Westminster Hall

14 October 2026

Westminster Hall House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:27 - 00:33
Speaker 1
Order.  Marie Goldman to move the motion. 
00:33 - 02:10
Speaker 3
Thank you very much, Chair.  It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, and I beg to move that this House has considered government oversight of underperforming NHS trusts.  Now, I should start by saying that I am the MP for Chelmsford, which is an Essex-based constituency, and my local trust is called the Mid and South Essex NHS Foundation Trust.  It decided a few years ago to kind of have three hospitals all under the same trust.  My local hospital is called Broomfield Hospital. 

It is not actually in my constituency, it's in the neighboring constituency of North West Essex, but is for all intents and purposes my hospital because it's the main hospital that serves my constituents, and it fills up my inbox every single day with tales of woe both from patients and from staff.  Now, back in, I should say as well that there are other members around the room, and I thank them very much for coming along today, who I know are also part of the same trust.  But there will be other honorable members from across the House who are served by other NHS trusts and will be probably experiencing very similar unfortunate things, and I look forward to hearing the stories from them because this is really important.  Getting NHS trusts that perform properly and serve their patients and look after their staff well is incredibly important.  It underpins everything that we do in society, looking after the most vulnerable, and we aren't getting it right at the moment, and I'm afraid to say I don't feel that the government is getting it right, and that's what I'm here to talk about today. 
02:10 - 02:52
Speaker 2
I should say that the Mid and South Essex Trust, it was recognized as somebody said to me earlier not too far away from me here today, they said to me, "Oh, I think I'm in the worst trust in the country," and I said, "I'll go round for round with you on that one," and I'll give you some details about why I believe that later on.  But it was announced back in March the Mid and South Essex was going to be placed into an intensive recovery program.  That was announced, I think, on late in March by the then health secretary, and we waited to find out what the details of that was going to be.  Now, the reason for that is that over several years, Mid and South Essex has been massively underperforming.  There have been huge issues, and I don't exaggerate when I say that it fills up my inbox every single day. 
02:52 - 03:49
Speaker 4
We're talking about long waits, we're talking of delays to treatment, we're talking about difficulty accessing care, but we're also talking about when they do access that care, patients are not getting the service that they need, they're not getting the outcomes, most importantly, that they need and deserve.  I'd like to pay very early on tribute to the staff who work at Broomfield Hospital and across the Mid and South Essex Trust, indeed across all of trusts across the country.  They are working in very difficult circumstances, quite a lot of the time in using infrastructure that isn't fit for purpose, that hasn't been invested in properly over many years, and they are doing their very, very best, but unfortunately they are not getting the support that they need.  I have met with staff and patients and the Mid and South Essex Foundation Trust leadership many, many times over a sustained period of time, and I know honorable members around this room from across the House have done the same thing as well. 
03:49 - 04:25
Speaker 2
I do believe it is unfortunately one of the worst trusts in the country on both patient and staff measures.  Um we pushed for change we pushed for changes locally but national support is needed.  Now let me talk about some of the range of issues that have been raised with me.  Now um I've walked around Broomfield Hospital both uh with the senior leadership team and with some of the um shall we say less uh senior leadership uh at the hospital.  And I don't think it should be possible actually for me to be able to walk around a hospital and point out things that are so obviously wrong and yet I could. 
04:25 - 05:19
Speaker 4
There were lights outside theatres that hadn't been working I was told for ten years.  Now these are things that should be relatively easy to fix but when patients have to write to me and tell me about mould that is growing on the walls and on the windows of a children's ward something is going seriously seriously wrong.  When an 80-year-old gentleman told me not a long time ago but two weekends ago he he told my staff that he had been um queuing out the door at the emergency department on a Saturday for an hour and he's in his 80s and nobody even bothered to offer him a seat to sit down on something is going drastically wrong when we have lost sight of the importance of just common decency of human compassion uh looking after patients.  Um and when consultants retire waiting lists are being disbanded they're not being replaced they're just being disbanded.  People are writing to me about those sorts of things all the time. 
05:19 - 06:01
Speaker 2
And patients have very very little way of uh of raising the concerns that they have.  They can go to PALS uh but unfortunately the delays in getting responses back from PALS are are enormous um and MPs don't uh while we can raise it with the trust leadership and we can go through PALS as well um we still don't get the responses that we need.  There seems to be a lack of communication between leadership and staff.  And and there seems to we seem to have lost sight a little bit of what's important and things that that just make sense to keep on doing.  Now I had a uh there was a round table for um the Mid and South Essex Trust the leadership there and um Essex MPs who were in that trust uh just earlier on this week. 
06:01 - 07:46
Speaker 4
And um while not all Essex MPs could come along I know many of them sent their staffers um I was certainly there and we talked about heat.  We talked about this very long hot summer that we've had recently.  Um and we talked about how that had had an impact on the running of the hospital and one of the things the um the chief executive told me in that meeting was that it meant that some of the theatres had had to be closed because um there was too much humidity um in the air and they said to so the theatres had to be closed obviously that has a knock-on effect to patient waiting lists and patient outcomes as well um and patient experience as well I would say increases the waiting lists and etc.  They said that they had been gifted some um air conditioning units by um I won't mention the name of the company but a very generous uh national company who'd gifted some air conditioning units.  That sounds great doesn't it? 

But they can't plug enough of them in because the electrical because the electrical circuits won't cope with it.  So we have an infrastructure and this is actually a fairly new build hospital it's a kind of combination of PFI and some older buildings uh but this is a fairly new hospital and yet we can't plug in enough air conditioning units to keep our theatres open to keep I was told by the way that humidity isn't reduced by air conditioning units I'm not too sure about that I'm sure there are other ways of reducing humidity but anyway.  So I said okay well you know it was a really hot summer and with El Niño happening next year we are expecting possibly to see an another hot summer next year possibly even hotter and what contingency plans are being developed to make sure that we can deal with it because we know that this is just going to keep on happening long hot summers.  Can I make this one final point and then I'll absolutely give way because I want to tell you what the chief executive's response was to my question about whether they were developing contingency plans for next summer and he said no we're not.