Financial Services Regulation Committee

22 July 2026

00:03 - 00:42
Speaker 8
Welcome to today's session, which is the eighth oral evidence session as part of the committee's inquiry into the regulation of the consumer insurance market.  And I thank you to Mr. Hargreaves, Mr. Storah, and Mr. Turner for attending.  The session is open to the public, it's broadcast live and subsequently accessible via the parliamentary website.  A verbatim transcript will be taken of the evidence and will be put on the parliamentary website.  Before we move to the detailed questions, could I invite each of you briefly to introduce yourselves, and then I'll get going with the first question. 
00:42 - 01:03
Speaker 4
Hi, I'm Alistair Hargreaves, I'm UK insurance CEO of Admiral.  Thank you for inviting me to give evidence today.  Admiral is a motor insurance company that's established as a motor insurance company about 30 years ago, has grown to serve about 9 million customers, including in home and travel insurance. 
01:03 - 01:24
Speaker 5
Hi, I'm Jason Storah, I'm the CEO of Aviva's UK and Ireland general insurance business.  Aviva is the leading insurance company, wealth and retirement business in the UK.  We have 21 million customers in total, and we insure about one in five homeowners and one in five travel policyholders in the UK. 
01:24 - 01:46
Speaker 6
Nick Turner, I'm the CEO of NFU Mutual.  We have about 935,000 customers.  We're a rurally focused mutual insurer, so we're owned by our members, which does make life a bit easier for us to think about what's the core purpose of our organisation.  But that's us, focused on rural communities. 
01:46 - 02:16
Speaker 8
Excellent.  I should declare that I'm a long-standing policyholder with the NFU Mutual, both for motor and home.  Could we start with some context, part of which I think Mr. Storah just gave.  We're concentrating on the consumer home and travel insurance markets.  Could you outline the total size of the UK market and your position, your market share each of you has in those markets? 
02:16 - 02:44
Speaker 4
The home insurance market is about 6 billion in terms of premium.  We have been in that market for about 13 years.  We have just over 2 million customers, which is about 7% market share.  The travel insurance market is just over a billion pounds worth of premium.  We've been in that market for about seven years and we have just over a million active customers, and again that's around about 7% market share. 
02:44 - 03:02
Speaker 5
I'm not going to repeat the market share numbers because I agree with what my colleague here said.  But yeah, as I say, we insure one in five homes in the UK and about one in five travel policyholders in the UK.  And so if you extrapolated that out, our market share based on his numbers would be aligned. 
03:02 - 03:23
Speaker 3
Of our 935,000 customers, about 370,000 have home insurance.  We're very minuscule in the travel market.  We really only write travel insurance for high-net-worth customers as part of their high-net-worth policies.  So we don't write for new business at the moment on travel. 
03:23 - 03:26
Speaker 1
And what percentage market share do you have of home? 
03:26 - 03:32
Speaker 2
Well, 370,000, it would be very low, so 1 or 2%. 

03:32 - 03:57

Sheila Noakes

Okay.

So, one of the things we've been struck by is the high rates of claims being declined by insurers in the home and travel markets, with varying percentages, some as low as 60%. Can you say what your decline rates are for your businesses and also describe what you see as the root causes of those low decline rates?

03:57 - 05:06

Alistair Hargreaves

Um, so if I start with home insurance. So for home insurance, the claims acceptance rate, which I think is the other side of the and the measure that the FCA report, our home acceptance rate, claims acceptance rate is about 70%. That's different from an insurance product like motor insurance, and when we look at that, we think that's predominantly because of the customer understanding of what is covered by home insurance. So the way in which we record that number, I think is important to note that any queries that we get, we will count as a claim. And if we, you know, so if a customer's calling us about some tiles that have come off their roof, even if there hasn't been a storm and we explain that that's wear and tear and it's not covered, then we would still capture that within that because we think that information is really helpful for us to understand the consumer understanding and we don't want to in any way put off a customer contacting us about those queries.

We obviously then use that information in order to improve our communication at point of sale throughout the journeys, remind the customer about that and make other changes, which I'm sure we'll get onto, so I'll leave it there.

05:07 - 05:39

Alistair Hargreaves

For travel insurance, our acceptance rates are about 85% for our main products. Similarly, the travel insurance covers a number of different aspects, but we see that it's about understanding of the product in terms of if there are cancellations or delays. So those are things that we make sure are disclosed very clearly upfront and again, really working to improve that through educating customers.

05:39 - 05:41

Speaker 10

Aviva?

05:41 - 06:19

Jason Storah

Yes, so very similar. So from a claims acceptance perspective, out of every 100 home claims we receive, we accept and pay 72. So if you take then that delta between the 72 and 100, of those remaining 28 claims, just to build on what my colleague said, so 13 of those claims would be would be claims that didn't involve an insurable peril. So somebody was phoning up about a claim, but there was no storm, for instance, or they were due to wear and tear, perhaps a roof got damaged, but it was because of the maintenance and the lack of maintenance and wear and tear on the roof rather than an insurable event like high winds because of a storm.

06:19 - 06:27

Sheila Noakes

And you operate the same definition of claim as Admiral?

06:27 - 08:41

Jason Storah

Yeah, for the purpose of the way the FCA captures the data, yes. The FCA, as my colleague said, does include queries, but we'll use the same the same definitions. So then so that's 13 of the 28 that we wouldn't have paid. Seven of the 28 would have had inadequate cover, so perhaps the individuals bought a product that didn't have certain product features or perhaps they chose not to include enhancements to the product features. So, you know, maybe they wouldn't have included cover for personal belongings or accidental damage.

And then the remaining, which I think is about six, would have just we would have declined those claims for a variety of reasons, or those claims wouldn't have proceeded for a variety of reasons. It could be that the claim level was going to be below the excess and the customer might decide, well, it's just not worth it because I'm going to have to pay an excess.

It could be that it could have been due to faulty workmanship or a breakdown or again some kind of wear and tear or the customers may just have decided not to proceed with the claim. So that's the breakdown for us and on the travel side by comparison so we would accept 84 out of 100 claims and of that remaining 16 in travel it would be for a number of reasons such as there wasn't a government travel advisory there wasn't sort of consequences that led to cancellation of flights or the cancellation of flights was that somebody was able to get another flight within a 12 hour period so they weren't stuck for a longer period of time. And in some instances as well you know people with what's going on in the world somebody just decides that actually they don't feel safe or they change their mind about traveling to a certain region. You know when everything happened in the Middle East earlier this year with Iran we saw a spike we had 12,000 claim calls in a very short space of time. And a number of those were calls that people just wanted a bit of advice.

