotland and across the UK.

And there is a clear solution. Small modular reactors producing a predictable, low-carbon, cheap energy system.

The waste product of nuclear fission is a concern, but nuclear is the only form of energy that prices in decommissioning and waste disposal at the start of the project. Scotland deserves better than student politics and political games of the SNP. But I support the stance of Minister Shanks not to impose unwanted nuclear infrastructure to Scottish on Scottish communities. The Scottish Parliament should decide and I'm pleased that we now have 10 more Liberal Democrat or 10 Liberal Democrat MSPs in Holyrood to influence the debate going forward.

02:44:04 - 02:44:18

Douglas Lumsden

She made the point that it should be the Scottish Parliament should decide.

Does she not agree with me that it should actually be the local planning authorities that decide given, you know, proper devolution, allowing the local communities to decide whether they want nuclear or not?

02:44:18 - 02:46:19

Susan Murray

Thanks to the honorable member for his intervention. I do agree that on most issues it's for the local authorities and the planning authorities to make the decisions, but for national infrastructure in Scotland, then there is a place for the for Holyrood to be involved. Plans announced by the shadow secretary by the shadow energy security secretary to override devolved planning laws should be roundly rejected.

Nuclear offers Scotland thousands of jobs, millions in tax revenue, billions in investment and an opportunity to revive the communities of remote and rural Scotland that have been left behind far too often. I'm proud to be Scottish with our own education system, health system and legal system. To protect our Scottish identity, Scotland could once again be a leading energy exporter in a way that protects our environment, grows remote and rural communities by providing housing and jobs, helping to pay for improved connectivity and saving the Gaelic language. Scotland has always worked closely with the rest of the with the rest of the UK, with people and products connected and mobile.

Nuclear power can continue this tradition by providing low-carbon energy to contribute to our evolving sustainable energy system, to reduce household bills and supply industry. And with that in mind, I have one final ask of the Minister: to build on their assessment of Scotland's nuclear power plant potential sites by setting out by the end of this parliamentary term the jobs and economic benefit that new nuclear could bring to Scotland. That way we can see in real terms the cost of the SNP's approach to nuclear. Thank you.

02:46:19 - 02:46:33

Graham Stuart

The question is that this House has considered the future of nuclear energy in Scotland. We'll be able to begin with four minutes, and if everyone's disciplined, everyone will get four minutes. I call Chris Murray.

02:46:33 - 02:47:52

Christopher Murray

Thank you, Mr. Stewart, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairpersonship. And I thank my namesake, the member for Dunbartonshire West, Mid Dunbartonshire, forgive me, forgive me, for securing this very important debate about an issue of huge concern and importance to all of our constituents. I am an MP for Edinburgh and East Lothian, one of two MPs for the county, which is home to Torness nuclear power station, Scotland's only remaining nuclear power station, with 40 years of local expertise. Torness is scheduled to close in 2028, despite powering 2 million homes and employing 500 workers, and the SNP's arbitrary ban on nuclear in Scotland means nothing will replace it.

Labour-led East Lothian Council, the GMB, workers, residents, and myself all back new nuclear at Torness. As the local MP, I support it because it will bring jobs, because it will protect the environment, and because it will lower bills. Everybody backs new nuclear at Torness, except the SNP. I cannot understand—yes, I'll give way happily.

02:47:52 - 02:48:24

Speaker 50

Thank you for giving way. The honourable member suggests that it would cut bills, but it manifestly is not cutting bills for the nuclear power stations that are being built at the moment. New nuclear power stations being built will also add to bills. And a nuclear waste facility, which could cost as much as 70 billion pounds—nobody has actually described how that's going to happen, even though it needs to happen, and how that will be paid for, but it'll probably go onto bill payers.

How is that going to reduce bills for anybody in any kind of reasonable timescale?

02:48:24 - 02:51:45

Christopher Murray

I profoundly reject everything the honorable member has just said there. One needs only look at France, one needs only look at France, where 15 or so years ago they pursued a policy of nuclear. Their domestic bills are a quarter lower, their industrial bills are half what they are in Scotland. One could, the minute that we could have the policy security that the SNP have blocked for the last 20 years in Scotland, we would be able to crowd in the private investment that nuclear would have. As it is, nuclear expertise, nuclear investment is going south into England and not coming to Scotland, thanks to his party's decisions.

And not only that, I cannot understand how the SNP can support drilling in the North Sea for oil and gas, yet not support nuclear in East Lothian.

