Highways (Financing) Bill

29 October 2026

Highways (Financing) Bill Actual start House of Commons

Follow its sittings
15:28 - 15:51
Speaker 2
Order, order.  Order.  We are now sitting in public and the proceedings are being broadcast.  Before we begin, I'd like to remind members to switch all your electronic devices to silent and that tea and coffee are not allowed in these sittings.  Today we will first consider the program motion on the amendment paper. 
15:51 - 16:12
Speaker 1
We will then consider a motion to enable the reporting of written evidence for publication and a motion to allow us to deliberate in private about our questions before the oral sessions begin.  In view of the time available, I hope that we can meet these matters formal and quickly without a debate.  Marvelous. 
16:12 - 16:19
Speaker 7
Okay, first call the Minister to move the program motion standing in their name, which was discussed on Monday by the program subcommittee for the bill. 
16:19 - 16:21
Speaker 4
I move formally. 
16:21 - 16:25
Speaker 2
Question is that the program motion as on the amendment paper.  As many as that opinion say aye. 
16:25 - 16:26
Aye. 
16:26 - 16:35
Speaker 2
To the contrary, no.  I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it.  Call the Minister to move the motion about written evidence. 
16:35 - 16:36
I move formally. 
16:36 - 16:40
Speaker 2
The question is the motion as on the amendment paper.  As many as that opinion say aye. 
16:40 - 16:41
Aye. 

16:41 - 16:42

Contrary, no.

16:42 - 16:44

Speaker 5

No.

16:44 - 16:58

Emma Lewell

I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Copies of written evidence which the committee receives will be made available in the committee room. I now call the Minister to move the motion about deliberating in private.

16:58 - 16:59

I move formally.

16:59 - 17:01

Emma Lewell

Okay, as many of that opinion say aye.

17:02 - 19:19

Emma Lewell

The contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. We will now go into a private session to discuss lines of questioning.

Order, order. We are now sitting in public again and the proceedings are being broadcast. Before we start hearing from our witnesses, do any of the members wish to make a declaration of interest in connection with the bill? If any interests are particularly... no, no interests. We will now hear evidence from the AA and the RAC Foundation.

Welcome. We must stick to the timings that are in the program motion that the committee has agreed, so this session we will have until five past twelve.

Could you please also both just briefly introduce yourselves for the committee? Thank you.

19:19 - 19:48

Edmund King

Yes, I'm Edmund King, I'm president of the Automobile Association and director of the AA Charitable Trust. I'm a former visiting professor of transport at Newcastle University, and I've been involved in roads and road infrastructure probably for about thirty, thirty-five years. I used to be a member of the British Road Federation, which campaigned for better roads in the late eighties and nineties. Thank you.

19:48 - 20:04

Steve Gooding

Good morning, I'm Steve Gooding, I'm the director of the RAC Foundation, which is the charitable research body set up by the Royal Automobile Club back in the 1990s to conduct and disseminate research relating to motoring.

20:04 - 20:06

Speaker 8

Greg Smith, Shadow Minister.

20:06 - 21:06

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Ms. Low. Pleasure to serve under your chairmanship this morning. And good morning, gentlemen. This bill, particularly from the second reading debate and other narrative that has come out since it was first published, on one level seems to be presented as answering the question: how do you solve a problem like the Lower Thames Crossing? But equally has a lot of other provision within it where perhaps it is badly drafted clauses or perhaps it is deliberate that seems to allow tolling and road pricing to extend further than the Lower Thames Crossing.

Is that something your organisations are concerned about? And do you feel that there has been enough focus given to the everything other than Lower Thames Crossing parts of this bill to general motorists in this country? Perhaps Mr King first.

21:06 - 22:56

Edmund King

Yeah, I think part of the bill, obviously if you look at the Lower Thames Crossing and you look at the need for it, you look at congestion, you look at the environmental issues currently at Dartford, I think it's quite easy to see that some alternative solution is needed. But I think as you rightly say with this bill, it's not just about the Lower Thames Crossing, it could allow that finance model with other schemes.

It might have been easier if it was concentrated on the Lower Thames Crossing because then you could have brought into it more restrictions, safeguards for motorists on tolls. Because currently as it stands on the one hand you've got the Office of Rail and Road as the regulator for it, and then you've got drivers who are the consumers, whether they're individual motorists or HGV drivers, whatever. And to some extent there might be a conflict between those two. The ORR has to ensure that the licensee makes money from it so it can be viable, but at the same time they regulate tolls for the drivers.

And you could argue that there might be a conflict in that at times. So certainly one of the things that when we've looked at similar schemes before, I did a paper on road miles with an economist that looked at this broader issue of kind of road pricing. One thing we called for was an independent body to oversee kind of tolling to ensure that it was fair. So I certainly think within this bill, the responsibility of the ORR where it comes to tolls could be strengthened and given more independence.

22:56 - 24:01

Steve Gooding

That's very helpful, Mr. Gooding. I think that the committee is clearly going to want to look very closely at clause 3, which is I think the key thing here. Yes, we looked at it, yes, we wondered is this a way of creating a framework that could be then applied to the existing road network, the existing motorway network.

Clearly the provisions relate to the trunk roads, the National Highways roads. I think that the way that clause 3 is drafted does tighten that down to where capacity is being added. But I think something the committee is definitely going to want to look at, we would want the committee to look at, is how much capacity is being added in order to make that a valid use of the powers in the bill. Is it simply, for example, playing tunes with the speed limit? Is it maybe adding a lane?

Is it what? And in those circumstances, would we be contemplating sections of the existing national road network being transferred over to a private company? I don't think that's the intention, but the intention is not always the actuality.

24:01 - 24:43

Greg Gregory Smith

That's very helpful. Could I just dig a little bit deeper on that?

Because I think the part of clause 3 that you're referring to is this part that refers to a license may provide for the holder of the license to secure the maintenance or operation or improvement of any part of a highway. I think, is it the view of your organization or your members that people would expect that to be an entirely new road or perhaps a dualed road that is currently single carriageway rather than what what many might consider a relatively minor improvement? Perhaps, I don't know whether this is an improvement, but smart motorway cameras or or something relatively minor.

24:43 - 25:10

Steve Gooding

No, I think our understanding of it, and it's why I think the committee will want to make sure this is clear, is that the subsections of clause 3 relate back to each other.

So it isn't a relatively minor maintenance of itself that would enable the license to be awarded. It has to be linked back, our reading of it is it has to be linked back to enhancement of capacity, but perhaps the minister might want to make that clearer.

25:10 - 25:52

Greg Gregory Smith

Yeah. My last point if I may, Ms. Lewell. Do you feel within the wider scope of the bill there is enough provision that where a new scheme is being proposed under the provisions of this bill, there is enough thought to other nearby existing roads, those that rely on those other nearby existing roads, businesses, homeowners, people who live there, schools, hospitals, etc., to be properly consulted on this? Because too often in this world, the new shiny thing gets all the attention without due regard to existing infrastructure.

Do you feel that's been adequately explored?

25:52 - 26:39

Edmund King

I think it you can say in relation to the Lower Thames Crossing because in in that part you you know the two elements, one is the current Dartford Crossing, one is the new crossing and you can look in that area. But if you look at the bill more generally, it's very difficult to say because we don't know where it'll be applied apart from, you know, it does say construction of a highway specified in the license, the bill 3.1a does say that. But obviously we don't know where that highway is, we don't know what are the competing interests with housing, with the economy, with routes to links. So I think in terms of this bill, it's difficult to say unless there is a concrete scheme that's being considered.

26:39 - 27:13

Steve Gooding

I think it's within the duties that are being placed here on the Secretary of State to consider where these powers are going to be used. So there are duties there in relation to having regard to users of the network, for example, but it could be made more explicit. After all, we are talking about a national asset here, and a national asset that people will, if faced with a toll and an alternative, might well choose the alternative with negative traffic impacts in the round. So that would be something that would have to be taken into account.