They saw what was happening on the news they were looking at government advisories and they just wanted to talk to us about the implications if they decided to change their travel plans but many of them didn't.

08:41 - 10:07

Nick Turner

So our claims level across all products is 96.7% claims accepted. On home policies you've got to split that between contents and buildings and buildings is where there's more complexity so our claims level would be around about 85% accepted and for contents it would be higher than 96.7 so and you can see why because it's much clearer to settle a claim on a contents than it is on a buildings and there'll be a big range amongst insurers anyway because it will depend on the kind of building stock that you insure. So if you could imagine rural insurers so you know we have quite a lot of older properties and in that scenario wear and tear is definitely a feature. So the majority of our disputes I suppose in that where people think we should be paying a claim comes down to working through what's wear and tear so did the storm cause the problem or did you need to fix your roof several years ago and didn't get round to it and now we're leaning into an insurance policy to get that repair done so that's not really the purpose of insurance and we try to make that clear I think the industry tries to make that clear but people do have selective memory when they're faced with a financial crisis understandably. So that's where we are our travel very very small so statistically insignificant.

10:07 - 10:08

Lord Turnbull.

10:08 - 10:41

Speaker 14

Just a point of clarification. You've all three quoted quite high rates of acceptance 72 84 96. Is that is there a difference between a claim where you come in and you pay it straight away claim that you refuse is a bit of a battle eventually could go to the financial ombudsman but eventually you accept all or part of it. Is this the total of claims that you pay out on or the claims that you meet without the customer having to fight for it?

10:41 - 10:52

Alistair Hargreaves

This would be the total number so it would include everything that we're contacted about and everything that we pay and so in terms of things that weren't paid that any which way it wasn't paid that would be captured within that number.

10:52 - 11:03

Speaker 14

But if it's refused initially challenged and then eventually you either change your mind or the ombudsman requires you to change your mind where do you score that?

11:03 - 11:46

Alistair Hargreaves

Okay so if we paid the claim I think that would be captured within the paid claims number but that would be a very very small number of claims that would have the sort of dispute that you're talking about. It might be something that would be investigated from a fraud perspective if we were worried about the risk of a fraudulent claim and we were investigating that then if we found that was not to be the case and we paid the claim then we'd include it in the number. Obviously we would our job is there to look after the customer at point of claim and make sure that if there's a claim on the policy that hasn't been isn't a query that is misunderstood we're there to look after those customers and pay those out.

11:46 - 11:47

Thank you.

11:47 - 11:51

Speaker 9

Do you want to ask I was going to go round you anyway.

11:51 - 11:54

Speaker 12

I love this new word declinature rate.

11:54 - 12:43

Speaker 14

I saw that. Go into the dictionary. Can I come to customer duty? There's a long chain of people involved, customers, brokers, companies like you, I don't know what you call yourselves, the principals, let's call them the principals. You then subcontract various activities, most notably subcontracting claims management.

Now, does the customer duty really percolate down right to the coalface where the real struggle is going on, or are you having lots of away days, seminars, board meetings, discussion with the regulator at the sort of corporate level?

12:43 - 13:58

Jason Storah

Well, I would say that, you know, the consumer duty obligations that we hold remain regardless of whether there is a third party involved in settling the claim, and the dialogue that we have and the data we share with the regulator holds us accountable to that. We use third parties to help give us more coverage. You know, using outsourcing claims to other other organisations can involve more cost for us, or it can sometimes involve cost savings, but we apply the same rigour to the completion and the customer journeys and the outcomes and all of the data and the metrics that we look at irrespective of whether an external party has been involved in settling a claim or whether it's all been done in-house. And particularly on home claims, you know, buildings, people's apartments, flats, houses are quite complicated, and certainly with more complex claims, it's not untypical to have anywhere from three to five different organisations, different companies and skill sets involved in assessing what's happened, assessing what remediation needs to be done. But ultimately, there's somebody in Aviva that holds the consumer duty responsibility to follow that claim all the way through and track the customer outcomes.

13:58 - 14:16

Speaker 14

Earlier witnesses have referred to this as the consumer duty as a work in progress, but it's three years on now. When does the work in progress become a point where by which the transition to a new relationship should have been completed?

14:16 - 15:39

Nick Turner

I could talk about, I mean, our perspective on consumer duty if that's helpful. We are as an organisation very supportive of consumer duty. I think the general transition towards outcome-based regulation is a positive, and we're obviously in a transition to that where we've got lots of rules that the regulator is looking at whether there's any streamlining they can do with those rules to lean into the outcome regulation. So that certainly, if that's the transition state that you're describing, that will take some time to work through, and I'm really supportive of that because if you remove rules too fast or you streamline rules too fast, it creates a friction of work. So, but I think leaning into the outcomes-based is good for the industry.

For us, it wasn't a very significant piece of work. It was a relatively modest cost. I'm not sure that's the case for everybody, but it was a very low cost for us, and it was largely an effort of bringing together the data that we already had into one single reporting environment to make sure that we could demonstrate that we were complying with consumer duty.

I think the mutuality that we've got helps because focusing on members is we have one customer to serve if you like, they own us as well. So that also focuses the mind somewhat, which is perhaps why we found it a relatively straightforward exercise to demonstrate our compliance.

15:39 - 15:41

Speaker 13

Unless you've got a different view, maybe we can...

15:41 - 16:23

Jason Storah

Well, I would say consumer duty did cost Aviva quite a lot of money, possibly because of our size and scale and the number of people that we insure across the UK and the breadth of propositions, brands, price points, coverages, all of those things. But it's well embedded. It really is. It's not something that still has a long way to run in terms of its impact on consumers and its embeddedness in companies. I can tell you that the visibility that's been achieved around customer metrics at both the board level and then all the way through the organisation, that's really good.

The type of metrics we look at, the type of dialogue we have and the clarity on what we're doing and its impact on customers is very well embedded in the business.

16:23 - 16:53

Alistair Hargreaves

I think the only thing I'd add is I think consumer duty is principle-based and it's outcome-based and it's about the outcomes for customers and looking at what those outcomes are. And we're talking about things like claims acceptance rate and customer understanding. And I think part of what consumer duty is designed to do is drive for continuous improvement across the industry. So I think it's very well embedded, but I think it's still highlighting areas that we as an industry are working hard to continue to improve and help customers.

16:53 - 17:05

Sheila Noakes

But can you point to any areas where there's visible improvement? Because I think the comment is generally made that people haven't yet seen any visible change from the impact of the consumer duty.