The ban on nuclear is possibly the most baleful, pernicious and counterproductive of all of the SNP's policies. As someone who cares passionately about climate change, it boggles my mind that after the hottest summer on human record, in which oil and gas companies have posted record profits, SNP policy is to oppose nuclear power stations and support a tax cut for oil and gas companies. Anybody who supports renewables, who wants to see a just transition from fossil fuels to renewables, must support nuclear. We need the energy resources when the sun doesn't shine and the wind doesn't blow. The right question is not, the right question we must ask is, what is that alternative?

Either it is nuclear or it is oil and gas. I say nuclear, the SNP support further fossil fuels. And nobody is arguing that nuclear is risk-free. But the risks of nuclear are far lower, one, than they ever were, and two, than those of fossil fuels, which are literally boiling the planet we are on. The risk from fossil fuels is attenuated, but it is higher than it is with nuclear.

And my final point would be, we must look internationally. Germany, after shutting down its nuclear power stations, now burns more coal than any European country.

Arguably, the party that has done the most to increase carbon emissions in Europe is the German Green Party when they pushed that country off nuclear. Compare that to France where, as I have said, they are 70% nuclear to their grid. Industrial bills are half of Scotland and domestic bills are a quarter. We know that if you want to gain support for the just transition, you need to get lower bills. Every party in the House of Commons now supports nuclear energy, even the Greens, even the Liberal Democrats.

There's more joy in heaven over one sinner who repenteth.

Only the SNP are the blockers. So my question for the government is this. What can we possibly do to persuade the SNP to stop blocking nuclear and allow it to lower bills and create a just transition to protect the environment?

02:51:45 - 02:55:41

David Mundell

Thank you, Mr. Stewart, it's a great pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I commend the honorable lady in securing this debate and I very much welcome the minister to her place. The Magnox reactor at Chapelcross near Annan provided highly skilled employment for five decades, supported families, sustained communities, and helped power the country. Like many people living locally, I am deeply frustrated that the possibility of a new nuclear plant on that site has been all but ruled out by dogmatic SNP policy.

Dogma which runs counter to the conclusions of the IPCC, the IEA, the EU's Joint Research Centre and the OECD amongst others. Mr Stewart, you'll recall that when we first joined this Parliament in 2005, nuclear was perceived as a declining industry, but as co-chair of the All-Party Group on Nuclear Energy, I've seen first-hand the renaissance that the industry is going through, but sadly only in England and Wales, where billions of pounds are being invested, new technologies are being developed, supply chains are growing, thousands of skilled jobs are being created. Yet Scotland, once at the forefront of the nuclear generation, is being left behind. That is the only conclusion that any reasonable person can reach when they look at the facts. And the honourable lady set out the numbers, but I think they are worth repeating.

Since 2014, England has added more than 47,000 civil nuclear jobs.

Scotland has added just 661. Scotland has missed out on almost 5,000 jobs, while many highly skilled Scots have little choice but to travel south to work on projects that could just as easily be taking place at home. And many people from the Annan area, for example, daily travel to West Cumbria when they would much rather be working closer to home. And while Scotland misses out on jobs, investment, and opportunities, what do the commu- what do communities like mine hear from the Scottish Government? The answer always seems to be more of the same: more pylons, more wind turbines, more solar panels, more substations, more battery storage, and more expensive energy.

None of which bring substantive employment to the communities actually impacted.

But when it comes to skilled jobs, apprenticeships, and long-term investment that nuclear can bring, the answer from the SNP is an unequivocal no. Dumfries and Galloway Council, like East Lothian Council and others, have called on the Scottish Government to take a fresh look at nuclear because they recognize the opportunities it could bring to their communities. The irony is that Scotland has some of the best potential nuclear sites anywhere in the United Kingdom. A recent technical assessment by Great British Energy Nuclear conceded that sites including Torness, Hunterston, and Dounreay all have high potential for future nuclear development if the Scottish Government were willing to reconsider its position.

And Chapelcross would be ideal for a small modular reactor and I very much continue to campaign for that to happen in my constituency. But what is the alternative, Mr. Stewart? A grid that is becoming increasingly expensive and volatile. Scotland now spends 1.5 billion a year balancing the electricity system, five times what it spent before Hunterston B retired. The communities I represent know the country needs reliable power.

They also want good stable jobs and they understand and they have seen for over five decades that that comes with a nuclear power station.

02:55:41 - 02:55:50

Speaker 59

Good afternoon, Mr. Stewart. It's a pleasure to have you in the chair as always. I'm thankful to the honorable member for Mid Dunbartonshire for bringing this important debate to Westminster Hall.

