Late Q&A: targeted legislative test cases, race and caste, sanctuary policies, and closing
The committee debates narrow statutory tests on birth tourism, the racial and historical stakes of undoing jus soli, links between sanctuary policies and immigration enforcement, and whether Barbara should now be treated as settled law, before concluding with reflections on Congress’s residual powers and U.S. exceptionalism in citizenship rules.
In this chapter
- Chairman Roy: consensus on birth tourism and legislative test cases
- Rep. Lee (D): racial caste, Dred Scott, and modern challenges
- Chairman Jordan: sanctuary jurisdictions, crime, and migration incentives
- Scanlon and Raskin: reaffirming Barbara and calling out bigotry
- Rep. Grothman (R): Congress’s residual powers and U.S. exceptionalism