17:05 - 17:54

Alistair Hargreaves

So if I talk about consumer understanding and some of the things that we've done as an organisation, we've talked about some of the reasons why claims get declined is because of excesses. So if I take that as an example, we make sure that that's very clear at point of sale on the journey and a customer often is actively selecting that. We reinforce those. For some of our excess levels, we've reduced the level of excess, which increases the claims coming through. And this is us looking at some of that data and saying, well, what's happening and what are the things that we think we can do to improve it?

And so I would argue that it's a push that we had as an organisation before consumer duty, but I think consumer duty encourages the industry as a whole to look at things in that way and continue to drive for continuous improvement.

17:54 - 19:13

Jason Storah

And I would just build on that. If I think about the desire to make sure that there's a breadth of product offering and price points for people, we and a number of other companies offer essentials type products. So it's coverage that's a bit more stripped out, it's lower premiums. But we also look at the data and the behaviour of those customers. So I can give you a couple of statistics.

If you think about the customer journey that people go on when they buy on price comparison websites and they have a number of options, 60% of the people that click on an essentials product, so a more bare-bones type of insurance product, 60% of those people subsequently choose a higher coverage product. So I think consumer duty has encouraged and has increased the understanding of people in terms of what they're getting rather than just comparing one price against another. And definitely price comparison websites have played a role in helping people understand the different price points. I think another thing we see is at renewal, 13% of our customers who have an essentials product renew with additional coverage. So again, I think these are all consequences, either direct or indirect, of consumer duty that mean that customers are making more informed choices and are learning as they go through buying insurance products.

19:13 - 20:06

Sharon Bowles

Right, I'd quite like to follow on a little bit from that on the comparison website point.

websites point and we've been told that price competition has led to a hollowing out of insurance products so that they can you know score in you know the cheapest on offer and that that will attract some some consumers. And so in response to that it's suggested sometimes should there be some minimum standards for products to ensure a baseline across the industry so that would be a form of standardization. So what do you think about that and what other issues do you think it might raise?

20:06 - 21:43

Nick Turner

I just NFU Mutual's not on price comparison websites. I'll jump in then if you want. You still have an opinion. I've got an opinion. I think standardization of products is not a good thing.

That's where I'd start but I think standardization of reporting might well be. So and there's FCA are already working and we're working with a number of other insurers through ABI and whatnot to try and improve the consistency of reporting to enable consumers to better compare some of their products and services. So I think that that's a good thing but for us price comparison websites doesn't isn't an environment that properly reflects the value proposition that we have built for our members. So you know if that were to change then that would be a distribution channel that we could consider but really we distribute through 300 agents that are all NFU Mutual branded. You know people can walk into those those shops for want of a better word sit down and discuss their insurance properly understand the value of the different component parts that make up an insurance product talk about claims service talk about what happens when your house burns down what does alternative accommodation mean all those kind of things so that you walk away understanding the risk that you're running as an individual but also matching the insurance and the service better to to what you what you're buying.

And we believe it's difficult to truly get a comparison of service quality cover value what and understanding through a price comparison website in its current form and so we're not on it.

21:43 - 23:11

Jason Storah

Yeah I mean 75% of our sales come through price comparison websites so obviously quite a different business model to to NFU. I don't think product standardization is the answer. I think and as as my colleague was saying comparability being able to compare what's in different products is really important. You know if I have five different price points that's sort of interesting but if I understand why those prices are different because there are different levels of coverage that's really meaningful. I would also say that I think minimum product requirements minimum product levels are quite difficult because we have seen you you referenced hollowing out of products we have seen some of that and paring back of coverages but you know I would argue that having some cover for home travel for for home insurance for instance having some cover for adverse events like a flood or a fire or a theft or subsidence is better than no coverage.

And what you see with minimum product product essentials products is they don't offer the frills so you you will get cover for a flood or a fire but you might not get cover if you stain your carpet. And and different people's life circumstances and situations mean that they have different needs. Focusing on the minimum product requirement and standardizing that feels like the lowest common denominator rather than giving people as he was saying the the ability to compare apples to apples across different products and brands and companies.

23:11 - 24:47

Alistair Hargreaves

Yeah we also use price comparison. We provide products for a wide range of customers and for our customer base affordability is really important and that's why they go on price comparison to to make sure that they're getting great value for money. We we if I look at our product suite for for most of our products it's about strengthening so we've increased limits for things like alternative accommodation personal belongings contents keys and locks and and things like that so I I don't recognize the hollowing out.

I think it's really about a very competitive UK market and then I think consumer duty holds us accountable for making sure we live up to that promise. And I think that combination works well. Just there is the essentials products, I think one thing I'd call out is that for motor we did launch an essentials product, but if you cast your minds back to 2023 and 2024, one of the big concerns was about motor affordability. So it was about a ways in which we can provide motor insurance more cost-effectively and essentials was a slimmed-down version of that. But for example on essentials cover it doesn't include windscreen, so we actively ask the customer, do you need windscreen and get a yes or no so that they know that they're buying and it still fulfills their needs.

So I think price comparison combined with that consumer focus and the accountability on all insurers through consumer duty can work well.

24:47 - 24:55

Sharon Bowles

So would you say that if things were standardized that it would actually interfere with competition?

24:55 - 25:19

Alistair Hargreaves

I think there's a risk that it oversimplifies. So a standardized product could be too much cover for some customers and not enough for others. And it might reduce the obligation to say, is my product fit for this customer, which is what consumer duty asks us to do by looking at the outcomes and the data and then to drive that continuous improvement. So I think I'd agree with my colleagues that I'm not sure that standardization, although it sounds good, I'm not sure it's a quick fix.

25:19 - 25:53

Jason Storah

And it could also lead to, you know, reduced competition, reduced innovation as well, reduced personalization. And I think if you look forward and think about AI for instance, AI is giving people the ability to get really hyper-personalized advice. So to suddenly take a step back and say we should standardize product sets would feel like it would go against the grain of, to Alistair's point, the value of having fit-for-purpose insurance for every individual, but then also the value of having coverages that are tailored to people's needs.

25:53 - 25:59

Sharon Bowles

So it's actually the drive is really in the opposite direction for more tailoring.

25:59 - 26:21

Jason Storah

Yeah, and the comparability, the ability to be able to compare apples to apples. Just looking at price alone is very misleading. You really need to understand the cover beneath that to understand what you're getting. And also, you know, there are de facto reviews and there's other information available out there for consumers to try and compare different products and different companies.

26:21 - 26:25

Speaker 17

Did you want to add anything or has it all been said?

26:25 - 26:27

Speaker 15

No, I think it's all been said.

26:27 - 26:29

Speaker 20

Okay, thank you. Lord Griffiths.