02:55:50 - 02:58:06

Brian William Leishman

And from the outset, I'll notify members to my membership of CND, and with that, I am most definitely ideologically opposed to nuclear. But it does irritate me, though, when that phrase is used as some sort of insult or indulging in student politics. Now, let me explain some of the reasons why I'm opposed. It is utterly ludicrous to suggest that nuclear is a green energy source. I mean, how can it be when it produces radioactive waste with long-term toxicity that's hazardous for thousands of years?

And nuclear is certainly not a low-carbon source either.

The powerful and wealthy pro-nuclear lobby, which we are very familiar with in this place, ignore the large carbon emissions arising from the uranium fuel cycle and, of course, from nuclear waste disposal. It's proven that nuclear power generation produces up to 20 times more CO2 per megawatt hour than renewable sources, and the construction of nuclear stations themselves release enormous quantities of CO2. So, compared to renewables, nuclear power is definitely not a low-carbon source. And what about the astronomical construction costs? Hinkley Point C initially was estimated at 18 billion pounds.

Now that's increased several times over the years. Now EDF say the cost is 32 billion and rising because of inflation. So clearly, nuclear construction costs are massively higher than those for renewable energy. The bottom line is, Mr. Stewart, that nuclear is just not value for money.

So why does anyone think Scotland having more nuclear sites would be any different? The ongoing Hinkley saga also proves that it takes ages to build nuclear sites. On average it takes nearly two decades to plan and build a nuclear reactor. So new nuclear power is not coming anytime soon. Nuclear is no quick fix solution for families struggling with energy bills in this cost of living crisis, not now and not for many years to come.

02:58:06 - 02:58:12

Speaker 61

Mr. Stewart, there's... I will.

02:58:12 - 02:58:38

Speaker 50

Just to emphasize a point I made earlier on that there are other alternatives here.

We could be investing in things like geothermal. Deep geothermal can generate huge amounts of heat and steam and power a turbine generation of electricity. It can be done for a fraction of the price, it can be built in a fraction of the time, and it's clean and leaves no waste legacy in the same way that nuclear does. Does the honorable member agree that that would be a useful way forward?

02:58:38 - 03:00:22

Brian William Leishman

Thanks very much to the honorable member. Now, I agree that we do need an energy mix and yes, of course, in tense circumstances like we face right now, we should be looking at exploring having a wide variety and assortment of different energies, but not nuclear. Mr. Stewart, there's been no real technological advancements or fundamentally new designs to nuclear reactors or processes this century. Large reactors are the same generation 3+ designs of the last 25 years.

Even the nuclear industry admit that reactor construction and design are cheaper for companies when it is done on a bigger, not a smaller scale. So the idea that lots of small reactors dotted around the country is going to be more affordable or safer or the answer to lower energy costs is pure fantasy. And finally, politicians say that the UK will likely be at war with Russia by 2030. And if these war hawks are correct, then big nuclear power stations or hundreds of small reactor sites up and down the country would surely make communities a target. Other truly green, more affordable and definitely safer energy sources are out there.

Renewable energy sources are largely an untapped market.

Now that's an industry that the government could create, could shape and control for the benefit of our people. So, to finish, ahead of time as well, I make no apologies for thinking that that's a far better ideology than having toxic radioactive waste.

03:00:22 - 03:03:24

Speaker 62

Thank you, Mr. Efford, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I would like to thank the honorable member for Mid Dunbartonshire for securing and introducing this important debate. So in my constituency of North Ayrshire and Arran, over the years, the nuclear power stations at Hunterston provided well-paid, skilled jobs and contributed greatly to the local economy.

Hunterston A operated from 1964 to 1990, and Hunterston B operated from 1976 to 2022, with both contributing greatly to the UK grid. This year, Hunterston B became the first advanced gas-cooled reactor to be relicensed for decommissioning, and even now, during the decommissioning process, there are skilled and unionised jobs. These are not in the same numbers as before, but they are still highly skilled jobs that make a huge difference to the constituency and the local economy. Sadly for us, as we have heard today, in Scotland, a no-nuclear policy stands. We could have so much more with a change in policy.

For example, Denmark is currently reviewing its 1985 ban on nuclear power and considering making small modular reactors a part of its clean energy grid. So why won't the Scottish Government do the same? Scotland has the most expensive grid, as we have heard, in the whole of the UK and spends 1.5 billion on balancing every year.