27:13 - 27:15

Speaker 12

Thank you. Minister.

27:15 - 28:16

Speaker 13

Thank you, Ms. Lopez, pleasure to see you in the chair this morning and thank you for coming in. I just thought I'd follow up on some of the questions from the shadow minister.

I think in terms of the operation of clause 3(1)(c), that it refers specifically to the maintenance of the licensed area, which is the part of the highway that's actually being increased in capacity as part of the legislation. So it isn't a general maintenance issue across the whole network. So I know there is a narrative that this is a Trojan horse for widespread road charging. We have made it very clear that the operation of this legislation is for specific and limited circumstances.

Is there something more that we can do or say to reassure you that this there is no sort of secret plan to widespreadly use this?

28:16 - 29:10

Steve Gooding

I certainly don't think that it's a conscious Trojan horse, if I may, but having been involved in similar exercises of drafting before, one always wants to destruction test this of could something be used in a way that wasn't anticipated? And I think when one looks at the proposals for Dartford Crossing and the Lower Thames, you are bundling in the existing crossing to the the package as it were that the private sector licensee is going to run. And one wonders whether there might be other instances where something is being brought into the contract, brought into the license within the ambit of the license, which we hadn't been expecting or even intending at the point of passing the legislation, but which might need a bit further tightening of clause three.

29:11 - 30:03

Edmund King

If I could just add to that.

I think part of the problem with government and tolls is previous record. And if you go back to the original Dartford Crossing, the tolls were meant to be removed when the bridge was paid for and certain maintenance was put aside. And that occurred in 2003, and subsequent governments haven't removed it. So drivers do remember that, that governments have rescinded on their promises. So there is that kind of mistrust.

Having said that, when we talk to drivers about new infrastructure, and it being new infrastructure, not existing infrastructure, they are much more open to it being tolled because they can see the benefits in time savings, congestion, etc. So, you know, and certainly Lower Thames Crossing, they can see the benefits from that.

30:03 - 30:04

Speaker 14

Okay, thank you.

30:04 - 30:33

Speaker 13

Just one more question. I think you've sort of mentioned the importance of having an independent body to oversee the interest of road users and referred to sort of the potential tension between the needs of the investors and the needs of the road users and indeed other stakeholders who may have an interest in this. What more would you like to see from the ORR to actually sort of deal with your concerns in that area?

30:33 - 31:13

Edmund King

I mean, clause 83 talks about a stakeholder group, but being appointed by the ORR, even though the chair is approved by the Secretary of State. Yeah.

And in a way, if the ORR is the regulator, surely the stakeholder group should be more independent. So we'd rather see that clause be changed, that either it's the Secretary of State that actually appoints that stakeholder group, so it has a degree of independence. If it's the regulator appointing the stakeholder group, well surely it will say what the regulator wants it to say. So I think more independence could be built in that.

31:13 - 31:14

Thank you. Okay.

31:14 - 31:16

Emma Lewell

Liberal Democrat spokesperson, Olly Glover.

31:16 - 31:54

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Thank you, Ms. Lewell-Buck, it's a pleasure to serve on another Bill Committee with you in the chair. I think one of the key concerns that I might have about this Bill is that a lot of it in there is about stuff being decided by regulations and secondary procedures and the ORR.

And there's a real concern about making sure that consumer rights are protected in terms of people who are going to be charged to use these roads. So do you have any suggestions in addition to what you've already said about better safeguards that the bill could have to make sure that tolls are set and continue to be maintained at an affordable level for people who are going to use these roads? Either of you.

31:54 - 32:49

Steve Gooding

Well, I think the starting point would be that the right sort of duties are applied in the bill to the ORR in terms of having regard to the interests of road users and customers of this service. Of course, there are certain things the bill provides for that we haven't seen yet. So we don't know what the terms of the license will be. We don't know what the terms of the Secretary of State's guidance to the ORR will be. And we don't know exactly what the ORR's template will be yet.

There's always a balance to be struck, I'm well aware, between what goes into those documents and what could actually be on the face of the bill. So in principle, I think the protection is there, but in practice, it may be having a bit more on the face of the bill and a bit less reliance in the other documents might be sensible. But until you see the drafts of those other documents, it's quite hard to tell.

32:49 - 34:09

Edmund King

Could I add to that? Clause 26 talks about tolls, and it talks about them being fair and transparent. I think we would have liked to see something built in there about affordability, because it can be fair and transparent, but can people afford it? And there was certainly, you know, because in effect, the Lower Thames Crossing in Dartford will be a monopoly position. You know, if you want to cross the Thames to the east of London, they're your choices.

And certainly it was rumoured with the M6 Toll when it was first opened that the tolls for HGVs initially were artificially high. And it was rumoured that the operators didn't particularly want HGVs to cause wear and tear of the tolls. So I think it is important that question of affordability. And it goes beyond cost because if people can't afford the toll, they will be using inadequate other roads or going the long way round the M25, which is already vastly congested near Heathrow. So I do think something about affordability should be built in, you know, linked to inflation, something more so that the monopoly position can't be exploited.

34:09 - 34:26

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

I just have a brief comment. I think your point about some of the things that are dependent on the bill not yet specified, like the license. We had a similar debate about that with the Railways Bill. And I think ultimately the government did decide to at least start publishing some of those things alongside. So hope that's something the minister might give some thought to.

34:26 - 34:27

Jim Dickson.

34:27 - 35:29

Jim Dickson

Thank you, Ms. Lewell. Pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. Thank you to the witnesses for being here. You won't be surprised to know as the Member of Parliament for Dartford, I have residents every day who are hugely inconvenienced by the overcapacity nature of the current Dartford Crossing and hugely welcome the plans which have been advanced very well under this government to build the Lower Thames Crossing.

One thing that's of concern to them is that there might be perverse incentives via the tolling to use one crossing rather than another. Would you have views about how we would make sure that that didn't happen? What the ORR would need to do in negotiation obviously with the license holder to ensure that didn't happen? And do you have any views about local resident discount schemes, how well they've worked elsewhere and whether they should be a necessary part of any future arrangement, albeit that may not be on the face of the bill itself?

35:29 - 36:31

Edmund King

Yeah, I think those are all absolute relevant questions. Things like even the time that it applies, you know, is it 24 hours a day? Is it 6:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. as currently? Are motorcycles free? What is the resident discount?

Could there be a resident discount? We believe that there should be because if there are frequent users, if you live one side of the crossing and you work the other side of the crossing, you know, you already pay motoring taxes in other ways, but is this a tax on jobs? So I think those issues are absolutely vital. And I also think it is vital to get the support of local people, whether it's businesses, whether it's drivers. So I think giving those concessions would help win that support, you know, particularly when we know the construction period will cause a lot of congestion in itself and adverse effects.

So I think those are all valid points.

36:31 - 37:05

Steve Gooding

I think all I'd add is that this is one of the, if you like, one of the challenges in creating an overarching framework in this bill rather than something specific to the Dartford and Lower Thames Crossing. I don't doubt that in the Secretary of State's guidance to the ORR, there will be very explicit reference to the need not to create the sort of problems that you've envisaged there, that in fact in setting the toll levels, they should be managed in a way as to manage the traffic flow between the two crossings, but we haven't seen that yet.

37:05 - 37:06

Mike Wheeler.

37:06 - 37:32

Michael Reader

Thank you very much. I just wanted to clarify, because it's important we don't speculate. To deliver a scheme under RAB, it has to have a certain scale and be developed with that in mind.

What other projects in the government's infrastructure pipeline do you think, you referred this could be used in other schemes, what other schemes are you specifically referencing that are currently being developed?