26:29 - 27:09

Speaker 16

Before I ask the question, can I just ask you how you define standardization? For example, if I go into a store, say to buy food, you know, I look at how much fat is in it, how much salt is in it. It's very clear. I mean, instinctively I feel standardization is going to add to cost and probably reduce competition and reduce your ability to compete with each other. So I'm not really sympathetic to it.

On the other hand, when I go into M&S or Waitrose, you know, I do value it. And I just wonder how do you define, how would you see it in relation to say food?

27:09 - 27:49

Jason Storah

I think, you know, standard excess levels, standard levels of cover for certain perils, you could provide that. And there will be, there'll be quite a lot of overlap between what different companies offer in their insurance products.

But to set standards that are rigid and there is no flexibility from, I agree with you entirely, it would reduce competition, it would reduce innovation. And to my colleague's point, you know, it would mean that you would create a vanilla average for everybody, and not everybody is vanilla. Everybody is, is different flavors.

27:49 - 27:56

Speaker 16

Can I now ask you, what did you make of the Which? super-complaint?

27:56 - 29:42

Alistair Hargreaves

I, I think, um, we've always been, um, very customer-focused and trying to strive to improve things for customers. Our customer promise is about giving customers great value, ease of use of, of insurance and being trusted at point of claim. And I think what Which? highlighted was that as an industry we've got a problem with trust with consumers. And actually the, the biggest aspect of that was about consumer understanding. So I think the points that, um, you, you've been focused on so far today in the committee in terms of these products, home and travel in particular, are more complicated than something like motor.

And as an industry we need to face into that, and things like wear and tear. I, I think, I think I say it's consumer understanding because our travel insurance products are, are broadly in line with the market. So it costs on average for us a bit less than three hundred pounds to cover your home and your contents, um, for unforeseen events. And some of those claims can be very expensive if there's a storm or, or etc. But in terms of maintenance of your home, checking your roof and things like that are the sorts of things that, um, if you look at the guidance that should be sort of at least annual and maintenance of your home and things like that is, um, is something that can't afford to be covered by a three hundred pound policy.

That's not the, the purpose of the policy. That said, you know, we need to explain that well to consumers. I do think some of the claims acceptance is queries and we shouldn't be putting point customers off at point of claim to understand and it's, it's understandable that they'd reach out to us as a, as an expert and ask about it. But I still within that I still think that as an industry we need to work harder because at the moment it is damaging that trust within us as an industry.

29:42 - 30:14

Nick Turner

So, um, we, we have quite a good relationship with Which? We, we've won the Insurance Brand of the Year, their Insurance Brand of the Year award for the last four years, which puts us in a reasonably good place. And whether, whether the learnings come from FCA good and bad practice, which I'd encourage them to do more of, or whether it comes from a super-complaint, our first go-to place is to look at all the, all the things that people are coming up as issues and do a gap analysis with our own operation. And we found no, no significant changes that we needed to make on the back of the super-complaint.

30:14 - 31:47

Jason Storah

Yeah, I would agree. I mean, I think Which? play a really important role. We had already done an awful lot of work and improvements and the FCA had looked at the work and improvements that we'd done. The one thing I will say is, you know, as I say, Which?, Which? plays an important role, but actually when you look at the basis upon the data they used for the super-complaint, they, I think they looked at thirty-three hundred claims, they surveyed thirty-three hundred claims and they, they spoke to twenty-four people. That's not a very big sample size.

You know, we settle three and a half thousand claims every two days. I've personally spoken to and met probably over a hundred customers in the last couple of years through customer insight and feedback sessions that we do. So I think there's always validity to somebody finding some data and putting it out there, but I think the validity of that data set is also something that's worth considering sometimes, the size of that data set. And then, and then the one other thing I would say is I think, you know, I do worry a little bit about broad brush statements and some of those headlines that get attention when actually there's quite a lot of texture beneath them. And any headlines that perhaps call into question the value of the insurance industry and the value that, that insurance companies provide.

You know, we all pay thousands of claims every day. And and that tends to get forgotten for the areas where there's definitely always areas for improvement. But the vast majority of people, they make a claim, they get it paid. We all have we all see examples of high claims satisfaction scores. And I think just maintaining that balance sometimes is important.

31:47 - 31:48

Thank you.

31:48 - 31:49

Lord Lilley.

31:49 - 32:07

Speaker 22

Is there any change you'd like to see in the regulatory regime you have to adhere to that would make life simpler and less costly to you without appreciable loss in quality to your customers?

32:07 - 33:21

Jason Storah

I mean, I would say that, you know, the regulation that the insurance industry has has has worked through over the last number of years has been significant. And one of the one of the issues one of the parts of dialogue over over recent months and the last year or so is the volume of regulatory work on companies. It is significant and I think the government and companies were were aligned around wanting to reduce the level of regulation overall. That's challenging when you have principles-based regulation, outcomes-based regulation and things get layered on top of each other. But the FCA, you know, they take they've taken their responsibilities really seriously.

I, you know, personally, I think we would look and say we would rather sometimes the regulator goes after bad actors or goes after individual instances of an outliers rather than takes something and then tries to do an across-the-board piece of work or data request. But they've certainly implemented consumer duty and all of the other components of the regulation, you know, thoroughly. But the ongoing regulatory burden is something that we, you know, we would definitely like to see a bit of prioritization in regulation going forward.

33:21 - 34:21

Nick Turner

I'd echo some of those those comments because obviously regulation if if you're everybody must comply with regulations, whether you're the target of the problem or not. So you so if you're operating in a very consumer-friendly way, you can have a cost of implementing a regulation that does nothing different to the way that you're currently dealing with your customers. It just becomes a cost which you then pass on you have to pass it on to members. So, you know, that that's painful. So again, we've got the consumer duty, which should give the regulator all the power they need to go after the bad actors, as Jason said.

And I think it would be good I mean, they are, by the way. I think they are they are increasingly doing doing that. So, you know, rather than increase the number of regulations going forward, use the powers that you've got to tackle problems that you've got in the market. And I think that was one of the drivers for consumer duty to give the regulator the power to do that with a bit more energy and gusto.

34:21 - 34:43

Alistair Hargreaves

I think I'd agree with what's been said. I think consumer duty gives the right framework. And I think it's the the FCA talk about predictability and proportionality. So I think it's about using using that going forward and and just being mindful of the cost of large data requests and and some of that activity and prioritizing it as as people have said.

34:43 - 34:59

Speaker 22

And if there are on reflection after this meeting there are sort of concrete changes you think something that's been inherited from before consumer duty but still there and is now unnecessary and could be removed, perhaps you'd let us know. Thank you.