This is five times more than what it spent before Hunterston B was retired. Small modular reactors are advanced nuclear reactors that produce up to 300 megawatts per unit, which is about one-third of the generating capacity of traditional nuclear reactors. SMRs have many advantages that are linked to their design. They're physically smaller than conventional stations, they have a smaller footprint, and they can be prefabricated and installed on site. Yet, as we have heard, the SNP Government still refuse to move on their stance towards nuclear power, despite being the only party in the House of Commons with a blanket stance against nuclear.

I was interested to read that 90% of the world's economy support expanding nuclear capacity as part of the clean energy strategy.

The SNP are lagging behind the future of energy security, both in the UK and worldwide. Scotland has lost out on nearly 5,000 jobs in the nuclear industry, and many Scottish nuclear industry workers, as we have heard, are forced to leave Scotland to go and work in England or Wales at other nuclear sites. It's really quite depressing to think of how much talent and skill Scotland is losing, is choosing to lose to other parts of the UK. In my constituency of North Ayrshire and Arran, an investment in new nuclear would make a great difference, bringing new highly skilled jobs to the constituency and and beyond, and offering the badly needed apprenticeships for local young people. The Hunterston site has so much potential, and Scotland is really missing out on a great opportunity for good jobs, thanks to backward SNP decisions.

03:03:24 - 03:03:26

Speaker 63

Lillian Jones.

03:03:26 - 03:03:29

Lillian Jones

Thank you, Mr. Chair, it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship.

03:03:29 - 03:03:31

Speaker 65

And I congratulate the honorable member for Mid Dunbartonshire for securing this important debate.

03:03:31 - 03:03:41

Graham Stuart

I'm sorry to interrupt, I'm going to call backbenchers at 5:23 so if you wish to share your time with your colleague then that would be helpful.

03:03:41 - 03:06:59

Lillian Jones

I'll be quick then, thank you. So I wish to congratulate the honorable member for Mid Dunbartonshire for securing this important debate. Now Scotland has a proud heritage and skilled workers, vast renewable resources and the North Sea. But to make the most of those strengths we need an energy policy that is ambitious, practical and focused on the future. I mean can we really believe that Hunterston B has now ended generation with no future plan to build the next generation of new nuclear?

For almost 46 years, that nuclear power station provided reliable, low-carbon electricity to Scotland. Now, at its peak, Hunterston B generated enough electricity to power almost 2 million homes a year. Over its lifetime, it produced just under 300 terawatt hours of electricity, enough to power every home in Scotland for more than 30 years, while avoiding more than 100 million tonnes of carbon emissions. Now, it supported around 500 jobs, 250 contractors and made a major contribution to Ayrshire's economy. Now, that's a remarkable legacy, and so is the legacy of Torness, which is now Scotland's most productive clean power asset in Scotland's history.

Now, since coming online in 1988, that generated more than 300 terawatt hours of clean electricity, and that's enough power for every home in Scotland for around 36 years.

And it also helped to avoid more than 100 million tonnes of CO2 emissions. Now these are not just statistics, they demonstrate what nuclear power has delivered for Scotland and continue and can continue to do so. And yet Scotland has no new nuclear power station under construction and no future plan. And that matters because nuclear and renewables should not be presented as alternatives. Scotland needs both.

Wind power is one of our greatest strengths, but wind does not blow every hour of every day. Nuclear provides dependable low-carbon electricity alongside renewables. And for families and businesses in my constituency in Kilmarnock and Loudoun and right across Scotland, energy security matters. We've all seen how global events can send our energy prices soaring. More, more secure domestic generation can reduce our exposure to those shocks and give families and businesses greater certainty.

And it's about jobs too. Hunterston and Torness demonstrated that nuclear investment can deliver highly skilled unionised jobs, apprenticeships, engineering expertise and opportunities for local supply chains. We should build on that legacy, not turn our backs on it. We should back offshore wind and we should invest in new technologies and we should look seriously at new generation of nuclear power. That's a balanced approach that Scotland needs.

However, the Scottish Government's energy strategy is nearly three years late. Families and businesses across Ayrshire need certainty now. They want to see new investment in new nuclear energy. Plainly speaking, they want to see the creation of Hunterston C. Hunterston showed us what is possible.

Torness is showing us it is still possible.

Now Scotland needs the ambition to build the next generation of new nuclear. And the Scottish Labour Party and UK Labour government are ready to work with the SNP government to deliver that energy certainty, investment and ambition for our communities and our young people. So will the SNP government drop their ideology on nuclear to help Scotland's energy future? That's the question.

03:06:59 - 03:07:03

Speaker 67

Final speaker, Elaine Stewart, with a two-minute limit, I'm afraid.