37:32 - 38:02

Steve Gooding

I couldn't point to anything else that's currently in the government's program that I thought specifically lent itself to this. I found myself wondering whether, having announced and disannounced it many times, things like the Stonehenge tunnel might find themselves reappearing as something like this, but of course another key link on a longer arterial route. But I haven't got a list.

38:02 - 38:31

Michael Reader

There may not be any other schemes. I mean, on the A303, I think the engineering challenges have probably outweighed any benefits of using finance through RAB.

I wonder if you could both set out, do you think that independent regulation under this model would give stronger consumer protection, particularly in the light of evidence you've given, Edmund, around M6 Toll and Dartford and, you know, how those haven't perhaps been managed in the best interests of the public? Will independent regulation be a better solution for taxpayers?

38:31 - 39:49

Edmund King

Yeah, I don't know if it has to be independent regulation, but more of a degree of independence alongside the ORR. I mean, if you look at the ORR, its history to date has been much more on railways than on roads. Yes, it has an overseeing body with National Highways, but, you know, of the executive for the ORR, I think five are from railway backgrounds, two from roads. So in terms of that, it needs to be strengthened.

But I do still feel alongside the ORR, an independent body that looks at things like level of tolls, feasibility. I mean, things like if drivers are going to be paying a higher toll to use these crossings, if the crossing isn't working for some reason, there are roadworks, there are incidents that should be cleared up. It should be a two-way process. Drivers should get money back. It you know, if this really is an independent business model, it has to work both ways.

And I think under this regulator model, you could push it a bit further to give that degree of independence, whether it's through that stakeholder group that that you then change how that's reported. But I certainly think it would help.

39:49 - 40:31

Steve Gooding

I think that the independence is actually of more importance on the other side of the equation, that if the investment world doesn't have the reassurance that the toll levels will be set at a level that enables them to remunerate their efficient costs, they'll be more suspicious. And I think the political pressure, as we've seen historically and I have dealt with in my past, has been to keep the charges, keep the tolls down. So if anything, the consumer pressure is slightly greater politically than it would be for the regulator, which is why it's important, as Mr. King and I are saying, that the regulator in this instance has to have a clear duty in respect of that consumer protection.

40:31 - 40:47

Michael Reader

In respect of that, it is on the investor to keep tolls at a reasonable level and keep the road open to get a return. So it would be counterintuitive to say that they would not fix roadworks quickly because they want people going through the toll, do they not? So you're not going to set a toll high if it's going to put off your users.

40:47 - 41:15

Steve Gooding

They'll certainly want the income, no question of that. I think we're probably comparing, for example, the M6 toll, which is one of very few other examples we have in this country, where there is an alternative free-of-charge route, whereas here, realistically, the operating cost, for example, for commercial traffic of going round to the west of London would make this much less viable as an alternative.

41:15 - 41:16

Alison Griffiths.

41:16 - 42:02

Alison Louise Griffiths

Thank you, Chair. And just to continue the conversation on the ORR, I'm struck as the Shadow Rail Minister that the role of the ORR in the Railways Bill is being significantly downgraded, but in this Bill, the balance seems to be the other way.

And I just wonder if you both of you could comment a bit further on that balance for the ORR and where is the right balance to be to make sure that there is that independence that we talked about so that we do get the right results for consumers and road users.

42:02 - 42:54

Steve Gooding

If I may, as somebody who used to work at the ORR back in the day... I used to work at ORR as well, so we've got a reunion. I think there are two key things here, and I think one of them is the independence, but the other one is the capability.

And specifically here, we're talking about growing and making sure that the ORR has the requisite capability to be undertaking what is going to be quite a tricky and very public, in a way, task of setting that. And it's something they would need to build up. As you say, a lot of the expertise in the ORR today is really about the railways. Yes, it's about engineering and construction and all of that, but there are some specific things about this project and the relationship with the existing crossing where I'd certainly like to be seeing a significant strengthening in the ORR's capability.

42:54 - 43:21

Edmund King

Yeah, I agree with that, and I do believe the ORR are looking to bring in new skills, particularly on economic regulation and the broader thing, which I think will be needed because whereas there are some similarities between road and rail, there are also some differences, and some of the consequences are quite different in terms of regulation. So I think it will need to be beefed up.

43:21 - 44:08

John Tristan Osborne

Thank you very much and it's a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. Two questions. First of all, does the bill, looking at it very specifically the crossing, but there are also other infrastructure upgrades in I'm an MP in North Kent, the A229, the Bluebell Hill upgrade, all of these are key junctions where congestion is a problem. Does the bill in your view take into account some of the other wider infrastructure upgrades that might be necessary? And second of all, I sit on Public Accounts Committee, we've just released a report this week on the RAB model in relation to Sizewell.

There are concerns there. Do you have a view on that model per se?

I appreciate you've indicated it's not been used elsewhere, but is there an educated view about whether or not an alternative model might have worked better, or what are your views on that?

44:08 - 45:15

Steve Gooding

I think that on the first point, I mean, the Bill, because it is not even specific to the Dartford Crossing and the Lower Thames Crossing, I don't think the Bill per se takes account of the other schemes that you've talked about, other than as the Committee's already raised, the general duty on the Secretary of State and on the ORR to consider the network as a whole, something the Committee might want to probe a bit further. As for the RAB model, I can certainly see the logic in this instance, but one has to start with one decision, which is the Chancellor does not wish to borrow the money themselves.

If that is the case, then I can see in this circumstance, given where National Highways has got to in contracting for the construction of the tunnel already, this appears to be a sensible model so long as, and I think again the committee will have heard this, the lessons of past RAB-based projects are learned, one of which is the ability and capability of the regulator to do what the regulator is being relied upon to do.

45:15 - 46:17

Edmund King

Yeah, if I could add just on the RAB model, I think one of the things that's quite hard to get your head round is that it's kind of open-ended. You know, there's, excuse me, there's no finish date. On the M6 Toll, I know it's a different private finance model, but it was given a 53-year concession. Under this model, in effect, the concession could be 100 years, could be 120 years, you know, from from the bill, unless unless the license is revoked.

And that's quite difficult to get your head round at first, because when you look at the Dartford Crossing, the tolls from Dartford go into the Treasury, a general field. This is totally changing that model. So we've got to be sure that the safeguards are there and built into the model. And that's why I think toughening up, strengthening the ORR, bringing in a degree of more independence is more vital.

46:17 - 46:18

Dr. Peter Prinsley.

46:18 - 47:03

Peter Richard Prinsley

Thank you. Thank you very much. I'm Peter Prinsley. I'm the MP for Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket in Suffolk, where we have a lot of problems with our roads and no motorways, by the way. So look, I think what the general public are anxious about is the price.

What is it going to cost for them to take their vehicles across this new tunnel? And what you said earlier on about there being very little choice, people will use this tunnel if it's there. And there's a fear that they'll be, that the public will be held to ransom.

That's actually the problem. How are we going to deal with that in actual fact? And what do you actually anticipate the price of taking my car through this tunnel is in fact going to be when it opens?

47:03 - 48:11

Steve Gooding

I hesitate to say what the price is going to be. I would suspect it's going to be whatever it costs today to go across the Dartford Crossing and some more. And I think the anxiety quite rightly that people have got at the moment is looking at the cost of the Lower Thames Crossing. There must be a question about does it have to cost quite that much? And I think whatever further pressure can be applied, everything is going to flow from that initial estimate.

The way that the the RAB is going to be valued over time is going to flow from what is it going to cost to build this thing. That's why it's so important at the outset that as much pressure is put on National Highways at the moment to keep the costs under control and preferably drive them down. That's what's going to affect things. Subsequently, of course, there are going to be some quite big bills coming on the refurbishment and renewal of the existing bridge and tunnel. Keeping pressure on those is important.

And that is why, as we keep saying, the pressure from the regulator to be pressing for the efficient cost is so important to the structure working.

48:11 - 48:15

Peter Richard Prinsley

And you'd like to see that written into the bill, the pressure?