34:59 - 35:01

Speaker 23

Lord Davies.

35:01 - 35:19

Speaker 25

Did did you watch or read what oh no, you can't have read because the transcript didn't happen. Did you watch our session last week when we spoke to the price comparison websites or have a briefing from that?

35:19 - 35:20

A briefing.

35:20 - 35:21

A few headlines, yeah.

35:21 - 35:22

Yes, headlines.

35:22 - 36:01

Bryn Davies

Yeah, headlines. Did you pick up anything that you would want to respond or add to what they said? As far as you know, it's a bit of an unfair question, but. I I didn't quite understand with the with the NFU, as you say, you always do well in the Which? reviews, but you say you don't participate in the price comparison websites.

And I don't know about other members, I got the impression that they had fairly universal coverage, but they just don't report on your policies.

36:01 - 36:12

Nick Turner

Price comparison websites? Yes. Yes, we're, you, they're effectively, I think of it like a supermarket. You can choose to put your products on their shelves or not. And we choose not to.

36:12 - 36:34

Bryn Davies

Right. And the other two, you choose to go on, but they raised the issue of claims rate information being, and they say they want it, but there's a reluctance in the industry to provide it. What's your take on that?

36:34 - 37:26

Jason Storah

I think the FCA collects claims data and there is claims data available. The FCA publishes that data. So the price comparison websites could take that. I think the key about, certainly look, we're very open to providing claims data and it being published. We just want to make sure it's consistent across all companies.

And when there are differences, you can create uncertainty, you can create distrust, and it's just because the data is slightly different. So to put that in the hands of price comparison websites wouldn't feel like necessarily the right idea. The best solution is the FCA collects that data, the FCA validates that it's apples to apples data and there isn't different interpretations of data that's reported, and then publishes that, and price comparison websites could use that as they see fit.

37:26 - 38:31

Alistair Hargreaves

Yes, so I'd echo that. I think on, we've talked a lot about claims acceptance rate, I think there's been an acknowledgement that that isn't necessarily consistent across the piece, which I think demonstrates the challenge to that. I think the other point that I would say is consumer understanding is about understanding what the consumer doesn't understand and making sure that they do. And insurance is quite a complicated product to a lot of people. So we do a lot of testing of that consumer understanding.

And then as I've mentioned, we're also looking at actually what is it that's causing the confusion and targeting that throughout the life cycle of our customers to ensure that we're giving good customer outcomes. So on top of the comparability, I worry slightly about giving more data that could confuse customers. So we are work, we will work with the price comparison sites and we're actively engaging with them on finding ways in which we can get that comparability. But I think for both the underlying data and for how you communicate it to customers, I don't think it's a quick fix. I think it takes time to do it well.

38:31 - 38:40

Speaker 27

But you are, those of you who engage with the price comparison websites, you are engaged in trying to agree a standard basis.

38:40 - 39:41

Jason Storah

Yes. It is just, it does bear some reinforcement though that the texture of reported data is quite important. And I'll give an example. Time to settle a claim is a stat that can be really meaningful with certain kinds of claims and it could be misleading with other kinds of claims. If somebody has a simple stain on a carpet and the piece of carpet needs replacing and it's covered, how quickly that gets done, that's a pretty simple claim, that can be a meaningful data point.

If somebody has a catastrophic flood or a fire or has a subsidence issue with a tree that's roots are causing problems on the foundations, the time to settle that claim can be quite significant. So you would just want to make sure that the way that reported data is used is apples to apples. And that's why we think going through the FCA and using that data, because they're collecting it for understanding and ultimately customer, regulatory and customer benefit, their primary use of it isn't commercial benefit.

39:41 - 39:58

Bryn Davies

Yes, okay. There's a slight difference in emphasis between yourselves and the price comparison websites about resolving this issue, but you are agreed that the market would be better if that information were available.

39:54 - 40:04

Jason Storah

But also some of that difference might be because we we operate in slightly different parts of the insurance ecosystem. We have different business models. So it's probably not a surprise that there are some differences.

39:58 - 39:59

Speaker 26

Yes.

40:04 - 41:23

Bryn Davies

Yes. Um, another issue that that was discussed was you you go on the website on a Thursday and you get a price and you go back the following Monday and there's a different price. Um, I've always felt that underwriting is is perhaps a bit more of a of an art than a science. I mean you you look the the explanation we had was that at any given point in time you're looking for different sorts of business. Would you like to expand on that point to explain to us why?

Uh, and the other aspect of that is I get the renewal premium and I speak to the person on the helpline and they say, "Oh, I'll I'll check if I can off make you a better offer," and they come back and they make you a better offer. And it all seems a bit um if if you you made the comparison with the supermarket. If I go to Sainsbury's, I know the price is there and the price is taken. Occasionally they do special offers, but it's there as a special offer, whereas with insurance companies you seem to be making it up as you go along.

41:23 - 43:33

Jason Storah

So pricing does change on a regular basis. I would use your example though. Um, if somebody makes the effort to phone up and sometimes people get a quote and then they go back a few days later and go through, but they might enter slightly different information or they they might they might enter a different quoting engine. If somebody is on the phone and they've been given a quote that they've completed online and they phone up and they give additional information, that additional information can change the price quite quite quite frequently. And it can sometimes increase the price and it can sometimes reduce the price.

And there are other factors that an agent can take over the phone that they can't necessarily take through a rigid 10-question set, but they can understand other products that a customer has and other variables that would factor into the price that the company feels is appropriate for the risk. So again, I I'd think it's a bit more nuanced than just saying um you pick up the phone and the price gets changed. There's there's a lot more to it than that. I I think I think what we're trying to do is we're trying to um cover customers for the for the risk of of them potentially needing to be looked after at point of claim. And what we're really trying to do is do that as affordably as we possibly can for that customer.

And price comparison is very transparent. So you want to be as cheap as you possibly can for that customer, but you need to make sure that across the piece you're covering enough so that you can look after them well at point of claim. And we try and use um data and update that data regularly to really understand as well as we can the risk of that customer. So that's the the the principle. In in terms of um renewals customers, the general insurance pricing practice means that um the price that we offer our renewals customers will be the same or lower than they would get at new business.

Uh, so um again it's a very competitive price. It's the same as they would get if they came to us at new business. But uh if a customer, you know, I think customers are quite used to negotiating in in their general life. So if a customer calls us, maybe gives us some more data, or um uh has found a cheaper price elsewhere, we will give a discount to that customer.