03:07:03 - 03:09:12

Elaine Stewart

Thank you, Mr. Stewart, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. And I thank the honourable member for Mid Dunbartonshire for securing this very important debate. In Ayrshire, coalfields generations of Scots once powered this country. And as we look to the next generation of clean, reliable energy, Scotland needs to grasp the opportunity of nuclear power to help power our nation once again. Let me be clear, investment in nuclear is not an argument against wind power or renewables.

Scotland has extraordinary renewable potential, and wind and solar remain central to our energy future. However, when the wind doesn't blow, and that's not too often in my area, I grant you, we do need reliable power to back it up. It's very clear nuclear does not replace renewables and it complements them. While the UK government moves ahead with major new nuclear investment, the Scottish government is refusing to act. That inaction has its costs, and we are exposed to volatile gas markets, more dependent on imported fuels, and more vulnerable to foreign conflicts thousands of miles away that drive up our bills here at home.

This is not just about energy security, it's about jobs and it's about fairness. When the coal mining declined, it took jobs and investment with it, and too many communities like mine are still feeling that loss today. Scotland has missed out on nearly 5,000 jobs with skilled Scots workers travelling south instead of working at home. These are not just jobs, these are apprenticeships for our young people, supply chain and decades of stable, well-paid employment. This also matters for our clean energy goals.

We are committed to ambitious decarbonisation targets and nuclear is proven low-carbon technology, technology. I'm trying to go as fast as I can. Technology that could help us get there without relying on gas. These countries achieve the fastest, most reliable decarbonisation. That's me.

03:09:13 - 03:09:14

Spokesman Jamie Stone.

03:09:14 - 03:09:50

James Jamie Stone

Thank you very much, Mr. Stewart. It's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I congratulate my honourable friend for securing this debate. Now, as regards the good-natured jibe from the honourable member for Edinburgh East and Musselburgh, I receive it in the manner in which it was intended, but I ken his mother quite well, so I'll be having a wee word in another place. My party's policy is to support small modular reactors and we make no bones about it. The rollout of these can provide a huge cost-effective and safe decarbonisation mix.

03:09:50 - 03:12:52

James Jamie Stone

And we also believe that planning should involve taking people with you. And that takes me straight away to what my honourable friend for, let me get this absolutely right, Dumfries, Clydesdale and Tweeddale mentioned, Dounreay.

Now, Dounreay was an example prior to 1954-55 of the tragedy of Highland depopulation. If you drive up the A9 from Latheron to Thurso, you see cottages, crofts with their roofs open to the skies. People had gone, and it was the curse. That is why there are so many people from Highland families living in all corners of the world. In 1954-55, the planning application to build the reactor at Dounreay went through—can you believe this, Mr. Stewart?—went through planning in three days flat.

Changed days indeed. And I can say that it was a godsend for the area. Not only did it halt Highland depopulation, but it reversed it. And we had people moving in, and the school rolls going up.

And I think it would be fair to say that not just in Caithness, but in the wider area of Sutherland, many's a person would work at Dounreay and still does today. And some would have a croft, which they'd work at Dounreay in the day and go back and run the croft in their other time. And so I could say that the advent of Dounreay literally, literally kept the lights on in the straths and glens of the Highlands. And I think none of us should ever, ever forget that. Highland Council, the local authority, is just the same as the other councils we've heard about.

It is keen to get a new reactor, an SMR, at Dounreay.

Great British Energy, as my colleagues have mentioned, they specifically mention Dounreay as being absolutely suitable for an SMR. And here's the nub of it, and this is really my conclusion, Mr. Stewart, is that at Dounreay, the first, one of the first sites ever in the UK, we have a licensed site. That's pretty dashed important. We have a highly skilled workforce, and we have a local population that would warmly welcome an SMR. All the bits of the jigsaw are in place.

And yet, and yet, we've heard repeatedly as to what the roadblock is. Well, to show that perhaps the nicer side of my nature, if there is one, could I just gently point to the fact to the Scottish Government that Plaid Cymru, they have embraced the concept of new nuclear, as we've already heard, in Wales.

So I do hope that Plaid and the SNP will talk to each other, because at the end of the day, you can't just go on punting out old policies which have absolutely no practical application whatsoever in Scotland. I hope they take my advice and I long for the day when the jobs come back to Dounreay through an SMR.

03:12:52 - 03:12:54

Speaker 71

His Majesty's Opposition spokesman, Douglas Lumsden.