48:15 - 48:54

Steve Gooding

I think it's very hard to write into the bill the need to keep that pressure up, absolutely, because that's why we have the independent regulator. We have some entity that is saying, effectively, you can tell me whatever you like about the cost of this, but in my opinion, the efficient cost of it is X. In this model, particularly if we're talking about the Lower Thames Crossing, that first estimate is going to be derived from the National Highways model, obviously with ORR involvement, but it won't be quite the same as subsequent reviews where it'll be entirely down to the ORR.

48:54 - 49:43

Edmund King

If I could just add, I mean, currently for cars it's £3.50 at Dartford, for HGVs £8.40. It brings in about 130 million a year.

And if you do some back-of-the-envelope calculations, if you took a 120-year concession, that would bring in 15.6 billion pounds. It's estimated that the scheme might cost 11 billion pounds. Now, okay. But I think if you look at the £3.50, people accept that. That's affordable.

So I think it should be based on that figure with limits built in, whether it's linked to inflation, whether it's linked to something else. But I do think that is vital. It's got to be affordable for people, not just fair and transparent.

49:43 - 49:44

Thank you.

49:44 - 50:49

Emma Lewell

Order, order. That brings us to the end of the time allotted for the committee to ask questions.

On behalf of the committee, can I thank our witnesses for their evidence. Thank you. We will now hear oral evidence from Logistics UK, the Road Haulage Association, and M6 Toll. For this session, we have until 12:45 PM. Would the witnesses please briefly introduce themselves for the record, please.

50:49 - 50:55

Ben Garratt

Ben Garrett, Interim Director of Policy and Communications at Logistics UK.

50:55 - 50:59

Speaker 22

And Michael Whelan, General Manager, M6 Toll.

50:59 - 51:05

Declan Pang

Declan Pang, Director of Policy at the Road Haulage Association.

51:05 - 51:06

Greg Smith.

51:06 - 52:25

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Ms. Lewell-Buck. Good afternoon, gentlemen. Can I start with Ben and Declan, please, from the logistics and haulage sectors? There was quite a lot of questions in the last session on the overall cost of the Lower Thames Crossing and any other schemes that might get a license through the provisions of this bill.

And I certainly know from my role as a shadow minister doing roundtables with Logistics UK and going to haulage firms in my own constituency, margins are very tight in the sector right now. And of course I equally get that juxtaposition of margins are even worse if you're stuck in traffic and can't get across the Thames or to wherever it is you want to go. But can you come on where the breaking point is, if I could put it that way, for the sector, so that if a toll for an HGV, for example, came out too high, there would be a perverse disincentive for haulage operators to use existing other routes to avoid that. Is there a risk that we actually end up building these things too expensive, the toll is then too high, and the haulage sector actually finds themselves in a worse position?

52:25 - 54:51

Ben Garratt

Yeah, I'll go first. Tricky question.

I think, you know, what we know is that the current situation and reliance on the Dartford Crossing costs the logistics sector a lot, as well as other users of the Dartford Crossing in terms of the congestion that comes from that. The overall congestion's been the cost of sitting in traffic estimated at 200 million a year. That's based on the time sitting doing nothing, but doesn't take into account the wider costs to the logistics sector and supply chains of goods not arriving on time. That's just based on the wasted time of the driver. And we also know that reliability, or lack of, is a cost borne by the sector that is then passed on.

And when we speak to our members, what they want is a reliable transport system so they can factor in how much a job is going to take, how much time, how many drivers will it take, what they should charge for it. And unreliability means that it's much harder to do that and we potentially as a sector have more assets than we need to to cover the same amount of ground. Which is why it's really important for the sector that capacity increases and why we support therefore the delivery of the Lower Thames Crossing. In terms of a breaking point, it's quite tricky because the reason why the sector has a low margin, we say like between one and three percent, is because it's a highly competitive sector.

It's a feature of the sector rather than something that we would say that we'd complain about. It's because there are lots of logistics businesses all competing with each other, all competing to deliver the best price. And therefore when there are cost pressures on the sector, over the medium to long term, it generally keeps that margin where it is, but it results in the overall cost being passed on to the public. So it's more, I'd say the risk is, unless it's priced ludicrously, the risk is more about the overall cost being passed on to the public rather than it breaking the operators as it were.

54:51 - 55:55

Greg Gregory Smith

So for the inflationary impact for that example. I think from the second reading debate we had, there is largely cross-party consensus on the need for the Lower Thames Crossing.

That is not a point that I think there is a political divide on. Where I think this bill opens up wider questions is the "what else" bit. How many more schemes under this model could come to pass in the future? And without wholesale change to other things like fuel duty, road fund license, etc., the inflationary impact if we suddenly end up with lots of schemes under this that general motorists as well as the haulage sector are using, there's going to be a tipping point, isn't there, where the inflationary impact of that with the pass-on of those tolls to customers becomes high? Do you have any modelling on where that might be?

55:55 - 58:01

Ben Garratt

No, no, we don't. I mean, we'd say that the inflationary impact is a balance between the direct input costs, so paying for a toll, paying for fuel duty, paying tax, and the indirect costs of congestion. And obviously as a sector we want to keep those two things in balance, but one of the things that we do want as a sector is more investment in the transport network, road, rail, and beyond, because there are some real hotspots on the sector that are causing congestion and therefore passing that cost on. This is one of them, it's not the only one.

Um so we need to make sure that that is in balance because not building and I know we're not just being building this particular crossing, but not building things in general has a cost in it in itself. Um so it's about making sure that it's fair and it's about, you know, therefore considering the different ways of paying for this. I mean traditionally these sorts of things would be done under general taxation, which, you know, we all pay for. Um we are not given the fiscal situation, we are not as a sector against a a toll approach and a private finance approach for this particular crossing. It is one heavily used by the logistics sector.

For us it is a key part of the route between trading route between, you know, Scotland, the Midlands, um the North and Europe, like it is not simply an East of London, Essex and Kent issue.

So we want to see it happen. We are prepared as a sector to help pay for it. And we just want to make sure that the toll, taking into account the different vehicles and different toll rates for different vehicles, takes into account that it's the sector, it shouldn't just be based on weight of vehicle and wear and tear. We need to take into account the economic value that logistics sector provides to the rest of the country and ultimately that we all pay for it in a way that other road users, that's slightly different.

58:01 - 58:29

Greg Gregory Smith

That's a point I fully understand. Declan, if you could also add your thoughts and the your organization's perspective. And maybe if I can just add one rider to the question I asked to Ben. Of course, when the last government removed tolls from the Severn Bridge, that was actually pretty well received by general motorists and the haulage sector itself.

And that's where I'm coming from to try and get an understanding of where the tipping point is.

58:29 - 01:00:05

Declan Pang

I mean, the cost and the affordability of toll rates is a significant concern for us. As you'll know, the majority of the haulage sector are SMEs, small businesses, and many of them micro-businesses. And they are the major users of the trunk road network. So their interests do need to be front and centre of how toll rates are being set. We've also got quite a fragile situation in the haulage sector at the moment.

We've got a particular rate of mergers and acquisitions as well as a high rate of insolvencies.

So that difficult climate, which has certainly been exacerbated by higher input costs and higher fuel costs, should certainly be considered when this bill is being looked at. From the bill itself, we're particularly concerned about the affordability of tolls, the transparency of how tolls will be set, as well as the wider impact of the financing model. And we very much would like the MPs to think about and look at how tolls will be calculated, how they might increase over time, and how the ORR as the regulator will assess the affordability of tolls, because we don't feel that that's clearly set out as it stands. There has also been lots of concern around the government having no plans to use the bill powers to introduce tolls on roads that are currently free, and we would certainly seek additional assurances on that from the minister.