43:33 - 44:01

Alistair Hargreaves

Now that would be a better price than it would have been than they would have got at new business, and we wouldn't give the same discount at new business. And it's a commercial decision because we, you know, that customer might have been with us for a number of years and we think, well, we would like them to stay longer. It's something that we evaluate and we think is it the right thing to do? But on balance, we think that being able to discount those customers that have been with us for a few years in in those circumstances is appropriate.

44:01 - 44:22

Bryn Davies

Like you say, suggests that maybe there is a struggle between rather than consumer understanding, perhaps we could rephrase it as provider explanation and having the lowest possible price. There is a struggle there that you have to work your way through.

44:22 - 45:27

Nick Turner

Sometimes. I think also the number of data points that go into a price these days, particularly in personal lines, can be in hundreds of data points. And so any one of those could change or be updated either from internal understanding of a risk or people putting in different data points. So actually getting to explain in a way that someone can absorb the impact of something is is a constant battle for insurers generally. And we we I mean AI does help with some of this stuff because it can help help surface some of the the rationale for any price changes that people and we have it at renewals where people come up to renewal and say, why has my price gone up by this amount or or even why has it gone down by this amount?

And actually getting on some of the more mechanized pricing that's generated is actually quite a large amount of work to go back to truly understand what's moved in a scenario to explain the price. And that's always going to be a battle between consumer's understanding and and our ability to explain that in an economic way.

45:27 - 45:58

Speaker 29

Thank you. Just quickly to follow up on that point, one of the things that we were told last week by the price comparison websites very forcefully actually was that typically they will save about 20% over your existing renewal from your existing provider if you go to the price comparison websites. Why is that? What's what's happening there and does that not somewhat undermine what you've just told us about the the process you've just explained?

45:58 - 47:24

Alistair Hargreaves

I think I think we've got changing prices and what customers at renewal tend to notice is when their price goes up. But some customers see their price go down. And if you see your price go down and you look at your auto-renewal because that's the nature of the beast of changing rates, you think I've got a good deal this year. To be honest, you probably forget about it and and you move on. If your price goes up, you think, well, why has my price gone up?

And often for a lot of our customers, they will shop because they've come to us from price comparison. And that's where our rating structure has changed and maybe somebody else's rating structure has changed in a different way, and so they they can save money. So I think that's the I think the price comparison sites are looking at people who have decided to shop probably because their price has gone up rather than looking at the whole market. I would also add again, I think you know, they might be able to get a cheaper price, but are they getting the same level of cover and how aware are they of the cover comparison? Probably not as as aware.

But but price comparison websites play a really important role and one of the big part of that role is the choice that they offer and the ability for people to get the options and the and reduced premium levels in some instances. But again, you know, price is not the only thing that we want customers to look at. We do want them to be able to assess cover versus cover and the prices available.

47:24 - 47:42

Speaker 29

My my main question is more, you know, you've talked about the acceptance rates and you've said that probably the main reason for declining a policy a claim is down to customer understanding of what they're actually covered for.

47:42 - 48:06

Speaker 30

You've also talked about the work you're doing to try and improve that customer understanding. So can you, you know, you've given us a snapshot at a point of time of the acceptance rates. What are the trends? Are, if you're making all these efforts, one would expect to see those declining rates declining, if that's the right way of putting it. What are the trends?

48:06 - 49:29

Alistair Hargreaves

We've seen an improvement in the 2025 results versus the 2024 results. We, as I say, we've been very focused on this for a number of years and we've been working on a number of changes. What we found is it's quite hard to engage with customers just via communication. So I'm probably one of the few people in the UK that gets excited by insurance. Generally, our customers at point of sale they'll be engaged then they won't be thinking about it very much unless they need it.

And so I think we'd have to accept with a product like home insurance where that wear and tear is there and a customer might want to query with an expert that they have got a relationship with, it will never get to motor. But I think there are things that we can do. And as I've said, we've gone beyond just the communication. So communicating at point of sale, follow up with areas to reiterate what they're covered for and what they're not covered on points that could cause confusion. If there is an event like a storm, we'll reach out to customers and explain things again to them because they might be interested at that point.

Some of the excess levels as I mentioned, so we've made changes to product. And we do see that come through to the results. But I'm not expecting it to get to the same level as motor insurance because of the nature of what we're dealing with.

49:29 - 50:09

Jason Storah

Yeah, I would just echo. I think we probably all get excited about insurance, but we've definitely seen an improvement. And just to be really clear, we want there to be an improvement. We don't want those decline rates to be, we want them to get narrower and narrower. Now, I do think there's a point at which there's only so much we can do.

And if you take a macroeconomic step back, the cost of living crisis, where people are spending the money, what they have in terms of disposable income and the choices they're making, perhaps fixing the roof or you know, making decisions on insurance products is one of those things that they're not going to necessarily be able to address. But we, we have seen improvements and we continue to work to make improvements.

50:09 - 51:53

Nick Turner

So I think without being complacent, I think we'd probably feel like we're close to the frontier of what's possible. Because I mean with the building rates, I mean we design the claim service around what people need. It's almost an insurance policy worked backwards. You work out what you need when your house breaks down or burns down or floods. And that designs the policy and the price is a function of that.

So that's the way our mindset works on this stuff. The declinature rate, you know, I think there's little that we can do because it's quite, when you're dealing with those issues you've got some fraud in there, you've got some wear and tear and things that are beyond the policy scope. I think the key to it though, I mean we also have a helpfully a 94.1% persistency rate, so the renewals, people renew with us at that sort of level. And because we have the agency network, that's 600 agents, nearly 3,000 staff out in the rural community where we actively encourage people to come and talk to us. Whether it's for a motor policy or a home insurance policy.

And we train the team in Mutual Direct in Glasgow and Cardiff very well and don't limit their ability to speak to people. They know, talk as much as you want, that is a differentiator for our business.

We see that as an educational thing. So every year, people come back to us, we have conversations and we reinforce the scope and range of the policies through those conversations, something that is difficult to do through other distribution channels. So, you know, if you've been with us for 25 years and we've had a conversation every single year about what you're covered for, chances are you know what you're covered for by the time you come to claim. So it does give us an advantage in that regard. So I think the model works for us.

51:53 - 52:11

Speaker 29

Just a very specific question on storm damage, where we've heard about, you know, storm being defined by wind speed and actually, you know, as a someone who has a house, you don't care what the wind speed is, you care that your roof's been blown off. Is that something that needs changing?

52:11 - 53:06

Alistair Hargreaves

There's a standard definition of a wind speed that meets a storm, and so that would be, that's something that we would use. But one of the things that we've looked at here is we've introduced more than one measure and we make sure we use the one that is the highest measure of those two. And then we give a 10% tolerance. So if the customer's within 10% of that definition of a storm, then that would meet our definition, we'd go ahead with the claim. If a customer disputes it, we'll look at it and we can send people out to take a look and understand exactly what's happened.