03:12:54 - 03:14:44

Douglas Lumsden

Thank you, Mr. Stewart, and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship and I welcome the Minister to her place today. I also want to thank the honorable member for Mid Dunbartonshire for bringing this debate and I welcome the Scottish Liberal Democrats getting off the fence and finally backing new nuclear.

The Prime Minister mentioned déjà vu at Prime Minister's Questions and I must feel I'm suffering from a bit of the same today, Chair. Because I fondly remember many debates in the Scottish Parliament where I made the case for new nuclear in Scotland, but was always blocked by the SNP. And I've always maintained that we should have an energy mix and nuclear is vital for our base load when the sun doesn't shine and the wind doesn't blow. And without nuclear it would be a real struggle for the Scottish Parliament to get the Scottish Government to get to net zero. Heard some of the contributions today.

The member for Mid Dunbartonshire was right to point out skills and opportunities. It is a, it could be a real path for oil and gas workers to make that transition.

And another key thing that was mentioned was grid stability that I actually hadn't thought of earlier. The inertia from the large power stations that we have just now is vital to keeping the grid stable, and it'd be good to hear from the Minister what plans there are to replace that once Torness closes. My honourable friend from Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweedback described the renaissance of nuclear, all the benefits, but Scotland are being left behind just now, being left behind in jobs, skills and also the local economy. And instead, SNP want to carpet bomb our countryside with monster pylons and battery storage. Now, it's clear that the SNP, it's clear, I'll give way, yes.

03:14:44 - 03:14:57

Speaker 50

I just wanted to know where the honourable member thinks, or how the honourable member thinks that energy from nuclear power stations the length and breadth of the country would be transported about the country.

03:14:57 - 03:18:27

Douglas Lumsden

It's a brilliant point because we actually would be probably building new nuclear power stations where the grid already is.

You know, we already have the grid connection at Hunterston. We already have the grid connection at Torness. So that's exactly why we should be back in new nuclear. But it's clear that the SNP's effective ban on new nuclear power is holding Scotland back, both in terms of our energy transition and our economy. Because right now Scotland has the most expensive and vulnerable grid in the UK, and much of that is down to the fact that the SNP have turned their backs on nuclear.

Now, when I was an MSP, I was fortunate enough to visit Hunterston B, and what a wasted opportunity that is. It was mentioned earlier. It has the grid connection. It has the space. It's all there.

It just needs the political will to make it happen so we can have Hunterston C.

And as we progress to sourcing more and more of our energy from renewables like wind, the problem of intermittency will only get worse. But the irony is that the SNP's own irrational opposition to new nuclear means a future Scotland would be completely reliant on English nuclear power when the wind doesn't blow and the sun doesn't shine. Now, luckily, we do have a UK grid, so we share the power with our neighbors, and Scotland would not face blackouts because of this SNP's failures. But while our shared grid means Scotland won't miss out on imported nuclear energy, thanks to the SNP's blind opposition, we are missing out on thousands of jobs and billions of pounds of investment.

Now, when I was at Hunterston, I met the young graduates and apprentices there during my visit, and it was heartbreaking, heartbreaking to hear that for them to have a future in nuclear, they were going to have to move away from Scotland. Talented young people, high-paid jobs, moving away because of the SNP's dogma. And it was interesting to hear that one in ten in Hinkley Point C were actually Scots. And what makes the SNP's Luddite approach totally senseless is that people in Scotland want new nuclear. We've heard it again tonight.

Sixty percent of the Scottish public are in favour of building new nuclear power stations to replace those being decommissioned. East Lothian, Dumfries and Galloway, and the Highland Council have all called for new nuclear development. Many of the jobs and investment that could be generated by new nuclear would go to some of Scotland's most deprived communities. We are in desperate, desperate need of thriving local industries.

Yet the SNP, who love to talk about devolution, have overruled these local wishes. For far too long, the SNP have weaponised devolved powers over planning to block new nuclear, which of course is a reserved issue. The SNP's bizarre opposition to this clean, consistent energy goes against science, against all common sense and against the wishes of the Scottish public. And the clear cross-party consensus from the Scottish MPs in the room tonight, apart from Mr. Leishman and the SNP of course, shows just how backward John Swinney's position really is. I thank everyone for their contributions to this important debate and very much hope that nuclear energy will have a bright future in Scotland.

Because if we are to transition beyond fossil fuels in the long term, nuclear will be a vital part of our energy mix and Scotland must not miss out as a result of the SNP Luddites.

03:18:27 - 03:18:30

Speaker 73

Thank you, Chair.