01:00:05 - 01:00:53

Greg Gregory Smith

That's incredibly helpful. Could I ask within that, given that affordability of tolls is so critical to your members from what you've just said, do you believe there should be a presumption or something stronger than that locked into the face of this bill that there should be a due regard to ensuring that schemes are built as, whilst within the boundaries of safety and meeting correct standards, be built as cheaply as possible? For example, with the Lower Thames Crossing, it's already being made more expensive by the banning of the use of diesel plant to build it.

Should there be that presumption that things should, whilst within safety and other due standards, be built as cheaply as possible?

01:00:53 - 01:01:35

Declan Pang

Absolutely. I think that the costs of constructing these schemes are absolutely essential in terms of reducing the level of tolls. We particularly think that the bill as it's drafted is quite open-ended in terms of the phrases that are used. As one of the previous witnesses said, affordability should be part of it, rather than just the phrase "fair and transparent". And we would like to see that included.

We're very supportive of Jim Dickson's amendment around the rates as well, and we would just like to see more consideration given to affordability for businesses.

01:01:35 - 01:01:59

Ben Garratt

I mean, I'd agree with everything Declan said.

I think also in the assurances space, we know in section one talks about the ORR having regard to economy. That also comes up in the other sections of the bill, and we would like assurances that includes an understanding that freight and supply chains is a part of economy, because it's quite a broad term otherwise.

01:01:59 - 01:02:22

Greg Gregory Smith

That's incredibly helpful. Mr. Whelan, I haven't brought you in yet. I mean, clearly you've got a niche interest around the M6 Toll elements of this. Do you feel the bill delivers for what is an existing toll road operation, and is there anything that you feel is missing out of this bill from your perspective?

01:02:22 - 01:02:34

Michael Whelan

Sure, sure. So our specific interest in the bill is part seven, which will enable us to introduce free-flow tolling.

01:02:34 - 01:02:38

Speaker 28

Sir, could I ask you to speak closer to the microphone, please? I'm struggling to hear. Thanks.

01:02:37 - 01:02:38

Is that better?

01:02:38 - 01:02:39

Keep going and I'll tell you.

01:02:39 - 01:03:49

Michael Whelan

Okay, all right. So I'll, I'll speak a bit louder then. Um, so, so from an M6 Toll perspective, our, our interest in the bill is specifically on part seven, which enables us to, to, to introduce free-flow tolling. So that basically means at the moment on the M6 Toll, we have barriers where you need to stop, slow down, and pay. So the Highway Bill part seven is the first step for us to enable free-flow tolling, which will help my freight and logistics friends to either side of me, not having to stop and slow down.

So that has many benefits: time savings. Also, the M6 Toll is a very reliable route compared to its alternatives, so it just further increases that reliability through increased time savings. And also CO2 emissions as well, reduced because of the less stop and start.

01:03:49 - 01:03:53

Speaker 31

That's helpful.

01:03:54 - 01:04:27

Speaker 13

Thank you. Good afternoon, gentlemen.

I think just quite helpful to hear from Mr. Garratt and Mr. Pang in a little bit more detail about the current importance of the area for the whole of the logistics network. In particular, it might be useful for committee members to hear what the current arrangements are when hazardous items have to go through the tunnel, because that's I think a big challenge at the moment.

01:04:27 - 01:06:06

Ben Garratt

Yeah, sure. So the current situation lacks resilience. We, the sector, is using the Dartford Crossing, the one current crossing east of London, as a part of what I'd describe as a core route for the whole country that connects Scotland, the North, the Midlands, Southeast, and Europe on that trading route, particularly trading across the short straits that handle over half of all goods traded between Britain and mainland Europe.

And it's currently overloaded. As we know, it's causing significant congestion, which adds costs. And then that's, as you've noted, isn't simply an even matter of a busy road. It's also the crossing being closed to allow hazardous goods to cross, which everyone else has to wait for, which has a significant impact across the whole network. So it's not sustainable.

And also that also takes into account the assumption the crossing is broadly open all the time, but things will need repairing over their lifetime.

We can see across the rest of the transport network, there is, you know, the structures fund and there's the focus of National Highways on other structures that will need repairing at some point. So we've got a resilience challenge as well as a cost challenge because of that capacity issue.

01:06:06 - 01:06:26

Declan Pang

I think absolutely we need to increase the resilience of that particular route as well as the whole the road network. Vehicle miles are increasing and congestion is forecast to increase, so this is a problem we have to get ahead of, and that means making sure we can increase trunk road capacity.

01:06:26 - 01:06:59

Speaker 13

Okay, just sort of one further question to you both.

Obviously you've talked about the impact of increased tolls. Could you just give us a sense in terms of the organizations you represent's overheads, what proportion would tolls generally be of the costs of running a business? And is there any way you can equate that to the delays that congestion causes? Is there a balance there, is there a trade-off?

01:06:59 - 01:08:53

Michael Whelan

Okay, so the key thing, well I can only really talk about the M6 Toll of course, so I won't be broader than that. But in terms of the M6 Toll, what our customers pay for, and they choose to pay, so they do have a choice, there are alternates.

But what they pay for is that reliability and travel time saving. What's really interesting in that we have seen recently is that HGV growth on our road has actually gone up over 50% compared to COVID, so pre-COVID numbers. And that's predominantly because of the reliability that we offer. And also the other one is that we find that the freight industry in particular find savings in terms of lower fuel costs, time, and obviously the delivery on time, for example. So in terms of toll prices and where it goes, so we are 100% privately funded, we don't receive any funds from the government.

So where the money goes is first of all to the government. We, like every other good law-abiding citizen, we have to pay our taxes and we do.

Then it goes into maintenance. And then the residual, because we're owned by infrastructure, sorry, pension funds, the money actually goes back into pension holders' pockets at the end of the day. So it's a cycling of pension investors going cycling around the money. Does that hopefully answer some of your questions?

01:08:53 - 01:09:02

Speaker 13

That's very helpful. I just wondered if the other two witnesses had anything to say from the sort of other side of the ledger as it were.

01:09:02 - 01:10:11

Ben Garratt

Yeah, I mean, it's a challenging calculation. I mean, we'd look at how much the logistics sector is currently paying to cross the Dartford Crossing.

So it's about 40% of the road use but it's more because HGVs and larger vehicles pay more then it's it's more than that. So we can assume they're paying over 100 million a year like sort of rough calculation to cross it. But we know the congestion the cost of congestion even just for sitting doing the cost of the driver is about 200 million a year. So we could add on to that we haven't got the number but we know beyond that is the cost to wider supply chains, the cost of a lack of reliability.

And I think making an assumption, you know, thinking about what's the experience on the M6 Toll, the sector would rather pay upfront for reliability than pay during the day for a lack of reliability, knowing that the costs for that are much bigger than the 200 million because of the impact across supply chains.

01:10:11 - 01:10:47

Declan Pang

I think the most important thing for our members is reliability. They want reliability and consistency of journey times, and congestion can be very unreliable, which drives a significant amount of cost into the supply chain. So that is the first and foremost the most important consideration. Clearly, if we ended up in a situation in the future where we had multiple tolled routes, for example, the cumulative impact of that situation would be very deeply concerning to us. But I appreciate this bill specifically is looking at the Lower Thames Crossing.

01:10:47 - 01:10:49

Speaker 32

Ollie Glover.

01:10:49 - 01:11:14

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

Thank you, Ms. Lewell. I just wondered if you could say a little bit more about what you think can be learned from M6 Toll in terms of how we might look to improve or amend this bill, because that is the perhaps the largest geographical manifestation of tolling at the moment and the most similar to the presumed application of this bill in terms of Lower Thames Crossing. Who would like to go first?

01:11:14 - 01:13:11

Ben Garratt

Yeah, for sure. I mean, I think there's the features of the bill that we're, I guess, not seeking amendment, but seeking reassurances around are just ensuring that there is a there is a strong regulator on it, for establishing the scheme and monitoring it going forward, and that, you know, relates to the licensing conditions too.