But we need a way of distinguishing between a storm and the wear and tear, and that's why there's the industry standard. But then we're keen to ensure that we're on the side of the customer and hence we give that flexibility and we make sure we're interpreting that definition well.

53:06 - 53:21

Jason Storah

Totally agree, we have the same. We look at the industry standard and then provide a number of parameters around that to understand the impact and whether it's wear and tear or whether it's the event of the storm that's caused the loss. So a very similar approach.

53:21 - 53:57

Nick Turner

Yeah, same for us. We would send, we would try and get eyes on the problem and understand exactly what's happened from the consumer's perspective. And I guess the thing that we focus on is being very pragmatic in the grey areas, because there often is in some of these areas. And if we can pay, we will, and if we can pay using some of the other covers that are within the policy, we will as well. So, I mean, the only statistic I can give you is last year in total we paid out 1.4 billion in claims and our CSAT scores, they scored us five out of five 83% of times.

53:57 - 54:04

Sheila Noakes

And last, did you target improvements in your acceptance rates?

54:04 - 54:17

Alistair Hargreaves

Yes, so we drive continuous improvement in terms of acceptance rates. So it's something that we've looked at a great deal and we, as I say, we've seen improvements in 2025 versus 2024.

54:17 - 54:33

Jason Storah

Absolutely, I would say, and but we drive improvements in the acceptance rates through understanding what are the issues, what are the areas of perhaps customer lack of clarity, where are the decline rates? And we do that as a consequence of focusing on the feedback that we get from customers, the types of claims.

54:33 - 54:51

Speaker 29

But you do seem to be quite stubborn. Do you share between the industry the sort of common reasons for declining, particularly where there are common misunderstandings? Is that something that you share between yourselves?

54:51 - 55:17

Alistair Hargreaves

I think in terms of the ABI, we work with the ABI on common issues and we'll have, as I've mentioned, the wind speed and how that works is something that is an industry-defined definition in order to get that standardization for that interpretation. So there are property working groups and things like that that work together in order to drive improvements.

55:17 - 55:19

Speaker 28

Lady Donaghy.

55:19 - 55:41

Speaker 32

Thank you, Chairman. I want to ask you about AI, but before I do, would you say there has been any change in your relationship with the FCA over the last, say, three or four years? Have some things improved? Is there room for improvement in other areas?

55:41 - 56:32

Jason Storah

We've probably got to know them better over the last three or four years. We spend a lot of time with them and a lot of data and a lot of dialogue. There's a lot of dialogue across a number of levels of the organization with the FCA teams. In terms of areas for improvement, as I think as I said earlier, I think one of the probably the only thing I would address is, you know, the level of regulation, the burden that comes onto us. And if you said you're going to reference AI, what is coming in future around AI and the implications of regulation on AI and the Mills report recently that came out, if that's just layered on top of the existing regulatory burden on companies, that's probably not ideal from our perspective.

We already spend a lot of money and a lot of time on that. And so just managing that balance between as regulation evolves, what's going to fall away and what's going to be prioritized.

56:32 - 57:40

Nick Turner

Just to build on that. So our relationship has not changed with the regulator. It's a respectful relationship and we engage with them fully openly and we have good good relations. The AI point, I think Jason's bang on. We have consumer duty which says you're still accountable whatever methodology you use within your organization to deliver great outcomes for members in our case and customers.

And so, you know, AI, using that as one of your component parts within the organization doesn't let you off the hook. You can't abdicate anything to the box did it over there or that algorithm did it over there. You're still entirely on the hook for it, which is perhaps one of the reasons why, you know, AI has not got into the regulated world as ubiquitously as it may have done in other industries because we have to be very careful that we don't damage any consumer outcomes through its deployment. So I'm sure all of us are doing it in a very controlled way, in a very cautious but proactive way because it has also positives for customers.

57:40 - 58:08

Speaker 32

The super complaint going back to Which?, now there in their evidence, they said it was a frustration at the lack of data despite spending months if not years trying to get that information. So there was an implication that the FCA wasn't doing its job. That's not your view.

58:08 - 58:38

Alistair Hargreaves

No, I think I think as we've been saying, I think we have close relationships with the FCA. I think some of the data that we're talking about, the GI value measures data, has been introduced as part of consumer duty looking at outcomes, having data that is visible and we can be discussing. And within when the FCA look at specific topics, they ask for a lot of data in order to dig into that.

58:38 - 59:01

Speaker 31

Okay. Well, on the AI, one of you, I can't remember, sorry, who said it, but talked about hyper-personalized advice. What progress are your organizations making on AI, bearing in mind what Nick's just said about cautious analysis and progress?

59:01 - 01:01:14

Nick Turner

Give a couple of examples of how we're using it. I mean, there's three sort of buckets I would put AI into. There's the use of things like Copilot, which are just generally helpful, like a Google search. You can you can ask questions of the AI and it will give you a shortcut answer or you can use prompts that create simple routines. So that we've rolled that out to all of our staff in a controlled way.

It's not using it's in a in a controlled environment and it allows people to help draft letters or reports, so it cuts away some of the work that we have which would take long, so people are more productive effectively.

So that's one way. The second way we've done things like tipped our 6,000-page underwriting manual into a large language model that allows our agents to speak to a machine and get an answer on whether we'll accept something or not from an underwriting perspective and then leads you to which page in that manual it is, so like a really engaging index. That stops our agents speaking directly to experienced professional underwriters, so asking questions that they could look it up themselves. So it helps educate them that way, it creates a triage. So that's some productivity, that's just one example.

I could give you others. I think where we'll get more value from it is a piece of work that we're doing on processes where we're remapping all of our processes with customer experience as the North Star. But once you've mapped those processes, you can then look at where you can automate or improve some of the outcomes within the processes towards that agenda of customer experience. And that's being worked on right now. So there's three buckets.

The one that I think will be the most impactful for us is the process re-engineering, but then you can get quite a, you know, you can test that to destruction, make sure it's delivering the right outcomes for customers before you roll that out fully. And across all of these, we've got human in the loop on everything. So we, as an organisation that is, we see as a differentiator, as you've probably picked up, our people at the front is going to remain. So a lot of AI is focused more on the back office and improvements in productivity there. So that's in a nutshell how we'd be using it.