03:18:30 - 03:18:41

Graham Stuart

I call the Minister, and if she wishes to finish at 5:43, she would be able to give two minutes' wind-up to the proposer.

03:18:41 - 03:20:58

Claire Melanie Ward

Thank you, and thank you, Mr. Stewart. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. Let me begin by congratulating the honourable member for Mid Dunbartonshire for securing this important debate on the future of nuclear energy in Scotland and thank her for her kind words as well. I agreed with many of the points that she made in her speech. This debate comes at an opportune time, and I'm pleased to be responding and to have heard from so many who share this government's desire to see Scotland harness the opportunities that civil nuclear power offers to Scotland.

The opportunity to create high quality jobs in communities across our country. The opportunity to deliver clean, secure and more affordable energy for our people as part of the energy mix of the future. But it's also an opportunity to deliver on our Prime Minister's mission to reindustrialise our country, to ensure that conversations about Scotland's industrial prowess are not just backwards looking at our heritage, but building our future with prosperous, secure and proud communities sustained by skilled jobs.

Scotland is indeed an energy powerhouse, and since taking up my position at the Scotland Office, I've had the privilege of witnessing a vast array of Scottish energy generation firsthand, spanning wind, wave, tidal, and nuclear energy, and above all, meeting the skilled and dedicated workforces that keep our nation powered. And just last month, the Secretary of State was in Aberdeen, meeting with representatives from the oil and gas sector and visiting Great British Energy's newly opened headquarters. This week I went to the station at Torness, which is one of the great Scottish nuclear power success stories, as we've heard in today's debate. It provides hundreds of quality jobs in East Lothian and beyond, while generating enough electricity over its lifetime to power every home in Scotland for 36 years.

As we've heard today, Torness is currently due to stop generating power by 2030. The reason that this site's days are numbered is the SNP's outdated ideological planning ban on civil nuclear energy. And as we've heard today, it is time that that changed.

03:20:58 - 03:21:25

Speaker 54

Certainly. Can I thank my hon. Friend for giving way and say how good it is to see her in her place and thank her for a brilliant visit to Prestwick this week? Can I say how proud I am to join my Ayrshire colleagues, my Labour Ayrshire colleagues and colleagues in calling for nuclear back in Ayrshire at Hunterston? And how frustrated I am at the loss of skills, loss of jobs, loss of investment in our communities? Can she say anything about why this anti-scientific, irrational stance of the SNP is continuing?

03:21:25 - 03:24:13

Claire Melanie Ward

Well, we've had a strong showing from colleagues from Ayrshire in the debate today. And as my hon. Friend points out, because of the impact that the closure of Hunterston has had on their communities. And what I would say is that the SNP will need to answer to the people of Ayrshire about why they have taken away the possibility of thousands of new jobs in their communities.

There is no logical reason for it. As I was saying, this week I went to the power station in Torness, and visiting there brought home what is at stake in this debate. It is families' futures. Highly skilled workers at Torness told me that they will likely have no option but to leave their homes in Scotland when the station there closes, taking those specialist skills elsewhere to England and Wales or even overseas.

Some of those men and women are part of generations of the same family that have worked at that site and their rightful pride in that heritage was clear to see. Now the honourable member for Mid Dunbartonshire asked if Torness could theoretically go beyond 2030 and the answer is that if EDF wished to do that and made a successful case to the regulator then indeed it is possible that that could happen. Now Mr Stewart this is a debate that needs to take place with the focus on the facts about civil nuclear power. There is too much myth and fallacy around on this topic. The British nuclear sector continues to operate safely and securely and that is not simply the industry's assertion.

It is the evidence-based conclusion of the independent Chief Nuclear Inspector in his recent annual report and the UN International Atomic Energy Agency calls nuclear one of the safest forms of energy generation that there is.

My honorable friend the member for Alloa and Grangemouth helpfully trailed his speech today in the media at the weekend, so I asked the Unite shop steward at Torness what he thought of the suggestion that we should make decisions about what is best for the future of our country based on the potential likes and dislikes of Vladimir Putin. His answer, and I quote, was that this is clutching at straws. He also mentioned construction and I would refer him to the 26,000 new jobs created by construction at Hinkley Point C. The reality is that countries such as Denmark, Poland and Japan are actively stepping up their plans on nuclear energy, whilst others such as Sweden, Belgium and Italy are reversing their previous anti-nuclear stances.

70% of electricity in France is supplied by nuclear power as we heard. And to be anti-nuclear power in Europe today is increasingly to be an outlier. And I say to the SNP that Scotland deserves better than this.