And therefore we see a value in there being a bill setting a broad framework and including the regulator in that, rather than, you know, potentially how things have been done in the past in a in a more, you know, individual scheme sense. But in terms of the so we would seek reassurances about about the strength of the regulator in that space and that they and that they will include thinking about freight and logistics when they're thinking about economy. But I think, you know, we've we've heard from Michael about how the sector is voting with its its feet, as it were, in terms of its wheels, indeed, in terms of using a toll road to improve reliability in that space.

And just to add a piece that was highlighted earlier as about the sort of risk of this rolling out to other roads, that we'd also have concerns about. It's why I mentioned that this is a particularly important route for the UK's trade. And we wouldn't want to see the powers in the bill used to sort of push out tolling much more generally, not coming with new capacity. And we think there's language in the bill about associating it with new capacity. And again, it's something we would seek further ministerial reassurances that it is focused on that and not widespread tolling.

01:13:11 - 01:14:03

Declan Pang

I would just add in relation to the role of the ORR, the stakeholder group needs to be strengthened much more in terms of how it's described at the moment. So certainly we think that there needs to be, there's no statutory requirement for a representative of the freight and logistics on the group, and really it's quite vague as to who would be sitting on it. I mean, in theory, you could have representatives from toll companies or from the DfT, for example, without excluding any industry or road users. So I think clearing that up and making the governance of that much clearer is vital. I do also agree with the previous witness who talked about the a more independent role for a stakeholder group, which would make it much more impartial.

01:14:03 - 01:14:09

Speaker 35

We would concur with all of that.

01:14:09 - 01:14:10

Jacob Collier.

01:14:10 - 01:14:37

Jacob Collier

Thank you, Ms. Lewell. Just to add to that, I suppose both yourselves and the previous witnesses have talked about a stronger independent regulation as being something that you would support. But obviously we've got the M6 Toll, which is a current operator. So how well do you think that current regulation works for the M6 Toll and is there anything that we need to change that is relevant to this bill?

01:14:37 - 01:14:41

Speaker 36

It's probably for Ben and Declan.

01:14:41 - 01:15:45

Ben Garratt

I mean, I think that the there is a there is a maybe a market dynamic around the M6 that is that lent that means that it's it's working reasonably well in that there is a good alternative route that isn't always congested. So, you know, that means I would assume by default that they're playing in a competitive environment and therefore and logistics businesses as we've said are choosing choosing to often use it. It's a slightly different situation on on other parts of the network when, you know, one of the you know the current crossing is full a lot of the time, so it it could be more of a let's say a distress purchase to use the alternative route and therefore it's important that the that is regulated and that and that there is a role of the regulator in ensuring fairness that maybe the broader market wouldn't necessarily apply in all parts of the network.

01:15:45 - 01:16:37

Declan Pang

Yeah, I think the role of the regulator is certainly very important and having having an independent element of that and making the strengthening the role of the stakeholder group as an independent group would be something that I think needs to needs to happen as part of this process. In terms of specific aspects of the bill which relate to toll amounts, there's chapter 25 which talks about classes of road vehicle in respect to which tolls are payable and we've got some concerns around how that might impact different types of haulage operation and different different types of HGVs and which may disadvantage certain types of of businesses. So that that's just an example of something that we think needs to be made a bit more consistent from what we've got with the M6 toll at the moment.

01:16:37 - 01:16:39

Emma Lewell

Tamsin Griffith.

01:16:39 - 01:17:14

Alison Louise Griffiths

Thank you, Chair.

And this is predominantly for Mr Whelan, but at the end if if Ben and Declan wish to weigh in, please do. But for the M6, how have the both economic and sort of operational outcomes that have been delivered over the last 20 years been what was envisaged? And then the second sort of follow-up to that is again around the role of the ORR. Does the regulation outlined in the bill provide sufficient certainty for private investors?

01:17:14 - 01:18:51

Michael Whelan

Okay. So in terms of economic benefits, so I think the best way to look at the M6 Toll is to consider that there's 50,000 vehicles a day using the M6 Toll.

If the M6 Toll was not there, the M6 and the surrounding network would be quite a mess. And what we've seen as a result of the M6 Toll, there's been significant investment into the region. Numerous businesses have invested in logistics sites, for example, there's a massive Amazon site just near us and throughout up and down that corridor. So that's not only, that also creates jobs as well for that, for that region. So I won't go through them all, they're in some pre-read that I know that you all have there, so please refer to that.

Um, in terms of what we're specifically interested for in the bill, which is part seven, which is an existing road, the ORR regulations, as we see it, do not apply. And if they were to, it would be a significant impact to our concession agreement, investors, and in particular lenders as well, who have all invested into the road. So it's something, you know, hearing this conversation is important, but for us it is a separate conversation, separate issue.

01:18:51 - 01:18:53

Speaker 39

Could you say that last sentence again? I was just...

01:18:53 - 01:19:02

Michael Whelan

In terms of ORR, it doesn't apply to the part seven in some respects. Oh, sorry.

01:19:02 - 01:19:06

Speaker 40

Okay. And Declan and Ben, do you have anything you wish to add in on that?

01:19:06 - 01:20:17

Declan Pang

Well, I think on this sort of RAB model in particular, I think we're supportive of any measures that will be brought forward to increase road building, so and road capacity, and efforts to in that regard. And we think RAB gives some certainty to the market around providing investment opportunities. In terms of the ORR, in addition to comments I've made around the stakeholder group, the ORR has been heavily weighted towards rail regulation and has a much smaller role on highways monitoring at the moment. As a proportion of what it does as an organisation, its role from a roads perspective is smaller than the rail element.

And that's probably reflected in the level of engagement that they have with the sector as it stands. So it would reflect quite a big, a significant change in the level of responsibilities that they have with this bill. And clearly we'd want to be sure about the capability and the capacity for them to be able to take on that responsibility.

01:20:17 - 01:21:25

Ben Garratt

I just wanted to expand on something that Michael referred to about the wider benefits of this. Obviously, understandably, the logistics sector invests around where there is transport capacity and junctions where it can then access the rest of the country. So there are particular parts of the road and rail network that have got a lot of logistics clustered around there.

It's also about having good journey times between large conurbations. And we can definitely see in other parts of the country where there has been, we would look at as artificially less logistics investment than there should have been because of transport constraints at that part of the network. So I think it particularly affects the North West where there is, it's more of a rail issue, whereas there's a lack of capacity on the West Coast Main Line and that leads to more modern logistics being clustered further south than maybe it otherwise would be. So there's a real economic benefit for the country of getting the capacity right.

01:21:25 - 01:21:27

Speaker 41

Jim Dickson.

01:21:27 - 01:22:06

Jim Dickson

Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the witnesses. Ben and Declan, you've set out very clearly the effect on your sector of the current situation at the Dartford Crossing, hugely over capacity.

I've talked about how it affects my residents hugely in terms of their quality of life and their air quality. It's been suggested by some that we don't need this project, we could potentially look at modal shift or, you know, instead of rather than alongside the solution of the Lower Thames Crossing. What do you think would happen, what's your scenario over shall we say the next decade if the Lower Thames Crossing wasn't built?

01:22:06 - 01:23:29

Ben Garratt

I think it would inhibit economic growth. Thinking about the modal shift piece, using the right modes for the right kind of journeys in our logistics system is really important. And it is not, but it is not simply about can we just, you know, get more off congested roads and and more onto rail.

There, rail can play a particularly strong role, as you'd understand, where there are railway tracks and they're connecting to ports and they're bringing in containers. I don't think as this, as this area gets congested, that that would automatically lead to, because of the lack of rail connectivity, the logistics sector switching to rail in this, in this space. It could over time lead to less use of the short straits, more use of container, container shipping, but really those dynamics are shaped by where the market, you know, where the goods are coming from in the world. So it would largely just simply be a bottleneck. It would increase the costs over time of exporters connecting to new markets.