01:01:14 - 01:03:47

Jason Storah

I'll maybe use a couple of examples, very similar, but if I think about claims summarisation tools which offer benefits both internally for our people and externally for customers. So, you know, during the life of a claim, somebody will phone up and tell us the first notice of loss, they've had a claim, there's water in the kitchen or there's been a fire or a theft. And so the claims agents would take a lot of information and then, you know, give them a claim number, there would be follow-up and somebody might phone back a few days or a week later. The claims summarisation tool using AI means that the person that the customer speaks to isn't having to spend time summarising the claim. It's all done instantly and next time that customer phones, if they invariably speak to a different claims agent, that agent instantly knows everything that's going on, the most pertinent parts of the claim and the conversation.

So that has more effective, more efficient usage of time for our people and a quicker response for the customer. So that would be one example. I think the other one that I would say is, you know, Aviva, I think we were one of the, or we were the first insurance company to offer the ability for customers to use ChatGPT to get a quote. And we did that not thinking that there would be hordes of people that would start getting quotes and buying their policies using ChatGPT, but we did it because the insight you get from the customer journey is really interesting. And I'll give you a couple of examples.

You know, when people go and quote online, we see 60% of the people that get a quote online go through, they complete their quote to get a, 60% complete the quote online. With ChatGPT, we were getting over 90% of the people were getting through to a quote. So it's a much higher throughput rate of people. But the real value came from, if you think about a quote journey normally, a customer is asked, is answering a prescribed set of questions. Particularly with a price comparison website, it's the same question set and then it pumps out a number of different quotes from different companies.

But with ChatGPT, and it was me that mentioned the hyper-personalisation, they can be asking questions and giving information that's very relevant to them. So any two people would have very different perspectives on what's important to them in their insurance, what's most pertinent to them in terms of maybe they've had a claim or maybe they're worried about X in their house. And so you get a much more individualised customer journey and the data you get and the insight is really, really interesting.

01:03:47 - 01:05:21

Alistair Hargreaves

They haven't left me much to say, have they? But we're similarly embracing AI and doing so in a controlled way. Maybe if I use a couple of slightly different examples just to build on what's been said. So another use that we've found for AI would be quality assurance. So we have a lot of transactions with customers and actually AI enables us to look at all of those transactions and then spot the exceptions in terms of any dissatisfaction.

So it can be a driver of quality and feedback in that sense. Also in terms of fraud, it enables you to look at a lot of information and identify inconsistencies or increasingly people outside of the business have AI and so might be having photographs that have been manipulated or things like that. So it enables us to identify it in that way as well. We think it's a very powerful tool and will be powerful for us going forward. We do have controls around that though as well.

So we have a data ethics team that is independent to the teams that are testing AI and is saying, look, are we, is this in line with consumer duty? Because whilst AI is a great opportunity to improve things for customers, we want to make sure we're not, we're still accountable for the outcomes for those customers whichever tools we're using. So we've got those appropriate controls and checks and balances as we try those new use cases.

01:05:21 - 01:06:08

Speaker 31

You've all mentioned the importance of keeping in mind humans. I'm not going to bore you with the argument I had with a bot once, but yesterday it took me half a morning to get to speak to a human being. And so there is another side of this of people in society feeling disenfranchised and alienated from the system. And I'm concerned that this will all add to that particular feeling. What measures within the regulatory regime are you putting in place to ensure that doesn't happen?

01:06:08 - 01:06:52

Alistair Hargreaves

So I'd say I think at a principle basis we want to provide great service for the customer. And I think where AI can do that, great, because it should be that customers are going there because it's easier and better for them. That would be our objective. But we'd still want to give choice of channel. So I think in the same way as digital changed things a lot for customers, but there was still customers who want to speak to somebody, we like to give customers that choice of channel.

So I think that'd be our starting point as an organization. I think consumer duty, if you look at it through that lens, consumer support and things like that, I think we'd frown upon anything that we thought was actually blocking that access to customers. I think customers should have that choice.

01:06:52 - 01:07:12

Nick Turner

I'll just say our business model is built around human interaction. So people who want a human service ring or talk to us or walk into one of our shops. But I completely understand not everyone does. I mean, we will have, I mean, we are in the process of having full multi-channel, but it'll still remain a people-based business.

01:07:12 - 01:07:51

Jason Storah

Totally agree. We will always have human oversight, assessment of journeys and experiences whichever channel they come through. And from a claims perspective, you know, we have baseline claims service and people that respond to claims no matter which channel people come into us from, no matter what kind of what product they've bought, what coverage they've bought, what brand of Aviva brand they've used to come into the company.

So, you know, when we have people that are augmenting their skills and their productivity with AI, those people are still very much involved in the process. But I'm sure we all have bot-type experiences as the one you mentioned.

01:07:51 - 01:08:18

Speaker 29

Of course. Jason, you talked about effectively consumers using AI to seek out policies and quotes, and you can sort of imagine a world where ChatGPT, Google, etc. actually end up sort of bypassing the price comparison websites. Price comparison websites are subject to regulation and consumer duty; Google, ChatGPT, etc. not. What's your thoughts on that and how should that be regulated?

01:08:18 - 01:09:07

Jason Storah

The only way to buy insurance is through a regulated company at the moment, and I don't know that anybody would want to change that. I don't think we would want that changing; I don't think the regulator would want that changing. I think there's two components to it: one, understanding the kind of AI and the impact on the customer journey that different regulated firms are using. And we're all regulated and we're all embedding AI into different parts of our business. I don't think there's a concern there.

But I think customers, consumers going outside of that regulated envelope is what you're flagging and what you're concerned about. And, you know, we will certainly identify any of those. We don't want that sort of Wild West behavior in in in the industry, and so we would flag those. But I also believe the FCA would be aware and other consumer groups would flag those kind of experiences.

01:09:07 - 01:09:29

Bryn Davies

Just to be clear, if a customer comes to you, you don't interrogate why they've come to you if they come direct. They might have come to you because they've got some duff advice from ChatGPT or Claude or someone.

01:09:29 - 01:09:34

Jason Storah

Maybe, but then they're going to go through our their they'll go through our quote journey and we'll get the information directly.

01:09:34 - 01:09:42

Bryn Davies

But presumably you're not saying, "Well, you really ought to go to somebody else to get your insurance because we're not the people for you."

01:09:42 - 01:10:01

Jason Storah

No, we we look, we in the case of Aviva, our home premiums range from 80 pounds a year to over a million pounds a year. So we have a pretty broad appetite and we think we can serve everybody's needs. But no, no, no, that that's not an outcome that we foresee.

01:10:01 - 01:10:17

Sheila Noakes

Well, thank you very much, Mr. Hargreaves, Mr. Storah, and Mr. Turner. That's been a fascinating morning. Thank you very much for your time and for answering our questions in the way that you have, which has been very very encouraging. So that completes this evidence session.