I will.

03:24:13 - 03:24:48

Speaker 50

I think that I welcome the minister's intervention first of all. But to suggest that being anti-nuclear is being anti-baseload or being anti-other forms of useful energy that can provide baseload is absolute nonsense. Will the minister accept that this is a very blinkered approach looking at only nuclear and not backing things like geothermal, not backing things like tidal energy properly? Because we could be making, we could be creating many jobs in Scotland from those. And God knows we know how to drill a hole and get stuff out of it.

03:24:49 - 03:25:55

Claire Melanie Ward

Well, I certainly didn't say that we were anti-baseload, that would be a ridiculous argument. In fact, this government, and I am proud that this government is making record investment in renewable energy, and I mentioned at the start of my speech having visited some of it myself since I was appointed. The point I'm making is that the SNP Scottish government is leaving Scotland behind in terms of jobs and opportunities. And speaking of which, we know that the UK used to lead the world, Scotland used to lead the world on nuclear power. And on that note, it was interesting to hear the comments of the honorable member for Aberdeen South and his party in recent days.

They may need this Labour government to remind them that in 14 years of Tory rule, their record on investment in new nuclear energy was zero. So their new-found enthusiasm rings a little hollow. And we reject too their proposals made by my party spokespeople to rip up the Scotland Act and override Holyrood's planning powers to force nuclear projects through.

This government will not take that path. We believe in the decentralization of power and we respect devolution.

03:25:55 - 03:26:22

David Mundell

Just on that last point, very briefly. How are you, how is the minister going to persuade the SNP to change their position? Because if they don't change their position, there won't be nuclear in Scotland because there'll be no investment because even if there was a Labour administration, people will know it could change. And we only got nuclear investment in the UK when people understood that both Labour and the Conservatives backed nuclear.

03:26:22 - 03:28:38

Claire Melanie Ward

Well, I would honestly have more time for that argument if the Conservative government had themselves invested in this anywhere in the UK during their 14 years in power. The fact is that the arguments against the Scottish government's position are strong.

The UK government is committed to supporting this industry and we've heard throughout this debate about the jobs, the 5,000 jobs that Scotland has already missed out on because of this de facto ban. We've heard about the investment that is taking place in England and Wales and Scotland could have this too. We in Scotland know the story of deindustrialization of our communities. The Clyde knows the story, Lanarkshire does, Ayrshire does, as we've heard from my colleagues today, and my area in Fife knows the story. These are lessons that the Scottish government should learn.

And so, we have heard so much about the disparity that exists with the rest of the UK. I would simply point out, as I said earlier, that many Scots say they will be forced to take their skills elsewhere. Many of them indeed already are.

We can see for example, the 184 Scottish businesses that are supporting Hinkley Point C's supply chain during its construction and the 10% of the 12,000 workers on that construction site who are Scottish workers forced to travel elsewhere to do these jobs. I know that I need to wrap up and so I would simply say the following. Companies across Scotland have expressed great interest in supporting the development of our nuclear industry. We heard about the potential that there is at Dounreay, we know that there is further potential across Scotland including at Torness. I would also say that it's worth noting that 57% of SNP voters say that they support new nuclear energy in Scotland.

Trade unions such as the GMB, Prospect and Unite are telling us that they want to grasp these opportunities and the SNP should back them.

So in conclusion, Mr Stewart, Scotland stands at a critical juncture. The Scottish Government can stand by and watch as jobs, opportunity and Scottish workers go elsewhere, or they can change course and work together with the UK Government, embrace civil nuclear power as part of our energy mix and make sure that Scotland remains an energy leader for generations to come.

03:28:38 - 03:28:42

Speaker 77

Susan Murray to wind up.

03:28:42 - 03:29:35

Susan Murray

Thank you, Mr Stewart. I'm really pleased to have heard so many excellent contributions to the debate this afternoon and thank you to the Minister, the opposition spokesperson and my honourable friend for the comments that they have been making.

It's clear that there is a majority agreement in the room. It's clear that there is an opportunity for Scotland to be an energy source, a powerhouse for the UK, and it's clear that the SNP is refusing to grasp the opportunity for families and communities despite the good examples that they can see in other countries of this being successful. So I would just urge the government to keep pressing the Scottish government to reconsider its position. Thank you.

03:29:35 - 03:29:47

Graham Stuart

The question is that this House has considered the future of nuclear energy in Scotland. As many as are of that opinion say aye. Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it. Order, order, the sitting stands adjourned.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.