Highways (Financing) Bill

29 October 2026

Highways (Financing) Bill House of Commons

Follow its sittings
00:02 - 00:42
Speaker 3
Order, order, we are now sitting in public again and the proceedings are being broadcast.  Before we start hearing from our witnesses, do any of the members wish to make a declaration of interest in connection with the bill?  If any interests are particularly, no, no interests?  No.  We will now hear evidence from the AA and the RAC Foundation. 

Welcome.  We must stick to the timings that are in the program motion that the committee has agreed, so this session we will have until five past twelve.  Could you please also both just briefly introduce yourselves for the committee?  Thank you. 
00:42 - 01:11
Speaker 4
Yes, I'm Edmund King, I'm president of the Automobile Association and director of the AA Charitable Trust.  I'm a former visiting professor of transport at Newcastle University, and I've been involved in roads and road infrastructure probably for about 30, 35 years.  I used to be a member of the British Road Federation, which campaigned for better roads in the late eighties and nineties.  Thank you. 
01:11 - 01:26
Speaker 2
Good morning, I'm Steve Gooding, I'm the director of the RAC Foundation, which is the charitable research body set up by the Royal Automobile Club back in the 1990s to conduct and disseminate research relating to motoring. 
01:26 - 01:29
Speaker 1
Thanks.  Greg Smith, shadow minister. 
01:29 - 02:29
Speaker 5
Thank you, Ms. Low, pleasure to serve under your chairmanship this morning.  And good morning, gentlemen.  This bill, particularly from the second reading debate and other narrative that has come out since it was first published, on one level seems to be presented as answering the question, how do you solve a problem like the Lower Thames Crossing?  But equally has a lot of other provision within it where perhaps it is badly drafted clauses or perhaps it is deliberate that seems to allow tolling and road pricing to extend further than the Lower Thames Crossing.  Is that something your organizations are concerned about? 

And do you feel that there has been enough focus given to the everything other than Lower Thames Crossing parts of this bill to general motorists in this country?  Perhaps Mr. King first. 
02:29 - 04:19
Speaker 4
Yeah, I think part of the bill, obviously if you look at the Lower Thames Crossing and you look at the need for it, you look at congestion, you look at the environmental issues currently at Dartford, I think it's quite easy to see that some alternative solution is needed.  But I think as you rightly say with this bill, it's not just about the Lower Thames Crossing, it could allow that finance model with other schemes.  It might have been easier if it was concentrated on the Lower Thames Crossing because then you could have brought into it more restrictions, safeguards for motorists on tolls.  Because currently as it stands, on the one hand you've got the Office of Rail and Road as the regulator for it, and then you've got drivers who are the consumers, whether they're individual motorists or HGV drivers, whatever. 

And to some extent, there might be a conflict between those two.  The ORR has to ensure that the licensee makes money from it so it can be viable, but at the same time, they regulate tolls for the drivers.  And you could argue that there might be a conflict in that at times.  So certainly one of the things that when we've looked at similar schemes before, I did a paper on road miles with an economist that looked at this broader issue of kind of road pricing.  And one thing we called for was an independent body to oversee kind of tolling to ensure that it was fair. 

So I certainly think within this bill, the responsibility of the ORR where it comes to tolls could be strengthened and given more independence.