The current situation will invariably be, will be inhibiting businesses from thinking about going to export because it's just, you know, it has an effect on the costs. So we want to, want to see that resolved.

So, in short, bad for the economy if it didn't happen.

01:23:29 - 01:23:31

Speaker 42

Thank you. Mr. Pang, do you agree?

01:23:31 - 01:23:49

Declan Pang

I mean, we're very much behind it and we're grateful to your efforts for campaigning for it. Absolutely. And we're very pleased to see that it got the development consent order was approved. And, you know, it would have a significant, it is already having a significant impact on the economy given the level of congestion. So it's vital we make sure we get it delivered.

01:23:49 - 01:24:31

Jim Dickson

Thank you. And if I could ask one separate question.

It's been suggested at the moment that the requirement across the various tolled arrangements we have in the UK already, so Mersey Tunnels, Tyne Tunnel, M6 and elsewhere, the need to sign in separately to use each of those tolled arrangements is a burden on a whole variety of road users. Mr Whelan, what do you think of the opportunity here to create interoperability between these tolled arrangements, making it better for the logistics industry but also for consumers who use, you know, multiple tolled arrangements?

01:24:31 - 01:25:51

Michael Whelan

Yeah, fully support that. And it's something as an industry that we're looking at. So some of the operators of toll roads have come together to discuss that. And what that would help with is having one account. So you can travel, and particularly for freight and logistics organisations, having one account just makes a lot of sense.

Then on top of that, that interoperability can be expanded into things, for example, signage.

If you go to anywhere else in the world, particularly toll roads will have a very unique colour or symbol. That's very important because it actually helps with making sure that you've got some sort of consistency and knowledge of what you're approaching as a customer, so in terms of when to pay, for example. And so coming to free-flow tolling, that's very important that people understand in advance what the rules are. So, and hence the part seven is something that we fully support, and with some minor amendments that we would like to see made within there in clause 92, 93 and 94, which are outlined in the pre-read. I think we may have run out of time to go through that at the minute, but thank you.

01:25:51 - 01:25:52

Douglas Lumsden.

01:25:52 - 01:25:53

Speaker 43

Thank you.

01:25:53 - 01:26:06

Speaker 44

Thank you, Chair. Mr Whelan, we heard in the previous panel that, you know, there could be potential to offer discounts for local residents. Is that something that M6 Toll actually does at present? And how does it work?

01:26:06 - 01:26:51

Michael Whelan

We have. So about two years, two and a half years ago, we put a new toll system in place. So we spent 20 million pounds on it. What that enabled us to do was introduce new toll pricing. So our local, so we've actually reduced prices for locals down to four pounds.

And we've held it there for the two and a half years. So we haven't increased that. So yes, that's something that we're conscious of and something that we've actively looked at as well as new products as well, some with discounts, some without.

Interestingly, it's the ones, it's the account product that does not have a discount that is our most popular.

01:26:51 - 01:26:52

Which one's that?

01:26:52 - 01:26:55

Speaker 46

Account Light.

01:26:55 - 01:26:57

Speaker 45

And what does that do, sorry?

01:26:57 - 01:27:13

Michael Whelan

Provides a, an easier way to get a receipt. And it also provides you the ability to drive through our, what we call breeze lanes, which the gates will automatically open if your account is in good status.

01:27:13 - 01:27:35

Speaker 44

Okay. And Mr. Barrett, you mentioned you would like to see ministerial assurance that this bill couldn't be used much more widely across the rest of the country.

Do you think ministerial assurance is enough or would you like to see something on the face of the bill to make sure that it isn't a Trojan horse as the minister says it wouldn't be?

01:27:35 - 01:28:09

Ben Garratt

Our sense is that the way it's currently drafted is relatively strong, which is why we're seeking assurances around that on the record rather than amendments. We don't as we don't want it to be used as a Trojan horse to spread this across the country. This is, you know, there's a particular case for it being on this particular route. But it I think given the way it's worded at the moment, verbal assurances would be proportionate.

01:28:09 - 01:28:24

Speaker 44

But in terms of, like, increasing capacity, for example, we've heard that, you know, moving to a smart motorway and using the hard shoulder could increase capacity and then could then mean tolls could be charged.

01:28:24 - 01:28:50

Ben Garratt

Yeah, I mean, that isn't how, I mean, again, it would be good to get an assurance that that is not the case. That is not our reading of it at the moment, but that doesn't mean that others couldn't interpret it who are looking at this at some point in the future. So that's why we're seeking a strong assurance that this is about adding actual new trunk road capacity and not doing things like you've just proposed.

01:28:50 - 01:28:52

Speaker 47

Does the RHA have any concerns?

01:28:52 - 01:29:22

Declan Pang

Well, we are concerned about the way that it could be applied for tolls to be introduced. You know, we do want to see greater assurances from the department about that.

I mean, clause 81 in particular gives the Secretary of State the power to direct any road to be made a trunk road. So, you know, we're just concerned about what could be brought into scope of this and we do want greater reassurances on that.

01:29:22 - 01:29:25

Speaker 48

Okay. Thank you, Chair.

01:29:25 - 01:29:34

Emma Lewell

Order, order. That brings us to the end of the time allotted for the committee to ask questions. On behalf of the committee, I thank our witnesses for their evidence. Thank you.

01:29:34 - 01:30:01

Speaker 49

Thank you very much.

01:30:01 - 01:30:12

Emma Lewell

We will now hear oral evidence from Transport Action Network.

For this session, we have until 1:00. Could the witness please briefly introduce themselves for the record?

01:30:12 - 01:30:34

Ralph Smyth

Thank you very much. My name is Ralph Smith, and I'm here on behalf of Transport Action Network. I have about 15 years of experience from influencing the Infrastructure Act 2015, serving on National Highways' Strategic Design Panel, so seeing some of the schemes that we've been discussing today, and also with road freight decarbonisation projects. Thank you.

01:30:34 - 01:30:37

Emma Lewell

Thank you very much. Greg Smith.

01:30:37 - 01:31:31

Greg Gregory Smith

Thank you, Ms Lewell, good afternoon. Can I ask, as you look at the totality of this Bill, including the elements around the Lower Thames Crossing, do you think the Government is joined up enough in terms of looking at where new schemes are delivered, be that the Lower Thames Crossing or anything else that might come to pass, with the existing infrastructure, local roads, intersections? We've just had the haulage sector giving evidence, so things like driver welfare facilities at roadside etc. Does this Bill risk being bringing nice new shiny things up to the strategic road network without the necessary backup to existing intersections, roads, things that those new schemes will rely on?

01:31:31 - 01:33:07

Ralph Smyth

It's a very good question, thank you, and I'd point perhaps first to the second National Infrastructure Assessment published three years ago.

That said that by the end of 2026, so where we are now, the government should publish an integrated strategy for road and rail. And I would say in that context that if you could see, you know, how you're going to improve the rail links, the road links, that would join up better and give confidence about where there should or shouldn't be, for example, a change to the roads. The other dimension is the local angle. And we've heard recently in the media how mayors might be given more of a say on water, for example. But this bill goes in the opposite direction.

It actually weakens or removes mayoral input on transport. I mean, transport is, has been the kind of totemic issue of devolution.

And oddly, this bill actually removes that. There is a special new category of highway created that's not subject to something called the network management duty that's about joining things up, both in long-term planning and short-term operations, such as where there's disruption. My concern is that some of the schemes talked about, like the Lower Thames Crossing, it's going to be difficult to attract the private sector to invest without making it easier for them, without reducing risk of, you know, mayors getting in the way or trying to promote a railway line that would actually obstruct some of the traffic, for example.

01:33:07 - 01:33:26

Greg Gregory Smith

Are you suggesting there that for those areas of the country that currently have a mayor, that they should be locked into this bill as, I suppose, key consultees in planning speak, before anything could go ahead?

01:33:26 - 01:33:29

Ralph Smyth

I wouldn't want to leave out the rural areas perhaps where there aren't mayors.

01:33:29 - 01:33:32

Speaker 53

Absolutely right. Don't leave the rural areas out.

01:33:32 - 01:34:19

Ralph Smyth

Yes, quite. The problem is the bigger context, the discussion about rewiring the state. That's talking about removing consultation. So simply a duty to consult to kind of give your views might not be worth much. Again, the problem is this needs to make economic sense for the investors.

This needs to make economic sense for the investors, and because some of these road schemes, I mean the M6 Toll didn't make a profit for 20 years, you're going to have to tilt this, particularly for very big schemes like the LTC, to make it attractive for our investors, and that could mean making things less affordable for drivers and less involvement for mayors, despite transport being one of their their big issues.

01:34:19 - 01:35:07

Greg Gregory Smith

Thinking to the whole national scene, I've asked this question of some previous witnesses. Where do you think the tipping point would be in terms of, if you take for red that there there is no change to road fund licenses, fuel duty, etc. as the core funding for the road network, where's the tipping point in terms of the number of additional toll roads put across the network that will will just make driving unaffordable, certainly for a haulage sector that is using longer routes every day of the week, and also the the average motorist that maybe doesn't travel that far every day, but does need to to make those journeys to see relatives, go on holiday, etc. across the strategic road network?

01:35:07 - 01:36:04

Ralph Smyth

I'd say the tipping point depends on the sector, the type of journey. For discretionary journeys like seeing a relative, then, you know, a sudden increase in toll might have an impact quite quickly. For things where you are commuting the same journey every day, for, you know, a haulage firm doing the same routes, that might take longer for a response to happen. I would also, since we're talking about tipping points, also talk about climate change, because some figures out from the Environment Agency said that by 2050, so, you know, not long after some of these roads might be built, about half of the UK transport network would flood regularly. That obviously means a lot of disruption.

That obviously means a lot of increased costs for the operator, owner of assets. Those things also might affect, or will affect, I think, given where we're going, our use of roads and railways and everything else.

01:36:04 - 01:36:09

Speaker 54

Okay, mindful that this is a shorter session, so... Thank you.

01:36:10 - 01:36:23

Speaker 13

Yeah, just very briefly, just following up on your comments. Obviously, this Bill is designed to cover the trunk road network. But it's correct, is it, that currently mayors don't have any specific control over those?

01:36:23 - 01:37:21

Ralph Smyth

It's correct, yes, and it's almost like an area that devolution has forgotten. I mean, we hear the importance of roads, we've heard from the previous witnesses, and it does appear a bit odd that there isn't much there.

I mean, one thing is that currently there is a duty whether you're a local highway authority, so county councils and so on, or the strategic highways authority, so National Highways currently, to to cooperate. And this bill would create a new type of private highway authority and it wouldn't join up. And some of the schemes that that have had funding withdrawn in RIS3, you do wonder some of these are very close to urban areas and if they were funded via this route, that would really not be an integrated approach, very much different to what we're hearing on the railways where the government has talked about the need for a single guiding mind.

01:37:21 - 01:37:23

Speaker 55

Thank you, Holly Glover.

01:37:23 - 01:37:36

Guy Nicholas Oliver Glover

So perhaps on that theme, do you have any concerns that the financing arrangements proposed in this bill and its general intentions could affect the balance of investment between strategic roads and local transport networks?

01:37:36 - 01:37:36

Ralph Smyth

I mean there is the issue of crowding out. There are also, you know, if there is certainty there's going to be a road scheme, then that makes it harder for a mayor or someone to promote an alternative such as a tram or, you know, a rail or bus upgrade. I'm actually taking part in the mass transit task force after this, forgive me, task force after this meeting where perhaps those issues will come up.

Very much so.

01:38:04 - 01:38:17

Michael Reader

Thank you, Chair. Um, if tolling is used, what's preferable, a statutory regulator with enforceable licensing conditions or an unregulated commercial tolling arrangement?

01:38:17 - 01:39:03

Ralph Smyth

I mean, the one big issue here, we heard a lot about regulation in the previous section. If you look at Ofwat or Ofgem, their income comes from a lot of different companies. You know, whatever you might think of some of the water companies, at least it means a diversity of income. If you compare that to the ORR, you know, with nationalisation now all the money will be, or soon will be, coming from DfT. Um, similarly for much of the road function, that's about National Highways and only a very small bit if there's only going to be one toll scheme.

So if you put your shoes, put yourself in the shoes of an investor, would you be confident that was an independent regulator if pretty much all its business comes from one person, which is the Secretary of State for Transport? So that might...

01:39:03 - 01:39:17

Michael Reader

The question wasn't whether the regulator's independent. My question was in general, would you prefer, is your preference a regulated tolling arrangement or an unregulated commercial tolling arrangement? Which is better for the public?

01:39:17 - 01:39:59

Ralph Smyth

I'm not sure how much difference there is. The problem is that if you build an expensive road scheme with a regulated model, you can, you can want to make it affordable, but at the end of the day, there will need to be a return for that private investor. So, you know, there's the theory and then there's the reality that this isn't a way of creating new money. It's either going to be paid if it's out of public funds, or it's going to be a regulated system, or, I mean, there's, as other witnesses have said, many of the roads don't have alternatives, but it's hard to see how a regulator can really make much difference.

01:39:59 - 01:40:24

Michael Reader

For as long as I've known LTC, and perhaps whilst the previous government suggested it be delivered by public funds, it was always assumed it would end up through some sort of PPP route. But surely the model here delivers cheaper finance and actually gives better investor certainty, and therefore what you're suggesting there about investor uncertainty may not be true under a specific RAB model on Lower Thames Crossing.

01:40:24 - 01:41:03

Ralph Smyth

I think talking about investor certainty, the problem is that assumes that traffic will keep on growing.

And there's something I've covered in my evidence for TAN is that if you look at the latest ONS forecasts, that's actually saying population will go down in the UK from around 2055. So I've heard the Minister saying demand will only increase, but actually if you start seeing demand going down, that means a very different picture. And then also that means that each user will have to pay more per journey, so that could lock you into, you know, higher unaffordable charges.

01:41:04 - 01:41:39

Jim Dickson

Thank you very much for being here to give evidence. The Transport Action Network, you're on record as being against the Lower Thames Crossing under any circumstances, however it's funded. Do you recognise the evidence that we've heard this morning that there really aren't very many other ways of dealing with the congestion? We've heard that from the logistics lobby. I've heard it from my residents as well.

Could I just ask you, are you still against the scheme and what is your alternative to deal with the manifest problems that we've heard about and that I hear about every day?

01:41:39 - 01:42:08

Ralph Smyth

I think I might struggle in the 15 minutes to persuade you on this. Just give us a summary. But I was interested the other witnesses say that if it wasn't built, then that might mean a shift in some of the trade routes, so helping rebalance away from the overheated Southeast. If you do want to read more, there's a report by TAN on what the alternatives are, and I'm very happy to send that to the committee after this meeting if that would be helpful.

01:42:08 - 01:42:28

Emma Lewell

There are no further questions from members. Can I thank Mr. Smyth for his evidence? That brings us to the end of this morning's session. The committee will meet again at 2:00 this afternoon here in the Boothroyd Room to continue taking oral evidence. I invite the government whip to propose the adjournment.

01:42:28 - 01:42:32

Speaker 56

I beg to move that further consideration of the bill be now adjourned.

01:42:32 - 01:42:42

Emma Lewell

Question is that further consideration of the bill be now adjourned. As many of that opinion say aye. Aye.

Of the contrary, no. I think the ayes have it, the ayes have it. Order, order.

Ask anything about this video — I analyse its transcript to answer.